development and validation of a pacgenomics-agilent microarray system for preimplantation genetic...

1
DESIGN: We have developed a sequencing-based PGS method that allows for the detection of gross chromosomal abnormalities. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The sequencing library preparation is based on a novel transposase-based tagging protocol. The sequencing li- braries were sequenced with multiplexed, 36 cycle single read sequencing runs on an IlluminaÒ MiSeq. Up to 12 samples were combined per sequencing run. After alignment, only perfectly and uniquely aligning reads were kept for tag counting. The reference genome was divided into variable sized bins depending on genomic context and the number of reads that map to each bin was counted. The read count per bin is subsequently correlated with copy number. Turnaround time from cell biopsy to analyzed data was less than 12 hours. RESULTS: In order to determine the limit of resolution, single cell, two cell and three cell aliquots of tissue culture cell lines with known aberrations were assayed. 12Mb events were readily detectable even at the single cell input level. The protocol was subsequently applied to single cells of cleav- age-stage embryos that had previously been characterized by FISH. Mono- somies of chromosome 13 and 14 were confirmed in one embryo and trisomy of chromosome 13 was confirmed in another. Additional aberrations were also detected that were previously unknown due to the non-comprehen- sive nature of FISH. CONCLUSION: PGS by MPS is a rapid, comprehensive screening method that allows for the detection of subchromosomal abnormalities in sin- gle cell biopsies. Supported by: The authors (FK, TR, and BK) are employees of Illumina, Inc. P-173 Tuesday, October 15, 2013 DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A PACGENOMICS-AGI- LENT MICROARRAY SYSTEM FOR PREIMPLANTATION GE- NETIC SCREENING (PGS) IN PATIENTS UNDERGOING IN VITRO FERTILIZATION (IVF). M. Li, H. Jin, R. Snyder, J. Zhou, L. Liu. PacGenomics, Thousand Oaks, CA. OBJECTIVE: Agilent CGH array is the most commonly used platform for postnatal CNV. However, it has not been used for aneuploidy PGS in IVF because of less reliability in gender confirmation due to sample-on-control (of one gender) co-hybridization and data analysis$ costly duel-color hybrid- ization$ time-consuming multiple manual data processing steps, which lead to potential human errors The aim of the study was to develop and validate an Agilent PGS pipeline to overcome such weaknesses. DESIGN: Given the limitations of Agilent’s cohybridization and data anal- ysis methods, PacGenomics has developed 1) a novel hybridization method, which utilizes sample-on-sample and control-on-control co-hybridization with control DNA of both genders. 2) In-house developed data analysis soft- ware, which generates 2 log 2 ratios for each sample relative to control DNA of both genders. 3) a fully automated scanning-data analysis-log 2 ratio re- porting pipeline.Results were compared with NimbleGen, BlueGnome and Coriell cell lines. MATERIALS AND METHODS: We used 42 embryonic samples in the study. Of those, we validated 15 (13 aneuploid, 2 euploid) samples with Blue- Gnome, 27 (10 aneuploid, 17 euploid) samples with NimbleGen. We also validated 8 Coriell cell lines with known karyotype (1 aneuploid, 7 euploid). PicoPlex (Rubicon) was used for single cell amplification. Agilent 60k, Blue- Gnome 24sure BAC and NimbleGen 270k arrays were used. All labeling fol- lowed manufacturers’ protocols. RESULTS: The ploidy detection results derived from the PacGenomics- Agilent pipeline had a 100% concordance with BlueGnome, NimbleGen re- sults, and Coriell cell line reports respectively (100% accuracy, sensitivity and specificity). P-values for aneuploidy calls were <0.05. The turn-around time is 13 hours, which is the same as BlueGnome. The PacGenomicsAgi- lent PGS pipeline allows us to $ increase reliability of gender confirmation $ reduce costs $ minimize human errors. CONCLUSION: PacGenomics’s Agilent aneuploidy PGS platform is an fast and accurate tool for PGS. P-174 Tuesday, October 15, 2013 PREIMPLANTATION GENETIC SCREENING (PGS) ON DAY-5 BLASTOCYSTS WITH A DAY-6 EMBRYO TRANSFER RESULTS IN A CLINICAL PREGNANCY RATE OF 71%. K. J. Tobler, a R. Kaufmann, b R. Ross, b R. P. Dickey, c A. T. Benner, d W. G. Kearns. a,d a Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Division of Reproductive Endo- crinology and