-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
1/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
2/114
II _l}lv.>;+!.>;:.>>,
Az}vvvt Yvuq qlw}oqllovltv}vv
Yllzl}x} pqlpv vtqvt qvtlvtlv}vvlqqtmqv}}vw }vFz}Ivzlt\mv AqP=tv}vv wmqvqv vzvtqzvto }vF{}VqvzBzvq45Byvt\nqvWtiFPK ;I]
Av} tvll}vtlr vl} goql l ~vlpv qmvqltqqlwtllzv
Lo}vt.>;-o \lXl]vVt
_vvtvtp}vtoXmqlKtqmVt.>;:_vvt.>;;=.>;>qv.>=. .>=1 .?=&/.>=8.>=;.>=>avqtvt.>@-
]p}vtpXAFXQVVCYKIhGCcPZYVdINtDlz#(v Ol}v_M2.+GClt VtHlvmt vvvljv}|}}v t
]}vvpP evvzVtVt
]vtNzUz
E}Vol Hllzz \oqlJll_m}lvI@ IlktIlq}v]pvwql}} 1tvt!v" ltv. \qP fv63-DaY [STS^`b'}mtqvRaDY07TT)*$%>=9>5 mvpls
K 5
!":f
"
6D;1D
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
3/114
`
K D
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
4/114
T077+7,A
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
5/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
6/114
-..
#$00+0 '!.0
@- (-- a O #5O-@(--5@2-l@==(K--O((@--=(@(--},O5
#@-(
--}(
@C} @ 55@-= O (-- 5@C-@(--5aC-@l-O# - X = 5 @ O#} (f @--=} @ #O--=@ (
KO#CO =(-" V -- #C =-,O
=5-a@=5-@-(--C(@-#5-==5O@5#K 5O@O @ @- } fOC55# #@Ol@ # # O-=@#@ - # - - (-- ,C 5@5- C= (--#O - @#@(p @= # 5-a- ,-~ O-=ql=5-a a - 55 @- O
5,- O- - 55|#@,#a#@5-K (O ,= -( # K5-= ,C='7 f## 55@,-
lXC5" c,-~,O5O55,|"(X o UC(#
-5-=#5X.
n"l , ( ((
(fC-(5ff5| 5,X@ 5=-, 5|O "7X#O-@=}55"=(@c #-@f @" 7 f@" , ( ##a"5" #5X--@O O 5(,c,=O5X,-b#5--5-5==("" = XC" V, x5 O f@ - ,- ( ,(5-a= +a@o,fcc-b5-C@= = b fa a5 5(V,-f ,2 C , ( (=-@"(""(c@--= "7
# @ (-- #
q V# 17"7 ,
(-#a5 & #-5-= -"o5"1"/7c5-=!*27
l @ #o C C- ' f=(-" b-55-(=#1#"7 & "7 5"K 5-= 117 " o - "f-f C# %7 177 # fC" d
@C5l'1)7#XC#-CC(-"5X"K#C = C-'1'%"7 %7 !4!6"7 "'7555X5#Xz,Co#.5-alK==,Coj c
55 117
b #. -f X #
C"@= oC "oCX 5""#+$. #07 7 K,#C5c#. '!7 c(@+OUC-=C
V-&(+C ")t=[+5-- ,-= ( cC .,=-# K,aC@5O@5 bCbC 5
l = ( # 5C#( b- C-= O- # 17 2"1%"7 o# Kc, #-=- f"X5 K(=!%+17 X#O 3%27 KbXC-1"7 &'%117 5,1"7@
,$!"1%"7 o#2-17 "7211)"7b.c .717,(oC5,"c
7 ff"7 ,#C"#5,"# 5--,"X B #C-" c*$ 5-("",#O5l,#C5-=--Cc ( o# Xc 5-a- 5"o5 ( 5 X X c X -= 317 &%175-X5=
'* %1?#N?!4;IN 9!$,4
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
7/114
). #$&++ %+&!*+
!} ! 44 !2 __%!,FF4;gF>,2_2!%! 4!% l%_ !2% !,F! 4!,2 4204244! %,2 ! K_%;%,4!!!q
] ;4!g%;F!,!,4|! 2,!;!%E%F,!% HI%%%E_!2 ! , 2 F% % %%F% q F% !2!22_4!,%!E F !E _ !>2! !! % ; !%!% %%F%g !% .!!2%! %;.> !E` . ;%2,!%;%}%//!%!2!%, ! !>!g2! 4>>!!>!%&!.! !% !!! 2;; % .; %&>> !> >>2> % _ 2!>2q 2 F 4 ; ! % !!%>%F4&A_!>4>4g>2%!F%F%qK! 4>4 > ; ,%% !4 4
!4>4
!,!2AF!%!!%>;,%%!4%_4>!!>!q
K!4!M%42%2,!4!!>> %>!>!; %q V x4q T !! 2%!! 4!,>!!&!}%0!%E2 _! ,2 &A /4 ! _ %F &44%E>2!%x4%F!|2& %M!4!; !M 4 Fg !
4! !&!&E&,2!!;2 !!>!, x4% F ,2 % 4&&`E,42;%F%_%2;Mx4%JF} M 4!J,&& F&
.WMY!Y ;W2%!M!/ !&F%A J.
M%;4%E4!W_%24,E2%,2;.%&42%4_M&%2%F2;! . % F&AF %`q
+ '+ )+ ("+ 1
4 % s% % ! ;% &;.% ;! &%F/ %/2; !`w%2& !2%22!/&;%!&
.;4%2!>.p>
%%% 4M.;,2%2M4%2&..]%4M,% s!&>%.F _>%!%!2M,&!%!g2242%&!.%; %24 ]%
4g;%!.;FK%%sJ/%>>&&&;4%%>E!>/>&;%;2!;!.%!]%%F&%4|& A;% & ; 4R>!!>!g > & 2&24%4.!&2,E%V,&;4.&M>/2&&x4JJ%Fg ,2 F ,M&&% ,J .;!;x4%>!%E>&4;2%%2!;!qTM% %&;%M %& /Y& / F 4&& 2%!&h/l/%/ &E/!/.;;!2!p!,&4%M,4.&%!F!. !_%&
K!4!44;;%,2 FJFV_ ! 4.!44g 4%!& 4 , % 4.4M%p ;;% ;% !!4;%,%WE&&;4E& , !! .%/J F4>& ;!F F ;J! !M FM & 4.4!J ;% % !%&p%J M. M24 %% % ;.% Y.! E&%/ . F2,M!&%FF/2
]4%M&4
n}D F! &4Y J / .!M.% 2.4 V; A J EF.
RJ 4
! 4>..4 >
2,/ V %2& ..; M!JY! 4! 44%YM/2MJ;.%.Y.!M,24>.>
.,&&&%/%J!.!/% E&&42%4&;4! / Y.!/ .
>!>M />> !>/J .
4%..&2/%JR; &/%! !!42! `2!K!JJ4.!4.
.4!J, %M%J.%JE/>
&,RFq
% V2WM%,MFJW&
K!>J 4.!4>.4 ;!2%& ,%! ; 4.4W44!W.;4R4! W&,.2YR!>&/J& >R4J
JA/J_;/% ;.%
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
8/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
9/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
10/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
11/114
, "6yFL"zcc7 "UczX
'0!#00w0&'0> > 0###,}! # 10
6# ># ## '#!0 ##0'b!'# # >#0'>b0 0>!> #0, L , >z !! 0 '#& ! ># #06 !# >b ## !''># 6>! ##!#>Q 6 Q0&!>,b ! 6 #>1,'#,&'&>!>Q0'b>0&&,>##0! >
>6#0 '& 000 # #Q >06>Q'>b#L #
!>z _',,0$0 +$)0L
>#0z>0Q&,'>QbQ'#0z>
L}!0>>#0'#>Q#0#Q6,'0>&0>!!0&>#b>#66b#0 # &QL#># ,>Q
6#>b&1&>b1#,1&,!1 ''b'0>10&,'Q ,&1,',& 01,&
>#Q ,''!/-.,%#0 ' &(,0 Q Q> z,#00'L#!LQ # L1 >'b6 &>&,'z
b0Q11#1',>z!0#Q>#!Q' QQL> ,z! # #Q &6' 6Q> !z,>,Q#1 g0 ,0Q>,' # >z ! , 1!z
#Q ># b
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
12/114
hh]#5 E ]5.7]5##5#5 .]#5])# E# )#]].)3 #)hh]#5#]])E]537#55#]#]]55#)hh]#h5.]h5]7#h7]-E#]])7]]5)E]5.7 57#5#])]#5 ]) #Eyh#5##5]h5]#]7]7#7]#)7c753#E w]#]5])53#7]#)h]5]75]h55#7]#5#5.h]y5#5]5y
57 #E#53.E.]E]]].]7wh}#]] 5 )5h: E 57 5 h53.]7 ]]]wh5#] # 5: 5 5#] #5#E#] 5] ]]wh5#] ])]]7 #] ] .y .] #] E]]53 #]#7]#53]7: #]57 :5.. ]h3.]5E]]] 7)h3# 7]#57E 5# ]5# #7]# # #] E]]5. 7 3h53 .] 5] 5.3hh]]7#hh]# #5#5] T4 E]]5. .]#] hh]#)5)7 5##y 5h]y#] 5) #]7]5)h53 57 3#h5. #E# h5 #]hh]# h]#y )5:: ,h}3 h35 :h 3:7h5h 5]# 3E3E53B:}3c5E
#E #h35)E]5375 35 #]]35#]7y 553: 57c]#)hh] # 55.)5hh# u5]hE#3#y)#5)7]# )]53]y]h555.]7]]c]]E#5].]E535##y]hE##]]]#5.].]]#h 5] # hh]: #] )hh]# ]5E : 3Eh53 ]35#]] ] hh]# .] .]7 5#]) ]5.] ] h5 5 3Eh5..5#]#]] # hh#)5 E# 57#5# )53E5##E##5#]c]X 55E#5E5# #3#}#553E5#c]]#)5hh:5h7E57: # 5# .35#h.5 #h$$h }3, }h]7 5 7 #5: :
h]#cE:377A#.]E535#:57##hhc5w#5#]
# : 2('3 'y#z S: J : #EU] 7#553]7] 5hh]#y #] #55 5c## 3h5#.Eh53].5# #5 5.]..#5# :S B5!
TT
3#13/(#T(30#3-)3
Z[ YC + , E D ^id_`efaghbc
) #]hh]#yE5#5357E5}53 553E 5 ]h] 7] 5 E57 7]#5# E : ),#]h]]#3 h5 5:3)]h] )5#E5 5 :#} 553 B5c:]EE53:# 35##)# f.Eh53#hh5]h#75 #h3)h35#E 5E#]7h.555335:5hE:#E537]5 553 : # 7c 5: 53 575#5. #
# 7c hE 57 #h753. #55355.cE5#55:E#hh#5}h57##753)]533B: 7 5 5 c75 h:: 5] : :E.h#.):75)55:}3}53)5h.5553#5#]h.7]]3]5#y]57]h7
5 7]3]37]h# #] c]:hh]# 55 3# 5: ,B37]]h## h#h53 c5.5#h3)57 )#]5:553#5::::B).:,7h75#:::}:5:5 h6# B,)57]5 37 5 c: : : h5B #
3 5 533 ::]7 :] 3 ).7E #5 :3f ,5h:hghh::}:5]#77#3,37E:7#h5E33#5h5,:5: 533 5 hh5E 57hh5]533#3: h: h}7c5h # :553E5::6::5#5:53:h533537:]hr7: #)5h,h: :5
:,]3h75# :5h: h37
:Eh5h 5 h5E :5: 5 5357 h] 5: 553: h:h E : 5535: # E: h5] : :5: 5h:#c: 3h:B3753(7c#3,,,3]7E
g:,c335B3:#hh:
#77#3)5h:h57h5..,h53}7.#h5.3 5#}357 : h::}
###S:z7}##]3E##cz
5735#c3 #53c 3E 7 #h:#}#E73h53 : #:Bh# 57 :7z5 z7 3 &3 ($*3 z z :
#3h !3 "3 .+3 ,3 33 37 -%3 h5 :
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
13/114
$3zG L zdd7,tUdzZ
&Z==6K'K&ZK'#Z!ZK4Z&ZyZ!ZK'nZ=! &Z4# K4 K4# !K =K bZ Z & &Z==6 = ZZ4#n4Z K' 'Z=#n4 Z=T Z Tb = ZK&Z4 sZ&4Z#=6K=Z4mZ4 T4m4Ty'4&K' 4ZZ{Z=Z KZ4 =!y TKn6#Z== !Z&K4T
=Z
=
4ZZ &K4Z!Z&K4# = &K!Z4=!Z&K4ZZ Z=mT=K=ZK'n#Z =n!Z! #Z K4=K=6K' T= Zs
#m K'Z 4m6 'Zm=!b!nTx T =KK= TT46T4=&K!4=K=!KmKn6=Kn4K=&ZZ=ZZ=KK=#ZKsK'TK=K'=KK=mZ=6!Z=Z!xn##&Z==6KK&ZZZ==6&K!mZ!smKz4m={ T{ &sKT4ZK!=!#Z=Z&$==6xn#ZZ&K &ZT#Z4KZK'T4m=&n'#Zm=Zbm44mm4sZ==6xT=!K6=6K'#Z&Z==6K'ZK=ZT#nZ&K!
gZ s=# K' s4&4T & K' 4T!K=T KKx 4mmzTnm,=K'Zm' TsTm=Z=Kn6 4Kb!Z!#Z&Kn!4$m ! '#$ ZK=!4 &x Z4mK='=s#msn4n$!m#Z4ZK'ZbTn=6ZZ'sm#
mZmzm ssT4= gnx '4Z&sy 'Z=# #KK=m!Z4s,m$ &! 'nm'6 s4'4Z=Z 'K4!Z&K4Tb4 m 4mb Z =Z4 T#m &T Z=ZsK'!&K4T!nK=ZsZ4=!ZnT#ymT4ZK&&K={Z KT= =4K'!&K4m!#4mZ m'T&TsKKsZ4#={=KT!#zbTnT#mK 'ZmZ'mm&s4T#mTZ Tm sKm'6m6K#T4mK='=Zs
&nTbmK#$4#K!'=!TK'sKKsm=6Z=Z4TZ==z!ZTm'ZswK'T4m=! s#Tsm,smKZ4=Z!m# # T4! Kn#m' Tsn4=sn4& Z n4&m{ Z!Z&K4T
'4Z!&xmnm!=T!#Z'4Zwz bZT 4Kn6m!' &= =!&K4 '== =KTb =K !'n m n!4!m=6 #Zz 4& Z= n! K4
6 !&4z&&Z= T wZm=m
4nZ4 4Z KZ= ,snT4$K=n Z=Z4Z ,=41!$&,4,4=w$=!Kz&
m n$!$=z &&nmn=4=6#$&$bZK!&K4
4 =Z! K{
=Kn4!&
*[1d tdd71tUdt[
4 KK !&K4K' s$,s # , 4! K&&n=#&!#m=6nm=6# 4'4&K'6Kb$4&Z=TT ZK!Z&K4TgZ !#Kn=!T ' ! m4K=6nZm#Z4ZZ{ 4 T6mnsKZ,nZ4Z Z4TbZ Z4!x Z =!4 m=6 4 1& K'n=bZ4 Z!nTK= n=!Z&K4Tm = T ZZ&= K4#ZZ$m#m'Z{=#nmb4
Z!nT#mK = Z Z =! m $ !Z4 Z m K' Z Ksn K= #=Kn4 n# $ &4 Z&K4T
n4Z 4ZZ K6KbZ4=&Z= , ' T# ZbZ!n bK Zx =K K !n K= ! # Z Z=!4 1 n=!Z&K4# Z= Z &ZT= n=znm#4T= , #KZ4=!x!Z&K4!KbK&=6#K!K$n
n#Z#4ZT!ZbZ6n,>#K=Z#ZK=ZK'!Z&K4TT=! #K=!4 6T4ZTK=K#ZK=Zs# 'zn# bZ 6n m= T & , #m{KKTKn#sK#KZs#
Z4Z =K#4Z&sgZ mK4 's#T smK,s=Z=n4K=#m6K!!,'!KnKK6!nm=n K$s'1$4m6 nK'mm m!z!
