Download - India's E-commerce Warzone_ Six Cut-throat Skirmishes Underway Between Global Giants & Indian Top Dogs - The Economic Times

4/20/2015 India'secommercewarzone:Sixcutthroatskirmishesunderwaybetweenglobalgiants&IndiantopdogsTheEconomicTimes

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/emergingbusinesses/startups/indiasecommercewarzonesixcutthroatskirmishesunderwaybetweengl 1/13

FOLLOWET:LogIn / Join

MustSeeSlideshows

China'snewrunway:AirstripinSouthChinaSea!Chinahasmaderapidprogressinbuilding

Goldlosingitssheen?

WhyyoushouldgivegoldamissthisAkshayaTritiyaBuyinggoldrightnowmaynotbeawise

SPOTLIGHT

Startups

LATESTNEWS>06:14PM: SriLanka'sexpresidentMahindaRajapaksefacesanti...06:08PM: Egyptiancourtconfirmsdeathsentencesfor22Islamists06:07PM: Centre,statesworkingonnewGSTrate:RevenueSecy...06:05PM: TrucetenuousasUkraineleadertackleseconomy,olig...

VikramPatel

Lackofpoliticalwilltoaddresscomplexhealthissues

< >

SMESector Startups SMEPolicy&Trends RegionalHubs Entrepreneurship Hardware

Youarehere: ETHome News EmergingBusinesses Startups

SENSEX27,886.21 555.89

NIFTY8,448.10 157.90

GOLD(MCX)(Rs/10g.)26,855.00 43.00

USD/INR62.91 0.53

LOGINtoTrackyourInvestments

ByRajivSingh,ETBureau|19Apr,2015,06.54AMIST 25comments | PostaComment

EcommerceisseeingaracebetweentheAmazonsandExpediasvstheFlipkartsandMakeMyTrips.Thedesientrepreneurshavethewindintheirsales,fornow.

Editor'sPick

Marketsdown,butdonotpanic,sayexpertstopstockstobuy

Sensexfallsover1Kptsgoodtimetobuy:Experts

HSBCaccountholdersfearattachmentofassets

Sensexcloses555pointsdownfivereasons

TradersbullishongoldaheadofAkshayaTritiya

ETSPECIAL: Lovevisualaspectofnews?Enjoythisexclusiveslideshowstreat!

India'secommercewarzone:Sixcutthroatskirmishesunderwaybetweenglobalgiants&IndiantopdogsREADMOREONVivekMadhukar|SundayET|Sequoia|SanjayModi|SachinBansal|representative|RachelSmith

Amazon,America'slargestetailer,beganasanonlinebookstorein1994.TwoyearsbeforeJeffBezosporedthroughthedictionaryandpickedouttheworld'sbiggestriverashisbrandname,lesserknown(atleastasoftoday)CharlesMStackfoundedbooks.com.Today,Stack'sonlinestores(alsoknownasBookStacksUnlimited)willbedifficulttolocatetheyweregobbledupbyBarnes&Nobleover15yearsago.

Contrarytopopularperception,Amazonwasn'tthefirstmover(bysomeaccountsitwassecond,byothersevenfourth).Alsocontrarytopopularperception,thefirstmoverdoesn'talwaysemergethewinner.

Marketingguruswilltellyouaboutthefirstmoveradvantage,whichistypicallytheheadstartthefirstentrantgainsbycapitalisingonamonopolylikesituationtorakeinfatprofitmargins.

Lessertalkedaboutisthesecondmoveradvantage,thecompetitiveadvantageanentrantgetsbylearningfromthepioneer'smistakes,copyinghissuccessfulstrategiesandstealinghisshare(insteadofwastingtimecreatingamarket).

The$12billionecommercebattlefieldinIndiaislitteredwithfirstmoversandsecond(andthird,andevenlast)movers.Fascinatingly,manyoftheleadersareventuresfoundedIndiabyIndians(albeitfuelledlargelybyforeignventurecapitalandprivateequity).Forinstance,etailerFlipkartandonlinetravelfirmMakeMyTriparebothaheadoftheirglobalpeersAmazonandExpedia.

Socantheorderofthefirstmoverbeingfirstrankerchange?Forsure,anaggressiveAmazonIndiawillinsistasitgoesaboutthetaskofclosingthegapwithFlipkart(andBezosmaygleefullyremindyouoftheBookStacksexample).BeyondAmazon,too,intheclassifiedmarketplaceforusedgoods,theglobalgiant(OLX)movedintoIndiatwo

SearchforNews,StockQuotes&NAV's

04:05PM|20APRMARKETSTATS

EOD

Home News Defence Company Industry Economy PoliticsandNation International EmergingBusinesses More

Indiatimes TheTimesofIndia TheEconomicTimes More

Airtelplanmayviolatespiritofnetneutrality:FlikpakrtCEOSachinBansalReadmore



anairstripsuitableformilitaryuseincontestedterritoryintheSouthChinaSea'sSpratlyIslands.

