The provision was inserted by Sen. Orrin G. Hatch (R-Utah).(Win McNamee / Getty Images)
A little-noticed measure would put Christian Science healing sessions on the same footing asclinical medicine. Critics say it violates the separation of church and state.
By Tom Hamburger and Kim GeigerNovember 3, 2009
Hello Visitor LOGIN or REGISTER Subscribe Place An Ad LAT Store Jobs Cars Real Estate Rentals Foreclosures More Classifieds
IN THE NEWS: LAKERS RETAIL WARS FORT HOOD SHOOTING USC-ARIZONA STATE UNEMPLOYMENT HEALTHCARE
HEALTH
LOCAL NATION WORLD BUSINESS SPORTS ENTERTAINMENT LIVING TRAVEL OPINION MORE Search GO
Healthcare provision seeks to embrace prayertreatments
E-mail Print Share Text Size
Reporting from Washington - Backed by some of
the most powerful members of the Senate, a
little-noticed provision in the healthcare
overhaul bill would require insurers to consider
covering Christian Science prayer treatments as
medical expenses.
The provision was inserted by Sen. Orrin G.
Hatch (R-Utah) with the support of Democratic
Sens. John F. Kerry and the late Edward M.
Kennedy, both of Massachusetts, home to the
headquarters of the Church of Christ, Scientist.
The measure would put Christian Science prayer
treatments -- which substitute for or supplement
medical treatments -- on the same footing as
clinical medicine. While not mentioning the
church by name, it would prohibit discrimination against
"religious and spiritual healthcare."
It would have a minor effect on the overall cost of the bill --
Christian Science is a small church, and the prayer treatments
can cost as little as $20 a day. But it has nevertheless stirred
an intense controversy over the constitutional separation of
church and state, and the possibility that other churches
might seek reimbursements for so-called spiritual healing.
Phil Davis, a senior Christian Science Church official, said
prayer treatment was an effective alternative to conventional
healthcare.
"We are making the case for this, believing there is a
connection between healthcare and spirituality," said Davis,
who distributed 11,000 letters last week to Senate officials
urging support for the measure.
MOST VIEWED MOST E-MAILED
Diabetes: What you need to know
Popular Topics: Wellness | Women | Men |Family | Fitness | Aging | Health careers
Health A-Z: Allergies | Asthma | Cancer | Dental| Depression | Heart | Obesity | See all
The Latest | NEWS AS IT HAPPENS
Former Presidents Bill Clinton and George W.Bush cancel local joint appearance - L.A. Now
11/07/2009, 1:16 p.m.
UCLA vs. Washington: Live in-game report - L.A.
Times - Sports 11/07/2009, 1:04 p.m.
Thanksgiving countdown: Creamy mushroomragout over sweet potato cakes - Daily Dish
11/07/2009, 1:04 p.m.
Team Canada beats U.S., 5-1, for women's FourNations hockey title - L.A. Times Olympics Blog
11/07/2009, 12:47 p.m.
UCLA vs. Washington live in-game updates - The
Fabulous Forum 11/07/2009, 12:42 p.m.
advert isement
HEALTH HOME FOOD IMAGE TRAVEL AUTOS BOOKS HOT LIST BRAND X MAGAZINE YOUR SCENE
Reader questions onHouse healthcare bill
Health insurance mandate alarms some
Editorial series:RehabilitatingHealthcare
More on thehealthcare debate
RELATED
STORIES
Healthcare provision seeks to embrace prayer treatments -- latim... http://www.latimes.com/features/health/la-na-health-religion3-...
1 of 4 11/7/09 13:55
"We think this is an important aspect of the solution, when
you are talking about not only keeping the cost down, but
finding effective healthcare," he said.
The provision would apply only to insurance policies offered
on a proposed exchange where consumers could shop for
plans that meet standards set by the government.
But critics say the measure could have a broader effect,
conferring new status and medical legitimacy on practices that
lie outside the realm of science.