Infertility, Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, Baltimore, MD; b Fort Worth Fertility, Fort Worth, TX; c The Fertility Institute of New Orleans, Mandeville, LA; d Center for Preimplantation Genetics, LabCorp, Rockville, MD. OBJECTIVE: To determine if a day-5 blastocyst biopsy and a fresh day-6 embryo transfer following PGS using comparative genomic hybridization microarrays (aCGH) is an alternative to embryo freezing / PGS and a future frozen embryo transfer (FET). DESIGN: Retrospective. MATERIALS AND METHODS: 241 embryos were obtained from 59 couples undergoing 59 in vitro fertilization (IVF) and clinically indicated PGS. The mean maternal age was 35.7 years (28-43). All embryos were biopsied at the blastocyst stage of development and the trophectoderm cell(s) underwent lysis, DNA extraction and amplification using a random priming protocol. This was followed by 23-chromosome pair aCGH micro- array using the BlueGnome 24sure chip and BlueFuse software analysis. Euploid embryos were transferred the morning of day-6 of embryo devel- opment. RESULTS: A total of 236 molecular karyotypes were obtained from 241 biopsied embryos. Five embryos showed no evidence of DNA amplification. All women had euploid embryos available for transfer. The overall clinical pregnancy rate per IVF cycle in this cohort undergoing aCGH microarray PGS was 71% (42/59). Two spontaneous miscarriages occurred: the cytoge- netic tissue analysis of the first one was 46, XY and the second one had no fetal tissue to analyze. CONCLUSION: This preliminary study suggests that PGS using 23-chro- mosome aCGH microarrays on day-5 trophectoderm cells with a day-6 trans- fer is a promising strategy to consider for patients undergoing IVF and PGS. This technology offers IVF/PGS patients an opportunity to undergo a fresh embryo transfer and reduce the requirements for a future FET. P-175 Tuesday, October 15, 2013 KARYOMAPPING (KM) AS AUNIVERSAL PREIMPLANTATION GE- NETIC DIAGNOSIS (PGD) FOR BETA-GLOBIN GENE (HBB) MUTA- TIONS COMBINED WITH HUMAN LEUKOCYTE ANTIGEN (HLA) GENOTYPING: A PROOF-OF-PRINCIPLE STUDY. S. Coskun, a W. Qubbaj, a S. AlHassan, a S. Natesan, b K. Awratani, a A. Handyside. b a King Faisal Specialist Hospital and Research Center, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia; b BlueG- nome an Illumina Company, Cambridge, United Kingdom. OBJECTIVE: Diseases caused by over 700 mutations in HBB are preva- lent in the Mediterranean countries. PGD is one of the effective methods used in prevention of transmission to the offspring. However, classical PGD requires extensive validation for each mutation/patient. KM has been suggested to be a universal method of PGD. The reliability of KM without any prior test development was tested following standard PGD with haplo- typing (PGH) in 4 patients with 3 different HBB mutations and HLA geno- typing. DESIGN: Proof-of-principle. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Four patients underwent PGD for HBB mutations. The diagnosis was made by sequencing and PGH. All patients became pregnant and delivered healthy babies. Following the delivery, a blinded KM was performed from the remaining MDA products. Karyomaps of each embryo from multiple displacement amplification (MDA) products were constructed to predict the presence of any HBB mutations and HLA ge- notype. Results were compared to the sequencing and PGH analysis of the original cycles. RESULTS: Amplified DNA following MDA was obtained from 30 em- bryos biopsied on day 3. Seven unaffected embryos identified by sequencing and PGH were transferred and four unaffected children were born. KM was performed on the leftover MDA products and DNA from children born following PGD. The average call rates and AB call rates for DNA were 96 and 30%, and for MDA products were 72 and 15%, respectively. The results of KM and PGH were 100% concordant. There was discrepancy between the results of sequencing, and PGH/KM in 3 em- bryos (10%) which stem from allele drop out of during sequencing. One embryo although concordant among the techniques as normal, KM/PGH showed only maternal allele at the HBB locus suggesting monosomy for the chromosome. Moreover, KM provided the euploidy status of all chro- mosomes. CONCLUSION: KM can be reliably used in PGD of HBB mutation without prior test development or knowledge of the specific mutations and might prevent the transfer of aneuploidy embryos. S198 ASRM Abstracts Vol. 100, No. 3, Supplement, September 2013

