Transcript
Page 1: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

!!!!! "#$ %&'$( "& )*+ ,$&,(-%#*.-/ 0.-/$0 *1"& 0"-2*/*3$4 "$((*"&(*-/ )(-5$'&(60 .-1 0$(7$1&" &1/8 -0 - "&&/ &) 4*0$5%&'$(5$1"9 $+./:0*&19 -14 4&5*1-"*&1 2:" -/0& -0 - 5$-10"& .&10"(:." $5%&'$(*1,9 *1./:0*7$9 -14 $7$1 $5-1.*%-"&(8 .&:1"$(,$&,(-%#*$0!;;

<($11$( =>??@9 %-,$ AB?C

!!D$&E/*2$(-/*05 *0 1&'9 -14 $7$( '-09 "#$ %&/*"*.0 &) "#$ .(*0*0!;;F*.6$// -14 G$.6 =>??H9 %-,$ IBJC

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`@J 5*//*&1 *1 *1)(-0"(:.E":($ -14 0$(7*.$09 -14 0"&&4 "& ($-% ST `>!M 2*//*&1 &7$( "$1 8$-(0! F#$($ '-0 1&$))$."*7$ 4$5-14 )&( "#$ '-"$( *1 "#$ %&&( -14 0%-(0$/8 %&%:/-"$4 0&:"#$(1 O/"*%/-1&9'#$($-0 "#$ 5*1$0 *1 R#*/$;0 %-(.#$4 1&("#$(1 4$0$(" #-4 2&"# "#$ 4$5-14 )&( "#$'-"$( -14 "#$ .-%*"-/ ($N:*($4 "& $+"(-." *" )(&5 *"0 -N:*)$(! F#$ 0"-"$ '&:/4 ,-*1($0&:(.$ ($1"09 -14 X.Y-(($1 '&:/4 %(&7*4$ ):140 )&( Q/&.-/ 4$7$/&%5$1"; =-5&:1"*1,"& -2&:" ST`AJJ %$( .&55:1*"8C! L%%&1$1"0 &) "#$ %/-1 '$($ *1*"*-//8 4*05*00$4 -0(-4*.-/0_ QQF#*0 28 -// 5$-10 #-0 "& #-%%$1;;9 -00$("$4 ]&.- O7*/-9 QQ<&/*7*- 1$$40 5&1$8

!"#"$ %$&"%'("'%)*+ #*, "-$ &(#.$ /0.)")(& 01 %'%#. 2#"$%+03$%*#*($ )* 40.)3)#

5-06#& 7$%%$#'."W$%-("5$1" &) a$&,(-%#89 T8(-.:0$ S1*7$(0*"89 T8(-.:0$9 Db >IMAAE>JMJ9 STOc$E5-*/_ "-%$(($-d5-+'$//!08(!$4:]$.$*7$4 M? P:/8 MJJIc *1 ($7*0$4 )&(5 M> P-1:-(8 MJJA

()*+$,)-#). %)& /'%))+)! 0 MJJH9 7&/:5$ IB9 %-,$0 MeI f M@A

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

!"#$%&'%&()*+,(%))

Page 2: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

-14 "#&0$ '#& &%%&0$ "#*0 -($ F(&"068*"$0;; =R#-V 7$39 MJJM9 %-,$ >9 "(-10/-"*&1 5*1$C! K1"#$ $149 #&'$7$(9 "#$ %/-1 "& $+%&(" 0:20:()-.$ '-"$( -""(-."$4 &%%&0*"*&1 )(&5 -2(&-4 (-1,$ &) 0&.*-/ ,(&:%0! \17*(&15$1"-/*0"0 '$($ .&1.$(1$4 -2&:" "#$ $))$."0&) '*"#4(-'-/0 &1 ($,*&1-/ '-"$( "-2/$09 -14 %-("*.:/-(/8 &1 g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h*4$0%($-4 %(&"$0" )&(.$4 "#$ ,&7$(15$1" "& '*"#4(-' *"0 0:%%&(" )&(X.Y-(($1;0 %/-19 -14 $7$1":-//8 *" #-/"$4 "#$ %(&i$."9 -" /$-0" "$5%&(-(*/8 =12# (3,),-+4.MJJMC! G(&i$."0 &) "#*0 0&(" #-7$ - '-8 &) ($0:()-.*1,9 #&'$7$(9 -14 W$.($"& T:%($5& MMeB9

& -&& ./012

& -&& 3.

!14+56.176 7+.1

!14+56.176 8+4/6+0

!14+56.176 9:;7<+5=

#76157+6/:7+0 9:;7<+5=

>/?15

/)0'$1 2. X-% &) <&/*7*-!

MeA F G$(($-:/"

Page 3: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

"#$ %($0*4$1"*-/ 4$.($$ "#-" '-0 "& -//&' "#$ $+%&(" &) '-"$( )(&5 G&"&0UV 9 5-8 8$" #-7$ *"04-8 =R#-V 7$39 MJJIC!

]$.$1" -""$5%"0 "& .&55$(.*-/*3$ '-"$( *1 <&/*7*- (-*0$ 0$7$(-/ N:$0"*&10 -2&:""#$ '-8 "#-" ($0&:(.$0 -($ ,&7$(1$49 -14 4$.*0*&10 -2&:" $17*(&15$1"0 "-6$19 *1 "#$.&1"$+" &) "#$ 0"-"$;0 ($.$1" 1$&/*2$(-/ ($0"(:.":(*1,! K1 '#&0$ *1"$($0" -($ ($0&:(.$0 "&2$ 5-1-,$4j <8 '#-" .(*"$(*- -($ 0:.# 4$.*0*&10 5-4$j K1 '#-" '-80 *0 ($0&:(.$5-1-,$5$1" *1)/:$1.$4 28 "#$ ($0.-/*1, &) "#$ <&/*7*-1 0"-"$j O($ 1$' )&(50 -140.-/$0 &) 0&.*-/ -14 %&/*"*.-/ &(,-1*3-"*&1 $5$(,*1, "& 0$.:($ -..$00 "& -14 "& 5-1-,$1-":(-/ ($0&:(.$0j F#*0 %-%$( -44($00$0 "#$0$ *00:$0 "#(&:,# -1 $+-5*1-"*&1 &) $17*E(&15$1"-/ ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- *1 "#$ .&1"$+" &) 1$&/*2$(-/ 0"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1,! K1%-("*.:/-(9 K -5 .&1.$(1$4 '*"# (:(-/ '-"$( :0$k%(*1.*%-//8 *((*,-"*&1k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i:5% 0.-/$0; *1 &(4$( "& .&:1"$(%(&.$00$0 &) 0"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1,!

31%4)+1$-4 $15%$6 -"& 1"7)$%"61"#-4 0%71$"-"(1 )" 8-#)" *61$)(-W:(*1, "#$ %-0" "#($$ 4$.-4$09 ,&7$(15$1"0 "#(&:,#&:" g-"*1 O5$(*.- #-7$ *5%/$E5$1"$4 %&/*.*$0 -..&(4*1, "& "#$ 0&E.-//$4 Qh-0#*1,"&1 .&10$10:09; '*"# "#$ ,&-/0 &)($0"(:.":(*1, 0"-"$ -14 5-(6$" *10"*":"*&10 -14 ($.&1)*,:(*1, "#$ ($/-"*&10 -14 ($0%&1E0*2*/*"*$0 &) "#$0$ *10"*":"*&10 7*0E-l E7*0 .*7*/ 0&.*$"8 =Z$(0#2$(,9 MJJIc P$00&%9 >??JC! O0*1 "#$ .-0$ &) "#$ Q0"(:.":(-/ -4i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eJ09-14 >?BJ09 '$($ "& 2$ 0:%%/-1"$4 28 "(*55$4E4&'1 0"-"$0 '#&0$ 5*00*&1 '&:/4 2$ "&)-.*/*"-"$ "#$ Q/&,*. &) "#$ 5-(6$"; =W$55$(0 $" -/9 MJJ>C! h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g- G-39 P-1:-(8 MJJIC! \))*.*$1" -//&.-"*&1 &) ($0&:(.$0 *0 "& 2$ -00:($4"#(&:,# - .&52*1-"*&1 &) 4$.$1"(-/*3$4 5-1-,$5$1" -14 =.$1"(-/*3$4C /*2$(-/ ($)&(509&7$(0$$1 28 - 1$'/8 5-(6$"E)(*$14/8 0"-"$ =m$2-//&0 Z:("-4& -14 n:*(&,- R($0%&9MJJIC! K14$$49 "& - /-(,$ $+"$1"9 "#*0 *0 %($.*0$/8 '#-" ($)&(5 -.#*$7$4 *1 <&/*7*-9 -0'*// 2$ 4*0.:00$4 2$/&'!

K" 5:0" 2$ 1&"$49 #&'$7$(9 "#-" "#$ &:".&5$0 &) 1$&/*2$(-/ ($)&(50 #-7$ (-($/85-".#$4 %&/*.8 &2i$."*7$09 -14 #-7$ )($N:$1"/8 5$" '*"# 0"-:1.# ($0*0"-1.$ )(&5 -1

T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14 "#$ 0.-/$ %&/*"*.0 &) (:(-/ '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- MeH

Page 4: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

-((-8 &) 0&.*-/ 0$."&(0! O""$5%"0 "& %(*7-"*3$ 1-":(-/ ($0&:(.$0 #-7$ *1 5-18 .-0$0)-*/$4 &:"(*,#"9 -0 "#$ .-0$ &) <$.#"$/;0 4$2-./$ *1 R&.#-2-52- -5%/8 4$5&10"(-"$0!X&($&7$(9 *" 5:0" 2$ ($.&,1*3$4 "#-" ($0&:(.$ /-'0 -14 %&/*.*$0 -($ "#$50$/7$0 0:2i$.""& .&1"$0"-"*&1 -14 5-8 .&1"-*1 *1"$(1-/ .&1"(-4*."*&10 "#-" ($)/$." %(&.$00$0 &)1$,&"*-"*&1 2$"'$$1 .&5%$"*1, *1"$($0"0 =<(*4,$ -14 X.X-1:09 MJJJc L($//-1-9>???C! O0 4*0.:00$4 2$/&'9 <&/*7*-1 '-"$( /-' %(&7*4$0 -1 $+.$//$1" $+-5%/$ &) "#*09-0 ($.&,1*"*&1 &) (*,#"0 -14 4$)*1*"*&10 &) -:"#&(*"8 -($ 2:(4$1$4 28 .&1"(-4*."*&1 -14/-.6 &) ./-(*"8 =<:0"-5-1"$9 MJJMC! K" *0 *5%$(-"*7$9 "#$($)&($9 "& ,:-(4 -,-*10" %($E0:5$4 .&1,(:$1.$ 2$"'$$1 1$&/*2$(-/ /&,*.9 "#$ ,&-/0 &) 0%$.*)*. %&/*.*$0 $1-."$4-..&(4*1, "& "#-" /&,*.9 -14 "#$ &:".&5$0 &) "#&0$ %&/*.*$0 &1.$ *5%/$5$1"$4!

K" 0.-(.$/8 2$-(0 5$1"*&19 5&($&7$(9 "#-" "#$ .&#$($1.$ &) "#$ 1$&/*2$(-/ %(&i$."5:0" 1$7$( 2$ -00:5$4! F#&:,# 1$&/*2$(-/ %&/*.*$0 "#$ '&(/4 &7$( 0#-($ -1 :14$(/8*1,/&,*.9 "#$8 -($ 0#&" "#(&:,# '*"# .&1"(-4*."*&1 -14 *1.&10*0"$1.8 "#-" ($)/$." "#$0"(:,,/$0 *17&/7$4 *1 4$0*,1*1,9 *5%/$5$1"*1,9 -14 ($0*0"*1, "#$5! F#:09 -0 "#$ <&/*7*-1.-0$ 4$5&10"(-"$09 ($0.-/*1, 0#&:/4 1&" 2$ 7*$'$4 -0 - #&5&,$1$&:09 5&1&/*"#*.%(&.$00 ($4:.*2/$ "& "#$ ):1."*&1-/*0" 1$$40 &) .-%*"-/9 2:" (-"#$( -0 #*,#/8 .&1"$0"$4-14 .&5%(&5*0$49 '*"# .&10*4$(-2/$ *10"*":"*&1-/ -14 ,$&,(-%#*. 7-(*-2*/*"8 =a/-005-19>???c Z-:,#"&19 MJJMC! O" - ,/&2-/ 0.-/$9 '$ 5-8 ($.&,1*3$ "#$ 7-/*4*"8 &) \(*6T'81,$4&:';0 =MJJJC -00$("*&1 "#-" "#$ /$,*"*5-"*1, 4*0.&:(0$0 &) 1$&/*2$(-/ ,/&2-/E*3-"*&19 &) '#*.# "#$ *4$&/&,*$0 &) 0"(:.":(-/ -4i:0"5$1" -($ - %-("9 )&(5 - %$(1*.*&:05#)4#6 # ")+.%+$# "#-" .&5%/*.-"$0 .&:1"$(#$,$5&1*. 5&7$5$1"0! a*7$1 #*0"&(*.-/ 0"(:.E":(-/ 4$%$14$1.*$0 &) g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ec T/-"$(9 >?@?C! T:.# *0 "#$ .-0$ *1 <&/*7*-9'#$($ .*7*/ 0&.*$"8 &(,-1*3-"*&10 -14 ,(-00(&&"0 5&7$5$1"0 #-7$ 7*,&(&:0/8 ($0*0"$4($0&:(.$ %(*7-"*3-"*&1 -14 #-7$ 0:..$00)://8 /*5*"$49 -14 *1 0&5$ .-0$0 ($7$(0$491$&/*2$(-/ ($)&(50! F#:09 - )&.:0 &1 0&.*-/ 5&7$5$1"0 -14 "#$*( 0"(:,,/$0 &7$( $17*(&1E5$1"0 -14 ($0&:(.$0 .-1 #$/% *//:5*1-"$ "#$ '-80 "#-" $17*(&15$1"-/ ,&7$(1-1.$ *0($0#-%$4 *1 "#$ .&1"$+" &)9 "#&:,# 1&" 1$.$00-(*/8 -..&(4*1, "&9 1$&/*2$(-/ *4$&/&,*$0!

