defend the right to free speech - sacc

1
MOAZZAM BEGG (former Guantanamo Bay detainee) “An avid defender of others’ rights is being forced to take the stand for attempting to defend his client. ‘Going for the lawyer’ is something I’ve seen happening in Guantanamo. I didn’t expect it would be happening in Britain too. I urge all fair- minded people in this country to stand with Aamer Anwar in solidarity for the sake of justice and freedom.” CHHOKAR FAMILY JUSTICE CAMPAIGN (Darshan Chhokar, Gurdev Kaur Chhokar PICTURED, Manjit Kaur, and Professor Phil Taylor) “Aamer is an honest and dignified professional who simply stands up and speaks out for those who are vulnerable against the system. He shouldn’t be punished for helping others.” ALEX NEIL SNP, JAMIE HEPBURN SNP, IAN McKEE SNP, MARGO McDONALD INDEPENDENT, CHRISTINE GRAHAME SNP, SANDRA WHITE SNP, AND ELAINE SMITH LABOUR PARTY (MSPS) “We are deeply concerned that Aamer Anwar is facing contempt of court. Conviction would set a dangerous precedent, threatening the ability of lawyers to speak out against perceptions of injustice in the interests of their clients. The Scottish judicial system is, and should be, robust enough to tolerate and absorb such criticism” LOUISE CHRISTIAN (human rights lawyer) “In a democratic society lawyers must have freedom of expression. Aamer Anwar is a dedicated campaigning lawyer who should not be subjected to this pressure on his professional career.” IAIN BANKS (author) “Aamer Anwar is a symbol of freedom. There is a need to speak out when the right to dissent and the right to speak the truths that need to be spoken are under threat. I’d urge anyone who believes in fairness and simple human decency to support him. The Scottish judicial system has enough to be ashamed of after the Lockerbie trial; let there be no more injustice in its name.” OPEN LETTER SIGNATORIES: Ahmed Ceesay, Refugee Legal Centre; Anne Gray, CAMPACC and Green Party (personal capacity); Alastair Lyon, Birnberg Pierce & Partners (solicitor, London); Alex Neil, Scottish Nationalist Party (MSP); Andrew Fullwood, EIS (council p/c, Glasgow); Angela Jackman, Fisher Meredith LLP Solicitors (partner and joint head of dept); Angie Zelter, peace and environmental campaigner; Ayesha Siddique, sister of Mohammed Atif Siddique; Bashir Ahmad, Scottish Nationalist Party (MSP); Bashir Mann, Muslim Council of Scotland (convenor); Beth Junor, writer; Bill Wilson, Scottish Nationalist Party (MSP); Caroline Austin, National Union of Journalists (London); Chris Nineham, Stop the War Coalition (national officer); Christopher Helm, Princes Park Labour Party (Liverpool); Colin Fox, Scottish Socialist Party; David Ferrard, singer-songwriter; Des Loughney, Edinburgh Trade Union Council; Dr Dora Scholarios, University of Strathclyde; Dr Eileen Berrington, Amnesty International (Scotland); Dr Eileen Berrington, Amnesty International and Manchester Metropolitan University (senior lecturer in criminology); Dr Geoff Whittham, University of Paisley; Dr Gerry Mooney, The Open University; Dr John McKernan, University of Glasgow; Dr John Welford, NO2ID (Edinburgh); Dr Jonathan Charley, University of Strathclyde; Dr Kirsty Newsome, University of Strathclyde; Dr Marion Hersh, University of Glasgow, University & College Union (national exec p/c); Dr Mark Cowling, University of Teeside (reader in criminology, school of social sciences and law, Cleveland); Dr Patricia McCafferty, University of Strathclyde; Dr Sacha Darke, University of Westminster; Dr Shafi Kauser, Glasgow Central Mosque (general secretary); Dr Susan Blackwell, University & College Union (national exec p/c); Duncan McLaren, Friends of the Earth Scotland (chief executive p/c); Eileen Pembridge, Fisher Meredith LLP (solicitor; senior partner; dept head, London); Eniola Adewale (Glasgow); Frances Webber, Garden Court Chambers (London); Gary Kelly, HIV