dimensions, and thermal stability of some heulandite … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the...

31
American Mineralogist Vol. 57, pp. 1463-149s (1972) COMPOSITION, OPTICAL PROPERTIES, CELL DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE GROUP ZEOLITES JeunsR. Bor,us,l Department of Geologg,UniuersitE ol Otago, Dunedin, N eus Zoal,and ABSTRACT Cell dimensions, optical, and thermal stability data are given for 14 analyzed heulandites and clinoptilolites, including 7 new analyses from Murihiku Super- group tuffs, New Zealand. The Murihiku specimens have a wide range of Si/Al ratios (3.G-4.3) and are rich in Ca. If both loosely and tightly bound water are considered, then 5.7 -{- 0.6 HrO moleculesare co-ordinated about divalent cations; and 3.2 -+ 0.5 moleculesabout monovalent cationsin heulanditegroup minerals. Crystals mo,unted in Lakeside 70 are length fasi if Si,/Al ( 3.52 and length slow if Si/Al > 3.57. Refractive index is strongly influenced by the types of cationspresent. Comparison of calcula,tedcell dimensions indicates that (l) clinoptilolites typically have smaller a, c, and p parameters then heulandites; (2) the area of the ac plane increaseswith increasing Al or divalent cation substitution; (3) b increases with increasing Mg substitution. Unit cell dimensions are given for two different contracted phases,phase 1 and phaseB of a dehydrated heulandite from Cape Blomidon, Nova Scotia. The phases appear at temperatures as low as 202"C -+ 3". For 11 heulandites and clinoptilolite the initiat change to phase 1 occurs at from 213"C to 312'C -+ 3' after heating for 2 hours and cooling for t hour. Three types of thermal stability are recognized in the mineral group. Minerals with a sum of unit cell divalent cations equal to or greater than 1.87 contract after heating. Higher temperatnres are required to contract samples with higher Si/Al ratios. INrnolucrroN The relationship betweenheulandite and clinoptilolite has been in disputefor some time. Hey and Bannister (1934)regarded clinop- tilolite as isostruct;ural with heulandite and favored the use of the term high-silica heulandite insteadof clinoptilolite.Mumpton (1960) and Mason and Sand (1960) regarded the two minerals as distinct species, but did not agree on the means to distinguish them. Mumpton believeddistinction was possible on the basis of Si/Al ratio and he suggested that the higher thermal stability of clinoptilolite provides an easy test for identification. Mason and Sand, on the other hand emphasized cations as the distinguishing featureand stated that heulandites have dominantCa ions but clinoptilolites have domi- l Present address: Geology Department, University of Wyoming, Laramie, Wyoming 82070. 1463

Upload: others

Post on 21-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

American MineralogistVol. 57, pp. 1463-149s (1972)

COMPOSITION, OPTICAL PROPERTIES, CELLDIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF

SOME HEULANDITE GROUP ZEOLITES

Jeuns R. Bor,us,l Department of Geologg,UniuersitE ol Otago,Dune din, N eus Z oal,and

ABSTRACT

Cell dimensions, optical, and thermal stability data are given for 14 analyzedheulandites and clinoptilolites, including 7 new analyses from Murihiku Super-group tuffs, New Zealand. The Murihiku specimens have a wide range of Si/Alratios (3.G-4.3) and are rich in Ca.

If both loosely and tightly bound water are considered, then 5.7 -{- 0.6 HrOmolecules are co-ordinated about divalent cations; and 3.2 -+ 0.5 molecules aboutmonovalent cations in heulandite group minerals.

Crystals mo,unted in Lakeside 70 are length fasi if Si,/Al ( 3.52 and lengthslow if Si/Al > 3.57. Refractive index is strongly influenced by the types ofcations present.

Comparison of calcula,ted cell dimensions indicates that (l) clinoptilolitestypically have smaller a, c, and p parameters then heulandites; (2) the areaof the ac plane increases with increasing Al or divalent cation substitution;(3) b increases with increasing Mg substitution.

Unit cell dimensions are given for two different contracted phases, phase 1and phase B of a dehydrated heulandite from Cape Blomidon, Nova Scotia. Thephases appear at temperatures as low as 202"C -+ 3". For 11 heulandites andclinoptilolite the initiat change to phase 1 occurs at from 213"C to 312'C -+ 3'after heating for 2 hours and cooling for t hour.

Three types of thermal stability are recognized in the mineral group. Mineralswith a sum of unit cell divalent cations equal to or greater than 1.87 contractafter heating. Higher temperatnres are required to contract samples with higherSi/Al ratios.

INrnolucrroN

The relationship between heulandite and clinoptilolite has beenin dispute for some time. Hey and Bannister (1934) regarded clinop-tilolite as isostruct;ural with heulandite and favored the use of theterm high-silica heulandite instead of clinoptilolite. Mumpton (1960)and Mason and Sand (1960) regarded the two minerals as distinctspecies, but did not agree on the means to distinguish them.

Mumpton believed distinction was possible on the basis of Si/Alratio and he suggested that the higher thermal stability of clinoptiloliteprovides an easy test for identification. Mason and Sand, on theother hand emphasized cations as the distinguishing feature and statedthat heulandites have dominant Ca ions but clinoptilolites have domi-

l Present address: Geology Department, University of Wyoming, Laramie,

Wyoming 82070.

1463

Page 2: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

L4M JAMES R, BOLES

nant Na and K ions. Furthermore, they suggested that clinoptiloliteshave a beta index of refraction less than 1.4g5 but heulandites havea beta index of refraction greater than 1.4gg.

Although most zeolites of this structural group can be classifiedusing the criteria of both workers, some investigators have reportedzeolites with intermediate properties, e.g., Iijima (196l), Hay (iOOa),Shepard (1961), Brown et a,t. (t920), Alietti (1967; 1972), and Minatoand utada (1970). Anomalous properties were.also found by the writerin a study of many altered vitric tuffs from the Murihiku Supergroupof rriassic age, southland syncline, New zearand,. The question mavbe asked: "Do heulandites and clinoptilolites represent dirtinci co*-positional groups or do varieties which have intermediate compositionsexist"? If the latter is true, a redefinition of present terminology isrequired to classify these intermediate specimens.

This study attempts to clarify the compositional relationship be-tween these zeolites. Furthermore, the relationships between mineralcomposition and unit cell dimensions, thermal stability, and opticalproperties were studied to predict the composition by ihese physicalproperties. A relatively wide range of si/Al ratios in the New zialand,samples provided an opportunity to evaluate these properties over arange of compositions.

Sa rvrpr,n Pnep,cnerto \.-

.. The following sample preparation was used specifically for optical, celldimension, and thermal stability determinations. Afler .*.hiog with a TEMArotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving.The powders, except for sampres 1 and 6, were repeatedry centrifuged in abromoform-acetone mixture to obtain the fraction having a iensity <i.za. tti,procedure resulted in a zeolite concentrate with (z percent impuiities. rn.spection in oils revealed the main impurities to be quartz and ihyllosilicateminerals. centrifuging was not required for samples 1 and 6 u, it uv ctotaio(3 percent impurities. Quartz was used for an internal X-ray standa.d. whu."necessar-y, a small amount of quarta was added, and the sample was groundfor a few minutes to assure mixing of the standard.

Hnur,exnrrn-Cr,rNoprrr,or,rrp CHnlr.rsrRyTable I gives heulandite and clinoptilolite analyses for samples

from the Murihiku rocks and for specimens from othlr areas. Zeolitesin the Murihiku tuffs were analysed by electron microprobe. Analysesof the other samples are from published wet chemical data of otherinvestigators.

Analytical procedure lor EMA analgs,isPolished thin sections of each sampre were anaryzed using a B-spectrometer

ARL electron microprobe analyzer at the Research school oirnyri*i-s.i"o""r,Australian National university, canberra, Australia, volatilization of liglt ete_

Page 3: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GROUP 1465

ments was reduced by using low sample currents of 0.028-0O30 pA at L3.5 kV,and a beam diameter of 10 pm. Silicon, aluminium, and iron were determinedsimultaneously as were calcium, sodium, and potassium.

A decrease in count rate occurs for sodium with consecutive 4-secondcounting intervals on the same spot. Potassium and calcium generally showlittle difference to slight gains with consecutive counting intervals. Silicon andaluminium count rates usually increase slightly with consecutive intervals. Theresults indicate that the light elements were volatilized. Hence, for each ele-ment about 10 spots were analyzed for 4 seconds each, after which another 10spots were analyzed for 8 seconds each. The counts were averaged for eachtimed interval and corrected for baekground and dead time. For samples whereobvious volatilization had occurred, the provisional oxide values were extrap-olated to zero time. Sodium shows up to 0.30 wt. percent loss of oxide valuesbetween 4-second and 8-second counts. Potassium and calcium sometimes showlosses of up to 0.15 weight percent. Appropriate gains occur in the provisionaloxide values of aluminium and silicon between 4-second and &second counts.In some samples, the count rates show opposite trends to what is expected withvolatilization, indicating that a slight compositional variation may exist inthe sample. Only the more accurate 8-second values were used for calculationin these samples. The compositional variations as inferred from these reversetrends never exceed 2 percent of the amount present. The provisional oxidevalues were then corrected for atomic number, absorption, and fluorescence.

To check the quality of the extrapolation technique, microprobe analyseswere made of a heulandite (sample 1) that was analyzed by wet chemicalmethods. The corrected microprobe values for SiOz and ALO. are within Ipercent of the amount shown in the wet chemical analyses, and CaO, SrO,Na"O, K-O are within 2-6 percent. As only one or two significant figures arereported for the oxides in the west chemical analyses, the agreement is consideredsatisfactory.

The quality of the EMA analyses can also be checked by the charge balancebetween the exchangeable cations (including Md-) aT a tetrahedral Al# zub-stitution. The sum of exchangeable cationic charges in the unit cell shouldequal the number of R"* cations in the tetrahedral sites in order that the struc-ture be electrically neutral. For samples in Table I the charge balance isgenerally within 0.5 units. Most of the analyses are slightly deficient in ex-changeable cations probably as a result of volatilization.