SevensmartwaystouseyourannualbonusHondaCarsIndiagearsuptointroducethenewJazz

decision.ButifyouwanttobuyitforreligiouspurposesonAkshayaTritiya,buyonlyasmallquantity.

MostRead

MostShared

MostCommented

NewsinPics 2/20

Mustseecarsfrom2015ShanghaiAutoshow

Whatcentralgovernmentemployeescanexpectfromthe7thPayCommission

SnapdealbuysFreechargeinbiggeststartupM&A

HowNarendraModigovernmentrescued3,500IndiansfromwarzoneYemen

SwachhBharat:PMModi'spromiseofcleaning&beautifyingVaranasidoesn'tappeartobeanemptyone

QatarhasbiginvestmentplansforIndia:SheikhTamimbinHamadAlThani

More

yearsbeforetoday'sleader(Quikr)gotgoing.Today,theIndiansecondmoverclaimstobeinfirstplacealthoughOLXtoomaintainsitisthemarketleader.

ButthentheseareearlydaysofecommerceinIndia,withbusinessesgrowingonthebackofreadyandwillinginvestors,andprofitabilityameregleamintheeyeoftheIndianfounders."WellfundedglobalplayerscaneasilyabsorbmillionsofdollarsinannuallossesandthiscanputIndianecommerceplayersintrouble,"saysSanchitVirGogia,chiefanalystandgroupCEOofGreyhoundResearch.

Sowillthelocalleadersbeabletokeeptheglobalgiantsatbay?Cansomeofthesecondmoverstakefirstplace?ETMagazinetakesalookatsixcutthroatskirmishesunderwaybetweenglobalgiantsandIndiantopdogsondifferentpartsoftheecommercebattlefield.Inmanyoftheseencountersthewinnermayhavealreadybeendecidedandit'snotnecessarilythetwobrandssluggingitoutbuttheIndianconsumer.

MydalavsGroupon

WhenGrouponenteredIndiain2011,theChicagobaseddailydealsgianthadnumbersonitsside120millionsubscribersglobally.Afterfouryears,thatnumberhasgotmoreformidable,climbingto260million.Forgoodmeasure,monthlyuniquevisitorsstandat160million,ithassold900millionunitssofarandthepercustomerannualspendonthesiteworksoutto$155.

ThepictureinIndia,though,doesn'tlookthatimpressivenotatleastwhenstackedupagainstthelocalleaderinthecountry.WhileGrouponIndiahasjust5millionuniqueusersand25,000merchants,itsnearestrivalandlargestplayerinthesegmentMydalahas10timesasmanyuniqueusersandeighttimesasmanymerchants.Ifthatwasn'tenough,theIndianNo.1has4milliontransactingcustomerseverymonth,andmobileusersdownloadroughly150,000vouchersfromMydalaeveryday.

Ifsuchnumbersaren'tfazingGroupon,perhapsit'sbecausethey'relookingatabiggerpicture."Indiaisthefastestgrowingamongst48countrieswhereGrouponispresent,"saysAnkurWarikoo,regionalhead,APACemergingcountries(India,Indonesia,Thailand,Philippines).

GrouponhashaditsshareoflearningsfromtheIndiamarketandhasbeenusingtofinetuneitsstrategy.Forinstance,IndiaistheonlycountrywhereGrouponhasthecashondeliverymodeofpayment.WhilegloballywellnessisthebiggestcategoryforGroupon,inIndiait'sfoodandbeverages.Andalmost90%ofthedealsclosedarefacetoface,saysWarikoo,whomanagedtogetSequoiaCapitaltoinvest$20millionintheIndianunitinMarchthisyear.Theinvestment,thoughnothingcomparedtowhattheIndianstartupsareattracting,showsanewfoundaggressivenessoftheIndianarmtotakeoncompetition.



ChangeyourlifeatworkwiththistodolistManagingyourworkgetstoochallengingattimes,youmayevenfailtofinish...

BMWbringsbackoldschoolgogglesforanewagetwistTheGermanautomakersMiniunitisshowingoffasystemthatsathrowbackin...

McDonald'sfaces'cockroachburger'claiminNewZealandAnnahSophiaStevensontoldFairfaxNewZealandthatsheboughtaBigMacmeal...

Motherofaustisticchilddevelops'universallanguage'appMarieSpitzdevelopedthe"TalkDifferent"appthatuses700

images,colours,...