blood tranfusion group (Glasgow); George Galloway (MP); Graham Campbell, African & Caribbean Network (chair p/c); Hassan Ghani, Islam Channel News; Hugh Kerr, Member of the European Parliament 1994-99; Humza Yousaf (Glasgow); Iain Banks, writer; Imran Khan (solicitor; partner, London); Jamie Hepburn, Scottish Nationalist Party (MSP); Jane Tallents, G8 legal support group in 2005; Jim Bollan, Scottish Socialist Party (councillor, West Dunbartonshire); Jim Mackechnie, Labour Party (councillor, Glasgow); Jim Taggart, Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (national exec p/c); Jock Morris, Glasgow Campaign to Welcome Refugees (chair); John McManus, Miscarriages of Justice Organisation (coordinator, Scotland); Keir McKechnie, Glasgow Stop the War Coalition (secretary); Keith Hammond, University of Glasgow; Khadijah Aadam, Muslim Prisoner Support Group; Lindsay German, Stop the War Coalition (national convener); Liz Davies, Haldane Society of Socialist Lawyers (chair); Lorraine Barrie, Govan Law Centre (associate solicitor); Maggie Dickson, Govan Law Centre (associate solicitor); Margaret Gordon, Christian Khan Solicitors (partner); Marion Snee, Unison (steward, Dundee); Mark Brown, theatre critic; Mark Golding, Children Of Iraq Association (Buckinghamshire); Massoud Shadhareh, Islamic Human Rights Commission (chair); Mick Napier, Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign; Mike Arnott, Dundee TUC; Mike Haseler, scottishhumanrights.org.uk; Moazzam Begg, former Guantanamo Bay detainee and spokesperson for Cageprisoners; Mohammad Naveen Asif, Scottish Afghan Society (president); Mohammed Sarwar, Labour Party (MP); Muddassar Arani, Arani & Co (solicitor, London); Nahella Ashraf, Greater Manchester Stop the War Coalition (chair); Nicola Fisher, Glasgow Stop the War Coalition (chair); Phil McGarry, RMT Scotland (regional organiser p/c); Prem Sikka, Association for Accountancy & Business Affairs (London); Professor Chris Baldry, University of Stirling; Professor David Miller, University of Strathclyde; Professor Frank Land, London School of Economics; Professor Gargi Bhattacharyya (West Midlands); Professor Jeff Hyman, University of Aberdeen; Professor Lindsay Farmer, University of Glasgow; Professor Mike Gonzales, University of Glasgow; Professor Phil Scraton, Queen’s University (Belfast); Professor Paul Stewart, University of Strathclyde; Professor R H Gray (Fife); Rev Hugh Drummond (Edinburgh); Richard Haley, Scotland Against Criminalising Communities (secretary); Robina Qureshi, Positive Action in Housing (director, Glasgow); Rowena Arshad, Centre for Education for Racial Equality in Scotland (p/c); Safia Ali, Pollokshields Development Agency (manager); Saghir Hussain, Johns & Saggar Solicitors (crime and prison law dept head, London); Samuel Tarry, London Young Labour (chair); Sandra White, Scottish Nationalist Party (MSP); Sean McLoughlin, TRP Solicitors (partner, Birmingham); Sean Wallis, University & College Union (secretary, University College London); Shirley-Ann Somerville, Scottish Nationalist Party (MSP); Susan Nash, ACLU Amnesty International and Human Rights Watch (USA); Tam Dean Burn; Tom Leonard, poet and author; Tommy Sheridan, Solidarity (co-convenor, MSP between 1999-07); Tony Benn, Stop the War Coalition (president); Tina McGreevy (solicitor); Wendy Pearman, Trident Ploughshares … GARETH PIERCE (solicitor who defended the Birmingham Six) “It is a sad and dangerous day for our country if a lawyer who sees injustice cannot say so loud and clear.” PROFESSOR LINDSAY FARMER (University of Glasgow school of law) “It is vital to the practice and success of democracy that lawyers and others are able to comment freely and critically on the conduct of court cases.” KENNY ROSS (Fire Brigades Union, Scotland) “It is the fundamental right of any citizen in a free society to voice their opinion, whether that