-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
1/50
2009Submitted by:
Anoop Kumar
3/20/2009
1 | P a g e
Impact of Loyalty programs on ConsumerPurchase behavior and design for an effective
loyalty card
usiness Research Methodologyatch 2008 - 2010
Submitted to:P. Bhardwaj
d Term project reportbmitted in partial fulfillment for theurse requirement of Business Researchthodology, Term III
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
2/50
CONTENTS
2 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
3/50
3 | P a g e
Declaration 3
Acknowledgement 4
Assumption used and scope of the study 5
Executive Summary 6
Introduction
I. Defining Loyalty
II. Loyalty programs basics
III. Benefits of Loyalty Programs
IV. Loyalty Program costs
8
Current Loyalty Program landscape 14
Literature review 16
Research Hypothesis 22
Methodology 22
Findings ,Analysis and Explication 24
Designing a Loyalty program 30
Suggested features of a contemporary loyalty Program 35
Scope for further research 37
Concluding Remarks 38
Appendices 39
Sources 43
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
4/50
Declaration
We, the undersigned, student managers (first year) at IMT Nagpur,
hereby declare that the opinions, analysis and implications contained in this
report have been predominantly drawn from our research on the subject:
Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Purchase Behavior and
design for a contemporary Loyalty Program and the accuracy of this
report is subject to the authenticity of the data provided by our respondents.
Other secondary sources of data, opinions and projections include magazine
articles, journals, Research papers and websites. The accuracy of this data
could not be verified. There may be significant variations in opinions across
countries and its people, consequently, readers discretion is advised.
4 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
5/50
Place: IMT NagpurDate: 30th March 2009
Anoop Kumar (08HR012)
Acknowledgement
We express our sincere gratitude to Smriti Y Verma maam, our BRM
course instructor, for giving us the opportunity and freedom to work on a
contemporary and relevant topic. We believe that the knowledge and
experience gained during the preparation of this report would be beneficial
to us as future managers. We are thankful to her for giving us periodic
guidance and encouragement to excel in all that we do in our careers.
We would also like to thank the IMTNs Library and IT staff for providing
us with all the resources needed for successful completion of this report.
We extend our heartfelt gratitude towards all our friends and family who
took the time and effort to fill our questionnaire, not to forget all the
5 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
6/50
strangers who accepted our request and gave us their views regarding
loyalty cards.
The acknowledgement would not be complete without a vote of thanks to
our critique group- Saurabh Jain, Shekhar Parashar, Shreyaa R Ranjan, Vinay
Chhajer and Saurabh Bharadwaj. Their genuine and insightful comments at
the right times, guided and helped us improve upon the content and feel of
our questionnaire and its analysis.
Thank you all!!!!
Assumptions and scope of the research
The Limitations of our study are as follows:
1. The results could be skewed because of a small sample size of 121 only.
2. Only the apparel industry is studied under this survey.
3. The scope of the research is limited to the city of Nagpur only.
4. People who have loyalty cards are assumed to be active loyalty programmembers.
6 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
7/50
We have undertaken this research project to find out the impact of loyalty cards on
consumer purchase behavior. Demographic and geographic constraints have limited
the findings and implications of this study. The data was collected from primary
sources, mainly from the consumers of Nagpur city. Most of the other respondents
were contacted through online questionnaires. Although efforts were made to
collect data from respondents belonging to various age groups, large numbers of
respondents were students in the age group of 22 to 25; hence the results could be
largely applicable to this age group.
Executive Summary
In his thought provoking book, The Loyalty Effect, author Frederick F. Reichheld
writes
Loyalty is one of the great engines of business success.
Loyalty programs are initiated by businesses with two main goals. The primary goal
for most loyalty programs is the acquisition of information relating to their
7 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
8/50
customers' spending habits, while the secondary goal is to actively cultivate loyalty
amongst customers to ensure they continue patronizing the business. While some
companies do reverse these priorities, the above hierarchy holds true for most.
Loyalty programs may offer benefits in a number of different ways. Many loyalty
programs offer a sustained discount (such as 10%) for a period of time - perhaps a
year, perhaps for the life of the business. Others offer a discount once certain
criteria have been met for example, a 20% discount on a single purchase once a
customer has spent $200 at the business. Still others offer points which may then
be redeemed for products which may or may not be directly related to the business.
Loyalty cards are the most common form of loyalty programs found throughout the
world today. In the United States, almost seventy-five percent of consumers own at
least one loyalty card, with over a third of all shoppers owning two or more. Major
supermarket chains, such as Safeway and Albertsons, nearly all have loyalty cards,
also known as rewards cards or benefit cards. These supermarket loyalty programs
usually operate by offering a discount on certain products, usually marked
throughout the store, to those who have a loyalty card. In exchange for this
discount, customers are giving the store access to itemized receipts of their buying
habits in the store, allowing the business to better cater to their needs and build
product purchasing and discounting to help retain their most profitable customers.
Loyalty programs have gained in popularity immensely in the past fifteen years, in
no small part due to the development of a culture of entitlement, in which
consumers feel that they deserve special treatment. Businesses have capitalized on
this when designing their loyalty programs, often offering benefits that cost little,
but carry with them an assumed prestige, such as access to faster-moving lines or
special parking spaces.
So we did this research with the aim to find that Is there any impact on the
customers loyalty by these loyalty programs. There were many other questions
which were to be answered such as What are the factors affecting customers
loyalty, Is loyalty greater than loyalty card or vice versa, Does loyalty programs
8 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
9/50
really works etc. We did a survey to find relationship between loyalty programs and
customer loyalty.
The outcomes of the research showed that there are many factors of a loyalty
program which has an impact on customer loyalty. These factors include discounts,
special offers, preferential treatment etc. Since customer loyalty is highly
dependent on each buyers individual perception, hence these are some factors
which have greater influence on wider consumer base. Acceptability of a loyalty
program by the consumer population has been a major issue. Hence these factors if
included in the loyalty program may increase its degree of success.
Ultimately, the success of loyalty programs depends on how well the business uses
the data it gathers to further refine its policies and loyalty programs. Many
businesses find little profit in the use of loyalty programs, while others, such as
eBay, attribute much of their financial success to a well-executed use of such
programs.
INTRODUCTION
9 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
10/50
Loyalty programs are everywhere in business. Customers interact with them
multiple times almost every daywhether shopping at a grocery store, buying a
cup of coffee, flying on an airline, staying at a hotel, or paying a cell phone bill. Inother words, companies have become convinced that it is possible to buy
customers loyalty. Do loyalty programs really work, or are these companies just
wasting their money? Can a loyalty program change how people behave and get
them to spend more money with that company? Can loyalty programs reduce the
likelihood that customers will move their business to a competitor?
