download judge bullock's ground rules here

53
UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION Washington, D.C. In the Matter of CERTAIN PROTECTIVE CASES FOR Inv- NI» 337-TA-955 ELECTRONIC DEVICES AND COMPONENTS THEREOF ORDER NO. 2: NOTICE OF GROUND RULES; ORDER SETTING DATE FOR SUBMISSION OF JOINT DISCOVERY STATEMENT (April 30, 2015) GROUND RULES The conduct of this Investigation shall be governed by the Commission Rules and the Ground Rules attached hereto. DISCOVERY STATEMENTS In order that the proceeding in this matter may begin expeditiously, the parties are directed to file a joint discovery statement, on or before May l5, 2015, addressing the questions and issues set forth in Attachment A. TARGET DATE . The parties are advised that an order will issue setting the target date after the undersigned has considered the positions of the parties as set forth in their respective discovery statements. SOORDERED. % Qrles E.Eulloek / 1 Chief Administrative Law Judge

Upload: lethuan

Post on 03-Feb-2017

222 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION

Washington, D.C.

In the Matter of

CERTAIN PROTECTIVE CASES FOR Inv- NI»337-TA-955ELECTRONIC DEVICES ANDCOMPONENTS THEREOF

ORDER NO. 2: NOTICE OF GROUND RULES; ORDER SETTING DATE FORSUBMISSION OF JOINT DISCOVERY STATEMENT

(April 30, 2015)

GROUND RULES

The conduct of this Investigation shall be governed by the Commission Rules and the

Ground Rules attached hereto.

DISCOVERY STATEMENTS

In order that the proceeding in this matter may begin expeditiously, the parties are

directed to file a joint discovery statement, on or before May l5, 2015, addressing the questions

and issues set forth in Attachment A.

TARGET DATE

. The parties are advised that an order will issue setting the target date after the

undersigned has considered the positions of the parties as set forth in their respective discovery

statements.

SOORDERED. %Qrles E.Eulloek /

1 Chief Administrative Law Judge

Page 2: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

ATTACHMENT A

Page 3: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

JOINT DISCOVERY STATEMENT

The parties shall file a Joint Discovery Statement that includes the following:

1. The parties’ positions on the applicable topics of the “Discovery Statement. Checklist” (see Exhibit A).

2. The parties’ positions on the applicable topics of the “Joint Electronic DiscoverySubmission” (see Exhibit B).

3. The parties’ proposed limitations and procedures for fact and expert discoveryincluding: _ i

a. Any recommendations for limiting the production of documents, includingelectronically stored information.

b. Any recommendations for limiting fact depositions, whether by numbersor da s of de ositions e. ., maximum number of de onents, limitinY P 8 P gdepositions by agreeing on a maximum nmnber of days a party maydepose witnesses, etc.).

c. A protocol for electronic discovery, including a brief description of anydisputes regarding the scope of electronic discovery.

d. Whether the parties recommend that expert discovery precede or followany summary determination practice.

e. Whether the parties agree to allow depositions, preceding the hearing, ofhearing witnesses not already deposed.

f. Whether the parties agree to conduct depositions in a particular location(e.g., bring up to five foreign witnesses to the U.S. for deposition).

g. Whether the parties recommend that the ALJ set a date before whichcontention interrogatory responses need not be provided.

h. Whether the parties agree that the provisions of FRCP 26(b)(4)(B) and (C)relating to expert communications apply.

i. Recommendations for limiting the number of claim tenns to be presentedto the ALJ for construction.

Page 4: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

When the parties believe the best time is to engage in mediation. The partiesshould also identify what discovery should precede mediation.

Page 5: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

EXHIBIT A

DISCOVERY STATEMENT CHECKLIST

Issues to be litigated

a. Identify all issues to be litigated (e.g., infringement, affirmativc defenses,importation, domestic industry, remedy, bonding, and public interest (if delegatedto the undersigned by the Commission))

b. Identify specific proposals in which these issues can be narrowed to make thehearing more meaningful and efficient.

A description of information and evidence that each party intends to submit to prove itsown case;

A description of the specific information and evidence that each party will be seekingfrom other parties and third persons;

Possible limitations on document preservation (including electronically storedinformation); .

Preliminary issues that are likely to arise that will require judicial intervention;

Identification of dispositive issues that should be resolved early in the Investigation, andspecific proposals for disposition of such issues;

Identification of issues amenable to stipulations (e.g., electronic service of discovery);

Proposed discovery limitations including, but not limited to:

a. limitations on types of discovery beyond those in the Commission Rules andapplicable Ground Rules (i.e., limits on depositions, number of interrogatories,requests for admission); _

b. limitations on scope of discovery;

c. limitations on timing and sequence of discovery;

d. agreements to allow depositions of hearing witnesses named if not alreadydeposed; and preservation depositions, foreign discovery, or other anticipatedissues; , , ,

e. agreements to exchange certain information without the use of formal discovery;

Page 6: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

f. agreements or limitations on discovery of electronically-stored information];

g. limitations on restoration of electronically-stored information; and

h. limitations on discovery of expert-related hearing preparation materials.

9. Status of any settlement discussions;

10. Status of any litigation that may affect any issue in this Investigation;

11. Status of any proceedings (including reexaminations) before the U.S. Patent andTrademark Office;

12. Proposal for any modifications to the protective order now in effect for this Investigation;

13. Whether a Markman hearing is necessary and if so, a proposed date for the Markmanhearing; and

14. Position as to target date.

i_ii—1This should include a brief summary of any agreements reached in the Joint Electronic Discovery Submission to besubmitted herewith.

Page 7: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

EXHIBIT B

UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION

Washington, D.C.

Before the Honorable Charles E. Bullock

Chief Administrative Law Judge

In the Matter ofInv. N0. 337-TA-955

CERTAIN PROTECTIVE CASES FORELECTRONIC DEVICES ANDCOMPONENTS THEREOF

JOINT ELECTRONIC DISCOVERY SUBMISSION AND [PROPOSED] ORDER

One or more of the parties to this litigation have indicated that they believe that relevantinformation may exist or be stored in electronic fonnat, and that this content is potentiallyresponsive to current and/or anticipated discovery requests. This Joint Submission and[Proposed] Order (and any subsequent orders) shall govem the electronic discovery process inthis action. The parties and the undersigned recognize that this Joint Electronic DiscoverySubmission and [Proposed] Order is based on facts and circumstances as they are currentlyknown to each party, that the electronic discovery process is iterative, and that additions andmodifications to this Submission may become necessary as more information becomes known tothe parties.

I. Competence. Counsel certify that they are sufficiently knowledgeable in matters relatingto their clients’ technological systems to discuss competently issues relating to electronicdiscovery, or have involved someone competent to address these issues on their behalf.

II. Meet and Confer. Counsel are required to meet and confer regarding certain mattersrelating to electronic discovery. Counsel hereby certify that they have met and conferred todiscuss these issues prior to submission of the Discovery Statement.

Date(s) of parties’ meet-and-confer conference(s):

III. Unresolved Issues: After the meet-and-confer conference(s) taking place on the

aforementioned date(s), the following issues remain outstanding and/or require judicialintervention:

Page 8: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

A. Preservation

1 .

Complainant(s):

The parties have discussed the obligation to preserve potentially relevantelectronically stored information and agree to the following scope andmethods for preservation, including but not limited to: retention ofelectronic data and implementation of a data preservation plan;identification of potentially relevant data; disclosure of the programs andmanner in which the data is maintained; identification of computersystem(s) utilized; and identification of the individual(s) responsible fordata preservation, etc.

Respondent(s):

2. State the extent to which the parties have disclosed or have agreed todisclose the dates, contents, and/or recipients of “litigation hold”communications.

Page 9: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

3. The parties anticipate the need for judicial intervention regarding thefollowing issues concerning the duty to preserve, the scope, or themethod(s) of preserving electronically stored infonnation:

B. Search and Review

1 .

Complainant(s):

The parties have discussed methodologies or protocols for the search andreview of electronically stored information, as well as the disclosure oftechniques to be used. Some of the approaches that may be consideredinclude: the use and exchange of keyword search lists, “hit reports,”and/or responsiveness rates; concept search; machine leaming, or otheradvanced analytical tools; limitations on the fields or file types to besearched; date restrictions; limitations on Whetherback-up, archival,legacy, or deleted electronically stored infonnation will be searched;testing; sampling; etc. To the extent the parties have reached agreement asto search and review methods, provide details below.

Respondent(s):

Page 10: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

2. The parties anticipate the need for judicial intervention regarding thefollowing issues concerning the search and review of electronically storedinformation: i

C. Production

Source(s) of Electronically Stored Information. The parties anticipate thatdiscovery may occur from one or more of the following potential source(s)of electronically stored information [e.g., email, word processingdocuments, spreadsheets, presentations, databases, web sites, etc.]:

1.

Comp1ainant(s):

Respondent(s)

Page 11: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

2.