is in the letters page of a newspaper, a parliamentary chamber, or on the steps of a court. It is vital for the sake of us all who cherish our freedoms that the case against Aamer Anwar is not only defeated but crushed.” ROSE GENTLE (Military Families Against War) “Aamer Anwar has fought injustice for years, in many campaigns, and has been a leader of the anti-war movement in Scotland. Nobody else will fight harder to represent your interests.” PADDY HILL (Birmingham Six) “As one of the Birmingham Six, beaten and tortured and wrongfully imprisoned for 17 years, I understand the importance of individuals who defend human rights. In a world where more people are seen as suspects, the need for human rights lawyers has never been more crucial.” OSAMA SAEED (Muslim Association of Britain, Scotland) “This process is a waste of time and resources. I don’t know anyone who was calling for Aamer’s blood after what he said. He enjoys enormous support from ordinary people who can see a witch-hunt here and are rankled by yet another double standard on free speech.” MOHAMMAD Atif Siddique was sentenced to eight years in prison for terrorism offences in October 2007. Irrespective of the differing views on the outcome of the case, the criticism levelled towards Mr Siddique’s solicitor, Aamer Anwar, over a statement he released on the day of the verdict is disturbing. Aamer was accused of showing disrespect to the judge, the jury, and the court, and is to face a contempt of court hearing with three High Court judges on April 29 and 30, 2008. This is deeply worrying and is an unprecedented attack on the principle of freedom of speech. Aamer has earned a reputation as one of the most prominent human rights lawyers in Scotland. He represented the Chhokar family in their long struggle for justice and has diligently defended asylum-seekers. Victims of the ‘war on terror’— people accused of terrorism but eventually proved innocent of all charges—have also been represented by him. In 2005, he helped negotiate a way to the G8 Summit at Gleneagles and defended demonstrators who were arrested during the protests. Following the collapse of the World’s End trial, the Lord Advocate stressed the importance of the independence of the judiciary and prosecution. Equally as important is an independent defence, which is often all that stands between the accused and the state. We might not always agree with Aamer but he is part of a rich and important tradition of campaigning lawyers that speak without ‘fear or favour’. A lawyer’s job is to represent their clients to the best of their ability—regardless of the crimes of which they are accused. All those who campaign against injustice and for a better world know that one day they may have to face the state in a courtroom. Everyone should be worried if the effect of this case is to make lawyers reluctant to carry out this work for fear of the possibility of repercussions. We, the undersigned, believe that the current attack on Aamer Anwar is an attack on the fundamental right of all lawyers to represent their clients. Open letter in support of Aamer Anwar ASIF SIDDIQUE (elder brother of Atif Siddique) “The Siddique family are angered and appalled at this attack on Aamer Anwar. It is an attempt to silence this courageous lawyer. The statement made outside Glasgow’s High Court last year was the view of Atif Siddique and our family. We stand shoulder to shoulder with Aamer. It is time to stand up and defend those who defend our civil liberties. DEFEND THE RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH Defend civil liberties Show your support and assemble outside the High Court in Edinburgh at 9.30am on Tuesday 29 April. For more information email [email protected] Advert produced by Defend Aamer Anwar Campaign. For the list of signatories (and to add your name) visit www.sacc.org.uk/aameranwar ADVERTISEMENT