This report attempts to answer these questions and takes a detailed look at the
current environment for loyalty programs and the strategies businesses are using in
implementing these programs. In addition, the paper presents a series of best
practices that can create meaningful competitive advantages for companies that
offer loyalty programs (that is, host companies), their partners, and their
customers.
DEFINING LOYALTY
Before examining how loyalty programs work, it is important to define exactly
what is meant by loyalty in the context of business development and retention.
Several broad definitions exist, including the following:
The commitment of customers to a particular brand or company
The extent to which your customers continue with key loyalty behavior when
competitors offer more attractive prices, products, and/or services
Faithful to any person or thing conceived of as deserving fidelity... characterized
by or showing faithfulness
For this report, loyalty is defined as follows: Loyalty is a positive belief,
generated over the course of multiple interactions, in the value that a company and
10 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
11/50
its products and/or services provide, which leads to continued interactions and
purchases over time.
Loyalty should not be confused with customer satisfaction. Although loyalty is built
on satisfaction, organizations can have satisfaction without loyalty. Customersatisfaction is an opinion measure about company performance and how
customers feel their needs were met in past interactions or by past purchases,
whereas customer loyalty is a results measure that includes expectations of future
behavior.
For example, 75 percent of consumer wireless customers are satisfied with their
current service, but 72 percent would be willing to switch to a competing provider.
Thus, when designing a rewards program to build loyalty, it is critical to think
about how to encourage true long-term customer loyalty and not just fleetingcustomer satisfaction.
LOYALTY PROGRAM BASICS
Companies typically have several goals when launching loyalty programs, all of
which are focused on generating greater profits from the programs members.
These goals include
Improving knowledge of the customer
Leveraging that knowledge to increase the sales of undersold and/or
highly profitable products/services
Increasing customer retention and purchase frequency
The most common type of loyalty program begins when a customer enrolls. From
that point forward, the organization accurately tracks information about that
member, captures the members purchases, credits points to the member based
on the rules stored in a loyalty engine, categorizes the member in tiers or groups
based on the members value to the organization, and enables the member toredeem points for products or services when various point levels are attained. The
specific types of behavior that are tracked and rewarded are unique to each
industry/company and are typically linked to the organizations profitability drivers.
11 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
12/50
BENEFITS OF LOYALTY PROGRAMS
Greater Customer Knowledge
A loyalty program enables a company to gain detailed knowledge about itscustomer base with the customers consent; customers actually want to provide
transaction and detailed profile information to ensure that they receive the full
benefits of being a member of the program. In some market segmentssuch as
business-to-businesscompanies already possess significant knowledge about their
customers. As a result, these firms will not see customer knowledge as an important
component of a loyalty programs value. However, for most business-to-consumer
companies, gaining this level of intimate customer knowledge is a critical benefit of
a loyalty program. In such B2C industries, loyalty programs enable companies to
match their faceless customer purchase data (what was bought, when, at what
store) with specific customer profile information, which can then be used to create
targeted marketing promotions or redesign services around high-value customers
needs.
Increased Customer Retention
A well-honed loyalty program improves customer retention rates, by increasing a
members switching costs, which are costs a member would bear in order to
switch to a competing provider. These costs can include decreased service and the
time and resources required to build a new relationship. The higher a members
switching costs, the more likely that member is to remain loyal.
Most loyalty programs today do not create high enough switching costs for
members. For example, airline industry frequent-flier programs all provide virtually
the same product (a seat, perhaps with a few extra inches of legroom) and the
same membership benefits (separate customer service number, priority boarding,
priority upgrades, and bonus miles). If gold-tier members on one airline want to
switch to a competitor because the competitor just added nonstop service on their
favorite routes, all they have to do is fax the competitor their last frequent-flier
12 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
13/50
statement, and they will immediately be made gold members of the competitors
frequent-flier program. Because the products and services these two airlines and
their loyalty programs provide are virtually identical, the members can switch to a
competing carrier at virtually no cost to themselves.
However, if the first loyalty program offered a unique set of benefits that the
competing carrier could not easily duplicate, it would be much less tempting for
members to switch. Companies use their loyalty programs to create these switching
costs, by
Leveraging in-depth member profile and transaction data to create unique offers
and product/services that a competitor, which does not know as much about themember, cannot match
Providing targeted service consistently across all channels
By using the personalized data provided by their loyalty program, companies can
create a win-win relationship with their members that cannot easily be replicated by
their competitors.
Differentiated Service and Brand Equity
Most companies do not want to compete on price. Even those whose business
models are initially predicated upon providing the lowest-cost service (for example,
low-cost carriers such as Southwest Airlines and JetBlue Airways) often find that
they must focus on providing value beyond price as they mature, their costs rise,
and new upstarts beat them on price.
In addition, for companies that have not traditionally competed on price but
suddenly find that their products are becoming commodities, brand equity is often
determined by the additional value these companies can provide beyond products
13 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
14/50
alone. Today, companies in a number of industries are in this position. Examples
include airlines that have reduced their offering to basically a seat with no food or
frills, big box retail stores that have depersonalized the shopping experience, and
wireless firms whose networks have now reached parity.
Companies can create this additional value by moving away from generic, one
product-meets-all-requirement products to targeted products and services that
address their customers unique needs. A loyalty program provides this detailed
information on transactions, demographics, and personal preferences required to
successfully identify the unique groups among a companys customer base and
then design products or services that meet those segmented members needs. For
example, retailers can use their loyalty data to ensure that the products desired by
high-value customers are always in stock, are easy to find and reach, and are
prominently displayed.
It is critical to note that customers are typically willing to pay for those products and
services that do a better job of meeting their underserved needs. For example, 83
percent of hotel guests say that personalized service and attention to their needs
14 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
15/50
provides value. It is value, rather than price, that defines a good deal for these
customers. Brand equity, which is achieved by providing highly valued, well
differentiated products and services, is the cornerstone of loyalty. It is the additional
value that customers believe a company provides relative to its competitors thatencourages loyalty to the host company and makes customers potentially willing to
pay more for its products and services.
Improved Profitability
All of the benefits discussed to this point lead to a loyalty programs key goal and
most important metric of success: improved profitability. Greater profits are a result
of
Profitable customer retention
Higher prices paid for unique products/services
Increased average purchase size
Decreased marketing and systems costs
Decreased unsold expired inventory
Increasing customer
retention significantly
improves a companys
profitability. According to
Frederick Reichheld of Bain
& Company, a 5 percent
increase in customer
retention results in a 25
percent to 100 percent
increase in profitability.
There are several sources
of these additional profits,
which Reichheld breaks
15 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
16/50
down into price premium, referrals, cost savings, revenue growth, and acquisition
cost.