Complainant(s)

Limitations on Production. The parties have discussed factors relating tothe scope of production, including but not limited to: (i) number ofcustodians; (ii) identity of custodians; (iii) date ranges for whichpotentially relevant data will be drawn; (iv) locations of data; (v) timing ofproductions; and (vi) electronically stored information in the custody orcontrol of non-parties. To the extent the parties have reached agreementsrelated to any of these factors, describe below:

Respondent(s):

3. Form(s) of Production:

The parties have reached the following agreements regarding the form(s) of production:

Complainant(s):

Resp0ndent(s):

Page 12: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

a. Please specify any exceptions to the form(s) of productionindicated above (e.g., word processing documents in TIFF withload files, but spreadsheets in native form):

b. The parties anticipate the need for judicial intervention regardingthe following issues conceming the form(s) of production:

Privileged Material Identification. The parties have agreed to thefollowing method(s) for the identification (including the logging, if any, oralternatively, the disclosure of the number of documents withheld), andthe redaction of privileged documents:

Page 13: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

5 .

Complainant(s):

Cost of Production. The parties have analyzed their client’s datarepositories and have estimated the costs associated with the production ofelectronically stored information. The factors and components underlyingthese costs are estimated as follows:

a. Costs

Respondent(s):

b. Cost Allocation. The parties have considered cost-shifting or cost­sharing and have reached the following agreements, if any:

Page 14: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

c. Cost Savings. The parties have considered cost-saving measures,such as the use of a common electronic discovery vendor or ashared document repository, and have reached the followingagreements, if any:

6. The parties anticipate the need for judicial intervention regarding thefollowing issues concerning the production of electronically storedinformation:

Other Issues:

Page 15: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

The preceding constitutes the agreement(s) reached and existing disputes (if any) between theparties to certain matters concerning electronic discovery as of this date. To the extent additionalagreements are reached, modifications are necessary, or disputes are identified, they will beoutlined in subsequent submissions or agreements and promptly presented to the undersigned forconsideration?

DATED: Respectfully submitted,

Counselfor Complainant

Counselfor Respondents

SO ORDERED.

Charles E. BullockChief Administrative Law Judge

ZAdditional written status reports filed pursuant to Ground Rule 4. 1.1(Discovery Committee) shall include the statusof electronic discovery and identify any issues or disputes that have arisen, including any additional agreements ormodifications to the e-discovery submission, as well as any newly arisen disputes.

Page 16: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

' GROUND RULES FOR SECTION 337 INVESTIGATION

These Ground Rules supplement the Commission's Rules of Practice and Procedure, 19C.F.R. Parts 201 and 210 (“Commission Rules"), in order to aid the Administrative Law Judge inthe orderly conduct of the section 337 investigation pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act,5 u.s.c. § ss6(¢). _ - ,

These Ground Rules govern a U.S. patent-based investigation pursuant to 19 U.S.C.§ 1337(a)(1)(B). In the case of an investigation based upon a registered copyright, registeredtrademark, or registered mask work pursuant to 19 U.S.C. § l337(a)(1)(B), (C) or (D), additionalGround Rules may govern. In addition, in a case involving a motion for temporary relief pursuantto 19 U.S.C. § 1337(e), additional Ground Rules may also govern. ' _

In case of any conflict between these Ground Rules and any subsequent order issued by theAdministrative Law Judge or the Commission in this Investigation, the subsequent order shallcontrol. ~

I

Page 17: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

- TABLE OF CONTENTS

Address; Requirements for Filing, Service, and Copies; Time ..............1.1 Address of Administrative Law Judge .........................1.2 ’ Filing Requirement. ........ .........................................1.3 Service Copy Requirements........ .........................................1.4 Word Processor Copy...........1.5 Submission by Fax Disfavored....... ........................1.6 1 AConcurrent Service. .............. ................ .,.... ..1.7 Computation of Time.....................1.8 Request for Extension of Time.... ..................1.9 ConfidentialSubmissions. ..............Procedural Schedule ..................... .........................Motions; Deadlines for Responses ..........................3.1 ' Contents; In General. ....3.2 Contents; Certification. ........... ..... ...............3.3 Contents; Motion for Summary Determination ................3.4 Contents; Response to Motion for Summary Determination.3.5 Contents; Discovery-Related Motions.......................................3.6 Deadline for Filing Response to Motion ................................. _3.7 Requestfor ShortenedTime to Respondto Motion. ..........3.8 No Motion Stops Discovery Except Motion to Quash Subpoena. .........Discovery .................................................................................................................4.1 Resolution of Disputes; Coordinated Discovery.

4.1.1 Discovery Committee ....................... .............................4.2 Stipulations Regarding Discovery Procedure. .............................4.3 Service of Discovery Requests and Responses...............4.4 Timing of Discovery Requests, Responses and Objections.

4.4.1 Depositions; Notice ................................................... ......................4.4.2 Interrogatories; Deadline for Responses and Objections .......................4.4.3 Requests for Production of Documents or Things or for Entry Upon

Land; Deadline for Responses and Objections. ......................................84.4.4 Request for Admission; Period for Service; Deadline for Responses

and Objections ................'.....................4.4.5 DiscoveryCutoffandCompletion.

4.5 lnterrogatory Limitation............. ...............................4.6 Subpoenas. ......................... ...........................

4.6.1 Issuance and Service. ...... ........

V 4.6.2 Motion to Quash Subpoena; Deadline. ................4.7 Bates Numbering ................................................................4.8 Translations. ......4.9 Privileged Matter. ....................... ...........................

4.9.1 Privileged Document List ................................................ ........104.9.2 'Motion to Compel_Pr'oduction of Privileged'Matter. ......§.l0

Notice of Prior Art ...........................................................................................................10

%\l\l\I\IQ\6\O\O\G\@\G\Ul?JlUIUlUIl~Jl~)l~)l\ll~Jl~)>—lb-It-It-ll—l

:

sowlaoeeeoeoeae

i

Page 18: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

PsawE’

9.

10.

Markman Hearingon ClaimConstruction........;....................................... ..Expert Witnesses and Reports .......................................Settlement/Mediation ..................................................Pre-trial Submissions......8.18.28.38.4

Pre-trial Statement ..........................Pre-trial Brief. ............................................ ............High Priority Objections for Pre-hearing conference.Motions in Limine. ............................................ .._........

Heari -E id ce and Exh'bits ................ ...............9.19.29.3

9.4

ng ven 1Material To Be Received Into Evidence......... ...............Legal Experts ......................................Witness Testimony. ................ ............................9.3.1 Format of Witness Statements............ .....................9.3.2 Language of Witness Statements.Exhibits. ................ .................. ............. .....9.4.1 Exchange of Proposed Exhibits Among Parties ......................9.4.2 Service of Proposed Exhibits Upon Administrative Law Judge...9.4.3 ' Format of Commission's Exhibit Set........................................9.4.4 Format of the ALJ’s Binder Set......._.........................................9.4.5 Maintenance and Filing of Final Exhibits and Final Exhibit List

9.4.5.1. Submission of Final Exhibits to theAdministrative Law Judge. .................................

9.4.5.2. Binder Exhibit Set for the Office of General Counsel. .Numbering and Labeling of Exhibits. ...................................9.4.6.1 .Confidential Exhibits.9.4.6.2 Physical Exhibits .......9.4.6.3 Demonstrative Exhibits.......Public and Confidential Exhibits........ ..................Exhibit Lists ............................ ...................

9.4.6

9.4.79.4.89.4.9 Foreign Language Exhibits. ......... ...................9.4.10 One Document Per Exhibit; All Pages Bates-numbered.........9.4.11 Witness Exhibit Binder ................................................9.4.12 References for Exhibit........9.4.13 Authenticity. ...... .........................9.4.14 Sponsoring Witness.......... .........................9.4.15 Exhibits in Dispute ...........................9.4.16 Filing of Exhibits by CDIDVD Media. ............» 9.4.1-6.1 Delivery to Administrative Law Judge..........

Hearing Procedure ......................................................._..........10.110.210.310.4

Hearing; Order of Examination.Closing Argument. ....... ................Hearing Hours .... ................Trial Decorum. .................10.4.1 Conversations at Trial. ........ ................ .......10.4.2 Reading Matter; Cell Phones and Beepers; Food and Beverages.

~ ii _

O

Page 19: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

10.4.3 Photos or Video Recording. ...................................................10.4.4 Swearing of Witnesses. .......................................10.4.5 Arguments on Objection. ...........................................

10.5 Examination of Witnesses. ......t.............10.5.1ScopeofExamination;InGeneral. ............10.5.2 Scope of Cross-examination. ............... ............10.5.3 Scope of Redirect and Re-cross Examination.10.5.4 Coordination of Witnesses. ........... ..10.5.5 Documents Presented to Witnesses. ..10.5.6 Scope of Expert Witness Testimony. ................10.5.7 Coordination of Respondents‘ Cross-examination.

. 10.5.8 Requests for Clarification of a Question .............10.5.9 Use of Translators. ..........................................................10.5.10 Conferring with Witness during a Break in Testimony...

Post-trial Briefs and Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law11.1 Initial Post-trial Briefs; Filing and Content. ................................11.2 Proposed Findings of Fact; Form and Content ..........11.3 Post-trial Reply Briefs; Filing and Content.‘.....................................11.4 Objections and Rebuttals to Proposed Findings of.Fact;

Form and Content. .............................................................Citation of Cases ...........................Coordination of Post-Hearing Briefs ..........................Cooperation Among Parties ......... ..........................Ex Parte Contacts ...........................................................................................

iii

Page 20: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

JUDGE BULLOCK'S GROUND RULES

1. Address; Requirements for Filing, Service, and Copies; Time

1.1 Address of Administrative Law Judge.

The Administrative Law Judge’s address is as_follows:

The Honorable Charles E. BullockU.S. International Trade Commission500 E Street, S.W., Room 317Washington, D.C. 20436

_ 1.2 Filing Requirement. .

