1
Chapter 15: Passive and Rental Activities
Page 229-254
15: Passive and Rental Activities
Upon completion of this seminar, participants should be able to—
Learning Objectives
2
• Define passive and rental activities and related carryovers and dispositions.
• Determine the impact of the 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT).
• Determine when to use elections for grouping activities and real estate professionals.
• Apply rules for passive and rental activities for self-charged interest income and mixed use property.
Page 229-254
15: Passive and Rental Activities
3
Key Developments
• Several court cases regarding significant participation. Page 234– TC Memo 2015-240, Leland– TC Memo 2015-59, Lamas
• TC Summ. Op. 2017-1, Makhlouf, worksheets provided were not supported by contemporaneous records. Page 235
• TC Memo 2017-65, Penley, Court finds “contemporaneous” records of taxpayer not trustworthy. Page 238
• TC Summary Op. 2016-23, Moon, able to prove compliance with rental professional tests. Page 239
Page 229-254
15: Passive and Rental Activities
4
Key Developments
• CA 9th 08/04/2016, 118 AFTR, 2d, ¶ 2016-5091, Gragg, failed to prove material participation. Page 239
• TC Memo 2017-68, Windham, failed some issues for real estate professional election, but proved activity hours, court found for taxpayer. Page 241
Page 229-254
15: Passive and Rental Activities
I. What’s New
There has been a significant amount of court activity to settle issues associated with IRC 469
Page 229
15: Passive and Rental Activities5
II. Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT)Related to Passive Activity
B. The final regulations attempt to take some of the confusion from what is and is not a trade or business activity subject to the NIIT.
Page 229
15: Passive and Rental Activities6
II. Net Investment Income Tax (NIIT)Related to Passive Activity
The Good the Bad and the Ugly
D. Recognized passive losses will reduce AGI and reduce exposure to tax.
E. Taxpayers with suspended losses should consider getting rid of portfolio income and look for a PIG (passive income generator).
Page 229
Image courtesy of imdb.com
15: Passive and Rental Activities7
III. Conceptual Framework
The Passive Activity Loss laws/rules were a creation of the Reagan Tax Reform in 1986 with the intended purpose of discouraging a taxpayer from purchasing loss activities to offset gain activities.The Bucket/BasketPassivePortfolioNon-passive Income
Page 230
15: Passive and Rental Activities8
III. Conceptual Framework
D. The two types of passive activities:
1. An activity that involves the conduct of ANY trade or business in which the taxpayer does not materially participate or
2. ANY RENTAL ACTIVITY unless one of the exceptions apply
Page 230
15: Passive and Rental Activities9
IV. Flowchart for Passive ActivityDecisions
Page 231
V. Rental Exception Test – Page 232
VI. Material Participation Test – Page 233
VII. Active Participation Test (Rental Loss) –Page 236
VIII.Self Rental Tests –Page 237
15: Passive and Rental Activities10
V. Rental Exception Test
The exceptions:1. Average use per rental 7 days or less2. Average use per rental 30 days or less AND
significant personal services are provided3. Extraordinary personal services are provided
by the owner of the property. – See court case4. Rental of property is incidental to its activity,
i.e. gross rental below 2% of basis or FMV –See example at bottom of page
Page 232
15: Passive and Rental Activities11
Page 233
The exceptions:5. Property made available to customers in
normal course of business6. Self rental property – The taxpayer has an
interest in property rented to “themselves”.
V. Rental Exception Test
15: Passive and Rental Activities12
VI. Material Participation
The seven tests of material participation(Reg. §1.469-5T(a)) :1. More than 500 hours2. Participation is substantially ALL for activity3. More than 100 hours and no-one participates
more (including non-owners)4. Activity is a significant participation activity
and total for taxpayer in all such activities is greater than 500
Page 233-234
15: Passive and Rental Activities13
VI. Material Participation
The seven tests of material participation(Reg. §1.469-5T(a)) :5. Material participation in any five tax years of
ten6. Activity is a personal service activity and
taxpayer materially participated in any three years.
7. Facts and circumstances – Taxpayer participates on a regular, continuous, and substantial basis (Must be greater than 100 hours)
Page 234
15: Passive and Rental Activities14
VI. Material Participation
Test 3. - All participants are less than 500 AND no one participates more than anyone else AND the participation level is greater than 100 hours
Page 234
15: Passive and Rental Activities15
VI. Material Participation
Test 3. - All participants are less than 500 AND no one participates more than anyone else AND the participation level is greater than 100 hours, the biggest wins
Page 234
15: Passive and Rental Activities16
VI. Material Participation
Test 4. - Participates in all activities greater than 100 hours but none more than 500 hours. The activities will be aggregated to determine if the taxpayer meets the 500 hour rule.
