defend the right to protest
DESCRIPTION
After the crackdown on protesters after the mass student demonstrations in 2010 and 2011, Revolution examines why it is so important to defend our democratic right to protest.TRANSCRIPT
REVOLUTION is an international socialist youth group. We are against capitalism and the war, poverty and climate chaos it creates. The rich and powerful clique responsible for slashing our public services, privatising education and throwing millions on the dole won’t give up their wealth and privilege by being voted out. They are launching a class war to make youth and workers pay the cost of capitalism’s crisis. We want to seize their wealth and abolish class society through a socialist revolution. This is what we are fighting for. www.socialistrevolution.org
Defend the right to
protest
Five articles
REVOLUTION PRESS
BRITAIN 2012
Cover art by RB
Layup by ChewDesigns
CONTENTSCONTENTSCONTENTSCONTENTS
[[[[PAGE 1]PAGE 1]PAGE 1]PAGE 1] INTRODUCTION
[PAGE 2][PAGE 2][PAGE 2][PAGE 2] WHO’S AGAINST
THE RIGHT TO PROTEST?
[PAGE 6][PAGE 6][PAGE 6][PAGE 6] FIGHTING CUTS IS
NOT A CRIME
[PAGE 7][PAGE 7][PAGE 7][PAGE 7] THE POLICE: ONLY
DOING THEIR JOB?
[PAGE 10][PAGE 10][PAGE 10][PAGE 10] FASCISM: NO
DEBATE – NO PLATFORM
[PAGE 13][PAGE 13][PAGE 13][PAGE 13] OCCUPY
EVERYWHERE?
web: www.socialistrevolution.org
email: [email protected]
phone: 020 1905 1917
First print 2012
Introduction
1 2
Who’s against the
right to protest? Why is the right to protest being
attacked and how can we defend
it?
The cuts have provoked massive
resistance – from the students to
NHS workers – millions have come
into struggle.
Yet from demonstrations to strikes,
the government has fought back,
using the courts, police and
parliament to crackdown on our
democratic rights.
Hundreds of students and youth
were beaten and arrested during
the revolt against fees. Strikes have
been declared illegal, and
communities affected by the August
Riots terrorised by punitive jail
terms.
And we’re not the only ones.
The vicious crackdown by security
forces on the Occupy camps in
Wall Street and Oakland took place
while revolutionaries in the Arab
Spring rose up in the face of
murderous repression from regimes
armed and funded by the USA.
Like every other right, the ‘right’ to
protest is not given automatically.
Just like the right to vote, it had to
be won, struggle by struggle, from
the capitalist class, who are
permanently trying to limit and
diminish its power.
All these attacks on the right to
protest are attacks on our right
to reject the politics of endless
war, cuts and poverty.
This pamphlet contains five articles,
each dealing with a particular topic
– from the role of the state and its
police in repressing the anti-cuts
movement, to the fight against
fascism and the rise of new
struggles like the Indignados.
We hope you enjoy this pamphlet. If
you like what you read – join us!
Editorial Board March 2012
When the world economy went into
meltdown in 2008, total collapse
was only avoided because
governments – the state - bailed out
the banks’ debts with $trillions of
their citizens’ money.
The economic crisis is a crisis of the
Capitalist system, and the
capitalists are determined to make
ordinary people shoulder the cost,
with cuts to our jobs, wages,
healthcare and education.
The Con-Dem government, and the
levers of state power it controls, are
the capitalists’ primary weapon for
achieving this. After all, there’s a
reason why the Lib-Dems are
mainly funded by giant private
healthcare firms…
But isn’t this a democracy? Isn’t the
state just a set of neutral institutions
enabling democracy to flourish?
What is the state?
Whenever we challenge the
multimillionaire corporations that
rule the world, against every march,
every protest, every picket, boycott,
strike and action... there is an
organised force trained, prepared
and waiting to block us, smother us
and stop us. What is this force?
It's the police that threaten us,
move us on, caution us, batter us,
arrest us and imprison us.
It’s the judges who try us and
condemn us, even though they
know nothing about how we live
and never will.
The faceless civil servants,
bureaucrats and lawyers who
create tax loopholes, outlaw strikes
and create the laws that protect the
privileges of the rich.