All submissions shall be filed with the Office of the Secretary of the Commission inaccordance with Commission Rule 210.4(f) unless otherwise specifically provided for in theseGround Rules or by order of the Administrative Law Judge. ­

' 1.3 Service Copy Requirements. _ ­

In accordance with the requirements of Commission Rules 2l0.4(t)(2) and (g), copies ofeach submission shall be served on all other parties, including the Commission InvestigativeAttorney. Also, on the same day that the submission is filed, a courtesy electronic copy in Wordor PDF fonnat, excluding attachments such as exhibits, shall be sent to the Administrative LawJudge's attomey-advisor, Irina Kushner, at the following email address:[email protected]. In addition, two courtesy paper copies of each submission (excludingnotices of appearance and subpoenas) shall be submitted to the Administrative Law Judge at theaddress listed in Ground Rule 1.1 the next business day afier the submission is filed. If the nextbusiness day is a Saturday, Sunday, Federal legal holiday, or a day on which weather or otherconditions have made the Office of the Secretary of the Commission inaccessible, the twocourtesy paper copies shall be submitted the next business day that is not one of theaforementioned days. ‘

' 1.4 Word Processor Copy. _ '

In the case of any filing of 25 pages or more (excluding attachments), or in the case of anyfiling that contains lengthy quotations from a--patent,transcript, treatise or other document, thecourtesy paper copies delivered to the Administrative Law Judge shall, if possible, beaccompanied by an electronic version of the filing in Microsofi Word.‘ A

l

Page 21: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

1.5 Submission by Fax Disfavored. - .

Submissions to the Administrative Law Judge by fax are strongly disfavored and are notto be made without his prior approval.

1.6 Concurrent Service.

Service on opposing counselmay be by hand, by facsimile, by e—mail,or by overnightcourier. Parties are encouraged to agree upon a method of service so that the parties will receiveall submissions at the same time the submissions are received by the Commission.

1.7 Computation of Time. A

The first day of the ten (10) calendar days for responding to a motion received by theAdministrative Law Judge shall be the first business day following the date that said motion wasfiled in the Office of the Secretary, and shall apply whether a motion is hand delivered, faxed orserved by overnight courier on the other patties. In addition to the requirements of CommissionRules 201.14, 20l.16(d), and 210.6 for computation of time, if the last day of the period of time formaking a submission falls on a day on which weather or other conditions have made the Office ofthe Secretary of the Commission inaccessible, the period shall rim until the end of the nextbusiness day which is not one of the aforementioned days.

1.8 Request for Extension of Time. , ; .

Any request for extension of time must be made by written motion the day before the duedate and good cause for such extension must be established.

1.9 Confidential Submissions.

The confidential nature of any filing with the Office of the Secretary of the Commission orof any submission to the Administrative Law Judge shall be conspicuously noted on the top pageof any filing or other submission. No cover letter or other document shall be stapled or otherwiseattached to a filing or other submission so as to obscure the confidential marking on the top page.

2 Procedural Schedule e

The Administrative Law Judge will promulgate a procedural schedule for the investigation.Modifications of the procedural schedule by any party shall be made by written motion showing

2 .

Page 22: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

good cause. The event and deadline dates in the procedural schedule will generally adhere to thefollowing chronological order: '

First settlement conference

Submission of first settlement conference joint report .

File identification of expert witnesses, including their expertise andcurriculum vitae _

Attendance at one-day mediation session‘‘ .

Submission of joint report on mediation

File notice of prior art _ E

Exchange of initial expert reports (identify tests/surveys/data)

File tentative list of witnesses a party will call to.testify at the hearing,with an identification of each witness‘ relationship to the party

Exchange ofrebuttal expert reports

Fact discovery cutoff and completion - _

Deadline for motions to compel discovery

Expert discovery cutoff and completion '

Second settlement conference ­

l . . . .Submission of second settlement conference _|omtreport

Deadline for filing summary determination motions

Exchange of exhibit lists among the parties

Submit and serve direct exhibits (including witness statements), withphysical and demonstrative exhibits available —Complainant(s) andRespondent(s)

Submit and serve direct exhibits (including witness statements), withphysical and demonstrative exhibits available —Staff

'— " ' File ‘pre-trialstatements and briefs —Complainant(s) and Respondent(s)

File requests for receipt of evidence without a witness

I For any questions -regarding the mediation program, the parties should refer to the Revised_Users' Manual forCommission Mediation Program, available at http:_//www.usitc.gov. _ '

- 2

Page 23: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

File objections to direct exhibits (including witness statements)

Submit and serve rebuttal exhibits (including witness statements), withrebuttal physical and demonstrative exhibits available '—all parties

Deadline for motions in limine I

File pre-trial statement and brief —Staff

File responses to objections to direct exhibits (including witnessstatements) '

File objections to rebuttal exhibits (including witness statements)

~Filejhigh priority objections statement

File responses to objections to rebuttal exhibits (including witnessstatements)

- File responses to high priority objections statement

File responses to motions in limine

Tutorial on technology (if necessary)

Pre-trial conference '

Hearing j _

. File initial post-trial briefs, proposed findings of fact and conclusions oflaw, and final exhibit lists

File reply post-trial briefs, objections and rebuttals to proposed findingsof fact

Initial Detemiination due

Target date for completion of investigation

4

Page 24: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

3 Motions; Deadlines for Responses

3.1 _Contents; In General.

All written motions shall consist of: (l) the motion; (2) a separate memorandum of pointsand authorities in support of the moti0n;2 (3) an appendix of declarations, affidavits, exhibits, orother attachments in support of the memorandum of points and authorities; and (4) a Certificate ofService as required by Commission Rule 20l.16(c). All responses to motions shall include theMotion Docket Number assigned to the motion by the Commission's Office of the Secretary ineither the title or the first paragraph of any such response, 3 and shall consist of: (1) amemorandum of points and authorities in response to the motion; (2) an appendix of declarations,affidavits, exhibits, or other attachments in support of the memorandum of points and authorities;and (3) a Certificate of Service as required by Commission Rule 20l.l6(c).

3.2 Contents; Certification.

All motions shall include a certification that the moving party has made reasonable,good-faith efforts to resolve the matter with the other parties at least two business days prior tofiling the motion, and shall state, if known, the position of the other parties on such motion. Saidcertification shall be placed at the beginning of the motion under a heading entitled "Ground Rule3.2 Certification" or similar language. '

3.3 Contents; Motion for Summary Determination.

In addition to the foregoing requirements for all motions, motions for sunnnarydetermination shall be further accompanied by a separate statement of the material facts as towhich the moving party contends there is no genuine issue and which entitle the moving party to asummary detemrination as a matter of law. The statement shall consist of short numberedparagraphs with specific references to supporting declarations, affidavits or other materials.

3.4 r Contents; Response to Motion for Summary Determination.

In addition to the foregoing requirements for all responses to motions, each party opposinga motion for summary determination shall append to the response a separate statement respondingindividually to the numbered paragraphs of the motion statement required by Ground Rule 3.3with which the party disagrees, with specific references to supporting declarations, affidavits orother materials. The responsive statement shall also include any similarly numbered paragraphsof additional facts, similarly referenced and supported, which the opposing party believes warrantdenial of summary determination. All material facts set forth in the moving party's statement maybe deemed admitted by a non-moving party unless so specifically controverted in the norrmovingparty’s responsive statement. i ­

2 For procedural motions, such as motions for extensions of time, a separate memorandum is not necess_ary.'3 Motion Docket Numbers may be obtained online through the Commission's Electronic Document InformationSystem (EDIS). '

5

Page 25: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

3.5 Contents; Discovery-Related Motions.

Any discovery-related motion must have appended to it the pertinent parts of the discoveryrequest and all objections and answers thereto. Additionally, if a party serves supplementalresponses subsequent to the filing of a motion to compel, that party must provide copies of thesupplemental responses, or where documents are produced, a detailed accounting of whatadditional documents were produced.

3.6 Deadline for Filing Response to Motion.

In addition to the requirements of Commission Rules 201.16 and 2l0._15(c)goveming thetime period for a nomnoving party’s response to a written motion, the date of service of a motionon a nonmoving party by electronic mail, hand-delivery or by an express-type mail or courierservice is the date of delivery. The additional time provided under Commission Rule 201.16(d)after service by mail does not apply in such instances, unless service by electronic mail,hand-delivery or by an express-type mail or courier service is to a nonmoving party in a foreigncountry, in which event the additional time allowed for responses to motions shall be five (5) days.

3.7 Request for Shortened Time to ‘Respondto Motion.

A motion may include a request to shorten the period of time during which other partiesmay respond to the motion. The fact that a shortened response time is requested shall be noted inthe title of the motion and the motion shall include an explanation of the grounds for such arequest. A request for a shortened response time shall not be made through a separate motion.