Annie Laurie Gaylor, co-president of the Freedom From
Religion Foundation, a group of atheists and agnostics that
promotes separation of church and state, said the opportunity to receive payment for spiritual care
could encourage other groups to seek similar status.
"This would be an absolute invitation to organize," Gaylor said.
The Christian Science Church, which was founded in Boston in 1879, has pushed throughout its
history to secure official recognition for its paid prayer practitioners. Their job, as outlined by the
church's founder, Mary Baker Eddy, was to pray for healing and charge for treatment at rates similar
to those of medical doctors.
In the early 20th century, the church sought recognition from state regulators so the practitioners
would not be prosecuted for practicing medicine without a license. Criminal courts have convicted
Christian Scientists in cases where children have died after visiting prayer healers instead of receiving
conventional medical care. The church says no such incidents have occurred for two decades.
About 90 years ago, private insurance companies began paying for Christian Science prayer
treatments, but more recently, managed-care insurers declined reimbursements, insisting on paying
for care that produced proven medical results.
The Internal Revenue Service allows the cost of the prayer sessions to be counted among itemized
medical expenses for income tax purposes -- one of the only religious treatments explicitly identified
as deductible by the IRS. Some federal medical insurance programs, including those for military
families, also reimburse for prayer treatment.
The spiritual healing provision was introduced in the House by Rep. John Shimkus (R-Ill.), whose
district includes a Christian Science school, Principia College.
Two committees in the House voted to include the measure in their versions of the overhaul, but
Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-San Francisco) stripped it from the consolidated House bill last week after a
few members argued it was unconstitutional.
Erwin Chemerinsky, dean of the UC Irvine School of Law, said the provision raised serious questions
about government support of religion.
"I think when Congress mandates that health companies provide coverage for prayer, it has the effect
of the government advancing religion," he said.
The legal issue, however, may not be cut and dried.
Michael McConnell, who heads the Stanford University Constitutional Law Center, said that "as long
as patients are the ones who choose, and religious choices are given no legal preference or advantage,
the proposals would appear to be consistent with constitutional standards."
In the Senate, the provision is included in a version of the bill drafted by the health committee.
Majority Leader Harry Reid (D-Nev.) is considering whether to include it in the consolidated bill he
will send to the Senate floor.
Kerry's spokeswoman, Whitney Smith, disputed that insurers would be forced to cover prayer.
Instead, she said, "the amendment would prevent insurers from discriminating against benefits that
qualify as spiritual care if the care is recognized by the IRS as a legitimate medical expense. Plans are
free to impose standards on spiritual and medical care as long as both are treated equally. It does not
Mexico Under Siege »
The drug war at our doorstep.
Ads by Google
Anthem Blue Cross(Official Site) Fast & Easy Quote. Call888-529-4512 or Apply Online!Anthem4Ca.com
MBA in HealthcarePrestigious Healthcare MBA degree fromGeorge Washington University.MBAhc.info/Healthcare-MBA
Health Insurance BrokerFind Affordable Health Insurance. CallToday For Competitive Rates.www.lahealthcoverage.com
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
Healthcare bill clears parliamentary hurdle inHouse
Democratic consultant says he got a warningfrom White House after appearing on Fox News
Sarah Palin's speeches were ready but never seen-- until now
Fork whets Pasadena's artistic appetite
Josh Powell's energy translating into success forLakers
Opening day: 'Christmas Carol' debut not lookingtoo jolly
United Commercial Bank is shut down, sold toEast West Bancorp
California cities act to ban cat declawing
Ft. Hood shooting suspect endured workpressure and ethnic taunts, his uncle says
Babies are found to cry in their mother tongue
Healthcare provision seeks to embrace prayer treatments -- latim... http://www.latimes.com/features/health/la-na-health-religion3-...
2 of 4 11/7/09 13:55
mandate that plans provide spiritual care."
