dopson et al (2013) health care managers' access & use of management research.pdf

8/14/2019 Dopson et al (2013) Health care managers' access & use of management research.pdf

1/242

National Institute for Health Research

Service Delivery and Organisation Programme

Queens Printer and Controller of HMSO 2013. This work was produced by "#$%#& !"

$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


2/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;?'

6$240/(+%./* %040$7$+0,

X-2% )#1(.*&, 2% 0& #(,$(, /+#. 0 +*%*0+1- $+#:*1, ,-0, K0% /(&)*) 45 ,-* ]B7^ 6*+O21*"*82O*+5 0&) R+30&2%0,2#& A6"RC $+#3+0..* 40%*) 0, ,-* ]0,2#&08 B&%,2,(,* /#+ 7*08,-^*%*0+1- JO08(0,2#&%D X+208% 0&) 6,()2*% E##+)2&0,2&3 E*&,+* A]JX6EEC 0, ,-* Q&2O*+%2,5#/ 6#(,-0.$,#&' X-* .0&03*.*&, #/ ,-* $+#:*1, 0&) %(4%*`(*&, *)2,#+208 +*O2*K #/ ,-*/2&08 +*$#+, K0% (&)*+,0W*& 45 ,-* ]B7^ 6*+O21* "*82O*+5 0&) R+30&2%0,2#& A6"RC$+#3+0..*' H+#. M0&(0+5 ?;>?D ,-* ]B7^ 6"R $+#3+0..* .*+3*) K2,- ,-* ]B7^7*08,- 6*+O21*% ^*%*0+1- A]B7^ 76^C $+#3+0..* ,# *%,0482%- ,-* &*K ]B7^ 7*08,-6*+O21*% 0&) "*82O*+5 ^*%*0+1- A]B7^ 76a"^C $+#3+0..*' 6-#(8) 5#( -0O* 0&5 `(*+2*%$8*0%* 1#&,01,%)#*)2,\%#(,-0.$,#&'01'(W'

8(*9#/:.0 /+'(#740/(+,

X-2% +*$#+, .05 4* /+**85 +*$+#)(1*) /#+ ,-* $(+$#%*% #/ $+2O0,* +*%*0+1- 0&) %,()5 0&)

*S,+01,% A#+ 2&)**)D ,-* /(88 +*$#+,C .05 4* 2&18()*) 2& $+#/*%%2#&08 :#(+&08% $+#O2)*)

,-0, %(2,048* 01WK8*)3*.*&, 2% .0)* 0&) ,-* +*$+#)(1,2#& 2% , 0%%#120,*) K2,- 0&5

/#+. #/ 0)O*+,2%2&3' b$$8210,2#&% /#+ 1#..*+1208 +*$+#)(1,2#& %-#(8) 4* 0))+*%%*) ,#[

]JX6EED 76a"^'

]0,2#&08 B&%,2,(,* /#+ 7*08,- ^*%*0+1-

JO08(0,2#&D X+208% 0&) 6,()2*% E##+)2&0,2&3 E*&,+*

Q&2O*+%2,5 #/ 6#(,-0.$,#&

b8$-0 7#(%*D J&,*+$+2%* ^#0)

6#(,-0.$,#& 6R>c d]6

;/%)24/7$#,

X-2% +*$#+, $+*%*&,% 2&)*$*&)*&, +*%*0+1- /(&)*) 45 ,-* ]0,2#&08 B&%,2,(,* /#+ 7*08,-^*%*0+1- A]B7^C' X-* O2*K% *S$+*%%*) 0+* ,-#%* #/ ,-* 0(,-#+% 0&) , &*1*%%0+285,-#%* #/ ,-* ]76D ,-* ]B7^ #+ ,-* "*$0+,.*&, #/ 7*08,-' B/ ,-*+* 0+* O*+40,2.`(#,0,2#&% 2&18()*) 2& ,-2% $(48210,2#& ,-* O2*K% 0&) #$2&2#&% *S$+*%%*) 45 ,-*2&,*+O2*K**% 0+* ,-#%* #/ ,-* 2&,*+O2*K**% 0&) , &*1*%%0+285 ,-#%* #/ ,-* ]76D ,-*]B7^ #+ ,-* "*$0+,.*&, #/ 7*08,-'
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]


3/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


4/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;;

N8#%%0+5 #/ ,*+.%=044+*O20,2#&% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' >;

b1WK8*)3*.*&,% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' >f

JS*1(,2O* 6(..0+5 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' >c

> B&,+#)(1,2#& ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ?>

? G2,*+0,(+* )#.02&% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ?f

?'> RO*+O2*K ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ?f

?'? X-* (,282%0,2#& #/ .0&03*.*&, +*%*0+1-[ JFL3, 0&) 2,% 1+2,21% '''''''''''' ?f

?'?'> JFL3, 0&) -*08,-10+* '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ?c

?'?'? TK8*)3* /+03.*&,0,2#& 0&) %5%,*.0,21 +*O2*K% ''''''''''''''''''''''' ?d

?'?'P X012, 0&) *S$8212, WK8*)3* ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ?e

?'?'@ E+2,212%.% #/ JFL3, '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' P>

?'P B&)2O2)(08 0&) 1#3&2,2O* 0$$+#01-*% ,# 8*0+&2&3 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' P>

?'P'> 9+01,21*g40%*) ,-*#+2*% #/ WK2&3 0&) 8*0+&2&3 2& #+30&2%0,2#&% ''' P@

?'P'? J$2%,*.21 1(8,(+*% 0&) WK8*)3* 4#(&)0+2*% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' Pd

?'@ 9#%%24282,2*% /#+ U$+01,21*g40%*) *O2)*&1*U 2& -*08,-10+* '''''''''''''''''''''' P E+2,212%.% #/ $+01,21*g40%*) 0$$+#01-*% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' Pe

?'f B&%,2,(,2#&%D $#K*+ 0&) -2*+0+1-2*% #/ WK8*)3* '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @;

?'f'> E82&2108 -54+2)% 2& -*08,-10+* .0&03*.*&, ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @?

?'c ^*/8*1,2#&% #& ,-2% 1-0$,*+ ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @@

P 6,()5 )*%23& 0&) .*,-#)% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @f

P'> h(082,0,2O* .*,-#)% 1#.$0+0,2O* 10%* %,()2*% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @f

P'? E0%* %,()5 0&) +*%$#&)*&, %*8*1,2#& ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @f

P'P "0,0 1#88*1,2#& '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @d

P'P'> 9-0%* > '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @d

P'P'? 9-0%* ? '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @d


5/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ; 0&) ? '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @e

P'c b1,2#& 8*0+&2&3 %*,% AbG6%C 9-0%* P ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @e

P'c'> 9(+$#%* '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @eP'c'? L*,-#)% 0&) $+#1*%%'''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' @e

P'c'P 90+,212$0&,% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' f;

P'c'@ b&085%2% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' f;

P'c'f 6($*+O2%2#& %$01* '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' f;

P'd H**)401W #$$#+,(&2,2*% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' f>

P''> TK8*)3* .0&03*.*&, %5%,*. ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' f@

@'>'? TK8*)3* 01,#+% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ff

@'>'P 723-823-,% #/ /2&)2&3% /+#. ,-* 10%* ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' ff

@'? J8.-#(%* K-0, W2&) #/ WK8*)3* #+30&2%0,2#& K0% ,-2%i '''''''''''''''' fc

@'?'> TK8*)3* .0&03*.*&, %5%,*. ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' fd

@'?'? TK8*)3* 01,#+% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' f

@'P'P 723-823-,% #/ /2&)2&3% /+#. ,-* 10%* ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' c?

@'@ L0$8*%-2+* g K-0, W2&) #/ WK8*)3* #+30&2%0,2#& K0% ,-2%i ''''''''''''''' cP

@'@'> TK8*)3* .0&03*.*&, %5%,*. ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' c@

@'@'? TK8*)3* 01,#+% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' cf

@'@'P 723-823-,% #/ /2&)2&3% /+#. ,-* 10%* ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' cf

@'f R0W.#+* K-0, W2&) #/ WK8*)3* #+30&2%0,2#& K0% ,-2%i ''''''''''''''''' cc


6/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;

@'c'P 723-823-,% #/ /2&)2&3% /+#. ,-* 10%* ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' d?

@'d 6(..0+5 ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' dP

f 7#K )# .0&03*+% 011*%% 0&) (%* .0&03*.*&, WK8*)3*i '''''''''''''''''''' d@

f'> B&,+#)(1,2#& ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' d@

f'? B&/8(*&1*% #& .0&03*.*&, $+01,21* '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' dcf'P X5$* #/ #+2*&,0,2#& ,#K0+)% WK8*)3* 82.2,%= 4#(&)0+2*% '''''''''''''''''' d 70&)82&3 0& 2%%(* #+ $(II8* ,# 4* %#8O*) ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' de

f'P'? R+30&2%0,2#&08 WK8*)3* 0% 1#.$*,2,2O* $+#)(1,2O2,5 ''''''''''''''''''


7/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;>f

c'P'P X-* +#8* #/ WK8*)3* 8*0)*+% 2& ,+0&%$#%2&3 .0&03*.*&,WK8*)3*% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>>d

c'P'@ H#+.0,2O* %$01*% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>>>e

c'@ E#&18(%2#&% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>>e

d b1,2#& 8*0+&2&3 0% 0& 02) ,# /01282,0,* WK8*)3* %-0+2&3 0&) WK8*)3*

(,282I0,2#& '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>?>d'> B&,+#)(1,2#& ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>?>

d'? R+2*&,0,2#&% ,# &*K .0&03*.*&, WK8*)3* 2& ,-* bG6 1#&,*S, ''''''''>??

d'P L0&2/*%,*) 0,,2,()*% ,# %-0+2&3 0&) 8*0+&2&3 2& 0 %*, ''''''''''''''''''''''''>?f

d'@ L0&03*.*&, WK8*)3*[ 2&,*+1-0&3*D 04%#+$,2#& 0&) ,+0&%$#%2,2#& '''>?d

d'@'> B&,*+1-0&3* 04%#+$,2#& 0&) ,+0&%$#%2,2#& ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>?d

d'@'? G#108 WK8*)3* 1#..(&2,2*% 0&) 1#..(&2,5 *S1-0&3* '''''''''''''>?P;

d'f'> V2,-2& %*, 2&,*+/01*% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>P;

d'f'? X-* U%($*+O2%2#&U %$01* ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>P>

d'c E#&18(%2#&% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>P>

Pf

Pe

@>

6,+(1,(+08 0823&.*&, '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>@>


8/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;@P

@@

@f

@c

e'> ^*,(+&2&3 ,# ,-* #+232&08 +*%*0+1- (*%,2#&% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>@c

e'>'> Q&)*+ K-0, 12+1(.%,0&1*% 0&) -#K )2) .0&03*+% 011*%% 0&) (%*.0&03*.*&, +*%*0+1- 40%*) WK8*)3* 2& ,-*2+ )*12%2#& .0W2&3i '''''''''''>@c

e'>'? V-0, K*+* ,-* 40++2*+% 0&) /01282,0,#+% #/ .0&03*.*&, WK8*)3*(%* 2& ,-* 1#&,*S,% %,()2*)i ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>@f>

e'? B.$8210,2#&% /#+ ,-*#+5 ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>f>

e'?'> H+#. .21+# ,# .21+#=.01+# ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>f?

e'?'? J$2%,*.21 /2, 0&) 180%- '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>fP

e'?'P ]#&82&*0+2,5 ,+0&%$#%2,2#& +0,-*+ ,-0& -23- /2)*82,5 2.$8*.*&,0,2#& >fP

e'?'@ b .#+* .#)*%, $+#:*1, /#+ JFL3,i ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>fP

e'P 9#8215 2.$8210,2#&% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>f@

e'@ B.$8210,2#&% /#+ -23-*+ *)(10,2#& 2&%,2,(,2#&% 0&) 4(%2&*%% %1-##8% '''''>ff

e'f B.$8210,2#&% /#+ -*08,- $+#/*%%2#&08%U *)(10,2#& g L0%,*+% 0&) 9-" 8*O*8,+02&2&3 '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>fc

e'c B.$8210,2#&% /#+ 1#..2%%2#&2&3 4#)2*%D EGb7^E%D b76E% 0&) #,-*+2&,*+.*)20+5 2&%,2,(,2#&% ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>fc

e'd 9+#.2%2&3 /(,(+* +*%*0+1- '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>fd

^*/*+*&1*% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>f


9/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ; 0&) 0& *S0.$8* #/9-0%* ? `(*%,2#&% '''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''>df

b$$*&)2S ? JS0.$8*% #/ B&/#+.0,2#& 6-**, 0&) E#&%*&, H#+. (%*) '''''''''''>>

b$$*&)2S e X-* .0&03*.*&, /*88#K +*$#+, ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''?>P


10/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ; B&/8(*&1*% #& .0&03*.*&, $+01,21* ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''dc

H23(+* ? B&/8(*&1*% #& .0&03*.*&, $+01,21* 45 #+30&2%0,2#&k ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''dd

H23(+* P 9-0%* ? ,+01*+ ,*S,% 0&) #+30&2%0,2#&08 2%%(*%=$(II8*% ,# 4* 0))+*%%*) '''''''e@

H23(+* @ E+#%% 10%* 0&085%2% #/ ,-* 9-0%* ? )0,0 ''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''''' >>>


11/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;

N8#%%0+5 #/ ,*+.%=044+*O20,2#&%

!33#$A/40/(+ -$#7 /+ '122


12/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


13/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


14/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


15/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;

=!55> 02=1?!5,D ;/D /2*8)K#+W 8*0) 2& #&* %2,*D K#+W #& b1,2#& 8*0+&2&3 %*,%D 1#&,+24(,2#&

,# 1+#%% 10%* 0&085%2%D K+2,2&3 #/ *.$2+2108 1-0$,*+% 0&) 1#..*&,2&3 #& )+0/,% #/ ,-*/2&08 +*$#+,'