Upload: others

Post on 03-Jan-2022

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DEFEND THE RIGHT TO FREE SPEECH - SACC

MOAZZAM BEGG (formerGuantanamo Bay detainee)“An avid defender ofothers’ rights is beingforced to take the stand forattempting to defend hisclient. ‘Going for the lawyer’

is something I’ve seen happening inGuantanamo. I didn’t expect it would behappening in Britain too. I urge all fair-minded people in this country to standwith Aamer Anwar in solidarity for thesake of justice and freedom.”

CHHOKAR FAMILYJUSTICE CAMPAIGN(Darshan Chhokar,Gurdev Kaur ChhokarPICTURED, Manjit Kaur,and Professor PhilTaylor) “Aamer is an

honest and dignified professional whosimply stands up and speaks out for thosewho are vulnerable against the system. Heshouldn’t be punished for helping others.”

ALEX NEIL SNP, JAMIE HEPBURN SNP, IANMcKEE SNP, MARGO McDONALD INDEPENDENT,CHRISTINE GRAHAME SNP, SANDRA WHITE SNP,AND ELAINE SMITH LABOUR PARTY (MSPS) “Weare deeply concerned that Aamer Anwar isfacing contempt of court. Conviction wouldset a dangerous precedent, threatening theability of lawyers to speak out againstperceptions of injustice in the interests oftheir clients. The Scottish judicial system is,and should be, robust enough to tolerateand absorb such criticism”

LOUISE CHRISTIAN (humanrights lawyer) “In ademocratic society lawyersmust have freedom ofexpression. Aamer Anwar isa dedicated campaigninglawyer who should not be

subjected to this pressure on hisprofessional career.”

IAIN BANKS (author) “AamerAnwar is a symbol offreedom. There is a need tospeak out when the right todissent and the right tospeak the truths that need tobe spoken are under threat.

I’d urge anyone who believes in fairnessand simple human decency to support him.The Scottish judicial system has enough tobe ashamed of after the Lockerbie trial; letthere be no more injustice in its name.”

OPEN LETTER SIGNATORIES: Ahmed Ceesay, RefugeeLegal Centre; Anne Gray, CAMPACC and Green Party(personal capacity); Alastair Lyon, Birnberg Pierce &Partners (solicitor, London); Alex Neil, ScottishNationalist Party (MSP); Andrew Fullwood, EIS (councilp/c, Glasgow); Angela Jackman, Fisher Meredith LLPSolicitors (partner and joint head of dept); Angie Zelter,peace and environmental campaigner; AyeshaSiddique, sister of Mohammed Atif Siddique; BashirAhmad, Scottish Nationalist Party (MSP); Bashir Mann,Muslim Council of Scotland (convenor); Beth Junor,writer; Bill Wilson, Scottish Nationalist Party (MSP);Caroline Austin, National Union of Journalists (London);Chris Nineham, Stop the War Coalition (nationalofficer); Christopher Helm, Princes Park Labour Party(Liverpool); Colin Fox, Scottish Socialist Party; DavidFerrard, singer-songwriter; Des Loughney, EdinburghTrade Union Council; Dr Dora Scholarios, University ofStrathclyde; Dr Eileen Berrington, AmnestyInternational (Scotland); Dr Eileen Berrington, AmnestyInternational and Manchester Metropolitan University(senior lecturer in criminology); Dr Geoff Whittham,University of Paisley; Dr Gerry Mooney, The OpenUniversity; Dr John McKernan, University of Glasgow;Dr John Welford, NO2ID (Edinburgh); Dr JonathanCharley, University of Strathclyde; Dr Kirsty Newsome,University of Strathclyde; Dr Marion Hersh, University

