document resume ed 204 594 - eric · pdf filedocument resume. ed 204 594 cb 029 523. author....
TRANSCRIPT
DOCUMENT RESUME
ED 204 594 CB 029 523
AUTHOR Wilson, Thurlow R.: And OthersTITLE On- the -Job. Training and Social Learning Theory: A
Literature Review. Special Report:INSTITUTION Human Resources Research Organization, Alexandria,
Vs.SPONS AGENCY Bureau of Mines (Dept. of Interior), Washington,
D.C.REPORT NO HumRRO-SR-ETSD-110-5PUB DATE May 80CONTRACT H030829VOTE 59p.
7DRS- PRICEDESCRIPTORS
ABSTRACT
MF01/PC03 Plus Postage.Apprenticeships: Behavior:Modification:'BehaviorPatterns: CommuniCation Skills: Comparative Analysis:Coordination: Disadvantaged: Education WorkRelationship: Malian Relations: Industry:.Interpersonal Competence: Literature' Reviews:Military Service: Models; Offthe;Job.,,Training:::the job, Trtiningi Outcomes-ofEducation::*PrograwEffectiveness: *School Business:Relationship:*SoCialitation:Supervisory Training:.,ZystemsApproach: *Training Method *Vocktional-Education
..
On7the-job training (OJT) is the post:trequently usedtraining method in'industry. This OJT is mostly unstrtictutedivAihileoff-job-site training (OJST) should prepare for Or*supplement OJT,coordination betweenAMT incrOJST is often poor. Advantages of OJTinclUde its low.cost, realistic nature, and motivatingfOrce.-Howevero. it is usually unplanned and alust take,a secondary plate toproduction. Most books on induStrial .training describe a four-stepmethod of conducting OJT. Although military OJT is more structured,it has many of the same problemS as ciiilianiOJT. Social leitningtheory, which has,beeh.developedto describe':and predit 1160 people.learn:from observation of models, can yielcYa.,number of rules for-optimal trainitg'conditions.Howeier, use, of social leirning theory ,,.,as a technique fot training and modifying behavior has_been studiedmostly outside of industrial settings. Social leariing. theory hasbeen applied to industry. in two ways: to teaChAtanigets-to deal moreeffectively with human relations problems and to predict whichsubordinites will imitate the behavior of.their supertisors.learning theory concepts and training methodt appear feasible foripplication'toA3JT. (Twenty training principles derived 'from thetheory, for use in structured OJT, are presented.) (MN)
*******************************************A*************************** Reprodictions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be made Yi* from the original document.********************4!*************************************************
, ,
SpecialReport80-5
HumRROSR-ETSD-80-5
HumRRO
t-4-cr% On-the-Job Training and
Social Learning Theory:r\J
A Literature Review
May 1980
Thurlow R. WilsonJoseph A. OlmsteadRobert C. Trexler
HUMAN RESOURCES RESEARCH ORGANIZATION300 North Washington Street Alexandria. Virginia 22314
2
I
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH,EDUCATION L WELFARENATIONAL INSTITUTE OF
EDUCATION
THIS DOCUMENT HAS BEEN REPRO.OUCED EXACTLY AS RECEIVED FROM ITHE PERSON OR ORGANIZATION ORIGIN-ATING IT POINTS OF VIEW OR OPINIONS ISTATED DO NOT NECESSARILY REPRESENT OFFICIAL NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF
irEDUCATION POSITION OR POLICY.
FOREWORD
This report was prepared by the Human Resources Research Organization(HumRRO). It discusses the current use of On-the-Job Training (OJT) inindustry, the application of Social Learning Theory to OJT and the impli-cations thereof.
The report is a part of a project under the U.S. Bureau of MinesContract No. H030828. Mr. W. Wiehagen of the Bureau of Mines ResearchCenter at Bruceton, Pennsylvania is the Technical Project Officer. Theresearch was conducted in the Educational and Training Systems Divisionof HumRRO in Alexandria, Virginia, where Dr. Robert J. Seidel is theDivision Director. Mr. Paul E. Loustaunau was the Project Director. Theprincipal author was Dr. Thurlow R. Wilsion, who was assisted by Dr. JosephOlmstead in the area of industrial training and by Mr. Robert C. Trexler
in the area of OJT.
The research and development effort in compiling this report occurredin December 1979 through May 1980.