Page 234
15: Passive and Rental Activities17
VI. Material Participation
B. IRS wants the taxpayer to substantiate their material participation, but how?
While contemporaneous records will establish participation they are not required, other reasonable means can be used:Appointment BooksCalendarsNarrative Summaries (BUT)
Page 235
15: Passive and Rental Activities18
VI. Material Participation
What happens if it is close – Get ready as IRS will bring out the big guns.
Page 235
15: Passive and Rental Activities19
IV. Material ParticipationPage 235-Bonus
Taxpayer beats the “oral testimony” problem of IRC 469In Stefan A Tolin, TC Memo 2014-65 IRS argued the nature of the involvement of the taxpayer in the activity using IRC 469The taxpayer successfully rebutted IRS’s arguments with oral testimony of employees, associates, and others involved in like activitieshaving an association with the taxpayer.
15: Passive and Rental Activities20
VI. Material Participation
Good News – Spouses can aggregate each other’s time for purposes of complying with the material participation standards – BUT work done must be that normally performed by a business owner.
Page 235
15: Passive and Rental Activities21
VII. Active Participation Test(Rental Loss)
B. The $25,000 of ACTIVE RENTAL LOSSES specially allowed to qualifying (active participant) taxpayers does not change the rental activity to non-passive.
100% of allowance $0 - $100,000Reduced by 50¢ for each $1 of excess income so is ZERO when taxpayer has income of $150,000
Page 236
15: Passive and Rental Activities22
Page 236
D. Meeting the active participation standard for rental property for the $25,000 allowance
Not a test of time – An issue of bona-fide management, owner must exercise “independent judgment” and not simply ratify the acts of the management company.
15: Passive and Rental Activities23
VII. Active Participation Test(Rental Loss)
VIII. Self-Rental Tests (Recharacterizations)
Bottom Line of Rule
If loss it is passiveIf gain it is non-passive
Applies when Taxpayer actively participates with the activity (employees too) OR has ownership interest in activity
Page 237
15: Passive and Rental Activities24
VIII. Self-Rental Tests (Recharacterizations)
When a taxpayer has self rental income subject to recharacterization whether by design or as an operation of the activity heads IRS wins and tails the taxpayer loses.
Page 237
15: Passive and Rental Activities25
VIII. Self-Rental Tests (Recharacterizations)
Applies to ALL tangible property including personal property, any flow thru retains nature as self-rental
Page 237
15: Passive and Rental Activities26
VIII. Self-Rental Tests (Recharacterizations)
Self Rental Income CANNOT touch rental losses, different buckets
Page 238
15: Passive and Rental Activities27
VIII. Self-Rental Tests (Recharacterizations)
The allocationOwner occupied 10,000 sq. ft. building that is self used (i.e. subject to Self Rental Recharacterization rules) in the amount of 4,500 square feet.
Net rental income for building $10,000Non-Passive $ 4,500Passive $ 5,500
Page 238-Bonus
15: Passive and Rental Activities28
VIII. Self-Rental Tests (Recharacterizations)
Estate of Stuller, (CA 01/26/2016) 117 AFTR 2d ¶ 2016-379
In an unusual case the court found that a corporation was:
Operating a hobby businessRenting the building from the shareholder Shareholder was subject to taxation on the non-deductible rent payments.
Page 238-Bonus
15: Passive and Rental Activities29
30
The IRS is concerned about abuse of status as a Real Estate Professional
To qualify as a real estate professional a taxpayer must:By a show of hands:A. Spend at least 50% of their time in real estate
activity.B. Must spend at least 750 hours annually in real
estate activities.C.Must comply with the material participation
requirements for each individual or grouped property.
D.A, B, and C. 15: Passive and Rental Activities
IX. Real Estate Professionals
To be a real estate professional you must:1. Spend more than 50% of your time in trade AND2. That 50% is greater than or equal to 750 hours.
Page 238
15: Passive and Rental Activities31
IX. Real Estate Professionals
The court found the log not reliable that indicated the taxpayer worked 12.88 hours per day
Page 238
15: Passive and Rental Activities32
IX. Real Estate ProfessionalsAirline Pilot and his spouse claimed to be real estate professionals. The taxpayers produced extensive detailed recordsindicating the activities of the taxpayers, but primarily those of Mrs. Moon. Result – Mrs. Moon did more work than anyone else, worked more than 750 hours in real estate, and more than 50% of her activities were in real estate.