3 4
The State is, in the words of one of the
first revolutionary communists,
Frederick Engels, the product of the
division of society into "irreconcilable"
classes, groups of people whose
interests directly clash and collide.
In short, the state is not a referee in a
football match who blows the whistle
when either team commits a foul. It is
a weapon that allow one class to rule
over another.
This means that there is no point
imagining that the states which exist
today will help the people do away
with capitalism. It exists to defend the
property of the capitalist minority from
the working class majority.
The division of society into a tiny
capitalist class and a huge majority of
working class people is an obstacle to
progress. At every step the capitalists
increase the threat of global warming,
destroy public services in favour of
private corporations, tighten the hold
of the banks on third world countries
through debt and build up ever bigger
nuclear arsenals. Production has
reached the stage where we can feed,
clothe and house the whole population
of the world a hundred times over - but
still millions starve in shanty towns.
To overthrow the rule of the capitalist
minority, we will first have to overcome
their resistance, which means we have
to overcome their state power.
Reformists and liberals believe that
this can be done peacefully through
parliamentary and constitutional
action. But from the Paris Commune of
1871 to the 1917 Russian Revolution
to Pinochet’s coup in Chile in 1973, all
history proves otherwise.
That is why the most determined part
of the working class, throughout the
history of modern capitalism, has
always argued that the state cannot be
reformed; it has to be forcibly
overthrown.
And there's the last deadly line of
defence for the system, the Army -
a killing machine waiting to spring
unthinkingly into action when their
paymasters' dirty work needs to be
done.
So how did the state come into
being? What makes it tick, and
can it be abolished?
If we want to be free and to break
the power of the corporations and
the billionaires, we need to try and
answer these questions.
Where do states come from?
It was only when societies had
advanced far enough for each
person to be able to produce a
little bit extra that a surplus arose -
and it is at this stage that a part of
society struggles to control that
surplus. Suddenly it is worthwhile
forcing other people to work for
you. It is possible to get rich - but
only by oppressing others. At this
stage, a class seizes control. It
makes the surplus of the group its
own private property. And it can
only do this by holding the rest of
the people down - by using force.
In other words, by establishing a
state - kings to rule, priests to lie
to the people about the king being
holier than everyone else, soldiers
to take action if the people see
through the lies and demand a
fairer share. Liberals believe that
the state is a neutral force that
exists to ensure fair play between
different interest groups in society.
To them, the state mediates
between the classes.
Many liberals argue that the way
to control global capitalism is to
strengthen the powers of the state.
The state will then be able to take
steps to limit the abuses of the big
corporations, cutting them down to
size and restricting the extent of
their control over the world's
resources.
It sounds nice - but it completely
misunderstands what the state is
and what it exists to do.
As we have seen, the State comes
into being when society is divided
into classes with different
relationships to the wealth that its
members have produced.
Fighting cuts is not a
crime
The only way this can be done is
by forming mass councils of
delegates from the working
population as alternative centres
of power, and by organising a
popular militia from among the
armed people to take action
against the capitalists, their allies
and protectors.
In short, it will take a revolution
to smash the capitalist state.
But does this mean we can move
overnight to a stateless society?
The capitalists will use every
means at their disposal to get their
property and their power back.
Until such time as a planned
socialist economy can redistribute
wealth and do away with class
division altogether, the old ruling
class will continue the fight. While
classes exist, there will be a need
for a state.
But after a socialist revolution, a
completely different type of state
will be needed - a working class
state.
The capitalist state exists to
defend the power and property of a
tiny minority. A working class state
would exist to do the opposite -
defend the property of the
overwhelming majority of the world's
population from a tiny former elite.
Instead of police – democratic
popular militias to defend our
communities. Instead of
parliamentary careerists and liars –
elected delegates from mass
councils of ordinary people. They
would be paid an average wage and
be subject to instant recall if they
broke their promises.
As classes disappeared there would
be less and less need for even this
special state machine. The functions
of the working class state could be
increasingly be taken over by
society as a whole.
The future lies in a society without
classes and states - a society based
on real freedom, fairness and
fulfilment. But there is only one road
to freedom: the revolutionary
overthrow of the capitalist state, and
the establishment of a democratic
working class state.
