![Page 1: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
National Risk Assessment 2019Overview of Strategic Risks
Prepared by the Department of the Taoiseachgov.ie
![Page 2: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
![Page 3: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
National Risk Assessment 2019Overview of Strategic Risks
gov.ie
![Page 4: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Foreword
1. Introduction 2019 1.1. OverviewoftheNationalRiskAssessmentProcess1.2. TableofRisks20191.3. OverviewofStrategicRisks
2. Geopolitical Risks 2.1. DepartureoftheUKfromtheEU 2.2. InstabilityinNorthernIreland2.3. FuturedirectionandstabilityoftheEU2.4. Changingdistributionofglobalinfluenceandmoveawayfromarules-basedsystem2.5. Terroristincidentsandarmedconflicts
3. Economic Risks 3.0. Introduction 3.1. EconomicImpactofBrexit3.2. RiskofOverheating3.3. PublicExpenditurePressures3.4. GlobalSlowdown,includingchangestointernationaltradingenvironment3.5. Internationaltaxchanges3.6. Relianceonmultinationalcorporationsandsectoralconcentration
4. Social Risks 4.1. CapacityofHigherandFurtherEducationSystem4.2. SkilledLabourShortages4.3. AnAgeingPopulationincludingpensionsandhealthsystemchallenges4.4. ImpactofSocialMediaonPublicDebate4.5. SocialcohesionincludingPerceptionsofRuralandRegionalImbalances4.6. Migrationandintegration
8
9
11
12
17
18
20
23
24
24
26
27
27
29
30
31
33
34
6
37
38
39
40
42
44
46
![Page 5: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
5. Environmental Risks
5.1. ClimateChange&Biodiversity5.2. Ensuringanaffordable,sustainableanddiverseenergysupply5.3. DeliveryofPublicInfrastructure5.4. Foodsafety5.5. SupplyandAffordabilityofHousing
6. Technological Risks 6.1. CyberSecurity6.2. Disruptivetechnologytrends6.3. Anti-MicrobialResistance6.4. MajorPandemics6.5. Nuclearcontamination
Annex1 GovernmentTaskForceonEmergencyPlanning– NationalRiskAssessmentforIreland2017Annex2 Ireland’sChangingDemographicsandrelatedrisksAnnex3 SnapshotofresultsfrompublicconsultationAnnex4 NationalRiskAssessmentPublicConsultation– groups/individualsthatmadeasubmissionAnnex5 NationalRiskAssessmentPublicConsultation– riskshighlightedbyrespondents
50
51
52
53
55
56
58
59
61
63
64
64
66
67
78
79
80
![Page 6: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Foreword
ThegreatAmericanpoet,MayaAngeloubelievedthatweshouldalwaysbe‘hopingforthebest,preparedfortheworst,andunsurprisedbyanythinginbetween’.TheNationalRiskAssessmentservesavitalfunctioninhelpingustodoexactlythat.
Asweknow,theeconomycontinuestoperformwell,butwearenotcomplacentortakingthatforgranted.Thenexttwelvemonthswillseeusfacechallengesofsignificantscaleandimpact,includingthoseemergingfromBrexitandClimateChange.Internationally,weseecontinuedtradetensionsandtheemergenceofaglobaleconomicslowdown.Domestically,wewanttocontinuetoensureourpublicfinancesarerobustandsustainable,sowecanrespondtotherisksidentifiedhere.Thescaleandpotentialimpactoftheserisksunderlineshowimportantitisthatweareawareofeverypossibleproblem,andtheNationalRiskAssessment:OverviewofStrategicRisksenablesustofacetheserisksheadon.
TheNationalRiskAssessmentensuresthatallvoicesareheardacrossthenation.Inthiswayweavoidrepeatingthemistakesofthepast,bytakingintoconsiderationtheconcernsandviewsofbusinesses,academicsandresearchers,civilsocietygroups,andmembersofthepublic,aswellasthepublicsector.Theultimategoalistoavoid“groupthink”whenitcomestorecognisinganddiscussingrisksatanearlystage.
Thisyear,Iamdelightedtoseeover650submissionsthroughthepublicconsultation,asubstantialincreaseonthenumberreceivedlastyear,andastrongendorsementofthevalueoftheNationalRiskAssessment.Inparticular,itwasnoteworthythatClimateChange&Biodiversityemergedasthemostimportantpriorityforrespondents.
AswepublishtheReportforthesixthyear,itisimportanttonotehowtherisksidentifiedhavedevelopedandevolved.Thereisaconstantlychangingriskbackdrop.Forexample,thisyearwehaveincludeda‘CapacityinHigherandFurtherEducationSystem’risk,aswellasdiscussingtherisksaroundperceivedruralandregionalimbalances.
Someriskshaveincreasedinsignificancesincelastyear’sreportincludingtheBrexitrisksinboththeGeopoliticalandEconomiccategories,‘ClimateChange&Biodiversity’and‘CyberSecurity’.Theserisksareongoingandevolving,andthechangesherereflectthis.Alloftherisksidentifiedaremonitoredtoensurewecanrespondeffectivelytoeverychallengethatarises.
![Page 7: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
The2019NationalRiskAssessmentprovidesanimportantcontextforDepartmentsandAgenciestodevelopthenecessarymitigatingactions,asappropriate.So,itisrightthatwepromotediscussionandawarenessofthemostimportantstrategicrisksfacingIreland.Continuingtobevigilantoftherisksfacingourcountrywillhelpustomakebetter-informeddecisionsonhowtoprepareforthem.
Leo Varadkar Taoiseach
July 2019
![Page 8: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
1. Introduction 2019
![Page 9: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
9
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
1.1. Overview of the National Risk Assessment Process 1.2. List of Risks 2019 1.3. Overview of Strategic Risks
1.1. Overview of the National Risk Assessment Process
TheNationalRiskAssessment(NRA)pro-videsanopportunityfortheidentification,discussionandconsiderationofrisksfacingIrelandovertheshort,mediumandlongterm.SincetheNRAwasfirstpublishedin2014,theannualReporthasservedasanimportantindicatorofnational-levelrisks,andhascalledattentiontovariousrisksthatsubsequentlybecamemajorissuesforIrishsociety,includingBrexit,andrisksaroundhousingsupply,andcybersecurity.
TheNationalRiskAssessmentplaysanimportantpartintheearlyidentificationofpotentiallysignificantrisksthatIrelandmayface.Itisvitaltolearnfromthemistakesofthepast,andthisexercisewasintroducedtoensurethatwe,asaGovernmentandasawidersociety,encourageandparticipateinthesenecessaryhorizon-scanningdiscus-sionstoensurethatweidentifyrisksearlyandcanrobustlyprepareforthem.Whilenotintendedtoreplicateordisplacethedetailedriskmanagementthatisalreadyconductedwithingovernmentdepartmentsandagencies,theNationalRiskAssessmentdoesaimtoprovideasystematicoverviewofstrategicrisksthatcanformanimport-ant,andinclusivepartoftheoverallprocessofriskmanagement.
DetailedriskmanagementbeingconductedseparatelytotheNationalRiskAssess-mentprocessincludestheworkoftheDepartmentofFinanceandtheCentral
Intro
ducti
on 2
019
BankofIrelandwithrespecttofinancialandmacro-prudentialrisks;andtheworkoftheGovernmentTaskForce(GTF)onEmergencyPlanning,supportedbytheOfficeofEmergencyPlanning(OEP),whoproduceaNationalRiskAssessmentforIrelandcentredonrisksrelatingtopotentialcivilemergenciesatnationallevelwhichisconductedinthecontextoftheStrategicEmergencyManagementNationalStruc-turesandFrameworkapprovedbyGov-ernmentin2017andIreland’sreportingcommitmentsundertheEUCivilProtectionMechanism.Inaddition,aNationalSecurityAnalysisCentre(NSAC)isbeingestablishedbytheGovernmentaspartoftheimple-mentationofthereportoftheCommissionontheFutureofPolicinginIreland.TheNSACwillbringthevariousagenciesrele-vanttonationalsecuritytogethertopoolexpertiseandinformation,soastoproduceacomprehensivepictureofthethreatstotheStateanddevelopanintegratednation-alsecuritystrategy.
TheDepartmentsandagenciesinvolvedintheseriskmanagementexercisesalsofeedintothisNationalRiskAssessmentprocess,therebyensuringcoherenceandalignmentwithotherelementsoftheoverallriskman-agementapproach.
Separately,andinaccordancewithacom-mitmentmadebyGovernment,anUpdateoftheWhitePaperonDefence(2015)iscurrentlybeingfinalisedbytheDepartmentofDefence.Animportantstrandofthisisafullyupdatedassessmentofthesecurity
![Page 10: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
10
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Inthatcontext,thedraftNationalRiskAssessment2019waspublishedforpub-licconsultationinMayandlaidbeforetheHousesoftheOireachtas.Over650sub-missionswerereceivedaspartofthiscon-sultation,andtheseareoutlinedatAnnexes3and4.
Inparallelwiththisconsultation,workalsocontinuedwithingovernmentdepartmentstofurtherstrengthenthequalityofIreland’sriskgovernancemechanismsandtoensurethatappropriatemitigationframeworksareinplace.Asoutlinedabove,thisincludestheworkoftheGovernmentTaskForceonEmergencyPlanning,supportedbytheOfficeofEmergencyPlanning,theworkoftheDepartmentofFinanceandtheCentralBankofIrelandwithrespecttofinancialandmacro-prudentialrisks,thenewNSAC,andtheSteeringGrouprepresentinggov-ernmentdepartmentsandagencies,whichoverseespreparationoftheNRA.
ThefinallistofstrategicrisksforIrelandin2019isincludedonthefollowingpage.Therisksaregroupedacrossgeopolitical,economic,social,environmentalandtech-nologicalcategories,inlinewiththeWorldEconomicForum’sannual‘GlobalRisksReport’1.ThisNationalRiskAssessment2019,therefore,istheresultofextensiveconsultationandengagement,includingasignificantpublicconsultationelementwithover650responses,anditsetsoutabroadviewofthehigh-levelstrategicrisksfacingthecountrytoday.
1WorldEconomicForum,GlobalRisksReport2019availableat:https://www.weforum.org/reports/the-global-risks-report-2019
environmentcarriedoutbyaninter-depart-mental/inter-agencygroup.WhenapprovedbyGovernment,theupdatewillincludeanoutlineofdevelopmentsinimportantas-pectsofthesecurityenvironmentsincethepublicationoftheWhitePaperonDefencein2015.
TheDepartmentsandagenciesinvolvedintheseriskmanagementexercisesalsofeedintothisNationalRiskAssessmentprocess,therebyensuringcoherenceandalignmentwithotherelementsoftheoverallriskman-agementapproach.
AbroadanddiverserangeofcontributionstotheNationalRiskAssessmentareencour-agedthroughseverallayersofdebateandengagement,toensureweavoidthepos-sibilityof‘groupthink’.AttheinitialstageoftheNationalRiskAssessmentprocess,aSteeringGroup,chairedbytheDepartmentoftheTaoiseachandcomprisingrepresenta-tivesfromallGovernmentDepartmentsandagencies,workedtogethertodrawupaninitialdraftlistofrisks,asinpreviousyears.
Asmentionedabove,oneoftheoriginalimpetusesbehindtheNationalRiskAssess-mentprocesswastoavoidthepossibilityof‘groupthink’whenidentifyingstrategicriskstothecountry.Tothisend,eachiterationoftheNRAhasinvolvedanopenpublicconsultationtogaugewhetherthereareanysignificantrisksthathavebeenoverlookedorunderplayed,andtoensureinclusiveengagementfromallcornersofsociety.Forthisexercisetoberobust,comprehensiveandinclusive,itisimportantthatallvoices–includingdiscordantorminorityones–areheard.Amorerigorousandwide-rangingdebatewillbolsterourabilitytoidentifyandquantifytheriskswefaceandourabilitytomaketherightchoicesforthefuture.
Intro
ducti
on 2
019
![Page 11: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 20191.2. List of Risks 2019
![Page 12: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
1.3. Overview of Strategic Risks
WhilemanyoftheStrategicRisksdiscussedinthe2018NationalRiskAssessmentcon-tinuetoberelevantfor2019,thecontextandpressuresaroundseveralofthemhaveshiftedandevolvedintheinterimperiod.
Forexample,wehaveseentheuncertain-tiesaroundtheformBrexitwilltakepersistandindeedincreaseoverrecentmonths,bringingwithitastrongerfocusonthepotentialriskofano-dealBrexitandtheimpactsuchanoutcomecouldhaveontheIrisheconomyandonstabilityinNorthernIreland,aswellaswiderimplicationsacrosstheentireriskspectrum.PotentialrisksfortheopenIrisheconomyarisingfromacon-tinuedincreaseintradetensionsevidentattheinternationallevel,andexacerbatedbytheemergenceofaglobaleconomicslow-down,alsocontinuetobeareasofconcernforus,warrantingclosediscussionandawareness.Domestically,emergingspend-ingpressuresmustbecloselymonitoredandcontrolled,toensurethatourpublicfinancescontinuetobesustainableandstable,andtoensurewecanrespondtothechallengesarisingfromtheserisks.
Inaddition,severaloftheriskshaveevolvedinnewdirections,includingthosearoundthecapacityoftheHigherandFurtherEducationsystem,identifiedasastrate-gicsocialriskthisyear.Whilerisksaroundhumancapitalandskillsneedsforagrowingeconomywerediscussedlastyear,andinpreviousyears,andaredealtwiththisyearundera‘SkilledLabourShortages’risk,anadditionalriskfor2019focusesaroundtheimportantroletheHEandFETsectorsplayintheIrisheconomy,andtheimportanceofensuringadequatelevelsoffundingfortheHEsectoraremaintained,andthatanappropriate,sustainablemodeloffundingisinplace,especiallyinlightofdemographic
challengesandtheincreasingdemandforthirdlevelplacesoverthecomingyearsthatisnowforecast.
Anotherstrategicsocialriskthathasemergedthisyearrevolvesaroundriskstosocialcohesionandinparticularrisksaroundperceivedimbalancesinaregionalandruralcontext,versusurbanareasandcities.InlinewithsimilartrendsinothercountriesinbothEuropeandtheUS,therearesignificantperceptionsofafocusonjobcreationandinfrastructureinvestmentconcentratedincities,andtothedetrimentofruralcommunities.
OtherongoingriskssuchasinternationaltaxchangesandtheIrisheconomy’sreli-anceonmultinationalcorporations’inaneconomiccontext,thesocialrisksassoci-atedwithourchangingdemographicsandageingpopulation,environmentalriskssuchassupplyandaffordabilityofhousingandovercominginfrastructuregaps,andongo-ingandevolvingcybersecurityrisksarestillrelevant,andarediscussedthroughouttheReport.
Forsomeongoingrisks,whiletheymaynotbenewrisksidentifiedforthefirsttimethisyear,greaterpublicawarenessandanincreasedsenseofurgencyandresponsive-nesstotheriskscanbefelt,forexample,inthecaseofbothClimateChangerisks,whereanincreaseddemandforactioncanbefeltfromthepublicandthepoliticalsys-tem,andinthecaseoftheimpactofsocialmediaonpublicdebate,withboththepolit-icalandpolicysystemandindustryrampingupactioninthisarea.
Asalways,andasevidentthroughtheabovediscussions,theinter-connectionsbetweentheserisksareeverapparentandmustbetotheforefrontinanydiscussionofindividualrisks.WeknowthatBrexit,
Intro
ducti
on 2
019
![Page 13: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
13
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
regardlessoftheformittakes,willimpactnegativelyontheIrisheconomy,whichinturnwillhaveimplicationsbothforotherpotentialrisksfortheeconomyincludingtheriskofoverheatingandlossofcompet-itivenessontheonehand,aswellasim-pactingonsocialrisksidentified,includingexpectationsforpublicexpenditure,andrisksandissuesaroundmigrationandinte-gration,tonamebuttwo.Indeed,Brexitcanbeseenasanoverarching,umbrellarisk,interactingwithandamplifyingthemajorityoftherisksidentifiedacrossthegeopolit-ical,economic,social,environmentalandtechnologicalspheres.
Similarly,inter-connectionsandknock-onimplicationscanbeseenbetweenunderin-vestmentinHigherEducation,theimpactofdisruptivetechnologytendsonjobsandtheeconomy,andperceptionsofregionalandruralimbalances.Andofcourse,weknowthatnuclearcontaminationcouldhaveseri-ousimplicationsforfoodsafetyandanimaldisease,thatchallengesarisingfrombio-diversityriskshaveeconomicandsectoralimpactsaswellasenvironmentalimpacts,andthatrisksaroundsupplyandaffordabili-tyofhousinghavebothsocialandeconomicaspects,aswellasenvironmental.
WhilewecategorisetherisksinthisReportonthebasisofthemodelusedbytheWorldEconomicForum(geopolitical,economic,social,environmentalandtechnological),forthepurposesofbothorganisationandeaseofconsideration,manyoftheriskscross-cutseveralcategories,andtheRisksandReportshouldbereadandconsideredwiththatinmind.
Inaddition,thisyearweareincludingathematicpiece(atAnnex2),whichtakesamoredetailedlookatoneofourSocialrisks,‘AnAgeingPopulationincludingpensionsandhealthsystemchallenges’.Itdetailsthe
changingstructureandprojectedfuturetrendsinIreland’spopulation,againstaninternationalbackdrop.WhileitisclearthatIreland’spopulationisageing,inlinewithtrendsinothercountries,thisworksetsouttheimpactsthiswillhaveacrossarangeofsectors,andhighlightstheimportanceofappropriatepolicyresponses.Theseinclude,forexample,increasingtheStatePensionAge,increasingparticipationratesofolderpeopleintheworkforce,increasingsavingsforprivatepensionprovision,deliveringonreformsforthehealthsystem,andconsider-ationofpoliciesthatwouldstemthefurtherdeclineinfertilityandbirthrates.
Geopolitical RisksAsasmallopeneconomy,weknowthatIrelandisparticularlyvulnerabletogeopolit-icalrisks.Whilethetop5strategicgeopo-liticalrisksidentifiedforthe2019NationalRiskAssessmentmirrorthosediscussedin2018,itisclearthatineachcasetheriskshaveevolvedand,insomecases,increasedsignificantly.
Asmentionedabove,therisksaroundBrex-ithavecontinuedtointensifyinthemonthssincethe2018Reportwaspublished,withbothuncertaintyandthepossibilityofano-dealBrexitpersistingthroughoutthenegotiationstodate.AlliedtothisarepotentialimpactsandriskstothestabilityofNorthernIreland,andtotheGoodFridayAgreement.These,andotherriskscontinuetoberelevantinthecontextofriskstothestabilityandfuturedirectionoftheEU,asitlookstothestartofanewlegislativecyclein2019withbothEuropeanParliamentelectionsinMayandanewEuropeanCom-missionlaterintheyear.
OutsideofEurope,thelasttwelvemonthshavealsoseenanincreaseingeopoliticaltensionsataregionalandgloballevel,aswellasthecontinuedwithdrawaloftheUS
Intro
ducti
on 2
019
![Page 14: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
14
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
comingyears,andinthecontextofongoingdifficultiesaroundinfrastructureconstraintsandhousing,wecouldseeriskstoourcompetitivenessandoverheatingpressuresemerge.
Inaddition,publicexpectationsofaddition-alexpenditureareanincreasingconcern,especiallyatthispointintheeconomiccy-cle,andinthecontextofsignificantdomes-ticandexternalrisks,andtheimportanceofmaintainingappropriatecontrolonexpendi-tureisdiscussedinSection3.3.
Thereareindicationsthatescalatingtradeconflictsattheinternationallevelnowap-peartobeimpactinggrowth,withtheIMFwarningnationalgovernmentstoprepareforan‘economicstorm’asglobalgrowthlevelsundershootexpectations.AsasmallopeneconomyIrelandishighlyexposedtosuchfluctuationsinglobaleconomicandtradingconditions,andtheeconomicrisksinthiscontextforIrelandaresignificant.
Workoninternationaltaxreformcontin-ues,andcontinuestobehighlyrelevantforIreland,particularlyinthecontextoftheim-portanceofIreland’scompetitivecorporatetaxofferingwhichisanimportantpartofourwidercompetitivenessoffering,andtheemergenceofchallengestoourcorporatetaxregime.Relatedtothis,andasdiscussedinpreviousyears,oureconomyandemploy-mentareheavilyinfluencedbyarelativelysmallnumberofmultinationalcorporations,concentratedinafewenterprisesectors.While,ontheonehand,thismultinationalinvestmenthasbeentransformativefortheIrisheconomy,italsocreatesavulnerabilitytochangesinIreland’sattractivenessasalocationforthosecompanies,aswellastosector-specificchangesorrisks,andthesearediscussedinSection3.6oftheReport.
fromthefreetrademodelandincreasinglystrainedrelationswithRussia,withassociat-edrisksofreducedglobaleconomicgrowth,andincreasedinstabilitiesintheglobaleconomy,andfortheIrisheconomy.Risksarisingfrompotentialterroristincidentsandarmedconflictsendure,withsignificantpublicsafetyandsecurityimpacts,aswellaslonger-termreputationaldamage,shouldsuchanattackhappenhere.
Inthisincreasinglytensegeopoliticalland-scape,andwithsuchhighstakes,wemustensurethatweareaspreparedaspossibleforhowtheserisks–bothnearandfar-mightimpactonIrelandeconomicallyandsocially,aswellasinthecontextofpeaceandsecurity.
Economic RisksWhileIreland’seconomycontinuestoperformstrongly,itsgrowthisagainstabackdropofcontinuinghighindebtedness(bothpublicandprivate)whichimpactsonourscopetobuildmeaningfulfiscalbuffersinthecomingyears,againstabackdropofBrexit,theshapeandimpactofwhichisstillunclear,andinthecontextofemergingspendingpressureswhichriskdestabilisingthepublicfinancesifnottightlycontrolled.
WeknowthatanyformofBrexitwouldhavenegativeimpactsfortheIrishecon-omy,buttheimpactsofano-dealBrexitwouldbeparticularlyharsh,andtheserisksaresetoutinSection3.2oftheReport,withaparticularfocusonthemostvulnera-blesectorsoftheeconomyinthisregard.
NotwithstandingthepossibleeffectsofBrexit,therisksofoverheatingintheecon-omy,andrelatedlossofcompetitivenesscontinuetoberelevantfor2019.Asthelabourmarketcontinuestotightenandtheeconomypotentiallyreachesandexceedsitssustainablelevelofproductioninthe
Intro
ducti
on 2
019
![Page 15: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
15
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
discussedinpreviousyears,greaterpub-licawarenessandanincreasedsenseofurgencyanddemandforactiononrelatedrisksareapparentthisyear.ResearchfindsthatEarthiscurrentlylosingbiodiversityatarateseenonlyduringmassextinctions.Inaddition,Irishbiodiversityishighlyvulner-abletotheimpactsofclimatechangeandhasalowadaptivecapacitycomparedtoothervulnerablesectors.
Intermsofclimatechangemitigation,weknowthatthecostofinactionexceedsthecostofaction,andthatthisdifferentialwillrisesteeplywithtime.PotentialcoststotheexchequerincludethoseassociatedwithnotachievingcompliancewithourEUGHGemissionsandrenewableenergytargetsto2020and2030.Itwillalsobecriticalbothtopricethecostofcarbonintooureco-nomicmodeltoprovideappropriatelong-termsignals,andtodefineourapproachtocarbonneutralityfortheagriculturesectorinawaythatallowsfortheachievementofourclimatetargetsanddecarbonisationgoalswhilerespectingsustainablefoodsecurity.
Intermsofenergy-relatedrisks,disruptionstothesupplyorpriceofoil,gas,orelectric-itycouldhavesignificanteconomic,socialorcompetitiveimpacts,andourgeographicpositionrendersusparticularlyvulnerabletosuchdisruptions.Brexitposesaparticu-larriskasIrelandimportsthevastmajorityofitsenergyrequirements,oil,gasandtransportfuels,fromorviatheUK.Thispro-videsanaddedimpetustoincreasetheuseofourrenewableresourcesandtodiversifyoursourcesofsupplybydevelopingfurtherelectricityinterconnectiontoneighbouringmarketsincludingFrance.Asweelectrifyvitalservices,newassociatedrisksarounddevelopmentcosts,andsocietalprovisionsandacceptancefornecessaryinfrastructuredevelopmentwillemerge.
Social RisksAsmentionedabove,someoftherisksidentifiedinthesocialcategoryhavetakenaslightlynewdirectioninthisyear’sRe-port,includingrisksaroundthecapacityoftheHigherandFurtherEducationsystemandthepotentialimpactsonoureconomy,discussedinSection4.1andrisksaroundagrowingpublicdiscourseonruralandregionalimbalancesinthecontextofsocialcohesionastheeconomicrecoverycontin-ues,whicharediscussedinSection4.4.
Aspreviouslymentioned,whiletherisksarisingfromtheimpactofsocialmediaonpublicdebatewereincludedinthe2018Report,increasingpublicawarenessandagreatersenseofresponsivenessonallfrontsisapparent,withboththepoliticalandpol-icysystemandindustryrampingupactioninthisarea.Withlargenumbersofcitizensnowobtainingtheirnewsfromsocialmediaplatforms,thereareclearimplicationsforthegeneration,rapiddissemination,andimpactofonlinedisinformation.Large-scaledisinformationor‘fakenews’campaignsspreadonlineareahigh-riskissueforsoci-etyglobally,includingIreland,andinpartic-ularwheretheytargettheelectoralprocess,andelectoraloutcomes.DevelopmentsinthisareaareoutlinedinSection4.3.
Thischapteralsooutlinestherisksemerg-ingfromdemographicissues,andinpartic-ularpensionandhealthsystemdifficultiesinthecontextofourageingpopulation,aswellasexpectationsforpublicexpenditureandassociatedrisks,andtherisksinvolvedifwefailtomaintainourpositivetrackre-cordintermsofmigrationandintegration,madeallthemorepertinentinthecontextofBrexit.
Environmental RisksAsmentionedabove,whiletherisksaroundClimateChangeandBiodiversityhavebeen
Intro
ducti
on 2
019
![Page 16: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
16
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Relatedtothis,widerrisksaroundourcapacitytoovercomeinfrastructuregaps,inthecontextofchallengesindeliveringasignificantincreaseincapitalinvestmentun-derProjectIreland2040,arestillrelevant,particularlywhencoupledwithanongoingundersupplyofhousingandassociatedaf-fordabilityissues,atighteninglabourmarketandcontinuedstrongeconomicgrowth(asdiscussedinthecontextofoverheatingrisks).