@A$, 4!5%1!- ;/- 1#&,+24(,2#& ,# ,K# /2*8)K#+W %2,*%D 1+#%% 10%* 0&085%2% 0&) 1#..*&,2&3

#& )+0/,% #/ ,-* /2&08 +*$#+,'

:$,!""! 02;'%%)23D #(+ .0&03*.*&, /*88#KD 1#&,+24(,2#& ,# 1+#%% 10%* 0&085%2% D 01,2#&

8*0+&2&3 %*, K#+WD 1#..*&,% #& /2&08 +*$#+, 0&) ,-* .0&03*.*&, /*88#K +*$#+,'


16/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;' B) !C*%)5! 3!$%"32$5! D$,$8!5+E )A, 5!+*),+!+ ") "3! 5!+!$523F'!+"1),G H',9!5 A3$" 2152'D+"$,2!+ $,9 3)A 9) D$,$8!5+ $22!++ $,9'+! D$,$8!D!," 5!+!$523IJ$+!9 K,)A%!98! 1, "3!15 9!21+1), D$K1,8LHMB& #+)*+ ,# %2,(0,* ,-* *&`(2+5 2& ,*+.% #/ .0&03*+%U )05 ,# )05


17/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


18/242


19/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


20/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


21/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;C' 7#K*O*+D 2, .05 4* 0+3(*) ,-0,-*08,-10+* .0&03*+%U .#,2O0,2#& 0&) 04282,5 ,# 011*%% 0&) (%* .0&03*.*&,+*%*0+1- .05 A(&)*+ %#.* 12+1(.%,0&1*%C 4* 2&1+*0%2&3 /+#. -2%,#+2108858#K 8*O*8%D )(* ,# ,-* $+#/*%%2#&082%0,2#& #/ .0&03*.*&, 0&) 0 )*O*8#$2&3-23-g`(082,5 WK8*)3*g40%*' X-2% +*%*0+1- $+#:*1, %#(3-, ,# 2&O*%,230,*,-* $#%%24282,5 ,-0, $+*O2#(% /2&)2&3% 0+* K )0,*) 0&) ,-0, 0 4*,,*+)*O*8#$*) +*%*0+1- 40%* 0&) 1(8,(+* 2% K *.*+32&3 K2,-2& -*08,-10+*.0&03*.*&,'

X-2% 4+#0) 2)*0 K0% #$*+0,2#&082%*) 2&,# ,-* /#88#K2&3 +*%*0+1- `(*%,2#&[

HT,9!5 A3$" 2152'D+"$,2!+ $,9 3)A 9) D$,$8!5+ PJ)"3 8!,!5$% D$,$8!5+$,9 3>J519 2%1,12$% D$,$8!5+R $22!++ $,9 '+! D$,$8!D!," 5!+!$523IJ$+!9K,)A%!98! 1, "3!15 9!21+1),ID$K1,8LH

X-* ,-+** $-0%* +*%*0+1- )*%23& A)2%1(%%*) 2& )*$,- 2& E-0$,*+ PC (%*).2S*) .*,-#)% 0&) )*824*+0,*85 2&O*%,230,*) ,-* 4#(&)0+5 4*,K**&.0&03*.*&, +*%*0+1- 0&) $+01,21*' E#+* ,# ,-* )*%23& K0% *S$8#+2&3 ,-*01`(2%2,2#& 0&) (,282%0,2#& #/ WK8*)3* /+#. ,-* /2*8) #/.0&03*.*&,=#+30&2%0,2#& %,()2*% 2& 0 K2)* )2O*+%2,5 #/ -*08,- +*80,*)%*,,2&3%' X-*%* K*+* $(+$#%2O*85 %*8*1,*) /#+ ,-*2+ %23&2/210&1* ,# /01*,% #/$+#1*%%*% #/ WK8*)3* $+#)(1,2#& 0&) (,282%0,2#& 2& 0 ?>%,1*&,(+5 -*08,-WK8*)3* *1#.5 K-21- -0% 4*1#.* .#+* )2O*+%* 0&) .(8,2g805*+*) 0&),# *S$8#+* ,-* 82&W% 4*,K**& 2&)2O2)(08 .#,2O0,2#&D 8*0+&2&3 0&) 01,2#&'

"*%$2,* .(1- K#+W #& -#K 182&2120&% (%* 0&) *&01, 182&2108 +*%*0+1- K-21-

2% K K*88 WK&D ,-*+* 2% 8*%% #& -*08,-10+* .0&03*+%U (%* #/.0&03*.*&, +*%*0+1-0&) -#K ,-2% .23-, 4* *O#8O2&3' J0+82*+ K#+W 45%#.* #/ ,-* 0(,-#+% #/ ,-2% +*$#+, 1#&18()*) ,-0, -*08,-10+* .0&03*.*&,K0% 80+3*85 2&O2%248* 2& ,-* JO2)*&1* F0%*) L*)212&* AJFLC 0+*&0 A>D ?C'7*08,-10+* .0&03*+% .05 -0O* 4*1#.* .#+* 2&,*+*%,*) 2& *O2)*&1*g40%*)3(2)*82&*% A*'3' ]0,2#&08 6*+O21* H+0.*K#+W%CD 4(, 0 +*1*&, %,()5 APC /#(&).0&03*+% K*+* .#,2O0,*) ,# .**, ,0+3*,% +0,-*+ ,-0& ,# +*0) #+ U#K&U+*%*0+1-' 6# ,-* 40%*82&* 2% #&* #/ O*+5 82.2,*) *&303*.*&, #/ -*08,-10+*.0&03*+% K2,- +*%*0+1-' X-* $##+ ($,0W* #/ .0&03*.*&, +*%*0+1- 45$+01,2,2#&*+% 10& 4* 0,,+24(,*) ,# &(.*+#(% /01,#+%[ )2//*+*&1*% 4*,K**&


22/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;?C #+ U-0+) /01,%U A>PC' b11#+)2&3 ,# %#.*010)*.21 K+2,*+%D ,-* ,*&)*&15 2% /#+ .0&03*+% A0&) ,# %#.* *S,*&,D+*%*0+1-*+%C ,# /#88#K .0&03*.*&, U/0)%U 0&) U/0%-2#&%U A>@D >fC K2,-#+30&2%0,2#&% 0)#$,2&3 #+ 2.2,0,2&3 .0&03*.*&, ,*1-&2`(*% ,-0, 0+* ,&*1*%%0+285 *//*1,2O*'

V-5 .23-, ,-2% )*$+*%%2&3 $21,(+* 1-0&3*i X-* 4+#0)*+ 1#&,*S, 2% #&* #/ 0O*+5 %23&2/210&, *S$0&%2#& #/ .0&03*.*&, *)(10,2#& 3*&*+0885 #O*+ ,-* 80%,,K*&,5 5*0+% K-21- -0% 4**& 1-0+01,*+2%*) 45 0 3+#K2&3 &(.4*+ g 0&)O0+2*,5 #/ .0&03*.*&, $+#3+0.% 0&) -23-*+ *&+#8.*&,% A>cC' F(%2&*%%61-##8% K 011#(&, /#+ 04#(, #&* %*O*&,- #/ 088 %,()*&,% 2& QT 723-*+J)(10,2#& A2& ?;;e=>;D %** >dC' X-* +2%* #/ ,-* F(%2&*%% 61-##8 2% 0,*K#+,-5 /*0,(+* #/ QT 723-*+ J)(10,2#&' X-* bF6 K*4 %2,* A>dC 82%,%#O*+ >;; .*.4*+ 61-##8%D *O*& ,-#(3- ,-* /2+%, ,K# 61-##8% AG#&)#& 0&)L0&1-*%,*+C K*+* /#(&)*) 0% +*1*&,85 0% >ecf' b% $0+, #/ 0$+#/*%%2#&082%0,2#& $+#1*%% A>eC .0&03*+208 `(082/210,2#&% 0+* .#O2&3

,#K0+) 3+0)(0,* #+ *O*& $#%, 3+0)(0,* *)(10,2#& A?;C' X-* U+*.0+W048*+2%*U 2& 4(%2&*%% 0&) .0&03*.*&, *)(10,2#&D *%$*120885 ,-* *S$0&%2O* LFb.0+W*, #/ ,-* >eee;%D -0% 4**& 0,,+24(,*) ,# ,-* 4*82*/ ,-0, 04(%2&*%% )*3+** K288 %($$#+, U$ 85$9'$"!E+ !$5,1,8 *)A!5 $,9 2$5!!5*5)+*!2"+U A?>D bBL *%*0+1- ^*$#+,C' H0+ 8*%% 2% WK& 04#(, ,-*.#,2O0,2#&% #/ 0)(8, 8*0+&*+% K-# 1#.$8*,* 4(%2&*%% )*3+**% K-28%,*.$8#5*) 2& .0&03*.*&, 0&) ,-* 2.$01, ,-2% -0% #& ,-*2+ $+01,21*'

X-* *.$-0%2% #& *.$2+2108 +*%*0+1- 2& .0&5 QT F(%2&*%% 61-##8% -0% 4**&011*&,(0,*) 45 ,-* *//*1,% #/ ,-* +*%*0+1- 0%%*%%.*&, *S*+12%*%' X-*+* -0%4**& 0& *S$0&%2#& #/ $**+ +*O2*K*) 010)*.21 :#(+&08%D K2,- 0 -2*+0+1-5 #/*%,**. *.*+32&3 A0% 2& ,-* bF6 82%, #/ $**+ +0&W*) :#(+&08%C' X-* ,#$

.0&03*.*&, :#(+&08% 0+* K *S,+*.*85 1#.$*,2,2O* ,# $(482%- 2&D K2,-%#.* 1#.$802&,% ,-0, F(%2&*%% 61-##8% 0+* )2O#+12&3 ,-*.%*8O*% /+#. ,-*2++##,% 2& $+01,21* 0&) 4*1#.2&3 10$,(+*) 45 $+#/*%%2#&08 +*%*0+1-*+% A??C'X-*%* )*O*8#$.*&,% -0O* 2&,*&%2/2*) 0& #&3#2&3 )*40,* 04#(, ,-*+*8*O0&1*D +#8* 0&) 0$$82104282,5 #/ .0&03*.*&, 0&) #+30&2%0,2#&08 +*%*0+1-,# $+01,2,2#&*+%' 61-#80+% -23-823-, ,-* %,0+W )2O2%2#& ,-0, %*$0+0,*%010)*.21 0&) $+01,2,2#&*+ K#+8)% A?Pg?fC 0&) -0O* .0)* &(.*+#(%%(33*%,2#&% ,# 0.*82#+0,* ,-2% 30$' H#+ *S0.$8*D .2++#+2&3 ,-* *S$*+2*&1*#/ #,-*+ /2*8)%D %(1- 0% .*)212&* A?cD ?dCD *)(10,2#& A?


23/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;ee;%D 0&)0& 2&1+*0%2&3 *.$-0%2% #& ,-* *O2)*&1* 40%*) 182&2108 )*12%2#& .0W2&3 0%3##) $+01,21*D .23-, +*&)*+ -*08,-10+* %*,,2&3% $0+,21(80+85 +*1*$,2O* ,#JFL3, 0% 0& 2)*0 AP@D PfC' b, 0& 2&%,2,(,2#&08 8*O*8D N#O*+&.*&, $#8215 -0%8#&3 %,0,*) ,-* #4:*1,2O* #/ QT -*08,- $#8215 -0O2&3 0 U+21!,"1N12 J$+1+U APcC0&) 1+*0,2&3 U$ 5!+!$523I%!9 $,9 !?19!,2!IJ$+!9 UV&U APdC'

X-* *.*+3*&1* #/ 182&2108 .0&03*+208 -54+2) +#8*% A%(1- 0% E82&2108"2+*1,#+%C -0% 08%# 4**& %23&2/210&,' X-*%* +#8* -#8)*+% K*+* #+232&0885*)(10,*) 0% )#1,#+% 2& L*)2108 61-##8% K-*+* ,-*+* 2% 0 K*88 )*O*8#$*)42#.*)2108 +*%*0+1- 40%*D 4(, ,-*& 01`(2+*) 0 %*1#&) 2)*&,2,5 0% 0

.0&03*+' E82&2108 .0&03*+% 4*30& ,# )*O*8#$ ,-*2+ #K& 2&%,2,(,2#&% 0&):#(+&08%' B&O*%,230,2&3 ,-* U+*%*0+1- .2&)*)&*%%U #/ ,-*%* 182&2108.0&03*+208 -54+2)% 0% K*88 0% ]76 3*&*+08 .0&03*+% K0% 0 W*5 $0+, #/ ,-2%$+#:*1, 0&) 8*) ,# ,-* )*O*8#$.*&, #/ ,-* 1#&1*$, #/ ,-* UWK8*)3* 8*0)*+UD%#.*#&* (&(%(0885 2&,*+*%,*) 2& 0&) #/,*& `(2,* %W288*) 0, ,+0&%$#%2&3+*%*0+1-g40%*) ,*S,% 2&,# (%048* WK8*)3* 0&) K-#%* %,0,(% K2,-2& ,-*#+30&2%0,2#& K0% %(//212*&, ,# *&048* ,-0, ,# 4* 011*%%*) 0&) (%*) 45#,-*+%'

B& 0))2,2#&D 0 &*K 2&,*88*1,(08 )2%12$82&* #/ 7*08,- 6*+O21*% ^*%*0+1- A76^C-0% *.*+3*) K-21- 4+2&3% ,#3*,-*+ +*%*0+1-*+% /+#. .0&5 401W3+#(&)% 2&2&O*%,230,2&3 `(*%,2#&% #/ -*08,-10+* %*+O21* )*82O*+5D 2&18()2&3 %#.*182&2120&%' b K2)*+ +0&3* #/ &g,+0)2,2#&08 .*,-#)%D 2&18()2&3 01,2#&+*%*0+1- 0&) `(082,0,2O* K#+WD -0% 4**& *O2)*&, AP