D$&/*2$(-/ ($)&(5 #-0 2$$1 .#-(-."$(*3$49 *1 g-"*1 O5$(*.- -14 $/0$'#$($9 28- %(&1&:1.$4 =($C*1"$(1-"*&1-/*3-"*&1 &) "#$ 0"-"$9 (&&"$4 *1 "#$ )&(5-"*&1 &) "(-10E1-"*&1-/ ./-00 -//*-1.$0 -5&1, $/*"$0 '#&0$ *1"$($0"0 .&17$(,$ :%&1 "#$ 5-+*5*3-"*&1&) *1"$(1-"*&1-/ *17$0"5$1"9 *(($0%$."*7$ &) "#$*( 1-"*&1-/ &(*,*1 =a/-005-19 >???C!F#&:,# g-"*1 O5$(*.-1 $.&1&5*$0 #-7$ 2$$19 "& 7-(8*1, 4$,($$09 "*$4 "& *1"$(1-E"*&1-/ .*(.:*"0 &) "(-4$ -14 -..:5:/-"*&1 )&( &7$( HJJ 8$-(0k-14 "#*0 *0 %-("*.:/-(/8"(:$ &) 1-":(-/ ($0&:(.$ 0$."&(0k"#$($ #-0 *1 ($.$1" 8$-(0 2$$1 - ($&(*$1"-"*&1 &)$.&1&5*. 4$7$/&%5$1" "&'-(4 "#$ )&0"$(*1, &) "(-101-"*&1-/ *17$0"5$1" -14 $+%&("02-0$4 &1 "#$ %(*1.*%/$ &) Q.&5%-(-"*7$ -47-1"-,$;! K1 "#*0 .&1"$+"9 "#$ .&(%&(-"*0"0&.*-/ 0"(:.":($0 -14 *5%&("E0:20"*":"*&1 %&/*.*$0 )&0"$($4 4:(*1, "#$ %&0"Eh&(/4h-( M $(- &) 0"-"$E/$4 1-"*&1-/ 4$7$/&%5$1" #-7$ 2$$1 /-(,$/8 4*05-1"/$4 =W$55$(0$" -/9 MJJ>C! F#$ *1"$(1-"*&1-/*3-"*&1 -14 -00&.*-"$4 ($0"(:.":(*1, &) 0"-"$0 #-7$ 2(&:,#"-2&:" "#$*( ($"$((*"&(*-/*3-"*&1 &1 2&"# 0:21-"*&1-/ -14 0:%(-1-"*&1-/ 0.-/$09 *17&/7*1, "#$&(*$1"-"*&1 &) $.&1&5*. %&/*.8 "&'-(4 "#$ *1"$($0"0 &) ($,*&1-/ "(-4$ -,($$5$1"0 -14"(-101-"*&1-/ *10"*":"*&10 =)&( $+-5%/$9 "#$ h&(/4 <-169 KXY9 -14 ($,*&1-/ 4$7$/&%5$1"2-160C9 -14 "#$ 0*5:/"-1$&:0 %(&4:."*&1 &( ($*10.(*%"*&1 &) 0:21-"*&1-/ 0.-/$0 =<($11$(9>???C!

Mee F G$(($-:/"

Page 5: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

F#$0$ %(&.$00$0 $1"-*/ '#-" T'81,$4&:' =>??B-C #-0 ($)$(($4 "& -0 "#$ Q,/&.-/*3-"*&1;&) 0"-"$ ($0%&10*2*/*"*$09 -0 -:"#&(*"8 )&( 4$.*0*&15-6*1, 0#*)"0 4&'1'-(4 "&'-(4 /&.-/0"-"$ -:"#&(*"*$0 -14 &:"'-(4 "&'-(4 *1"$(1-"*&1-/ ($,:/-"&(8 )(-5$'&(609 5:/"*/-"$(-/*10"*":"*&109 -14 "(-4$ -,($$5$1"0 =0$$ -/0& <($11$(9 >??@c Z-:,#"&19 MJJMc T'81,$4&:'9MJJJC! W$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 &) ,&7$(1-1.$ #-0 2$$1 %(&5&"$4k1&" /$-0" 28 "#$ <&/*7*-1,&7$(15$1"k-0 *1.($-0*1, %&%:/-( %-("*.*%-"*&1 -14 2:($-:.(-"*. $))*.*$1.8 =)&($+-5%/$9 O(4-8- -14 F#$V 7&39 MJJ>c ]&14*1$//* $" -/9 >?@?C! K14$$49 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&15-8 *1 0&5$ *10"-1.$0 *5%(&7$ ,&7$(1-1.$ -14 %(&5&"$ 4$5&.(-"*3-"*&1 *1 - .&:1"(8'#$($ 2&"# #-7$ #*0"&(*.-//8 2$$1 '$-6! O0 <$1i-5*1 o&#/ =MJJMC $5%#-0*3$0 *1 "#$.-0$ &) <&/*7*-9 #&'$7$(9 *" *0 *5%&("-1" "& ($.&,1*3$ "#-" 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 *0 - .$1"(-/$/$5$1" &) "#$ 1$&/*2$(-/ %(&i$." *10&)-( -0 *" 2(*1,0 -2&:" "#$ ($0.-/*1, &) "#$ 0"-"$ -14"#$ $5$(,$1.$ &) $.&1&5*.-//8 .&5%$"*"*7$ 0:21-"*&1-/ 0%-.$09 (*%$ )&( "(-101-"*&1-/*17$0"5$1"! O1 *5%&("-1" (&/$ &) "#$ 1$&/*2$(-/ 0"-"$ *0 "#:0 "& %(&4:.$ QQ($/-"*7$/8.&#$($1"9 %(&7*0*&1-//8 0"-2*/*3$4 "$((*"&(*-/ .&1)*,:(-"*&10 :%&19 '*"#*19 -14 "#(&:,#'#*.# $+%-14$4 .-%*"-/ -..:5:/-"*&1 .-1 2$ ,$1$(-"$4;; =<($11$(9 >??@9 %-,$ AeMc0$$ -/0& R$(189 >??Hc X-.g$&4 -14 a&&4'*19 >???C! O45*1*0"(-"*7$ 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1*0 &1$ 0"(-"$,8 28 '#*.# "#*0 ,&-/ *0 -.#*$7$4!

K1 "#$ .-0$ &) <&/*7*-9 #&'$7$(9 "#$ ($/-"*&10#*% 2$"'$$1 0"-"$ ($"$((*"&(*-/*3-"*&1-14 "#$ *5%/$5$1"-"*&1 &) 1$&/*2$(-/ %&/*.*$0 *0 )-( )(&5 4*($."! <&/*7*-1 ($0&:(.$5-1-,$5$1" #-0 *14$$4 2$$1 ($0.-/$49 2:" *1 - 5-11$( "#-" *0 %$(#-%0 5&($ .&5%/$+"#-1 5*,#" 2$ %($4*."$4 28 "#$&(*0"0 &) 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1! Y&//&'*1, "#$ 1$&/*2$(-/ /&,*./-*4 &:" 28 P$))($8 T-.#0 -14 Y(-1.*0.& g-((-*1 =>??IC9 "#$ <&/*7*-1 ,&7$(15$1" #-00&:,#" "& 4$.$1"(-/*3$ -45*1*0"(-"*&1 &) /&.-/*3$49 1&1"(-4-2/$ ,&&40 -14 0$(7*.$0 "&"#$ 5:1*.*%-/ /$7$/ '#*/$ 0$$6*1, "& %(&5&"$ "#$ $1"(8 &) "(-4-2/$ ,&&40 -14 0$(7*.$0*1"& ,/&2-/ 5-(6$"0! F#$ /-""$( #-0 2$$1 -.#*$7$4k&( -" /$-0" -""$5%"$4k"#(&:,#"#$*( ($.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 -14 5-1-,$5$1" 28 0:%$(*1"$14$1.*$09 '*"# -:"#&(*"8 "& ($,:/-"$0%$.*)*. $.&1&5*. 0$."&(0 =)&( $+-5%/$9 $/$."(*.*"89 #84(&.-(2&109 "$/$.&55:1*.-"*&109"(-10%&("-"*&19 )&($0"0 -14 ($1$'-2/$ ($0&:(.$09 -14 4&5$0"*. '-"$( 0:%%/8 -14 0$'E$(-,$C! F#$ %(*5-(8 &2i$."*7$ &) "#$ 0:%$(*1"$14$1.*$0 *0 "& )-.*/*"-"$ "#$ 5-1-,$5$1"&) "#$0$ $.&1&5*. 0$."&(0 -..&(4*1, "& 1$&/*2$(-/ %(*1.*%/$09 *1 &(4$( "& -//&' )&("#$*( $1"(8 *1"& '&(/4 5-(6$"0! g&.-/*3$49 05-//E0.-/$ ($0&:(.$ :0$09 0:.# -0 "#$5*.(&E*((*,-"*&1 080"$50 "#-" .&5%(*0$ "#$ 2:/6 &) 3%-5#4+), *((*,-"*&1 *1 <&/*7*-9-($ 5-1-,$4 "#(&:,# /&.-/ 5:1*.*%-/*"*$09 .-5%$0*1& &(,-1*3-"*&109 -14 ($0&:(.$E:0$( -00&.*-"*&10!=>C F#:09 ($0&:(.$ 0$."&(0 2%*# 2$$1 0:2i$." "& 5-(6$" /&,*.9 "#(&:,#"#$*( ($,:/-"*&1 -14 .&1.$00*&1*1, 28 "#$ 0:%$(*1"$14$1.*$0! Y-( )(&5 2$*1, - 0*5%/$):1."*&1 &) -45*1*0"(-"*7$ 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&19 #&'$7$(9 *5%/$5$1"-"*&1 &) 5-(6$" %(*1E.*%/$0 #-0 "-6$1 %/-.$ "#(&:,# "#$ .($-"*&1 &) #*,#/8 .$1"(-/*3$4 $1"*"*$0 '*"# 1& /&.-/&7$(0*,#"! S10:(%(*0*1,/89 "#*0 #-0 2$$1 - #*,#/8 .&1"$0"$4 %(&.$009 -14 )&(5$4 &1$ &) "#$.$1"(-/ *00:$0 2&"# )&( "#$ R&.#-2-52- '-"$( '-( -14 )&( "#$ *((*,-"&( 5&2*/*3-"*&1 "#-")&//&'$4!

=>C F#$ "$(50 &) 0$/)E*4$1"*)*.-"*&1 :0$4 28 <&/*7*-;0 O5$(*14*-1 5-i&(*"8 -($ .&5%/$+9 -147-(8 '*"# $"#1*.*"89 ($,*&19 0&.*-/ ./-009 -14 %&/*"*.-/ &(*$1"-"*&1! <&/*7*-;0 #*,#/-14 O85-(--14 n:$.#:- ,(&:%0 )($N:$1"/8 :0$ "#$ "$(50 3%-5#4+), -14 ,$+!+)%$+, -0 0$/)E4$0.(*%"&(09 '#*/$"#$ "$(5 +)&76 !#)% *0 5&($ .&55&1/8 :0$4 -5&1, O5-3&1*-1 O5$(*14*-1 ,(&:%0! F#$($ *09*1 %(-."*.$9 .&10*4$(-2/$ 0/*%%-,$ 2$"'$$1 "#$ "$(50 -14 1& ./$-( 4*0"*1."*&1 2$"'$$1 "#$5!h#*/$ K -.61&'/$4,$ "#$ .&5%/$+*"8 &) "#$ *00:$9 -14 "#$ #*,#/8 .#-(,$4 *4$1"*"8 %&/*"*.0 "#-" *"$1"-*/09 K #-7$ -4&%"$4 "#$ "$(5 Q.-5%$0*1&; "& ($)$( "& %$-0-1" &( 05-//#&/4$( -,(-(*-1 ,(&:%09-14 Q*14*,$1&:09; "& ($)$( "& O5$(*14*-1 %$&%/$0 -0 - ,(&:%9 *1./:4*1, O85-(- -14 n:$.#:-.&55:1*"*$0! K1 )-."9 *1 "#$ 5-i&(*"8 &) .-0$09 -0 p-7*$( O/2&V =>???C 1&"$09 2&"# "$(50 -%%/8!F#-" *09 (:(-/ %$&%/$0 *1 <&/*7*- -($ 5&0" &)"$1 .-5%$0*1& *1 "#$*( 0&.*&$.&1&5*. 0"-":09 -14*14*,$1&:0 *1 "#$*( .:/":(-/ *4$1"*"8!

T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14 "#$ 0.-/$ %&/*"*.0 &) (:(-/ '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- MeB

Page 6: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

O1-/8"*.-/ )&.:0 5:0" "#$($)&($ 2$ 5-*1"-*1$4 &1 "#$ 0#*)"*1, *10"*":"*&1-/ -14$17*(&15$1"-/ 0.-/$0 -" '#*.# ($0&:(.$ 4$.*0*&10 -($ 5-4$ -14 .&1"$0"$4 *1 ($0"(:.E":($4 -14 ($0.-/$4 %$(*%#$(-/ 0"-"$09 -0 '$// -0 &1 "#$ -%%-($1" .&1"(-4*."*&10 -14*1.&10*0"$1.*$0 *1 "#$ 1$&/*2$(-/ /&,*. :14$(/8*1, 0"-"$ ($)&(50! K14$$49 "#$ 7-(*-2/$0.-/*1, &) *((*,-"*&1 080"$50 *1 <&/*7*- #-0 2$$1 - )&.:0 &) %&/*"*.-/ -45*1*0"(-"*&1-0 '$// -0 - 0&:(.$ &) 0&.*-/ "$10*&1 0*1.$ %($EZ*0%-1*. "*5$0 =m*55$($(9 MJJJ-C!O..&(4*1, "& a-7*1 <(*4,$ -14 O14($' P&1-0 =MJJM9 %-,$ Be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k-0 *0 &)"$1 "#$ .-0$ *1 %$(*%#$(-/ 0"-"$0k*10"*":"*&1-/ .&#$($1.$ 5-8 2$4*))*.:/" "& 0:0"-*1! R-:"*&1 *0 '-((-1"$49 "#$19 *1 -00:5*1, "#$ 0"-2*/*"8 &) *10"*":"*&1-/($0.-/*1, &) $17*(&15$1"-/ 5-1-,$5$1" -14 0&.*-/ ($,:/-"*&19 )&( -0 O4-5 F*.6$// -14P-5*$ G$.6 1&"$9 QQ"#$ -0.$14-1.8 &) 1$&E/*2$(-/*05 ($%($0$1"0 - ($,:/-"&(8 #&/$9 &1$'#*.# #-0 $/$5$1"0 &) 5-(6$" ($,:/-"*&1 2:" '#*.# ($%($0$1"0 "#$ %84#)3# &) - 1$'*10"*":"*&1-/ )*+;; =>??H9 %-,$ Ie?9 $5%#-0*0 *1 &(*,*1-/C! R/$-(/89 "#$19 "#$ *1#$($1"*10"-2*/*"8 -14 .&1"(-4*."*&1 &) *10"*":"*&1-/ -((-1,$5$1"0 :14$( 1$&/*2$(-/*05 5:0"2$ ($.&,1*3$4! K14$$49 *) F*.6$// -14 G$.6 =>??HC -($ .&(($."9 "#$1 1$&/*2$(-/*05 *0.#-(-."$(*3$4k/*6$ "#$ <&/*7*-1 0"-"$ *"0$/)k28 .(*0*0 -14 *10"-2*/*"8! T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(E*1, -14 "#$ ($0.-/*1, &) $17*(&15$1"-/ ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- #-7$ 2$$1 .&1"$0"$4 28-1 -((-8 &) (:(-/ -14 :(2-1 0&.*-/ 5&7$5$1"09 4*0(:%"*1, "#$ 1$&/*2$(-/ %(&i$." &) 0"-"$$/*"$0! F#$ "-06 &) "#*0 %-%$(9 "#$19 *0 1&" "& *4$1"*)8 0"-2/$ *10"*":"*&1-/ )*+$0 "#-")-.*/*"-"$ 1$' ($,*5$0 &) -..:5:/-"*&19 2:" (-"#$( "& $/:.*4-"$ "#$ '-80 "#-" -""$5%"0"& ($0.-/$ ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- -($ *5%/$5$1"$4 -14 .&1"$0"$49 -14 "#$ $))$."0 &)"#$0$ %(&.$00$0 &1 ($0&:(.$ -..$009 0&.*-/ 5&2*/*3-"*&19 -14 (:(-/ /*7$/*#&&40!