Samples 1, 6, 9, 10 and 12 through 14 are from wet chemica"l data by otherworkers; except for number 14, the samples used for this study are reportedlyimpure portions of the original analyzed specimens. An impure whole rockanalysis reported by Ames et al. (1958) on the flector, California tuff is used

for sample 14 although the analysis includes some quartz, calcite, and clayminerals. I do not know how closely specimen O'U' 16672 conforms to this

analysis. No analyses are available of samples 15 and 16, the former specimen

being too fine-grained for EMA analysis even using a beam with a diameter of

10 pm.

Si/ Al ratios

Mumpton (1960) proposed a molecular SiO2/Al2O3 ratio of 5.5 to6.4 for heulandites and 8.5 to 10.5 for clinoptilolites, corresponding to

Page 4: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

1466 JAMES R. BOLES

Si/Al ratios of 2.75-3.25 for heulandites and 4.25-5.25 for clinop-tilolites. He also suggested a compositional gap between the two min-erals and that clinoptilolite should be classified as a distinct mineralspecies.

Table 1 shows that all New Zealand samples except numbers 2and 11 fall within the supposed compositional gap. Samples 6, 9,and 10 also have "intermediate" Si/Al ratios as defined by Mumpton.Similarly Piekarska and Gawel (1954), Hay (1963), P6csi-Don6,th(1966), Alietti (1967) and Brown et aL (1969) reported zeolites ofthis structural group with intermediate Si/AI ratios. Figure 1 is ahistogram of Si/Al ratios from published heulandite-clinoptiloliteanalyses. Also included in Figure 1 are unpublished values for speci-mens from the Murihiku tuffs which have been analyzed by electronmicroprobe. Seemingly, Si/Al ratios in the heulandite-clinoptiloliteseries between 2.75 and 5.25 are possible although most of the heu-landites and clinoptilolites probably fall within the two groups definedby Mumpton. Although there seems to be a complete range of Si/Alratios, zeolites of this structural group with SilAl ratios of 3.75-4.00are either rare or rarely analyzed. ,However, if Si/Al * Fes* ratios areplotted several more analyses will fall within this interval.

Cation aontent

Mason and Sand (1960) indicated that heulandites can be distin-guished from clinoptilolites on the basis of the ratio of monovalentto divalent cations. They contended that (Na * K) exceeds Ca inclinoptilolites but is less than Ca in heulandites. On this basis, allthe New Zealand samples would be classified as heulandites, and theremaining specimens listed in Table 1, except sample 1, would beclassifled as clinoptilolites.

The New Zealand samples are unusual in that they have lowNa/K ratios and are relatively high in Mg. Mg is probably a com-mon impurity in wet chemical analyses of clinoptilolites and heu-landites separated from vitric tuffs because of intimately associatedphyllosilicate minerals which commonly line the altered glass shards.Electron microprobe analyses should minimize this contamination.Electron microprobe analysis of the phyllosilicate minerals associatedwith the relict shards in the New Zealand tuffs indicates that totalFe2O3 exceeds MgO by a factor of 2 to 5. Low Fe9O3 in these samples,except for number 7, indicates that most of the Mg in the analyzedshards of the New Zealand specimens is not related to phyllosilicateimpurities. Many of the altered glass shards in the New Zealandtuffs have an abundance of minute reddish brown inclusions which

Page 5: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GNOAP T467

are thought to be hematite, accounting for at least some of the TezOsin the analyses of Table 1.

K-rich specimens with Si/Al ratios ) 4.00 have been describedfrom Japan by Minato and Utada (1970). Minato and Utada de-scribed sample 10 of Table 1 as a "Ca-clinoptilolite" although on thebasis of unit cell contents the specimen is slightly richer in K than Ca.

Although "zeoliLic"-Lype substitution, i.e., (Na*, K.)2 for Car*,would theoretically permit Na-rich, K-rich, and Ca-rich members ofany Si/Al ratio, recorded natural specimens do not show such exten-sive variation. Conspicuously absent are analyses of natural heu-landites with Si/Al < 3.50 and dominantly monovalent cations. Theonly sample of this type which has been reported is a K-rich heu-landite (Si/Al - 3.46) recorded by Alietti (19G2).

The reason for the rarity of such variants may be the large num-ber of monovalent cations that would be required to balance the nega-tive charge of the higlrly aluminous framework. The large number ofions required might create undesirable cation-cation interactions. Nev-ertheless, such Na (or K) heulandites have been formed from Caheulandites by means of ion-exchange experiments at temperaturesgreaterthan 100"C (Shepard and Starkey, 1966).

HpO content

The water content for the electron microprobe analyses shown inTable 1 is calculated by difference. Most of these analyses are some-what low in total water, probably as a result of water loss duringprobing. Therefore, the unit cell water is not calculated for thesesamples. The relative increase in the other oxides due to loss ofwater will not affect the unit cell contents calculated on the basisof 72 oxygen atoms in the anhydrous unit cell.

It is not clear in zeolites which part of the total water content issignificant to the structure. I have not attempted to distinguish betweenloosely and tightly bound water, in part, because Breger et al. (1970)have pointed out that determinations of HzO' by conventional meth-ods can give results of doubtful significance in the case of heulanditegroup minerals. Furthermore, removal of even the loosely bound waterresults in a structural contraction (Ogawa , 1967; Breger et al., 7970).Most of the more loosely bonded water in a heulandite studied byMerkle and Slaughter (1968) was found to occupy specifi.c sites inthe structure.

Breger et aI. (197O) suggested that the correct, amount of tightlybound water in a heulandite and a clinoptilolite which they studiedwould correspond to 8-9 H2O molecules per 72 oxygen unit cell. If

Page 6: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

TASLE I: CHWICN, OPTICI, TgEru STA3ILIry, AND CELL DIENSION DATA FOR 15 HEUI.ANDITE

5 6 . 8 6 0 . 6 1 6 2 . 8 5 6 3 , 7 6 6 3 . 5 6 6 7 . 1 4 6 4 , 3 6 6 3 . 0 11 6 . 6 1 7 . 0 3 1 5 . 3 9 ! s . 5 2 r s . 3 2 L 4 . 5 2 1 4 . 3 0 1 3 . 3 0

McoCeOSr0B a o t r . d . 0 . 3 5 < 0 . 1 7 < 0 . 1 7 o . d . n . d . < 0 . I 7 n . d 'N a 2 o 1 , 6 L O 7 0 . 3 5 0 . 2 6 O . L 2 4 . 4 a 0 , 2 1 O . 2 4K " O 0 . 8 2 . 7 6 2 . O O 0 . 3 3 0 . 4 7 0 . 9 4 2 . 4 0 l - 7 6H ; O c r s . 7 s 1 1 . 8 0 1 3 . 0 2 1 2 . 8 3 1 2 . 0 9 1 4 . 1 6 1 2 . 0 1 1 6 . 0 0TOTAL 99.44 1qO.0O 1O0.OO 1OO.OO 100.00 99.12 100.00 100.00neiFr*r,w

1 . 5 0 6 ( 3 ) 1 . 5 0 2 ( 2 ) 1 . 5 0 0 ( 2 ) 1 . 4 9 9 ( 1 ) 1 . 5 0 8 ( 3 ) 1 ' 4 8 7 ( 2 ) 1 . 4 9 8 ( 1 ) 1 . 4 9 6 ( 1 )Optical oElental ione

AI 'O!ezO c E O . O 3 0 . 3 8 0 . 2 9 0 . 6 3 n . d ' 7 , L 2 0 . 6 7

r r 0 . 5 4 0 . 7 7 0 . 6 7 0 , 4 5 0 . 2 8 0 . 8 3 1 . 3 55 . 8 6 . 2 3 5 . 2 4 6 . 3 4 7 . L 6 3 . 6 0 4 . 5 6 3 . 6 72 . 0 0 . 1 8 < 0 . 0 9 < 0 . 0 9 0 . 2 0 n . d . O . 2 I < 0 . 0 9

fas ! fas ! fas t t

Unit cell diDensloDJ

b

B

7 7 . 7 2 5 7 7 . 7 2 3 r 7 . 7 0 3 1 7 . 7 o O L 7 , 6 9 6 r 7 ' 5 7 0 r 7 , 6 9 7 1 1 . 6 9 4r 7 . a 6 4 1 7 . 9 1 5 1 8 . 0 1 9 r 7 . 9 9 6 1 7 , 9 4 4 l 7 . 9 A 2 1 8 . 0 3 1 1 8 . 0 5 4

7 . 4 2 7 7 . 4 3 1 7 . 4 2 2 7 . 4 2 5 7 , 4 2 3 7 . 4 0 4 7 . 4 r 2 7 . 4 1 6Lr5"24.21 u6"22.O' 116'21.1' L76"24.9' 116"24. 'O' 116'23.6' rL6"22.7' 776'22.6'

v o ] . @ e 2 , 7 0 6 . 5 2 , 1 1 4 . 3 2 , L 2 r . 6 2 ' 7 1 8 . 7 2 , 1 I I . 3 2 ' 7 0 7 ' 4 2 ' r I A . 4 2 ' 1 2 2 . 7

Theml 8 rab l l1 tygH U H E T { 1 I I 1

N@ber of lons on the basle of 72 ory8enss tAIFet3H g .CaS rB a 0 . 0 6N a 7 . 4 6 0 . 9 2 0 . 3 0 0 . 2 3K 0 . 4 8 1 . 2 3 1 . 1 4 0 . 1 817zO 24.A2s l / A 1 2 , 9 L 3 , D 2 3 . 4 7 3 , 4 92 (Ca+!tg+Sr+ B a ) + ( N a + K ) 8 . 9 2 9 . 0 5 7 . 4 6 7 . 2 1

2 6 . 8 4 2 7 , 0 2 2 7 , 2 9 2 E . O 7 2 7 . 9 4 2 8 , 0 0 2 A . 3 9 2 8 . 7 99 . 2 5 8 . 9 5 8 . 0 7 8 . 0 5 7 , 9 4 7 . A 4 7 . 4 3 7 . 1 6

0 . 0 1 0 . 1 3 0 . 1 0 0 . 2 1 0 . 3 7 0 . 2 30 . 3 6 0 . 5 1 0 , 4 4 0 . 2 9 0 . 1 9 0 . 5 5 0 . 9 2

2 , 9 4 2 . 9 8 2 . 5 0 2 . 9 9 3 . 3 7 ! . 7 7 2 . 1 5 1 . 8 10 . 5 5 0 . 0 5 0 . 0 5 0 . 0 5

0 . 1 0 3 . 9 8 0 . 1 80 . 2 6 0 . 5 5 1 . 3 5

21.7 43 . 5 2 3 . 5 7 3 . 4 2

o . 2 71.03

4 . 0 0

7 , 7 8 8 , 4 5 7 . O 3 6 . 7 0

sJ.02 63.74 65.17 67.45i l r o r 1 3 . 1 5 1 3 . 3 8 1 3 . 2 7r e l o . a o l . 0 6 0 . 3 1M C O 0 0 . 5 3 I . 0 3c a o 7 , 3 7 3 . 2 2 3 . 8 6S r O n . d . n . d . < 0 . 0 9B a O n . d , n . d . < 0 . 1 7N a 2 o 3 . 6 8 ! . 6 2 0 . 2 6K z O 3 . r 7 2 . 8 2 2 . 2 5E2Oe 74.A7 11.43 11.56

6 4 . 7 0L 2 . 4 3o , 4 40 . 3 41 . 2 6B . d .0 . 5 34 . 3 22 . 2 8

6 5 . 1 0 6 7 . 7 91 1 . 0 6 1 1 . 2 8

1 . 4 8 0 . 8 51 . 0 7 0 . 4 00 , 2 2 0 . 5 8n . d . n . d ,E . d . n , d .