LOYALTY PROGRAM COSTS
Despite their many benefits, loyalty programs can be expensive to develop and
maintain. The costs associated with loyalty programs generally fall into two
categories: program costs and system costs.
Program costs are nontechnical expenses related to administering the programs
points, rewards, and services.
System costs are those invested in the technical infrastructure to support the
loyalty program.
Although some costs are directly attributable to the programfor example, loyalty
program management softwarethere are other costs a company would likely incur
even without a loyalty program, such as marketing software and hosting a Web site.
However, even these costs can be increased due to factors such as integrating the
marketing software with loyalty software or providing additional loyalty-related
functionality on the company Web site.
A companys program costs will vary significantly, depending on the rewards that
are provided. For example, airlines and hotels, which are high-fixed-cost, low
variable-cost businesses, will have lower program costs. This is because airlines can
allow members to use points to redeem only those seats that would otherwise go
unsold. The cost to fly additional people who purchased their tickets with points is
trivial. Further, although members can use airline points to purchase products with
any of the airlines partners (hotels, car rental agencies, and selected retailers),
people place such a high value on airline seats that nonairline flight redemptions
account for only approximately 3 percent of all airline loyalty program redemptions.
16 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
17/50
Other companies, such as retailers, in which every product redeemed for points
must be paid for by the company with cash, will have higher program costs. For
example, depending upon the programs rewards and generosity, a retailers loyalty
program can cost between 2 percent and 10 percent of a customers totalexpenditures.
C URRENT LOYALTY PROGRAM LANDSCAPE
The first mileage-based loyalty program was launched by American Airlines more
than 23 years ago (May 1981).Today, loyalty programs are ubiquitous. There are
more than one billion people worldwide enrolled in loyalty programs,and in some
industries such as airlines and hotels, loyalty programs have become one of the
most critical means by which companies manage their customer relationships.
More than 125 million people worldwide are enrolled in airline loyalty
programs.
About 76 percent of all U.S. grocery retailers with 50 or more stores have a
loyalty program.
Almost 50 percent of the top U.K. retailers have loyalty programs.
About 75 percent of Americans belong to at least one loyalty program.
Shoppers stop claims more than 60% of sales from loyalty members.
Subhiksha claims 80% of sales comes from loyalty members.
Loyalty programs are considered to be one of the most effective relationship
marketing tool across the industry. Loyalty programs are offered not only by the
MBOs but it is also offered by saloons, casinos, hypermarkets etc. MBOs (multi
brand outlets) like Shoppers Stop, Westside, Pantaloons, Lifestyle, Globus, Indiabulls
megastore (pyramids) in India have active loyalty programs in our research
17 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
18/50
category (apparel industry). Let us look at the benefits given by current loyalty
programs:
Shoppers Stop
BenefitsClassic
momentsSilver edge Golden glow
First citizenship N - -
First citizen rewardpoints (on netpurchase)
1 reward point forevery purchase of
Rs. 100
1 reward pointfor every
purchase of Rs.50
1 reward point forevery purchase of
Rs. 34
Extra reward points on
preferred brands
- 1% 2%
Associate card yes (Rs. 100)yes (up to 2: Rs
100)Yes 2 free (3rd:Rs
100)
Regular updates Yes Yes Yes
Exclusive cashcounters*
Yes YesExclusive golden
glow cash counter
Free Parking* Yes# Yes#
Yes* -Reservedparking on a firstcome first serve
basis
Valet parking* Yes^ Yes^ Yes^Free first update - - Yes
Home delivery of alterations
- - Yes
Out-store offers Yes yes Yes
Exclusive previews-merchandise &sale
Yes Yes Yes
Validity 1 Year 1 Year 1 Year
Upgradation >= Rs.10000 >= Rs.40000 >= Rs.40000* conditions apply
#Parking charges reimbursable against purchase at shoppers stop only
^ Available at select stores
18 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
19/50
Consolidated list of the benefits offer:
ParticularsShoppers stop
Pantaloons
Westside
Globus
Redeemable reward points Y Y Y YUpdates Y N Y Y
Exclusive cash counter Y N N Y
Free parking Y N N N
Valet parking Y N N N
Home delivery of altered goods Y N Y Y
Exclusive sale Y Y Y Y
Special occasiondiscounts(birthday\anniversary)
N N Y Y
Exclusive billing counter duringsale
N Y N N
Reserved parking N N N Y*Note: The benefits are offered by different retailers at different levels (i.e. silver,
gold, platinum card).
The main benefits that retailers are focusing today are discounts on the basis of
accumulated points, the points are offered on the basis of the net shopping credited
in their card at the end of a pre decided period. The discounts are not offered
directly except for few occasions. This implies that they are offering deferredbenefits.
LITERATURE REVIEW
Diverse Performances of Loyalty Programs
Prior research has documented mixed outcomes of loyalty programs operating in
the same markets. For example, Meyer-Waarden and Benavent (2006) compare a
consumer panels observed purchases at seven grocery stores with Dirichletpredictions and find excessive loyalty attributable to loyalty programs for only three
stores. The loyalty programs that Leenheer and colleagues (2007) study also varied
on their share-of-wallet impact and profitability. A natural question from these
19 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
20/50
mixed findings is why loyalty programs exhibit diverse performance. Although this
phenomenon may not be surprising, a systematic understanding of the factors
contributing to diverse loyalty program performances is important because it can
aid in managers assessment of whether a loyalty program is appropriate in acertain context and can help identify ways of improving the effectiveness of such
programs (Bolton, Kannan, and Bramlett 2000).
In studying loyalty program performance, it is important to recognize that loyalty
programs do not operate as separate entities in an isolated environment. Their
success depends not only on the programs themselves but also on other facilitating
or inhibiting factors present in the environment. Specifically, we propose three sets
of factors that represent the main market entities involved: the focal loyaltyprogram, the consumers (i.e., target market), and rival programs and firms (i.e.,
competition). Figure 1 lists the factors and sample studies within each set. Of these,
programrelated factors explain a firms internal strategies that can contribute to the
success of a loyalty program, whereas consumer and competition factors represent
things in the external environment that are equally important to loyalty program
performance. We argue that it is the joint force of all these factors that determines
the eventual outcome of a loyalty program. This line of thinking resembles other
studies of marketing strategy, in which the initiation and outcomes of marketingstrategies are affected by both the internal environment of the firm and external
market and industry environments (Varadarajan and Jayachandran 1999).
