depleted uranium a presentation prepared by the medical association for prevention of war
TRANSCRIPT
Depleted Uranium
A presentation prepared by the Medical Association for Prevention
of War
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
2
Why is Depleted Uranium of Concern?
Australia exports uranium to states with weapons using depleted uranium (DU)
Risks to those exposed to radiation from military uses of DU are sufficiently high to warrant concern
DU constitutes an unacceptable cost of contemporary armed conflict to civilian populations
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
3
Depleted Uranium
The basics Military uses of DU Health effects Action
The Basics
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
5
Uranium
Silver-white, lustrous, dense, weakly radioactive element Found the natural environment Mixture of three radioactive isotopes 238U, 235U, and
234U Approximately 90 µg (micrograms) of uranium exists in
the human body from normal intakes of water, food and air. About 66% is found in the skeleton, 16% in the liver, 8% in the kidneys and 10% in other tissues.
Used primarily in nuclear power plants. However, most reactors require uranium in which the 235U content is enriched from 0.72% to about 1.5-3%.
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
6
Depleted Uranium
The uranium remaining after removal of the enriched fraction contains about 99.8% 238U, 0.2% 235U and 0.001% 234U by mass; this is referred to as depleted uranium or DU
Depleted uranium (DU) contains at least three times more 235U than natural uranium
Weakly radioactive and a radiation dose from it would be about 60% of that from purified natural uranium with the same mass
The behaviour of DU in the body is identical to that of natural uranium
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
7
Depleted Uranium
Troops exposed to multiple agents including: DU, insect repellent, petrochemicals, vaccines, + nerve gas and drugs against nerve gas.
May be implicated in Iraqi illnesses and congenital deformities
Gulf war syndrome
>25,000 US and UK veterans Precautionary principle:
IPPNW calls for a ban on the use of depleted uranium for military purposes
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
8
Depleted Uranium
Waste product of uranium enrichment (and reprocessing)
U235 0.7% reduced to ~0.2%, 60% of radioactivity of natural uranium
Half-lives: U238 4.5 b y U235 710 m y U234 250 k y
Sometimes contaminated with U236, transuranics - plutonium, americium, neptunium, technetium-99
Huge quantities available (eg US DOE 728,000 T) Inexpensive
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
9
Isotope Composition, Chemical Half-lives and Isotope Ratios in Natural and Depleted Uranium
ISOTOPE NATURAL DEPLETED HALF-LIFE
U-238 99.2749% 99.7947% 4.49 billion years
U-235 0.7196% 0.2015% 710 million years
U-234 0.0055% 0.0008% 248,000 years
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
10
DU Use
Civilian: counterweights in aircraft, radiation shields in medical radiation therapy machines and containers for the transport of radioactive materials
Military: defensive armour plate
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
11
Alpha Particle, Beta Particle, Gamma Ray (small).
DU is Radioactive and Produces:
Military Uses of DU
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
13
Military Uses of Depleted Uranium
Iraq/Kuwait1991
Bosnia1994-5
Kosovo/Serbia/Montenegro
1999
Afghanistan2001-3
Iraq2003
Source UK tanksUS aircraftUS tanks
US aircraft US aircraft US aircraft UK tanksUS aircraftUS tanksUS fighting
vehicles
Quantity 286 metric tons
3.2 metric tons
9.5 metric tons Unknown Unknown
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
14
Twice as dense as lead, rel easy to work with, pyrophoric (ignites > 600°C), ‘self-sharpening’
Aerolisation, burning, oxidation Armour plating esp tanks Munitions 20 - 120 mm Used by various militaries (no longer Australia) Known use:
Persian Gulf war 1991 350 tonnes Balkans mid 90s 11 tonnes Iraq 2003 1100 - 2200 tonnes
Regarded by US /NATO as ‘conventional’ weapon
Military Uses of Depleted Uranium
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
15
Military DU exposure: vehicles/tanks exposed to fires involving DU fragments resuspended dust
Civilian DU exposure same as military residual munitions /fragments (70-80% of munitions used) Dust resuspended - children ingestion Food and groundwater
Commercial and military use : precautions re exposure - personal protective equipment, respirators
Military Uses of Depleted Uranium
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
16
Military Uses of Depleted Uranium
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
17
Uranium is a very dense metal Munitions with dense penetrators such as uranium and
tungsten, pierce through most materials When it hits a target, the uranium tip of the penetrator
melts so that the core gets sharper. In contrast, tungsten penetrators tend to blunt (‘mushroom’) on impact.
