-
: / , , , , . , , .
- 2014
Popper
Lakatos
Laudan
Kuhn
Feyerabend
07.
-
7:
: anoixti-skepsi.tumblr.com
open-thought-blog.tumblr.com
, 2014
-
- , 2008-2014. . , - , , , .
, , . , , , . , , -, , , .
-
1
3
Popper23
- Lakatos34
Laudan38
H (Kuhn & Feyerabend) 42
Kuhn 43
Feyerabend53
: 56
67
-
1
, - . , , , , () , , ( ). , , , .
( -), , , , , , .
- ( ) : , , - , , - - ( , ).
: (epistemology) ( Cassirer, The Problem of Knowledge:
-
2Philosophy, Science and History Since Hegel)
: (Theory of Knowledge) , , .. . [ (intuition), , , Carnap].
: ( , - ) - , - .
: - (Philosophy of Science). - , - , - , , , .. - , .
-
3
. , , - 1940-60. , (- -). , , .
Logical Positivism
Knowledge Empricism Verifiability Theory of Meaning
Logical positivism is a combination of empiricism and rational thought that is not as strict as empiricism. There are two key concepts within this discipline. These are Knowledge Empiricism and Verifiabiliry of Meaning.
Pro-science
Pro-reason
Pro-logic
Anti-spiritual
Anti-mysticism
Anti-romanticism
Anti-nationalist
Concerned with distinguishing science from non-science
1920. :
O -, Hilbert, Peano, Frege Russell.
, . -
-
4 Hobbes, Locke Hume. O Hume, , , , (- ) ( ). - (-- ) . - Comte ( , Mill, Spencer Durkheim) - , , -. , . , Comte, - . Comte, - (- ) - . , .
, - , .
, ,
-
5 . , , .
1920 . , Moritz Schlick , , , Rudolf Carnap, Herbert Feigl, Kurt Goedel, Hans Hahn, Karl Menger, Otto Neurath Friedrich Waismann. Hans Reichenbach, , , Walter Dubislav, Kurt Grelling Carl Hempel. (Frank). 1930 Erkenntnis Carnap Reichenbach, - . , Ludwig Wittgenstein Karl Popper - .
, - - Charles Morris, Ernest Nagel Willard Van Orman Quine.
, .
-
6 :
-
, . , -, . . , -, - .
, , , . , , , . . , , , . .
-
7 , -, - .
- -- -. , :
1. -, ,
2. , - - .
- , . Mach, , , . , , L. Wittgenstein . Russell. - , . , , , .
, , , , ,
-
8 , - . , , , . - .
, , .
, , :
a priori - . . . -, , , , , - . , .
, , . -, - . ,
-
9 . - .
- , - . , .. : 3 , 36 C. , , - : , quarks .
, , - . . , -, , - . - .
, , , , , . -, . .. Einstein Newton -, . . .. Einstein Newton -, -
-
10
, - . - . - - , .
, (Popper, Lakatos, Putnam), (Kuhn, Feyerabend) - . , , - .
, -, Kuhn Feyerabend, --, -, . , , - . -, Einstein , . , - , , , , , .. 12. , - Thomas Kuhn .
-
11
-
, Ayer, Carnap, Shclick .., , . - , . - , , . - - . - , , , , , - . . Ayer, - , , . , - , . , , , - - , . - , . , . , . -
-
12
, , , .. - - - .
- - . , , - , - , - . - - . - . , , , , . - , . , , - . - . - . -, . , - -, - . - - , - , ,
-
13
, . Popper , . , . , . .
, : - . , - -, , . , , , . , - . - . Schlick - . , . : - , , . , . ,
-
14
- . .
() . , : , . , - , , -. , , ( , ) ( - ) , , . , - ( , ) ( ) - .
, . , - . , - 60 , .
() -
-
15
K. Popper, T. Kuhn, I. Lakatos, P. Feyerabend, N. R. Hanson .. - - . :
) .
, - . , , - , - . , , .
, , , - . : - - , . , - - , , . , , , , .
-
16
. , - - - . -- , . - -. .
, , . - - . , , - . , ---. a priori . - , . , , - , . - a priori . - - . -
-
17
- . -, . , , . - : - , . , . .
) .
, . , , -- , , , - .
- - . , - , (, , ). ( ) ( ) a priori - . , , - .