24/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;C' X-2% $+#:*1, %**W%,# /288 ,-2% .0:#+ 801(&0'

X-* +*$#+, 2% #+30&2%*) 0% /#88#K%[

E-0$,*+ ? #(,82&*% 0 %(..0+5 #/ ,-* 82,*+0,(+* )#.02&% /#(&) (%*/(8'E-0$,*+ P $+*%*&,% ,-* +*%*0+1- )*%23&' E-0$,*+ @ $+#O2)*% 0 )*%1+2$,2#& #/,-* 10%* %,()5 %2,*% 0&) -23-823-,% #/ ,-* 10%*%' E-0$,*+% f ,# d 1*&,+* #&,-* +*%*0+1- `(*%,2#&%D &0.*85[

Q&)*+ K-0, 12+1(.%,0&1*%D 0&) -#KD )# .0&03*+% 011*%% 0&) (%*.0&03*.*&, WK8*)3*i AE-0$,*+ fC

V-0, 2% ,-* (%* #/ .0&03*.*&, WK8*)3* 2& 1#&,*S,i V-0,.0&03*.*&, WK8*)3*% -0O* ,-* 10%* %2,*% )*40,*)D (%*) #++*:*1,*) 0&) K-0, 10& 4* 8*0+&, /+#. *S$8#+2&3 ,-* +*80,2#&%-2$%4*,K**& %(1- WK8*)3*%i AE-0$,*+ cC

V-0, 2% ,-* O08(* #/ ,-* 01,2#& 8*0+&2&3 %*, AbG6C 0% 0 .*,-#) #/

%-0+2&3 +*%*0+1- 40%*) 8*0+&2&3 0&) #/ *&1#(+032&3 0&) /01282,0,2&3,-* ($,0W* 0&) (,282%0,2#& #/ +*%*0+1- 40%*) *O2)*&1*i AE-0$,*+ dC

E-0$,*+ < +*/8*1,% #& K-0, 0$$*0+% ,# 0%%2%, ,-* (%* #/ .0&03*.*&,WK8*)3* 01+#%% ,-* 10%*%' E-0$,*+ e $+*%*&,% %#.* 1#&18(%2#&%'


25/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


26/242


27/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;eeeD V08%-* 0&)

^(&)088 A>>C 12,* ,-* U)?!5'+!UD U',9!5'+!U 0&) UD1+'+!U #/ -*08,-10+*2&,*+O*&,2#&% 0% *S0.$8*% #/ $##+ .0&03*.*&, $+01,21* A/#+ *S0.$8*D ,-*#O*+(%* #/ -#%$2,08 .*+3*+%C' X-* 0(,-#+% #4%*+O* ,-0, ,-* 1(8,(+*% 0&)$+#/*%%2#&08 K#+8)% #/ 182&2120&% 0&) .0&03*+% 0+* O0%,85 )2//*+*&,D K2,--*08,-10+* .0&03*+% 82W*85 ,# -0O* )2O*+3*&, 10+**+ 401W3+#(&)% 0&)`(082/210,2#&%' X-2% ,-*5 $*+1*2O* 0% 0 $+#48*. /#+ JFL3, )*12%2#&g.0W2&34*10(%* -*08,-10+* .0&03*+% 0+* , $+*)2%$#%*) ,# (%2&3 +*%*0+1-*O2)*&1* 2& ,-* %0.* .0&&*+ 0% 182&2120&%' B& 0))2,2#&D U"3!5! 1+ ,)+*!21N1!9 N)5D$% J)9> )N K,)A%!98!U A$' @PeC 04#(, *//*1,2O* .0&03*.*&,,-0, -*08,-10+* .0&03*+% 10& 011*%% ,# 2.$+#O* ,-*2+ $+01,21*D *O*& 2/ ,-*5K0&, ,# A>>C' 62.280+85D T#O&*+ *, 08 APfC ,*) ,-* ,*&)*&15 /#+ 80+3*

-*08,-10+* #+30&2%0,2#&% ,# +*85 #& *S,*+&08 1#&%(8,0&,% /#+ U51+K1!5 +"5$"!8121,"!5?!,"1),+UD 4(, 0 1#&1#.2,0&, /028(+* 45 .0&03*+% ,# U518)5)'+%>23$%%!,8! "3! 1,N)5D$"1), '*), A3123 +'23 5!2)DD!,9$"1),+ $5! J$+!9U'

B&)**)D -*08,-10+* 2% $*+1*2O*) 0% ,-* 2)*08 *&O2+#&.*&, /#+ JFL3, 4*10(%*#/ ,-* /2*8)U% 2&-*+*&, 1#.$8*S2,5 0&) 1#++*%$#&)2&3 &**) /#+ 4*%, $+01,21*%#8(,2#&% 2& #+30&2%2&3 Ac;C' T#O&*+ 0&) (&)088 A@dC +*/*+ ,# U!?19!,2!J$+!9 3!$%"3 +!5?12!+ D$,$8!D!,"U AJF76LC 2& 0 %,+0,*321 %*&%*D )*/2&*)0%[

B3! +>+"!D$"12 $**%12$"1), )N "3! J!+" $?$1%$J%! !?19!,2! ") "3!!?$%'$"1), )N D$,$8!51$% +"5$"!81!+ N)5 1D*5)?1,8 "3! *!5N)5D$,2! )N3!$%"3 +!5?12!+ )58$,1+$"1),+MMM"3! 5!+!$523 !?19!,2! ),! '+!+ 1, @*!+ )N K,)A%!98! $,91,N)5D$"1),M

7#K*O*+D 2& 0 82,*+0,(+* +*O2*K #/ UN$9+- N$+31),+- $,9 J$,9A$8),+U 2&-*08,-10+* %,+0,*35D T02%%2 0&) F*3(& Ac>C /#(&) U,) !?19!,2! "3$" 1D1"$"1),+"5$"!81!+ $5! D)5! 2)DD), 1, 3!$%"3 2$5! "3$, 1, )"3!5 1,9'+"51!+U 0&)U%1""%! !?19!,2! ), "3! $**5)*51$"!,!++ )N 1D1"$"1), 1, "!5D+ )N 1"+*!5N)5D$,2! !NN!2"+MU ]*O*+,-*8*%%D ,-* 2&,*3+0,2#& #/ JFL3, K2,- JFL 2%O2*K*) 0% 0 $+#.2%2&3 .*0&% ,# 2.$+#O* ,-* $*+/#+.0&1* #/ -*08,-10+*#+30&2%0,2#&% Ac?C'

E@E@E H+(52$":$ '#4:7$+040/(+ 4+" %9%0$740/) #$A/$5%

X-* /+03.*&,0,2#& 0&) $8(+082,5 #/ WK8*)3* ,-0, 2% /#(&) 2& .0&03*.*&,0&) #+30&2%0,2#& %,()2*% 2% $*+1*2O*) 0% 0 /(&)0.*&,08 )2//21(8,5 ,# +*082%2&3JFL3, AcPD @eC' X-2% 08%# 0$$82*% ,# %(4g)2%12$82&*%D %(1- 0% 2&)(%,+208g#+30&2%0,2#&08 $%51-#8#35 0&) -(.0& +*%#(+1* .0&03*.*&, A7^CD K-*+*U"3! J!+" $?$1%$J%! !C"!5,$% !?19!,2!U #& +*%*0+1- ,#$21% 2% (&82W*85 ,# 4*011*%%248* ,# $+01,2,2#&*+% #+ #4O2#(% ,# +*%*0+1-*+% AfeD >;C' JFL3,%($$#+,*+% 1#&,*&) ,-0, %5%,*.0,21 +*O2*K% #/ +*%*0+1- *O2)*&1* 0+* 0


28/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;9!?!%)*D!," $+ A!%% $+ "3! "!$231,8 $,9 *5$2"12! )N !?19!,2!IJ$+!9D$,$8!D!,"ME

65%,*.0,21 +*O2*K% U!C*)+! +"'91!+ ") 518)5)'+ D!"3)9)%)812$% +25'"1,>U 0&)$+#.#,* ,-* )*O*8#$.*&, #/ 0 +*82048* WK8*)3* 40%* Ac@C' 7#K*O*+D,-*+* 0+* )#(4,% 04#(, ,-* $#%%24282,5 #/ 0& *`(2O08*&, .*,-#)#8#35 4*2&30$$82*) ,# .0&03*.*&, +*%*0+1- 32O*& ,-0, /*K ^EXg,5$* %,()2*% *S2%,' b%X+0&/2*8) *, 08 Ac@C K+2,*[

/" 1+ ',%1K!%> "3$" $885!8$"1?! $**5)$23!+ ") 5!+!$523 +>,"3!+1+- +'23 $+

D!"$I$,$%>+1+ A1%% J! $**5)*51$"! 1, D$,$8!D!," 5!+!$523 $+ "3!3!"!5)8!,!1"> )N +"'91!+ *5!?!,"+ "3! *))%1,8 )N 5!+'%"+ $,9 "3!D!$+'5!D!," )N "3! ,!" !NN!2"1?!,!++ )N 1,"!5?!,"1),+M

L0&03*.*&, 0&) #+30&2%0,2#&08 WK8*)3* 2% #/,*& *`(2O#108 Afd[ $'>cCK2,- +*%*0+1- )+0K2&3 ($#& )2//*+*&, $0+0)23.% ,-0, 0+* , &*1*%%0+2851#..*&%(+048* AcfD ccC' V-28%, JFL3, 0)O#10,*% +*.02& #$,2.2%,21 ,-0, 0%5%,*.0,21 0$$+#01- ,# WK8*)3* %5&,-*%2% .#)*88*) #& .*)212&* 2%/*0%248* 2& .0&03*.*&, %,()2*%D #,-*+ K+2,*+% AcPD cdD c,"3!+!+ 1, 0S& 5!+!$523 $5! J!+" $22)D*%1+3!9 '+1,8

$ 251"12$% 5!$%1+" !*1+"!D)%)8>M ;51"12$% 5!$%1+D $2K,)A%!98!+ "3$" $%%D!"3)9+ 3$?! %1D1"+MMM Z$"3!5 "3$, $9?)2$"! ),! D!"3)9 )?!5 $,)"3!5MMM 251"12$% 5!$%1+D D$K!+ +'23 $ 23)12! ',,!2!++$5>M /,+"!$9- 1"!D*3$+17!+ "51$,8'%$"1), $25)++ D!"3)9+ $,9 N)5D+ )N 9$"$M

B, &*O*+,-*8*%% +*.02&% ,-* 10%* ,-0, 2& 0)O#10,2&3 0& JFL3, 0$$+#01-D*O*& /+#. 0 +*082%, *$2%,*.#8#35D K+2,*+% %(1- 0% F+2&*+ 0&) ^#(%%*0( AfeCK#(8) 0$$*0+ ,# -0O* 2& .2&) ,-* $+2#+2,2%0,2#& #/ %12*&,2/21 +*%*0+1- %,()2*%,-0, *S0.2&* 10(%08 +*80,2#&%-2$% 4*,K**& #4:*1,2O*85 #4%*+O048* 0&).*0%(+048* $-*.*&0 A*'3' ,-* 2.$01, #/ $05 2&1*&,2O*% #+ 3#08 %*,,2&3 #&*.$8#5** $*+/#+.0&1*C' ^*%*0+1- %,()2*% ,-0, 0,,*.$, ,# (&)*+%,0&)


29/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


30/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;K-21- 2% UD!91$"!9E- E+1"'$"!9E-E*5)?1+1),$%E- E*5$8D$"12E $,9 E2),"!+"!9E'

X-2% +*%#&0,*% K2,- 2)*0% *%$#(%*) 45 U%2,(0,*) 8*0+&2&3 ,-*#+5U K-*+*

8*0+&2&3 2% (&)*+%,##) ,# 4* %#120885 0&) 1(8,(+0885 U*.4*))*)U 2+30&2%0,2#&% 0&) $#K*+ +*80,2#&% AddC' B&,*+*%,2&385D G0. Ad


31/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


32/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ; 9'! ") J1)%)812$% D$"'5$"1), )5 $8!1,8M A242)C

E#&,*.$#+0+5 0)(8, 8*0+&2&3 ,-*#+2%,% ,* ,-0, 2&)2O2)(08 U/+0.*% #/+*/*+*&1*U A-042,(0,*) K05% #/ ,-2&W2&3 0&) /**82&3C 10& +*.02& (&1-0&3*)

#O*+ ,2.*D K-21- .05 %*+O* 0% 0 40++2*+ ,# 0 $*+%#& 01`(2+2&3 &*KWK8*)3*' 7#K*O*+D 8*0+&2&3 .05 0+2%* 2/ 0 $*+%#& 2% /01*) K2,- 0%23&2/210&, %2,(0,2#& #+ *S$*+2*&1* ,-0, $+#.$,% +*/8*1,2#& 0&)=#+ 01,2#&' H#+*S0.$8*D L*I2+#K A !%1D1,$"1,8 "3!)5!"12$%$,$%>+1+ )5 5!%!?$," 2$+! *5)J%!D+M /D*5)?!D!," A1%% 2)D! "35)'831,"!85$"1), )N "3! +23)%$5%> $,9 *5$2"12$% %!$5,1,8 +">%!+M A +1"'$"1),U Ae>C'

b+35+2% *S$#(&)% #& ,-* 2.$8210,2#&% #/ 2&)2O2)(08 1#3&2,2#& 0&) 4*-0O2#(+/#+ #+30&2%0,2#&%' b(,#.0,21D ,012, +*0%#&2&3 $+#1*%%*% 0+* 1#&1*$,(082%*)