20 | P a g e
Figure 1
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
21/50
Competing Loyalty Programs: Impact of Market Saturation, Market Share and CategoryExpandability: Journal of Marketing Vol. 73 (January 2009), 93108
Before we turn to the literature, however, it is important to note that loyalty
program performance can be measured in multiple ways. Nunes and Drze (2006)
suggest that loyalty programs can serve different goals, such as retaining
customers, increasing spending, and gaining customer insights. Therefore, each
program should have its own unique set of success measures depending on its
intended goals. For cross-comparison purposes, however, it is also useful to
21 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
22/50
examine some standard measures. Prior research has used consumer level
outcomes, such as purchase frequency, transaction size, and share of wallet, as well
as firm-level factors, such as store sales and traffic. Although all these measures are
useful, because each measure may be driven by different underlying mechanisms,caution should be taken before directly comparing some of the existing studies.
Existing Research on Loyalty Program Performance
Program-related factors:
Program-related factors include both program design and management. From the
design perspective, a loyalty program needs three key specifications: (1)
participation requirements, (2) point structure, and (3) rewards. The first element
pertains to the convenience and cost of participation. Participation modes can be
differentiated by voluntary versus automatic enrollment and free versus fee-based
membership. Programs also differ in terms of how convenient it is for consumers to
participate (OBrien and Jones 1995). For example, some programs automatically
accumulate points, whereas others require more effort from consumers, such as
manual code entry required by My Coke Rewards. OBrien and Jones (1995) suggest
that the convenience of participation can affect the appeal of a loyalty program. So
far, however, the effects of participation requirements have not received much
empirical examination.
The second aspect of a loyalty program, point structure, involves how reward points
are issued, what the point thresholds are for redeeming rewards, and whether a
tiered structure is used. Regarding the issuing of reward points, Van Osselaer, Alba,
and Manchanda (2004) find that though point threshold stays the same, the way
points are issued over each purchase (ascending points versus same points per
purchase) affects consumerschoices. This suggests that point issuance is not a
nuisance to consumers and shouldnot be determined arbitrarily. Point threshold is
another important aspect of point structure, and it has been tied in to program
relevance (OBrien and Jones 1995). If the point threshold for a free reward is too
high, it will be considered unobtainable for the average consumers and thus will be
22 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
23/50
dismissed as irrelevant. The final aspect of point structure involves tiered structures
(e.g., gold and platinum memberships based on spending levels). Taking this tiered
structure into account, Kopalle and colleagues (2007) find that program tiers create
a point pressure effect on purchases by both price-conscious and service-orientedconsumers, whereas the frequency reward itself creates such an effect only for
price-conscious consumers.
The third design element, choice and availability of rewards, has received the most
extensive attention in existing studies. This design element includes reward value
and cost, actual rewards offered, and their compatibility with the focal brand. For
example, OBrien and Jones (1995) suggest reward ratio, variety of reward
redemption options, and aspirational value of rewards as important considerations.Kivetz and Simonson (2002) test the aspirational value aspect in an experimental
setting and find its effects to be moderated by effort requirement. A luxury reward
is preferred when effort requirement is high, whereas a less aspirational necessity
reward is preferred when effort requirement is low. A few studies have considered
the congruence between rewards offered and the focal brand and find that, in
general, brand-congruent rewards are more effective than incongruent rewards,
though this effect is moderated by factors such as consumer involvement and
promotional reactance (Kivetz 2005; Roehm, Pullins, and Roehm 2002; Yi and Jeon2003). Focusing more from a firm strategy perspective, Kim, Shi, and Srinivasan
(2001) use game theory to identify the optimal conditions for offering cash versus
free products as rewards. They find that the former is better if there are few price-
sensitive heavy buyers, whereas the latter is more effective when the heavy buyer
group is large or not very price sensitive.
In addition to program design factors, research has shown the impact of program
management on the success of a loyalty program. For example, from a survey of
180 retailers, Leenheer and Bijmolt (2008) conclude that the success of a loyalty
program is affected by the effort spent on capturing and analyzing consumer
intelligence derived from the program. It may be surmised that the success of a
23 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
24/50
loyalty program also depends on organizational support of the program and the
amount of resources dedicated to program management, but these organizational
factors have not been subject to empirical testing.
Consumer characteristics:
Although proper program design and management are critical, it is consumers
reactions to a loyalty program that ultimately determine program success. Fewer
studies have examined the impact of consumer characteristics on loyalty program
effects. Consumer characteristics can be crudely classified into firm specific
attitudinal and behavioral factors versus traits and characteristics that carry across
firms. In the former category, Lal and Bell (2003) and Liu (2007) examine the
moderating effect of consumers usage levels. Contrary to traditional wisdom ofloyalty programs as a defense mechanism mainly for heavy buyers, these studies
find the biggest increase in spending and purchase frequency among light buyers.
This is attributed to loyalty programs ability to eliminate cherry-picking (Lal and
Bell 2003) and to encourage cross-selling (Liu 2007). Within this category of studies,
Kivetz and Simonson (2003) also examine the effect of perceived effort advantage.
Rather than treating point threshold as a program design factor, as we discussed
previously, Kivetz and Simonson find that it is not the effort required per se but the
perceived effort advantage a consumer has over other consumers that affects his orher likelihood of joining a program. This perceived effort advantage again can be
driven by consumers usage levels. However, note that this effort advantage effect
may drive program joining decisions but may not carry over to what consumers do
after they have joined a program.
Additional studies have segmented consumers according to their generic traits or
characteristics, such as socio-demographics (Leenheer et al. 2007), shopping
orientation (Mgi 2003), future orientation (Kopalle and Neslin 2003), variety
seeking (Zhang, Krishna, and Dhar 2000), and price sensitivity (Kim, Shi, and
Srinivasan 2001; Kopalle et al. 2007). However, few of these factors have received
empirical support. This may be attributed to the over generalized nature of these
24 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
25/50
variables. So far, two factors, future orientation and price sensitivity, have received
some support. Because loyalty programs reward consumers current behavior at
some point in the future, it is not surprising that such programs are found to be
more appealing to consumers who do not heavily discount future benefits (Kopalleand Neslin 2003). Corroborating this view, Lewis (2004) finds that treating
consumers as dynamically oriented better explains their purchase decisions in the
presence of a loyalty program. The second factor, price sensitivity, has been found
to moderate consumers reactions to program design elements (Kopalle et al.
2007).
Overall, existing studies of consumer-related factors appear to suggest that firm-
specific behavior and attitudes are better predictors of consumer reaction to aloyalty program. However, further research is needed to identify and test other
consumer traits before a final conclusion can be drawn. We also note that though
consumer-related factors have been mainly used to explain differential responses to
the same loyalty program, they can also contribute to the diverse performances
across programs by considering the varying composition of program members.
Examples of this approach can be found in two game-theoretic models related to
loyalty programs (Kim, Shi, and Srinivasan 2001; Zhang, Krishna, and Dhar 2000), in
which individual characteristics, such as variety seeking and price sensitivity, aretranslated into market characteristics.