2 . 9 4 1 . 0 7L 2 . 7 3 7 2 . 0 6

TOTA.L 99.98 99.39I{ea-refi-t

-i;e;d-

7 . 4 8 O ( 2 \ L 4 e 7 Q ) r . 4 9 4 ( 2 \ t - . 4 7 9 Q ) r . 4 7 7 Q ) r , 4 7 6 ( 2 ' 1 . 4 8 4 ( 2 ' r . s O O ( 2 )

opt ica l o r len ta t lones low s low s lou s los s low €1ow s loe fas l-ure

a : . 7 . 6 5 0 1 7 , 6 8 3 1 7 . 6 8 9 L 7 . 6 2 7 1 7 . 6 3 5 7 7 . 6 2 3 1 7 . 6 4 9 1 7 . 7 L 8b 77.917 18.025 18.044 77.955 17.968 71.909 77.902 18'019c 7 . 4 0 4 7 . 4 0 8 7 . 4 0 8 7 . 3 9 9 7 . 3 9 2 7 . 3 9 5 7 . 4 O 1 7 . 4 2 8s 1 1 6 ' 1 7 . 2 ' 7 1 6 " 2 4 . 3 ' 7 7 6 " 2 r . 2 ' 7 1 6 ' r 7 . 3 ' | 1 1 6 " 1 8 . 7 ' r 1 6 ' 1 5 . 3 r 1 1 6 ' 1 6 . 4 r 1 1 6 ' 2 3 , 6 'v o l s e 2 , 0 9 9 . 6 2 . 7 1 5 . 1 2 , n 8 , 8 2 , 0 9 9 . 7 2 , 0 9 9 . 8 2 , 0 9 3 , 4 2 , O 9 A . 7 2 , 1 2 4 . 4Theru1 stabilityg

c r r c c c c H

s i 2 9 , 0 9 2 A , 7 A 2 9 , 2 4 2 9 . 7 9 2 9 . 2 7 2 9 . 7 3A 1 7 , O 7 6 , 9 6 6 . 7 A 6 , 6 7 5 . 8 6 5 . 8 3F e + 3 0 . 3 5 o . r o 0 . 1 5 o . 5 o 0 . 2 8u c 0 . 3 5 0 . 6 7 O , 2 3 O , 7 2 0 . 2 6c a , 5 7 L , 5 2 1 , 7 9 0 . 6 1 0 . 1 1 O . 2 7

:^N a 3 . 2 5 1 . 3 9 0 . 2 3 0 . 0 9 4 . 4 4 5 . 0 7K 1 . 8 4 1 . 6 0 1 . 2 5 1 . 3 1 1 ' 6 8 0 . 6 0H z O 2 2 . 6 3 1 6 . 8 4 2 O . 4 O 1 9 . 0 9 1 1 - 6 4s i / A 1 4 . r 2 4 . 1 3 4 , 3 1 4 , 4 r 5 . 0 0 5 . 1 0

2 (Ca{g+Sti i " ) + i n " + r ) 0 . + a 6 . 7 3 6 . 4 0 6 . 9 5 7 ' 8 2

4 A*Lysee conected fa" co2 and equiDaLent Cao to mke caLcite,b oLL t" in eLectrcn micvoF,lobe @a,!ses @smed to be P?esett 6 te2o3'

e H2o in electrcn mieroprcbe tuL!;ee iletemined by dLfferenee-d Mnosun.

"nt" in MaD Light. an- =

fiAe Fast @') ov ela (r') dLreetion parcLLet to clealage or fibet T.ength df,te! tuwting

an MKesLde /u.f st*a*d em! in a, b ' e, are LeeB tL@ !0.002! i .n B Le88 t l@ !0.41

9 Themal stabiLita ?efere to cheges in x-rcy pufui dlff,tactim PattenB lfte! hedting

far Ls how6 at 450oC.C = Na chege in d-spaeings. Mi@? Possible i4tensit! Losar = clwnge i" a-"paiingei hoaeoet a portion of nlneml pereieto aith otigiwl

d-epaeings, Majo? intensit! Lo63H = Essentialla conplete ilaettuction

Page 7: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEALANDITE GNOUP

this small amount of water is the only water which is essential to thestructure of the mineral group, then why do naturally occurring speei-mens show total water contents which consistently vary between 19and 26 H2O molecules per 72 oxygen unit cell? For the above reasons,I believe that both loosely and more tightly bound water are importantin these minerals. In the discussion to follow the total water contentas shown by conventional analyses is considered.

Ideal heulandite contains 24 HzO molecules per unit cell (Hey andBannister, 1934), and many workers assume that clinoptilolite shouldhave a similar number. However, Mumpton (1960) reported that themolar ratio of HzO/AlzOa is between 5 and 6 in heulandites and be-tween 6 and 7 in clinoptilolites. Published wet chemical analyses forheulandite and clinoptilolite commonly indicate 23-26 HzO per unitcell for heulandites and 79-22 H2O per unit cell for clinoptilolites.Some workers have attributed the low water content of clinoptilolite toloss of weakly held water (Hey and Bannister, 1934; Mason and Sand,1960). Breger et al. (1970) suggested that tightly bound water in heu-Iandite-group zeolites is more firmly held to Ca ions than to Na or Kions. Recent work by Merkle and Slaughter (1968) demonstrated that5HzO molecules are co-ordinated about each Ca ion in heulandite.Inasmuch as clinoptilolites are usually rich in Na*-K* ions and lowin Ca relative to heulandites and as clinoptilolites usually contain

1469

E. V. Shannon.7. Sirich heulandite-Ca; OU26047; altered vitric tufi: Hokonui Hills, Southland, New Ze-

land; EMA analysis by J, R. Boles.8. Si-poor clinoptilolite-Ca; OU26042: altered vitric tufi; Hokonui Hills, Southland, New

Zealand.; EMA analysis bv T. R. Boles.9. Si-poor clinoptilolite-Na; Y-l (OU26051)t altered tufi from geothqmal bore hole; Yellow-

stone National Park, Wyoming; Ifonda and Muffier (1970); wet chemiel analysis byToshio Neeishi.

10. Si-poor clinoptilolite-K: OU26055: altered vitric tufi; Shizuma, Japan; Minato and Utada(1970) ; wet chemica l ana lys is .

11. Si.poor clinoptilolite-Ca; OU26043: altered vitric tufi; Taringatura Hills. Southland. NewZealand: EMA analysis by T. R. Boles.

12. Si-ooor clinoDtilolite.Nai -SM-4-4A

(OU26ASD: altered vitric tuff; San Bernardino Countv.C,lifornia: Sheppard and Gude (1969); wet chemical analysis by E. S. Daniels.

13. Clinoptilolite-Ndi T4-60C (OU26053)i altered vitric tufr; Hectoi. California; Ames er aJ'(1958) : wet chemica l ana lvs is .

15. Si-noor clinonti lolite -Na or -Kl; Deeri Sea Dril l ing Pro;ect l-5-3-1 (OU26q54): Tufiaceoussilty clay sampled at 65-67 feet; Lat. 25'51.5'N Long. 92011.0'W, A,tlantic-Ocean. -

16. Hellandite-C;ri OV26048i alte;ed vitric tufi; Hokonui Hil ls, Southland, New Zealanc.

1 Composition estimated frm optical, cell dimension, and themal stability data.

Page 8: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

7470 JAMES R. BOLES

Frc. 1. Frequency histogram of the si/Al ratios of 60 heulandite group zeolites.Nine unpublished EMA analyses from Murihiku tuffs in addition to those shownin Table 1, have been included.

less tofaZ water, Na*-K* ions may have fewer total number of watermolecules co-ordinated about them than do the Car* ions.

To test this hypothesis, unit cell H2O contents were plotted against100 x (Ca * Sr + Mg/Ca * Sr * Mg * Na -t K) (i.e., percentdivalent cations) for wet chemical analyses from the literature (Fig.2). The plot shows a much closer correlation than a plot of unit cellHpO vs unit cell Al content, or a plot of Ca * Sr * Mg * Na * Kvs unit cell H2O, and indicates that lhe total water content of theheulandite-clinoptilolite unit cell is a function of the type of cation.Furtherrnore, total water content increases with the percentage ofdivalent cations.

An approximation can be made of the number of H2O moleculesco-ordinated about monovalent, and divalent cations. If. r : numberof water molecules about the monovalent cations and y ': numberof water molecules about the divalent cations, then. for each of theanalyses used in Figure 1:

Number of HrO per unit cell : c (Z monovalent cations)

r A (2 divalent cations).

Using a least-squares program and solving all 28 equations for r andg, the H2O co-ordination number for monoyalent cations is 8.2 + 0.b

Page 9: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEALANDITE GROUP

and for divalent cations is 5.7 :L 0.6. Grouping all the cations intodivalent or monovalent groups is probably a rough approximation asindividual cation size and charge/cation radius ratio factors are alsoprobably significant in determining water co-ordination mrmbers.Nevertheless these calculations confirm that the total water contentof heulandites and clinoptilolites is closely related to the proportionof monovalent to divalent cations. Clinoptilolites generally have lesstotal water than heulandites because of high contents of Na* and K*ions.