of Glasgow, University & College Union (national execp/c); Dr Mark Cowling, University of Teeside (reader incriminology, school of social sciences and law,Cleveland); Dr Patricia McCafferty, University ofStrathclyde; Dr Sacha Darke, University ofWestminster; Dr Shafi Kauser, Glasgow CentralMosque (general secretary); Dr Susan Blackwell,University & College Union (national exec p/c); DuncanMcLaren, Friends of the Earth Scotland (chiefexecutive p/c); Eileen Pembridge, Fisher Meredith LLP(solicitor; senior partner; dept head, London); EniolaAdewale (Glasgow); Frances Webber, Garden CourtChambers (London); Gary Kelly, HIV blood tranfusiongroup (Glasgow); George Galloway (MP); GrahamCampbell, African & Caribbean Network (chair p/c);Hassan Ghani, Islam Channel News; Hugh Kerr,Member of the European Parliament 1994-99; HumzaYousaf (Glasgow); Iain Banks, writer; Imran Khan(solicitor; partner, London); Jamie Hepburn, ScottishNationalist Party (MSP); Jane Tallents, G8 legalsupport group in 2005; Jim Bollan, Scottish SocialistParty (councillor, West Dunbartonshire); JimMackechnie, Labour Party (councillor, Glasgow); JimTaggart, Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament (nationalexec p/c); Jock Morris, Glasgow Campaign toWelcome Refugees (chair); John McManus,Miscarriages of Justice Organisation (coordinator,

Scotland); Keir McKechnie, Glasgow Stop the WarCoalition (secretary); Keith Hammond, University ofGlasgow; Khadijah Aadam, Muslim Prisoner SupportGroup; Lindsay German, Stop the War Coalition(national convener); Liz Davies, Haldane Society ofSocialist Lawyers (chair); Lorraine Barrie, Govan LawCentre (associate solicitor); Maggie Dickson, GovanLaw Centre (associate solicitor); Margaret Gordon,Christian Khan Solicitors (partner); Marion Snee,Unison (steward, Dundee); Mark Brown, theatre critic;Mark Golding, Children Of Iraq Association(Buckinghamshire); Massoud Shadhareh, IslamicHuman Rights Commission (chair); Mick Napier,Scottish Palestine Solidarity Campaign; Mike Arnott,Dundee TUC; Mike Haseler, scottishhumanrights.org.uk;Moazzam Begg, former Guantanamo Bay detainee andspokesperson for Cageprisoners; Mohammad NaveenAsif, Scottish Afghan Society (president); MohammedSarwar, Labour Party (MP); Muddassar Arani, Arani &Co (solicitor, London); Nahella Ashraf, GreaterManchester Stop the War Coalition (chair); NicolaFisher, Glasgow Stop the War Coalition (chair); PhilMcGarry, RMT Scotland (regional organiser p/c); PremSikka, Association for Accountancy & Business Affairs(London); Professor Chris Baldry, University ofStirling; Professor David Miller, University ofStrathclyde; Professor Frank Land, London School of

Economics; Professor Gargi Bhattacharyya (WestMidlands); Professor Jeff Hyman, University ofAberdeen; Professor Lindsay Farmer, University ofGlasgow; Professor Mike Gonzales, University ofGlasgow; Professor Phil Scraton, Queen’s University(Belfast); Professor Paul Stewart, University ofStrathclyde; Professor R H Gray (Fife); Rev HughDrummond (Edinburgh); Richard Haley, ScotlandAgainst Criminalising Communities (secretary);Robina Qureshi, Positive Action in Housing (director,Glasgow); Rowena Arshad, Centre for Education forRacial Equality in Scotland (p/c); Safia Ali,Pollokshields Development Agency (manager);Saghir Hussain, Johns & Saggar Solicitors (crime andprison law dept head, London); Samuel Tarry, LondonYoung Labour (chair); Sandra White, ScottishNationalist Party (MSP); Sean McLoughlin, TRPSolicitors (partner, Birmingham); Sean Wallis,University & College Union (secretary, UniversityCollege London); Shirley-Ann Somerville, ScottishNationalist Party (MSP); Susan Nash, ACLU AmnestyInternational and Human Rights Watch (USA); TamDean Burn; Tom Leonard, poet and author; TommySheridan, Solidarity (co-convenor, MSP between1999-07); Tony Benn, Stop the War Coalition(president); Tina McGreevy (solicitor); Wendy Pearman,Trident Ploughshares …

GARETH PIERCE (solicitor who defended theBirmingham Six) “It is a sad and dangerousday for our country if a lawyer who seesinjustice cannot say so loud and clear.”