5 6
The government is doing its best to criminalise protest and create a climate of
fear. In this task it is helped by the courts, police and private businesses –
including university managements.
These are just some of the most punitive sentences imposed. Their
purpose is to intimidate people and paint those fighting back as
‘criminals’. We refuse to be silenced.
Frank Fernie – threw placards at police – 12 MONTHS
Omar Ibrahim – threw smoke bomb – 12 months
Zenon Mitchell-Kotsakis – threw placards at police – 12 months
Alfie Meadows – beaten into coma - charged with violent disorder
Cambridge uni student – read poem to David Willetts
Jordan Blackshaw – ‘incited riot on facebook’ – 4 years
- suspended for 2 and a half years
15 young muslims – accused of violent dis- order on protests against massacre in Gaza
January 2010 – 12-30 months
The police: only
doing their job?
7 8
The media portrays the police as
the thin blue line, defending
'normal' people from the hordes of
criminals waiting to rob, rape or
murder us. Recent events have
shattered this myth.
The truth is of an organisation that
ignores the security and well-being
of the majority of people. Anti-
social crimes committed against
against working-class families are
ignored. Women who are victims of
rape or domestic violence find the
police unsympathetic. Black people
are victimised. Many hold this up as
proof that the police should have
more money and power. Such a
conclusion is utterly wrong. The fact
is that the fundamental role of the
police is not to protect us from crime.
First and foremost, the duty of the
police is to defend the existing social
order. This means repressing
resistance to capitalism and its
effects. This is their 'law and order',
and it is not in our interests. As such
the state must disguise this true
purpose.
The police need the trust of ordinary
people, to ensure our day-to-day
obedience and our acceptance of
law and order policies: more power,
more weapons. They need to con us
into believing that without them
Into believing that without them
crime would explode. Press and
politicians - Tory, Lib Dem and
Labour alike - spread this lie. It is all
based on the idea that communities
would be incapable of policing
themselves, if allowed to.
These lies have been smashed.
Thousands of ordinary students,
exercising their democratic right to
protest, have over the past year
experienced the true brutality of the
police at first hand. For all the smoke
and mirrors deployed by the state
and the media, the violent,
repressive nature of the police can
no longer be hidden from the people
it claims to serve.
Police power
At the student demonstrations of
2010, the police armed themselves
with batons, horses and kettling
tactics, and used them ruthlessly in
medieval displays of force. Alfie
Meadows suffered brain damage as
the result of a truncheon blow. Jody
McIntyre was pulled from his
wheelchair and beaten. The media
has done its utmost to cover up or
distort these acts of barbarity.
Meadows and McIntyre were lucky.
Others have died as a result of
police repression. Ian Tomlinson
was a victim of such indiscriminate
violence. And we are far from seeing
the worst of what the police are
capable of.
There are suggestions that water
cannon be used at demonstrations,
despite a protestor in Germany
having been blinded by them. There
is even a strong lobby for the routine
carrying of guns. Given that Met
chief Sir Paul Stephenson described
the protestors that vandalised the
royal car as having been “lucky” for
not being shot, the results of all
police carrying guns are not hard to
predict.
Who they really police
The true role of the police exposes
itself most nakedly when the working
class and oppressed organise
together and fight back.
In 1984, the most militant section of
the working class, the miners,
9 10
fought against the Tory
government's attempts to destroy
their industry. The Tories knew this
was a movement they had to crush
at any cost - they pumped billions of
pounds into the police force and
intelligence services like MI5.
Thousands of police were poured
into the pit villages. Pitched battles
were fought as they tried to break
the strike. The state was determined
to smash the miners, and the police
force was the weapon of choice. Any
opposition to the established order
was attacked ruthlessly. The march
against the BNP in Welling and the
demonstration against the Criminal
Justice Act at Hyde Park were both
attacked by a tooled up police force
on government instructions.
We cannot turn the other cheek to
the repressive aims and methods of
the police. We need to organise
disciplined defence, so that we are
capable of defeating police attacks.
On demonstrations, stewarding
should be geared to defence and
organised enough to resist attack.
On pickets, defence squads run
On pickets, defence squads run by
the workers need to stop the police
breaking strikes.
