document resume ed 415 139 so 027 632 author stix, andi … · 2014. 5. 19. · document resume. ed...
TRANSCRIPT
DOCUMENT RESUME
ED 415 139 SO 027 632
AUTHOR Stix, AndiTITLE Creating Rubrics through Negotiable Contracting.PUB DATE 1996-00-00NOTE 26p.; Paper presented at the Annual Conference of the
National Middle School Association (23rd, Baltimore, MD,November 1996).
AVAILABLE FROM The Interactive Classroom, 27 Siebrecht Place, New Rochelle,NY 10804; phone: 914-636-0888.
PUB TYPE Speeches/Meeting Papers (150)EDRS PRICE MF01/PCO2 Plus Postage.DESCRIPTORS Academic Achievement; Elementary Secondary Education;
*Grading; Holistic Evaluation; *Student Evaluation; TeacherStudent Relationship
ABSTRACTThis paper explains the construction of a grading rubric
that is designed to empower students with expectations of quality work.Teachers and students "negotiate" a mutually acceptable consensus. Thecontract process is based on the idea that when students feel they are valuedparticipants in the assessment process, they become motivated to strivetowards those criteria-based standards. The process can be used to setshort-term goals for lessons that do not require formal assessment but forwhich quality work is expected. Samples of assessment sheets and student worksamples are presented with criteria for evaluation. (EH)
********************************************************************************
Reproductions supplied by EDRS are the best that can be madefrom the original document.
********************************************************************************
Creating RubricsThrough Negotiable Contracting
by
U.S. DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATIONOffice of Educational Research and Improvement
EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES INFORMATIONCENTER (ERIC)
41 This document has been reproduced asreceived from the person or organizationoriginating it.
Minor changes have been made toimprove reproduction quality.
Points of view or opinions stated in thisdocument do not necessarily representofficial OERI position or policy.
PERMISSION TO REPRODUCE ANDDISSEMINATE THIS MATERIAL
HAS BEEN GRANTED BY
Andi Srix, Ed.D. I ANDI 5 rficTO THE EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES
INFORMATION CENTER (ERIC)
cn The Interactive Classroom27 Siebrecht. Place
New Rochelle, NY 10804
c*N1
C.) tel: 914-636-0888
CD BEST COPY AVAILABLEweb: [email protected]
fax: 914-632-0171Ci)
2
Empowering students
The success of negotiable contracting relies on giving students shared
ownership of their own learning. Although the teacher is ultimately responsible
for grading, her main function is to serve as a facilitator of discussion about the
assessment process. hi this way, students do not view the teacher as an all
powerful judge of their work. Before the teacher discusses the expectations of
upcoming assignments, she asks students what they think would constitute
quality work for the particular task. Teacher and student meet at the
'negotiating table' to reach a mutually acceptable consensus. When students
feel like valued participants in the assessment process, they become motivated
to strive towards those criteria-based standards.
The contract process can be used in the classroom for many purposes. It
is ideal for setting short-term goals for lessons that do not require formal
assessment, but 'for which teachers want to establish criteria for high quality
work. For example, if students work together in groups on a research project,
negotiable contracting helps define expectations such as cooperative roles,
research materials, and graphing and charting formats.
As classroom teacher Roberta
Horn explains, 'Using a contract has
enabled me to inform the children of 14 siilt ..k..., jo,rs L..6
all research project requirements and ,14.1 Pi teot .631- lreks ;A,
$0ir, 4 4) rrttUrAfAligliSeeR0/ A3111~tte 4,.' ito guide the students through every/: 4) 4f.ar:- "".
step of their work. The contract 'Of,s,..i 4 04(..oluot fre.640:4,2ple.qoun,..,,,i,
makes clear to them what the -,.., , , ...,_,...0,J 4 erA41414 kariStrinsitity el'i,
expectations are and by what date ;.J-2,` ',,417?a4:7456"1".45'414!' ?e
each of those expectations are to be . ,,,tsRa
met"
I%
: ;k
'V,
fl'; :1 1
8
3
Martha Polln uses the contract
to create an assessment sheet.
319V1IVAV Ad03
How to Create RubricsThrough Negotiable Contracting
by Audi Slix, Ed.D.
I. Define the project
2. Brainstorm with your neighbor or cooperative group
what a teacher would be looking for
3. Chart results as a whole group
4. Prioritize the top four or five items
5. For each item, what does it mean? List 2 to 3 subtopics
6. Create the labels or headings for the chart
7. Fill in the matrix or chart with information
Part II: Activity I:
1. In whole group, the students brainstorm the questions that they should answer. Thefollowing list is provided as a sample for the students to complete::
a. Name the explorer:
b. What year(s) did the exploration(s) take place?
C. What was discovered?
d. Who financed their voyage or expedition?
e. What was the reason for the voyage or exploration? (motivation)
-f. Describe the route they took
g. What are the coordinates of the place discovered?
h. Was the voyage or expedition successful?
i. Describe the story behind the voyage or expedition:
j. Other notable comments:
The Diary Activity
1. After the students have finished conducting their research, the students should workon a rough draft for their creative writing piece. It would be fun if the students tookthe point of view as one of the explorers and wrote it up in a diary form,including sketches and pictures. Review the aspects of historical fiction, that it isbased on fact. However, they can use their discretion as how they depict people'sreactions and their emotions to any given situation. Please see a sample diary sheetlocated at the end of the unit. Hard covered blank books can be ordered ahead ofschedule. A good reference for this is: Bear Back Books: Treetop Publishing: 414-884-0501. On the other hand, students may wish to create them on their own,using hand made paper or other resources. Other students may wish to create avideo tape, a cassette, or use a computer presentation package such as Hyper Studioor Astound.