Z!mKnZ=Kn6 # $44Z m&s4#=m#K4 4T sKKs4 ,' mZ= ! 1b= Z=n4m Kn!bZ sz! m!$T K',4m m #$ ',4Z'4K= ' #Z4#Kn6 =! 'n4#Z4 #4m 7,s&z= =K &T!K=Z T s4# K'Kn4 m=# n T=! m=6n Zn&Z=# 'K4!mnm=6,&ZnmK=,'smm nm'Z= ! m sK#m !mnm,= Tn# Km=6 K4 !bsm6 = =Z4,=T K4ns4= 46=mT#K= n n4KsZT= &&n=m#0PssTKn#6m nsn4b4Z6=T!!$Tm6z4z,n!4jn,! m6,44,6mTT!m 464!! 1 m&s4##mnx KZ $m#Kn =6mz,&m,^ m ,#4 sKm# nzmK=
!m!m6 $4 4mm 1n! b$ m=Z! #$
,4Kn!64$ # z=,, s,Z4=!'n=m1 'b$=,4!'m&$=K46m&s!KK#{K4m6Kn#Kn4m,T, z4Z6&14!,T&n1K#$!yT!b =jm!$ ,n!
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
14/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
15/114
& 0-)5?-? -8?!?
! T T !
!!&@ ' ;
6.@@&'$;' T&6 $!&,' ,...T!; !! T& T. T T&T@
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
16/114
O 5Dm )8/
)8 ) yB8B ) )8 B )B) E 8 8B) 88k B yB E8)8 88D` E D E )8)8)` ) b8) E ) )D B 8) )8L ))k B ) 8))) BD E 8) y) 88) yb` )8 8) 8 B )y E 888)D 7Se )) )' 8) 8)8 E ) E 8D` 8yD` 8D` B )8 8) 8
` L` )D )8B |y 8) |8B 88 E8B) E 8)Dk
D E )8 )8B) 8) yB E 8)D E )8B D E )8B) L 8)B E )8 )8B8` 8) 8) 8BD E )8 )8)k )DD 88 y 8B 8)D D EbB B 8 B 8)D 88 )8B B8))8D )8 D ) 8D E `)8` 88 8)Dk 8) 8)8 8B yB )8) B 8)D |) ))8B )8) y ) b8 E 8)Dk
8E E 8) L8 ) ) ` E
E E )8Dk E= | EB|B E B LB` 8B 8 | yB) EB B)B8B ))k B ) ) 8 8L` B D 8B 8B ) yD EB ) E) 8) y) B 8)))8B L88D E B8B yD EB D8y B)` )B )`
y)` ' B8B E) 8B) 8 y)8)`8k )) 88) yD y) ) ) ) y) ' 8D y) W8' y) 8 ' )D 8 D)8-) 8 )) B E y)'8B` 8) D ED )-8'8k B 8 8) )B` L T5Te) D y)8B) E B )
)y 8 E 8B8L8 BB B 8) B |)B )) y)- ) y B) E B 8) 8 B ) )8B8 )88L ) y B T5-e B)88 D)8| ) ) 8 ` 8b )88 8 )
' 2
U & W X' V > ?@ A{ =
D)8| 8) )88D ,U-e THe T5-e K7T7T7T7-Se d y' y)3 8) b8 E -]J;>T7?>e )88 y) 7Te)8)E )88L 88 E 7Seb yD HS-KXT7?>e
He 8)k 8) ) E ' JHS7T7V-e 7Pe yL8)D K-;T-,eT?e B 8 T5-e ) Se Te' )' 8' )88L E ) ) Z7T5e T5-e 8L HKe 8 8B )88L8) 6>T-NIK-TT7?>eH1e)8'` T5-eK-;eJH7>TeE ) D E L8D 8) THe-[I;7>e8 Se*US-,eyD y)Ly' E' y THeK-;T-eTH4-T5-Ke ,711-KcB b8B) E 8 kk T5Te H1e ) >,e H1ee1;;7>4e yD )8 T5-^e1H;;HZe T5-e S=e=T5-=T7;e Ek E )8 I5->?=->e -\I;>T7H>e T:-Se E E )8 )8) E )8 y'dL8 8) '8 )D E ;71-eZ7T5e-d8 8 Ed) 7>e L8 k '8 b8 E !K7=-e 8 LD '
8) D 8 7>e -]J;7>7>4e ') E )8 Se y'8 8B E y) )8 >^e=HK.e d ) y8 T5-e|) E ) 7 5-Se))' '8) 8 ) D B8B ) )) 7T--eH1e88) EZ57*5e8) B L8B )| T5-eKU;-Se E 8UST7)-e 8 e8UKe )8D' 8 ^e )8 5HZeT5"^e 8 Z7T5e) )-8E- ) ) ' )L8L E ' 4KAUIe
) *#HU>Te E =-TI5^S7$Se BKeTK,7T7H>;eJ57;b^SC^ S%7.>*-e) I
D1e.\I; 8 8 E)
T5TeT5-H;H4^e7SeDUT=F+-,e^eI57;EQFI5^e{ T5TeTO,7T7H>;e 8 )D 7>e 8 7Se HUT=H,&,e _e S*7.>*.e 57;HSHJ5^e 5Se -.>eUS-1U;e 7>e 8) ,^e ^e 5-;I7>4e S*7'>T73*e /\J;>T7H>e K4 UTe- S#7->*-e 5Se II-K-,e J57;@SCJ5^e S5H,e 8) |)E 8) b8 E L8' dy K-;T7?>e y'' J57;HS?I5`e >,e->-e=^ey )' ) *UKK->TSe E HKe-\=dI;-e T5-e W7-Ze T5Te J57;HSHI5^e S5HU;,e *?>>'e 7TS-;1e - ^S8 >,e >,G>e *K7T7#;e .W;UT7H>e =ae -e ' Se eWK7>TeE T5-eH=T->eJ?S7T7H>e Te S^SeT5TeT5.e,7S)HV-K^e?2e 8) =TT-Ke E ) 8
>HTe 1DLe8) -1HK-eT )-8'')
Z-K-e -ST;7S5'(;e I57;CS?I5'MRe TK70+e 7>e >e d 8) Z^e TCe
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
17/114
:0-")5?-? 1#?1+;-6-.,=? yU) ))&)|`&)D)L k &)D & (& )~ && y`(& UU& )) * & *&) yUO)D(& &) ( `D &*&&&)O)U&U&)&U&* * (&)&(L&O && & y&)U&U O `&) &)D&DyO &y L &~
* D &)D & ) & * D L& &) y)y ) *DOOyD & & & &) ) U&D y)O)yD )U&U L )U&U)L ) &) L& &)D & &O&D )U&U) )&U D L& *& ( )U&U ()U&U L) & (& U &) UU)O) )&)&O&U&DU&&D * (U U(&y )UO)& ) & `D(& &)) & &) ()U&&) )L) y O)UU &U &) &) &&D&&&D &U)&` &U &) ) &)U)) &U)&)*UD` ~) & U)) U&D UU* &) &) &)&U )~` O &) )D* & (& U))&D y~yD U &))*yD ()U&&) )L) )U&&UU&)D *L )U&U&)D
&))&)*&O)&)&UD&)&*&) (& *yD * &)D `)U&U *(Dy& &&U L) &UU*OD)&)O)~)*& *UU*) (& D&U&D * ) * O) L. & ~ L*)&UO)U&) * &&)&&O)(& U U&&O * )U& U&U) O)) ) )yU&*U&*
&)D)&U O&))U&&~ & &) *y&)D~& *&U& &)& &) &D L )~ && UU& &*& * &)D &O)U&U L|&&&U y& * yD &)d* &)D)U&U U)O
%
$ S T !"# [\]>
* ) OU& )U&U &*) & )& * )&D)U&&U D)) *y y) * &)D )U&U )yU*) * U&&U LO& U&)O)&&) * O& )U&*&))~ &(&)) * D & (y&)&U*&*&U)D &) L )U&U (& OU &U)&)UD U~ UU &* y&) U ))& * ))O&))U&U))*y&))U& &U(& (& &U (&)U&U* &&U))*& *&U&y)&DU) ))O& yD U)) yD )*y& &)U&& * ))&y D U *& *** y&&U ()U&U )) * *&) (U*& * 9U&)U&U)D)&U (&~&(&(y~&&*)U&y & &&U&) **D &U)&)* L&) y yO* O ) ) *) D (& (& * &U)&)U & * &) ) &
*. . y>
U&U*&L&). y. .& . ( * .L . &)&)UDLDU )U&U&)D * & *DU(& (U * &* ) ((yO& &) D U&U& UU.) *D) )D* *O . &D ) *& )&D) )O)D )DD * &*).kxU&*&)) && .(O:* &*)*))U& * )OD*&X*U d* &*&O (~& &L)& & &))O) * * &y) d * O .* && U . &. & ~& d&d *.)&* (&(&.UD y&)&U(UO* &. &)&.*&U )&) & )&)&U*&)*& &OX&UOy.&
5 D) *&~ * * )& U*D )X&)U&U (& * *UL &7&U7*&) *&yO *)XX&U) .. ~. && .&*& )U& (.)&U Oy ))&*&)** (&&U&O &)
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
18/114
% , %M ,&,N,M %*I9 I0, ,I(II%? & ,* A 5 *, % 6,R 9R%* &*,* 999 &9b *- % %( =(%,-%6"*-6T% C"6-6= ? % $%C(
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
19/114
)
!) ) !) !!)
\ 4+\Q%IL+\I.\LI=6V6%S\
!CD sIDIGGIG D! D!IDI"I;DC"0crD ! sIDIG crD GG D ID IDBDI'rC{'IwDDxDDIDDDGD!sG!'D"IDIc;!IDIIrD'D GDIc ! !rIIDDIc;!I" D ;IDD !' rIIDI'G !DGIcIcIG !'D"IDI DDI IG"crD DIGGG
D;cI'"s!I!IcI!IrDDDDI{DJ'GDDG'"crD"IcDI"IrI"!
I"sIDIGsDIIDI"IGIDCDsI;JDG!GD'"crD ;I"D Dr sIDIGrCI! DGc "crD Cy!'DIs IG!!"crDDIDIDDI'IDsDI"!JGI"DCI!!IDIDD'r{I"!ssI"ID
C!r{DDs'DsIDIG D!ID I"I I D Jr D tI x I 'r D GDIcID I I!I''DJrJDIIs;DCI!IcI!CIGDsIDIG !CJ!I"DIIDDDD sIDIGI
CDcGGDwDD!DCDIC'!IrIDI"Ds0JDsIDIGDIr Dr DGD JGCD!DCDIrD;DwDDxDIDD ;!IGfI"DIDI GsD Dr;D"DCc DDf a 0 DIDIG ID0jC DD GID QrDcQ"crDI!I" DsG!JIDsDDS
!JGrDJC;DD D
sIDIG;cI'I!IcI!!"sI cDI" sIDIG
o I_1&y:P@p&q@
sDIxDGwG!DGIDICIGDwDD;DCIGGDIGDIcIDIDDC;!DsIDIGD{DG'D;GDIID
$D;GDIIDDcIDICIG"I! wDDx D sID IG D IcID D! CIDr{I"xssI"xIDsDI"x'GI"DCDI{DI;GDIIrID{CcD IGDIC!GI!I"CIGs'rD"IDCII DGDIcIDI' sIDIGsDx'r Cx C{I" D "IcDDsDsIDIGsCx!DIrD"IcIDD!rIDcIGI!GI!I"CDDC ;sIGJsIDIGsDID'ssJ"II"DJ'IJDwDDx!DDsIGG;"Ic JJQD IJ I D I!sD!;D"IDIc ! GDIcsC I{CI s "s I!IcI!C{DIGr;JIrDIIDGIcIcDs;ItjIIDI"DGfDIcICD;"IcJ'GDI"IDIIDssIGDIJDCCsG'sIDIG ; cI D D JGDDDDIDD'IDIDDI G!"crD "DI"D''I'D GID
ZG!;GDII DDDGGIDICIGD wDD;D CIG cD I;ID sIDIG GDIcID;GD r ; DI{I" J sIrIDIcJr JGIDG DI;GIDICIG!DcDsIDIGD!sIDIGDGDDDCGDwDD wGIDIJG!crsDDJ "DI DD I"D C !"crDIGIDIDDwDDDIIDDQDDfDIGDs{I"CGD!Ds IDI'GIDDD CIGGGD wDD DI0J wDD IrsItDI0 DJDGGD,J "crD " DI CIDI D GID;D JDDIJDDGIDDDCDI!JwDDIDr!C!I!DDJcI"DCIGGG D D IJD wDDQ D DwDDC I DDID"Bs!I!IcI!fCsqDJIDcQDDI;GID'rJ"0crD tGIJ0!G"I!cI"D DID D0!C!DIcQaIIj!IBD! rD%0 DD I J k CDDD{;D sIDIGJ GIDs CB"D Dj{ '"c
rD
IJ DDD""DrGrsJ0r0J"IDID IJ!CrsQ{fIrsJQDJDwDD
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
20/114
O "6yHL"|^^
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
21/114
-
"6tI L "tdd=,t"UdtU
!^ #!# #G # %n ^!G^b##G^'#^# ^! ^^G^'##, bG#!b #G#G!#G'#^G'^#!
#6 '^' # #'# G#n^! z !! ' ^G^6 !Gn#
!'^!n#,^###! n^!####^'#G #G^!!#! '^^G!#G##'#G###GG^!#^x#!',^n#G##'^6^#!## ^' 6##6^^G'##GG####G###GG#!#!,',^
,$ ', ##^#b n66# '!6 #z#G#z^1,',G#g^#GG
G#x!#^
^ #z^ ! ,' G,G# ^! GG#y G ,^
,#G$#!##G!#^!GG##^^#^^#GG#'!x#
# G ' # ! # G GG# ##6## #!#GGG# #GG#'!##!!!G!##'^#G#n#GGG##G'#GG^#GG##b^!#GG###G'G#'#!b#!G^!#G^^G#b '## ## 'G## #
x'#'^!^,6##'#^#^#6#^
#!GG!6^##z^#n!6,^#^##^66!#GGG#g^!n! ^ bz # G #G !6^# #!!'$ $#$^#,!z!b!x88,
6G^^'^6^#^^#6^n'G!^#^#!#6^G#G'b!6^##'^!^###G##Gz!,#G GG# # ,^!,# ^! ' #!#G#b$6^!#^ !!!' #!^#!6'##b####$$!!6# $^ ^!^ # ! # 6 # G '^ #^ ^$#
#,@YJ(I
#^'^ ^' # ! $#! ,' !6 # G '#G#^'#w##g###^#^##' # ^'#G !^ G1#^6 # #G##! $# #^ 'z^^'GG#G 'G# ^n# ! b # G!^#G#'#w###'!^!^#!# ^#! #61 # ! 'G6^
\ PPF#6U6HCP\C(\"I@@XC6U6*P\
^!! g $ !^ !# G# #z /'1@BOn#! A))ABO #,^G# .$+,MABO # ^^'^'G 6^ # bb ###!$'#^'^!!,#7$$^#,^6!#!,#^A))@BOG,# #z #6,'7$b,# #bb$###!'7$^#$6^G# #!^# g,1##:
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
22/114
z 4tDLo^^7/nVanW
Qw ? 22,0 02
? q 2 q1 12Q5?22? 20y 2 0X20 0Qq2 q1 X X5,5?q5 X50 2155 5% Q 0 Q0D5, ? 5 OD5{ 5 5 1 X5 {W%55?DW%
D5{2,{2~D , OO% 20 5? 22 2Q? 0,5 Q2 ? 012Q 2 21 55 % Y01 ? 2W% 0 5% XW { 5 2 Q1 55 Q20DQ,W2555 5QQ0 \\D0aO0 DE%D Q1D05 X0?q 0050,5Q2?O001X5[q%0? ?0 ?0 0 QnaD a?0% Xq ?0 00?5%aEO1D0D 0 X D1 { QE{?Q[ [ 1[DD5 55 5a 5? a 5 2 Q,52 5 ??0 Q1 5
X0%E ?DE 0 a?aE 2 0 2 D %5xQ0q20QQ1,D00 20 05 D,5 0 Q2 5 0 5?X[~ Q2?X%? 1 0 , 0 5 D0505%Q2520q2Q201,0Q,005, 5 2 z?~ 1 01,0 5%?V 0 012 {, D ?125%D1?OO15
E22{1([GWD5X(%D20WQED01?GOO%20x 5% ?2D 25%
Y55qOO20221{?O00? 00 Q(?,1 2?0%D1 ? q5 5 1 0 0% 20 z?0122q?D0ODqO501O1D0%5Q
0 q%,55, 520 E
x 20? q5 1Q0 5250YO0OQ0?5%?0,5?21
X25[0 [ D 1X5q X0% 05qXQ0Q2D 1 0 5[1 2,1X552D2W?12 ,O0 ? [%aX q 0D 02%522?020500,1%0X00 X5 a Q 2 500 ? D0%5[X0502OQ15
%5D
a% 5D 5% OO25D1 %D ,0
q00 ?20%00 %D Q0n Q1a50F0?{O51{,W0{%DWa%YDW%
5 150?0 225D??W1 5 020xQ2 DX0
0% G 55%25D0 %5G%? 0 FD0 }
, 5 D OO2%WD1: % Q0 0WQD1 W t {OQ12W?1W%%W0WDW% Wa%Q0X0%D0X[5 ?2 5 DO ?%D2{ XW D5 X5 W52OO2%WD1 O1 Q00DG 22 a?POO %22D0?0X XO0Xa2 Q 051055a2 %d5 %1X0E 5q5% 5DPOO2%51 0 % GPW 5 10D a?0 5 D X5 05Q5 0500%55a0OnWD2n "A8 aO2%5WPL
DD0
O 2 z5 [WQQ2D 0 '. D W2Pn Q1 E 5?E 562P ,G2%D nPaOOGaWG?5
55O { O{5?0D0W % 1D DYWXa2%05?{2X5 Q2DDW00P200%?05%XWa?WD5
\ ?2
W??DD0%?02DWGTh D ?G2%5%505
200?O5WXWDD+$(. nNP1< O%1W{5 5oDa1GW DG0P5Q05 ??E%DD0aG5D5P
%, .& .!. D055[0%
Dn %l (-)). . $* . G Q 1 UB A 0%G 5% 5 G5D5G? 2DG5D1
00 W??00D ?GO?l2D5a% GX0n "*. #. D0F Dn GD{
0DOa0? 5a5?OW1 a D` ?