Imagine if a movement, supported
by the mass of working people, tried
seriously to change the distribution
of wealth from the rich to the poor. It
is clear what side the police would
take. They are an arm of the state -
ultimately the state will always
defend the greed of the elites
against the interests of the people.
The state is not neutral and neither
are the police. This has been proven
by the attacks on our protests.
A generation of students has been
shown the brutal truth of how our
'democracy' works, of how their
basic human right of education is
worth less than the profit and power
of the elites. We cannot let this pass
unopposed.
The police are a real, daily threat to
ordinary people and an obstacle on
the road to socialism. We must strip
them of their powers, and fight for
democratic self-defence of our
communities.
Fascism: no debate –
no platform
This article looks at the tactics
necessary to oppose the rise of
fascism as a violent force on the
streets of Britain.
The economic crisis has given a boost
to racist and fascist organisations as
some workers are persuaded by the
media lies that immigrants are to
blame for the lack of jobs and housing.
Groups like the English Defence
League and the Infidels have
broadened out from abusing Muslims,
to targeting trade union, socialist and
anti-cuts meetings and protests.
Fascists today might seem
marginalised, but history shows they
are always the capitalists’ last line of
defence against a revolutionary
working-class.
Despite splits, setbacks and infighting,
the last 12 months has seen the
the last 12 months has seen the
English Defence League
successfully exploit prevalent
Islamophobic ideas to develop the
basis for a fascist street force
prepared to wage a violent
campaign of hate and intimidation
against minorities in working-class
communities.
Fascist tendencies thrive during
times of economic crisis, and the
EDL seek to capitalise on the fallout
from the economic crisis, by stoking
fires of division in working class
communities between white workers
and the new scapegoats, Muslim
and migrant workers.
11
The media exposure extended to tin-
pot fascists like Nick Griffin and
Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, aka
Tommy Robinson, hooligan and EDL
ringleader, has presented
Islamophobia as a mainstream
political opinion, rather than the
prejudiced hatred of racists and
bigots.
Airtime for fascists and racists
reflects the role of media and the
purpose of fascist ideology in
capitalist society; that is, to allow the
ruling class to divide and rule.
The ideas of the BNP and EDL are
no threat to the established powers;
they strengthen the bosses’ rule by
dividing the working class along
ethnic lines. This is why the police
defend the fascist marches, and it is
why the EDL ‘whiteshirts’
volunteered to help the police
‘restore order’ during the riots.
The lessons of history ar
implacable. In the 20
everywhere fascism rose to power
as the last resort of the capitalists
confronted by the revolutionary
struggles of the working
examples of Spain, Germany, Italy,
are proof of fascism’s historic role as
the final defence
property relations against workers’
control and socialism.
Blame the bosses, not foreign
workers
It is no coincidence that fascist ideas
gain a wider audience just as the
bosses are launching a de
offensive on working
pensions and public services.
The bosses ruthlessly exploit
immigrant labour during the boom
years, paying lower wages,
strengthen the bosses’ rule by
dividing the working class along
ethnic lines. This is why the police
defend the fascist marches, and it is
why the EDL ‘whiteshirts’
volunteered to help the police
‘restore order’ during the riots.
The lessons of history are
implacable. In the 20th century,
everywhere fascism rose to power
as the last resort of the capitalists
confronted by the revolutionary
struggles of the working-class. The
of Spain, Germany, Italy,
fascism’s historic role as
defence of capitalist
property relations against workers’
control and socialism.
Blame the bosses, not foreign
It is no coincidence that fascist ideas
gain a wider audience just as the
bosses are launching a devastating
offensive on working-class jobs,
pensions and public services.
The bosses ruthlessly exploit
immigrant labour during the boom
years, paying lower wages,
refusing to recognise trade unions and
impoverishing their communities. All
the while the capitalist media wages a
constant campaign of sensationalism,
lies and racism which manages to
vilify immigrants in general, Muslims in
particular, and the welfare state in
general as the root of moral decay.
The fascists blame unemployment on
the poorest, most exploited sections of
society, despite the fact that the only
people who benefit from
unemployment are the bosses – who
use it to lower wages and make
ordinary people turn against each
other when there aren’t enough jobs
to go round.
