development opportunity analysis … opportunity analysis chugach mountain valley lodge volume four...

28
DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITY ANALYSIS CHUGACH MOUNTAIN VALLEY LODGE VOLUME FOUR September, 1994 Prepa red j()r: Anchorage Economic Development Corporation Prepared b)l: Davidson-Peterson Associates, Inc. The Office of Thomas J. Martin David L. Dahlquist Associates Tryck, Nyman, Hayes, Inc. GDI\tl, Inc. I t~f;: '- ~- ~ ---c ~

Upload: vandien

Post on 19-Mar-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

DEVELOPMENT OPPORTUNITY ANALYSISCHUGACH MOUNTAIN VALLEY LODGE

VOLUME FOUR

September, 1994

Prepa red j()r:

Anchorage Economic Development Corporation

Prepared b)l:

Davidson-Peterson Associates, Inc.The Office of Thomas J. MartinDavid L. Dahlquist Associates

Tryck, Nyman, Hayes, Inc.GDI\tl, Inc.

It~f;: '-

~- ~ ---c ~

TABLE OF CONTENTS

~

Introduction i

I. Project Concept 1

II. Site Considerations 5

Ill. Comparable Projects 7

IV. Market Support Considerations 9

V. Facility Sizing 11

VI. Development Costs 14

VII. Regulatory Environment 16

VIII. Financial Feasibility 18

IX. Development Strategies 25

;

r~';~C- ~ ~ ~-~-

INTRODUCTION

The following development opportunity is a result of a comprehensive evaluation of the

potential for the continued development of tourism in the Anchorage area with a

particular emphasis on winter tourism development. This development opportunity

represents a project which could be developed within the context of the overall strategy

for increased tourist activity in the Anchorage area.

I~

I. PROJECT CONCEPT

The Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge would provide a rare accommodation facility and

experiences for visitors to Anchorage at any season of the year, but primarily in the

winter season of late October through March. This project would derive its primary and

special characteristics from several existing assets. The Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge

would:

...Be located in one of the scenic valleys of the Chugach Mountains;

...Provide guests with direct access to a portion of the network oftrails associated with the Chugach State Park;

...Have direct vehicular access from the existing road and highwaysnetwork of Anchorage;...

...Provide a supplemental type of accommodation not presentlyavailable in the Anchorage Bowl or surrounding communities;

...Stress an "Alaska outdoor" experience for guests in all aspects ofthe project --marketing image. site of facilities. design of thebuilding and its interiors;

...Demonstrate a high sensiti\,ity to the natural environment throughthe project"s planning. design. construction and operations.

Guests of the Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge could enjoy a variety of experiences and

attendant facilities. Being a lodge first and foremost. the primaf)' offering would be

accommodations for short as \\'ell as extended stays. Forty to sixty lodging rooms would

be pro\,ided with each containing a main bedroom and sitting area. a full private bath.

and entry way. All lodging rooms \...'ould he in one huilding with connecting corridors and

hallways. Rooms on the ground level may have a second direct exterior egress. The

building would afford each guest room with a good view of the spectacular surrounding

scenery .

An equally important experience and facility would be a full-ser\,ice restaurant offering

breakfast. lunch and dinner m~I1Us. Bar ser\,ice and Sp~IC~ \\'ould ..llso he provided. While

the restaurant's primary function w()uld he to ser\'e I()dge accommodation guests, it is

anticipated that it would also ..lppeal to local residents.

-

--"-

While the primary facilities of the Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge would be accommodations

and the restaurant, the primary attraction for guests would be the opportunities to

experience Alaska outdoors. Opportunities for guest., would range from simply having

relaxed time to view the spectacular scenery surrounding the Lodge, to actively

participating in the various trail-based winter recreation activities: Nc;>rdic skiing,

skijoring, dog mushing, possibly snow machining and others. Options for participating

would range from guests using their own personal trail equipment, to renting equipment,

receiving instruction at beginning, intermediate and advanced levels, to taking guided

tours of the back country of Chugach State Park. Each package of equipment rental,

instruction and guide services would have a range of pricing. Providing these services

to guests introduces new income-generating opportunities for local residents who could

provide instruction. guide ser\/ices, equipment rental and other services under contract

with the Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge management. Typical length of stay would range

from one night to as long as several weeks. It is anticipated that most parties would

stay in the range of 4 to 6 nights.

While the principal purpose of the Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge project is to serve

tourism development in the \\linter months. the project would be planned, designed and

constructed to operate in similar ways during the late spring. summer and early fall

months.,

Summer opportunities for guests would als() he focused on providing an Alaska outdoors

experience. Vie\\ling scenery. ohser\ling plants and animals, and using thc hiking trails

would be the primary :.lttr:.lctions during the summer. Except for possihle shutdowns for

maintenance. restaur:.lnt. bar service. entertainment, .lnd guest ser\/ices would be provided

on a year-round hasis. Marginal operations or shut-do\\/n for annual maintenance and

refurhishing would occur during the late fall ~lnu "hreak-up" period of early spring.

In summary, the Chugach Mc)untain Valley Lougc pro.icct \\-"c)ulu incluue the folll)\\'ing

features:

Core requirements:

.Site area of 4() to gO .lcres is desirahle

.A single perm~lnent structure which \\'ould contain and enclose:

...Fc)rty to sjxt~' guest rO()IllS

...COlllllll)n I()uge entr~1 ~lnu lohhy

..~~~-

--3

...Guest registration and information

...Full-service restaurant and kitchen with attendant

equipment and storage

...Bar and evening entertainment area

...Meeting rooms

...Gift shop

...Porch and observation decks

...Manager's apartment...Hallways, corridors, elevators, and stairways

...Storage, laundry and maintenance areas

...Mechanical and utility spaces

...Outdoor equipment barn

.Site development. including:

...Access drives from existing road

...Parking for guests and staff

...Deli\fery. unloading and drop-off zones

...Site amenities and landscape plantings

...Trail heads and trail extensions to meet with existing

public trails

...Roadv..'ay. parking. and path lighting

...Concealed storage of materials and trash

...Utility ser\!ices would probably have to be brought to the

site

...Septic system to he constructed on site

...Water ser\rice from \--fell to be installed on site

...Utility ser\'ice appurtenances

.Access tt) the tr~lils of Chugach State Park

.Go()d orientation t() winter sun

;:: Overall de\fel()pment and ()p~rations plan for pro\fiding

environmental Iv sensiti\fe constructions and sustainable

operations.

The sketch presented in Figure 1. while not based on a specific design for the Chugach

Mountain Valley Lodge. illustrates the o\ferall character and scale of the project.

!

--

w0c0-J>W-J-J«~

>G)

Z

~

«C

)t-ii:Z

=>

0~J:(.)«0=

>J:(.)~

--5

II. SITE CONSIDERATIONS

Site and location for the Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge is an important consideration in

providing an uncompromised visual experience of the Alaska outdoors, and is essential to

the success of this proposed project. The concept is to bring Alaska to Anchorage.