-
18
- - , , - . -- , , - Dunhem-Quine ( .
-, . : , , . , , , , .
, , , - :
, -, ...
- , , , . - . - -.
-
19
. , , , , , - - . , , - ( Kuhn). , , , -. , , . - - .
)
( ), . - , - . Karl Popper, 30, - . , Popper . , Popper , - . Popper, , - . , , -
-
20
, . , , , , - - . , - ( ), Popper ( -) () ().
, , , , - . , Popper , -, . , , - , , - . , Popper . - ( 1687) 1900. 1900-20 - , , , - - . - .
)
, . - . , , , -
-
21
. , , - . - / . - . - - () - - . , , , , - , . - , - . . , , - . - -. , . - - - - . ,
( - ), -- .
-
22
)
, . , - . , - . - , - -, .
, - -; -, - . - , . , - - . , - . .
-
23
Popper
Karl Popper , - .
, , Popper . - -, Popper - . , Popper, , - . - - , , , . Popper, -- , , . , , , , - . - -, . Popper . Popper -- . - .
Popper -
-
24
( ) . , Popper , -, . (Locke, Berkeley Hume), - , (, Leibniz ..) a priori , . , Popper (, , -) - . , (1959, 1934) (1963).
Popper - . Popper, David Hume.
David Hume
David Hume ( - ) - . - .
Hume , -, -. , , , ...
-
25
, . , , . ; - , , - .
Hume, - . . - , . . ( ), . - .
, , - . , . DNA . . , - . . .
Hume : -
-
26
; -. () - (). - (), - ().
: - - ; Hume . a priori ; ; . - , . , . , Hume, .
, - , , . , - , Hume , . - . . , . , Hume, . . , - - . . . . .
-
27
. . - , . - .
. Hume a priori . - :, , - , . Hume , - . , - . Kant () (a priori) . - , .
H Popper, -
Popper , Hume, . ( - Hume - -- ).
-
28
Hume: () .
Popper {( Hume) + post hoc ergo propter hoc (- , )} - .
Hume Popper ( ). .
Popper , . ( - ). , -, .
- :
-
29
modus tollens
- , Popper - . .
If A, then BNot B
Therefore not A
, .
.
, .
Modus Tolens
: - . - , modus tollens ( ).
, Karl Popper, , , - , , . , , - , - . , , , ... . , - , , - . ,
-
30
.
Popper - -, - -. Popper , , - . , , - - - . Popper - .
Popper , , - . , . , - . , , , .., , - , . Popper, , , - -- . Popper -- , --.
-
31
Popper -- , , -, - . - . - - - ( ). - .
. . , , . .. - , -, .
Popper, . -, . , , - - - . ,
-
32
. Popper, - . - , , . , , - ( ) , , . ( ), Popper ( ), () (). , , , , - . , Popper, , (corroboration), - . Popper, - . , - .
Popper, , : ) , -, ) ) . . . , : - ( , -
-
33
), , .
: -, Popper - - .
-
34
- Lakatos
, Kuhn , , Imre Lakatos Larry Laudan. Lakatos Laudan , Kuhn, - : .
Lakatos
Imre Lakatos ( ) Karl Popper. Popper - . Popper Lakatos Kuhn - . Lakatos Popper, . , Lakatos, Duhem-Quine , . , Popper, Lakatos Kuhn, . Lakatos, , , - -
-
35
.
Lakatos
Lakatos , - . - -. - .
- () () . Lakatos - . .
Lakatos - - . . , , - , . , , , , - .
Lakatos . -
-
36
- , - . Lakatos, - : Lakatos , - . Lakatos -, , - (Hess 1997, . 28-29).
Lakatos, , - - . Kuhn, , - . , Lakatos, (1970, . 93), - , .
, , Lakatos , - . , - . , Lakatos, , ,
-
37
. , Lakatos, - .
-
38
Laudan
, Larry Laudan - , - , , Kuhn Lakatos. Laudan, , Popper Kuhn. Laudan -, .
, Laudan - , . Laudan - , .
, Laudan, - , . , - . , , , , - . - . , , Laudan .
Laudan ,
-
39
- , . , Laudan, , - Kuhn. Lakatos. Laudan, :
- : - .
, , , - .
( ) - , ( ) , , ( - ), (Laudan, 1977, . 78-79).
