The opinions expressed in this presentation are those of the speaker. The International Societydisclaims responsibility for views expressed and statements made by the program speakers.
Engaging Employees in Wellness Initiatives: Lessons Learned
Emily Talley, CEBS, SPHRBenefits ManagerTanner Health SystemCarrollton, GA
11A-1
It’s Been a Marathon, Not a Sprint!
1990s—Laying the Foundation◦ Health risk assessments with biometrics for
spouses and employees◦ Variety of on-site exercise and nutrition programs
with limited participation◦ Limited annual benefit for preventive care or
reimbursement for wellness items
Tanner’s Road to Wellness
11A-2
2000s—Broadening the Effort◦ 2002—Telephonic disease management program◦ 2003—Discounts at local gyms◦ 2005—Preventive care benefits incorporated into
health plan◦ 2008—Leadership and community challenges;
Tobacco Free workplace; Exercise facility on main campus◦ 2009—Employee weight loss challenge; Additional
exercise facilities; System-wide health fairs
11A-3
2010s—Building Accountability◦ 2010—Wellness credit program; Expanded exercise
facility & educational offerings◦ 2011—Requirement of all 5 target areas and
disease management participation; In-house healthy dining options; Family access to exercise facilities◦ 2012—In-house disease management program with
co-pay waiver incentive; Streamlined alternative means
11A-4
Like many other employers, Tanner’s health plan costs were unsustainable
Why Engagement Matters
11A-5
Who are We Trying to Engage?Demographics◦ Demographics◦ 82% female◦ Average age: 43◦ Varied education levels
Cultural◦ Traditional southern food◦ Caregiver (not care-taker) mentality◦ Busy lifestyles and competing priorities
Work Challenges◦ Long work hours◦ Short meal breaks◦ Sedentary jobs◦ Knowing ≠ doing
Designing an Effective Program
11A-6
Where Do We Focus Our Efforts? Use claims data analysis to:◦ Identify cost drivers e.g., Avg. cost/EE broken down by biometrics
◦ Focus on conditions directly impacted by wellness e.g., Cardiovascular and diabetes
◦ Use industry benchmarking to identify areas of potential savings e.g., Reduce in-patient admissions for CAD
Use HRA results to determine leading risk factors◦ e.g., Overweight, inactivity
Measurement is key!
11A-7
What Targets Should We Set? Goal: Targets that motivate healthy behaviors◦ Direct link to healthy behaviors◦ Set at achievable level◦ Easy and relatively inexpensive to measure to allow to
check progress◦ Credibility—supported by physicians and recognized
authorities Issues encountered◦ Self-reporting vs. independent verification◦ Alternative measures◦ Tobacco usage as separate consideration
11A-8
How Do We Get Employees to Participate? Goal: Make it worth it to employees to engage◦ Taking into account avg. salary, current health plan
design and premiums, cost to organization Incentives considered◦ Carrot vs. stick approach◦ Type of incentive: lower deductible, co-pay waivers,
FSA/HSA contribution, premium credit, etc. Issues encountered◦ Making it visible to employees e.g. separate line item on paycheck
◦ Qualification for new hires/newly enrolled
11A-9
Taking inventory of current programs Selecting the right partner◦ e.g., Broker, Consultant, TPA, Carrier
Ensuring HIPAA, GINA & ADA complianceDetermining administration ◦ e.g., in-house, external or combination
Keeping communication in mindDetermining how success will be measured
Other Key Steps in Design
11A-10
Year 1: All employees given credit up front with opportunity to qualify by May 31
Healthy Advantage Program
WAYS TO QUALIFY FOR THE CREDITHealth Targets(Meet 3)
Meet theTarget
OR Complete a Health Source Program
OR Other Methods
BMI 30 or Lower
Weight Loss ChallengeOR
12 Week Exercise Log
Physician-supervised Programs
and Medication
Therapy
Blood Pressure 140/90 or Lower
Hypertension EducationOR
12 Week Exercise Log
Blood Glucose 130 or Lower
Diabetes EducationOR
12 Week Exercise Log
HDL-LDL Ratio 0.5 or Higher
Cholesterol EducationOR
12 Week Exercise Log
Tobacco Use None Tobacco-Free Education
Included disclaimer regarding consulting physician and if unreasonably difficult or medically
inadvisable due to medical condition.