F#$ 0"(:,,/$0 &7$( '-"$( 5-1-,$5$1" -14 0"-"$ ($)&(5 *1 <&/*7*- $+$5%/*)8 '$//"#*0 7-(*-2*/*"8 -14 .&1"$0"-"*&1! K1 <&/*7*-9 -0 *1 &"#$( %$(*%#$(-/ 0"-"$09 "#$ %&0"Eh&(/4 h-( M *10"*":"*&10 &) 0"-"$E/$4 %(&4:."*&1 -14 .&10:5%"*&1 #-7$ 2$$1 2(&6$1-%-("9 2:" #-7$ 8$" "& 2$ ($%/-.$4 28 -18"#*1, -%%(&-.#*1, 0"-2/$ &( (&2:0" *10"*":E"*&1-/ -((-1,$5$1"0! O/"#&:,# "#$ <&/*7*-1 /-2&( 5&7$5$1" -14 .$("-*1 .&(%&(-"*0"&(,-1*3-"*&10 #-7$ 2$$1 '$-6$1$4 =R-//-9 MJJJ-C9 ($.$1"/8 )&(5$4 %&/*"*.-/ %-("*$0-14 0&.*-/ 5&7$5$1"0k"#$50$/7$0 5-4$ %&00*2/$ 28 %&/*"*.-/ ($)&(50k#-7$ $5$(,$4"& .#-//$1,$ "#$ #$,$5&18 &) - '$-6 0"-"$ -%%-(-":0! F#&:,# )(-."*&:09 "#$0$ &(,-1*3-E"*&10 1$7$("#$/$00 %/-8 -1 *5%&("-1" (&/$ *1 .&:1"$(2-/-1.*1, "#$ 0"-"$;0 1$&/*2$(-/%(&i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i$."!

91,(-4)"0 :-#1$ 6-"-0161"#R&10*4$(-2/$ -""$1"*&1 #-0 2$$1 %-*4 *1 ($.$1" 8$-(0 "& "#$ 1$&/*2$(-/ ($0"(:.":(*1, &)'-"$( 5-1-,$5$1"! X:.# &) "#*0 '&(6 #-0 )&.:0$4 &1 '-"$( 5-(6$"*1,9 &( '#-" o-($1<-66$( =MJJMC ($)$(0 "& -0 -#$3%).+'+9%3+,6 )9 - %(&.$00 "#-"9

Me@ F G$(($-:/"

Page 7: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

!!$1"-*/0 "#$ *1"(&4:."*&1 &) "#$ /&,*. &) "#$ 5-(6$" "& '-"$(E($0&:(.$0 5-1-,$5$1"-14 -//&.-"*&1 -14q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e@ f Be?9$5%#-0*0 *1 &(*,*1-/C!

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c MJJMC %&*1"0 &:" =-14-0 '-0 -))*(5$4 -" "#$ MJJJ h&(/4 h-"$( Y&(:5 *1 F#$ Z-,:$C9 '-"$( *0 "& 2$($.-"$,&(*3$4 -0 -1 $.&1&5*. ,&&49 &1$ "#-"9 -/&1, '*"# *"0 .&10:5$(09 5-8 2$ 0:2i$.""& "#$ 4*0.*%/*1-(8 $))$."0 &) "#$ 5-(6$"! O0 '*// 2$ 4*0.:00$4 2$/&'9 #&'$7$(9 "#$0$5-(6$"E&(*$1"$4 %&/*.8 *4$-/0 #-7$ 5$" '*"# .&10*4$(-2/$ ($0*0"-1.$9 -14 "#$*(($-/*3-"*&1 #-0 2$$1 )-( )(&5 %$()$."!

K" *0 *5%&("-1" "& 2$-( *1 5*149 5&($&7$(9 2&"# "#$ 0&.*-/ ):1."*&1 -14 "#$*1#$($1"/8 4:-/*0"*. 1-":($ &) '-"$(! h-"$( $+*0"0 -0 - 1-":(-/ %#80*.-/ $1"*"89 '#*.#/*6$ &"#$( 0:.# $1"*"*$09 *0 2(&:,#" *1"& 2$*1, -0 - ($0&:(.$ "#(&:,# #:5-1 /-2&(=Z-(7$89 >?BAC! S1/*6$ &"#$( ($0&:(.$09 #&'$7$(9 '-"$( *0 $00$1"*-/ "& &:( 5&0" 2-0*./*)$ ):1."*&10 &1 - 4-*/8 2-0*0! h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

K1 <&/*7*-9 '-"$( 5-(6$"*1, #-0 "-6$1 7-(*&:0 )&(50 =X-(7*1 -14 g-:(*$9 >???C!X&0" )-5&:0/89 -""$5%"0 "& %(*7-"*3$ '-"$( 0$(7*.$0 *1 "#$ .*"8 &) R&.#-2-52- 5$"'*"# 5-00*7$ &%%&0*"*&1 )(&5 -1 -((-8 &) 0&.*-/ 5&7$5$1"0 -14 .*"*3$10; ,(&:%0 '#&)&(.$4 "#$ 1-"*&1-/ ,&7$(15$1" "& (&// 2-.6 ($)&(5 -14 ($0&.*-/*3$ "#$ .*"8;0 '-"$(0$(7*.$ =Y-("#*1, -14 o&#/9 MJJ>c a-(.UV - $" -/9 MJJIc T.#:/"39 MJJIC! F#$ <-13$(,&7$(15$1";0 $))&("0 -" '-"$( %(*7-"*3-"*&19 %(&5&"$4 28 "#$ h&(/4 <-169 .&1)&(5"& - '&(/4'*4$ %-""$(1 &) '-"$(E5-(6$"*1, 0"(-"$,*$09 -14 )&(5 i:0" &1$ %-(" &)- 5:.# 2(&-4$( 1$&/*2$(-/ %(&i$."! R&.#-2-52-;0 Q'-"$( '-(; #-0 2$$1 .$/$2(-"$4&1 "#$ /$)" -0 - 7*."&(8 *1 "#$ 2-""/$ -,-*10" .&(%&(-"$ ,/&2-/*3-"*&1 =)&( $+-5%/$9<-(/&'$ -14 R/-(6$9 MJJMC9 -14 /-5$1"$4 &1 "#$ (*,#" -0 - 0$"2-.6 )&( "$.#1&.(-"*.$))*.*$1.8 =)&( $+-5%/$9 D*.60&1 -14 [-(,-09 MJJMC! O0 .&5%$//*1, -0 "#*0 *00:$ *09

T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14 "#$ 0.-/$ %&/*"*.0 &) (:(-/ '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- Me?

Page 8: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

#&'$7$(9 *" #-0 4*7$("$4 -""$1"*&1 )(&5 /$00 7*0*2/$ 2:" $N:-//8 *5%&("-1" 0"(:,,/$0&7$( '-"$( 5-1-,$5$1" *1 "#$ <&/*7*-1 .&:1"(80*4$! T.#&/-(/8 -14 %&%:/-( /*"$(-":($&1 '-"$( ($,:/-"*&1 :14$( 1$&/*2$(-/*05 #-0 )&.:0$4 %(*5-(*/8 &1 :(2-1 '-"$(E0:%%/8080"$50 -14 "#$*( =%-("*-/C %(*7-"*3-"*&1 =0$$9 *1"$( -/*-9 <-66$( MJJJc MJJMc Y*11$,-19MJJMc Z-:,#"&19 >??@c MJJMc X-(7*1 -14 g-:(*$9 >???c D*.60&1 -14 [-(,-09 MJJMcT'81,$4&:'9 >??B2C! O/"#&:,# 0:.# 080"$50 #-7$ - 4*($." $))$." &1 5&0" &) "#$'&(/4;0 %&%:/-"*&19 %-("*.:/-(/8 *1 '$-/"#8 -14 #*,#/8 :(2-1*3$4 0"-"$09 *" *0 '&("#($5$52$(*1, "#-" 0&5$ BJr &) '-"$( :0$ '&(/4'*4$ *0 .&10:5$4 28 -,(*.:/":($=- )*,:($ "#-" ./*520 "& @Jr *1 <&/*7*-C =Z-(%$(9 MJJ>c [-1 W-55$9 MJJMC! X&($&7$(9*1 .&:1"(*$0 /*6$ <&/*7*-9 '#$($ 1$-(/8 AJr &) "#$ %&%:/-"*&1 *0 (:(-/9 N:$0"*&10&) -,(*.:/":(-/ '-"$( 5-1-,$5$1" :14$( 1$&/*2$(-/*05 -($ *1):0$4 '*"# - 0$10$ &):(,$1.8! K1 <&/*7*- ($.$1" %(&.$00$0 &) 0"-"$ 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 -14 $.&1&5*. /*2$(-/*E3-"*&19 '#*.# .&1)&(5 "& '#-" <(*4,$ -14 P&1-0 =MJJM9 %-,$ BeJC *4$1"*)8 -0 "#$QQ%-(-4*,5-"*. 7$(0*&1;; &) 1$&/*2$(-/ ($)&(59 #-7$ .($-"$4 *5%&("-1" "(-10)&(5-"*&10*1 "#$ '-8 "#-" (:(-/ '-"$( *0 ($,:/-"$4! F#$0$ .#-1,$0 #-7$ *1 ":(1 /$4 "& 1$' )&(50&) 0&.*-/ &(,-1*3-"*&1 &1 "#$ %-(" &) .-5%$0*1&0 -14 -."*7*0"0 *1 &(4$( "& -..$00 -145-1-,$ '-"$( )&( *((*,-"*&1!

h#$($-0 "#$ 1$&/*2$(-/*3-"*&1 &) '-"$( 5-1-,$5$1" *1 "#$ :(2-1 .$1"$(0 &)R&.#-2-52- -14 g- G-3q\/ O/"& #-7$ 2$$1 #*,#/8 7*0*2/$9 .&1"$0"$49 -14 %:2/*.*3$49"#$ $))$."0 &) 1$&/*2$(-/ ($)&(5 #-7$ 2$$1 ($/-"*7$/8 /$00 %(&1&:1.$4 *1 (:(-/ -($-0!F#*0 *0 *1 %-(" 2$.-:0$9 :1/*6$ #84(&.-(2&19 5*1$(-/9 &( 0&5$ :(2-1 '-"$( ($0&:(.$09*((*,-"*&1 '-"$( #-0 1&" =8$"C 2$$1 %(*7-"*3$4 *1 <&/*7*-! F#$ .&55$(.*-/*3-"*&1 &)(:(-/ '-"$( '&:/4 *17&/7$ "#$ ,(-1"*1, &) .&1.$00*&10 -14 "#$ .&1"(&/ &) '-"$(0&:(.$09 4*7$(0*&109 -14q&( .-1-/ *1)(-0"(:.":($ *1 - /-(,$9 5&:1"-*1&:0 &( O/"*%/-1&$17*(&15$1"k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e '-"$( /-' #-0 2$$1 -5$14$4 0$7$(-/ "*5$09 2:"#-0 8$" "& 2$ ($%/-.$4 28 .&5%($#$10*7$ /$,*0/-"*&1 s4$0%*"$ "#$ )-." "#-" &7$( "#*("87$(0*&10 &) 0:.# - /-' #-7$ 2$$1 %(&%&0$4 *1 ($.$1" 8$-(0 =<:0"-5-1"$9 MJJMCt!h#$($-0 *((*,-"&(0; (*,#"0 "& '-"$( ($5-*1 %&&(/8 4$)*1$49 '-"$( (*,#"0 )&( .&5%$"*1,0$."&(0k4&5$0"*.9 5*1*1,9 $/$."(*.*"8 ,$1$(-"*&19 *14:0"(8k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

MBJ F G$(($-:/"

Page 9: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

31%4)+1$-4 ,#-#1 $1,#$'(#'$)"0 )" ;%4)7)-<(%"%6)( ($),), -"& ,#$'(#'$-4 -&=',#61"# )" #>1 2?@A,<&/*7*- :14$('$1" *"0 )*(0" (&:14 &) 1$&/*2$(-/ 0"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, *1 >?@H9 *1 ($0%&10$"& %(&)&:14 -14 4$$%$1*1, $.&1&5*. .(*0*0! F#(&:,# "#$ )*(0" #-/) &) "#$ >?@J09<&/*7*-;0 )&($*,1 4$2" 0'$//$49 -14 ,(&00 4&5$0"*. %(&4:." 4$./*1$4 $7$(8 8$-( 2$"'$$1>?@> -14 >?@e ='*"# - ?!>r 4(&% *1 >?@M -/&1$C! \.&1&5*. ,(&'"# -7$(-,$4 !"!#r *1"#$ >?@J09 '#*/$ -11:-/ *1)/-"*&1 -7$(-,$4 >?e?!Ar9 ($-.#*1, -1 -11:-/ (-"$ &) M>BBr*1 >?@A9 -14 %$-6*1, -" -1 -0"&:14*1, @>BJr 4:(*1, "#$ )*(0" 0*+ 5&1"#0 &) >?@H=o/$*19 >??M9 %-,$ MBMc T-.#09 >?@BC! O0 "#$ ,&7$(15$1" "$$"$($4 &1 "#$ 2(*16 &)$.&1&5*. -14 %&/*"*.-/ .&//-%0$9 G($0*4$1" Z$(1-V 1 T*/$0 m:-3&9 $/$."$4 -5*40" .(*0*0*1 >?@M9 .-//$4 )&( $-(/8 $/$."*&10 *1 >?@H!

h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i:0"E5$1" ($)&(509 2-0$4 &1 %&/*.*$0 4$0*,1$4 %(*5-(*/8 28 Z-(7-(4 $.&1&5*0" P$))($8T-.#09 '#*.# .-//$4 )&( ./&0*1, 0"-"$E&'1$4 5*1$09 %(*7-"*3*1, 1-"*&1-/ *14:0"(*$094$7-/:*1, "#$ .:(($1.89 -14 $/*5*1-"*1, "-(*))09 %(*.$ 0:%%&("09 -14 &"#$( Q%(&"$."*&1*0";%&/*.*$0 =R&1-,#-1 $" -/9 >??JC! F#$ D\G -/0& 0&:,#" "& ($4:.$ %:2/*. $+%$14*":($0 280:0%$14*1, *17$0"5$1" %(&i$."09 )($$3*1, ,&7$(15$1" 0-/-(*$09 -14 ($4:.*1, %:2/*.$5%/&85$1"! W&5$0"*. -,(*.:/":(-/ 5-(6$"0 '$($ /*2$(-/*3$49 *1"$($0" (-"$ .&1"(&/0'$($ ($5&7$49 -14 ,-0&/*1$ %(*.$0 '$($ (-*0$4 28 >JJJr =o-*5&'*"3 $" -/9 >???C! F#$0$%&/*.*$0 '$($ $))$."*7$ *1 .:(2*1, 4$5-14 -14 2(*1,*1, 4&'1 #8%$(*1)/-"*&19 '#*.# )$//"& i:0" ?r *1 >?@e! F#*0 .-5$ -" - 0"-,,$(*1, %(*.$9 #&'$7$(! T&5$ MJ JJJ 5*1$(0 /&0""#$*( i&20 -0 - ($0:/" &) "#$ ./&0:($ &) 0"-"$ 5*1$09 '*"# 4$7-0"-"*1, $))$."0 &1 5*1*1,.&55:1*"*$0 *1 L(:(&9 G&"&0UV 9 -14 g- G-3 W$%-("5$1"0 =T-1-2(*-9 MJJJC! X-1:)-.":(E*1, i&20 %/:55$"$4 28 IH JJJ 2$"'$$1 >?@H -14 >??J9 -14 28 >?@@ "#$ *1)&(5-/ 0$."&(-..&:1"$4 )&( BJr &) "#$ '&(6*1, %&%:/-"*&1 =;,'+*+% ;"''#.+) >?@?c Y-("#*1,9 >??>C!