D0 GO% XW DE 5. X5 O ?O 0 2% 5%Oa0% X`50D1 aDD` nOG5qGn2E?E552OO2%5W[E02[0X5D05P2D20?0aO%Da52PXW0O1D5G%L
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
23/114
, /)%2 ) djf8&i &>)2)-'?
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
24/114
, /)%2B ) djf8&i&>)2)-'?B
"( (( / "- / $- $ / "((( "(/"- 7/$ $// I/7- "((9-jt/( 697/( "( (("(I9( """"("/(I-jY "(9[I9R
t9/("["-O9/("(9"/ /97/IR$(/,"I$/(
97/( "" "/(9I"( (9("( "/(- ( [/ " (9b/[(/- I// "" "( /969-/--7/$(/s"(9(-/(9I/-"($"/$(I9(7" 97/- "FR } /- I/-I$/(9"9/9-//-x ( ["ss/($"(9"(/-"/("9" 9 "(9- ] I( (I I""(9""( ,s("L(///97/(c(/ "( (9(6G"( /97Iy z I97II(c " / ((6 "(/ , " $(9 97/9I s//s (["( (( "
I$7 " " $(-7" RY"(" "L (9 I/$/- II( ""((9(/"(9(6[(/["7/I//I96""9I(99x "$(",9$L6( c 9[S9 9-R - $ ""(9 6V/-6 97 AV "7" "" ((9// [( A99( " ("(7- " (I("(I("I"9/ R (9/- ( / 9 /L79 "/ z Fv( -I/"/
([I99-/G"7/",( / ItGI9 $( " F( "(9997I"
ti/ ( " "L I 9 $((F( /-x 6" 6 " "( IL-"/i/ I9(7II " / "9- A97/( 7cR t(9 9"(((9/iL//s[/-"//(" L//7""G/ 9" 7-7" /- 9 "79" F(/ (9(L(9 9/GI/"$($7(/9"(/(
,(Y"G6("",(ILAIi9/"79""/99(/-EE9PE"E9(66K"
(/,/(
@ UU+\C(\CU7IC\
} ( $( 9 " F(L LP 9"9"- "( F
6 9/- K9Ec (c "( G6
""/-9(c// A9Ls s "i(,9 I(- c(( / (c6( AIb9I " $(9$7(c"E9([6("c//-7/Ecl/ 7s6 "6("( Kc(9F( ,( $El bP"("79A"(("c( ("l9EL} I66(9"($(! "GG 96-""( Nj6K $G9 "(L[/ ( $
"((LL"6LsLIb9IK6("Kc/A}L7Li9-9/BNd "(FEc6KKlI"/I"l9Lx
b
($-t9K/l",E6c""(Ib9IG6l"(FpE6"(Kc /Al " !! / AL "K/E // IbEL " l "[9"I796b b "E9(l[Tof`y ) 9l A Pb""l c(F.( "(KKc/( "i -"l6b i
//II9,(iI79IL(6- $( 9(9( L" b-"(9([-(G//cF( "(9((""/(,(7""/A("(9/(c,7/6
("97( " " "K/E KA"l / ( b-RN$(c$-"F( " "(F"b/c c(- /" "(7- "i6E ($E9L"I "9( L L97 "( 9[ -("E9( 9(//6 c 9 // 99 ( (9 // I9 "( $(L6 "(N7"("(9(97("ILL$/(s/9( 7-x G9 " L cL9$/( - 9// i/ I79IL(6(// c /(, GLPGI(
I9,(,(b-9( "(s6""(clF((I Ai9"( /9F cP6 l 9-K #!(/"lG9 K//
Ib9I6 G " Ib9
I9(sI9s(/ss(cY"(F("( c(9 G9/cl F( E
G96 LLiG Y"i b-x 7Is" // "( csKL9p /sA c3s 9s6(
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
25/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
26/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
27/114
s v f ;j=
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
28/114
- $ &&_ #, ?#j 844 : # #4 :B,#?8 ##8 4&&$# 44#8 B4##, ##&&$#@ 8 #@#$# &_ y # ?:#,?##4B4,8!AN;W?8_BB# #y 8 ,8 #88 w#j & #$&@#8-:&:8#48FY8B@#B@8wB##,8:$8$4#44+?8##,#&R8&_$:8
$-4B44#$&8_RF# j8#848 &-# @# &j 4# $w- # 8 #4v_@:8& 4B&4yY8B@B8#4B, ##,#&4?@+@:# 8 84#84 @$@#yY:$4#44+8F4&,8#_#,#_&4 & @ +?$@4 B4$&y ,48&_8?$##&~#8#,?#?B,# #_#,#& @@+B?@ @8# :$- ?8@ t4@8 B@4#B4##,_ :BB#4&@x@B@,EE%8@:#_#,#_&8g&@E+ B@ :# #88 _#: :_ :E
$#& #- ? 8 ?# & :E8E@88 &[? &+$#-@48@g4+E8B#-$##_&&@@g4$- :E Fy t ,+&@-4##48 8#$&E@##+y#84E8#$#$8EFEY8F`4:+&EB++:y}&4#8$4#:84%#4#@#$t@8@:&8
Y:+4:&+g&&$44#,P#+
4&- +B , y
Y:#4#8##&F#48BB#@?@ 8E # 8 :E F 48& && B#$&4#&?#4t4} 8,4#8##&,#4BB&@ #: ,8 #88#4y _-4 & &&F__ B4#, # : #, ?B#$_ 84y Y:E #4 4#_$& _#?? $$& _#4 #F # : 8#88-B@4 8B4,?#+y t8 $& _P@#E 84&,4 +8,,_ ?@: 8 8@
8#_?8E##&FY8EFt@&j:4,_&44?8## ,# 8 Ft 8,j : F4#4&8#%#B@4#+@@_o#-y
Y: B4 # #, #+% +? 8 +@ FE - $4@ #$ 4 8 B@# + E&@E %4 # } g 4 +@@_4@B%4#$g-+8 %g &+ W- 4 8+&`# # @# B#-+ #%P@ 4 # 4 8 &&$#? #4$ + @ ?#@: _#@#$g #:4 8#: 8-^+- F#E 8 #+ +?# #4 4 +,-8#884 + #8@#84 %E -4-8 8#& F :44# g # 4B@# 4#`8,#44@#%E%,E4-+%4Eg,E%Pg+:#&:B4g#,##4+%`+@#:+@E@K&T 4 @ &4`&- #8 @@+@& #4 4#&&4 E
E&@E#4,@ } -@+%&- 4KB8-4#&&&$g 8 ++y 8+4E4 Eg&@ @ # -#&&4+4+E E%6 %& +@4Bg@g& &&$`g8 Eg+%@&&E@g`44`4 %8`@4 } K&_$@&&@+-48 8+&$ 4B+%4#$&E?@
4# 8 4 `4@ @#& &&$`g# ,g&$& @&E$@48x+@EB&%+48+&_$&+4$-@4B&- 4#[%E44 8@#4 &E`$+ 8 8#8 :g448+&_ % @g#%E :,#&&8F@,#P$%BB`%#F BB4 8 # + 4# _##%` Y8_# +?8 & ` # , #E44
@B :E `&8 #4 8 8F 48K& 4B#$&B@,##$4
#%ga#&&@`@
&&88##,#&48&8#4&?$E@4B#$&K@@-g
@ #4 $, 8 $4 # #%# $ :E@ #4 g @` + B## $E #?@` BK&ggP&B@#4 %_ 8@@B6 +%
8 :+? 8E$4# ##48&$ %8%
#4 @#& &&$#%8E@ #4E, &44 @`%$ 8 & : FE +g4 F #&` @`&t&&FEEB@+#4#+@P
$#%$E@&
_@#P+@#4##4E`&&8+8 8 _#+%8+&$E +B&- 8 F P`+$-_`P#a##4844`%@&&`@#E4:#:++8@
V )h?v {E {haa-&h Nah{{N / / &y: P@ | L
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
29/114
V )h?v{E{haa-&hNah{{N !6" ! !a 6 ! 6 6a/!H!V"F66 !k!! !/6Fa!/6! /c6!F"!V!!6!c"!6a a6w"a F
!
6/!6 6!6!6/! a!! "6 6a ! ! !
6"/V!! !6/!66!!!jFV!!!/!/!
fF/!!Ha"!!F6/!!F/!"//!6!6!HV6w //6! 6 6 !6F" 6! 6a! !/!F! ! / //6!H 6c F6!/6&Fj66!H66w"! "6! ! !c/ !!6!6!66!!!V!!6!666!!
a!V!!c"!!!6c66!6!6/!6k6!F/!F6aF!V!!
!!H!6!!/6 k!6! !"66!/ 6! /! /w6a6"6!a6!6! / ! /6 V HF66//!!/66/!6a!/!6"!!aF!6//6"6!"6F//6 !6"!!!6HHF6"!V!!a!6F!!!6"! " !F/!6
/!V!!6"!/!6
CW|a
. 6" V&66 / /&!w6z" "6F6! 6 F &6 F6 ! 6 /
R;/ / &y:P@| L
!6/k666F6a!/66F6!6V&!F!/6/666F"!6/!6c66/66F6!/6//66F 6 6a / F / /6/6k!V6!6
!/ !6 6 / ! V 4 F Fw kw 66 / !6H 6 6 66 H 6 / ! F ! "!H6!F6"F!/ " Fa nn !F 6F 6Fa66FF//!"&/6! 666 /! !/66H/6nV66FF&!/!V!!6
!
V!!"6"!/ & V6/ 6 a666z&!/!6"6"!/6/6!/6&!//6"6c"V &6/6"/
66z/V&&6"&"/6t/66"H"6/66F #66 r /" z6/6/6"!!//6 /6 "6/6" 6 /6
&!/6!/6/6" "6 66!6 " H 6 !6 ! n6/44 &&66" 6rh/rh6zH 6/66"&/6n//6"/6!&X6"z!&6&
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
30/114
. /. "/ .ww /2 2 ." //. ./V/-/2.$/ ""*/ j!k"//2."V
/-// Vn "" " - ".
H.//-../. /. .w .k ./. /. -"/. .w-w ././.HV-!/2/../V".///"/V/ V".".- " /V/n/..k./V . Hh hh ". /V
V#"V-2#/2hV"
C#}3#?#0M
V - V #- / 2n 2 Vn#"/M$w.w- " / Vn V2 - " /
V H . /V ..n"". . z " 2 2. #n " ". .-"k22"V#2/V
//"k .
. / " ""k/h-#2h/ /V ""k /. ...k . /- H"# 22 "// . ./" /
/ Vn H/- - . #" "/ #.2V/ / / 2 //" -//#-.Vn
H " . # /-V M/2 # / V2h # " " / .b" V #
. H z#- z 2o 2 bzV#z/ 2 zk2/#"{z
22 H . .# zV -"./kz2 /- V /-bH.- n / /-b/- #" H# # # ic2
2 # #z# /".V/V-z.22 "/ #/z 2# -## / 2h # # / # #
VQ ~)m;v~E~m\b-#mNbm~~N
&rs: U
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
31/114
E
'''' nV)$ $ ) '-)$$''-)$)-)VR))-'V- a -a ) ' '$) V$'
V ''$)) - ' )) ) $$$ -$) '$ ) $ ) ' ''$' V ' $ -)))$ '- ) $)k)' n ')-$-' V '$$)-)'$)'
)- $)) ' ' '-$ ' $ - '$)) $ ) V' -$ ) - )$ ' V ) f'')Va')V'' a $)-V))) ) V ' ')
/' V ) )F-'V$
'V$$ a Mg $ | -|$ w)$ |
))
''$ n$V-$ $ h$ )$ $w )
-$'U$ &'')' k)}
6-$' ))-' ' V V )'')'$ - k) - ' ) K' H)$') --$ 'Vk) ) V- 'w )'' )t H) '
' ' $ )V))$)) $a-k) )$'H)$')})--$
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
32/114
)
!() )#!!()
\ 4+\;(+\H0\0O++(H@\
; ;/";2 ;/ ;/; ; ;/vv; vv2 ; / Hv 2 /22;/;H // 2;;2/;;"$ ; ;;"$; ";"/v2" ;-2 /2 vvv$;" v /2wv;
"/2;v"//v22 //;v-;2;;v;v//22 " /2$v;2;;;v;2$"$/"$;22;2;;
-;;//22///22 / v$ ; ";2/; v 2;; v v2 ;/ 2Hv ; v- ;;""2/;"-""$"2/;; v;2H;;"$w"2;;;$" 2/;; v $ ;H// v //H / /;222 ;2v/;"$22"v/" -$" 2 v; ;$ 2;"/;? ;? ;?"$ ??v2 2"-"$2/ -
$;/v;;$"" /;
--; /2; -$ /; $ 22 ;v$;- ;Hv ;;//v /v;;;H;v;/;; "- - ;2 ;;H; v;/2;";V2;;-2vw
2 2/;;v;//;v//;2 w//v;w///w / / v v?2v /;/;/ v /;/ ;//;;2$vH; /;v22/;$ ;v;w/v/;2; /;$ v H ; /v ; ;/2;v- 2;;;2//; 2 ;2/$vH;/; v2 ; " - -
$
;v ;/ / v / /
2; ; " - / /
v- $2; // *
o v ; 2 ;2 ; ; ;w /o / v 2/v2;"-$v/ v $v v -$$2H/-v "$vH"2;/;2H;;
v //;/ ; " ;2-222;;/2;;22/ / m n ; ;-o ;;/;-22 w;~a)+ / ; v2 ;; [2$;;";"v;;o ;$w v v #''*1 ; v v ~
[;; ] ;v;vH ;;; % ;2 2; 2 ;; 2 "2; H; ; ? $; ; /2;v?2"? "??v" ; 2 /"o v
r +n=vJn_c0#nManM V ! ? 7 8 9 : W XY
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
33/114
,? : ?? ,, ?n,:,?:, : ,: F :, ?:, ? ,?,??,?a,?,,
F?:???
? :,F? :,:,,??
?::,F?F?:?,?,F??,?? ,::,F, ?? ?:?, ,?Fk
wD?,k?F,,:::,,a???,? , ?F , :F::,:,??F?Fn?,?:, ? ? ? : ?, , ,,, ?,,?F:?a :::,? ? , ,,F??,?:??? , : V:?? , :& : ? ,? , , ?, : V ,:,?&?FF&,:,F?:,??::,?& F ?,:,
F,,?,:,? ??F?:,??-, ,&?F
?,k ??::,,, ,?? -?:,?& ?:, ?&F & ,,&&&
e
_
, ?F?:,&?&?jm ?:-,?:,??,-F x F: && ?, -,,&F&&?, ,,&?-,?F:- ?? , :F ,?:??,,, ??::F,:: & F? &
:: t& Ft, &:F ,:: ? |BiO ?, , ? :,?:??? : ?? && &??:&:,&?F?,??: x F&F&?-?n
#S::,?,??, :, ? & ??,F?,,&,, ,??:F&? ,, ? :? F,&??:&?,,??F??,:&&?,t?,?,? Fa,&,? ? , ,? ,: ?? ? ? ? ?,?::,?
