file:///Users/vincetodd/Desktop/CORA110111/Text31.htm[1/11/11 10:00:29 AM]

Dear Mr. Todd: Please find attached the department’s response to your Colorado Open Records Act request. Also attached are theresponsive documents outlined in the letter. Betsy HarrahParalegal and Records Liaison OfficerColorado Department of Public Health and EnvironmentOffice of Legal and Regulatory Affairs4300 Cherry Creek Drive SouthDenver, CO 80246303-692-2034

Vincent C. Todd Page 2 of2 January 10, 20 II to your broad requests for information concerning sodium fluoride tubes, attached are six documents maintained by the department which include

• Notes taken by Jeff Groff based upon responses he received to the survey you reference in your letter

• A 5/27110 email notification to the department from the Colorado Springs Police Department Metro Crime Lab regarding the sodium fluoride tubes

• An affidavit from Patricia Sulik, PhD • A 5/2811 0 email from Ian Fitch, PhD • A 6/111 0 emai l from Ian Fitch, PhD • Affidavit of Cynthia Burbach dated 611611 0

Additionally, the Colorado Springs Police Department Metro Crime Lab on January 6, 2011 provided three documents to the department that are a lso responsive to your request, which include

• Colorado Springs Police Department Metro Crime Laboratory Corrective Action Report* • Blood Alcohol Cases Affected by Monojet Tubes* • Affidavit of Ian Fitch, PhD dated 6/311 0

*Where these documents contain personally identifying information, that information has been redacted.

Contrary to your assertions, the department has not withhe ld documents, but has worked with due diligence to identify records that are responsive to your numerous requests. The department has fully responded in good faith to your repeated requests for these records. If you have further questions, I can be reached at (303) 692-3472 or ann.hause@state.co.us .

Sincerely,

Ann Hause Director Office of Legal and Regulatory Affairs

cc: Jeff Groff, Certification Progranl Manager, Laboratory Services Division, CDPHE Cindy Burbach, Toxicology Supervisor, Laboratory Services Division, CDPHE Joan Smith, Assistant Attorney General, Colorado Department of Law

From: "FITCH, Ian" <FITCHIA@ci.colospgs.co.us> To: "Jeff Groff" <jagroff@smtpgate.dphe.state.co.us> CC: "PILLARD, Kurtis V. (Cmdr.)" <PILLARKU@ci.colospgs.co.us> Date: 05/27/2010 9:44 AM Subject: Affidavit Attachments: RMLaffidavit.pdf Jeff, I wanted to give you an update on the new issue. Attached is Sulik's affidavit. I spoke to Grant Moen of AnsiProducts who supplies our blood kits, and sure enough the Microject tubes have only 25 mg NaF compared to 100 mg in the BD Vacutainer tubes. He told me that the Microject tubes were added to the kits in error, and basically admitted it was their mistake. He also told me that according to their records, approximately 50 kits were affected since February 2010. I am trying to identify the affected bloods. Upon reading the affidavit you can tell that this is really a CDPHE compliance issue, so I was wondering if someone at your end might be in a position to respond with a counter-report stating that while the Microject tubes are not compliant, they don't affect the BAC result. Unfortunately, I don't have any Chemists to respond to this challenge, so if you guys can help, I'd appreciate it. Thanks, and call me if you have any questions. Ian Ian Fitch, PhD Crime Lab Supervisor Metro Crime Laboratory Colorado Springs Police Department 705 South Nevada Avenue Colorado Springs, CO 80903 Tel: (719) 444 7799 Fax: (719) 482 7137

