Download - Complex solutions for complex problems
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Complex solutions for complexproblems
Dr Joseph E. Kasser, DSc, CEng, FIET, CM, CMALT
Visiting Associate Professor, TDSI
National University of Singapore, Block E1, #05-05
1 Engineering Drive 2, Singapore 117576
Email [email protected]
Handphone +65 9776 7464, Skype: Prof_G3ZCZ
Web page http://www.therightrequirement.com
The Third International Symposium on EngineeringSystems
June 18-20 2012Delft, The Netherlands
1
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Topics• Problems and problem solving
• Classification of problems
• Problem classification matrix
• Solving non-complex problems
• Solving complex problems
• Systems approach
• Questions and discussion
2
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Problems and problem solving
3
ConvertsUndesirable situation
ToDesirable situation
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Classification of problems• Level of difficulty of the problem
• Research and intervention problems
• Structure of the problem
• Complexity of the problem
• Others
4
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Levels of difficulty• Easy - can be solved in a short time with very little thought.
• Medium - can be solved after some thought, may take a fewmore steps to solve than an easy problem and can probably besolved without too much difficulty, perhaps after somepractice.
• Ugly - will take a while to solve. Solving them involves a lotof thought, many steps and may require the use of severaldifferent concepts.
• Hard - usually involve dealing with one or more unknowns.Solving them involves a lot of thought and some research andmay also require iteration through the problem solving processas learning takes place 5
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Research problems• The undesirable situation is the inability to explain
observations of phenomena or the need for someparticular knowledge. In this situation:– the solution is the knowledge often in the form of the
supported hypothesis,
– the problem is how to gain the needed knowledge, and
– the problem solving process is commonly known asthe scientific method, and works forwards
• from the current situation towards a future changed situation inwhich the knowledge has been acquired.
6
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Intervention problems• The undesirable situation is when something needs to be
changed over a period of time into a feasible conceptualfuture desired situation (FCFDS). In this situation:– the solution is the FCFDS,
– the problem is how to realize a smooth and timely transition from the currentsituation to the FCFDS, and
– the problem solving process first uses the research problem solving processworking forwards, selects the best one, and then works backwards to thecurrent problematic situation to document:
• the FCFDS, and
• the realization plans documented as a forward process starting from thecurrent situation and ending with the deployment of the FCFDS.
7
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Structure of the problem• Well-structured
– the existing undesired situation and the desired futuresituation are clearly identified.
– may have a single solution or sometimes more than onecorrect solution.
• Ill-structured– either or both the existing undesired situation and the
desired future situation are unclear
• Wicked– extremely ill-structured problems
8
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Complexity of the problem• Number of issues, functions, or variables
involved in the problem;
• Degree of connectivity among thosevariables;
• Type of functional relationships amongthose properties;
• Stability among the properties of theproblem over time
9
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Problem classification matrix
Wicked Here be dragons
(there are no solutions)Ill-structuredWell-
structured Simple ComplicatedNon-complex
Easy Medium Ugly Hard
Level of difficulty
10
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Solving non-complex problems• Easy well-structured problems
– Simple problems requiring little if any research before creating thesolution.
• Medium well-structured problems– Less simple requiring some research before creating the solution.
• Ugly well-structured problems– Complicated yet require little if any research before creating the
solution.
• Hard well-structured non-complex problems– Complicated and require research before creating the solution.
11
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Solving complex problems-1• Well-structured complex problems
– consist of a set of interconnected well-structured non-complexproblems
– the remedy to one may affect another, these problems cannot besolved in one pass thorough the problem solving process.
– must remedied by evolving a solution using multiple passes of theproblem solving process where each iteration produces a better(less undesirable) situation.
– one party’s remedy may be another party’s undesirable situationand foster further change.
• Makes it more complicated
12
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Solving complex problems-2• Ill-structured complex problems.
– These problems cannot be solved.
– They need to be converted to well-structured problemsbefore attempting to provide solutions.
– Different people convert ill-structured problems intodifferent and sometimes contradictory well-structuredproblems and which would generate different andsometimes contradictory solutions.
• Wicked Problems.– The fundamental paradox with respect to Wicked
Problems is that there are no such problems. 13
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Systems approach to dealing withproblems
Observeand think
Formulatehypothesis
Testhypothesis
Research
RefutedSupported
8 Descriptive STPs*
Scientific STP*
* Kasser and Mackley, 200814
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Remedying complex problems1. Convert the ill-structured complex problem to a well-
structured problem.
2. Convert the well-structured complex problem to a set ofwell-structured non-complex problems that provide partialsolutions to the complex problem.
3. Realize a partial solution to the complex problem byremedying one or more of the non-complex problems.
4. Reexamine the undesirability of the changed situation.
5. Go back to step 1.
15
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Summary• Problems and problem solving
• Classification of problems
• Problem classification matrix
• Solving non-complex problems
• Solving complex problems
• Systems approach
• Questions and discussion
16
Temasek Defence Systems InstituteTemasek Defence Systems Institute
Questionsor
comments
Questionsor
comments
17