For the Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge to successfully offer guests the desired

experiences, a number of factors need to be met. These include:

...Direct vehicular access to existing highway and street networks~

...Location in one of the valleys of the Chugach Mountains;

...An outdoor setting relatively free of commercial and residentialdevelopment and intrusions~

!--

--()

...A site relatively close to or with direct access to the existingtrail network of the Chugach State Park;

...A preference to consider privately-owned lands for the developmentof this project;

...Winter sun access with relatively good exposure or orientation tolow winter sun;

...Topography not so steep as to present difficulties fordevelopment;

...Attractive surrounding valleys and mountains, providing scenicvistas.

Following an assessment of many locations in the overall Anchorage municipal area, a

number of valley regions were identified as potentially offering locations for the Valley

Lodge. These regions are:

Eklutna River Valley near Eklutna Lake;

North side of Eagle River in the \1icinity of the Eagle RiverVisitor Center;

Rabbit Creek Valley

Bird Creek Valley

For additional information regarding locations for the Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge,

please contact the Anchorage Economic De\1elopment Corporation.

..-

--7

III. COMPARABLE PROJECTS

There are no current comparable projects in the Anchorage area. The potentially

comparable projects are currently located in more remote areas of Alaska and in other

parts of the U.S. and Canada. The Kenai Princess Lodge is one example of the Valley

Lodge concept. This project is located near Cooper Landing on a bluff above the Kenai

River, about a two-hour drive south of Anchorage. The 43-acre property is located within

the Chugach National Forest, and next to the Kenai National Wildlife Refuge. There is a

Main Lodge which includes a reception area, small bar/lounge, and 80-seat restaurant, as

well as a small conference/meeting room. Other facilities include a gift and Christmas

shop, hot tubs, an exercise room, and an RV park. The 50 rooms/suites are located in a

series of free-standing buildings in a landscaped area adjacent to the Main Lodge.

Quoted rates are $165 for a singe/double from June 1 through September 15, and $200 for a

suite, with winter rates somewhat lower. The Lodge is currently adding 10 more units.

Activities and organized tours at the Lodge include nature hikes, "flight-seeing," float

trips. fishing, and wildlife tours at Kenai Fjords National Park, which is an hour away

in Seward.

The Kennicott Glacier Lodge is another example of a back-country lodge. The Kennicott

Glacier Lodge was built to resemble an historic structure which burned in 1983. In 1992,

it was expanded to its current size of 25 guest rooms in one structure, which also

includes a dining area and common area lounges. The Lodge is open seasonally from May 15

through September 20, with private rooms ranging between $119 and $199 per night

depending upon occupancy. Because of its isolated location. the Lodge generates its own

electricity (11Ov, 60hz). Located ahout an X to 9 hour drive from Ancho~age in the

Wrangell-St. Elias National P.lrk, the Lodge offers its guests a variety of activities

including hiking, mountain climbing. glacier hiking. ice climbing, flight-seeing and

river rafting.

Data in Figure 2 gives information on some smaller-scale projects that are particularly

oriented to outdoor recreation and \\'inter sports activities.

--~

Figure 2

CHARACTERISTICS OF LODGE PRODUCTS

# of Room Activities/AmenitiesRooms Rate

Alaska:

Kennicott Glacier 25 $150-$220 Open summer season only --

Lodge activities include glacier hikes, iceclimbing, river rafting, flight-seeing,mountain climbing.

Kenai Princess 50 $ 99-$160 Open 10 months --activities includeLodge Room hiking, ski touring, fishing, river

$150-$200 rafting, flight-seeing.Suite

Westmark Cape 72 $ 98-$148 Urban property -located above theFox Lodge; downtown area of Ketchikan -offersKetchikan dining room and lounge, gift shop

and access to area attractions.

Other Locations:

Lone Mt. Ranch at 23 $173-$267 Near Yellowstone Park and theBig Sky, Montana rooms, Spanish Peaks. Nordic ski area with

Rustic overnight wildernessCabins accommodations. Also snow-cat

tours.

Garnet Hill Lodge; 16 rooms $70 per Adjacent to Siamese PondsAdirondacks, New 3 houses person, wilderness. 50,000 acres of hillsYork State with food and mountains --superior winterresort for Nordic skiing. .

Trapp Family 93 rooms $81-$144 Modern lodge set on 2,000 acres inLodge, Vermont Green Mts. with extensive ski-

touring, ski school, 100 km trailslinked with Mt. Mansfield.

Mountain Top Inn; 50 rooms $105-$126 1,300 acre resort with winter andVermont summer activities including hiking,

ski-touring on 67 miles of trails,horseback riding, etc.

Source: Hotel and Travel Index, and survey of individual projects.

-

--9

IV. MARKET SUPPORT CONSIDERATIONS

There are estimated to be approximately 5,900 rooms available in Anchorage in 111

properties, ranging from large hotels in downtown Anchorage and near the Airport to bed &

breakfast properties. Seventy percent of the properties have fewer than 25 rooms. Due

to the peak demand in the summer months, room rates are relatively high. Current rates

quoted in the summer 1994 edition of Hotel & Travel Index for standard rooms in selected

properties are as follows:

Hotel Rate

Alyeska Prince Resort Hotel $170-$325

Anchorage Hilton $110-$260

Anchorage Super "S" $ 90-$111

Barratt Inn $ 65-$150

Holiday Inn $125-$140

Regal Alaskan $112-$150

Sheraton Anchorage $157-$205

Westmark Anchorage $110-$162

The lodging industry in Anchorage is characterized hy high occupanC)' in the peak summer

seasons and lower occupancy in the winter months due to the seasonality of visitation to

Anchorage.

--10

Typical monthly occupancy rates are shown in the text table below.

Month 1992

January 52% ~

February 60%

March 59%

April 56%

May 65 %

June 85%

July 93%

August 89%

September 67%

October (jO%

November 52%

December 52 %

S()urct:: Anchor.lge C"B.

Even with these considerations, the De..."tillatio/1 Alaska report indicated a shortage of

447 rooms in the peak months in Anchorage. and a need to provide more variety of

accommodations. Since this report was published, the Alyeska Prince Resort Hotel has

opened a four-season property with 307 rooms. The Alyeska Prince Resort Hotel provides a

major new resource for winter tourism and should help to develop and expand the winter

market for Anchorage.

The type of accommodations a\'ailable in Anchorage (\,-rith the notable exception of the

Alyeska Prince Resort Hotel. which \,-'ill open in September 1994) are oriented to the

business visitor and to the group trade represented by the cruise ship operations. There

are no resort-type properties which could cater to the winter visitor (or the summer

visitOr), and pro\,ide for an "Alaska" experience with direct access to the activities

available in the outdoors. The proposed project is meant to address this market niche

\\/ith particular emphasis on the winter-time acti\,ities available in the Anchorage area.

Because of its relatively small size. the proposed project \\/ould be able to work within

the context of the existing hOtel stock very \\'ell, and be considered as a supplement to

the existing stock of rooms.

--11

V. FACILITY SIZING

This section outlines essential program information for this project. Suggested land

areas, allocation of building floor spaces, and identification of site development

features, while not based on a specific design for this project, represent a compilation

of information from similar projects. Refinements, adjustments, and modifications of

this information can be expected to accurately reflect local conditions, selection of a

site(s) for the project, actual project design plans, and the objectives of prospective

developers and investors.