3.8 . No Motion Stops Discovery Except Motion to Quash Subpoena. '

No motion stops discovery except a timely motion to quash a subpoena.

4 Discovery

4.1 Resolution of Disputes; Coordinated Discovery. . 4 '

All parties shall make reasonable efforts to resolve among themselves disputes arisingduring discovery. Parties with similar interests must coordinate and consolidate depositions andall other discovery. '

4.1.1 Discovery Committee. "

Commencing with the first full week after these Ground Rules are issued, a discoveryconference committee (the "Discovery Committee") consisting of the lead counsel of each partyand the Commission Investigative Staff Attorney shall conveneiat least once every two weeksduring the discovery phase of this Investigation, either in person or by telephone, to resolvediscovery disputes. The Discovery Committee shall confer in good faith to resolve every

6

Page 26: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

outstanding discovery dispute in a timely manner within the deadlines set forth in the ProceduralSchedule. Within ten calendar days alter the end of each calendar month during the discoveryphase, the Discovery Committee shall report in writing to the Administrative Law Judge alldisputes that were resolved during the preceding month and all disputes on which there is animpasse as of the end of that month. No motion to compel discovery may-be filed unless thesubject matter ofthe motion has first been brought to the Discovery Committee and the Committeehas reached an impasse in resolving the matter.

4.2 Stipulations Regarding Discovery Procedure.

Unless otherwise directed by the Administrative Law Judge, the parties may by writtenstipulation (1) provide that depositions may be taken before any person, at any time or place, uponany notice, and in any manner and when so taken may be used like other depositions, and (2)modify other procedures governing or limitations placed upon discovery, except that stipulationsextending the time provided in Groimd Rules 4.4.2, 4.4.3, and 4.4.4 for responses to discoverymay, if they would interfere withthe target date of the investigation or with any time set in theprocedural schedule or in an order for completion of discovery, for hearing of a motion, or for thetrial, be made only with the approval of the Administrative Law Judge upon a written motionshowing good cause. .

4.3 Service of Discovery Requests and Responses.

Discovery requests and responses thereto shall be served upon all parties, including theCommission InvestigativeAttorney, but shall not be served on the Administrative Law Judggunless they are pertinent to a motion. Discovery documents need not be served on the Office ofthe Secretary of the Commission unless they are appended to motions.

4.4 Timing of Discovery Requests,'Responses and Objections.

4.4.1 Depositions; Notice. . ,

In addition to the requirements of Commission Rule 210.28(c), unless otherwise ordered,any party desiring to take a deposition shall give notice in writing to every other party of not lessthan ten (10) days if the deposition is to be taken of a person located in the United States, or of notless than fifteen (15) business days if the deposition is to be taken of a person located outside theUnited States. '

7

Page 27: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

4.4.2 Interrogatories; Deadline for Responses and Objections.

A In addition to the requirements of Commission Rule 210.29(b), unless otherwise ordered,the party upon whom interrogatories have been served shall serve a copy of the answers, and anyobjections, within ten (10) days after the service of the interrogatories. _ i

4.4.3 Requests for Production of Documents or Things or for Entry Upon' Land; Deadline for Responses and Objections.

In addition to the requirements of Commission Rule 2_10.30(b)(2)with respect to a requestfor the production of documents or things, or to permit entry upon land, unless otherwise ordered,the party upon whom a request has been served shall serve a written response within ten (10) daysafter the service of the request.

l 4.4.4 Request for Admission; Period for Service; Deadline for Responsesand Objections.

In addition to the requirements of Commission Rule 2l0.31(a) and (b), unless otherwiseordered, a request for admission may be served at any time twenty (20) days after the date ofservice of the Complaint and Notice of Investigation. Unless otherwise ordered, a party uponwhom a request for admission has been served, shall serve an answer or objection within ten (10)days after the service of the request, otherwise the matter may be deemed admitted.

4.4.5 Discovery Cutoff and Completion.

All discovery requests, including without limitation requests for admissions, must beinitiated in sufficient time prior to the fact discovery cutoff and completion date so that theresponses will be due prior to that date within the time periods set forth above. Discoveryrequests by any party that would require responses after the fact discovery cutoff and completiondate must be approved in advance by the Administrative Law Judge upon a showing of compellingcircumstances. - _ i

4.5 Interrogatory Limitation. ,

Without leave of the Administrative Law Judge or written stipulation, any party may serveupon any other party written interrogatories not exceeding 175 in number including all discretesubparts. Leave to serve additional interrogatories shall be granted by the Administrative LawJudge only upon a written motion showing good cause. »

‘ 4.6 Subpoenas. <

, 4.6.1 Issuance and Service. . . . q ' V

Pursuant to Commission Rule'210.32, application for subpoena may be madeex parte tothe Administrative Law Judge. The application shall be in writing ‘withthe proposed subpoena

1

8

Page 28: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

attached, and one (l) copy thereof submitted to the office of the Administrative Law Judges. Theapplication shall set forth with specificity the relevancy of the information sought and thereasonableness of the scope of the inquiry. In addition, the subpoena should set forth a time limitfor a motion to quash and should also state that the subpoena will be served by overnight delivery,if not sooner. Any dates in a subpoena set for appearance of a deponent or production ofdocuments should take into account the date set for the filing of any motions to quash. A copy ofthe issued subpoena and the application shall be served by the applicant upon the subpoenaed partyand all other parties to the investigation on the next business day, at the latest, after the subpoena isissued, and all parties including the subpoenaed party shall be notified on that day about thecontents of the subpoena. One (l) copy of the issued subpoena, the application, and the proof ofservice to the subpoenaed party shall be supplied to the Administrative Law Judge. Samples ofsubpoenas are attached in Appendix A hereto. The application and subpoena need not be filedwith or served on the Office of the Secretary of the Commission, including EDIS, unless they areappended to a motion to quash or motion for a protective order. ' _

4.6.2 Motion to Quash Subpoena; Deadline.

In addition to the requirements of Commission Rule 2l0.32(d), any motion to limit orquash a subpoena shall be filed within ten (10) days after receipt thereof, or within such other timeas the Administrative Law Judge may allow. Filing of any motion to quash an issued subpoenaautomatically stays such subpoena pending disposition of the motion by the Administrative LawJudge. I

p4.7 Bates Numbering.

If documents produced by any supplier in response to a document request are fumished tothe requester as copies of original documents, every page of every such document shall benumbered sequentially by a unique number (commonly known as a "Bates number")- The Batesnumber shall appear stamped on the lower right-hand corner of the page.

4.8 Translations.

All documents produced in response to a document request shall be the "originalor truecomplete copies of originals. If an English translation of any document produced exists, theEnglish translation shall be produced. If any of the parties dispute the translation provided by theproducing party, then the translation must be certified by a qualified and neutral translator uponwhom counsel can agree. -_ ' I

4.9 Privileged Matter.

In order to expedite discovery, the following procedure shall be followed with respect tothose documents for which counsel claims privilege (attomey-client or work product).

9

Page 29: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

4.9.1 Privileged Document List. .

If production of any document is withheld on the basis of a claim of privilege, each withhelddocument must be separately identified via a privileged document list.4 The privileged documentlist shall be supplied, unless otherwise ordered, within ten (10) days after objections based onprivilege to the underlying document requests are due. The privileged document list mustidentify each document separately, specifying for each document at least the following: (1) thedate; (2) the author(s)/sender(s); (3) the recipient(s), including copy recipient(s); and (4) thegeneral subject matter of the document. The sender(s) and recipient(s) shall be identified byposition and entity (corporation or firm, etc.) with which they are employed or associated. If theauthor/sender or recipient is an attorney or foreign patent agent, he or she shall be so identified.The type of privilege claimed must also be stated, together with certification that all elements ofthe claimed privilege have been met and not waived with respect to each document.

4.9.2 Motion to Compel Production of Privileged Matter.

Any party seeking production of allegedly privileged documents shall file an appropriatemotion only alter examining the privileged document list. .

The Administrative Law Judge is aware that, oflen times, parties agree that production of aprivilege log is not necessary. The Administrative Law Judge finds such an agreement to beacceptable; however, if such an agreement is in force, the Administrative Law Judge will notconsider any motions involving privileged documents.

5 Notice of Prior Art

. , Parties must file on or before the date set in the procedural schedule, notices of any prior artconsisting of the following information: country, number, date, and name of the patentee of anypatent; the title, date and page numbers of any publication to be relied upon as anticipation of thepatent in suit; or as showing the state of the art, and the name and address of any person who maybe relied upon as the prior inventor or as having prior knowledge ofor as having previously used oroffered for sale the invention of the patent in suit.

