david saiget zigzag ranger district · 2005-10-21 · zigzag ranger district. bull run reserve...

58
Coastal Cutthroat trout Shoal Spawning in a high montane lake of the Cascade Range of Oregon David Saiget Mt. Hood National Forest Zigzag Ranger District

Upload: others

Post on 29-Jun-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Coastal Cutthroat trout Shoal Spawning in a high montane lake of

the Cascade Range of Oregon

David Saiget

Mt. Hood National Forest

Zigzag Ranger District

Page 2: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 3: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 4: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves as the drinking water supply for Portland metro area

Page 5: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 6: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 7: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

4.2 mile circumference - 486 ac

natural lake level fluctuation 12’/year

Page 8: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 9: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 10: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 11: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 12: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

As the headwater source for Portland-metro area drinking water, lake drawdown can occur in times of high water need which may have an affect on the fish population

Page 13: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Objectives:-determine extent of shoal spawning

Page 14: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

-collect spawner, redd, and fry counts

Page 15: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

-observe shoal spawning behavior

Page 16: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 17: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 18: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 19: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 20: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 21: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 22: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 23: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 24: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 25: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 26: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 27: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 28: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 29: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 30: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 31: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 32: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 33: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 34: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 35: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 36: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 37: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 38: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 39: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 40: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 41: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

low avg high (n=5)

050

100150200250300350400

# of Eggs in excavated tributary redds

Avg length of females 14-18 inches

Page 42: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

03-May07-May

11-May14-May

18-May21-May

24-May28-May

01-Jun05-Jun

09-Jun13-Jun

01020304050607080

Num

bers

N. Point & boat rampEast Isle

Snag Patch SW corner 4A shoal

Shoal spawner counts, 2003

Page 43: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

05

101520253035

No.

Fry

Experimental gravel Natural Road/pit run

Fry production by substrate type

Page 44: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

2.5 3.7 4.2 4.3 4.9 5.1 5.5 6 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.8 8.5 9

Depth, feet

05

10152025

3035

Fry production by Water depth

Page 45: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

07-M

ay12

-May

17-M

ay20

-May

24-M

ay29

-May

03-Ju

n08

-Jun

13-Ju

n18

-Jun

23-Ju

n28

-Jun

03-Ju

l08

-Jul

13-Ju

l18

-Jul

23-Ju

l28

-Jul

5

10

15

20

LakeTrib 4A

shoal ht of spawntrib ht of spawn

Shoal emergence Trib emergence

Lake vs. tributary water temperature

1st redds observed 1st fry observed

Page 46: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Conclusions

Page 47: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Warmer temperatures and earlier emergence

Page 48: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

may represent an advantage for shoal fry over tributary fry in the early growth stages

Page 49: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Limited spawning habitat in the tributaries may drive spawning in the shoals

Page 50: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Changes in lake surface elevation which prevent tributary accessmay force spawners to utilize the shoals

Page 51: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Shoal and tributary spawning may represent two divergent life histories

Page 52: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Absence of up- or down -welling, low DO’s, or poor substrates may be limiting fry production in shoal areas

Page 53: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Low productivity, oligotrophic nature of the lake may have in effect changed shoal spawning opportunities into feedingopportunities for many of these fish

Page 54: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Despite the high predation of eggs and less than optimal substrates, the presence of emergent fry in the shoal areas suggests that spawning in the shoals is a successful life history adaptation

Page 55: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

Funded by:

Mt. Hood National Forest

Zigzag Ranger District

City of Portland Water Bureau

Page 56: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves

1992 1994 1995 199510001300160019002200250028003100340037004000

Population Estimates from hydroacoustics

Page 57: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves
Page 58: David Saiget Zigzag Ranger District · 2005-10-21 · Zigzag Ranger District. Bull Run Reserve established in 1895 which closed public access in the Bull Run Watershed which serves