Risksaroundfoodsafetycontinuetoberelevant,asinpreviousyears,withsignifi-canthealth,trade,andreputationalimplica-tionsshouldafoodscareorincidentoccur,andarediscussedinSection5.4.Again,inter-linkagesbetweenrisksarepertinenthere,withtheagri-foodsectoroneofthesectorsparticularlyexposedtoBrexit.
Finally,thesupplyandaffordabilityofhous-ingpersistsasasignificantriskinthisyear’sNationalRiskAssessment,witheconomicandsocial,aswellasenvironmentalim-plications.WhileCSOstatisticsfor2018showthatsupplyisincreasing,difficultiesaroundhomelessnessandaffordabilityarepersisting,andoverallhousingdemandisalsoincreasing.Inthecomingyears,housingshortagesarelikelytoactasaconstraintoneconomicactivityandcompetitiveness,andreflectoneofthemostprominentrisksfacingthecountry.
Technological RisksIntermsoftechnologicalrisks,risksaroundcybersecurity,includingpotentialdisruptiontocriticalinformationinfrastructure,anddatafraudandtheft,continuetobeperti-nentandcontinuetoevolveastheextenttowhichsocietyreliesondigitaltechnologyincreases.WithIrelandpositioningitselfasatechnologicalsociety,withagrowingdependenceononlineservices,theimpactofanattackorincidentontheprovisionof
Intro
ducti
on 2
019
services,andonthereputationofbusiness-esandpublicservicewouldbesignificant.
Disruptivetechnologytrendslikewisecon-tinuetoadvance,andtheseadvancesbringrelatedrisksastheypredictsignificantjobsshiftsanddisruption.Automationisexpect-edtoreplacesomejobs,re-shapeothers,andalsocreatenewones.Inaregionalcon-text,researchalsohighlightedthegreaterrisksforregionsfromautomationandjobloss.Therisks,therefore,ifoureducationandskillssystemdon’trespondappropriate-lyandintime,aresubstantial.
Asinpreviousyears,risksaroundAnti-Mi-crobialResistanceandMajorPandemics,andNuclearContaminationarerelevant.Anti-MicrobialResistanceisanincreasingconcernglobally,withtheextensiveuse,misuse,andoveruseofantimicrobialsinhu-manhealthraisinglevelsofresistanceinawiderangeofpathogensinallcountriesandinpatientsofallagegroups.Intheanimalpopulation,therateofdevelopmentandspreadofantimicrobialresistancehasalsoincreased.Inaddition,therisksarisingfromapotentialMajorPandemichaverelevanceacrossseveralriskcategories,includingfinancial,geopolitical,social,environmental,andtechnological.Intermsofnuclearcon-tamination,whiletheprobabilityforIrelandislow,theobviousriskstopublichealthandwell-being,aswellasnegativeeconomicimpactsareclear,andbothawarenessandplanningisimportantinthisregard.
![Page 17: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
2. Geopolitical Risks
![Page 18: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
18
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
2.1. Departure of the UK from the EU 2.2. Instability in Northern Ireland 2.3. Future direction and stability of the EU 2.4. Changing distribution of global influence and move away from a rules-based system 2.5 Terrorist incidents and armed conflicts
Geo
politi
cal R
isks
2.1. Departure of the UK from the EU
ThedecisionoftheUKtoleavetheEUpresentsuniquelysignificantandunprec-edentedpolitical,economic,socialanddiplomaticchallengesforIreland,giventheextentoftheinter-connectednessofoureconomiesandpeople.ThesearechallengesbothtoIreland’speaceandprosperity,andhowtheyaredealtwithinthemonthsandyearsaheadmayhavesignificantimpactsforIrelandintothefuture.
Ireland’sprioritieshaveremainedconsistentthroughouttheprocess:minimisingtheimpactonIreland’stradeandeconomy;pro-tectingthePeaceProcessandtheGoodFri-dayAgreementinallitsparts;maintainingtheCommonTravelAreawiththeUK;andsecuringIreland’sfutureinastrongEU.Asaresultofintensiveandsustainedengage-mentattheEUlevel,Ireland’suniqueissuesandconcernshavebeenfullyunderstoodbytheEU27andhavebeentotheforeoftheEU’snegotiatingapproach.
FollowingtwoyearsofintensiveArticle50negotiationsbetweentheEuropeanUnionandtheUnitedKingdom,theEuropeanCouncilendorsedtheWithdrawalAgree-mentandthePoliticalDeclarationonthefuturerelationshipinNovember2018.TheWithdrawalAgreementwassubsequentlypassedtotheEuropeanParliamentandis
awaitingitsconsent.TheBritishGovern-menthasalsoagreedtoboththeWith-drawalAgreementandthePoliticalDeclara-tion.However,theWithdrawalAgreementisstillsubjecttoratificationbytheUKParliament.
TheWithdrawalAgreementestablishesthetermsoftheUK’sdeparturefromtheEU.ItensuresthatthewithdrawalwillhappeninanorderlymannerandofferslegalcertaintyoncetheTreatiesandEUlawceasetoapplytotheUK.TheWithdrawalAgreementcoversallelementsoftheUK’swithdrawalfromtheEUincludingcitizens’rights,thefinancialsettlement,atransitionperiod,ProtocolsonGibraltarandIreland,aswellasarangeofotherseparationissues.ItincludesaProtocolonIrelandandNorthernIrelandandalegallyoperational‘backstop’toensurethattherewillbenohardborderbetweenIrelandandNorthernIreland.ItcontainsUKcommitmentsnottodiminishtherightssetoutintheGoodFridayAgree-ment1998andrecognisesthatpeopleinNorthernIrelandwillcontinuetoenjoyEUcitizenshiprights,andtoprotectNorthSouthcooperation.ItacknowledgesthemaintenanceoftheCommonTravelAreaarrangementsbetweenIrelandandtheUK,andforthepreservationoftheSingleElectricityMarketontheislandofIreland.
ThereispersistinguncertaintyregardingtheratificationoftheWithdrawalAgreement
![Page 19: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
19
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
intheUKparliament.ThedecisionoftheEuropeanCounciltoextendtheArticle50processuntil31October2019providestheUKwithmoretimetoensureanorderlywithdrawal.However,thepossibilityoftheUKleavingtheEuropeanUnionwithoutanagreement–ano-dealscenario–remainsasignificantrisk.
Duetotheclose,highlyintegratedandcon-centratednatureofourtradingrelationshipwiththeUK,amongstallEUMemberStatesIrelandcouldbethemostadverselyaffectedbyBrexitandtothegreatestextentinanodealscenario.innumerousGovernment
publications1,andtherecentlypublishedContingencyActionPlanUpdatelistsanumberofsignificantshort-termrisksthatmayariseintheeventofano-dealBrexit.Inadditiontotheeconomicimpactandrisks,whicharediscussedindetailinChapter3,Brexit-relatedimpactsincludethosetotheCommonTravelArea(CTA)betweenIrelandandtheUK,whichallowsIrishandBritishcitizenstomovefreely
1 TheseincludepreviousNationalRiskAssessments,Budget2019documentation,theCopenhagenEconomicsreport“IrelandandtheImpactsofBrexit”publishedbytheMinisterforBusiness,EnterpriseandInnovation(available:https://www.copenhageneconomics.com/publications/publication/ireland-the-impacts-of-brexit),the2019ESRI/DepartmentofFinancereport“IrelandandBrexit:modellingtheimpactofdealandno-dealscenarios”(available:https://www.esri.ie/news/new-study-estimates-the-impact-of-various-brexit-scenarios-on-the-irish-economy),andtheContingencyActionPlan,Dec2018(available:https://www.dfa.ie/brexit/getting-ireland-brexit-ready/governmentcontingencyactionplan/)
Geo
politi
cal R
isks
•SignificantnegativeimpactontheNorthernIrelandeconomy,especiallyintheareaofagri-foodexports;
•LossoforlimitedaccesstorightsandentitlementsforNorthernIrelandresidentsentitledtoEUcitizenship;
•DisruptioninNorth-Southtradeandtheall-islandeconomyduetotariffsandtheimpositionofvariousregulatoryrequirements;
•DisruptiontoNorth-Southcooperationinareassuchasenergy,roadandrailconnectivity;
•LossofaccesstofishinglandingsfromUKEEZ,anddisplacementofotherEUfishingactivityintoIrishwaters;
•Notwithstandingmitigationmeasuresinplace,potentialdisruptiontodailylifeinareassuchasonlineretailpurchasesfromUK,accesstomedicinesandmedicaldevices,andfinancialservicessourcedfromtheUK
•DisruptionofEast-WesttradebetweenIrelandandBritainduetodelaysatportsand/orinabilityofbusinessestomeetregulatoryrequirements;
•DelaystotransitofexportsandimportsthroughtheUKlandbridge,withknock-onimpactsonwholesaleandretailsupplychains;
•Closureofbusinessesand/orlossofjobsinIrelandduetotradedisruptionandassociatedcosts,tariffsandcurrencymovement,inparticularintheagri-food,fisheries,manufacturingandtourismsectors;
•Regionaleconomicandlabourmarketimpactsduetothelocationofmost-exposedbusinesssectors;
•DeteriorationinIreland’smacroeconomicposition,includingdeteriorationinthepublicfinances;
•Communityrelationsundermined,andpoliticalinstabilityinNorthernIrelandandpotentialrelatedsecurityconcerns;
Short-term risks of a no-deal Brexit
TheGovernmentpublisheditsContingencyActionPlanUpdateinearlyJuly,notingthatdespitetheextensivemitigationmeasuresbeingundertakenatEUlevelbytheIrishGovernmentandbybusinesses,significantshort-termrisksintheeventofano-dealBrexitinclude:
![Page 20: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
20
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
andresideineitherjurisdictionandenjoyassociatedrightsandentitlementsincludingaccesstoemployment,healthcare,educa-tion,socialbenefitsandtherighttovoteinlocalandnationalparliamentaryelections.AswellastheEast-Westdimension,theCTAarrangementsalsounderpintheGoodFridayAgreementinallitsparts,aswellasthecross-borderfreedomscentraltothelivesandlivelihoodsofthepeopleofNorth-ernIrelandandtheborderregion.Anydimi-nutionoftheCTAcouldhaveadestabilisingimpactonthepeaceprocessandonNorth-Southrelations.TheIrishandBritishGov-ernmentshavecommittedtothecontinu-ationoftheCTAinallcircumstancesandaMemorandumofUnderstandingontheCommonTravelAreawassignedbybothGovernmentson8May2019.Separate,sectoralagreementstounderpintherightsoftheCTAhavealreadybeen,orwillshortlybeintroduced.Forexample,theagreementrequiredtomaintainthecurrentarrange-mentsinthefieldofsocialsecurityaftertheUKleavestheEUisinplace–itwassignedbybothStateson1February2019andcompletedtherequiredParliamentaryproceduresinbothStatesduringMarch.
BrexitwillalsoimpactontheoperationofawiderangeofEUlegalinstrumentscon-cerninglawenforcementandjudicialcoop-eration.OfgreatestconcerntoIrelandisthefutureoftheEuropeanArrestWarrant,aswellasEUinstrumentsthatprovidefortherecognitionandenforcementofjudgementsincivil,commercialandfamilylawmatters.Disruptiontolawenforcementandjudicialcooperationarrangementswouldhavea
particularimpactatNorth-Southlevel2.
Inthecontextofimmigration,BrexitmayalsogiverisetoanincreaseinillegalmovementofthirdcountrynationalsintoIrelandfromtheUK,aswellaspossibleconsequencesforsecondarymovementsofasylumseekersandillegalmigrantsfromtheUKtoIrelandintheeventofUKdivergencefromEUasylumlaw. Ano-dealBrexitwouldbeanexceptionaleconomiceventwhichwouldbemetwithexceptionalmeasurestosupportthecontin-uedoperationoftheIrisheconomyandourinternationaltradinglinks.Extensivecon-tingencyplanningandpreparednessworkisunderwayacrossallGovernmentDepart-mentsandAgenciesforapossibleno-dealBrexit.Thisresponsewouldbeimplementedincloseco-operationwithourEUpartners.
2.2. Instability in Northern Ireland TheresultsofthereferendumontheUK’smembershipoftheEuropeanUnioninJune2016showedthatamajorityofvotersinEnglandandWalesvotedtoleavewhilstamajorityinNorthernIrelandandScotlandvotedtoremainwithintheEU.ThishasgivenrisetoconsiderableissuesforWest-minsterandthedevolvedadministrationstoconsider.
ThebreakdownoftheNIExecutiveandthecollapseofthetalksontheformationofanewExecutivetogetherwithincreasesincrosscommunitytensionscreatedbythe
2ThePoliticalDeclarationsettingouttheFrameworkfortheFutureRelationshipbetweentheEUandtheUKoutlinesthebasisforaSecurityPartnershipwhichreferencesmeasurestoensurecoopera-tioninlawenforcementandjudicialcooperationincriminalmatters.IfaWithdrawalAgreementisratifiedtheapplicationofthefullEUacquistotheUKduringatransitionalperiodisofgreatimportance.IntheeventthataWithdrawalAgreementisnotratified,domesticlegislationisbeingpreparedtoensureworkableextraditionandimmigrationarrangementswiththeUKcancontinue.However,anycontingencymeasureswillnotandcannotmitigatetheoverallimpactofano-dealscenario.
Geo
politi
cal R
isks
![Page 21: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
21
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Brexitvote,meansthatNorthernIrelandisfacingachallengingperiodahead.TheinabilityoftheNorthernPartiestoreachacompromiseoncontestedissuesduringthetalksprocesshasallowedthedevelopmentofapoliticalvacuuminNorthernIreland,alongwiththeincreasedpossibilityofthere-introductionofdirectrulebytheUKGovernmentinNorthernIreland.ThisissomethingtowhichtheIrishGovernmentisopposed.
Therestorationoftheinstitutionsisessen-tialinthecontextoffullimplementationoftheGoodFridayAgreement.FollowingthetragickillingofLyraMcKeeinDerry,thetwoGovernmentsconvenedanewshortandfocussedtalksprocessaimedatrestor-ingalltheinstitutionsoftheGoodFridayAgreement.
TheGovernmentwillcontinuetoengagewiththeBritishGovernmentandthepartiesinNorthernIrelandasaco-guarantoroftheGoodFridayAgreementtosupportthere-establishmentattheearliestopportunityofthepower-sharinginstitutions.
Brexithasaddedanadditionalandsignif-icantchallengetothepoliticalsituationinNorthernIreland.Thelackofapower-shar-ingExecutiveinrepresentingandpursuingNorthernIreland’sinterestsinthecontextoftheEU-UKnegotiations,withtheUKandIrishgovernmentsasappropriate,isofsignificantconcerninrelationtothespecificchallengesofBrexitforNorthernIreland.AnExecutiveisalsorequiredforthefunction-ingoftheNorthSouthMinisterialCouncil,tooverseeandfurthercross-bordercooper-ationintheagreedsectorsandtoconsiderandaddresstheall-islandissuesraisedbyBrexit.ThelackofanExecutivehasresult-edinatangibleslowdowninNorthSouthengagementatpoliticallevelandhashadadetrimentaleffectontheeffectiveopera-
tionoftheNorthSouthbodiessetupundertheGFA.
BoththeIrishandtheUKgovernmentshaveaffirmedthattheprinciples,proce-duresandinstitutionsoftheGoodFridayAgreementremainthebasisfortheiren-gagementinNorthernIreland.EnsuringthattheGoodFridayAgreementandthebene-fitsofthepeaceprocessarenotdisturbedbyaUKexitfromtheEUispriorityfortheGovernment.
AsmentionedaboveasregardstheUKwithdrawalfromtheEU,theWithdraw-alAgreementalsoincludesaProtocolonIrelandandNorthernIrelandandalegallyoperationalbackstoptoensurethattherewillbenohardborderbetweenIrelandandNorthernIreland.ThereiscontinuinguncertaintyregardingtheratificationoftheWithdrawalAgreementintheUK.TheGov-ernmentsobjectivesinanyBrexitscenarioareclear–toavoidahardborderontheislandofIrelandandtoensuretheintegrityofthesinglemarketandthecustomsunion.
Anumberofsubmissions,outofthe650plussubmissionsreceivedunderthepublicconsultation,relatedtothe“borderpollquestion”.Althoughaborderpollwouldnotberegardedasarisk,andtheveryimport-antandsensitivepolicyissuesrelatedtoitwouldnotbedealtwithintheNationalRiskAssessmentprocess,thequestionofrelationshipsontheislandofIreland,andbetweenthetwoislands,arealwayscon-sideredaspartoftheannualNationalRiskAssessment.TheNationalRiskAssessmentwasoneofthefirstofficialacknowledg-mentsoftherisksposedbyapotentialBrexitincludingassociatedrisksforNorth-ernIreland.SincetheNationalRiskAssess-mentwasfirstintroduced,theseissueshavefeaturedprominently,andbeensupportedbyaccompanyingtextinthepublishedan-nualreports.
Geo
politi
cal R
isks
![Page 22: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
22
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
ThePreparingforthewithdrawaloftheUnitedKingdomfromtheEuropeanUnion–ContingencyActionPlanUpdatepublishedinJuly2019alsoidentifiesthatanodealBrexitriskssignificantlyunderminingwidercommunityrelationsandpoliticalstabilityinNorthernIreland,withpotentialrelatedsecurityconcernsandelaboratesthatcallsforaborderpolltobeheldwouldincreaseinsuchascenario.Thiscouldalsohaveim-plicationsforthestabilityoftheinstitutionsiftheyareinplace,ortheprocesstorestorethemtooperation.Thelongertheuncer-taintyofanodealscenariopersists,themorepoliticalandcommunityrelationshipsinNorthernIrelandwouldbetested.
Uncertaintyaroundaphysicalborderontheislandcouldalsobeexpectedtobecomeafocusfordissidentrepublicanparamil-itaryrecruitmentandactivity.GardaandPSNIauthoritieshavesaidpubliclythatanyborderinfrastructureorpersonnelwouldbecometargetsfordissidentrepublicanparamilitariesandrequirepoliceorotherprotection.
AnodealBrexitalsohasthepotentialtobecomeafocusforincreasedloyalistpara-militaryrecruitmentandactivity,includinginresponsetodissidentrepublicanparamil-itaryactionsandanincreasedpublicfocusonaborderpoll.
IftheinstitutionswerenotinplaceatthetimeofanodealBrexit,thereisariskthattheUKGovernmentmightinitiateamovetoDirectRuleinNorthernIrelandasaresponsetomanagingthetransitiontonewarrangementsinthetimeframeinvolved.
ThecentralpriorityoftheGovernmentinthisregardistoworkurgentlyandinpart-nershipwiththeUKGovernmenttosupporttherestorationoftheinstitutionsoftheGoodFridayAgreementtofulloperationon
amoresustainablebasis,andtoaddresskeyissuesofdivisionbetweenthemainpartiesthathaveaffectedpartnershipgovernmentinNorthernIreland.Havingtheinstitu-tionsworkingonbehalfofallthepeopleofNorthernIrelandwouldbecrucialinman-agingtheimpactsofanyBrexitscenarioontheisland.
TheGovernmenthasalwaysrecognisedtheneedforadvancepreparationsforreferendaandthiswouldbeofparticularimportanceinthecaseofaborderpollgiventhepoten-tialimpactonallthepeopleoftheislandofIreland.ThelessonsoftheUKBrexitRef-erendumareofparticularresonanceinthiscontext.
BrexithasalsoplayedsignificantlyintothedebateinScotlandaboutitsfuturewithintheUK,raisingquestionsinrelationtothedevolutionsettlementandthepossibilityofafurtherindependencereferendum.DisagreementshavearisenbetweentheScottishandUKGovernmentsinrelationtotheoperationofcurrentdevolutionar-rangements,andinparticularthehandlingpost-BrexitofmattersofEUcompetencethatwerenotreservedtoWestminsterunderthetermsoftheScottishdevolutionsettlement.ThestatusofScotlandintheUnitedKingdomisaninternalmatterforthepeopleofScotlandandthepeopleoftheUnitedKingdom,andthereforeamatteronwhichtheIrishGovernmentdoesnotandwillnotengage.
QuestionshavebeenraisedregardingtheapplicabilitytoScotlandofanyarrange-mentsmadetoaddressthechallengesposedbyBrexitforNorthernIrelandandfortheislandofIreland.However,thesitua-tioninNorthernIrelandisuniqueandnotdirectlycomparabletothatinScotlandinparticular,giventhenatureofthepoliticalandconstitutionalsettlementoftheGoodFridayAgreement.
Geo
politi
cal R
isks
![Page 23: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
23
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
2.3. Future direction and stability of the EU
Europehasundergoneaseriesofcrisesinrecentyears:theeurozonecrisis,themigrationcrisis,terrorattacksinanumberofMemberStatesandtheshockofBrexit.Thesehaveplayedoutagainsttheback-groundofariseofpopulismasshowninelectoraladvancesbyextremeright-wingand/orEuroscepticpartiesinanumberofEUstateswhileinsomeCentralandEasternMemberStates,thereisagrowingdefianceofEUvaluesandnorms.
Inaddition,concernsaboutadversemarketreactionsasmonetarypolicynormalises,andvulnerabilitiesinthebroadereuroarearemain,particularlyinthecontextoftheunwindingoftheECB’sQuantitativeEasingprogramme,andsignificantamountsofdebtinsomeEUeconomies,includingIreland,withrelatedrisksaroundthesustainabilityoftheEurozone.
Ontheotherhand,employmentinEuropeisatarecordhighandunemploymentatarecordlow3.TheEuropeaneconomyisexpectedtogrowfortheseventhconsec-utiveyearin2019,butatamoremoderatepaceatatimeofmorepronouncedglobaluncertainty.
ThisyearmarksthestartofanewlegislativecycleintheEU.InMay,therewillbeEuro-peanParliamentelectionsand,inturnthenewParliamentwillelectthenextEuropeanCommissionPresidentandapprovetheap-pointmentofanewEuropeanCommission.
TheEuropeanCouncilisresponsibleforde-terminingthegeneralpoliticaldirectionandprioritiesoftheEUandinJuneitwilladoptanewStrategicAgendafor2019-2024.
3 Availablehere:https://ec.europa.eu/social/main.jsp?langId=en&-catId=89&newsId=9316&furtherNews=yes
ButarecentEuropeanCouncilonForeignRelations(ECFR)reportprovidesaworryingsnapshotofthepotentialdisruptiveeffectaone-third“anti-European”Parliamentcouldhaveonforeigntrade,theruleoflaw,mi-gration,foreignpolicy,andtheappointmentofthenextCommission4.
ThenewEuropeanParliamentwillalsohaveanimpactontheEUbudgetfor2021to2027,theMultiannualFinancialFramework(MFF).ThisisthefirsttimeIrelandwillenteranewMFFasanet-contributor.Itwillbeachallengetoensurethefinaloutcomere-flectsIrishprioritiessuchastheprotectionoftheCommonAgriculturalPolicyandpro-videsadequatefundingfornewchallengessuchasmigration.
AdditionalongoingorcontinuingriskstotheunityandeffectivenessoftheEUinclude:
• Riskofnegotiationsbreakingdown,caus-ingdivisionsamongstMemberStates–forexample,inrelationtotheEUbudget;• RiskthatthelossoftheUKvoiceinEUdecision-makingcouldtipthebalanceofintereststowardsamoreconservativeorprotectioniststance;and•RisksspecifictoIreland’sinterestsandin-fluencingpowerwithintheEUwhichcouldemergefromadisruptiveEuropeanParliamentandthelossoftheUKasanegotiationpartner.
2.4. Changing distribution of global influence and move away from a rules-based system
Geopoliticalvolatilityanduncertaintycontinuedthroughout2018andinto2019,givingrisetoheightenedthreatsto
4 Availablehere:https://www.ecfr.eu/specials/scorecard/the_2019_European_election
Geo
politi
cal R
isks
![Page 24: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
24
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
internationalpeaceandsecurity,exacerbatedbyeffortstoweakenthemulti-lateralrules-basedsystem.
Thelasttwelvemonthshaveseenanin-creaseingeopoliticaltensionsatregionalandgloballevel,including(thoughnotlimit-edto)theKoreanPeninsula,betweenRussiaandtheUS,RussiaandUK,ChinaandtheUS,theUSandIran,andIndiaandPakistan.TheseriousconflictsongoinginSyriaandYemenarecausingsignificanthumanitariancrisesandirregularmigration.Thehumani-tarianandpoliticalsituationintheOccupiedPalestinianTerritorydeterioratedfurtherin2018,withsettlementbuildingincreasingintheWestBank,andsignificantunrestinGazabeingmetbyseeminglydispropor-tionateIsraelimilitaryforce.TheUSwith-drawalfromtheIrannuclearagreementhasincreasedtensionsacrosstheMiddleEast,andrisksdamagingthepotentialtoresolveotherglobalconflictsbymeansofinterna-tionalagreements.Themarkedincreaseintheuseofchemicalweaponsinrecentyearshasseriouslythreatenedtounderminetheuniversalprohibitionontheuseofchemicalweapons.
ThecurrentUSadministration’swithdraw-alfromtheJointComprehensivePlanofActionwithIran,aswellastheTrans-Pa-cificPartnership(TPP),re-negotiationoftheNorthAmericanFreeTradeAgreement(NAFTA),reducedroleattheWorldTradeOrganisation(WTO),andintroductionofseveralroundsoftariffsonChineseproductsover2018and2019allfurtherstrengthenpreviousindicationsthattheUSaremovingawayfromthefreetrademodel,withassociatedrisksofreducedglobaleco-nomicgrowth,andincreaseduncertaintiesandinstabilitiesintheglobaleconomy.
Russia-USrelationsareincreasinglystrained,asarerelationsbetweenRus-
siaandtheUKandWesternallies.Thisisreflected,forexample,intheexpulsionbytheUKof23diplomatsfollowingapoison-ingincidentintheUKinMarch2018withsuspectedRussianinvolvement,andthesubsequentexpulsionsbyanumberofEUandWesternstates,includingIreland,andtheUSandNATOinsolidarity.TheRussiangovernmentretaliatedwiththesubsequentexpulsionof59diplomatsfrom23coun-tries,including1fromIreland.
PreviousNRAReportsdiscussedglobalisa-tiontrendsinvolvinganongoingandsignif-icantshiftofpoliticalandeconomicpowertowardscountriesintheEastandSouth,representingachallengetotheexistinginternationalorder.Commentsthatsuchtrendsnecessitatemorestrategicanddeep-erengagementwithAsian,AfricanandLatinAmericancountriescontinuetobevalid,intermsofprotectingandpromotingIreland’strade,tourismandinvestmentinterests.
Asanopenglobaleconomy,anymoveawayfromarules-basedmultilateralismsystemattheinternationallevelwouldnotbeinlinewithIreland’sinterests,andcouldposesignificantrisksforus.