From: "FITCH, Ian" <FITCHIA@ci.colospgs.co.us> To: "Jeff Groff" <jagroff@smtpgate.dphe.state.co.us>, "Harold Wells" <hlwell... Date: 06/01/2010 11:33 AM Subject: RE: Microject tubes I just re-read some old emails I sent, and I have been referring to the non-compliant blood tubes as Microject tubes. My mistake, the non-compliant tubes are actually MONOJECT tubes. This email is just to set the record straight. No need to reply. Thanks, Ian Ian Fitch, PhD Crime Lab Supervisor Metro Crime Laboratory Colorado Springs Police Department 705 South Nevada Avenue Colorado Springs, CO 80903 Tel: (719) 444 7799 Fax: (719) 482 7137 -----Original Message----- From: FITCH, Ian Sent: Friday, May 28, 2010 9:05 AM To: 'Jeff Groff'; Harold Wells; Jennifer Richardson; Joel Fay; Cindy Burbach Subject: Microject tubes Hi Everyone, We have had another issue here in the lab pertaining to blood-alcohol analysis. I've discussed this with Jeff and Harold already. Bottom line is, the vendor that supplies our blood kits switched some blood tubes on us, replacing BD vacutainer tubes with Microject tubes. BD vacutainer tubes have 100 mg NaF, Microject tubes have only 25 mg, and so are not CDPHE compliant. The kits with the Microject tubes are in the minority, and I think I have identified most of them. However, it's possible that you guys may receive some blood samples from us in Microject tubes. If you do, or if you have already, please let me know the subject's name and DOB, etc. I need to let the DA's office know as soon as possible. You shouldn't see many of these tubes, but please let me know if you do. Thanks, Ian Ian Fitch, PhD Crime Lab Supervisor Metro Crime Laboratory Colorado Springs Police Department 705 South Nevada Avenue Colorado Springs, CO 80903 Tel: (719) 444 7799 Fax: (719) 482 7137

Corrective Action Report Form ver. 1.1 Page 1 of 3 Issued 09/16/08 Authorized by ITF

CAR# 008

Colorado Springs Police Department Metro Crime Laboratory Corrective Action Report

Initiator: Ian Fitch Incident or discovery date: May 25, 2010 Laboratory case number(s) affected (if applicable): Multiple CAR initiation date: May 27, 2010 CAR close-out date:________________ Description of non-conformance (to include how problem was discovered, effect on results or conclusions reported, other impact(s), etc.): 5/25/10 Dr. Fitch spoke with DUI Officer Christine Somersalmi about an affidavit from Rocky Mountain Labs stating our blood tubes did not comply with CDPHE guidelines. Apparently, BD Vacutainer tubes were replaced with Monoject tubes in some of our blood kits supplied by Ansci Products. RML measured the Sodium Fluoride (NaF ) concentration of a blood tube which came out to be 0.3% instead of >0.9%. Ian spoke with Grant Moen from Ansci Products who said that he remembers using the alternative tubes when BD were not available, and said he would email Dr. Fitch the specs on those tubes. Ian spoke to Cmdr. Pillard, CDPHE’s Howard Wells and Jeff Groff about this issue. The NaF is present to prevent bacterial growth. Dr. Fitch asked DNA analyst Sarah Brown to perform a literature search to determine the effects of lower NaF concentrations. 5/26/10 Grant Moen emailed Ian the specs on the Monoject tubes which shows that the Monoject have only 25 mg Sodium Fluoride compared to 100 mg in the BD Vacutainer tubes. He admitted the Monoject tubes should not have been placed in the kits, and offered to replace those kits. Ian responded, requesting more information so that we can define the scope of the issue. Moen stated that according to their records less than 50 kits contained the Monoject tubes in kits sent to our lab in February 2010. 5/27/10 Dr. Fitch went through all recent blood tubes in the BA fridge, and identified a total of 121 cases where blood was drawn into Monoject tubes. 5/28/10 Ian spoke with CDPHE’s Cynthia Burbach who stated that the NaF difference is a non-issue, and she’d be happy to testify to that effect, and has literature to support her opinion. Apparently, unless the subject was sick and had a high fever, the blood sample is unlikely to become infected such that fermentation occurs to produce endogenous ethanol. The NaF is added as a precaution, and while the CDPHE guideline states that blood samples should contain >0.9% NaF, it is not mandated. Cindy said that she and others in her lab have testified to this (non-)issue previously. 6/1/10