G-3 \0"$100&(&;0 D\G /-*4 "#$ )&:14-"*&1 )&( /-"$( 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 -14 5&($0'$$%*1, $.&1&5*. ($)&(50! <$"'$$1 >?@? -14 >??I9 "#$ -45*1*0"(-"*&1 &) P-*5$ G-3m-5&(- /-(,$/8 )&//&'$4 "#$ %&/*.*$0 &) #*0 %($4$.$00&(9 -14 0:..$00)://8 )&0"$($4$.&1&5*. 0"-2*/*"8 -14 5&4$(-"$ $.&1&5*. ,(&'"# "#-" -7$(-,$4 0&5$ Ar -11:-//8!K1 0%*"$ &) "#*0 0:..$009 #&'$7$(9 %(&)&:14 %(&2/$50 ($5-*1$4! ]$-/ '-,$0 )$// -14%&7$("8 ,($'9 "(-4$ ($5-*1$4 4$%$14$1" &1 "#$ $+%&(" &) (-' 5-"$(*-/09 -14 "#$*1)&(5-/ $.&1&58 .&1"*1:$4 "& ,(&' *1 ($/-"*&1 "& "#$ )&(5-/ $.&1&58! O0 4*0.&1"$1"'*"# "#$ #*,#/8 .$1"(-/*3$4 ,&7$(15$1" *1.($-0$4 -5&1, "#$ $/*"$0 &) <&/*7*-;0 4$%-("E5$1"0 -14 /-(,$( 5:1*.*%-/*"*$09 %($00:($ ,($' )&( 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&19 -14 "#$ .($-"*&1 &)7*-2/$ 4$%-("5$1"-/ ,&7$(15$1"0 =o&#/9 >???9 %-,$0 HB f H@C!

B#-#1 $1,#$'(#'$)"0 )" #>1 2??A,K1 >??I 5*1*1, 5-,1-"$ a&13-/$3 T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4- '-0 $/$."$4 %($0*4$1"9 $-(1*1,- /-(,$ %/:(-/*"8 &) "#$ %&%:/-( 7&"$! O0 X*1*0"$( &) G/-11*1, :14$( G-3 \0"$10&((&9T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4- 4$0*,1$4 -14 *5%/$5$1"$4 0&5$ &) "#$ 5&($ (-4*.-/ $/$5$1"0 &)"#$ D\G9 -14 1& 4&:2" )&(5:/-"$4 *4$-0 )&( ):("#$( $.&1&5*. -14 %&/*"*.-/ ($)&(50!Y&( T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4-k- 5$52$( &) %($.*0$/8 "#$ 6*14 &) $/*"$ '#&0$ "(-101-"*&1-/./-00 -//*-1.$09 "(-*1*1,9 -14 $+%$(*$1.$ -($ .$1"(-/ "& "#$ *1"$(1-"*&1-/*3-"*&1 &)%$(*%#$(-/ 0"-"$0 =a/-005-19 >???Ck"#$0$ ($)&(50 ./$-(/8 .&10"*":"$4 - %&/*"*.-/9-0 '$// -0 $.&1&5*. %(&i$."! Y-( )(&5 '$-6$1*1, &( 4*0-2/*1, "#$ 0"-"$9 -0 0&5$

T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14 "#$ 0.-/$ %&/*"*.0 &) (:(-/ '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- MB>

Page 10: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

)&(5:/-"*&10 &) "#$ Q#&//&'*1, &:"; "#$0*0 '&:/4 -00:5$9 0"(:.":(-/ ($)&(5 '-0 )&(#*5 - '-8 "& ($-00$(" "#$ -:"#&(*"8 &) - '$-6$1$4 0"-"$! K1 >?@H T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4-#-4 4$./-($4 "#-" 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 '-0 - 5$-10 &) QQ($$0"-2/*0#*1, "#$ -:"#&(*"8 &)"#$ 0"-"$ &7$( 0&.*$"8;; =T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4-9 >?@H9 N:&"$4 *1 R&1-,#-1 $" -/9 >??J9%-,$ >@C! Y&( T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4- "#$19 0"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, '-0 *1"$14$4 "& ($4:.$ "#$*10"-1.$ &) &))*.*-/ .&((:%"*&19 ($1$' "#$ 0"-"$;0 /$,*"*5-.89 -149 1&" *1.*4$1"-//89)-.*/*"-"$ *1"$(1-"*&1-/ *17$0"5$1" =T-1-2(*-9 >???C! G($0:5-2/89 "#$0$ 5&"*7-"*&10:14$(,*(4$4 "#$ 0'$$%*1, ($)&(50 T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4- *10"*":"$4 -0 %($0*4$1" -4$.-4$ /-"$(! K1 "#$ $-(/8 >??J0 5&2*/*3-"*&1 -5&1, 2&"# ($,*&1-/ $/*"$0 -14 0&.*-/5&7$5$1" &(,-1*3-"*&10 *1.($-0$4 .-//0 )&( "#$ 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 &) 0"-"$ -:"#&(*"89'#*.# #-0 "(-4*"*&1-//8 2$$1 #*,#/8 .&1.$1"(-"$4 *1 g- G-3 =O/2&V 9 >??AC!

h#$1 T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4- "&&6 &))*.$ *1 >??I9 #$ N:*.6/8 *10"*":"$4 #*0 /'%) &#1,&,4 =G/-1 )&( \7$(8&1$C9 - 0'$$%*1, ($)&(5 %-.6-,$ "#-" (-4*.-//8 ($0"(:.":($4"#$ 0"-"$ -14 $.&1&58! F#$ G/-1 4$ F&4&0 *17&/7$4 0$7$1 5-i&( .&5%&1$1"0_ =>C .&1E0"*":"*&1-/ ($)&(5c =MC -45*1*0"(-"*7$ 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 "#(&:,# "#$ g-' &) G&%:/-(G-("*.*%-"*&1 -14 "#$ g-' &) W$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1c =IC %(*7-"*3-"*&1 &) 0"-"$ *14:0"(*$0"#(&:,# "#$ g-' &) R-%*"-/*3-"*&1c =AC - 0$.&14 -,(-(*-1 ($)&(5 "#(&:,# "#$ g-' &)"#$ D-"*&1-/ K10"*":"$ &) O,(-(*-1 ]$)&(5c =HC $4:.-"*&1 ($)&(5c =eC ($0"(:.":(*1,&) "#$ %$10*&1 080"$5 -14 *1"(&4:."*&1 &) 0&.*-/ *10:(-1.$ %-85$1"0 )&( .*"*3$10 &7$(eH 8$-(0 &) -,$c -14 =BC ($)&(5 &) "#$ i:4*.*-/ 080"$5 =o&#/9 >???c XD]EX]Fog9>??IC! F#$ )*(0" &) "#$0$ ($)&(509 "#$ ($'(*"*1, &) "#$ R&10"*":"*&1 *1 >??A9 %-7$4"#$ '-89 2&"# $.&1&5*.-//8 -14 .:/":(-//89 )&( "#$ ($)&(50 "#-" '&:/4 )&//&'! F#$1$' R&10"*":"*&1 ($.&,1*3$4 <&/*7*- -0 - QQ%/:(*E.:/":(-/9 5:/"*E$"#1*.;; 1-"*&19 -14$0"-2/*0#$4 .$("-*1 .:/":(-/9 ($0&:(.$9 -14 %&/*"*.-/ (*,#"0 )&( *14*,$1&:0 -14 .-5%$E0*1& %$&%/$0 =Z$-/8 -14 G-:/0&19 MJJJc [-1 R&""9 MJJJc m*55$($(9 MJJJ2C! Z&'$7$(9-0 R#-(/$0 Z-/$ =MJJMC %$(0:-0*7$/8 -(,:$0 *1 "#$ .-0$ &) a:-"$5-/-9 "#$ '-7$ &)Q%/:(*q5:/"*; ($)&(50 "#-" 0'$%" g-"*1 O5$(*.- *1 "#$ >??J0 2(&:,#" %(&2/$50 -0'$// -0 %(&5*0$9 -0 1$')&:14 (*,#"0 "& .:/":(-/ $+%($00*&19 $"#1*. "$((*"&(89 -14 "(-4*"*&1-/($0&:(.$ :0$0 '$($ .*(.:50.(*2$4 28 1$&/*2$(-/ %&/*.*$0 "#-" "$14$4 "& :14$(.:" /*7$/*#&&4&%"*&10 -14 )&($./&0$ -/"$(1-"*7$ 0"(-"$,*$0 )&( 0&.*-/ &(,-1*3-"*&1 =0$$ 2$/&'C!

<&/*7*-1 ($)&(50 '$($ -..&5%-1*$4 28 1:5$(&:0 %*$.$5$-/ 5$-0:($09 *1./:4*1,'-,$ )($$3$0 -14 ($4:."*&10 *1 0&.*-/ 0%$14*1, "#-" ):$/$4 1$-(/8 .$-0$/$00 %&/*"*.-/:1($0" "#(&:,#&:" "#$ >??J0! T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4-;0 G/-1 4$ F&4&0 '-0 )-( 5&($ "#-1i:0" - %/-1 "& /*2$(-/*3$ "#$ $.&1&58! K" ($%($0$1"$4 -1 -""$5%" "& ($5-6$ "#$ 0"-"$90*5:/"-1$&:0/8 ($)&(5*1, -45*1*0"(-"*7$ -14 )*0.-/ 0"(:.":($09 *14:0"(89 0&.*-/ 0$(7*.$09-14 -,(*.:/":($ -14 /-14 5-(6$"09 -// /$,*"*5-"$4 "#(&:,# - ($'(*"*1, &) "#$ .&10"*":E"*&1 =[-1 R&""9 MJJJC! O0 o&#/ =MJJM9 %-,$ AHIC 1&"$09 QQF#$ *5%&("-1" *11&7-"*&1 &)"#$ <&/*7*-1 /'%) &# 1,&,4 '-0 "#-" *" 0*5:/"-1$&:0/8 -""$5%"$4 "& ($.&1.*/$ "#$4$5-140 &) 0:21-"*&1-/ ($,*&10 )&( ,($-"$( -:"&1&58 '*"# "#&0$ &) *1"$(1-"*&1-/*10"*":"*&10 )&( &%$1 5-(6$"0!;; F#$ G/-1 4$ F&4&0 0#*)"$4 0"-"$ ($7$1:$0 -14 4$.*0*&1E5-6*1, -:"#&(*"8 "& "#$ /&.-/ /$7$/9 '#*/$ -" "#$ 0-5$ "*5$ )-.*/*"-"*1, "#$ $1"(8 &)"(-101-"*&1-/ .-%*"-/ *1"& 1-"*&1-/ 5-(6$"0! O0 o&#/ =>???c MJJMC #-0 -(,:$49 "#$ "'*1%*//-(0 &) <&/*7*-1 0"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1,k$.&1&5*. /*2$(-/*3-"*&1 -14 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 &),&7$(1-1.$k0$(7$ /$00 "& .($-"$ 0:0"-*1-2/$9 /&.-//8 2-0$4 4$5&.(-"*. *10"*":"*&10 "#-1"& %(&7*4$ "#$ -%%$-(-1.$ &) %&/*"*.-/ 0"-2*/*"8 4$$5$4 1$.$00-(8 "& -""(-." )&($*,1 *17$0"E5$1"! K" *0 *1 "#*0 0$10$ "#-" '$ 5-8 $+-5*1$ "#$ *10"*":"*&1-/ ($0.-/*1, &) "#$ <&/*7*-10"-"$9 -14 *"0 Q,/&.-/*3-"*&1;9 *1 ($0%&10$ "& *1"$(1-/ %&/*"*.-/ 4$5-140 -0 '$// -0 .(*0$0 *1,/&2-/ .-%*"-/*05 =T'81,$4&:'9 >??B-C! L) "#$ 0$7$1 5-i&( .&5%&1$1"0 &) "#$ G/-1 4$F&4&0 /*0"$4 -2&7$9 "#$($ -($ "#($$ "#-" #-7$ %-("*.:/-( 2$-(*1, &1 (:(-/ '-"$( ($0&:(.$0_-45*1*0"(-"*7$ 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 =<#: &# /%$.+3+5%3+,6 ) /,5"'%$C9 %(*7-"*3-"*&1 &) *14:0"(8=<#: &# =%5+.%'+9%3+,6 )C9 -14 -,(-(*-1 ($)&(5 =<#: >?@0C!

MBM F G$(($-:/"

Page 11: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

8-: %5 C%C'4-$ C-$#)()C-#)%"F#$ >??A <#: &# /%$.+3+5%3+,6 ) /,5"'%$9 &( g-' &) G&%:/-( G-("*.*%-"*&1 =gGGC 4(-5-"*.-//8($0.-/$4 -45*1*0"(-"*7$ ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*-! K" .($-"$4 I>> 1$' 5:1*.*%-/*"*$0 =$00$1"*-//828 ($4$0*,1-"*1, -45*1*0"(-"*7$ :1*"0 61&'1 -0 %(&7*1.*-/ 0$."*&10C9 ,-7$ "#$5 -:"#&(*"8&7$( 4$7$/&%5$1" %/-11*1,9 *1)(-0"(:.":($ .&10"(:."*&19 -14 2:4,$" 4$.*0*&109 -14-00*,1$4 "& "#$5 MJr &) "#$ 1-"*&1-/ 2:4,$"!=MC S14$( "#$ gGG9 1$*,#2&(#&&4 ,(&:%0-14 *14*,$1&:0 -14 .-5%$0*1& &(,-1*3-"*&10 '$($ ,(-1"$4 /$,-/ 0"-":0 -0 ($%($0$1"-"*7$0&) "#$*( .&10"*":$1.*$0 "#(&:,# "#$ $0"-2/*0#5$1" &) F$((*"&(*-/ <-0$ L(,-1*3-"*&10 =F<L09*1 T%-1*0#9 A$!%)+9%3+,)#4 1#$$+.,$+%'#4 &# ;%4#C! ]$%($0$1"-"*7$0 &) "#$0$ F<L0 )&(5&7$(0*,#" .&55*""$$0 "#-" #-7$ "#$ ($0%&10*2*/*"8 "& $10:($ "#-" 5:1*.*%-/ 2:4,$"-(84$.*0*&10 -($ 0&:149 -14 -($ ,(-1"$4 7$"& %&'$( &7$( "#*0 %(&.$00 =o&#/9 MJJMC! F#:09 -.$1"(-/ ):1."*&1 &) "#$ gGG *0 "& 0"($1,"#$1 "#$ *10"*":"*&1-/*3-"*&1 &) /&.-/ ,&7$(1-1.$!F#$ gGG ./$-(/8 4$)*1$0 "#$ '-80 "#-" 5:1*.*%-/ .&0"E0#-(*1, ):140 5-8 2$ 0%$1"9/*5*"*1, $+%$14*":($0 "& #$-/"#9 $4:.-"*&19 5*.(&E*((*,-"*&19 (&-409 -14 0%&("0 )-.*/*"*$09-14 5-14-"$0 "#-" @Hr &) ):140 5:0" 2$ 0%$1" &1 *5%/$5$1"-"*&1 =0"*%:/-"*1, .&1E0"(:."*&19 1&" 5-*1"$1-1.$C9 /$-7*1, &1/8 >Hr )&( -45*1*0"(-"*&1 =o&#/9 >???9 %-,$ BMC!Y:140 )(&5 "#$ .$1"(-/ ,&7$(15$1" -($ "& 2$ 0:%%/$5$1"$4 28 /&.-/ "-+ ($7$1:$09 -14"#$ gGG $+%-140 "#$ -2*/*"8 &) 5:1*.*%*&0 "& (-*0$ "-+ ($7$1:$0! K1 "#$ -($- &) *((*,-"*&1-14 '-"$( 0$(7*.$09 "#$0$ 0"(:.":(-/ .&10"(-*1"0 #-7$ /$4 "& 4$.($-0$4 -""$1"*&1 "& 5&1*"&(E*1, &) '-"$( N:-/*"8 -0 '$// -0 "$.#1*.-/ 0$(7*.$ %/-11*1, -14 *5%/$5$1"-"*&1 =Z&&,$14-5-14 [-(,-09 >???-C! g&.-/ ,&7$(15$1"0 (-($/8 #-7$ "#$ 2:4,$"-(8 &( "$.#1*.-/ .-%-.*"89&( "#$ *55$4*-"$ *1"$($0"9 1$.$00-(8 "& -45*1*0"$( '-"$( ($0&:(.$0 -4$N:-"$/8!