Kuhn Lakatos, Laudan -. , Laudan - . Laudan - :
,
-
40
- (Laudan, 1977, . 68).
, Laudan, - , . , . Kuhn Lakatos, Laudan . , - . - - .
, Laudan - . (Laudan, 1977, . 202). - . , - , (1977, . 202-203). , Laudan (1977, . 202), - .
(1984), Laudan . ( ) -
-
41
, - . Laudan, , - , . , , , , , - , - (Laudan, 1984, . 5). Laudan , Kuhn . Laudan . , Laudan ( Giere, 1988, . 44-45).
-
42
H (Kuhn Feyerabend)
The Kuhn Cycle
NormalScience
Prescience
ModelDrift
ModelCrisis
ModelRevolution
ParadigmChange
, Kuhn Feyerabend, - , - . - . , , , - .
, - , . , , -. , , , .
-
43
Kuhn
Thomas Kuhn . , Kuhn , . , , Popper . - . - Kuhn , Paul Feyerabend, Russell Hanson, Stephen Toulmin , , Imre Lakatos. Kuhn , , , - .
Kuhn - - , - . - , , . - . , - . , - , , , .
-
44
, . , , , - , , , , Kuhn, .
, - , . , - , .
, , . , ( ) . Kuhn Feyerabend - - . . , , , - , - . , , , , , , .
,
-
45
:
.
.
, , , , .
Kuhn, , , : , - . . , -, - .
Kuhn Feyerabend, -, Einstein. Kuhn, Einstein, , . , , , , .. , - , . , ,
-
46
, - . . - : , , , , . , , , Einstein, Dalton, - , , .
, , , , , , , , - . , , , . - Feyerabend Feyerabend . , , -, Einstein , Kuhn , Feyerabend . Feyerabend - . , , , .
Kuhn, , , ( - c) -
-
47
. , Einstein , , .
Kuhn . - , , . - , Kuhn, . - Kuhn - , .
Thomas Kuhn
. Kuhn , , : - ...
, - , : - , - , -. Kuhn , .
I. Hacking, Kuhn
- . - :
-
48
, : , , - , . . - . .
, : - , . , , - , , . - , - , - Einstein, , , , Kuhn .
, , - , -, . - . , - . , Kuhn, . - . , .
, , , ,
-
49
. , - , . , . - , , , , -. Kuhn . , , - ...
, , Kuhn Feyerabend, , - . -, , , - . , Kuhn, , , .
, , Kuhn , - -- , , . , . , . , , - -
-
50
. .. ( ). - . Lavoisier - . Maxwell -, Einstein , ...
, , . - , - . - , , , . Kuhn , - . R. Hanson, - - . , , - .
, Kuhn, :
, - [ ] -. , . - , . - , . ,
.
, ,
-
51
- . . .
, - Kuhn: - , , , - - /. , Kuhn .
, , Kuhn . , Objectivity, Value Judgement, and Theory Choice , . . , , , , , . , , , .
, - , , - I. Hacking, , Kuhn , - . , Objectivity, Value Judgement, and Theory Choice :
, -,
-
52
, , - , , . , , - .
: - Kuhn , - Kuhn ,
, , - , . , - Kuhn - .. , , .. , .
-
53
Feyerabend
Feyerabend -
Feyerabend - : . Feyerabend ( - ) - . - . , -. Feyerabend - .
Feyerabend { : ( , ) + Wittgenstein + (- ) = ( -)}. , Feyerabend -, , , (anything goes), . . Feyerabend -, , , - (.. ) ..
Feyerabend, -, , -
-
54
. , , Against Method . , , - . Against Method:
, [ - ] , , - , . , ,
.
, , a priori . . , , , , , . , , Feyerabend, . - , - . , , - , .
Feyerabend -, . - . , .
-
55
Feyerabend , , , , - . , Against Method Science in a Free Society, Feyerabend , J. S. Mill On Liberty, Mill -, , , .
Feyerabend ,
. . , , .. , , , , . , , - , , . , , Science in a Free Society, , .
-
56
:
: -; , - ; - .
- , , - . Carl Popper, The Logic of Scientific Discovery, - , , , - .
- . - , - . , . , -, . , Reichenbach ... .
, -
-
57
. , - Braithwhaite,
, - . - .
, - :
, , .
