discovering worldviews and belief systems across cultures an introduction darrell whiteman...
TRANSCRIPT
Discovering Worldviews and Belief Systems
Across Cultures
AN INTRODUCTION
Darrell Whiteman
Presentation by Mark Snowden
Chinese Poem Go to the people Live among them Learn from them Love them Start with what they know Build on what they have
Chinese Poem Go to the people (as cross-cultural witnesses)
Live among them (emptying self of “Americanisms”)
Learn from them (they can teach us -- “Teach me!”)
Love them (become vulnerable and receive love, too)
Start with what they know (common interests)
Build on what they have (grow as they do)
Culture Definition doesn’t mean
• art, music, etc.
• cultural events
does mean• array of ideas
• expressed publicly
• observable behavior
CultureIDEAS BEHAVIOR RESULTS
Ideas generate behaviors that bring results.
To illustrate, let’s suppose you’re an Americanwho feels a need to find a new church.
CultureIDEAS BEHAVIOR RESULTS
“Join a Church!”
ChurchShopping
ChurchSelection“Fit”
CultureIDEAS BEHAVIOR RESULTS
We get our “ideas” about “church” or otherimportant life issues from the culture we live in.
What kind of church would you be looking forif you were a Muslim, a Buddhist, etc.?
- -
Culture Learned
• not inherited
• by age 5
Shared• aggregate of society
• mental map
Acquired• member of society
• norms & aberrations
Culture: Basic Needs Metabolism: need for oxygen, liquid, food
Reproduction: sex drive
Bodily Comforts: temperature, etc.
Safety: prevented accidents, animals, humans, etc.
Movement: activity, exercise, sports, etc.
Growth: maturation, enculturation (love)
Health: maintenance and repair of organismThese are from Malinowski, an 8th is added by the author.
Religion: religious need, psychological impulse
Culture as a System
SOCIALSOCIALRELATIONSRELATIONS
ECONOMY &ECONOMY &TECHNOLOGYTECHNOLOGY
IDEAOLOGYIDEAOLOGY
ComputersMedicine/HealthEfficiency
ChristianityIslamAnimism
RacismWomen WorkingLaws
Note: Arrows show interaction betweensystem sections.
We confuse the gospel with our own culture.
We are influenced by our own culture.
The Impact of Cultureon the Individual
OBJECTIOBJECTIVEVE
REALITYREALITY
WorldviewWorldview
So that’s whereworldview shows up!
The Impact of Cultureon the Individual
We would never think of becoming “Judaisers”mentioned in “Acts.” (imposing Jewish customs)
Yet, we impose other American cultural hangupson non-Christians in other cultures.
The Impact of Cultureon the Individual
CLOTHINGCLOTHING USA
• Immodest to go naked
• Personal taste
OTHEROTHER CULTURESCULTURES• Go naked to prove
yourself
• Wear on “occasion”
• Change in public
The Impact of Cultureon the Individual
AGEAGE USA
• Undesirable, tolerated
OTHEROTHER CULTURESCULTURES• Old people unwanted
• Old people revered
The Impact of Cultureon the Individual
EDUCATIONEDUCATION USA
• Formal, outside home
• Teacher-oriented
OTHEROTHER CULTURESCULTURES• Hired specialists
• Learn by doing
• Proverbs & folktales
The Impact of Cultureon the Individual
RAPIDRAPID CHANGE CHANGE USA
• Change = Progress!
• Positive
OTHEROTHER CULTURESCULTURES• Conservatism valued
• Aim at stability
• Negative
Why Understanding CultureImpacts Missions
Self-awareness of our own culture’s influence
“We bring all who we are to God.”
A fish would not discover water.
How does the culture influence those in the target culture?
Must be aware to understand and appreciate.
Why Understanding CultureImpacts Missions
Disraeli said, “If God calls you to be amissionary, don’t stoop to be a king.”
Why Understanding CultureImpacts Missions
How does God interact with and relate to humans in their culture?
The Kingdom of God and the Ameri-can Dream are not the same thing.
GospelGospel + + Culture Culture + + FaithFaith produce produce ChristianityChristianity
We must communicatein such a way that faith can beexplained in the local culture.
“Culture” actuallyexplains “faith”!
