1
AOA Performance Based Oversight
Jon Round - Safety Programme Manager Graeme Ritchie - Manager Aerodromes
CAA24 June 2014
2
Agenda
PBR transformation SARG reorganisation Performance Based Oversight – the essentials Phase 1Rollout Plan and process Phase 2 – moving towards full PBO Value to industry
3
Transformation Programme We need to:
Concentrate our resources and efforts where they will have the greatest effect.
Get better at identifying emerging risks Put the right amount of effort into each risk, or reduce effort
where the risk is less.
It means: Reorganised structure Moving to a more performance-based approach The ESP transformation programme will deliver the
capabilities we need to achieve this. Using the best data and evidence available to highlight the
most serious risks and then put in place action plans to address them.
4
Reorganised Structure
Safety and Airspace Regulation Group (SARG) Intelligence, Strategy and Policy - centralised team to provide
data and intelligence to identify key risks and drive more coherent and consistent policy.
Capability teams - (flight operations, airworthiness and airspace, air traffic management and aerodromes)
General Aviation - a new dedicated unit to ensure we take a more proportionate view on GA regulation
Business Management - centralised team to work is managed efficiently and properly prioritised
The Hub - one stop shop for stakeholder engagement – through modernised services, online transactions and new way to engage
6Page 1ESP Briefing, December 2013
EASA Pivot to Performance Based Regulation
OR*.GEN.200 (a) 3:The identification of aviation safety hazards entailed by the activities of the operator, their evaluation and management of associated risks, including the actions to mitigate the risk and verify the effectiveness
EASA ARA/ARO.GEN.305 The oversight programme ….must be developed taking into account the specific nature of the organisation, the complexity of its activities, the results of past certification and/or oversight activities required by ARO.GEN and ARO.RAMP and shall be based on the assessment of associated risks.
The ESP Programme and associated IT deployments are designed to support and implement the provide the requirements placed on National Authorities to ensure PBR
ADR.AR.C.010 Oversight programme (a) The Competent Authority shall for each aerodrome operator and provider of apron management services declaring their activity to the Competent Authority: (1) establish and maintain an oversight programme covering the oversight activities required by ADR.AR.C.005; (2) apply an appropriate oversight planning cycle, not exceeding 48 months. (b) The oversight programme shall include within each oversight planning cycle, audits and inspections, including unannounced inspections, as appropriate. (c) The oversight programme and planning cycle shall reflect the safety performance of the aerodrome operator and risk exposure of the aerodrome.
8
Performance Based Regulation
Transformation program until March 2016 What have we done In the last 12 months?
CAA Reorganisation SARG Pathfinders Live trials Team of 20, working to change the organisation Performance Based Oversight + CAA internal SMS
9
PBO – The Process
Feedback (Sharing knowledge and lessons learnt – Internally & Externally)
INTELLIGENCE RISK OUTCOME ACTION CHECK FEEDBACK
CAA view Our Actions
Entity Actions
Entity view
Risk List (current & future)
Agreed Desired
Outcomes
Identify Options for
Action(cost/benefit)
Compliance and
Performance
Proactive Leading
IndicatorsAssessment
ActionsDelivered &Measured
Total System Actions
Data
Intelligence
Rules
Risks/Issues: • What CAA knows• What others know
Planned changes
Incidents & Accidents
Performance Based Oversight – Core Regulatory Decision Making
CAA Risk List
Performance Comparison
CAAGovernance of Safety
International influence
UnregulatedSectors
10
PBO - Rollout Plan
Jan 14 Apr 14 Jul 14 Oct 14 Q1 (’15) Q2 (’15) Q3 (’15) Q4 (’15) Q2 (’15)
Q3 (’15)Q4 (’15
Q1 (’16) Q2 (’16)
90 AOC led Entities Fixed: Phase 1
60 Helicopter Led Entities: Phase 1Flight Ops led
Entities
50 EASA Aerodromes and 30 additional to be rolled out over 15 months
ANSP led entities (numbers/schedule to be determined in Feb)
AW led entities (numbers/schedule to be determined in Feb)
90 AOC led Entities Fixed: Phase 2
60 Helicopter Led Entities: Phase 2
Planning
Proportionate involvement; e.g. adoption of ESP principles
Entity Groups
Aerodrome led Entities
ANSP led Entities
Airworthiness led Entities
Other (GA, CPG, PPT).
Two year Deployment Schedule
Bu
sin
ess
chan
ge
driv
en b
y E
SP
Pro
gram
me
Ena
blin
g To
ol
deve
lopm
ent &
de
ploy
men
t (P
PI)
Project Priority #1 for Q1/2 2014 is Q-Pulse roll-out to Flight Ops (and ASSI), then wider
Project Priority #2 for Q2/Q3 2014 is to develop the next generation of the tools to enable PBO ways of working
Influence tech
roadmap, planning
IT Tools
Project
Enabling the above rollout…
11
PBO Process
Periodic
(currently annual)
• Audit• Out brief (Aerodrome specific)
Following audit (within 4
weeks)
• CAA Internal Review Meeting (IRM) including all entity inspectors: ADR Ops, RFFS, ANSP Ops, Engineer
Within 4
weeks of IRM
• Accountable manager meeting• OM + AM + additional specialists as required
Phase 2
• Oversight consciously planned in accordance with the above
12
PBO Process
Accountable manager meeting Risk based discussion Taking clear account of ANSP and other key stakeholder
risks Cross organisation risks
No surprises Agenda + record of discussions/actions agreed
13
PBO – Phase 2
Base lining data which ultimately will lead us to PBO Data = Compliance, MORS, SMS, Changes, Risks = Performance Standard format using ARMs methodology This time next year beginnings of PBO based on Performance +
Complexity Remember this builds on the regulatory compliance obligation
14
Value to industry
Joined up regulator Focus on substantive risks Vs merely compliance Sharing of best practice Ability to see and share sector trends (Data protection) Focus on poor performing organisations will improve safety in
UK Oversight regime more tailored to the organisation's complexity
& performance An ability to influence EASA and their view of PBO