![Page 1: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
GENERAL STAFF ARMED FORCES OF UKRAINE
EW LESSONS LEARNED
Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine
RUSI
20 March 2019
Major General Borys KREMENETSKYIDefence and Air Attache, Embassy of Ukraine to the UK
![Page 2: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Smolensk
Sevastopol
Rostov-on-Don
Stavropol Vladikavkaz
RUSSIA
UKRAINE
BELARUS
MOLDOVA
GEORGIA
KAZAKHSTAN
WEST
139 0001555
2666
1637
28422963
2
48
SOUTH
WEST MD
150 000
401
2696
1083
259
52
7
30
415
SOUTH MD
Russian forces deployed on Western and South-Western directions pose a real threat to overall European security
HUNGARY
ROMANIA
76 ABn
Kursk
SLOVAKIA
NATO/USA
Kyiv
LITHUANIA
ESTONIA
St.Petersburg
POLAND
Kaliningrad
Pskov
Voronezh
Valuyki
Novocherkassk
MoscowLATVIA
RUSSIAN AGGRESSIVE POSTURE AGAINST UKRAINE & THE REST OF EUROPE
2
![Page 3: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Deployment of the Russian EW Units on the occupied territory of Ukraine
(December 2016 – Dec 2018 )
3
ОТУ
ОТУ
ОТУ
DONETSK
LUGANSK
MARIUPOL
![Page 4: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
RUSSIAN EW TACTICS4
TACTICS
Demonstration of
presence in the
specified areas
Disturbing and
turbulent jamming
tactics
EW Superiority
(Domination) in the
Electronic Domain
• Jamming some designated equipment;
• Suppression of some networks;
• Sending SMS to the enemy soldiers;
• Interference in specific areas.
• Full network suppression;
• Blocking all communication;
• Enforce to use GSM or SATCOM
or mobile Internet;
• Determine access points for GSM
and mobile Internet.
TASKS and MISSIONS
![Page 5: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
PECULIARITIES of EW EMPLOYMENT by RUS FORCES
use of new physical principles, the effect of application equals electromagnetic
weapons which destroy electronic equipment (System Murmansk BH in some types of
operation radiates the signal of blocking with the power of 400 kWt that covers the
distance up to 5000 km and affects the receiving equipment in UHF lines.
FEATURES
-hidden influence of radio-electronic warfare means on radio communication (sudden
disappearance of radio communication due to unknown reasons);
-sending SMS messages to private phones of the military with the indication of places
for their gathering, in fact, places for planned fire shooting;
-blocking GSM radio communication with its further restoration, defining the points of
access and shooting the areas of mass access to GSM radio communication;
-using the capabilities of radio-electronic warfare means for spotting the places of the
location of counterbattery radars with further shooting on them;
5
![Page 6: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
COURSE OF ACTIONS by Russian EW Units in Ukraine6
the enemy defines C2 of the UKR forces and determines the
most important (crucial) objects,
searches and defines the most effective positions for radio-
electronic warfare means,;
evaluates the effectiveness of blocking radio means of the
UKR Armed Forces executing short-term radio break offs of
different functional purposes and registers the reaction on the
loss of radio communication in the UKR units
blocks radio communication of the UKR units in some tactical
episodes.
disclosing of UKR units control systems on the level union –
battalion – brigade,
defining the most critical purposes of radio blockings that can lead
to the loss (violation) of control;
learning the scenarios of actions of UKR units in case of the loss
of communication.
NEGATIVE EFFECTS
BEFORE THE
ACTIVE
COMBAT
ACTIONS
![Page 7: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
COURSE OF ACTIONS by Russian EW Units in Ukraine 7
Spotting of the operating radio systems, jamming
systems, counter-battery radars and targeting fire on
them,;
operational maneuver by EW units on the new directions
of actions;
breaking the control (misleading) of the UAV.
loss of control over the ATO units in the directions of active
combat;
damage of the positions of jamming systems, counter-battery
radars;
impossibility to use UAV.