PROFESSOR LINDSAY FARMER (Universityof Glasgow school of law) “It is vital to thepractice and success of democracy thatlawyers and others are able to comment freelyand critically on the conduct of court cases.”

KENNY ROSS (Fire BrigadesUnion, Scotland) “It is thefundamental right of anycitizen in a free society tovoice their opinion, whetherthat is in the letters page of anewspaper, a parliamentarychamber, or on the steps of acourt. It is vital for the sakeof us all who cherish ourfreedoms that the caseagainst Aamer Anwar is notonly defeated but crushed.”

ROSE GENTLE (MilitaryFamilies Against War) “AamerAnwar has fought injusticefor years, in manycampaigns, and has been aleader of the anti-warmovement in Scotland.

Nobody else will fight harder to representyour interests.”

PADDY HILL (BirminghamSix) “As one of theBirmingham Six, beaten andtortured and wrongfullyimprisoned for 17 years, Iunderstand the importanceof individuals who defend

human rights. In a world where more peopleare seen as suspects, the need for humanrights lawyers has never been more crucial.”

OSAMA SAEED (MuslimAssociation of Britain,Scotland) “This process is awaste of time and resources.I don’t know anyone whowas calling for Aamer’sblood after what he said. He

enjoys enormous support from ordinarypeople who can see a witch-hunt here andare rankled by yet another double standardon free speech.”

MOHAMMAD AtifSiddique wassentenced to eightyears in prison forterrorism offences in

October 2007. Irrespective of thediffering views on the outcome of thecase, the criticism levelled towardsMr Siddique’s solicitor, Aamer Anwar,over a statement he released on theday of the verdict is disturbing.

Aamer was accused of showingdisrespect to the judge, the jury, andthe court, and is to face a contemptof court hearing with three High Courtjudges on April 29 and 30, 2008.

This is deeply worrying and is anunprecedented attack on the principleof freedom of speech.

Aamer has earned a reputation asone of the most prominent humanrights lawyers in Scotland. Herepresented the Chhokar family intheir long struggle for justice and hasdiligently defended asylum-seekers.

Victims of the ‘war on terror’—people accused of terrorism buteventually proved innocent of allcharges—have also been representedby him.

In 2005, he helped negotiate a way

to the G8 Summit at Gleneagles anddefended demonstrators who werearrested during the protests.

Following the collapse of theWorld’s End trial, the Lord Advocatestressed the importance of theindependence of the judiciary andprosecution. Equally as important isan independent defence, which isoften all that stands between theaccused and the state.

We might not always agree withAamer but he is part of a rich andimportant tradition of campaigninglawyers that speak without ‘fear orfavour’. A lawyer’s job is to representtheir clients to the best of theirability—regardless of the crimes ofwhich they are accused.

All those who campaign againstinjustice and for a better world knowthat one day they may have to facethe state in a courtroom. Everyoneshould be worried if the effect of thiscase is to make lawyers reluctant tocarry out this work for fear of thepossibility of repercussions.

We, the undersigned, believe thatthe current attack on Aamer Anwar isan attack on the fundamental right ofall lawyers to represent their clients.

Open letter in support of Aamer Anwar

ASIF SIDDIQUE (elder brother of AtifSiddique) “The Siddique family are angeredand appalled at this attack on AamerAnwar. It is an attempt to silence thiscourageous lawyer. The statement madeoutside Glasgow’s High Court last year wasthe view of Atif Siddique and our family. Westand shoulder to shoulder with Aamer. It istime to stand up and defend those whodefend our civil liberties.

DEFEND THE RIGHT TO FREE SPEECHDefend civil liberties

Show your support and assemble outside the High Court in Edinburgh at 9.30am on Tuesday 29 April. For more information email [email protected] produced by Defend Aamer Anwar Campaign. For the list of signatories (and to add your name) visit www.sacc.org.uk/aameranwar

ADVERTISEMENT