2.5. Terrorist incidents and armed conflicts
Therisksarisingfromterroristincidentsandarmedconflicts,ashighlightedinpreviousReports,remain.2018sawcontinuinghightensionsintheMiddleEastandinNorthEastAsia(DemocraticPeople’sRepublicofKorea)aswellasterroristincidentsandattacksacrossEurope,inparticularintheUK.OngoingtensionsbetweenIndiaandPakistanrepresentathreattoregionalsta-bilityandthusIrishinterestsintheregion.Inaddition,asbotharenuclearpowers,in-creasedconflictisathreattoIreland’spolicy
Geo
politi
cal R
isks
![Page 25: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
25
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
positiononandeffortstosupportnuclearnon-proliferation.
Overthepast12months,conversationsaroundtheriskstoIrelandandtheIrishresponsecapacityinthisregardhavealsoincreased,highlightingincreasedawarenessoftherisksinvolvedintheIrishcontext.
Europoldatasuggeststhattheoverallthreatfromjihadistterrorismremainshigh,withthenumberofarreststotalling705in2017,downslightlyfrom718in2016.Therehasalsobeenasignificantslowdowninthenumberofforeign-bornfighterstravellingtoSyriaandIraq.Therehasbeenamarkedriseinright-wingextremistattacks,withajumpfrom99attacksin2016to137attacksin2017.ThistrendisevidencedbytherecentmosqueattacksinNewZealand.Leftwingandanarchistterrorismhasdeclinedslightlybetween2016and20175.
Likeothercountries,Irelandanditscitizenscouldbenegativelyaffectedbyterroristincidents,dependingonthelocationofsuchincidentsandtheirwiderimpact.The2017attacksinLondon,ManchesterandtherecentattacksonaMosqueinChrist-churchandSynagogueinPittsburghservetohighlightthechallengingnatureofthethreatandtheneedforcontinuedco-oper-ationamongpartnerstatestocounteractit.Suchanattackherecouldhavesignificantimpactintermsofpublicsafetyandsecurityintheshortterm,andtherecouldpossiblybelonger-termreputationaldamagetoIre-landasasafeandsecuredestinationtoliveandworkin,andtovisit.Anyimpactsonthetourismsector,forexample,couldhavepotentiallyseriouseconomicconsequences.
Likewise,abreakdownininternationalpeaceandsecurityarisingfrominter-state
5EuropeanUnionTerrorismSituationandTrendReport2018;https://www.europol.europa.eu/activities-services/main-reports/eu-ropean-union-terrorism-situation-and-trend-report-2018-tesat-2018
warsorotherarmedconflictscouldhavesignificantrepercussionsforIrelandandtheEU,includingpotentialimpactsonenergysupplies,transportroutesortheenvironment.
OntheislandofIreland,theGoodFridayAgreementhasdeliveredastablepeaceprocessthatcommandsoverwhelmingcrosscommunitysupport.Nonetheless,certaingroupsinbothcommunities,albeitwithverylimitedlevelsofsupport,remainintentondisruptingthesignificantprogresswhichhasbeenachievedandperpetratingactsofviolence.Recenthigh-profileincidents,includingattacksonsecuritypersonnelinNorthernIreland,thecarbombinDerryandthemurderofjournalistLyraMcKee,areareminderthatwecannotbecomplacent.Accordingly,therelevantauthoritiesneedtocontinuetheirworktocombatthesegroupsandtheiractivities.LegacyissuesarisingfromconflictinNorthernIrelandandcurrentsocialandeconomicchallengesalsoneedtobeaddressed.BoththeIrishandBritishgovernmentshavereaffirmedtheircommitmenttoensuringthatthebenefitsofthepeaceprocessarepreservedinanynewarrangementsarisingfromtheUK’sexitfromtheEU.
Geo
politi
cal R
isks
![Page 26: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
3. Economic Risks
![Page 27: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
27
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
3.1. Economic Impact of Brexit 3.2. Risk of Overheating 3.3 Public Expenditure Pressures 3.4. Global Slowdown, including changes to international trading environment 3.5. International tax changes 3.6. Reliance on multinational corporations and sectoral concentration
3.0. Introduction
WhiletheIrisheconomycontinuestoperformstrongly,therearevariousfactorsthatcouldpresentsignificantrisks.Therisksareoutlinedinthefollowingsectionsindetail.Theyshouldbeseenagainstabackdropofcontinuinghighindebtedness(bothpublicandprivate)andemergingexpenditurepressures.TheState’scomparativelyhighlevelofdebtmeansthat,atanadvancedstageoftheeconomiccycle,Ire-landexhibitsminimalscopetobuildmeaning-fulfiscalbuffersinthecomingyears.Indealingwiththeseissues,todateIrelandhasbenefit-tedfromabenigninternationalfinancialen-vironment.Anyreversalinlowglobalinterestrates,suchastheexpectednormalisationinECBmonetarypolicy,wouldleadtoincreaseddebtservicingcostsandassociatedimpactsonthepublicfinancesovertime.Thesefactors,andalackofmeaningfulfiscalspace,wouldamplifytheimpactontheeconomy,shouldemergingspendingpressuresriskdestabilisingthepublicfinances,andshouldanyoftheeco-nomicrisksoutlinedbelowmaterialise.
3.1. Economic Impact of Brexit
TheexitoftheUKfromtheEUisanunprec-edentedeventinmoderneconomichistory.Therecontinuestobeconsiderableuncertain-tyregardingmanyissues,notleastofwhichisthelikelyformatoftheUK’sexit.However,assetoutintheContingencyActionPlan
Update,publishedon9July,itistheGov-ernment’sassessmentthatthereisnowasignificantriskofano-dealBrexiton31Octoberorthereafter.
Itisclearthatduetoourcloseeconom-icandtradingrelationshipwiththeUK,IrelandwillbeimpactedmorethananyotherEUcountry.Brexitwillhaveasignifi-cantimpactonoureconomy,includingtheall-islandeconomy,thelabourmarketandthepublicfinances,withthemostnegativeimpactslikelytobeinagri-foodandindige-nousmanufacturingsectors.
TheUK’sdeparturefromtheEUisaneventwithoutprecedentinmoderneconomichistory,andquantifyingtheimpactofthisischallenging.Nonetheless,estimatingtheimpactisimportanttohelpGovernmenttounderstandthepossiblemacroeconomicimplicationsandtodesigntheappropriatepolicyresponse.
InMarch2019,theESRIandtheDepart-mentofFinanceproducedupdatedes-timatesofthepotentialmacroeconomicimpactsofBrexitontheIrisheconomy.Thisworktakesaccountofsubstantialnewmicroeconomicresearchontheimpactoftariffandnon-tariffmeasures,alongwithrevisedassessmentsoftheimpactontheUKthathavebeenproducedsincetheini-tialimpactassessmentofBrexitbytheESRIandDepartmentofFinancein2016.The
Econ
omic
Risk
s
![Page 28: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
28
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
variousBrexitscenarioresultsshowthattheimpactsontheIrisheconomyarelargeandthatBrexitwillultimatelynegativelyimpactfirms,households,thelabourmarketandthepublicfinances.
Thisstudyfindsthat,comparedtoanoBrexitbaseline,thelevelofGDPinIrelandtenyearsafterBrexitwouldbearound2.6percentlowerinadealscenarioand5.0percentlowerina‘DisorderlyNoDeal’scenar-io,respectively.
Ano-dealBrexitwouldresultinasharpreductioningrowthwithnegativecon-sequencesthroughouttheeconomy.Thereducedgrowthwouldfeedthroughthefiscalchannelastheautomaticstabiliserswouldbeactivated.Specifically,taxrevenuewouldbelowerandtherewouldbeupwardpressureonexpenditureareas,inpartic-ular,socialprotectiontransfers.Ireland’sEUbudgetcontribution,fundedfromtheExchequer,mightalsoincreaseinanodealscenario,giventhattheEU’scontingencymeasureinrelationtotheEUbudgetisfor2019only.
ThestudyalsoemphasisesthenegativeimpactBrexitwillhaveontheIrishlabourmarket.Theresultsfromthestudyshowthatemployment,inthelongrun,wouldbe1.8percentlowerinadealscenarioand3.4percentlowerina“DisorderlyNoDeal”scenario,comparedtoascenariowheretheUKstaysintheEU.
ThedeteriorationinIreland’sfiscalbalancewouldbestructural,notcyclical,innature.Thiswouldreflectapermanentreductioninthesizeoftheeconomyand,consequentlyintheamountoftaxrevenueitgenerates.UnderthedisorderlyBrexitscenario,thiscouldinvolveaheadlinedeficitintheregionof–½to–1½percentofGDPfornextyear,dependingonthemagnitudeofthe
economicshock.Thewiderangereflectstheuncertaintysurroundingthebudgetaryimpactofsuchanunprecedentedshock.
Itisimportanttorecognisethatsuchestimatesmaynotcapturethefullimpact,andthefiguresmaybeconservative.IntheeventofanodealBrexit,therewouldbesignificantdisruptionwithfurtherneg-ativematerialimpactsonIrelandandtheall-islandeconomy,particularlyintheearlyyears,arisingfromissuessuchassignificantmarketvolatility,furthersterlingdepreci-ation,anddisruptiontotradewiththeUKincludingNorthernIreland.ThefullimpactwillalsodependondecisionstakenbytheUKinrelationtotariffsimposedongoodsfromtheEU,includingIreland.
Therearealsosignificantsectoralandre-gionaldimensionstothiseconomicimpactandsomesectorsandregionswillbemoreaffectedthanothers.Indeed,thenegativeimpactswillbemostkeenlyfeltinthosesectorswithstrongexporttiestotheUKmarket–suchastheagri-food,manufac-turingandtourismsectorsandalsoSMEsgenerally–alongwiththeirsuppliers.Theimpactwillbeparticularlynoticeableintheregionswherethereisarelianceonthesesectorsandbusinessesasfirmsadjusttopotentiallyhighertariffandnon-tariffbarri-ers,aswellascurrencyfluctuations.Fur-ther,givenIreland’suniquemacroeconomicandsectoralexposurestotheUK,theseimpactswouldbedisproportionaterelativetotherestoftheEU.
Theunprecedentednatureoftheeventmeansforecastsaresubjecttogreateruncertaintyandvariancethanduringnormaltimes.AnalternativestudybytheCentralBankofIrelandsuggeststheshort-runandlong-runimpactsofadisorderlyBrexitcouldbemorenegativethantheDepart-mentofFinance/ESRIstudysuggests.This
Econ
omic
Risk
s
![Page 29: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
29
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
studyputsgreaterweightontheeffectsofuncertaintyonconsumerandbusinessdecisions.TheCentralBank’sestimate,aspublishedinJanuary2019,isthatadisor-derlyBrexitcouldreducethegrowthrateoftheIrisheconomybyuptofourpercentagepointsinthefirstyear.Overtenyears,theCentralBankestimatesthatadisorderlyBrexitcouldreducetheoveralllevelofIrishoutputby6.1percent,ascomparedto1.7percentinthecaseofatransitiontoaFreeTradeArea-likearrangement.
TheGovernmentiscurrentlyplanningitsapproachtoBudget2020basedbothonanorderlyandadisorderlyscenario.TheGovernmentwillcloselymonitordevelop-mentsintheUKoverthecomingmonthsanddecidewhichscenarioisthemostlikelyandbaseBudget2020onthat.
Theservicessectortoofacessignificantdisruption.InsomeareaswherefirmshavenotdoneadequatecontingencyplanningconsumerswillnolongerbeabletoaccessfinancialservicesfromUKproviders.RiskstoconsumersaresignificantlyreducedasthefivelargestretailbanksareauthorisedinIrelandandlargepartsoftheinsurancesectoraresimilarlyauthorisedintheEEAorwillbeauthorisedtherebeforeBrexit.Themostmaterialriskisforcustomersofinsur-ancefirmsanddistributorswhohavenotcompletedanadequatecontingencyplanintime.ThisissuehasbeensolvedthroughtheBrexitOmnibusBill.InothersectorsoffinancialservicescustomersmaybedealingwithfirmsintheUKwhocannottransactwiththempost-Brexitandcompetitionmaybelessenedinsomenichelinesofbusiness.WhilethismayariseitisnotexpectedtobematerialandweexpectthatsuchcustomerswillhavealternativeprovidersavailableandauthorisedintheEU27.Buttheriskcannotbeeliminated.
Intermsofregulatoryrisks,ano-dealBrexitwillintroducebothimmediateandlon-ger-termdisruptionforIrishbusinessesandindustrieswhocarryoutsignificanttradewiththeUK.Inadvanceoftheoutcomeofnegotiations,thelevelofriskisdifficulttofullyassess.LessdemandingregulationcouldputUKfirmsatacompetitivead-vantagewhilstfurtheradvantagescouldemergeshouldtheUKbeabletoaiditsindustriesandbusinessthroughtheuseofStateAidinthefuture.Regulatorydi-vergencewouldalsointroducebarrierstotrade,potentiallyinterruptingthesupplyofgoodsandservices,disruptingsupplychainsetc.
Moregenerally,Brexithasintroducedalev-elofuncertaintywhichmayresultinforeignenterprisesholdingoffoninvestmentde-cisionsuntilgreaterclarityemerges.ThereisaneedtomaintainafocusonenhancingIreland’scompetitivenessasaresultoftheincreasinglycompetitivemarketforinterna-tionalinvestment,andasotherEUMemberStatescompetetoattractforeigninvest-mentlookingforaccesstotheEUmarket.
3.2. Risk of Overheating Followingonfromtheperiodoffiscalconsolidationintheyears2008to2014,ithasbeenpossibletoonceagainincreaseexpenditureonthedeliveryofpublicser-vices.Budgetssincethenhavesetaboutincreasingexpenditureinkeypriorityareaswhilealsoensuringtheviabilityofthepublicfinances.TheenhancedengagementwiththeOireachtas,particularlytheSelectCommitteeonBudgetaryOversight,hasalsoassistedinformulatingBudgetswhilereachingbroadconsensusonkeypriorities.
Astheeconomicrecoverycontinues,theexpectations,fromarangeofsources,that
Econ
omic
Risk
s
![Page 30: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
30
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
additionalresourceswillbemadeavailabletomeetgrowingdemandsfornewservicesandserviceimprovementsmaynotbeconsistentwiththeavailableresourcesbothintheshortandmediumterm.Thisrequiresacontinuedfocusontheeffectivenessandsustainabilityofpublicexpenditureandabroadunderstandingoftheneedtoen-surethatpublicexpenditureincreasesareaffordablebothtodayandoverthelongerterm,andthatcostover-runsandaddition-alexpenditureiscontrolled.Atthisstageoftheeconomiccycle,emergingspendingpressuresmustbecloselymonitoredandcontrolled,toensurethatourpublicfinanc-esremainsustainableandstable,andtoen-surewecanrespondtothechallengesaris-ingfromtherisksdiscussedthroughoutthisReport.TheIrishFiscalAdvisoryCouncil,forexample,intheirNovember2018FiscalAssessmentReport,warnedthat“repeatedfailurestopreventunbudgetedspendingincreaseshaveleftthepublicfinancesmoreexposedtoadverseshocks”.
PublicServicesaredeliveredthroughtheworkofpublicservants.Consequently,thepublicservicepaybillisanimportantelementofoverallpublicexpenditure.Ex-pectationsinrelationtoincreasesinpublicservicepayneedtobemanagedwithinthecontextofensuringsustainablepublicfinancesandeffectivedeliveryofservices.
Further,Ireland’spublicdebt,andthepotentialforrisinginterestrates,marketvolatility,Brexit-relatedmattersandotherfactorstoimpactonthecostofservicingourpublicdebt,couldhaveconsequentimpactsontheappropriatefiscalstancefortheeconomy.Sustainabilitymetricsshowthatalthoughdeclining,publicindebted-nessremainshighinIreland.Thesemetricsincludetheabsolutelevelofdebt,debtinterestpaymentsasashareofrevenueanddebttoGNI*.
TheUK’sdeparturefromtheEUwillhavesignificantimpactsforsectoralpolicy,publicexpenditureandthewidereconomy.DedicatedmeasurestoprepareforBrexitwereannouncedinBudgets2017,2018and2019,toensurethatIrelandisinthebestpossiblepositiontorespondtothechallengesthatBrexitwillbring.However,theextentoftheimpactsandthenatureofriskswilldependonthebasisonwhichtheUKdepartstheEU.Giventhisriskintheexternalenvironment,itisallthemoreim-portantthatexpenditurepressuresarisingfromotherareas,includingdemographicgrowth,capitalinvestmentneedsandpublicdemandsforincreasedservices,areman-aged,withunplannedadditionalexpendi-turecontrolledtoensuresustainabilityovertheeconomiccycle.
3.3. Public Expenditure Pressures
Followingonfromtheperiodoffiscalcon-solidationintheyears2008to2014,ithasbeenpossibletoonceagainincreaseex-penditureonthedeliveryofpublicservices.Budgetssincethenhavesetaboutincreas-ingexpenditureinpriorityareaswhilealsoensuringtheviabilityofthepublicfinanc-es.TheenhancedengagementwiththeOireachtas,particularlytheSelectCommit-teeonBudgetaryOversight,hasalsoassist-edinformulatingBudgetswhilereachingbroadconsensusonpriorities.
Astheeconomicrecoverycontinues,theexpectations,fromarangeofsources,thatadditionalresourceswillbemadeavailabletomeetgrowingdemandsfornewservicesandserviceimprovementsmaynotbeconsistentwiththeavailableresourcesbothintheshortandmediumterm.Thisrequiresacontinuedfocusontheeffectivenessandsustainabilityofpublicexpenditureanda
Econ
omic
Risk
s
![Page 31: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
31
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
broadunderstandingoftheneedtoen-surethatpublicexpenditureincreasesareaffordablebothtodayandoverthelongerterm,andthatcostover-runsandaddition-alexpenditureiscontrolled.Atthisstageoftheeconomiccycle,emergingspend-ingpressuresmustbecloselymonitoredandcontrolled,toensurethatourpublicfinancescontinuetobesustainableandstable,andtoensurewecanrespondtothechallengesarisingfromtherisksdiscussedthroughoutthisReport.TheIrishFiscalAd-visoryCouncil,forexample,intheirNovem-ber2018FiscalAssessmentReport,warnedthat“repeatedfailurestopreventunbudget-edspendingincreaseshaveleftthepublicfinancesmoreexposedtoadverseshocks”.
PublicServicesaredeliveredthroughtheworkofpublicservants.Consequently,thepublicservicepaybillisanimportantelementofoverallpublicexpenditure.Ex-pectationsaboutincreasesinpublicservicepayneedtobemanagedwithinthecontextofensuringsustainablepublicfinancesandeffectivedeliveryofservices.
Further,Ireland’spublicdebt,andthepotentialforrisinginterestrates,marketvolatility,Brexit-relatedmattersandotherfactorstoimpactonthecostofservicingourpublicdebt,couldhaveconsequentimpactsontheappropriatefiscalstancefortheeconomy.Sustainabilitymetricsshowthatalthoughdeclining,publicindebtednesscontinuestobehighinIreland.Thesemet-ricsincludetheabsolutelevelofdebt,debtinterestpaymentsasashareofrevenueanddebttoGNI*.
TheUK’sdeparturefromtheEUwillhavesignificantimpactsforsectoralpolicy,publicexpenditureandthewidereconomy.DedicatedmeasurestoprepareforBrexitwereannouncedinBudgets2017,2018and2019,toensurethatIrelandisinthe
bestpossiblepositiontorespondtothechallengesthatBrexitwillbring.However,theextentoftheimpactsandthenatureofriskswilldependonthebasisonwhichtheUKdepartstheEU.Giventhisriskintheexternalenvironment,itisallthemoreim-portantthatexpenditurepressuresarisingfromotherareas,includingdemographicgrowth,capitalinvestmentneedsandpublicdemandsforincreasedservices,areman-aged,withunplannedadditionalexpendi-turecontrolledtoensuresustainabilityovertheeconomiccycle.
3.4. Global Slowdown, including changes to international trading environment
Ireland,asahighlyopen,export-focussedeconomyisparticularlysensitivetoaslow-downinworldtradeandoveralleconomicgrowth.AdverseexternaldevelopmentscouldimpacttheIrisheconomythroughnumerouschannels,includingthroughex-changeratefluctuations,reduceddemandforexports,increasedpublicandprivatesectorborrowingcosts,anddeterioratingconsumerandmarketsentiment.Inaddi-tion,increasedtariffandnon-tariffbarrierscouldcreatebarrierstotradethatwouldadverselyaffecttheexportsofIrishfirmsandMNCsoperatinginIreland.
Theoutlookfortheglobaleconomyhasbeenworseningsincethesecondhalfof2018.Thelatesteconomicdata,highfre-quencyindicatorsandeconomicforecastsallpointtothepaceofglobalgrowthslow-ing.TheIMFwarnednationalgovernmentstoprepareforan‘economicstorm’asglobalgrowthlevelsundershootexpectations.TheIMFreferenced‘tradetensionsandtariffescalation,financialtightening,uncertaintysurroundingBrexitandanacceleratedChi-neseslowdown’asthefourcrucialfactors
Econ
omic
Risk
s
![Page 32: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
32
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
underminingglobaleconomicgrowth1.Inaddition,theECBcutitseuroareagrowthprojectionsfor20192,signifyingincreaseduncertaintyregardingtheoveralleconomicoutlook.Similarly,theWorldBankpredictsglobalgrowthtobemoderateaseconomicslackdissipates,monetarypolicyaccommo-dationinadvancedeconomiesisremoved,andglobaltradegraduallyslows,andtheOECDsuggestthatglobalGDPgrowththoughstrong,haspeaked.
Asasmallopeneconomy,andoneinwhichmulti-nationalcorporationsplayanimportantrole,Irelandishighlyexposedtochangesinglobaleconomicandtradingconditions.TheEuroAreaaccountsforthelargestproportionofIreland’strade.Some29percentofourgoodsandservicesexportsweredestinedfortheEuroAreain2017,comparedto15percentofgoodsandservicesexportsdestinedfortheUKin2017.Havingoutperformedexpectationsin2017,growthintheEuroAreahasmod-erated.TheEuropeanCommission’slatestforecastsshowtheEuroAreagrowthratein2019willbealmosthalftheratein2017,reflectinggrowinguncertainties.
Momentuminmajoreconomiesisslowing.Severaladvancedeconomies,suchasJapanandGermany,experiencedcontractionsinthethirdquarterof2018.TheItalianeconomyfellintoatechnicalrecession(twoconsecutivequartersofeconomiccontrac-tion)inthesecondhalfof2018.ThepaceofgrowthintheChineseeconomyhasalsoslowed.UKeconomicgrowthcontinuestobemodest,asuncertaintysurroundingBrexitcontinues.
Furthermore,escalatingtradeconflictsarenegativelyaffectingthegrowthoutlook
1 https://www.worldgovernmentsummit.org/events/annual-gather-ing/session-detail/a-conversation-with-christine-lagarde
2 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-ecb-policy-forecasts/ecb-cuts-growth-inflation-forecasts-idUSKCN1QO1O9
inallcountries.Thereareclearindicationsthattradetensionsarebeginningtoim-pactgrowthwithtradevolumes,industrialproductionandmanufacturingpurchasingmanagersindex(PMIs)declining.Leadingindicatorsarealsoacauseforconcern.TheUSyieldcurve,whichhasgoodsignallingproperties,ispointingtoaslowdownintheUSeconomy.Similarly,theOECD’sCom-positeLeadingIndicatorspointtomoderat-inggrowthintheUK,theEuroAreainclud-ingGermany,FranceandItaly,andintheOECDareaasawhole.
Whilstthereisacyclicaldownturninworlddemand,someofwhichisrelatedtocoun-try-specificidiosyncraticfactors(e.g.carindustryinGermany,tradetensionsetc.),therearealsolonger-termstructuralfac-torsatplaywhichhaveresultedinalmostnoexpansioninglobalisationoverthelastdecade.
InaEuropeancontext,theslowdowncanbeseentobeexacerbatedbyspecificeuroareavulnerabilities,forexample,Italianbor-rowingcostscontinuetobeelevatedandaweakereuroareaoutlookcombinedwithapossibleglobaleconomicdownturncouldpresentfurtherchallengeswithcontagiontotheeuroareacontinuingtobeasignif-icantrisk.TheconclusionofQuantitativeEasing(intermsofnetbondpurchases)willbringanendtoaprolongedperiodoflowinterestrates,presentingamorechal-lengingfundingenvironmentintheyearsahead.Quantitativetighteningmayalsofilterthroughtotherealeconomyvis-à-vishigherSMEborrowingcostsormortgageinterestrates,placingadditionalpressureonanalreadyhighlyindebtedhouseholdsectorintheIrishcontext.
Inadditiontothis,aslowdownintheUSandChineseeconomies,furtherintensifica-tionoftradetensionsandacontinuedmove
Econ
omic
Risk
s
![Page 33: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
33
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
towardsprotectionistpolicies,increasingglobalindebtedness,changingglobalfinan-cialconditions,andthetimingandnatureofBrexit,amongstotheruncertainties,poseriskstotheglobaleconomicoutlookgoingforward.
Asmentioned,thisslowingworldgrowthmomentumhasimportantimplicationsforIreland’seconomy.SensitivityanalysisintheBudget2019EconomicandFiscalOutlookshowsthatanexternalshockof1percentinworlddemandwouldreducethelevelofoutputbyaround0.3percentinthefirstyearandbyaround1.0percentafter5yearsrelativetoabaselineprojec-tion.Thisdecelerationwouldbereflectedinthelabourmarketandfiscalbalances.Thisunderlinestheimportanceofimprovingtheresilienceoftheeconomybybuildingfiscalbuffers,maintainingappropriatecontrolonexpenditure,andfocussingoncompetitive-ness.
Overall,recentexternaldevelopmentssuggestthattherehasbeenanoticeabledecelerationinglobaleconomicactivity,partlydrivenbyadversetradepolicydevel-opmentsinsomeofIreland’smaintradingpartners.
3.5. International tax changes
Ireland’scorporationtaxregimeisamajorfactorincreatingfavourableconditionsinwhichIrish-basedenterprisesoperate,aswellasinensuringastableenvironment,transparencyandpredictabilityforinwardinvestment.ItcontinuestobeanimportantpartofIreland’swidercompetitivenessof-feringtoassistenterprisesbasedinIrelandinvest,innovateandcompeteinternation-ally3.However,thehighdependenceof
3NationalCompetitivenessCouncil(2017)Ireland’sCompetitive-nessChallenge2017
Ireland’soutputandvalueaddedonForeignDirectInvestment(FDI)presentsavulner-abilityintermsofhowanchoredforeignmultinationalsaretotheIrisheconomy,whichisfurthercomplicatedbytheongoingprocedureofinternationaltaxreform.
