Download - Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 ......Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 25.02.2019 22 Storyline: ‘FLR should remain

http

s://de.w

ikiped

ia.org/w

iki/Ham

let#/m

edia/File:D

avid_G

arrick_in

_Ham

let,_A

ct_I,_Scene_4

.JPG

25.02.2019Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 3


STANDARD


STANDARD

http

s://ww

w.d

esignb

oo

m.co

m/d

esign/d

esign-in

dab

a-20

12

-po

rky-hefer-o

f-anim

al-farm/


How did youdo it?

http

s://de.w

ikiped

ia.org/w

iki/Ham

let#/m

edia/File:D

avid_G

arrick_in

_Ham

let,_A

ct_I,_Scene_4

.JPG


ConceptualLiterature

Existent Standards & Commentary

Expert Interviews




Expert Interviews

Argumentative DiscourseAnalysis

Hajer, 2006 & Nielsen, 2016




Expert Interviews

Argumentative DiscourseAnalysis

Standard/GuidanceTypologies

Hajer, 2006 & Nielsen, 2016


What was the result?

http

s://de.w

ikiped

ia.org/w

iki/Ham

let#/m

edia/File:D

avid_G

arrick_in

_Ham

let,_A

ct_I,_Scene_4

.JPG


Sou

rce:

htt

ps:

//p

ort

als.

iucn

.org

/lib

rary

/sit

es/l

ibra

ry/f

iles/

do

cum

ents

/20

14

-03

0.p

dfSo

urc

e: h

ttp

://w

ww

.bo

nn

chal

len

ge.o

rg/c

on

ten

t/ch

alle

nge


Sou

rce:

htt

ps:

//p

ort

als.

iucn

.org

/lib

rary

/sit

es/l

ibra

ry/f

iles/

do

cum

ents

/20

14

-03

0.p

dfSo

urc

e: h

ttp

://w

ww

.bo

nn

chal

len

ge.o

rg/c

on

ten

t/ch

alle

nge

htt

ps:

//w

ww

.wri

.org

/pu

blic

atio

n/r

esto

rati

on

-dia

gno

stic

Sou

rce: http

s://po

rtals.iucn

.org/lib

rary/sites/library/files/d

ocu

me

nts/2

01

8-0

22

-En.p

df

http://genderandenvironment.org/resource/paving-the-way-for-gender-responsive-flr-enhancing-cultural-identity-livelihoods-and-ecosystems/


http

s://imgflip

.com

/mem

egene

rator/Fu

turam

a-Fry


Based on: Hajer, 2006 & Nielsen, 2016

Storyline:

Problem (agenda

setting)

Solution (policy tool)

Vision (improved

outcome)

Storyline: ‘Business as usual in FLR must be improved or is unsound.’

Problem

Solution

Vision


Storyline: ‘Business as usual in FLR must be improved or is unsound.’

Problem • Unbalanced objectives• (Ab)use of FLR label

Solution • Standards/guidance sound FLR

Vision • Integrity of FLR label• Enhanced FLR quality



Storyline: ‘FLR should remain inclusive and also open to more private and

financial involvement to reach upscaling.’

Problem

Solution

Vision


Storyline: ‘FLR should remain inclusive and also open to more private and

financial involvement to reach upscaling.’

Problem • Exclusion could hamper uptake• Notorious lack of funding

Solution • Inclusive guidance

Vision • Conceptual inclusivity• Increased funding

De

cen

tral

ize

d

vs.

C

en

tral

ize

d a

dm

inis

trat

ion


Global level

Global w/ national

interpretations

Global w/ landscape

interpretations

National level

Landscape level

Forest biome level

De

cen

tral

ize

d

vs.

C

en

tral

ize

d a

dm

inis

trat

ion


Global level

Global w/ national

interpretations

Global w/ landscape

interpretations

National level

Landscape level

Forest biome level

De

cen

tral

ize

d

vs.

C

en

tral

ize

d a

dm

inis

trat

ion


http

s://de.w

ikiped

ia.org/w

iki/Ham

let#/m

edia/File:D

avid_G

arrick_in

_Ham

let,_A

ct_I,_Scene_4

.JPG

Can youmanage

this?


Complementingtypologies



• Principle-basedguidance

• Definition-basedguidance

• Policy integrationstandard






Normative typologies






Normative typologies

• Safeguard type ofguidance

• Qualityguidance/ standard

• Inclusiveguidance


Content-specifictypologies



• Carbon focusedstandard

• Forest certification-based guidance

• Ecological standards

• Conciliatory guidance







Other typologies







Other typologies

• Decentralized guidance

• Non-guidance/ nostandard


http

s://de.w

ikiped

ia.org/w

iki/Ham

let#/med

ia/File:David

_Garrick_

in_H

amlet,_A

ct_I,_Scene_4

.JPG

Download - Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 ......Marcel Starfinger -To guide or not to guide FLR?- FLR 2019 Conference 25.02.2019 22 Storyline: ‘FLR should remain

Top Related