GospelGospel + + Culture Culture + + FaithFaith produce produce ChristianityChristianityGospelGospelGod-given
One, unique, holy
Universal--for allEternal, revealed in history
Makes new creation in Christ
GospelGospel + + Culture Culture + + FaithFaith produce produce ChristianityChristianityGospelGospelGod-given
One, unique, holy
Universal--for allEternal, revealed in history
Makes new creation in Christ
CultureCulture Human made, makes humansMany local & regional forms
(good, neutral & evil)Universal--in all societies
Historical, changing, temporalConditions people & reachable
areas of creation
GospelGospel + + Culture Culture + + FaithFaith produce produce ChristianityChristianityGospelGospelGod-given
One, unique, holy
Universal--for allEternal, revealed in history
Makes new creation in Christ
CultureCulture Human made, makes humansMany local & regional forms
(good, neutral & evil)Universal--in all societies
Historical, changing, temporalConditions people & reachable
areas of creationTowards culture:G. traverses C. judges and saves C. dedicates, sanctifies C. beautifies C. exorcises demons in C.
Towards Gospel:C. receives or rejects G. communicates G. conditions peoples for faith in G. brings glory to G.
GospelGospel + + Culture Culture + + FaithFaith produce produce ChristianityChristianity
GGOOSSPPEELL
CCUULLTTUURREE
interaction in
FAITH
producesmany forms
ofChristianityin the world
object of F.inspires F.instills F.generates F.illuminates F.
sustains F.explains F.articulates F.communicates F.celebrates F.
“Worldview” understanding is powerful, but it is like trying to nail gelatin to the wall!
Yeah, and it’s tough to get empirical data, too.
Art/MusicPolitics
Economy
ReligionReligion
Social Organization
Education
WORLDVIEW
Worldview is the “soulof society” -- the essenceor center of a person.
Cultural Forms
VOICESAre YOU more Americanthan Christian? Only bystudying, learning andongoing revelation by theHoly Spirit can our ownworldview be offset.
The reason to learn languageis not to tell others ideas,but to learn how others learnand organize their thoughts.
Worldview is even morebasic than religion.
No language is inadequate to meet the needs of its people.
Our own worldview is established by age 5.
Worldview: Basic Assumptions
Assume truth without prior proof
Persuasively taught to next generation
People interpret and run their lives by them
Worldview: It can change! When experiences are
unable to be interpreted in light of our own worldview
Oh dear, I believednothing could piercethis magic shirt!
FACT: The Massacre at Wounded Kneein 1890 was because Sioux Indiansbelieved they were given shirtsthat would stop US Cavalry bullets.
Worldview: It can change! When experiences are
unable to be interpreted in light of our own worldview
When an alternate set of explanations and assumptions cannot be ignored or won’t go away
The world is round!
FACT: The CatholicChurch formally apologized to Galileo,but not until 1995.
VOICESGod used a religious revoltin Hawaii in 1819 to pre-pare the people to receivethe Gospel when mission-aries arrived in 1820.
Christianity opened in Javaafter one million communistswere killed in 1965. It made people question the Muslims’ actions. (Indonesia)
Our lives can change.Christ can vault us into a new way of thinking.
God comes to us in forms of our own worldview. God doesn’t expect us to be stuck in our worldview.
Christianity is trans-cultural.
Studying Worldview AssumptionsKey #1 to “The Way Things Are”
God• Exist or not?
• Love/angry/capricious
Universe• Mechanical/Center
Human Beings• sinful, good or neutral
Disease• punishment, fate
Studying Worldview AssumptionsKey #2 to “Values”
Judging Good or Not• Aesthetics, beauty
• Visual/Oral Styles
Ethics• Moral/Immoral
Proper Behavior Work
• Working together
• Competition
STOP & THINKSTOP & THINKWhich of these are “essential”
to the church in every age? Greet with a holy kiss. Do not go to court to settle issues
between Christians. Abstain from fornication. Use only real wine & unleavened
bread in the Lord’s Supper. Anoint with oil for healing. Women are not to teach men. Do not drink wine at all. Remain single. Say “Amen” at the end of prayers. Lift your hands when praying.
Appoint elders and deacons in every congregation.
Elect the leaders. Confess sins one to another. Confess sins privately to God. Construct a building for
worship. Be baptized as an adult. Be baptized as a child/infant. Do not be a polygamist. Do not divorce your spouse
except for adultery.