Land Area Needs

Land required to adequately site the primary building and its attendant utility

structures, access and service driveways, parking areas for staff and guests, landscape

amenities, and other incidental features will range from 40 to 60 acres, This includes

an allowance for on-site buffering and screening; however, additional land may need to be

controlled through easement or acquired in fee title to assure maintenance of scenic

views for guests from the Valley Lodge. Some potential locations for the Valley Lodge

may also require additional land for development of an exclusive access road.

Building Program and Space Assignments

The concept for the Valley Lodge and a review of comparable projects suggests that the

primary structure for this project will involve construction of approximately 35,000

square feet. Based on the program presented herein. a schedule of space assignments

would be similar to the outline presented in Figure 3.

Site Development Features

Site development for the Valley Lodge will also involve the construction and installation

of a variety of features listed in Figure 4. Water supply and sewerage treatment

requirements are expected to he 7,500 gallons per day.

\

--~-~

--.1.'"

Figure 3

CHUGACH MOUNTAIN VAlLEY LODGE SPACE ASSIGNMENTS

SPACE SQ. FT. TOTALS

1. GUEST ROOMS:50 Rooms (Min. room dimension 12X24) 14,400Circulation at 15% (corridors) 3,000Ice, vending, maid & linen storage, at 5% 1,200

SUB-TOTAL 18,600

2. PUBUC SPACES:Arctic Vestibule 200Administration, Front Desk, Expeditor 600Dining Room 1,400Kitchen 1,000Lobby/Rrepiace 1 ,200Public Restrooms for Lobby (2 @ 100 sq.ft.) 200Gift Shop 300

SUB-TOTAL 4,900

3. BACK OF HOUSE:Storage 400

Med1anicai (Ventilation Equipment) 200T elephone/T. V. 125Manager's Apt (1 bdrrn/1 bath) 625Rrst Aid Room 120Locker Room (Lockers, staff toilet) 400Housekeeping Office 100Unen ~inen storage only) 50Housekeeping Storage 50Circulation, at 15% 350Trash/Recyciing Room 250Receiving/Storage 500Secure Storage 45

SUB-TOTAL 3,215

4. UNASSIGNABLE SPACE:Wall thicknesses, pipe chases, etc. @ 5% of total 1,336

BUILDING TOTAL 28,051

Outdoor Equipment Barn/Generator & Boiler Bldg.:Generator, Heating Plant Snow Machine Storage,Ski Lockers, Waxing Room, Equipment Rental 2.400

Porch and Deck 1 .500

SUB-TOTAL 3.900

PROJECT TOTAL 31,951100/0 Contingency 3,195BLDG. AREA USED FOR COST FORECAST 35,146

Source: GDM, Inc.

1162SP1.XLS9/15/94

--13

Figure 4

CHUGACH MOUNTAIN VALLEY LODGE -SITE DEVELOPMENT FEATURES

Item Description

On-site septic system Requires soil investigation, ground water andnitrate monitoring, and permitting. Constructionwill include lift station, septic tanks, 10,000 sq.ft.drain field, and various incidentals.

On-site water system Assumes a 200-foot well, treatment system andbuilding, and on-site distribution system.

Requires permitting.

Site grading Minimum impact grading and preservation ofexisting vegetation for building, driveways,parking areas, and utilities.

Access road and service Hard-surfaced drives for guest vehicles, buses,drives and delivery vehicles.

Parking Involves hard surfacing for 50 to 75 parkingspaces (with final requirements established byzoning ordinances), landscape buffering, sitelighting, and connecting sidewalks.

Landscape amenities Includes walkways and paths, nativelandscaping, sitting areas, retaining walls, trailheads, and other features.

Source: Tryck Nyman Hayes, Inc.

--1'1

VI. D EVELO PMENT CO STS

The schedule of probable costs presented by data in Figure 5 covers many of the likely

development features for the project. Other development cost items are included in data

in Figure 10. This estimate reflects typical construction costs associated with similar

projects, but does not reflect a specific site or design for the Valley Lodge. The

schedule of probable costs is based on square footage and lump sum costs associated with

similar projects and types of construction in the Anchorage area. A number of features

which will have cost implications for the project are not included in this schedule as

well. These might include costs for:

.Extension of utilities and roads from off-site locations;

.Off-site project information centers and guest reservation

systems;

.Contract guest sef\/ices such as winter sports equipment rental,instructions, and outfitting.

--15

Figure 5

CHUGACH MOUNTAIN VALLEY LODGE. CONSTRUCTION COST FORECAST

Date of Estimate: 9/6/94 location: Muni of Structure Type: Type 5 -1 HRArchitect: GDM, Inc. Anchorage Mountains Estimate Type: ConceptualContractor: Fair Cost -Owner: Private Total Area: 35,150 sq.ft.

no prevailing wage Developer

Diy. Description Labor Materials Sub-Contracts Totals

1 General Conditions $ 376,800 $ 251,200 $ 628,0002 Site Work/landscaping $ 750,000 $ SOO,OOO $ 1,250,0003 Concrete $ 126,000 $ 84,000 $ 210,0004 Masonry5 Metals $ 25,200 $ 16,800 $ 42,0006 Carpentry $ 276,600 $ 184,400 $ 461,0007 Moisture Protection $ 151,200 $ 100,800 $ 252,0008 Doors & Windows $ 75,600 $ 50,400 $ 126,0009 Finishes $ 326,400 $ 217,600 $ 544,000

10 Specialties11 Equipment $ 100,800 $ 67,200 $ 168,00012 Furnishings $ 50,400 $ 33,600 $ 84,00013 Special Construction14 Conveying Sys1ems15 Mechanical $ 607,000 $ 607,00016 Electrical $ 378,000 $ 378,000

Total: $ 2,259,000 $1,506,000 $ 985,000 $ 4,750,000

Contract Overhead and Profit15% laborSOlo MaterialSOlo Other CostsSOlo Sub-Contracts

Mark-Ups: $ 338,850 $ 120,480 $ 59,100 $ 518,430

Sub-Total: $ 5,268,430

Builders Risk Insurance 0.75% $ 39,513Contract Bond 1.75% $ 92,198Contingency 5.00% $ 263,422

TOTAL ESTIMATED CONSTRUCTION COST: $ 5,663,562

Source: GDM, Inc.

1162CON1.XLS9/1 5/94

~--- -

--10

VII. REGULATORY ENVIRONMENT

Planning, developing, and operating the Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge will be subject to a

number of federal, state and municipal requirements and regulations. The list presented

below outlines many of the apparent permits and approvals that may be required. Thesymbol "*" indicates those which will most likely be involved with this project.

Coastal Project Questionnaire -Through this questionnaire, the Division of Governmental

Coordination, a State of Alaska office, coordinates State and Federal Natural Resource

Permits.