Corrective Action Report Form ver. 1.1 Page 2 of 3 Issued 09/16/08 Authorized by ITF

Office Specialist Jerry Gibson sent Dr. Fitch a worksheet that Dr. Fitch initiated with the 121 cases. Jerry, with volunteer Liza Romero’s help, added subject’s name, etc. Dr. Fitch asked Liza to double-check the cases by going through the boxes of stored blood samples. Liza identified one additional case, bringing the total to 122 (Note: in three cases, including #122, the Metro Crime Lab tested blood from a BD Vacutainer, but the second tube is a Monoject. In one case, the Metro Crime Lab tested from a Monoject, and the second tube is BD). 6/15/10 Dr. Fitch received a report from the CDPHE ( ), he suspected because the blood was drawn into a Monoject tube. The tube lot # on the Chain of Possession tube was 922607. Upon checking other Monoject tube cases, he confirmed this is the lot # of the Monoject tubes (Note: the tubes also have the number 352788 which may be written on the Chain of Possession instead). This represents case #123. Dr. Fitch emailed the DA’s office. Date/Initials: Dates above/ITF Root cause(s) (to include a description of any troubleshooting performed, and the investigative steps taken to identify the cause(s) of the problem): 5/27/10 The Metro Crime Laboratory has been using Ansci Products in Greeley, CO, to generate blood alcohol kits for a number of years. To our knowledge, they have always supplied the kits with BD Vacutainer tubes which contain 100 mg NaF and 20 mg Potassium Oxalate. These are the tubes specified in the lab’s Blood Manual. After speaking with Grant Moen, it is apparent that the company at some time in early 2010 had trouble getting the BD tubes and replaced them with Monoject tubes instead. These tubes have 25 mg NaF and 20 mg Potassium Oxalate. Both are grey-topped tubes. The company either failed to realize these tubes were not equivalent, or did not feel the lower NaF concentration was an issue. Grant Moen now understands that using Monoject tubes is unacceptable. The blood alcohol kits come in cardboard boxes containing plastic bags containing Styrofoam mailers containing two tubes. The kits also contain alcohol swabs and needle fixtures. The Metro Crime Lab has had no reason in the past to check these kits before taking them to the hospitals. Therefore, lab personnel were not aware that some kits contained Monoject tubes. The phlebotomists clearly just used the kits as usual. Dr. Fitch spoke with Senior Forensic Chemist Bobby Striebel 5/27/10 who has analyzed most of the 121 Monoject blood samples, and Bobby stated he had not noticed the change in tubes. Date/Initials: Dates above/ITF Description of Corrective Action Plan (to be completed following a discussion with the QAM, and TUL, if applicable): 5/27/10 The Metro Crime Lab needs to ensure that no more blood samples are drawn into Monoject tubes. Therefore, lab personnel will check each kit before it is taken to the hospitals. On 5/26/10, Dr. Fitch went to Memorial Central Hospital to ensure all kits at the hospital had BD tubes. None had the Monoject tubes. On 5/27/10, he did the same for the Memorial North Hospital. He identified seven kits with Monoject tubes and removed them. On 5/27/10, Dr. Fitch also emailed Lt. Buckley in charge of the CSPD DUI officers and told her to ensure that the phlebotomist(s) who deploys with the mobile blood alcohol vehicle ensure that they use kits with BD tubes.