OppolaunchesJoyPlussmartphoneatRs6,990ThesmartphoneoffersaDualSIMcardwith1700mAhLiIonremovablebatterya...

Peoplearefaintingduring'MohenjoDaro'shoot:HrithikActorHrithikRoshanisfindingittoughtoshootfor"MohenjoDaro"industs...

ET PANACHE

MostWatchedVideos

MOREFROMVIDEOS

"ThereisnothingthatpreventsforeignplayersfromleadingintheIndianmarket,"saysWarikoo,wholooksataFlipkartorMakeMyTripashisrivalratherthanMydala.Mydalareturnsthecompliment."They[Groupon]don'tstandanywherenearus,"saysAnishaSingh,cofounderandCEOofMydala."IthasfailedinIndiabecauseofitsbigdaddyattitude."

Therivalrybetweenthebrandshasaninterestingbackground.In2011,whenGrouponwasplanningtoenterIndia,itwasintalkswithaslewoflocalplayersforabuyout.Mydalawasalsoapproached.However,thetalksfailedovervaluationsandtermsofthedeal."Itwasablessingindisguise,"saysSingh.

TheDelhibasedcompany,whichwasstartedin2009,reportedsalesofRs75crorein201314,withaprofitaftertaxofRs40lakh,afteradjustmentsforanemployeestockownershipplan(ESOP).Itexpectstocross$40millionorRs250croreby201617.

WhathashelpedMydalastealamarchonitsrivalsismassiveuseofdataanalytics."Ithelpsmerchantstargetrelevantusers,"saysSingh.Theanalyticsrevealsnotonlywhatuserstendtobuyandthepricepointstheymightlike,italsotracksthespendingpatternandpredictsthedealsthatwouldworkoutbestforthem.

WhathasalsodonewondersforSinghandtheothertwocofoundersArjunBasuandAshishBhatnagarisworkingearlyonmobilestrategy,connectingwithlocalmerchantsandfocusingondealsofallkindsunlike,say,aGrouponthattargetsrelativelyhigherenddealsatafarmorenicheaudienceintopmetros.SaysSingh:"WearenotheretomakemoviesforthecriticsbuttosetthecashregistersringinglikeDabangg'sChulbulPandey."

CashKarovsTopCashback

ForSwatiandRohanBhargava,itwasthebiggestgambleoftheirlife.Andtheoddsweren'tquiteintheirfavour.

PouringPounds,theircashbackwebsiteintheUK,wasamongthetop10cashbacksitesbutstillway,waybehindthelargestplayer,TopCashback.RatherthanconsolidatingtheirpositionintheUK,thehusbandwifeduodecidedtoshiftbasetoIndiainApril2013,amarkettheirUKrivalhadtakentheplungeintoayearbefore."Wewentbyourgut.We

Watch:SpectacularTejaslanding

Watch:SpectacularTejaslanding

Buynow,sellnow:Answerstoviewersq...

Allaboutstocks:Yourinvestmentstrate...



feltthechancesofbeatingtheminIndia,amarketwearemorefamiliarwith,werehigher[thanintheUK],"saysSwati.

CashKaroofferscashrebatestocustomerswhobuyproductsfromthewebsite'sretailpartners.Forsalesdrivenfromthesitetoecommercefirms,itgetsacommission,apartofwhichispassedonasextracashbacktocustomers.

Twoyearson,numbersrevealthatCashKaroiscomfortablyaheadofitsUKrival.Itboastsof3,500transactionsperday,anastounding1,000%growthoverthepast12months,1millionmembersacrossplatforms,600+retailersandagrossmerchandisevalueof$50million.CompareitwithTopCashbackandthenumberstellthestory1,0002,000transactionsperdayandarosterof300+retailers.Howdidtheduopullitoff?Simple,theyhadto."Wedidn'thaveaPlanB.SoourfocuswastomakeitbiginIndia,"saysSwati.

SincethefoundingteamwasbasedinIndia,itbecameeasiertofocusondirectrelationshipswithmerchantpartnersandusers,whichinturnhelpedfasterdecisionmaking."ThisisnotthesamewithTopCashbackasitsparentcompanyisbasedintheUK,"sheadds.Moreover,thepresenceofalargegroundteam(over45)enabledCashKarotoimproveitsbackendtechnologyconstantlyamidstafastchangingecommerceecosystem.

Anotherdecidingfactorwasthehungertosucceed.Mostoftheforeignplayersdon'tenteranewmarketwiththatfire,saysRohanBhargava."Justbeingpresentinamarketwithagrowingeconomyandanevenfastergrowinginternetpopulationperhapsissatisfactionenough."

Tobesure,TopCashbackisn'texactlyinahurrytograbpoleposition,preferringtoplayalongtermgame."WewouldlovetobethenumberonecashbackfirmonedaybutIndiaisvast,growingandathoroughlyexcitingplace,"saysNatashaRachelSmith,chiefcommunicationsofficerofTopCashback.

WhatdifferentiatesTopCashbackfromothersisthatitpassesontheentirecommissionitearnstotheusers.Sotheonlymoneyitmakesisfromtheadvertisements.However,thathasnotactedasadeterrentfortheUKmajor."WehavebeenseeingexplosivegrowthinIndiawiththeamountofcashbackearnedinthefirstfewmonthsofthisyearalreadyexceedingthatearnedinthewholeof2014,"saysSmith.

Tillnow,TopCashbackhasdonerelativelylittlemarketing.Amajorityofitsmembershavecomefromreferralsfromexistingusers.Sotheroomforgrowthisimmense.ButcanaforeignplayerclinchNo.1slotinIndianecommerce?"It'sabsolutelypossible,"Smithsays.Watchout,CashKaro.Thebigdaddyofcashbackisgettingreadytofightback.

MakeMyTripvsExpedia



MakeMyTripcouldn'thavebeenbornataworsetimein2000,banginthemidstofthedotcombust.Ayearlater,9/11terroristattacksontheUnitedStatescameasahugesetbacktothetravelindustry.Thetriplewhammywascompleteinlate2002whenthesevereacuterespiratorysyndrome(SARS)brokeout.

ForcofoundersDeepKalraandRajeshMagow,theaftereffectswerenearfatal.Investorspanickedandpressedtheexitbuttons,andfreshfundswerenowhereinsight.Tostayafloat,theduodecidedtofocusontheUSIndiatravelmarket,withnonresidentIndiansastheirtargetcustomers.

Today,NRIsstillcontributetoMakeMyTrip'sbusiness,butjustaboutafraction.Therestcomesfromthedomesticmarket,helpingtheportalemergeasIndia'slargestonlinetravelfirm.

"Thefirstmovertaggaveusastrongerrecallandanenduringassociationwithtravellerswhobookedtheirfirstairticketwithus,"saysMagow,CEOofMakeMyTrip."Therewasnolookingbackafterthat."

Fifteenyearson,MakeMyTripisstillanoverwhelminglydominantplayerwitha47%onlinetravelmarketshare.Beingclosertothemarketdefinitelyhelpedittaketherightdecisionsattherighttimeandalsocapitalizeonitsexistingrelationshipswithsuppliers.

Butwhilethegoinghasbeensmoothsofar,thefinancialsoverthelastfewquartershavebeendisappointing.MakeMyTripreportednetlossesof$3.66millionforthequarterendedDecember30,2014,ascomparedtoa$1.6millionlossinthesamequarterlastyeartheninthstraightlossmakingquarterforthecompany.

Magowandhisteamhavebeenworkingtoputthingsbackontrackbyfocusingonnonairproductssuchashotelsandpackages(H&P)."It'sastrategicfocusareaforus.TheH&Pbusinessdisplayedovera70%growthintransactionsinthepastquarteroverayearago."

Butdoescompetitionworryhim,especiallyfromgloballeaderExpedia?Theworld'slargestonlinetravelcompanybyrevenuesenteredIndiain2008,agoodeightyearsafterMakeMyTrip,andappearshappywithitsprogresssofar.

"Wearenotinthenumbersgameofgettingtoa50%marketshare,"saysVikramMalhi,



managingdirectorAsiaofExpedia."Doingsomethingsillyforthesakeofacquisitionofconsumersissomethingthatwewillshyawayfrom.Iamnotgoingtoburnaholeinthepockettoacquirecustomers."

India'sventurecapitalbackedtravelfirms,hecontends,maybesplurgingonadvertisingandpromotionstorackupsales,butasfarasExpediaacompanywhichlikeMakeMyTripislistedontheNASDAQintheUSisconcerned,itwon'tgoabout"spendingRs1,200toearnRs200fromthecustomer."

SohowwillExpediaplaythegame?Simple,byusingtechnologytoslicedataandcomeupwithproductssuitedforIndians."Wehaveearmarked$10millionfortechnologydevelopmentonlyforIndia,"saysMalhi.WillthatbeenoughtomakeExpedia'stripinIndia?

NaukrivsMonster

In2004,JobsAhead,anIndianjobportal,hadanover40%shareoftheonlinejobsmarketinthecountry.Whileitsnearestcompetitor,Naukri,wasbusydevisingastrategytotopthecategory,theonlyforeignplayerinthesegment,Monster,toowasfiguringoutwaystogetintothegame.