Irelandhasplayedanactiveroleinimple-mentinginternationaltaxreformsthroughtheBEPSproject,andisamongstthecountrieswhohaveadoptedearlythecoun-try-by-countryreportingforlargefirms.Inaddition,UStaxreformshouldleadtosomebehaviouralchangeandshouldeliminatetheabilityforUScompaniestopayverylowtaxratesontheirglobalprofits.Neverthe-less,thereisastrongnarrativethatlargefirmscontinuetohavetheabilitytooperatewithinajurisdictionwithoutpayinganap-propriateamountoftax.Workoninterna-tionaltaxreformcontinueswithadditionalproposalsunderdiscussionatEUandOECDlevelastohowdigitalcompaniesaretaxed.WhileanEUleveldigitaltaxappearslesslikely,theproposalscurrentlyunderdiscus-sionatOECDhavewidenedtoencompassthebroadereconomy.Ultimately,anyre-formwhichseekstoallocategreatertaxingrightstousersorcustomerlocationposeschallengesforsmallcountrieslikeIreland.
Irelandhastakensignificantactionsoncorporatetaxoverrecentyearsandhasintroducedmeasures,bothdomestical-lyandaspartofthewiderinternationaleffort,totackletaxevasionandavoidance.TheOECD’sBEPSproject,andtherelatedDirectivesagreedatEUlevel,haveagaindemonstratedthatco-operative,multi-lat-eralagreementsarethemosteffectivemeanstofacilitateinternationaltradeandcounteractcross-bordertaxevasion.Chang-estoIrishcorporatetaxresidencyrulesim-plementedin2014and2015havereducedopportunitiesforaggressivetaxplanning.TheIrishKnowledgeDevelopmentBox,
Econ
omic
Risk
s
![Page 34: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
34
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
AsdiscussedinpreviousNationalRiskAs-sessments,Ireland’seconomyandemploy-mentareheavilyinfluencedbyarelativelysmallnumberofmultinationalcorporations(MNCs),concentratedinafewenterprisesectors.WhilemultinationalinvestmenthasbeentransformativefortheIrisheconomy,thisalsocreatesaparticularvulnerabilitytochangesinIreland’sattractivenessasalocationforthosecompanies,aswellastosector-specificchangesorrisks.
Foreign-ownedmulti-nationalcorporations(MNC’s)areconcentratedinIreland’smostcompetitiveexportsectors,suchasmodernmanufacturingandICT,andaccountforadisproportionatelylargeshareofoutput,value-addedandproductivity7.ThemostrecentavailableCSOdataindicatesthatasmallnumberof‘foreign-ownedMNCdom-inated’sectors8accountedfor39percentoftotalGrossValueAdded(GVA)in20179. Whileononehand,thisevidenceshowshowsuccessfulIrelandhasbeenatattract-ingandretainingFDI,ontheotheritseemstocorrespondwithmuchmoremodestperformanceamongstIrish-ownedfirmsinthesamesectors.
DespiteseveraldecadesofFDI-ledgrowthinIreland,thereareprevailingandincreas-inggapsinGVA,productivity(GVAperemployee)andwagesbyownership,withforeign-ownedenterprisesgenerallyseeingmuchhigherandincreasingproductivityandwages,relativetoIrish-ownedenterprises.Indeed,despiteIreland’sstrongproductivityperformanceinaninternationalcontext,
7Dept.Finance,PatternsofFirmLevelProductivityinIreland,March2018,seelink:https://www.gov.ie/en/publication/975f17-pat-terns-of-firm-level-productivity-in-ireland/
8Theterm‘foreign-ownedMNEdominated’sector–usedfrequentlyinthepaper–referstoagroupofsubsectorswhereforeign-ownedMNEscreatemorethan85percentofthesectorturnover.
9Seelink:https://www.cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/er/gvafm/grossvalueaddedforforeign-ownedmultinationalenterprisesandother-sectorsannualresultsfor2017/
introducedin2015,hasbeenapprovedbytheCodeofConductonBusinessTaxationGroupandtheOECDForumonHarmfulTaxPractices.TheGovernmentpublishedanIndependentReviewoftheCorporationTaxCode4in2017andcarriedoutacon-sultationontheimplementationofsomeofitsrecommendations5.TheDepartmentofFinancepublisheditsCorporationTaxRoadmapinSeptember2018whichlaysoutthenextstepsinIreland’songoingworkoncorporatetaxreform.WorkisalsoprogressingonthetranspositionoftheAnti-TaxAvoidanceDirectives(ATADs),withControlledForeignCompany(CFC)rulesandanewExitTaxintroducedinFinanceAct2018,andapublicconsultationcon-ductedinearly2019onimplementationoftheATADanti-hybridandinterestlimitationmeasures.
ItisimportantthatIreland’staxofferingcontinuestobecompetitiveforfirmsseek-inganEUbaseforoperations,andtoattractanddevelopknowledge-basedinvestmentrelatedtoR&DandIP.Astheinternation-altaxenvironmentischangingrapidly,maintainingagoodreputationhasbecomeincreasinglyimportantforthesustainabilityofcorporationtaxpolicyhereinIreland6.Inthiscontext,andinparallelwithdomesticreformsandrestructuring,itisessentialthattheGovernmentcontinuestobeproac-tiveintheongoinginternationaleffortstoco-ordinatetaxstandards.
3.6. Reliance on multinational corporations and sectoral concentration4 https://www.gov.ie/en/publication/fa53d4-review-of-irelands-cor-poration-tax-code/
5 https://www.gov.ie/en/consultation/47e576-consultation-on-cof-fey-review/
6NationalCompetitivenessCouncil(2017)Ireland’sCompeti-tivenessChallenge2017;http://www.competitiveness.ie/News-Events/2017/Competitiveness%20Challenge%202017.pdf
Econ
omic
Risk
s
![Page 35: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
35
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
cantlyimpactIrelandasasmallopenecon-omyhighlydependentonforeigntradeandinvestment.
Inaddition,thenarrowportfolioofMNCsmaygiverisetonegativespill-overeffectstoothersectorsofthelabourmarket.Industrysectorsthataredominatedbyforeign-ownedenterprisesexhibitedthehighestaverageearningsin2018,andthesesectorsalsodisplayedthehighestshareofnon-Irishworkersinrecentyears.Thereisthepotentialofcrowdingoutofemploy-mentinothersectorsasmorepersonsseekemploymentopportunitiesinMNC-domi-natedsectors.Asthesefirmsaretypicallylocatedwithinasmallnumberofurbanareas,thisriskcouldgiverisetoincreasingpressuresinrentalmarketsandthewiderconstructionsector.Highconcentrationmayalsodampencompetitionandinnova-tion.
ItisworthnotingthatIrishcorporationtaxishighlyconcentrated,withthetop10pay-erscontributingcloseto40percentofthistax.Reflectingthelargenumberofsmallandmicroenterprisesintheeconomy,75percentofcorporationtaxpayerspaidanamountlessthanorequalto€20,000;theseaccountforslightlylessthan2percentoftotalnetcorporationtaxreceipts.Therisingshareofcorporationtaxreceiptswithinoveralltaxation(circa19percentoftotalrevenuein2018)andtheconcentrationofreceiptswithinasmallnumberoffirmspos-esasignificantrisktothepublicfinances11.
The2018performanceofthecorporationtaxheadingwasexceptionallystrongwhichinturnhelpedtooffsetunder-performanc-esinotherheadings.Abouttwofifthsofthisfinalcorporationtaxover-performancewasnotanticipatedonBudgetdaywhichunderscorestheinherentvolatilityofthis
11DepartmentofFinance,AnnualTaxationReport,February2019
researchbytheNationalCompetitivenessCouncil10showsthatmostbusinesseshaveexperiencedadeclineinproductivityinrecentyears.Thenarrowbaseofenterpris-esinhighvalue-addedsectors,andwithinsectors,thereforedisguisesthemajorityofunderperformingfirmswhereproductivitygrowthisstagnantorfalling.Theresearchsuggeststhatthetop10percentoffirmsaccountfor87percentofvalue-addedinmanufacturingand94percentinser-vices;thishighlightsIreland’sexposuretofirm-specificshocks.
ThehighdependenceofIreland’soutputandvalueaddedonFDIpresentsavulner-abilityintermsofhowanchoredforeignmultinationalsaretotheIrisheconomy.Manyoftheforeign-ownedenterprisesthatoperateintheIrisheconomytodayhavealong-standingandsubstantiveinvestmentinIreland.However,Ireland’srelationshipwithFDIislikelytobecomplicatedbytheongoingprocedureofinternationaltaxreformandrisinganti-globalisationandpro-tectionistsentiments,inparticularintheUSandUK(thetwolargestsourcesofFDIinIreland),asdiscussedabove.Thesedevelop-mentspresentarisktothesustainabilityofFDIinIreland,andhighlighttheincreasingexposureoftheIrishpublicfinancestopo-tentiallyvolatilecorporatetaxreceipts.
TherearemanyreasonswhyfirmschoosetoinvestinIreland.However,theEU’sDigitaltaxproposalsforacommonconsol-idatedcorporatetaxbaseandthecurrentdiscussionsforfurtherBEPSreformatOECDhavethepotentialtosignificantlyimpactforeigninvestmentflowsinfuture.Asmentionedabove,theemergenceoftheprospectofatradewarbetweentheworld’slargesteconomiescoulddisruptglobaltradeandinvestmentflows,whichwouldsignifi-
10NationalCompetitivenessCouncil,ProductivityStatement2018,seelink:http://www.competitiveness.ie/Publications/2018/NCC-Productivity-Statement-2018.html
Econ
omic
Risk
s
![Page 36: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
36
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
taxheadingineitherdirection.However,itshouldbenotedthesurgeincorpora-tiontaxreceiptsfrom2015onwardshasoccurredintandemwithasurgeincor-porationprofitabilitysincethen.ThisisverymuchconsistentwithdatafromtheRevenueCommissioners,whichshowthattradingprofits(excludingbalancingcharges)increasedby€63billion(66.5percent)between2014and2016(latestavailabledata).
Whilecorporationtaxincomevolatilityhasbeenpositivetodate,inascenariowhereeconomicgrowthslowsoradverseinter-nationaltaxand/ortradedevelopmentsreducecorporatetaxincome,Ireland’scur-rentfinancescouldencounterdifficulties.Inthiscontext,thereisariskoftheStatebecomingdependentonvolatilesourcesofnationalincome.
Econ
omic
Risk
s
![Page 37: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
4. Social Risks
![Page 38: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
38
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
4.1. Capacity of Higher and Further Education System 4.2. Skilled Labour Shortages 4.3. An Ageing Population including Pensions and Health System Challenges 4.4. Impact of Social Media on Public Debate 4.5. Social Cohesion including Perceptions of Rural and Regional Imbalances 4.6. Migration and Integration
4.1. Capacity of Higher and Further Education System Anadequatelyresourced,flexible,responsiveandalignedHigherEducation(HE)andFur-therEducation&TrainingsystemhasacrucialroletoplayinsustainingenterprisegrowthinIreland.Skillsaretheglobalcurrencyof21stcenturyeconomies,andmanycountriesareplacingamajorfocusontalentdevelopmentandinvestmentineducationandtraining.ResearchcommissionedbytheIrishUniversi-tiesAssociation(IUA),andpublishedinApril20191,foundthattheIrisheconomybenefit-tedby€8.9billionlastyearfromIreland’ssev-enuniversities,withtheuniversitiesgenerat-ing€386millionperannuminexportearningsand€1.5billioninR&Dimpacts.
Ireland’sHigherEducationInstitutions(HEIs)havebeencentraltodifferentiatingIreland’stalentpoolinaninternationalcontext,aidingtheestablishmentofasuccessfulentrepre-neurshipecosystem,growingindigenousmultinationalenterprises,andcontinuedattractivenessforforeigndirectinvestment.Ensuringthisalignmentbetweenenterpriseskillsneedsandgraduateoutputhelpsdrivein-firmproductivity,innovationandultimatelythecompetitivenessoftheIrisheconomy.
AnydiminutioninresourcesfortheHEsector
1 IndeconInternationalEconomicConsultants;https://saveourspark.ie/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/Delivering_for_Ireland_An_Impact_As-sessment_of_Irish_Universities_2019.pdf
would,however,poseachallengetothiscontinuedrole,placingasitwouldastrainonthesector’spotentialtorespondwithflexibilityandagilitytotheevolvingskillsneedsoftheeconomy-includingtotherequiredscale-aswellasthesupportingroleplayedbyIndustry-Academiacollabora-tionindrivingtheinnovationofindigenousandforeign-ownedenterprises,andinturntheabilityofIrish-basedfirmstocompeteinoverseasmarkets.
Recentyearshaveseenaworryingdown-wardtrendofIrishuniversitiesinglobalrankings,attributedmainlytopost-reces-sionunder-investmentinthesector,andanincreaseinstudentenrolmentnumbers2. Therehasalsobeenasignificantincreaseinthenumberofstudentsenrollingforauniversityeducation,withover120,000studentsenrollingin2017,up40percentfrom20083.
NotwithstandingthatsignificantprogresshasbeenmadeinrecentbudgetsinincreasinginvestmentinHEaswellasotherdevelopmentssuchasanewHuman
2 Itshouldbenotedthatwhilerankingscanimpactoninternationalperceptionsofuniversities,theyrepresentaperceptionofqualityinthesectoronly.
3 AsperHigherEducationAuthoritystatistics,availableat:https://hea.ie/statistics-archive/
Soci
al R
isks
![Page 39: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
39
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
theoverallparticipationratehascontinuedtobebroadlyflatsince2011andisatthesamelevelastheparticipationrateintheearly2000s.Inaddition,whilesourcinginternationaltalentwillalsobenecessarytoovercomecapacityconstraintsintheshortterm,inthepost-recessionworlditislikelytobemoredifficulttoattractforeigntalent.Irelandmustcompetewithothercountriestoattractbothhighandintermediatelevelskilledlabour.
RisksaroundskillsshortagesintheareaofDigital/ICTareparticularlypertinent.Theavailabilityofappropriateskillsfordevel-oping,implementingandusingICT,aswellasgeneralDigitalskills,areanimportantconditionforthecompetitivenessandinnovationcapabilityoftheIrisheconomy.ThestrongEuropeancompetitionforskills,especiallyinaregionwherethereisfreemovementoflabour,makesitimportantforIrelandtodevelop,attractandretaintherighthighlevel,andintermediatelevelDigitalandICTskillstosatisfythedemandacrosstheIrisheconomy.ItislikewiseimperativeforIrelandtobeabletocontin-uetoattractandservetheR&Dactivities,hightechmanufacturingandglobalservicescompaniesthatareimportantforIreland’seconomicgrowth.
Theeducationandtrainingsystem,encom-passingboththeHEsectorandFurtherEducationandTrainingSector,willplayacrucialroleintacklingexistingandemergingskillsneeds,providingeducation,trainingandskillsdevelopmentopportunitiestonewentrantsaswellasongoingupskillingandreskillingofexistinglabourmarketparticipants.Inadditiontotheriskstojobsfromautomation,thenewdigitalworldofworkwillalsocreatejobsnoteventhoughtoftoday.Weneedtoensureoureducationandtrainingsystemissufficientlyadaptable,andappropriatelyresourced,tomeetthe
CapitalInitiative4,thereisariskaroundfailingtosustaintheselevelsofre-invest-mentinfuturebudgetarycycles,toensurethequalityoftheHEsectorismaintained,andtoaccommodatethestrongdemo-graphicgrowththatispredicted.Recentlypublishedstatisticsestimatethatdemandforthirdlevelplaceswillincreaseeachyearupto2030,risingfromthebaselevelof184,000(in2017)topeakatover220,000studentsby2030.Thecontinuedre-invest-mentinHE,combinedwiththedevelop-mentofalonger-termsustainablefundingmodel,willbenecessaryinordertocontin-uetoaidthegrowthandqualityofourHEsystemintheyearsahead.
TheDepartmentofEducationandSkillsiscurrentlyengagedinaproceduretoidentifyamoresustainablefundingmodelforHEintheyearstocome,includinganeconomicanalysisofthethreepolicyoptionsidenti-fiedbytheExpertGrouponFutureFundingin2016.ThisanalysiswillassisttheJointOireachtasCommitteeonEducationandSkillsintryingtobuildpoliticalconsensusaroundthemostappropriatefuturefundingmodelforhighereducation.
4.2. Skilled Labour Shortages Astheeconomycontinuestoexpand,in-creasingtheparticipationrateandsourcingskilledinternationaltalentwillbeimportantsupplementsnecessaryinthecontextofgrowinglabourmarketdemandaswellasexistingskillsshortagesinspecificareas.DespiteIreland’srecoveryinthelabourmarket,theparticipationratecontinuestobebelowits2007peaklevel5andinfact,
4 Budget2019alsoannouncedanewHumanCapitalInitiativethatwillinvolveinvestmentof€300millioninhighereducationoverthe5yearperiodfrom2020to2024,with€60millionbeingmadeavailableineachofthoseyears.
5 ESRIQuarterlyEconomicCommentary,Winter2018.Seelink:https://www.esri.ie/system/files/media/file-uploads/2018-12/QEC2018WIN.pdf
Soci
al R
isks
![Page 40: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
40
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
continuetogrow8.Thesecondisthatthedependencyratio-i.e.,theratioofpersonsunder15andover65topersonsofworkingage(15-64)-willincreaseintothefuture,intheabsenceofimprobablylargeimmi-grationofpeopleofworkingage,whichwillimpactonareassuchaseducation,childincomesupports,healthcare,long-termcare,transport,employment,housingandpensionprovision.Eachofthesewillbeanareaofacuteconcernbutpensions,andchallengesforthehealthsystemmaybeamongthemostserious.
TheEuropeanCommissionestimatesthatpension-relatedexpenditurewillincreaseby4percentageofGDPpointsby2070,whentakingonlydemographicfactorsintoaccount9.WhileIrelandhasacomparativelyyoungpopulationrelativetootherEurope-ancountries,itneverthelessfacesthesamelonger-termageingchallenges.AleadingissueinthisregardisthesustainabilityandcoverageofpensionsinIreland.Statepen-sionsaccountforthesinglelargestblockofsocialwelfareexpenditure,andtheIrishpensionsystemfacesmultiple-veryseriousdemographic,adequacyandsustainabilitychallenges.Thetaskoffinancingincreasingpensionspendingwillfalltoadiminishingshareofthepopulationasprojectionsindi-catetheratioofpeopleofworkingagetoeverypersonagedoverStatepensionagewillreducefromitscurrentrateof4.9:1to2.3:1overthenext40years.ThispresentssignificantfundingchallengeswiththeSo-cialInsuranceFundforecasttoaccumulateapotentialdeficitofupto€335bn10 over thenextfiftyyears.Notwithstandingthe
8 TheCentralStatisticsOfficeestimatesthatthenumberofpeopleagedover65willalmosttrebleto1.45millionpeoplebetween2011and2046.
9 EuropeanCommission(2019)EuropeanSemesterCountryReportIreland.Availablehere:https://ec.europa.eu/info/sites/info/files/file_import/2019-european-semester-country-report-ireland_en.pdf
10 DepartmentofEmploymentAffairsandSocialProtection2017ActuarialReviewoftheSocialInsuranceFund2015.Availablehere:http://www.welfare.ie/en/downloads/actrev311215.pdf
needsofthefuture.
Continuedinvestmenttodeveloptalentandskillstomeetemergingskillsneedsisthere-foreimportant.ThisisparticularlyevidentintermsofthefullimplementationofProjectIreland2040,toensureadditionaleconomiccostsarenotincurredfromcapacityissuesinthiscontext.Thereisaneedtocontinuecooperationbetweenprovidersandem-ployerstoensurethattrainingismeetingemergingskillsneeds.
4.3. An Ageing Population including pensions and health system challenges
Irelandfacessignificantrisksintermsofanageingpopulation.Theshareofpopulationaged65andoverisprojectedtoincreasefromoneineighttooneinsixby2030,andthenumberofpeopleaged85andoverisprojectedtoalmostdouble6.Olderageco-hortstendtobethehighestusersofmosthealthandsocialservicesandhavemorecomplicatedcareneeds.TheresultsfromCensus2016showthatIreland’spopulationincreasedfrom4.588millionin2011to4.762millionin2016.Thenaturalpopula-tionincreasewas196,100withnetoutwardmigrationestimatedat22,5007.Planningfordemographicchangesinthepopulationsoresourcesandservicescanbedirectedwhereneededisdifficult,andtheuncertain-tiesassociatedwithBrexitwillonlyaccen-tuatethisproblem.
Notwithstandingtheuncertaintiesassociat-edwithpopulationprojections,tworelatedissuesarehighlyprobable.Thefirstisthatthenumberofpeopleagedover65will
6 ESRI,2017.Availablehere:https://www.esri.ie/system/files?file=-media/file-uploads/2018-02/RS67.pdf
7 CentralStatisticsOffice(2016)Census2016SummaryResults–Part1(Dublin:CSO).
Soci
al R
isks
![Page 41: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
41
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
ofpeopleinolderagecohortswillcreatesignificantadditionaldemandforarangeofhealthandsocialcareservices,includingnursinghomecare,homecare,andmedi-cines.
Inthecontextofthehealthsystem,IrishhealthexpenditurecontinuestobewellabovetheOECDaverage,notwithstand-ingouryoungpopulation13.AccordingtotheEuropeanCommission’s2018AgeingReport,long-termcareexpenditurewillseeanincreaseby1.9percentagepointsofIrishGDPbetween2016and2070,withanincreaseof1percentagepointofGDPforhealthcarespending,bothaboveEUaverageexpendituregrowth.
Futurehealthcaredemandandthecostofhealthcareprovisionwillbeimpactedbyavarietyoffactorsincludingdemographics;increasingincidenceofnon-communicablediseases(i.e.heartdisease,stroke,diabetes,cancer,chroniclungdisease,anddemen-tia);lifestyleriskfactors;changestomodesofhealthcaredelivery(e.g.ambulatoryemergencycarereducingadmissionsfromEmergencyDepartments,shifttodaycasesurgery);availabilityofnewdrugsandothertechnologicaldevelopments;changesinthesocio-economicstructureofthepopulation(educationlevel,income,employment)andchangesinpeople’sexpectationsofhealthservices;proportionofthepopulationwithprivatehealthinsurance;andsupply-in-duceddemand(e.g.additionalfundingallocatedtoserviceprovision).
Themajorchronicdiseasesofcardiovas-culardisease,cancer,diabetesandchroniclungdiseasealreadyaccountforasignif-icantproportionofhealthcareactivity,including40percentofhospitaladmissions
13 HousesoftheOireachtas(2017)IrishHealthExpenditure:thecomparativecontext,availableat:https://www.oireachtas.ie/parliament/media/housesoftheoireachtas/libraryresearch/lrsnotes/Irish-health-expenditure---the-comparative-context.pdf
gradualincreaseinStatepensionagefrom65in2010to68in2028,itisestimatedthatthenumberofpersonsatStatepensionageandolderwillmorethandoublefrom586,000in2015,to1,402,000by2055.
Inaddition,Irelandalsohasaverylowlevelofprivatepensioncoverage,withapprox-imatelyonly35percentoftheprivatesector-employedpopulationcoveredbyasupplementarypension.Thissuggeststhatahighpercentageoftheworkingpopulationisnotsavingenough,orisnotsavingatall,forretirement,reflectingasignificantriskbothintermsofthefundingandsustain-abilityofpensionsinIreland.
Ariskalsoexistsinhowourworkplaceswilladaptandencourageolderpeopletocon-tinueparticipatingintheworkforce.Whilstasignificantnumberofpeoplefeelretire-mentcomestooearlyandwishtocontinuetowork,itislikelythatthiscohortmayrequirespecificassistanceoradaptations.Olderpeoplemaywishtoreducelevelsofresponsibilityorworkpatternsintheirroles,andthiswillrequirean“AgeFriendly”approachbyemployerstoutiliseandenablethiscohorteffectively.Employedpeopleover50arelesslikelytoavailoforhaveaccesstolifelonglearningopportunities;lessthanoneintenpeople(8.0percent)aged50+participateininformaleducationandtraining11.Reducedopportunitytomaintainandincreaseskillslevelswillalsoreducethelikelihoodofolderpeoplestay-ingintheworkforcebeyondthetraditionalretirementage.Whiletheemploymentrateforadultsaged50-64hasincreasedintheyears2014-2016,theemploymentratefor65+continuestobeeven12.
Thesignificantincreaseinthenumber
11 Healthy&PositiveAgeingInitiative–PositiveAgeingNationalIndicatorsReport(2016)
12 Healthy&PositiveAgeingInitiative–PositiveAgeingNationalIndicatorsReport(2016)
Soci
al R
isks
![Page 42: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
42
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
ofhowbillionsofpeoplearoundtheglobeconnectandcommunicate.Whilesocialme-diaplatformsoffermanybenefits,therela-tivelackofoversightofbothsocialmediausersandtheirdatahasledtoagreaterriskofthespreadingofdisinformationorso-called‘fakenews’,withassociatedchalleng-esforandrisksaroundregulatorysystemsreadilyapparent.Thetargetingofsocialme-diauserswithpoliticaladvertisementsandsponsorednewsstoriestoinfluencetheirbeliefs,opinionsandpossiblyvotinginten-tions,forexample,isofconsiderablecon-cern.Balancedandrepresentativediscourseanddebateisvitaltoensuretheintegrityofanyreferendumorelectoralprocess.Thereisalsoariskthatthemultiplicityofinforma-tionplatformscouldleadtomorepolarisedsocietalviewpoints.