Corrective Action Report Form ver. 1.1 Page 3 of 3 Issued 09/16/08 Authorized by ITF

According to lab records, 1000 blood alcohol kits were shipped to the lab in January or February 2010. Until all of these kits are depleted, lab personnel will check each kit for BD tubes before going to the hospital. 5/28/10 Cynthia Burbach sent Dr. Fitch the contact for the company the CPDHE use for their blood kits. As part of our corrective action plan, we will stop using Ansci Products once we have used up all of the kits we have, and switch to Therapak. 6/1/10 Dr. Fitch spoke with an officer from Teller County Sheriff’s Office and asked that he bring in all blood kits so that we can check them. He did so the following day. All 18 kits were fine. 6/3/10 Dr. Fitch emailed Lt. Buckley to ask that all kits in patrol vehicles, or elsewhere, be checked to ensure they contain BD Vacutainer tubes. Based on some literature Cynthia Burbach sent him, Dr. Fitch wrote an affidavit explaining why in his opinion the use on Monoject tubes should have no effect on the blood alcohol results. Dr. Fitch sent it to Officer Somersalmi for her DOR hearing. He also sent it to the DA’s office, who will forward it to all 122 subjects. Dr. Fitch also asked Ms. Burbach to write an affidavit. She agreed. 6/24/10 Cynthia Burbach emailed Dr. Fitch her affidavit addressing the sodium fluoride issue. Dr. Fitch forwarded it to the DA’s office and DUI Officer Christine Somersalmi. 9/21/10 Office Specialist Jerry Gibson started picking up Therapak kits from the CDPHE sometime in August. These will be used instead of Ansci Products’ kits from now on. CDPHE requests for the various agencies in El Paso County were sent to us by the CDPHE (as .pdfs), and binders containing these requests were placed in both Memorial Hospitals so that they can be filled out whenever blood is drawn for blood-alcohol analysis into the Therapak kits. Date/Initials: Dates above/ITF Discussion concerning the effectiveness of the corrective action following a period of monitoring the plan: Date/Initials:

Analyst (if applicable): _________________________________ Date:

Technical Unit Leader (if applicable): _____________________ Date:

Quality Assurance Manager:___________________________ Date:

Crime Lab Supervisor:_________________________________ Date:

From: "FITCH, Ian" <FITCHIA@ci.colospgs.co.us> To: "Jeff Groff" <jagroff@smtpgate.dphe.state.co.us>, "Harold Wells" <hlwell... Date: 05/28/2010 9:04 AM Subject: Microject tubes Hi Everyone, We have had another issue here in the lab pertaining to blood-alcohol analysis. I've discussed this with Jeff and Harold already. Bottom line is, the vendor that supplies our blood kits switched some blood tubes on us, replacing BD vacutainer tubes with Microject tubes. BD vacutainer tubes have 100 mg NaF, Microject tubes have only 25 mg, and so are not CDPHE compliant. The kits with the Microject tubes are in the minority, and I think I have identified most of them. However, it's possible that you guys may receive some blood samples from us in Microject tubes. If you do, or if you have already, please let me know the subject's name and DOB, etc. I need to let the DA's office know as soon as possible. You shouldn't see many of these tubes, but please let me know if you do. Thanks, Ian Ian Fitch, PhD Crime Lab Supervisor Metro Crime Laboratory Colorado Springs Police Department 705 South Nevada Avenue Colorado Springs, CO 80903 Tel: (719) 444 7799 Fax: (719) 482 7137 -----Original Message----- From: Jeff Groff [mailto:jagroff@smtpgate.dphe.state.co.us] Sent: Monday, May 24, 2010 2:35 PM To: FITCH, Ian; Harold Wells; Jennifer Richardson; Joel Fay; Cindy Burbach Subject: everyone's contact information CDPHE/LSD