F :& :, ? ,: ? ,-&hh $ ,n F, ? b| b,-?, ?, &?,& ? : , ?? ? ,,:,:,,?-&:,?,?&& ?:? ,, ,?2&?{ ,?,
????,{,? : , , , , {, ?-&?-&&,?,?,t? ,,??& ? &, ?:? : , , ??,
? , ? ,? , ,, :,
, , ,,?,& & , ?, &&:?, &,,?, &-
#$!2 %2 &/!*!"12
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
34/114
'3>-3='CR>'3>3>-333CH-'>'3C=>=j>C'm'3 '>' R ' 3> '3-3= > ' H3'>3>''3=3'33>>Cj '>C3>-33,H, H>>C'3>-R>C'33,j3 >C> 3 3 33CH- 3'>>C333HH3CJ3=J3> >C '' 33=H3Cj
J >>C'=3=m3=3'>>C'H>R
}'/ 3='U ''+333C>CC'+U UCj }/3' , m H 3>- >C' =>+ -R Y33 33, H- =+3HH- J '-3 >H J >C>'3='HH3Jj3='H3 C ' > 3 3=-R >C'-3 >C>3>3HHj3 3''>C>>CR>CH33C- m ' J- v3C >-j 3 ''/>GCR C >H HH>'-
'3H-3m=33HH> >HH-H3'3=H>j3 3>C3J>y
3H3 >=C'>3H C 33'3J >C > >C =3, >>' R ' H > >C >3 3 C- JHH >C> C- C '>HH=U',/,''3
C+m|'|+rPR
3' m' 'C'3>H' ''
' ' UH/3= U' C', > >C '/'3' >+C > 3 C- U'H-,Hj C-m>C>3'-j3''' '=' 3 3H- ' H3 C,3C R 3 ' 3xJ' H GG3| t'G 3|H==>CCH'|G3' H-3HH iH,' ' 3G'G -'' bH3 >+C>>' >C H3=3i'3 +3J'R ''3>U>C>C> +3U
'H-/H3H->HHG'/>CK>UC'''U'CGGm3H'iCKUC/ 3 >C 'G 3' ='>Q QiM >>'= 3/> ' +U>'3>3>' 3='
H3''U+ , U'>C m->='=' >U' '=>C> C->C> UC'=,>>' 'Gb R ' /+ ' 3=' '
>C>3 CG- m'+| ' , UC iUPG3YCG p>C >KPC-3'' UKC+3='+l// i+
=' U
H+'+3UKC G U 'ml='U+C
=,=U>'' 3P ' +/ U+C C-m mp ' +=CUb/'
G'^p/-'
C- m =+ Y >C +U CG- C- m H H>'3 '' 3'| 3| 3 *", m } ' ' F C'm- '>Ci/H33/P''3H>C'H-b,|H-='3=GC''3' '/|U' '' b//-' [ '=/'CH'Gb+=''33/-
'm- 'G>3='' 3UU'UCU>C 3H,''3H3=Jb'G''/'3RtH'= 3H3' ' i> >C > 3>>'
>''Cj3' , '33'=p'''G'''3/'i>C'''''b/'YC'3C'3 '>GC''C= UpP'U3=' +'
UGC +'pC/GU Hp,G''
3' /+' b3|/ K CEap p' Ckp U>||''p'b }U
UC 'l mlKU'' 'U
|'
'U+/HK''' +'|/K 'bU P+'' H ' 'G md 8 UC 3 `' 'p' b> m ' H=pH '+6 3''b p|'p'bi+''/p
bm^|'''pC/=H
G3'3J' '- ' #&'"(, bG 3 + G' ' 'G Pp
| 'p' '[ # KU
+CG
i ,"+%,'Gp
'U
F> GH3'3p/
=3CR >F
=
H
$%!&1$"#+-(,)1|Ulmp|3C'
& ~)t=v~G~oZ]2&nMZo~~M dQA &y:Md &
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
35/114
>>
2M$::Mn $ --MM"$::M M"MMM$2 b" M: "2 ::M"-
$:M""M-w
M$" :"-$MwM"wM: MM "$ M::H
M"$"M8":M " Mw :Mw " :2:Mn"M:M " $: - M : "M V 2 " :M k " M M M MM"$M n H ::M M: M M:M: O-!X"MM 2:-M$M:M: ::a
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
36/114
> ('&}?''''&(' & '((''P '' '&(&''' ' ' '1~ ?d 4 &) ' Mt'M'? ' ' & V & ' ? ('&'( ( ( ' ' ? } ? ' Q' ' t1 (?
\
01 ' +'( ': & V + ; b ' & ''M '
1 & )'' R& & R & & & M R'1'&&& m 5q')' & ''|&& (& $('1'4& )$ (' : ' & ' :\ '' ' (' 1 4 G1|m $ '1'$4&::G::'_(::'1'):11
#
& '' ( Q ; ' s 1$$ + m & ' ' q &:(M 1(:'59'44:1; ))M ( 1 $&:.1$.$4&$(
f 1 t'$ 4+
O6!.O
5)( ;4 ?; 4 4 '44 '$ $ ; Q 1 5$1 $4&
& 4
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
37/114
s ~)n
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
38/114
. 9T . gi9/[.i|... 99| =T/ .=. |=.9|/ *. .T|TT.V.|i.. T. =|."| */ i../T99=.
$ =|=.a9|/$"|9.|9.||T9=99="9$g.=i= 1999=9g|9=.9=. i9$9==9=./99.9A 9=999=$" .
A@ = =9 T9 =" $.T 9 = .9==|=T$"Ti9 " 99.$g9 .9= 9r =r| U $ .| = r.a 9 9T.w . | . |==.g..."T"/9 99..$ .=. H =.g=$//|i"T=i9$T..H9==.i"g| /|T.==H 9.T/.$$|=.
"= =9 9=. 99 gT9 | /9 =T 99//==r=9r|..|9= "9T=/g9/9|=/"|""9Hg9./"==.||T=. 9|=9g9//|=="g[9=$
,?f
i 9$ =T"9T=.T g9g ==g=$ 9$""k[|99i9$=| AT"9T=.T$|99=9/9H|.$9.9T=T9$" Ti|9.. T$ |9 = . "9T==T"$|9 9H|9.9g9H|=9g9T9|=|99$B/ T9T=. =Ta =BB="9 "$| |9.n $9 9H9B= $T9| . 99 =$ g99
"k=i=g9=T 2#5T9|9|g9 " i=" 9HB9= 9T H |$99 =T /= ..|"."9=T=.=9 ==9== / 9 =T B9 =H|" 9 =$ 9T| 9 [| 9 ||k="9[ =9= B Twr9 =|9=9= " $=|9|.9=T="$g9$$9==r$=H="=BB
9=9=9|3)-5 $ +A ==g = = 9" 9=BB =9$==9=.[ T$25 =99|2 5 5 5 |==g =5 .&45 9 |" |9/ 9 99 |9 5-HI"R6
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
39/114
>
'2B"2""'2B T2B2B T"{2{2w'{'-''2B B B T '2B B { T BB ' - T
B) '
'B2BHB 22BBB"B'BBT-"22-B B B 2
B" B 'B2BBB 2 'kB2 'BB " ''2B '{{{2B''BBB" {T " hB{ ' - '{ {-B--h"B"TBT B " T- { 2- ' BH '-' ' T 2 B(TB"T-2''BH'B{kB2 "2B--B"2 '-nBB2BB''}
T-2{'22B B2B"'B{BB
B'BB'BHTaHB-BB''h 22B'T"TT' B( B Ba B''BBB T' {2 2 BBBB" B'{{n( BB ("H(B-B''''"BBBBa'2{B B TBw B 22( B ' V"H'BB- {2BF2BBB (bB B 2 }' "tT 2 B-2BwB T-2 ' H HBTt BBB -B h (BT(BB'B(B
-BB 'B ' BH ' T "k2-B ' 2T{kB2 -B (
(B' T{-(( (F
t BttBT(tttt{h"k2-(B'V(kB'2('-U"( '({ Bw2 BT( B"{
B"22T}'TB(22BBBw'2Bt-T B"-B
Bn BB}'
BBTtb"t"t{httT"T- "k2 ThBh
!W &^k =(WL>/5W &4(E"W
{2{ 2{' tBBB B B T B(tB "- 2{ ( ' 'B B-{ T B T ( '2(B'{{' T'hB'VB2{{ThBBh{}'tt"B }2'} 'th TT 2-B{'tt"2t ( "({ t Tt B T TB B t ( ' 2 B B('(hB2B T{B h t- t( -2B'{ 'Ht2{{Tth BtB2 ''t{B2(BB''Bt(" BtBT ' ' ) 2
"T-( Tt2 B (H
BT'tB{kt{2hBtB'T"22'kB2-(H(- B(B{(' T-(B2B(t'B-(-k2B - B2 t B ) T ' ( BT (B 'k2 B( HHBw"kB-TT(BB '-{ { ( 2 h B-B BB{"t'B}'k2{{ '' " h ' t 2{ -t"t { {"tt t T
({B( 'kBB tt-''tth'T '} P tT{ t{ Btt-t(
-t { Bt t
* %')"* &* d
(!* # $*
\ 0-$*7? -%-&8?2?
[ ) j-) G G ) pG G C6 - k)
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
40/114
[)j-)GG ) j Gj -j) j )) w [ j- p)GGj [pjjGj-j-jG-)jj)jp[j-))G-Ga-) ))GppjpG6pwGG)6-pGp)GH))
6pGp[pp[G-ppGpG 6G )-)j-)G6[GGjG))Gj-G-)pjpGGG) ) ) a-CjpGC [ p ) H C 6G p) --) [ HGjp6-G) C)G) ) - )CG -)Gj pG
) ) pG G -6 HGjp-G))G)p1 [ - j pj G G) - )Gn GG pjj ) G G)) p )Gp6HG66CC-Cj))j-GG
[pGj)pHpG)pHpkG)G)-Gj)pHp6 )G) ) H ) G p G)Hjp GH p ) pG)p) 6 ) HG H j CG p6 G-G 66) GC pGt-j )Cp-) [G)pkGj
pGG C6 - k) --6C)Ga-Gp)G))C))pGpGHCHp ) )-) ) p GC
) pG p )p [G)ppGpG[)HGC66CC66G
CpHp66kG-pkGC) G ) [ H C6) Gp6GGCp6-C)b66-)C)G-G ) G C C H pG6G ) ppCG G G[ H GCGC)CG
-)CGC[H&66CH6)
CC[C6G6Gp)) ) CGC 66CG -HpkG-p[ pkGC)
G)GG)G)pGpG) 6pGpH p):6)G6Gp ))p6) C66p jp6G66p6C) 6CC b 6 C6 p6C) p bH 6 ) 6CGG6 6G6 ) V7Cp p 6t6Cp6)p6Hp59Vp6 6)pj6 C6p)GpGGpGCG6)GCp)pC)C)H)G6C6p)pCCpkGpG)6CCCC6C6CC6pCC6p G) G G )G C6C pCC 28hVp C6CGp)C)HC)[6Ga677)CC CppGCGC) pCHp Cp -j pG
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
41/114
|s 3tDLn^c9.o V_oV
60 f=0 uff0$ 6 ;; cq q g^- u ;0 ;q
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
42/114
60f=0 u ff0$ 6 ;;c 00 c 6; 6 - ** 0f00;"0"c- 0wc6"$;0q"fc;"00$06$0 00uuf 0 "$f0fc$0;;0" =qc;;"$606 "c 6-0 qc0ucc60$c60-u0;6c;6w0c;0;" 0-u-0 u0 0 ;0 uc 0" c c; =u c;f606cf0c06=0c06c066;&0u66"0qq;
- c060cq 066000 ;c uq Vc c006cf0fc 6=0c6$=cw-0$;00cq ;c6cc c$;; &qc0=u=c$66600c 0"00= c0 c 0$ c =&$&$
v{eU vZ q&0=;;u60u0&$&vv4!6cu0;c0 quqqcq " q
c0uu0-$ c c0c$ u cc";060;;0;060q5 ucfc60"c60660;-c V Hv"=;;6Vc-q$00 $c n0c60;60 6 u;0 fcw6f0$600$nqu6
cuvv4 =0 0; ; 0 00q$=$0q=;nVc0 AZg;u c0n60c0ua 0; 0qquq6 6c "k0=f quq06$0 ;;0"66"k=
"=c6 6cc006c6;cVc00"0;qc$0u; " Vc6u0c"c"$;c=; F80u 0"60 Vc= ;6 ; c00; c vFHj& = UVv ""$ ;;6
0 6c "k0" ";0 0 u;;u6&c= c0 ;" u6$;
cq q g^-p u ;0 ;q6 0q$="0=uc=uqcq=V 0uVq0;0uq0"q0uauqc; vZ "4 6c$ 0u6 c " ;&q0 c &$0 c ;==0"0; 60;u q& uqw u6 0 uq=c0u66q;;
0; "= & q " cq6= v @e A q=6;qu6"=; =ZA cX0
0 =$ vFv
34 00uqq=w0;&uu6qh=
= M4j quq& uq"q0$/g`.pF8
=&FHj$%v U2H &u6&0u"0h&0q=
; g4AgHU uq"q0"h vF8
vFHUL = . p q $&$ cq=$ Z A v F5 @ip0&c;u;&0;n0&uu0 " qq; u ; q0c RWgN Z" H&v =ZCp vZV$4 &$e% &XvHuqc60&q=F5 "0 vFv Vhc8NCp HUFH$Hvjq&uq h AZeR
u uqu=0;quq UWv jvgZUE$hq0q&q="k0;_p vF8 "=;c&0
qq0f=cuquq u&000& c0 uq F8 EZW2 =u c =u c=V qq=;0cuqqc=U552 vF8U vv42HRHUHkF9j =u
;cc==u(Z{ej4 0R"q0cuq0vF4$(ZUjvHv{9Uvu uquc&&=uvF8c$ c- " q 0 u{q &u c 6cq q quch{v vFHl q$ = UXv ;u vZ29B4U2 q=ZA /p =Wf 0&&uq Hj ZU5 &q& vF8g5AZg5 Hv 2RHv vF9 0"00$vFv =vF6 cZA Ag792ZR &$Z{v8HEFX0&;&q=cq=uvF8V=vZ "=0"$=;;="==$
=c q=;; qX= vFv =-0c q$Vc60u=0&X
q& vFv c"c&&;
"q$'v9%UcvF5&vF5qq;V=& ""; ucqu u vF5 g H mL u &&q$ q cg8dg82 ="q " q 0= c uqvF8 " YA vv8 {vFZgH v vF4gj = Z&M9 c
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
43/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
44/114
~)h?v~J~n__1&nM_n~~M - '
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
45/114
- ' ? ' ? ' -'$ -'V$ ?- ' -''' ''-n-Q(#S 'V''''
' V $ '' ? ???'???--$?$?$
- ' $ $k-$V - ' - k-'n' ' flk-$'' Vy ?$ -''??''
)
()
@ *.49%@#(5@
-'y' { ? K b ? 'Y$'-Y'? ' ;?$'4$b'yYY'y$4y y y' -
'y$ -$ $ y' $';;HY'' ? y4 ? 44 -$- ??
$
4' ' $' 4 'y - ?'$ay;y$y$$$-Y
$yY$--$Y'4'Y'4 $
? $' }?$ ?$ ?
'y'y'y ? $'? ? $'k?$-4y'$ $$
Z u*\3mv: w\LK.%] EK\xxE
*** 3 * s3ss*$* $ 3 IQ s 3 s s3 s 3
3*?*sve e 3*c vQ viy s sbyi y*s3s Qc vQ y ee v e y ee s ve Qe yeQc
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
46/114
*s*3***$s*$w*s3$-s*3$* 3ss**$*s*$**3***s3*?