The effect of cation type on water content may also be found inother zeolites. Zaporozhteseva (1960) noted that, the Ca-zeolitelaumontite has a lower H2O' content when the Ca ions are partiallyreplaced by Na or K. Foster (1965) noted that small amounts of Catend to increase the HsO content of the zeolites natrolite, scolecite,and mesolite.

Nol,rnwcr,e,ruRE oF run Hnur,erql.ro Mrwpn.tr, Gnoup

At present, there is no general agreement as to the nomenclaturefor heulandite group minerals (e.g., Mumpton, 1960; Mason and Sand,

9 6 O I V A L E N T C A T I O N S

Fro. 2. Plot of unit cell water content' (rIzO total) against percent divalent cations(100 x [car+ * Mgz+ * But* + Sr2+/Car+ * Mgr+ * But* + stt* * Na+ * K+])

for 28 wet chemically analyzed heulandites.

t47l

F

2

oF

Page 10: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

1472 JAMES R. BOLES

1960). This problem has become more acute in recent years due tothe discovery of minerals with intermediate compositions. For pur-poses of discussion in this paper, I will use some modifiers to describemembers of the heulandite mineral group.

Use of the term heulandite or clinoptilolite should imply some"fundamental aspect of their chemistry and not derivative propertiessuch as thermal stability. The silicon and aluminum contents of thetetrahedral framework are a more fundamental property than thepredominant type of exchangeable cation, as ion exchange in thesezeolites allows substitutions of the type 2Na- or 2K, = Ca*2 (Shepardand Starkey, 1966; Minato and Utada, 1970) . Therefore the nomencla-ture in this paper will follow that proposed by Mumpton (1960) whoregarded clinoptilolite as the Si-rich member of the group.

The previous data have shown that no compositional gap exists interms of Si/Al ratios for members of the heulandite group, thus it isnecessary to choose some arbitrary composition to divide the series.As most end-member heulandites have a Si/Al ratio of 2.g-8.0 andend-member clinoptilolites have a ratio of 8.0-b.1, a Si/Al ratio of4.0 may be used to divide the series. For the purpose of this paper, amember of the series having a Si/Al ratio 4.0 or greater is termedclinoptilolite, and if less than 4.0 is termed heulandite. In terms ofunit cell contents, where ideally Si + Al = 86.00, a Si/Al ratio equalto 4.0 corresponds to 28.8 Si atoms. The two groups are further sub-divided by the prefix "Si-poor" or ,'Si-rich,'. Hence, a Si-rich heu-landite would have a Si/Al ratio greater than or equal to 8.5 but lessthan 4.0, whereas a Si-poor clinoptilolite would have a Si/Al ratiogreater than or equal to 4.0 but less than 4.b.

Although the type of cation may not be fundamental to thezeolite framework, evidence presented later in this paper suggesrsthat the type of cation plays an important role in thermal stabilityand index of refraction, and in unit cell dimensions. Therefore, thedominant cation will be placed as a suffix to each of the above terms.e.9., clinoptilolite-Ca. Examples of the application of these terms tomineral analyses is shown in the explanation to Table l.

Oprrcer, Pnopnnrrns

Inder of refraction

Mason and Sand (1960) reported that heulandites have an index ofrefraction B greater than 1.488 and clinoptilolites have B less than1.485. Some workers have reported minerals which have B intermediatebo this: e.9., Ross and Shannon (1924), Shepard (1961), Hay (1968),

Page 11: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEALANDITE GROAP 1473

and Brown et aI. (1969). Before indices of refraction, n, can be usedas a means of identifying a mineral as "heulandite" or "clinoptilolite",it is imporiant to evaluate what it means in terms of composition.

Mason and Sand (1960) suggested that heulandite-clinoptiloliterl's are a function of both Si/Al ratio and cations. Shepard and Starkey(1966) confirmed lhal n is in part a function of type of cation sub-stitution as they noted an increase in n. when Ca is substituted forNa-K in a clinoptilolite. The New Zealand samples have "heulandite"indices of refraction as defined by Mason and Sand (1960), eventhough the Si/Al ratio of these samples is 3.02-4.31. The naruow rangein mean z of these specimens must be attributed to their high divalent/monovalent cation ratio, and possibly to the higher water contentgenerally associated with divalent cation substitution.

Si/Al ratios are also important in determining the z of heulandite-clinoptilolite. In comparing samples from Table 1 which have similarproportions of divalent/monovalent cations but which differ in Si/AlraLio (e.9., samples 8 vs ll and 3 vs 7), the effect of Si/Al ratio byitself on index of refraction can be estimated. In these cases, a dif-ference in Si/Al ratio of about 0.3 results in a difference in mean nof about 0.002.

Figure 3 is a plot of Si/Al ratio and dominant cation against meanindex of refraction for 41 heulandite group zeolites. Included in theplot are unpublished data on a Si-poor clinoptilolite (Si/Al * Fe3* =4.03) from Wikieup, Arizona, which contains dominantly Ca ions(66 percent) and has a mean n of. 1.482 (R. e. Sheppard, writtencommunication, 1971). The plot shows that n. is not a sensitive indica-tor of either cation content or Si/Al ratio. Nevertheless it appears thata mean n I 1.482 implies dominantly Na-K ions and a value > L.494implies dominantly Ca ions. Similar implications can be made withrespect to Si/AI ratios and mea;n n.

Figure 3 should be used with caution because some compositionshave not yet been reported. For example, the upper mean n limit forclinoptilolites will probably have to be raised when a clinoptilolite-Cais described. The lower mean % limit for Si-rich heulandites is prob-ably close to the value shown (n'= L.487) as the sample defining thislimit is a, Na-rich specimen (sample 6). The lower mean n limitfor heulandites may be close to the value shown (n = 1.494) as thisspecimen is K-rich (Alietti, 1967).

Optical ori,entation

Slawson (7925) recorded a rotation of the optic axial plane andchange in 2V of heulandite when heated. In Slawson's paper it is

Page 12: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

1474 JAMES N, BOLES

< 3.5

t 3.5 < 4.0

:4.0< 4.5

?-4,5

1 .47 1 .48 1 .A9 1 .50 l . 5 l

mean re f r ac t i ve i ndex ( ? )

Frc. 3. Plot of Si/Al ratio and domina,nt exchangeable cation against meanrefractive index of 41 heulandite group zeolites. Squares are data frorn Table 1.Triangles are data from other sources. Dashed line represents possible indicesof refraction for clinoptilolite (Ca).

implied that with heating the a and B vibration directions remainparallel to the o-c crystallographic plane, which means that heu-landite would remain lengih fast in this direction. Gilbert and Mc-Andrews (1948) reported on a heulandite-clinoptilolite zeoiite (prob-ably Si-poor clinoptilolite or clinoptilolite as the mean index ofrefraction - 1.480) which was length fast when unheated but changedto length slow when mounted in Canada balsam. They also tested twoestablished heulandites which were length fast irrespective of themounting medium, in agreement with Slawson's data.

When samples 6 through 15 are examined in thin section preparedwith Lakeside 7O (i.e., thin sections heated to 10O-120'C for 15-40

.9(l

=\,;

Page 13: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GROUP t475

secs before applying cover slip) the cystals are length slow. The re-maining samples of Table 1 are length fast when prepared in Lakeside70. In thin sections which are mounted with araldite mounting medium(i.e., cold) all the samples of Table 1 are length fast except samples12 and 14.

The only chemical similarity between the samples which arelength slow when heated is that all have a Si/Al ratio )8.57. Thisconclusion was confi.rmed with numerous other samples. Using thistest, I was able to select the more clinoptilolite-like specimens froma large suite of tuffs altered to heulandite group zeolites from theSouthland Syncline, New Zealand. The group of samples which havelength slow crystals when prepared with Lakeside 70 were later shownto have Si/Al ratios greater than 3.52 (most around B.8O-a.10) byelectron microprobe analyses. Samples of Na- and K-rich clinoptilo-lites (Si/Al 4.75 and 5.00, respectively) described by Minato andUtada (1970) and the large clinoptilolite crystals (Si/Al = b.0-b.2)described by Wise et al. (lg6g) were also testecl. All of these sam-ples were length slow when the crushed mineral was dispersed inmolten Lakeside 70, confirming the previous observations. Sheppardand Gude (1969) also reported that some large zoned clinoptilolitecrystals from the Barstow Formation, California, have varying opticalorientations within a crystal. The cores are length slow, but the rimsare length fast. Subsequent microprobe analyses revealed that therims contain 2.9-3.5 weight percent less SiO2 than the core.

In summary, optical orientation after heating appears to be relatedto Si/Al ratio. Present da,ta indicate that zeolites with S,i/Al ratios)3.57 are length slow when prepared in Lakeside 20, but those withSi/Al ratios 13.52 are length fast.

UNrr Cnr,r, DprnntvrrrvArrows

Unit cell dimensions were determined from diffractograms indexed on theassumption that heulandite and clinoptilolite have essentially identical struc-tures and the same space group. Merkle and Slaughter (1g68) determined theheulandite space group as Cm. Hey and Bannister (lg34) had previously con-cluded from single-crystal photographs that heulandite and clinoptilolite areidentical in structure, and this observation is verified by the close similarityof diffractograms of these minerals when the zeolites are of similar crystallitesize. Reflections having similar spacings and intensities were therefore indexedthe same for all members of the series. Computer refinement confirrns thatmost clinoptilolite and heulandite reflections recorded in difrractoErams carrbe satisfactorily indexed.

Alternate settings of the monoclinic unit cell have been used by difierentauthors: body-centered B - 91"2fl by lVyart (lgBB), c-face centered p -113'59 by Shepard and Starkey (1966), and c-face centered p = 116.20 by

Page 14: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

r476 JAMES R. BOLES

Strunz and Tennyson (1956) andsetting is here adopted althoughapproach to orthogonal axes.

Quartz was used as an internal sta,ndard for all samples. Two portions of eachpowdered specimen were prepared on glass slides using ethyl alcohol as adispersing agent. The following diffractometer settings were used:

Radiation: CukaFilter: NiScan speed: *'/minuteSlits: 1o-0.2mm-1"

Merkle and Slaughter (1968). The latterthe setting of Wyart (1933) gives a closer

Time constant: 4Rate meter: 8Chartspeed: 400mm/hourInstrument: Phillips

A specially constructed scaled measuring bar with a horizontal sliding plate wasclamped over the diffractograms. Peak positions were generally selected at 2/3peak height and ] peak width. Conversions of peak positions to degrees 20 wetehased on an average of the 1011 and l0f0 quartz reflections at 26.662o 20 and20.876"20, respectively. Peak positions were taken as the average from the two diffracto-grams. The average precision of measured peak positions is * 0.0060 20.