Upload: l

Post on 30-Dec-2016

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

DESIGN:We have developed a sequencing-based PGSmethod that allowsfor the detection of gross chromosomal abnormalities.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: The sequencing library preparation isbased on a novel transposase-based tagging protocol. The sequencing li-braries were sequenced with multiplexed, 36 cycle single read sequencingruns on an Illumina� MiSeq. Up to 12 samples were combined persequencing run. After alignment, only perfectly and uniquely aligning readswere kept for tag counting. The reference genome was divided into variablesized bins depending on genomic context and the number of reads that map toeach bin was counted. The read count per bin is subsequently correlated withcopy number. Turnaround time from cell biopsy to analyzed data was lessthan 12 hours.

RESULTS: In order to determine the limit of resolution, single cell, twocell and three cell aliquots of tissue culture cell lines with known aberrationswere assayed. 12Mb events were readily detectable even at the single cellinput level. The protocol was subsequently applied to single cells of cleav-age-stage embryos that had previously been characterized by FISH. Mono-somies of chromosome 13 and 14 were confirmed in one embryo andtrisomy of chromosome 13 was confirmed in another. Additional aberrationswere also detected that were previously unknown due to the non-comprehen-sive nature of FISH.

CONCLUSION: PGS by MPS is a rapid, comprehensive screeningmethod that allows for the detection of subchromosomal abnormalities in sin-gle cell biopsies.

Supported by: The authors (FK, TR, and BK) are employees of Illumina,Inc.

P-173 Tuesday, October 15, 2013

DEVELOPMENT AND VALIDATION OF A PACGENOMICS-AGI-LENT MICROARRAY SYSTEM FOR PREIMPLANTATION GE-NETIC SCREENING (PGS) IN PATIENTS UNDERGOING INVITRO FERTILIZATION (IVF). M. Li, H. Jin, R. Snyder, J. Zhou,L. Liu. PacGenomics, Thousand Oaks, CA.

OBJECTIVE: Agilent CGH array is the most commonly used platform forpostnatal CNV. However, it has not been used for aneuploidy PGS in IVFbecause of less reliability in gender confirmation due to sample-on-control(of one gender) co-hybridization and data analysis$ costly duel-color hybrid-ization$ time-consuming multiple manual data processing steps, which leadto potential human errors The aim of the study was to develop and validate anAgilent PGS pipeline to overcome such weaknesses.

DESIGN: Given the limitations of Agilent’s cohybridization and data anal-ysis methods, PacGenomics has developed 1) a novel hybridization method,which utilizes sample-on-sample and control-on-control co-hybridizationwith control DNA of both genders. 2) In-house developed data analysis soft-ware, which generates 2 log2 ratios for each sample relative to control DNAof both genders. 3) a fully automated scanning-data analysis-log2 ratio re-porting pipeline.Results were compared with NimbleGen, BlueGnome andCoriell cell lines.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: We used 42 embryonic samples in thestudy. Of those, we validated 15 (13 aneuploid, 2 euploid) samples with Blue-Gnome, 27 (10 aneuploid, 17 euploid) samples with NimbleGen. We alsovalidated 8 Coriell cell lines with known karyotype (1 aneuploid, 7 euploid).PicoPlex (Rubicon) was used for single cell amplification. Agilent 60k, Blue-Gnome 24sure BAC and NimbleGen 270k arrays were used. All labeling fol-lowed manufacturers’ protocols.

RESULTS: The ploidy detection results derived from the PacGenomics-Agilent pipeline had a 100% concordance with BlueGnome, NimbleGen re-sults, and Coriell cell line reports respectively (100% accuracy, sensitivityand specificity). P-values for aneuploidy calls were <0.05. The turn-aroundtime is 13 hours, which is the same as BlueGnome. The PacGenomics’ Agi-lent PGS pipeline allows us to

$ increase reliability of gender confirmation$ reduce costs$ minimize human errors.CONCLUSION: PacGenomics’s Agilent aneuploidy PGS platform is an

fast and accurate tool for PGS.

P-174 Tuesday, October 15, 2013

PREIMPLANTATION GENETIC SCREENING (PGS) ON DAY-5BLASTOCYSTS WITH A DAY-6 EMBRYO TRANSFER RESULTSIN A CLINICAL PREGNANCY RATE OF 71%. K. J. Tobler,a

R. Kaufmann,b R. Ross,b R. P. Dickey,c A. T. Benner,d W. G. Kearns.a,d

S198 ASRM Abstracts

aDepartment of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Division of Reproductive Endo-crinology and Infertility, Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions, Baltimore,MD; bFort Worth Fertility, Fort Worth, TX; cThe Fertility Institute of NewOrleans, Mandeville, LA; dCenter for Preimplantation Genetics, LabCorp,Rockville, MD.