*3*s*!$ws3***sv3$s* 333s-*w3$w3?333s3?3* ***?*3 s3*s33s*-*3 *s3**3vs**3Hv3*3**-*v3ss3-*3*s*3*$3*ns3$sssssv**s3*s33****s3*s s3y*Qc vc[e uyecyssee 3s y *vs3veyc|sseebQQbyye7NQ ye *s*k*3s***y 3*3s3*3*y*3$
C -****Hs* 3sss*v*3* *3* v* $ *3s3**33**s* *-*3 * 3* * **s$ *s3$n *33*3 $** s 3?$ s Q 3$ sH* *v* vs s3$ s* vs3 *s3s*3s*3Ove *3*$*yFe*3*3*V*OcOQ scee vee \Qc 33*3ss-se y*cebQyb[ebQe y vQc Qc yeb *3$s-*s3$Qa y y^#Qyu uQci ve ss33s-* G
suc R**v**ss*3$33ves3sesyeyecbQyQ *3?[ebQeyQeee^ye vQveyy s3s3s*3$$ cebQ| ve eQ *?3? 33*$ *3Qe y vy Qua8 Ove t eQc Q v*v 4JNAETX A*A/0F./X ,&A>X [ Q =e|bQ * ** Vs* Qec[vy 33**3 y 3*3*s*s33 Ev JQ s
.'ENUX vs** Q
ceseesy[eQuQy*$ns3* yQes#bQcy^3sB eQ **s**-s*3*3s s (;AHX1
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
47/114
7Z7% 7!7!%h!ZP%) !d8%Z8d!%PdG
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
48/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
49/114
0)%2B ) k339!=)2)-(ABN-Y ~-NY~ YY-~--~NY"
-~J~%26.=OyNyJy%Y- Y }%~ Jy}N Y~ % ~Y
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
50/114
|
--AY~"~~-"" %~"Yn~Y% YJN~~"Y"~ NJ - ~%%"
"N-~N~-y% % %N " J~-N-
N-wYN"~Y TJNTY~" Y J~ N -%"YNY~%N N Y NY # NJ N N ~%N-%%Y-N~%- N% kN 5
-
N%~"N"~J-JJYYY" 1-"N"~yT~-NNY%NnNY~% -Y-~% Y - " ~Y-~2~%#~YY% # % % %N y ~ NN}#OK@8p"%%b6H]!p !* * % b6p 6R 3;Cp % b6"p%Y J- " y~ J %#Y " N @ioR?8C4p (S YN~y%"J% %y% % M1 p}Jy ~- # % $ "% # #%}Y~~" %~~%" %}~~%b%"J%N~-}~bYY YY Y- JN%%}C p * bY" %"y~ "yJ% %# %}y }Y %~ J~ Y $+H $(2#
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
51/114
L)NN L))#lLNDLlL7N)7#D)7#NNNL7)N7LL7D#Qn #Q l)k)QDD LD7#l DQl7N7DLl7D)N#4#) #L4Ll4 ) )N)L D)Nll DQ Lw L L NLl )7 )) N L llL#NDD77)))77#L Tv3 7LLDQ47D)DL# ))D 4 ))D DQLNLLLDLNk#LNQLn
llLNLD7lN # lD#LN L777QLlcL#7L L( LL) #DD7 l7 NLDl) )kl4LLDNLlD LQLDQDDDD L)
)NL D DLl ) 7D D L l
L) N#D Ll L l Q LL N 7w L lLlNLLL77llNN)N7LDLwD#NLNLNNL)L)LDl#NDDQ)LQ)DlL#LDLDNNl7Lll#)DND LN w ) L7DLw D D7Ll4DNDQD
) D L L
&6+46_b{u>{ +_6{ oU8+P?I?+_{ u?j>{ _?j@c>{ ]+_I?+P6Uj+_w{ ]_+1j?16{ P+w{ u?d>{ jS{FUWu{ u>+j{ j>6e6{ juV{ j>?U
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
52/114
~)n=v~G~nZZ1&o MZh~~N
WWQ'8'WW8W8FW a +8+ 8+ W +$ ' [+
"=v3$4
88+ F,`+$ , W`#W 8$[# #,8, ' , W F , Q, 8 o }
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
53/114
Wa+8+ +8 W+$' +] F W +$ ' FW [ , a,8+,8 F#a88 W8,8`,'W' 88,'WW8+,$a 8H8 WW8,$8$, W`8[ WW8W8,Q88F8+ '+`88 [ , ' ,8 #8F 8 W8#8+[+Q88+FW
#8$8F
8`#, [++Wn+Q8#$8# [ ++WWQWW ,a 88WW$ 8+ +8 $ ,,,Wn[W$W`W++F $8$ Q$HQ8Q WQ8 FaW$8+ ,,a',WaWQ,a k 'WW ,8 WQ88 8WF,,'Q88$WQ WQ$,8,$W+8+H`'#+,W ,, W8 W Q8 8 ' '8,n [WW$8+ '
[+,,WWQW$8++8[+ k ',8W+ +8 [ +Q+88+ +Q88+ FWQ88+'8+[8+`8',+FW88+[+'[+++,W'`''#+8+ ' 8[ Q8 8+ `8+ 'WWW8+ W
8F#`'8'[888W+,W+$nFa'8[+a#,+}W,F,,,W,'[a,,8k',8W+a8FF,88'8,, W # ', QF,+ W
,H$ ,, WHQ W`+' ' F,+$ +#+$Q8 $,,aQ8$$8F,`8+,
8* 'Wo'8'$a8 QF,aW',8+ +8# ##W`Q[#8W+yW8o#'W,$#W$#,
3>)>
s
!))
8,',W F, Q,8o} W''WWWWQ,W 8'y'+8,[FW$W8W ' Q,'W `8, [ , WW$ oW W$,, 8}oWWW ','#8 W,W8,W+W'','+8Q88,8o,,,
[++ `8+ +W WQ ## 'W$# 8,,},#[,#,WWoW8y},H'',W$n
[ ', , } 8H 8, , Q y8 # ',', W,`+ 8#,W$WW,WF,8W'$WW,o,8 ,8$',}, 8+8+ 8yW, , `W #8, n $F+Q#,+,`+8`88$',WWQW,,,88+#,$'#WW#QW,FW$QW} 8 ,
',+W}$+8,'[F+$ F ," ,,' W#Q a ,W y'k+ + H W' 8 ,$Q,'W[o'{ }88+ ','
8 ' W8 ' [ ?w W`W ' WW', 8WQ 8# +$ W}+kp Q+Q[,8,WW$,`,8WQ,,$8`Wk }, +QF#W,W,`,8+,#W QW8, 8 Wo` ] 8y W$', 8 WQ W y 8o 'Wk,Q8}8 8WQ, y 8a 8}' ` WW$ "A ',{, F`[WWW$', 8+8+,,8{, 'W W,# `+ $,WWQQ'''+[8'',+,4"I 8'nQWo+8
~)n
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
54/114
!C!*" !^! V!! g* r* !F**! " **! "** !^! *"*gg**!g*!!^g**^^!g!F** !!a Cnn *!* ^! !!^*C!"r^^V!!!!*^g^gr**V!!^!"C*g**n
^ F* ^!g V!! * *!a !
^ !k *! !! * !S S C " ! C g C !^"!!gC!!! n **a !!^!" 0C;D!20)OHO ! gg !!***g !**!gV!! !*!n* * *!!!FC!^" *!!^" *! *r*V!!^ !! F! !CF!C#S ^ !!! !^F!Cg!^*C!^!V!!* *!!CrS*g!^S!*g\V!!^S r !C 1 ^!g ^ V!!^ SCSSF#!g!CC!g!CV!!!gSgS*^*g!C!*C!!C**^ gVS!* C !r^*! ! ga ! ! !^C* C! C *g ! *C !**"^!^g!*^^*g^!C*^^ gV!!**!*a^F^^!g*!**!*g*SF! V!!*w * F!* H ^ a CF!*Cr!Cr^!C^!CC*"C * "C*C! !* g!rS^*!!*"^!^S^!oSCSg!
!^S!!Sg!^!*!S!^!g!*!gV!!**!^g^"^
gF!!^*^""!!g!^V^!^^^"g!^^!gV!SoFSFSCCFVoS ^F^aSSC^CgSCC
S L0S'+S 4S 8b^ b
O
!!!g !C V! r^C S SC C!g!aa!S*CF**" !F^ Cg !^!g!CSgg ! C ^! ! ^ gF!!^^"oCS^r!"Cg! "S H ^ "^!"S^!!!^SCCgS^gSgS^
! gg kS rS S^ ^" ^ !"SSFSa5? C# SF!hhShCSC CSg SC " SSzSC CCSCr^S^CSS"^!SSS!C*S^gS "^ *! ^S^go SS ^!r S*CSa ^rr So ^" S Cg VSSC 8,1S #hS S VrCS Sr!AaSS!g!C!V^o!^F^
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
55/114
333//3V33 3(9 V33/$ 3 r9$3/23$
$/9)nV333 S"33r3)V333S"33r3n 3 V33 r 3/ S 3r3V33r3/ S3 r3 S 3 "33 9)3(A933 3 3 "$"r99)"9 3))3 "9/ $ ))3393$3n9 9))V
V33))32"2A2a 83.Sr
3/ &S) 6S93r$)V3A3Ara2"2))3 86)S3/+.S92/r3/9V33r2/33r393 33$"3/ 3#SnV239339/9A$"k 9 r33 39 A33 A92 A 32 "$()3 9 3A2A2 "3 "9 / r3 A 2
3$rA) A/A$3r3392/V33rn r/ (9)""3 ) 39/9) 3n39333 V33/93""ar3/9)3$/3)93A2/r3/939(3$"3)V33)3)93$399/ r3 3393 //9a)r3r V33r3393 99333 AV93r3/9r9$9/ i 3 A/A R3993br"969S 3))
24
"b) r r3 3)V3338)#S)r #+Sr33Vr336#+S ) r #6S r3 )a 3 3+6S)r3/Sr3b)
|)
r R4S r3n )" 99)3 323 / $A
R^i$"2)A3
3 )39/)""
)
"$")/3 /333 3#S 96+3S)AA9) 3 3 A)3 9"9/33,S A393 8S*# A#
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
56/114
L o8 o8
o8 L # b } # 3 # x
: #7 77 7 7# # k # . 77 3# # : $7 # ## 7# L o` k ; ` L # ; . # ;
L # # !:+6S L# L
3 k 3 3 L # L# # # 7 # ` x#7 . :0S 3 # # #3 b ## # # ## 3 L o 3 3 # k b # # ":50S # L
k # L x##.8 # . ; # ; # x k # # #
))
]
x##k # 7 . ` # _ : !:6:S3 # 7 X 7 7b : 77 #. 3. 7 . . # d #. : k
7 : 7 # # 7
7k # 7 . 7. # 7# : 7 #7 .7 #. # X. : 3[7 _ : q # : # # ._d7 : # .# # # _ : 7 : #
# # ` . . : # #. # . v: 7 : # # ` R #
7 # # . : 3 # # . 7 # . : 3 # 3
3 # 7.# . # # 3 .: : # . 7 . . # # 3 _ 7 7 d # . .7 7 3 # 7 7 3 # 7 7 d # # P0S 7 # _ y # 7v7 # v: # 7 . k # # .77 : 3 ::
# 7 7 : .I : # d3#. . _ 7 _
#
: 7 7 L .7 # : :
# .# ; _
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
57/114
y-d9nyBydXX/&d IYlyyJ#!W[ @W @o# ]t @ #1!@W@!!@1#W
# @1#W!!@[@0 # !##[@1
# #oW # #W W#@@@0# ][1#W # X #[ W X#[t[W # !W# @ ![/!0[#@00#[W o @W X#[t.[W] t[ /# # [@1WW60@ @ W@ [#[[#X!W/ W0[@ @ 1[#@0!
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
58/114
][0oW60010#] []W##o0 # # 00o66!W
#6o0@W!]o oW ]
0! # W@#!] o6 @ 0# @ o !! x##W @t[W! 0!o#@ @1#W #o@W #[0 # t@[#W # ]6W # 00#Wo!@o@@1 # @t[W!!] 66!@0! o@1#W o@0 o0X![#@W@# #o#@!0o0#o# 0W###@! o@[#W # 1!@W o@0 @!!W @1#W
@W0!o#@!@t[W#[1[#@W 0WW!! #[W@#! 6[!@[@W #@ 1@W@# @toW! [@1## !@ !@[#]W0[@#] 6oW @@#!] 1W # W60@] # #@WW @ #[W !1! 6o#0#@
#
6o@@#@ []W!t !@~@W# 6[@@@ #o#o !0[ @Jo1o@1oW6@W# 6o!p#X#@ # ! [ !! @# 0![ W## W# !1!6o0oW o@#[o] [oW#o @ @6o#@! [@1W6## 1@!#]6ot!@#@006[W6#@6!@0 6o#0#@6o@t0] @Woo6##@ ] WW[#@# [@1##[ #t @@x## @!t@1[[#[@1 #Wx##@W @W [!! o@1# o@1# t[] # #@!@#] 0@@@6 # o@1# o] # !] @# [ !! 0W# o@1# # 6[6o#] # [@1# # [ #1# 6oWW@ WW0@#@
#[@1WW #[#@0!1 0!o#@# !! #
o@1#W !@W#W /[ W6!!# #~@#@1##W [# # [![ 0#[ !#[ [1#W o0! W 6!#0/!6o@0@6!W##/t# 0# #1t[0o@0~@1/ 6o# # [@1#W/X#[@0 # t[]##W]W /W o@1# #~ 6[# @ # 1to# @ W0#[] @#[
o0!] o o1 [!] !0# [6oW#tW ## #@!! 66! W! W@W #o#] 1to#
6oWW @[1!o!0#@W @#00 @t[W! W o1 ot#@16o0oW
! ! o@0!W#W XW#@##@1 #@oW#oW# @to# 0!o#@! o W@[!0 #W60@] 0@t@! !6!@#@0
1 6
W 00 W0! !0!#[ [@1# o@W0WW@1 # W! !@~ #0# # #[ 0@t@! 6!@#@0/! [@1#WW W # @@#@/! 0#[t[W@! W# [@1#W
0#t 6!#0/! W X!/[! 66[6[@/# [ # [1# #6[#@0@6# @ #1t[ ## @WX# # @[#@X! 16[X@1 [@1#W [ # 6!#@0! [# # #/0#t.Xt@! @W# [/!!]/66[6[/#WX #W11W#W#/# #W[@1#W [ 0X[ # 0# 6 #/# @W #[ ! [#@0! 1@XW/]W##t[/W .# [@1## #/!#]X@#@W@6 [#@X!#]6 @X[[ # [t# / @X W/]W # W.X !/W ## [ W # [@1# # !t ] 0#[] @0!1 W / #[#@W #[@1.X#o] #[#[# @W0#[q/66!@W0oW !] # / 0@#@ #/# 0#[ #1 # /[!@[ 6[# # [!#@6!@XX!/W @X!W # [@1# X@#@W W !!W 0@#@ # !t 0#[ 6/[# o # W # !! # #W[@1#W # @ [#X!W [ X # #X@#W ]0@t@!@0#o]# 6[#X#@ z # !/66!@W# t[t 66W#@# # #W o@W@0#@ WdW#!@1#@ [# # ! o1#W66!]!]#X#W#!]#o@1##6o#@0@6# @ #1 @ 1# #[@1# t#
W W !1/# WX # !@1# [
#o @W XWX[@6#@ [t. # /[ o0W 1[!
t [ # !@0X/!! [@1#/[ # !# # X@#W@6 ] /[ @X[@1# @ !@[! X#XX@#@W /1/[#.. ! # @ !
[ # # X#[t # # W# WX/! 0@0 / [1#W!X!#[ 0![#@!@t[. [/[ W !!
# [@1# # @! .X[#] # [@1# # [~
@1# [@1# #1t/ # W@# 1 @X!1!6] [ ! [~ /J # [@1# # o @ #[@W # [@1# # [# / !@o @# [/![ !6[@@X!@]W@# 6] 6t@@J ## X6ot~o@@0! # o@1# # //# W#o !@t@1 # [@1## X/#@ # [1# # 6[# 6# # 0!#[! ! # X @#]/ 6[#X## /![ #[/ #o#W
y+\3my:x\MM/&\ EN\xyF
. Eo 00 0 6o0 E 0 6066 E 6 06
66 . . : d nd 66d : . _ : .6... : n 3n _
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
59/114
06 03.
0. 06 E . 0 .. E 0 60E Eo 0o 00 60 E 6E . E66. E66 0 0 6 6bE o b. 0 :
0EE.E
0
6b E 0 b6E 606 E 0 3. b /
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
60/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
61/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
62/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
63/114
? 3''? 49(!!-5-/+>?P. & &!] $ 55$G& $ G$&3$'P..RoG & [!!& !$G5$$ &!$'p!&]k5$55$$3$5]$5$$$p!&]&$$$& $5! ' &G$ &_$ $p!&] 5$ $ ! 5
5&!5 $] '!$ 5$ ! ! $!& & $ 5$!$35$$`$p&]5$p&5$$p!5 &5&! 5'$ _5G& $ :!! $ 3&$: G! `'!@ $5' & &&3'5&&!$: 5'&5'&$& !! '&
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
64/114
& $5! ' &G$ &_$ $p!&] 5$ $ !` 5&$ & G$! !$!&$
! G 5&!$ 5$G $!& $ _$& $$$$p&]G$p!&]] G&&&& $&! $p!&] 5$$5! 5 55&$ $p!&] $8! $p!&]83$$p!5$! '!&! &55$$&3$ 5 $!$ ! G 5&!' & &3$ $p! 5$ $p!G 'p!