Refinement of cell dimensi,ons

Two computer programs were used for refining unit cell parameters: DSPACE(written by P. B. Read) and INDCER (Evans et al., 1963). The former pro-gram generates aII possible d spacings given extinction conditions and unit celldimensions, and the latter program is used for refinement of ceII dimensions.

The refined cell dimensions are based on reflections which occur at 131' 20.It, is necessary to base the refinement on these low-angle reflections because withhigher angle reflections, attempts to index all difiractograms identically becomesincreasingly difficult. In addition, the sharp reflections for heulandite and clinop-tilolite diffractogra.ms are at (33' 2t. Some accuracy is necessarily sacrificed byexcluding the higher angle reflections.

The rspecn program generates approximately 60 possible reflections at (33'2d for CuK" radiation. Sorne of these are not recorded by the difiractometer,and others are eliminated by comparison of intensities on singletrystal Weissen-berg photos. Some peaks are composite.

For each sample, cell dimensions were calculated initially from a few re-flections which lacked ambiguities. A new set of possible reflections were thengenerated using the DSpAcD program allowing more of the observed reflectionsto be indexed. Unit cell dimension were then refined again with the TNDcEB pro-gram. By this procedure all reflections at (35" 20 were satisfactorily indexed.In order that the refined cell dimensions for all ,samples could be compared,only identically indexed reflections were accepted for the final caleulation.

Resu,Its

Computer-refined cell dimensions for the 16 heulandite and clinop-tilolite samples are shown in Table 1. Table 2 gives the indices used inthe unit cell refinement and the range of d spacings measured fgr the16 specimens. Figure 4 shows typical heulandite and clinoptilolitepatterns with the apprcpriate indexing.

The unit cell dimensions of the heulandite and clinoptilolite sam-ples are 17.623-17.7254 for d,17.86+-18.0544 for b,7.392-7.4314 for

Page 15: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GROUP

T A D L E 2 : S u E E a r y o f d l l f r e c t i o n d a t a u a e d f o r c € l l r e f i n c l r n to f 1 5 h c u l a n d i t " g r o u p r i n c r a l r .

r477

, Harinu! l l lDilul l{axitrut l l iniDur Int6naity Aycragc(hkr ) nE d qb ! d qbr oz9 o2e_ Ranfc G/ f )

( l) ( t) (cuk;) (cuk;) (r/r")

(o20) 16

(2oo) 16

(2o l ) 16

(oo l ) 16

(220) 5

( 1 ]O) 1

11t71 16

( 1 1 1 ) 1 6

( 1 lT) 16

(o40) ,( 4 o 1 ) 1 ,

( 2 2 1 ) 1 t

(2oZ) 12

11t21 16

(zz2) 15

( l r r l ! . 5

(4zZ) 16

( 4 4 1 ) 1 5

(1 tz t 16( 5 1 ) g $

9.o,x 8,9?o2

?.9rr1 ?,89\25.8077 5.?5186.6618 6.6256

5.9t19 5.92125 , r81?

5.26?1 ' .2 ' ,184

5 .1241 ' . 1O \ '4.6?8, 4.61994 . r1 r1 4 .4568\. )669 4.54\ ,

t . 8 \ 8 t t . 8 t \ ?t .?128 ) .6991t.566t , . r48ot . 4 t27 ) . \ 157t .4o\r r . rgt ,t .1808 t .164,, .1t5o , . , t18?, .0842 t ,o?192,9892 2.9619

9 .85o 9 .2691 1 . 2 o 8 1 1 . 1 5 01t. '112 1r .oo41r.16, 1r .28?

1 \ . 914 14 .882't5.88?

16.99O 15.84817.r72 ' t7. rO'

19.12? 18.96819.8?6 19.8t1

20.441 20. t t ,

2r .19\ 2t . ' , t112\ .o57 2r .96725,o98 2\.96726.o87 2r.95526.tt9 26.17428 .199 28 .o r128.621 28.45029,06? 28.9\9

n .1 ro 29 .889

,7-1OO 79

20-r, ,210-25 18

?- ' t7 1 '

5-20 ?

,1O- t7 21

a2-4o zg

zz-5? ,1

>-15 8

?-1 , 12

1 O - 1 ? 1 2

1 0 - 1 5 1 2

1O-aO 18

17-47 t7

2o-f2q 2?

17-42 t

zO-tO ?'

10-22 1?

45-80 ,?

t

b

lurbc! of la lplcr in rhicb

( f O 2 ) r y h a r c c o n t r l b u t G du l p l a ! .

( l 5 O ) u y h a Y a c o l t r i b u t c dr r i p l c ! .

t h l r r G f l c c t i o a t r a i B d c x c d .

t o t h l r r c f l , c c t i o B i n r o ! .

t o t h i ! r a f l c c t l o D i n . o 6 c

c, and 116"15.3-116"25.Y for ,8. Unit cell volume is 2,0g3-2,124A'.The cell dimensions of the Nova Scotia heulandite (sample l) arecomparable to those for a heulandite from Wallis, Switzerland of. a =17.73, b = 17.82, c : 7.43L, and p - Il6"2Ot (Merkle and Slaughter,1968). Heulandites have larger a, c, and nB dimensions than clinoptilo-lites.

Correlation ol tnt;it cell dim,ensions with nuineral compositian

The o, c, and ,,B dimension of heulandites and clinoptilolites showa positive correlation with cell chemistry, as does the cross sectionalarea of the qc plane (area = e x c X sin [180" - p]). Figures baand 5b show an increase in oc plane area with an increase in divalentcations and with an increase in Al, respectively. The standard error ofestimate of the ions on the ac plane area in Figures ba and bb is 0.48and 0.42 ions/unit cell, respectively. If Lhe ,ac plane area is plotted

Page 16: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

1478 JAMES N. BOLES

a.gainst Al-(! Ca * Mg t Sr * Ba), the correlation is better thanin either Figure 5a or 5b. The significance of the latter correlation isunknown, but it is probably because some points (e.g., sample 9) fallon opposite sides of the "best fit" line in Figures 5a and 5b.

A plot of Al vs I Ca * MS * Sr * Ba demonstrates that the two

<- 20 (cuKc)

Frc. 4. X-ray diffractograms of heulandite and clinoptilolite with indexed reflec-tions. a - indices used for cell refinemenr, QT - quartz.

I

15Cods3b3b

Page 17: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GROAP

( m 9 + C r + S t + A a I O N S ) . / U [ l f C E L L

Frc. 5a. Plot of area of ac plane larea = o X c X sinsum of exchangeable divalent cations (sum - Mg { Ca {refer to samples in Table 1.

1479

z

4

o€o

G

4.O

(180' - F)l againstSr * Ba). Numbers

z

t

o

Frc. 5b. Plot of area of oc plane t;Jl:")';') r ,,o (180' - F)l asainst Alions/unit cell. Numbers refer to samples in Table 1.

variables are not entirely independent. Therefore, it is difficult tointerpret to what degree either Al or I Ca * Mg * Sr * Ba influencesthe area of the oc plane. Nevertheless, the observed relationship be-tween Al and area of the oc plane is predictable from the Si-O andAl-O bond lenglhs determined by Merkle and Slaughter (1968). They

Page 18: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

1480 JAMES R. BOLES

reported that the Si-O bond is 1.62A, and where the tetrahedral site ispartially occupied by Al the bond length increases to about 1.664.This expl4ins the increase in ,o,c plane area with increased Al sub-stitution.

The corelation between divalent cations and oc plane area may bea result of the larger amount of water associated with these eationsthan with monovalent cations, which might increase the area of theac plane. Alternatively, the correlation may be apparent becausehigh I Ca * Mg * Ba * Sr values tend to be associated with highAl values,

The variations in the oc plane can be detected in the (401) reflection.Such (ft,01) reflections are unaffected by the relatively large variationsin the b cell dimension, which affects all, (hlcl) reflections. However, theshift of the (a01) reflection is only 0.llo 20 and is not convenient forquick differentiation of heulandite from clinoptilolite.

The b cell dimension shows a greater variation than either a or cin heulandite and clinoptilolite, but the b dimension cannot be cor-related with either divalent cations (I Ca * Mg * Sr * Ba) or Alcontent. This suggests that an ion unique to neither heulandite orclinoptilolite may be responsible for these variations. Shepard andStarkey (1966) reported that cell size increases when K enters eitherheulandite or clinoptilolite. Coombs (1958) noted larger d spacingsin clinoptilolite than in heulandite which he attributed to the pre-sumed higher K content of the former. Figure 6a is a plot of b celledge vs K content and demonstrates that the increase in b cell edgeis not due to K substitution. Figure 6b is a plot of b cell edge vs Mgcontent and shows that this ion tends to increase the b cell edge.

The reason for the relationship between b and Mg content is un-clear. From a size consideration, the small ionic radius of the Mgion (0.65A) compared with Ca(0.99A), and K (1.334) ions wouldnot appear to preferentially increase the b cell edge. However, thehEdrated. radfus of the Mg ion may be large compared with hydratedCa, Na, and K ions. Breck (1964) reporbed that the hydrated radiusof the Na ion is actually slightly larger than that of a hydrated Kion, and it has already been demonstrated in this paper that moreH2O molecules are associated with divalent cations than with mono-valent cations. Therefore, an increase in b cell edge could result fromsubstitution of hydrated Mg ions, which may have relatively largeradii.

Hpur,eNlrruB

The term heulandite B (Mumpton, 1960) refers to the contracted

Page 19: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GROAP 1481

x lors/u| l r c lr l

Frc.6a. Plot of b cell edge against K ions/unit cell. Data from Table 1.

Frc. 6b. PIot of b cell edge against Mg ion/unit cell. Data from Table 1 andfrom Hay (1963), Oeawa (1967), and Merkle and Slaughter (1968). ,n = wetchemical analysis of crystals from an amygdale. Q - wet chemical analysis ofzeolite separated from vitric tuff. A - EMA analysis of zeolite in vitric tuff.

state of heulandite due to dehydration (Wyart, 1933). The contrae-tion can be induced by heating or by suitable dehydrating conditions.An X-ray powder diffraction study of heulandite "B" has been madeon the Nova Scotia heulandite (sample 1) .to compare the behaviorof a well-defined heulandite with that of the other sDecimens describedin this report.