F#:09 "#$ gGG 1&" &1/8 0#&($4 :% "#$ $(&4*1, -:"#&(*"8 &) "#$ 0"-"$9 -0 -1"*.*E%-"$4 28 T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4- #*50$/)9 2:" -/0& #$/%$4 .($-"$ "#$ /&.-/*3$4 .&14*"*&10&) ,&7$(1-1.$ 4$$5$4 1$.$00-(8 )&( "(-101-"*&1-/ *17$0"5$1" )/&'0! g&.-//8 2-0$4,&7$(1-1.$ 0"(:.":($09 1$&/*2$(-/ &("#&4&+8 -00:5$09 '*// 2$ 5&($ )/$+*2/$ *1 )-.*/*E"-"*1, *17$0"5$1"9 -14 5&($ -"":1$4 "& /&.-/ 5-(6$" .&14*"*&10! K1 "#*0 ($,-(49<&/*7*-;0 ($)&(50 5-8 2$ 7*$'$4 -0 -%%$-/*1, "& *1"$(1-"*&1-/ 4$5-140 "& 0"-2*/*3$-..:5:/-"*&1 "#(&:,# "#$ $0"-2/*0#5$1" &) 1$' *10"*":"*&1-/ -14 0.-/-( .&1)*,:(-E"*&10! S14$( "#$ g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k-/5&0" .$("-*1/8 -1 =:1*1"$14$4C&:".&5$ &) "#$ gGG =*1"$(7*$' '*"# ]$."&(9 S1*7$(0*4-4 4$ /- R&(4*//$(-9 g- G-39MJ W$.$52$( MJJMC! K1 5-18 .-0$09 #&'$7$(9 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 #-0 0$(7$4 "& ($*1)&(.$"#$ %&'$( &) /&.-/ $/*"$0 =o&#/9 MJJMC9 -14 #-0 *1 )-." )-*/$4 "& -""(-." 5:.#*1"$(1-"*&1-/ *17$0"5$1"!

=MC B")+3+5+,4 -($ -1-/&,&:0 "& .&:1"*$0 =(-"#$( "#-1 .*"*$0C *1 "#$ STO *1 "#-" "#$8 *17&/7$ - .*"8 &("&'1 -14 "#$ (:(-/ ($,*&1 0:((&:14*1, *"! <$.-:0$ &) "#*0 4*))$($1.$9 K :0$ "#$ T%-1*0# "$(55:1*.*%*& *1 "#*0 %-%$(9 (-"#$( "#-1 -4&%"*1, "#$ \1,/*0# .&,1-"$ 5:1*.*%-/*"8! F#$ gGG *1*"*-//8.($-"$4 I>> 5:1*.*%*&0 -.(&00 "#$ .&:1"(89 -14 "#($$ 5&($ '$($ /-"$( -44$4! F#$0$ -($ %(*5-(*/805-// -14 (:(-/ *1 .#-(-."$(! L) "#$ I>A 5:1*.*%*&0 *1 <&/*7*-9 I>r #-7$ %&%:/-"*&10 :14$( HJJJ9BIr #-7$ %&%:/-"*&10 :14$( >H JJJ9 -14 ?Ar #-7$ %&%:/-"*&10 :14$( HJ JJJ =TDGGEWDYR9 >??B9%-,$ >>9 N:&"$4 *1 o&#/ MJJM9 %-,$ Ae>9 )&&"1&"$ >BC!

T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14 "#$ 0.-/$ %&/*"*.0 &) (:(-/ '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- MBI

Page 12: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

8-: %5 (-C)#-4)D-#)%"F#$ 0$.&14 6$8 $/$5$1" "& T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4-;0 G/-1 4$ F&4&0 '-0 -1 *11&7-"*7$)&(5 &) $.&1&5*. /*2$(-/*3-"*&1 :14$( "#$ >??A <#: &# =%5+.%'+9%3+,6 )9 &( g-' &)R-%*"-/*3-"*&1! S14$( "#*0 /-'9 )*7$ 0"(-"$,*. *14:0"(*$0k"$/$.&55:1*.-"*&109 &*/ -14,-09 $/$."(*.*"8 ,$1$(-"*&19 -*(/*1$09 -14 (-*/(&-40k'$($ %-("*-//8 %(*7-"*3$4 =o&#/9>???9 %-,$ BJC! F#$ /-' .-//$4 )&( "#$ 0-/$ &) HJr &) $-.# *14:0"(8 "#(&:,# - .&5E%$"*"*7$ 2*44*1, %(&.$00c A?r &) "#$ ($5-*14$( '-0 -//&.-"$4 "& - 1-"*&1-/ %$10*&10080"$5 -14 >r "& $5%/&8$$0 &) "#$ )&(5$( 0"-"$E&'1$4 )*(50! O0 o&#/ =MJJMC 1&"$09%(*&( "& .-%*"-/*3-"*&19 "#$0$ 0"-"$ )*(50 -..&:1"$4 )&( 0&5$ eJr &) 0"-"$ ($7$1:$09'*"# A@r .&5*1, )(&5 &*/ -14 ,-0 -/&1$! g*6$ 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 "#(&:,# "#$ gGG9"#$ g-' &) R-%*"-/*3-"*&1 .&1"(*2:"$4 "& -1 $1-2/*1, *10"*":"*&1-/ )(-5$'&(6 "#-"#-0 )-.*/*"-"$4 "#$ %(*7-"*3-"*&1 &) 0&5$ '-"$( 0$(7*.$0 -14 )&($0" ($0&:(.$0 -14 #-0$1.&:(-,$4 )&($*,1 *17$0"5$1" *1 5*1*1, -14 -,(*.:/":($! K" #-0 -/0& %(*&(*"*3$4 *17$0"E5$1" %-""$(10 -14 -00&.*-"$4 $.&1&5*. -."*7*"*$09 0:.# -0 0&82$-1 %(&4:."*&1 %(&5&"$428 "#$ h&(/4 <-169 "#-" #-7$ -..$/$(-"$4 ./$-(-1.$ &) "(&%*.-/ )&($0"0 =o-*5&'*"3 $" -/9>???C! T*,1*)*.-1"/89 '-"$(E5-(6$"*1, $))&("0k0:.# -0 "#$ %(*7-"*3-"*&1 &) :(2-1 '-"$(0$(7*.$ *1 g- G-3 -14 \/ O/"&9 "#$ $))&("0 "& %(*7-"*3$ '-"$( *1 R&.#-2-52- -14 $+%&("*" )(&5 0&:"#$(1 G&"&0UV k'$($ ),. .-((*$4 :14$( "#$ g-' &) R-%*"-/*3-"*&19 2:" (-"#$('$($ %(&5&"$4 2&"# 28 "#$ h&(/4 <-16 -14 28 %(*7-"$ .-%*"-/ :14$( "#$ /&,*. &)5-(6$" /*2$(-/*3-"*&1 =[*4-/9 MJJIC! K1 <&/*7*- "#$ g-' &) R-%*"-/*3-"*&1 )&(50 "#$.$1"$(%*$.$ &) /*2$(-/*3*1, $))&("09 -14 %(&7*4$0 "#$ &(,-1*3-"*&1-/ -14 *10"*":"*&1-/($0"(:.":(*1, 1$.$00-(8 "& .-((8 *" &:"! F#:09 -/"#&:,# .-%*"-/*3-"*&1 4*4 1&" %(*7-"*3$1-":(-/ ($0&:(.$0 %$( 0$9 *" .&1"(*2:"$4 "& -14 #$/%$4 .&10&/*4-"$ -1 *10"*":"*&1-/ -14*4$&/&,*.-/ .&1"$+" *1 '#*.# ($0&:(.$ %(*7-"*3-"*&1 *0 $1.&:(-,$4 -14 )-.*/*"-"$4!

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u &3 \/01$(9 MJJJ9%-,$ >@eC! Y/&($0 =>??BC ($%&("0 "#-" 28 >?@?9 @H!Ir &) "#$ .&:1"(8;0 %(*7-"$/8 #$/4 /-140'$($ &'1$4 28 i:0" >!@r &) /-14#&/4$(0! F#$ >??e g-' &) "#$ D-"*&1-/ K10"*":"$ &)O,(-(*-1 ]$)&(5 =KD]O g-'C 0&:,#" "& .&(($." )&( "#$ )-*/:($0 &) "#$ >?HI -,(-(*-1($)&(5 28 .($-"*1, 5&($ $N:*"-2/$ /-14 4*0"(*2:"*&1 -14 (-"*&1-/*3*1, /-14 5-(6$"0 -14%(&%$("8 "*"/$9 )&.:0$4 %(*5-(*/8 *1 "#$ $-0"$(1 /&'/-140! K5%&("-1"/89 #&'$7$(9 "#$KD]O g-' *0 '#-" #-0 2$$1 ($)$(($4 "& -0 - Q0$.&14 ,$1$(-"*&1; ($)&(59 *1 "#-" *"'-0 %-00$4 -)"$( -14 *0 0:20:5$4 :14$( "#$ gGG9 -//&'*1, 0:20$N:$1" /-14 ($)&(50"& 2$ .-((*$4 &:" *1 - 4$.$1"(-/*3$4 5-11$( =X:1u &3 \/01$(9 MJJJ9 %-,$ >@BC! F#:09:14$( 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&19 5:1*.*%*&0 -4i:4*.-"$ /-14 4*0%:"$0 -14 "*"/*1, =%($7*&:0/8 "#$($0%&10*2*/*"8 &) 4$%-("5$1"-/ ,&7$(15$1"0C9 -0 '$// -0 4$7$/&%5$1" -14 5-1-,$5$1"&) 1$' 5*.(&E*((*,-"*&1 %(&i$."0 =0$$ 2$/&'C9 ,(-1"*1, /&.-/ ,&7$(15$1"0 -:"#&(*"8 &7$(0:((&:14*1, (:(-/ .&55:1*"*$09 /-1409 -14 ($0&:(.$0! K1 "#*0 0$10$9 "#$19 "#$ KD]Og-' *0 ):1."*&1-/ "& <&/*7*-1 1$&/*2$(-/*05 *1 "#-" *" ./-(*)*$0 -14 ($0.-/$0 /-14E"$1:($($/-"*&109 "#$($28 0"-2*/*3*1, .&14*"*&10 )&( -..:5:/-"*&1! g-14 -14 '-"$( 5-1-,$5$1"9:14$( "#$ KD]O g-'9 '-0 "& .&10&/*4-"$9 -14 2$ ($0%&10*7$ "&9 /&.-/ ,&7$(1-1.$!

O0 o&#/ =>???C %&*1"0 &:"9 "#$ KD]O g-' *//:0"(-"$0 '$// "#$ 0&.*-/ .&1"(-4*."*&10*1#$($1" *1 T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4-;0 ($)&(50! F#$ /-' $+"$140 /-14 (*,#"0 )&( .-5%$0*1&-14 *14*,$1&:0 ,(&:%0 28 $+$5%"*1, 0:20*0"$1.$ )-(5$(0 -14 *14*,$1&:0 .&55:1*"*$0)(&5 %(&%$("8 "-+9 -14 28 ,(-1"*1, /-14 "*"/$ "& $*,#" *14*,$1&:0 .&55:1*"*$0! K" -/0&

MBA F G$(($-:/"

Page 13: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

,:-(-1"$$0 '&5$1 $N:-/ (*,#"0 "& %(&%$("8 *1#$(*"-1.$ -14 &'1$(0#*%9 ($,-(4/$00 &) .*7*/0"-":0c 4$./-($0 "#-" &1/8 .-5%$0*1&09 *14*,$1&:0 ,(&:%09 -14 .&/&1*0"0 -($ $/*,*2/$ )&():":($ 4&1-"*&10 &) 0"-"$ /-14c -14 ($N:*($0 -2-14&1$4 /-140 "& ($7$(" "& 0"-"$ &'1$(0#*%!<:" -/"#&:,# 5-18 0:.# -0%$."0 &) "#$ KD]O g-' 5-8 N:*"$ (*,#"/8 2$ 7*$'$4 -0 0&.*-//8%(&,($00*7$9 *" -/0& ./-(*)*$0 -14 0$.:($0 %(&%$("8 (*,#"0 )&( /-(,$ /-14#&/4$(09 5-18 &)'#&5 -.N:*($4 "#$*( #&/4*1,0 "#(&:,# /$,-//8 N:$0"*&1-2/$ 5$-10 =S(*&0"$9 MJJIC! S14$("#$ KD]O g-'9 /-140 .-1 &1/8 2$ $+%(&%(*-"$4 -14 ($4*0"(*2:"$4 *1 .-0$0 &) -2-14&1E5$1"9 4$)*1$4 -0 "#$ )-*/:($ "& %-8 "-+$0! F#:09 /-(,$ /-14&'1$(0 5-8 0$.:($ "#$*(#&/4*1,0k$7$1 *1 .-0$0 &) 1&1:0$ -14 -20$1"$$*05k28 %-8*1, -11:-/ "-+$0 &) >r &)"#$ 4#'CD%44#44#& 7-/:$ &) "#$ /-14! G(&%$("8 -00$005$1" *0 2-0$4 &1 7-/:$0 ($%&("$4 28 "#$/-14#&/4$(0 "#$50$/7$09 .($-"*1, -1 $1&(5&:0 *1.$1"*7$ )&( :14$(($%&("*1, /-14 7-/:$=<&1*)-39 MJJ>c o&#/9 >???9 %-,$ @AC! K1 "#*0 '-89 "#$ KD]O g-' -00:($0 "#$ %$(0*0"$1.$ &)/-(,$ /-14#&/4*1,0 -14 "#$ .&1"*1:-1.$ &) *1$N:*"-2/$ /-14 4*0"(*2:"*&109 %-("*.:/-(/8 *1"#$ $-0"$(1 /&'/-140 =L($//-1-9 MJJ>C! F&,$"#$(9 "#$ KD]O g-'9 "#$ gGG -14 "#$ g-' &)R-%*"-/*3-"*&19 #-7$ #-4 0:2"/$ 2:" *5%&("-1" *5%/*.-"*&10 )&( "#$ ,&7$(1-1.$ &) (:(-/'-"$( *1 <&/*7*-9 "& '#*.# K 1&' ":(1!