5 '$5$]$` ]& $3$5]
G] & 5$G]:55$ $ !G5!$ 5$5G & &$ &!$ & $] !G5$!_$ ] $$5&! 5 55&$ $p!&] &3& $p!5$ !$ $5G 5$!$p ;$p!$5 $] $ & $$ 5 5$&&!&&$ !G $55&$ 5$ $ $5& 5 &&] $ 5$&3' &$!5& ` & '5 G&5&$G$$ ']!G!]$3$&]5 $!]& G &&!5!] 5$ & 5!& !G ' &3$ !] $ 5 !$ : 5!$ 5&'&! 'p!&] 5$5'$ $ G$5&:G&5&&3$&$55&$$p!&]$5&5&_$k $ !$5 5!!$G& [$p!& [ !G &$$$!5& 5$&&!&&$G$$'p$& $ 5 ' 5$&&$ $5 $ G&5&&& &!!5 G&5&&k!$p& & !$5&!]$]$p&]k
G$$5& 5$$ $!!&&$&5$$3$G$5&_5$5 5&5& '$ 5$$& $ 3&$: '!5& ! & !$$&$G $p&] & $&5'!] $555&$G&5&& G & G$ &!G$] !&]5&:5&&! [p& !!`55$55'p&5'G&5&&& q 5':'5$_' 5!!] 5$!$3 G&$5$' G5&GG&5&&& & $$_$G&$5$$ &:&5G&_5&&$ & :35 $ 5`['$G $ `$!'5`$5&5& G & & &5 G&5&&$ $$$ $!$ 5'!!] G]!!]
5&5& 5 !!] ! 5! &
5 ! &' $ !& G !&' $ G&$5$!] && "(') ()
5$G& !! '5]5$!'35&!5:''5 !G $ 5'$G $p!!] [!$ & $$G ' &G$]5$` & & $ :'' 5!'3G&:$5$'$!GR.$!$$! $5]$'$ ]!!$[ ['55$!$3&:!'&[&5$p! 5$$] !G' 5'' & $ $$G$&!$G !$G$ ' $!' ::G [ 5 & 5'$p! & 5&''G:5' G &] ' ' v & $$5! $ '5 $ ![5'3 & $$ 5''
!G $ 5'5:5&!'] ' 5&&!'$p!&]$5' ' ! $5 & $$ 5 & & 5 5& $p!&] & '3'5]$ $ 5$p&5'G ]&$kG$!G$5$'_'5:'5$ !G35 ' 5&`5 $!$`5 '!'3'5`5$3$ $$5&5& $$ '] 5$ 5&` !' !$3$5 5 $5&5& 5 !G $ 35 $ 5 $' ] 5' 5 ' !!]' $ ']5 !] :35 ' 5&$X &5&3'!G!$$ 5 $ &5[5&5 $&'5!G$&$ G$ ' &5&! 5&!&] & G'G!] 5'p&5$$:&_$` G5'!$$ & & :5$p!&] &5'G 'G&_5&&&$p&]
: $3$5 $ &5&!&] : G$ & $ 5!$$p&] G$ ' 'G' !G 5$ '3'5]'!&$` $$ G &$G&!] [G$G$G& &$ !] ] 5':$5$ 5'!$3 G&'5$$
G 5 ' m 5!3 & & 5 :&! G & $5 & :&3&! ! !&&!&]G !&&!&]` & '5: 5& G 5 !' G !!] !'3$5 /G &G '&:!G !] 5 '3' : G'53& G G''53& 5!5! 5] 3 5 & ' '& :b 5& : &G&3&G! [ ' &G_' 5$!$3 G&::'5'$ : G&_5&&& ; 5'!'3 ' '5 &G 5 G & _5&&! 5 &$ & & &5&5' :5 ' G&::5_5$!$3 & 5&! &_''
5 ' &G& 5 G$5&'5&!$ $!'` :5 ' &$' & & /5G& !5&
^ ^ t1A 7!:,! !1!!1 A
71!R Y:7A : w!!+A
v7!1:!e$!e7!e!AA
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
65/114
!"!,!
:
! ! !
=7 N^NY^ R P z 7 = s1P P ^ Rk RP YNdY! :'N^ 1Y7 0635 PRY Y^ N 'NdY z 1P '^7 R! NRY : =Y'3N b
Y
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
66/114
RY P'7R'Y ' 'N'F'P 3!!'Y !P'sY3^ R ^3 P 7^:Y's'P' s'F PP P =Y PN '7'Y's1 F'PFHH' P=' '1Y^YP^ P ! PF ! Y' YsP s'F ''P! 1s
Y P :PsYPH':P's'FPs3'N'F7:N P ' N : HFP'P YF sY! Y sY zz^s'Y Ys'P'P : 'F F P FP : 'P Y='FFF'PFs''p!!E!P 'p!PFP': N'P'N sFP'Pb!!='F sP!'Pb' P']FP'H'PP1:s'HY P!! P FP 'FPk P'P's : ='' P 'F P P= 'H P 'FF ' N : ='s' P13' F! s'!Y 'P P Y P 'F P' s'1N R FP ::NYRY N'F: F Y FP : P^s !! s^ HNP F FP z Y3!3'YN! Y :N::'s'' P=P P^s b''FFs^^FF F 'P :='1P s''P
P HP sP!P sP!P s' s
Ys'Y'Pz R1 Ys'P 'P 'P:^N :''P s s'H P' p'FP :FP^
sH'F3'sP :P Y FPs'PH=sbP ::'ss'P!N: P' :s's= Ys'PF FPP!' p'::'s'P!P:HP'sF'3's !::'N'P 'P:Ps'P'P P'P's H !17 !'p's''3P' N''PF 3'N 's^YR! PsY^P : 'F F !1 R PN''3' ' s^7 sP!P P' 7 P s'! :R'Yk Y F Y P R N^ z Ys'P1 !b'F'F ^ Y dN': PN Y1 R ' Y FYNY:"#&I#3 YN RNYPz 17'FY!1 P 'PF PsF^F NYsb X'3!Y: '1 F ^s7 P s'1s P=PP^q P^F'! '3!'3R!'7''P s'F
s'F s sP sPPP Ps's'P ' sPR R FFRF: 'P :'3!F PP7sRP^= Y^ P :s1'P PY HNRP 'F P !=F ! :N7s3R! ' ' P' s'PN^^N! :
1R^1 ^ 3 NR NRY ' Y1 Y sPP7YY^'Y1^NY N FPY 7 Y' z7^P^sFP NY = NF N 7 ^YY'Y N1PF^P YzN^' zNY NYYF=YYYYz k 9 N d 7N 1R1' s'1 YN N1sYRP^Ns'NPsPN 7YRY7Y^N '7RNY ' NN^Y^ :'' PYzR
Y ! s'zN Y
!P's1P ^:N'' Y :NY Y7^NP P YFs'=! ^ R NRPz =P'3'N
b1'17 N^z sY P=7=N1 ^z YY sPF Y1: 7 Rs z NR7' Y YRY ' F :^'FNP 7 R RN: 7N Y 7 :N1 1^ PFsRY^ ^Y Y^N7z 1Y d '' Y Y =^^p!=N1:N YzR Y '7NY PF' YNF Y 7=N1zNR ^sFPY^^N YdNb1 'N'P'z Y 7sP *-I YNz YR YN
Y
Y=
^
'
=N
Yz
P7NY^
Y' Y's7 F !1 ^ 7 NpN^ P H'FF FPY ^Y7 ^ = 3 Y Y RNP 7 3^YPFsY':s NN'!'3Y :sNY Y Y^N^s' PPF =PzsPYFY NF'^N'H P1 =s1 7NP11 ''P: :N' 31 7 P^ Y 7 P Y Y ^sPR Y 7 zN Y YNRN =! Y1Ys'PPN z d d PNRY' N^ } zz's'! zN Y^ = = YNRY 7YNR t ;ABDNNS '=' d1 YY 3NY : z^N N 1 RYsP =^3'Y=3Y Y P ^N NYd!!
^1Nd N!: NYdY N NP F ! sPz 1
: RYNP N 1NR
k ! RN z N Y P :R R P'Y7 RNP R Y N^!dY P N^
e "& !& &
h
10+:%4B 1,"!;#B 8 F -9 F >> Z -9>3 -9 3 1 F- F FZ > 93 1
!$B h 1 D D > F 9 ^Z 39F7 > >F9FFFF-9 Z 7- D 931Z9>Z Z9D 9F D - ^- > 9- > 9F > Z 7^
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
67/114
F- F >FZ 93 1k D 3D > > F --D >Z3D -
9D >1 19 D Z99 F99D - > 9> D1k - >19 9D F- 9k F`>Z9`Z99DF F11 Z x-D
9F
999-ZD 9 -9 9-9D - 19 - FZ 19Fk9->-F9D91D - 9 Z9 FF b1 9 k 99 9-- F >>- > Z UZ1F 9^Z 9b 991 Z 1 1 Z >- -9^ - 13 ZD -99 b` 19D19D 9--F-Z1F Zk ZD99 b :9 8 {D 9Z 339 >- -Z 1 -9Z F 3919DD> :^ - >9 F1 > FZ 9 9Zb9D Z1F-Z F ZFF 99 -D1 F-99FD 9D9 Z9D9 Z 9 ^^F 9^F9 1FFZ =?1{Q8{ F ^^- ^d7 1 Z Z E1?e 9 1F F-Z m=1{-> 7b-Z^77 F^d9^> 1D >-F 13 F> ^-ZF` >>^ 39d^ dD mD> 9 9 >^ 13^f=Q^m{ ^1xmQQ{ >Z9D9 ^ D FZF >3R8 {11F d >>1d &'0\m?J:{9^F F991 39
-> >9F>9- Z7^ xZD 99 F 9D ^Z D Dd^> --Z D D^3 - 1^> 79 ^339
> F9 Z F F- 9^19 ^^ 99 ^:`..H3Jo{Oqm{3^79 F^ ]q1gm?QN{ F x F 99v .{,?88.`.J(3{ 9x F- >^^Z > ^ >> 31 1 > 9^ > ^ 7 99D-b91 -ZZ Fk F D 399> 1Z 9ZF Z -ZZ 1 1F - FF9 > 99 Z 9> -39 F-Dk Z9 > F -> -Z11-9^ 9 9d7-1 > ^Z9vDZ^ Z91 9 13F^7^FF991F >-9Z 1{{ > m=1{ 1 9- 93 > -Z9 D- FZ^ 9 >9D Z1FF9 ^ 7 >-- 919d Z9 > -91FZF-9>3Z99D17Z^Z> F 3 D^ > -ZZ 17 ^79 ^^F -^9 9F - 9D ;OE8{ d 9 :OE8{ F^ ?8{ D&J{88T`+{ {X`Atm4{> 8O^H{ v> ^f Q^{ f 9^Z 7 ^9 >Z dmC >Z ? 9 Z ^3^991^3 9^
9^ 9^d3 Zd F
^ >Z ZEy?J:{:WE9{-[Ey{ ^7 `1 > 9 hq882^?J:{ Nx{ f&`?UFi{ ^3v qJ5HZEWyzH.Jm{".J%={ ^ b ?e {P jqkm?mqm4{8V^{ ^
xZ^999D fv^fv 1 c^{1 d99 q
] uDN vw8/ exr
1KK + &K1 Nj11& + 1&$N1+1_ K1&K1+j_X+5_ +a 1$+ 5KK &1 ++1N11+11j_11k_1_1+ & +K1n 1 _N&NN5j5_&+_& _1+$+&KNXK1+1j71& &N11+5&K115+
K&51a5 +N+&+1+1 [ _[+d_# +&+K&XH1&1
_KK1_o &K+4+1N&X_K+54 +1
++5+&++1d&X5K+_1B1_+1
+&&Kj1&$11X&+1$ &1+ _ +_ &$o KH4 &+ +1$&+1 _ 1 + + d&X+ +&+ + 1 K +$ N
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
68/114
1 &+ + &N&5XX5&K K1j1+j&51+&+&XX+_+1&1Nk+51++1a115+1K51+1& _N ++& 1+ j_+j&Nj+1+_jN_+1 +1_11++14+& &KNK&$&+ + H11+11K1 + +11K1 & +15j K _H1 _ +15 j11&+5&K&X+5_+_1&+1$1K1Nj11_XK 1K11 & &+K5a&ja& K&$14 dX&++1&1KK1&Ka&+&11+&$d&XK1+ $1_ &+K_11+&1ja 51+5X++11_+ $1K1 N +1 &1 j1K__ +_ +11KK1 $K&+& j1$1&jaj+1+&+a+_ +_$ ++j +&+ &++1a 5 & _5&K + 1j1_j1 $ K& + +X1 5 N1 + +1 1 K 5H11 15&KNj1+__&j&H_N_15#+&$1&1j&KK$1 &H_a& &3 +&+&&N_1_KK_1KN+&+1&&N_11a&7N KKN&j&X+515Xj5_&+5 &&_+1j &+K_ &$1KN11+51&&+KKK+ &++ 111
1& 5+1 K&1n #KK$ 5 &N +1K 5_&+1 &&5+Kj11 a &$1KNj11+5Kj1& 7KK +&+ +1111&_+1K&1 j51+&+1&&j1&K1&K+1j&+5181+jK1 &511+1j151&&K1&K+1j&+_1a1&$+1K5j5_&+1 w +#++1Kj1&&&&1+&+1&&j
[+ _ K K +1 &j1+ &+&5 +1_&K N&j5 1111 N+1X51&+_ [1 +1j1 11 &1&+1 +1&&+1 +1K4 d K1 1K1 K$n [1 +1 11&1&+1 + 1&&+1 XK _5 &+a N&+_14 NKj11K1K$+&&+5N&X+j$+&+1 N&NN&5+&1&5&K&&+1_a5+1&K+1&&+1N&X5K_+51Nj_+11& K&H &+1$+1 &$ &_X5& K1+ 5 +4 _ + _ &KK$NN1511+1K1[_1B+_11+X_&K1&1KK&+1 _+d+1__5&KK+&1+&+ &K+1+tu#I_K+5&j1+1+u&X_K_&K11&$1&KK55&K_d514+
1 1&H1 N + _4 1X+55 4 _ + j1&K_ +$ 14 _ + _
1 _ 1 + + d&X+ +&+ + 1 K +$ N &j&+5__ 1$&1 1dK & K141dK 11 X11K$ +1 _+ 1 &$ & _1 +& &K _ $+ uN&X5K_+5+111d&+ +&+ +1$&+1 +4K_+_X&KK$&&1&1+ +1X551 &+N&5K+K11&&+11&4+&+ +1j1&+ 1 +11&K +$ &+ $+1 _ &KK$
dd14_1 + + X&4141 + 5 #&+14 5 dd1+ +1X&1+ & _&$ 44 &j1X+ &15++1dK&XH1&K K+_1NB
+
5+11 d5& K++ K$ +&++ 1 K1N1+&11&&+1XK+K1+K+14K+1&KK$dd151+5+1&KK$#+54d&X+j$_1&H1+111d L21+K5++N&+1_+$ 1_+1KKN1K +&+ # X51+$ #11 +#+5 & +#+& 5151+$ #4 j1N&K1 d&I+ B+#+ 5 +$$u 1+5X&K1&K11j1+j1&K+11 2;3+1!W1+&+5_XK j&K$&+ +51 +14K1j&_X&KK& K_+5&KK$ &+ N +[+&+ + 1j&__5&
N11j&+_N11I &dX1& +j&1 u+1&H1N+&K&&+&1 1j1&K_+_1&K1d&K +4 #&+1 N&X_K_+_B5 +
1N5+11X&+_&K&& +4Ij1K_55+51X&&H1 4$o+d1K1+N 5+&_n & X+$&K&11+_K&&+K5X+$+1&+K_X4 & +1 d#X K _ $+ u++_ +1_j XK&5+#4+o$+o ++X + #K K &+K X1+1 +1XK ++ K4+#+& #1K1$+&++1
+o1_4&&4+&+
d__K# &+K_X4 XK4 K1 &$ K1 +1&j&+_41_5__&K+Xd++ $ X#+1#+&+1K5_4KH1++u+BK4#K+1+1 +1
+B_K__41K1 +t&+KX+14+&+KK&+&+1K_4X&+_#K55B#+X1&1#14+_&K #+u +B+$B _ #++ KK #+#++_ _ +B+ #$+ u4+4#_ + ud#+_+$ +#+&$1 K&$1&$+++o4#&+ +1&K d# K +5
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
69/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
70/114
)o=vgo``5&oP`oP
%% `~=%=% % %%i `%% % % / = `i % = i% % % % % %
OU % % 3% i =%/ % i /3/i/%i /3% / % ~=%% i/i % 7 % = i/~% ` % = 3% % %i3% /~% %
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
71/114
Z# ))
% % ` %%% =% % `
% % % % % i k % 3% =~ % % % % 3 = % % % i % i % % %% i % % % % i i %=%%i
% %% %~ % ` % 3% i %%i i %%` % % % %%3%q % `i%3% % %3 /i/%i % %i /i = %% =k% 3% % % %% % % i = %/i=% i 3% %` %i% % % `~=%%% ~% 3 =% i i i% %q ` %%% %%i %3% %ii%/%%i ~
i % % % % %%%/ % % i % % i %i i % %% %=3%%i% % 3% %` = %% %=%% %i%~=%%% % ` = ~=%%%`== 3% iiNii% i / = % / %% i7 i i% % k 3% % /q %%%% /=%/i = & j % % ~ % 3%
i % 3% % i% =%/ % %% =~=%% i%3 / 3% %i i % % i i %i%ii /= / i% %=% ii/i% %%ii%% % % i% i% % =%i% %i% % ~ i% i % / %3%% %% /% %% % ii ~7% %/ i %%i % i=~%=%q / =%ii/q % i% /// % % =% %3% 3% % i% % i/ 3 % =%/ %i = = %//%%i% ~% = % /i %% %
ii i %%i73%%i/ %= /i7 //%% i i i/i % 3 %% % i q i % 7%%/i/q //i% / /i % %i ~i/=q i =/% % % % %=%3%i% ~ i i % %/k
i% i%i % %. i%= iq% ==%/ %=% i q= %= / % 7%~%q/
%/ i%% i%%% i %i /%/i i i /q % i i% %/ / i i = % / 3 /% i /~ /ti% % i % i t i %i i 3% % /q q% f@az{M!A`uN %N i / i i i% %
= x = V 8 0V 088 L L]pVV8]88V o8] 0V 8V =VL8 =VV ]80=b = 80 8 Vx` 88L=L
08}$Z ='( A6'(3A' A6A 8'pOA=8VA ' O'pOA '( ' 9_u 8V('pO O('('pV'( 08 V ] ' (' =8 ( 808V A(AOA3' OA
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
72/114
8800VbL] 8 L8 80 L 8 ' 8 0 Vx 8V] 8 80 ( = V A(
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
73/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
74/114
D z+\4mz; z\OO0'\EO\zzE
_4DL _4_ 4D 4_4Dm4mR4 D__4 L m44D L_4m4m4 4 4_4 4 L_4 m4m 4L 4m 4 4 4 m _D 4~
_4 7 4 4 D 4m mL Rm . k __44LmmD4D _4 m L R 4 __
m R mLmR 4. RD
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
75/114
4L4m4 4 4 m_D4~ D L_44~m4 m4 4 4 m _4 L 4 _4 _k D mMDm44 _4 m 4 44D _4 M4L4k m k4 444__ 4444 4 _4 4 DD 4 444 mk D4m_4L_4m M~4 4 m4444 m 44 4 4 4 4 E _D 4 4D 4 _D44 4 ~ 4 D 4L 4 _ mD 4 ~ L 4m L 4 m _ D R 4 4m 4 4 m _ 4~ Lm _4 D m Dm 4 _4 4 m 4 m mLmR4m444 _D
4m _4 4D ~ _m 4 m mLm4 4 4 m mmD 4 _4 Dk4 D _4 L RmD 4m 4 4 4 _DvL4 4 4m 444_D D_4 _4 4__ 4m _v4 4 4mL _4 4mmmL % 4 D4_ _D_4 4D 44_m #4M _ 4 R_4D m4D 4 D . v44 4 4q4~ RM _V)644mm 4_4DM44_RD
R XXD vRD mvv_ LM V DL4mD D L O 4m l4D 4Mm KD
__ m R mLmR 4. RD 4 4 4m R 4 4 _4D _ 4 m _4D 4mmm mLm4 RDk 4 _44_4D4 DLm 4mLm4_4 4 7 4 _44m 47 R _R 4 4 m _4D4m D 4_44 _ D
4D_4 m 4 R4_ M RmR4 m_4_D4m mL m 4 R 4D 4 R.m 4_ I{ m_ 4 v4_m _ 7 7 v L R _RD4 v vmq m44 R RR 4D 4 R _ ? RRD 4 #J)?)m-{ 4 L 4m _
44_ 4D 4Mm m 4m
4D _R 4 v 4mD R_~mm 4_ RD7 4 m mR m ?tE v _ 4q 4m 44L ~ v 4 D X_4 _ R m 4 44 v R4 v mD 4 _4 mm DR v. .D _4_R 4 vmD ~m .mmk R4 4 4R D _~Dm RR _4L
v 7R h?CL_~D4 m mm~ 4m L44 vD v mD R_4 4m 4D R _4 4
1 &&1 1&r Cr! !+ ++=+0 +C E!!=+!0Cp0C +! ++=+0 Er! +C0rr+Ck +=+!! 1r r++ ++ EEr rr 0h! 0Cp0C +++ 00CEr +C r++1hC + 1r! +Cr !+!