I

Irao l

l

U

Page 20: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

t4u JAMES R. BOLES

Ground portions of sample 1 were dispersed on glass slides whichwere then placed in a preheated laboratory oven (temperature moni-tored with a calibrated glass thermometer and chromel-alumel thermo-couples). Aftef heating and cooling for specified periods the slideswere X-rayed using the previously described diffractometer settingsbut with a scan speed of l'/min. and chart speed of 800 mm1hr. Aftermeasuring d-spacings, least squares refined cell parameters were ob-tained from a computer program written by Cox and Stewart (1967)and modified by P. B. Read. A new slide was prepared for eachthermal test to avoid reheating of samples., It should be noted that the structural states which result from these

and other heating experiments which I have conducted were deter-mined at room temperature after heating and are not inferred to bethe state which is present at a particular high temperature. Wyart(1933), Ogawa (1967), and Breger et al. (1970) have determinedstructural states of heulandite at high temperatures.

Results

Changes in the (020) reflection of heulandite after heating forvarious periods atr 262oC and cooling at 18-20"C for t hour at 1 atmare shown graphically in Figure 7. Unit cell dimension of the contractedheulandite phases are shown in Table 3. Conclusions which can bedrawn from these experiments and from other thermal tests are asfollows:

1. Heating of heulandite results in a contraction of a, b, and ccell dimensions and an increase in the p angle (see Table 3). Themaximum reduction in unit cell volume is about 31043.

2. After heating, two phases coexist, each of which has contractedspacing relative to unheated heulandite (e.9., Fig. 7). The more con-tracted phase, which is hereafter called phase B following Hay (1963),Breger et aI. (1970) and Alietti (1972), has a d (020) of 8.25-8.354.Following Alietti (1972) the less contracted phase is hereafter calledphase .[, and has a d (020) of 8.73-8.874.

Above a critical temperature ol 202 i 3oC but below the tem-perature at which the mineral becomes amorphous to X-rays (450"Cafter heating for 15 hours), the proportion of phase B relative tophase / increases with increased temperature at a fixed heating periodor with increased heating time at a fixed temperature.

Cooling of the sample results in a reversal of this process withphase 1 gradually increasing in amount relative to phase B. For ex-ample, in a sample which has been heated for 2 hours at 233"C :L 3o

Page 21: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GROUP 1483

I h t 3 0 m i n u n h e a t e d

Frc. 7. Change in (020) reflection of heulandite (sample 1) after heating 5specimens for various times at 262'c -r 3" and cooling for t hour. Dashed line =10'24 (CuKa). Horizonta.l bar represents a distance of 1.2;e.

and then placed on the diffractometer, the relative intensity of phaseB progressively increases from 27 to 68 while that of phase 1 progres-sively decreases from 73 to 32 during a 4O-minute cooling period.

3. Phases I and B do not have flxed cell parameters, but each showsa slight but generally progressive contraction with increased heatingtime (see Table 3). The progressive contraction of phases l and B isexemplified by the (020) reflection which gradually shifts from 8.284A

t t B L E ] : U n r t c . l , l d i n . o l l o n ! o f h . n l r n d i t . ( a r p l . 1 ) ^ r f t a r h . r t i n ! r t : 5 a " c l r o f o .r r r l o u G t i n . 6 r i d c o o l i D a f o r t h o l r r t 1 8 - 2 o " C . 1 . t . . p r . . r u r . .

Palcant o l Dhraa

"': i : l t prorelt ! 3tl)i ^ r r l r nBn

r r l t . t l l ! (d.ar..e) t;i;;'

2hr4 h r

Xo b.. t -l a 8

JO rlD

t toE

2 l F u r .

{ houra

16 ho!r.

1 @ O O

o r 5 6 5

o ? o E o

o 2 o 8 o

o r o 9 0

o o t o o

t?.?zzl.@+

nr r i? . { lo : .o1O

"a.r6.999!.oza' r ' r7 . t r75 f .o lOrBnl?.o?o:.o22

" r i"9 "17 .qr2 ! .o r l .. rn

"B{15.951: .o t?.r .l B r 1 6 . g 2 1 : . o 1 6

17. 865:.OOO2 Z.trZrl.OoOr

tz.>29!.ooz z.)9{:.00616.{6r:.o14 ?.28?:.o2\16.511:.006 ?.)8t' l .oo?16.505:.o16 ?.290:.O15

r6 .5ra t .o re t .ag5! .oos

r6 . r .8 r ! .OZ ' z .a6r r ! .o r6

15.tr?:.oo8 ?.2\6!.ooJ

t 1 6 . l r r 5 o : . O O 2 2 , 1 o l r . ) 6

r 1 6 . 6 r f . o o r 2 , o 2 1 . o 51 1 ? . i o : . o @ 5 1 r 8 i ? . i r 9

rrg.rf.ooor a.oar.tgr1? .11 : .ooo) 1 r8a5.o l

rt7.aa3.oooz rrgez.a8

rr7.t7l.s66l1 1.Eo5.r,

r l? . lE : .o@1 1 .?E.89

! rqt lntcd frcr ! .1| t1r. i ! ia! . l t l . r ol (O2o) Ff l rct tc! .

Page 22: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

1484 JAMES R. BOLES

to 8.727L and 8.345A to 8.255a, respectively, for the conditions shown

in Table 3. For untreated heulandite the (020) reflection al2v25"cis at 8.970a. cornparing refined cell dimensions from certain heated

intervals, for example 3O minutes against t hour heating times, one

observes a slight increase in some cell dimensions. This expansion is

believed to be only an apparent increase due to the large standard

errors of these cell refinements.Previous investigations implied that X-ray reflections from the

contracted phases of heulandite occur at fixed d-spacings, e'g', Shepard(1961), and Hay (1963) rather than over small ranges of d-spacings'

Breger et 'at. (1970) noted a gradual increase in 2d from 9'9 to

10.16' (CuKo radiation) corresponding to phase 1 of this paper'

4. A general reduction in peak intensity occurs with Ionger heat-

ing times and/ot higher temperatures. An exception to this generaliza-

tion occurs with the appearance of phase B, where two reflections

become more intense. The d-spacings of these reflections are 5.182-

5.215L and 3.621-3.648a. The ospecn computer program indicates

that these two reflections should be indexed as (221, 130) and (240),

respectively. ogawa (1967) reporbed abrupt intensity increases for

two reflections with similar d-spacings to those given above, which

he indexed as (130) and (240). ogawa also noticed an increase in

relative intensity of the (020) reflection-a phenomenon not ob-

served by me.5. Using a fixed heating time of 15-16 hours with a short cooling

period (less than 1 minute) the shift to phase /, as defined above,occurs at 202"c 't 3o. under these conditions a weak reflection cor-

responding to phase B also forms (relative proportion of phase I to

B is about,8:1). Apparently phase / can be formed atroom tempera-

ture by placing the heulandite in a vacuum. Ogawa (1967) reporteda change in (020) spacing from 9.03A at 1 atm. to 8.75A (phase 1) in

a vacuum.6. In general, higher temperatures and/or longer heating times

result in more rapid and permanent phase changes, stronger develop'ment of phase B and in a greater degree of destruction.

The above conclusions differ from those of Breger et al'' (1970)

who reported the first occurrence of the heulandite B phase near

255"c while heating a sample of heulandite from Berufjord, Iceland

on a heating stage. The cape Blomidon heulandite shows a develop-

ment of this phase at temperatures as low as 202"c after heating for

16 hours. These differenees probably reflect the different heating and

cooling processes and possible differences in sample composition.

Page 23: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GROUP 1485

Breger et al. (197il found no phase changes when their samplewas continuously heated at the same temperature on a heating stage.For samples which I have tested, above the critical temperature andheating and cooling at I atm, the rate of

'phase change can be closely

related to heating fime (e.g., Fig. 7). Under the experimental condi-tions described here, both heating time and cooling time must becarefully controlled for reproducible results. as also noted bv Alietti(1972\.

Cause of stru,ctural con"traction

The structurdl collapse in heulandite is generally attributed todehydration, e.9., Slawson (1925); Wyart (1933) 1 Breger, et al.(1970). However, Breger et al. (lg7}) showed that clinoptilolite losesa similar amount of water in the same temperature range as heulandite.Heulandite-Ca undergoes a structural contraction and clinoptilolite-Na, K does notl therefore, the heulandite structural contraction wouldnot appear to be due to water loss in itself. Shepard and Starkey(1966) demonstrated that a clinoptilolite in which Ca is substitutedfor Na-K shows a similar stluctural contraction to heulandite. Theyalso reported that substitution of K in a heulandite results in greaterthermal stability. Shepard and Starkey's work demonstrated the de-pendence of structural contraction on the type of exchangeable cation.

Merkle and Slaughter's (1968) structural analyses of a heulanditeshowed that 5 water molecules are co-ordinated about each Ca ion.Furthermore their investigation showed that two of the five watermolecules are more closely bonded than the other three. Ogawa(1967) indicated that in a heulandite which he studied the contractedphase (Phase 1) which forms in a vacuum results from the loss of10.18 wt. percent H2O or about 3/5 of the initial total water content(16.20 wt. percent). Breger et al. (Lg7O) found that a thermally in-duced lattice contraction appeared between 25oC and 180.C (phase 1of this study) in their sample and they suggest that "this was probablyrelated to the loss of loosely held water . . .", i.e., the outer threewater molecules. Furthermore they have suggested that transition tophase B occurs after partial removal of the inner two water molecules.

The removal of water from Ca ions in the heulandite structure maycause these ions to shift position in the structure and hence cause struc-tural distortion. Removal of the outer three water molecules may resultin only a slight shift of position with a slight contraction resulting (phase1). Partial removal of the inner two water molecules may result in moredrastic shift of Ca-ion positions and a relatively large contractionresults: (phase B). Marked changes in atomic position are suggested by

Page 24: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

1486 JAMES R. BOLES

the marked increase in relative intensity of the (22I, 130) and (240)

reflections in ohase B.A similar phenomenon occurs in other zeolites. The cation position

in chabazile (Breck, 1964) and in the synthetic zeolite Zk-5 (Meier,1968) is supposedly a function of dehydration state. In the case ofchabazite, structural distortion is noted during dehydration as theCa ion changes position (Breck 1964). The contraction in the Cazeolite laumontite (Coombs, 1952) when dehydrated to leonharditemay also result from a similar shift in atomic position.