Large-scaledisinformation15or‘fakenews’campaignsspreadonlinebymaliciousactorsareahigh-riskissueforsocietyglobally,includingIreland.Thereisinternationalconsensusthattheriskofpublicharmissubstantialwhenonlinedisinformationisdesignedtoinfluencepublicdebateonpoliticalissuesandattempttoinfluenceormanipulatetheoutcomeofelectoralprocesses.Amajordriverofthisriskisthatlargenumbersofcitizensnowgettheirnewsfromsocialmediaplatforms;thishasclearimplicationsforthegenerationandpotentialimpactofonlinedisinformationandhowitisrapidlydisseminated.Resultsofa2018EurobarometerSurveyindicatethatlevelsofawarenessoftheriskarehighinIreland-81percentofIrishinternetuserswerefoundtobeconcernedaboutdisinformationormisinformationonline
15DisinformationisdefinedbytheEUas:“…Verifiablyfalseormisleadinginformationthatiscreated,presentedanddisseminatedforeconomicgainortointentionallydeceivethepublic,andmaycausepublicharm.Publicharmcomprisesthreatstodemocraticpoliticalandpolicy-makingprocessesaswellaspublicgoodssuchastheprotectionofEUcitizens’health,theenvironmentorsecurity.Disinformationdoesnotincludereportingerrors,satireandparody,
orclearlyidentifiedpartisannewsandcommentary.”
and75percentofhospitalbeddays.Inad-dition,thepopulationwithlifelongdisabilitywhoareageingisalsoincreasing,leadingtoadditionaldemandforresidentialcareplaces,andtoincreasingcomplexityandcostofcareforthosereceivingdisabilityservices14.Some60percentofthoseagedover50reporthavingatleastonechroniccondition.Thelevelofmulti-morbidityisincreasingwith18percentofadultsover50havingtwoormorechronicconditions.Itisestimatedthatwithinthenextdecade,thenumberofadultswithchronicdiseaseswillincreasebyaround40percent,withrelativelymoreoftheconditionsaffectingthoseintheolderagegroups.Theeconomicburdenofhealthcareexpenditureregardingchronicdiseasesisconsiderable,notonlyforthehealthsystembutalsointermsoffamiliesandsocietyasaresultofreducedincome,earlyretirement,anincreasedreli-anceonsocialcareandwelfaresupportanddiminishedproductivityandabsenteeism.
Atthesametime,therearedifficultiesattractingandretainingsuitablyqualifiedhealthcareworkerstomeetdemand.Ourworkforceisageing,with21percentaged55yearsorover.TheEuropeanCommissionhasestimatedapotentialshortfall,withintheEU,ofaround1millionhealthworkersby2020.Globaldevelopmentsintechnol-ogywillalsoimpactonourworkforcewithunpredictableconsequences,includingthepotentialfornewrolesandskilldevelop-mentbutalsotheautomationandredun-dancyofotherroles.
4.4. Impact of Social Media on Public Debate
Socialmediahasbecomeanintegralpart
14 WorkingGroup1,TransformingLives(2018)ReportonFutureNeedforDisabilityServices.DepartmentofHealth.https://health.gov.ie/wp-content/uploads/2018/06/Working-Group-1-Report-on-future-need-for-disability-services.pdf
Soci
al R
isks
![Page 43: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
43
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
responsesarecomprehensive,continuouslyassessthephenomenonofdisinformation,andadjustpolicyobjectivesinlightofitsevolution.
RecognitionatanEUlevelofthesignif-icantthreatofonlinedisinformationtodemocracyisalsoclear,asevidencedbyvariouscountermeasuresbeingprogressed,includinganActionPlanagainstDisinfor-mation,launchedinDecember2018,whichsetsoutmeasurestotackledisinformationinacoordinatedapproachamongtheEUinstitutionsandincooperationwithMem-berStates.MeasuresincludeaRapidAlertSystem(RAS)–aninformation-sharingmechanismondisinformationactivities;anEU-widevoluntaryCodeofPracticeonDis-information;andsupportinganindependentnetworkoffact-checkers,medialiteracyinitiativesandtoolstopromotequalityjournalism.
Inthecontextofdataprotection,thedisclosureofharvestingofthird-partydataanditsuseintargetingcertaingroupsandcohorts,aswellasongoinginvestigationsandcommentaryinboththeUSandUKaroundelectionmanipulationbythirdpar-ties(includingforeignactors),underlinetheneedbothforgreaterprotectionofcitizens’privacyrights,andgreatertransparencyfromorganizationsonhowtheyareusinganypersonaldatatheycollect.TheGeneralDataProtectionRegulation(GDPR),whichcameintoeffectacrosstheEuropeanUnionin2018,isdesignedtoachievethesegoals.Inaddition,theDataProtectionAct2018includesaprovisiontolimitthescopeofanyprocessingofpersonaldatarevealingpoliticalopinionstopreventmisuse.
Thesewiderconcernsalsoraisebroad-erquestionsaroundthesustainabilityoftraditionalmedia,whichhavebeenviewedhithertoascustodiansofthepublicinterest,
duringthepre-electionperiod16.
Asignificantnumberofrecentelectioncam-paignsacrossEuropeandelsewherehavebeencharacterisedbysubstantivereportsofapparentdeliberateattemptstomanip-ulateoutcomesusingavarietyofdifferentmeansincludingonlinedisinformation.Incertainjurisdictions,officialinvestigationsintosuchallegedactivitiescontinuestobeongoing.
Irelandisalsovulnerabletothisrisk,aswasseen,forexample,duringthereferenduminMay2018ontheThirty-sixthAmendmentoftheConstitutionBill2018.TheTrans-parentReferendumInitiative(TRI)17builtapublic,searchabledatabaseofpoliticaladsbeingtargetedatIrishvotersrelatedtothereferendumandinformationonthesocialmediaaccountspromotingthem,andfoundthatadsfromuntraceablegroupswereusedto‘misleadvoters,discreditpoliticalfiguresandgroups,mimicofficialorneutralinfor-mationsources,gathervoterdataandsharedisturbingimages’.18InitsfirstpublishedRe-port,theInterdepartmentalGroup(IDG)ontheSecurityofIreland’sElectoralProcessandDisinformationfoundthatwhileriskstotheelectoralprocessinIrelandarerelative-lylow,takingintoaccountthemitigatingfactorsalreadyinplace,amoresubstantialriskisposedbythespreadofdisinforma-tiononlineandtheriskofcyber-attacksontheelectoralsystem.ThisisinlinewithEUfindingsandrecentinternationalexperi-ence.Giventherapidpaceoftechnologicalchange,itisthereforeimportantthatpolicy
16SpecialEurobarometer477DemocracyandElections,EuropeanUnion,2018.p.56;http://ec.europa.eu/commfrontoffice/publi-copinion/index.cfm/survey/getsurveydetail/instruments/special/surveyky/2198
17TheTRIisavolunteer-led,civicinitiativethatwasestablishedtoadvocateforincreasedtransparencyofdigitaladvertisingduringelectoralcampaignsinIreland.Seehttp://tref.ie/
18 PolicyProposalsforregulatingonlineadvertising-TransparentReferendumInitiative–June2018https://docs.google.com/docu-ment/d/1zGdjWuilY9gms7NkHjYRXyYbR7Vdn3OzBeCGrg8uRvQ/edit
Soci
al R
isks
![Page 44: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
44
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
befurtherexacerbatedbytheroleofsocialmediainpublicdebate,discussedfurtherinSection6.3.Conversely,inthecontextofsocialmedia,thereispotentialforanin-creasingsenseofisolationandexclusionforthosewhomaynothavethenecessaryre-sourcesorskillsintermsofaccesstosocialmediaandservicesdeliveredonline,againwitharuraldimensionintheIrishcontext.
InIreland,taxationandsocialtransferpoli-cieshavebeeneffectiveinoffsettingmarketincomeinequality.In2017,transfersre-ducedtheat-risk-of-povertyratefrom32.3percentto15.7percent,apovertyreduc-tioneffectof51.4percent.IrelandisoneofthebestperformingEUmemberstatesinthisregard,underliningtheeffectivenessofsocialtransferpoliciesandtaxationinoffsettingincomeinequality21.Similarly,thequintileshareratio,i.e.theratiobetweentotalincomesreceivedbythetop20percentofearnerscomparedtothebottom20percentofearners,stoodat4.8in201722,slightlyabovethe2016figureof4.7.Thisfigureis,however,downfrom5.1in2012attheheightoftheeconomicdownturn.Inrecentyearstherehasbeensomeimprove-mentinmeasuresofpovertyandinequality,withtheGinicoefficient23fordisposablein-comefallingbelowtheEUaveragein2015,andfallingfurtherin2016to29.3(Figure1below).Nonetheless,measuresofconsistentpovertyremainedsubstantiallyabovethetargetssetfor2020anddespitetheconsid-erableimpactofsocialtransfersonpoverty,socialtransfersalonewillnotresolveissuesofincomedistributionandinequality.Migration,discussedinSection4.5below,
21 http://cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/er/silc/surveyoninco-meandlivingconditions2016/
22 https://www.cso.ie/en/releasesandpublications/ep/p-silc/sur-veyonincomeandlivingconditionssilc2017/introductionandsummary-ofresults/
23 TheGinicoefficientmeasurestheextenttowhichthedistribu-tionofincomeamongindividualsorhouseholdswithinaneconomydeviatesfromaperfectlyequaldistribution.AGinicoefficientofzerorepresentsperfectequality.
andtheirrolebothinIrelandandglobally.Athriving,independentmediaisessentialtoahealthysociety,especiallyinthisincreasing-lyonlineera,whereriskstotraditionalprintmediaandtheiraudiencesandreadershiplevelsarebecomingincreasinglyapparent.
4.5. Social cohesion including Perceptions of Rural and Regional Imbalances
Themostrecentrecession,andtheconse-quentneedtostabilisethepublicfinanceshasraisedconcerns,airedinothercountriesalso,aboutincomedistributionandinequal-ity.AccordingtotheOECD,growingin-comeinequalitycanhaveanegativeeffectonsocialcohesionandimpedeeconomicgrowth19.TheOECDhassaidthateconomicrecoverysince2010intheOECDareahasnotledtoinclusivegrowth,andhasnotreversedthetrendofincreasingincomeinequality20.
Asdiscussedabove(Section2.3),theglobaltrendofrisingpopulismandanti-estab-lishmentsentiment,evidentinFrance,Poland,HungaryandAustriaamongoth-ers,isfurthercontributingtorisksaroundthiserosionofsocialcohesionandtrustininstitutions.Thisinternationalpopulismcanbeseenaspartlyrootedingreatdivides,suchasthosebasedonage,geographyandwealth,aswellasaphenomenonofincreas-ingurbanisation.
Inlinewithdevelopmentsinothercoun-tries,weareseeingincreasingperceptionsofregionalandruralimbalancesinIreland.Issuesarisingfromgrowinginequality,cou-pledwithariseinpopulismandperceptionsofregionalorgeographicdifferences,may
19 OECD(2015)InitTogether:WhyLessInequalityBenefitsAll(Paris:OECD).
20 OECDIncomeInequalityUpdate(Paris:OECD)http://www.oecd.org/social/OECD2016-Income-Inequality-Update.pdfb
Soci
al R
isks
![Page 45: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
45
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
introducedtodealwiththisintheformoftheEmployment(MiscellaneousProvisions)Act201824.
Anotherconsequenceoftherecentre-cessioninIrelandwasadamagingeffectonpublictrust.TheOECDnotesthatthedeclineofpeople’strustininstitutionsintheaftermathoftheglobalfinancialcrisishasbeena“keypolicyconcern”inrecentyears.Furthermore,lowerpublictrustininstitutionslimitsthecapacityofGovern-mentstoimplementtheirpolicies,andhasbeenlinkedtoincreasingdissatisfactionwithdemocracy.25Thereportalsoreflectstheextenttowhichthepopulationfeelsithasasayinwhatgovernmentdoes.Accord-ingtothereport,IrelandisbelowtheOECDaverageintermsofthepercentageoftheworking-agepopulationwhofeelthattheyhaveasayinwhatthegovernmentdoes26. The2019EdelmanIrelandTrustBarome-
24 TheEmployment(MiscellaneousProvisions)Act2018wassignedintolawon25December2018.
25 OECDHow’sLife2017https://read.oecd-ilibrary.org/economics/how-s-life-2017_how_life-2017-en#page186
26 OECDHow’sLife2017https://read.oecd-ilibrary.org/economics/how-s-life-2017_how_life-2017-en#page185
canbeanotherfactorandpotentialchal-lengeconcerningtheerosionofsocialcohe-sion.ThecontinuedsuccessfulintegrationofsecondandthirdgenerationimmigrantsinIrelandwillbeimportantinensuringthatriskdoesnotmaterialiseinanIrishcontext.Socialgroupsthatcontinuetobedispropor-tionatelyaffectedbypovertyincludejoblesshouseholds,thoselivinginsocialhousing(oftenassociatedwithspatialconcentrations)andlone-parenthouseholds(mainlyfe-male-headed)acrossthelifecycle,withchil-drenmorelikelytobeinpovertythanadults.Eurofound,OECD,ILO,NESCandtheESRIhaveallcommentedonthefactthattherouteoutofsocialexclusionispromotionforindividualstobeinwork,andthatenhancedtrainingandeducationcanbebeneficialinachievingthis.Althoughthelabourmarkethasseensignificantrecoveryinrecentyears,riskspersistinthisareaintermsofaccesstoandthequalityofwork.Accesstostableemploymentcontinuestobeachallenge,inparticularforyoungpeople,andtheuseoftemporaryandprecariousemploymentpracticesbyindustryalsocontinuestobeaconcern,althoughlegislationhasbeen
Soci
al R
isks
Figure 1: Gini coefficient Ireland versus EU, 2010-2016
Source:Eurostat
![Page 46: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
46
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
riskofreducedsocialcohesion.Inlinewithdevelopmentsinothercountries,forex-ampleincludingBrexit-relateddiscourseintheUK,andsimilartrendsintheUS,publicdiscourseinIrelandexhibitssignsthatthisperceptionexists,andthisriskmustthere-forebemanagedandmitigatedbyincreas-ingpublicawarenessthroughclear,positive,andevidence-basedmessaging.
Inaddition,andasmentionedaboveintheEconomicRiskssection,inthecontextoftheeconomicimpactsofBrexit,weknowthatsomesectorswillbeharderhitthanothers,andthatforthesesectors–theagri-foodandfisheries,andindigenousmanu-facturingsectors–theirregionalspreadismoreconcentratedinruralregions,whichhavehadacomparativelyslowerpost-crisisrecoverythantheDublinregion.Asdis-cussedinSection6.2onDisruptiveTech-nologies,astudybytheESRIfoundthatataregionallevel,Dublinistheregionatleastriskfromautomation(2percentathighrisk,mainlyinRetailandHospitalitysectors),whiletheMidlandsregion(5percentathighriskand64percentatmediumrisk)andBorderregion(5percentathighriskand62percentatmediumrisk)aretheregions’mostatrisk.Inaddition,actionsneededtotackleclimatechangecouldpotentiallyimpactmoreadverselyonruralandregionalareasoverthecomingyears.ThedifferinglevelsofimpactfromBrexit,ClimateChange,andotherrisksonregional,ruralandGaeltachtareas,mustthereforeremaintotheforefrontaswetacklethesechallenges.
4.6. Migration and integration
Migrationhasbecomeoneofthemostcontentiousandcontestedissuesinpoliticaldebatesacrossmanycountriesinrecentyears.ItplayedasignificantroleintheUK’s
terfindsthatthemediaistheleasttrustedinstitutioninIreland,mainlydrivenbyadistrustinsocialmedia(27percent)ratherthantraditionalmedia(67percent),how-evertrusthasrisenslightlysince2018.ThemosttrustedinstitutionsinIrelandareNGOs,whichalsosawamodestriseintrustsince2018.Globally,trustinemployershasrisento75percent,whichissharedbyIrishrespondentstothesurveyas69percentofIrishemployeeshavetrustintheiremploy-er.WhiletrustinGovernment,themedia,andNGOsrosebetween2018and2019,trustinbusinessdecreasedmarginally,andIrelandisamong20ofthe28countriessurveyedwhodisplayedoveralldistrustininstitutions.TheTrustBarometeralsohigh-lightsthat64percentofpeoplesurveyedinIrelandareworriedaboutfakenewsbeingusedasaweapon.Overall,theEdelmanreportnotesthatdistrustisatarecordhighglobally27.
Asmentioned,thereisanincreasedrisktosocialcohesion,andofunderminingtheworkdoneinrecentyearsinthisarea,shouldperceptionsofruralandregionalimbalancepersistorincrease.Inagrowingeconomy,therecanbeaperceptionthatruralandregionalareasarenotbenefittingequallyfromtheeconomicprosperitytakingplace,includingjobcreation.Therecanbeaperceptionofafocusonjobcreationwithincertaincities,andthereforethattherecoveryandbenefitismoreurbancentric,withinvestmentinlargerinfrastructureprojectslocatedintheseurbanareas,tothedetrimentofruralcommunities.Whetherthisperceptionisarealitycanbechal-lengedbyevidence.However,thepercep-tionitself,whichcanbestronglyfelt,canleadtoareducedconfidenceofruralandregionaldwellersandentrepreneurs,andcanthereforecontributetoanincreased
27 Edelman2019TrustBarometerhttps://www.edelman.com/sites/g/files/aatuss191/files/2019-02/2019_Edelman_Trust_Barom-eter_Global_Report_2.pdf
Soci
al R
isks
![Page 47: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
47
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
referendumonBrexit,ithasfuelledtheriseofextremenationalistpoliticalpartiesinsomecountriesandithascausedothercountriestore-establishsomeformofbor-dercontrolswithinEurope.EventhoughIre-land’slocationinEuropemeansthattodateithasnotfeltadirectimpactfrommanyofthesepressures,thisshouldnotinducecomplacencyabouttheissuesthatmigra-tionandintegrationcangenerate,particu-larlyinthecontextofcontinuingpressuresfromtheMediterraneanandAfrica,andthesheervolumesseekingtomigrateintotheEU.
Inaddition,asmentionedinSection1.1above,BrexitintroducesnewpotentialrisksaroundimmigrationincludinganincreaseinillegalmovementofthirdcountrynationalsintoIrelandfromtheUK,aswellaslegaldivergencepossibilitiesregardingasylummatters.AsBrexitevolvestheremayalsobesignificantlabourmarketimplicationsforIreland.Togiveoneexample,theexpansionoftheconstructionsectorinIrelandmayat-tractmanyEasternEuropeanConstructionworkerscurrentlybasedintheUK.ThishasbothpositiveandnegativeimplicationsforIreland,dependingonthescaleofimmigra-tionofsuchworkersfromtheUK.
Intermsofinternalintegrationrisks,Irelandhaschangedfromanethnicallyhomoge-neoussocietytoamuchmoremulti-ethniconeinslightlyoverageneration,atrans-formationreflectedinruralaswellasurbancommunities.Census2016showsthat810,406peopleor17.3percentofthepopulationwerebornoutsidetheState(thisfigureincludespeopleofIrishnationalitywhowerebornoutsidetheState,includ-inginNorthernIreland),andthat535,475peopleor11.6percentofthepopulation-donotholdIrishnationality28.Whilethis
28 CentralStatisticsOffice(2016)Census2016SummaryResults–Part1(Dublin:CSO).
representsasmalldecreaseonthe2011Census29,itrepresentsanincreaseofalmost139percentinthenumberofpeoplewithoutIrishnationalitysince2002,thefirsttimetheCensusincludedaquestiononnationality30.
Thisbringswithitaneedtoberesponsivetothechangingnatureofsociety,forexam-pleintermsoftheneedsofanowmultilin-gualsocietyandthepotentialforlanguagetobecomeabarrierinaccessingGovern-mentcommunicationsandservices.
Structuralrisks,includingbarrierstomi-grantsaccessingemploymentorprogress-ingwithintheworkplace,therebycreatingpotentialsocialexclusion,andincreasedincidencesofracismagainstmigrantcom-munities,havebeenidentifiedbynumeroussources.TheseincludereportsbytheEco-nomicandSocialResearchInstitute(ESRI)andtheEuropeanAgencyforFundamentalHumanRights(FRA),theMigrantIntegra-tionStrategyMonitoringandCoordinationCommittee,GovernmentDepartmentsandstakeholders.IrelandhasaMigrantInte-grationStrategy(2017-2020),ledbytheDepartmentofJusticeandEquality,whichdefinestheactionstobetakenonintegra-tionduringthatperiod.
TheincreaseintheimmigrantpopulationinIrelandhashappenedinaveryshorttimeandwithoutanyoftheupheavalthathasoccurredinothercountrieswithsuchdra-maticmovementsofthepopulation.Failuretomaintainthislevelofcohesion,especiallyassecondandthirdgenerationmigrantcommunitiesemerge,representsasignicantriskofnegativeconsequencessimilartothoseexperiencedbyothercountries.
29 The2011Censusshowedthat544,357people,or12percentofthepopulation,didnothaveIrishnationality
30 Inthe2002Census,224,261peoplewererecordedasnothavingIrishnationality.
Soci
al R
isks
![Page 48: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
48
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 49: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
49
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 50: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
5. Environmental Risks
![Page 51: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
51
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
5.1. Climate Change & Biodiversity 5.2. Ensuring an affordable, sustainable and diverse energy supply 5.3. Delivery of Public Infrastructure 5.4. Food safety 5.5. Supply and Affordability of Housing
5.1. Climate Change & Biodiversity
ObservationsshowthatIreland’sclimateischangingandtheobservedscaleandrateofchangeisconsistentwithregionalandglobaltrends.ThemostimmediateriskstoIrelandwhichcanbeinfluencedbyclimatechangearepredominantlythoseassociatedwithchangesinextremes,suchasfloods,precipitationandstorms.However,futureimpactsofclimatechangearealsopredictedtoincludesealevelrise;watershortagesinsummer;wildfires;andadverseimpactsonwaterquality.Indeed,sealevelriseisalreadybeingobservedandisprojectedtocontinuetoriseintothefuture,whichwillincreasebothfloodanderosionrisktoourcoastalcommunitiesandinfrastructuralassets,aswellasthreatencoastalsqueezeofinter-tidalhabitats.Inaddition,itisprojectedthatthenumberofheavyrainfalldaysperyearmayincrease,whichcouldleadtoanincreaseinfloodingincidents.Someeffectsofclimatechangeareinevitableandincreasedsevereweatherposesarisktolives,livelihoods,prop-ertyandenvironments.Itwillbevitaltotakeprudentprecautionarystepsnowtobuildre-silienceintooursocietyandsystems,shoreupvulnerabilitiesanddevelopstrategiestocopewithconditionsthatmayariseinthefuture.
TherearesignificantthreatstoIreland’sbiodiversity,withtheBiodiversityIndicatorSurveyfor2017statingthat91percentofourhabitatsdesignatedunderEUlaware
“inadequate”orof“bad”status1,andtrendsinthestatusofthreatenedspecies,insectsandbirdsallregisteringasatintermediaterisk.Headlineresultsfromthe2018Liv-ingPlanetReport,publishedbytheWorldWildlifeFund,revealthatEarthiscurrentlylosingbiodiversityatarateseenonlyduringmassextinctions.Amorerecentbiodiver-sityreportfromtheUN,publishedinMay2019,outlinedtheimpactofhumansonnatureandfoundthatnearlyonemillionspeciesisatriskofbecomingextinctwithindecades,anditnotedthatcurrenteffortstoconservetheearth’sresourceswilllikelyfailwithoutradicalaction2.ThisrequiresIre-landtodevelopacomprehensiveseriesofmeasurestomaintainandwherenecessaryrestorethesehabitats.AsaPartytotheUNConventiononBiologicalDiversity,IrelandisalsocommittedtoprepareActionPlanstowardstheachievementoftheConven-tion’stargets.ImplementationoftheNa-tionalBiodiversityPlan(2017-2021)willbeafundamentalpartoftacklingtheserisks,andtheNationalDevelopmentPlanalsorecognisestheneedforincreasedfundingforbiodiversity.
Irishbiodiversityishighlyvulnerabletotheimpactsofclimatechangeandhasalowadaptivecapacitycomparedtoothervulnerablesectors.ClimatechangehasmajorindirectimpactsonIrishbiodiversity
1 https://indicators.biodiversityireland.ie/
2 https://www.un.org/sustainabledevelopment/blog/2019/05/na-ture-decline-unprecedented-report/
Envi
ronm
enta
l Risk
s
![Page 52: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
52
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
throughitsinteractionwithotherstressors,inparticularhabitatfragmentationandloss;over-exploitation;pollutionofair,waterandsoil;andspreadofinvasivespecies.
IntermsofClimateChangeMitigation,thereisaneconomicrationalefortakingearlyactiontomitigategreenhousegas(GHG)emissions,investinrenewableenergy,improveenergyefficiencyandimplementadaptationmeasurestotheeffectsofclimatechange.Thecostofinactionexceedsthecostofactionandthiscostdifferentialwillrisesteeplywithtime.Itwillbecriticaltotakeactiononclimatechange,assetoutintheNationalDevelop-mentPlan,theNationalAdaptationFrame-workandthenewAllofGovernmentPlanonClimateDisruption,toavoidthreatstohumanhealth,economicdevelopment,property,in-frastructureandecosystems,aswellasrepu-tationaldamage.
PotentialcoststotheexchequerincludethoseassociatedwithnotachievingcompliancewithourEUGHGemissionsandrenewableenergytargetsto2020and2030.Thereisarangeofeconomicrisksassociatedwithfailingtopricethecostofcarbonintooureconomicmodel.Providingappropriatelong-termpricesignalsonthecostofcarbonwillbeimport-antinordertoinformmediumtolongterminvestmentdecisionsintheprivatesectorandtoencouragebehaviouralchangeinbroadersociety.Itwillalsobecriticaltodefineourap-proachtocarbonneutralityfortheagriculturesectorinawaythatfurtherstheachievementofourclimatetargetsanddecarbonisationgoalswhilerespectingsustainablefoodsecu-rityandtomakeinvestmentstodevelopnewandinnovativeeconomicopportunities,forexampleinthebioeconomy.Diversificationofagri-businesswillbecrucialtomaintainingcompetitivenessinthelowcarboneconomyandcreatingviableeconomicopportunitiesforruralIreland.Anassociatedriskisthemismanagementandover-exploitationofour
bio-resources,andeffectivestewardshipwillberequiredtoensuretheintegrityofournaturalresources.
Aswetransitiontoalowcarboneconomyandtraditionalindustriesandpracticesaredisrupted,decouplingoureconomicgrowthfromcarbonemissionswillbecomeincreas-inglycriticalinmaintainingourcompetitive-ness.Itwillalsobeimportanttoplanforthesocietaldisruptioncausedbythistransitionandprepareretrainingandreskillingoppor-tunitiestoensureindividualsandcommuni-tiescanmakethenecessarychanges.
Arelatedriskisfailingtoplanforsuccessandeconomicgrowthinthiscontext.Ire-land’sgreenreputationcouldalsobeim-pactedbyaclimate-changerelateddegra-dationinthequalityofournaturalenvironment.
Bothpoliticalandsocietalwillingnesstotacklethelonger-termrisksofclimatechangecouldpresentachallenge,assignifi-cantup-frontinvestmentisrequired,whichmaynotyieldbenefitsformanydecades.Fundamentalbehaviouralchangewillbenecessaryinthisregard,fromthepublicandprivatesectorsaswellasthegeneralpub-lic,giventhatoureffortstotackleclimatechangeeffectivelyarepredicatedonsignifi-cantbuy-infromthesegroups.EngagementwiththesegroupscanbefacilitatedthroughinitiativessuchastheNationalDialogueonClimateAction.
5.2. Ensuring an affordable, sustainable and diverse energy supply
Ireland’ssituationasanislandontheperipheryofEuroperendersitparticularlyvulnerabletodisruptionstothesupplyorpriceofoil,gasorelectricitywhichwould
Envi
ronm
enta
l Risk
s
![Page 53: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
53
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
havesignificanteconomic,socialandcompet-itiveimpacts.Suchdisruptioncouldarisefromnaturaldisaster,economictrendsorgeopo-liticalchange,suchasBrexit,disruptiontooilsuppliesintheMiddleEast,RussiansanctionimpactsongassuppliesandOPECcuts.
BrexitposesaparticularriskasIrelandimportsthevastmajorityofitsenergyrequirements,oil,gasandtransportfuels,fromorviatheUK.ThepotentialimpactofBrexitontheSingleElectricityMarketisalsoofparticularnote.Thisprovidesanaddedimpetustoincreasetheuseofourrenewableresourcesandtodiversifyoursourcesofsupplybydevelopingfurtherelectricityinterconnectiontoneigh-bouringmarketsincludingFrance.
AsIrelandelectrifiesvitalservices,suchastransportandheating,whichwillbenecessarytomeetclimatechangeobligations,thechal-lenges,developmentcostsandrisksaroundenergysecuritywillcontinuetoshiftandevolve.Withenergydemandincreasingfromagrowingpopulationandeconomy,thereisarealneedtoensurethatwecanbuildsocietalsupportandacceptancetodevelopappro-priatelevelsofinfrastructuretoservicethisgrowth.
AlargeproportionofIreland’senergyneedsaremetthroughimports-circa66percentin2017.However,itisworthnotingthatindig-enousenergyproductionisincreasing-from12percentofthetotalprimaryenergysupplyin2015to34percentin2016.ThisisinpartduetothecomingonstreamofnaturalgasproductionfromtheCorribproject.Increasinglevelsofrenewableenergywillhelpoffsetourdependencyonimportedfossilfuels,intro-ducemorecertaintyintheenergyfuelmixandmoveIrelandtowarditsfuturerenewableen-ergytargetsassetoutintheNationalEnergyandClimatePlan(NECP).
Ensuringanenergysupplythatisnotonly
affordable,sustainableanddiversebutalsosecurewillbeextremelyimportantaspres-sureincreasesontheworld’sresourcesduetoclimatechangeandincreasedenviron-mentalconcerns.Therearealsogeopoliticalimplicationscontributingtothisrisk,withinternationalrelationsandtensions,includ-ingincreasedpressureonglobalfreetradeagreements,creatingdoubtoverthesecuri-tyandpriceofenergysupply.
Inthelastfewyears,thepriceoffossilfuels,particularlyoil,havebeenmorevolatile,withinternationalpricesbeginningtoriseafteraperiodofsustainedlowprices.Thishasbeenpassedthroughtotheconsumerwithpriceincreasesevidentinthegas,elec-tricityandtransportfuelsectors.
5.3. Delivery of Public Infrastructure
IrelandwasagainthefastestgrowingeconomyintheEUin20183,anditspopu-lationiscontinuingtogrow,expandingby3.8percentovertheinter-censalperiod2011-2016.Thiscontext,coupledwithanunder-supplyofhousingandassociatedaf-fordabilityissues,atighteninglabourmarketandthecontinuedstrengthofeconomicgrowth,couldgiverisetooverheatingintheeconomy(seeSection2.4formoredis-cussiononrisksaroundoverheating).ThisbringswithittheriskofnegativeimpactsforIreland’scompetitivenessandvalueformoneyconcernsfortheStateintermsofcapitalprogrammes,aswellasfortheindi-vidualconsumer.
Followingasignificantreductioninpubliccapitalexpenditureoverthecourseoftherecession,thelevelofcapitalexpenditurehasincreasedastheeconomyhasreturned
3 OnthebasisofGDP;https://www.cso.ie/en/releasesandpublica-tions/er/na/quarterlynationalaccountsquarter42018/
Envi
ronm
enta
l Risk
s
![Page 54: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
54
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
togrowth,andthepublicfinancesrecovered.However,whileProjectIreland2040waslaunchedinFebruary2018,andsetoutboththe20-yearNationalPlanningFramework2040andadetailedcapitalinvestmentplanfortheperiod2018to2027(theNationalDevelopmentPlan2018-2027),risksaroundcapacityconstraintswhichcouldprovechal-lengingforitsfullimplementationareappar-ent.Inparticular,risksintermsofbothinsti-tutionalcapacityandcapacityintheeconomyincludingskillsconstraintscanbeseen,withskillsconstraintsparticularlyevidentintheconstructionsector,aswellasconcernsregardingsupplychaincapacityinthesector.Thesechallengescouldhindertheimplemen-tationanddeliveryofprojectsundertheNDPandNPF,withtheassociatedriskofcontrib-utingtopriceinflationiftheseconstraintsarenotalleviatedinordertoensureinfrastructureconstraintsaredealtwithinasustainableway4.AsmentionedaboveinSection3.2,theimpactofconstructioncostinflationonthedeliveryofmajorinfrastructureprojectsisalsoarisk.
By2040anadditionalonemillionpeoplewillliveinIreland,almostaquarterofwhomwillbeover65(doublethecurrentlevels).Anadditionaltwo-thirdsofamillionpeoplewillworkhere,andanadditionalhalfamillionhomeswillbeneededtoaccommodatethisgrowth.
Aplan-ledapproachtoinfrastructuralinvest-mentisthereforevital.Historically,constraintsonpublicfinancesandamarket-anddevel-oper-drivendevelopmentenvironmenthasresultedininfrastructurefollowing,ratherthandriving,changeanddevelopmentforthebenefitofsociety.Failingtorenewanden-hanceourinfrastructuralcapabilitiesthroughastrategicplanwillimpactoncompetitiveness,
4 Inresponse,theGovernmenthasestablishedtheConstructionSectorGroupwhichwillleadthedevelopmentofpoliciesandindustrypracticeswhichcandriveanimprovementinproductivity,attractyoungpeopletopursuecareersintheconstructionsectorandhelptheindustrybecomemoreenvironmentallysustainable.
qualityoflifeandourabilitytomeetnewenvironmentalchallenges.
Preparingforandmanagingprogressiveandsustainablegrowthrequirescarefulpreparationandplanningforallregions.Inaddition,decouplinggrowthfromaddingtoenvironmentalpressuressuchasclimatechangeanddecliningbiodiversityiscritical.Inresponse,theNationalPlanningFrame-workwasdevelopedinparallelwiththeNationalDevelopmentPlan.Thestrategiescombinetopresentamapforeffectivespatialplanningandstrategicinvestmentininfrastructure,whichwillallowIrelandtoaccommodateanticipatedpopulationgrowthwhileensuringgrowthcontinuesinabalancedway.
TherisksandimplicationsofnotdeliveringontheobjectivesinProjectIreland2040areclear.Thedeliveryandmaintenanceofcompetitively-pricedworld-classinfrastruc-ture(e.g.energy;telecoms;transport;waterandenvironmentalservices)andrelatedser-vicesiscriticaltobolstercompetitiveness,whichinturndeterminesthesustainabilityoflivingstandards.Inadditiontothecapac-ityandskillsconstraintsoutlinedabove,theNationalCompetitivenessCouncil(NCC)quotesIMFestimateswhichshowthatanincreaseof1percentagepointofGDPininvestmentspendingcanincreaseoutputbyapproximately0.4percentinthesameyearandby1.5percentfouryearsafterthein-creaseininvestment.5Overall,indeliveringupontheobjectivesofProjectIreland2040,itisimportanttoensurethatefficiency,effectivenessandvalueformoneycontinuetobeatthecentreofprogrammeandproj-ectimplementation.
Theabilityofthepublicservicetodeliv-erinfrastructureprojectsontimeandon
5 NationalCompetitivenessCouncil(2017)Ireland’sCompetitive-nessChallenge,availableat:https://dbei.gov.ie/en/Publications/Pub-lication-files/Irelands-Competitiveness-Challenge-2017.pdf
Envi
ronm
enta
l Risk
s
![Page 55: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
55
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
budgetiscritical.WhileIrelandhasmademuchprogressindeliveringprojectsontimeandwithinbudgetoverrecentyears6,withprojectscominginonbudgetacrossmostsectors,itisclearthattherecentexperienceofcertainprojects,suchastheNationalChildren’sHospital,exceedingtheirinitialcostestimatesmustbedrawnupon,andlessonslearned,toensurethatthisriskisavoidedinfuture.Arangeofreformsarethereforebeingprogressed,includingtherevisionofthePublicSpendingCodeandthedevelopmentofthenextgenerationoftheCapitalWorksManage-mentFramework7intheOfficeofGovernmentProcurementtoensurebetterprojectappraisalmechanisms,thedeploymentofstrongercom-mercialskillsinthedeliveryofprojectsandbetterestimationandmanagementofprojectcosts.
Furthermore,inadditiontopotentialriskstocross-borderinfrastructureprojectsinthecontextofBrexit,impactsonroadinfra-structurefromanincreaseinsevereweatherevents,andunforeseenbudgetarypressuresonplannedcapitalfundingoverthecourseofProjectIreland2040,asignificantthreattodeliveryofProjectIreland2040isrisinglevelsoflitigationleadingtodelaysininfrastructuredelivery.Thereisalsoariskthatthegrowinginfluenceofsocialmediamaybecomearele-vantfactorinthecontextofoppositionofcit-izensandcommunitiestotheimplementationofinfrastructureprojects.Widercommunitieshaveinsomecasesopposedprojectsdespiterigorousplanning,environmentalassess-mentandconsultationprocesses.Enhanced
6Inparticular,recentyearshaveseenmajorprogressintheprofession-alismofprojectmanagementinthewatersector,motorwaysandpublictransportarea,withanormnowwell-establishedthatallsuchprojectsshouldcomeinontimeandonbudget.Reformsarecurrentlybeingdevelopedwhicharedesignedtoextendthesamelevelsofdiscipline,professionalismandperformanceacrossthepubliccapitalprogrammemorebroadly.
7 TheCapitalWorksManagementFramework(CWMF)isastructurethathasbeendevelopedtodelivertheGovernment’sobjectivesinrelationtopublicsectorconstructionprocurementreform.Itconsistsofasuiteofbestpracticeguidance,standardcontractsandgenerictemplatedocuments.Allthedocumentsthatmakeuptheframeworkareavailableonline.
mechanismstocreatebettercommunityownershipofandparticipationinrequiredinvestmentprojectsmaygosomewaytomitigatingthisoppositionbyallowingthosemostaffectedtobenefitmoredirectlyfromthedevelopmentofsuchinfrastructure.Ireland’sdevelopmentconsentsystemsneedtoberobustandefficienttomaximisecertaintyandminimisedelayinconvertingcapitaltoprojectsthatdeliver.
5.4. Food safety Potentialrisksaroundfoodsafetyandani-maldiseaseclearlyrepresentbothahumanhealthriskand,asaconsequenceofthat,riskstointernationaltradeinIrishfood.Ourfoodsafetyandproductionstandards,whichincludeafavourableanimalhealthandwelfarestatus,areimportanttoconsumerconfidenceinIrishfoodanddrinkproductsbothathomeandabroad.Whilethepossibilityoffoodcontaminationoranoutbreakoffood-bornehumanillnessclear-lyrepresentsarisktothehealthofcitizens,afoodsafetyincidentofIrishoriginoramajordiseaseoutbreakinfarmedanimalsinIrelandcouldalsojeopardiseinternationaltradeinIrishfood.
Anysuchadverseincidentcouldleadtoim-mediateexclusionfromcertainmarketsanditcouldtakeaconsiderableperiodoftimetorecoverconsumerconfidenceandmar-ketshare.Giventhevitalimportanceoftheagri-foodsector,anditshighdependenceonexports,thiswouldleadtosignificantimplicationsfortheIrisheconomy,partic-ularlyinruralareas.Theagri-foodsectorishighlyexportdependent.In2018,thevalueofagri-foodexportswasover€13.7billion,representingagrowthof74percentsince2009.41percentor€5.55billionofthisisexportedtotheUK,leavingthesectorpar-ticularlyexposedtorisksrelatedtoBrexit.
Envi
ronm
enta
l Risk
s
![Page 56: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
56
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
5.5. Supply and Affordability of Housing
Oneofthemostcriticalchallengescurrent-lyfacingtheStateisthesupplyofhousing.Housingsupply,bothsocialandprivate,isessentialforsocietalwell-beingandeconomicgrowth.However,housingandrelatedmar-ketshavedisplayedmarkedvolatilityinrecentdecades,includingthepricecorrectionduringtherecessionyears,whichactedasasevereshocktotheconstructionsector,inadditiontowiderfiscal,consumption,creditmarketandothermacro-economicimpacts.
Thishasnegativelyaffectedthecountrybothsociallyandeconomicallywithchallengesintheprovisionofsocialhousinginthefaceofincreaseddemand,lackofaffordabilityforthoseonaverageincomes,anincreaseinhomelessness,andconstraintsoncompeti-tiveness.
Underlyinghousingdemandhasoutpacedactualsupplyinrecentyears,manifestinginstrongergrowthinhousepricesandrents,withsuchincreasesbeingrapidinDublinandotherurbanareascomparedwiththerestofthecountry.HousingundersupplyhasbeencompoundedbytherapidgrowthoftheIrisheconomyinrecentyearsresultinginafford-abilityissuesandrentalpropertypricesrisingabovetheirpreviouspeaks.
Thelackofaffordableaccommodationhastranslatedtorisinglevelsofhomelessness,withsignificantsocialandfinancialcosts.Inadditiontotheincreasednumberofroughsleepersrecordedinrecentyears,homelessfamilieshavebeenlivingforlongperiodsoftimeinemergencyaccommodationwithconsiderableimpactsonfamilylife.Difficultiesaccessingaffordableaccommodationareamajorsourceofconcernformanypeople.
Thereisnowagrowingriskaroundtheissueofaffordabilityas,evenassupplyin-creases,affordabilitypressurespersist.ThisisofparticularconcerninIreland’scities.Thesepressuresmayfurtherexacerbatealreadyincreasingwagepressures,whichmaythenleadtoafurtherincreaseinhouseprices,whichcouldinturnresultincon-tinuingaffordabilitychallenges.Intermsofincreasingwagepressuresfromthepublicsector,suchrisksarelinkedwithincreasingexpectationsforpublicexpenditure,whichisdiscussedaboveinSection4.3.
Collectively,thesechallengespresentarisktothecontinuedrelativecompetitivenessoftheeconomy,withpotentiallyadverseimpactsonIreland’sabilitytocontinuetoattractForeignDirectInvestment(FDI),asavailabilityofhousingisafundamentalcon-cernforlargemulti-nationalsconsideringlocatinghere.
Currently,pressuresonthehousingmar-kethaveledtoovercrowdingandloweringofqualityoflife.Theimmediatetaskistomoderatepricemovementsandimproveaffordabilityinrentalandpurchasemarketsbyencouraginggreatersupplyofhousingintherightlocationsandincreasingthesupplyofsocialhousinginaplannedandsustain-ablemanner.
Increasingsupplytomeetdemandalsocar-rieswithitrisksfortheconstructionindus-tryandcreditsector,whichisundergoingalengthyandasyetunfinishedrecovery.Alonger-termtaskistodampenvolatilityandsuppressthecyclicalnatureofhousingmarkets,sothatwehaveahousingsysteminwhichrealhousepricegrowth(andrents)donotdeviateforlengthyperiodsfromrealeconomicgrowth.
WhiletheCSOstatisticsfor2018showthatsupplyofhousingisincreasinginline
Envi
ronm
enta
l Risk
s
![Page 57: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
57
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
withthegoalsundertheGovernment’sRebuildingIrelandprogramme8,andthereisstronggrowthinthesupplyofsocialhousingbylocalauthorities,overallhousingdemandisincreasingtoo,andinthecomingyearshousingshortagesarelikelytoactasaconstraintoneconomicactivityandcom-petitiveness,andreflectoneofthemostprominentrisksandchallengesfacingthecountry.
ThepotentialeffectsofBrexit9,inwhat-everformitoccurs,arealsolikelytohaveanimpact,withrisksincludingconstraintsontheavailabilityofconstructionmateri-als,impactsonavailabilityofconstructionworkers,impactsonconstructiontimelinesandpotentiallyahigherdemandforhous-ing.TheDepartmentofHousing,Planning&LocalGovernmentcontinuestomonitorthesituationinthisregardandcontinuetopreparetomitigatetheeffectsofBrexit.
8 http://rebuildingireland.ie/
9https://data.oireachtas.ie/ie/oireachtas/committee/dail/32/joint_committee_on_housing_planning_and_local_government/re-ports/2019/2019-02-07_examining-the-potential-impacts-of-brex-it-on-ireland-s-housing-market_en.pdf
Envi
ronm
enta
l Risk
s
![Page 58: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
6. Technological Risks
![Page 59: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
59
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
6.1. Cyber Security 6.2. Disruptive technology trends 6.3. Anti-Microbial Resistance 6.4. Major Pandemics 6.5. Nuclear contamination
6.1. Cyber Security Disruption to critical information infrastructure
Cybersecuritymattersbecausetheextenttowhichsocietyreliesondigitaltechnologyisnowsoall-encompassingthatthistechnologycannolongerbeviewedasbeingataremovefromeverydaylife.Almostallaspectsofourliveshaveadigitaldimension,andtheubiquityofconnecteddevices-the“InternetofThings”(IoT)-hasbroughttrulymassivebenefitstooursocietybuthasalsoopenedupvariousnewandunpredictablethreatvectors,andawiderangeofsignificantrisksformajorna-tionalinfrastructureincludingenergy,trans-port,telecomssystemsandfinancialsystems.WithIrelandpositioningitselfasatechno-logicalsocietywithagrowingdependenceononlineservices1,theimpactofanattackorincidentontheprovisionofservices,andonthereputationofbusinessesandthepublicserviceissignificant.
Europolcurrentlyjudgestheriskofcyber-ter-rorismtobeoneofhighpotentialbutlowprobability,thoughtheprobabilitymaybeincreasing.ThisisanissueofgrowingconcernatEUandinternationallevelsreflectingtheimportanceofcontinuingtobuildourexper-tiseandcapacityincybersecuritytoenableustoidentifythesethreatseffectively.
1 Suchasbuild-to-shareandfinancialmanagementSharedServicesprojectswhichrequirenetworkconnectivity,andcloud-basedserviceswhichrequireconnectivityfromanexternalprovider
Inaddition,criminalenterprisesoperatingindifferentpartsoftheworldhavegrowingcapabilitiesintermsoflaunchingdisruptivecyber-attacksandalsoholdingentitiestoransomwheretheysucceedinencryptingbusinessandpersonaldata.Tworecentincidentshighlightthecontinuedthreatofcyber-attacks.OnaEuropeanfront,thedataofhundredsofGermanpoliticianswasleakedfromregional,nationalandEuropeanparliamentsattheendof2018.Thiscameonfootofalonglineofpreviousattacksonpoliticians,militariesandseveralembassies.Morelocally,thedataofalmost3,500usersoftheLuaswebsitewashackedatthebe-ginningof2019.AccordingtotheEuropeanUnionAgencyforNetworkandInformationSecurity(ENISA)ThreatLandscapeReportfor2018,thethreatofmalwarecontinuesasthetopcyberthreat,withthethreatofweb-basedattacksandphishingincreasing.Thisindicatesthatthethreatofphishingat-tacks,andotherattacks,maybecomemorefocussed,personalisedandstrategicallytargeted.
ThepossibilityofsuchattacksareincreasedbyrisksincludingtheriseofArtificialIn-telligence(AI)inthecontextofopenplat-formswhichhaveputthesesystemsintothehandsofeveryone,includingmaliciousactors;therisksaroundcriminalsandexter-nalattackersby-passingsecuritymeasuresbyattackingtheauthorisedusersofthesystems;andrisksthroughpersonaltech-nology,i.e.asdevicesbecomemoreuseful
Tech
nolo
gica
l Risk
s
![Page 60: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
60
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
forusersweriskexposuretoriskthroughtheirowndevicesinteractingwithoursystems.
Theriskoffurtherattackscontinues,attackswhichcouldhaveseriouseffectsontheeconomyandonthecohesionofsocietyingeneral2.Thepotentialimpactontheprovisionofserviceshasthepotentialtoleadtocivilunrestinadditiontosignificantdisruptionforcitizens3,whileprolongedorrepeatedinci-dentsriskcreatingabacklashagainstdigiti-zation,withfurthereconomicconsequencesandreputationaldamagetobusinessesandthepublicservice.RelatedtothisistheriskofCyber-activismwherecivilunrestorprotestisexpressedthroughdisruptivepracticesonpublicbodiesorcriticalinfrastructure.
Cyberspaceisanintegralpartoftherules-basedinternationalorder.Thebestguaranteeforafuturewithanopen,freeandstableinternetisacommonunderstandingamongnationsthatexistinginternationallaw,normsandprinciplesforstatebehaviourontheinternationalstagealsoapplyincyberspace.Toprotectnationalinterests,mitigaterisks,andenhancethesecurityofInternetusers,thereisaneedforcontinuedcyberdiplomacybetweencountries.ThefocusoftheEUisthegovernanceandapplicationofinternationallawincyberspace,includingprotectingthefreeandopenInternet,reducingcybercrime,buildingcapacityinthirdworldcountries,en-hancinginternationalstability,andprotectingthedigitaleconomy.
Wehaveseenactivitybynon-stateactorswhoarereadyandwillingtomoveintofillavoidignoredbystates.Thesecurityand
2 Forexample,theFirstReportoftheInter-departmentalGrouponSecurityofIreland’sElectoralProcessandDisinformationidentifiestheprimarycyber-relatedriskstothesecurityoftheelectoralprocessasDestabilisationEvents,ManipulationoftheElectoralRegister,andDataExfiltration;Seemorehere:https://www.gov.ie/en/news/37e936-government-publishes-first-report-of-the-interdepartmental-group-on-/
3 Forexample,anyattackthataffectstheavailabilityofcashsuchasatBanks,PostOfficesorATMswillrestrictaccesstocashforsocietyanddependingonthedowntimecouldhaveseriouseffectsonthosedepen-dentonSocialProtectionPaymentsandtheeconomyingeneral.
resilienceofcyberspacecanonlybefullyachievedthroughcollaborationandcoop-erationwithvariousactors,includingnationstatesandtheprivatesector.
Data fraud and theft
Asmentionedabove,theinternetisanimportantenablinginfrastructureforeco-nomicgrowthandprosperity.Side-by-sidewithitsincreasingimportance,however,hasbeenagrowthinattemptedcyber-attacks,duetothehighvalueofpersonalandcor-poratedata.Althoughtherehavebeensig-nificantimprovementsinbuildingresiliencetoattacks,thiscontinuestobeagrowingchallengeforbusinessesandindividuals,andsocietyingeneral,includinginregardtotheprotectionofgovernmentdigitalassets.
Immediaterisksforbusinessesandindivid-ualsincludethelossortheftofpersonalorbusinessinformation,oreventhede-structionofpropertyorcriticalrecordslikemedicalrecords.Theimpersonationofindi-vidualsinordertomakefraudulenttrans-actionsisamajorissueinvolvingbillionsofeuroglobally.Significantdatabreacheshavebeenreportedoverthepastseveralyearsbyvariousmultinationalcompanies.
AnychallengetothequalityofIreland’sdataregulationenvironment,whichhasbeenacriticalfactorinthecontinuingex-pansionandgrowthofthedigitaleconomyinIreland,createsariskofbusinessdisrup-tionaswellasreputationaldamage.Irelandhasthepotentialtoleveragethesignificantexpertisethatexistsinourprivatesector,aswellasinformation-sharingandcooperationwithagenciesinothercountries,inordertotacklethisrisk.
Thepublicserviceisalsoamajorcollectorandprocessorofdata.Aspecificriskisthetargetingofpublicservicedatarepositories
Tech
nolo
gica
l Risk
s
![Page 61: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
61
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
andthetheft,exfiltration,denialofaccessto,orcompromisingof,thatdata.Asuccessfulincidentwouldhavetheimmediateeffectofreducingconfidenceinpublicserviceadmin-istrationandtheuseoftechnologyforpublicservices.
TheGeneralDataProtectionRegulation(GDPR),whichcameintoforceinMay2018,isaregulationtostrengthenandunifydatapro-tectionwithintheEU.Itwillgivetherighttoapersonwhohassufferedmaterialornon-ma-terialdamagetoseekcompensationfromadatacontroller.Asignificantdatabreachcouldresultinsignifi-cantcompensationpaymentsbeingmade.
Thechallengesdiscussedabovearejustsomeofthemanyformsthatcybercrimemaytake.Thecyberdimensiontoconventionalcrimebringswithitsignificantdemandsintermsofthetoolsneededtogatherevidence,identifyperpetratorsandundertakepreventioninitia-tives.Attacksonthedatastoredoncomputersorthesystemsthemselvesisanotheraspectofcybercrimethatposesbothlawenforcementissuesandinsomecases,Statesecurityissues.Theinternationaldimensiontoinvestigatingcybercrimebringswithitmanychallengesintermsofinternationalcooperationandjuris-diction.Therearefurtherchallengesfacedbylawenforcementagenciesincludinglossofdata,encryption,virtualcurrencies,lossoflocation,theneedforexpeditedmeasures,managingonlineinvestigations,andmanagingpublic-privatecooperation,amongstmanymore.
6.2. Disruptive technology trends
Disruptivetechnologytrendsarecontinuouslybringingnewwaysofconductingbusiness,manufacturingproductsandmakingdeci-sionswhichcoulddisrupttraditionalmethodsandleadtosignificantjobshiftsandlosses
inaffectedsectorsandroles.Legislativeandregulatorychallengesmaycomewithadvancesindigitaltechnologies,aswellasthreatstocurrentformsofemployment.Thespeedofadoptionoftechnologicaladvancesisseeingtheemergenceofnewglobalbusinessmodels,products,markets,sectorsandactivities;aswellasdisruptingwaysofworkingandimpactingonskillsneeds.
A2018OECDstudy(NedelkoskaandQuintini)suggeststhat14percentofjobsinOECDmembercountrieshaveahighprobabilityofbeingautomated.Itshouldbenotedthatalternativemodelsandmeasure-menttoolshavebeenusedinotherstudiesinthisareawhichhavegeneratedsignifi-cantlyhigherestimatesofjoblossesarisingfromautomation.Inaddition,andasmen-tionedinSection4.2aboveindiscussingSkilledLabourShortages,whiletheimpactofautomationonjobsisexpectedtovarybetweencountriesandregions,theOECDhavefoundthatonaverageasmuchastwooutofeveryfivejobscouldbesignificantlyimpactedbyautomationoverthenexttwodecades4.Automationislikelytoreplacesomejobs,re-shapeothersbutalsocreatenewones.Therefore,inthecomingyearsitwillbecriticalthatworkerscanacquiretheskillsnecessarytotransitionsuccessfullyastechnologytransformstheworldofwork,includinginthecontextoftheFETSectorintermsofdevelopingintermediatelevelskills.