33/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ; $ N!A )N $%% *)++1J%! $%"!5,$"1?!+MMMM 61D1"!9 2$*$21">D)9!%+ !D*3$+17! "3! 5)%! )N 2)8,1"1?! 3!'51+"12+ $,9 +1D*%1N>1,8K,)A%!98! +"5'2"'5!+ 1, 5!9'21,8 1,N)5D$"1),I*5)2!++1,8 9!D$,9+M Ae?C

T0-&*.0& Ae@gecC )2%,2&3(2%-*% 4*,K**& +*0%#&2&3 0&) 2&,(2,2#&' B&,(2,2#&.05 4* 1#&%,+(1,2O*D *O*& U*)A!5N'% $,9 $22'5$"!UD %(1- 0% K-*& %W288% 0+*01`(2+*) ,-+#(3- $+#8#&3*) $+01,21* 0&) +*%(8, 2& *//#+,8*%% $*+/#+.0&1*'B&,(2,2#& 10& ,-*+*/#+* 0%%2%, K2,- *//212*&, )*12%2#& .0W2&3 2& $+01,21*D08,-#(3- 2, )#*% +2%W *++#+%' X-* O2*K ,-0, %5%,*.0,21 *++#+% .05 +*%(8,/+#. :()3.*&,08 -*(+2%,21% 2% , K2,-#(, 1+2,212%.D -#K*O*+' N23*+*&I*+AedCD /#+ *S0.$8*D -0% )2%$(,*) ,-2% 1802. )+0K2&3 ($#& $+#404282,5 ,-*#+50&) +*2&/#+12&3 ,-* $#2&, ,-0, )*12%2#&% 0&) :()3.*&, 0+* 0//*1,*) 45 %#12081#&,*S, 0&) *&O2+#&.*&,[

V'D$, W'98D!," +!!D+ ") J! 9)D$1,I+*!21N12 5$"3!5 "3$, 8'19!9 J>+)D! 8!,!5$% D!,"$% %)812'

J8%*K-*+*D "0&* 0&) 9+0,, Ae;;C' B& ,-*2+ O2*K 2&,(2,2O* )*12%2#& .0W2&3 2% *//*1,2O* K-*& 2, 2% 4#,-U1#.$8*S 0&) )#.02&g+*8*O0&,UD 0% 2% ,-* 10%* K2,- ,-* -23-85 %W288*)$+#/*%%2#&08 *S$*+, A%(1- 0% ,-* )#1,#+ #+ &(+%*C' X-*5 0+3(* ,-0, ,-*+* 2%0 %-#+,/088 2& +*%*0+1- *S$8#+2&3 ,-* 1#.$8*S +*80,2#&%-2$% 4*,K**& 2&,(2,2O*WK2&3 0&) ,-* 4#)5D #+ 2&,(2,2O* WK2&3 0&) 1(8,(+08 /01,#+%'


34/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;;?C

E@I@C K#4)0/)$L34%$" 0.$(#/$% (' ?+(5/+: 4+" 2$4#+/+: /+

(#:4+/%40/(+%

X-*+* 2% 0 3+#K2&3 *.$-0%2% 2& ,-* #+30&2%0,2#&08 82,*+0,(+* #& U$+01,21*40%*)U $*+%$*1,2O*% ,# #+30&2%0,2#&08 8*0+&2&3 0&) WK8*)3* A>;PC' 6(1-$*+%$*1,2O*% #//*+ 0& 2&,*+*%,2&3 1#&,+0%, ,# *O2)*&1*g#+2*&,0,*)(&)*+%,0&)2&3% #/ WK8*)3* (,282%0,2#& A,-* %#g1088*) U%12*&1* $(%-U 0&38* %** f?C 0&) 1#3&2,2O* ,-*#+2*% #/ 8*0+&2&3 ,-0, /#1(% #& 2&)2O2)(08 .*&,08$+#1*%%*% A>;@C' B& 4+2*/D $+01,21*g40%*) #+2*&,0,2#&% 0,,*.$, ,#(&)*+%,0&) -(.0& 01,2#&% 0% %#120885 %2,(0,*) $-*.*&0 ,-0, 3*&*+0,*.*0&2&3/(8 4*-0O2#(+% 2& 0 1(8,(+08g-2%,#+2108 1#&,*S,'

9+01,21*g40%*) K+2,*+% )+0K ($#& %#12#8#32108 0&) 0&,-+#$#8#32108 ,-*#+2*%0&) .*,-#)% ,# *S$8#+* ,-* 01,2O2,2*% ,-0, 2&)2O2)(08% $0+,212$0,* 2& 45 4*2&3.*.4*+% #/ #+30&2%0,2#&% #+ 8##%*+ U1#..(&2,2*% #/ $+01,21*U A>;fC'9+01,21*g40%*) ,-*#+2%,% #4%*+O* ,-0, 0 %-0+*) U8#321 #/ $+01,21*U A>;cD >;dC(&)*+$2&% 0&) )2+*1,% -(.0& 01,2O2,5D , 2& ,*+.% #/ +(8*g/#88#K2&34*-0O2#(+ 0% *S$#(&)*) 45 /(&1,2#&082%, 0&) +0,2#&082%, 011#(&,% #/ %#1208#+)*+D 4(, 011#+)2&3 ,# 0 1#88*1,2O* UWK8*)3*04282,5U ,-0, 1-0+01,*+2I*%$0+,21(80+ /2*8)% #/ 01,2#& A>;;eCD %(1- 0% 2& ,-* )#.02&% #/ %12*&1* #+

.*)212&*' b% V*&3*+ -0% %(..0+2%*)[

B3! 2),2!*" )N *5$2"12! 2),,)"!+ 9)1,8- J'" ,)" W'+" 9)1,8 1, $,9 )N 1"+!%NM/" 1+ 9)1,8 1, $ 31+")512$% $,9 +)21$% 2),"!C" "3$" 81?!+ +"5'2"'5! $,9D!$,1,8 ") A3$" A! 9)M /, "31+ +!,+!- *5$2"12! 1+ $%A$>+ +)21$% *5$2"12!'A>;fC

J&303*.*&, 2& 0&5 /#+. #/ 2&,*+01,2#& /#+ *S0.$8*D .0&032&3 0 ,*0. 2&0& #+30&2%0,2#& +*`(2+*% ,-* %W28/(8 011#.$82%-.*&, #/ 0 +0&3* #/ 01,2O2,2*%0&) %#120885g+*1#3&2%*) 1#.$*,*&1*%D %(1- 0% 2&,*+$+*,2&3 8#108 .*0&2&3%D.#&2,#+2&3 #&*U% 4*-0O2#(+ A0&) ,-0, #/ #,-*+%CD 8*0)2&3D $+#)(12&3 ,*S,(08


35/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ; %)2$"!9 1, 1,91?19'$%+ D1,9+ $,9D$,1N!+"!9 1, A51""!, "!C"+- 5!*5!+!,"$"1),+ $,9 5)'"1,17!9 J!3$?1)5+ 1+needlessly and, in our view, erroneously restrictiveM

E#++0)2 *, 08 A>>;C #4%*+O* ,-0, $+01,21*g40%*) ,-*#+2I2&3 U1+ $ *)A!5N'%9!?12! A1"3 A3123 ") 5!I91+2'++ "3! *)+1"1?1+" $,9 5$"1),$%1+" *$5$918D+-A3123 $5! +"1%% $2"1?! 1, ?$51)'+ N1!%9+ )N )58$,17$"1), +"'91!+MU 60&)4*+3 0&)X%#(W0% A>>?C 1#&,*&) ,-0, ,-* )#.2&0&, U%12*&,2/21 +0,2#&082,5U -0%)2%1#&&*1,*) 010)*.21 WK8*)3* 0&) +*%*0+1- /+#. $+01,2,2#&*+%U %#1208

1#&,*S,%D +*&)*+2&3 2, 8*%% +*8*O0&,' X-* %1-#80+85 0.42,2#& ,# 1+*0,* O082)D,+(,-/(8 +*$+*%*&,0,2#&% #/ ,-* K#+8) (%2&3 ,-* .*,-#)% #/ %12*&1* )#*% 2&/01, 04%,+01, UN5)D "3! "!D*)5$% N%)A )N *5$2"12!- +'23 $+ "3! *5$2"12$%,!2!++1"1!+- ',2!5"$1,"1!+- $,9 '58!,21!+ 1, A3123 *5$2"1"1),!5+ $5! ">*12$%%>!,"$,8%!9MU X-2% $#2&, 2% %($$#+,*) 45 F+#K& 0&) "(3(2) A>>@CD K-#1#..*&, ,-0,[

/, $ +)21!"> "3$" $""$23!+ *$5"12'%$5 ?$%ue to abstract knowledge, the9!"$1%+ )N *5$2"12! 3$?! 2)D! ") J! +!!, $+ ,),!++!,"1$%- ',1D*)5"$,"-$,9 !$+1%> 9!?!%)*!9 ),2! "3! 5!%!?$," $J+"5$2"1),+ 3$?! J!!, 85$+*!9MB3'+ !9'2$"1),- "5$1,1,8- $,9 "!23,)%)8> 9!+18, 8!,!5$%%> N)2'+ ),


36/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;;@D >>fC AK-21- 4(28)% ($#& 0 $+01,21*g40%*) *$2%,*.#8#35C0&085%*% K#+Wg40%*) 01,2O2,5 0&) 2% 1#&1*+&*) K2,- %#1208 1#&,*S, 0&)1(8,(+*' G*0+&2&3 2% 0&085%*) +*80,2#&0885 %2&1* 2&)2O2)(08% 10&, 4* O2*K*)0% )*,01-*) /+#. ,-*2+ U%#1208 K#+8) #/ 01,2O2,5U #+ U1#..(&2,5 #/ $+01,21*UA>>cD >>dC' b&085%2% #/ +*80,2#&%-2$% 2& %#1208 &*,K#+W% .05 08%# 4*2.$#+,0&, 2& #+)*+ ,# (&)*+%,0&) -#K U2&/#+.0,2#& %**W2&3 0&) %*0+1-2&3U4*-0O2#(+% 0//*1, 8*0+&2&3 A>>+*1#3&2I*) 45 #,-*+% 0&)*S$+*%%*) ,-+#(3- ,-* 01,2#&% #/ ,-* 4#)5 A>>;D >?;C' B&)**)D K2,-2& 0$+01,21*g40%*) /+0.*K#+WD K,)A1,80&) %!$5,1,80+* , %**& 0% %*$0+0,*01,2O2,2*% 0% *01- $+#1*%% 2.$82*% ,-* #,-*+' X# %(11*%%/(885 $0+,212$0,* 2&0&5 $+01,21* A4* 2, $+#/*%%2#&08 #+ #,-*+K2%*CD 2, 2% , %(//212*&, /#+2&)2O2)(08% ,# 2&,*+&082I* U/01,% 04#(, ,-* K#+8)U X-*5 .(%, 4* %#120885+*1#3&2I*) 0% 1#.$*,*&, 01,#+% 2& ,-* K#+8) A>>@C'

F#(+)2*( (%*% ,-* 1#&1*$, #/ U-042,(%U ,# +*/*+ ,# ,-* $+#1*%% 45 K-21-*S,*+&08 %#1208 %,+(1,(+*% 0+* 2&,*+2#+2I*) ,-+#(3- 8*0+&2&3 0&) 80,*+*S,*+&082I*) ,-+#(3- $+01,21*% A>?>C' X-2% -* *S$+*%%*% 0%[ U,-* 4#)5 2% 2&,-* %#1208 K#+8) 4(, ,-* %#1208 K#+8) 2% 2& ,-* 4#)5U A>??C' X# O2*K ,-* 4#)50% 2&%1+24*) 45 %#12082I0,2#& 0&) 5*0+% #/ %#1208 $+01,21* 2% ,# +*1#3&2I* ,-0,&g1#)2/2*) /#+.% #/ WK2&3 A,-* *S$*+2*&,208D %*&%#+5D 1#+$#+08D 0&)2&,(2,2O*C K288 -0O* $+#/#(&) +*8*O0&1* /#+ (&)*+%,0&)2&3 -#K 8*0+&2&3#11(+% 2& 2&%,2,(,2#&% )5&0.210885' X-2% 1#&1#+)% K2,- ,-* 2)*0 #/ U*.4#)2*)K#+WU A>?PC 0&) U,012, WK2&3U AdPC %02) ,# 4* 2&,*3+08 ,# ,-* $*+/#+.0&1*#/ %12*&,2/21 2&`(2+5' b11#+)2&3 ,# N*23*+ A>?@C[

[,)A%!98! $+ K,)A1,8 1+ ,)" "3! )'"2)D! )N 5$"1),$% 9!21+1),+ 5!+'%"1,8N5)D +21!,"1N12 D!"3)9+ J'" 1,+"!$9 9!+251J!+ $ *5)2!++ )N 2),"1,')'+!,$2"D!,"- 5!N1,!D!,"- 5!*5)9'2"1), $,9 23$,8! J$+!9 ), "$21"%> +3$5!9',9!5+"$,91,8+ A1"31, $ *5$2"121,8 2)DD',1">M A$'>P@C

B&)2O2)(08% 0+* , O2*K*) 2& 1#3&2,2O* 2%#80,2#& /+#. #&* 0,-*+ 4*10(%*0&5 $+01,21* 2% 45 2,% )*/2&2,2#& %#1208 2& &0,(+*' X-2% $*+%$*1,2O* 2% 18*0+850+,21(80,*) 2& V*&3*+U% A>;fC 1#&1*$, #/ U1#..(&2,2*% #/ $+01,21*U AER9%CK-21- 4*32&% /+#. ,-* $+*.2%* ,-0, K* 0+* *%%*&,20885 U%#1208 4*2&3%U' ER9%0+* , )2%,2&1, *&,2,2*% 4(, 4*,,*+ ,-#(3-, #/ 0% 2&/#+.08D /8(2) (&2,% AB42)C'b, 0&5 #&* ,2.*D V*&3*+ %(33*%,%D K* *01- $0+,212$0,* 0&) 0+* .*.4*+% #/%*O*+08 1#..(&2,2*% #/ $+01,21* $*+-0$% $+#/*%%2#&08D K#+Wg40%*) #+