If _atrademark is involved, the parties must file on or before the date set in the proceduralschedule, notices of any art on which a party will rely at the hearing regarding the functionality ornon-functionality of any trademarks at issue. " _

In the absence of such notice, proof of said matters may not be introduced into evidence atthe hearing except upon a timely written motion showing good cause. ­

4 See Duplan Corp. v. Deering Milli/(in, Inc., 397 F. Supp. 1146, l84 U.S.P.Q. 775 (D.S.C. 1974). .

- ' 10 '

Page 30: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

5A. Markman Hearing on Claim Construction

If the Administrative Law Judge determines that a Markman hearing would be beneficial tothe Investigation, the Administrative Law Judge may conduct a Markman hearing on the date setforth in the procedural schedule for the purpose of construing any disputed claim tenns of thepatents at issue in the Investigation. The parties and Commission Investigative Staff shall meetand confer on these issues no later than ten (10) days before the Markman hearing in order toreduce the number of disputed claim terms to a minimum. Before the Markman hearing,Complainant(s), Respondent(s) (if there is more than one Respondent, they are required to file ajoint brief), and Staff shall file with the Administrative Law Judge, by the date set forth in theprocedural schedule, a short written ‘statementof its interpretation of each of the remainingdisputed claim terms together with its support for each interpretation as a matter of ordinarymeaning, or as derived from the claims, specification, or prosecution history of the patent(s) atissue, or from extrinsic evidences If there are multiple patents at issue, the brief should beorganized by patent, similar to the outline for post-trial briefs (see Appendix B). Rebuttal briefsmay also be filed by the date set forth in the procedural schedule. After the Markman hearing, theparties shall submit a joint chart, by the date set forth in the procedural schedule, setting forth theirpost-hearing constructions. Afterwards, the Administrative Law Judge will issue an orderconstruing the disputed claims for the purposes of the Investigation. Thereafter, discovery andbriefing in the Investigation shall be limited to that claim construction.

6 Expert Witnesses and Reports

On or before the dates set forth in the procedural schedule, a party shall disclose to otherparties the identity of any person who is retained or employed to provide expert testimony at thehearing and shall provide to the other parties a written report prepared and signed by the witness.The report shall not be filed with the Office of the Secretary of the Commission. The report shallcontain a complete statement of all opinions to be expressed and the basis and reasons therefor; thedata or other information considered by the witness in forming the opinions; any exhibits to beused as a summary of or support for the opinions; the qualifications of the witness, including a listof all publications ‘authoredby the witness within the preceding ten years; the compensation to bepaid for the study and testimony; and a listing of any other cases in which the witness has testifiedas an expert at trial or by deposition within the preceding four years. The parties shall supplementthese disclosures as needed in the manner provided in Commission Rule 210.27(c).i5 See Phillips v. AWH Corp,, 415 F.3d 1303 (Fed. Cir. 2005) (en bane); Markman v. WestviewInstruments, Inc., 52F.3d 967, 979-81 (Fed. Cir. 1995), aj]"d, 517 U.S. 370 (1996). '

11

Page 31: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

7 Settlement/Mediation _

All parties, throughout the duration of the proceedings, shall explore reasonablepossibilities for settlement of all or any of the contested issues. All panics shall certify in theirpre-trial statements that" good faith efforts were undertaken to settle the remaining issues.Additionally, for each of the required settlement conferences and the one-day mediation providedfor in the procedural schedule, the parties shall provide the Administrative Law Judge with twocopies of a joint report signed by all the parties setting forth any stipulations on which the partieshave agreed. These reports are due by the time designated in the procedural schedule or withinsuch other time as the Administrative Law Judge may allow. The reports shall not be filed withthe Office of the Secretary of the Commission.

8 Pre-trial Submissions

8.1 Pre-trial Statement. .

Each party who desires to participate in the hearing in this Investigation must file on orbefore the date setforth in the procedural schedule a pre-trial statement containing the followinginformation: . ‘

(a) The names of all known witnesses, their addresses, whether they are fact or expertwitnesses (and their area of expertise), and a brief outline of the testimony of each witness.In the case of expert witnesses, a copy of the expert's curriculum vitae shall accompany thissubmission. V

(b) A list of all exhibits which the parties will seek to introduce at the hearing.

(c) A list of any stipulations on which the parties have agreed.

(d) A proposed agenda for the pre-trial conference.

(e) Estimated date and approximate length for appearance of each witness. The parties shallconfer on estimated dates and approximate length prior to submission of their pre-trialstatements.

(t) Certification regarding good faith efforts to settle. _

12

Page 32: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

8.2 Pre-trial Brief.

On or before the date set forth in the procedural schedule, each party shall file a pre-trialbrief. The pre-trial brief shall be prefaced with a table of contents and a table of authorities. Thepre-trial brief shall set forth a party’s contentions on each of the proposed issues, includingcitations to legal authorities in support thereof, and -shallconform to the general outline set forth inAppendix B hereto. All issues, including issues not specifically named in the general outline thatany party seeks to address, shall be inserted into the general outline where appropriate. Theparties shall meet and confer as needed prior to filing the pre-trial briefs in order to determineappropriate common locations for each issue in the foregoing outline of every pre-trial brief. Theparties shall provide complete proposed claim construction for all patent claims at issue.

Any contentions not set forth in detail as required herein shall be deemed abandoned orwithdrawn, except for contentions of which a party is not aware and could not be aware in theexercise of reasonable diligence at the time of filing the pre-trial brief. _

8.3 High Priority Objections for Pre-hearing conference.

Each party's objections to rebuttal and/or supplemental exhibits shall be accompanied byanother submission listing and providing a narrative explanation of the objections to exhibitswhich the party believes to be of high priority for discussion and/or ruling at the pre-trialconference. The objections placed on the high priority list may be taken from the party’sobjections to direct, rebuttal and/or supplemental exhibits. No party shall place more than tenobjections on the high priority list. .

High priority objections and responses thereto shall include the exhibit(s) that is the subjectof the objection and/or exhibit(s) that is referenced or discussed in the objection or response. Anyhigh priority objection that does not include said exhibit(s) will not be considered.

8.4 Motions in Limine.

Unless otherwise permitted by the Administrative Law Judge, each side shall be limited toa maximum often motions in limine. The parties should not attempt to circumvent this limitationby including numerous subsections in a motion in limine.

Motions in limine and responses thereto shall include the exhibit(s) that is the subject ofthemotion and/or exhibit(s) that is referenced or discussed in the response. Any motion in limine thatdoes not include said exhibit(s) will not be considered. " ' '

9 Hearing - Evidence and Exhibits

9.1 ‘ Material To Be Received Into Evidence. . _

Orily factual material and expert opinion shall be received into evidence. ' Legal argumentshall be presented in the briefs. I

V 13

Page 33: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

9.2 Legal Experts. ,

Legal experts may only testify as to procedures of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office.

9.3 Witness Testimony. ' .

All direct witness testimony, with the exception of adverse witnesses, shall be made bywitness statements in lieu of live testimony. Staff may, however, ask the witness supplementaldirect testimony on the witness stand. Witness statements shall be marked and offered intoevidence as exhibits, and witnesses shall be available for cross-examination on the witness standunless waived. Witnesses will not read their prepared testimony into the record.

9.3.1 Format of Witness Statements.

A witness statement shall be in the form of numbered questions from counsel, with eachquestion followed by the witness's own answer to that question, and with the final question fromcounsel asking the witness whether or not the witness statement contains the witness's answers tothe questions from counsel, followed by the witness’s answer to this question and the witness'ssignature. The witness statement shall be assigned an exhibit number and each question shall benumbered consecutively. ,

9.3.2 Language of Witness Statements. _

A witness statement shall be in the language of the witness, and a foreign language witnessstatement shall be accompanied by a certified translation thereof.

9.4 Exhibits. '

9.4.1 ~ Exchange of Proposed Exhibits Among Parties.

Copies of documentary proposed exhibits, along with a proposed exhibit list shall beserved on the opposing parties .(including the Commission Investigative Attorney) on the dateordered in the procedural schedule. Once the parties have exchanged their proposed exhibit lists,they shall eliminate any duplicative exhibits or renumber such exhibits as joint exhibits and updatetheir exhibit lists before they are submitted to the Administrative Law Judge by the due date in theprocedural schedule. Proposed physical and demonstrative exhibits need not be served, but shallbe identified in the proposed exhibitlist. Proposedephysicaland demonstrative exhibits, however,must be made available for inspection by the other parties on the date established for thesubmission and service of proposed exhibits. Proposed exhibits shall not be filed with the Officeof the Secretary of the Commission. '

. _14

Page 34: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

g 9.4.2 Service of Proposed Exhibits Upon Administrative Law Judge.

On the date that is set forth in the procedural schedule, the Administrative Law Judge shallreceive an electronic PDF version of all proposed exhibits, along with a proposed exhibit list. Theelectronic version of proposed exhibits may be submitted on an external hard drive or a flash drive.If "apatty has received permission from the Secretary to file the Com1nission's exhibit set on paper,said party shall also submit a set containing each proposed exhibit in an individual folder (whichwill be used for scanning purposes). Clear photocopies may be used instead of originaldocuments.

9.4.3 Format of Commission’s Exhibit Set.

The following shall apply ONLY if a party has received permission from the Secretary tofile the Commission’s exhibit set on paper: '

Exhibits in the Commission set shall consist of loose sheets (which may be clipped but not stapled)in folders (file folders, accordion folders, etc.) that are provided in sequentially-ntunbered boxes.Each folder must be labeled to reflect the number of the exhibit contained therein, e.g., RX-0014C.In each of the boxes of the Commission exhibit set, the folders containing the exhibits shall beplaced in numerical order.