WhennobodywaswillingtogivetheAmericangiant,whichenteredIndiain2001,achance,itcameupwithamonsterofamovebybuyingJobsAhead.ThecombinedentitywasalmosttwicethesizeofNaukri,whichhadbegunoperationsin1997.

Fastforwardto2015,andthepeckingorderchangeth.WhileNaukriisthedominantplayer,MonsterisinvolvedinascrapforthesecondslotwithTimesJobs,ajobportalfromtheBCCLGroup(whichpublishesTheEconomicTimesMagazine).

"Inhindsight,thekillingofJobsAheadbyMonsterwasaturningpoint,"saysHiteshOberoi,CEOandmanagingdirectorofInfoEdgeIndia,whichrunsjobsportalNaukri.

Initially,JobsAheadandMonsterranasseparateentities.ButlatertheidentityoftheacquiredbrandwasmergedwithMonster."Sometimesalocalproductismoresuitedforthelocalmarket,"addsOberoi.



VivekMadhukar,chiefoperatingofficerofTimesJobs,believesIndianplayershaveagreatercapacitytocustomisetheirofferingsfordomesticcustomers."Inaddition,thelogisticsandprofileoftheuserwouldbesignificantlydifferentinIndiaascomparedtotheWest,forwhichforeignplayers'offeringsareprimarilydesigned."

SowhathasenabledNaukristayaheadoftheglobalcountercounterpartinIndiasuperiorunderstandingofthemarketorconsistentinnovationorearlyprofitability?Perhapsamixofallthree,reckonsOberoi.

Tobeginwith,thefirstmoveradvantagehelpedNaukriincomprehendingthenuancesofthemarket.AndanearlyrealisationthatmanpowerintensiveIndianeedsadifferentapproachalsocamehandy.

"ForMonster,Indiawasjust2%ofglobaloperations,butforusIndiawas100%,"explainsOberoi."Soforusitwasadoordiesituation."

TheInfoEdgeCEOalsopointstoanothercriticaldifferencebetweenahomegrown,entrepreneurdrivenfirmandonerunfromtheglobalheadquarters."Attheendoftheday,thepersonwhoisheadingtheIndiaoperationsisjustanemployee.Obviously,pressuretoperformistherebutthestakesarenotashigh[asinafounderdrivenIndianstartup]."

SanjayModiobviouslydoesn'tthinkso.ThemanagingdirectorofMonster(India,MiddleEast,SouthEastAsia,HongKong)pointsoutthattheparentcompanyhaspulledoutallstopstoinstilanentrepreneurialspiritamongemployeesinIndia."ThedecisiontoacquireJobsAheadwastakenlocally,"saysModi."Weareaglobalplayerbutweactlocal."

Forhispart,ModitakesadigattheIndiancompaniesbysayingthattheyhavebeenapingthebusinessmodelsthathavebeenprovenglobally."Nobodycreatedanewmodel.EventhefundingofthesocalledIndiancompaniesisdonebyforeigners."

MonsterenteredIndiain2001,atthetailendofthedotcombust.

Aftersurvivingafewtumultuousyears,itbegantofinditsfeetandadapttolocalmarketconditions.ModifeelsthatlearningsofoperatingintheIndianmarkethaveputitinapositiontotoppletheleader.With1,00,000livejobs,44.9millionregisteredusersand15,000newresumesaddedeveryday,MonsterIndiaisgearinguptotakepoleposition."WearenotheretogaineyeballsbuttobecomeNo.1."

Thecompanyisplanningto"significantly"stepupinvestmentsinIndiathisyeartosupportitsaggressiveintent."It'sonlyamatteroftimebeforewegoinforthekill,"saysModi.LookslikeatoughjobbutMonsterisonit.

QuikrvsOLX

Failfast,scalefastisthemaximPranayChuletlivesby."QuickandQuikrwinstherace,"saysthefounderofQuikr,India'slargestonlineclassifiedsite.

Forthetimebeing,ChuletseemstohavewonthefirstfewroundsbyscalingexponentiallyandgrowingquickerthanglobalrivalOLX,Inc.TheIndianclassifiedsiteboastsofover8.2millionuniquevisitors(asofFebruary)across1,000citiesanddealsinover10categoriesand170subcategories.OLXinIndiahassome5.3millionuniquevisitors.

Startedin2008,Quikrrecentlyraised$150million(aroundRs900crore)fromHongKongbasedSteadviewCapitalalongwithitsexistinginvestors,includingTigerGlobalManagement,raisingatotalofover$350million.Thefreshroundoffundingtakesitsvaluationtoastaggering$1billion.