STOP & THINKSTOP & THINKWhich of these are “essential”
to the church in every age? Greet with a holy kiss. Do not go to court to settle issues
between Christians. Abstain from fornication. Use only real wine & unleavened
bread in the Lord’s Supper. Anoint with oil for healing. Women are not to teach men. Do not drink wine at all. Remain single. Say “Amen” at the end of prayers. Lift your hands when praying.
Appoint elders and deacons in every congregation.
Elect the leaders. Confess sins one to another. Confess sins privately to God. Construct a building for
worship. Be baptized as an adult. Be baptized as a child/infant. Do not be a polygamist. Do not divorce your spouse
except for adultery.
As a Christian in a cross-cultural setting,you will need to learn the differencesbetween those elements essential to the church in every culture, and those whichare not.
As a Christian in a cross-cultural setting,you will need to learn the differencesbetween those elements essential to the church in every culture, and those whichare not.
STOP & THINKSTOP & THINKWhich of these are “essential”
to the church in every age? Greet with a holy kiss. Do not go to court to settle issues
between Christians. Abstain from fornication. Use only real wine & unleavened
bread in the Lord’s Supper. Anoint with oil for healing. Women are not to teach men. Do not drink wine at all. Remain single. Say “Amen” at the end of prayers. Lift your hands when praying.
Appoint elders and deacons in every congregation.
Elect the leaders. Confess sins one to another. Confess sins privately to God. Construct a building for
worship. Be baptized as an adult. Be baptized as a child/infant. Do not be a polygamist. Do not divorce your spouse
except for adultery.
How “Contextualization” WorksWORLDVIEW MEANINGSWORLDVIEW MEANINGS Is it possible for Is it possible for
us to communicate atus to communicate atthe worldview level?the worldview level?
Art/ MusicPolitics
Economy
ReligionReligion
Social Organization
Education
WORLDVIEW
Worldview is the “soulof society” -- the essenceor center of a person.
Cultural Forms
How “Contextualization” WorksWORLDVIEW MEANINGSWORLDVIEW MEANINGS
Cultural FormsCultural Forms
Remember thisRemember thisgraphic? There were graphic? There were many cultural forms.many cultural forms.
How “Contextualization” WorksWORLDVIEW MEANINGSWORLDVIEW MEANINGS
Cultural FormsCultural Forms
ReligionReligionTheologyDance/ArtBehavior
Historically we have tried Historically we have tried communicatingcommunicatingthe Gospel at this level.the Gospel at this level.The problem is thatThe problem is thatmany worldview issuesmany worldview issueshaven’t been changed,haven’t been changed,so in times of trouble,so in times of trouble,the “new” Christiansthe “new” Christiansrevert to “old” customs.revert to “old” customs.
Warning: Religion can besuperficial. When there isno transfer to the next generation,nominal Christianity results.
How “Contextualization” WorksWORLDVIEW MEANINGSWORLDVIEW MEANINGS
Cultural FormsCultural Forms
ReligionReligionTheologyDance/ArtBehavior
Indigenous Indigenous ChrististianityChrististianity
If we start with the If we start with the worldview, then every worldview, then every aspect of the culture aspect of the culture is affected and there is affected and there is a better chance is a better chance of being vital!of being vital!
This takes time. We havea lot of work to do beforeJesus returns.
Belief Systems
Sensory Perception
Belief systems start at the primal level.The world is totally experienced throughthe senses. What you see is what you get.
Belief Systems
Sensory Perception
Folk Religion
Folk religion focuses on the here and now.It is not organized well. No fulltime priests,no seminaries, no written text, but uses drama,stories, songs, legends that hold beliefs andis event oriented.
Belief Systems
Sensory Perception
Folk Religion
HighReligion
Highly instutionalized religion(Muslims, Christianity, etc.)use doctrine codes, holy books,ideals, churches & seminaries.
Belief Systems
Sensory Perception
Folk Religion
ABSTRACT
seen
unse
en w
orld
other worldly
this world
HighReligion
Folk religionis unseen, butof this world.
CONCRETE
Jesus taught and communicated at the lowest levels possible. For instance, He used many parables, which were agriculturally (sensory) based. The “signs and wonders” communicated power (folk level).
Missionaries tend to communicate on the highest levels, which are often beyond reach. For instance, seminaries, literate discipleship workbooks, and a step-by-step “do it fast” approach are rewarded and encouraged.
Missionaries often don’t even see folk religion. Instead, they call it “superstition” or “ignorance.”
Jesus, again our role model
Christianity is a lifestyle.And remember...