Competition-related factors.
One problem with considering only program- and consumer-related factors is that it
puts the program-offering firm and consumers in an isolated setting. In reality,
however, most loyalty programs face competition from rival programs that offer
similar benefits, and enrollment in multiple programs is common. In the retail
industry, for example, consumers hold an average of three loyalty program cards
(Meyer-Waarden 2007). This has led to the suggestion that firms need to take into
account cardholders card portfolios when evaluating the effectiveness of loyalty
programs (Mgi 2003, p. 104). However, research on this type of influence is the
25 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
26/50
scarcest, as is apparent in the shortest list of published studies in this set shown in
Figure 1. A majority of existing studies have examined a single loyalty program in
isolation. Among the few studies that have considered simultaneously the
performances of multiple loyalty programs (e.g., Leenheer et al. 2007; Meyer-Waarden and Benavent 2006), most treat the programs as parallel strategies and
do not explain the inter- action among those programs.
Only four published studies have considered loyalty programs in a competitive
setting. Two of these studies (Mgi 2003; Meyer-Waarden 2007) find that
consumers holding loyalty program cards from competing chains reduces the share
of wallet and customer lifetime for the focal chain. However, they do not consider
the direct effect of competition on program performance, nor do they identify the
reasons for competitive influence. Two earlier studies offer more specific
examination of loyalty program competition and study the effect of firm-level
factors. Nako (1992) analyzes travel records from three firms in the Philadelphia
and Baltimore metropolitan areas. The results show that the value of a frequent-flier
program increases with the airlines share in a travelers main airport, suggesting
the influence of a firms market position on the success of its loyalty program. Along
similar lines, Kopalle and Neslin (2003) model loyalty program competition and
demonstrate that free rewards offered by firms charging higher prices are valued
more by consumers. However, this proposition is not empirically tested and is likely
to be constrained by model assumptions about market conditions and consumer
behavior.
Summary
With limited research on loyalty programs, it is still unclear to what extent loyalty
programs are effective and, more important, what induces the success and failure
of different programs. Although some studies have examined the moderating
effects of program and consumer characteristics, existing research tends to put a
loyalty program in a vacuum that is void of impact from rival firms and programs.
26 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
27/50
This omission of competitive influence is undesirable; prior research has shown that
myopic profit maximization without considering competition can lead to suboptimal
firm decisions (e.g., Carpenter et al. 1988). It also counters the marketplace reality
of loyalty program proliferation within many industries. Questions still remain as towhether competitive loyalty programs in such industries really cancel one anothers
effects out, creating a zero-sum game, or whether some firms may enjoy
asymmetric advantages with their loyalty programs due to their competitive
positioning. Answers to these questions are critical to a complete understanding of
loyalty programs. Incorporating competition will also offer more useful decision
support to loyalty program managers and to firms that are pondering the
establishment of a new loyalty program in the presence of existing rival programs.
RESEARCH HYPOTHESIS
The main objective of this study was to study the impact of loyalty program on the
consumer purchase behavior and thus also to bring out the ways consumers
perceive a loyalty program to be. The study is also conducted to determine the
factors which consumers appreciate in a loyalty program the most and which they
dont. Thus according to the findings of the study the research aims to design a
contemporary loyalty program.
The following hypotheses are developed to test the study:
1. Store purchase frequency is higher for loyalty program members vis-a-vis non-
loyalty program members.
2. Loyalty precedes loyalty cards.
3. Discount is significant features for a loyalty program
4. Significance of loyalty card on consumer purchase behavior
METHODOLOGY
A sample design is a definite plan for obtaining a sample from a given population. It
refers to the technique or the procedure the researcher would adopt in selecting
items from the sample. Since the population size is infinite sample size for the study
27 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
28/50
was taken as 121 respondents. The research includes data collection only from
primary sources.
All the respondents were 16 years or older. The respondents included both loyalty
program members as well as non members. Non members were also included so as
to design a contemporary loyalty card which would suit the needs of the potential
customers. A mall intercept and web based approach was selected for the purpose
of data collection. The sampling method thus used was convenient non probability
sampling technique. A questionnaire method approach was adopted.
THE QUESTIONNAIRE
The questionnaire was divided into two parts. In the first section, demographic
items were included to obtain information regarding respondents age, gender,
education and income. These demographic variables helped to explain different
consumption behaviors of different types of consumers. In the second section, items
were asked regarding the concept of store loyalty cards and other factors that may
have an effect on customers store loyalty. The respondents were chosen from a
wide range of income groups and ages. The following parameters were kept in mind
while formulating the questions:
1. Prepared with laymans level of understanding.
2. Short and crisp questions.
3. Respondent friendly layout.
A copy of the questionnaire is attached in the appendix
STATISTICAL TOOLS
When all of the 121 surveys were compiled, the data was coded and entered in
EXCEL. The coded data was sorted and analyzed by SPSS program. Chi-squareanalysis, Cross tabbing and descriptive analysis was used to examine the loyalty
card use and store loyalty variables.
28 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
29/50
FINDINGS, ANALYSIS AND IMPLICATIONS
We test our different hypothesis with three different research designs
H1: Store purchase frequency was higher for loyalty program members
than for non members.
For testing of this hypothesis store purchase frequency was measured by two
variables: the frequency of their visit to the shop and the amount of money they
spent when they visit such shops. All the respondents whether a loyalty program
member or non member were considered for this study. As per the findings of this
research we saw that among 121 respondents 109 were valid data and among
these distributions of respondents were as follows:
All the respondents who had more than one loyalty card were classified as members
and the ones who had zero cards were non members.
For the frequency of visit we could observe the following:
29 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
30/50
All the respondents who shopped for once in a week, once in a month or
twice in a month were classified as high frequency shoppers while the ones
who shopped for once every two months or once every 6 months were
classified as low frequent shoppers.
For the amount spent each visit the following data was collected:
The amount of less than 500 and within 500-2000 was classified under low
frequency and above 2000 was high frequency. To test the relationship between
these variables SPSS was used and cross tabbing was conducted on the variables.
The cross tabbing results were further confirmed by Chi Square test.
The contingency table which was generated with the help of SPSS showed that the
most frequent visitors were the loyalty program members and there is a significant
relationship between these two variables. The Pearson Chi Square coefficient value
is 0.003 which was less than 0.05 which proves that the variables are significantly
related.
The similar test was conducted for amount spent each visit and membership. The
Pearson Chi Square coefficient value is 0.146 which was more than 0.05 which
proves that the variables are not significantly related.
H2: Loyalty precedes loyalty cards.