AskChuletthereasonforthesuccessofIndianplayers,andhehasananswer(aquickone,ofcourse):"Greatbusinessesarenotbuiltbyhiredguns."HereferstotheIndianheadsofglobalMNCsthataretrailingtheircounterpartsinthecountry.

"Entrepreneursarehungrytosucceed,areagile,nimbletoadapttochangingsituationsandpassionate,"heexplains.ThereasonslistedprobablyexplainwhyQuikrracedaheadofNaspersownedOLXinspiteofnothavingthefirstmoveradvantage."[Thatdisadvantage]wascompensatedbylearningfromthemistakesofthosealreadypresent,"hesays.

Also,innovationwasanimperativetocounterthefirstmover.Quikr'sfirstmajorinnovationcameinthefagendof2012.

Consumerswereaskedtogiveamissedcallonanumber,andaQuikrrepresentativewouldcallthembackandtakedownthelisting.ItnotonlyallowedlakhsofofflineconsumerstopostadsonQuikreasily,italsohelpedthebrandpushitsapponthephones."Itacceleratedourgrowth,whichwasnowmuchfasterthanthecompetition,andchangedourtrajectory,"saysChulet.

Twoyearslatercameanothermasterstroke:MSPormaximumsellingpricefortheusedgoods.Sincethenthebrandhaskeptupitsinnovationtempo.QuikrNxt,thelatestofferingrolledoutinJanuarythisyear,isaninstantmessengerservicethatallowsuserstochatusingthewebsiteormobileapp.

WhilethegoinghasbeensmoothforChuletsofar,canhewardoffthechallengefromOLX,whichispresentinover100countriesand,inIndia,iscloseontheheelsoftheleader?

Inanemailreply,anOLXIndiaspokespersonsaidthatinecommerce"OLXistheonlyglobalplayerwhichisthemarketleader".Inrestofthecases,theglobalplayersseemtobelaggingbehindtheirIndiancounterparts,thespokespersonsaid,addingthattheIndiateamofOLXistravellingandwon'tbeabletocomment.

MarketinganalystssayOLXislikelytouptheantesoon."OLXhasdeeppockets,has



madeanimpactwithitscommunicationsanditisonlyamatteroftimebeforeitestablishesitself,"saysAshitaAggarwalSharma,professorofmarketingatSPJainInstituteofManagement&Research.

Thisdoesn'tbotherChulet.Globalguyshavebigmoney,butit'snoteverything,hesays."Ifyouareburningmoneyandthereisnoreturnoninvestment,thensomebodywillwakeupandsmellthecoffee.Itcan'tgoonforlong."ButitmayalsohelpOLXscaleupquickerthanbefore.

FlipkartvsAmazon

AmitAgarwal,countrymanagerandvicepresidentofAmazonIndia,isan'obsessed'man."Weareobsessedwithourcustomers,weareobsessedwithcustomerfeedback,andweareobsessedwithhelpingsellersgetonline..."SuchobsessionhashelpedAmazontakethefighttoFlipkart,India'slargestonlineretailer,inalittleover20monthstintinIndia.

"WeareIndia'slargestonlinestore,"declaresAgarwal,dismissinganytalkaboutbeingsecondlargestinthecountry.Andnotforhimanydifferentiationbetween'foreign'ecommercefirmsandhomegrownones(likeFlipkartandSnapdeal)."Allthese[Indian]companiesareownedbyforeigninvestors."

Agarwal'sclaimtobeingthelargest,though,maynotbebackedbythenumbersthatmatterthoseofsales.InFebruarythisyear,newsreportsquotingunnamedsourcessaidFlipkarthadclocked$4billioninannualgrossmerchandisevalue(GMV).InMarch2014,itsGMVhadstoodat$1billion.GMVisafigureforthevalueofallgoodssoldonthesiteandusedtomeasuretheperformanceofonlineretailers.FlipkartdidnotshareanyfinancialdetailswithETMagazine.

InJuly2014,AmazaonfounderJeffBezoshadsaidinastatementthat"atcurrentscaleandgrowthrates,Indiaisontracktobeourfastestcountryevertoabilliondollarsingrosssales".Twomonthslater,onavisittoIndia,Bezosletonthat"this[India]teamhasblownpastourhighestexpectations."WhenaskedaboutthelatestGMV,AmazonIndiadeclinedtosharenumbers.