9'$-4 :-#1$ 6-"-0161"# '"&1$ "1%4)+1$-4),6S14$( "#$ gGG "#$ ($)&(5$4 5:1*.*%-/ /-' $0"-2/*0#$0 "#-" 5:1*.*%*&0 -($ ($0%&10*2/$)&( "#$ $0"-2/*0#5$1" -14 5-*1"$1-1.$ &) 1$' 5*.(&E*((*,-"*&1 080"$509 -14 #-7$-:"#&(*"8 &7$( 0%(*1,0 -14 0"($-50 =Z&&,$14-5 -14 [-(,-09 >???2C! X:1*.*%*&0 -($($0%&10*2/$ )&( 5&1*"&(*1, -14 ($,:/-"*1, '-"$( N:-/*"89 "#&:,# 5&0" 5:1*.*%*&0#-7$ 1$*"#$( "#$ "#&(&:,# *17$1"&(*$0 &) *((*,-"*&1 080"$50 *1 "#$*( i:(*04*."*&1 1&("#$ "$.#1*.-/ &( )*1-1.*-/ '#$($'*"#-/ 1$.$00-(8 "& .-((8 &:" ($,:/-( 5&1*"&(*1,=Z&&,$14-5 -14 [-(,-09 >???-C! K1 )-."9 "#$ 1-":($ &) "#*0 i:(*04*."*&1 *0 N:$0"*&1-2/$!O("*./$ >Ie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i&(*"8 &) "#$0$ ./-*50 -($ 1&" /$,-//8 ($.&,1*3$4 28 "#$ 0"-"$ =<$..-(9 >???C!]-"#$(9 "#$ 0"-"$ ($.&,1*3$0 &1/8 "#$ /$,-/ (*,#"0 &) /-(,$ *((*,-"*&1 080"$509 )*1-1.$428 "(-101-"*&1-/ /$14$(0 &( "#$ 0"-"$ *"0$/)! F#:09 "#$($ *0 .&1):0*&1 -0 "& '#&0$*1"$($0"0 -($ ($%($0$1"$4 28 .:(($1" '-"$( /$,*0/-"*&19 -0 2&"# "(-101-"*&1-/ .-%*"-/-14 05-//#&/4$( %$-0-1"0 .-1 5-6$ =&)"$1 .&1)/*."*1,C ./-*50!

<&/*7*- #-0 1& 0*1,/$9 .&#$($1" 2&48 &) /-' "#-" ,&7$(10 '-"$( :0$! K10"$-49 '-"$( :0$*0 ,&7$(1$4 28 - 7-(*$"8 &) 1-"*&1-/ /-'0 .&7$(*1, &"#$( 0$."&(09 5&0" 1&"-2/8 5*1*1,9-,(*.:/":($9 *14:0"(89 -14 4(*16*1, '-"$( -14 0$'$(-,$9 -14 *0 "#:0 4(*7$1 5&($ 28.&5%$"*1, 4$5-140 -14 *1"$($0"0 "#-1 28 -18 .&#$($1" %&/*.8 )(-5$'&(6 =*1"$(7*$''*"# ($%($0$1"-"*7$ &) R$1"(& OaSO9 R&.#-2-52-9 IJ P:/8 MJJ>C! K1 T$%"$52$( >???"#$ <-13$( ,&7$(15$1" *5%/$5$1"$4 g-' MJM? =g$8 4$ O,:- G&"-2/$C ,&7$(1*1, '-"$(:0$! T:%%&("$4 -14 %(&5&"$4 28 "#$ h&(/4 <-169 "#$ <#: &# 0!"% /,.%8'# .($-"$4 -1-"*&1-/E/$7$/ T:%$(*1"$14$1" &) h-"$( -14 -//&'$4 )&( %(*7-"*3-"*&1 -14 .&1.$00*&10&) :(2-1 '-"$( 0:%%/*$09 0$" '-"$( "-(*))0 *1 4&//-(0 =(-"#$( "#-1 "#$ 1-"*&1-/ .:(($1.89"#$ 8,'+*+%),C! F#$ /-' %(&7*4$4 1& 5$.#-1*05 )&( %:2/*. *1%:"9 -14 )-*/$4 "& ($.&,1*3$*14*,$1&:0 -14 .-5%$0*1& '-"$( (*,#"0! K1 ($0%&10$ "& R&.#-2-52-;0 '-"$( '-( -14-00&.*-"$4 %(&"$0"0 $/0$'#$($ *1 "#$ .&:1"(89 *1 O%(*/ MJJJ "#$ ,&7$(15$1" N:*.6/8 %-00$4g-' MJee9 0:%$(0$4*1, "#$ g$8 4$ O,:- G&"-2/$! S14$( "#$ 1$' /-'9 "#$ T:%$(*1"$14$1"&) h-"$( #-0 2$$1 .#-1,$4 "& "#$ T:%$(*1"$14$1" &) <-0*. T-1*"-"*&1 ='*"# -:"#&(*"8 &7$(4(*16*1, '-"$( -14 0$'$(-,$ &1/8C! F#$ %(*7-"*3-"*&1 &) :(2-1 '-"$( 0:%%/*$0 ($5-*10

T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14 "#$ 0.-/$ %&/*"*.0 &) (:(-/ '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- MBH

Page 14: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

- %&00*2*/*"89 2:" *0 1&" $+%/*.*"/8 %(&7*4$4 )&(c '-"$( "-(*))0 -($ 0$" *1 2&/*7*-1&0 '*"# - ./$-(5$.#-1*05 )&( %:2/*. *1%:"c -14 *14*,$1&:0 -14 .-5%$0*1& '-"$( (*,#"0 -($ ($.&,1*3$4 *1"#$ )&(5 &) - ($,*0"(8! O/"#&:,# )(&5 "#$ %$(0%$."*7$ &) %$-0-1" *((*,-"&(0 g-' MJee *0 -1*5%(&7$5$1" &7$( *"0 %($4$.$00&(9 *" ($5-*10 -1 *5%$()$." )(-5$'&(6 )&( ,&7$(1*1, '-"$(5-1-,$5$1"! F#$ 0"-"$;0 ,&-/ &) .($-"*1, - T:%$(*1"$14$1" &) h-"$( 0%-(6$4 )$-(0 "#-" -.$1"(-/*3$49 1-"*&1-/E/$7$/ -,$1.89 #$-4$4 28 - 0*1,/$ *14*7*4:-/9 '&:/4 )-7&( "#$ 4&5$0"*.-14 "(-101-"*&1-/ 5*1*1,9 $/$."(*.*"89 -14 $+%&(" -,(*.:/":(-/ *1"$($0"0 -" "#$ $+%$10$ &)%$-0-1" )-(5$(0! F#&:,# 0$$5*1,/8 .&1"(-4*."&(8 "& "#$ /&,*. &) -45*1*0"(-"*7$ 4$.$1"(-/E*3-"*&19 *1 <&/*7*- ($"-*1*1, .&1"(&/ &) '-"$( *1 - .$1"(-/*3$4 0"-"$ -,$1.8 085%-"#$"*. "&"#$ &2i$."*7$0 &) 1$&/*2$(-/*05 *0 ./$-(/8 "#$ $-0*$0" '-8 "& %(*7-"*3$ '-"$( ($0&:(.$09 -0#-%%$1$4 *1 g- G-3 -14 \/ O/"& *1 >??B9 -14 '-0 /-"$( -""$5%"$4 *1 R&.#-2-52- -14G&"&0UV !

g$,-/ .&1):0*&1 &7$( '-"$( (*,#"0 -14 i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k$0"-2/*0#$49 "(-4*"*&1-/%(-."*.$0 0%$.*)*. "& - %/-.$ -14 - 0&.*-/ ,(&:%k*0 4$(*7$4 )(&5 T%-1*0# .&/&1*-/ /-14-14 '-"$( /-'9 *"0 ($*10$("*&1 *1"& <&/*7*-1 %&/*"*.-/ -14 /$,-/ 4*0.&:(0$ .-1 2$ "(-.$4/-(,$/8 "& "#$ $-(/8 >??J09 '*"# "#$ 4:-/ %(&.$00$0 &) 1$&/*2$(-/ 0"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14*1.($-0*1, *14*,$1&:0q.-5%$0*1& %&/*"*.-/ 5&2*/*3-"*&1! F#$ .&1.$%" &) :0&0 8 .&0":5E2($0 *0 ($.&,1*3$4 2&"# 28 "#$ >??A R&10"*":"*&1 -14 "#$ >??e KD]O g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a:"*$V (($39 >???C! F#$ "$10*&1 *1#$($1" *1 "#$.&1.$%" &) :0&0 8 .&0":52($09 2$"'$$1 "#$*( "(-4*"*&1-/ .#-(-."$( -14 "#$*( 481-5*..&1"$5%&(-(8 1-":($9 5-6$0 "#$ .&1.$%" 2&"# *55$10$/8 %&'$():/ -14 4$$%/8 %(&2E/$5-"*.! F#$ /$,-/ -14 %&/*"*.-/ .#-//$1,$ )&( .-5%$0*1&0 -14 *14*,$1&:0 %$&%/$09 "#$19*0 "& )&(5-/*3$ .:0"&5-(8 :0$0 *1 0:.# - '-8 "#-" "#$8 '*// 2$ ($.&,1*3$4 /$,-//89 2:"'*// 0*5:/"-1$&:0/8 5-*1"-*1 "#$*( )/$+*2*/*"8 =*1"$(7*$' '*"# ($%($0$1"-"*7$ &) R$1"(&OaSO9 R&.#-2-52-9 >A W$.$52$( MJJMC!

!$$)0-#%$ 6%+)4)D-#)%" -"& #>1 C%4)#)(, %5 ,(-41 =IC

Y&( "#($$ 4-80 *1 P:/8 MJJ>9 *1 "#$ '-6$ &) R&.#-2-52-;0 '-"$( '-(9 &7$( >JJ($%($0$1"-"*7$0 &) 05-//#&/4$( *((*,-"*&1 -00&.*-"*&10 ,-"#$($4 *1 "#$ .*"8 &) L(:(&9&1 <&/*7*-;0 '*140'$%" O/"*%/-1&! K((*,-"&(0 '$($ -00*0"$4 /&,*0"*.-//8 28 - 1:52$( &)

=IC S1/$00 &"#$('*0$ *14*.-"$49 *1)&(5-"*&1 %($0$1"$4 *1 "#*0 0$."*&1 *0 2-0$4 &1 %-("*.*%-1"&20$(7-"*&1 -14 &%$1E$14$4 *1"$(7*$'0 .&14:."$4 '*"# *((*,-"&(09 -."*7*0"09 -14 0.#&/-(0 *1R&.#-2-52-9 g- G-39 -14 L(:(&9 <&/*7*- 4:(*1, - "&"-/ &) "#*("$$1 5&1"#0 &) )*$/4 ($0$-(.#2$"'$$1 MJJ> -14 MJJA!

MBe F G$(($-:/"

Page 15: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

<&/*7*-1 *1"$//$.":-/0 -14 1&1,&7$(15$1"-/ &(,-1*3-"*&10 =Da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cm*55$($(9 >??eC! K1 "#*0 5$$"*1,9 *((*,-"&(0 -14 "#$*( -//*$0 *1 .*7*/ 0&.*$"8 0&:,#" "&)&(5 - 1-"*&1-/E/$7$/ &(,-1*3-"*&1 *1 &(4$( "& .&:1"$( "#$0$ "#($-"0! O" "#$ #$-(" &)"#$0$ 4*0.:00*&10 '-0 "#$ 1$$4 "& ./-(*)8 "#$ '-80 "#-" '-"$( 5-1-,$5$1" *0 *10"*":E"*&1-/*3$4 *1 <&/*7*-_ "#$ &(,-1*3-"*&1-/ )&(50 -14 /$,-/ )(-5$'&(60 *17&/7$4 *1,&7$(1*1, -..$00 "& -14 5-1-,$5$1" &) '-"$( -149 .(:.*-//89 "#$ 0&.*&0%-"*-/ 0.-/$0-" '#*.# "#$0$ '&:/4 &%$(-"$! K1 %-("9 *((*,-"&(0; .&1.$(10 '$($ 2-0$4 *1 "#$ *10"*":E"*&1-/ .&1):0*&1 *1#$($1" *1 <&/*7*-1 '-"$( /-'! G$-0-1" *((*,-"&(0 #-7$ 1& ./$-( /$,-/&( *10"*":"*&1-/ )(-5$'&(6 *1 '#*.# "& 2-0$ "#$*( ./-*50 "& '-"$( (*,#"09 -14 )$-( "#$/&00 &) "#$*( .:0"&5-(8 (*,#"0 "& 5*1*1,9 *14:0"(*-/9 &( :(2-1 :0$0 '#&0$ .&5%$"*1,*1"$($0"0 -($ 5&($ ./$-(/8 4$)*1$4 /$,-//8! K1 -44*"*&1 "& /$,-/ .&1):0*&1 &7$( '-"$((*,#"09 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 #-0 .($-"$4 -1 *10"*":"*&1-/ 7&*4 *1 "#$ -($- &) $17*(&15$1"-/,&7$(1-1.$ -0 "#$($ *0 &)"$1 1& .&5%$"$1" 0"-"$ -:"#&(*"8 "& ,&7$(1 &( -(2*"(-"$4*0%:"$0! W$%-("5$1"-/ ,&7$(15$1"09 28%-00$4 *1 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 *1 )-7&( &) 5:1*.*E%*&09 -($ '$-6 -14 &)"$1 :1'*//*1, "& 5$4*-"$ ($0&:(.$ .&1)/*."0! X$-1'#*/$9 5:1*.*%*&0#-7$ &1/8 %-("*-/ -:"#&(*"8 &7$( (:(-/ '-"$( :0$9 -14 &)"$1 /-.6 2&"# "$.#1*.-/ $+%$("*0$-14 i:(*04*."*&1 &7$( *((*,-"*&1 4*0%:"$0 =<$..-(9 >???c Z&&,$14-5 -14 [-(,-09 >???2C!