Federal approvals:

US Forest Ser\,ice Lands

US Coast Guard -Navigable Waters* US Corps of Engineers (CaE) -Wetlands

US Environmental Protection- National Pollution Discharge Elimination Permit

State approvals:* Department of Natural Resources -Chugach Park Advisory Commission

* Department of Fish & Game -Habitat

* Department of Environmental Conser\'ation -Drainage, Noise, Septic Systems, Wells

Other state appro\'als::;: Department of Transportation -Right ofWa)' Permits~ Utilit)' Agreements

:;: Fire Marshal -Hydrants; Fire Lanes & Signage

Municipality of Anchorage .Type of project determines need for:

Planning and zoning:* Conditional Use

* Public Facility Project Landscape Review

Condition of Approval of Previous Case

Variances

Subdivision Approval" * Zoninu Chanue~ry-- :;,:;

--17

Approval requirements and standards approved by:

Zoning Board of Appeals

Platting Board* Urban Design Commission

* Planning and Zoning Commission

Wetlands* Community Councils

Public Works approval:* Gradino and Drainaoe Permits

0 0

* Driveway Permit

Flood Hazard Permit

Building safety:* Building Permit

Utility Services -Project developers will need to determine whether public or private

utilities serve the specific project site. Various agreements and easements will likely

be needed.

Public -Anchorage Water & Wastewater (AWWU)

Sewer Sef\!ice -Notice of Intent to Discharge

Water

Private -Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC)

..Requires DEC Permit

-.

--1~

VIII. FINANCIAL FEASIBILITY

A financial feasibility analysis of the prototype Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge was

conducted using the project concept and market support consideration prepared in this

report. Basic assumptions in the analysis include the following:

...Total development and land costs of $8.05 million for a fifty room

lodge with accompanying full-service restaurant and gift shop.

This cost does not include access. utility provision or associated

recreational facility development. "Standard" financing terms for

a project of this type are assumed.

...The lodge is operated year-round. but at reduced lodging capacity

during the winter months. The project would be designed to close

down some rooms during slow periods, and this would save on

utilities and other expenses.

...Restaurant and gift shop facilities receive heavy usage by guests,

and in addition receive market support from other tourists in the

area as well as local residents.

...Visitor activities such as cross-country skiing, dog-sledding,

hiking, fishing. touring. biking etc. are assumed to be provided

by outside contractors. This analysis has not assumed revenue

generation for the lodge fr()m recreational activities.

...High summer occupancy r.ltes and winter and shoulder season outdoor

activity programming allow for .In acceptable overall usage

pattern.

...Room rates are .It a base ()f $140 during the winter with a premium

for shoulder and slimmer seasons.

--19

Pro Fonna Summary

Data in Figure 6 presents annual operating projections for a single /stable/ or typical

year at a Chugach Mountain Valley Lodge. Summer months are the busiest and have the

highest room rates. Income from non-lodging guests peaks during this period as well.

However, the winter months of November through April contribute about 35 percent of total

revenue, which is crucial to project feasibility. During the winter and to a lesser

degree the summer, the majority of meals are assumed to be taken at the lodge. Operating

expenses are assumed to be typical of a project of this type, except that utilities are

much higher than for projects in the lower 48 states. Additional detailed assumptions

used in the analysis are shown by data in Figure 10.

Data in Figure 7 uses the single year analysis of Figure 6 to project operations for a

10-year period. This analysis includes two project expansions of 25 rooms each in years

4 and 7, which yields a total project size of 100 rooms. This growth pattern is based on

the growth in the Alaska tourism economy and the substantial market position such a

project would enjoy.

Data in Figure 8 presents a financial analysis of the feasibility and attractiveness of

the project to an investor/operator. Based on the assumed construction costs, land costs

and operating income potential. along with standard financing assumptions as presented in

Figure 9, the project may have considerable investor appeal, as represented by a 27

percent internal rate of return on investment.

Data in Figure 10 presents many underlying assumptions to the analysis.

Given the income expense and capital cost assumptions underlying the feasibility

analysis, at stable operations, this project could cover its debt service with a debt

coverage ratio of 1.2 to 1.6 in different years. and produce a developer.s return on

equity of 27 percent. This project assumes a phased expansion program which lowers

project risk. Therefore, based on the scope of this analysis, the Chugach Mountain

Valley u)dge project promises to he financially feasihle and is worthy of more detailed

analysis and planning.

~-~- ---

!5! ~

;-~~

:::.~~

~

.~.

~

§~

§~~

! i~

§~

:':~~

§~~

~5~

~

-~:8

I:: ~

~~

. ~

@

~

~

X

~

': i

-'i,""~

&"

"':~r.;:"~

.g~~

.: N

r;I;

~

~.

=

'" ~

- N

. ~

-.3:

-'. ~

--'" -0-

~

...I-

--'" I-

--'"~

~

~

~

~

~~

~

~

~~

~

~

~~

~~

~~

~

~

~

I 5! @

~ M

~

~

~ ~

~

§-

~. ~

~-~

;- 2 ~

§. ~.

~. ~

~

_! ~

- ~-;~

. '(:;. ~- 8- -:;- g-~

. ~ §- ~

~

.R

:8

--~;

-:!:6""" ~

R

;;2-

~

:!:"""@.o

~

~

~

M

~

~M

~

~

~~

~

~

~~

~

~

~~

~~

~~

~

~

~

}2@~

~§'~

~~

§

~~

~~

~

2~§

~

~;

§~~

~

~

~g-:;g~

~re

~

$~

-..;

.: .:~

... ~

co" N

.,;..,...: ~

-'..;",

8.";OoiO

";NO

";"': 0

..",.0 -.0

-..",oD

--'" ~

0 -'"

0 --

z Z

~

~

~~

M

!~

~~

~

~

~~

~

~

~~

~~

~-~

~

~

j ~

0 ~

r; ~. ~

~

~. ~

~

j)i § g ~

~

~ 8: ~

§ ~

~

~!

~ ~

~

~

~ ~

~ r:;: g ~

~ *

~

~t!

--N

N

N~

"" ~

...:.:...:-. co"

11 ooi..,..,.

"':"'NO

co"N-.oi

s:f ..,.

0 ~

co

"':: re

0 -.co

~

---'" -.0

NoD

~

~

001~"'~

~

~

M

~~

~

~

~~

~~

~~

-~

~

~I

~ 0 ~

~

~

~

§ ~

§~.

~- ~

~. ~

~.

§ ~ §.

~.

~. ~

~

. f

~- ~. ~

*-

~. ~

. ~. r:;:-

~ ~

- ~~.~

. '§.

~K

...'" "'~

... -.0'"

='"

~.-""-'

'" ~

co.oo.o..,.o'"~

.0J.

-~

'" ..,

,", '" C

.0

---N

-0 ~

cn '"

-'" ---

~

~<

001~

~

~

M!M

~

... ~

~

~-

~

~~

~~

~~

...J~

~

M

~~

!

2°~

r;~.

~ ~

5. R

; ~

~~

§~~

~

~

:;~

~!

~*~

~

!~

~r:;:g~

~~

g

§U

J~

j --oR

N

N

~'i

~':i

r.;;" oi"':g" j

~~

~

~

c;"'i:!;R:R

:CO

""'~R

: ~

'4

cn"-l ~

-~

,

-~

~~

~

~

~

~

~~

~

M

~

~~

~

~

~-~

-~-~

~

~

~i=

0<

"35!°~M

5I~~

~-

-"'~N

8g ~

88 g

"'8"'?!. "'.o~

0

!&"'O

I"""OI"'~

'" g

U

:I:cn

...~

~

~ :-

@~

. ;. ...:S

o 0;.- -N

-;

~.

b. co :8. ~

~

. ~. ~

:o- ~

- ;- ~. ..~

. :g. ; -;

g. ~

-U

JU~

'" "'.'"