11A-11
Year 2: Meet all 5 targets and participate in disease management
Year 3: Streamlined alternative means
Healthy Advantage Program
HOW TO QUALIFY FOR THE CREDITOption 1: Complete HRA and Meet the 5 Healthy Advantage Targets
Healthy Advantage TargetsBMI 30 or LowerBlood Pressure 140/90 or LowerBlood Glucose 130 or LowerLDL High Risk: 100 or Lower Low Risk: 130 or LowerTobacco Use None
Option 2: Complete HRA and Customized Health Source ProgramHealth Source Alternative Programs
If You Missed One Target Complete Online Health Education Module
If You Missed Two Targets Complete Online Health Education ModuleAND 8 Week Exercise Log
If You Missed 3 or More Targets Complete 12 Week Health Coaching ProgramIncluded disclaimer regarding consulting physician
and if unreasonably difficult or medically inadvisable due to medical condition.
11A-12
THS Average Measurements 2010 2011
Body Mass Index 35 29.4Blood Pressure 124.6/75.8 122.5/74.4Total Cholesterol 186.5 180.2HDL Level 51.4 52.7LDL Level 114.6 101.5Glucose 92.4 95.3Tobacco Usage 9% 6%
Program Results
Based on 1,543 participants who completed health risk assessment in both years
11A-13
Bending the curve through wellness initiatives and plan design (including HDHP)
Why Engagement Matters
11A-14
Incentives matter◦ The power of a t-shirt and a cup◦ Keep financial incentives visible
Keep it simple◦ Easily determined measurements◦ Easy to follow alternative means
Make it fun◦ Competition, games, immediate feedback
Walk-the-walk◦ Top leadership involvement◦ Cafeteria menu
Offer support◦ Smoking cessation and other educational programs◦ Reinforce small changes
The power of individual stories, positive peer pressure and a culture of wellness
Lessons Learned
11A-15
Get releases up front ◦ e.g., Disease management eligibility and data analysis
Use measures that are easily benchmarked Have back up measurement plans◦ e.g., Waist-to-hip ratio, cholesterol screening
Have a single point of contact for administration◦ e.g., Submission of materials, verification of eligibility
Incorporate accountability into self-reporting◦ e.g., Measurements with exercise logs, tobacco tests
Require detail and follow up in physician reporting Videotape classes to allow for future viewing Determine how to handle exceptions
◦ e.g., Pregnancy, cancer treatment, other health concerns Review program for HIPAA, ADA & GINA compliance
How to Avoid Common Pitfalls
11A-16
Brand your program Know your audience and tailor the message
◦ e.g., “You take care of others, now it’s time to take care of yourself” Communicate first to leaders (formal & informal) Convey what’s in it for the employee
◦ e.g., live active and healthy life, keeping premiums affordable Use employee stories and testimonials Determine timeline of communication
◦ e.g., program awareness, initial notification, reminders, confirmation of qualification, notification of failure to qualify
Determine the methods to be used (multiple recommended) Print—newsletters, flyers, brochures Meetings—managers, program champions, employees Electronic—intranet, internet, e-mails, texts
Make it easy to find information◦ e.g., HR policies, handbook, enrollment guide, orientation, intranet
Target the family as well
Communication Checklist
11A-17
0.00
20.00
40.00
60.00
80.00
100.00
120.00
140.00
Patie
nts P
er 1000
2010 THS2010 Benchmark2011 THS2011 Benchmark
Next Steps: Targeting Chronic Conditions
11A-18
Engaging those with chronic conditions◦ Comprehensive program involving using nurse
practitioner, health coach, dietitian, pharmacist, diabetes education, and EAP◦ Challenges—identification of candidates, setting
measurable goals, meaningful Rx co-pay incentives, physician coordination
Engaging spouses Keeping the program moving forward◦ Tougher health targets, more challenging
alternative means
Next Steps
11A-19
Questions?
11A-20