9.4.4 Format of the ALJ’s Binder Set.

The exhibits in the Administrative Law Judge‘s binder set shall be individually tabbed,with each tab reflecting the number of the corresponding exhibit, e.g., CX-0003C. Each bindermust be labeled on its spine with the name and number of the investigation and the nature of thecontents of the binder, e.g. Complainant's Exhibits CX-0001 through CX-0018C. The exhibits inthe binder set shall be in consecutive numerical order, and shall not be separated according toconfidential or public status.

" 9.4.5 Maintenance and Filing of Final Exhibits and Final Exhibit List.

Each party must submit a final exhibit list prepared in accordance with Ground Rule 9.4.8reflecting the status of all exhibits, including those admitted and rejected during the hearing, on thesame date that the post-hearing briefs are due. Any withdrawn exhibit shall be identified on thefinal exhibit list only by exhibit number and shall indicate that it is withdrawn. ' A

V The -parties are responsible during the course of the-hearing for updating the exhibit listsand for maintaining and updating the Commission set of exhibits, which shall become the set thatis filed with the Commission after the record is closed, as well as for confirming that all admittedand rejected exhibits are included among the Commission exhibits and the final exhibit list at theconclusion of the hearing. Any exhibits that are not included with the Commission exhibits andthe final exhibit list at the conclusion of the hearing will not be considered as part of the record tobe certified to the Commission when the final initial determination issues. ' i p

15

Page 35: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

All final Commission exhibits‘shall be submitted to the office of the Administrative LawJudge who will transmit the Commission exhibits to Docket Services. The Commission exhibitsshould not be submitted directly to Docket Services. » '

9.4.5.1. Submission of Final Exhibits to the AdministrativeLaw Judge. C

On the same day that initial post-hearing -briefs are due, the parties shall submit '[1] theAdministrative Law Judge's binder set of all the final exhibits in the format set forth in GroundRule 9.4.4; [2] an electronic version‘ofthe final set of exhibits to the Administrative Law Judge forhis use in drafting the final initial determination; and [3] the Commission set of exhibits, withrejected exhibits submitted under separate cover and so marked. The Commission set of exhibitsm be submittedon CD. The Administrative Law Judge's set, however,may be submittedon anextemal hard drive or flash drive and need not be separated in the manner set forth in Ground Rule9.4.16. ,

9.4.5.2. Binder Exhibit Set for the Office of General Counsel. ‘

No later than thirty (30) days after the submission of post~trial reply briefs, each party shalldeliver one additional binder set of copies of all exhibits except withdrawn exhibits directly to theOffice of General Counsel along with a final exhibit list, with rejected exhibits submitted underseparate cover and so marked. In the altemative, the parties may submit this set electronicallypursuant to Ground Rule 9.4.16.

9.4.6 Numbering and Labeling of Exhibits. _ i

Written exhibits shall be marked serially commencing with the four digit number “O0O1"and preceded by the prefix “CX” for Complainant's exhibits, "RX" for Respondent(s)' exhibits,“SX" for the Commission Investigative Attorney's exhibits, and “IX” for any joint exhibits. Theparties shall not "reserve" numbers, but instead shall assign all numbers in consecutive sequence.

Each, exhibit shall be marked by placing a label bearing the exhibit's number (e.g.,CX-0003C or RX-0005) in the upper right portion of the exhibit's first page. The pages of eachexhibit must be sequentially numbered in a consistent location on the pages.

Respondent(s) shall coordinate their numbering to avoid duplication in numbering.Additionally, the parties shall coordinate exhibits to avoid unnecessary duplication (e.g., patents;fl-le-wrappers)-.~'F'urther,eallexhibits or copies -ofexhibits shall be clear and legible. Lastly, eachexhibit may be assigned no more than one number. . - _

i ' 9.4.6.1 -Confidential Exhibits. _

' If an exhibit contains confidential business information, a "C" shall be placed afier theexhibit ntunber. Furthermore, exhibits containing confidential business information shall-be sodesignated pursuant to the Protective Order. ~Inaddition, on any exhibit list submitted, exhibits

.16 ­

Page 36: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

which contain confidential business information shall be denoted by placing a "C" after the exhibitnumber in the listing. No exhibit list shall contain confidential infonnation; all exhibits lists shallbe public documents.

< 9.4.6.2 Physical Exhibits.

Physical exhibits shall be numbered in a separate series commencing the four-digit number"0001" preceded by the prefixes “CPX", “RPX”, “SPX" and _“JPX",for Complainant, Respondent,the Commission Investigative Attorney, and joint exhibits, respectively. Confidential exhibitsshall be denoted with the letter “C” as in the case of documentary exhibits. ­

9.4.6.3 Demonstrative Exhibits. ­

Demonstrative exhibits shall be ‘numbered in a separate series commencing with thefour-digit number “0001l" preceded by the prefixes "CDX", “RDX", and "SDX", for Complainant,Respondent(s), and the Commission Investigative Attorney, respectively. Confidential exhibitsshall be denoted with the letter "C". Additionally, the parties shall provide the AdministrativeLaw Judge with two (2) copies of key demonstrative exhibits (e.g., charts, drawings, etc.) reducedto 8 ‘/2 inches x 11 inches. ­

- 9.4.7 Public and Confidential Exhibits.

If any portion of an exhibit contains confidential business information, the entire exhibitshall be treated as confidential. For certain lengthy exhibits of which only portions areconfidential, the parties may be asked to submit a public version of the exhibit.

The exhibits in the binder sets shall be in consecutive numerical order, and shall not beseparated according to confidential or public status.

' 9.4.8 Exhibit Lists._ .

Every exhibit list shall consist of a table enumerating all exhibits serially by exhibitnumber and identifying each exhibit by a descriptive title, a brief statement of the purpose forwhich the exhibit is being offered in evidence, the name of the sponsoring witness, and the statusof receipt of the exhibit into evidence. In the case ofjoint exhibits, every exhibit list shall identifysuch exhibits, _andthe parties shall meet and confer before submitting the lists to agree upon acommon descriptive title, statement of purpose, and sponsoring witnesses that shall appear on-everylist for each joint exhibit. In any exhibit list submitted prior to the offer of any exhibit intoevidence, the entry in the column for the status of receipt shall be left blank. In any exhibit listsubmitted after the exhibit is offered into evidence or withdrawn, the entry in that column shallshow the date of admission into evidence or rejection of the exhibit or shall indicate its withdrawal.

Exhibit lists shall .include public and confidential exhibits, and shall list all exhibitstogether in numerical order, e.'g., _CX-0001,CX-0002, CX-0003C, _CX-0004,'CX-0005C, etc.'

l7

Page 37: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

9.4.9’ Foreign Language Exhibits. .

No foreign language exhibits will be received into evidence unless a translation thereof isprovided at the time set for the exchange of exhibits. The translation shall be included as part ofthe foreign language exhibit.

9.4.10 One Document Per Exhibit; All Pages Bates-numbered.

Except for good cause shown, each exhibit shall consist of no more than one document andevery page of every document shall be Bates numbered in accordance with Ground Rule 4.7above. Exceptions to this "one document per exhibit“ rule include instances when it would beappropriate to group certain documents together as one exhibit, such as a group of invoices orrelated e-mails.

9.4.11 Witness Exhibit Binder.

In examining witnesses on direct with prepared written testimony, counsel shall providethe witness, the Administrative Law Judge, and other counsel, just prior to the commencement ofthe examination of each witness, with a binder containing _cLlythe witnesses's prepared writtentestimony, along with a table of all exhibits referred to within the prepared written testimony alongwith ablank column entitled “Received Into Evidence" or having similar language. ­

In examining adverse witnesses who have not prepared written testimony, orcross-examining witnesses, counsel shall provide the witness, the Administrative Law Judge, andother counsel, just prior to the commencement of the examination of each witness, with a binder(or binders) containing all exhibits, in numerical order, and individually tabbed, to be used in theexamination of the witness. Each binder must be labeled on its spine with the name and numberof the investigation and the nature of the contents of the binder, e.g., Cross-Examination ofWitness - Volume lof 1. In addition, the front of the witness binder must include a table of allexhibits to be used in the examination of the witness with a blank colunm entitled "Received IntoEvidence" or having similar language.

' If there are certain exhibits (i.e., patent, prosecution histories) that will be used frequentlywith more than one witness, a separate exhibit binder containing those exhibits may be used withthose witnesses and do not have be included in the separate witness binder for each witness.

9.4.12 References for Exhibit.

If it is appropriate, exhibits shall cite sources of information and methods employed informulating accounting, economic or other types of data. _Rebuttal exhibits, if submitted, shallrefer specifically to exhibits being rebutted. '

" 18

Page 38: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

9.4.13 Authenticity.

All documents that appear to be regular on their face shall be deemed authentic, unless it isshown by particularized evidence that the document is a forgery or is not what it ptuports to be.

