delay discounting by humans and other animals: does the species matter?

1
NBTS 2010 Abstracts NBTS1 Delay discounting by humans and other animals: Does the species matter? Leonard Green Washington University, Saint Louis, MO, United States When rats, pigeons, and people choose between immediate and delayed rewards, the subjective value of the delayed reward decreases as time to its receipt increases. In all three species, this decrease, which represents the discounting of the delayed reward, is well described bya hyperboloid function. Interestingly, we have observed a magnitude effect (in which larger delayed rewards are discounted less steeply than smaller delayed rewards) with humans but not with rats or pigeons. Humans consistently discounted larger delayed rewards less steeply than smaller delayed rewards. In contrast, the nonhuman animals showed equivalent discounting of both large and small rewards, as well as of both more- and less-preferred rewards. In addition, we have observed that in humans, if an additional waiting period is added prior to both rewards, thus creating a delay common to both alternatives, rate of discounting decreases as the common delay increases. We recently have examined the effect of adding a common delay on discounting in pigeons. When the sooner and later alternatives were differentially signaled throughout, the pigeons (in contrast to humans) showed substantial increases in discounting rate with increases in the common delay. When the common delay to both rewards had the same signal but the additional time to the later reward was differentially signaled, however, rate of discounting decreased as the common delay increased, a result consistent with that obtained with humans. Taken together, these results illustrate the difficulties involved in determining whether delay discounting relies on similar processes in different species. doi:10.1016/j.ntt.2010.04.002 NBTS2 Ontogeny of Hippocampal-Dependent Memory Processes: Developmental Amnesia in Monkeys and Humans Maria C. Alvarado, Jocelyne Bachevalier Yerkes National Primate Research Center, Emory University, Atlanta, GA Substantial progress has been made in the understanding of the neural substrates of memory processes in human and nonhuman primates. How these processes emerge during development and how the brain systems that mediate them mature during ontogeny are important questions that give us insight into adult memory and the cognitive consequences of perinatal perturbations to those neural substrates. Using a variety of cognitive paradigms we have begun to map out normal developmental changes in memory and have explored the consequences of neonatal damage to medial temporal lobe structures to normal memory development. In particular, three classes of cognitive task: delay-dependent recognition, spatial recognition/navigation, and non-spatial relational memory, show similar protracted development and sensitivity to early hippocampal damage in monkeys. We will demonstrate that: A) cognitive processes that are sensitive to hippocampal dysfunction are late- developing in monkeys; B) within those tasks that depend upon the hippocampus, the degree to which the behavior requires the trisynaptic pathway may develop later than those which engage the direct pathway; and C) in comparison with reports in the literature, developmentally amnesic children or adults with hippocampal damage, performance on the same or similar cognitive tasks produces striking similarities to the results we find in monkeys. doi:10.1016/j.ntt.2010.04.003 NBTS3 Modeling the cognitive deficits of Parkinson's disease Jay Schneider Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA, United States Cognitive dysfunction is an important aspect of Parkinson's disease (PD). PD patients often display a variety of cognitive deficits, many of which resemble those found in patients with frontal lobe dysfunction and appear to involve primarily fronto-striatal circuits. Cognitive improvement has not been consistently reported, or at least has not been significant after treatment with dopaminergic agents. Remediation of cognitive deficits of PD is a major unmet medical need. There is significant need for therapies that can be administered adjunctively with levodopa to improve cognition or counteract detrimental effects of levodopa on cognition and not diminish the therapeutic effects of levodopa on motor functioning. Unfortunately, such development efforts have been hampered in part due to lack of an appropriate animal model in which to carryout critical preclinical studies. To overcome this problem, we have developed a model based on chronic administration of low doses of the neurotoxin MPTP to non-human primates. These animals develop early appearing at- tention and executive function deficits with minimal or no motor Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Neurotoxicology and Teratology journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/neutera Neurotoxicology and Teratology 32 (2010) 496510 pii:S0892-0362(10)00054-1

Upload: leonard-green

Post on 10-Sep-2016

214 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Delay discounting by humans and other animals: Does the species matter?