-"'... ~

'" ~

..0-..0

-NO

O"'."'O

'" '"

Z

.0 .0

~

'" 01

"'NN

N

""" -.

-'>zO

-~

,

-~

~i=

~

~

~

~

~~

M

~

~

~~

- ~

M

~~

~~

~~

~

M

~

Q.U

J<

~2°~

~§~

~~

<D

~

5I~

"'8~

88§

~

:88 r;

~

~~

re:» "'~

;:~~

g~~

:: ~

,~ "

a:.; .:

~ '" ~

-"'.

"'- ~ ~

. 0; ~.

-N

.~-

.0. -0.'; "'. "'. 01..

:So ~

"'. .-"'. ..~.o."'-

"'.to

'-'aUJ

'" '"

"'.- -"",,""".0

-"'..,... 01"""0""""'01'"

=Z

Q.

0 ~

'"

'" ~

"'0

'" ---'"

-~

'" co

Q)

-0 '"

-'" --'"

'- I-

0:J

<-l

~

~

Mj~

~

~

~~

~

~

~~

~

~

~M

M~

~001~

M

~

~

a:~~

~

~o~

r;~

~£~

<D

~

~

~~

8~

~8~

8

~8

51 ~

;g!&

-~

:!~~

~~

~~

:=3:;;

UJ-l:I:

~

"'.~~

"' "'~

"'o~

N~

"" ,

~

-C!:(;~

m

.o ~

.O'"

Q.-ll-

: .:..,;

:.., '"

co" ':co"'"

8.";OoiO

co"NO

co""': oi

O<

z ~

'"

'" ~

;;

..,oD

---N

~

..,

<>

~

~

~

~~

M

~

~M

~

~

M~

M

~

MM

MM

MM

M

M

~

~~

a: ~

~~

gg~~

~§~

§~

~28~

~

~

~8""

gm

~

~~

~~

~"'~

S:

8 :g

0<'-

c .'"

-~~

oo~

N

~

"'. ~

c

-~

~

.o", go"'.

mu.

1 ...:

.:...,. :

0 ..,.'"

0 ':co"-

oi ...co""':oco"':m

co".,;~-

zUJ

.0 ~

"'

cb """...

-N

.0 ~

-

0::»- --

a:0-l ~

~

M

~

~~

M

~

M

M~

M

M

~~

MM

MM

~M

M

~

Q.~

<

~~

0~r;5I

.;~~

o~

0~"'

o8§

0 "'0

'" ~

"""'"

~

m"'

"'oD""".o

_I--'"

0 00

~

""0'" '"

'" N

~

~

~

~

01 o~

=-o"'=

"" '"

:I: -..: :

01 01. 0 -.N

-""- oD

.'" oD.;

01. "'. '" "'.

01- 01- .0. ~. "". "'- 01 N. 01- "'.U

Z~

-'"

-~.o

-m

'" "'~

01

~

, m

"""-O

"""N~

'"

'"'"

'" '"

..,... '"

-=

0 '"

<

--'" -'"

" ...~

¥)M

~

~

~M

M

M

MM

M

M

M~

MM

MM

~

M

M~

~

~ 0 ~

re ~

~

~

~

~

§. ~

. ~ a'. ~

~.

51 ~~.

~-

~. ~

;- ~

~

- ~.,;;~.

§. ~. ~

- -:;. ~. 8. ~~

. ~

. ~

..D

0

-oD""

"'.., "'.D

01-"""

"'00l0"""0~'"

'".-oD

. o.

NoD

01

--N

'" ..,

1; N

~

~

~

44~.

44~

MM

M

M

MM

¥)

MM

MM

¥)~M

~

M

~

.~

~@

~M

g ~

~~

~

~

~£~

8° ~

~8~

~

~

g 0

~

8S:~

~

~

~~

~~

"'~2

~

:g :

~

"'~","'-

~

N~

-O~

-N

~

'" ~

~

~~

"""'01

~

..,~o~

...:8~cz

=

~~

,.,.

.: ..:~

...'8..-co"""

..,.'" co"

~

':o-~.

:...:OC

O".:

,; oi

co"...

=

~

-'" ""

""" N

"'..,-

-.., -J

M

~

MM

! M

M

44~

~

MM

~

~

M~

~~

M~

M~

~

44:

..~

~"i

c: ...~

~

,.

~G

-.C

C-

"" ~

I: ..~

!

~

."8

",,~",,~

~,,"

.~

0 -C

-~

. "

C

~

a: ...;

~"&

i

'O.~

~

:g

.I i

8~

" ",-'

>

C

~

.'" C

.It!

.c ~

0

E.

8."&

.." ~

x.

C

C

UJ'

G

C

~ ~

..~

-j

> 2 ~

>

- ~ -'

~

G :

]""

~.S

-C

~

0 o"'u.-"U

J'. "

w~

"" ..,

co ~

:c

~;a

., .",'"

Co

C

~

co -\O

J C

-C

Q

.G

i

!?' ,£ ~

~

i'

~

.? .!! ~

~

~

i ~

~

m

z. [

g, -E

..~

! ,!

~.z.

~

"-~

z",,~~

~t~

i~~

~~

"-~E

",,"~

,,1:'J~_0~

-~

iE

"..EII:

"281:.c

E80

~

" ~

"u" ~

i

:;: "-

2 ~

.!!"

~

1&1";

C

~

~

I: i"

~:5

~

~

[-=

80

~

~

c a:

~

0 8

C

~

0 "

0 u.

m

~

~

i ...~

C

C

0

~

8. ~

U

t: ~

,~

8"" ~

i".

-=co

I:.Q~

~

~

~

~~

~

~

",,0

g'o~""

-0"->

'8 o.E

~

£

~,;j~

~

t:

"§~~

co-"c-g. ..c

-U~

~"cc

"C:~

-- c

"00. -C

-c

~>

-o..oo.-'C

D £

~~-C~

] ~

a:

. iC

~0..

~ "i'

8. a: c a: ~

E

~~

'1. ~

~,~

-.=

i >

- 'C C

= Z

0

-'"

.-0. 0.

0.E

~

~

.2 ..-'"

~

-'"

-.~

-'" ..~

-.

-~

"" c

"0 =

: ~

-. ".

..xc- -,,-.

~

~ g.~

~

~

8

8 g ~

8

]" ~

" '~8

:g ~ ~

; 0

~,5

"0Oz. a. 8 8;c

"0 ]

~ ;; .;a ~

~ ~

~ ~

"0

8-O

o-a:<o<

ooo<

~

Ii:Z"-Z

:;"- ~

«a: I-

00 I-

~a:,,-"

I- ~

<

~~

UJ"--=

~O

- I-

0

--21

0 0§

R. ~

~

~

ID

'" 0 "'8

~

~

I-- ID

ID

=

~

~

ID

~

ID

a;:

=

~

0 ..~

N

0 =

'"

...=

1-- ID

O

I-- N

- '"

OID

ID

'" .'"