2. Students and teachers should generate a list of standards that mark excellence. It isstrongly recommended that this list be generated before the students embark onthis task so that they know the level of expertise sought.Some suggestions are:
Does the writing capture the reader's interest?In what ways does the diary reveal emotion?How detailed is the writing?Does the student highlight the essential points in his or her account?Is the beginning and the ending of the piece strong?Do the middle paragraphs support the introduction?Does it flow properly and logically?What pictures does the student choose, draw, or photocopy?Any appropriate sketches or doodling?Any leaves, branches, fake fur, or other materials incorporated?Does the student decide to dress up and take some photographs depictingthe time and place?How dramatic is the performance or writing?How original is the project? Is it so obviously personal?Does the writing reflect hundreds of years ago?Does the student incorporate some foreign language or regional sayings?How artistic is the piece?Is it long and laborious or does it show great variety?
3. If the teacher chooses to use an alternative way of assessing students, an alternativerating sheet or form can be chosen, reviewed or created at this point. Please refer tothe back section if you choose to implement this procedure. However, the criteriagenerated in #2 should be used to choose the top three or four criteria forassessment.
4. It is recommended that students have a full session to go through the writingprocess with one another. In other words, in a cooperative group of four students,one student can proof read for spelling errors, another for punctuation, another fordepth of detail, and another for proper paragraphs.
On the due date, students are given time to enjoy one another's projects.
1. It is important to discuss ahead of time the different things that would be interestingin discussing the diaries. Using the original list created before they wrote their diaries(Diary Activity #2), students begin to discuss and positively critique each other'sfinished products. Please refer to the back of this section for samples of peerassessment sheets.
2. 13e sure to model this procedure for the students. Imagine sitting with a friend in aliving room. You are up in the mountains and you are both sipping a glass of icetea. The discussion should flow naturally as if you were chatting about the latestmovie that you both saw and discussing why you liked it so, what parts were sooutstanding and what parts needed a bit more clarification. But the dialogue shouldbe casual and relaxed.
3. Have each pair of students exchange their diaries with another pair. It is suggestedfor each pair of students, who sit shoulder to shoulder, to read together. As one pairreads, the other pair reads as well. Then the students can discuss the two diaries asa group. They repeat the format with the other two diaries. The teacher and/or thestudents should utilize four or five of the most important criteria generated by theclass for his or her own evaluation of F' ch student's work..
4. The following pages provide assessment sheets, a sample rating system, peerassessment sheet, teacher assessment sheet and a whole class numerical ratingform. reel free to use whatever method is most suitable. It is recommended that thefollowing sheets are used as guides for you to create your own with the students. Ifyou decide to create your own, please select one of these forms together with thestudents ahead of time in order to help guide them.
Here is a sample of an assessment that could be used:Diary of an
Explorer Novice Apprentice Veteran Master
Captivates
Reader
Does not
interest
reader.
Unfocused,
Not
stimulating
Pts. 1-2
Reader
struggles to
maintain
interest. Barely
engaging.
Pts. 3-4
Reader is
captivated with
a strong focus,
stimulated and
drawn in to
material.
Pts. 5-6
Reader is
excited to read
the piece and
does not want
to put it down.
Reader is highly
motivated.
Pts. 7-8
Reveals
Emotion
Little to no
emotion
Pts. 1-3
Some emotion
Pts. 4-6
Clear feeling of
the intended
emotion.
Fits. 7-9
Gives great
detail and feels
strong emotion.
Pts. 10-12
Detail
and
Deptli
hardly any
facts, brief
Pt. 1-3
some facts
general
information
Pts., 4-6
covers body of
information
with supporting
detail
Pts. 7-9
comprehensive
thorough and
gives many
specifics
Pts. 10-12
Essential
Higliligfas
vague
not focused
Pts. 1-2
some points
are mentioned,
haphazard
Pts 3-4
highlights
important
points
Pts. 5-6
wonderful
highlights,
showcase the
crux of the
matter
Pts. 7-8
Use of
Props
little to no
drawings or
pictures
incorporated
Pts. 1-3
a few drawings
pictures, props
used that
support writing
Pts 4-6
adequate
amount of
drawings,props
pictures that
support wilting
Fits 7-9
detailed pictures
props and
drawings used
that extend and
support writing
Pts 10-12
BEST COPY AVAIJABLE
4.
5.
6.7.
9.10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.21.
22.23.24.25.26,27.
28.29.30.31.
52.33.34.35.36.37.
38.
BEST COPY AVAILAiiiii
MA
IN T
OPI
CK
now
ledg
e of
Sub
ject
Mat
ter:
Not
able
Poi
nts
In W
hat.i
vnis
i.:tr
idif
ieitO
dent
spe
akJe
s;e1
Y.0
3.::1
3;.a
*:.0
Si(S
)4e
was
fam
iiarw
lth th
e to
pic?
Wes
they
PRE
SEN
TA
TIO
N.:
clar
ity,p
ruje
ctio
n or
voi
ce, e
yeco
ntac
t, vo
ice
infl
ectio
n4 p
rofe
ssio
nal
beha
vior
MU
LT
I-M
OD
AL
:In
Wha
t way
s tli
d th
e vi
sual
s,dr
ama,
son
g, e
tc..
rein
forc
e th
i,
vies
Sob-
topi
c I:
ob-t
opic
..
Sub-
topi
c 3:
Sitb
-top
ic 4
:
In w
hat w
ays
did
the
grou
p di
vide
/del
egat
e th
e re
spon
sibi
litie
s so
that
eac
h pe
rson
cont
ribu
ted
equa
lly?
Did
the
pres
enta
tions
flo
w f
rom
one
per
son
to a
noth
er a
nd d
id th
e st
uden
ts c
onne
ctth
eir
sub-
topi
cs to
the
mai
n to
pic?
Nam
e:
0
Dat
e:
BE
ST C
OPY
AV
AII
AB
LE
Tea
cher
: Mr.
Hrb
ek
It
MA
IN T
OPI
C:
1700
g,P
i e.4
:imoK
n--S
e..i4
-Hem
em-t
;PI
E N
ntS/
IvA
int I
A
CO
NT
EN
T:
Kno
wle
dge
of S
ubje
ctM
atte
r: N
otab
le P
oint
s
FAM
ILIA
RIT
Y:
In w
hat w
ays
did
the
stud
ent s
peak
free
ly to
pro
ve th
at (
s)he
was
fam
iliar
with
the
topi
c? W
ere
they
able
to a
nsw
er q
uest
ions
eas
ily?
1.4,
44,4
I..8
1.0.
Mee
r M
QA
....
eyvc
y N
tAis
iNte
r--)
.-N
A/ A
-SV
-e-P
-7/ C
-Cgi
vrcO
efft
fle
i'v 1
.4le
ew...
..\-6
0-1-
c,
PRE
SEN
TA
TIO
N:
clar
ity, p
roje
ctio
n of
voi
ce, e
yeco
ntac
t, vo
ice
infl
ectio
n, p
rofe
ssio
nal-
beha
vior
.....s
ci..4
e_M
A-F
eel
wits
.
MU
LT
I-M
OD
AL
:In
wha
t way
s di
d th
e vi
sudr
ama,
son
g, e
tc.,
rein
fon
rese
arch
-rte
s_r
I A
e.,
1..*
1/4,
C3V
NIad
-÷L
.54"
azal
W e
_ l I
.1 .0
s ?T
sc=
t-e-
scR
.; .6
e_gz
iI I.
Sub-
topi
c 1:
AN
cke.
.40w
// H o
usiN
G.'
Des
czi;i
es4
p t A
ce _
m.e
...1+
47F
uou
ses;
co ?
-1-S
tg-o
c---
÷r-
c)43
A.A
A-4
e..P
. At s
/ =1"
=-
RI
geA
cz1
Fee.
05
ec-t
-eid
1-4
I S
v o
I c-
e._.
-V
- T
.S k
ishe
rr',.
,4 +
4eA
r-rt
t..
Sub-
topi
c 2:
MA
RI s
A/
1./..
..S-1
-oci
cAct
c.!
.iiite
eA
-c--
-f-u
A-
IL
-L-S
ed -
frL
9--
c4-e
i-k
.'i-4
-e-r
tAz
---h
,6
i(f=
qi I
4 4
.IPc
-c--
-)3
--4-
0 c.
-04-
ci-e
.
1Fo
P-i-
rax3
S vc
CA
e (c
ePre
S4/
5Q+
WA
-s r
07.
c eS
1.-
c.Z
qz-
eser
iIN
C.g
-
../-k
cc('-
etiu
tcP(
1.1.
,'t.
e"(-
-,47
II
Tic
e- -
-+-°
,,_
__c"
''``1
,4
Wks
. nC
-4-3
(''''t
-fle
-7fz
ehic
ieR
cca
NT
c..e
. y/ c
-o (
o g
cQ
.+ 4
) I,.
c.3
MeA
s ug
e,t-
LeA
lis ;
A`f
42c=
t-e+
AL
Ls
OF
-4-f
e,,U
AA
4.2-
b.de
r-
Sub-
topi
c 3:
NA
-rA
i-.i
/fs
ot,,N
;-1-
"-fic
es\N
c_IL
S/
i t.I
.FoR
hi.c
i c_1
>t-
ssA
6.t.
04-.
07z"
trzt
ic=
h-07
°t--
1--/
V4
Ls O
F w
els
,--
.C
iL
I4L
-0 U
-seS
''.
1-ki
ale.
.'1
.1F
oe.A
.0-
t i o
...1
LLI
ft-S
F*c
.---
r u
Pt 1
j CP
-Lec
esw
eie.
.. H
AI-
141e
.,4..r
a-ri
5 F
--A
<:::
:Ii=
m. i
X
.1=
%_1
:.c:,
fk+
Hl t
ars
g.e.
A-,
ca.n
. LIT
f.{
prei
Oa
0 =
.C A
Z I
-C1.
4.E
.yz
- c.
c,14
-t-is
.+-
vv1-
14...
.A
.L.L
=1I
e.4.
3 c.
.,e._
1'01
Nt-
i-el
0i u
. -f-
c .i.
e -1
-e...
; (S
cp...
Sire
-Tza
rre
tev
Av.
%-1
---4
cl.u
.A4
Sub-
topi
c 4:
1.)A
hli-e
_t te
..../
.e,-
-rA
;.., 1
L.:I
Ne'
t
Ver
>V
-ni
p7
Oft
iFi
-cSf
iE\v
)t.)
.
1-(e
_?._
g-ef
otc
.-i-
-4-Q
S.
1/4.
1 i-
i, 42
..A.n
i
de.4
-.4-
Z-
Iuz
0 ).
---
-144
A_
sib
-
Nac
Azc
1.0
0
( A
v..)
-.5-
r.ok
e w
.e.t1
1434
%3
c(
,o...
...sw
e te
..e.d
guee
rid
r.I.
S.s
. A-4
-, s
--F
.,*--
-trz
ie.i,
/ -"N
e,-a
V9
/C
--0
.3 F
-7;=
(e43
+.
/
L.I.s
e,c
14-e
r+
0 e.
A.t.
F I
nks.
1-2-
.0f4
C-A
",1:
,k-.
) '
I
--17
44-k
i.ei
-....
.---
-.In
wha
t way
s di
d th
e gr
oup
divi
de/d
eleg
ate
the
resp
onsi
bilit
ies
so th
at e
ach
pers
oD
id th
e pr
esen
tatio
ns f
low
fro
m o
ne p
erso
n to
ano
ther
and
did
the
stud
ents
con
nect
/41
(tv
iA-T
op-
.--
(---
of-r
-c.c
I4,
,,Ii-
--4
-=.
'rF(Z
...,
, r-e
. ey
/411
F -
6 0
g . _
-(1.
1&,v
1 40
/4Is
c_G
A-k
ft-e
AkP
A.)
--econt
ribu
ted
thei
r su
b-to
pics
0A
e_g_
.0
equa
lly?
to th
e m
ain
topi
c?c_
ovec
e..e
g i
L.:I
0 /,
.) 4
4-0e
fi e
/.e
+c-
P-t
671-
ter-
-- .
Nam
e:-A
Ilag
rat
MA
,CT
S1
lar*
NA
4-M
-142
Ne-
eRA
-I
te. 0
I2
Dat
e:
319V
11V
AV
Ad0
0 .1
331
Tea
cher
:
13
Com
paris
onC
ontr
ast C
hart
Pre
Pos
t Civ
il W
ar
Sec
tiona
lism
1800
Rec
onst
ruct
ion
Gild
ed A
ge18
66-1
890s
Bla
cks/
Sla
ves
,Sla
ves
Fre
e bl
acks
ofte
n ha
d m
enia
l lab
orB
lack
s se
t fre
eM
enia
l Lab
orT
hey
had
a co
ntin
uous
str
uggl
e fo
r ci
vil r
ight
sS
egre
gatio
n em
erge
d
Bus
ines
smen
Fam
ily b
usin
ess
Ofte
n F
athe
r-S
on r
elat
ions
hips
Par
tner
s
Big
bus
ines
s an
d co
rpor
atio
ns e
mer
ge
Wom
enV
ery
few
rig
hts
Dom
estic
Beg
an to
see
k rig
hts:
(S
enec
a C
onve
ntio
n)
Eliz
abet
h B
lack
wel
l ope
ned
the
door
s fo
r w
omen
toen
ter
colle
ges,
som
e st
ates
gav
e th
em th
e rig
ht to
vote
, tem
pera
nce
mov
emen
t (no
drin
king
)
Fac
tory
Wor
kers
Few
rig
hts,
long
hou
rs, p
oor
cond
ition
s,S
even
day
wor
k w
eek
Mili
tant
uni
onis
m e
mer
ges
(Mol
ly M
cGui
res-
min
ers,
Nob
le O
rder
of t
he K
nigh
tsof
Lab
or, A
FL
and
CIO
Fam
ilies
of L
arge
Pla
ntat
ion
head
of l
arge
pla
ntat
ion,
maj
or p
rodu
ct: c
otto
n,ow
ned
hund
reds
of s
lave
s, le
isur
e lif
e, g
over
nmen
tse
rvic
e
Pla
ntat
ions
are
bro
ken
up, s
mal
l far
mer
s, s
hare
crop
pers
(50
%of
goo
ds)
and
tena
nt fa
rmer
s (p
ure
rent
pay
ers)
take
dye
r la
ndM
en: e
ntre
pren
euria
l in
dive
rsifi
ed in
dust
ry
Iris
hM
enia
l lab
or a
s th
ey w
ere
the
late
st im
mig
rant
sB
uilt
Eer
ie C
anal
Em
erge
d as
a p
oliti
cal p
ower
gro
up, B
oss
Tw
eed
runs
NY
C a
nd p
lace
s hi
s ow
n pe
ople
in th
e po
lice
forc
e, fi
re a
nd s
anita
tion
depa
rtm
ents
Nat
ive
Am
eric
ans
Nom
adic
Fre
e sp
irits
End
of t
heir
life
styl
e. B
ecom
es a
per
iod
of b
enig
nne
glec
t as
fede
ral g
over
nmen
t for
ces
them
into
rese
rvat
ions
St n
ail
Far
MC
I'S
Nat
ion
of s
mal
l far
mer
s an
d la
nd h
olde
rsF
arm
ing
chan
ges.
Peo
ple
leav
e fa
rmin
g an
d go
into
indu
stry
. Sm
all f
arm
s ta
ken
over
by
bank
s an
dbu
sine
sses
and
bec
ome
gian
t com
pani
es
Sm
all T
own
Mai
n S
t. F
olk
Sm
all t
owns
with
mai
n st
reet
: gen
eral
sto
re, c
hurc
h,ba
rber
sho
ps, p
ublic
sch
ools
, and
chu
rche
sS
mal
l citi
es a
nd la
rge
citie
s em
erge
as
they
attr
act
wor
kers
. Peo
ple
mov
e to
thes
e ar
eas
.
BE
ST C
OPY
AV
AIL
AB
LE
1415
gliWIYany ,-QOperC-;,:contact.,
7.
11.
12,
13.
1:14.
15
16.
18.
19..
20.21.
22.23.
25.
26.27.
11 26,
29.11 30,
31.
52.33.
34.
35.
.36,
37.
38.
16 BEST COPY AVAILABLE
Ln
t.\-2
.,5
Nam
e:(Y
) dI
sSa
ND
ate:
\ IL°
q 6
Tea
cher
:\N
AS
..fo
rn
Pre
sent
er's
Nam
eS
ubje
ctM
ost I
mpo
rtan
tin
form
atio
nQ
ualit
y of
Pro
ject
Pre
sent
atio
n S
kills
S\ob
nibe
xcA
oosc
x
VN
CkC
niz
,
a_c_
5A
poV
s-A
,
icn,
.k-\
c'Ir
- 0
f-eA
s--
\_-
.\-
,...\[
A--
z-7_
TO
-e,
L),
)c-4
Yvk
,-vk
uo,_
.\
T__
\otc
,z._
---\
(\,e
__,,,
5cu4
k,
p no
ce_
c_.4
-..
`)ac
k\T
\--i
-(D
u\-
-Lni
rL_,
R)r
-Li
wo(
LIN
,i-
4-L
t
-f:`
' 12
\ c,,J
e. s
ei\c
/AE
OL
*
1-e6
kSi"
"rlA
-)b
fv\V
Q,
irt/V
1(ir
\ t -
4--H
e_to
L)
c,L
er
.Yr(
kID
,cv.
.,\E
I1G
vh
nckc
_as\
VI
Vve
..nh.
e_ u
jo,5
0 0\
r),
`(\ 1
2.N IL
ud
-n)6
koi
e ?4
i),
r Im
e3k-
rS
/VI
Le_
v/ s
vac
Is.
she
ti.)
as)-
1--Q
uil L
'eI'
oo P
SI I
r)
4-ke
i-II
AJ-
Dpi
p6(
v._
(00\
003
151,
tr -
1-,-
k.bo
or\
tuof
)4.p
eif-
Cc,
tQj
Cow
ilict
Ncu
t mar
te,.\
-
n 04
6-tr
man
a.e
(yia
§+c,
t(r-
eci
, vito
e
ra2:
,(ou
,2-
,fr,
14-Q
-v
Iue
- r
,vc
.,
7/
LC
ii(D
401,
Lle
- r
Vitl
iU
e,
S1\1
_, w
cks
veSP
e_c
i-Pi
c,-1
-11a
-F,5
he a
j -
LC
kurc
1uda
icto
"6.r
e_01
-
(7(
I A
-_
te
6
*E-e
, v),
IVoo
pLop
e,
V21
1 n
t a.
neel
f
LkA
.,,\
difo
L\o
\
.s\,\
_,z,
_Ir)
e
u,)\
n 0,
,,-v\
IL. w
cts
-i-o
,Abi
\(4_
cA_(
/-20
Ji-,
17R
EST
rnpv
AV
AII
API
18
Janine Bartico's class negotiated the following criteria and created their
own headings and interpretations:
Poetry Novice Apprentice ::: Veteran Master
Captivates
Reader
Does not
interest reader
Unfocused,
not
stimulating
(1-2 ptsJ
Reader
struggles to
maintain
interest
Barely
engaging
(3-4 ptsJ
Reader is
captivated
with a strong
focus,
stimulated
and drawn in
to material
(5-6 ptsJ
Reader is
excited to read
the piece and
does not want
to put it down
Reader Is
highly
motivated
(7-8 ptsJ
Portrayal of
Imagery
Difficult to
visualize
image
(1-3 ptsJ
Some sense
of image or
Image or idea
(4-6 ptsJ
Clear use of
imagery to
portray Ideas
(7-9 ptsJ
Vivid, detailed
Images
(1012 ptsJ
Use of
Language
Imprecise or
inappropriate
choice of
words
(1-2 ptsJ
Expresses
thoughts
marginally
(3-4 Os)
Appropriate
choice of
language
(5-6 ptsJ
Uses rich and
imaginative
language
(7-8 ptsJ
Reveals
Emotion
Little to no
emotion
(1-3 ptsJ
Some
emotion
(4-6 pts)
Clear feeling
of the
intended
emotion
(7-9 pts)
Gives great
detail and feels
strong emotion
(10-12 ptsJ
31 BEST COPY AVAILABLE
73Z
izi
ziZ
3 C
I1:
31Z
311
2za
40-
cctil
-W
ork
Stan
dard
sO
wev
5
CC
1/41
7*-6
9,1
A.X
CB
t...L
s w
rN
/BS
YG
OO
DG
000
FAIR
Poo
R
Ne.
c.,,x
,,,,s
CL
) R
ea.c
.k..k
0k. i
le.c
37,6
it.C
N0
c.r.
Dss
.0...
;:4G
C..
1 e.
c...r
.L
i.....
tarr
y,pf
,-e.
0 R
e..C
.s-c
)C,b
lt. ;
\ e.c
; it:A
t
rz.
I -
a c.
.\--.
..,1-
c,-t
i
CD
C'A
t'''''
''kk
''..4
Cor
.,?(
-441
-4-
T G
a.d
kc...
..,c)
.....i
r,4-
.,nct
='-7
re.
c,ci
c..1
,4gi
3 -
4 cr
roS1
- 0
.-C
trC
l rc,
,,L
... .-
r 4.
''''' .
-.-.
.^-
'''D"
PGL
Y4,
r
S f.
:,c,c
1hC
.....c
.1,,i
r;-1
r-,..
-t,
bc.i.
'
rec\
-6cc
.1:e
',1)
J\O
CIt
-CX
.5C
.irC
.0
i.Ct
(3.1
C.,-
.....
,--4
,1.e
.d?a
-p4-
e.
CD
C.a
., '..
"C.C
11 I
160
. r G
a.Z
5 In
art
. ti-
u.-r
,tr
a:.,s
- a
:..-,
..a.ta
(3)
c-A
-...,
-.pi
a.d
saa.
r-i-
Pst.t
.k.k
.-1-
0.L
t
'f1S
c---
-?,-
--.4
.7-.
.-,-
0 SV
,...-
.....,
-, a
ll th
e. s
teps
.-,-
,S.
0 -4
; -,-
,,,,3
-S4;
,,t_
Ara
ble,
..T
Gra
ta,w
2.42
.3 s
)...r
ese-
a.c.
T.c
v.c:
s4..q
iIS
Lab
eAs
to..:
11
s, ..
.-.)
.9\c
,.....
.,,cA
.,..i.
,-5.
,.;S
rtec
rizo
LA
Sti "
ta.,1
4.4
I c)
....c
..-1.
s 1
s:,..
csr-
,:".-
-,.
i,-._
.;1
5 -,
-.44
.4,1
.1.%
All
'LL
arr.
,- a
CX
vuow
.14"
'S
Avv
,.....
+1.
,e :'
,.a.
tt C
rtsk
zn.
.a.
C...
-ce,
cx,
t .7,
c.,..
....,d
e..,-
,T14
..t.a
.44
0 ..3
1.o.
...,s
al)
Aka
.st
eps
...,
sYro
1::iv
r, s
c.' v
;...9
.-
0 1.
$4c
..? c
az e
'sc-
ra44
..,-
0 1-
0..,e
sT
s-v.
.J.,
c.),
,..,..
,-.:s
.,,...
..,,-
;....
1.)
Lis
a4 1
:r...
.bta
.,1c)
.-w
-rks
i
cLac
yra-
-. ,
;.i,,,
,,ie.
,)e
,,;.
,..,
,.--
--
:n 1
06,
....e
s.li,
cy...
. utr
ma,
Abi
u
OtA
,ssa
_s I
cis
#1--
c.s.
tafs
v"^
rob.
.....-
Sol
,; -,..-
,....)
,.....
.ir54
$1 c
h"3*
'I'S
-"-
s V
oes
'net
. lab
el)-
.2.
4.0c
rs.
i I.A
,,,,,
tc,s
,s,/
ci.,.
.1.
4 i
.3ta
...3.
-a..-
...;i
,..,,_
4,.,4
5 a
..,,c
..c-r
re a
12.
.....a
....
P.-r
- s
:G
l
cy,L
LS-
inc"
LL
-rvA
rnsL
ae.r
cA°
CO
Mss
a.s
2st
z.fs
--
SAc6
)t...
. 0 0
T17
Skt
.,.;.
Sol.-
ctio
S01.
,,,,
1-lo
t +1.
4_4
rtei
x...
..
(Z 2
. StR
ps c
. .5
ek c
-r.1
'.-
., v.
''
?-ro
bir.
r.. s
-...;
,-.5
ra I
N.
v..-
rx.i
c \e
z.-.
- C
.X91
a.nr
-Jrc
- 0
titv,
c*-r
eX
pa--
..za.
,,a,
11.b
e....
X. I
c...
..lor
beA
eel -
S-0E
ic.%
.1)
PA
ess,
6' to
-61c
/c.k
a./
Ji-a
G''')
Mt.-
.s,3
tabl
e /..
ha -
.z /
c4 4
...a.
....
.
c..-
a.c:
yea.
...r,
ei,-
Nc.
a.-1
-ra.
a.7.
.al
....-
.1(
0...
, c...
.-re
. c c
7. a
...c.
o.-4
2,n
-.
-P"
"-4/
7-'.
3"..A
. 1 c
r"."
1"-.
-c.
rm'e
a 1
..i
6:&
;,...-
ritz
t,;S-
C-3
.4+
;"6.
....
'''' C
6"-y
k.-6
.-d
145
'
JIt
ei-
41.A
.4.
..>cy
cc.-
exoc
.c7.
t_d
Lur
tr64
--
G S
i., c
ws.
-,3
0, L
-Vg.
i ,1
L.:-
./1.,
CZ
,., .-
t-1.
2..,
sk.(
11-.
vary
,ii..
TiL
1....
c.4
is 1
.,(1.
4..
,...
r-k.
.-t:t
tcr-
rcr
?rio
t- S
....,,
a...1
04,,
;*i:
Si...
0N°
foL
i L A
y..
c9 s
v,j,,
....,;
rueA
0.0
1 .5
le.-
11-
....
2+ k
...6v
-..-
,74
rik
ada
rr L
.2",
0 P.
L:t:
I:C
I ro
a'S
ci r
a-sc
axn-
cl,
Vc-
rti U
lla: t
.G.r
t-nr
i i.."
4-1-
4t_
,*..
rstu
i,,,d
,.1-
4.14
..c.-
rti^
Gw
k. ,
a. J",
-% a
syc
Jepl
,
_
0C
e-,-
,-)1
ed'1
;. .4
i-u-
txpd
aLet
..., c
ri,-
.
,D S
Irso
,...,.
.c1
y,-,
..../.
.,-
..r...
.ti.,
SIG
.Z.1
11
e k.
A.,.
.d:.4
,,...
pr."
-S-
,...A
ce19
-es
.,,,b
,..-t
xt,3
,-,,.
-ic.
laze
b....
1 cf
t. -I
rtr.
dat
e. ',
Jr..,
ate
.4...
... (
"el
-,..
c..7
1. 4
,4
y-rc
.:-E
j i14
.,,d,
.....
1erk
;Sr
-. I
c-c
z) .
/k-N
CC
" c
l-r-
7,tz
z....
) i
S.IS
0 04
) .tv
44,0
1,...
.)a.
.30.
44...
.ei
0 U
sed
vv-%
c.7.
1..
S k.
t lk
0.)
L,,,
,,,,.e
i..,
.1.
..,-,
o...
.11.
4)cc
.
t-,4
tr 4
A.1
0 $.
4fy
.C.''
C f
rt."
''.
Sta.
14;
ra a
-re-
a.
40.4
,44
G.:t
r.-i
c.::,
-, "
t,,...
C)
9i o
frc
.s.c
.c."
-t./.
....
)e-1
-4.
,
3021
C...
.r,-
..Act
g.ci
3/.1
di 4
1-,..
ta..A
._.
® U
.b.c
e,..
y.'c
al.,
ySc.
.;LL
,
Snc.
,14.
G. l
,.%,-
-..S
4.,
sy,-
;,-,
......
-....
,fe.
.e.4
9c.
,e7j
S.I
ta.,.
.cz;
.),-
S-c.
, -11
+...
.4.
0;c3
1,,,
, 1-2
4.4.
0, -
el.
c....
.-S-
,:S
1-r
,G4,
311-
d -
20B
ES
T C
OP
Y A
VA
ILA
BLE
21
ASSESSMENT SHEET
Name: 1-A,t, fe,y, cLsie,tc) Topic: Arark (4,
Evaluator: frirs ot,,t,,) Date: -2151967
IA. Criteria:
I1. Language is clear and easy to understand
2. Offers logical sequential evidence toIsupport every major point
3. Manipulates diagrams appropriately
I4. Coordinates diagrams, pictures, and words
II5. Exhibits a level of understanding
B. Application:
1. k.t.e
N A
1 2
1 2
1 2
1 2
1 2
2. .cl, 5
3 YA a Ld Gait1-1-11-t- 11-4
4 jet 66-0 cfrtki 35. q? CA-71 = 36.
7.
IIC. Comments:
3
3
D
Words Pictures Numbers
V 1/
pU azt, )/1&-e.
CJ
.hcL
01-erwr [AAA fig-
1111)0 /1A .
pi D. Overall Rating:
Novice Apprentice Proficient
1 2 3
BEST COPY AVAILABLE 2 2
Distinguished
Andi Stix, 1994
Ms. Pa rtko Wagner
ACHER ASSESSMENT SHEETName: 1 2ev+Raii-i4ort Assignment: Ec-,5cuh Due Date:
-e
'Rating
0 1 2 3 4
gov---ck 0 1 2 3fcc used
i II o 0 1 2 3 4
5
4. Stiv\pnt wri-mc tanitiir rntti-ore _ tA5Inj
0-e. OCO 0 1 2 3 40
0 1 2 3
Teacher comments and rel ctions:(11
N\-NN6-RN-Pli bimore_ 1 dectt-7
Overall Grade: (k6 23 BEST COPY AVAILABLE
Ms. Bartho Wagner
ASSESSMENT SHEETName: Alz)Av-k VW-AA FR Assignment: a:-NIMN\ E5.--A-1 Due Date:
, Criteria Rating1. SUefiA A4,e1)`,`-es -\'Ve -Cl\-)\ e' L.)\\ \I
student teacher
eNet--,,c, -A-6-n c\c\k,k , ,,,...e-..At A , p-Vt \cr. 01 2 3 475-) 01 2 305, , 3 n
Inkcs-ve.mm-yst,--. cw AA-Y. 1 Y^,c"kr...4., .
2. 'F--....,1 ,...., c cNveco\Vi y\s,,,,,wA An )c,\\ ow student teacher
11-r, 4s--Aoce Z-A--- A -'ac-c-c\c.\\ F-s.&11, 1-6 \s .., A 2 3 4 0 01 2 3 4®CV.P.,ci k(t'QN( ',\ (\-f4k 1e 115z: ("Nn 11 4Tc .
3. ,s\, &.1.-r\- ckc...c.\-1\--e--, e.-..c)er \c\r- i m>9.?-it-IPAc.. student teacher
pN(Nry,c1.-, -Prcncy. -'1,,, \cw\Vs tc' A8c)c-rs<AV FvnA 01 2 3 4 01 2 3 4®rkiNnsiki 4, nrkek, V\ e er, c-eor\ ry sw\ris .
4. ic.,\,t--\ e dr (-4c-Aes 0 \P ac-\y -eThvi'fv0v, PArY1/4
- .
student teacher.
ri\A\-re\\I lilt&, k,),c7f-, 4-vviNA .\p,;(-)rle./ 01 2 3(i) 01 2 3 40p,cxpcx-\Pc\e , -k-v,ecr-,-5,ux, eV-yAlen3r qe.01.,\-\\V\c('4\6 q"" c'"\-Y--6-``)
5. .5-V&A- c \ e ,.,c.\\I Aem-A-TAc47.... Vcri. ,)\-- e cP student teacher
-\\--e erv,\:-_, c 4y-,,, lkop.,A -4 hr, `nom Cr PC\ 01 2 3.4 01 2 3 40
Student comments and reflections: "7"
Acve, --cleeVrcs NeCA A SVV.- ba-k-,S .\* \\Ck
t' C\
Ac% '''Clc-e--' "P, t ' 4-n le 1-)C (10"-e .
Teacher comments and reflections: Mau\-- W .. \\ 0.c3Ve_diki)C\\ of-V\izediP ,c.ock tfacIN9V), -%poi snce_ \cu 6i, uN\A '.5.---rott\vv.s, ktoor oryl
P job 45e-Q\ck\ \\I -& our-fc-st Eski Exm
verall Gra e:
BEST COPY AVAILABLE24
Assessment Sheet
Name: Top lc:
Evaluator: Date:
A. Criteria:
. 0 02. 0 03. ® 04. ® 0
B. Comments:
C. Overall Rating:
40 25
Assessment Sheet
Name: Topic:
Evaluator: Date:
A. Criteria:
1. N A V M
2. N A V M
3. N A V M
4. N A V M
5. N A V M
B. Comments:
C. Overall Rating:
Novice Apprentice Veteran
1 2 3
42
Master
4
U.S. Departthent of EducationOffice of Educational Research and Improvement (OERI)
Educational Resources Information Center (ERIC)
REPRODUCTION RELEASE
I. DOCUMENT IDENTIFICATION:
(Specific Document)
0
ERIC
Title: 1-6.A.) To C..rcaR_ -Rkk'i3tric-5 Tkrolh Neoaki °Jo if_ co cri,neLcAl
Author(s):
Corporate Source:
Itetkeyac-IrtA acksseoom,: Publication Date:
1 Aloe 1,14, Viggo
II. REPRODUCTION RELEASE:In order to disseminate as widely as possible timely and significant materials of interest to the educational community, documents announced
in the monthly abstract journal of the ERIC system, Resources in Education (RIE), are usually made available to users in microfiche, reproducedpaper copy, and electronic/optical media, and sold through the ERIC Document Reproduction Service (EDRS) or other ERIC vendors. Credit isgiven to the source of each document, and, if reproduction release is granted, one of the following notices is affixed to the document.
If permission is granted to reproduce and disseminate the identified document, please CHECK ONE of the following two options and sign atthe bottom of the page.
Check hereFor Level 1 Release:Permitting reproduction inmicrofiche (4' x 6' film) orother ERIC archival media(e.g., electronic or optical)and paper copy.
The sample sticker shown below will beaffixed to all Level 1 documents
PERMISSION TO REPRODUCE ANDDISSEMINATE THIS MATERIAL
HAS BEEN GRANTED BY
TO THE EDUCATIONAL RESOURCESINFORMATION CENTER (ERIC)
Level 1
The sample sticker shown below will beaffixed to all Level 2 documents
PERMISSION TO REPRODUCE ANDDISSEMINATE THIS
MATERIAL IN OTHER THAN PAPERCOPY HAS BEEN GRANTED BY
\e
2;.
TO THE EDUCATIONAL RESOURCESINFORMATION CENTER (ERIC)
Level 2
Documents will be processed as indicated provided reproduction quality permits. If permissionto reproduce is granted, but neither box is checked, documents will be processed at Level 1.
Check hereFor Level 2 Release:Permitting reproduction inmicrofiche (4' x 6' film) orother ERIC archival media(e.g., electronic or optical),but not in paper copy.
'I hereby grant to the Educational Resources Information Center (ERIC) nonexclusive permission to reproduce and disseminatethis document as indicated above. Reproduction from the ERIC microfiche or electronic/optical media by persons other thanERIC employees and its system contractors requires permission from the copyright holder. Exception is made for non-profitreproduction by libraries and other service agencies to satisfy information needs of educators in response to discrete inquiries.'
Sign Signatu
here) I 1-Vra*44
pleasebig.
i Printed Name/Po sitionfritle:I
i Ar`30% SIPA if el, covlsoL-TAkiv, Telephone: i FAX:
INTERACTNE CLASSROOM l'etItta; Address: "7 : baiteL:"61-- °11 127SIEBRECHT PLACE i
kSI*0 docLcie i.eleil It- "lo -lbNEW EreitaLatini2804 II
National MiddleSchool Association's 23rd Annual Conferenceand Exhibit "SAIL INTO THE
FUTURE" (Baltimore, Maryland; Oct. 31-Nov 3, 1996).