9.4.14 Sponsoring Witness. '

Each exhibit that is offered into evidence shall have a "sponsoring witness." One of thepurposes of having a sponsoring witness associated with an exhibit is to establish a fotmdation forthe exhibit and to prevent exhibits from coming into the record that have no explanation regardingit. Sponsoring witness testimony does not necessarily have to be in the form of live testimony if allparties are in agreement to allow otherwise. For example, if parties are willing to stipulate andagree to designate portions of deposition testimony into the record in lieu of live testimony, alongwith certain exhibits that were discussed during the deposition, such request will generally bepermitted, as long as the exhibit was clearly identified and discussed during the deposition and thedeposition pages discussing the exhibit are included in the designation. '

Except in an investigation in which there is no participating Respondent, if a party believesevidence to be non-controversial and to be appropriate for receipt in evidence without a sponsoringwitness, that party may present with each such exhibit on or before the due date set forth in theprocedural schedule: (1) an affidavit or declaration that the declarant prepared or someone underthe declarant's direction prepared the exhibit; (2) a request that the exhibit be received in evidencewithout a witness at the hearing; and (3) a statement of grounds for receiving the exhibit inevidence without a witness at the hearing. Any party who wishes to cross-examine the declarantmay object in writing within three (3) days of service of the affidavit or declaration and request,specifying whom the party intends to examine. In the absence of objections, and upon good causeshown, the exhibit shall bereceived in evidence without a witness subject to the right of objectionon other grounds. 1

9.4.15 Exhibits in Dispute.

For any exhibit in dispute or to be discussed at the hearing that is not included in a witnessexhibit binder, a copy of said exhibit shall be provided to the Administrative Law Judge for hisreview and consideration. ‘

9.4.16 Filing of Exhibits by CD/DVD Media.

The Commission set -ofexhibits shall be submitted in electronic format. The procedurefor submitting exhibits electronically is set forth at:http://www.usitc.gov/docket_services/documents/EDIS3UserGuide-CDSubmissionpdfi

There are twenty-four standard exhibit categories: CX, CDX, CPX, RX, RDX, RPX, JX,JDX, JPX, SX, SDX, SPX, CX-[four-digit number]C, CDX-[four-digit number]C,CPX-[four-digit number]C, RX-[four-digit number]C, RDX-[four-digit number]C, .RPX3[four-digit number]C, -IX-[four-digit _ntunber]C,JDX-[four-digit number]C, JPX-[four-digitnumber]C,‘SX-[four-digit number]C, SDX-[four-digit number]C, and SPX-[four-digit number]C.

. 1 9 .

Page 39: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

(3)

Each category of exhibit must be placed on a different CD and labeled with the Investigation name,number, and the range of exhibits contained on the CD. In addition,"all source code exhibits shallbe submitted on a separate CD.

A Table of Contents file which lists the names of all files on the disc should be created andincluded on each disc.

9.4.16.1 Delivery to Administrative Law Judge. _

The electronic media containing the Commission set of exhibits should be delivered to theAdministrative Law Judge's office on the same day that initial post-hearing briefs are due. Itshould’not be delivered directly to Docket Services. - '

10 HearingtProcedure

10.1 Hearing; Order of Examination. _

The order of examination at the hearing is as follows (subject to alteration at the pre-"trialconference or other changes in the discretion of the Administrative Law Judge):

(1) Brief Opening Statements '(a) Complainant (limited to one hour)(b)’ Respondent (limited to one hour)(c) Commission Investigative Attomey (limited to half an hour)

(2) Complainant's Case-in-Chief. A

Respondent’s Case-in-Chief: In the event there is more than one respondent, the order ofpresentation will be determined at the pre-trial conference. Respondents, where possible,should avoid u_nnecessaryduplication of effort. »

Commission Investigative Attomey’s Case-in-Chief.(4)

(5)

(6)

Complainant's Rebuttal

Respondent's Rebuttal

20

Page 40: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

10.2 Closing Argument.

The Administrative Law Judge normally does not schedule closing arguments. Partiesmay request closing arguments, which are to be held at the discretion of the Administrative LawJudge. Typically, such closing arguments are held alter all post-hearing briefs have beensubmitted. '

10.3 Hearing Hours.

Normal hearing hours are 9:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. with a one-hour and fifteen minuteluncheon recess, beginning each day at approximately 12:15p.m. Fifieen-minute breaks will alsooccur at approximately 10:45 a.m. and 3:00 p.m. each day.

10.4 Trial Decorum.

10.4.1 Conversations at Trial.

No cross conversation between opposing counsel will be permitted. Rather if counsel hasanything to say to opposing counsel, such statement must be made through the Administrative LawJudge. ­

_ 10.4.2 Reading Matter; Cell Phones and Beepers; Food and Beverages.

No reading of extraneous material will be permitted in the courtroom. Audible cell phoneand beeper signals shall be turned off in the courtroom during trial,_andall cell phone calls must betaken outside of the. courtroom. No food, gum, or beverages other than bottled water will bepermitted in the courtroom during trial. V

10.4.3 Photos or Video Recording. A

No photo taking or video recording is permitted in the courtroom.

. 10.4.4 Swearing of Witnesses. '

When _awitness is sworn, the witness shall remain standing. All others in the trial roommust be seated and quiet. A . ~

. 10.4.5 Arguments on Objection.

Argiments or objections may only be made by counsel prior to a ruling. . Once a ruling ismade, no further discussion of the matter will be permitted.

21

Page 41: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

10.5 Examination of Witnesses. . p

10.5.1 Scope of Examination; In General.

Except in extraordinary circumstances, examination of witnesses for Complainant'scase-in-chief and Respondent(s)' case-in-chief shall be limited to direct, cross, redirect, andre-cross.

10.5.2 Scope of Cross-examination. _

Cross-examination will be limited to the scope of the direct examination. For witnessescalled for the purpose of giving testimony in support of a position on an issue that is the same asthe position on that issue of a party desiring cross-examination of that witness, that party isprecluded from asking that witness leading questions; i.e., “no friendly cross-examination." ­

When counsel is presenting a witness with a question that refers back to the witness'sprevious testimony, counsel shall refrain from summarizing the witness's previous testimonybecause this can lead to a time-consuming objection that counsel's summary was not an accuraterecitation of the witness's previous testimony. If counsel wishes to refer back to a witness'sprevious testimony, counsel must use direct quotations.

10.5.3 Scope of Redirect and Re-cross Examination.

Redirect examination will be limited to matters brought out on cross-examination.Re-cross examination will be limited to matters brought out on redirect examination.

10.5.4 Coordination of Witnesses. i .

The parties are expected to coordinate examination of witnesses so as to allot appropriatetime for examination of each of the witnesses within the total time allotted for the trial.

' 10.5.5 Documents Presented to Witnesses.

Any document which counsel wishes to show to a witness must first be shown to opposingcounsel.

10.5.6 Scope of Expert Witness Testimony.

An expert's testimony at the trial shall be limited in accordance with the scope of his or herexpert report(s), deposition testimony, or within the discretion of the Administrative Law'Judge.

10.5.7 Coordination of Respondents‘ Cross-examination. : . . - ._

i Respondents shall coordinate cross-examination through one attomey as far as practicableto avoid duplication. If that is not possible, counsel who intends to cross-examine must be present

A22

Page 42: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

in the trialroom during the entire preceding cross-examination of the witness so as not to engage inrepetitive questioning. '

- 10.5.8 Requests for Clarification of a Question.

" Requests for clarification of a question only may come from the witness or theAdministrative Law Judge. p

10.5.9 Use of Translators.

If a translator will be used at trial, the parties are responsible for obtaining one qualified,neutral translator upon whom counsel can agree. It is suggested that the translator be chosen from­a list of approved translators, such as may be kept by various federal district courts or federalagencies. Translators will be swom in. 1

A 10.5.10 Conferring with Witness during a Break in Testimony.

Counsel shall not confer with a witness during a break in the witness's testimony on thewitness’s substantive testimony.

11 Post-trial Briefs and Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law

11.1 Initial Post-trial Briefs; Filing and Content.

On or before the date set forth in the procedural schedule, each party shall file a post-trialbrief. Each party must also submit a copy of its final exhibit list with its post-trial brief. Thepost-trial brief shall discuss the issues and evidence tried within the framework of the generalissues determined by the Commission's Notice of Investigation, the general outline of the briefs asset forth in Appendix B, and those issues that are included in the pre-trial brief and any pennittedamendments thereto. All other issues shall be deemed waived. i

A reasonable page limit will be imposed for all post-trial briefs, which will be determinedon a case-by-case basis. Parties are required to use double-spacing (with the exception ofheadings, footnotes, quotations, etc.), at least 12 point font, and l inch margins (excluding headersfor CBI and footers, such as page numbers). Parties must submit a courtesy electronic copy oftheir brief to the Administrative Law Judge in Word format. If the parties have any questionsregarding the acceptable fonnatting requirements for post-trial briefs, they should contact theAdministrative Law -Judge's attomey-advisor. ' " » ' ’

23 '

Page 43: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

11.2 Proposed Findings of Fact; Form and Content.

In accordance with Commission Rule 210.40, a party may elect to file proposed findings offact and conclusions of law; however, the other side is not required to respond to the proposedfindings of fact and conclusions of law. The lack of a response does not mean that the proposedfindings of fact and conclusions of law are admitted, unless specifically stated as such. If a partychooses to file proposed findings of fact and conclusions of law, they must be filed on the samedate as the initial post-trial brief. 1

The proposed findings of_fact shall be in the form of numbered paragraphs. The findingsshall reflect all section 337 elements, all issues outlined in the Notice of Investigation, and anyother issues that arose duri_ngthe course of the Investigation. Section headings consistent with theoutline of the post-hearing brief may be used to set off paragraphs that relate to particular section3.37elements or issues. To be accepted without alteration, a proposed finding of fact must be anassertion of fact only (i.e., without argument more appropriately placed in the post-hearing brief).Each proposed finding of fact must be followed with citations to supporting authority in theevidence. Examples of commonly used citations are as follows:

Transcript: Smith, Tr. 895 [Witness Name, Transcript page, Line numbers (s)]Exhibits: CX-O03; RX-005; SPX-0002 'Pleadings: Complaint 1]4, at 2; XYZ Corp. Response to Cornplaint 11S, at 3.