NBTS 2010 Abstracts

NBTS1Delay discounting by humans and other animals: Does thespecies matter?

Leonard GreenWashington University, Saint Louis, MO, United States

When rats, pigeons, and people choose between immediate anddelayed rewards, the subjective value of the delayed reward decreasesas time to its receipt increases. In all three species, this decrease, whichrepresents the discounting of thedelayed reward, iswell describedbyahyperboloid function. Interestingly, we have observed a magnitudeeffect (in which larger delayed rewards are discounted less steeplythan smaller delayed rewards) with humans but not with rats orpigeons. Humans consistently discounted larger delayed rewards lesssteeply than smaller delayed rewards. In contrast, the nonhumananimals showed equivalent discounting of both large and smallrewards, as well as of both more- and less-preferred rewards. Inaddition, we have observed that in humans, if an additional waitingperiod is added prior to both rewards, thus creating a delay common toboth alternatives, rate of discounting decreases as the common delayincreases. We recently have examined the effect of adding a commondelay on discounting in pigeons. When the sooner and lateralternatives were differentially signaled throughout, the pigeons (incontrast to humans) showed substantial increases in discounting ratewith increases in the common delay. When the common delay to bothrewards had the same signal but the additional time to the later rewardwas differentially signaled, however, rate of discounting decreased asthe common delay increased, a result consistent with that obtainedwith humans. Taken together, these results illustrate the difficultiesinvolved in determining whether delay discounting relies on similarprocesses in different species.

doi:10.1016/j.ntt.2010.04.002

NBTS2Ontogeny of Hippocampal-Dependent Memory Processes:Developmental Amnesia in Monkeys and Humans

Maria C. Alvarado, Jocelyne BachevalierYerkes National Primate Research Center, Emory University, Atlanta, GA

Substantial progress has been made in the understanding of theneural substrates of memory processes in human and nonhumanprimates. How these processes emerge during development and how

the brain systems that mediate them mature during ontogeny areimportant questions that give us insight into adult memory and thecognitive consequences of perinatal perturbations to those neuralsubstrates. Using a variety of cognitive paradigms we have begun tomap out normal developmental changes in memory and haveexplored the consequences of neonatal damage to medial temporallobe structures to normal memory development. In particular, threeclasses of cognitive task: delay-dependent recognition, spatialrecognition/navigation, and non-spatial relational memory, showsimilar protracted development and sensitivity to early hippocampaldamage in monkeys. We will demonstrate that: A) cognitiveprocesses that are sensitive to hippocampal dysfunction are late-developing in monkeys; B) within those tasks that depend upon thehippocampus, the degree to which the behavior requires thetrisynaptic pathway may develop later than those which engage thedirect pathway; and C) in comparison with reports in the literature,developmentally amnesic children or adults with hippocampaldamage, performance on the same or similar cognitive tasks producesstriking similarities to the results we find in monkeys.

doi:10.1016/j.ntt.2010.04.003

NBTS3Modeling the cognitive deficits of Parkinson's disease

Jay SchneiderThomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA, United States

Cognitive dysfunction is an important aspect of Parkinson'sdisease (PD). PD patients often display a variety of cognitive deficits,many of which resemble those found in patients with frontal lobedysfunction and appear to involve primarily fronto-striatal circuits.Cognitive improvement has not been consistently reported, or at leasthas not been significant after treatment with dopaminergic agents.Remediation of cognitive deficits of PD is a major unmet medicalneed. There is significant need for therapies that can be administeredadjunctively with levodopa to improve cognition or counteractdetrimental effects of levodopa on cognition and not diminish thetherapeutic effects of levodopa on motor functioning. Unfortunately,such development efforts have been hampered in part due to lack ofan appropriate animal model in which to carryout critical preclinicalstudies. To overcome this problem, we have developed a model basedon chronic administration of low doses of the neurotoxin MPTP tonon-human primates. These animals develop early appearing at-tention and executive function deficits with minimal or no motor

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Neurotoxicology and Teratologyj ourna l homepage: www.e lsev ie r.com/ locate /neutera

Neurotoxicology and Teratology 32 (2010) 496–510

pii:S0892-0362(10)00054-1