IntermsofregionalimpactsinIreland,theExpertGrouponFutureSkillsNeeds(EGFSN)publishedareport5inDecember2018,whichfoundthatDublinistheleast
4 JobCreationandLocalEconomicDevelopment2018,Pre-paringfortheFutureofWork,seelink:https://read.oecd-ilibrary.org/employment/job-creation-and-local-economic-develop-ment-2018_9789264305342-en
5 EGFSN(2018)‘DigitalTransformation:AssessingtheImpactofDigitalisationonIreland’sWorkforce’Availablehere:http://www.skillsireland.ie/Publications/2018/Digital-Transformation.pdf
Tech
nolo
gica
l Risk
s
![Page 62: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
62
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
atriskfromautomation(2percentathighrisk,mainlyinRetailandHospitalitysectors),whiletheMidlandsregion(5percentathighriskand64percentatmediumrisk)andBorderregion(5percentathighriskand62percentatmediumrisk)aretheregions’mostatrisk.GiventhelikelyimpactofBrexitontheseregions,andwithunemploymentalreadyhigherthanaverageinthesetworegions,thisisparticularlychallenging,especiallyinlightofconcernsofruralandregionalimbalanceexpressedearlierintheReport(Section4.4).
Inaddition,aUCCstudy6identifiesthetownsinIrelandthataremostatriskfromjobau-tomation7.Thereportfindsthattheauto-mationriskfortownsismainlyexplainedbypopulationdifferences,educationlevels,agedemographics,theproportionofcreativeoccupationsinthetown,thetownsize,anddifferencesinthetypesofindustriesacrosstowns.TheresultssuggestthatthepatternofjobriskfromautomationacrossIrelanddemandspolicythatisnotone-size-fits-all,butratheralocalised,place-based,bottom-upapproachtopolicyintervention.Thereportfoundwidedifferencesbetweentheaveragenumbersofjobsathighriskofautomationacrosstowns,fromalowof26percenttoahighof58percent.Inaddition,theanalysisfoundthatmany‘athighrisk’townshave‘atlowrisk’nearbytownsandmany‘atlowrisk’townshave‘athighrisk’neighbours.Theanal-ysisalsofoundthattherearesomeconcentra-tionsof‘atlowerrisk’townsandseparately,concentrationsof‘athigherrisk’towns.Forexample,intheDublincityregion,Malahide,SkerriesandDonabateareallatlowerriskofautomation.TheReportpointedoutthattownsexposedtoagricultureandmanufactur-ingshouldbemainconcernsastheyarelikelytobethetownsmostdisruptedbyfutureau-tomation.Itnotesthatmakingskillsdevelop-
6 https://www.ucc.ie/en/media/projectsandcentres/srerc/SRERCWP2019-1_upload.pdf
7 Acrossthe200townswhichhaveapopulationof1,500ormoreusingdatafromthe2016census
mentandeducationmorefinanciallyacces-sibleandremotelypossiblewillhelptocurb‘braindrain’andunlocklocalcompetenciesinperipheraltowns.
Whilenosectorwillbeimmunetotheimpactofdisruptivetechnology,jobsandfunctionsthatrequiregreaterdegreesofcognition,subjectivethoughtandpersonalinteractionwillbesomewhatcushioned.Theacquisitionofnewskillsisvitaltokeeppacewithadvancesintechnology.Similarly,theavailabilityoftherightskillsisanim-portantenablerofenterpriseperformanceandgrowth.Jobsasweknowthemareundergoingasystemofchangewiththeskillsrequiredwithmanyjobschangingsignificantly.Numerousacademicstudiesandreportshaveidentifiedthatre-skilling/up-skillingoftheworkforceisarequirementofthefutureasjobsbecomeincreasing-lydigitalised.Thus,itisessentialthattheworkforceisequippedwiththerequisiteskillstofullyunlockthebenefitsofthedigi-taleconomy.
Inaddition,therearerisksassociatedwithdisruptivetechnologiesaroundfailingtocommunicatethevaluethattheycanpro-videingrowingtheeconomy,andfailingtocapitaliseoneconomicopportunities,andfailingtodeploytheminpublicsectorrapid-lytoprovideconcurrence(andensurevalueformoney)withtheprivatesector.Failingtoassessandmitigatetheadversesocietal,workplaceandsocialimpactofdisruptivetechnologiesonthelivesofourcitizens,associatedregulatorychallenges,andfailingtoadequatelyplanforemploymentshifts,arealsoriskstobeconsideredandtackledatanearlypoint.
Technologicaladvanceswillalsoleadtonewjobsbeingcreated,aswellaseconom-icbenefitsassociatedwithmoreefficientwaysofdoingbusiness.AccordingtoPwC
Tech
nolo
gica
l Risk
s
![Page 63: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
63
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
analysis,smartautomationhasthepotentialtoadd$15trilliontoglobalGDPby2030.However,thereisariskthatthesenewjobswillbelessdependentonhumanlabour,orwillrequiresignificantre-skilling.Thescaleofthere-skillingproblemisbecomingapriorityfortheEuropeanCommission,asithasbeensuggestedthatinthenearfuture,90percentofexistingjobswillrequiresomedegreeofdigitalskills.Whilethispresentsbothoppor-tunitiesandthreatstheresearchgenerallyin-dicatesthat,acrossallcountries,workerswithalowerlevelofeducationareatthehighestriskofdisplacement.Asartificialintelligence(AI)continuestodevelopitcouldalsobethatinthefuturehigherskilledoccupationsmayfacehigherriskofautomationthanthecur-rentstateoftechnologyimplies.WhilethisisnotariskuniquetoIreland,itrequiresactionsacrossarangeofareasincludingasignificantincreaseinourdeliveryoflifelonglearningandskillsdevelopmentaswellastheneedforcontinuedinvestmentinthedigitaleconomyandR&D,andappropriatesocialsafetynetmeasures.
IrelandhasparticipatedinthecreationandagreementoftheEUCoordinatedPlanontheDevelopmentandUseofArtificialIntelli-gencewhichwaspublishedbytheEuropeanCommissioninDecember2018.ThePlansetsoutaframeworkofissues,togetherwithsuggestedinitiatives,whichneedtobedealtwithbyMemberStatesinordertoenabletheEUtocompetegloballyinthefieldofAI.ThePlanalsospeakstotheneedtoensurethatAIsolutionsareethicallysound,makingsurethattheyarefreefrombiasandunintendedcon-sequences.IrelandiscurrentlydevelopingaNationalArtificialIntelligenceStrategytoalignwithEU-relatedinitiatives.TheGovernmentalsoestablished,underProjectIreland2040,a€500millionchallenge-basedDisruptiveTechnologiesInnovationFund,reflectingtheimportanceofaction,andinvestmentinthisarea.
6.3. Anti-Microbial Resistance
Anti-microbialresistance(AMR)isanin-creasingconcernacrosstheglobe,withtheWorldHealthOrganisation(WHO)describ-ingitas“acrisisthatmustbemanagedwiththeutmosturgency”8.Antimicrobialshavebeenessentialfortheprovisionofmodernmedicalcaresincethe1940s,substantial-lyreducingmortalityandmorbidityfrominfectiousdiseasesandcomplications.Theseadvancesarenowbeingputatriskbyasignificantriseintheprevalenceofbacteriathatareresistanttooneormoreantimicrobials,withknock-onconsequencesforhumanhealthaswellastheeconomyintermsofmoreexpensivetreatmentcostsandlostproductivity.
TheWorldEconomicForum’sGlobalRisksReportfor20189includedareflectionontheevolutionofthisriskontheworldstage.ThisquotedresearchfromtheWorldBank,theUKGovernmentandtheWellcomeTrustestimatingAMRwouldexertadragonglobalGDPofbetween1.1percentand3.8percentbetweennowand2050,aswellascosting$100trillionandkilling10millionpeopleoverthatperiod.Thatreportalsonotedthatresistancetoeventhestrongestantibioticscontinuestospread,astheyareincreasinglyusedtocombatdiseasesresistanttoweakerantibiotics.Itnotesthatresearchconductedin2017demonstratedthatbacteriaresistanttocolistin,the“anti-bioticoflastresort”,hadspreadthroughouttheworldwithin18monthsoftheresis-tantstrainfirstemerging.Additionally,theOECDpredictthatresistancetosecondandthird-lineantibiotics,whicharealastlineofdefenceintreatinginfections,isexpectedtoincreaseby70percentacrossOECDcountriesby2030,overtheanti-microbial
8 WEFGlobalRisksReport2018http://reports.weforum.org/glob-al-risks-2018/anti-microbial-resistance/
9 https://www.weforum.org/reports/the-global-risks-report-2018
Tech
nolo
gica
l Risk
s
![Page 64: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
64
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
resistancerateseenin200510.
Theextensiveuse,misuseandoveruseofantimicrobialsinhumanhealthhasincreasing-lyraisedlevelsofantimicrobialresistanceinawiderangeofpathogensinallcountriesandinpatientsofallagegroups.Intheanimalpop-ulation,therateofdevelopmentandspreadofantimicrobialresistancehasalsoincreased.Theincreasingglobaldemandforaffordablefood,andinparticularanimalprotein,hasledtointensificationincertainanimalsectors,whichcanresultinhigherpotentialrisksofdiseaseoutbreaks.Therefore,astrongrelianceonavailabilityofeffectiveantimicrobialstotreatdiseaseandprotectanimalwelfarehasoccurred.
Therearealsoincreasingconcernsabouttheroletheenvironmentmayplayinthespreadofclinicallyrelevantantimicrobialresistance.Environmentalregulatorsmonitorandcontrolsomeofthepossiblepathwaysresponsibleforthereleaseofantimicrobialsintotheenviron-ment,e.g.throughwatercontaminationandagriculturalrun-off.However,agreaterun-derstandingofmanyoftheissuesconcerningtheenvironmentalrolewillfurtherenhancethedeliveryofenvironmentalprotectionfromAMR.Theriseinantimicrobialresistanceisthusoneofthegreatestpotentialthreatstohumanhealthatglobal,Europeanandnationallevelswithseriousconsequencesforpublichealth,animalhealthandwelfare.Giventhatthenaturalresponsesofmicrobestotheuseofantimicrobialsisresistance,theythereforeneedtobeusedasprudentlyaspossibletoretaintheirefficacy.
6.4. Major Pandemics
Everyfewyearsanewpathogenemerges.Thevastmajorityarevectorborneand,asaresult,
10 OECDStemmingtheTideReport,October2018.https://read.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issues-migration-health/stemming-the-superbug-tide_9789264307599-en#page18
arenotasignificantriskinIreland.
Pandemicinfluenzawasdeterminedasthereasonableworst-casescenariointheIrishcontext.Theinfluenzavirusmutatescontinuouslyandtherehavebeen12pandemicinfluenzassince1895,themostrecentofwhichwasin2009.Historicalevidenceshowsthatsuchpandemicshavethepotentialtocausedeathandillnessonasignificantscaleandtodisruptnormalsocialandeconomicactivity.Advanceplan-ningandpreparednessarecriticaltohelpmitigatetheimpactofapandemic.Whenthenextpandemicoccurs,itwillrequireawhole-of-governmentresponsetoensurethatthreattopublichealthanddisruptionofservicesandsocietyareminimised.
TheInternationalHealthRegulations(IHR)(2005),togetherwithDecisionno.1086/2013/EU,providesthelegalframe-workforthetimelyandeffectiveman-agementofabroadrangeofseriousandpotentiallyinternationalpublichealthrisksandevents.Throughthese,Irelandisrep-resentedontheEUHealthSecurityCom-mittee,andtheDepartmentofHealthandtheHealthServiceExecutivemaintainclosecontactwiththeEuropeanCentreforDis-easePreventionandControlandtheWorldHealthOrganisation.Theseclosecontactsareusedtomonitor,predictandmitigatethespreadandimpactofpandemicinfluen-za,andotherinfectiousdiseases.
6.5. Nuclear contamination
Contaminationasaresultoffalloutfromanuclearaccidentisariskthathastobeacknowledged,despitethelowprobabilityassociatedwiththisforIreland.Obviousriskstopublichealthandwell-beingarise,aswellasthepotentialfornegativeeco-nomicimpact.Thisissignificant,inpartic-
Tech
nolo
gica
l Risk
s
![Page 65: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
65
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
ularinrespectofthepotentialreputationalrisktotheagriculturalsector.ThereisariskofconsumerresistancetoevenminisculelevelsofradioactivityinthefoodchainandIreland’scompetitorsportrayingIreland’sfoodproductsasunsafe,werecontaminationtooccur.
ApaperpublishedbytheEconomicandSocialResearchInstitute(ESRI)examinedthepoten-tialcosttotheIrisheconomyundermultiplescenariosinvolvingvaryinglevelsofcontam-ination11.Whilestressingtheverylowriskofanuclearaccidentandwithoutmeasuringthelikelihoodofanyparticularscenario,thestudyassessedpotentialcoststoIrelandinfourhypotheticalscenarios:costsrangedfrom€4.1billioninascenariowithnocontamina-tionwherelossesarereputational,throughto€115billion,wherehighlevelsofradioactivecontaminationwouldnecessitateaprolongedperiodoffoodcontrolsandagricultureprotec-tiveactions.Thepaperalsoestimatesthatin-directlossesintheIrisheconomywouldrangefrom€287millioninascenariowherelossesarereputational,to€44billioninascenariowithhighlevelsofcontamination.
TheintersectionsofthisriskwithFoodSafetyarehighlightedintheESRIpaperwhereitisstatedthatmeatanddairyproduceaccountfor57percentofthelostvalue,wherelossesarepurelyreputational.Inthemostextremescenariodealingwithhighlevelsofcontamina-tion,thetotalvalueoflossofexportmarketsissome€84bn,withmeat,dairyandseafoodproduceaccountingforover€50bn.
Inviewofthepotentiallycatastrophichuman-itarianconsequencesofanucleardetonation,itwillcontinuetobeimportanttocontinueinternationalengagementrelatingtonuclearsafety,aswellasonnucleardisarmamentandnon-proliferation.
11 ESRIDisastercostassessment:Acasestudyofthepotentialeco-nomicimpactofanuclearaccidentaffectingIreland:https://www.esri.ie/events/disaster-cost-assessment-a-case-study-of-the-potential-econom-ic-impact-of-a-nuclear-accident-affecting-ireland
Tech
nolo
gica
l Risk
s
![Page 66: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
66
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Annex 1. Government Task Force on Emergency Planning – National Risk Assessment for Ireland 2017
ThisNationalRiskAssessmentcomplementsthedetailedriskassessmentworkcarriedoutbytheGovernmentTaskForceonEmergencyPlanning,chairedbytheMinisterwithre-sponsibilityforDefence,whichisconductedinthecontextoftheStrategicEmergencyManagementNationalStructuresandFrame-workapprovedbyGovernmentin2017andIreland’sreportingcommitmentsundertheEUCivilProtectionMechanism(UCPM).ThroughtheOfficeofEmergencyPlanning,undertheDepartmentofDefence,athreeyearNationalRiskAssessmentprocessandmethodologyisapplied,whichfocusesonrisksrelatingtopotentialcivilemergenciesatnationallevel.
TheWhitePaperonDefence(2015)setsouttheGovernment’scommitmenttomain-tainandfurtherdeveloparobuststrategicemergencymanagementframework,andtheGovernmentTaskForce(GTF)onEmergencyPlanningconductsacyclicalprocessofhazardanalysisandriskassessmentasanessentialstepintheprocessofidentifyingthechalleng-esthatmayhavetobeaddressedbysociety,particularlyinthecontextofemergencyman-agement.
TheGTFriskassessmentprocesswasfirstcar-riedoutin2012andledtothepublicationofthefirstNationalRiskAssessmentforIreland2012,whichwasacceptedbytheEuropeanCommissionasmeetingtherequirementsoftheUnionCivilProtectionMechanism(UCPM).Followingareviewin2016bytheOfficeofEmergencyPlanningandDublinCityUniversityBusinessSchool,theGTFincorpo-ratedanumberofmethodologicalchangestothisprocess,whichweredesignedtoreflectcurrentriskmanagementstandardsandinter-nationalgoodpractice.
ThisledtotheproductionofafurtherNationalRiskAssessmentforIreland2017,whichconsideredspecificrisksrelatingtopotentialcivilemergenciesatnationallevelandwasadoptedbytheGTFinMarch2017andwassubsequentlynotedbyGovern-ment,submittedtotheEUCommissionandpublishedatwww.emergencyplanning.ie.
TheNationalRiskAssessmentforIreland2017hasspecificallyidentifiedtwentykeynationalrisksthatwillbeusedtoguidefuturemitigation,planningandpreparationactivitiesatnationalandregionallevelandwillhelpinformfutureassessmentsofriskmanagementcapabilities.Floodingremainsoneofthehighestlikelihood/impactrisksonthisNationalRiskMatrix2017,withInfectiousDisease,FoodContamination,NuclearIncidents(abroad),DisruptiontoEnergySuppliesandNetworkandinforma-tionSecurity/CyberIncidentshighlightedashavingpotentiallythehighestimpactonIreland.
InlinewithgoodpracticeandtheUCPMrequirements,whicharecurrentlyunderreview,theaimistorepeatthisprocessatthreeyearlyintervalssoastocapturenewandemergingthreatsandchangingtrends.TherevisedUCPMandthesubsequentGuidelinesbeingdevelopedwillrequirePar-ticipatingStatestoreportontheirNationalRiskAssessmentsandRiskManagementCapabilityAssessmentsagainbytheendof2020.
![Page 67: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
67
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Annex 2. Ireland’s Changing Demographics and related risks
Introduction
Ashasbeenthoroughlydocumented1,Ireland’sdemographicstructurecontinuestochange.Asmodernmedicinecontinuestoadvance,lifeexpectancyrisesandhencemortalityratesfall.Thedecreaseinmortalityratesleadstoincreasednumbersofolderpeoplecontinuingtolivelongerandhealthierlives.
Themostrecent2016Censusshowsthatthenumberofpeopleaged65andoverhasseenthelargestincreaseofanyagecohortsincethelastcensusin2011,increasingby19.1%,or102,174people2.TherehasbeenasteadyincreaseinthenumberofolderpeoplelivinginIrelandsincethe1980s,whichdemonstratesaconstantriseintheolderagecohort,shiftingIreland’spopulationstructureupwards.
TofeedintothedevelopmentoftheNationalPlanningFramework3,theESRIformulat-edpopulationprojections,whichindicatethatIreland’spopulationwillgrowbyjustunder900,000people.ThiswillbringthepopulationofIrelandtoc.5.7millionpeopleby20404,whichisbroadlyinlinewiththeCSO’spopulationprojectionsto20465.
Inthecontextofprojectingpopulationgrowth,migrationratesaregenerallyfactoredin.InIreland,however,migrationrateshavehistoricallyvariedsignificantlyovertimereflectingthesmall,opennatureoftheeconomyandhistoricpatterns.Thiscanmakeforecastingactualpopulationgrowthdifficult.TheESRIusedamid-rangescenariotoinputintotheNation-alPlanningFramework,whichisbasedonsustainedin-migrationandeconomicgrowthto2040.
Thesechangesinourdemographicstructureareextremelysignificantintermsoftheirim-plicationsfortheStateandforIrishsociety,astheyraisechallengesacrossarangeofareas.Challengesincluderelatedpressuresonexpenditureonpensionsandhealthcare,aswellasimplicationsfortheeducationsystem,andappropriatehousingsupply,amongothers.ByfirstlysettingouttheprojecteddemographicchangesforIreland,inthecontextofsimilarEUandinternationaltrends,secondlyoutliningthemostsignificantimpactsfortheeconomyandsociety,andlastlydiscussingtheinterlinkageswithmanyoftheotherRisksidentifiedinthisyear’sNationalRiskAssessment,thisworkwillattempttohighlighthowpertinent,timelyandsignificanttherisksandimplicationsofourageingsocietytrulyare.
1 SeereferencestoIGEES,TheDepartmentofFinance,TheParliamentaryBudgetOfficeandtheESRIthroughout,amongstothers.
2 CSOPressStatement:Profile3–AnAgeProfileofIreland.Availablehere:www.cso.ie/en/csolatestnews/presspages/2017/census2016pro-file3-anageprofileofireland/
3 publishedaspartofProjectIreland2040inFebruary2018
4 ESRI:ProspectsforIrishRegionsandCounties(January2018).Availablehere:https://www.esri.ie/publications/prospects-for-irish-re-
gions-and-counties-scenarios-and-implications 5 CSOPopulationandLabourForceProjections2016-2046.Availablehere:https://www.cso.ie/en/statistics/population/populationandlabourfor-
ceprojections2016-2046/
![Page 68: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
68
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Part 1: Changing Population Structure in Ireland
Asmentionedabove,weareseeingasteadyriseinIreland’solderagecohort.Inaddition,asthenumberofpeoplegrowingolderincreases,thenumberofyoungerpeopleisnotgrowingataratefastenoughtoreplacethoseleavingtheworkforce.TheAgeDependencyRatio(ADR)hasgrowninIreland,ameasurewhichtheCSOcalculateasthesumofyounger(0-14years)andolder(+65years)peopleasapercentageoftheworkingagepopulation(15-64).Between2011and2016,thispercentagegrewby3.4percen6t andisforecasttocontinuetogrowinthefuture.
Tolookspecificallyatthedependenceoftheolderagecohortontheworkingagepopula-tion,theold-agedependencyratio(OADR)isthemostusefulmetric.Currently,accordingtothe2016Census,thepopulationintheolderbracket(65+),is0.6millionpeople,whiletheworkingagecohortcurrentlystandsat3millionpeople.ThisindicatestheOADRisapproximately20percentatpresent.Inotherwords,thereare5peopleworkingforevery1retiree.Inthecontextofanincreasingnumberofolderpeople,andadecliningnumberofyoungerpeopletoreplacetheworkingpopulation,theOADRisforecasttoincreasesignificantly.TheDepartmentofFinancestatethatthisfigureistogrowto45.7percent7 bymid-century(usingEurostatprojections),andtheParliamentaryBudgetOffice(PBO)estimatethefiguretobe44percent8in20519.Theseforecastsindicatethattheratioofworkingagepopulationtotheolderpopulationissettodeclinefrom5:1to2:1inthenext30years.Table1illustratesthepopulationofIreland20yearsprevioustothemostrecentcensus,andtheprojectionfor20yearslater.Asisclear,Ireland’spopulationissettogetincreasinglyolder,whichwillsteadilyincreasetheOADR.
International Comparison
ThedemographicchallengescurrentlyfacingIrelandarenotunique.Whencomparedinternationally,wecanseethesametrendsinothercountries,insomecasestoanevenmoreextremedegree.IntheEuropeanCommission’s2018AgeingReport,theOADRiscalculatedfrom2016to2070forallEUcountries.Table2setsouttheprojectionsfor2016,2050and2070.WhilewecanseethatIreland’sOADRisprojectedtobeoneofthelowestintheEU27in2050,andthelowestin2070,thegraphillustratestheextentofthechangebetween2016(21%)and2050(46%)withIreland’sOADRmorethandoublinginthatperiod.
WorkbytheDepartmentofFinancealsocomparestheEUaveragewithJapanandtheUSwiththeOADRintheUSexpectedtoreach43.1percentby2070,whileJapanisexpectedtoreach69.6percentbythesameyear10.Japan’spopulation,inparticular,isageingatanalarmingrate,asdeathsnowoutnumberbirthsbyanaverageof1,000perday,indicatinga
6CSOPressStatement:Profile3–AnAgeProfileofIreland.Availablehere:www.cso.ie/en/csolatestnews/presspages/2017/census2016pro-file3-anageprofileofireland/
7 DepartmentofFinance:PopulationAgeingandthePublicFinances(August2018).Availablehere:https://www.gov.ie/en/publica-tion/2e8463-population-ageing-and-the-public-finances/
8 ParliamentaryBudgetOffice:DemographicsandVotedExpenditure(2019).Availablehere:https://www.oireachtas.ie/en/search/?q=demo-graphics+and+voted+expenditure
9 Resultscandifferduetoassumptionsusedwhenprojectingpopulationgrowth,particularlyaroundmigrationandfertilityrates.Initspopulationprojections,theCSOprovidethreedifferentmigrationratescenariosandtwodifferentfertilityratescenarioswhenprojectingpopulation,whichmeanspopulationcanbeprojectedinamultitudeoffashions.
10 DepartmentofFinance:PopulationAgeingandthePublicFinances(August2018).Availablehere:https://www.gov.ie/en/publica-tion/2e8463-population-ageing-and-the-public-finances/
![Page 69: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
69
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
EU27 Belgium Denmark Germany Ireland Spain France Italy Netherlands Poland Portugal
Table 2 - OADR EU Projections
2016 2050 2070
Table 1: Population Pyramids for Ireland
Table 2 - OADR EU Projections
![Page 70: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
70
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
declineinthepopulationbyabout842,000by202011.
InthecontextofOECDdata,weseethesametrends,withtheOECDexpectingIreland’sOADRtomorethandoubleby207512.WhiletheOECDratiosreportedarenotdirectlycom-parabletootherfiguresoutlinedhere(astheOECDcalculatestheOADRusingaworkingagepopulationof20-64asopposedto15-64),itisclearthatthetrendisthesameinternationallywithallindicatorspointingtoanOADRthatissettoincreasesignificantlyinthefuture.
Part 2: Impact of our Changing Demographic Structure
AsIreland’sdemographicstructureshiftstowardsanageingpopulation,itwillhavewide-rangingimpactsontheeconomyandsociety.Certainsectorswillseethemostimpactfromthesedemographicchanges,andareoutlinedinthissection.Thesesectorshavebeenrecognisedbyresearchinstitutesandpolicymakersasacuteareasofrisk,withpolicyre-sponsesalreadybeingimplementedtotacklemanyoftheseissues.
- State and Public Pension pressuresOneofthesectorsthatwillbemostaffectedbyanageingpopulationisthepensionssector.Asincreasingnumbersofpeopleretire,andaresettolivelonger,thisincreasesthedemandforboththeStateandPublicServicePension,asgreaternumbersofpeoplewillwithdrawpensionsoveralongerperiodoftime.Withdecreasingnumbersofpeoplewithinthework-ingagepopulationtoreplacetheseretiredworkers,thiswillfurtherincreasepressureonthepensionssystemasthetaxbasenarrows.
