Transcript
  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    1/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 1/12

    Mastery Quiz 1 – 2

    10/14 questions correct

    You haven't passed yet. You need at least 11 questions correct to pass.

    Review the material and try again! You have 1 retake every 8 hours.

    Review Related Lesson (/learn/negotiation/home/week/2)

    1.

    Preamble: This is the first mastery quiz for the course. The questions on this quiz are meant to test whether you have

    watched all the material and understand the concepts presented in Modules 1 – 2. If you are reading this, I hope that

    means you’ve had a chance to look over the questions in advance (provided in the Preview of Mastery Quiz 1 – 2) and

    so you know what to expect.

    Q1. What is the pie?

    The pie is the benefit the negotiating parties could get if they work together.

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/home/week/2https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/home/week/2

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    2/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 2/12

    Well done!

    The pie is the difference between the benefit the negotiating parties could get if they work together and the

    sum of the benefits each party could get on its own.

    The pie is the difference between the benefit one party can get on its own and the benefit the other partycan get on its own.

    3.14159…

    2.

    If Abe and Bea reach an agreement, they can create 12 together. If they don’t, Abe can create 3 on his own and Bea

    can create 1 on her own. What is the pie?

    8

    Well done!

    That’s right. The pie is how much more the two parties can create by working together compared to what they

    can create without an agreement. Therefore the pie is 12 - (3 + 1) = 8.

    3.

    In the above scenario, how much should Abe get?

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    3/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 3/12

    7

    Well done!

    That's right. If Abe and Bea split the pie (8), Abe will get 3 + 4 = 7.

    4.

    Andrea and Beth are dining at a fine restaurant. There is a bottle of 2009 Grgich Hills Chardonnay on the menu and

    the price is $100. To keep things simple, albeit unrealistic, assume the restaurant only sells whole bottles and this is

    the only wine they carry.

    Andrea would be willing to pay $110 to drink the whole bottle.

    Andrea would be willing to pay $90 to drink half the bottle.

    Beth would be willing to pay $80 to drink the whole bottle.

    Beth would be willing to pay $50 to drink half the bottle.

    They would like to share a bottle if it makes sense to do so (and if they can agree on how to divide the costs). To see if 

    it makes sense, what is the pie, in dollars?

    40

    Sorry, that’s not what we’re looking for.

    This is a challenging question. Remember the pie is how much more the two parties can create by working

    together compared to what they can create without an agreement. If they don’t reach an agreement, what

    would Andrea do on her own? What would Beth do on her own? If they do reach an agreement how much

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    4/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 4/12

    value do they create? How much more  value do they create together compared to the result with no

    agreement?

    If you are still stuck, you might want to review the Sea Corp. video.

    Acceptable responses

    $30

    If they don’t reach an agreement, Andrea will get $10 and Beth will get nothing. If they do reach an agreement,

    they will jointly have created $40 of surplus ($90 + $50 – $100). Thus the pie is $30.

    30

    If they don’t reach an agreement, Andrea will get $10 and Beth will get nothing. If they do reach an agreement,

    they will jointly have created $40 of surplus ($90 + $50 – $100). Thus the pie is $30.

    5.

    In the question above, how much should Andrea pay, in dollars, if they split the pie?

    70

    Sorry, that’s not what we’re looking for.

    Andrea needs Beth just as much as Beth needs Andrea to do this deal, so they should split the pie. If you’ve

    calculated the pie correctly, then both Andrea’s and Beth’s gain from sharing the bottle will be half the pie. For

    Beth, that means she pays that amount less than her value of the bottle. But that’s not quite the case for

    Andrea.

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    5/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 5/12

    A common mistake here is to leave out the gain Andrea can get on her own. Remember that if they don’t

    reach an agreement, Andrea will still buy a bottle of wine and get some surplus. Thus Andrea has to do even

    better than that as a result of the agreement.

    Acceptable responses

    $65

    If they split it evenly, each side will end up with $15 of the pie. Thus Beth pays $50 – $15 = $35 and Andrea

    pays $90 – ($15 + $10) = $65. Note Andrea starts with the $10 of value that she can create on her own.

    65

    If they split it evenly, each side will end up with $15 of the pie. Thus Beth pays $50 – $15 = $35 and Andrea

    pays $90 – ($15 + $10) = $65. Note Andrea starts with the $10 of value that she can create on her own.

    6.

    Recall that if Aegean and Baltic share the cost of a new software program, Aegean will benefit $100 while Baltic

    benefits $200. If the software costs $100 total, how much should Aegean pay, in dollars?

    50

    Well done!

    If the software costs $100, the net benefit they would receive together is $200. If they work on their own,

    Aegean will not buy the software since the cost ($100) cancels out its benefit ($100). Baltic will buy the

    software for a net benefit of $200 - $100 = $100. Therefore the pie, or the difference between working

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    6/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 6/12

    together and working separately, is $200 - $100 = $100. The pie should be divided equally: $50/$50. Aegean

    and Baltic will each pay $50. Here it is in tabular form:

    Aegean Baltic Total

    Net Benefit: Together ------- ------ 200

    Net Benefit: On Their Own 0 100 100

    Pie ------- ------ 100

    Total benefit each side gets when they split the pie 50 150 200

    How much each pays 50 50 200

    Show other acceptable response

    7.