Lab # Case/Summons # Agency Subject's Name DOB Analyst BAC10L-0280 2729472 Colorado Springs Police ROGERS, DEVIN M 9/5/1987 RJS 0.13810L-0307 2787405 Colorado Springs Police HALL, THOMAS B 3/19/1960 RJS 0.063 RETEST TO RML 05/04/1010L-0308 2791837 Colorado Springs Police BARNES, BRANDON M. 1/22/1993 RJS 0.22110L-0309 2723393 Colorado Springs Police PALMER, CHARLES W. 1/9/1991 RJS 0.200 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 03/11/1010L-0311 10-01975 Colorado Springs Police VAUGHAN, JAMES E. 9/3/1979 RJS .197, .179, .16210L-0312 10-03319 Fountain PD EHRIE III, ELMER E. 8/18/1957 RJS OVER .30010L-0314 10-01965 El Paso County S/O BURGE, BRENT D. 12/17/1979 RJS 0.14210L-0321 10-01976 Colorado Springs Police DIDION, MICHAEL J. 6/19/1985 RJS 0.245 RETEST TO COURIER PROCESS 03/18/1010L-0322 10-05730 Colorado Springs Police CLARK, JOHN 5/1/1972 RJS 0.07310L-0329 10-02069 Colorado Springs Police HOVASSE, CHRISTOPHER D. 2/25/1983 RJS OVER .30010L-0330 10-02264 El Paso County S/O VOLLMER, ELICIA R. 6/26/1992 RJS 0.03910L-0331 10-02173 Colorado Springs Police GILLEY, CODY ALLEN 8/21/1981 RJS 0.18510L-0332 10-02170 Colorado Springs Police VICKERS, RYAN LEE 3/12/1986 RJS 0.26010L-0333 2732000 Colorado Springs Police STEWART, ROBERT 8/9/1988 RJS 0.19510L-0334 10-02023 Colorado Springs Police HOOVER, BENSON W. 1/7/1980 RJS .229, .201, .17910L-0335 2799916 Colorado Springs Police HAGAN, ROXANNE 1/14/1989 RJS 0.02010L-0336 2792550 Colorado Springs Police CLAYTON, DANIEL P. 11/17/1979 RJS 0.18210L-0338 10-02154 El Paso County S/O RUGGLES, CLYDE E. 9/4/1982 RJS 0.13410L-0340 2730237 Colorado Springs Police DEHERRERA, DIANA M. 12/1/1982 STM 0.25810L-0342 2811943 Colorado Springs Police KIM, HYE YONNG 1/8/1978 STM 0.27410L-0343 10-02134 El Paso County S/O DIX, ELIZABETH G. 1/4/1982 STM 0.12610L-0344 2809086 Colorado Springs Police CLARK, CHRISTIAN A. 10/3/1986 STM 0.10010L-0345 2811949 Colorado Springs Police BARNS, JEREMY M. 4/21/1988 STM 0.21010L-0346 2802650 Colorado Springs Police SWEET, RANDAL S. 1/18/1985 STM 0.13310L-0347 10-02177 Colorado Springs Police RODRIGUEZ, JOSUE R. 2/7/1989 STM 0.21010L-0348 2729693 Colorado Springs Police HERNANDEZ, RICHARD T. 7/1/1977 STM 0.177 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 03/11/1010L-0349 2813827 Colorado Springs Police ESQUIVEL, JUAN A. 6/23/1986 STM 0.28610L-0351 2809110 Colorado Springs Police PERRY, BRANDIS M. 5/20/1983 STM 0.24910L-0358 10-02223 Colorado Springs Police CALO JR., WILLIAM 10/17/1983 STM 0.19510L-0359 10-04222 Fountain PD JIMENEZ, ABRAHAM J. 5/19/1971 STM 0.21210L-0360 2812005 Colorado Springs Police EPPINGHAUS, TRAVIS J. 8/31/1979 STM 0.28710L-0361 10-02260 Colorado Springs Police BRUSHWEIN, SCOTT D. 7/8/1992 STM 0.29210L-0362 2800024 Colorado Springs Police ABEL, MICHAEL T. 12/9/1984 STM 0.15710L-0363 10-06696 Colorado Springs Police ANWEILER, DENISE K. 6/4/1963 STM 0.26810L-0364 10-02219 Colorado Springs Police ELLIOT, ART R. 12/31/1952 RJS XXX INSUFFICIENT AMOUNT FOR ANALYSIS10L-0365 2787185 Colorado Springs Police PETROVIA, NICHOLAS 1/22/1983 RJS 0.20710L-0366 10-02515 El Paso County S/O VELASQUEZ, JAY D 10/12/1987 RJS 0.283