AnactuarialreviewoftheSocialInsuranceFund2015,carriedoutbyKPMGfortheDepart-mentofEmploymentAffairsandSocialProtectionin2017,forecastsandidentifiesthescaleofthesepressures.Thepensionsupportratio,whichKPMGdefineastheratioofworkerstoindividualsovertheageof66(similartotheOADR),isprojectedtodeclinefrom4.9workersforeverypersonover66currently,to2.9workersby2035,and2.0workersby2055.
ThisprojectioniseasedslightlybytheincreaseintheStatePensionAge(SPA),settoincreaseto67and68in2021and2028,respectively.TheincreaseintheSPAwillincreasethepen-sionsupportratioin2035from2.9workersto3.4workers,andfrom2.0workerto2.3work-ersin2055.ItisalsoanticipatedthenumberofpersonsofSPAandolderwillalmostdoublefrom586,000in2015to1,136,000in204513.
WhiletheincreaseintheSPAalleviatessomeofthepressuresonthepensionssystem,itisworthnotingthattheeffectiveretirementage,thatistheagepeopleactuallyretireat,isusuallylower.Thiseffectiveretirementagedrivestherequirementsforbenefitsandfunding,whichislikelytohappenatanearlierstagethantheSPA.
TheGovernment’sRoadMapforPensionsReform2018-2023,however,publishedinFeb-ruary2018,representsamajorreformoffutureState,privateandpublicservicepensionprovisioninIreland.UndertheRoadMap,aTotalContributionsApproach(TCA)fortheStatePension(Contributory)isduetobeintroducedfrom2020,andanew‘AutomaticEnrolment’
11 FinancialTimes:Japan’sageingpopulationmilestoneintensifiesinvestorfocus(19April2017).Availablehere:https://www.ft.com/content/be6bf7ac-43bd-11e8-803a-295c97e6fd0b
12 OECD:PensionsataGlance2017.Availablehere:https://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issues-migration-health/pensions-at-a-glance-2017/old-age-dependency-ratio_pension_glance-2017-22-en
13 KPMG,ActuarialReviewoftheSocialInsuranceFund(2017).Availablehere:http://www.welfare.ie/en/downloads/actrev311215.pdf
![Page 71: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
71
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
retirementsavingssystemisduetobeintroducedfrom2022tosupportandencouragepersonalsavingsprovision.Throughtheseandadditionalmeasures,theRoadMapaimstoaddresschallengesfacingpensionprovisioninthecomingyearsinIreland,whichincludeimplicationsarisingfromanageingpopulation,withanexpectedcostof€400billiontotheSocialInsuranceFundoverthenext50years14.
- Healthcare pressuresTheimplicationsofanageingpopulationonthehealthcaresystemaresignificant,intermsofincreaseddemandandrelatedcapacityissues.Althoughtherehavebeenimprovementsinthegeneralhealthofwesternpopulationsasmodernmedicinecontinuestoadvance,chal-lengessurroundingaccesstocare,supportfortheelderly(includingnursinghomes,commu-nitycareetc.)andthegreaterdemandforhealthcareservicesamongtheolderagecohortsareincreasing.
Asthedependencyratiocontinuestoincrease,i.e.theratioofpersonsunder15yearsandover65yearstopersonsofworkingage(15-64),itposestworelatedrisksinthecontextofhealthcare;theriskofadepletedtaxbaseduetoalowervolumeofthepopulationcontrib-utingincometax,andthegreaterneedforservicestocarefortheelderlyincludingincreasecomplexityandtheneedfornewpackagesofservicestomeetthatcomplexity.Whilemuchresearchhasbeencarriedoutontheseissues15andrelevantpolicyhasbeendevelopedwithinthiscontext(e.g.includingtheSláintecareImplementationStrategy,andthe“FairDeal”StatutoryNursingHomeSupportScheme),theimplicationsofanageingpopulationwillcon-tinuetoposesignificantrisksandchallengestothefutureofhealthservicesprovisionbothhereinIrelandandelsewhere.
AsdiscussedinSection4.2ofthemainReport,futurehealthcaredemandandthecostofhealthcareprovisionwillbeimpactedbyavarietyoffactorsinadditiontodemographics,includingincreasingincidenceofnon-communicablediseases(i.e.heartdisease,stroke,dia-betes,cancerandchroniclungdisease),andlifestyleriskfactors.Olderagecohortstendtobethehighestusersofmosthealthandsocialservicesandhavemorecomplexcareneeds.Itisestimatedthatwithinthenextdecade,thenumberofadultswithchronicdiseaseswillincreasebyaround40percent,withrelativelymoreoftheconditionsaffectingthoseintheolderagegroups.TheESRIestimatethatintheyearsto2030demandforpublichospitalserviceswillincreasebyupto37percentforinpatientbeddaysandupto30percentforin-patientcases,andthatdemandforGPvisitswillincreasebyupto27percent16.Thesefiguresdemonstrateclearlytheincreasedpressureshealthserviceswillfacewithinthenextdecadefromanageingpopulation.
TheESRIpredictthatthisprojectedadditionaldemandwillgiverisetodemandforadditionalexpenditure,capitalinvestmentandadditionalstaffingandwillhavemajorimplicationsforcapacityplanning,workforceplanningandtraininginthehealthsector.TheESRIaddthatadditionalinvestmentwillberequiredformostformsofcaretomeettheneedsofarapidlygrowingandageingpopulationinIreland.
- EducationComparedtothesectorsabove,wheredemandpressurescontinuetoriseinthelonger-term,educationdemandandcostpressuresaremoreacuteinthenearer-term,andthenbeginto
14 ARoadmapforPensionsReform2018-2023.Availablehere:https://www.gov.ie/en/publication/abdb6f-a-roadmap-for-pensions-re-form-2018-2023/
15 ESRIandIGEEStonametwo,andreferencedthroughoutthissection
16 ESRI,2017.Availablehere:https://www.esri.ie/system/files?file=media/file-uploads/2018-02/RS67.pdf
![Page 72: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
72
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
moderate,especiallyinthecasesofprimaryandsecondaryeducation.Inapaperestimat-ingthebudgetaryimpactofchangingdemographicsintheyears2017-2027,IGEESnotethatprimarypupilenrolmentissettopeakin
2018andsecondlevelenrolmentin202517.Thiscreatesaneedforadditionalteachersintheshort-term,withassociatedimplications,particularlyintermsofretirement,redeploy-mentandrecruitment.
Thirdlevelcostpressuresarealsoexpectedtorisegiventhestrongdemographicgrowthintheschoolsystem.IGEESestimateincreasingnumbersofpupilsattendingthirdlevelupto2027(thecutoffyearfortheirresearch),withtheExpertGrouponFutureFundingforHigherEducationreportingthatthisnumberissettopeakin202918.Demandforasso-ciatedthirdlevelexchequerfunding(grantstoHigherEducationInstitutionsandStudentSupportpayments)willcontinuetoincreaseasaresultofthistrend,placingfurtherdemo-graphicbudgetarypressuresonStatespending.
TheReportoftheExpertGrouponFutureFundingforHigherEducation,publishedin2016,foundthatadditionalfundingof€600millionwillbeneededtofundhighereduca-tionby2021,increasingto€1billionby2030.Inadditiontothis,theExpertGroupesti-matesthat€5.5billionwillalsobeneededincapitalinvestmentoverthenext15years.Lastly,theExpertGrouprecommendsthatanadditional€100millionisneededtoadeliv-eryamoreeffectivesystemofstudentfinancialaid.
- Housing Whendiscussingchangingdemographicstructures,itisalsoimportanttobecognisantoftheeffectonhousingcapacityandneeds.Wehaveseenabovethatthepopulationintheagecohortof65+willincreasedramatically,withtheESRIprojectingthatthenumberofpeopleaged80+willincreasebybetween89percent(128,000people)and94percent(135,000people)from2015to203019.Housingprovisionwillneedtoadjustinordertosupportthisincreaseinolderpersons.
Unlikethebudgetarypressuresdiscussedforthethreesectorsabovewhichwillrequirelargeincreasesincurrentexpendituretomeetfuturedemandsinpensions,healthcareandeducation,capitalexpenditure(Exchequerand/orprivate)willberequiredtotransformthehousingsectortomeettherequirementsofanageingpopulationi.e.once-offspendingtotransform/buildnewhomeswhicharefitforpurpose.Intermsofpolicyinitiativesbeingdevelopedtotackletheseissues,theDepartmentofHousing,PlanningandLocalGovernment,alongwiththeDepartmentofHealth,havedevelopedapolicystatement20whichaimsto“encourageandfacilitatetimelyplanningbyolderpeople,andtorebalancethecaremodelawayfrominappropriateresidentialand/oracutecare,tosupportingolderpeopletoremainlivingindependentlyintheirownhomesandcommunitiesforlonger,asopposedtofasttrackingintolongtermstayoracuteset-tings”.
17 IGEES,BudgetaryImpactofChangingDemographics2017–2027(September,2016).Availablehere:https://igees.gov.ie/budgetary-im-pact-of-changing-demographics-2017-to-2027/
18 InvestinginNationalAmbition:AStrategyforFundingHigherEducation(March,2016).Availablehere:http://www.education.ie/en/Publi-cations/Policy-Reports/Investing-in-National-Ambition-A-Strategy-for-Funding-Higher-Education.pdf
19 ESRI,2017.Availablehere:https://www.esri.ie/system/files?file=media/file-uploads/2018-02/RS67.pdf
20 HousingOptionsforourAgeingPopulation(2019).Availablehere:https://health.gov.ie/blog/publications/housing-options-for-our-age-ing-population-policy-statement/
![Page 73: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
73
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
- Budgetary Pressures and Capital Expenditure
IGEESidentifiesthreekeydriversofpublicexpenditureintheSpendingReviewPaper2018,Trends in Public Expenditure;demographics,publicservicepayandpensions,andthelabourmarket21.Overthenext10years,additionalcostsofover€400millionayearareexpectedfrom2023to2027acrossthehealth,educationandsocialprotectionareasduetodemographicpressures22.
TheDepartmentofFinancehavealsoinvestigatedtheeffectsofchangingdemographicsonpublicfinancesandnotethatthecurrentdebt-to-GNI*ratio,whichcurrentlystandsat104percent23,willcausefurtherdifficultiesintermsoftheabilityofthepublicfinancestoabsorbage-relatedspending.ResearchconductedbytheDepartmentin2018findsthat,inascenariowherenofurtherpolicyresponsesareimplemented,theimpactofpopulationageingwouldcauseasignificantincreaseinthedebt-to-GNI*ratioby2070(circa50percentagepoints)24.TheDepartmentofFinancefindthatarangeofpolicyresponses,suchasanincreaseinboththeemploymentrateofolderworkersandofthoseofworkingagecouldhelptomitigatetheimpactofpopulationageingonthepublicfinances.TheDepartment,however,warnthatadditionalmeasureswillberequiredtoensuresustainabilityofpublicfinances.TheincreaseddemandonExchequerfundingwillcreateassociatedopportunitycosts.AlthoughcapitalexpenditureisalreadysetoutintheNationalDevelopmentPlanto2027,underProjectIreland2040,thereisariskthatadditionalpressuresonthepublicfinancescouldthreatenthedeliveryoftheplannedprojectsandprogrammesunderthePlan.
Conclusion
MentionedaboveareonlysomeoftherisksIrelandfacesasourpopulationtransforms.Evidenceandresearchcanillustratethetangibleriskstotheeconomyandrelatedsectors,howeveritisdifficulttofullyforecasttheriskssocietyfacesasaresultofthesedemo-graphicchanges.Itisimportanttoremaincognisantofthepotentialemotional,mentalandsocietalimpacts,aswellasthefinancialpressuresthattheeconomywillface,asoursocietyages.
Part 3: Ireland’s Changing Demographics and the 2019 Risks
Thisthematicpiecegrewoutofadeeperanalysisofoneoftherisksdiscussedinthere-port,‘AnAgeingPopulationincludingpensionsandhealthsystemchallenges’,anditsinter-linkageswiththeotherrisksidentifiedinthisyear’sreport.Whilechangingdemographicsarenotnecessarilyrelevanttoalloftherisks,asforexamplewithnuclearcontamination,andterroristincidentsandarmedconflicts,whatisstrikingistheimpactchangingdemo-graphicswillhaveonthevastmajorityoftherisksdiscussed,underliningboththesignifi-canceandtheurgencyofplanningnowforthesechanges.
21 IGEES,SpendingReviewPaper:TrendsinPublicExpenditure(2018).Availablehere:https://www.gov.ie/en/collection/6551ae-spend-ing-review-2018/#public-sector-staffing-pay-and-pensions
22 IGEES,BudgetaryImpactofChangingDemographics2017–2027(September,2016).Availablehere:https://igees.gov.ie/budgetary-im-pact-of-changing-demographics-2017-to-2027/
23 CSO:QuarterlyNationalAccountsandInternationalAccountsresultsforQuarter12019.Availablehere:https://cso.ie/en/csolatestnews/pressreleases/2019pressreleases/prnaq119/
24 DepartmentofFinance:PopulationAgeingandthePublicFinances(August2018).Availablehere:https://www.gov.ie/en/publica-tion/2e8463-population-ageing-and-the-public-finances/
![Page 74: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
74
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Economic & Environmental Risks: Public Expenditure Pressures; Delivery of Public Infrastructure; Risk of Overheating; Supply & Affordability of Housing
Givencurrentbudgetarypressures,asoutlinedinSection3.3above,‘PublicExpenditurePressures’,itisimportanttorecognisetherisksthatdemographicchangeswillposefortheExchequer.Asoutlinedabove,anageingpopulationissettoincreasethenumberofExchequer-fundedpensionpayments,andtheirspanoveralongerperiodoftime,andtocreateadditionalpressuresontheprovisionofhealthcareservices,tonamebuttwosectors.AsdiscussedinPart2above,arangeofothersectors,includingtransport,housingandeducation,willneedtoadjusttochangingdemographicsrequiringthepublicfinancestoabsorbtherelateddemandsforadditionalcurrentandcapitalexpenditure.
AsmentionedinSection5.3above,‘DeliveryofPublicInfrastructure’,increasesinpop-ulationcoupledwithanunder-supplyofhousingandassociatedaffordabilityissues,atighteninglabourmarketandthecontinuedstrengthofeconomicgrowth,couldgiverisetooverheatingintheeconomy.ThisisalsolinkedwithSection3.2,‘RiskofOverheating’,whichalsodiscussestheneedtomaintainIreland’scompetitivenessinordertoensurestrongeconomicgrowth.Discussedinthemainreport,issuesaroundthesupplyofhous-ingremainoneofthemostcriticalchallengescurrentlyfacingtheState.Thishasledtochallengesaroundaffordabilityaspricesandrentsincrease.Asmentionedabove,asthepopulationincreasesandgetsolderthesupplyofadditionalandadequatehousingmaybecomeamoresignificantchallengeoverthelong-term.
Itisclearthatforwardplanningisvitaltoensureinfrastructureneedsaremet,toensuresufficientcapacityisdevelopedinlinewithboththeincreaseinpopulationanditschang-ingstructure,andalsotoensurethatpublicfinancesremainstableinordertobeabletorespondtocurrentandfuturespendinglevelslinkedwithachangingdemography.
Economic, Social & Technological Risks: RelianceonMNCs§oralconcentration;InternationalTaxchanges;CapacityofHigher&FurtherEducationSystem;SkilledLabourShortages;ImpactofDisruptiveTechnologytrendsonjobs&theeconomy
Inoutliningtherisksaroundrelianceonmultinationalcorporations’andsectoralconcen-tration,themainReportdiscusseshowIreland’seconomyisheavilyinfluencedbymultina-tionalcorporations(MNCs),concentratedinafewenterprisesectors.Ireland’sattractive-nessforFDIiscomprisedofamultitudeoffactors,includingafavourablylowcorporationtaxrate.Theavailabilityofayoung,skilledandeducatedworkforce,however,isalsoapull-factorforMNCstoconductbusinessinIreland.
Asthesizeofourworkforcenarrows,coupledwithquestionsaroundthesustainabilityofthefundingmodelfortheHigherEducationsector,thisrisksareductioninIreland’sat-tractivenessasacountrytoinvestin.GivenIreland’srelianceoncorporationtaxreceiptstodate,thiscouldhaveknockoneffectstothepublicexpenditurepressures,mentionedabove.AsdiscussedaboveinPart2ofthisthematicpiece,demographicmovementswillplaceincreasingpressuresonthehighereducationsystemovertheshort-to-mediumterm.Thiscontinuedgrowthofenrolmentsissettopeakin2029.Inordertomaintainthesamelevelofqualityeducation,theremaybecallsforpublicfundingtorisetomeetthisde-mand.
![Page 75: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
75
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Followingonfrom2029,asthenumberofstudentspredictedtoenrolbeginstodecline,andwhilerelatedpublicexpenditurepressuresmayease,areductioninthenumberofstudentswiththirdleveleducationmayreduceIreland’sattractivenesstoMNCs,asabove,andmayresultinareductionintheeconomicbenefitsassociatedwithbothourhighlevelofFDI,andouruniversitysector.AsmentionedinSection4.1above,theIrishUniversitiesAssociationestimatethattheIrisheconomybenefittedby€8.9billionin2018fromIre-land’ssevenuniversities.
Anageingpopulationmayalsohaveimplicationsforproductivity.Researchhasbeeninconclusiveabouttheeffectsanageingpopulationhasonproductivity25,howeverrecentworkbytheIMFfoundthatanageingworkforcereducesgrowthinlabourproductivity,duetothenegativeeffectontotalfactorproductivitygrowth26.TheIMFalsostatethatthelargestnegativeimpactwilloccurincountrieswhererapidworkforceageingisanticipatedinconjunctionwithhighdebtburdens,andtheysiteIrelandasanexampleinthiscontext.
Section4.2discussestherisksaroundskillsshortagesinthelabourmarket,andinpartic-ularthelowparticipationratesintheeconomy.Asthelabourforcedeclinesinthefutureduetoanageingpopulation,thisriskmaybeexacerbated,particularlypost2029asthenumberofhigher-levelgraduatesbeginstodecline.
Asdiscussedintherisksarounddisruptivetechnologytrends,thelikelihoodofautomationreplacingjobsandimpactingothersisincreasing,with2outofevery5jobsathighriskofautomation.Ifautomationresultsinanincreaseinunemployment,thisdisplacementofjobscouldhaveanegativeknockoneffecttothecollectionofincometaxes,oneoftheleastvolatiletaxrevenuestreams(inadditiontothewidersocietaleffectsthatwouldarise).Asdiscussed,anarrowingtaxbasewouldpresentchallengesinfutureyearsinordertomeetfuturedemandscausedbychangingdemographics.TheimpactofthesedisruptivetechnologytrendswillneedtobemonitoredandoptimisedforIrelandtounlocksomeoftheopportunitiestheymaybring.Inparticular,itwillbeimportanttoensureweplanforthesetrendsthroughincreasinglife-longlearningandupskillingopportunitiesforthoseatriskofdisplacement.
Social Risks: Social Cohesion including Perceptions of Rural and Regional Imbalances; Migration & Integration
Growinglevelsofinequalityhavebeenacauseforconcernbothnationallyandinternation-ally.Section4.5,‘SocialCohesionincludingPerceptionsofRuralandRegionalImbalances’,notesthattaxationandsocialpolicytransfershavebeeneffectiveinoffsettingmarketincomeinequality.Aswehaveseenalready,increasesintheOADRarelikelytocreatepressuresontheprovisionofsocialservicesandpayments.Itisimportanttoconsidertheeffectsofchangingdemographicsonincomeinequalityandensuringthatlevelsofpovertydonotincreaseasaresultofapossibledeclineintaxrevenuestreamstoredistribute.
Althoughdemographicchangescanleadtonegativeconsequencesinthecaseoftherisksmentionedabove,whendiscussingrisksaroundmigrationandintegration,increasedimmigrationcouldhaveapositiveeffectonIreland’sdemographicstructure.Generally,
25 Maestasetal.(2016)findsthatanageingpopulationreducesthegrowthrateofGDP,mainlydrivenbyaslowdowninthegrowthrateoflabourproductivityofworkersacrosstheagedistribution(availablehere:https://www.nber.org/papers/w22452),whileBurtless(2013)findsthat’sworkersagedbetween60-74aremoreproductivethanyoungerworkersandfindslittleevidencethatanageingworkforcehashurtproductivity(availablehere:https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2275023).
26 IMFWorkingPaper:TheImpactofWorkforceAgingonEuropeanProductivity(2016).Availablehere:https://www.imf.org/en/Publica-tions/WP/Issues/2016/12/31/The-Impact-of-Workforce-Aging-on-European-Productivity-44450
![Page 76: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
76
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
immigrantsareofaworkingagewhenenteringacountry,withthelatestCSOCensusdatashowingthatnearlyhalfofallnon-Irishnationalswereagedbetween25and42comparedwithlessthanaquarterofIrishnationals.Personsaged65yearsoroveraccountedforlessthan5percentofthenon-Irishpopulationinsharpcontrasttothenearly15percentforIrishnationalsandtheyoungeragecohort(0-14years)accountedfor12.3percentofnon-Irishnationals,comparedwith22.5percentofIrishnationals.
Predictionsofmigrationtrendscanbedifficult,astheseareinfluencedbyeconomicper-formance,howeverifnetmigrationremainspositive,i.e.thenumberofpeopleenteringIrelandisgreaterthanpeopleleaving,thiscouldimprovetheprojectednumberofpeopleintheIrishworkforceinyearstocome.
Environmental Risks: Climate Change & Biodiversity
Climateactioniscurrentlyoneofthehighest-priorityissuesformanycountries,includingIreland.Asthenumberofpeoplelivinginourcountryincreases,sotoodoesthedemandforfood,transportservices,housingetc.Increaseddemandforgoodsandservicesstem-mingfromagrowingpopulationmayresultinanincreasedcarbonfootprint.TheGovern-ment’srecentlypublishedClimateActionPlanonClimateBreakdownreferstoIreland’spredictedpopulationgrowthof1millionpeopleby2040,whichmayresultingreaterdemandfortransportacrossvariousmodes,intensifyingthedecarbonisationchallenge.
Transport,however,isnottheonlysectoroftheeconomyinwhichgreaterdemandmayleadtoanincreaseinemissions.Agriculture,touseoneotherexample,historicallyandcur-rentlyisthelargestgreenhousegas-emittingsectorinthecountry.Thereisariskthatasthepopulationincreases,wewillseerelatedincreasesindemandforhousingandtrans-port,aswellasanincreaseineconomicgrowth.Theserisks,however,maybemitigated,nowandintothefuture,asplanstotackleclimatechangetakefulleffect,andnewtech-nologiesaredeveloped.
Environmental and Technological Risks: Food Safety; Anti-Microbial Resistance; and Major Pandemics
AsdiscussedinPart2above,pressureontheprovisionofhealthcareinIrelandwillin-creaseduetoincreasesinthepopulationintheolderagecohort.Risksaround‘FoodSafety’,‘Anti-MicrobialResistance’and‘MajorPandemics’,asdiscussedinthemainreport,couldbeexacerbatediftheseriskscometopass.Itisalsoworthnotingthattheserisks,havingmajorhealthconsequences,couldpotentiallydisproportionallyaffectolderpeople,whichcouldplaceevengreaterpressureonthehealthsystemanditscapacitytodealwithsuchacrisis.
Conclusion
IntakingacloserlookatthechangingstructureandprojectedfuturetrendsinIreland’spopulation,andsettingthesetrendsagainstanInternationalbackdrop,itisclearthatIreland’spopulationisageing,inlinewithtrendsevidentinmanyothernations.Thesechangesbringaboutsignificantrisksandimplicationsforfutureplanning,bothhereandelsewhere.
TheserisksarediscussedthroughoutPart2ofthispiece,highlightingthosesectorsthat
![Page 77: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
77
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
aremostvulnerabletopopulationchangesandtheeffectsofanageingpopulation.Whilethesesectorsareseenasmostatrisk,wecanseefromPart3thattheimplicationsofachangingdemographicstructurearetrulycross-cutting,impactingon,andinsomecasesexacerbatingmanyoftherisksfacingIrelandcurrently.
Inthiscontext,whilesomeofthechangesandimplicationsmaybeviewedasmediumorlonger-termtrends,theimplicationsaresowide-rangingandpervasiveastounderscoretheimportanceofcontinuingtoplannowfortheconsequencestheymaybringacrossallsphereswithinIreland’seconomyandsociety.
Thesedemographictrends,asadriveracrossarangeofrisks,thereforehighlighttheimportanceofpolicyresponsesincludingincreasingtheStatePensionAge,increasingparticipationratesofolderpeopleintheworkforce,increasingsavingsforprivatepensionprovision,deliveringonreformsforhealthcareandthehealthsystem,andconsiderationofpoliciesthatwouldstemthefurtherdeclineinfertilityandbirthrates,inworkingtomiti-gatetherisksofageingpopulation.
![Page 78: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
78
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Annex 3. Snapshot of results from public consultation
![Page 79: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
79
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Annex 4. National Risk Assessment Public Consultation – groups/individuals that made a submission
ApartmentOwnersNetworkBirdWatchIrelandCARICiscoErviaEuropeanPlatformAgainstWindFarmsFeastaGetupandGoals,APartnershipwithAfricaICMSAIrishCongressofTradeUnionsIrishEnvironmentalNetworkIrishFarmersAssociationPegasusRiskConsultingc.640PrivateIndividualsSeánFleming,T.D.andSenatorMarkDalySocialJusticeIrelandSocietyofCharteredSurveyorsIrelandUnionofStudentsinIrelandZeroWasteAllianceIreland
![Page 80: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
80
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
Annex 5. National Risk Assessment Public Consultation – risks highlighted by respondents
Thefollowingtablesummarisestheriskshighlightedbythe650+respondentstothepublicconsultation.ItalsooutlineshowtherisksarereflectedinthefinalReport,asappropriate.
Theresponsesweresubmittedinanswertothequestion:‘Have the correct strategic risks been identified or are there other significant risks that should be included?’
![Page 81: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
81
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 82: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
82
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 83: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
83
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 84: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
84
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 85: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
85
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 86: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
86
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 87: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
87
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 88: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
88
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 89: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
89
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 90: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
90
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 91: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
91
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
![Page 92: 2019...Assessment 2019 was published for pub-lic consultation in May and laid before the Houses of the Oireachtas. Over 650 sub-missions were received as part of this con-sultation,](https://reader036.vdocuments.net/reader036/viewer/2022070811/5f099d0e7e708231d427ac79/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
National Risk Assessment – Overview of Strategic Risks 2019
gov.ie