Hatch said, "I offered this amendment because I believe that everyone, regardless of religious
affiliation, should have access to healthcare."
But Dr. Norman Fost, a pediatrician and medical ethicist at the University of Wisconsin, said the
measure went against the goal of reducing healthcare costs by improving evidence-based medical
practices.
"They want a special exception for people who use unproved treatments, and they also want to get
paid for it," he said. "They want people who use prayer to have it just automatically accepted as a
legitimate therapy."
Christian Science leaders say many critics misunderstand their faith. Christian Scientists do not reject
medical care, church leaders said. Instead, they promote spiritual healing and do not interfere with
decisions about whether to pursue medical help.
Davis has been trained as a practitioner and still occasionally treats the sick.
"We'll talk to them about their relationship to God," he said. "We'll talk to them about citations or
biblical passages they might study. We refer to it as treatment. It's an affirmation of their relationship
with God, and the understanding that comes from their prayer, of their relationship with God."
During the day, Davis may see multiple patients and pray for them at different moments. He charges
them $20 to $40 for the day, saying, "I think that it would be considered modest by any standard."
The church, which has seen a steady decline in adherents, does not reveal membership numbers. It
claims between 1,700 and 1,800 congregations in more than 60 countries.
Davis said the church consulted legal experts to develop legislation that was constitutional and
consonant with the overall goals of healthcare reform. It also hired a major Washington law firm,
Mayer Brown, to lobby for the provision.
"We think this is an important aspect of the solution," Davis said, arguing that Christian Scientists are
leading the fight for all who believe in spiritual healing. "We don't believe there should be hurdles
between an individual and spiritual treatment that could be the most important solution to healthcare
in this country."
Copyright © 2009, The Los Angeles Times
RELATED STORIES
Around the WebOrrin Hatch and Other People’s Money -- By: Andrew Stuttaford | corner.nationalreview.com
E-mail Print Digg Twitter Facebook StumbleUpon Share
Healthcare provision seeks to embrace prayer treatments -- latim... http://www.latimes.com/features/health/la-na-health-religion3-...
3 of 4 11/7/09 13:55
Can you guess these placesfrom these aerial images?
Chefs Thomas Keller, MarkPeel take on home cooking
Fingerprint-scan deadbolt caneliminate need for keys
S. Carolina embarrassed bypoliticians behaving badly
Stephen Colbert's name game
Local
Nation
World
Business
Technology
Sports
Opinion
Columnists
Obituaries
NewsTelevision
Movies
Music
Arts & Culture
Celebrity
The Envelope
Calendar
Company Town
TV Listings
Movie Listings
Tickets
EntertainmentTravel
Health
Food
Home
Image
Magazine
Books
Autos
Hot List
Horoscopes
Crosswords
LivingVideo
Photos
Data Desk
Your Scene
Times on Twitter
RSS
Newsletters
Kindle
E-edition
MultimediaL. A. Now
Celebrity
TV Show Tracker
Politics
Gold Derby
Company Town
Technology
Music
Travel & Deals
Health
Top BlogsCorrections
Readers' Rep
Print Edition
Contact Us | Help
About Us
LATMG Media Kit
Digital Media Kit
Subscribe
Manage My Account
Site Map
More
Save more than 50% off the newsstand price. Click here to subscribe to The Times.
Coastline Pilot Daily Pilot Huntington Beach Independent Valley Sun Burbank Leader News Press KTLA Hoy Brand XLA, Los Angeles Times Magazine
Baltimore Sun Chicago Tribune Daily Press Hartford Courant Los Angeles Times Orlando Sentinel Sun Sentinel The Morning Call
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Los Angeles Times, 202 West 1st Street, Los Angeles, California, 90012 | Copyright 2009
A Tribune Web site
Healthcare provision seeks to embrace prayer treatments -- latim... http://www.latimes.com/features/health/la-na-health-religion3-...
4 of 4 11/7/09 13:55