Blood Alcohol Cases Affected by Monoject Tubes (CAR #8)

Page 1 of 4

10L-0367 10-02290 Colorado Springs Police MORALES, RAFAEL A. 7/5/1957 RJS 0.26010L-0368* 2809664 Colorado Springs Police CAMPBELL, BARBARA E. 10/18/1982 RJS 0.116 (*First tube is BD, second tube is Monoject)10L-0369 10-02296 Colorado Springs Police MARTINEZ-SARMIENTO, JERONIM 9/30/1986 RJS 0.13310L-0370 10-02546 El Paso County S/O RODRIGUEZ, LARRY L. 4/4/1956 RJS 0.20110L-0371 2809495 Colorado Springs Police ROGERS, CARL R. 4/3/1984 RJS 0.04710L-0372 2787411 Colorado Springs Police WINEMILLER, SCOT E. 1/16/1962 RJS 0.13410L-0374 2808004 / 05 Colorado Springs Police EMUEL, DERAMUS D. (JOHN DOE 5/4/1980 RJS 0.17710L-0377 10-02293 Colorado Springs Police RAGGIO, MICHAEL 6/26/1979 RJS 0.26810L-0379 10-02315 Colorado Springs Police PFALMER, CHRISTINA M. 7/12/1979 RJS 0.25510L-0380 10-07142 Colorado Springs Police ROMERO, ROBERT A. 10/31/1986 RJS 0.18610L-0381 2787383 Colorado Springs Police ANAYA-SUAREZ, RAY 4/1/1987 RJS 0.26210L-0382 10-02327 Colorado Springs Police DAUBS, KENNETH M. 5/9/1981 RJS 0.23910L-0383 10-02330 Colorado Springs Police ARMSTRONG, JEFFERY M. 8/2/1988 RJS 0.16010L-0384 2810152 Colorado Springs Police PEREZ-LUJAN, SABAS R. 1/10/1962 RJS 0.05310L-0386 10-07235 Colorado Springs Police ERRERA-AVILA, SALVADOR 8/17/1987 RJS 0.22510L-0387 10-02579 El Paso County S/O VANCE, BRANDON S. NOT ON COC RJS OVER .30010L-0388 10-07349 Colorado Springs Police BISHOP, JENNIFER A. 12/10/1983 RJS 0.20610L-0425 10-02384 Colorado Springs Police DUNN, WALTER V. 5/11/1987 RJS 0.24010L-0426 10-07595 Colorado Springs Police DAVIS, FRANGESCA 8/1/1960 RJS 0.17610L-0427 10-07573 Colorado Springs Police BILLINGSLEY, CRYSTAL D. 1/13/1973 RJS 0.17410L-0428 10-07574 Colorado Springs Police CALIP, KEITH D. 3/11/1979 RJS 0.21110L-0429 10-07715 Colorado Springs Police COUSIND, DEVIN J. 1/6/1988 RJS 0.13110L-0430 A57289 El Paso County S/O JOHNSON, STEVEN D. 5/22/1980 RJS 0.16510L-0431 10-02353 Colorado Springs Police NEWELL, JAMES D. 11/18/1985 RJS 0.14310L-0432 10-02369 Colorado Springs Police MARLER, DOUGLAS W. 4/14/1961 RJS 0.210 RETEST TO RML 04/06/1010L-0433 10-07553 Colorado Springs Police CARTER, KATHLEEN E. 1/9/1970 RJS 0.223 RETEST TO COLORADO PRO COURIERS 3/16/1010L-0434 10-07470 Colorado Springs Police SPIEGELBERG, BECKY M. 8/11/1986 RJS 0.15110L-0435 10-07571 Colorado Springs Police VARELA III, PABLO 10/28/1972 RJS 0.22610L-0436 10-07787 Colorado Springs Police ELLIS, KAREN RAE 12/7/1962 RJS 0.109 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 04/13/1010L-0437 10-07712 Colorado Springs Police ROTGUN, JASON R. 1/27/1970 RJS 0.14510L-0438 10-02440 Colorado Springs Police STEPHANY, LOGAN K. 9/22/1986 RJS 0.11710L-0439 10-02417 Colorado Springs Police RIVARD, RYAN S. 12/13/1988 RJS 0.19610L-0440 10-07814 Colorado Springs Police FIGUEROAJEDA, CARLOS M. 5/2/1972 RJS 0.20310L-0441 10-05104 Fountain PD BYELICK, DANIELLE E. 12/28/1988 RJS 0.20210L-0442 10-07808 Colorado Springs Police CROMER, STEVEN H. 8/13/1962 RJS 0.17910L-0443 10-07818 Colorado Springs Police CARTAGENA, ROBERTO 11/18/1980 RJS 0.10510L-0444 10-07804 Colorado Springs Police WOOD, ROBERT CHAD 7/1/1986 RJS 0.223 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 04/13/1010L-0445 10-07907 Colorado Springs Police COMBS, CHANDA C. 11/23/1978 RJS 0.20810L-0446 10-07956 Colorado Springs Police LONGFELLOW, ROBERT S. 6/2/1951 RJS OVER .300 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 4/13/1010L-0447 10-02463 Colorado Springs Police LOTZER, TRAVIS L. 6/17/1988 RJS 0.133