The reporled structural changes in a dehydrated Ca-clinoptilolite(Shepard and Starkey, 1966) support the conclusion that the Ca ionis of major importance in causing these phase changes. However,Shepard and Starkey reported that even with almost complete Casubstitution in clinoptilolite, the structural contraction is 75oC higherthan the transformation in heulandite-Ca. The clinoptilolite frame-work contains more Si-O bonds than heulandite, which presumablycan strengthen the framework. As will be subsequently shown, ther-

,mal stability data from the New Zealand samples support this con-clusion.

T unniulr, Sr.rnrr,rrv

Thermal stability is used by many investigators as a rapid methodto distinguish between heulandite-clinoptilolite. The test, proposed byMumpton (1960), involves heating the sample at 450oC overnightand then X-raying. Heulandite is supposedly destroyed (X-rayamorphous), but clinoptilolite remains unchanged. Several workershave reported members of the group which show "intermediate" ther-mal stability (e.9., IIay, 1963 ; Shepard, 1961 I Shumenko,'7964; Brownet aL, 1969; Minato and Utada, 1970; and Alietti, 1972).

Brown et aI., Minato and Utada, and Alietti have shown that min-erals with intermediate thermal stability have a composition inter-mediate to most samples of heulandite'Ca and clinoptilolite-Na orK. I attempted to establish whether or not zeolites with slightly dif-ferent compositions can be distinguished by thermal stability tests.

Samples were prepared on glass slides or silicon plates prior toheat treatment so that they could be X-rayed immediately after thecooling period. This procedure prevented rehydration which eouldhave occurred due to X-ray slide preparation, and it had the addedadvantage of standardizing the volume of powder heated. A newsample was prepared for each temperature investigated as heating,cooling, and reheating of the same sample results in progressively

Page 25: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GROUP

lower temperatures at which phase changes take place (see Bregeret a\ . ,7970) .

The ovens were preheated to the desired temperature for all ex-periments. Temperature was monitored with chromel-alumel thermo-couples when greater than 350oC, and with a calibrated glass ther-mometer when less than 350"C. After heating, the samples werecooled in a temperature controlled room (lg-22"C).

Results

Results of the thermal stability experiments are summarized inTable 4. In general heat treatment causes either a d-spacing con-traction accompanied by x-ray intensity reduction or by an intensityreduction without changes in d-spacings.

The results shown in Table 4 indicate that the thermal stability ofthese heulandites and clinoptilolites can be classified into one of threegroups:

Group 1: (a) Characterized by complete destmction at 450.C for15 hours.

(b) Formation of the phases 1 and B contracted state.Phase -I appeared at temperatures of. 212-2SO"C, e.g.,samples 1-5, and 16. Phase B contracted state formedin all samples of this group, but the phase is not shownon Table 4.

Group 2: (a) Characterized by partial destruction at 4b0"C for 15hours. A portion of the original (020) reflection per-sists at temperatures greater than 450.C.

(b) Formation of the phases 1 and B contracted state.Phase 1 appeared at temperatures equal to or greaterthan 255'C, e.g., samples 6 through 8, 10 and 11.

Group 3: (a) Characterized by general stabiJity at 450.C for 15hours.

(b) d-spacing unchanged at all temperatures. However,some destruction was indicated by a reduction in in-tensity in the 450-6b0.C range, e.g., samples g and 12through 15.

The results shown above are in close agreement with the thermalstability data of Alietti (1972). By heating at 550.C for t2 hours,Alietti recognized 3 main types of thermal stability in heurandite groupminerals and demonstrated that the difference of thermal behavioris due both to different si/Al ratios and divalent cation contents ofthe minerals. Minerals of Group I thermal stability plot into the

t487

Page 26: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

1488 JAMES R. BOLES

T A B L E l r 3 T h c r n a l 6 t a b i l i t y o f t h e 1 5 h c u l ' a n d i t c S r o u p n i n ' r a l ' r

f r o t I a b 1 " 1 .

Tcnpera-tu r " re -

q u i r e dfor appcar-a n c e o l

Fbasc " Ing

k . la t i y " * . " " " t l l i i r lF (o2o) re f lec t ions a f te r

r+5ooc 5>Ooc Sroo c

A I 8 D A I B

1 2 1 t o 7- - - ^ o ^

, lqgoc

4 2c8oc

5 z>OoC

6 zrroc? zgctoc

E 295"c

9 a . d .

10 >rococ

1 1 t i z o a

1 2 n . d .

1 t n . d .

1 l + D . d .

1 t n . d .

11. 2ttoo C

d€ a t royc d

d e a t r o y r d

de 6 t royed

de 6 t roye d

de6t royed

20

2 Z

b 6

1 6

100

100

100

ao

r+6

b

1 4

d r 6 t r o y c d

, 8 < ,'t6 51 5 5 < 5

b U

n . d .

Eq

100

1CO

9a

<5

40

1 2 5 < 51 2 5 < '

,oD . d .

1 l f I < ,

EO

66

8lt

7\

Sanr l?6 hca tcd fo r 2 hour t and coo lad fo r 1 bour .Phaac " ; " app"arGd !1oc o f t "Ep" ra tu ra a t r ted .

Sa i lp1c6 heatcd fo r 15 hours and coo lcd lcaa tha !t hour . In i , t i t l (o2o) ia tcns l ty o f pha3. raa 1oo.(o2o) lpac in8s o t phas . ! :

A = iD j . t t l l phaac = E.g l -g .O>1

= 8,?r-8.8?' l= '6.n-8.t57

I = p h a a c I

B = p h a a c B

composition field of "heulandite type l" in the mole plot SigOre-Ca+.rAlgOra-Na,KeAleOls shown by Alietti. Similarly, Group 21 and3 types plot in composition fields of "heulandite t'ype 2" and "clinop-tilolite" shown by Alietti.

The new data shown here allow t'he contraction phenomena to beinterpreted more fully. Specifically, samples of Group t have a SD'zvalue greater than 2.94, those of Group 2have a SD value of 1.87-2.90'and those of Group 3 have a SD value less than 1.00. The data indi-cate that when the sum of the divalent cations exceeds 1.87, the

'sample 6 plots just inside of Alietti's "clinoptilolite" composition field butdoes not conflict with the data given.

'SD - sum of divalent cations = (Ca'* * Mg'* f Sf' { Ba'*)

Page 27: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GROUP 1489

contracted phases form. Shepard and Starkey (1966) documentedthe effect of exchanged cations on thermal stability of heulandite andclinoptilolite. They reported that a clinoptilolite-Ca contracts uponheating whereas a heulandite-K does not. Anomalously, Na-treatedheulandite and clinoptilolite contracted upon heating..shepard andStarkey, however, reported that the heulandite had recrystallized dur-ing the exchange experiments.

Although the type of cations may control whether or not contrac-tion will occur, thermal stability also eorrelates with Si/Al ratios.Figure 8 shows a plot of temperatures at which contraction firstoccurs, with 2 hour heating and I hour cooling against Si/Al ratiofor samples of Groups 1 and 2. The plot demonstrates that the initialtemperature for contraction is related to Si/Al ratio. Higher Si/Alratios progressively strengthen the framework against contraction,but the relatively high proportion of divalent cations in the sampleseventually permits contraction. The higher Si/Al ratios of mineralsin Group 2 (Si/Al > 3.57) compared with those in Group 1 (Si/Al <3.52) may have caused the persistence of part of the original phaseobserved after heat treatment.

The samples of Group 2 are of. particular interest because theyhave thermal stabilities intermediate between most heulandites andclinoptilolites. These specimens show a persistence of the original(020) reflection even though the majority of the specimen is destroyedafter heating at 450-650oC. In addition, the intensity of the persisting

3.50Si,/Al ratio

Frc. 8. Plot of temperature required for appearance of phase 1 against Si/AIratio of sample. Data from Table I and Table 4.

(,oI

6

ocF

Page 28: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

1490 JAMES R. BOLES

phase becomes weaker at higher temperatures, sample 6 being theexceptibn (see Table 4). A similar phenomenon was reported by Hay(1963) for a heulandite group mineral from Oregon and by Alietii(1972). The thermal stability of Group 2 could be a:btributed to amixture of clinoptilolite and heulandite; however; the minerals havea relatively uniform refractive index and no discernible zoning wasfound with an electron microprobe (10 pm beam diameier).In addi-tion the higher temperatures required to induce phase changes (Fig.

8) do not indicate a mixture of heulandite and clinoptilolite. There-fore, it is concluded that the thermal stability of Group 2 is a char-acteristic of the "intermediate" compositions (c/., Alietti, 1972).Nevertheless, it is difficult to understand how a portion of the mineralcan persist, while the remainder is destroyed without compositionaldisordering on at least a submicroscopic scale.

The samples of Group 3 show no contracted phases at any tem-perature (c/. Alietti, 1972). However, a partial breakdown of struc-ture occurs in the 450-650"C temperature range. Sample 9 shows thegreatest degree of destruction in this temperature range, possibly dueto its relatively low Si/Al ratio (4.12).

Estimating composition of heulartdite group minerals

The composition of a heulandite group mineral can be estimatedfrom optical properties, unit cell dimensions, and thermal stability.Two examples of the procedure are given below using samples 15and 16.

Sampte -15. The mineral is length slow which indicates a Si/Alratio ) 3.57 (see Table 1). A mean index of refraction of 1.484 indi-cates a Si/AIratio > 4.00 (see Fig.3). The b cell dimension of sample15 is 17.90A and indicates a very low Mg content, probably less than0-20 ion/unit cell (see Fig.6b). o, c, and B parameters give an ocplane area equal to 117.22L2, a value greater than the areas determinedfor samples 9, 12, 13, and 14. Sample 15, therefore has more divalentcations than the latter specimens (see Fig. 5a) and/ot it has more Al(see Fig. 5b), i.e., a lower Si/Al ratio. Thermal stability indicatesthat the SD value is less than 1.00 indicating predominantly mono-valent cations similar to samples 12, 13, and 14. Re-examination ofthe interpretation from unit cell data indicates that sample 15 prob-ably has a lower Si/Al ratio than samples 12, 13, and 14 and isprobably most similar to sample 9. Therefore, the SilAl ratio ofsample 15 is estimated between 4.00 and 4.31. This sample can tenta-tively be classified as Bi-p'oor clinoptilolite-Na or -K.