, -- - . , , . Braithwaite , :
, , . . .
. R. Hanson, , - , ,
-
58
a prior , , . , Hanson, - , . , , - - . :
, , .
, Hanson - , , , - - -. , Hanson - . , , . - .
C. S. Peirce
Hanson, - C. S. Peirce, . Peirce , . -
-
59
Peirce - , , . - , , , , (VII ).
Peirce , . , - -. Peirce , , , - .
C. S. Peirce
C. S. Peirce, - . Peirce, , - , . - : , , :
. . . ,, , . . .
, , - Peirce, -
-
60
. , , 1867, . .
, , . , - - .
... , ... ( ) - ...
; Peirce , , :
.
, , .
, , .
, , , , , , , .
Hanson - . , :
-
61
. . . , - ,
. . .
, Peirce, - .
. . . , ,
. . .
, , - . Peirce ,
Popper :
. . . , - . . .
. Hanson, . - Peirce, :
.... , [ ] .....
Peirce , - . , - , .
-
62
C. S. Peirce,
: ; - , ; Peirce - , , . , . , , , - .
Peirce :
... , - ...
Peirce , , , -, . - , , - . , , . . - :
il lumen naturale - . Kepler, Gilbert Harvey - - - - , , .
-
63
Peirce - Einstein :
- , - . , , , .
, Peirce, . (1.46). - . - , . , . , - , Peirce, , - : , , , . , Peirce :
, . .
-
64
Popper
Popper - Peirce . Peirce , , , Popper . -, , Popper, - - . , Popper , Bergson. , , . Popper Einstein :
- , - . , , , .
Popper - , -. Novalis Popper : : (Hypotheses are nets: only he who casts will catch).
. Popper
Popper - ,
-
65
. , Popper, , - Einstein - , , . , Einstein , Popper.
, , - . - , , .. , . 20 Einstein . , , . , - , Einstein. , , , . , . : , - ; Popper . - . - . Popper -, ,
-
66
, , , . - : , , , -. , , , - , (verisimilitude), - /. , , , , - . , , . , - . . Popper .
, - , , - , , Popper, - . , , , . , , - , , .
-
67
, , , : ... , 1993
- , , , , .
, , , : , 1991
, , , , , 1997
Bertrand Russell, , -: . , (: I. . ), . 699-700.
Chalmers, A.F, ; , 2000.
Comte, the Positive Philosophy of Auguste Comte, London 1913
Lakatos, Imre, ;;History of science and its Rational Reconstructions.
Laudan, Larry, A Confutation of Convergent Realism.
Quine, Two Dogmas of Empiricism.
Karl Popper, The Logic of Scientific Discovery (Hutchinson, 1972, 1 . 1959), . 31.
. , Is there a Logic of Scientific Discovery, , Historical Types of Rationality. Proceedings of the First Greek-Soviet Symposium on Science and Society. Athens, October 23-26 1992. National Technical University of Athens, . 239-50.
Hans Reichenbach, Experience and Prediction (University of Chicago Press, 1983), . 383.
-
68
R. . Braithwaite, Scientific Explanation (Cambridge University Press, 1986, 1 . 1953), . 122.
, . 12.
. . R. Hanson, Is there a Logic of Scientific Discovery?, H. Feigl G. Maxwell (eds.) Current Issues in the Philosophy of Science (Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1961), . 20-25, . 28.
R. . Braithwaite, . ., . 20-22.
. R. Hanson, . ., . 31.
.
. R. Hanson, Patterns of Discovery (Cambridge University Press, 1958, 2 . 1972), . 90.
. .
, Charles S. Peirce, Collected Papers of Charles Sanders Peirce. Vols. 1-6. (ed. C. Hartshorne and P. Weiss. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1931), Vols. 7-8. (ed. A. Burks. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press, 1958). , , - 5.363, 5 363 .
. R. Hanson, Patterns of Discovery, . ., . 87.
Albert Einsten, Principles of Research (1918), Einstein, Ideas and Opinions (Bonanza books, 1954), . 226.
Hanson, . . . , Alan Musgrave, Deductive Heuristics K. Gavroglou et. al. (eds.), Imre Lakatos and Theories of Scientific Change (Kluwer, 1989) 15-32.
Karl Popper, Objective Knowledge, 1972, . 19.
, . 70.