37/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;?PC -0% $(, /#+K0+) ,-* 1#&1*$, #/ U*$2%,*.21 1(8,(+*%U ,# *8(12)0,* -#K

)2//*+*&, %(4g/2*8)% #/ %12*&1* (,282%* )2O*+%* *$2%,*.21 $+01,21*% 0&)0$$+#01-*%' 7*+ *.$2+2108 +*%*0+1- 2&,# ,K# %(4g%5%,*.% #/ %12*&1* A-23-*&*+35 $-5%21% 0&) .#8*1(80+ 42#8#35C 1-088*&3*% ,-* 1#&1*$,2#& #/ %12*&1*0% 0 -#.#3*(% /2*8) /#(&)*) ($#& *$2%,*.#8#32108 03+**.*&, #+ 0 (&2/2*)1#..#& 1(8,(+*' R& ,-* 1#&,+0+5D T++gE*,2&0 A>?PC *.$-0%2%*% ,-*U)2O*+%2,5U 0&) )2%(&2,5 /#(&) 2& ,-* &0,(+08 %12*&1*% 0% )2//*+*&, %(4/2*8)%*S$8#2, O0+2*) .*1-0&2%.% ,# )*82O*+ WK8*)3* #(,$(,%[

X/Y" 1+ ,)" ),! !,"!5*51+! J'" D$,>- $ A3)%! %$,9+2$*! )5 D$5K!" )N1,9!*!,9!," !*1+"!D12 D),)*)%1!+ *5)9'21,8 ?$+"%> 91NN!5!," *5)9'2"+MEAB42)C

b11#+)2&3 ,# ,-2% O2*KD )2//*+*&, *$2%,*.21 1(8,(+*% 0)#$, )2%,2&1,2O*WK8*)3* $+01,21*% 0&) %,0&)0+)% K288 /(&1,2#& 011#+)2&3 ,# )2//*+*&,+.% 0&) +(8*%' H#+ T++gE*,2&0 A>?PCD 2, 2% ,-* O0+20,2#& 2& ,-**5)2!++!+0&) D!23$,1+D+#/ UWK8*)3* 1#&,*S,%U ,-0, )*.0&)% /(+,-*+ 0,,*&,2#&D#O*+ 0&) 04#O* )2//*+*&1*% 2& ,-* 2),"!,"#/ ,-* WK8*)3* ,-0, 2%$+#)(1*)'

X-* 2)*0 #/ *$2%,*.21 1(8,(+*% *S2%,2&3 2& %12*&1* +*%#&0,*% K2,- %,()2*% #/+*80,*) 2&)(%,+2*%' N2,,*8.0& 0&) T#3(, A>?


38/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;;fC' X-* 1#&1*$, #/ U4#(&)0+5#4:*1,%U 2% #&* *S0.$8* A>?eC' F#(&)0+5 #4:*1,% .05 4* )#1(.*&,%D1#&1*$,% #+ 0+,*/01,% A>?eg>P?C ,-0, 0+* 011*$,*) 0% 8*32,2.0,* 45 0//*1,*)$0+,2*% 0&) K-21- %,+(1,(+* :#2&, 01,2#&' 7#K*O*+D ,-*5 10& 08%# ,0W* #&&g.0,*+208 /#+.% A%(1- 0% %,#+2*%D 1#&1*$,%C 0&) +*/*+ ,# #+30&2%0,2#&08$+#1*%%*% #+ $+#1*)(+*% A>PPD >P@D >?fC' F*10(%* 4#(&)0+5 #4:*1,% 0+*.088*048* ,-*5 10& +*%$#&) ,# )2//*+*&, *&O2+#&.*&,% 0&) 2&,*+%*1, 0, ,-*

4#(&)0+2*% 4*,K**& )2//*+*&, %#1208 K#+8)% A>?eC' 6#12#g.0,*+208 #4:*1,%.05 4* #/ $0+,21(80+ +*8*O0&1* 2& %*,,2&3% K-*+* %$*12082%, #+ #11($0,2#&08WK8*)3* 2% K2)*85 )2%$*+%*) 0&) $##+85 2&,*3+0,*) 01+#%% 1#..(&2,2*%'7*+* WK8*)3* .05 4* %02) ,# U%,21WU +0,-*+ ,-0& /8#K A>>@D >PfC'

7#K*O*+D ,-* +#8* #+ $+*%*&1* #/ 4#(&)0+5 #4:*1,% 2% 1#&,*%,*) 2& ,-*#+5'R+82W#K%W2 A>; $5! ,)"91+25!"! )JW!2"+ ") J! !C23$,8!9 )5 +"$J%! *5)2!++!+ ") J! *$2K$8!9 $,9"5$,+*)5"!9 ") )"3!5 9)D$1,+M .5$2"12!+ $5! 8!,!5$"!9 "35)'83 *!)*%!E+!?!5>9$> $2"1),M

45DE3::'F'9'&'#:


39/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;PdC 0&) )2%1(%%*) *0+82*+ 1#&1*+&2&3 U%2,(0,2#&08)*$*&)*&1*U[

B3! +K1%%!9 *5$2"12! )N D!9121,! 1+ ,)" D!5!%> $J)'" K,)A1,8 $ +!" )N$J+"5$2"!9 5'%!+ $,9 5!2)DD!,9$"1),+ J'" $J)'" 9!2191,8 A3123 )N D$,>2)D*!"1,8 5'%!+ 1+ D)+" 5!%!?$,"M A>PcC

N+**&-083- A>PPPeC )2%1(%% ,-* $+#%$*1,% /#+ 3*&*+0,2&3 U$+01,21*g40%*) *O2)*&1*'U X-*2+ +*%*0+1- +*O*08*) ,-0, *O*& -23-85 $*+/#+.2&3$+2.0+5 10+* 182&2120&% )# , )2+*1,85 011*%% +*%*0+1- *O2)*&1* AU/#+.08WK8*)3*UC 0&) 2.$8*.*&, 3(2)*82&*% 2& ,-* .0&&*+ 0%%(.*) 45 ,-**O2)*&1*g40%*) .*)212&* .#O*.*&,' X-2% *1-#*% ,-* #4%*+O0,2#& .0)*

*0+82*+ 45 61-#& A>@;C ,-0, $+#/*%%2#&08 K#+W 08%# )*$*&)% ($#& U,012,+*1#3&2,2#&%D :()3.*&,%D 0&) %W28/(8 $*+/#+.0&1*%UD *O*& K-*& U+*%*0+1-g40%*) ,-*#+2*% 0&) ,*1-&2`(*%U 0+* *S$8212,85 (%*)' N04405 0&) G* L05A>PeC )*%1+24* -#K 182&2120&%U 2&,*+&082%*) "$21"3(2)*82&*% AK-0, ,-*5 ,*+.U.2&)82&*%UC K*+* .#+* 2&/8(*&,208 2& )05g,#g)05 $+01,21* ,-0& ,-* *S$8212,(%* #/ *O2)*&1*g40%*) 3(2)*82&*%'

N04405 0&) L05 1#&18()* ,-0, )(* ,# U01`(2+*) *S$*+,2%*U 0&) $+#/*%%2#&08-042,(%D 182&2120&% -0O* +*0)5 011*%% ,# ,012, (&)*+%,0&)2&3 0&) $+01,2108WK8*)3*' b% 0 +*%(8,D ,-*5 +*1#..*&) ,-0, *O2)*&1* %-#(8) 4* U5!N1,!9$**5)*51$"!%> 1,") K,)A%!98!I1,I*5$2"12!I2),"!C"E A>PeCM

E@J@C 8#/0/)/%7% (' *#4)0/)$L34%$" 4**#(4).$%

J8W:0*+ A>>fC $#2&,% #(, ,-0, %#1208 8*0+&2&3 0$$+#01-*%D %(1- 0% ,-#%**S$#(&)*) 45 G0O* 0&) V*&3*+ A>?cCD $#%* )2//21(8,2*% /#+ (&)*+%,0&)2&3,-* 2&/8(*&1* ,-0, U1#&1*$,% 0&) ,-*#+2*%U -0O* #& 2&)2O2)(08 8*0+&2&3 0&)K-21- .05 0//*1, ,-* 01`(2%2,2#& #/ &*K WK8*)3* 0&) *S$*+2*&1*%'L#+*#O*+D %#1208 $+01,21* ,-*#+2%,% g 2& ,-*2+ 0,,*&,2#& ,# 3+#($ $+#1*%%*%0&) 1#88*1,2O* 01,2O2,5 g .05 #O*+8##W 03*&15 0&) ,-* +#8* $805*) 45$+#.2&*&, 2&)2O2)(08% 8#10885 A>;@C[


40/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ; 1,N%'!,"1$% 1,91?19'$%M

45IC;:&'&%&'3;:J 238#- ,;A 0'#-,-$0'#: 3< K;389#A=#X-2% %*1,2#& +*O2*K% 82,*+0,(+* )2%1(%%2&3 ,-* +*80,2#&%-2$ 4*,K**& $#K*+0&) WK8*)3*D K2,- 0,,*&,2#& 32O*& ,# ,-* .01+#=2&%,2,(,2#&08 8*O*8 #/0&085%2%'

H+#. 0 H#(10(8)20& $*+%$*1,2O* A>@>D >@?CD WK8*)3* 2.$82*% $#K*++*80,2#&% 0&) 0 /2*8) #/ WK8*)3*' TK8*)3* 2% , ,0W*& ,# 4* #4:*1,2O*D)*,01-*) #+ O08(*g/+** 4*10(%* WK8*)3* 0&) $#K*+ 0+* 2&*S,+2104852&,*+,K2&*)' b% H#(10(8, K+2,*%[

.)A!5 $,9 K,)A%!98! 915!2"%> 1D*%> ),! $,)"3!5\ "3$" "3!5! 1+ ,) *)A!5

5!%$"1), A1"3)'" "3! 2)55!%$"1?! 2),+"1"'"1), )N $ N1!%9 )N K,)A%!98!- ,)5$,> K,)A%!98! "3$" 9)!+ ,)" *5!+'**)+! $,9 2),+"1"'"! $" "3! +$D! "1D!*)A!5 5!%$"1),+M A>@>[ $'>dfR

b WK8*)3*=$#K*+ )(082,5 2% 0+,21(80,*) 2& ,-* H#(10(8)20& 1#&1*$, #/U3#O*+&.*&,082,5U A>@PC K-21- )*%1+24*% -#K .#)*+& 2&%,2,(,2#&% /(&1,2#& 0%WK8*)3*g30,-*+2&3 0&) WK8*)3*g1+*0,2&3 *&,2,2*%' B, 2% %(33*%,*) ,-0,.#)*+& )*.#1+0,21 3#O*+&.*&, -0% +*82*) ($#& 2&/#+.0,2#& 04#(,$#$(80,2#&% ,# *&01, $#K*+D 0% *O2)*&1*) 45 ,-* +2%* #/ $#$(80,2#& %,0,2%,21%)(+2&3 ,-* >e,-E*&,(+5 A>@@C' E#&%*`(*&,85D 3#O*+&.*&,% *&303* 2&011(.(80,2&3 /01,% ,-+#(3- U1*&,+*% #/ 1081(80,2#&U A>@fC' b% ^#%* 0&)L288*+ A>@cC $#2&, #(,D WK8*)3* 2& ,-2% 1#&,*S, )#*% , *`(0,* ,# 04%,+01,2)*0% 4(, 2&%,*0) +*/*+% ,# ,-* UO0%, 0%%*.4803* #/ $*+%#&%D ,-*#+2*%D$+#:*1,%D *S$*+2.*&,% 0&) ,*1-&2`(*% ,-0, -0% 4*1#.* %(1- 0 1*&,+081#.$#&*&, #/ 3#O*+&.*&,%'U

H#(10(8)20& ,-*#+5 %,+*%%*% ,-0, U3#O*+&.*&,082,5U g ,-* +0,2#&082,5 ,-0,%#.*,-2&3 10& 4* .0&03*)D .#&2,#+*) 0&) 1#&,+#88*) g 2% )*$*&)*&, ($#&2&%,2,(,2#&08 WK8*)3* 011(.(80,2#& 0&) 180%%2/210,2#&' ^#%* A>@@C%(33*%,% ,-0, 3#O*+&.*&, -0% 1#&,2&(0885 %,+2O*) ,# U81?! 1"+!%N $ N)5D )N"5'"3 !+"$J%1+3 $ K1,9 )N !"312$% J$+1+ N)5 1"+ $2"1),+'U

b H#(10(8)20& %,0&)$#2&, -0% 4**& (%*) ,# 1-088*&3* $#%2,2O2%,

$+*%*&,0,2#&% #/ %12*&,2/21 ,+(,-' ^#5 M01`(*% A>@dCD /#+ *S0.$8*D *S0.2&*%,-* U.*,0&0++0,2O*U #/ .0&03*.*&, %12*&1* 0% 0 WK8*)3* /2*8) /+#. 01(8,(+08g-2%,#+2108 $*+%$*1,2O*D %(33*%,2&3 ,-0, .0&03*.*&, WK8*)3* -0%/088*& 2&,# ,-* U,+(,-g,+0$U #/ %12*&1*' 7* #4%*+O*% ,-0, 010)*.21 +*%*0+1--0% +*%(8,*) 2& 0 +*820&1* #& )0,0 ,# $+#)(1* U,+(,-UD )*%$2,* ,-* 801W #/(&2,5 2& ,-* /2*8) #/ #+30&2%0,2#&08 2&`(2+5 0&) U1#.$*,2&3 $0+0)23.%U #/WK8*)3* 1#g*S2%,2&3' V2,-2& ,-* /2*8) #/ .*)2108 %#12#8#35D J$%,*2& A>@