'" "'1---

"'IDO

NI---ID

I-- ~

'"

-.1Da..

...", ID

." '"

N

~=

In

-~

-"'1--"'-1--"'- 0

...0

ID

'" 0-

~.

..""". """,.

..0 .",.

-"'~N

1--=

O

lD

-.="'ID

1---=

N

ID

. 0

-.00>

0>=

1--0--=1--

I-- '"

~

'" ~

'"

'" =

-'"

'" ~

"'",'"

=01--1D

"'1D0'"

-'"..N

. a..

--"'.:

"'-N

ID.

"""N

'" a..

ID.

~.

: N

N

=

>

--'" -"'N

~

~

~

~

~

~

~~

~~

~~

~

~

88~re

~~

I--~

~

"'O~

N

I--

0 I--~

'" """ID

IDID

'" =

'"

.ft.ft- .-'"

N

I--N-

N

--O~

"I"

01 1---

-0>--~

_.~..

ID-.'

ID'~

"I" '"

I-- O

>'-ID

=

"'ID~

I--~

=

=0

~~

~

~~

.O

~~

...;~

~..;.:

cri 0

cri~..;

...:.".."...;..;.". '..;

...~

'"

'" ",'

-'" ~.

=-

=

I--O>

ID"I"~

'" =

'"

: ..1

-..N.N

~'

"'NN

.- ."'.1--.

>-

N

N

=

>--'"

"'N

~

~

Mo

~

~

~

~~

~~

~~

~

M

oo08

~~

~

~

~~

~

"I"ID~

-'"

ID

O~

N

-1--"'0>

-0>

0 ID

0'" ID

NN

ID

"'I--O

ft 0>

'"

N

"'0

ID

0"1" ID

"'O

ID

'" '"

-"'.ID=

. ..ID

. ID

",.-

N

'" I--

=

=

==

1--="'-

ID

0m

ID

-~

==

..N

'" ...0'

..m

.0>.

"""N

IDI--

"'.=

0 "'-",

-'" ID

ID

='"

IDO

-"'N=

0

W~

~

=

'"

'" -0

~

~.

NO

-ID

O>

ID"'~

'" W

=

: .O

. ID

. -1--.

.N.N

"'.

"'NN

~-

.-."'.>

- N

N

I--

>--'"

"'N

~

~

Mo

Mo

~

~

~*M

oMo~

* ~

~

o08~

"'~~

~

O:£~

'"

~",:g

'" N

-N

~

-I--ID=

NO

"'ID

'" ID

'"

1--0 0>

N

'"

~"'

ON

'"

N

~_ID

-I--"'W

"'I--I--O>

'"

ID~

-"'.W...

ID~

.' "I"

N'

'" =

ID

I--~

--"'-N

"'.",O

N

'"~

ID

-~

IDI--

..-'" ..~

",. =

. ~

"""N

ID

I-- =

~=

0

"'-0 '"

0 '"

1--=,.,

IDN

"I"-=ID

N-

I-- ID

~

"I" =

"",,=

0 I--

~.ID

""" ",=

If)N"""=

""'I"Ncn

: .0>

. "1".

-"'. '"

N

N

~

-N

1--. "'.

"1".<

>

- "I"

-N

I-- >

--'" -~

N

~

~

* ~

M

o *

* *

***~**

Mo

Mo

_cn ~

~~

~

~~

'"

"'~~

0>

m

-~

N

'" '"

0:£'" -0

"I" 1--"1"

N

-NW

cn-"'I--'" "1"-

0>

"'",N

'" "'0>

1-- =

0>

ID

"'=

-N

ID-N

",o>

N

~'"

"'.' '"

"" 0

0>

I-- ID

'"

-~lD

mO

>ID

W

-cn

,",- -1--",m

O>

O

..N""

."'0.. .ID

."1"'

"",- -N

N-

W=

=

1--",=

0

.-m

-'" M

"I"m

~

mm

",o-", =

If)

Z--.~

M

'"

0 '"

~

mo>

o ~.

=",

ID

=N

O~

-~

-m'"

'" '"

1--.

m

"I" N

NN

"'- ~

I--

O~

<

: ..;

.: .:

on" >

- -t'i

'..; .:

~O

ZU

~

<

~

M

o ~

*

Mo

* *

~

Mo_*~

~

~

Mo

WU

cn ~

~~

~

~~

~

=

N~

=

O

-~

I-- N

M

N

~ID

0>

"""8

"1"- '"

=-

zz"'I--ID

0'"

co ~

I--N

...="'",

ID

I-- '"

"1"",'" N

ON

I--ID

I--

I--#

..,. -N

.' 0

=.

ID

'" 0

0 '"

I--mlD

~ID

'" .If)

0-0

1ft 1--"'=

=

=

..-'" .."'1--.

.1ft .=

. -N

N-

CO

I-- =

1--",=

=

"'-'"

'" -'"

NO

O

"'-"'o=~

1---

--~

CO

'"

N

'" ~

=

0>

N

~.

~'"

'" I--N

O>

"'O~

If)

I--~

W-L-

.'" ~

m

~

.=

'"

NN

-"'- I--

IDD

..G'<

:

..; .:

.: on"

>-

-t'i '..;

.:

,... ~

0

ffi M

o ~

~

~

M

o ~

~

M

o ~

*~~

- M

o M

o!

~O

;D..

~~

~~

~

~

=

=g:~

=

C

O-~

=

-.I--~

'" N

"'-N=

I--

I---'--

0-~

N1--0

._O

N'"

--'" ~

I--

I-- =

=ID

=

~-W

O

=

=--'~

'-." '"

"'.' N

N

' =

0>

If) ~

'"

"""=N

'" N

N

--'- .1--"'=

ID

I-- ..-'"

..""". ..."'..

--'-. N

N-

IDI--

'" lD

",m

0>

"'-", ~

ID

I--

-",I-- -"'M

-'" '"

~

-~W

-~

0 '"

'" '"

~

0>

=

ID

~.O

~

'" I---O

>N

O

0 C

Ou.

W

,<

: N

. "'-

1--. -..=

- N

. N

N-",-

.CO

. "'.

D..,:j~

>

- '"

--'" >

- N

-'"

-

0 ~

~

~

M

o *

~

Mo

Mo

Mo

_*~M

o* M

o M

o

~z

<

gg~~

~

~

~

"'~~

=

"""~

-N

~

O

~I--

WI--"'-"""I--~

-'"

~

N=

ID

~-

I-- N

",N

~

WI--",

N

=

N

No>

'" N

NO

NC

O~

N-

I-- '"

--0

'.0;0 =

"'.~

'"

"'N

'" I--

'" I--

ID

I--N=

O>

"'=N

- I--

'"~

<

PO

~

~~

C

O=

cri

on"~=

on"

t'i-~.".