    What is the Shapley Value?

    Well done!

    Well done.

    For each party in the group, it is the amount of pie created by that party joining others in the group,

    averaged across all possible orderings in which parties join the group.

    For each party in the group, it is half of the amount of pie created by that party joining others in the group,

    averaged across all possible orderings in which parties join the group.

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    7/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 7/12

    For each party in the group, it is the maximum portion of the pie created by that party joining the group,

    across all possible orderings in which parties join the group.

    8.

    In the Planet–Gazette merger, the Gazette was twice as big as the Planet. If the Planet were the same size as the

    Gazette, how much more of the pie would you expect the Planet to get?

    Well done!

    The pie gets split in half, not because the Planet and Gazette are equal in size, but because the cooperation of 

    both parties is needed to complete the merger and create the pie.

    No more

    50% more

    100% more

    9.

    Recall in the Planet–Gazette merger case, the increased productivity from the Gazette’s know-how was worth $1

    million to the Planet. Imagine the Planet could hire a consultant to improve its productivity up to the same level as the

    Gazette. The cost of the consultant would be $200,000. Of course, with the merger, there is no need for the

    consultant. When the Planet has the ability to hire a consultant, how much more money should the Planet get in the

    merger?

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    8/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 8/12

    Sorry, that's incorrect.

    The possibility of hiring the consultant changes the benefit that the Planet can achieve on its own without the

    help of the Gazette. What is the new pie and what is the Planet's new starting position?

    The same amount as before

    $200,000 more

    $300,000 more

    $400,000 more

    $500,000 more

    10.

    Consider a potential merger between two hypothetical beer companies. Prior to the merger, the first, Ann Hy, is worth

    $150 billion and the second, Czar Bosch, is worth $100 billion. If they merge, they will gain $30 billion in increased

    value from reduced costs and additional sales (in present discounted value). Thus the combined value of the new

    entity (called Ann Hy-Czar Bosch) would be $280 billion. How much more could Czar Bosch hope to get by using the

    theory of the pie instead of proportional division?

    0

    $1.3 billion

    $3 billion

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    9/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 9/12

    Sorry, that's incorrect.

    First, what is the pie? How much would Czar Bosch get under proportional division? Hint: Proportional division

    is based on the pre-merger numbers, and $100b / ($100b + $150b) = 40%. How much more does Czar Bosch

    get if they split the pie evenly instead of using proportional division?

    $5 billion

    $10 billion

    $10.7 billion

    11.

    Consider an Ultimatum Game where the pie is $100. You are the receiver. What reserve price, in dollars, maximizes

    your expected payout?

    0

    Well done!

    Your reserve price doesn’t change what the other side will offer. Thus anything you turn down is like throwing

    money away. You may choose to do so out of spite or to enforce a social norm, but doing so will lower your

    expected payout.

    Show other acceptable responses

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    10/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 10/12

    12.

    In an Ultimatum Game where the pie is $100, would you rather be:

    Well done!

    Remember the old adage: It is better to give than to receive. You would rather be the one making the offer

    since that person should get more than half of the pie. The advantage of being the one receiving the offer is

    you can guarantee yourself some money by saying yes to everything.

    the person making the offer

    the person receiving the offer

    13.

    You should propose proportional division if it benefits you.

    Well done!

    If a proportional split leads you to get more than half the pie and the other side is willing to agree, then goahead.

    Yes

    No

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    11/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 11/12

    14.

    Abe and Bea each have some money to invest in a CD (Certificate of Deposit). Abe has $5,000 and Bea has $20,000.

    Both are interested in making a 6-month investment at Synchrony Bank. The CD rates for Synchrony Bank (as of July 8,

    2015) are as listed below.

    With 0.41% interest, Abe would get $5,010 in six months. With 0.50% interest, Bea would get $20,050 at the end of six

    months.

    If they pool their funds, they will be able to purchase a $25,000 CD, which pays a higher interest rate. The 0.60%

    interest will return $25,075 at the end of six months.

  • 8/16/2019 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 _ Coursera

    12/12

    12/8/2015 Mastery Quiz 1 – 2 | Coursera

    https://www.coursera.org/learn/negotiation/exam/XzOmj/mastery-quiz-1-2 12/12

    Obviously, Abe gets back his $5,000 principle, and Bea gets back her $20,000 principle. How should the $75 interest be

    divided between the two of them?

    Well done!

    If they don’t pool their funds, then Abe will only earn $10 of interest and Bea will earn $50. By coming

    together, they can earn $75, which is an extra $15 of interest. The two should spit this evenly, $7.50 and $7.50.

    Thus Abe would get $17.50 and Bea would get $57.50.

    Note that this increases Abe’s effective interest rate from 0.41% to 0.7%, which is more than what Bea is

    getting. The reason is that Bea is not able to increase her payout from 0.50% to 0.60% without Abe’s

    cooperation. Were Bea able to find someone else with $5,000 to invest with her, then she would likely get

    much more of the gain.

    Divide up the interest according to the amount invested. Since Bea has 80% of the funds, she should get

    80% of the interest, or $60 in total. This is the same as both parties getting 0.60% interest on their funds.

    Divide the interest in two, so each gets $37.50.

    Abe gets $17.50 and Bea gets $57.50.


Top Related