Sample -16. The mineral is length fast which indicates a Si/Al ratio

Page 29: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GNOUP

< 3.52 (see Table 1). A mean refractive index of 1.500 indicates aSi/Al ratio less than 4.00 and predominantly Ca ions. The b celldimension is 18.02A and indieates a unit cell Mg content of about0.30 to 0.50 ion/unit cell (see Fig. 6b) . a, c, an'd,B parameters give anac plane area of 117.884 which is a lower value than that for sample1 but greater than that of sample 3. This indicates that sample 16 hasan intermediate divalent cation content with respect to these samplesand/or intermediate Al content. As all three samples have Group Itype thermal stability (indicating similar divalent cation contents),one might guess that sample 16 has an intermediate Al content withrespect to the other two samples. This implies a Si/Al ratio of. 2.94-3.47. The initial phase change occurs ̂ l 240"C (see Table 4) andindicates a Si/Al ratio between 3.2 and 3.4 (see Fig. 7). Sample 16can tentatively be classified as a heulandite-Ca.

AcxNowr,nncnprvrs

The author wishes to acknowledge the following individuals and organiza-tions for samples: Dr. R. A. Sheppard of the U.S.G.S., Denver, Colorado; Dr.L. J. P. Muffier of the U.S.G.S., Menlo Park, California; Dr. W. S. Wise of theUniversity of California, Santa Barbara, California; Dr. II. Minato of the Uni-versity of Tokyo, Japan; U.S. National Museum, Washington, D.C.; and DeepSea Drilling Project, National Science Foundation. Dr. P. B. Read of the De-partment of Geology, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, is thankedfor assistance with single crystal photographs and computer refinement. Mr.J. M. Pillidge, University of Otago technical staff, provided excellent polishedsections for EMA analysis. Permission to use the EMA analyser at the ResearchSchool of Physical Sciences, Canberra, Australia, and the assistance of Mr.N. G. Ware is gratefully acknowledged. Dr. D. S. Coombs of the University ofOtago, and Dr. R. A. Sheppard critically reviewed the manuscript. Lastly theauthor wishes to thank Dr. D. S. Coombs for his continuous encouragement andhelpful advice during the course of this investigation. The research has beensqpported by National Science Foundation Grant GA 754 (Coombs).

RannnrNcps

Ar,rnrrr, A. (1967) Ileulanditi e clinoptilotiti. Mi,neral. Petrogr. Acta 79, 119-138.- (1972) Polymorphism, and crystal-chemistry of heulandites and clinoptilo-

tites. Amer. M ineral. s7, 1437-1451.Arvrns, L. L. Jn., L. B. Ser.rn, eNn S. S. Gor,orcrr (1958) A contribution on the

Hector, California bentonite deposit . Eoon. GeoI. s3,22-37 .Bnrcr, D. W. (1964) Crystalline molecular sieves. .f. Chem. Educ.41, 678-689.Bnncnn, I. A., J. C. Cnewlr,nn, ervn P. Zurlovtc (1970) An infrared study of

water in heulandite a;rd clinoptiloliLe. Amer. Mineral. 55, 825-840.Bnowx, G., J. A. Cem, eNn A. H. Worn (1969) Zeolites of the clinoptilolite-

heulandite type in sediments of south-east England. M'tnera'L. Mag. 37,480-488.

Coorvrns, D. S. (i952) Cell size, optical properties and chemical compo.s.ition of

t49r

Page 30: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

t492 JAMES R. BOLES

laumontite and leonhardite, with a note on regional occurrences in NewZealand. Amer. Mineral. 37, 812-830.

- (1958) Zeolitized tuffs from the Kuttung glacial beds near Seaham, NewSouth Wales. Austral. J. Sci. zt, l8-lg.

A. J. Er,r,rs, W. S. Frrn, aNo A. M. Tevr,on (1959) The zeolite facieswith comments on the interpretation of hydrothermal systems. Geochim.C osmochim. Acta, 77, 53-107.

Cox, A. A., eNn E..G. Srnwem (1967) An I.C.T. Fortran program for least-squares refinem.6nt of crystal structure cell dimensions. Acta Crgstallogr.23, 1113-1114.

Dnnn, W. A., R. A. Howrn, eNn J. Zussrrelr (1963) Rock-form'i,ng Minerals !.John Wiley and Sons, New York, 435p.

Evexs, II. T., Jn., D. E. Appr,nrrAN, AND D. S. HeNnwnnxen (1963) The leastsquares refinement of crystal unit cells with powder diffraction data by anautomatic computer indexing method. Amer. Crgstallogr. Assoc., Cambridge,Mass., Ann. Meet., Program. (abstr.),4243.

Fosten, M. D., (1965) Composition of zeolites of the natrolite group. U'5. GeoLSuru. ProJ. Pap. 504-D, 7p.

Gunonr, C. M., enn M. G. McANnnews (1948) Authigenic heulandite in sand-stone, Santa Cruz County, California. J. Sed,. Petrology, 18,91-99.

ITsv, M. II.. ,rxr F. A. BeNNrsren (1934) Studies on the zeolites. Part VII."Clinoptilolite", a silica-rich variety of heulandite. Mineral. Mag.23,556-550.

H,rv, R. L. (1963) Stratigraphy and zeolitic diagenesis of the John Day Formationof Oregon. Uniu. C akl. Publ. GeoI. Sci. 42, 199-262.

IloNne, S., exn L. J. P. Murrr,rn (1970) Hydrothermal alteration in core frornresearch drill HoIe Y-1, Upper Geyser Basin, Yellowstone Park, Wyoming.Amer. M ineral. ss, l7 14-1737 .

Ir.rrrre, A. (1970) Composition and origin of clinoptilolite in the Nakanosawatuff of Rumoi, Hokkaido. Amer. Chc,m. Soc.,?nd Int. Conf . MoL. Sieue ZeoL,W orcester, M oss., preprints, 540-547 .

Mesow, B, aNr L. B. SeNn (1960) Clinoptilolite from Patagonia: The relation-ship between clinoptilolite and heulandite. Amer. Mineral. 45, 341-350.

Mnrnn, W. M. (1968) Zeolite structures. In Molecular Sieues, 1964 Conf . ol Soc.Chem. Inclustr., Londom, p.1V27.

Mnnxr-n. A. 8.. eNn M. Sr,eucrrrnn (1968) Determination and refinement of thestructure of heulandite. Amer. Mineral. 53, 1120-1138.

MrN.rto, H., eNn M. Urare (1970) Clinoptilolite from Japan. Amer. Chem. Soc.,?nd Int. Conf. MoI. Sieue ZeoI., Worcester, Mass., preprints, 535-539.

MurrlroN, F. A. (1960) Clinoptilolite redefined. Amer. M'inerar. 45, 351-369.Oclwe, T. (1967) On the varieties of heulandite. J. Sci. Hirosh'im. Uniu., Jap'an,

s,267-285.P6csr-Dow.4nrr, E. (1966) On the relationship between lattice structure and

"zeolite water" in gmelinite, heulandite, and scolecite. Acta Uniu. 9zeged,.Acta Mineral. Petrogr. 17, 143-158.

Prsnansre, E., aNl A. Gewnr, (1954) Heulandite from Rudno (Cracow district).Ann. Soc. Geol. Pologne zz, English summary, 367-373; lMineral,. Abstr. 72,484 (1955)1.

Ross, C. S., eNo E. V. SnelrlroN (1924) Mordenite and associated minera.ls fromnear Challis, Custer County, Idaho. Proc. U.S. Nat. Mttseum,64, l-lg.

Snnraru, A. O- (1961) A heulandite-like mineral associated with clinoptilolite in

Page 31: DIMENSIONS, AND THERMAL STABILITY OF SOME HEULANDITE … · rotary crusher or agate mortar, the (4bpm fraction was obtained by sieving. ... spection in oils revealed the main impurities

HEULANDITE GilOUP 1493

tuffs of Oak Springs Formation, Nevada Test Site, Nye Co., Nevada, U.S.Ge,ol. Suru. ProJ. Pap.424-C, CB20-322.

exo H. C. Sremnr (1966) The effects of exchanged cations on the thermalbehavior of heulandite and clinoptilolile. Mineral Soc. Indtia, IMA Vol.,p. 156-158.

Snnream, R. A., er.rn A. J. Guon, 3d., (196S) Distribution and genesis of authigenicsilicate minerals in tuffs of Pleistocene Lake Tecopa, Inyo County, Cali-fornia. U.S. GeoI. Swu. ProJ. Pap.597, 38 p.

- (1969) Diagenesis of tuffs in the Barstow Formation, Mud Hills, SanBernardino County, California.. U.S. Geol. Suru. Prol. Pap.634,35 p.

Suurroxro, S. I. (1962) Varieties of authigenic secondary heulandite in theUpper Cretaceous of the Ukraine. Akad. No,uh. SSSR, DokI., Earth Sci. Sec.r44, I347-13&O (in Russian); (1964), r44, 144-146 (English translation).

Sr,ewsoN, C. B. (1925) The thermo-optical properties of heulandite. Amer. Min'eral. L0,305-331.

SrnuNz, H., eNn C. TbNNvsoN (1956) "Polymorphie" in der Grqppe der Blatter-zeolithe. Neues Jarltrb. M'ineral Monntash., l.

Wrsn, W. S., W. J. Noxr,nnonc, er.rr M. Korrxos (1969) Clinoptilolite and fer-rierite from Agoura, California. Amer MineraJ. 54, 887-895.

Wvenr, J. (1933) Recherches sur les zeolites. BuIl. Soc. Fr. Mi'neral- Crista\I'ogr.56, 8l-187.

Zeponoznrsnv,l, A. S. (1960) On the regional development of la,umontite inCretaceous deposits of Lena coal basin. Ahad. Nawk. SSSR' 1zu', Geol. Ser.No. e.52-59.

Ma:nnncri'pt recei,ued, JuIy 31, 19/1; accepted' lor pubkcation, May 1I' 1972.