K1 "#$ L(:(& 5$$"*1, *((*,-"&(0 $+%($00$4 - 0"(&1, 4*0"(:0" &) "#$ ,&7$(15$1";0%(&%&0$4 1-"*&1-/E/$7$/ 0:%$(*1"$14$1.8 &) '-"$(9 -14 -(,:$4 *10"$-4 )&( -1 *10"*":E"*&1-/ 0"(:.":($ "#-" '-0 5&($ /&.-/*3$49 4$.$1"(-/*3$49 -14 0$10*"*7$ "& =/&.-/C :0&0 8.&0":52($0! K1 &(4$( "& -.#*$7$ 0:.# 4$.$1"(-/*3$49 /&.-//8 2-0$4 '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$9#&'$7$(9 *((*,-"&(0 61$' "#-" "#$8 #-4 "& &(,-1*3$9 )&( "#$ )*(0" "*5$9 -" "#$ 1-"*&1-/0.-/$! K1 %/-.$ &) - T:%$(*1"$14$1" &) h-"$(9 *((*,-"&(0 %(&%&0$4 "#$ .($-"*&1 &) -E#$*+3+, ?%3+,)%' &# 0!"%4 =D-"*&1-/ h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k*1 "#$&(8 -" /$-0"k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

K1 D&7$52$( MJJI *((*,-"&(0 #$/4 "#$ Y*(0" D-"*&1-/ K((*,-"&(0; R&1,($00 *1 "#$ .*"8&) R&.#-2-52-! F#$ "#($$E4-8 $7$1" -,-*1 2(&:,#" "&,$"#$( *((*,-"&(0 )(&5 -.(&00 "#$.&:1"(8 =*1./:4*1, )&( "#$ )*(0" "*5$ - 4$/$,-"*&1 )(&5 "#$ O5-3&1*-1 %(&7*1.$ &)<$1*C! K((*,-"&(0 0%$1" "#$ )*(0" "'& 4-80 4$2-"*1, "#$ .&1./:0*&10 -14 %(&%&0-/0&) "#$ %($7*&:0 8$-(0; 5$$"*1,09 '*"# "#$ &2i$."*7$ &) $0"-2/*0#*1, "#$ &(,-1*3-"*&1;0

T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14 "#$ 0.-/$ %&/*"*.0 &) (:(-/ '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- MBB

Page 16: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

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h-"$( T80"$50C! F#$*1./:0*&1 &) .&55:1*"8E2-0$4 4(*16*1, '-"$( 080"$50 *1 "#$ "*"/$ *0 0*,1*)*.-1"9 -140*,1-/0 - ($.$1" .&1.$(1 &1 "#$ %-(" &) *((*,-"&(0 &7$( .#-1,*1, ,&7$(15$1" ($,:E/-"*&10 )&( (:(-/ 4(*16*1, '-"$( 0:%%/*$0! K1 %-("*.:/-(9 0"-"$ ($,:/-"*&1 &) 4(*16*1,'-"$(9 "&,$"#$( '*"# 0$."&(-/ 4$7$/&%5$1" %(&,(-50 ):14$4 28 "#$ K1"$(EO5$(*.-1W$7$/&%5$1" <-16 -14 "#$ a$(5-1 )&($*,1 -*4 0$(7*.$ aFm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aL09 *1 &(4$( "& ($.$*7$ /$,-/ 0"-":0!

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i:5%*1, 0.-/$0; "#(&:,# "#$ )&(5-"*&1 &)1-"*&1-/E/$7$/ %$-0-1" 1$"'&(60 =T5*"#9 >??MC9 -14 ($-00$("*1, "#$ /&.-/ "#(&:,# "#$ /$,-/-14 4*0.:(0*7$ :0$ &) :0&0 8 .&0":52($0 =R&+9 >??Bc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i$."*1, "#$ .&55&4*)*.-"*&1 &) '-"$(9 -14 4$5-14*1, ($.&,1*"*&1 &) '-"$( -0 -0&.*-/ ,&&4 -14 #:5-1 (*,#"! F#$0$ -(,:5$1"0 -%%$-/ "& "#$ %/:(*q5:/"* ($)&(50 &)"#$ >??A R&10"*":"*&19 -14 "#$*( ($.&,1*"*&1 &) *14*,$1&:0 -14 .-5%$0*1& .:/":(-/ -14($0&:(.$ (*,#"09 &) '#*.# :0&0 8 .&0":52($0 -($ - .$1"(-/ $/$5$1"! F#$0$ (*,#"09#&'$7$(9 -($ 4$0"-2*/*3$4 28 "#$ 1$&/*2$(-/*3-"*&1 &) -,(*.:/":(-/ -14 /-14 5-(6$"09- %(&.$00 "#-" :14$(5*1$0 "#$ -2*/*"8 &) %$-0-1" )-(5$(0 "& %:(0:$ "(-4*"*&1-//*7$/*#&&4 0"(-"$,*$0 =b-0#-(9 >???C! F#$ :1.$("-*1"8 &) (:(-/ '-"$( (*,#"0 )&( <&/*7*-1

MB@ F G$(($-:/"

Page 17: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

.-5%$0*1&0 -14 *14*,$1&:0 %$&%/$0 "#:0 $+$5%/*)*$0 "#$ 4&:2/$E$4,$4 1-":($ &)1$&/*2$(-/ 5:/"*.:/":(-/*059 '#*.#9 -0 Z-/$ =MJJMC 1&"$09 &))$(0 2&"# &%%&(":1*"8 -14%$(*/!

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a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

E%"(4',)%"]$0%&14*1, 2&"# "& "(-101-"*&1-/ *5%$(-"*7$0 &) $.&1&5*. /*2$(-/*3-"*&1 -14 0"-"$4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&19 -0 '$// -0 "& 1-"*&1-/ 4$5-140 "& /&&0$1 "#$ 0"-"$;0 #*,#/8 .$1"(-/*3$4%&/*"*.-/ 0"(:.":($9 <&/*7*-;0 1$&/*2$(-/ ,&7$(15$1"0 #-7$ (-4*.-//8 ($0"(:.":($4 "#$0"-"$! F#$ 0"-"$ 5-8 *1 "#*0 '-8 2$ 7*$'$4 -0 -""$5%"*1, "& &7$(.&5$ %&/*"*.-/ -14$.&1&5*. .(*0$0 28 ($0.-/*1, %&/*"*.-/ -45*1*0"(-"*&1 -14 $.&1&5*. ($,:/-"*&1! Y&(<&/*7*-k-0 )&( &"#$( g-"*1 O5$(*.-1 0"-"$0k"#*0 #-0 5$-1" ($0"(:.":(*1, *1 &(4$("& $1#-1.$ "#$ %&/*"*.-/ 0"-2*/*"8 -14 4$5&.(-"*. %-("*.*%-"*&1 1$.$00-(8 "& $1.&:(-,$)&($*,1 *17$0"5$1"! F#*0 *09 #&'$7$(9 -1 :10"-2/$ %(&.$00! O0 D$*/ <($11$( =>??@C1&"$09 "#$ "$10*&1 2$"'$$1 "#$ )*+*"8 -14 5&"*&1 &) .-%*"-/k-14 -00&.*-"$4 4$"$((*"&(*E-/*3-"*&1 -14 ($"$((*"&(*-/*3-"*&1 &) "#$ 0"-"$k*0 - ):14-5$1"-/ .&1"(-4*."*&1 &)1$&/*2$(-/*05! K1 <&/*7*- "#$ *1#$($1" *10"-2*/*"8 &) "#*0 %(&.$00 #-0 /$4 "& "#$ $5$(E,$1.$ &) 1$' )&(50 &) 0&.*-/ 5&2*/*3-"*&1 "#-" #-7$ .#-//$1,$4 "#$ 0"-"$;0 ($0.-/*1, &)$17*(&15$1"-/ ,&7$(1-1.$9 -14 #-7$ -""$5%"$4 "& ($%/-.$ *" '*"# 1$' -45*1*0"(-"*7$)&(50 -14 0.-/$0! T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4-;0 %-.6-,$ &) %&/*"*.-/ -14 $.&1&5*. ($0"(:.":(*1,'-0 -..&5%-1*$4 *1 >??A 28 .&10"*":"*&1-/ ($)&(50 '#*.#9 -5&1, &"#$( "#*1,09,(-1"$4 .$("-*1 .&//$."*7$ (*,#"0 "& *14*,$1&:0 %$&%/$9 -14 ($.&,1*3$4 <&/*7*- -0 -%/:(*.:/":(-/9 5:/"*$"#1*. 0"-"$ =Z$-/8 -14 G-:/0&19 MJJJc [-1 R&""9 MJJJc m*55$($(9MJJJ2C! <:" "#*0 .-((*$0 '*"# *" -1 *1#$($1" .&1"(-4*."*&1_ "#$ %/:(*q5:/"* /&,*. &)0"-"$ 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 *1 "#$ O14$09 -/"#&:,# 1$.$00-(8 "& &7$(.&5$ .(*0$0 *1 .-%*"-/-..:5:/-"*&1 s*1./:4*1, "#$ 1$$4 "& 4$):0$ -14 )(-,5$1" ./-00E2-0$4 &(,-1*3*1, =o&#/9MJJMCt9 -/0& .($-"$0 1$' "$((*"&(*-/ -14 0&.*&0%-"*-/ 2-0$0 )&( %&/*"*.-/ &(,-1*3*1,=O00*$09 MJJJC! \7$1 -0 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 :14$(.:"0 "#$ 2-0*0 )&( 1-"*&1-/E0.-/$ ./-00E2-0$4 &(,-1*3*1, *1 <&/*7*-k-0 $7*4$1.$4 28 "#$ 4$./*1$ &) "#$ <&/*7*-1 h&(6$(0;R$1"(-/ =RL<C9 &1.$ &1$ &) g-"*1 O5$(*.-;0 5&0" %&'$():/ /-2&( :1*&10 =R-//-9MJJJ-Ck*" %(&4:.$0 1$' 0%-.$0 -14 0.-/$0 )&( ,(-00(&&"0 &(,-1*3*1,9 /$-4*1, "& ,($-"$(.-5%$0*1& -14 *14*,$1&:0 %-("*.*%-"*&1 *1 $/$."&(-/ %&/*"*.09 -/2$*" &) - )(-,5$1"$4 -14)(-."*&:0 1-":($ =m*55$($(9 MJJJ2C! F#:09 '$ 0$$ *1 <&/*7*-1 1$&/*2$(-/*05 "#$ 0&("&) Q4&:2/$ 5&7$5$1"; &) .-%*"-/*05 *4$1"*)*$4 28 o-(/ G&/-18* =>?AAC_ '*"# "#$ *1"$10*E)8*1, *1"$,(-"*&1 &) .-%*"-/ *1"& 0&.*-/ ($/-"*&109 /*)$'-809 -14 /*7$/*#&&409 .&5$0 "#$%(&4:."*&1 &) .&14*"*&10 1$.$00-(8 "& ($0*0" "#$0$ 7$(8 %(&.$00$0!

T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14 "#$ 0.-/$ %&/*"*.0 &) (:(-/ '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- MB?

Page 18: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

F#$ %&"$1"*-/ )&( .&:1"$(#$,$5&1*. &(,-1*3*1,9 %-("*.:/-(/8 )(&5 '*"#*1 $"#1*.%&/*"*.0 -14 <&/*7*-;0 %/:(*q5:/"* 0"-"$ ($)&(509 5:0" 2$ 7*$'$4 .(*"*.-//89 #&'$7$(! O0T'81,$4&:' =MJJJ9 %-,$ eBC #-0 .-:"*&1$49 "#$ ($.$1" $5%#-0*0 &1 5:/"*.:/":(-/*"8-14 "#$ %&/*"*.0 &) *4$1"*"8 -14 4*))$($1.$ QQ*0 2:" "#$ &"#$( )-.$ &) "#$ ,/&2-/*0-"*&1%(&.$00;; "#-" 0*,1-/0 "#$ QQ(:"#/$00 .&/&1*0-"*&1 &) "#$ $7$(84-8 28 "#$ /&,*. &) "#$.&55&4*"8!;; T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, #-0 *14$$4 .($-"$4 1$'/8 *10"*":"*&1-/*3$4 )&(50 &)%&/*"*.-/ %-("*.*%-"*&1 )&( .-5%$0*1& -14 *14*,$1&:0 %$&%/$09 -0 *1 "#$ F<L0 -14&7$(0*,#" .&55*""$$0 $0"-2/*0#$4 :14$( "#$ gGG! K1 5-18 .-0$09 #&'$7$(9 "#$0$ #-7$%(&7*4$4 - 7$1$$( &) 4$5&.(-"*3-"*&1 '#*/$ 5:1*.*%-/*3-"*&1 #-0 0$(7$4 "& .&1.$1"(-"$%&'$( *1 "#$ #-140 &) /&.-/ $/*"$0 =R-//-9 MJJJ2c o&#/9 >???c 0$$ -/0& X&#-19 >??eC!X&($&7$(9 "#$ 1$'/8 $0"-2/*0#$4 5:1*.*%-/ 2&:14-(*$0 *1 0&5$ .-0$0 )(-,5$1" "(-4*"*&1-/*14*,$1&:0 "$((*"&(*$09 "#$($28 .&5%/*.-"*1, "#$ -2*/*"8 &) *14*,$1&:0 .&55:1*"*$0 "&%-("*.*%-"$ $))$."*7$/8 *1 "#$ 5-1-,$5$1" &) $*"#$( =<&1*)-39 MJJ>c L($//-1-9 MJJJC!K1 "#*0 0$10$9 1$&/*2$(-/*05 .*(.:50.(*2$0 "#$ %&/*"*.-/ -14 $.&1&5*. &%%&(":1*"*$0-7-*/-2/$ "& <&/*7*-;0 *14*,$1&:0 -14 .-5%$0*1& %$&%/$09 $7$1 -0 *" 5-6$0 0:.# &%$1E*1,0 %&00*2/$ =Z-/$9 MJJMC! O0 o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

K" *0 '*"#*1 "#*0 .&1"$+" "#-" *((*,-"&(0 #-7$ 2$,:1 "& 5&2*/*3$ 1-"*&1-//8 *1 4$)$10$&) "#$*( (*,#"0 "& '-"$( -14 /*7$/*#&&40! K1 ($0%&10$ "& ($.$1" $))&("0 "& %(*7-"*3$5:1*.*%-/ '-"$( 080"$509 -14 "#$ 0%$."$( &) 2:/6 '-"$( $+%&("0 -0 ($%($0$1"$4 28 "#$)*-0.& *1 G&"&0UV 9 *((*,-"&(0 #-7$ 0$$1 "#$ 1$.$00*"8 &) Qi:5%*1, 0.-/$0; -14 )&(5*1, -1-"*&1-/E/$7$/ &(,-1*3-"*&1 =T5*"#9 >??eC! ]$%($0$1"-"*7$0 &) *((*,-"&( -00&.*-"*&10"#(&:,#&:" "#$ O/"*%/-1& -14 #*,#/-14 7-//$80 #-7$ 2$,:1 5&2*/*3*1, ($,*&1-//8 -141-"*&1-//89 )&(5*1, 4$10$ 1$"'&(60 0"($".#*1, )(&5 /&.-/ .&55:1*"*$0 "& "(-101-"*&1-/DaL0! F#$ .$1"(-/ -*5 &) "#*0 5&2*/*3-"*&1 #-0 2$$1 "& )&(5 -1 &))*.*-//8 ($.&,1*3$41-"*&1-/E0.-/$ &(,-1*3-"*&1 "#-" '&:/4 0$(7$ -0 -1 -47&.-"$ )&( *((*,-"&(0; (*,#"09 -14.&:1"$( "#$ *1)/:$1.$ "#-" *14:0"(89 5:1*.*%-/9 -14 5*1*1, *1"$($0"0 -/($-48 $1i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i&(*"89 "#$($28 )*//*1, -7&*4 /$)" 28 - '$-6$1$4 /-2&( 5&7$5$1"! F#$ )&(5-"*&1 &) "(-10/&.-/ 1$"'&(60 /*16*1,%$-0-1" *((*,-"&(0 '*"# 1-"*&1-/ -14 *1"$(1-"*&1-/ DaL09 0.#&/-(09 -14 %&/*"*.-/ -."*E7*0"0 -//&'0 *((*,-"&(0 "& i:5% 0.-/$0 &(,-1*3-"*&1-//89 '#*/$ -00$("*1, "#$ *5%&("-1.$&) "#$ /&.-/! F#*0 %(&.$00 *0 2&/0"$($4 .&1.$%":-//8 28 "#$ 4*0.:(0*7$ -14 /$,-/ $5%#-0*0&1 :0&0 8 .&0":52($0 *1 /$,*"*5-"*1, %$-0-1" ./-*50 "& '-"$( (*,#"0! K1 "#*0 '-89%$-0-1" *((*,-"&(0 -($ .&1"$0"*1, "#$ ($($,:/-"*&1 &) 0"-"$ -14 5-(6$" *10"*":"*&10 :14$(1$&/*2$(-/*059 "#$($28 1$,&"*-"*1, "#$ ($0.-/*1, &) $17*(&15$1"-/ ,&7$(1-1.$!