Page 2 of 4

10L-0448 10-02468 Colorado Springs Police SHAVER, ALAN D. 3/25/1984 RJS 0.25510L-0449 10-07973 Colorado Springs Police LACHAT, JOSEPH J. 12/20/1952 RJS 0.11810L-0451 10-02857 El Paso County S/O PORTNOVA, NICOLE M. 3/3/1982 RJS 0.13010L-0452 10-07998 El Paso County S/O GONZALES, EDWARD 2/2/1974 RJS 0.23810L-0453 A58211 El Paso County S/O SOLIS, JULIAN 5/25/1974 RJS 0.24310L-0478 10-08450 Colorado Springs Police HAIZLIP, ERICA NICHOLE 6/16/1984 RJS 0.15210L-0521* 10-02702 Colorado Springs Police JOHNSON, ELIZABETH ANN 1/16/1988 STM 0.195 (*First tube is BD, second tube is Monoject)10L-0545 10-09765 Colorado Springs Police HOPKINS, AUSTIN L. 7/4/1979 RJS 0.05310L-0549 10-02850 Colorado Springs Police HORN, CHRISTOPHER A. 7/1/1986 RJS 0.04910L-0559 10-09957 Colorado Springs Police WOLFSWINKEL, CAROLE C. 12/8/1937 RJS 0.22410L-0561 10-09979 Colorado Springs Police MIRANDA, FRANCO E. 5/29/1990 RJS 0.12210L-0562 A57571 El Paso County S/O HOLT, ANDREW D. NOT ON COC RJS 0.146 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 5/4/10