However, opposing fascism isn’t just a
battle of ideas. Based on a reactionary
and illogical ideology, fascism can
only demonstrate its value to the
bosses through “well-directed boots
and fists.”
This is why the EDL have stepped up
their campaign of attacking left-wing
and trade union meetings – to disrupt
working-class organisations and
weaken our ability to resist the
bosses’ offensive on our jobs.
12
refusing to recognise trade unions and
impoverishing their communities. All
the while the capitalist media wages a
constant campaign of sensationalism,
lies and racism which manages to
vilify immigrants in general, Muslims in
state in
The fascists blame unemployment on
the poorest, most exploited sections of
society, despite the fact that the only
people who benefit from
who
use it to lower wages and make
ordinary people turn against each
other when there aren’t enough jobs
isn’t just a
battle of ideas. Based on a reactionary
and illogical ideology, fascism can
only demonstrate its value to the
rected boots
This is why the EDL have stepped up
wing
to disrupt
class organisations and
weaken our ability to resist the
In times of economic and social crisis,
the fascists will offer racism and
violence as a solution to people’s
desperation.
The question of No Platform must be
posed as an issue of working-class
unity against the bosses’ efforts to
divide and rule.
It is also a question of our right to
organise self-defence against fascist
pogroms and attacks on our meetings
and demonstrations.
That's why, when the English Defence
League march in our cities and towns,
attacking black and Asian areas,
screaming racist abuse, we need our
own "Antifascist Defence League" to
drive them off the streets. A trained,
organised and democratic defence is
the best way to protect our
communities from racist thugs and the
police alike.
No platform
works
“ ”
13 14
Occupy everywhere?
The economic crisis has hit all the
major economies of the world. While
trade union leaders across Europe
were still pleading for negotiations, the
youth of Spain and Greece took
matters into their own hands.
The movement born from these
protests – los indignados – ‘the
outraged’ spread across Europe,
drawning hundreds of thousands of
young people into radical protest
against the system they identified as
the source of their problems.
Occupying central squares and plazas
in major cities, defending them against
police attack and organising through
democratic General Assemblies, the
uprising of the Indignados was an
inspiration to millions across the
world.
Inspired by the Arab Spring and the
Spanish youth camps against
austerity, the Occupy Wall Street
movement has laid the blame for the
economic crisis squarely at the door of
of the 1% - the elite class of
international bankers, speculators and
their governments who are
determined to make the 99% pay for
their crisis.
By taking the slogan 'we are the
99%' to the heart of every major
financial district in the world, the
movement has opened the door to
putting an anti-capitalist alternative
at the centre of international
resistance to austerity.
Yet the camps have now all been
cleared, some peacefully, most with
the use of police, private security and
public-health laws. So what went
wrong, and is this a good model?
Ultimately, Occupy's consensus-
based model proved incapable of
providing a practical alternative to the
existing power structures. But in just
three months on the steps of St.
Pauls, OccupyLSX played a pivotal
role in galvanising a wider social
movement alongside the historic
actions of the organised labour
movement last year.
Resistance to austerity and
exploitation is escalating
throughout our society - from
Primark staff to nurses, people are
fighting back.
If we are to succeed in bringing down
the government to stop these cuts,
then we need to win the argument by
leading the struggles to show how
collective action gives us the potential
to transform our society. We want to
channel the anger and energy into
a united organisation capable of
rallying all those committed to fighting
for an anti-capitalist alternative.
Faced with the enormously centralised
violence and power of the capitalist
state - which employs the combined
wealth of society to forcibly defend the
privileges of the 1% - any Occupy
movement must
movement against the cuts must be
prepared to react by building its own
organisations, capable of defending our
camps, demonstrations and
communities.
The economic crisis is a crisis of
capitalism which can only be resolved at
the expense of one class over another.
We stand with the working class, the
youth, and the unemployed who produce
all the world's wealth, against the
capitalist class - the 1% who defend their
exploitation with the bullet and the ballot
box.
We stand for resistance to the massacre
of jobs, education and public services.
We stand for the creation of a new
organisation of struggle which can
unite those fighting for an alternative
to capitalism – now is the time to fight
– join us!