Page 239
15: Passive and Rental Activities33
IX. Real Estate ProfessionalsQuestion before the Court, did the law require that the taxpayer to deduct losses meet the material participation tests:The Court Said – While the taxpayers did qualify as real estate professionals they failed to establish that they were in fact material to the losses in question.
Page 239
15: Passive and Rental Activities34
IX. Real Estate Professionals
Be cautious of the traps: The IRS Audit Guide for Passive Activities says:
Page 239
15: Passive and Rental Activities35
It only takes one on a joint return, does not apply when filing MFS, each spouse stands on their own.
Page 240
15: Passive and Rental Activities36
IX. Real Estate Professionals
C. A taxpayer with several rental activities can make a grouping election making multiple rentals easier to qualify as actively participatory BUT
Page 240
15: Passive and Rental Activities37
IX. Real Estate Professionals
A taxpayer who failed to make the election and qualified: Was still a real estate professional, BUT No grouping election means, each property had
to qualify.
Page 241
15: Passive and Rental Activities38
IX. Real Estate Professionals
X. Grouping Activities
The good, the bad and the ugly of separate versus grouping.
Put two activities together and material participation is required only for the whole.
But grouped activities will require the disposition of ALL activities before suspended losses are released.
Page 243
15: Passive and Rental Activities39
X. Grouping Activities
What are the standards of activity grouping?In most instances an issue of facts and circumstances but factors given most weight:
a. Similarities and differences of activityb. Extent of common controlc. Geographic locationd. Interdependencies of business with each other
Page 243
15: Passive and Rental Activities40
X. Grouping Activities
The grouping of activities requires a disclosure on the initial grouping made. This requirement was effective for tax years beginning after 01/25/2010.
See the Windham case, Page 241, grouping elections must be made.
Page 243
15: Passive and Rental Activities41
X. Grouping Activities
C. What cannot be grouped?
Mixing is not allowed –Real property and personal property cannot be grouped unless they are substantial in relationship to each other.
Page 244
15: Passive and Rental Activities42
X. Grouping Activities
Disclosure and Consistency RequirementOnce grouped an activity must remained grouped unless: The grouping was inappropriate There is a material change The commissioner says so
In the event the taxpayer makes a determination that a grouping must be “fixed” disclosure must be made with the return
Page 245
15: Passive and Rental Activities43
XI. Suspended Losses and Dispositions
If PALs are suspended on the current year return they are carried forward until:1. There is a net passive income
2. The taxpayer is eligible for the $25,000 (or portion of) loss allowance.
3. The activity is disposed of.
Page 246
15: Passive and Rental Activities44
XI. Suspended Losses and Dispositions
Losses can be freed up when:
There is a LTCG from the disposition of a passive activity.
There is a “complete” disposition of the activity that has an accumulated loss.
Page 246
15: Passive and Rental Activities45
XII. Self-Charged Interest Income
When a taxpayer has loaned monies to a pass-thru entity that passes through passive income the interest income will be deemed to be passive income versus portfolio income.
Page 248
15: Passive and Rental Activities46
XII. Self-Charged Interest Income
How does it work?Will be allocated their relative share of the interest payments as passive subject to limit.
Page 249
15: Passive and Rental Activities47
XIII. Mixed Use Property andRenting Part of the Home
A dwelling is a home (at least partly) if the taxpayer uses the home either:
More than 14 days
Or
More than 10% of the rental use
WHICHEVER IS GREATER
Page 250
15: Passive and Rental Activities50
XIII. Mixed Use Property andRenting Part of the Home
There is such as thing as tax-free incomeRent your home OR vacation home for less than 15 days and do not report the income AirBNBs are subject to same reporting rules
Page 251
15: Passive and Rental Activities51
XIII. Mixed Use Property andRenting Part of the Home
Page 253
The primary issue with vacation rentals is the 7 day or less issue – i.e. no $25,000 rental exception – Materialparticipation versus Activeparticipation
15: Passive and Rental Activities52
Page 253
XIII. Mixed Use Property andRenting Part of the Home
Mixed Use – When a taxpayer has an individual who has a bedroom and shares the balance of the home AND there is NO separate entrance for tenant space.
Issue – Property will be treated as vacation home rental – Operating expenses and depreciation cannot create a loss, these expenses will be carried forward until consumed OR property disposed of.
15: Passive and Rental Activities53
Page 253
XIII. Mixed Use Property andRenting Part of the Home
So the renting out part of your home:
Expenses are allocated to the “business use only” areas. Any areas used by the owner are considered personal use.
15: Passive and Rental Activities54
Page 254
XIII. Mixed Use Property andRenting Part of the Home
15: Passive and Rental Activities55