Through this hypothesis we wanted to test what is more important for a consumer -the loyalty for a store or loyalty card of a store. If a consumer is loyal towards a
particular store but if he is offered a loyalty card of a different store so will he
change his shopping preference or continue being loyal to the same store.
30 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
31/50
Response for the question like Will you shop in your favorite store even if you dont
have loyalty card of the same and Do you tend to increase your purchase from a
particular store even if you dont have a loyalty card of the same were tabulated in
excel. Cross tabbing was done on the two variables and no significant relationshipwas found between the two variables.
H3: Discounts are significant features for a loyalty program.
One of the major aims of our study was to design an ideal loyalty card program. For
this we tested various features like discounts, special offers, preferential treatment
etc., in order to measure their relative impact on consumers. We did this mainly so
that we could find out which feature was most important for the consumers and
which feature would appeal to them most while purchasing a loyalty card.
Accordingly, that feature could be included in our ideal loyalty card program which
could be of use to retailers. For this we asked the consumers a question like You
would want a loyalty card of a particular store because they offer:
1. Discounts
2. Special Offers
3. Updates (New arrivals etc.)
4. Preferential treatment
5. Status Symbol
We asked them to rate the above features on a Likert scale with strongly agree
being coded as 5, agree being coded as 4, neutral being coded as 3, disagree being2 and strongly disagree being 1. The results we obtained are shown in the following
bar graph.
31 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
32/50
Using the above codes, we also calculated the means of all the features, which were
as follows:
Feature Discounts Special offer Updates Preferential
Treatment
Status Symbol
Mean 4.1100 4,0092 3.4771 3.6422 2.8807
From the above table it is clear that discounts have a highest mean which shows
that it is the most preferred feature moreover that can also be pictorially seen inthe bar chart. Thus we concluded that discounts are the most important features of
a loyalty card program.
H4: Significance of loyalty card on consumer purchase behavior
Our last hypothesis was to find out if loyalty cards had any significant impact on
consumer purchase behavior. For this we asked them their opinion on various
questions, the responses to which are shown below:
Questions were as follows:
1. I would shop in any store that suits me regardless of whether they have a
loyalty scheme
2. I shop wherever I get better discounts
3. I usually get better discounts from in-store promotions than loyalty schemes
4. I think a loyalty scheme is worthwhile
5. I have saved substantially due to loyalty program
6. I have loyalty cards which I don't use
7. It takes too long to get anything worthwhile
32 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
33/50
8. I am nervous about how the organization uses the personal information I give
9. I buy products if they earn me extra points
10.I spend less in stores where I dont have a card
11.I wouldnt change where I shop for the sake of a loyalty scheme12.I buy products due to promotions surrounding them
From the above the implications drawn were as follows:
Consumers do not tend to increase their purchase from a particular store just
because they have loyalty card of the same.
Consumers shop in stores which provide better discounts, regardless of
whether they have loyalty card of the same
D ESIGNING A LOYALTY PROGRAM
The popularity of loyalty programs has led numerous companies to offer loyalty
programs that simply mimic the program offered by the leader in their industry.
Rather than providing a competitive advantage, this strategy simply creates a
competitive stalemate while driving up expenses due to the cost of maintaining the
loyalty program.
The key point is that a company must design its loyalty program to createcompetitive advantage today and in the future. In addition, when choosing a system
to support a loyalty program it is important to select a system that provides the
flexibility to cost-effectively make changes as required.
What follows is a high-level, step-by-step process for designing a successful loyalty
program. This ensures that an organizations technology investments will be made
to support business goals, minimizing the chance that technology limitations will
later dictate business strategy.
Step 1: Identify desired business outcomes
33 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
34/50
A loyalty programs goal is obvious to improve profitability. However, companies
generally need to also establish additional, more specific goals for their loyalty
program, such as the following:
Increase sales revenue
Increase the rate of inventory turnover
Improve the service provided to the most valuable members
Identify the least valuable members and then either improve their profitability
or implement a strategy for removing them from the customer base
Clearly articulating specific goals helps ensure that the actions and mind-sets of
everyone who contributes ideas to the program are aligned.
Step 2: Identify Key Profitability Drivers
At heart, loyalty programs reward changes in customer behaviour. The specific
actions targeted should be the ones that are most likely to increase a customers
profitability, which will vary by both industry and company.
It is critical to identify not only the profitability drivers but also the underlying
factors that drive peoples behaviour as it relates to each of these drivers. For
example, what criteria do consumers use when deciding whether to purchase add-
on features? These are the actions that could be built in to the loyalty programs
incentive structure to encourage more- profitable behaviour.
Note that a change in strategy often requires re-examining profitability levers. For
example, if a company decides to target a new customer segment, this group will
likely have at least some profitability drivers that are different from those of the
current customer base. The loyalty programs incentives would need to be adapted
to meet these changing requirements.
Step 3: Design an Integrated Marketing Strategy
34 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
35/50
Developing and implementing an effective loyalty marketing strategy is critical to
generating a positive return from a loyalty program, because marketing promotions
will be the primary lever used to get members to change their behaviour and
purchase undersold and/or more profitable products or to use more-cost-effectivecustomer service and purchasing channels. Companies generally have two types of
marketing programs:
Proactivetargeted at improving customer profitability
Reactiveproviding incentives for customers to purchase undersold products
Proactive Campaigns
The goal of a proactive marketing strategy is to increase members long-term
profitability by executing a series of actions that shift a member from a less
profitable to a more profitable customer segment. When creating the campaigns to
implement this strategy, many companies use data mining capabilities to identify
what types of promotions (specifically, which rewards) are most likely to cause the
desired changes in customer behaviour. Cutting-edge companies not only define
member segments and model how those segments are expected to respond to an
individual promotion or series of promotions but they also manage the changes in
Ensuring Customer Loyalty: Designing Next-Generation Loyalty Program. These
campaigns are based on how customers respond to a series of promotions, where
the goal of each promotion is to move members through a series of tiers so that
they are eventually raised from a lower-profitability to a higher-profitability tier.
The best-performing companies recognize that a members loyalty is based not on a
single transaction but on a sequence of transactions with a company and that all of
these interactions need to be managed as a cohesive whole.
When creating a proactive marketing strategy, leading firms optimize their
marketing spending by defining which promotions to offer to different groups,
based on their companys budget, risk tolerance, and desired payoff. This
optimization should be done across the entire loyalty marketing portfolio, not just
for an individual promotion.