N

on" P

O

.".gM

""";";""on"";~on"

cri ..;

OL-W

~

'"

N

-M

~

N

=

N

~.M

OO

-1--"""=

"'1--00 -

'-.- .-'"

'" ID

. '"

W

N--N

--I--

0>u.Z

U

: t'i

.: M

>-

-.: .:

t'i

O~

~

0 ~

M

o M

o ~

M

o *

Mo

~

~-~

~~

*

~

~D

..~O

g~

~~

~

~

-N~

~

'" W

ID'b'

=

=

"'~O

C

O"'=

OID

I--

CO

N

-N=

~

0'" 0

M_N

ID

N

"'ID

ID

-NID

N

N"'M

"'I-- N

~

I--

~~

.."

0>

=.

N

",. =

I--

1--. M

-NM

=

'" '"

'"~

D..

~

="'N

=

=

..-'" ..N

~.

.N

.N.

" .'

---IDI--

~

.N=

---0>

'"

0 M

- ID

M

O>

NN

N

N

0>

-""

~

'" N

I--

M

'" ID

If)

~.-0

N

-ID"""=

I--

C)

'"<

: O

. =

N

. "".

"'- "'.

N--N

0.

"'. =

G

>-

N

-'" >

- --N

.~

M

o *

~

~

Mo

-~

~

~**~

Mo

~

~

~

U

g~~

~

~~

-"'~

~

0 ':008

0 -M

~M

M

IDM

OM

C

D

C)

N.

N=

- 1--0

M

~I--N

0

~O

OC

D

0 N

~

C)O

-N

OO

CO

I--

I-- ~

~

.." C

) M

.' M

M'

C)

'" C

) '"

-N=

O~

C

D

'" '"

C)

="'N

C

DI--

..0'" .Q

.N

",. .-.M

. C

OI--

'" ~

N=

0>

1:--1--.

~

~ID

N

I--~I--"'O

-~

C

) C

)~

'"

N

N

-;:.M

M

0 ~

...~

C)

'" 0

CD

~

~

~

.C)

=

.:

"'. =

~

N

. N

.. ~

~

. N

--N

O.~

. I--

..>

- -0

-'" >

- --N

X

.,. ..;

I: =

~

~

0 ~

~

~

~

~

~

-~~

~

~

~

~

.c~

NC

O

..Q

~

--g'

.E

.!eo c»

c» ~

~

:.~

.-VI

Q

=

C

C

.on =

.t:

~

E

"b ~

'5'- ~

~

~

>'

.C

=-0

0 ~

c-8' I:

~

~U

on

0 "';0

~

0 .,-

g' a:

.~

~

.m

E

o: .,

~~

-' ~

"C-g.;;,.

C

.~.-,

co" "C

~cn

E.~

~

c» ~

. I:

W'

on0

o~

0 ~

O'

~?:C

o"B.

.~!

m

C

-.~..0:.0

It ?:-~

e

-~)(-'

~

.~

~,g

~

i !:

~

-~

.~o~

u.

I:cnUJ",-

~

:1: -~

e

~~

~

cn 13~

~

Q

cn!~

>

' ~

~I:O

..t.

~~

-~

8.

VI

)( '-

I-~

~

<"itt

~on!l~

~

~

~~

z ~

C

»I:.O

~

W

E

-~

~V

I ~

~

0: V

I .;0

on '5.] 0:

~'~

Q;E

'0

on"'. l~

~~

'-

coO

O~

~

C

»8

0.9'<

E

"itt"itt

E

OJ

~

~

~ 8

&

>'

: 0

0. e

I: ~

~

~

~

..,,~E

s

~

~:-5

~

on ~

.§ ~

VI Z

V

I 8 0: 0:

0 ~

C

C 0

0 >

- O

J ~

C

» ~

u. .=

C

C

W

"rc 8.~;

E .:;

~

)( 5

c .E

. ~

E

E

E 0:

~

~

&

~

'tI '0

'0 g,~

~

..'a,~

>

' '8

~

~

e go ~

~

-0 C

o ~

~

C

» ~ ~

~

~

~

-g

i go

08

8 ~"i

~

~

Q) ~

~

Q

; Q; ~

0 ~

~

] &

~

~

~

0: a:

i \:

on ~ ~

~

.~

~

~

>-~

g ~

g

0 ~

-.;

o:a: '5.

Coo.

E'tI.o.o~

O"t)

~-'=

. -cn~

E

-o- 'tI.~

~~

C»Q

)e-s- -..u

--,: ~

~

~

e

0 E

E

~

,-=

0

'- "'-

~;o

~

-Q)

~

.~

0 0

~

I: E

~

.~

~

Co

~

~

~

~

.~13

S

=

u u

u ~

0

0 ~

~

~

on

0 :g

0 ~

~

0

==

,5 0

~

.-0 0

0 0

-0 =

=

c

e on.-

0 0

~

0

~~

~o

00 <

&

~Z

Zo.>

u. ~

z<o:

I- 00

I- O

Qo:u.1-

~<

~~

wo.E

.~1-

I- 0

cn

.-~

--22...",0)

-M"'O

) '"

M

"'0 O

Il)NO

N

0 "'-

'" 0-

"'- 11)- '" O

. "'-

~

M

N~

-"'...~

...~

~

~

~

~~

$~

$.N

O

M

--M

->

- ~

~

~

~~

~

~

N

N

"'... N

0)

0) 0)

N'"

0) 0

~

11)- Q

)- O

. M

- Q

)- "'-

~

~

~

iO"~

~

~

Q)

": "'.

-.M

": N

->

- N

N

~

N

-

~

~

~~

~

~

'" '"

0) '"

'" N

M

M

M'"

M

'"

~

0- 0-

"'- --0-

"'-~

$

$ :8~

$

~Q

) 1/)-

"'- '": M

"'-

O.

>-

N

'" -N

-

~

~

~.,.

.,. .,.

I/) '"

0) I/) '"

-'"

'" -'"

'" Q

)...M

- M

. M

. 0- M

- 0)-

~~

'"

'" M

'"

'" ...

.N

N

-0) N

-

00 Q

) ~

"'-

N_N

~

. 01

-00 >

- N

N

-N

~:s.,.

.,. .,..,.

.,. ~

::;,<

N

-M

'" M

Q)'"

'" ;:-

0) '"

01 "'O

IN

01 ...

Z

W

00 --N

- '":

"'. "'- "'-

M- -"'.

--I/)

0 -00

-"'0 '"

N00

<

,., ~

II)

...m

M

U)

M

'" M

...

Z~

.."'-

~.

"'. "'.

11)- Q) N

"'. ~

00- >

- ~

~

...r-.

'" ...

OZ

[I:~

[I:O

~

~

~.,.

~~

.,. ~

.,.

(.,):;)J: Q

) ~

0)'"

Q)

'"W

L-(.,)'" ...0-'"

I/)r-

I/) '"

M

r-. '"

'"~

W

Z

U

t..: ..:

",- 0"':

.,.-0

[I: ~

...'"

...'" M

...Q

)-Q

) '"

II) N

'"

'"[I: c

->-..:

..: ..:

D..Z

W,,<

" ~

.,.

~~

~

.,.

CO

Z

C

... ...M

O)

...I/)Q

) 000

Q)

Q)

Q)M

~

'"

'- t=

:>

-J .,.