41/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;@eg>f>CD K-0, T0++*.0& A>f?C )*%1+24*% 0% ,-* U$#K*+ 0% +*%,+02&2&3/#+1*U $*+%$*1,2O*' E8*33 A>f;CD /#+ *S0.$8*D $+#O2)*% 0 %,+(1,(+08 011#(&,

#/ -#K U%,+(1,(+*% #/ )#.2&0&15U 2& #+30&2%0,2#&% 10& $+#)(1* 0 U%5%,*. #/%#1208 #+)*+UD K-21- K288 )*,*+.2&* 01,#+%U 4*-0O2#(+ 0&) K-0, 2% $*+1*2O*)0% 8*32,2.0,* 01,2#& A>@eC' R& ,-* #,-*+ -0&)D $#K*+ .05 4* 0 U$+#)(1,2O*/#+1*UD ,-2% 011#+)2&3 K2,- 0 H#(10(8)20& $*+%$*1,2O*D K-*+*45 $#K*+ +*%(8,%2& 0 .(8,2,()* #/ 01,2O2,2*% 0&) $+01,21*% A>f?C' H+#. ,-* 80,,*+ $*+%$*1,2O*D0, ,-* .21+# 8*O*8D $#K*+ .0&2/*%,% ,-+#(3- U,*1-&2`(*%U ,-0, *&1#(+03*%*8/g3#O*+&2&3 0&) %*8/g)2%12$82&2&3 4*-0O2#(+ 0&) 1#&/#+.2,5 K2,- )#.2&0&,+0,2#&082,2*%D )2%1#(+%*% 0&) 2)*#8#32108 1#&%,+(1,% A>fPg>ffC' F#,-,-*#+*,2108 $*+%$*1,2O*% #& $#K*+ 0+* (%*/(8 /#+ (&)*+%,0&)2&3 K-0, 2% %**&0% 1#&%,2,(,2&3 8*32,2.0,* WK8*)3* 2& 0& #+30&2%0,2#&D 1#&,*S, #+ /2*8)D

0&) -#K )2//*+*&, WK8*)3*% A#+ +0,2#&082,2*%C .05 1#.$*,* A>fcC'X-*#+2*% #/ ,-* $+#/*%%2#&% %,0,* ,-0, U/#+.08 WK8*)3*U 2% /(&)0.*&,08 ,#,-* 8*32,2.015 #/ $+#/*%%2#&08 K#+WD 0% 2& .*)212&* A>fdD >ffdCD ,-* U(8,2.0,* 8*32,2.015U #/$+#/*%%2#&08 K#+W 2% 3+#(&)*) 2& ,-* /#+.08 WK8*)3* ,-0, 0 $+#/*%%2#& -0%011*%% ,# g 010)*.21 ,*S,4##W%D ,*01-2&3 0&) +*%*0+1-_ 2& #,-*+ K#+)%D 0&04%,+01, WK8*)3* 40%*' 7#K*O*+D 2& $+01,21*D ,-2% WK8*)3* 2% 0$$82*)8##%*85 %2&1* $+#/*%%2#&08% .0W* U0+42,+0+5 0&) %*8*1,2O* )*12%2#&%'U R& ,-*#,-*+ -0&)D 0).2&2%,+0,#+% A.0&03*+%C K288 0,,*.$, ,# ,+0&%/#+. 0&)%,0&)0+)2I* WK8*)3* A*'3' 2&,# $+#,#1#8%D 3(2)*82&*%C 0% ,-*5 %**W ,#2&/8(*&1* ,-* $*+/#+.0&1* 0&) *O08(0,2#& #/ $+#/*%%2#&08 K#+W' H#+H+*2)%#& A>fdCD ,-*&D )2//*+*&, $*+%$*1,2O*% 0&) $#%2,2#&% 8*0) ,# )2//*+*&,(%*% #/ /#+.08 WK8*)3*'

7#K WK8*)3* 2% ,+0&%/#+.*) 0&) %*8*1,*) 45 $+#/*%%2#&08 3+#($% 2% 0(,1#.* #/ $#K*+ 0&) 2&,*+*%,%D 0% K*88 0% 2&%,2,(,2#&08 1#&%,+02&,%' X-2%+02%*% 2.$#+,0&, `(*%,2#&% 04#(, ,-* /#+.% #/ &*K WK8*)3* ,-0,$+#/*%%2#&08 2&%,2,(,2#&% %($$#+, #+ +*%2%,_ ,-* 4#(&)0+2*% 0+#(&)#11($0,2#&08 WK8*)3* )#.02&%_ ,-* ,5$*% #/ WK8*)3*% ,-0, 0+* %*8*1,*)2& $+#/*%%2#&08 #+30&2%0,2#&%' H#+ *S0.$8*D K-28%, $+#/*%%2#&08% .05 %**W#11($0,2#&08 0&) :(+2%)21,2#&08 1#&,+#8 #O*+ ,-*2+ K#+WD .0&03*+% .05 0)#$,&*K ,*1-&2`(*% 0&) WK8*)3*% A%(1- 0% ,-#%* )*O*8#$*) 45 *S,*+&08.0&03*.*&, 1#&%(8,0&,% #+ *S$*+,%C ,# *//*1, 1(8,(+08 1-0&3* #+ 1-088*&3*$+#/*%%2#&08 $+01,21*%D $#,*&,20885 8*0)2&3 ,# 1#&/821, A>feg>c?C'

H2&0885D ,-2% +*O2*K -23-823-,% ,-* 82,*+0,(+* #& UWK8*)3* 2&,*&%2O*g/2+.%U0&) .0&03*.*&, 1#&%(8,0&15 0% UWK8*)3* K#+WU A>cPD >f?D >c@C'b)#$,2&3 0 1+2,2108 $*+%$*1,2O* ,# ,-* 1#&1*$, #/ WK8*)3* K-21- 2% %**&0% 2&-*+*&,85 0.423(#(% g b8O*%%#& A>cfC 1#..*&,% ,-0, ,+0)2,2#&08$+#/*%%2#&% ,-*#+5 2% 4*2&3 (&)*+.2&*) 0% .#+* #11($0,2#&% 0+* U/#(&)*) 2&-23-*+ *)(10,2#&U 0&) 048* ,# .0W* WK8*)3* 1802.%D *O*& 2/ ,-*5 801W


42/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ; 1, "3!15 2%$1D+ N)5 $'"3)51">- +"$"'+ $,925!91J1%1">M

B, %-#(8) 4* ,*) ,-0, 010)*.21% K+2,2&3 2& ,-2% 0+*0 #4%*+O* ,-* 3*&*+08801W #/ *.$2+2108 +*%*0+1- #& .0&03*.*&, 1#&%(8,0&15 0&) WK8*)3*g2&,*&%2O* /2+.% A*'3' >cdD >c@C' 7#K*O*+D 08#&3%2)* ,-* ,-*#+*,2108

O2*K$#2&,% %(+.2%*) 04#O*D ,-*%* 0&085%*% +*2&/#+1* ,-* $#2&, ,-0, ,-#(3-WK8*)3* .05 4* ,+*0,*) A2& 4#,- 010)*.21 0&) $+01,2,2#&*+1#..(&2,2*%C 0% 0 &*(,+08D +0,2#&08 #(,$(, ,-0, %$*0W% /#+ 2,%*8/D 2, 2% 08%#1#&,*%,048*D 0.#+$-#(%D 0&) %(4:*1, ,# $#K*+ )5&0.21% 0, .(8,2$8* 8*O*8%#/ 0&085%2%'

E@M@C 82/+/)42 .93#/"% /+ .$420.)4#$ 74+4:$7$+0

V2,- ,-* 2&,+#)(1,2#& #/ ]*K 9(4821 L0&03*.*&, A]9LC +*/#+.% 2& ,-*>ecd;D >>D>d>C' E82&2120&% 10& 08%# )*.#&%,+0,* 0 801W #/ +*%$*1, /#+ .0&03*+%U*)(10,2#& 0&) ,+02&2&3D 0&) `(*%,2#& .0&03*+%U 04282,5 ,# .0W* 0$$+#$+20,*-*08,-10+* )*12%2#&% A>ceD >d>C'

X-#+&* A>d;C %**% ,-* 182&2108 )2+*1,#+ +#8* 0% 0 $0+,21(80+85 $#K*+/(8 #&* 2+30&2%0,2#&% 4*10(%* 182&2120&% 01, 0% U$+#/*%%2#&08 2&%2)*+%U K2,- U$22!++ ")D!912$% $,9 D$,$8!51$% !C*!5"1+! $,9 $ *5)N!++1),$% %!81"1D$2>MU 6-*#4%*+O*% ,-0, #&1* 182&2120&% .0%,*+ U.0&03*+208 80&3(03*UD ,-2% *&048*%,-*. ,# U+*2&,*+$+*, 0&) +*/+0.* $+#48*.%U 2& K05% ,-0, ,+0)2,2#&08.0&03*+=182&2108 +#8*% 0+* , %*, ($ ,# )#'

E82&2108 #+ .*)2108 )2+*1,#+% 10&D ,-*+*/#+*D $#%%*%% 1#&%2)*+048* 2&/8(*&1*2& -*08,-10+* %*,,2&3%D #O*+ 4#,- 182&2108 0&) .0&03*+208 #11($0,2#&083+#($% A>d?D >ceg>d>D >c


43/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;c;C 0+3(* ,-0, U-54+2)2%0,2#&U #11(+% K-*& 182&2120&%0$$+#$+20,* .0&03*+208 *S$*+,2%* 0&) 2&1#+$#+0,* 2, 2&,# ,-*2+ #K& $+01,21*'X-2% 2% 0 %,+0,*35 ,# *S,*&) :(+2%)21,2#&08 1#&,+#8 #O*+ $+#/*%%2#&08 K#+W 0&)+*%2%, *S,*+&08 1#&,+#8 45 .0&03*.*&,' 7#K*O*+D -54+2)2%0,2#& -0% 4+#0)*+1#&%*`(*&1*%[

Q+ *5)N!++1),$%+ 1,"!5,$%17! D$,$8!D!," "!23,1F'!+ 1, $, !,9!$?)'5 ")+"$?! )NN D$,$8!D!," !,25)$23D!,"- "3!> J!2)D! 1,25!$+1,8%>D$,$8!51$% 1, "!5D+ )N "3!15 *5$2"12! $,9 19!,"1">M

JO2)*&1* /+#. #(,%2)* ,-* QT -0% +*O*08*) ,-0, 182&2120&% -0O* 4**&%(11*%%/(8 0, 2&1#+$#+0,2&3 /2&0&1208 WK8*)3* 2& 0 1#&,*S, #/ ]9L +*/#+.%_,# ,-* *S,*&, ,-0, -#%$2,08 )#1,#+% +*$#+, 8*0+&2&3 011#(&,2&3 %W288% 0&)2&1#+$#+0,2&3 ,-*. 2&,# ,-*2+ *S2%,2&3 WK8*)3* 40%* A>dPC' 7#K*O*+D 2&T(+(&.0W2U% A>dPC %,()5D /(88 U-54+2)2%0,2#&U )2) , #11(+ 4*10(%* 182&2120&%*.$-0%2%*) ,-* 2.$#+,0&1* #/ .0%,*+2&3 (%*/(8 U,*1-&2`(*%U +0,-*+ ,-0& 0&*K 4#)5 #/ WK8*)3**!5 +!' X-2% #4%*+O0,2#& 2% %($$#+,*) 45 H*+82* *, 08A>cceC %,()5 #/ 01#-#+, #/ P> )#1,#+% ,-0, ,##W #& .0&03*.*&, +*%$#&%24282,2*% -23-823-,*)1*+,02& 2&/8(*&12&3 /01,#+%' H#+ *S0.$8*D ,-* /01, ,-0, 1-0&3*% 2& ,-* -*08,-%*1,#+ *&048*) 182&2120&% ,# (&)*+,0W* 182&2108 )2+*1,#+ +#8*% #& 0 $0+,g,2.*40%2% A.#%, K0&,*) ,# .02&,02& ,-*2+ 182&2108 $+01,21*CD #+ ,-* $#,*&,2081-088*&3* 0&) %,2.(80,2#& #//*+*) 45 ,-2% K#+W' b% 2& #,-*+ %,()2*%D182&2120&% )*.#&%,+0,*) 0 10$012,5 ,# 04%#+4 &*K .0&03*+208 WK8*)3*%

%(1- 0% %,+0,*321 .0&03*.*&, 0&) .0+W*,2&3 ,-+#(3- *S$#%(+* ,#.0&03*+208 ,*1-&2`(*% 0&) ,+02&2&3' 7#K*O*+D 2&2,20885D .#%, -0) 0 82.2,*)(&)*+%,0&)2&3 #/ ,-* 4+*0),- #/ ,-* .0&03*.*&, /2*8) 0&) -*8) 0$*+1*$,2#& ,-0, U.0&03*.*&, 2% *0%5 ,# 8*0+&'U

b, 0 .2))8* .0&03*.*&, 8*O*8D E(++2* A>d@C 0&) E(++2* 0&) 9+#1,#+ A>dfC)*%1+24* -#K &(+%*% 0&) #,-*+ 0882*) -*08,- $+#/*%%2#&08% -0O* *&,*+*).0&03*+208 +#8*% 2& ,-* ]76 0&) ,0W*& 0)O0&,03* #/ ,+02&2&3D %(1- 0% LFb$+#3+0..*%' 7#K*O*+D *)(10,2#&08 0%%2%,0&1* /#+ .2))8* .0&03*+%)2.2&2%-*) K2,- 4()3*,0+5 1(,%D 8*0O2&3 .2))8* .0&03*+% K2,-#(, 0&5/#+.08 .0&03*.*&, *)(10,2#& /**82&3 (&)*+g%($$#+,*)'


