U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

David M. LeglerU.S. CLIVAR Office

U.S. Climate Variability and Predictability Program

www.usclivar.org

legler@usclivar.org

Strategic Themes for US CLIVAR

US CLIVAR Summit

July 2009

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

Need for Themes• Encourage new ideas/thoughts from you! • Identify most important (ie prioritize) scientific

challenges US CLIVAR wants to address• Stimulate strategic (multi-year) thinking and

planning• Encourage integration across US CLIVAR, &

(where it makes sense) with other programs

Who cares?

• Agencies: agency strategic plans, funding cycles

• PIs: does US CLIVAR have any focus or interests that intersect my own? Should I get involved in/pay attention to US CLIVAR?

• Other Programs (e.g. WCRP, Carbon Cycle, etc): What are US CLIVAR’s “implementation” activities? Do we share any interests? How can we better coordinate plans, and activities?

Who cares?

• Agencies: agency strategic plans, funding cycles

• PIs: does US CLIVAR have any focus or interests that intersect my own? Should I get involved in/pay attention to US CLIVAR?

• Other Programs (e.g. WCRP, Carbon Cycle, etc): What are US CLIVAR’s “implementation” activities? Do we share any interests? How can we better coordinate plans, and activities?

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

Current U.S. CLIVAR Themes (formerly Foci)

Current U.S. CLIVAR Themes (formerly Foci)

I Drought

II Decadal Variability/Predictions

Science Themes Are Increasingly Being Motivated by Interactions with Service and

Decision Making Communities

I Drought

II Decadal Variability/Predictions

Science Themes Are Increasingly Being Motivated by Interactions with Service and

Decision Making Communities

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

Drought• Activities (2-page summaries from Panels):

– Physics/Mechanisms of drought-relevant processes: DRICOMP, some field campaigns

– Attributing of causes of drought: ongoing activities in data assimilation; IESA; analyses of past droughts, etc

– Predictability of drought: Drought Working Group experiments, links to Int’l modeling efforts

– Observations: unclear….motivation for improved ocean and soil moisture observations?

• Strategy (scope unclear, not formalized…)• Future activities (TBD…Working Group input…)

What do we do to build on past successes?

2007 2009 2011

Drought WG - predictability What more?DRICOMP

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

• Activities (2-page summaries from Panels):– Physics/Mechanisms of “decadal” processes: ongoing analyses

of observed/simulated decadal variability; some field campaigns (KESS, CLIMODE)

– Attributing causes: Distinguishing natural from anthropogenic factors (Decadal Predictability Working Group), ongoing agency-sponsored research, AMOC

– Predictability: Decadal Predictability Working Group diagnostics, AMOC

– Observations: unclear…

• Strategy (still early, not formalized except in AMOC Strategic Vision document….)

• Future activities (analysis of CMIP5 runs? AMOC activities, further Working Group input…)

Decadal Variability/Predictions

2009 2011 2013

Decadal Predictability WG

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

What is a US CLIVAR Theme?

• Compelling topical area/challenge of coupled climate scientific research (motivated in part by needs of users and services communities)– Investment of time and energy is anticipated to hasten progress

and provide some early payoffs– Sufficiently focused…

• Intersects aims and interests of two or more Panels• Addresses mandates or missions of CLIVAR agency programs• Reflects readiness of research community to get involved and

realize rapid initial payoff• Provides opportunities to engage communities and programs

that need to work with CLIVAR to address key scientific frontiers• Guides/catalyzes US CLIVAR-lead activities for a minimum of 3-

5 years (sufficient time to allow new activities to bear fruit)

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

Planning

• Guided by a set of questions

• Guided by a Strategic vision (motivation, scope, overview of strategic directions) encapsulated in a 5-10 pg brief

• Guiding questions addressed/assessed as a concluding action

Implementation

• Leverages funded research activities

• Builds upon current capabilities and tools (eg models, observational networks, etc)

• Employs US CLIVAR Working Groups and Panels.

• Works closely with agencies to identify research gaps and seeks modest/limited agency support for additional research

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

Charge to Panels on Themes

• Wed/Thurs: Develop and discuss potential Themes • Thurs evening Plenary Present top choices (3 max)• Thurs PM: Executive will determine overall top 3

candidates• Friday AM breakouts by 3 candidate Themes:

develop further the strengths, possible scope, intersections with Panels, possible activities (e.g. Working Groups)

• Friday Friday late AM: Breakout reports• SSC Meeting Friday late AM: Identify new theme(s)

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

Example Areas for Themes Many of these are too broad, don’t restrict discussion to just these

• Climate and (marine?) ecosystems

• S/I Prediction of Tropical SSTs, including ENSO

• Climate Analysis of the Earth System

• Arctic climate changes/relationship to global system

• Carbon cycle diagnosis/prediction (with Carbon Cycle Science Program?)

• Extremes

• Climate and Aerosols (some activities underway within WCRP)

• Risk Assessment

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

Next Steps (post Summit)

• Develop prospectus for new Working Group(s) for consideration (later this year)

• Identify partnerships/linkages that need be established/nurtured… (USCPO and agencies can help)

• Summit 2010 to center around new theme …

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

Discussion• What more can/should CLIVAR lead with

regards to Drought? Scope of our efforts? – What follow-up activities will Panels take on? – Do we need another Working Group?– Do we just let other activities (Siegfried’s list)

continue and revisit Drought later…

• Themes– Sufficient motivation? – Attributes of a good Theme? – Desired outcomes clear?

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

What a US CLIVAR Theme Isn’t

• A means to stimulate and coordinate routine ongoing research activities without focus and without an expressed intent of desired outcomes

U.S

. C

LIV

AR

Pro

gra

mU

.S.

CLI

VA

R P

rog

ram

Theme Life-Cycle?

• Theme Identified

• Working Group(s) to initiate focused activities and hold community workshop

• Strategic Plan to carry on beyond WG