DOCKETED

Docket Number: 15-AFC-01

Project Title: Puente Power Project

TN #: 206301

Document Title: Oxnard NRG P3 Alternative Sites

Description: City of Oxnard, Six Alternative Sites/Areas

Filer: PATRICIA LARKIN

Organization: Shute, Mihaly & Weinberger LLP

Submitter Role: Intervenor Representative

Submission Date: 10/8/2015 10:47:57 AM

Docketed Date: 10/8/2015

City of Oxnard Staff are available for CEC questions and data requests August 11, 2015 Six Alternative Sites/Areas To NRG P3 CEC 15-AFC-01 Chris Williamson, Principal Planner (805) 385-8156 (805) 612-6433 Cell Chris.Williamson@ci.oxnard.ca.us

Slide 1

C I T Y O F

OXNARJ3 C A L I F O R N I A

Slide 2

All close to high pressure gas lines and SCE transmission lines

1. Sanitation District “Flower Field” 2. Beedy Street (2 sites) A & B 3. Camino Avenue 4. NEC Del Norte & Fifth Street 5. CalPine proposal (Santa Paula) 6. Ormond Beach area along SCE line

Calpine site

Need to be near high-pressure natural gas line Sl

ide

3

Gas Transmission and High Pressure Distribution Pipeline Interactive Map - Ventura

Find Address Enter your zip code or address.

/s aticoy <

now, TURA V

\ ura aventur* te Beac

ThiWe St

rm^WA Ollas Park Ot

IVERPARK El Rio

101 r-Q ^(V\ne ardAvp

5 >

W Gonzales Rd L5 o WGoiuale ;Rd

tyyeriuxaB/vf

Doris Ave Camino )e/

0 W 2nd St_

OxnVtftir irgis Rd

W O l l i Q l 34 * '

f. W Wooley Rd r

^ N 1 I yM *1 W Hemlock St g

W Channel Islands Blvd

> et $

CD 9? 60 9

…also near SCE Transmission Lines/Corridors

Slide 4

/ SANTA CLARAD • S G Y' i k i w i — ^ j San Buen^vegtuig ' ^ r f ,

*

i • W

• •> . K I

VENT i *- •• r-

^4-. ^r1-¥<*1 . ^ . ' -

V ••: -> . -c Ml I

CHARMtN SHORE

. 1 GONZALES i : UNIOlu,'

MANDALAYg] MCGRATH BEACHT-__

CHANNEL ISLANb • - *

LEHMANQ OCNARD WWTl

WILLAMETTE ^

Tf OXNAR • COLON IA

O^GEN I " I » . -

LEVY %_ CAR s

•—

I r- •• I m

I -"^•ESTERO

CASPER P.l

mm

ORMAND •v_

BEA

SITE 1 Ventura County Sanitation District ‘flower field’

City Golf Course w/recycled water

Bailard Landfill (closed) 20 acres

Santa Clara River /levee

Gas line

Slid

e 5

•;

!W

I -

' %

* . Si .V >

I **

h

w ll r " 11 % c

'f •

' f I %

•V,' j rw* • • ' :

• • '

• i. i • , 6

.-. § J- to jrM .

••'"'.'U •; IK.-r

- ' .

. '.'.r-: - r w i ^J I? \ kA'' m

LJ - -KL3S A-!

ji/ij F^j^* »* KW—

a i fl

Slide 6

^ u n B __ ^?|^vttpy/ww\^.vr5d.cQm/BQard.html P ^ C | 3J Board of Directors O X

File Edit View Favorites lools Help

•

A

tf^. * CV e Board of Directors o Jv

>

5 0 N

ITtSD is governed by a nine-member Board of Director s composed of representatives from member agencies. City Council members from eight cities and one representative selected by special districts having sanitation responsibilities uiithin the County sit on

v/1 K. •fc U % N >

the VRSD Board.

Board Members Staff Contacts (click on name to send an email) About Ua Mark Lawler. General Manager

Ke^in Kild.ee City of CamariUo (805-658-4600)

Board of Directors Josie Guzman, Clerk of the Board Sick Neal, 2015 Chairman City of Fillmore

Betsy Clapp City of Ojai

Bert Per ell o City of Oxnard

Jon Sharkey City of Port Hueneme

Martin Hernandez City of Santa Paula

[S05-65S-4642) Our Services

Legal Counsel Mark A. Zirbel. Attorney at Law Arnold, LaEioclidIe> Mathews, Van Conas & ZirteL LLP Solid Waste/Biosolids Operations

Board Meetings VRSD Board Meetings are held the first and third Thursday of each niontli, beginning at 8-30 AM. Members of the public are encouraged to attend. Meetings are held in the Ventura Regional Sanitation District Board Room, 1001 Partridge Drive, Ventura, California.

Water/Wastewater Operations

Human Resources

News and Public Documents Joel Price City of Thousand Oaks Contact Us Jim Monahan City of Ventura

Jim Acosta Special Districts

Board and Committee Meetings - 2015

Bosrd and Committee Meetings - 2014

V & - V^SD. All rights r-^ . ;•:! QjcJjg^ggS CgBBEi Nags Craitert I SjMMgg

SITE 2 Beedy Street site and County 2 parcel site A) Beedy Street Properties, LLC about 8 acres red box B) Ventura County, about 20 acres white box

County Juvenile Justice Center

Slide 7

C-K;, '

• ' jrf ir

i ^ / -**• i#?

1£. . *

^ •., ' ' < V>>

''^ A •vN, Sty • C V" 'y / •

; . / : •

A A v ; i f J /- A

5a M M ^>' • A J?--

M -'•' -M I m^m<

» : Tij. .-•

'' ;i> . •»• /? X

'(&&•' ^Wf '/

s- 'y, <w.< JjBjS ' <2£H v' /•,

p :•/.- ?>v - v" vV ( v^SNf M : ;'/7 ., |

mm^m m

•Vve/" •

1 ' •.• V* / > x. <^ , _ ^

af

// /'A' . *ii

/ • #/ •" tf'". r !#•

w.^v /AT^ntf-k * .

x-'

•s ^ ' ;••-;/ , k. ;g£j

m WW, y 4<r//'-/ ' • J

•Sx / ;,-5c.j ' /^ /

i''; ' /' /,

V / ^ f ' \ ', •-

SITE 3 Power Machinery site Alice Ranch Co (Rick Power), about 25 acres Light Industrial zoning.

SoCa

l gas

line

Slide 8

Vi BK|

^ • svN^.-' '

5 *i.i- : : . •;: / h >*¥*••'"••':••: • • r;

- c y . . • -101 FWY SOUTH *

-=.

i »»j|» --r:.;r,.. -L'U. -V i-Jg PV^PB :' CAMINO

^ T^C^% f,

ii*rt" ' i ¥/'i

jSr *&. •••M n •V1' ? r -

I li • j! >.iV

ii 1 ll J 1 i i

I / UJ

1 2

< i

I I

>i tu Q ii

z w«t yjm

I i i a A

i

i i i - \ 1\ ^ A •V

V \J

'• "?•,;', • ."1 fir' i

.J, x " . ;

SITE 4 Del Norte – Fifth Street Todd Industrial Park, LLC 12.5 acres zoned heavy industrial

SoCa

l gas

line

SCE Transmission Line

Oxnard Regional Materials Recovery Facility Future bio-gen For farm and city organics

Oil refinery (County)

Slide 9

u II

11 --IRi mt

* " ili • __n6 r : mmm

v-xW ^ n 'r y. ""'n 1 r <>_!

•Ji 4 ,

i'1 i I 'ji

! r • ^

f a • (-Y ' -S'J- -,

\jd/m - • - . J; •.

' <ir

i* 1! W t

k»m l f i

*

r

I ''I

gn^V* •>---"

^ .

i *;

.• | * ,• -. k i f e

1-^ V I :• m s ;•

•^ir 1 tt: - jlSI Bp y ' ••

_•£ •• •-• M

• —»- T f e Cv!-

"i" l<fl |Sg t — 1' <

.1 K3 MP m •• w1

• « \5 >; S Ps ::i i'>i

• air E

, i XL > S'

r:f^ - 3j:i >v

BiiMirti&Mi _1' v."-] • v'. - v . • . — — L 1

IPHpaWL- ~ mrngrnrnmaS

BBBRM mmmmrn ,,r -E FIFTH ST

• % V i BV TT i iM

"Jjtoj; f T"-

iJ.3 r s uPvfBH n r r

SITE 5 Mission Rock Energy Center

10 miles inland Industrial-zoning 10 acres Low-profile (80ft) Easements obtained Recycled water Compatible uses Source: “Alternative proposed to prevent peaker plant along Oxnard coast” Pacific Coast Business Times/ Friday, July 24th, 2015 Calpine

Slide 10

i / •'» j, /,•', fs-flA • aE#|&i r -y' *

JrT ^ J|r\\ L «• r •# ,

rj&s/ t

S'i , fl Vifln M r r ?'

A M >>:

•\ •Vi] : X >

!^|i| V • »1 i > IK5 yvvvv>'> . J- •

' . \ > jz-

t i .

T'' ;W-; '019^ /4 I S a 1 g H^// V

WwrA fa*..

y Ssi-- 7 J d V *W: A

k\l.< > )• 4^ 1

aigE Bg

iJ ' tf Jf x> 41

' > •• .l\'w!

K .

K twIs Sn % , \vTT •vyy »• in

!•«>. • ' ».•

SITE 6 Ormond Beach Area along SCE line

Former “Southshore” area within SOI, probably going to Port-related industrial uses

BMW

Arcturus Ave Industrial area

City Recycled water plant

Existing recycled water line

SCE 220k line

Ormond NRG Slide 11

R 1 . ;

Yr -• * \ • '. = '$*m ' ||?p£|

~ \ *. frm ^ '. - .t* .V »• 'V *lt \ J ^ . •" . •' ' • ••"& •« •:• • •"• ; •• . '? . fx' i^tv « I*-™

CiWSA^BtVjL-^lPW • \ ' ' ^ R!> •. 5 J"i» ' ^ • • ^ "W^f^^fi% v;.#i-i> VJ»f *•'&i . • X V . V v - \ . D Y L A N D r t ' ^

m\' --T• '3 V\' VI, ,.-:g, ;H• •. • ;.- : N Vfei •. - - - ML . / *• . Wv^ w^r?.<L. •\- tft -V".-r> .- f-r..- \ W J & A

% •v1-0 ' •- v -1 ' • r fft- lli Ss I I PHpHi MMy vi^^- -... _

I3WJ7-.: S: ivuSjS^Siv: !; $T^fpg rr^n - -

-It if 44 "

% _ :•.?•. "t*-1 /T -•• I ;:r jfflpl fcji • -o 0

en • Y - . -.i •. • (jB! cCwTZ i

1. *

s. m ;iiMsas * ; la 's. 11 I „ w3 SiTl

i - •.SS.EHUENEMER,

' ftv—

1 EXILMQ , •.Z;,*ir«l

3 'vieiV • iWi »Wp.-M • H I(M|I Mi \

'IK; • ffi ! 0. ' 4 RD —,- 1 •,.

P K i

t..» A

i i Wl ml i

y-kJim » 1 p-mSP ttintt . \ «

*. |gin.qr> S > Tsa •

s» •• •'J * ' V . •'.ivV

'•

A v J - i> .:\ p .%Tv i

SW S CTi - PMEyhA\? • *%, d%¥>' •RtTsV ^ : '

rl if.'J A

CMS \

" ' ' * *,V "5 M f v -

-^ifc-SW =" /JT

Coastal Conservancy’s preferred 2009 plan

Slide 12

Oi—jnd Be»t> ^ t *1 • -tt Rntoralten Fcanity StxHtf

7 - ~ -^SsriSlsKi Legend

u tinckdirie [55 acres)

: Deacti ano snuoiBrn toredune |1S2 acresl

KSB Discfcsh niarsh (non koal) (46 aoesj coastal grassland [221 acrosl

oaiisM gntsaUnl (uanannnal} |30S acresj

I I tnansoed dud ponds |168 aci«3| open water [119 acres] seascrwl pcrri / pame |93 acrits|

Kascnal wetiand deprnsiuit iwvelated) (77 aciesj vaultwm coftstal sal nuwsti (non-Mat) [t 90 8cr«s|

v>ulh«m ciMxtat sal m«Rih (tKtat) [!46 acn»|

' Umlmenl wetiands (25 acres)

unvegetated in«er-tidal ft 3 ftcras)

wllow scrub (<3 acres]

• - - - nermttenl channel

Clv»nn«l Bloc*

Channel

MrfOTOTW fl(t

ar r...- •J : ! - . ' --..I * ' H j la I °

-> 1 <

\

Area (aoes: kv/IMBM

H -o

i v V

v" : , mmrn p ij • >v „ ." i.'

--t Icwpef wc MSH . ,.4 P * - ^

JUbx, k

e KX > ; •i frviJCf-

rSWViLtVp* / / •

- a ^ / S SvN pigMr*! s-g

Preliminary Habitat Map for Alternative 2U N Aspen C fOX 2COO 4X0

S».rc«. PtiAp Wflaim 1 AAIUL «i<9 2Mf. Scclo r =00

5-11

And the “Constrained” plan with Ormond still there – much more expensive to build around NRG

Slide 13

Ormand Beech Walfcnd Rsatombori F©as^;|ry Stv&f

' wmmm V 'v Legend

bsdtdune |44 acres)

V b « » c h H t n j |9Q a<f«»]

brackBh fnarah inon •aal) [2* acreaj

coastal grassland [70 aceri graMiiNtcl [127

open water [64 acxea)

|g seaocrv^ pond < panne [90 acre*)

a««scnat vwlland tM^roaaicn <v«gei89ed| [16 acres]

vouhnm coastal salt maish {non-Udari [142 actasl

soutietn coastal saft marsh <l»dal> [7d atres)

^ •- I'MH'niH'ii [7 awes)

urM*gatatad inMr-«dil [15 acraa]

wlltrw scnjto (5 acresl

• •• >riM«irtQ«r4 chann«l

Chamal Bock

Chamri

Hieo«fm Id

dJEi 6

; -

i / . ¥-i

m /una Ur-/Mn* pr^a

fi" ~

I 10

X

up •«.?4

Xty / l^v

' V y-v •' ' ' 4

• .y^y/f

V. . -[Caaocr Ra.

KT %**-W6*M~ w '•?»-

' 'r '

w

rP~ i fi' y /9m

v -" / / •

_ Fiqur? W

Preliminary Habitat Map for Alternative 2C N C 1X0 2X0 4X0 Aspen

iuA "I fool S».rt«. Pfilp WAIama 1 Aa»oc«lM. 2fiO».

5-12 October 2009 final