NEGATIVE EFFECTS
To disorganize C2 of UKR units in the area of active
combat;
DURING ACTIVE
COMBAT
ACTIONS
![Page 8: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
RUSSIAN ARMED FORCES PRIORITIES
in EW in the EASTERN UKRAINE
8
PRIORITIES
1
To suppress
enemy’s UAV by
deployment of
Jamming
stations
R-330Zh
“SHYPOVNIK –
AERO”
2
Jamming of VHF
and UHF, GSM
communication by
deployment of
BORISOGLEBSK -2
AND INFAUNA SPR-
2M SYSTEMS
3
EW SYTEMS AND
STRIKE WEAPONS
INTEGRATION
4
DETECTIONS OF
THE INFORMATION
LEAKAGE
CHANELS AND
THEIR Suppression
Systems SVET-KU,
“Dziudoist”
“Шиповник”Р-330Ж “Інфауна”СПР-2М Р-330БМВР-378БМВ
![Page 9: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
THE STRUCTURE OF THE DETACHED EW COMPANY1 AND 2 ARMY CORPS OF THE RUSSIAN PROXIES
9
LEER - 3 * 2 pcs Р-378БМВ – 2 pcs Р-330БМВ – 2 pcs Р-330Ж – 2 pcs
РП-377Л – 2 pcs
Р-934УМ – 2 pcs
Р-330Ж
РБ-341В “Леер-3”
Р-378БМВ
Р-330БМВ
EW COMPANY
C2
PLATOON
VHF JAMMING
/INTERFERENCE
PLATOON
UHF JAMMING/INTERFERENCE PLATOON
JAMMING/INTERFERENCE PLATOON
![Page 10: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
EW System “Leer – 3”10
Training of Russian proxies (May 2015). On the left in
the red frame Leer-3”
Donetsk, Ukraine 2016
Territory of Ukraine
Jamming frequencies ,
МHz
935-960, 1805-1880
890-915, 1710-1785
![Page 11: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
11Electronic Interference Station Р-378BMVfrom “Borisoglebsk-2” SYSTEM
Territory of Ukraine
Pictured 18.12.2014, in Internet since 08.05.2016
![Page 12: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
R-378BМ INTERFERENCE/JAMMING STATION(Occupied territory of Lugansk Region)
12
R-378BМ deployed
close to
Stahanov
Lugansk Region
Jamming, interference and signal intelligence
frequencies, МHz
1,5 – 29,9
![Page 13: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
JAMMING STATION R-330BMVAS PART OF BORISOGLEBSK-2 SYSTEM
13
Jamming, interference and signal intelligence
frequencies, МHz
25 – 960
TRANSPORTATION OF R-330BMV
TOWARDS UKRAINE TERITORY,
26.05.2015
![Page 14: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
JAMMING STATION R-330Z “Zhitel”
SIGNAL INTELLIGENCE
frequencies, МHz
100 – 2000
JAMMING frequencies, МHz 1227,6; 1575,42; 1500 – 1900
01.07.2015, MAKIIVKA, DONETSK REGION
ANTENNAS OF R-330Z “Zhitel”
Territory of Ukraine
![Page 15: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
EW STATION RB-531B “INFAUNA”
RB-531B “INFAUNA”
22.06.2014,
OCCUPIUED TERRITORY OF
DONETSK REGION
Jamming, interference and
signal intelligence
frequencies, МHz
25 – 2500
15
![Page 16: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
EW SYSTEM “LORANDIT”
signal intelligence frequencies,
МHz
20 – 2000
Jamming, interference
frequencies, МHz
137 – 174
410 – 470
100 – 500
RP-377LA “LORANDIT”
16
![Page 17: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
MOBILE AUTOMATED RADIO CONTROL SYSTEM“DZIUDOIST”
17
16.01.2015, 12.40 – LUGANSK, Shopping Center AURORA
TOT of Ukraine
![Page 18: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
INTERFERENCE AND JAMMING STATION R-330BМV“BORISOGLEBSK-2”
18
TOT of
Ukraine
25.07.2015,
Bryanka,
Lugansk
Region
![Page 19: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
INTERFERENCE AND JAMMING STATION SPR-2М “Rtut’-BМ”On the TOT of Ukraine (Lugansk Region)
19
Interference System SPR-2M at Lugansk Airport area.
Pictured 21.09.2016, tactical Sign 18 in Square belongs to the Russian proxies unit
05776
TOT of Ukraine
![Page 20: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
EW System “SHIPOVNIK-AERO”On TOT of Ukraine Donetsk Region
20
22.07.2016 Donetsk city center
“SHIPOVNIK - AERO.
Yandex maps picture
“Terraserver”
![Page 21: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
RUSSIAN EW UNITS on the TOT of UKRAINE21
RB-636
R0330
R-330Z
12.11.2016
West side of Bryanka town, Donetsk reg.