James W. SingletonPresidentHuman Resources Research Organization
3
Ili
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page,
FOREWORDiii
SUMMARY3
OJT in Industry3
Social Learning Theory5
INTRODUCTION7
PART I. INDUSTRIAL OJT7
Scope of Review and Sources7
Scope of the Review of OJT Literature7
Sources of Literature Reviewed7
Definitions Used in Literature Review8
The Use of OJT in Industry8
Frequency of Use of OJT8
Use of Structured and Unstructured OJT8
On-The-Job Training and Off- Production-Site Training
9
Training by Large Versus Small Employers11
Strengths and Limitations of OJT 11OJT for Disadvantaged Workers
13Methods of Conducting OJT
15
The Four Steps of Job Instruction Training15
Expansion of the Job Instruction Training Model. . 16
Apprentice Training17
A Systems Approach to Training by Private Industry . 22OJT in the Military Services
22
Investigations Comparing the Results ofDifferent Training Methods
25
Structured Compared to UnstructuredTraining of a Semi-Skilled Job
26
Accelerated Training for PrecisionMachinist Apprentices
26
Proficiency-Based Training 27
Training Path and Current Job Performance 28
PART II. SOCIAL LEARNING THEORY
Social Learning Theory and Learning from Models
'aining Principles Based on Social Learning Theory . .
terapeutic Applications of Observational Learning . .
aching Interpersonal Skills
.Istrial Application of Social Learning TheoryModeling
Interaction Modeling for Supervisory Training
Modeling
Role-Play
Social Reinforcement
Transfer of Training
An Experimental Analysis of InteractionModeling
Validity Studies of Interaction Modeling
Subordinate Imitation of Supervisors
CONCLUSIONS
IMPLICATIONS
REFERENCES 47
29
29
32
34
35
35
35
38
38
39
39
40
41
41
43
45
5vi
TABLES
1. Subject Matter of Structured Training: By Purposeand Type of Training
2. Comments and Suggestions on How to Improve On-The-Job Training by Former Apprentices
3. Results of Studies Using Modeling to TeachInterpersonal Skills
4. Result of Experimental Analysis of InteractionModeling
5. Correlation Between Supervisor Characteristicsand Behavior Similarity
vii
10
18
36
41
42
ON-THE-JOB TRAINING ANDSOCIAL LEARNING THEORY:
A LITERATURE REVIEW
7
SUMMARY
OJT in Industry
The most frequently used training method in industry is OJT. Mostlythis OJT is unstructured, that is, lacking a training plan designed todevelop specific skills and lacking a trainer. Structured OJT is mostoften found with employers with very large work forces. Off Job SiteTraining (OJST) should prepare for or supplement OJT. In practice thecoordination between OJT and OJST is often poor.
OJT is commonly thought to have certain advantages; OJT is low cost,realistic, and can motivate those employees who are turned off by classroomtraining. The weaknesses of OJT is that it is usually unplanned. Also itis seldom possible to maximize training on the job and production; OJT mustnecessarily take a secondary position to production.
Most books on industrial training describe a four-step method ofconducting OJT.
Before instruction: make a job breakdown, make a courseoutline, have equipment and materials ready.
Step 1. Preparation: put learner at ease; find out whathe already knows about the job, pt learner interestedin the job.
Step 2. Presentation: tell, show and illustrate oneimportant step at a time; stress each key point,instruct clearly, completely and patiently, but nomore than he can master.
Step 3. Application: have him do the job and correcterrors; have him do the job again as he,exp/ainseach key point; have him do the job over until youknow he knows.
Step 4. Follow-up: put him on his own; check frequently,praise good work, reinstruct to correct poor work.
Studies of apprenticeship reveal the following difficulties in manyapprenticeship programs:
- the trainee is treated as a helper or semi-skilled laborer-
- the trainee fails to rotate between all the tasks of the job.
3
- classroom training (OJST) is poorly correlated to OJT.
- the demands of production receive most or all of the trainer'sattention and the needs of the trainee are neglected.
- trainers lack knowledge or skill regarding instructional methods.
- training material is inappropriate--outdated, inaccurate, writtenabove reading level of the trainee.
- completion of training is based on exposure time rather thandemonstrated proficiency.
- the training plan is not based on an accurate job analysis.
Military OJT is highly structured compared to OJT commonly found itindustry. The most advanced training technology will be found in use inmilitary OJT. Nevertheless, military OJT systems have many of the sameproblems as civilian OJT, such as difficulties coordinatinC between class-room and job proficiency training, unsuitable training materials, failureof the trainee to get experience in all the aspects of the job.
Investigations comparing the results of different methods of conduct-ing OJT found:
- for a semi-skilled factory job structured training resultedin a significant reduction of training time compared to un-structured training (4.6 hours compared to 16.2 hours).
- for machinist apprentices, training can be accomplished in afr