11.3 Post-trial Reply Briefs; Filing and Content.

On or before the date set forth in the procedural schedule, each party shall file a post-trialreply brief. The post-trial reply brief shall discuss the issues and evidence discussed in the initialpost-trial briefs of each opposing party, following the general outline of the briefs as set forth inAppendix B. _

A reasonable page limit will be imposed on all post-trial reply briefs, which will bedetennined ona case-by-case basis. Parties must submit a courtesy electronic copy of their briefto the Administrative Law Judge in Word format. The formatting requirements detailed inGround Rule 11.1 govem. _ 1

11.4 Objections and Rebuttals to Proposed Findings of Fact; Form and Content.

Should a party elect to respond to proposed findings of fact, objections and rebuttals toproposed findings of fact of an opposing party shall repeat the text and citation to the record of theproposed finding of fact being objected to or rebutted and its paragraph number. Rebuttals shallassert only facts (i.e., without argument more appropriately placed in the post-hearing reply brief),and must be followed with citations to the supporting authority in the evidence.

24

Page 44: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

12 V Citation of Cases

The official case reporter citation must be included for any published decision or order thatis cited in a party's briefs or pleadings. Additionally, the docket number and the full date of thedisposition must be included in the citation of any tumreporteddecision or order that is referencedby the parties. A copy of any cited decision or order that is not available on Westlaw or LEXISshall be provided in an appendix to the brief or pleading. Further, every party must cite to thespecific page(s) of the cited decision or order that includes the holding for which the authority iscited. ’ . ‘

13 Coordination of Post-Hearing Briefs _

To the extent there is more than one complainant and/or respondent in an investigation,complainants and/or respondents shall coordinate their efforts and submit a single brief.Exceptions to this mle will be made on a case-by-case basis. This rule shall also apply topost-hearing reply briefs. '

14 Cooperation Among Parties

Due to the time limitations imposed by section 337, counsel shall attempt to resolve, bystipulation or negotiated agreement, any procedural problems encountered, including thoserelating to discovery and submission of evidence. To assure the proper cooperative spirit in thisinvestigation, continuing good faith communications between counsel for the parties is essentialand expected. ' l

15 -ExParte Contacts

There shall be no exparte contacts with the Administrative Law Judge. Any questions ofa technical or procedural nature shall be directed to the Administrative Law Judge'sattorney-advisor, Irina Kushner, at (202) 205-2694, or [email protected].

25

Page 45: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

APPENDIX A

26

Page 46: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSIQNWashington, D.C. A

In the Matter of

Certain . . . »_

_ InvestigationNo. 337-TA-_

SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM ~

TO: NAMEADDRESS

_ TAKE NOTICE; By authority of section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930, as amended (19

U.S.C. § 1337), 5 U.S.C. § 556(c)(2), and pursuant to 19 C.F.R. § 210.32 ofthe Rules of Practice

and Procedure of the United States International Trade Commission, and upon an application for

subpoena made by [“Complainant(s)” / “Resp0ndent(s)"/ etc., followed by name of company]

9 ' ‘ _

YOU ARE HEREBY ORDERED to produce at

, on , or at such other time and place agreed upon, all of the

documents and things in your possession, custody or control which are listed and described in

Attachment A hereto. Such production will be for the purpose of inspection and copying, as

desired. ­

If production of any document listed and described in Attachment A hereto is withheld on

the basis of a claim of privilege, each withheld document shall be separately identified in a

privileged document list. The privileged document list must identify each document separately,

specifying for each document at least: (1) the date; (2) author(s)/sender(s); (3) recipient(s),

including copy recipients; and (4) general subject matter of the document, The sender(s) and

Page 47: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

recipient(s) shall be identified by position and entity (corporation or firm, etc.) with which they are

employed or associated. If the sender or the recipient is an attorney or a foreign patent agent, he

or she shall be so identified. _Thetype of privilege claimed must also be stated, together with a

certification that all elements of the claimed privilege have been met and have not been waived

with respect to each document. ‘ "

I If any of the documents or things listed and described in Attachment A hereto are

considered “confidential business information," as that tenn is defined in the Protective Order

attached hereto, such documents or things shall be produced subject to the terms and provisions of

the Protective Order. '

Any motion to limit or quash this subpoena shall be filed within ten (10) days after the

receipt hereof. At the time of filing of any motion concerning this subpoena, two courtesy copies

shall be served concurrently on the Administrative Law Judge at his office.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF the undersigned of the United StatesInternational Trade Commission has hereunto set his hand andcaused the seal of said United States Intemational ‘Trade .Commissionto be affixed at Washington, D.C. on this _ day of

, 20 l_. .

Charles E. Bullock _' Chief Administrative Law Judge

United States International Trade Commission

2..

Page 48: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

' UNITED STATES INTERNATIONAL TRADE COMMISSION

" Washington, D.C.

In the Matter of

Certain . . .' - Investigation No. 337-TA-__

SUBPOENA AD TESTIFICANDUM

TO: NAMEADDRESS ­

TAKE NOTICE: By authority of section 337 of the Tariff Act of 1930,as amended (19

U.S.C. § 1337), 5 U.S.C. § 556(c)(2), and pursuant to 19 C.F.R. § 210.32 of the Rules of Practice

and Procedure of the United States Intemational Trade Commission, and upon an application for

subpoena made by [“Complainant(s)" / "Respondent(s)" / etc., followed by name of company]

3

YOU ARE HEREBY ORDERED to present yourself for purposes ofyour deposition

upon oral examination on < , at . A ,

or at such other time and place agreed on, concerning the subject matter set forth in Attachment A

hereto. _ i » » '

This deposition will be taken before a Notary Public or other person authorized to

administer oaths and will continue from day to day until completed.

Alfany of your testimony is considered “confidential business information,’fas that tenn is

defined in the Protective Order attached hereto, such testimony shall be so designated and treated

according to the terms and provisions of the Protective Order. - '

Page 49: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

Any motion to limit or quash this subpoena shall be filed within ten (10) days after the

receipt hereof. At the time of filing of any motion concerning this subpoena, two courtesy copies

shall be served concurrently on the Administrative Law Judge at his office.

INIWITNESS WHEREOF the undersigned of the United StatesInternational Trade Commission has hereunto set his hand andcaused the seal of said United ‘States International TradeCommissionto be affixed at Washington,D.C. on this _ day of€__, 201_.

< Charles E. Bullock

Chief Administrative Law Judge _United States International Trade Commission

3

Page 50: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

r

APPENDIX B

Page 51: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

GENERAL OUTLINE FOR ALL BRIEFS .

INTRODUCTION

A. Procedural History

B. The Parties

C. Overview of the Technology

D. The Patents at Issue

E. The Products at Issue

JURISDICTION ­

PATENT "A"

A. Claim Construction

l.

2. ­

First Disputed Claim Tenn (Claims 1, 2, 3, . . .)

Second Disputed Claim Tenn (Claims 1, 2, 3, . . .)

B. Infringement i "

1.

I 2.

Claim 1

Claim 2

C. Domestic Industry - “Technical Prong"

D. Validity

1.

i 2.

Anticipation Under 35 U.S.C. § 102(a)

Obviousness Under 35 U.S.C. § 103(a)

E. Unenforceability ‘

F. ~ Other Defenses ­

PATENT .“B”

Page 52: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

DOMESTIC INDUSTRY - ECONOMIC PRONG

A. Significant Investment in Plant and Equipment

B. Significant Employment of Labor or Capital

REMEDY AND BONDING

Page 53: Download Judge Bullock's Ground Rules Here

CERTAIN PROTECTIVE CASES FOR ELECTRONIC Inv. No. 337-TA-955DEVICES AND COMPONENTS THEREOF

PUBLIC CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I, Lisa R. Barton, hereby certify that the attached ORDER has been served to thefollowing parties as indicated, April 30, 2015.

On Behalf of Complainants:

Garret A. Leach, Esq.KIRKLAND & ELLIS LLP300 North LaSalleChicago, IL 60654

Resgondentsz

Speculative Products Design, LLC177 Bovet Rd., Suite 200San Mateo, CA 94402

Tech2l UK LimitedSyd’s Quay, Eel Pie IslandTwickenham, TWI 3DYUnited Kingdom

Lisa R. Barton, SecretaryU.S. International Trade Commission500 E Street, SW, Room l l2Washington, DC 20436

[I Via Hand Delivery[:1 Via Express DeliveryEl Via First Class MailCl Other:

E] Via Hand DeliveryII] Via Express DeliveryVia First Class MailCl Other:

l:| Via Hand DeliveryCl Via Express DeliveryVia First Class MailIII Other: