doing business in mongolia

7/29/2019 Doing Business in Mongolia

1/58

LLLEL88DBBC

1-0,

-010

43-0+334-*+

1.-(


2/58

""!

'!""!"! 7

$CIGD9J8I>DC "DK:GCB:CIHIGJ8IJG:':C>CC(DC6

#!!!$"

JH>C:HHA>B6I: !G::/G69:5DC:H $CI:GC6I>DC6A67>A>INDBE6C>:H'' +6GIC:GH=>EH -:EG:H:CI6I>K:*;;>8:H -:HIG6I>DC+GD8:HH>C":C:G6A

#"! !!#"''67DJG(6G@:I '67DJG-:A6I>DCH 2DG@>CI>DCH.D8>6A.:8JG>IN.NHI:B !DG:>


3/58

=6GID;88DJCIH J9>I -:FJ>G:B:CIH /6M.NHI:B>G:8I6C9$C9>G:8I/6MJG9:C+G>C8>E6A/6M:H ':HA6I>K:!G6B:LDG@$C8DB:/6M /6M/G:6I>:H /6M-:IJGCH6C9+6NB:CIH HH:HHB:CIH EE:6AH

2>I==DA9>CIH +:C6AI>:H 9K6C8:/6MA6G>;>86I>DC

"&""!DGEDG6I:/6M.NHI:B $C8:CI>K:H /6M67A:$C8DB: :9J8I>7>A>IND;ME:CH:H -:A6I:9+6GIN/G6CH68I>DCH !DG:>9>6GN"GDJE/6M6I>DC .E:8>6A/6M6I>DC-:B:H

"&"$#!/:GG>IDG>6A>IN6C9-:H>9:C8:"GDHH$C8DB: :9J8I>DCH /6MG:9>IH *I=:G/6M:H /6M9B>C>HIG6I>DC /6M -6I:H

$#"& $"$CIGD9J8I>DC .8DE:D; 1/ 5:GD-6I>C:H /6M67A:BDJCI )DC:9J8I>7A:$CEJI1/1/$C8:CI>K:H 1/.>BEA>;>86I>DC1/DBEA>6C8:

%"#!!


4/58

& "! & 7 "!#!!!$!"!& 7 "&"!& 7 #"&""!


5/58

+%&&%&%

10,1.-(

&;@-8>1- HF@B

?@59-@10";66C9=>C6

A>>1:/E (DC


6/58

!! F "$!

:@>;0A/@5;:

&/(2"0)9".%,*-"4&

(DC6 >H6A6C9AD8@:98DJCIGN>C6HI6C9:CIG6AH>6$I7DG9:GH-JHH>6IDI=:CDGI=6C9I=:+:DEA:H-:EJ7A>8D;=>C6IDI=:HDJI=:6HI6C9L:HIAI=DJI= &6O6@=HI6C >IH L:HI:GCBDHI ED>CI >H DCAN @>ADB:I:GH B> ;GDB&6O6@=HI6CH:6HI:GCI>E

I HFJ6G: @>ADB:I:GH HF B> (DC6 >H I=: I= A6GC9:E:C9:CI8DJCIGN>CI=:LDGA9 L>I=6EDEJA6I>DCD;6GDJC9 B>AA>DC

E:DEA:$I>H6AHDI=:LDGA9HH:8DC9A6GCHK:GNA>IIA:6G67A:A6C96HBJ8=D;>IH6G:6>H8DK:G:97NHI:EE:HL>I=BDJCI6>CHIDI=:CDGI=6C9L:HI6C9I=:"D7>:H:GIIDI=:HDJI=

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

HJBB:GH 9JG>C8= BDHI D; >IH 6CCJ6A EG:8>E>I6I>DC ;6AAH /=: 8DJCIGN 6K:G6I>HJHJ6AAN6II=:8:CI:GD;6G:DCD;=>8EG:HHJG:+G:8>E>I6I>DC>H=>CI=:CDGI=6K:G6AA>B:I:GHID>CE:G

N:6G6C9ADL:HI>CI=:HDJI= L=>8=G:8:>K:H IDB>AA>B:I:GH ID >C6CCJ6AAN/=::MIG:B:HDJI=>HI=:"D7>HDB:G:DCHD;L=>8=G:8:>K:CDEG:8>E>I6I>DC6I6AA>CBDHI

N:6GH

/=:C6B:"D7>>H6(DC8=JHJ6AANG:;:GHID686I:9G6CI=>CHJ;;>8>:CIK:DCIDHJEEDGI B6GBDIH 7JIL>I=:CDJCH="D7>;GDB9:H:GIEGDE:G6AI=DJHI>C8I>DC>H CDI6AL6NH6EE6G:CIIDDJIH>9:GHJC;6B>A>6GL>I=I=:(DC6CA6C9H86E:"D7>G6CAN9:HIGDN:97NDK:GC8=G:HJAIH>C:ME6CH>DCD;I=:IGJ:9:H:GI6HIDCN

L6HI:L=:G:CDI:K:C 68IG>6C86B:AH 86CHJGK>K:

*34/29

$BEDGI6CIEG:=>HIDG>8H>I:H6G:I=:+6A:DA>I=>886K:9G6L>C9/H:C@=:G>>C)DGI=:GC 6K: D; AJ: >C &=DK9 +GDK>C8: 6C9 I=: /H6I: 6K: >C6N6C@=DCC8:):DA>I=>8;6GB>CCDGCD9+GDK>C8:DCI:BEDG6GN ;>C9>CC8AJ9: DCAN I:BEDG6GN :C86BEB:CIH D;=JCI:GH 6C9 ;>H=:GH /=: EDEJA6I>DC 9JG>CCI=: 6HID;L=6I>HCDL(DC66C96H:JGDE>9>CI=: 2:HI

$C I=: H:8DC9 B>AA:CC>JB 9JG>CEG:H:CI @:G::H 96I: I=: 9::G HIDC:H 6H I= DG I=8:CIJG>:HK6HI>GDC66A8DBEA:M;GDBI=:I=G98:CIJGNA6I:G6AHDJH:97NI=:3>DC


7/58

(DC6 H>C8: EG:=>HIDG>8 I>B:H =6H 7::C >C=67>I:9 7NCDB69H L=D ;GDB I>B: ID I>B:;DGB:9DCHI=6IGDH:IDEGDB>C:C8:/=:;>GHID;I=:H:I=:3>DCC6I:9(DC6 ;DG8:CIJG>:HJG>C:H I=:N L:G: HJ88::9:9 7N 0NI6CH 6C9%JG8=:CHNI=:I=8:CIJGNI=:8DJCIGNL6H9>K>9:9>CIDCJB:GDJHIG>7:HA>C@:9I=GDJ:CI6AA>6C8:H6C9>CKDAK:9>CI=:DA9E6II:GCHD;>CI:GC6AHIG>;:

$CI=:8=6DHD;I=:A6I:I=8:CIJGN68=>:;I6>CC6B:9 /:BJJ?>C ;>C6AANHJ88::9:9>CJC>I>C6 6C9 I=: AI6> (DJCI6>CH $C =:IDD@ I=: I>IA:":CH&=6C6C9L6:HD;B>A>I6GN86BE6>G7GJI6A>IN6C9;:GD8>IN HL::E>CCCLDGA9=>HIDGN0C9:G=>HHJ88:HHDGH>IHIG:I8=:9;GDBEG:H:CI96N+DA6C9>CI=:L:HIID&DG:6>CI=::6HI6C9;GDB.>7:G>6>CI=:CDGI=IDI=:"JA;D;*B6C6C9

1>:IC6B>CI=:HDJI=8DK:G>CADB:I:GH HF B> D;6GI=HIDI6AA6C96G:66C9=6K>CDCD;DK:GB>AA>DCE:DEA:

;I:G":CH&=6CH9:6I=I=::BE>G:L6HHJ79>K>9:9>CID;DJG@>C8=:K:CIJ6AAN7:86B:FJ6H>>C9:E:C9:CI6;I:G (DCC*C:D;I=:@=6C6I:HI=:"G:6I&=66C6I:8DCH>HI>C &=6C I=: C9:E:C9:C8: ;GDB I=: -:EJ7A>8 D; =>C6 6C9 JCI>A ID C >CI:GC6I>DC6AG:8DI>DC

(DC6 HJ7H:FJ:CIAN 86B: JC9:G HIGDC6C 6C9 .DK>:I >C;AJ:C8: >C I=:(DC6C+:DEA:H-:EJ7A>8L6H9:8A6G:96C9(DC6CEDA>I>8H7::I EDA>I>8H D; I=: I>B: ;I:G I=: 7G:6@9DLC D; 8DBBJC>HI G:B:H >C6HI:GC JGDE: >C A6I: (DC6 H6L >IH DLC :BD8G6I>8 -:KDAJI>DC >C :6GAN

L=>8= A:9 ID 6 BJAI>E6GIN HNHI:B 6 C:L 8DCHI>IJI>DC >C 6C9 I=: G6I=:G GDJI>DCID6B6G@:I:8DCDBN


8/58

;B1>:91:@?@>A/@A>1

6&26*&7

(DC6>H 6 E6GA>6B:CI6GN G:EJ7A>8 /=: E6GA>6B:CI >H:A:8I:97N I=: E:DEA: 6C9 >C IJGC:A:8IHI=:9:CI>H:A:8I:99>G:8IAN(DC6H8DCHI>IJI>DCDCG:A>DC6C9DI=:GHG>I>86AE6GI>:HI=: 7>8 +6GIN+(DC6C EDA>I>8H 86C 7: IJG7JA:CI

L>I=;G:FJ:CI8=6CC867>C:IB:B7:GH6C98D6A>I>DCE6GIC:GH

)&2&3*%&.4

(DC6H EG:H>9:CI =6H 6 A6G8 GDA: 7JI 86C 7AD8@ I=: +6GA>6B:CIH 9:8>H>DCHI=GDJ8= G:FJ>G:H 6 ILDI=>G9H B6?DG>IN D; E6GA>6B:CI ID DK:GG>9:(DC6H 8DCHI>IJI>DC EGDK>9:H I=G:: G:FJ>G:B:CIH ;DG I6@>C8: 6H EG:H>9:CI I=:86C9>96I:BJHI7:6C6I>K:7DGC(DC6C7:6IA:6HIN:6GHD;69:9>C(DC6;DG;>K:N:6GHEG>DGIDI6@>C8:/=:EG:H>9:CI>H6AHDG:FJ>G:9ID;DGB6AANG:H>HDG=:GE6GINB:B7:GH=>E

)&4"4&2&"4)52", : 4)&"2,*"-&.4

(DC6JH:H6JC>86B:G6AE6GA>6B:CI6GNHNHI:B>CL=>8=I=:EG:H>9:CI=6H6HNB7DA>8GDA:6C9I=:H:H:M:8JI>K:EDL:G/=:A:HA6I>K:6GBI=:.I6I:"G:6I&=JG6A=6HDC:8=6B7:GL>I=H:6IH6C9>H8=6>G:97NI=:HE:6@:GD;I=:+6GA>6B:CI$I:A:8IH>IHB:B7:GH:K:GN;DJGN:6GH7NDCH

2*-&*.*34&2".%4)&"#*.&4

/=:+G>B:(>C>HI:GD;(DC6>H6EED>CI:97NI=:.I6I:"G:6I&=JG6A/=:B>C>HI:GHD;:68=D;I=: (>C>HIG>:H 8DCHI>IJI: I=: EG>B:B>C>HI:GH 867>C:I /=: 867>C:I >HCDB>C6I:9 7N I=:EG>B:B>C>HI:G>C8DCHJAI6I>DCL>I=I=:EG:H>9:CI6C96EED>CI:97NI=:.I6I:"G:6I&=JG6A

&$&.4/,*4*$3

/=: (++;DGB:G(+-+ ;DGB:9I=:A>C6DC:E6GINHNHI:B6C9;GDBID!GDBID>IL6HE6GID;68D6A>I>DC

L>I=I=:+6C9ILDDI=:G E6GI>:H6C9 7:IL::C 6C9>I L6H I=: 9DB>C6CIE6GIN>CILD ;JGI=:G 8D6A>I>DCH/=:+L6HI=:9DB>C6CI;DG8:>CI=:GJA>CI>DC7:IL::C6C9 6C9 6AHD 6C 6EEGDM>B6I:AN :FJ6A E6GIC:G L>I= I=: (++ ;DGB:G (+-+ >C I=:

8D6A>I>DC

/=: A6HI E6GA>6B:CI6GN :A:8I>DCH L:G: =:A9 >C %JC: /=: + LDC H:6IH DJI D; G:HJAI>CC I=: ;DGB6I>DC D; 6 8D6A>I>DC L>I= ;DJG HB6AA:G E6GI>:H A:9 7N :M +G:H>9:CI)6B76GNC C@=76N6GZH (+-+ C:L 867>C:I L6H I=:C 8=DH:C A:9 7N I=: + )DGDK>>C

AI6C@=JN6< 6H+G>B:(>C>HI:G /=: +>H:ME:8I:9ID8DBEG>H: D;I=:C:L867>C:I

CJB7:GD; 9:BDCHIG6I>DCH IDD@ EA68: >C 6C9EGDBEI:96BDCCC< D; (+-+;GDB(+>C6C9 I=: 8DGGJEI>DC>CK:HI>DC6C9

"!#"''"""!#"''""

"!#"''""

"!#"''""


9/58

6GG:HID;:M+G:H>9:CI)6B76GNCC@=76N6G #DL:K:GI=: 8DJCIGNZHEDA>I>8H=6K:DCG:HJAI

/=:C:MI E6GA>6B:CI :A:8I>DCL>AA I6@:EA68:>CI=:HJBB:GD; 6C9+G:H>9:CI>6A:A:8I>DCL>AAI6@:EA68:>CI=:HJBB:GD;C:MIN:6G

13-8%E?@19

&(*3,"4*6&2"-&7/2+

/=: A:8G:KDAJI>DCD;6C9>HE6GID;I=:DCI>C:CI6A-DB6CD":GB6C>8A:I>DC/=:8DG:

D; (DC6C A6L >H I=: DCHI>IJI>DC I=6I L6H :C68I:9 >C /=: EGDK>H>DCH D; I=:DCHI>IJI>DCI=:A6LH8DGG:HEDC9>CIDI=:GG:DC6AIG:6I>:H6C9DI=:G8DBB>IB:CIHD;(DC66HL:AA6HG:DCHD;DCHI>IJI>DC6ADJGI/H:IH6C9I=:.JEG:B:DJGI8DBEG>H:I=:;JC8I>DC>CC(DC6

$CI:GC6I>DC6A IG:6I>:HG6I>;>:97N (DC6 =6K: :FJ6A L:>IH 9DB:HI>8 A6LH 6C9 6G:9>G:8IAN>BEA:B:CI:9:M8:EI>C86H:HL=:CI=:6EEA>86I>DCD;6C>CI:GC6I>DC6AIG:6ING:FJ>G:HI=:EGDBJADCD;6A6L88DG9>CIJI>DCD;(DC6>CI:GC6I>DC6AIG:6I>:H6C9DI=:GA:8II=:DCHI>IJI>DCH=DJA9CDI7:;DAADL:9

/5243

/=:8DJGIHNHI:BD;(DC6>C8AJ9:HI=:.JEG:B:DJGIG:DC6A8DJGIH6C9DI=:G8DJGIH:HI67A>H=:97NA6L:6A>O:97NINE:HD;86H:H

/=: .JEG:B:DJGID;(DC6 >HI=:=>CI=:?J9>8>6GNHNHI:BD; (DC6/=:.JEG:B:DJGI=:6GH6EE:6AHD;ADL:G8DJGI9:8>H>DCH6HL:AA6H=JB6CG>I7NI=:+GDH:8JIDG":C:G6ADGI=:DCHI>IJI>DC6ADJGID;(DC6/=:.JEG:B:DJGI>CI:GEG:IH 6AA (DC6C A6LH :M8:EI ;DG I=: DCHI>IJI>DC L=>8= >H I=: EGDK>C8: D; I=:DCHI>IJI>DC6ADJGI

5%*$*",%-*.*342"4*/.

2>I=>C I=: %J9>8>6A 9B>C>HIG6I>DC ?J9CI:9 7N I=: +G:H>9:CI D; (DC6 /=: CDB>C6I>DCH ;DG ?J9IH B:B7:GHID 7:

=>:;%J9CIB:CI>HB69:7NI=:+G:H>9:CI;DGI=:H>MN:6GI:GB

"1;


10/58

.>C8:I=::C9D;HD8>6A>HB(DC6=6H:ME:G>:C8:969:8A>C:D;IDI6A;:GI>A>ING6I:8=>A9G:CE:GLDB6CI=6I>HHI::E:GI=6C>C6CNDI=:G8DJCIGN>CI=:LDGA9688DG9>CB6I>DCH>C;:GI>A>INL6H:HI>B6I:9ID7:8=>A9G:CE:GLDB6C7JI >C >IL6H I>B:HA:HH

I=C>8(DCDC6C98DCH>HID;&=6A@=66C9DI=:GHI>CH=:9EG>B6G>AN7N9>6A:8IHD;I=:(DCC< >C8AJ9: JGN6IH JG7:I(DCCI=:CDGI=6C96G>IJI: D; (DC6H EDEJA6I>DC 6C9 I=: G:HI 6G:/JC8E:DEA:H=>C:H:6C9-JHH>6CH

&,*(*/.

88DG9>CI6I>DC ;GDB )6I>DC6A .I6I>HI>8H *;;>8: D; (DC6 D;(DC6HEDEJA6I>DC;DAADLHI=:/>7:I6CJ99=>HB 6G:A>HI:96H=6K>CDC 6G:.=6B6C>HI (* 6C9=G>HI>6C6C9 6G:(JHA>B

16G>DJH ;DGBH D; .=6B6C>HB =6K: 7::C L>9:AN EG68I>8:9 I=GDJHIDGN D; L=6I >HCDL BD9:GC 96N (DC6 6HHJ8=7:A>:;HL:G: 8DBBDC6BDC8 E:DEA: >CH>6C=>HIDGN.J8=7:A>:;HHB7JI .=6B6C>HB=6HA:;I6B6G@DC(DC6CG:A>DJH8JAIJG:6C98DCI>CJ:HID7:EG68I>8:9BDC8:HD;I=:(DC6CE:DEA:L:G:A6GC=D>76AH6C8DBEA>:9

L>I= I=: DG9:GH D; %DH:E= .I6A>C 9:HIGDN>CHIBDC6HI:G>:H6C9@>AA>CHIBDC@H9GDEE:9;GDB>CID>C

/=:;6AAD;8DBBJC>HB>C G:HIDG:9I=:A:IND;EJ7A>8G:A>DJHEG68I>8:6C9/>7:I6CJ99=>HB L=>8= =69 7::C I=: EG:9DB>C6CI G:A>DC >C I=: G:DC 7:;DG: I=: G>H: D;8DBBJC>HB6CGDH:ID7:8DB:I=:BDHIL>9:ANEG68I>8:9G:A>DC>C(DC6/=::C9D;G:A>DJHG:EG:HH>DC>CI=:H6AHD6AADL:9;DGDI=:GG:A>DCHHJ8=6H$HA6B6=6>!6>I=6C9 =G>HI>6C>IN ID HEG:69 >C I=: 8DJCIGN 88DG9>CHI>6C B>HH>DC6GN HI>6CHC ID6GDJC9 6HD;

".(5"(&3

/=: D;;>8>6A A6CH HED@:C 7N D; I=:EDEJA6I>DCK6G>:IND;9>;;:G:CI9>6A:8IH6G:HED@:C68GDHHI=:8DJCIGN/=:H:9>6A:8IH6G:>C8AJ9:9>CI=:(DC8A6CC8AJ9:9>CI=:AI6>8A6C86AE=67:I6AI=DJCI=:E6HI>IL6HLG>II:CJH>CEICD;;>8>6AG:>CIGD9J8I>DCD;I=:DA9H8G>EIL6HEA6CC:9;DG

7JI =6H CDI N:I I6@:C EA68: 6H DA9:G DCHZ :C8DJCI:G:9 EG68I>86A 9>;;>8JAI>:H /=:IG69>I>DC6A6AE=67:I>H7:>CCIGD9J8:9I=GDJ


11/58

7N CH= I=DJC =>C:H: 6H I=: A6CC6A>HIE:G>D9:9J86I>DCL6HDC:D;I=:6G:6HD;H>;>86CI68=>:K:B:CI>C(DC6 $AA>I:G68N L6H K>GIJ6AAN:A>B>C6I:9 >C E6GI I=GDJCA9G:CD;CDB69>8;6B>A>:H!JC9>CCCI=:H8DCIG>7JI>CC8G:6H:9>AA>I:G68N

+G>B6GN 6C9 H:8DC96GN :9J86I>DC ;DGB:GAN A6HI:9 N:6GH 7JI L6H :ME6C9:9 ID N:6GH.>C8:I=:H8=DDAN:6GHC:L;>GHICI>DCIDI=:N:6GHNHI:BL>AACDI=6EE:CJCI>AI=:H8=DDAN:6GL=:CI=:8JGG:CI;>GHIK:GH>I>:H6G:6AAHE>CD;;H;GDBI=:)6I>DC6A0C>K:GH>IND;(DC66C9I=:(DC6C0C>K:GH>IND;.8>:C8:6C9/:8=CDAD7:G6A>O6I>DCD;I=:HA:9ID67DDB>CEG>K6I:>CHI>IJI>DCHD;=>DC6AI=DJH6L>9:G6CCI=:>GFJ6A>IN

*6*.( 4".%"2%3

2>I=6#JB6C:K:ADEB:CI$C9:M#$D; DJID;(DC6=6H6G6C@D;I=6BDC:H >BEGDK:9;GDBI= >CI=:EG:K>DJHN:6G8DBE6G:9ID-JHH>6ZH#$D; 6C9 =>C6ZH D; :IL::C 6C9 (DC6H #$ GDH: 7N 6ABDHI 6CCJ6AANG:;A:8I>CCBDHIG:DCHD;I=:LDGA968=

N:6G 0)+ZH #JB6C :K:ADEB:CI -:EDGI EJ7A>H=:H I=: =JB6C 9:K:ADEB:CI >C9:M #$L=>8=ADD@H7:NDC9"+ID67GD69:G9:;>C>I>DCD;L:AA7:>CCK:H 6C9 DEEDGIJC>I>:H I=: #$ EGDK>9:H 6 BJ8= BDG:8DBEA:I:E>8IJG:D;68DJCIGNH9:K:ADEB:CII=6CDI=:G>C9>86IDGHHJ8=6H"+E:G86E>I6

/=:A>K>CC(DC66G:=DL:K:GCDII=:H6B:68GDHHI=:EDEJA6I>DC6C9I=:8DJCIGN88DG9>CDCI:C9HID 7: BJ8= =>DC L=>A: 6GDJC9 D; I=:

(DC6ZHEDEJA6I>DC A>K:H DCDGA:HH696N

/;:;9E

&.&2",6&26*&7

(DC6ZH 8JGG:C8N I=: IJ@ ;:AA H=6GEAN 6CHI I=: 0. 9DAA6G ;DAADL>CC8DBBD9>INEG>8:H>CA6I: 6C9 =6H:ME:G>:C8:9 8DCI>CJ:9 JEH6C99DLCH H>C8:I=:CDCNI=:7:CC>C


12/58

/=:HIG:CCC8::6GAN/=:HI67>A>H6I>DCD;I=::M8=6CCJ: I=: EGD8:HH D; G:7J>A9>CC:6GAN 6HI=:8:CIG6A76C@IG>:9IDHJEEDGII=:8JGG:C8N 7N H:AA>CIH G:H:GK:H D; ;DG:>C/=:A6HIFJ6GI:GD;:C9:9L>I=67GD6976H:9G:8DK:GNHJEEDGI:97NIG6CHEDGI6I>DC6C98DCHIGJ8I>DC *C6BDCI=GDAA>CH I=: 7J9C8G:6H:9IDD;"+>C(6G8=JE;GDB6 9:;>8>I >C (6G8= /=: 7J98IH 6 HI::E >C8G:6H: >CCAA>DC()/ :FJ6AIDD;"+688DG9>CBEDGIH>C8G:6H:9IDG:8DG9A:K:AHD;L>9:C>C8>IID0.B>AA>DCL=:G:6H:MEDGIHL:CIJEID/=>HL6HHJEEDGI:97NI=:JEL6G99G>K:>CB:I6AEG>8:H6C9A6GBEDGIH7N=>C6L=D67HDG7HD;(DC6ZH:MEDGIH

2".30/24"4*/.

(DC6=6H6CJB7:GD;9DB:HI>86>GEDGIH/=:DCAN>CI:GC6I>DC6A6>GEDGI>HI=:=>CDC6A>GEDGI>C0A66C766I6G>G:8I;A>DCH:M>HI7:IL::C(DC66C9 .DJI= &DG:6 =>C6 %6E6C -JHH>6 ":GB6CN 6C9 /JG@:N ($/ >H(DC6H A6G:G>C(DC66C9EGDK>9:H7DI=9DB:HI>86C9>CI:GC6I>DC6A;A>AL6N>HI=:B6>CG6>AA>C@7:IL::C(DC66C9>IHC:>7:G>6C -6>AL6N >C -JHH>6 6I I=: IDLC D; 0A6C 09: 8GDHH:H >CID

(DC6GJCHI=GDJCID=>C66IG:C=DIL=:G:>I?D>CHI=:=>C:H:G6>AL6NHNHI:BH:E6G6I:G6>AGD69A>C@8DCC:8IHI=::6HI:GC8>IND;=D>76AH6CL>I=I=:/G6CH.>7:G>6C-6>AL6N=DL:K:G I=6IA>C@ >H 8ADH:9 ID E6HH:CC(DC66G:DCANBEA:8GDHH8DJCIGNIG68@H/=:G:6G:E6K:9GD69H;GDB0A66C766I6GIDI=:-JHH>6C6C9=>C:H:7DG9:G6C9;GDB6G@=6CIDJADCEGD?:8IH6G:8JGG:CIANJC9:GL6N 6C9HDB:=6K:6AG:69N7::C8DBEA:I:9X;DG:M6BEA:8DCHIGJ8I>DCD;I=::6HIWL:HIHD86AA:9(>AA:CC>JB-D69

&,&$/--5.*$"4*/.3

(DC6ZHI:A:E=DC:C:ILDG@>H>BEGDK>CI=>CI:GC6I>DC6A9>G:8I9>6A>CA67A:>CB6CN6G:6H ;>7:GDEI>8 C:ILDG@ =6H 7::C >CHI6AA:9 I=6I >H >BEGDK>C86I>DC H:GK>8:H 7:IL::C B6?DG JG76C 8:CI:GH L>I= BJAI>EA: 8DBE6C>:H EGDK>9>CCI:G8>IN ;>7:GDEI>8 867A: H:GK>8:H /=: ;>M:9A>C: I:A:E=DC: HNHI:B =6H 6 K:GN ADL I:A:9:CH>INL>I= 6 9:8G:6H>CCA>C:H/=:G:L:G:6GDJC9A>C:H>CJH:7NI=::C9D;69GDE8DBE6G:9IDI=:EG:8:9>CA:E=DC:HJ7H8G>7:GH=>EH:GK>8:97N ;DJGEGDK>9:GH>H >C8G:6H>C9ANG:68=>CAA>DC>C

88DG9>CDC6A .I6I>HI>8H *;;>8::K:GN HDJB 69B>C>HIG6I>K: JC>I >C (DC6 >HCDL8DK:G:97N8:AAJA6GH:GK>8:

ME6CH>DCD;$CI:GC:IJH:=6H7::CA>B>I:97NI=:G:A6I>K:ANADLDLC:GH=>ED;8DBEJI:GH>C(DC6(DHIJH:GH688:HHI=:$CI:GC:I6IEJ7A>8DGLDG@;68>A>I>:H0H6H8DC8:CIG6I:9>C0A66C766I6G$C E:DEA: L:G: JH>C


13/58

;>153:&>-01

$C(DC6ZH:MEDGIH6C9>BEDGIH >C8G:6H:9 7N6C9 G:HE:8I>K:AN8DBE6G:9IDI=:8DGG:HEDC9>CCI=:G:7N >C8G:6H>C< I=:8DJCIGNZHIG69:9:;>8>I7N /=:B6>C:MEDGI 8DBBD9>I>:H L:G:8DEE:G 8DC8:CIG6I:H 8D6A >GDCDG:8GJ9: D>A G6L 86H=B:G: O>C8 DG: 8DC8:CIG6I:H BEDGIH 6G: 9DB>C6I:9 7N B>C:G6A EGD9J8IH BDHI D; L=>8= 6G: D>A EGD9J8IHB68=>C:GN 6C9 :FJ>EB:CI 6H L:AA 6H IG6CHEDGI K:=>8A:H $BEDGIH ;GDB -JHH>6 6G: A6GC66C9.DJI=&DG:6

5:5:35:;:3;85-

(DC6 =6H G>8= B>C:G6A G:HDJG8:H 6C9 :MEAD>I6I>DC D; I=:H: =6H 7::C >C8G:6H>CC I=:IG6CH>I>DC E:G>D9IDI=:B6G@:I:8DCDBN

42"4&(*$ &0/3*43

N9:;>C>I>DCD;I=:'6LDC(>C:G6AHB>C:G6AG:HDJG8:HC6IJG6AAND88JGG>CC(DC66G:I=:EGDE:GIND;I=:.I6I:/=:G:;DG:I=:.I6I:6HI=:DLC:G=6HI=:G>C>CC E:G8:CI6C 6 B>C:G6A 9:EDH>I D; HIG6I:8>BEDGI6C8:6 9:EDH>I L=>8=B6N =6K:6 EDI:CI>6A >BE68I DC C6I>DC6A H:8JG>INC6I>DC6A DGG:DC6A:8DCDB>8DGHD8>6A9:K:ADEB:CIDGI=6I>HEGD9J8>C6AIDEGD9J8:BDG: I=6C D; I=: IDI6A 6CCJ6A 8 EGD9J8I $; I=: 9:EDH>I FJ6A>;>:H 6H 6B>C:G6A 9:EDH>I D;HIG6I:8>BEDGI6C8:I=:CI=: .I6I:B6N 68FJ>G: 6 8:GI6>C E:G8:CI68>E6I: JE ID ?D>CIAN L>I= 6 EG>K6I: A:C I=::MEAD>I6I>DCD;6B>C:G6A9:EDH>ID;HIG6I:8>BEDGI6C8:L=:G:I=:.I6I:86CEGDK:I=6I>I=6H8DC9J8I:9 .I6I: ;JC9:9 :MEADG6I>DC 6C9 I=6I I=: .I6I: ;JC9:9 :MEADG6I>DC L6H JH:9 ID9:I:GB>C:I=:EGDK:CG:H:GK:H#DL:K:GI=:A:HA6I>DC9D:HCDIEG:H8G>7:L=6I;DGBI=>H:FJ>IN >CI:G:HI B>I >H JC8A:6G L=6I I=: 9G6;I:GH B:6C 7N [E6GI>8>E6I:\ /=:E:G8:CI6C:9 7N 6C 6I6I>DC D; I=:9:EDH>I8DCH>9:G>CCK:HIB:CIB69:7NI=:.I6I:/=:.I6I:B6NDLCJEIDD; I=: H=6G:HD; 6C >CK:HIB:CI ID 7: B69: 7N 6 A>8:CH:=DA9:G >C 6 B>C:G6A 9:EDH>I D;HIG6I:8>BEDGI6C8:L=:G:EGDK:CG:H:GK:HL:G:9:I:GB>C:9I=GDJCI/=:E:G8:CI6C:9 7N 6C 6I6I>DC D; I=: 9:EDH>I8DCH>9:G>CCK:HIB:CIB69:7NI=: .I6I:

D-@5;: DDCD;6HIG6I:89:EDH>IL=:G:G:H:GK:H6G: 9:I:GB>C:9

7NI=:.I6I:;JC9:9:MEADG6I>DC

.I6I:B6N=6K:JEIDE6GI>8>E6I>DC>CI:G:HI

)DCHI6I: ;JC9:9 :MEADG6I>DC D; 6HIG6I:89:EDH>IL=:G:I=: G:H:GK:H6G:9:I:GB>C:97NDI=:GB:6CH

.I6I:B6NDLCJEIDD;H=6G:HD;6C>CK:HIB:CI

"!#"''""

"!#"''""


14/58

/=:(DC6C9:CI>;>:96CJB7:GD;I=:A6GIHI=6I=6K:HIG6I:8>BEDGI6C8:;DGI=:8DJCIGN6C9L=:G:9:K:ADEB:CID;I=:B>C>CC9JHIGNH=DJA97:;D8JH:9JGG:CIAN;>;I::C9:EDH>IHI=6I=6K:7::C8A6HH>;>:96H [.IG6I:8:EDH>IH\H=DLC>CI=:I67A: 7:ADL /=:H: 6G: 8JGG:CIAN =:A9 :>I=:G 7N I=: .I6I: +GDE:GIN DBB>II:: I=GDJH=:9HI6I:DLC:9:CI:GEG>H:H.*HDG>CHDB:86H:H7NI=:EG>K6I:H:8IDG/=:G:6G:6C 699>I>DC6A I=>GINC>C: 9:EDH>IH JC9:G 8DCH>9:G6I>DC ;DG 8A6HH>;>86I>DC 6H [.IG6I:8:EDH>IH\

%&!%&$&"!%&%

;

1B1?$1?;A>/1?

/6K6C/DA

!DHH>A8D6A0BCJ/HD>

B>AA>DCIDCC:H8D6A

)6G>>C.J@=6>I

!DHH>A 8D6A0BCJ"JGK6CI:H

B>AA>DCIDCC:H8D6A

6DCIDCC:H8D6A

.=>K::*KDD

GDLC8D6A"D7>HJB7:G.=>K::"D7>

B>AA>DCIDCC:H8D6A

(6G96> 0G6C>JB DGCD96H=76A76G IDCC:H6I0*

DGCD9 0G6C>JB DGCD96H=76A76G IDCC:H6I0*


15/58

"JGK6CJA6JB DGCD96H=76A76G IDCC:H6I0*

/DBDGI:> $GDC .:A:CAA>DCIDCC:H6I!:

*NJ/DA DEE:G"DA90BCJ&=6C7DAA>DC IDCC:H D; DG: B>AA>DCIDCC:HD;8DEE:GIDCC:HD;9:H6IJ6C9 (D B>AA>DC IDCC:HHJAE=>9:H6IJ6C9(D

G9:C:IDEE:GBDAN79:CJB

*G@=DC 6N6CDC9DG

7>AA>DC IDCC:H 6I J 6C9(D

JG:C@=66C +=DHE=DG &=J7HJDCIDCC:H6I+*

DGDD "DA9 .:A:CAA>DCIDCC:H6I5C

HAK:G6N6C0A>)DAA>DCIDCC:H6I


16/58

>11&>-01,;:1?

/=:(DC6CIH;G::IG69:ODC:!/5EGDCJGG:CIANI=:G:6G:ILD!/56G:6HAD86I:96ADC7:G>6C=>CI=:CDGI=6II=:-JHH>6(DC67DG9:GIDLCD;AI6C7JA6CI=:HDJI=6II=:=>C:H:(DC67DG9:G6II=:IDLCD;56BNC0J9/=:EDGID;:CIGND;/H6C6N6C*A>EGDK>C8:>H7:>CI:D;6I=>G9!/5

:@1>:-@5;:-83>1191:@?

(DC6>H6E6GINIDB6CN>CI:GC6I>DC6AIG:6I>:H>CK6G>DJH6G:6H W ;GDBI=:EGDI:8I>DCD;I=: :CK>GDCB:CIID ;G:: IG69: I=: EGDI:8I>DC D; ;DG:>CK:HIB:CIH 6C9 I=: 6KD>96C8:D;9DJ7A:I6M6I>DC)DI67AN>IG6I>;>:96CJB7:GD;76H>8>CI:GC6I>DC6A8DCK:CI>DCH W I=:/G:6IN

DCI=:>K>A6C9+DA>I>86A->86A.D8>6A6C9JAIJG6A ->C8: (DC6C A:HA6I>DC G:8DO:HI=: EG>B68N D; $CI:GC6I>DC6A /G:6I>:H >C 86H:D; 6 8DC;A>8I

L>I=9DB:HI>8A:HA6I>DC

2>I=G:HE:8IID;DG:>CK:HIB:CI(DC6>H6 H>CDCDCI=:.:IIA:B:CID;$CK:HIB:CI>HEJI:H7:IL::CI=:.I6I:6C9)6I>DC6AD;CDI=:G.I6I:

?D>C:9>CL=>8= EGDK>9:H ;DG I=:H:IIA:B:CID; >CI:GC6I>DC6A >CK:HIB:CI9>HEJI:H$I >H6AHD6H>DCDC$CK:HIB:CI$CHJG6C8:?D>C:96C9=6H

7::C6 B:B7:GD;I=: (JAI>A6I:G6A$CK:HIB:CI"J6G6CI:: A6I:G6A 6I= CJB:GDJH 8DJCIG>:H C8DJG6CDC D; $CK:HIB:CI I= 8DJCIG>:H 6C9

M:BEI>DCDCDJ7A:/6M6I>DCI=8DJCIG>:H

13-8:B5>;:91:@

/=: (DC6CA:H 76H:9DCI=:-DB6C":GB6C8DCI>C:CI6AA:C8>E6A A:H I=: DCHI>IJI>DC $C B6CN 86H:H A6LH 6G: LDG9:9 L>9:AN DG

K6CIJ9:;DG6AI:GC6I>K:>CI:GEG:I6I>DCH

.I6I: 7D9>:H 86C >HHJ: G:DCH HDB: D; L=>8= 6G: 8DCH>9:G:9 6H G::H6EEAN>CCDCHHI>EJA6I:97NA6LH6C96G:BDG:8DB;DGI67A:>C6EEAN>CA:9HE:8>;>8G:DCH

/=: G7>IG6I>DC '6L D;G:IG6I>DC 9>HEJI:H $CI=: 9G6;I>CC(DC6>CBDHI86H:HE6GI>:H6G:;G::IDH:A:8I>CI:GC6I>DC6A6G7>IG6I>DC6HI=:B:I=D9;DGI=: G:HDAJI>DC D; 9>HEJI:H D; 8:GI6>C INE:H D; >CI:GC6I>DC6A IG69: 8DCIG68IJ6A 6C9 CDC8DCIG68IJ6A 8>K>A 9>HEJI:H (DC6 >H 6 H>DC DC I=:-:8DI>DC 6C9 C;DG8:B:CI D; !DG:>IG6A L6G9H ):L 4DG@ DCK:CI>DC L=>8=B6C96I:HI=6I6G7>IG6I>DC6L6G9HB69:L>I=>CI=:/:GG>IDGND;(DC6 6G::C;DG8:67A:>C(DC66C9DI=:G8DJCIG>:HI=6I6G:E6GI>:HIDI=:):L4DG@DCK:CI>DC

/=: G7>IG6I>DC JG:6J DE:G6I:9 7N I=: (DC6C )6I>DC6A =6B7:G D; DBB:G8: 6C9$C9JHIGN>HHDB:I>B:HG:C:HHE:DEA:6C9I= ;DG:>CK:HIDGH 6H EDA>I>86AAN CDI >C9:E:C9:CI 6C9 JC;6B>A>6G L>I= 8DBB:G8>6AEG68I>8:HEGDBEI>CCI:GC6I>DC6A6G7>IG6I>DC#DL:K:GHJEEDGI;DG7>C9>CCI:GC6I>DC6A 6G7>IG6I>DC =6H CDI E:C:IG6I:9 AD86A (DC6C 6:H G:HEDCH>7A: ;DG:M:8JI>CI:9 G:CII6C8:H 6C9 B6>CI6>CH :M8:EI>DC6AAN A>7:G6A EDA>8>:H ;DG I=:H:IG6CH68I>DCH /=DJ86AAN I=:G: >HCD9>;;>8JAIN>CD7I6>C>CC:H:-:CB>C7>JGDHG>I>H=+DJC9H-J7A:HDG0.DAA6GHI=:G:6G:I>B:H L=:C A>B>IH 6G>H: 76H:9 DC I=: 6K6>A67>A>IN D; ;DG:>C I=: (DC6CB6G@:IEA68:

$CG:8IG6CH68I>DCH>C I=: +6GA>6B:CID;(DC6:C68I:9A:HA6I>DCB6C96I>CDCH7: :MEG:HH:96C9 H:IIA:9DCAN>C I=: AD86A 8JGG:C8NH6G:HJAI 6AA 9DB:HI>8 IG6CH68I>DCH BJHI 7: 8DC9J8I:9 >C (DC6ZH C6I>DC6A 8JGG:C8N I=:/J@:M8:EII=DH::CI>I>:H6AADL:9HE:8>;>8L6>K:GH6H9:I:GB>C:97NI=::CIG6A6C@D;(DC66C9I=:!>C6C8>6A-:HH>DC

/=: (DC6C AN >C 6C9 DJID; I=: C6I>DC L>I= DC::M8:EI>DC!DG:>CI:G:HI7:6G>CCHJ7?:8IID6L>I==DA9>CHG:9J8:9EJGHJ6CIID6C6EEA>867A:I6MIG:6IN/=:76C@G:I6>CHD;6AAHJ8=>CI:G:HIE6NB:CIHH:CI67GD696C9G:B>IHI=>HL>I==DA9>CIND;(DC6*I=:GL>H:7JH>C:HH:HG:EDGICD9:A6NH>CG:B>II>CCK:HIB:CIG:IJGCHDGG:8:>K>CC7DJC9;JC9H(DHIIG6CH;:GHD88JGL>I=>C7JH>C:HH96NHDG6IBDHI6H>CC:HH

L::@

6H:D;IG6CH;:G6H>9:;DG:>CK:HIDGH 8G>I>8>O: (DC6ZHA68@D;HDE=>HI>86I:9B:8=6C>HBH;DG8DCK:GI>C:H6C9E6G@>C7>I>CGDBE:I>I>DCL6HE6HH:9>C6C9DC%JC:I=:+6GA>6B:CI6EEGDK:9I=:6B:C9:9'6L[*C DBE:I>I>DC\

/=: EJGEDH: D; I=>H '6L >H ID EGDK>9: 8DC9>I>DCH ;DG ;6>G B6G@:I 8DBE:I>I>DC 6BDC7>I6CN68I>K>I>:HI=6I6AADLB6G@:I9DB>C6I>DC6C9A:HH:C8DBE:I>I>DC ID 9:I:GB>C: I=: A:H ;DG I=: 8DBE:I>I>DC G:IN 6C9 IDG:DCH6BDCA>IN;DG(DC6ID:CIGJHI>HHJ:H6C98DBE:I>I>DC86H:H>H A>B>I:99J:I=:A68@D;G:A:K6CIH@>AAH6C9@CDLA:9IHEGD;:HH>DC6AH

.4&,,&$45",2/0&249

(DC6 =6H ?D>C:9 I=: 2DGA9 $CI:AA:8IJ6A +GDE:GIN *GO6I>DC2$+* 6C9 H>;>:9 BDHI IG:6I>:H 6C9 8DCK:CI>DCH >C8AJ9>C


18/58

DENG>:HL:G:H>;>:9DC%JAN

0C9:G /-$+. 6C9 (DC6C A6L I=: (DC6C JHIDBH JI=DG>IN 6C9 I=: 8DCDB>8G>B:H 0C>I D; I=: )6I>DC6A +DA>8: 0 6AHD =6K: 6C D7A>DC ID EGDI:8I $CI:AA:8IJ6A+GDE:GIN ->IN B6N 9:CN I=: :CIGN D; CHEJI:9$+-H6II=:7D6G976H:9DC6E:I>I>DC7NI=:DLC:GD;I=:G:A:K6CI$+-H/=:0=6HI=::M8AJH>K:EDL:GID8DC9J8I8G>B>C6A>CK:HI>DCH6C97G>CB>C6A8=6GG6I:H/=:$+*(=6HI=:69B>C>HIG6I>K:6JI=DG>INID>CK:HI>O:;6@:H

L>I=DJI 6 8DJGIDG9:G*;I=:H:I=G::I=:$+*(B6@:HI=:BDHI8DCH>HI:CII=:;;DGIID;JA;>AA>IHB6C96I:H

/.35-&22/4&$4*/.

/=:EGDI:8I>DCD;8DCHJB:GH>HI=I=:DBE6CN '6L I=: DBE6CN '6L EGDK>9:H;DG 67>A>IN D; CC>HIG6I>K: H6C8I>DCH ;DG CDC8DBEA>6C8: :H /=>H EGDK>9:H ;DG G:DGO6I>DCI=GDJDCH:E6G6I>DC9>K>H>DCIG6CH;DGB6I>DC

">;@E->71@

*;;>8:HE68:>C0A66C766I6GG:B6>CH8DCH>9:G67AN8=:6E:GI=6C>CI=: C:>C:H6AI=DJC8G:6H>CA9>C8:HE68:

-:CI>CCI=:HJ7JG7HID6HBJ8=6HDC:>HL>AA>CK:IDH>MGDDB;A6I;JAAN;JGC>H=:9L>I=AD86ADG;DG:>IJG:>CI=:8>INH8:CIG:$I>H >BEDGI6CIID8DC;>GBI=6II=: E:GHDC G:CI>CIH A:IA: 6C9 I=:G:;DG: I=: G>I>DCEGDE:G>9:CI>;>86I>DC6C96H>BEA:A:6H:6C(DC6C6C9CH=H=DJA97:D7I6>C:9':6H:H6I6K:GNB>C>BJBH=DJA9HI6I:I=:I:GBHD;G:CI>CH ;DG 6 LDG@>CDCH=>E 6C9 JC9:GHI6C9>CI= 6A6C9ADG9 $C HDB: 6GG6CI>:H 8=6GCI:GC6I>DC6AE=DC:8=6G8G:E6>GH

!DG:>IA:9ID DLC7J>A9>CC(DC67JICDIA6C9'6C9ADG9H6G:JCL>AA>C9:GG:CI6AE:G>D9HD;A:HHI=6CI=G::BDCI=H:HE:8>6AAN;DGG:H>9:CI>6A688DBBD96I>DC/=:G:6G:6CJB7:GD;G:6A:HI6I:6:HI=6I86CD;;:G6HH>HI6C8:>CI=>H6C9DI=:G6G:6H;DG6G:6HDC67A:;::

8I>K>I>:H6HHD8>6I:9L>I=A6C9JH6E6G:G:


19/58

!$(%&&

;>153::B1?@91:@

/=: '6L DC!DG:>CK:HIDGH>C(DC66C9IDG:CCK:HIB:CI $I 6AHD H:IH DJI I=: EGDK>H>DCH ;DG I6M HI67>A>IN 6CK:HI>CI>:H

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

HIG6I:8>BEDGI6C8: 6C9>C (DC6ZHC6H8:CIJG6C>JBH:8IDG =6K:HEJGG:98G>I>8>HBI=6II=:H8JGI6>A>CCK:HIDGH>C;6KDGD;I=:(DC6CHI6I:/=:G: >H 8DC8:GC I=6I 8=6CJB A6L =6K: 8G:6I:9 6 EG:8:9:CI ;DG ;JGI=:GG:HIG>8I>DCHDC!$

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

HIG6I:8 >BEDGI6C8: >; I=:N 8=DDH: ID [DE:G6I:\ >C (DC6 DG >CK:HI >CID 7JH>C:HH:H6;;>A>6I:9:CI>I>:HDGI=>G9E6GI>:H86GGN>CC:HHDE:G6I>DCH>C(DC6

/=: =6HIN9G6;I>CC8AJ9: I=:I>B>CDCHL>I=;DG:>CK:HIB:CI I=: C:K: >BE68I DC EJ7A>86AAN A>HI:9 8DBE6C>:H DG 8DBE6C>:HEG:E6G>CHI:>I=:G >CH>9: DG DJIH>9: (DC6 A>B>I6I>DCHDC D7I6>C>CC6C8>CK: AD8@JE DC I=: (DC6C E6GIN >IH ;6>AJG: ID 8A:6GAN 699G:HH 8DAA:8I>K: ;DG:>CK:HIB:CI 6C9I=:EDI:CI>6A;DGI=:.!$' ID7:6C;DG:>CK:HIDGH

"!#"''""


20/58

-:75:3%E?@19

.>C8:(DC6=6H=696 ILDI>:G76C@>CHI=:8:CIG6A76C@D;(DC66C9G:EG:H:CIHI=:JEE:G;>GHI I>:GD;I=:76C@>C:GD;I=:76C@>CBEA:B:CIH BDC:I6GN EDA>8N 7N G:CIHB6>CD7?:8I>K:D;8JGG:C8NHI67>A>IN688DG9>C


21/58

A:C9>CCGHI=6A;D; I=DJCH HI>AAG:A6I>K:AN=>C ;68IDG =>C9:G>CH I=: A68@ D; 86E>I6A E6GI>8JA6GAN />:G $ DG DI=:G ;>C6C8>6A HDJG8:H $C I=: A>CCC;G6HIGJ8IJG: 6C9 =DJH>CFJ>9>IN>I8G:6I:HI=:(DC6C76C@H6G:8JGG:CIANJC9:G86E>I6A>O:9DBE6G:9IDDI=:G:B:GCK:AN ADL />:G 86E>I6A 7J;;:GH /=: G6I>D D; CDCE:G;DGB>CCC)6I>DC6AJGG:C8N

:B1?@91:@:?@5@A@5;:?

/=:)6I>DC6A$CK:HIB:CI6C@D;(DC6)$6C@L6H:HI67A>H=:9>C6C9L6HI=:;>GHI;DGB6A>CK:HIB:CI>CHI>IJI>DC>C(DC6L>I=?D>CI>CK:HIB:CIH;GDB(DC6%6E6C

6C9I=:0.$IHH:GK>8:H>C8AJ9:7DI=8DBB:G8>6A6C9>CK:HIB:CI76C@>C6AAN A6JC8=:9 I=: :K:ADEB:CI 6C@ D;(DC66HI6I:DLC:9EDA>8N76C@L>I=6B6C96I:IDEGDK>9:B:9>JB6C9ADCBEDGI6CI H:8IDGH HJ8= 6H >C;G6HIGJ8IJG: >C9JHIGN :C:GH 6AHD :ME6C9>CDC L>I= I=: >CI:GC6I>DC6A 9:K:ADEB:CI 76C@H 6C9DGO6I>DCH6C96IIG68I>C86C9;DG:>I6A;DGA6GDG>INEGD?:8IHI=6I=:AEID 688:A:G6I: I=::8DCDB>8 AA>DCHDK:G:>DC6A>CK:HIDGHJC9:GI=:JGD(:9>JB/:GB)DI:+GDHHJ:>H;JAANIG6I>CC>I>6A96C8:9J:ID=>HBHI=GDJ8=>C8:CI>K:HID>CK:HIDGH6G:D;;:G:9>CI=:;DGBD;>CK:HIB:CI6I=:GI=:!DG:>8= 6G: B6>CAN ;DG I6M HI67>A>IN 6C9 I=: DC8:HH>DCH '6L L=>8= EGDK>9:H ;DG I6M8DC8:HH>DCH>CEG>DG>INH:8IDGHD;I=:(DC6C:8DCDBN

-71@?

/=:(DC6C.ID8@M8=6CH=:9>C6H6K:=>8A:ID>BEA:B:CII=:K6I>O6I>DCD;A6GH:H$C6C6II:BEIID:CHJG:6C :FJ>I67A: 9>HIG>7JI>DC D; 6HH:IH I=:(DC6C C>I>6I: 6 KDJ8=:G

76H:9H8=:B:DC:7AJ: KDJ8=:GLDGI= ()/L6H>HHJ:9ID:K:GN8>I>O:C7DGC7:;DG:(6N;DGI=:EJG8=6H:D;H=6G:H>CA6GH:H6C9G:9KDJ8=:GHLDGI=()/

"!#"''""

"!#"''""


22/58

L=>8= 8DJA9 7: JH:9 ID EJG8=6H: 6HH:IH >C HB6AA:G :CI:GEG>H:H CDI A>HI:9 DC I=: :M8=6CDCHD;;>8>6AAN7:CH ;>GHI E=6H: IG69>C6B:CI E6HH:9 I=: Y'6L DC.:8JG>I>:HZ 6AADL>CH6AHD:HI67A>H=:9I=:ILDI>:G:9:M8=6CI=I=:EG>B6GNB6G@:I;DG$+*H6C9I=:H:8DC96GNB6G@:I;DGHJ7H:FJ:CIIG69>CCH CDL DE:C 7:IL::C 6C9 :K:GN L::@96N ;DG I=: 7DI= EG>B6GN 6C9H:8DC96GNB6G@:IH/G69>C< 86C6AHD7:9DC:DK:GI=:>CI:GC:I

/=: G:K>H>DC ID I=:.:8JG>I>:H 6C9 M8=6C-:/1?1/@;>

$CHJG6C8:68I>K>I>:H>C(DC66G:G:


23/58

86E>I6AB6C6CHJG6C8:6C9;>C6C8>6AG>H@B6C6CI:GC6AEGD8:HHD;>CHJG6C8:8DBE6C>:H

"!$&*"!$&

&>1:0?5:A?@;9?";85/E

.:K:G6AB>C>HIG>:H6C96:H>C8DCHJAI6I>DCL>I=G:EG:H:CI6I>K:HD;I=:EG>K6I:H:8IDG6G:>CKDAK:9>CI=:;DGBJA6I>DC6C9>BEA:B:CI6I>DCD;IG69:EDA>8>:H/=:(>C>HIGND;$C9JHIGN6C9/G69:>HI=:B6>CI=BDC>IDG>C< 6C9>CE6GI>8JA6G >IZH/G69:+DA>8N6C9DDE:G6I>DC:E6GIB:CI>HG:HEDCH>7A:;DG8DDG9>C6I>C8N/=:(>C>HIGN >H 6AHDG:HEDCH>7A: ;DG 6AA >HHJ:H G:A6I:9 ID IG69: EGDBDI>DC IG69: ;68>A>I6I>DC 6C9:MEDGI9:K:ADEB:CI$BEDGI6C9:MEDGI68I>K>I>:H6G:G:;;H8DCH>HID; DC(!)7DJC96C96EEA>:9 JHIDBHI6G>;;H6G:86A8JA6I:9 69K6ADG:B DC8>;K6AJ:HD;>BEDGIHC "% 6",/2&- (!)I6G>;;G6I:D;E:G8:CI>H6EEA>:9IDBDHI>BEDGI:9;; G6I: >H 6EEA>:9 ID DI=:G I6G>;; A>C:H >C8AJ9>CK: 6C>B6AH ;DG

7G::9>CDC9>HH:B>C6I>DC:FJ>EB:CI6C9>IHHE6G:E6GIHDI=:GB68=>C:H;DG>C;DGB6I>DC9:K:ADEB:CIIG6CH>HIDG9>D9:H6C9H>B>A6GIG6CH>HIDGH6C9K6G>DJHB:9>86A:FJ>EB:CIH:6HDC6A>BEDGI9JING6I:D;E:G8:CI>H6EEA>:9DC;ADJG6C9K:8EGD9J8:GH7:IL::CJA*JIH>9:D;I=>HE:G>D9I=:G6I:>HE:G8:CI(DC67DJC96AA>IHI6G>;;H6IE:G8:CI;DGBDHII6G>;;A>C:H

"!#"''""


24/58

/=: G6C:9 (!) G6I:H >H O:GD ID E:G 8:CI (DC6 9D:H CDI 6AI6G>;;H

/=:I6M76H:>HI=:EG>8:9:I:GB>C:97NJHIDBH>C8DC;DGB>INL>I=I=:JHIDB/6G>;;'6LEAJH8JHIDBH9JIN:M8>H:I6M6C9DI=:GI6M:H

/=: M8>H: /6M '6L D; EGDK>9:H I=6I >C H: I6M:H 6G: A:K>:9 DC 9:G:9ID7: 96B6CGDCB:CI$I>H6AHDA:K>:9DCAJMJGN>I:BH6C9DC>I:BHG:A6I:9IDCH:I6M:H6EEANIDI=: 67DK: C (DC6 6H L:AA 6HID >BEDGIH 6C9 6G: 86A8JA6I:9 :>I=:G 7NFJ6CI>INDG6H6E:G8:CI667A:E9@$18512

/=:JHIDBH'6L8DCI6>CHEGDK>H>DCHDCI:BEDG6GN69B>HH>DCD;B68=>C:GN6C9:FJ>EB:CI$I86C7:>BEDGI:9I:BEDG6G>AN;DGG::MEDGIJC9:GI=:8DC9>I>DCI=6II=:BEDGI:9;DG JH: >C 9:BDCHIG6I>DCH DG :M=>7>I>DCH 6C9 L>AA 7: G::MEDGI:9 L>I=>C DC: N:6G $; I=:>BEDGI:G D7I6>CH 6C >BEDGI:MEDGI E:GB>I HJ8= I:BEDG6GN >BEDGIH 6G: :M:BEI:9 ;GDB8JHIDBH9JI>:H

A?@;9?A@51?:/1:@5B1?

+JGHJ6CIID I=:JHIDBH'6LD;I=: ;DAADL>CI:BH6G::M:BEI;GDBJHIDBH9JI>:H>C(DC6

, 6EEA>6C8:H;DGHE:8>6AJH:7N I=:9>H67A:9 6C96GI>;>8>6ADGC6C6HH>HI6C8:6C9H>B>A6G9DC6I>DCH, :FJ>EB:CI ;68>A>I>:H B6I:G>6AH G6LB6I:G>6AH 6EEA>6C8:H E:IGDA:JB 9>:H:A ;J:A ;DGD>A

:MEADG6I>DC:MEAD>I6I>DC6C9JH:688DG9>C;/10A>1?

$CDG9:GID;68>A>I6I:I=:IG69:EGD8:HH[DC:HIDE\H:GK>8:H=6K:7::CEGDK>9:96II=:B6?DG8JHIDBHED>CIHD;I=:8DJCIGN/=:H:H:GK>8:H6G:>CI:C9:9IDB6@:>IEDHH>7A:ID8DBEA:I:6AAI=:C:8:HH6GN8JHIDBH9D8JB:CI6I>DC6C9EGD8:9JG:H>CDC:AD86I>DC

/=:H:EGD8:9JG:H>C8AJ9:EGD8:HH>CI>:H8JHIDBK6AJ6I>DCE6NB:CID;8JHIDBH9JI>:H6C96AAI6M:H6C98JHIDBH:M6B>C6I>DC.>C8:(DC6=6H>CIGD9J8:9I=: JIDB6I:9.NHI:B ;DG JHIDBH $C;DGB6I>DC(6C6C>HIG6I>DC


25/58

JHIDBH 9D8JB:CIH HJ7B>II:9 >C ;DG:>8:G $; HJ8= 9D8JB:CIH 6G: ;DJC9 ID 7: >C69:FJ6I: DG >AA:7A: 6 (DC6CIG6CHA6I>DCL>AA7:G:FJ>G:9(DHI9D8JB:CIHG:FJ>G:9;DG8A:6G6C8:6G:LG>II:C>CCH=6C9-JHH>6C6C98JHIDBHD;;>8>6AHCC(DC6>CDG9:G;DGI=:EGDE:G9D8JB:CI6I>DCID7:EG:E6G:96C99JI>:H6C9DI=:GI6M:HID7:8DAA:8I:9"DD9H86C7:HIDG:9;DG6B6M>BJBD;ILDN:6GHL>I=I=:EDHH>7>A>IND;6DC:N:6G :MI:CH>DC

K6G>:IND; 68I>DCH6G:6AADL:9>C7DC9:9L6G:=DJH:H>C8AJ9>CCHE:8I>DCD;I=: CC


26/58

;5:@ %@;/7 ;9H68DBE6CNL=DH:86E>I6A >CK:HI:9 7N I=: H=6G:=DA9:GH >H 9>K>9:9 >CID H=6G:H L=>8= 6G: G:HI:G:9 6I I=:(DC6C.ID8@M8=6C8=B6N7:;G::ANIG69:97NI=:EJ7A>8L>I=DJIG:K:G>H 68DBE6CNL=DH:86E>I6A>CK:HI:97NI=:H=6G:=DA9:GH>H9>K>9:9>CIDH=6G:HL=>8=6G:G:HI:G:96II=:.:8JG>I>:HA:6G>CIDGN D; (DC6 .# 6C9 L=>8= 6G: IG69:9 DJIH>9: D; I=:(DC6C.ID8@M8=6CEI>DC

*E:C%.H6G:G:FJ>G:9IDG:EDGI IDI=:!>C6C8>6A-:HH>DC!-DC;>C6C8>6A

6C98DGEDG6I:B6II:GH

34"#,*3)-&.4

DI=8ADH:96C9DE:C%.HBJHI7:G:HI:G:9L>I=I=:.I6I:-:HIG6I>DC*;;>8:ID68FJ>G:EGDE:G A:C (DC6 /D G:HI:G 6 %. I=: ;DAADL>C< 9D8JB:CI6I>DC BJHI 7:HJ7B>II:9IDI=:.6I:-:HIG6I>DC*;;>8:

EEA>86I>DC ;DGB 6C9G:FJ:HIA:II:G =6GI:G D8JB:CI 8DC;>GB>C< I=: 699G:HH (>CJI:HD;I=:;DJC96I>DCB::I>CGB>CG:9B>C>BJB6BDJCID;DLC:GZH:FJ>IN D8JB:CIH8DC;>GB>C9:CI>IND;;DJC9:GH6C9E6NB:CID;I=:G:FJ>G:9;::;DG

HI6I:G:HIG6I>DC6C9 ':II:GD;EEGDK6A;GDBI=:!-

/=:8=6GI:GD;6%.BJHI7:CDI6G>O:96C9H=DJA9;N;JAA6C97G>:;C6B:D;I=:8DBE6CNI=:CJB7:GD; 6JI=DG>O:9 >HHJ:96C9 DJIHI6C9>CGE6G K6AJ:I=:CJB7:GD;B:B7:GHD;I=:D6G9D;>G:8IDGHB>C>BJBB:B7:GHDC:I=>G9D;L=>8=H=6AA

7: >C9:E:C9:CIB:B7:GH EGD8:9JG:H ;DG I=: ;DJC96I>DC 8DBE:I:C8N 6C9 68I>K>I>:H D; I=:8DBE6CNZH 7D9>:H>C8AJ9>CCC:HEGD8:9JG:H;DG>C;DGB>CK>I>:H D; I=: 68I>K>IN 6 A>HI D; CI>DCHB6C96IDGN6EED>CIB:CID;6C6J9>IDGI:GBD;I=:;>H86AN:6GD;I=:8DBE6CN;>H86A:I8

$C>I>6A86E>I6A>HEGDK>9:97N8DCIG>7JI>DCH;GDBHJ7H8G>7:GH6C9B6NI6@:I=:;DGBD;86H=DGDI=:GEGDE:GIN6C9EGDE:GING>CBDC:I6GN:FJ>K6A:CI/=:B>C>BJB6BDJCID;

8=6GI:G86E>I6A;DGA>HI>CAA>DCL>I=I=::M8:EI>DCD;76C@H6C9>CHJG6C8:8DBE6C>:HL=>8=BJHI=6K:6=>I6A

%.HI=6IL>AA:CC:G6AG:HDJG8:H76C@>CC6C8:DGB:9>66C98DBBJC>86I>DC6G:HJ7?:8IIDI=:6EEGDK6AD;I=:"DK:GCB:CID;(DC66C9>CHDB:86H:H+6GA>6B:CIJC9:G I=: '6L DC -:DC D; !DG:>C JH>C:HH CI>I>:H *E:G6I>C< >C .:8IDGHD; .IG6I:8 $BEDGI6C8:

8ADH:9 %. >H ;DGB:9 I=GDJEI>DC L=:G: I=: H=6G:H 6G: D;;:G:9DCAN ID 68:GI6>C DC ;DGB0EDC 8DBEA:I>DC D;I=: HJ7H8G>EI>DCE:G>D9I=:HJ7H8G>7:GH>HHJ:I=:8DBE6CN8=6GI:G6C99:8>H>DCD;I=:;DJC9:GH':H68FJ>G:9DCANL=:CG:HI:G:9L>I=I=:.I6I:-:HIG6I>DC*;;>8:6C9I=:.#HD;%JANI=:9:I6>A:9EGD8:9JG:;DGI=::HI67A>H=B:CI6C9G:HIG6I>DCD;8ADH:9%.H>HN:I


27/58

ID7::C68I:97NI=:!-*E:C%.H=6K:I=:699>I>DC6AG:FJ>G:B:CID;=6K>CGH=6G:HG:HI:G:9L>I=I=:!-

/=:BDHI8DBBDCEG68I>8:D;;DGB>CHI=GDJDCD;6A>B>I:9A>67>A>IN8DBE6CN/=:H=6G:=DA9:GHD;I=:A>B>I:9A>67>A>IN8DBE6CNB6@:69:8>H>DCDCHJ8=G:DGO6I>DC7N6 B>C>BJB ILDI=>G9H KDI:!DAADL>CDCI=:C:LAN;DGB:9DE:C%.>HG:HI:G:9L>I=I=:.I6I:-:HIG6I>DC*;;>8:6HHI6I:967DK:EGDK>9:9=DL:K:GI=6II=:!-=6H6EEGDK:9HJ8=G:DGO6I>DC6C9G:HI:G:9>IHH:8JG>I>:H

/=: A:HA6I>DCD;(DC69D:HCDI:M8AJ9:I=:EDHH>7>A>IND;;DJC9>CI>O:CL>I=I=:6EEGDK6AD;I=:!-6C9EJGHJ6CIIDI=:9:967DK:#DL:K:GI=:G:>HCDEG:K>DJH:ME:G>:C8:D;HJ8=:HI67A>H=B:CID;6%.

)"2&3".% *()43

/=:>HHJ6C8:D;H=6G:H>C6CDE:C%.BJHI8DC;DGBL>I=I=:(DC6CH:8JG>I>:HA:HA6I>DC6C9 BJHI 7:G:HI:G:9 L>I= I=: !- 2>I=G:HHJ6C8: D;H=6G:HBJHI7:G:HI:G:9L>I=I=:.#/=:G:6G:ILDINE:HD;H=6G:H DG9>C6GN6C9EG:;:GG:9/=:G:>HCDA>B>IIDI=:CJB7:GD;EG:;:GG:9H=6G:HI=6I86C7:>HHJ:9

/=: =DA9>CIN G>K: 9>K>9:C9H 6C9 6AHD 6H9:I:GB>C:97NI=:8DBE6CNZH8=6GI:GIDE6GI>8>E6I:>CEG>DG9>HIG>7JI>DCD;EGDE:GIN>CI=::K:CI D; A>FJ>96I>DC =DA9:G D; 6 EG:;:GG:9 H=6G: =6H CD G>C I=:B6C6C86H:HEGDK>9:97NI=:A6L

>K>9:C9H B6N 7: E6>9 >C BDC:I6GN ;DGB >C EGDE:GIN DG >C I=: ;DGB D; H:8JG>I>:H /=:9:8>H>DC DC L=:I=:G 9>K>9:C9H L>AA 7: 9>HIG>7JI:9 BJHI 7: B69: 7N I=: 8DBE6CNZH 7D6G9

L>I=>C96NH6;I:GI=::C9D;I=:8DBE6CNZH;>H86AN:6G

/=:(DC6CDBE6CN'6LG:8DO:HI=:8DC8:EID;C I=:86H:D;EG>K6I>O6I>DCD; 6HI6I:DLC:9 8DBE6CNDG 6 8DBE6CN >CL=>8=I=:HI6I: >HI=: B6?DG>INH=6G:=DA9:G/=:"DK:GCB:CIB6N=DA9DC:8=9D:HCDI;DGBE6GID;I=:H=6G:86E>I6A6C9L=DH:=DA9:G9D:HCDIG:8:>K:9>K>9:C9H /=:=DA9:GD;I=:8>E6I:H >CI=:B6C6DCH ID7:B69:7NCG:8IDGH6C9I=::M:8JI>K:7D9N:9E:G>D9D;I>B:

&2-*."4*/.

%.B6N7:I:GB>C6I:9>CI=:;DAADL>CG8JBHI6C8:H

N6IHH=6G:=DA9:GHDG

0C9:G68DJGI9:8>H>DC6HEGDK>9:97NA:HA6I>DC>C8AJ9>CCHDAK:C8N/:GB>C6I>DCB6ND88JGI=GDJDCDGA>FJ>96I>DC'>FJ>96I>DC>H86GG>:9DJI7N6A>FJ>96I>DC 8DBB>II:: 6EED>CI:9 7N I=: CC 86H: D;>CHDAK:C8N7NI=:8DJGIH

595@10 5-.585@E ;9


28/58

''H BJHI 7:G:HI:G:9 L>I= I=: HI6I:ID 68FJ>G: A:;DE:G6I>CCB>C:G6AG:HDJG8:H 76C@>CC6C8: DG B:9>6 6C9 8DBBJC>86I>DC H:8IDGH B6N C::9 6EEGDK6A;GDBI=:"DK:GCB:CIDG+6GA>6B:CI/DG:HI:G6C''I=:;DAADL>CDCBJHI

7: HJ7B>II:9 ID I=: .I6I: -:HIG6I>DC *;;>8: 6C9 6H 6EEA>867A:ID I=: !DG:>DC ;DGB 6C9G:FJ:HIA:II:G =6GI:G D8JB:CI 8DC;>GB>C< I=: 699G:HH (>CJI:HD;I=: ;DJC96I>DCB::I>CGB6I>DCA:II:G8DC;>GB>CG:9B>C>BJB6BDJCID;DLC:GZH:FJ>IN

6C9I=:HI6GI>CC6GN6C9EG:;:GG:9/=:G:>HCDA>B>IIDI=:CJB7:GD;EG:;:GG:9H=6G:HI=6I86C7:>HHJ:9/=:=DA9:GD;6CDG9>C6GNH=6G:=6HI=:G>CI=::A:8I>DCD;B6C6:H/=:=DA9:GD;EG:;:GG:9H=6G:H=6HEG>DG>ING>K:9>K>9:C9H6C96AHD6H9:I:GB>C:97NI=: 8DBE6CNZH 8=6GI:G ID E6GI>8>E6I: >C EG>DG 9>HIG>7JI>DC D; EGDE:GIN >C I=: :K:CI D;A>FJ>96I>DC=DA9:GD;6EG:;:GG:9H=6G:=6HCDG>CI=:B6C6C86H:HEGDK>9:97NA6L

.=6G:=DA9:GH B6N :A:8I ID 9>HIG>7JI: 9>K>9:C9H >; I=: 8DBE6CN >H HDAK:CI 6;I:G HJ8=

9>HIG>7JI>DC >K>9:C9H B6N 7: E6>9 >C BDC:I6GN ;DGB >C EGDE:GIN DG >C I=: ;DGB D;H:8JG>I>:H

&2-*."4*/.

8DBE6CNB6N7:I:GB>C6I:9>CI=:;DAADL>CG8JBHI6C8:H

N6IHH=6G:=DA9:GHDG 0C9:GI=:8DJGI9:8>H>DC6HEGDK>9:97NA:HA6I>DC>C8AJ9>CCHDAK:C8NG:6HDCH

/:GB>C6I>DCB6ND88JGI=GDJDCDGA>FJ>96I>DC'>FJ>96I>DC>H86GG>:9DJI7N6A>FJ>96I>DC 8DBB>II:: 6EED>CI:9 7N I=: CC 86H: D;>CHDAK:C8N7NI=:8DJGIH


29/58

"->@:1>?45


30/58

!'$$&!% %!%'$&+

-.;A>->71@

88DG9>C8>6A JC:BEADNB:CI G6I:H 6G: :HI>B6I:9 ID 7: BJ8= =>H6EEGDM>B6I:9

-.;A>$18-@5;:?

'67DGG:A6I>DCH>C(DC66G:A6GCI>DC DG 7N I=: INE: D; LDG@ E:G;DGB:9 9:;>C: I=: I:GBH D; :BEADNB:CI .I6C96G9LDG@>CI=HE:8>6AEGDK>H>DCH ;DGH:6HDC6AH=>;ILDG@ HJ8=6HI=: :MIG68I>K: >C9JHIG>:H DG 68JAIJG: .6A6G>:H 6G: :HI67A>H=:9 7N I=: :BEADN:G>C9:E:C9:CIAN7JI B6N CDI7: ADL:G I=6CI=: B>C>BJB L6H=:9 7N (DC6CA:HA6I>DC/=:B>C>BJBBDCI=ANL6CID()/26AA:9 LDG@:G L>I= CH= A6CIN 6G:H>;>86CIAN=>5@E%E?@19

>I>O:CHD;(DC6;DG:>I>O:CH6C9HI6I:A:HHE:GHDCH:BEADN:9DC68DCIG68I76H>H7N6AAINE:H D; :8DCDB>8 :CI>I>:HDGO6I>DCH DJHDG DI=:GDGO6I>DCH6C9

;DG:>8 :CI>I>:H86GGN>CK>I>:H>C (DC6 6G:HJ7?:8I ID I=: 8DBEJAHDGN>CHJG6C8:L=>8=>H9:9J8I:9;GDBI=:153:"1>?;::18

AA ;DG:>:H DG DGO6I>DCH H:I JE I=GDJ6AIG:6I>:HBJHI7: E6>9>C(DC6CIJ@>CIDIJ@76C@688DJCIH>C(DC6E:GI=:'6LD;(DC6DCDC9J8I>CC)6I>DC6AJGG:C8ND;%JAN!DG:>GH6A6G>:HDK:GH:6H

JGG:CIAN LDG@ E:GB>IH BJHI 7: D7I6>C:9 ;DG 6AA ;DG:>C 8DBE6C>:H 6C9G:EG:H:CI6I>K:D;;>8:H*7I6>C>CIH86C7:I>B:8DCHJB>CDC6AILDL::@H6;I:G:CIGN:;DG:6GG>K6A6H>CH6BJHI7:6EEA>:9;DG6I6CN(DC6C:B76HHNLDGA9L>9:+G68I>8:K6G>:H;GDB:B76HHNID:B76HHN

;I:G :CIGN I=: ;DG:>I=>C H:K:C 86A:C96G 96NH 6I I=:$BB>DC*;;>8:DG;68:6;>C:D;JEID()//=:6EEA>86I>DCEGD8:HH;DGI=:

LDG@E:GB>I6C9K>H6L>AA6AHD8DCI>CJ:6;I:GI=::BEADN:::CI:GH2=>A:EGDK>H>DC6A6EEGDK6A;DG6LDG@E:GB>IBJHI7:6EEA>:9;DG6C9D7I6>C:97:;DG::CIGNDC8:I=:;DG:>I BJHI 7: D7I6>C:9;GDB I=: '67DG *;;>8: D; I=: (>C>HIGN D;

"!#"''""


31/58

'67DG6C9.D8>6A2:A;6G:LDG@EA68:;::>CI=:6BDJCID;()/E:GBDCI=D;I=:LDG@E:GB>IBJHI6AHD7:E6>9>C69K6C8:IDI=:'67DG*;;>8:

*C8:I=:LDG@E:GB>I=6H7::CD7I6>C:9I=:H>CH6BJHI7::MI:C9:9ID6ADCEA::CIGNK>H699>I>DC6AAN6ADC9:C8NE:GB>IBJHI6AHD7:D7I6>C:9;GDBI=:$BB>DC*;;>8:

$C9>K>9J6A CDI 8DGEDG6I: H=6G:=DA9:GH DG I=: G:HI:G:9 M:8JI>K: >G:8IDG D; 6 ;DG:>CK:HI:98DBE6CN9DCDIC::9ID=DA9LDG@E:GB>IH>CDG9:GIDLDG@>C(DC6/=:H:86I::HD;:BEADN::HFJ6A>;N;DG6C$CK:HIDGZH6G9;GDB!$!/6C9I=:688DBE6CN>CH66C96ADC9:C8NE:GB>I#DA9:GHD;6/K>H66G:CDIG:FJ>G:9E6NI=:LDG@EA68:;::

/=:"DK:GCB:CID;(DC6H:IH;DG:>CK:HI:98DBE6C>:HDE:G6I>CC(DC6:E:C9>CAA6AHD >C;AJ:C8: >IH FJDI6 /=: 9:;6JAI 7JH>C:HH 68I>K>IN D; 6AA ;DG:>CK:HI:9 8DBE6C>:H >H[;DG:>8=6II68=:H6FJDI6D;/=>HB:6CHI=6I68DBE6CNBJHIB6>CI6>C(DC6C:BEADN::H;DG:K:GN;DG:>C8G:6H:9:E:C9>CCHI6C8:8DBE6C>:H=6K>CC>CDCA>8:CH:=6K:6FJDI6D;

L=>A:68DBE6CN:MIG68I>CADGC6IJG6ACI6>C6LDG@;DG8:8DBEG>H:9D;;DG:>CH86AN:6G:C9HDC:8:B7:GCI>I>:HH=DJA9;>A:I=:>G 6CCJ6A6J9>I:9;>C6C8>6AHI6I:B:CIH L>I= I=: G:A:K6CI HI6I: G:C6C8>6A HI6I:B:CIH 7N I= D; I=: ;DAADL>CC 688DG96C8: L>I= HE:8>;>8;DGBH6EEGDK:97N(>C>HIGND;!>C6C8:

!>C6C8>6A HI6I:B:CIH H=DJA9 7: EG:E6G:9 >C 688DG96C8: L>I= $CI:GC6I>DC6A !>C6C8>6A-:EDGI>C:;688DJCI6CIHD;HI6I:DLC:98DBE6C>:HDG8DBE6C>:HL>I=HI6I:DLC:GH=>E6G:G:FJ>G:9ID=DA96C6I>DC6A+FJ6A>;>86I>DC

4->@;2//;A:@?

JGG:CIAN:8DCDB>8:CI>I>:H>C(DC66G:G:FJ>G:9ID6EEANI=:=6GID;88DJCIH>HHJ:9>C:8:B7:G 7N I=: (>C>HIGN D; !>C6C8: 6C9 8DCDBN )"*H =6K: 6 H>B>A6G 7JIHE:8>6A>O:9=6GID;88DJCIHL=>8= L6H69DEI:9>C:8:B7:G+G>C8>E6AANI=:=6GI D;

88DJCIH H:IH I=: ;>GHI ILD 9>IH D; 76A6C8:H=::I 6C9 EGD;>IADHH 688DJCIH L=>8= 6G: ID 7:JH:9CI>I>:H86C9:8>9:DCI=:CJB7:G6C96GG6CK>H>DCHD;688DJCI8D9:HI=:BH:AK:H

*C *8ID7:G I=: 6C@ D; (DC6 (DC6ZH 8:CIG6A 76C@ 69DEI:9 6 =6GI D;88DJCIH6EEA>867A: ;DG76C@>CCHI>IJI>DCHL=>8=H:IH I=:76H>8 8A6HH>;>86I>DCHNHI:BID 7:JH:97N76C@H;DGI=:EJGEDH:D;I=:>G;>C6C8>6AG:EDGI>CC


32/58

A05@$1=A5>191:@?

$C688DG96C8:L>I=I=:(DC6CA6LDC J9>I>CCDCH6G:G:FJ>G:9ID =6K: I=:>G ;>C6C8>6A HI6I:B:CIH 6J9>I:9 >C 688DG96C8: L>I= $CI:GC6I>DC6A .I6C96G9H D;

J9>I>C


33/58

'6LDC!DG:>C:G6AH

:HE>I: H:K:G6A GDJC9H D; 6B:C9B:CIH D; K6G>DJH A:HA6I>DC DK:G I=: E6HI ;:L N:6GH I=:A:HA6I>DCG:B6>CH>C>IH>C;6C8N 6C98DBEA>86I:9>HHJ:H6G:CDI9:6AI L>I=8A6G>IN

/=:G:;DG:>I>H>BE:G6I>K:IDD7I6>C69K>8:DCI=:>CI:GEG:I6I>DC>BEA:B:CI6I>DC6C9EG68I>8:69DEI:9 7NI=:I6M 6JI=DG>I>:H 6HL:AA 6H:CHJG>CDC>H 7:>C9:G:9

:/;91&-D

(DC6C8DGEDG6I:>C8DB:I6M JH:HI=:EGDK:G6I:H86A:;GDBH=DJA96EEAN;DG6CCJ6A>C8DB:JEID 7>AA>DC(DC6C/J@ ()/6EEGDM0.B>AA>DC6C9H=DJA96EEAN;DG6CN:M8:HHD;7>AA>DC()/

,"33&3/'"80"9&2

$C9:CIH6G:I6M67A:DCI=:>GLDGA9L>9:>C8DB:L=>AHICDCG:H>9:CIH6G:DCANI6M67A:DCI=:(DC6CHDJG8:>C8DB:/=>H6EEA>:HID7DI=C6IJG6AE:GHDCH6C9A:I>:H

"8"#,&.$/-&

/6M67A:>C8DB:>H 9:;>C:96H61-@51?

(DC6=6H8JGG:CIAN8DC8AJ9:9DJ7A:/6M/G:6I>:HL>I=8DJCIG>:H$C699>I>DCI=:G:6G:;>K:L=>8=6G:E:C9>CHID;DJ7A:/6MIG:6I>:HEA:6H:H::EE:C9>M

/=:G: =6K: 7::C 8:GI6>C 68I>DCH I6@:C 7N I=: "DK:GCB:CI D; (DC6 >C I=: 6G:6 D;>CI:GC6I>DC6AI6M6I>DC6C96EEA>86I>DCD;I6MIG:6I>:H/D>C>I>6I:I=>HI=:(>C>HIGND;!>C6C8:=6HEG:E6G:96EGDEDH6AIDI=:(>C>HIGND;%JHI>8:6C9(>C>HIGND;!DG:>GHID86C8:AHDB: 6II=: //HI=6I(DC6 8JGG:CIAN =6H >C;DG8: /=:/H I=6I =6K:7::C>9:CI>;>:96G: ):I=:GA6C9H'JM:B7DJGI

&-D$1@A>:?-:0"-E91:@?

/6MG:EDGIH6G:8DBE>A:97NI=:I6ME6N:GI6M6GG:EG:H:CI6I>K:/=:G:EDGIHBJHI

7: HJ7B>II:9 >C E6E:G ;DGB6I 6C9 :A:8IGDC>86AAN 6C9 BJHI 7: >C (DC6C HJEEDGI>CDC BJHI 6AHD 7: >C DG IG6CHA6I:9 >CID (DC6C -:8:CIAN I=: I6M69B>C>HIG6I>DC HI6GI:9 ID >BEA:B:CI 6C :;>A>CI>:H6G:6AADL:9IDHJ7B>I:A:8IGDC>8I6MG:EDGIHDC8:I=:ND7I6>CI=::H>II:96G:HJ7?:8IID6C69B>C>HIG6I>K:8=:8@ID:CHJG:I=6II=:N8DBEANL>I=I=:G:FJ>G:B:CIH;DG 8DBEA:I>C86AG:K>:L D;I=: I6MEDH>I>DC I6@:C6C9I=:JC9:GAN>CDC;DGBHE6GID;6I6M6J9>I L=>8=B6N7:86GG>:9DJI>CI=:;JIJG:0EDCI=:8DC8AJH>DCD;6C6J9>II=:I6M6JI=DG>I>:HL>AA>HHJ:6C Y68IZ H:II>CG;>C9>C


34/58

2=:G:6I6ME6N:GD7?:8IHID69:8>H>DCD;I=:I6M>CHE:8IDGI=:A:C>HIG6I>DCL>AA>CK:HI>HEJI:6C9K:6CDE>C>DC$C86H:I=:9>HEJI:86CCDI7:G:HDAK:97NI=:A:HG:K>:L:97NI=:/6M>HEJI:DJC8>A8DCH>HI>CM E:GHDCH6C9>H8=6>G:97NI=:=:69D;I=:-:K:CJ::E6GIB:CID;I=:(>C>HIGN D;!>C6C8:$;I=:I6ME6N:G9>H6I=I=:G:HDAJI>DCHD;I=:DJC8>AI=:86H:86C7:I6@:CIDI=:":C:G6A DJGI

)5@44;805:3&-D1?

(DC6C:CI>I>:H6G:G:FJ>G:9IDL>I==DA9I6MDC9>K>9:C9HGDN6AI>:HID:8DCDB>8:CI>I>:HG:H>9:CI >C (DC6 6C9 ?JHI DC GDN6AI>:H ID >C9>K>9J6AH 6H 9>K>9:C9H 6G: :M:BEI ;GDBI6M6I>DC;DG>C9>K>9J6AHJCI>A$C7DI=86H:HI=:G6I:>H2>I==DA9>CH6EEA>:9ID

I=:BBDK67A:EGDE:GIN6I

)DCG:H>9:CIHL>I=CDEG:H:C8:>C(DC66G:HJ7?:8IIDL>I==DA9>CC8DB::6GC:9 >C I=: I:GG>IDG>:H D; (DC6 6C9 DC (DC6C HDJG8: >C8DB: /=>H 8DK:GH I=:;DAADL>CK>9:C9H$CI:G:HI

-DN6AI>:H-:CI6A(6C6C>HIG6I>K::ME:CH:H$C8DB:8:HEGDK>9:9>C(DC66C9

2DG@DGH:GK>8:HEGDK>9:99>G:8IANDGI=GDJ8B:6CH

&-DA05@?

I6M>CHE:8IDG>H:BEDL:G:9ID:M6B>C:;>C6C8>6A9D8JB:CIH8DCC:8I:9L>I=I=:E6NB:CID;I6M:H 6C9 6H@ DG :MEA6C6I>DCH /=: D;;>8>6A 86C I:BEDG6G>AN H:>O: 9D8JB:CIH L=>8= 6G::K>9:C8:D;I6M6KD>96C8:6C98DENI=:B

"1:-8@51?

$CI:G:HI86A8JA6I:9DC696>AN76H>H;DGI=:E:G>D97:IL::CI=:9J:96I:6C9;DGE6NB:CI6C9I=: 68IJ6A E6NB:CI 96I: 6C9 E:C6AI>:H 6G: >BEDH:9 DC A6I: E6NB:CI D; I6M:H !A6I G6I:E:C6AI>:H6AHD:M>HI;DGI=:;6>AJG:ID8DBEANL>I=K6G>DJH69B>C>HIG6I>K:G:FJ>G:B:CIH

0B-:/1&-D8->525/-@5;:

-JA>CC:9;GDBI=:I6M6JI=DG>I>:H7JII=:H:6G:CDIA:C9>C


35/58

(DC6C:8DCDB>8:CI>I>:H !DG:>8:CI>I>:HI=6I=6K:I=:>G=:69FJ6GI:GH>C(DC66C9 !DG:>8:CI>I>:HI=6I:6GC>C8DB:>C(DC6DI=:GI=6CK>6I=:67DK:

$I>HCDI8JGG:CIANEDHH>7A:;DG6;DG:>C(DC6

:/1:@5B1?

/6M >C8:CI>K:H DG 7:C:;>IH 6G: 6K6>A67A: ID I=: 68JAIJG: 6C9 B>C>CC9JHIG>:H !DG:>CK:HIDGHB6ND7I6>CH>B>A6G7:C:;>IHL=:G:I=:NB::IB>C>BJB>CK:HIB:CIA:K:AH

&-D-.81:/;91

/6M67A:>C8DB:;6AAHJC9:GI=:;DAADL>CK>I>:HL=>8=>C8AJ9:H6 JH>C:HH68I>K>I>:H7 .6A: D;H=6G:H6C9H:8JG>I>:H8 "6>CHDC;DG:>C8AJ9:H6 -:CI6A7 -DN6AI>:H8 >K>9:C9H9 $CI:G:HI

$C8DB: ;GDB I=: H6A:D; EGDE:GIN 7DI=>BBDK67A: 6C9 BDK67A::M8:EI ;DGH=6G:H 6C9H:8JG>I>:H

/=: (DC6C8DGEDG6I:>C8DB:I6MG6I: >H EGDK:G6I: 6C9 G6CGHI 6CCJ6A >C8DB: D; 7>AA>DC (DC6C /J@ ()/6EEGDM0.B>AA>DC6C9H=DJA9 6EEAN;DG6CN:M8:HHD;7>AA>DC()/

:GI6>C INE:HD;>C8DB:B6N7:I6M:96I9>;;:G:CII6MG6I:H

%;A>/1;25:/;91 K>9:C9H

-DN6AI>:H

$CI:G:HI "6B7A>CCBBDK67A:EGDE:GIN


36/58

.4&2&3480&.3&3 $CI:G:HIE6>9IDI=>G9E6GI>:H>H9:9J8I>7A:$CI:G:HIE6>9ID6H=6G:=DA9:G>HHJ7?:8IID69:7IID:FJ>ING:HIG>8I>DC!JGI=:GG:HIG>8I>DCH6EEANID>CI:G:HIDCAD6CHB69:;GDB6(DC6C>C9>K>9J6AL=D8DCIGDAHI=::CI>IN

&02&$*"4*/. :EG:8>6I>DC;DGI6MEJGEDH:H>H86A8JA6I:9JH>CC:B:I=D9DK:GI=:JH:;JA:8DCDB>8A>;:D;I=:6HH:I/=>H9:E:C9HJEDCI=:C6IJG:D;I=:6HH:IG6CCEB:CIIDN:6GH;DG7J>A9>CDCH

*3",,/7"#,&&80&.3&3 ":C:G6AAN:ME:CH:HC::9ID7:HE:8>;>86AANHI6I:96H9:9J8I>7A:HDI=:G:6G: CDI B6CN :ME:CH:H HI6I:9 6H HE:8>;>86AAN 9>H6AADL67A: #DL:K:G I=: ;DAADL>C7A:;DGI6MEJGEDH:H !>C6C8:A:6H:E6NB:CIH

!>C:H6C9E:C6AI>:HME:CH:H>C8JGG:9;DG:6GC>CC8DB:ME:CH:HCDI9D8JB:CI:97NI=:I6ME6N:G6C9+6NB:CIH;GDBL=>8=I6M>HCDIL>I==:A97JIG:FJ>G:9ID7:L>I==:A9

$18-@10"->@E&>-:?-/@5;:?

$CDCH6G:K6AJ:9;DGI6MEJGEDH:H6I I=:8DCI68IK6AJ:2=:G:IG6CH68I>DCHI6@:EA68:7:IL::CG:A6I:9E6GI>:H67DK:DG7:ADLI=>H K6AJ:I=:I6M6JI=DG>I>:H=6K:I=:G>9:H 6CDI=:G 9:;>C>I>DC DC I=: [G:A6I:9 E6GI>:H\ I=6I >H76H:9 DC 67>A>IN ID E6GI>8>E6I: >C B6C6C 699>I>DC ID I=: 67DK:9:;>C>I>DC

;>153:D/4-:31

$C8DB:6C9:ME:C9>IJG:>C;DG:>:HH=DJA97:IG6CHA6I:9>CID()/DCI=:96I:D;I=:IG6CH68I>DC-:6A>O:9CH6C9ADHH:H;GDB;DG:>K:AN

;??1?

'DHH:H86C7:86GG>:9;DGL6G9;DGJEIDILDN:6GH6C9JH:D;HJ8=ADHH:H>HG:HIG>8I:9IDD;I=:I6M67A:EGD;>I>C6CNN:6G;DG:8DCDB>8H:8IDGHDI=:GI=6CB>C>CC;G6HIGJ8IJG:

!DG B>C>CC;G6HIGJ8IJG: H:8IDGH ADHH:H 86C 7: 86GG>:9 ;DGL6G9 ;DG ;DJGID :>CCK:HIB:CI6BDJCI 6C9I=:L=DA:I6M67A:EGD;>I86C7:D;;H:I>C6N:6G CDA>B>I 6EEA>:H

&-D;9I FJ6GI:GAN6C96CCJ6AG:IJGCHIDI=:I6M6JI=DG>I>:H7NI=:I= D;I=:BDCI=;DAADL>C


37/58

6H:9DCI=:H:I=:I6M6JI=DG>I>:H>HHJ:BDCI=ANFJ6GI:GANE6NB:CIH8=:9JA:H6C9E6NB:CIHBJHI7:B69:7NI=:I=D;:68=BDCI=

$CEG68I>8:I=:(DC6CI6M6JI=DG>I>:H6AADL8DC8:HH>DCH6H;DAADLH 8DBE6CN L>I= 6CCJ6A I6M67A: >C8DB: D; A:HH I=6C ()/ B6N E6N I6M DC 6

FJ6GI:GAN76H>HDG2=:G: IDI6A I6M E6>9 :M8::9H I=: I6M A>67>A>IN I=: :M8:HH 86C 7: 8G:9>I:9 6CHI DI=:GI6M:H 9J: DG 8G:9>I:9 6CHI ;JIJG: I6M E6NB:CIH $I B6N 6AHD >C I=:DGN7: G:;JC9:9EG68I>8:=:G:>HA:HH8A:6G6C98DCH>HI:CI

2>I==DA9>C< I6M:H BJHI 7: E6>9 L>I=>C H:K:C ID I:C 96NH D; I=: JC9:GAN>CCHH>DCIDI=:I6M6JI=DG>I>:H7NI=:I= D;I=:BDCI=;DAADL>C&-D1?

8$*3&"8

M8>H: I6M >HA:K>:9 DCCDG >BEDGI:9>CID(DC6HJ8= 6HID7688D6A8D=DAC:6C99>:H:A;J:A6C9E6HH:C8A:H-:8:CIJC8:GI6>CINDK:G>CI:GC6I>DC6AHJEEA>:H D; C: 6C9 9>:H:A ;J:A =6H A:69 ID K6G>6I>DCH >C I=: A:KN M8>H: I6M >H 6AHD>BEDH:9DCI=:E=NH>86AJC>IHD;HE:8>6AEJGEDH:I:8=C>86A9:K>8:H6C9:FJ>EB:CIHJH:9;DG

7:II>C:H D;>C9>K>9J6AH 6C9A:I>:H I=6I8DC9J8I HJ8=68I>K>I>:H

--/6"#,&2/0&249"8

$BBDK67A:EGDE:GIN I6M >HA:K>:9 6I D;I=: K6AJ:D; I=: >BBDK67A: EGDE:GIN !DGI6MEJGEDH:HI=:K6AJ:JH:9>HI=:K6AJ:G:HI:G:9L>I=I=:DC6JI=DG>IN$;I=: EGDE:GIN>HJCG:HI:G:9I=:>CHJG:9K6AJ:>HJH:9$CI=:67H:C8:D;:>I=:G6G:HI:G:9DG>CHJG:9K6AJ:I=:688DJCI>CHJH:9!GDB%6CJ6GNI=:>BBDK67A:EGDE:GINI6M

L>AA 7: D; >BBDK67A: EGDE:GIN K6AJ:9:E:C9>CO: AD86I>DC 6C9 B6G@:I9:B6C9:I8

4"-0549

.I6BE9JIN>H >BEDH:9DCI=:;DAADL>C


38/58

;A6I8JHIDBHI6G>;;D;6EEA>:H>CG:HE:8I ID BDHIBEDGI:9>CID(DC6:M8:EI;DG>C;DGB6I>DCI:8=CDAD86A :FJ>EB:CI6C9EJG:7G:9A>K:HID8@L=>8= 6G: O:GDG6I:9:GI6>C:FJ>EB:CI>BEDGI:97NHB6AA6C9B:9>JBH>O::CI:GEG>H:H.(6G::M:BEI;GDB8JHIDBHI6G>;;

MEDGI9JI>:H6EEANID8:GI6>C:MEDGI:9GDC6AJB>CJB8DEE:G7G6HH6C9>C9:CIJG:986H=B:G:

*2/,,54*/."9-&.4

/=:'6LDC>G+DAAJI>DCE6NB:CIH 86B:>CID:;;:8I;GDB%JAND;+GD9J8:9G6L8D6AJH:9DG>BEDGI:9DG8HDAK:CIH6C9K:=>8A:H6G:HJ7?:8IIDI=>HE6NB:CI

>-:/4 53 %A.?505->E

$I>HCDI8JGG:CIANEDHH>7A:ID:HI67A>H=67G6C8=D;6;DG:>C(DC6 .I:EH6G:JC9:GL6N6II=:(DC6C/6MJI=DG>I>:HID6AADL+:GB6C:CIHI67A>H=B:CIHIDG:HI:G6HI6ME6N:GHH6II=:96I:D;EJ7A>H=>CC6A 9:I6>AH =6K:CDI7::CEJ7A>H=:9

>;AII>CCK:HI>CC A:K:A B6N 6EEAN;DG 6HI67>A>IN 6CK:HIB:CIEGDK>9>CI>DCH IDI=:>G>CK:HIB:CI ;DG6;>M:9I:GB

JGG:CIAN 6C >CK:HIB:CI D; JE ID 0. B L>AA E:GB>I 6 N:6G I:GB 6C9 6 0. B>CK:HIB:CI6N:6GI:GB

*.*.(

B>C>CA>IN 6A>IN 6C9 DI=:G 7JH>C:HH G>C>BJB>CK:HIB:CI G:;:GH ID I=: 6BDJCI >CK:HI:9 DK:G I=: ;>GHI ;>K: N:6GH D; I=: EGD?:8I 6C9 L>AAEGDK>9:HI67>A>IN;DG6;>M:9I:GB6H;DAADLH

0.B;DGI:CN:6GH0.B;DG;>;I::CN:6GH6C90.B;DGI=>GINN:6GH

AA:MEADG6I>DC8DHIHH=DJA97:86E>I6A>O:96C9I=:C6BDGI>O:9DC6HIG6>C: 76H>HDK:GI=:A>;: D; I=: B>C: ;DAADL>CDC '>8:CH: 68FJ>H>I>DC 8DHIH 6G:6BDGI>O:9DK:GI=:A>;:D;I=:A>8:CH:

*.*.(".%80,/2"4*/.*$&.3&&&

/=>H K6G>:H ;DG :MEADG6I>DC 6C9 B>C>C8:CH:H (>C>C8:CH: ;:: >H 6CI=: B>C>C8:CH:MEADG6I>DC A>8:CH: ;::H 6G: 76H:9DC I=: CJB7:G D; N:6GH D;:MEADG6I>DC

/9",49&&3


39/58

-DN6AIN;::H6G:E6>9DCI=:H6A:D;B>C>CCC:96HL:AA6HI=:6BDJCID;K6AJ:699:9H:GK>8:H7:>CC(DC6

B:C9B:CIHL:G:B69:ID I=:'6L DC(>C:G6AHI=6I 86B:>CID :;;:8I;GDB %6CJ6GN /=:8=6CCAN;D8JHDC>BEDH>C< 699>I>DC6AGDN6AI>:H76H:9DCI=:B6G@:IEG>8:>C8G:6H:D; B>C>C8:H 7:>CC(DC6

&*&!!('%

&1>>5@;>5-85@E-:0$1?501:/1

E:GB6C:CIG:H>9:CII6ME6N:GD;(DC6>HHJ7?:8IIDI6MDC=>H=:GLDGA9L>9:>C8DB:CDCG:H>9:CII6ME6N:GD;(DC6>HHJ7?:8IIDI6MDCI=:>C8DB::6GC:9>CI=:I:GG>IDGND;(DC6>C6I6MN:6G

E:GB6C:CIG:H>9:CII6ME6N:GD;(DC6 >H

C>C9>K>9J6AL=DDLCH6G:H>9:C8:>C(DC6DGC>C9>K>9J6AL=DG:H>9:H>C(DC6;DGDGBDG:96NH>C6I6MN:6G

CDCG:H>9:CII6ME6N:GD;(DC6>H

C>C9>K>9J6AL=D=6HCDG:H>9:C8:>C(DC66C9=6HCDIG:H>9:9>C(DC6;DGDGBDG:96NH>C6I6MN:6G

>;??:/;91

-0,/9&&2/33.$/-&

AA 9>G:8I 6C9 >C9>G:8I >C8DB: G:8:>K:9 I=GDJK>I>:H 9JG>CH>C8AJ9:H7DI=I6M:96C9JCI6M:9>C8DB:6II=:HDJG8:D;E6NB:CI

"0*4","*.3".%.6&34-&.4.$/-&

"GDHH>C8DB:;GDBH6A:D;>BBDK67A:EGDE:GIN>HI6M:96I6G6I:D; "6>C;GDBI=:H6A:D;BDK67A:EGDE:GIN>C8AJ9>CI>:H>HI6M:96I6G6I:D;

>K>9:C9H6C9>CI:G:HI>C8DB::6GC:97N>C9>K>9J6AH>HI==:A96IHDJG8:/=:I6MDC>K>9:C9H 6C9$CI:G:HI L>AACDI8DB:>CID;DG8:JCI>A%6C

10A/@5;:?

53*.&33&%5$4*/.3

/=:G:6G:CD7JH>C:HH9:9J8I>DCH6AADL:9;DG:BEADN::HC>C9>K>9J6AB6N 8A6>B7JH>C:HH9:9J8I>DCH>;G:HI:G:96H6C:CIG:EG:C:JG


40/58

.D8>6A>CHJG6C8:8=6G7A:;DG+$/EJGEDH:H

/.53*.&3380&.3&3

/=:G:6G:CD9:9J8I>DCH;DGCDC7JH>C:HH:ME:CH:H

&23/.",,,/7".$&3

/=: BDHI CDI67A: 6AADL6C8: >H 6 DC L6105@?

8G:9>I >H6K6>A67A: ;DG>C9>K>9J6AH L=D=6K:HJ;;:G:9I6M>C DI=:G8DJCIG>:H JC9:GI=: I:GBH

D;6DJ7A:/6M/G:6IN

/6M8G:9>IH6G:6AHD6K6>A67A:;DG68JAIJG6AEGD9J8I>DC6C9:9J86I>DC6A;::H

!@41>&-D1?

/$*",&$52*49"8&3

>I>O:CHD;(DC6;DG:>I>O:CH6C9HI6I:A:HHE:GHDCH:BEADN:9DC68DCIG68I76H>H7N6AAINE:H D; :8DCDB>8 :CI>I>:H DGO6I>DCH DJH DG DI=:GDGO6I>DCH6C9;DG:>8:CI>I>:H86GGN>CK>I>:H>C(DC66G:HJ7?:8IIDI=:;DAADL>CCHJG6C8:

+:CH>DC>CHJG6C8::BEADN:G:BEADN::

:C:;>I>CHJG6C8::BEADN:G:BEADN::#:6AI=>CHJG6C8::BEADN:G:BEADN::$C9JHIG>6A688>9:CI6C9D88JE6I>DC6A9>H:6H:>CHJG6C8::BEADN:GID6C90C:BEADNB:CI>CHJG6C8: :BEADN:G:BEADN::

BEADN:: 9:9J8I>DCH 6G:86EE:96I()/ E:GBDCI=0.BEADN:G E6NB:CIH6G:CDI86EE:9/=:H: 8=6G7A:;DG $/EJGEDH:H

.D8>6A $CHJG6C8: 6C9 #:6AI= >CHJG6C8: G:IJGCH H=DJA9 7: HJ7B>II:9 :A:8IGDC>86AAN 6C9 7NE6E:G7:;DG:I= D;I=:;DAADL>CH+6NB:CIHH=DJA97:6AHD B69: 7NI= D;I=:;DAADL>C6A $CHJG6C8: !JC9

#,*("4/29&.3*/./.42*#54*/.3

$C8AJ9:9>C I=: .D8>6A.:8JG>IN/6M:H

&",4)"8

/=:G:>HCDL:6AI=I6M>C(DC6

/$","8&3

/=:G:6G:CD699>I>DC6AAD86AI6M:HDC>C8DB:

&-D095:5?@>-@5;:

33&33-&.4


41/58

/=:;DAADL>CC8DB:6G:HJ7?:8IIDL>I==DA9>CC8DB:$CI:G:HI-DN6AI>:H6C9>K>9:C9H

+A:6H:CDI:I=6I9>K>9:C9H6C9 >CI:G:HI 6G::M:BEI;GDBI6M6I>DC>C8AJ9>CI==DA9>CA%6CJ6GN

&452.3

L>I==DA9:G H=6AAHJ7B>I 6FJ6GI:GANG:EDGID; I6ML>I==:A9 7NI=: I= D;I=:;>GHIBDCI=D;

I=:;DAADL>CCCIN

$C8DB:CDI8DK:G:97NI=:67DK:H=DJA97:G:EDGI:9DC I=: 6CCJ6AI6MG:IJGC L=>8=BJHI7:7:HJ7B>II:9IDI=:I6M6JI=DG>I>:H7NI= !:7GJ6GN;DAADL>C8=>HI=:86A:C96GN:6G

"9-&.4/'"8

/6ML>I==:A9H=DJA97:E6>9IDI=:I6M6JI=DG>I>:H7NI=:I= D;I=:;DAADL>CC8DB:H=DJA97:E6>97NI=:I= D;I=:;>GHIBDCI=D;I=:;DAADL>C/1;25:/;91 C8DB: JH>C:HH6C9EGD;:HH>DC6A>C8DB:$C8DB: ;GDBEGDE:GIN>: 9>K>9:C9HGDN6AIN >CI:G:HI86E>I6A C;GDBH6A:D; H:8JG>I>:[email protected]:D;>BBDK67A:EGDE:GIN:CI>;>8A>I:G68N 6GI>HI>8 LDG@H >CK:CI>DCH EGD9J8I9:H>B>A6G>C8DB:C


42/58

1/ 6II=:G6I:D;>H >BEDH:9DCI=:HJEEAN D; I6M67A:8:H>C(DC66C9DC>BEDGIH>CID(DC6

/6ME6N:GH6G:G:FJ>G:9ID G:HI:G;DG(DC6C1/EJGEDH:HL=:CI=:>GI6M67A:IJGCDK:G:M8::9H B>AA>DC ()/ 0. & /6ME6N:GH B6N 6AHD KDAJCI6G>AN G:HI:G L=:C I=:>GI6M67A:IJGCDK:GG:68=:HB>AA>DC()/0.&DG>;I=:N=6K:>CK:HI:9BDG:I=6C0. B>C(DC6 2:JC9:GHI6C9I=6I6II=:I>B:D;EJ7A>86I>DCI=:(/>H8DCH>9:G>CC8G:6H>CDCI=G:H=DA9ID()/B0.@

%/;H A:K>:9DCI=:;DAADL>CC(DC6

2DG@E:G;DGB:96C9H:GK>8:HG:C9:G:9>C(DC6 "DD9HHDA9>C(DC6 "DD9H>BEDGI:9>CID(DC6ID7:HDA9DGJH:96C9 "DD9H:MEDGI:9;GDB(DC6;DGJH:DG 8DCHJBEI>DCDJIH>9:(DC6

/=:EGDK>H>DCD;H:GK>8:H6AHD>C8AJ9:HI=:;DAADL>C9: :A:8IG>8>IN =:6I 86I>DCH 6C9 DI=:GH:GK>8:H

/DA:6H:CDI=:G;DGBH /DG:CI DJIGDDBH>C=DI:AHDGH>B>A6GEA68:HDG6AADLDC:IDEDHH:HHDGJH:I=:B>C

DI=:G;DGBH /DG:CIDJIGDDBH>C=DJH:HDG7J>A9>CCDI=:G

;DGBH /DA:6H:>BBDK67A:6C9BDK67A:EGDE:GINDI=:GI=6C=DJH:H6C97J>A9>CCDI=:G;DGBH /D IG6CH;:G A:6H: DG H:AA>CCDK6I>DCH EGD9J8I 9:H>C;DGB6I>DCDC6HH:IH /D>HHJ:ADII:G>:HDE:G6I:FJ>OO:HDGC9: >CI:GB:9>6GNH:GK>8:H /DE6ND;;9:7IH7NE:G;DGB>C9>C8:H /=:E:G;DGB6C8:D;LDG@DGEGDK>H>DCD;H:GK>8:H;GDB6CDCG:H>9:CIID6G:H>9:CI

6C9 /DE6N>CI:G:HI6C9;>C:HIDDI=:GH9J:IDB>H8DC9J8I

/=:H6A:D;C8AJ9:HI=:;DAADL>C868I>K>IN

-:I:CI>DCD;6HH:IHJEDCI=:I:GB>C6I>DCD;IG69: .:IIA:B:CID;69:7IL>I=9:CIIDG:H>9:CI

,1>;$-@5:3

/=:;DAADL>CDCH:GK>8:H .:GK>8:HEGDK>9:9DJIH>9:(DC6 .:GK>8:H EGDK>9:9 ID 6 ;DG:>I>O:CDG A:IN CDI EG:H:CI >CI=: I:GG>IDGND;

(DC69JG>CH>DCD;H:GK>8:H>C8AJ9>C8:H


43/58

.:GK>8:H EGDK>9:9 ID 9DB:HI>8 DG >CI:GC6I>DC6A 6>G8G6;IH 8DC9J8I>CCI:GC6I>DC6A;A>CHEGD9J8:99DB:HI>86AAN6C9 MEDGID;;>C6A>O:9B>C>C6AH

D19IH 8DCI6>C:GH:FJ>EB:CIH8JHIDBB68=>C:GNB:8=6C>HBHIDDAH

6C9HE6G:E6GIH (DC6C 8JGG:C8>:HEG>CI:9>C;DG:>:H7NDG9:GH "DA9HDA9

):LHE6E:GH HDA9 +GD9J8IHG:HJAI>C:CI>;>8G:H:6G8= (>C>CCINE:HD;AD6CH -6L8D6A 0H:9DG>BEDGI:9DG8HDAK:CIHK:=>8A:H +GD9J8:9 DGEA6CI:98:G:6AH +GD8:HH:9B:6I6C9 (>A@6C9B>A@EGD9J8IH:I8

/=:;DAADL>C8:HH=6AA 7::M:BEI:9;GDB1/

JGG:C8N:M8=6CDCH 6C@>CDCH $CHJG6C8:6C9EGDE:GING:HIG6I>DC /G6CH68I>DCH>CHID8@H6C9H:8JG>I>:H 'D6CH /G6CH68I>DCH8DC8:GC>CHHJ6C8:6C9IG6CH;:GD;>CI:G:HI;DGEA68:B:CID;BDC:I6GN

6HH:IHD;HD8>6A6C9=:6AI=>CHJG6C8:;JC9H -:H>9:CI>6A688DBBD96I>DC 9J86I>DC6AH:GK>8:H #:6AI=H:GK>8:H .:GK>8:HD;G:A>DJHDGO6I>DCH .I6I:H:GK>8:H +J7A>8IG6CHEDGI6C9 .DB:H:GK>8:HIDIDJG>HIH


44/58

"DD9HLDG@DGH:GK>8:H EGDK>9:9 ;G::D;8=6GDCH=6AACDI7::M:BEI:9;GDBK6AJ:

&-D-.819;A:@

"#,&500,*&3

$CHI=:;6>GB6G@:IK6AJ:D;I=:8:HEGDK>9:9

!DG>BEDGI:9HH=DJA9>C8AJ9:8JHIDBH9JIN:M8>H:I6M6C9DI=:GHJ8=I6M:HIDI=:8JHIDBH K6AJ: D; I=: H=>CDC>CHJG6C8:6C96CN8DBB>HH>DCDGGDN6AIN6BDJCIH6G:>C8AJ9:9

/6ME6N:GHH=DJA9688DJCI;DG1/DC8:D7I6>C:9;GDBCDCG:H>9:CIH

/G6CH68I>DCH>C6;DG:>G:9ID7: IG6CHA6I:9>CID()/6II=:G6I:6EEAN>CDC

''3&4

1/E6>9 ;DG 8:H 86C 7: D;;H:I6CHI 1/E6N67A: ID I=: J9HBJHI7:HJ7HI6CI>6I:97N9D8JB:CI6GN:K>9:C8:/=>H86CDCAN7:9DC:DC8:6 8DBE6CN=6HG:HI:G:9;DG1/

+GDG6I>CH G:FJ>G:9 L=:G: 1/ >H >C8JGG:9 E6GI>6AAN ;DG :M:BEI 6C9 E6GI>6AAN 1/67A:EJGEDH:H ID;68>A>I6I:6G:8DK:GND;I=:1/$CEJI/6M

",$5,"4*/.".%''3&4"229/27"2%

/=:1/A>67>A>IND; 6I6ME6N:G 8DBEG>H:H *JIEJI1/>:1/8=6G:1/E6>97N6I6ME6N:GID>IHHJEEA>:GH>C6G:EDGI>CD9

/=: :M8:HH D;>CEJI 1/ DK:G DJIEJI 1/ B6N :9 ;DGL6G9 6CHI ;JIJG:1/A>67>A>I>:HDG D;;H:I6CHIDI=:G I6MA>67>A>I>:H$CEG68I>8:G:;JC9H6G:9>;;>8JAI IDD7I6>C6AI=DJ7:6EGD8:9JG:;DGG:;JC9HJC9:G8:GI6>C8DC9>I>DCH

&6&23&)"2(&".%''3&4

(DC6C8DBE6C>:H6G:G:FJ>G:9ID688DJCI;DG-:K:GH:=6GK:96C9EB:CI7DJI>:H

-:8:CI6B:C9B:CI>CI=:1/A6LHI>EJA6I: I=6I -:K:GH:=6GI==:A9 7N(DC6CG:H>9:CIHDCH:GK>8:HEGDK>9:9LDG@E:G;DGB:96C9BEDGI:97NCDCG:H>9:CIHH=DJA9CDI7:6AADL:9;DGD;;H:I6CHI*JIEJI1/ 7NI=:(DC6CI6ME6N:GH6II=:96I:D;I=>HEJ7A>86I>DC 6 CJB7:G D; I6ME6N:GH =6K: 8=6AA:CH >C I=: DJGIH D; '6L 6C9 I=:DJI8DB:=6HCDI7::C9:I:GB>C:9

;:10A/@5.81:9 >C I=: 8DJGH: D; >BEDGI DG EJG8=6H: D; I=: ;DAADL>C7A:;DG 8G:9>I6CHIIDI6AK6AJ:699:9I6M:H9J:7N67JN:G

JIDBD7>A:H6C9>IH8DBEDC:CIH 6C9HE6G:E6GIH "DD9HDGH:GK>8:HEJG8=6H:9;DGE:GHDC6ADG:BEADN::HZ JH:6C9 "DD9HLDG@HDGH:GK>8:H>BEDGI:9DGEJG8=6H:9;DGHE:8>;>8EGD9J8I>DCEJGEDH:H


45/58

(&:/1:@5B1?

CJB7:G D; 1/ :M:BEI>DCH =6K: 7::C >CIGD9J8:9 DJIH>9: D; I=: A6L DC 1/ /=:H: 6G:I6G;>8 >C9JHIG>:H 6H L:AA 6H HE:8>;>8 EGD?:8IH L=>8= =6K: 7::C ;JC9:9 7N>CI:GC6I>DC6A>CHI>IJI>DCHHJ8=6HI=:2DGA96C@DG;DG:>


46/58

"$)&$!'%!!"$%!!

,"".#""4"2

;:@-/@-91? 00>1?? ;99A:5/-@5;:?

->;8E:8->71(6C6CI6C9 HHJG6C8:+6GIC:G6A:M:NM;:K:/6M>G:8IDGIH:C9B668=D>?6BIHBCEL88DB

A>011G:8IDGCI6A(6G@:I6C9:6AH':69:G

?D=6CC6M86K:BCEL88DB

-E->9---B--

"$#"!"!'!$%

;80.--@->!/45>?A>1:J9>I6C9 HHJG6C8:(6C6GHJG:CBCEL88DB

+G>8:L6I:G=DJH:DDE:GHJ9>I'':CIG6A/DL:GI= ;ADDG.J>I:.J@=766I6G.FJ6G: .0A66C766I6G(DC6

(6>CD;;>8:CJB7:GH/:A!6M


47/58

""* "$2/&$/./-*$.%*$"4/23/'/.(/,*"

"3>;C@4

:28-@5;:

";85/E>-@1;21:@>-8-:7 E:G 6CCJB

>;??;225/5-85:@8>1?1>B1? 0. BA%JC:

;A:@>E>-@5:3 .+ W (6G8=!>I8= W (6G8=

A>>1:/E (DC6C/J@ ()/

D/4-:31>-@1 ()/ 0.J


48/58

""* W *03'/253*.&33 *3*4/23

*3"3

(DC6G:FJ>G:HK>H6IDIG6K:AIDI=:8DJCIGNL>I=6;:L:M8:EI>DCH>C8AJ9>CI:9.I6I:H6C9H:K:G6AH>6C8DJCIG>:H2=>A:I=:G:6G:6K6G>:IND;K>H6HI=:6EEA>86I>DCEGD8:HH>HI::6HNEEA>86I>DC86CI6@:EA68:6I6CN(DC6C:B76HHNLDGA9L>9:6C9CDIC:8:HH6G>AN>CI=:=DB:8DJCIGND;I=:6EEA>86CI/=:6EEA>86I>DC6I6C:B76HHNC:HH96NH(DC6C:B76HH>:H9DCDI;DAADLHI6C96G9EGD8:9JG:6C9D;I:C=6K:I=:>GDLCGJA:H6C9G:DCHD;I:CG:FJ>G>C;;:G:CIE6E:GLDG@6C9>HHJ>CH6H;DG9>;;:G:CII:GBH!DG:M6BEA:L=>A:HDB::B76HH>:HB6NDCAN>HHJ:H>CH6HDI=:GH L>AA >HHJ: N:6GADCEA::CIGN LDG@ K>H6H .>CH6H 6G: 6EEGDM>B6I:AN0.L=>A:N:6GADCH6H6G:6EEGDM>B6I:AN0.CI=>H;::HIGJ8IJG:K6G>:H;GDB:B76HHNID:B76HHN!DG:M68I9:I6>AH>I>H69K>H:9ID8DCI68INDJGAD86A(DC6C:B76HHN

/G6CH>IK>H6H6G:C:8:HH6GN;DGE6HH:CCCI=GDJC< IDI=:(DC6C'6LDCI=:':I>O:CH7JI6HE:8>;>8I>B:E:G>D9>HCDIK:C+6HH:CC6>CI:GC6I>DC6A;A>I(DC6;DG6E:G>D9D;=DJGHL>I=DJI6K>H6

88DG9>CDC D;;>8>6AH >I >H EDHH>7A: ID D7I6>C 6 K>H6 DC 6GG>K6A >; I=: IG6K:A:GZH=DB:8DJCIGN9D:HCDI=6K:6(DC6C:B76HHNDG8DCHJA6I:/=>H>HDCANI=:86H:;DG6IDJG>HIDG67JH>C:HHK>H66C9CDI6EEA>867A:IDLDG@K>H6H+G>DG6EEGDK6ABJHI7:D7I6>C:9;GDBI=:$BB>DC*;;>8:>C0A66C766I6GL=>8=L>AAI=:CH:C96C6EEGDK6AA:II:GIDI=:6>GEDGI

2=:CD7I6>C>CH6 I=GDJCK>I6I>DC;GDB6 =DHI

DGO6I>DC >C (DC6 6 E6HHEDGI E=DIDH 6C9 I=: 8DBEA:I:9 6EEA>86I>DC ;DGB L=>8=H=DJA97: 6K6>A67A:;GDBI=::B76HHN6G:JHJ6AANG:FJ>G:9+6HHEDGIHH=DJA97:K6A>9;DG6IA:6HII=G::BDCI=H;GDBI=::C9D;I=:K>H6E:G>D90EDCG:8:>EID;I=:K>H68DC;>GBI=6II=:96I:H>CI=:K>H66G:8DGG:8I6C98DK:GI=:E:G>D9D;HI6N

2"6&,

!>K: 6>GA>C:H;ANID=>CDC6A>GEDGI>C0A66C766I6G 6C9IDIN ID ;AN ID 6C9 ;GDB (DC6 DC :K:GN 96N D; I=: L::@ !A>


49/58

/LD C6I>DC6A 6>G 86GG>:GH OC>H >GL6NH 6C9 :GD (DC6 DE:G6I: 9DB:HI>8 ;A>C(DC6 6H L:AA 6H C:6G 9:HI>C6I>DCH HJ8= 6H 0A6C09: >C -JHH>6 6C9 #J= #DI >C $CC:G(DC6=>C6

534/-3

JGG:CIAN 8JHIDBH 9:8A6G6I>DCH 6G: G:FJ>G:9 >; >I:BH ID 7: 9:8A6G:9 :M8::9 0. 6C9DGBDG:I=6C0.>C86H=L=>8=BJHI7:688DBE6C>:97N8DC;>GB6I>DC;GDBI=:IG6K:A:GZH 76C@>CCHI>IJI>DC 8DC;>GB>CI=9G6LC ;GDB I=: 76C@ /=:8JHIDBH9:8A6G6I>DC9:H8G>7:HI=:8JGG:C8N6C96BDJCID;BDC:NK6AJ67A:H6C9DI=:G>I:BH

7:>CBEDGI:9$;68JHIDBH9:8A6G6I>DC>HHJ7B>II:97DI=;DGBHLDJA97:HI6BE:96C9DC:

L>AA7:G:IJGC:9/=:DC:I=6I>H G:IJGC:9BJHI7:HJ7B>II:9JEDC9:E6GIJG: ;GDB(DC6IDI=69:E6GIJG:9:8A6G6I>DC/=:9:E6GIJG:9:8A6G6I>DC6CG:FJ:HIH>C;DGB6I>DC8DC8:GC>CC86AANI=: 6JI=DG>I>:HH::@ID8DC;>GBI=6IK6AJ67A:HL:G:CDIHDA96C9I=6I BDG:BDC:N>HCDI7:>CK>9J6AH6G:CDIE:GB>II:9IDI6@:BDG:I=6C0.86H=DJID;I=:8DJCIGN

&(*342"4*/.

2>I=>CH:K:C96NHD; 6GG>K6A>C(DC6>C8AJ9>CI=I=:$BB>DC*;;>8:>;I=:E:GHDCL>AAHI6N>C(DC6DK:G96NH!6>AJG:ID9DHDB6NG:HJAI>C6;>C:JEDC9:E6GIJG:D;JEID()//=:G:HIG6I>DCHI6BE>H96I:9;GDBI=:96I:D;G:HIG6I>DC:G:HIG6I>DC>HCDIC:8:HH6GN

5>85:1? 8534@?@;'8--:.--@->

($/(DC6C>GA>C:H !GDB

:>?>CC K>6 (DH8DL /=JGH96N .JC96N (6G8=

*8I /J:H96N JCI>A JA .:EI

(DH8DL/=JGH96N.JC96N(6G8=*8I

.:DJA96NH6L::@

/D@ND (DC96N /J:H96N 2:9C:H96N .6IJG96N 6C9

.JC96N JC9:G HJBB:G H8=:9JA: 9>G:8I ;A>96NJC9:GL>CI:GH8=:9JA:K>6.:DJA

*H6@6/J:H96N!G>96N%JA.:E

#DC96N6C9.JC96N

%JC *8I6AHDDC/=JGH96N

>G=>C6:>?>C< 96NH6L::@HJBB:GH8=:9JA:

&DG:6C>G.:DJA 96NH6L::@HJBB:GH8=:9JA:

/JG@>H=>GA>C: $HI6C7JA /J:H96N/=JGH96N6C9.6IJG96NHJBB:GH8=:9JA:


50/58

$$/--/%"4*/.3

/=:G: 6G: 6 CJB7:G D; 7JH>C:HH FJ6A>IN =DI:AH >C 0A66C766I6G /=: DGEDG6I: #DI:A&:BE>CH@> #DI:A&=6C+6A68:-6B696 6C9 =>CC I=:8:CIG: D; IDLC /=: 6N6CH6;>K:HI6G=DI:AH>IJ6I:9>C"DG@=>/:G:A?)6I>DC6A+6G@86@B;GDBI=:8>IN

+!!&

-6I:H0.>C8AJ9:1/G:6@;6HI>H>C8AJ9:9/:A!6M

'%+!&

-6I:H0. 1/>C8AJ9:9G:6@;6HI>H>C8AJ9:9/:A

%!&

-6I:H0./:A!6M

!$"!$&!&

-6I:H0.1/ >C8AJ9:9G:6@;6HI>H>C8AJ9:9/:A!6M

"%!&"

-6I:H0.1/ >C8AJ9:9G:6@;6HI>H>C8AJ9:9/:A!6M

$!&

-6I:H 0. 1/ >C8AJ9:9G:6@;6HI>H >C8AJ9:9/:A !6M

&$!&

-6I:H0.1/6C9.:GK>8:8=6GHCDI>C8AJ9:9+=DC:!6MB6>AG:H:GK6I>DCI:G:A?=DI:A8DB


51/58

'&$!&

-6I:H0.1/ >C8AJ9:9G:6@;6HI>H>C8AJ9:9/:A !6M

,"".#""4"2

0A66C766I6G>HI=:86E>I6A6C9A6GINL>I=6EDEJA6I>DCD;DK:GDC:B>AA>DC'D86I:9>CI=: CDGI= 8:CIG6A E6GI D; I=: 8DJCIGN I=: 8>IN A>:H 6I 6C :A:K6I>DC D; 67DJI B:I:GH ;I>C6K6AA:NDCI=: /JJA->K:G$I>HI=:8JAIJG6A>C9JHIG>6A6C9;>C6C8>6A=:6GID;I=:8DJCIGN$I>H6AHDI=:8:CI:GD;(DC6HGD69C:ILDG@6C98DCC:8I:97NG6>AIDI=: /G6CH

.>7:G>6C-6>AL6N 6C9I=: =>C:H: G6>AL6NC:ILDG@

J:ID>IH=>DCG:A6I>K:AN=>IJ9:AD86I>DC=JC9G:9HD; @>ADB:IG:H ;GDB6CN8D6HI6C9I=::;;:8IHD;I=: .>7:G>6C6CI>8N8ADC:0A66C766I6G >HI=:8DA9:HIC6I>DC6A86E>I6A>CI=: LDGA9 L>I= 6 BDCHDDC>C;AJ:C8:9 HJ76G8I>8 H:B>6G>9 8A>B6I: &SEE:C 8A>B6I:8A6HH>;>86I>DC .@ L>I= 7G>:; L6GB HJBB:GH 6C9 ADCCI:GH+G:8>E>I6I>DC 6I 6C 6CCJ6A IDI6A D; B>AA>B:I:GH >C >H =:6K>AN 8DC8:CIG6I:9 >C I=:

L6GB:GBDCI=H$I=6H6C6K:G6EH>C 6C9DJIH>9: 0A66C766I6G L: G:8DBB:C9 7JH>C:HHIG6K:A:GH ID =>G: 6C :ME:G>:C8:9 6C9 G:A>67A: 9G>K:G L>I= 6 G:A>67A: 86G G>K:GH 6G: 6AHD 6

C:8:HH>IN;DG ;DG:>C:HHE:DEA: >C 0A66C766I6G6H 7JH>C:HH =DJGH>C (DC6 86C7:ADCB:H>GG:9:0A66C766I6G?::EHL>I=;DJGL=::A9G>K:6G:C:8:HH6GNH>C8:BDHID;8DJCIGNH>9:GD69H6G:CDIE6K:9G>K:GHL>I=86GH6G:BDHI:6H>AN6C9G:A>67AN=>G:9I=GDJCK>I>CDC1:GN;:L9G>K:GH HE:6@CH=DG6CNDI=:GL:HI:GCJGDE:6CA6CDCH6C9DC:H=DJA97:67A:ID8DBBJC>86I:L>I=DJI6IG6CHA6IDG

$I >H EDHH>7A: ID =>G: 6 86G L>I= 6 9G>K:G ;GDB .>MI (DC6 /:A !6M :CIG6A G6C8= =>CA >C;DH>MIBC-6I:HHI6GI;GDB0. 696N;DG6H=DGII:GBG:CI6A

.4&202&4&23

AI=DJC:HH E:DEA: 6C9 8>6AH >C (DC6 HE:6@ CH= I=:N8DC9J8I BDHIB::I>CC (DC6C$C 7JH>C:HH C:6I>DCH:K:C L>I=CH=HE:6@>CC:HH E:DEA: HDB:I>B:H ;>C9 6C >CI:GEG:I:G JH:;JA$CI:GEG:I:GH 8DJA9 7: 7:HI 6GG6CI>CDC /=: 8DHI >H6EEGDM>B6I:AN 0. E:G 96N *JIH>9: 0A66C766I6G ;:L (DC6CH HE:6@ 6 ;DG:>C:HH8A>B6I:>C(DC6B::I>CHHJ:H 7:8DB: :K:C BDG: JGCIB:CIHBDG:I=6CILD96NH>C 69K6C8:$;EDHH>7A:8DC;>GBI=:6EED>CIB:CI6C=DJG

7:;DG:6GG>K6A


52/58

/2+*.( /523

.I6C96G9LDG@>CC:IDH>M;>K:96NH6L::@L>I=BDHIE:DEA:LDG@>CA:BDHI6G:6AHDDE:CDC.JC96N(DHID;;>8:H8ADH:;DG6C =DJG DGHD 9JG>CCB:

522&.$9

(DC6=6H6 86H= 6C9>C8G:6H>CI :8DCDBN+A6CID =6K:86H=/J@>C I=::K:CII=6INDJG8G:9>I86G99D:HCDILDG@6II=:G:HI6JG6CI DGH=DE

/=:G:6G:B6CN;DG:>IB6N7:BDG:G:A>67A:IDJH:I=:76C@HDGI=:=DI:AHL=:G:EDHH>7A:H>C8:G6I:H6C9H:8JG>INB:6HJG:HK6GN68GDHHI=:8DJCIGN2=:C

8=6CC9:96H BDHIEA68:H688:EIDCAN7>AAH>CI>DC

JIDB6I:9 I:AA:G B68=>C:H /(H 86C CDL 7: ;DJC9 >C BDG: 6C9 BDG: EA68:H >C0A66C766I6G/(HINE>86AAN9>HE:CH:AD86A8JGG:C8N6C9JHJ6AAND;;:G6G:6HDC67A::M8=6C


53/58

2=>A:>C 686G 8DCH>9:GAD8@>CCC9DLH 8ADH:9:K:C>;I:BE:G6IJG:H6G:=>99G>K>C6AAN>C9:H:GI:96G:6HAL6NH

7: 6A:GI >C EJ7A>8 EA68:H $; NDJ 6G: JC8DB;DGI67A: DG HJHE>8>DJH D; I=: H>IJ6I>DC 9D CDI=:H>I6I:ID6AI:GNDJGEA6CHDGGDJI:

2"%*4*/.3

(DC6 >H 6 ;6H8>C6I>CI= 6 9::E 6C9 K6G>:9 8JAIJG: /=: (DC9:G:9 ID 7: DC: D; I=: ;DJC9>C:CI 8>K>A>O6I>DCH D; I=: LDGA9 6C9 B6CN D; I=:IG69>I>DCH8JHIDBH6C9:I>FJ:II:IGJ:6II=:I>B:D;":CAAIGJ:ID96NH

L>I=6CNDI=:G8>K>A>O6I>DCH8JHIDBH6C97:A>:;H6G:9>;;:G:CII=6C>CDI=:GE6GIHD;I=:LDGA9>I>H69K>H67A:I=6I6H6K>H>IDGID(DC6NDJ67>9:DG6IA:6HIIGNIDJC9:GHI6C9I=:AD86A8JHIDBHIG69>I>DCH6C97:A>:;HHDI=6INDJB6N7:II:GJC9:GHI6C9I=:8DJCIGN6H6L=DA:/=:IG69>I>DCH6C97:A>:;HD;I=:(DC6C+:DEA:6G:;6GIDDCJB:GDJHIDA>HI6AA>C=:G:7JI=:G:

HDB:HJI=H(DC6CH6G:IDA:G6CI6C9;G>:C9ANE:DEA:I=:NL>AACDI:ME:8INDJID7:;6B>A>6GL>I=6AAI=:>G8JHIDBH

(DC6CH 6G: H:CH>I>K: ID DJIL6G9 6EE:6G6C8: 6C9 C:6I 6EE:6G6C8: >H BJ8=6EEG:8>6I:9 /=>H 86C D; 8DJGH: 7: EGD7A:B6I>8 >; NDJ =6K: IG6K:AA:9 DK:G =JHI6C8:H6C96G:;::A>CIIA:9G6>C:97JI>I>HLDGI=G:B:B7:G>CC6AANCDB69H=DHE>I6A>IN>HH::C6H:MIG:B:AN>BEDGI6CI6C9I=:G:6G:HDB:ED>CIHIDG:B:B7:G>C8DCC:8I>DCL>I=I=>H/=:;>GHI8DC8:GCH;DD96C99G>C@2=:CNDJ6G:D;;:G:9HDB:I=>CC@6AL6NH688:EI$;>CG:6A>INNDJ6G:CDI@::CDC:6I>CC@>C8JA6GI=>C77A:DGH>E I=:C EJI >I9DLC$I >H 8DCH>9:G:9 GJ9: IDG:;JH: DJIG>B>A6GAN IGN CDIIDH=DL6CNC:K:;::A>C;L=6I=6H7::CD;;:G:9>HCDIIDNDJGI6HI:/=>H6AHD6EEA>:HID7:>CEHL>AAHJ;;>8:>;NDJ

9DCDIL6CIID9G>C@

: 86G:;JA L=:C K>H>I>CGIG69>I>DCH6C9I=:G:6G:B6CNIG69>I>DCH8DC8:GC>C< (&23/GN ID;6B>A>6G>H:NDJGH:A;

L>I=HDB:D;I=:H:IG69>I>DCH/=:;>GHID;I=:H:>HI=6I>I>H8DCH>9:G:9JCAJ8@NIDHI:EDCI=:9DDGHI:ED;I=:9DDG;G6B:IDI=:HI=6IG:EA68:DC:CI:G>CAA>C9>86I:6HJ>I67A:EA68:IDH>I$;NDJ=6K:G:CI:9NDJGDLCH=

442"$4*/.3

K:CI=DJC:HH>C(DC686C7:I>B:8DCHJB>CCIN#:G:6G:HDB:>9:6H;DG0A66C766I6G

/."34&2*&3

BDC:H>H I=:=D>?>C '6B6(DC6HI:GN 6J99=>HI BDC6HI:GNI=6IL6H8DBEA:I:9>C$I:H86E:9I=:9:HIGJ8I>DCD;(DC6CBDC6HI:G>:HL=:C>IL6HIJGC:9 >CID 6 BJH:JB >C CDI=:G >HI=:"6C96C (DC6HI:GN L=>8=96I:HID I=: I=8:CIJGN $IHBDHI;6BDJH 6IIG68I>DC>H 6 B:I:G=>


54/58

L6H A6I:G 8GDLC:9 DC >BE:G>6A G:H>9:C8:H L=>8= L:G: AD86I:97:IL::CI=:(>99A:JC9K:GH/=:HJBB:GE6A68:L6H86AA:9G9B>>C96A6>7JN6C 8=JJA H:GUUC DG9 *I=:G E6A68:H L:G: I=: 2=>I: E6A68:/H6HEA6NH 6 8DBEG:=:CH>K: 8DAA:8I>DC D; 8DBEA:M LDD9:C IDNH ID 7:6HH:B7A:97NEA6N:GHJH>CHI>86I:9B:I=D9H

0&2" /53&

/=:0A66C766I6G*E:G6#DJH:H>IJ6I:9>CI=:8:CI:GD;I=:8>IN=DHIH8DC8:GIH6C9BJH>86AE:G;DGB6C8:H

5+)#""4"215"2&

.J@=766I6G .FJ6G: >C I=:HIG>8I >H I=:8:CI:G D; 0A66C766I6G /=:HFJ6G: >H HFJ6G: B:I:GH >C H>O: $C I=: B>99A: D; .U@=766I6G .FJ6G: I=:G: >H 6 HI6IJ: D;6B9>C>> .J@=766I6G DC =DGH:768@ /=: HEDI L6H 8=DH:C 7:86JH: I=6I L6H L=:G:.J@=766I6GH=DGH:=69JG>C6I:96CH I=: (DC6C +6GA>6B:CI 7J>A9>CCDC6A.EDGIH.I69>JB>HI=:B6>CHEDGI>CK6A>H=:A9=:G::K:GN%JAN


55/58

522/5.%*.(3

"DG@=>/:G:A?)6I>DC6A+6G@6C6IJG:EG:H:GK:L>I=B6CNIDJG>HI;68>A>I>:H>H 6EEGDM>B6I:AN@B;GDB0A66C766I6G6C9688:HH>7A:K>6E6K:9GD69.@N-:HDGI(DC6H;>GHI9:9>86I:9H@>6G:6>HAD86I:9@BB>;GDB0A6C6IDG6C9DE:C:9>C/=:G:HDGI=6HGJCHD;K6GN>C;;>8JAIN 6C9 A>;IH$I>H AD86I:9DCD


56/58

""* W "8"4&3

& ;DGI=:;>GHI7>AA>DC()/0.B6EEGDMI=:G:6;I:G;DG>CK:HIB:CI>C8DB:GDN6AI>:H9>K>9:C9H>CI:G:HI

16GN>C;>8INE:HD;>C8DB:

&-D 11/5-@5;: .IG6>C:DK:GJH:;JA:8DCDB>8A>;: IDN:6GH

)5@44;805:3&-D -:H>9:CIH)DCG:H>9:CIH

"1>?;:-8:/;91&-D

16GN>C;>8INE:HD;>C8DB:

(&

99;B-.81">;@E&-D ;GDB%6CJ6GN


57/58

""* W /5#,&"82&"4*&3

JGG:CI

JHIG>6:AJBJA66C696=>C6+-O:8=-:EJ7A>8!G6C8:":GB6CN

#JC6$C9DC:H>6&6O6@=HI6C&DG:6-*&&JL6>I&NG6/=6>A6C9


58/58

66626))1//0

doing business in mongolia

Documents