44/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


45/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


46/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;M E#&%(8,0&15 -0% 4**& 2&1+*0%2&385)+0K& ($#& 45 -*08,-10+* #+30&2%0,2#&% 0&) 0% %(1- 011*%% ,# J8.-#(%**&048*) *S$8#+0,2#& #/ ,-* 2.$01, #/ 1#&%(8,0&15 WK8*)3* #& .0&03*+%2& ,-* ]76'

41585)?!- $, Q2$9!D12 V!$%"3 &21!,2!+ ;!,"5! PQV&;RD +*1*&,85*%,0482%-*) ,# $+#O2)* #$$#+,(&2,2*% /#+ ,+0&%/#+.2&3 -*08,-10+*D 45&0++#K2&3 ,-* 30$ 4*,K**& 40%21 0&) 182&2108 %12*&1*%' X-* b76E #//*+*)0& #$$#+,(&2,5 ,# %,()5 ,-* (%* #/ .0&03*.*&, WK8*)3* 2& 0 &*,K#+W*)$0+,&*+%-2$'

0$*%!+315!- $ ;)%%$J)5$"1), N)5 6!$9!5+31* 1, Q**%1!9 V!$%"3 Z!+!$523 $,9;$5! P;6QVZ;RM X-* EGb7^EU% K*+* %*, ($ 01+#%% ,-* QT 2& +*%$#&%* ,#,-* E##W%*5 *$#+, A@?C' X-* 02.% 2&18()* )*O*8#$2&3 2&O0,2O* .#)*8%/#+ 1#&)(1,2&3 0$$82*) -*08,- +*%*0+1- 0&) ,+0&%80,2&3 +*%*0+1- /2&)2&3%2&,# 2.$+#O*) #(,1#.*% /#+ $0,2*&,%' X-* EGb7^E *&048*) *S$8#+0,2#& #/

,-* +#8* #/ .0&03*.*&, WK8*)3* 2& 01-2*O2&3 ,-2% 02.'

S$KD)5!- $, /,9!*!,9!," &!2")5 V)+*1"$%M R0W.#+* 2% 0 $+2O0,*1-0+2,048* ,+(%, #//*+2&3 %$*12082%, %*+O21*%D #//*+2&3 ,-* #$$#+,(&2,5 ,#%,()5 ,-* +#8* #/ .0&03*.*&, WK8*)3* 2& 0 %*,,2&3 #(,%2)* ,-* ]76D 4(,K#+W2&3 18#%*85 K2,- 2,'

O1%%)A"),- Q .51D$5> ;$5! B5'+" P.;BRM X-2% #+30&2%0,2#& 1#..2%%2#&% 04+#0) %$*1,+(. #/ -*08,-10+* %*+O21*% #& 0 $#$(80,2#& 40%2%' X-2% %2,* 2%(&)*+3#2&3 %,+(1,(+08 0&) %,+0,*321 1-0&3* 0% 2, *%,0482%-*% 0 8#108D182&2108858*) 1#..2%%2#&2&3 3+#($ 0&) )*O#8O*% )*12%2#& .0W2&3 2&

+*%$#&%* ,# &0,2#&08 $#8215' X-2% .0:#+ )*O*8#$.*&, $+#O2)*) 0$$#+,(&2,5 ,# %,()5 .0&03*.*&, WK8*)3* (%* 0, 0 ,2.* #/ ,+0&%2,2#&0&) +0)2108 #+30&2%0,2#&08 +*)*%23&'

X-* +*%*0+1- K0% #+30&2%*) 0% ,-+** $-0%*%' X*0. .*.4*+% K#+W*) 2&$02+% 2& &*3#,20,2&3 011*%%D (&)*+,0W2&3 U%1#$2&3U 2&,*+O2*K K#+WD%#.*,2.*% 2&,*+O2*K2&3 :#2&,85 0&) 08K05% %-0+2&3 )2%1(%%2#& #/ ,-*0&085%2%' X-* 01,(08 K+2,2&3 #/ ,-* 10%* K0% 8*) 45 #&* +*%*0+1-*+D-#K*O*+D 0% *S$802&*) 80,*+D 088 ,*0. .*.4*+% +*0) ,-* 10%*% 0% ,-*5*.*+3*) 0&) 1#&,+24(,*) ,# ,-* 1+#%% 10%* 0&085%2%'


47/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


48/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;D 0&) K-*+* $#%%248* +*%$#&)*&,% 2& 9-0%* ? K-# -0), $+*O2#(%85 4**& 2&,*+O2*K*) 0% $0+, #/ 9-0%* > K*+* 0%W*) 9-0%* >`(*%,2#&%' b% K2,- 9-0%* >D 088 2&,*+O2*K% K*+* +*1#+)*) 0&) ,+0&%1+24*)'

X5$210885D 2&,*+O2*K% 80%,*) 4*,K**& @; .2&(,*% 0&) >n -#(+%'

X-* $80& K0% ,# 1#&)(1, ,-* %2S 10%*% 1#&1(++*&,85_ -#K*O*+ 2%%(*%%(++#(&)2&3 *,-2108 0$$+#O08 2& L0$8*%-2+* A%** 4*8#KC .*0&, ,-0, ,-2% 10%*K0% %,0+,*) %#.* c .#&,-% 80,*+ ,-0& ,-* #,-*+%'

E-0+01,*+2%,21% #/ +*%*0+1- $0+,212$0&,% /#+ 9-0%*% > 0&) ? 0+* 32O*& 2&,04(80+ /#+. 2& b$$*&)2S P' ]#,*D ,-*2+ 10+**+ 401W3+#(&)% 0&) *)(10,2#&0+* 2&18()*) 0% K*88 0% ,-*2+ 1(++*&, +#8*%D 0% ,-2% 2&/#+.0,2#& K0% 1+(1208 /#+,-* 1+#%%g10%* 0&085%2%' X-* 1#)*% 32O*& ,# 2&)2O2)(08% 2& ,-* ,048* 0+* ,(%*) 2& ,-* *.$2+2108 1-0$,*+% ,# $+#,*1, 0&5.2,5'

B5DP22-3,$0 &3 ,;,9.:': C 0&) ^(42& 0&) ^(42& A>


49/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;C' X-* L0&03*.*&, H*88#K 08%# $0+,212$0,*) 2& ,-*0&085%2% $+#1*%% A%** b$$*&)2S eC'

X-* 1+#%%g10%* 0&085%2% $+#1*%% 1#..*&1*) K2,- 0& 2&,*++#30,2#& #/ ,-*)0,0 40%*) #& ,-* 1#+* +*%*0+1- `(*%,2#&%' X-* )0,0 #& ,-*%* `(*%,2#&%K0% 1#.$0+*) 01+#%% ,-* %2,*%' E#+* ,-*.*% K-21- -0) *.*+3*) K*+**S0.2&*) 0&) 1#.$0+*) 01+#%% %2,*%' RO*+088 ,-*.*% *.*+32&3 /+#. ,-*1+#%%g%2,* 1#.$0+2%#& K*+* ,-*& 82%,*)' X-* 82,*+0,(+* +*O2*K K0% ,-*&

2&,*++#30,*) ,# *S$8#+* K-*,-*+ 10&)2)0,* ,-*#+2*% *&048*) 0& *S$80&0,2#/ ,-* )0,0' H2&0885D -#K ,-* )0,0 .23-, *S,*&)D )*O*8#$ #+ +*/(,* *S2%,2&3+*%*0+1- K0% 1#&%2)*+*)' H#+ 0& *S0.$8* #/ ,-2% $+#1*%% %** b$$*&)2S @

B5LP$&'3; 9#,-;';= :#&: QPR*:S E0,:# BX-+** bG6% K*+* /#+.*) 2& #+)*+ ,# ,*%, 0&) *O08(0,* ,-2% /#+. #/2&,*+O*&,2#& 0% 0 .*,-#) #/ %-0+2&3 WK8*)3* 0&) 8*0+&2&3' "*,028% #/.*,-#)% 0&) $+#1*%%*% 2& ,-* bG6% 0+* 32O*& 2& )*,028 2& b$$*&)2S cD K-21-08%# %($$#+,% E-0$,*+ dD 0 4+2*/ %(..0+5 2% $+#O2)*) -*+*'

I@O@C K1#*(%$

9-0%* P K0% 08K05% 180%%*) 0% U*S$*+2.*&,08U' X-* +*%*0+1- $+#,#1#8 %,0,*%,-0, ,-* bG6% K*+* U") "!+" $,9 !?$%'$"! "31+ N)5D )N 1,"!5?!,"1), $+ $D!"3)9 )N +3$51,8 5!+!$523IJ$+!9 %!$5,1,8 $,9 )N !,2)'5$81,8 $,9N$21%1"$"1,8 "3! '*"$K! $,9 '"1%17$"1), )N 5!+!$523 J$+!9 !?19!,2!MU

I@O@E G$0.("% 4+" *#()$%%

X-+** bG6% %,033*+*) ,-+#(3- ,-* $*+2#) #/ +*%*0+1- K*+* $80&&*)' X-*,-+** %*,% +0& 4*,K**& R1,#4*+ ?;>; 0&) M(85 ?;>>D 0&) *01- %*, K0%

$80&&*) ,# .**, ,-+** ,2.*% K2,- %*O*+08 .#&,-% 4*,K**& *01- .**,2&3'X-* 2)*0 K0% ,-0, *01- %*, K#(8) 1#&,02& ,-* .0S2.(. O0+2*,5 #/$0+,212$0&,%D /+#. 0% .0&5 #/ ,-* 10%* #+30&2%0,2#&% 0% $#%%248*' X-*+*1+(2,.*&, $+#1*%% 2& #+)*+ ,# #4,02& ,-2% .2S $+#O*) .(1- .#+* )2//21(8,,-0& -0) 4**& /#+*%**&' X-2% K0% $0+,85 )(* ,# ,-* %,033*+*) &0,(+* #/ ,-*$+#1*%% &*1*%%2,0,*) 45 ,-* +*%,+21,*) $*+2#) #/ ,-* +*%*0+1- $+#:*1, 0&)08%# ,# 0 )*805 2& #&* #+30&2%0,2#& AL0$8*%-2+*C :#2&2&3 ,-* $+#:*1,'

J01- %*, K0% %($$#+,*) 45 #&* /01282,0,#+ 0&) 0,,*&)*) 45 #&* &g$0+,212$0&, #4%*+O*+ /+#. ,-* ,*0.' X-* /01282,0,#+% K*+* 088 *S$*+2*&1*) 2&+(&&2&3 bG6%' B&O2,0,2#&% K*+* %*&, ,# $#,*&,208 $0+,212$0&,%' R&1* ,-*5


50/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ; -0) f $0+,212$0&,% A0, ,-* %,0+,C_ %*, ? -0) P $0+,212$0&,%0&) %*, P -0) @' ^*1+(2,.*&, ,# ,-* %*,% K0% 45 2&O2,0,2#& ,# 088 ,-#%* K-#

-0) $0+,212$0,*) 2& ,-* +*%*0+1- 0, *01- #/ ,-* %2S +*%*0+1- %2,*%' X-(% 088$0+,212$0&,% K*+* O#8(&,**+% 0&) 088 K*+* .2))8*g8*O*8 ,# %*&2#+g8*O*8 -*08,-.0&03*+%' b% /0+ 0% $#%%248*D 2, K0% 02.*) ,# -0O* 2&)2O2)(08% /+#. 0, 8*0%,,-+** #/ ,-* +*%*0+1- %2,*% 2& *01- %*,D ,# $+#)(1* O0+2*,5 2& 401W3+#(&)D$+#/*%%2#& 0&) *S$*+2*&1*'

I@O@J !+429%/%

X-* )0,0 /#+ *01- %*, 1#&%2%,*) #/ ,-* #4%*+O*+ 0&) /01282,0,#+%U /2*8) ,*%0&) +*/8*1,2#&% 0&) ,-* ,+0&%1+2$,%' X-* #4%*+O*+ 0&) /01282,0,#+ /+#. *01-%*, 4*30& 45 0&085%2&3 ,-* )0,0 %*$0+0,*85 #& 0 %*,g45g%*, 40%2%' H+#.

,-2%D *01- $02+ #/ +*%*0+1-*+% 1#.$0+*) ,-*2+ 0&085%*% 0&) ,-*& $+#)(1*) 0%2&38* %*, #/ 0&085,21 ,-*.*% )*+2O2&3 /+#. ,-* )0,0' X-*&D 0 3+#($ #/ 088,-* 0&085%,% $8(% 0& 0))2,2#&08 ,*0. .*.4*+D .*, ,# +*O2*K ,-* ,-*.*%'H+#. ,-2% .**,2&3D ,-* 3+#($ $+#)(1*) 0 %*, #/ #O*+0+1-2&3 ,-*.*% /+#.,-* )0,0 #& 088 ,-+** %*,%' H2&0885D ,-*%* ,-*.*% K*+* +*O2*K*) 0&)2&,*++#30,*) 45 ,-* K-#8* +*%*0+1- ,*0.'

I@O@M N1*$#A/%/(+ %*4)$

b, ,-* 4*32&&2&3 #/ ,-* bG6D 2, K0% )*12)*) ,# 1+*0,* K-0, K0% )*%1+24*) 0%0 U%($*+O2%2#& %$01*U' "+0K2&3 #& 2)*0% /+#. $%51-#g,-*+0$5D ,-* 1#&1*$,


51/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;J519 2%1,12$% D$,$8!5+R $22!++ $,9 '+! D$,$8!D!," 5!+!$523IJ$+!9K,)A%!98! 1, "3!15 9!21+1),ID$K1,8LH

X-*+* 0+* #/ 1#(+%* K*88 WK& 10O*0,% 0&) )2//21(8,2*% 0+#(&) 088 ,5$*% #/+*%*0+1- .*,-#)#8#35' 7#K*O*+D 2, 2% 0+3(*) A%** 6*1,2#& P'>C ,-0, ,-*+*%*0+1- )*%23& 0&) ,-* `(082,0,2O* .*,-#)#8#35 (%*) K*+* ,-* .#%,0$$+#$+20,* 0O028048* /#+ 0))+*%%2&3 ,-2% ,5$* #/ `(*%,2#&D 0&) ,-0, ,-*+*%*0+1- )2) 3*&*+0,* O082) )0,0 K-21- 30O* %#.* 2&%23-, 2&,# ,-*1#.$8*S2,2*% #/ -*08,-10+* .0&03*+%U $*+%#&08 1-0+01,*+2%,21%D .#,2O0,2#&%0&) 01,2#&% 2& 011*%%2&3 0&) (%2&3 .0&03*.*&, +*%*0+1- 2& ,-*#+30&2%0,2#&% %,()2*)'


52/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


53/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


54/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


55/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


56/242


57/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


58/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ; ") $,>"31,8 *5)9'2!9 J> $,>),! "3$" 1+,E" @%D3)'+!M/N A! A51"! 1"- !?!5>),! 5!$9+ 1"M

b))2&3 ,-0,[

S'5 )A, K,)A%!98! 8!,!5$"1), 1+ +)D!"1D!+ ?!5> 8))9 $,9 1"E++)D!"1D!+ ,)" $" $%% 8))9MMM 1"E+ F'1"! %1D1"1,8M

J@E@E H+(52$":$ 4)0(#%

T*5 01,#+% 2& ,-2% 10%* %,()5 K*+* ,-* J8.-#(%* %*&2#+ 1#&%(8,0&, K-#0(,-#+*) ,-* J8.-#(%* .0&03*.*&, ,*S,D 0 .#+0$-' X-2%D A32O*& ,-*$%*()#&5. #/ ,-* J8.-#(%* X*S,C K0% *S$8#+*) 0% $0+, #/ ,-* .0&03*.*&,WK8*)3* ,+01*+ %,()5' 6*&2#+ 6,+0,*321 7*08,- b(,-#+2,5 A67bC .0&03*+%$805*) 0& 2.$#+,0&, +#8* 2& 1#..2%%2#&2&3 J8.-#(%* ,# 1#&)(1, ,-* h(082,5DB.$+#O*.*&,D 9+#)(1,2O2,5 0&) 9+*O*&,2#& AhB99C $+#:*1,' 9EX L0&03*+%0&) 9EXg40%*) 182&2120&% $805*) 0 1#(&,*+ +#8* 45 +02%2&3 )#(4,% 04#(, ,-*J8.-#(%* 0&085%2% 0&) 2,% U/2, K2,- +*082,5U 0&) $*+O*+%* *//*1,% #& $0,2*&,%

2& ]76 $+01,21*'

J@E@I V/:.2/:.0% (' '/+"/+:% '#(7 0.$ )4%$

E#&%(8,0&,% K*+* 0K0+* ,-0, ,-*5 .23-, +*85 ,## .(1- #& J8.-#(%*U% #K&2&,*+&0885 $+#)(1*) *O2)*&1*' E#.42&*) K2,- J8.-#(%*U% %,+#&3 1(8,(+*D-#.#3*(% *82,* +*1+(2,.*&, 0&) ,+0&%$0+*&, $*+/#+.0&1* .0&03*.*&,%5%,*.D ,-2% +2%W*) -*+.*,210885 %*08*) 8*0+&2&3D U%($*+/21208 2&O0,2#&U 0&).2%%2&3 &*K 2)*0% /+#. 010)*.20' R&* 90+,&*+ -0) +*1#3&2I*) ,-2%$+#48*. 0&) *%,0482%-*) 0& Ub10)*.21 F#0+)U ,# 1-088*&3* J8.-#(%*U 2)*0%0&) ,-2&W2&3 K2,- &*K 0&) )2//*+*&, 010)*.21 %,0&)0+)%' 7#K*O*+D ,-*+*K0% 08%# 0K0+*&*%% #/ ,-* &**) ,# 4080&1* 010)*.21 1#8804#+0,#+%U )*%2+* ,#U*S$*+2.*&,U K2,- U*S12,2&3U &*K ,-*#+*,2108 2)*0% #& J8.-#(%*U% 182*&,% K2,-U182*&, 2.$01,U 0&) U$+03.0,210885U W**$2&3 182*&,% -0$$5' X-* 1#..*&, K0%.0)* ,-0,[

Q2$9!D1$ $,9 2),+'%"1,8 $5! "A) A)5%9+ "3$" N1,9 1" 91NN12'%" ") A)5K")8!"3!5- 3)A!?!5- A3!5! A! 8!" "3! )?!5%$* 5183" 1"E+ $ 5!$% *1!2! )ND$812M

X-* J8.-#(%* ,+01*+ %,()5 A%** 6*1,2#& c'?'?C *S0.2&*) ,-* 0$$8210,2#& #/,-* .#)*8 #/ .0&03*.*&, 40%*) #& ,-* J8.-#(%* X*S, 2& 0 9EX AU]76


59/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


60/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;e;;%' b, ,-* ,2.* #/ ,-2%+*%*0+1-D ,-*%* ,K# #+30&2%0,2#&% -0) .0)* +0$2) $+#3+*%% K2,-2& ,-* b76E2& 0823&2&3 0&) +*#+30&2%2&3 ,-*2+ %,+(1,(+*% 0&) %*+O21*% ,# 1+*0,* EbN%D0&) 2, K0% ,-2% 08820&1* A-*&1*/#+,- +*/*++*) ,# 0% H2+3+#O*C K-21- K0% ,-*%(4:*1, #/ ,-2% 10%* %,()5'

Q&82W* .#+* -2*+0+1-2108 %,+(1,(+*% 0)#$,*) 2& ,-* K2)*+ b76ED H2+3+#O*

K2,- 0 8#&3 -2%,#+5 #/ 1#8804#+0,2#& 0&) 0 %,+#&3 *,-#% #/ 8#10885 )*%23&*)D$0+,212$0,#+5 0&) &*3#,20,*) %*+O21*%D -0) )*O*8#$*) 0 ,*0.g40%*) .#)*8#/ EbN 8*0)*+%-2$D )2+*1,*) 45 ,-+** #+ /#(+ %*&2#+ 010)*.21%D 182&2120&% 0&).0&03*+%'

X-* H2+3+#O* 08820&1* K0% 8*) 45 0 %,+#&3 0&) O2%248* 1#8804#+0,2#& 4*,K**&,-* E-2*/ JS*1(,2O* 0&) "*0&D K-# K*+* %**& 0% *.4#)52&3 ,-* %$2+2, #/1#8804#+0,2#&' X-2% K0% %($$#+,*)D .#+*#O*+D 45 ,-* K2)*+ 8*0)*+%-2$ ,*0.'H2+3+#O* -0) 0& (&(%(0885 %,048* 4#0+) AK2,- W*5 .*.4*+% -0O2&3 -*8)$#%2,2#&% /#+ 0 )*10)*CD 0&) ,-* #+30&2%0,2#& /*0,(+*) %,+#&3 +*80,2#&08*&303*.*&, 0&) 2)*&,2/210,2#& K2,- 2,% 8*0)*+% K-# U!?)K! $ 2!5"$1, $D)',"

)N *519!U 0&) K*+* $*+1*2O*) 0% U*',231,8 $J)?! "3!15 A!183"U 2& ,-*2+ /2*8)'

J@I@C H+(52$":$ 74+4:$7$+0 %9%0$7

H2+3+#O* U% #$*&&*%% ,# 2)*0% 0&) 2&O0,2#&D 0&) 2,% 0%$2+0,2#&% /#+)*O*8#$.*&, .*0&, ,-0, ,-*+* K0% 0& #O*+088 2&,*+*%, 2& 1+*0,2O* 2)*0% 0&)$+01,21*' ^*%$#&)*&,% )*%1+24*) 0 %,+#&3 *,-#% #/ 82%,*&2&3 ,# 0&) ,0W2&3%*+2#(%85 #,-*+%U O2*K%D K-21- ,*&)*) ,# *&1#(+03* 1+*0,2O2,5' b& R"2&,*+&08 1#&%(8,0&15 (&2, AR"BEC K0% #&* *S0.$8* #/ 0 8#108 2&2,20,2O* K-21-


61/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;- ?!5> 91NN!5!," A$>+ )NK,)A1,8U K*+* (%*) ,# 1#.42&* U%0&2,2%*) )0,0U K-21- .23-, %)+! D!$,1,8K2,- 0 U8#108 /**8U #/ *S$*+2*&1* 0&) +*80,2#&%-2$% ,-0, "$K! ), D!$,1,8Mb11#+)2&385D .0&03*.*&, ,-*#+2*% 0&) .#)*8%D 10%* %,()2*%D (%*% #/&0++0,2O*D 0&) #+30&2%0,2#&08 )*O*8#$.*&, /+0.*K#+W% K*+* +*30+)*) 0%2.$#+,0&, 2& $+#O2)2&3 ,-*#+*,2108 /+0.*K#+W% ,# %($$#+, .0&03*.*&,+*/8*S2O2,5'

"*O*8#$2&3 0& 2&,*3+0,*) WK8*)3* .0&03*.*&, %5%,*. 01+#%% ,-* b76EK0% 0 %23&2/210&, 1-088*&3* ,# ,-* &*K $0+,&*+%-2$D 0&) 1#&&*1,2O2,54*,K**& ,-* )2//*+*&, H2+3+#O* %5%,*.% K0% $0+,208' ]*O*+,-*8*%%D 0&2&O0,2O* )*O*8#$.*&, #/ ,-* *8*1,+#&21 182&2108 +*1#+) %5%,*. K0% 0 &*K+*%*0+1- ,##8 ,# 1#&)(1, N##38*g82W* %*0+1- 0&) 2&,*++#30,2#& #/ ,-*1#.$8*,* )0,0%*, #/ `(082,0,2O* 182&2108 +*1#+)%' X-2% -0) %,+#&3 0$$8210,2#&0% 0& *S$*+, %5%,*. /#+ 2)*&,2/52&3 `(082,0,2O* ,*S,% ,-0, 1#(8) 2.$+#O*182&2108 10+* 0&) +*%*0+1-D 0% K*88 0% 2.$+#O2&3 #+30&2%0,2#&08 $*+/#+.0&1*D3#O*+&0&1* 0&) 8*0+&2&3'

J@I@E H+(52$":$ 4)0(#%

T*5 WK8*)3* 01,#+% 2& H2+3+#O* 2&18()*) .*.4*+% #/ ,-* %*&2#+ 8*0)*+%-2$,*0. K-# K*+* WK& 0% 2&,*+&0,2#&0885 *82,* %1-#80+%D 182&2120&% 0&).0&03*+%' B& $0+,21(80+D ,-* E-2*/ JS*1(,2O* 0&) ,-* "*0& K*+* *S$*+,% 2&010)*.21 -*08,- %12*&1* 1#8804#+0,2#&' X-*5 4#,- -0) 2&,*+&0,2#&08+*$(,0,2#&% 0% WK8*)3* 8*0)*+% 2& ,-* /2*8)_ ,#3*,-*+ K2,- ,-*2+ K2)*+,*0.D ,-*5 .05 4* %**& 0% *.4#)52&3 ,-* ,+2$0+,2,* b76E .2%%2#& #/2&,*3+0,2&3 010)*.21 +*%*0+1-D ,-* #+30&2%0,2#& 0&) )*82O*+5 #/ -*08,-10+*D0&) *)(10,2#&'

b& (&(%(08 WK8*)3* 01,#+ 2& ,-2% 10%* K0% 0 )2+*1,#+ 2& ,-* +*%*0+1-g40%*) R"BE' X-* (&2, %($$#+,*) 8*0)*+%-2$ ,*0. )*O*8#$.*&, 01+#%% ,-*$0+,&*+%-2$ 2&18()2&3 0, 4#0+) 8*O*8D K-*+* ,-* )2+*1,#+ K0% +*30+)*) 0%$8052&3 0 W*5 +#8* 2& ,+0&%80,2&3 .0&03*.*&, WK8*)3* 2&,# $+01,21*D$0+,21(80+85 2& )*O*8#$2&3 0 1#01-2&3 1(8,(+*'

b, 0& 2&,*+.*)20,* 8*O*8D 2&O0,2O* EbN% K*+* %**& 0% ,-* U$#K*+-#(%*U #/1#8804#+0,2O* K#+W2&3 ,-+#(3- 0 ,*0.g40%*) )*$0+,.*&, .#)*8 2&,*3+0,2&3010)*.21D 182&2108 0&) .0&03*.*&, 8*0)*+%-2$' EbN% K*+* +*30+)*) 0% 0W*5 ,*1-&2 (* ,# 4+2&3 ,#3*,-*+ .(8,2$8* WK8*)3*%' X-* H2+3+#O* EbN8*0)*+%-2$ %,+(1,(+* )2//*+*) /+#. ,-0, #/ ,-* K2)*+ b76E 2& $+#)(12&3 0


62/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


63/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


64/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


65/242


66/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

9+#:*1, ;


67/242


$%' (&)*+ ,-* ,*+.% #/ 0 1#..2%%2#&2&3 1#&,+01, 2%%(*) 45 ,-* 6*1+*,0+5 #/ 6,0,* /#+

7*08,-'

dopson et al (2013) health care managers' access & use of management research.pdf

Documents