Uranium particles ignite spontaneously (pyrophoricity), which can lead to combustion
The huge waste stockpiles of the uranium enrichment industry require costly storage and monitoring. So the raw material (DUF6) is readily available at low cost
Military Advantages Of Uranium Weapons
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
18
China France
Greece Israel
Pakistan Russia
Saudi Arabia Turkey
Ukraine United Kingdom
United states of America
Countries with DU Munitions or Armour
Health Effects of DU
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
20
Uranium Health Effects
Toxic and radioactive heavy metal Soluble and insoluble forms, can enter body by ingestion, inhalation
or embedded fragments Average adult intake ~500 mcg /y Soluble forms excreted by kidney fairly quickly, insoluble forms
slowly (T1/2 10-20 y) Toxicity:
kidney - esp proximal tubule (largely reversible) Radioactivity:
alpha, beta and gamma major long-term issue is lung / lymph node alpha irradiation
following inhalation (Royal Society 2002 estimate worst-case ~2x lifetime risk)
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
21
Uranium Health Effects
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
22
Medical Effects of DU
Health studies have found that:
populations with well-above-average occupational exposure to inhaled or ingested uranium do not suffer from increased rates of the cancers most likely to be associated with radiation
Do not exhibit the blood disorders that might be expected as a result of chemical toxicity
Studies do not account for:
New experimental data suggesting a role for dust toxicity in the lung
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
23
In the kidneys, the proximal tubules (the main filtering component of the kidney) are considered to be the main site of potential damage from chemical toxicity of uranium
Possible adverse effects on the central nervous system (studies have suggested this but difficult to draw firm conclusions from work done so far)
Medical Effects of DU
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
24
Problems from 238U Dust
After burning, 238U creates fine radioactive and toxic vapor and dust
More than 50% of these particles are just the right size to be inhaled, where they lodge in the lungs and remain for years
It is easily carried by the wind, and stays in the air for hours after impact
It also easily dissolves in water Ground contamination allows resuspension into the air and
eventual water contamination No ground cleanup has occurred in Iraq or Kuwait since the
first Gulf War
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
25
Problems from 238U Fragments
Unburned, 238U remains radioactive – is classified as a “low-level” waste, subject to proper disposal and controls
Fragments corrode with time, creating more dust and contaminated soil
High levels of radioactivity have been measured from fragments found after the first Gulf War in Iraq, Kuwait and Saudi Arabia
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
26
Possible DU Exposure
Level I: Personnel struck by DU munitions/fragments or who were in, on, or within 50 meters of an armored vehicle when it was struck
Level II: Personnel who routinely enter DU-damaged vehicles or fight fires involving DU munitions as part of their military occupational specialty
Level III: Personnel with “incidental” (insignificant DU exposures) -- infrequent exposure not expected to result in significant uptake of DU
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
27
WHO, UNEP, Royal Society recommend identification, signage, clean-up of impact zones proper disposal long-term monitoring food (esp milk) and water prevention exposure of children evaluation of exposures long-term studies (including reproductive) of exposed
personnel IPPNW, MAPW
In addition to long-term environmental and health monitoring: assessment of exposures ban on use clean-up of contaminated sites (refused to date)
DU – Concerns, Recommendations
Action
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
29
International Legal Issues
Not banned by a specific treaty
Contravenes international humanitarian law (Geneva Conventions)
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
30
International Campaign to Ban DU Weapons
After over a decade of sporadic and ad-hoc campaigning the official campaign was launched by over 30 NGOs in 2004
Draft Convention to ban DU weapons being worked on currently by the International Coalition to Ban Uranium Weapons
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
31
Take Action Today!
Join MAPW in lobbying the Australian government against allowing the US military to test and use DU weapons in training exercises on Australian soil
Support the International Coalition to Ban Uranium Weapons (www.banuraniumweapons.org)
MAPW (Australia) Depleted Uranium 2006
32
Medical Association for Prevention of War Australia
(MAPW)
National Office: P.O. Box 1379, Carlton VIC 3053, AustraliaPh: 03 8344 1637 Fax: 03 8344 1638
www.mapw.org.au [email protected] affiliate of International Physicians for Prevention of
Nuclear War (IPPNW)