InitsfourthquarterfilingsinJanuarythisyear,Amazonmentionedthatin2014ithas


http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/emergingbusinesses/startups/indiasecommercewarzonesixcutthroatskirmishesunderwaybetween 10/13

NEWEST OLDEST RECOMMENDED(2) MOSTDISCUSSED AGREE DISAGREE

Top10MutualFundsBuyMutualfundsonline.Selectfrom5000+schemes.OpenFreeA/cnow.:www.myuniverse.co.in/ZipSip

AdsbyGoogle

emergedasIndia'slargestonlinestore.

AmazonIndiahasacollectionofover2.2croreproductsoutofwhich7lakhareavailablefornextdaydeliveryacross19,000pincodesinIndia.Ithasacombinedsellerbaseof100,000withJunglee(whichAmazonacquiredinthelate90s),andhasseeneighttimesgrowthintheRs1croreplussellerclubsaleslastyearitpostedaRs321.3crorenetlossintheyearendedMarch2014."Weareinvestingaggressively,"explainsAgarwal.

What'shelpingAmazoninitssurgeinIndiaisthedeeppocketsoftheparentcompanyBezoscommitteda$2billioninvestmentlastyearandpromisedtokeepthetaprunningaswellasitsfocusoninnovationsandgettingSMEsonboard."Inthelastoneyear,Amazonhasuppeditsgame,"saysSanchitVirGogia,chiefanalystandgroupCEOofGreyhoundResearch.

ShouldFlipkartbeworried?"Competitionisalwaysahealthythingthatdrivesustoinnovateandexplorenewerideas,"saysMukeshBansal,headofcommerceplatformatFlipkart.FoundedbyformerAmazoniansSachinBansalandBinnyBansalin2007,Flipkarthasraised$2.5billion(Rs15,600crore)sofar,hasover40millionregisteredconsumers,shipsabouteightmillionunitsamonthandisvaluedataround$11billion.Andthereisasetoffewambitioustargetsaswell:shippingabillionunitsamonth,serving100millionconsumersby2018,clocking$5billionsales(overRs30,000crore)bytheendofMarch2016(Amazongloballyhadsalesof$88.99billionin2014).

Withover20millionproductsacross70pluscategories,customerscanshopfromawiderangeofnationalandinternationalbrands,saysBansal.

ForFlipkart,whichhasalreadyhadfiveacquisitions,includingfashionretailerMyntra,buyoutsremainacrucialfocusareathisyear,especiallyintechnologyandmobilespace."WewanttheseM&AstodrivetheinnovationengineatFlipkart,"hesays.AsforAmazonasBezosindicatedontheIndiavisitgrowthismorelikelytobeorganic,withacquisitionsbeingastrategytoacquireuniquecapabilitiesratherthanmarketaccess.SmallwonderthenthatAgarwalisputtingpedaltometal.

READMOREONVivekMadhukar|SundayET|Sequoia|SanjayModi|SachinBansal|representative|RachelSmith

FollowthissectionforlatestnewsonStartups

Yourcomment

Readers'opinions(25)

Havesomethingtosay?PostyourcommentCommentsaremoderatedandwillbeallowediftheyareaboutthetopicandnotabusive.

Charactersremaining(1500)



Vryniceandinterestingarticle Agree(0)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

nicetoreadsuchgreatinspirationalstories Agree(0)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

Interesting.LetusstandbyourIndiancompaniesandcreateafiercebattleforground.Andletthecompetitionbringmorebenefitstoconsumers.UnlessourIndiancompaniesarenotstrong,MNCswouldexploitusandgobbleourmoneys.

Agree(0)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

Coolarticle,detailedinfoonallcompanies.!Changestheperceptioneasily. Agree(0)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

Goodinformation Agree(0)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

technologylivingitsbesteverspellkeeponservingcustomers Agree(1)Disagree(0)Recommend(1)Offensive

HELLOFRIENDS,Youcanearn30,000to50,000permontheasilyfromhomeworkingoninternetjobswhichareabsolutelyfreetojoin!,Freetojoinparttimeinternetjobs,Formoredetails,checkmyblogh$tt$ps:/$/rajarya$nm$mb4u.wor$dpress.c$om(remove$signandusethislink)


ThisisthebesttimetobeinIndia'secommercemarket. Agree(1)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

Interesting.LetusstandbyourIndiancompaniesandcreateafiercebattleforground.Andletthecompetitionbringmorebenefitstoconsumers.UnlessourIndiancompaniesarenotstrong,MNCswouldexploitusandgobbleourmoneys.