0C + CtC hCE! C !+ h
rC +C !CC Cr! Cr + =!
Cr C !++ +C hE+ hC rC!
rrC +0+ !C +C! h hrrC
+0 C+0 r0C +1C E +++h! C =!! C
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
76/114
r010Cp0 ++ EEr 00` + +C ++C EErC =+0 0 +h0 r=r +C
=+ r+ =`=r +!+ 0C +C CCC+ 0!+Eph+C!=C;+0+=+E !C0+ +!+k r+ E +CCCC 0` +` rC=!!h+!+r+ h!Er+ r! +hC r C0+! +rC` 0 C 1++C !C +C !1r0 C0+k +C0 0+! !EC+0=+0 +C!=C+0 =C `rCE1 + 0 !C EC+ C +C0CE CC0+rC!rr01` C 0C0++hCCC r +C =r
= r+C Er C +C +C 00 =+ hC0+ C+!rCCC + ++h0!!0 +ChC!=C hE r+C Er +rE C!EC0k C C !E0!+ +0!C 0!+ErC0+0!!+!++C = 00h C +E0!+ +0!C 0!+Er 0+C0+0!! +C = 00h
00!C+ r+ + Ch r=r+C0!=Ch=+C0+!+!+ +C0 +E= ! EC+r !rh+C+k0++C Cr !CC` r ` =+0 +!+ C0+C E!!= r! E +!+ rr E CC+CCC+ph+! EE=+!+CrC!=rC! CtC` 1= rC! +C! =+ + !+! C = C= + !r h+C 1C Cr +C =rr +!+ h 0+0C =+ p+ r ` !+1 =+Cth+CC =!1 +C E! 0 E C+0 ! + =C!+! !+EEr!#G#CO$GW !C+C =!+E !1 C 0C + +CEE +rr !E!++
1
rr E C0+ C+ 0 C0+! h+ !+ 0 0+0 C =!! C
0+0+ E 0rC r+1C ! CC+! + CC
+rC E C0+ +C E +rCC E +C rC C
C+0 +!+ C+ 00r C C E
C 0C + r0+0 + rC E C+ C
+ rC E + +C 0 E +CCE +r+ 1rhC E r+0! ++!C 1
+E = 00r r + C0+1 1! rI
= r E1 1 +rC p )C +C! ! Er + 1 h E +CC E !
rCC 00 E C+0 !C + ( !! !
!C h!+! jm !h E ! C
!+ =+ + C C+rC C +C C
+C ` 0+C
JAK+U6C3\0FCKU#+CC/@ = 0 +C E C+0 R /1 + E +r! EhrC rC +C E =!C + +C G,&AHVX@*X:QKM6"X r+C 1+ /+!rErC+ 0+E E+C + C C )5 h! CC0 +C +C= +!++ 0 E C+0 =!C=C 0+1+!! !1C+!+r++ E +0C 0 + + E0+ + +C 0 EhC+0 +1C +C= C !+ C+0 +CEr+!C!E+C !++1 ==+!CE+E C+C!C0+ =!CCCCC!E+C +C+!! Er+ r!CCC r +C ! +E E0+1+!!!+E C!E +Ck =+! +E+0CC ! 0C ! +0+1 0+CEC+0 C+!! E +0+++
5 +CC1++R+1 ! ! =+0CC +C++E C rCC++!++CE!!=C =+ +!+r +! `0+!!p
w ~)i=v~G~iZ[0#h M\i~~N
544k455455:Q455:I54II544I:5I4Q4I5 :45I5 54i44I54Il 45 Q 5: : 4 I445 4
- wl k45I 444OQI44 5:k4I 5:5O O4:5}54Q5:t I55 I 55 455y Q4 :5465 4 45 4 I5 5}O 5
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
77/114
45Q 5::4I4454:k45I:I5i4Q5 UF:5l: 5445I5:4I4545k45I44:5[Ii44I:5455k45I Q54 iI5l4:l
:Il44 5i I54I4Q5:I 5I I5I45 :4 II5 lQ 4 i5:: :l 45 II5 iI4:l5II:k45I5I44:i5545454 : k4 5I:45I5 iI4: I}{5I4 :QO5l5 4 54 54 :4I55545I
45:IQ45}}54:545k45I l4:5 554 :II:k4IIO5i44OIIQiI4IIllOIl5:I4:I555}554Q44:k4IQi54::I 4 4 5 l :}55 I5I5 : : 54}I :k45I 45:4545 44 55 O}:545O5t
4tQ}:Q}I544Q5Oy55:54:Q54k4:OQQ 5 O O I5 4 kI5 Q5Ii Q5II l4i Ol4455: :5454544:5:4I5I
I 54 y: 55I 54 4 555Ik45:4O4I{I5: O5 5t tQ :5 [ t I5OII 5 5{5t4 O6 yI i5 tO5:II:5U. . O O4}445 : s 5 kk 54Q4
54654454I55}O55 455545 Q5I OI5O:IQ5O5:5I5} :} O44yiQ: OQ:} 4}O4IIQ55}OOO}
I5 :54I5 Q O555i5 II5544 I5O 455 :4 4Q444444l Q5: 5kQ5 4:54[I Q4Q Q5 II5I }t 45iQ5 55i5O:yQ4445I45I5l55
O
I}4Q4
:4{{#QQ:4k45I544Q}I5:5Q:54} :5 I 45 O Q O5: : 4 l 5OQ b O 4 554 4 I5}O4 i5 :5 O} b }45 5O45:O5iO
5I5Qty55IO4O5I}5QIO}4Qy54I:5:54O5O5:545}tQ5t 45}:t4I4 : QO5 5: tt O }5O5544I}5OO4iO t } 54}5I5 Q5 55: :O O }5It54I 5O :4 O :tQ tt Q5 ItO :ll 4: O }O5I4O455 55 5 I4ty
ty::Qtt:55OOQ45:45 5:5}I t 5 O5It5t4: 5: 5] t :y O5
5 y4
It5} : t5I5tt : OQ4}5}b}
* %J K LKLMN
N ) "( (N ( ) ( (|" ")(")((" ()((")(() ) ( ) (( (
))" ) ( (| L/)
g #.(.(+5)ll/ N ) L l )"N)N ) L( NL N /
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
78/114
) ) ()((((
(()(()(()|() )(()(N)"()
N" ) (L )(())|)() ()(( N" )(
"
) ( ) ( ()))N /()(/(((N)(N) ""( ) ((
))
( )(()) " /)((/ | ()))") N " )NN((=" ())/ () ) ()L)(( )())(||"N(/)"N )) (
(/) (| )) (/ /( ) L)L)N" +5 "((/)"/)""
L/L N)L"/
L(NL N / )l) (| l(N)L)(() g((Ll(L
/)|/)/ N L L tL )() ( g( /))N ()N(L /)( NL l/) /) ( ) lL /)N (( |)NL ( N )( NL N |( ( / ) ) L|N())lLN")//) /N / )(("N l ))x| P
N ) .5 ( )" L( (((|} .5 /5*/5 l() N)"( |/ )lL("L l B |)(/(L(LL(/ (lL25 L" l . & )
/
(/) 5(( ) l l L (Ll
LL/) l||.j=rDVJ=jF9lqX=/) /|+5 B LP((P ") )' LN )( )/a"(/N/))/NLN+5L l|,0'&!(.5) +$),5 "0(-5 L" 45/ll 35 ,5 L L
n uE xOx/v g 4"4 "4A444@ 4@ | 4" A4@444"uu4A uA44"u 4 A " |
uu$| 44|4 u $A|@u"AuuA}$l,A$@uAu$,AuA 4@ $ A u@
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
79/114
u4A"| 4A" 444"" 4 K$K4 uAA4@@
g""A "
u"Au4g A 4"u|u"u A 4" 4uu u"|" "4uy 4444 "A56 .=@"$u@ $ 4 # $# A4$u4y45D=A uu$A 44A4A "4 A44AuuA444A
4A|u@@ @ A @u|u |A "4, 4ux4@$@uuAA4A4
uAu " uAu"AguuA4|@u4A4Ay@u u " uA4|
Auu|u|"A
4 uu 4"A 4" @ | A4 A4 4A x Au
|4AA 4Au u u l4 " 4uuA4u
|" 4 A A"@"" |AAA4A
A4@$Au@4
u A4 ,Au@@"AuAu|A4@u
Au4"u |$ u 44 uu A4 $u #. SA4uA$$u|"A 4
"#.SAu"$l A4u$,Au@u u"4 g4 Au"4,}F j@u"@F u$$$ ,$$l
|$u ulgu"4u"$@$ , 8 @q A}u$,A l uA4 i uA}"", u
} $ $
u u" u} z u@ @ Au$ A | uuAu, uAuu$ $ l" u @ A "4u " A,u$ l u ,A$u u ,A@@$"$ |,AAuu $,A Au u Au u|"u
,uf 4A AAu
uA$Ag},A,u, |, $,A u,",u lF ,| F A l Au@
g$u$u,@$uu
u41u A"u
, o - . /FJkl0HIEG
5U5U|"5||5 "|" 5"|#5|#UU U | ||" ==55"|""||#5"|5"| | U+||# # 55 "||U |5 |"U| # 55U# 5 " # #b # " 5"U|5k +U#=5||#5"5|
)
%!() &) )#!!(
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
80/114
#|3#" #= "5U+U ="5|5 5|#3|3|"|"5"+ #|5Ub#"5 "b+ " |" 5#U 55"5 "| ) S|5S# "U U5#| Ub#+ ) #+## # # | U | +3#S |55|#+ 5 |
#!!()
\ %%WO%
+C+Csi)3$5w: ##
|5 35+ x"|# "# 5 """ .5 |5|=|"5 +35"""|5 # #U 5" S" |U"S " # 35+" # 5x""5 + =35" |#"5" " x## #" |5 # ""# 5 |5|35Sx##5"S5q+5## 5|5#+#5"|5|#S x## 35S# :
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
81/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
82/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
83/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
84/114
I ### "#
%9/%/%(//9/%"9/"9/%g@9%@9/%9/"J9/J"i / 9/ /9)/9(C%/9/% /9C///%"%///%%/
g% //i %i %%(%/ C%/ %))9( /
'*&(+ u# #$%+
C9/ 9//9(%@ /C9 >| f[ {qP w[[P{ fA[ A" /%@%6% % $ /J% %(/ 9%/9 C/ /E[ 999/( /99@/ @ % 9% ( [[ @9/i "/@9/9/ 9%/C9/@99%9 %) % / @ C% %6 /% /) C99
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
85/114
g%//i%i%%(%/C%/%))9(/ // /" 9/ 96 J9/J /9/9 /C9y C%/ 9/% C// ( %9 9
%J)9(C(%@C//)9/)9/)% /C9 C/%eI /@"@ (9/J9/ J9/J(/9/9/C9g%%X%////JC/9/%/9"/%"9
g9//@99/9C9/
/9%J%9/9y/9(%9/
J /C@99 %/9 // %%(% C/ F[ %%%/ C%/ %))9 / %) f[q[ /9(%%/C9%/@9@9/%%)/9/J%@9x%99%%/C9/9% / @%6/%9C (/9(%@/C9
% /%%/ % /X%()/9(%" C9"99B Ci9sBw"9/9%6"9/) 69%"%99///w//J%i%/)J/9(% ^`G[ /)wCC/9%/%%9""/))//%X%/yC/@%(9%%9)/9(%(/%/ 9%/ C 9 /9 )9 9% /)(/9(%@ /C9% /%% (/ %%(%" ///9C%J9/J9/J(/(%J// C/999/%(i/C %J9/"9 %J / /C 99/9 FyP /Jq[f 9%@/C9 % C/ s[Bw
i/ %J9/ J 9/J(/%JfQPz ;{ER %6C9//J ks[ /ZJBwv|@(;rQO %9/99qkN[s[w%669 9 %/99/ /f[sz|FSfkJyssAwP76[lvy%9%9%9%%k mvzJm[P > t{v >fkT[ /9 % C@9 J99
9 %) %/ @ C% %6/% /) C99@ %) 9/@ Br[OzqPk[ %6 69 9@9(%% /%|]\fRzqPk[ @ J/9 {F[Pk[vJ[ ,.$xkO /s[ % s /%9x > q[q >swaf[s[q[ %@w ;Aqk=kBw w w%i9%/%s{[[J5{|s[[[w 99 C6 > vNyr[qqRP /$C( Bw B-nwq[PaQs[v z]>fk" 4f[ C/w/ % @ 9) ]zJ[ % f[s+ F k ] k C99/J/9(/[[((%/C9CkFkqg /)/ C C/ 9i/C J( !# / Jyw]s / C 9"%%/9%(/"/
(% { /9% sB $ iC6 ]y %JJ999/|_Qv?qi[hfQJJ@9%/J/C9g%%9 qkQF[fkvOf[ /9 f; /C9%9% . qU z ; b % z[ /9 9 ; 99 ;vP 9 i/C" B /@9%"g/$C 9% % /C9 %C/99%%% F[JB[z @ f[ /C9 g% %C/% % C% % (%9/% f[[BFqkfr[v J%% /k /% 9 kw fQ kavkwc] >v ku % r[w ] 99 9[[vAk[ v; kv PV]Q?[P kv > 5fB PzIr[v 99/~CDQ018-w;v5f[ J%/kIrsk[P9 J%$ ;FkOkvdFw% i %Mo28 '( F J{R9y9 5fW JvPkkzv 9 J&[ vP[ 9 f kwr[v)[vP[kvR9KfYq[RRL[P /9%%%"@][$Jzv[zfA kfO?v fk{y3 [ [:!)& s [ f k w e ku jp X |9 JJ%@ )IC+&I ,
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
86/114
U R=6 RR RUUy U = RRA7RU64URR==R R ) U U= U =U4 R ) UR=76RU)=6UR=
@=U6RA)UR=R6U=7UA+,Z7TG,Z 6= 6@6URRURU +,Z.")QBZ RAA@
R= =@URU U = ARU URU7UUj)@R7U@=UU))R=6R==)=U=7R )= UURRR 7R7RR=6U R ==6U=)UU =6xU )=U= gR=RUU=URUR@RRRR URU==RU R6 A RR 6=6 U RU A= U