10L-0564** 10-02906 Colorado Springs Police BULLOCK, ANDREW 8/31/1969 RJS 0.205 (**First tube is Monoject, second tube is BD)10L-0568 10-10103 Colorado Springs Police CRUMRINE, JUSTIN B. 4/18/1987 RJS 0.18710L-0574 10-02927 Colorado Springs Police LASZAR, PAUL J. 8/10/1979 STM 0.186 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 4/20/1010L-0575 10-02929 Colorado Springs Police GORDON, KEVIN E. 2/19/1956 STM NEGATIVE10L-0612 10-10322 Colorado Springs Police ALEY-NEWBERRY-RIEHL, JEREMY 5/31/1984 STM 0.26610L-0613 10-02970 Colorado Springs Police MCHENRY, MICHAEL EDWARD 3/15/1965 STM 0.30010L-0614 10-10430 Colorado Springs Police MALUCHNIK, KRIS ALLEN 5/16/1976 STM 0.287 RETEST TO COURIER PROCESS 05/18/1010L-0615 10-10569 Colorado Springs Police ACKER, ROBERT LLOYD 8/16/1982 STM 0.22410L-0616 10-10564 Colorado Springs Police PETERS, BRIAN LEE 8/30/1960 STM 0.21010L-0621 10-10573 Colorado Springs Police SOTO, GONZALO 10/17/1988 STM 0.10410L-0622 10-10836 Colorado Springs Police AMBUEHL, CORY P. 3/20/1973 STM 0.21810L-0623 10-03044 Colorado Springs Police INSKEEP, JOSHUA C. 4/19/1980 STM 0.213 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 05/11/201010L-0624 10-10942 Colorado Springs Police HEATON, PATRICIA M. 12/31/1968 RJS OVER .30010L-0627 10-03003 Colorado Springs Police OHLSEN-GARCIA, NATALIE C. 5/29/1980 RJS .202, .179, .15410L-0630 10-03015 Colorado Springs Police NICHOLS, JOHN A. 2/21/1985 RJS 0.11910L-0632* 10-03037 Colorado Springs Police STODDARD, EDWARD E. 3/31/1954 RJS 0.174 (*First tube is BD, second tube is Monoject)10L-0634 10-10842 Colorado Springs Police BALBUENA-GARCIA, ARMANDO 7/20/1971 RJS 0.21110L-0635 10-10832 Colorado Springs Police HODGDON, JULIE D. 3/15/1974 RJS 0.22610L-0636 10-10843 Colorado Springs Police ROSADO, CARLOS 4/3/2010 RJS 0.214 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 05/11/201010L-0637 10-03040 Colorado Springs Police CHAMBERS, JONATHAN BRANDO 5/2/1979 RJS 0.26110L-0639 10-10940 Colorado Springs Police QUINTANA, ISRAEL 6/5/1986 RJS 0.23310L-0641 10-10950 Colorado Springs Police MARTINEZ, ANNETTE 5/13/1986 RJS 0.16610L-0645 10-04046 El Paso County S/O ROUSH, JOHN F. 11/16/1958 RJS 0.110 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 05/18/201010L-0646 10-03042 Colorado Springs Police CHOI, BRIAN 8/16/1987 RJS 0.22110L-0647 10-03048 Colorado Springs Police LEHR, BRETT C. 8/25/1972 RJS 0.13510L-0658 10-11252 Colorado Springs Police MANZANARES, MARCUS R. 9/6/1986 RJS 0.11810L-0659 10-04188 Colorado Springs Police IANITELLI, KERRY J. 6/5/1979 RJS 0.134 RETEST TO CHEMATOX 06/01/201010L-0665 10-04242 El Paso County S/O BAILEY, GRANVIL P. 10/8/1984 RJS 0.112

Page 3 of 4

10L-0672 10-11597 Colorado Springs Police BALENTINE, SHANE W. 8/12/1976 RJS 0.15610L-0690 10-11721 Colorado Springs Police WESLEY JR., WILLIE 6/14/1964 RJS 0.15010L-0691 10-03195 Colorado Springs Police WILLIAMS JR., DAVID B. 4/10/1987 RJS 0.12010L-0704 10-12194 Colorado Springs Police MALLON, BRIANNE R. 4/10/1989 STM 0.11910L-0758 10-12978 Colorado Springs Police WILLIAMS, DEEDEE M. 4/9/1982 RJS 0.22210L-0823 10-0209 Monument PD NORTON, KENT E. 2/13/1965 Fay 0.256 Worked by CDPHE (worked by Bobby in last batch,

but was not reviewed. Bobby's result was 0.247)

Page 4 of 4