RB-636
R-330Z Antennas trailer
R-330 Zh Antennas trailer
R-330Zh
![Page 22: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
R-934BMVR-934UМV
RUSSIAN UHF JAMMING SYSTEMS
signal intelligence frequencies,
МHz
100 – 2000
Jamming frequencies, МHz 100 – 400
signal intelligence frequencies, МHz
100 – 400
Jamming frequencies, МHz 100 – 150,
150 – 220,
220 – 400
22
![Page 23: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
STATION “MURMANSK-BN”(CRIMEA, cape FIOLENT)
23
Satellite
picture
26.03.2015
![Page 24: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
STATION “MURMANSK-BN” (CRIMEA, cap FIOLENT)
24
![Page 25: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
DEVELOPMENT OF THE RUSSIAN EW SYSTEMS
WAY AHEAD
25
“INFAUNA”
SIGINT
JAMMING
ARMOREDIED PROTECTION
SPR-2М “RTUT-BМ”
PROTECTION FROM THE
RADIO CONTROLLED
FUSES
SIGINTSUPPRESION
JAMMING
R-330Zh “Zhytel”
GSM 1800JAMMING
IMMARSAT, IRIDIUM
JAMMING
GPS JAMMING
“LEER-2”
SIGINT
INTERFARENCE SIMULATION OF RADIO ACTIVITY
MULTIFUNCTIONAL EW COMPLEXES
![Page 26: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
WAY AHEAD in DEVELOPING RUSSIAN EW SYSTEMS26
1. Assets for blocking strategic, operational and tactical
C4I. In 2017 instead of the system Borysohlibsk-2 a new
system Palantin was deployed.
2. Fighting the air assets equipment. It is ensured by
blocking air communication and on-board radars, including
ISTAR aircrafts.
3. Assets for blocking signals of GPS and fighting UAV. In
2016 a new EW with small-size UAV Repellent-1 was
developed.
4. UAV EW Assets. UAV Leer-3 is used for collecting data
from personal GSM, namely IMEI and MTIMSI.
![Page 27: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
![Page 28: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine
![Page 29: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Armored vehicleBPM-97 “Vystrel”
Artillery rocket missile complex“Pantsyr-С”
Antitank rocket complex“Konkurs-М”
RF produced weaponry and equipment found
in the Eastern Ukraine (never used by UAF)ARMOR Air Defence Antitank Armament
Unmanned Aerial Vehicles
UAV “Eleron-3СВ” UAV “Takhion” UAV “Orlan-10”
![Page 30: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Мариуполь
1 мсб
Новоазовск
УКРАИНА
REW station “LEER-2” REW station “Shypovnyk--aero”
Mini UAV “ZALA”
Small-size navigation equipment 14C822 “Grot-m"Radio “Azart-P1”
REW station R-330G “Gytel’”
REW station R-330М1P “Diabazol” Artillery radar system “Rys’”
Mobile patrol complex“Patriot-OKAPI”
UAV “Dozor-100” UAV“Takhion”
RUSSIAN MADE WEAPONS AND EQUIPMENT USED
IN THE EASTERN UKRAINE
![Page 31: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
2/1 омсбр
3/1 омсбр
3/9 ошмсп мп
1/9 ошмсп мп
17 отбр54 орб
RUSSIAN UAV’S ACTIVITY
Умовні позначенняРайон застосування БПЛА тактичного
рівня
Маршрут руху БПЛА оперативно-
тактичного рівня
Маршрут руху БПЛА оперативно-
тактичного рівня з перетином ДКУ
Granat -1
Granat-2
Orlan-10
2017 - 641 cases of the of
enemy UAV usage observed
MARIUPOL
DONETSK
LUHANSK
250 cases of UAV employment by enemy have
been observed in 2018.
Frequency of UAV usage in 2018:
Daily average - 1-2 flights; in case of favorable
weather conditions – 10-13 flights
![Page 32: EW LESSONS LEARNED Russian Hybrid Warfare in Ukraine · Orlan-10 2017 - 641 cases of the of enemy UAV usage observed MARIUPOL DONETSK LUHANSK 250 cases of UAV employment by enemy](https://reader031.vdocuments.net/reader031/viewer/2022021800/5e3dc88a38ac9c243e05a190/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)