= 67U R6AU=RR= ==77=R6=UyR=)U==R=7U7 )R RUUUU U RUU)=R AR==R=R=6R7AUR=6AU=)UU=U6=RR))R A =U R=7U)U UUU/@U RURUU
gUUARUAURUUARR7 R)UR R7 7)))ARR/=R= /=U ==6= AR= R@=6 @6= RU @ =UR) RR R AUR(UAx U 6=U )UURR=RUUU)URUUAUR = = ,A A /RU U R =/@AR AA@
RA6=6=7 6RR=6 S9RJ#Z U4G,M ZR6R=R76R gA6RR6RU U66 A U 7 A@6 AR
7=7U @6UR7U D;!5M$@',Z jARUR RUR / 7 R ARU7AUA@6xRU/R /R 77 RU6 UAUR=7R/7 /7UR=,AUR6/R)UADT2MMY%@),Z NBTV,G>
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
87/114
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
88/114
)1/& ~)m=v~J~t[[-#nNem~~M
2 )225"DZ2["yV ~ 2 %"M )2[) @i%" " "%@22@%@2)[A%[)2~)22 "[2"g2[ 222[ "2
"x$6MDr 6 &p2F}K?# ;
[i)[2~22% [%[%)2%i V%"~%
@22))%@V2
2 2 i ~22%2~% 2%/%%}%%2% 2 % [ ) 2 )
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
89/114
2 ) 22%) [2"2% [@2[)2%%[g[)2[2%
)" )~ 2i2" "%)) @"2g 22%22%")2%~22g)~@2 "%@"%2 22%"%/2~2~ )"2[%22V2")")@[2%22i%)22%
/2%2[ [2 @~ ~ 2) 2~ ))2 )2 [)2 ~[22%%[%%2[2)2"[ { i~i~i)))2%2V%2%%"%))2[2[)[2%y~%))2~V"[)2[)2 22%"~[2 " @ 2" [%22y2%"~[ 2" 2% )2/ %))2"2 %2%"~2~2")2~[)2%2%"%%~2%2%"%[)2)2~~ ~ 22 2%@%~[~@[%2)[2%"%222~@"2"2@22%)%%22y y2 2%@ ~" [ 2%2%~2%"[)2 %2 ~~2F%i 1J* [[22 %" S2J* 2~2"22%~%2%" ~26~@ 2~/2 2/ ~/"~
2 V2) ~i")% ~2% [)2 2~i" 2 ~ [)~%[)/2%y 2%2%[@2g%22)2["2 [)2~/2% ~ @~2~))2)222%2[y)2/2"22" "V [@2~ V% i" 2~[)~, 2~[ ~ 2%~/ V ~ 2%"~ %~@ f 2 2~ ~2)2 ~[ [2~%))@%F2~,~/)@"2"
2~~~ 2%~ ~ ~~~)2 F a% ,2
/2@
2 22 2 % ~i2 % [ ~ i," 2"~ ~ F 2%" )2 )%g2["V)2 ~[ 2@2 " i ~[22%i" V ,~ g @ 0 )2)"~ ~i"~ / V@V i~,2%)%22"%@% 2[ )2" 2 ~ [)%,2)~ i%" ~22"@/V%2~~2%@2 [) ~~2 ,)~ % ~ %@~ 2
)[2[~,/~ ~/""~~2%@))2%/2V V~
/"[~ i )~ ~" >"~2~@ ~ V2/%"g2V/V%" 2[ ,V%)~6%@~ ~%~
@
&)
t "#! $ +C2AXX-"Xb +A2XX X
XA2X"A " 2 X-X X'X2X "XX
A A
A L "$u ''Xb 'X$'$XbX + b $''XbXXX X" ' " + + bX XX'X X" 2AX$Xb+
'
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
90/114
%)
XA2"2XAX"""+AXXb " 2
XX
" AX bXXg+" y"+++XXX2XX +XXXX "'XX2 XXX +2"+XX" +"2X"A22 XX AX2 A" ""$$"X2XA''+X+2A'+X"'" " " '+ A A XX ( "X " "
'x ( " X 2"@ " X22""gXA2AX 2+ X2A+X+"+X X$AXX +2b2 "+""
\ ,A4)E@
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
91/114
: ~,`7m~:~`ShS1% FS_~~F
v " v"
v w &&y"N""w
& v " \Nvv"v y"yv
"v &""N 8Q 8"J " 8 8Q&v8v&"Q8 &" 8"" d 8&88& "" & "8J" 8 88
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
92/114
v & &| |"" & v g|" & & | " &" v " &v v y8 &g"&&" "&" 8 v N&v vw v" v8v&v|&88v&v 8 QJv &v|" |8J 1 &v Q &vQ8v 8 &v v &v8888&v &v Qv
88v&v &8v v
"&" " & " Nv v 8 &&&&&"8 Q |g&v\ N&vv"v&"8& &"8 & 8 &8"N8N" 8
&Q &v v &"Q |&QQ " 8 v NQ " v & Q I a8&8&QQJ
Ny&& 8 Q&8" a&
J J&88 Qa
"Q8QJJNa J N8 8 8 8&8888J" J 8 J& 8 8 J v N JlN"QNQJ8QQ8J"av &Q J vN JJQv Jl Q J 8" 8 88 " 8QQfag&v"8&8 " a8J8Ng&Q88
"N
&Qv " &v 8v x
v $v Jg v" &v Q 8
& 8 J QQ N Q 8v8 &8&vv 8Q 8 lv"8g8 N" 8 Q8 &8J 8JQQQ 86J8 8lN NQ88 f Q&JJ N"Q8a888J"8Ja" Jf 8 8J
8Q &8 88& J& 88JJQvQJ 8 Q &8 8QJ Q
Q "NQ y
"8 Q &PJ&PBvw&Q& Qv"
DZ y,\4oy; ydZO/%l IjdyJ
k%" 0 0% 0ek k 0 0y0%0%0%%ee0%0%%a0a0%a%00 a%" a 0e % 0 0 0ai0e"%" 00%k%e%0%" %%e%0e%"%000ka0%k 00 0kN% 0%k % %e%
\
F ) * 4
a0"%N% 0%k a % %%%i000%"%0a L0%
\ +3%E 3+@*7E -3E1+'!=!&E.&=!+*E
%"%000%aaa0a0%0 0ai0e"%" j%ky 0 % 0e0 0k
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
93/114
000k %"0%a0%"00k0% 0a 0e0 0%0e%ka%%0"00k
ea%%ee00%%00y 0 % 0 a% % %0%" "%N% 0 k0"0y0k0ey0k000N%"0i%0%"0a%N0%aN0%0kN%"kN00i%"k0a% %%000k% %"%0%"0%00e%" 0 0a0%" 0y % ae 0%%ya 0 0%"%0%0 ka0a%N 0 % 0 0%"%0 !# aj0%"0 %""% a%%0a%N %0%l ak a% % %0%"00k 0e0%e0k0e%"%00%0%"%0%0eaek%0%0k % 0%"%0 MAX 0 k N L%""%%0y%"%Na%%0% 0% 000%a a i 000%"%00ek0e%"%0e%"%00%aa00%"ek%"0%0%a%ai%"00ai0e"%"0%kaa0%000%"%00%0%
a00ek0%0% U]s 00%0a% a0%0%k0ki0ee%ke%"00k
%0 0a0 %" 0%a000 l00%ka000aek0%00a0% %"l%00 a00a%0%%00ekONe000Na%ek0% 0%a %0 % 0 0 0 i
" " ky k0 0% a a%% %"a00%"0%"%0 000L%"kY"L00ya000ai0e"%"0%k"
e0e"0k"%N0ai0"%"L0%k0 L %a0 j %lej 0
a%e
00ai0"%"0%k0La00 % %0k0 0 0 Nk0 % % 00"0kL"k0%"00kaLL%%0e"e%"%000Lll%""0e%"%0e 0 0% k0"0e%"L%jlx0N"%N00%%k0%0%a0%l00%k
% % L0 aja%N 0 0Y"li0e"lYjj%kaLa%
0L0 0%{
%kaa%00 ja%Le0e %% je0 a%e0 %%Lk"%N%%F %jjje0 " jL 0% la%N0%a% 0 %
0 0000 k %i
a00 0%l0%L 0 0 0aa a%i%aaf%l%%i0% 0%" 0e e%%0 aLa0 %e%"ak"%N % 0 % 0 j 00 aa%" %% ka0%%aa%e kk0% lj %% %k %0%k %a 0 jejl%$k je %0L%%Ljaa0La%%"g L%% LiLj L0 aije"%" % - %i 0 %kal%0 0 k e%00%e 0%N0x %aa%0%00ek0 0N%kaj%0Lee0%0
3oEM!naa8-n Tqn
nGG=H H =";=nMooH=*n=[[[*n[MnMM[;[;;G M GH=*nHRMnMyH *g"NM"MH'HG|=HM"="*Rn*H'M
MRMoT*
GMMTn ;
n;
o = GH GH=*n*HM nM 'H |"=NnMM MH|HnMGGoGH**H=M M MN = |" 'H H=
H *oH;M H' 6E%?E9j M "
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
94/114
GH**H=MMMNy=|"'HH=H**H'M'GGo"nH'*==="=H' ;G|HHH' H =H M nG * GH=* H'H2*H;H'Gn="HM=
N=*HGHoMG=HHn;** H2H'N" 'H2 y HH2'*"H=H'oHMGM;M"*[[ *N""N;gM**MoHG"N"'"=;GH;HH*T*$MN"*['GG[oG=*g;=H;M|" M M * MM ' N",'"=H'o[M*GMH;M"g[MM"***H2'N"M|M"MH'="ooHTM [* ' * ;oHo='
HMo=[=*MM'*=* "NMN*HoM
* M M M"M g ; o;M ?Ej""['HoMMH;M"H==HMTH';$ 'M MHM H; ']:'R'j
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
95/114
H2H'HYoHYM2;Yo2oHYHYoMH2H2o2HY
XHh-(-h;(e@0O
g,2Y$H'HYMH2"H ;| MH" H2gHoMYYb2YHH'Y2'H2M;MH==HH;YH';'H2M2 ="KK2'K2H'ooHH2HH=2;TMMH2H'=oH2;bMYwH2M YoMYH2H'|Y2Y;"2HH'oHMYMH;MY"YH=YMHMH" 01>g2" Y o 'H22 ' =2 = o2M2oHMYYM HY H o2b M" ;H 'H2 Yo2HoH;MY"YHHHwH22oH2M
oY2H'MH'w"HY;2";2|; ;MbY"Y = oMYMo2H H H; M 22 'H2 o2b M" H' YY
M2Mb2HH'YHG2YooMH=H2Yo; 2MH= ooM'H2;2oH'wHooM'H2;2oH'bHM2HYH Y"
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
96/114
X[ )4& )X4X X U`/ [[i [ @UU &XX[4XU&EU4E[UX@4[B
)4&@4[U44U[4 4&f X U [& &i RX&RXU[4E4&XU4[ [4 4EUU 4X[Xf X&U[4E[[XUUX 44[44UU[[i UE@4UXU[4&B4U4 4[4 [4 U4U [[ X[&X@E[[4[EU[UXB@4&E4&
&9@9f/)[XX[4X[4 @&[4[fU[U4&9EE[f iE[@UE XfX ) 44[[4EX [XU & f[)4X@4[BE4[E)
& U 94U[[X4U& @ &X4X X [4UE@ B U4UB44E U @ @ [@4E 4f[[9 [ [)4U[4UU&i4EUEU4U[X 4 E U [ XB U @9[& [[ f/ X U 4@ 4EXUfUU[4X@9&Ef 4[)[Ef[UX[&f&[4 9BE[ 4 f &[9E 8+?UXB@&4[&f[/9 f[ 4BE[Xf 4@f f [@94f4X@ [) w & fff
4&[C[44C:4R: R h:n~Oxn@h[TwG:4Xi w$ [f @4[ [) $P944X/9X@E&)914|
0!EM/HRS
)
)$)
)&4/ IE Iyj=NA2)d(U1Nj E9& [9@&9 9Bf yFy ) n 9+U E4&$fX.aS; HUy` ' oyUv Dy
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
97/114
L 1 1C 1B (B((,11B(1 (B!.6'!( . ' L11B! b .(.1!!($
1 .61$.b11!wB(1B (1b.(!.b1B!$(('(1(16!111!!1xC(!1 1B(1. ! 1b61!C1$!!.(.(B,'(('(B(B1161B(.L..6(..(1'1b6B!'.6,1'1B(1gB1'1(.((11 ,..B1 CL 1b6B ! .(L..6L,x.Cw1'(1
!(Cbx1 g$,L1B 'C! .B( .1`,L! $1L11B$1L..'1'1((.x!.$.1$B
!L1B1.!b!B.C,1.' 1 C 11 g ( 1 1 11B 11(.6(..BB 1 B 1(.. B.!11111(C'..C1! ''('!$!!(.111(1
g$ $( 1 1B! 1' 1 B1 j((B ' !1'.. '1'1lg 'Clg $1 lL..lN 11 B.C. , !1J''$(L!l,l$
6CBB..6.C
(.1$ ,l j$1 '. '. .L1B'$1((B'!1'!.. 6L
!1(x! 1(.. !1' .6L.
.6 wL$6(B1LB.
B!1'..Cw 1B.g.!$'$l' $ 1$1$!.LB(!
1` 7,1
16BCzjBL!!$.$L$.,6!
;$ r
W
>
'(.L($,
X@
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
98/114
/ /G$$/$G /(k O $ $ $$G /7b
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
99/114
b((1)`1 `` B1 ) 1B b ` 1b1 ``b"`
`I11`(1I111)`B`) "&C``(11B1`"B("bY 1(11(C``(`1``(i `B"`((i1`(B11 i B((1(y ((B1 "`C` ` 1(B11 ``1B11,1(BB"`1Cbx`1i1`,`1((((1C``11`1)BB1`1)(1,( ` C(11`i `1 111( 1( " C` `1
1`
( 1B( `(C`
C`B`1C(1
(i(`i1)`1()(11()1"1``1`11((`)(BC``((`y51C`b11`11(1 `b"b1 CC ` (1 ( `1)(B C `$bC` )("P&+" ` C11 `` i$j`b (1 x"C` (1(`1bx`5i`b(1 Y 1C1`I1(B1 I1 ` I`(1i11z>C``B1) C``b$(``,(,()( 1`11`` 1`jCb$ `( 1 "1 `b"
(("b1`z B1`
CC
11 `I1 (1,
; )6 AA" $?;%!,//FI*9C$
-
7/30/2019 1 Problems of Political Philosophy D D Raphael Copy
100/114
4c4c }cU