"'- "'-

M- "'.

N.

"'-:)

<>

~

~

~

~

~

~

~C

I [I:O

>

: '"

I/) m

N

'" V

iI: W

Ii ~

>

-..: ..:

-'

D..-J-J

~

~

~.,.

.,. ~

0«>

M

N

...N

0)...0 N

N

<-

I/) IX

) N

'"

0 "'~

'"

M,..

I/) 0)

0) V

0)

'" '"

V

'"~

'""'Z

M..

~z

'" 0

M

-V

MO

O

~

m

...I/) N

I/)'" M

""-« Q

) 0)

0- N

. "'-

M-

"'- N

- ~

OZ

"- >

- ~

V

'"

U)

'"

LI..-ZO

Ll..:;) ~

~

~

~

~

~.,.

~

~[I:C

O

N

N

1/)0) N

Q

) '"

~W

M

'"

...'" Q

) 0

D.. L- ~

N

M

- ~

" '"'.

11)- M- M

- ~

. "'.

r-:r-

-~

1/)'" ~

M

N

(.,)J: ~

I/)

I/) M

'" I/)

...01W

,.. ~

IX

) m

"'-

~--

'"'" >

- M

~<

.,.

0" ~

~

~

.,..,..,.D

..[I:

:;) N

N

I/)

01 m

J:'" ...V

I/)

M01

01 -0

...

(.,) :

oj oj

r-:M.

oj.IX

) IX

) V

M

0

...Q

) 1/)-

-0)>

- (;I

M~

~

~

~

~.,.

.!!IX

0 0

0 0

0 0"

Mc

I/) 0

'" I/)

I/) I/)

~O

N

0 N

N

N

N

""'

E

~~

~

§ ~

~

~

~

g

.~

-2:

-V-

O.

0- 0_.

e~

--~

-'"

m

m

~

~

-M

~

-(I) -.S

c ~

'"

't:0

~

~co

U

0 ~

~

~

~

~

.,..,. Ii:

S

~~

~

-,

'" 0

'"~

~

E

-=

~

-~

0---0

~.c

~~

~

~

-0"0; ~

VI~

~~

~

-=

~

LL Q

)a: -

~

E

.c .c

.c -;

-; -;

"i .9-

I- .c

.:=!

-0uS

c..c..c.._==

V

I.,.,.._U~

M

~

0

~...C

)-.

2;- )-.

0 0

0 ~

0

.=

-m

~

~

!l:'-'~

5'~"

..""

.~~

~~

clt2. U

--:-

CD

C"C

OC

" ~

... -~

I:e

~II)

.=

UJ

UJ

UJ

.c .r:.r:"

c C

C

8

~

m

'a; ~

a:

U~

~

~

~

~

~

8..~

~

~

.~ "1:;

29 ~

.~ ~

j

! !

~

~0.

§ ~

~

,

U)

--U).n

u. ~

-ft

-~a

~

-D

D

a ~

---"

--'" -

~

w

o"""w.

MM

M__.r:.

>

-~

-

->

>

>

>

-C

C

C

.D

.D

~

-A'

--0~

~0000000

88000"0

-.;~

(/)zooo~

~~

a:1- 00001-

0 ,-

--./.'"

Figure 9

PRO FORMA OPERATING PROJECTIONSCHUGACH MOUNTAIN VALLEY LODGE, ANCHORAGE, ALASKA

DEBT SERVICE ANALYSIS

Debt Service Analysis

Interest Rate 8.5%Financing Period 20 Years

.Outstanding Total TotalPrincipal Annual Interest

Years Amount Payments Portion

Phase I $ 6,437,000

1 $ 6,437,000 $ 680,204 $ 547,145

2 6,303,941 680,204 535,835

3 6,159,572 680,204 523,564

4 (Phase II) 10,286,858 1,087,022 874,383

5 10,074,219 1,087,022 856,309

6 9,843,505 1,087,022 836,698

7 (Phase II) 14,274,343 1,508,384 1,213,319

8 13,979,279 1,508,384 1,188,239

9 13,659,134 1,508,384 1,161,026

10 13,311,776 1,508,384 1,131,501

REVERSIONARY VALUE (SALE)

10th Year Operating Income $ 2,933,434

Overall Capitalization Rate 12.0%

Reversionary Value $ 24,445,280

Less Cost of Sale $ 977,811

Less Mortgage Repayment $ 12,934,894

Net Proceeds Before taxes $ 10,532,575

Source: Office of Thomas J. Martin 1162htl3.xls17 9/94

--,j.,'+

Agure 10

PRO FORMA OPERATING PROJECTIONSANALYSIS ASSUMPTIONS

CHUGACH MOUNTAIN VALLEY LODGE, ANCHORAGE, ALASKA

Develo ment and Construction Assum tions 0 tions

Building Size in SF Phase I 35,000 Rooms Depart. Expense % to Rooms Revenue 25%

Gift St"M:>p Square Footage 300 Net Margin on Food & Beverage 80%

Development Hard Costs Per SF Phase I $ 162.00 Admin. & Gen. % of Gross Revenue -Plus 2.5%

Building Size in SF Phase II 22,000 Administrative Axed Cost $ 125,000

Development Hard Costs Per SF Phase II $ 177.02 Marketing % of Gross Revenue 5.0%

Building Size in SF Phase III 22,000 MainL & Operation % of Gross Revenue 4.5%

Development Hard Costs Per SF Phase III $ 193.44 Energy and Utilities Cost Per SF $ 7.00

Development Soft Costs % to Hard Costs 25% Property Taxes as a % of Construction Cost 1.0%

FF&E Costs as a % of Hard Costs 10% Insurance % of Gross Revenue 1.0%

Number of rooms Phase I 50 Miscellaneous % of Gross Revenue 5.0%

Number of rooms Phase II 50 % increase in Non Departmental Expenses

Land Acquisition Cost $ 250,000 Upon Project Expansion Phases 20%

Gift Shop Cost of Goods Sold 50%

OperatinQ Assumptions Financial Assumptions

Basic Room Rate $ 140 Permanent Financing Interest Rate 8.50%

Shoulder Season Premium To Room Rate 15.0% Anancing Period -Years 20

Summer Premium To Room Rate 25.0% Debt/Equity Ratio 80%

Persons Per Room 2 Cash Row Discount Rate 1 ~/o

Average Nights Stayed at Facility 3.00 Residual Cap Rate 12.0%

Rooms closed during Winter months 20 10th Year Sales Cost 4.0%

Visitor Daily Food & Beverage Spending $ 40.00 Inflation Rate 3.0%

Avg. Per Person Non-Lodging FoodExpenditures $ 12.00

Growth In Demand for Food & Lodging

Until Full Capacity Is Reached 2%

Other Revenue Per Visitor $ 2.00

Total Gift St"M:>p Sales Per Square Foot $ 250.00

Source: Office of Thomas J. Martin 1162htl3.x1s1 9/94

--25

IX. DEVELOPMENT STRATEGIES

There are a number of sites within Anchorage where the proposed development can occur.

The Anchorage Economic Development Corporation supports the development initiative

outlined in this report and requests that potential developers contact AEDC for more

information on this development opportunity.

-