35 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
36/50
A proactive loyalty marketing strategy should identify and target members whose
value to the business appears to be dropping or who are likely to churn. Rather than
waiting for a member to leave and then instituting a win-back campaign, the
characteristics of customers who are likely to defect need to be identified. A seriesof customer retention marketing actions can then be done to keep valued
customers from leaving. For example, marketing campaigns can be timed according
to the most recent transactions made by customers rather than to the historical
time between transactions (for instance, offers can be e-mailed to people who have
not made a purchase in 1.5 times their average time lag). These actions are
generally less costly and more effective than trying to win back customers once
they have left.
Reactive Campaigns
Reactive campaigns are focused on improving short-term profitability by getting
members to purchase undersold products. In general, a reactive campaign will
involve several stages:
1. Determining the target (product/service/market segment) for a promotion
2. Identifying customers (individually via segmentation or by using predefined
segments) that may be interested in a specific product
3. Identifying which promotion will most cost-effectively change the targeted
customers behaviour and how this promotion should be presented to these
members to maximize their response rate
4. Creating the loyalty promotion. (A loyalty promotion tells the loyalty engine
how many points to credit or debit a member for purchasing or redeeming a
specified item.)
5. Creating the overall marketing campaign.
6. Creating the marketing offers.
7. Executing the campaign
36 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
37/50
8. Analyzing promotion, campaign, and offer effectiveness and identifying
lessons learned for improving future promotions and campaigns.
Step 4: Design the Incentive Structure
Loyalty programs are designed to change members behaviour by providing a web
of overlapping incentive structures. A company must design and manage each
structure, as well as the relationship between the different incentives, in order to
ensure that members are motivated to behave in the desired manner. Popular
incentive areas include
Bonuses and rewards
Purchase accrual rules
Non-purchase accrual rules
Redemption rules
Promotions
Product offering
Bonuses and rewards:
Companies encourage changes in members behavior by offering customers
rewards or bonuses for behaving in a desired manner. There are accrual rewards
(where the member receives something for making a purchase or completing an
action), redemption awards (where the member receives discounts or even free
products or services, generally by redeeming points or using a voucher), and
service awards (where the member receives specialized services). For a loyalty
program to be successful, these rewards must be aligned to encourage membersto take actions that make them increasingly valuable to the host company.
When choosing rewards, companies should optimize the use of accrual,
37 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
38/50
redemption, and prioritized service awards, based on what members value and
the companys cost structure.
Purchase Accrual Rules
Members typically earn points by purchasing products from the host company.
The rules that govern how many points a member earns are called purchase
accrual rules.
Loyalty systems need to meet two requirements to support purchase accrual
rules:
Point allocation rules should be flexible enough to map to profitability drivers.
The system must allow a company to easily change the point accrual rules for
purchases.
Non-purchase Accrual Rules
In addition to providing incentives for specific purchases, companies want to
encourage members to take valuable non-purchase actions such as referring new
members, updating their profiles online, or using the companys Web site rather
than its call center to process redemptions. The loyalty system should allow the
host company maximum flexibility in designing which non-purchase actions it
wants to encourage.
Redemption Rules
Once members have earned their points or vouchers, the loyalty program must
provide attractive ways for these rewards to be used. This is governed by
redemption rules. The key to a successful redemption policy is that the offering
must match the profitability of the actions that were taken to earn the points or
vouchers. Most companies try to do this by giving away fewer points for less
profitable purchases and more points for more profitable purchases.
A well-designed loyalty program should include a method to ensure that the
most-profitable members receive the appropriate level of service when
redeeming rewards. The redemption and accrual rules should focus on key
38 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
39/50
profitability drivers and be flexible enough to allow for continual adjustments and
refinements. Further, a balance must be struck between short- and long-term
rewards.
Promotions
Companies use promotions to provide added incentives for members who
perform a specific action within a specified time frame. A promotion generally has
a set of requirements and one or more rewards for members meeting those
requirements, such as bonus points or free vouchers.
Loyalty programs of all types feature some combination of the following
promotions:
Selected members only selected members (for example, only silver-tiermembers, people in a specified customer segment, or members on a list that
was created just for this promotion) will receive the bonus reward.
Flat bonus the member receives a fixed reward (such as 1,000 bonus points
or a free upgrade voucher).
Percentage bonus the bonus is based on the base accrual points the
member earned for purchasing the product. For example, if a hotel is offering
Product Offering
Rather than simply using a loyalty program to encourage members to buy what is
already being produced, the most-successful loyalty programs also use the data
collected to redesign the actual products and services the company provides. These
firms identify which products and features are desired by different customer
segments and then redesign the products to meet those needs or, if the products
are already available, to ensure that they are always in stock.
Redesigning a product/service offering can yield a significant competitive
advantage, because competitors will not have access to the same data and, thus,
will not be able to adapt their own products.
39 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
40/50
Step 5: Final product
The loyalty program based on this features should be designed considering the
companies goal and long term strategy. The product should be designed in such a
way that it is flexible enough to adapt the changing customer preferences. Thecurrent requirements for designing a loyalty program based on our research
findings will be discussed in the next section suggested features of a contemporary
loyalty program.
S UGGESTED FEATURES OF A CONTEMPERARY LOYALTY PROGRAM
As per the research conducted we listed the current offerings and tried to identify
what customers actually want vis--vis current schemes. The following are the
features or services that our respondents indicated as the most preferred ones.
Preferred features for loyalty card
Discounts
Special offers
Preferential treatment
Updates (New arrival)
Preferred features for shopping
Product
Ambience
Discounts & Services
Convenience
Location & Price
The above listed features clearly indicates that Indian consumer is growing more
matured, they are demanding non-material benefits more compared to material
benefits demanded previously. The consumer today is demanding higher level of
service than products. Retailers need to focus on delivering (selling) experience
along with products. They should make the card holders feel more important.
40 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
41/50
The most important result that came out from our study was that customers do
demand discounts but they want discounts that are redeemable easily and at their
ease. Thus the program should be designed such that it gives customer benefits
that are redeemable easily and quickly.
Our study also indicated that customers find it difficult to carry different loyalty
cards every time they go for shopping. Thus it is essential to offer more convenient
way to use the loyalty card. We have indicated few options that can be adopted,
such as:
One card for all: I-mint is a very good example which is offering this
solution in the light of one card for all. They partner with variousorganizations and use same card for all the transactions undertaken by all
the partners. This strategy can be applied and a card for the apparel industry
can be designed which would ease the burden of carrying many cards at the
same time.
Code based usage: The second option is to remove the card system and
allot the customers special codes. This would just require the customers to
remember the code every time they go for shopping.
Integrate it with the credit card: The best possible option is to integrate
the loyalty card with the credit card. Customers always carry their respective
credit card for shopping this will ensure that customer is not required to
make any additional effort to avail the benefits of a loyalty program and at
the same time retailers can design a special credit card integrated with their
marketing strategy. This is a win-win situation for customers, retailers and
also bankers.