ForFlipkart,whichhasalreadyhadfiveacquisitions,includingfashionretailerMyntra,buyoutsremainacrucialfocusareathisyear,especiallyintechnologyandmobilespace."WewanttheseM&AstodrivetheinnovationengineatFlipkart,"hesays.AsforAmazon


4Hoursago

AnanthakrishnaBhat (Bang)

5Hoursago

Rakesh (Ddun)

7Hoursago

Manish (Delhi)

8Hoursago

ShivamAgarwal (NCT)

21Hoursago

SivaKumarDattu (Guntur)

23Hoursago

Name (Kawardha)

23Hoursago

Kiranshrma286 (Mumbai)

1Dayago

VSGR (Bangalore)

1Dayago

BharatVamsi (Tamilnadu)

1Dayago

GauravSaraswat (Unknown)



OnlineshoppingisbecomingacrazeinIndia.Indiancompanyshouldgiveagoodfighttoit'sforeigncounterpart.


ForthatweshouldsupportIndiancompanieswhogiveusvalueformoneyaswellassustainedqualityservice.


Yes,a2ndmoveradvantageisaveryvalidproposition Agree(0)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

Wah!Whatastory?Halfthefactsarewrong.Mr.Journalistgoandcheckyourfactsfirst.Intryingtobesensational,you'vegotsomenumbershorriblywrong.Pleasetalktoafewinvestors,customersandsellersbeforeyoupublishsuchrubbish.Yourtargetaudienceforthispostarethestartupfolkandatsomeofyourexamples,theymustbelaughingatyou


whatguaranteedoestheecommerceretailersgiveontheitemssoldontheirplatform....nothing................everythingseemstobeatthecustomersrisk........................


nice... Agree(0)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

FlipkartandsnapdealareIndianGoogleandYahoo. Agree(0)Disagree(1)Recommend(0)Offensive

survivalofthefittest Agree(0)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

Soverynaturalasonewillgowherethereareopportunities. Agree(2)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

Correct,Iagreewithyou. Agree(0)Disagree(0)

1Dayago

SunuSunup (Angul)

1Dayago

BharatVamsi (Unknown)RepliesToSunuSunup

1Dayago

PrashantNayakanti (Unknown)

1DayagoAbhijeet (NewDelhi)

1Dayago

PROUDINDIAN (Unknown)

1Dayago

MukeshKumar (Delhi)

1DayagoRajesh (192.168.23.10)

1Dayago

Akash76 (Hyd)

1Dayago

ZeyaAlam (Unknown)

1Dayago

SubrataPramanick (Kolkata)RepliesToZeyaAlam



GetaQuote BrowseCompaniesA B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z | 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

BrowseMutualFundsA B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z

OtherTimesGroupnewssites

TimesofIndia | | MumbaiMirrorTimesNow | Indiatimes | | LifehackerGizmodo | Eisamay | IGNIndiaNavGujaratSamay

LivingandentertainmentTimescity | iDiva | BollywoodZoom | Healthmeup | LuxpressoTechnology | Guylife | OnlineSongs | TravelGuides | HotelReviews | Cricbuzz.com

Networkingitimes | Dating&Chat | EmailMensXP.com

HotontheWebDailyHoroscope | WeatherinDelhiMumbaiMap | HoroscopeHotelsinDelhi | XiaomiMobilePhones

ServicesBookprintads | Onlineshopping | FreeSMS | Websitedesign | CRM | TendersMatrimonial | Ringtones | Astrology | Jobs | Property | Buycar | BikesinIndiaUsedCars | OnlineDeals | RestaurantsinDelhi | MovieShowTimingsinMumbaiRemittoIndia | BuyMobiles | ListenSongs

Aboutus / Advertisewithus / TermsofUseandGrievanceRedressalPolicy / PrivacyPolicy / Feedback / Sitemap / CodeofEthics Copyright2015TimesInternetLimited.Allrightsreserved.

LiveMarket News Portfolio Mobile LiveTV Newsletter Commodities Speed QnA Blogs Alerts

Recommend(0)Offensive

Thanksforagreeingbutitisauniversaltheoryofmigrationonopportunity.


Okay. Agree(0)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

Mypleasure.Itisaknownfactthatmigrationhappensforbettersituations.


BonazaafortheconsumersandbadnewsfortheMallswhohaslootedconsumerstilldate.


Naturallyonewillgowheretheopportunityisthere Agree(1)Disagree(0)Recommend(0)Offensive

1Dayago

ZeyaAlam (Unknown)RepliesToSubrataPramanick

22Hoursago

SubrataPramanickRepliesToZeyaAlam

1Hourago

ZeyaAlamRepliesToSubrataPramanick

1Dayago

PankajKumar (Pune)

1Dayago

ZeyaAlam (Unknown)RepliesToPankajKumar

TypeCompanyName GetQuote

Download - India's E-commerce Warzone_ Six Cut-throat Skirmishes Underway Between Global Giants & Indian Top Dogs - The Economic Times

Top Related