OBJECTIVE: To determine if a day-5 blastocyst biopsy and a fresh day-6embryo transfer following PGS using comparative genomic hybridizationmicroarrays (aCGH) is an alternative to embryo freezing / PGS and a futurefrozen embryo transfer (FET).DESIGN: Retrospective.MATERIALS AND METHODS: 241 embryos were obtained from 59

couples undergoing 59 in vitro fertilization (IVF) and clinically indicatedPGS. The mean maternal age was 35.7 years (28-43). All embryos werebiopsied at the blastocyst stage of development and the trophectodermcell(s) underwent lysis, DNA extraction and amplification using a randompriming protocol. This was followed by 23-chromosome pair aCGH micro-array using the BlueGnome 24sure chip and BlueFuse software analysis.Euploid embryos were transferred the morning of day-6 of embryo devel-opment.RESULTS: A total of 236 molecular karyotypes were obtained from 241

biopsied embryos. Five embryos showed no evidence of DNA amplification.All women had euploid embryos available for transfer. The overall clinicalpregnancy rate per IVF cycle in this cohort undergoing aCGH microarrayPGS was 71% (42/59). Two spontaneous miscarriages occurred: the cytoge-netic tissue analysis of the first one was 46, XY and the second one had nofetal tissue to analyze.CONCLUSION: This preliminary study suggests that PGS using 23-chro-

mosome aCGHmicroarrays on day-5 trophectoderm cells with a day-6 trans-fer is a promising strategy to consider for patients undergoing IVF and PGS.This technology offers IVF/PGS patients an opportunity to undergo a freshembryo transfer and reduce the requirements for a future FET.

P-175 Tuesday, October 15, 2013

KARYOMAPPING(KM)ASAUNIVERSALPREIMPLANTATIONGE-NETIC DIAGNOSIS (PGD) FOR BETA-GLOBIN GENE (HBB) MUTA-TIONS COMBINED WITH HUMAN LEUKOCYTE ANTIGEN (HLA)GENOTYPING: A PROOF-OF-PRINCIPLE STUDY. S. Coskun,a

W. Qubbaj,a S. AlHassan,a S. Natesan,b K. Awratani,a A. Handyside.b aKingFaisal Specialist Hospital and Research Center, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia; bBlueG-nome an Illumina Company, Cambridge, United Kingdom.

OBJECTIVE: Diseases caused by over 700 mutations in HBB are preva-lent in the Mediterranean countries. PGD is one of the effective methodsused in prevention of transmission to the offspring. However, classicalPGD requires extensive validation for each mutation/patient. KM has beensuggested to be a universal method of PGD. The reliability of KM withoutany prior test development was tested following standard PGD with haplo-typing (PGH) in 4 patients with 3 different HBB mutations and HLA geno-typing.DESIGN: Proof-of-principle.MATERIALS AND METHODS: Four patients underwent PGD for HBB

mutations. The diagnosis was made by sequencing and PGH. All patientsbecame pregnant and delivered healthy babies. Following the delivery, ablinded KM was performed from the remaining MDA products. Karyomapsof each embryo from multiple displacement amplification (MDA) productswere constructed to predict the presence of any HBBmutations and HLA ge-notype. Results were compared to the sequencing and PGH analysis of theoriginal cycles.RESULTS: Amplified DNA following MDA was obtained from 30 em-

bryos biopsied on day 3. Seven unaffected embryos identified bysequencing and PGH were transferred and four unaffected children wereborn. KM was performed on the leftover MDA products and DNA fromchildren born following PGD. The average call rates and AB call ratesfor DNA were 96 and 30%, and for MDA products were 72 and 15%,respectively. The results of KM and PGH were 100% concordant. Therewas discrepancy between the results of sequencing, and PGH/KM in 3 em-bryos (10%) which stem from allele drop out of during sequencing. Oneembryo although concordant among the techniques as normal, KM/PGHshowed only maternal allele at the HBB locus suggesting monosomy forthe chromosome. Moreover, KM provided the euploidy status of all chro-mosomes.CONCLUSION: KM can be reliably used in PGD of HBB mutation

without prior test development or knowledge of the specific mutations andmight prevent the transfer of aneuploidy embryos.

Vol. 100, No. 3, Supplement, September 2013