SCOPE FOR FUTURE RESEARCH:
41 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
42/50
Todays successful businesses distinguish themselves from their competition by focusing on
customer retention, incremental spending and extraordinary service. In an increasingly
competitive business climate it is critical to understand who is buying your products and
services so that CRM Programs can be tailored to keep your best and most profitablecustomers coming back for more.
The limitation of this research was that it was strictly limited to apparel industry.
There have been visible findings in this research which can be extended to the
other business sectors which pursue loyalty program technique to build and
maintain their customer base. There are various sectors other than apparels which
undertake loyalty schemes:
Airlines Industry
Petroleum industry
Commercial Banks
Electronic Industry
IT industry
Also some aspects influencing customer loyalty like dependency of loyalty on the
culture of the country, in-depth study of the demand for special treatments by the
customers holding loyalty card etc. are left untouched in this research due to timeconstraints which can further be explored.
42 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
43/50
CONCLUDING REMARKS:
Faced with intense price competition, retailers are challenged to ensure that their
programs offer both value and other customer benefits. Some industry executives
believe retailers should focus less on promoting high-volume products and more on
understanding what their best customers want even if they want slow-moving
products that the retailer might be tempted to stop carrying. The more targeted
approach may result in less use of mass-market advertising.
Retailers are exploring how to leverage technology such as predictive software to
uncover subtle buying patterns and identify customers who may be likely to buy in
categories they have never bought in before. Many are making greater use of the
Internet to promote their loyalty program through accessible and informative Web
sites and targeted e-mail.
Even while harnessing technology, growing numbers of retailers are stepping up
efforts to reconnect with consumers and to meet their changing needs on a more
local level. In the past, store owners knew their shoppers well and could easily
anticipate needs. Today, we use computers and data to help do the same. These
include using loyalty programs to support community initiatives, encouraging staff
to get to know customers personally, and otherwise making cardholders feel that
the store values their business and respects their right to limit access to their
personal information.
As customer loyalty being one of the most important factors for the business
today, loyalty programs, if well designed and implemented, can help the
business gain competitive edge and can hence increase profitability.
43 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
44/50
A ppendix 1
Questionnaire:
Personal Information
Name: ............................................................................................................................
1.Gender
Male Female
2. Age
16-22
23-29
30-36
More than37
3. What is your profession?
Students
Selfemployed
Salaried Professional
Others (Pleasespecify)
4. Familys monthly income?
Rs.25,000
Loyalty card question:
1. Where do you shop frequently?
Shoppers Stop
44 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
45/50
Pantaloons Globus Lifestyle Westside India Bulls Mega Store (Pyramids) Others: .........................................................................................................
1.Prioritize those features that make you revisit the above selected store?
Features 1 2 3 4 5
Price
Service
Loyalty
cards
Ambience
Convenienc
e
After sales
service
Discounts
Product
Location
Others (please mention):
3. How frequently do you shop from the above stores?
Ones in a week Twice in month Once in a month Once every 2 months
Once every 6 months Others (please
specify) : ....................................................................................................
4. What is the average amount you spend each time you go for shopping?
45 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
46/50
< Rs.500 Rs.500-2000 Rs.2000-5000 >Rs.5000
5. Are you aware about the loyalty programmes?
Yes No Interested in knowing
6. How many loyalty cards do you have?
1 2-4 > 4 none
7. If you have chosen none above, could you share your opinion about loyaltycards?
Never heard about it Waste of time Waste of money Excess of personal information sharing Others (Please
Specify): ....................................................................................................
8. Will you shop in your favourite store even if you dont have loyalty card of the
same?
Yes No Cant say
9. Do you tend to increase your purchase from a particular store if you have loyaltycard of the same?
Yes No Cant say
10. What is your opinion about retailers loyalty programme?
Beneficial in terms of offers, gifts etc. Quick/easy access to promotional information Waste of time
46 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
47/50
Excess Sharing of personal information junk mails Inconvenience in carrying cards Others Please
Specify: .............................................................................................
11. Do you think you share lot of personal information in order to get a storesloyalty cards?
Yes No
12. At the billing counter, if you were told that shopping for additional (Rs.300-500)can get you loyalty card, would you avail that option?
Yes No
h13. You would want a loyalty card of a particular store because they offer:
1 2 3 4 5
Discounts
Special
offers
Updates(ne
w arrivals)
Preferential
treatment
Status
Symbol
14.
Your opinion Agree Disagr
ee
I have loyalty cards which I don't use
It takes too long to get anything worthwhile
I would shop in any store that suits me regardless of
whether they have a loyalty scheme
47 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
48/50
I Save a lot of money by using my loyalty vouchers
I shop wherever I get better discounts
I usually get better discounts from in-store promotions than
loyalty schemes
I am nervous about how the organisation uses the personal
information I give
I buy products if they earn me extra points
I am sceptical about the usage of personal information
I think a loyalty scheme is worthwhile and I am willing to
give my personal details
I spend less in stores where I dont have a card
I am member of loyalty scheme but have no intention of
using my loyalty card
I wouldnt change where I shop for the sake of a loyalty
scheme
I have saved substantially due to loyalty programmes
I buy products due to promotions surrounding them
15. I have stopped using loyalty cards
because...................................................................................................... ......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
16. What according to you is an ideal loyalty card/Program?
.....................................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................................
..........................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................................
.....................................................................................................................................
............
48 | P a g e
-
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
49/50
Sources
Yuping Liu & Rong Yang Competing Loyalty Programs: Impact of Market
Saturation, Market Share and Category Expandability, Journal of MarketingVol. 73 (January 2009), 93108,
Ensuring Customer Loyalty: Designing Next-Generation Loyalty Programs,an Oracle White Paper: February 2005,
Loyalty Programs and their Impact on Repeat-Purchase Loyalty Patterns: a
replication and extension,Byron Sharp and Anne Sharp; Marketing ScienceCentre, University of South Australia
Yuping Liu (2007), The Long-Term Impact of Loyalty Programs on ConsumerPurchase Behavior and Loyalty. Journal of Marketing- October 2007.
Ergin, Parilti, Ozsacmac (2007), Impact of Loyalty Cards on Customers StoreLoyalty. International Business & Economics Research Journal- Feb 2007.
Waarden, Benavent, Loyalty Programs and their Impact on Repeat Purchase
Behavior. Bolton, Ruth, Kannan, Bramlett (2000), Implication of Loyalty ProgramMembership and Service Experience for Customer Retention and Value,
Journal of the Academy of Marketing Sciences, 28. www.google.com
49 | P a g e
http://www.google.com/http://www.google.com/ -
8/6/2019 27600792 Impact of Loyalty Programs on Consumer Behaviour
50/50