K" ($5-*10 "& 2$ 0$$1 #&' 0:..$00):/ "#$0$ $))&("0 '*// 2$! O/"#&:,# *((*,-"&(0#-7$ 0:..$00)://8 )&(5$4 - 1-"*&1-/ &(,-1*3-"*&19 "#$*( *1"$($0"0 -14 ./-*50 -($&%%&0$4 28 1-"*&1-/ -14 *1"$(1-"*&1-/ $/*"$0 *1"$1" &1 ):("#$(*1, "#$ %(*7-"*3-"*&1

M@J F G$(($-:/"

Page 19: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

&) <&/*7*-1 ($0&:(.$0 -14 -47-1.*1, "#$ 1$&/*2$(-/ 5&4$/! F#$ i:,,$(1-:" &)#$5*0%#$(*. Q)($$ "(-4$; *0 (-%*4/8 2$-(*1, 4&'1 &1 "#$ <&/*7*-1 %$-0-1"(89 *1 "#$)&(5 &) "#$ Y($$ F(-4$ O($- &) "#$ O5$(*.-0! K" *09 #&'$7$(9 -0 ./$-( "& %$-0-1"*((*,-"&(0 -0 *" *0 "& *1"$(1-"*&1-/ .-%*"-/*0"0 "#-" "#$ 2-""/$0 &7$( ($0&:(.$0 -14/*7$/*#&&40 '*// *17&/7$ "#$ 1$,&"*-"*&1 &) "#$ *10"*":"*&1-/ -((-1,$5$1"0 "#(&:,#'#*.# 4$.*0*&10 &7$( $17*(&15$1"0 -($ "-6$19 -149 .(:.*-//89 "#$ 0.-/$0 -" '#*.# "#$0$4$.*0*&10 -($ $1-."$4!

*(F"%:41&0161"#,. F#*0 %-%$( *0 2-0$4 &1 ($0$-(.# ):14$4 28 "#$ W$%-("5$1" &) a$&,(-%#8 -14"#$ X-+'$// T.#&&/ &) R*"*3$10#*% -14 G:2/*. O))-*(0 -" T8(-.:0$ S1*7$(0*"89 -0 '$// -0 28 -Y:/2(*,#"EZ-80 Y-.:/"8 ]$0$-(.# Y$//&'0#*%! K -5 *14$2"$4 "& 58 <&/*7*-1 .&//$-,:$0 ]&.UV &<:0"-5-1"$ &) R$1"(& OaSO9 ]$1$V L($//-1- &) R\DWO9 -14 X-(UV - \0"#$( S4-$-"- &) RKGRO)&( "#$*( 6*14 -00*0"-1.$! K -5 -/0& ,(-"$):/ "& G-5 X-("*19 P-5*$ G$.69 -14 "#$ -1&185&:0($7*$'$(0 )&( "#$*( 7-/:-2/$ .&55$1"0 &1 -1 $-(/*$( 7$(0*&1 &) "#$ %-%$(! T%$.*-/ "#-160 -($&'$4 "& X0! X$(* G$(-/"- )&( #$( %-"*$1.$ -14 %$(0$7$(-1.$! G+,4 5%!%$%4")H+I

9151$1"(1,O/2&V p9 >??A9 QQO14 )(&5 o-"-(*0"-0 "& XD]*0"-0j F#$ 0:(%(*0*1, -14 2&/4 -//*-1.$ 2$"'$$1

O85-(-0 -14 1$&/*2$(-/0 *1 <&/*7*-;;9 *1 >)&+!#),"4 /#,5'#4 %)& G#-,3$%3: +) <%.+) 0-#$+3%\4! W g[-1 R&"" =T" X-("*1;0 G($009 D$' b&(6C %% HH f @>

O/2&V p9 >??? AF,.%4 #) #' /,&#$ <,3%'J ="%.$, 0)K ,4 G#45"#6 4 sG$-0-1"0; 0-14-/0 *1 /&.-/ %&'$(_)&:( 8$-(0 /-"$(t =RKGRO9 g- G-3C

O/2&V p9 MJJM /"#8',4 >)&+,4 #) '% /,'76 .+3% sK14*-1 %$&%/$0 *1 %&/*"*.0t =G/:(-/ \4*"&($09 g- G-3CO(4-8- ]9 F#$V 7&3 g9 MJJ>9 QQG(&5&"*1, %&%:/-( %-("*.*%-"*&1_ /$00&10 "& 2$ /$-(1$4 )(&5 "#$

<&/*7*-1 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 %(&.$00;; B,").%+) @#4#%$32 %)& G#*#',5-#). G2=IC M>H f MMJO00*$0 h9 MJJJ9 QQK14*,$1&:0 %$&%/$ -14 ($)&(5 &) "#$ 0"-"$ *1 g-"*1 O5$(*.-;;9 *1 12# =2%''#)!#

,C G+*#$4+.:J >)&+!#),"4 /#,5'# %)& @#C,$- ,C .2# E.%.# +) <%.+) 0-#$+3% \40 hO00*$09a 7-1 4$( Z--(9 O Z&$6$5- =F#$/- F#$0*09 O50"$(4-5C %% I f M>

<-66$( o9 MJJJ9 QQG(*7-"*3*1, '-"$(9 %(&4:.*1, 0.-(.*"8_ "#$ b&(60#*($ 4(&:,#" &) >??H;; (3,),-+3L#,!$%52: HI=>C A f MB

<-66$( o9 MJJM9 QQY(&5 0"-"$ "& 5-(6$"j_ '-"$( -#$3%).+'+9%3+,6 ) *1 T%-*1;; ()*+$,)-#). %)&/'%))+)! 0 JK BeB f B?J

<-(/&' X9 R/-(6$F9 MJJM9 QQh#& &'10 "#$ '-"$(j 12# ?%.+,) M T$%"$52$(9 @664$**AAA'6@17+6/:7'8:.*doc.mhtml?i = 20020902&s = barlow

<$..-( g9 >???9 QQO,:-0 %-(- (*$,& 8 .&5%$"$1.*-0 5:1*.*%-/$0;; sK((*,-"*&1 '-"$( -14 5:1*.*%-/-2*/*"*$0t9 *1 0!"%4 : B")+3+5+,4 sh-"$( -14 5:1*.*%-/*"*$0t \4! G Z&&,$14-5 =G\K]O[qG/:(-/ \4*"&($09 R&.#-2-52-C %% IB f HJ

;,'+*+% ;"''#.+) >?@?9 QQF#$ *1)&(5-/ $.&1&58;; K=AC ><&1*)-3 R ]9 MJJ>9 QQR&5$1"-(*&0 - /- %(&%:$0"- 4$ 5&4*)*.-.*&V 1 4$ /- g$8 KD]O %($0$1"-4-

%&( /- .&5:1-/ -/ %&4$( $i$.:"*7&;; sR&55$1"-(*$0 &1 "#$ %(&%&0-/ "& 5&4*)8 "#$ KD]O/-' %($0$1"$4 28 "#$ =ABM?0< "& "#$ $+$.:"*7$t 0$.76 3"', /$+-#$, L=?C B f Ie

<($11$( D9 >??@9 QQ<$"'$$1 )*+*"8 -14 5&"*&1_ -..:5:/-"*&19 "$((*"&(*-/ &(,-1*3-"*&1 -14 "#$#*0"&(*.-/ ,$&,(-%#8 &) 0%-"*-/ 0.-/$0;; ()*+$,)-#). %)& /'%))+)! GJ E,3+#.: %)& E5%3# 2IAH? f A@>

<($11$( D9 >???9 QQ<$8&14 0"-"$E.$1"(*05j T%-.$9 "$((*"&(*-/*"89 -14 ,$&,(-%#*.-/ 0.-/$ *1,/&2-/*3-"*&1 0":4*$0;; 12#,$: %)& E,3+#.: G@ I? f B@

<(*4,$ a9 MJJJ9 QQF#$ 0&.*-/ ($,:/-"*&1 &) ($0&:(.$ -..$00 -14 $17*(&15$1"-/ *5%-."_ %(&4:."*&191-":($ -14 .&1"(-4*."*&1 *1 "#$ ST .&%%$( *14:0"(8;; L#,C,$"- J2 MIB f MHe

<(*4,$ a9 P&1-0 O \ a9 MJJM9 QQa&7$(1*1, 1-":($_ "#$ ($($,:/-"*&1 &) ($0&:(.$ -..$009 %(&4:."*&19-14 .&10:5%"*&1;; ()*+$,)-#). %)& /'%))+)! 0 JK BH? f Bee

<(*4,$ a9 X.X-1:0 G9 MJJJ9QQT"*.60 -14 0"&1$0_ $17*(&15$1"-/ 1-((-"*7$0 -14 4*0.:(0*7$ ($,:/-"*&1*1 "#$ )&($0"(8 -14 5*1*1, 0$."&(0;;0).+5,&# JG >J f AB

<:0"-5-1"$ ]9 MJJM9 QQg$,*0/-.*&V 1 4$/ -,:- $1 <&/*7*-;; sh-"$( /$,*0/-"*&1 *1 <&/*7*-t9 *1 >)&+!#),"4N%.#$ @+!2.4O <,3%' N%.#$ B%)%!#-#).O %)& ?%.+,)%' <#!+4'%.+,) \4! ] <&$/$109 :1%:2/*0#$4($%&(" %($%-($4 )&( h-"$( g-' -14 K14*,$1&:0 ]*,#"0 =h-,$1*1,$1 S1*7$(0*"8qKh\ -14S1*"$4 D-"*&10qR\GOg9h-,$1*1,$19 F#$ D$"#$(/-140C

T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14 "#$ 0.-/$ %&/*"*.0 &) (:(-/ '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- M@>

Page 20: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

<:0"-5-1"$ ]9 a:"*$V (($39 m9 >???9 QQS0&0 8 .&0":52($0 $1 /- ,$0"*&V 1 4$ (*$,&_ .-&0 : &(4$1 $1 /-,$0"*&V 1 4$ -,:- %-(- (*$,&;; sR:0"&5-(8 :0$0 *1 "#$ 5-1-,$5$1" &) *((*,-"*&1_ .#-&0 &( &(4$(*1 "#$ 5-1-,$5$1" &) '-"$( )&( *((*,-"*&1t *1 0!"%4 : B")+3+5+,4 sh-"$( -14 5:1*.*%-/*"*$0t\4! G Z&&,$14-5 =G\K]O[qG/:(-/ \4*"&($09 R&.#-2-52-C %% >eI f >@@

R-//- ]9 MJJJ-9 QQg&0 0*14*.-/*05&0 2&/*7*-1&0 .&1"$5%&(-V 1$&0_ .(*0*0 8 0$.:14-(*3-.*&V 1 4$ :15&7*5*$1"& 0&.*-/ 4$0-("*.:/-4&;; sR&1"$5%&(-(8 <&/*7*-1 0*14*.-/*050_ .(*0*0 -14 /&00 &)*1)/:$1.$ &) - 4*0-("*.:/-"$4 0&.*-/ 5&7$5$1"t9 *1 <,4B,*+-+#).,4 E,3+%'#4 #) '%4 G#-,3$%3+%40)&+)%4 sT&.*-/ 5&7$5$1"0 *1 "#$ O14$-1 4$5&.(-.*$0t \40 P X-00-/9 X <&1*//- =YgORTL\.:-4&( f KY\O9 n:*"&C %% M>H f MMB

R-//- ]9 MJJJ29 QQK14*,$1&:0 %$&%/$9 "#$ /-' &) %&%:/-( %-("*.*%-"*&1 -14 .#-1,$0 *1 ,&7$(15$1"_<&/*7*-9 >??A f >??@;;9 *112# =2%''#)!# ,C G+*#$4+.:J >)&+!#),"4 /#,5'# %)& @#C,$- ,C .2# E.%.# +)<%.+) 0-#$+3% \40hO00*$09 a 7-1 4$( Z--(9 O Z&$6$5- =F#$/-F#$0*09 O50"$(4-5C %% BB f ?A

R$(18 G9>??H9QQa/&2-/*3-"*&1 -14 "#$ .#-1,*1, /&,*. &) .&//$."*7$ -."*&1;; >).#$)%.+,)%' A$!%)+9%.+,)KI H?H f eMH

R#-V 7$3 h9 MJJM9 QQn:*$($ 7$14$( $/ -,:- 4$ G&"&0UV - R#*/$;; sF#$8 '-1" "& 0$// G&"&0UV ;0 '-"$( "&R#*/$t (' P"!#.# @%8+,4, >B D&7$52$(9 %-,$ >

R#-V 7$3 h9 MJJI9 QQG$"$( X.Y-(($1 *0*0"$ $1 0: %(&8$."&_ $/ -,:- 4$ G&"&0UV %-(- /&0 .#*/$1&0;;sG$"$( X.Y-(($1 *10*0"0 &1 #*0 %(&i$."_ G&0"&0UV ;0 '-"$( )&( "#$ R#*/$-10t (' P"!"#.# @%8+,4,B W$.$52$(9 %-,$ >>

R&1-,#-1 R X9 X-//&8 P X9 O2:,-""-0 g O9 >??J9 QQ<:0*1$00 -14 "#$ Q2&80;_ "#$ %&/*"*.0 &)1$&/*2$(-/*05 *1 "#$ R$1"(-/ O14$0;; <%.+) 0-#$+3%) @#4#%$32 @#*+#Q GL=MC I f IJ

R&+ o ] =\4!C9 >??B E5%3#4 ,C L',8%'+9%.+,)J @#%44#$.+)! .2# /,Q#$ ,C .2# <,3%' =a:*/)&(4 G($009D$' b&(6C

W$55$(0 P9 Y$(1-V 14$3 P*/2$("& O \9 Z&,$12&&5 <9 MJJ>9 QQF#$ "(-10)&(5-"*&1 &) g-"*1 O5$(*.-1%&%:/*05_ ($,*&1-/ -14 ,/&2-/ 4*5$10*&10;;9 *1 B+$%3"',"4 B#.%-,$52,4#4J 12# ?#,'+8#$%'+9%.+,),C <%.+) 0-#$+3%) /,5"'+4- \40 P W$55$(09 O \ Y$(1-V 14$3 P*/2$("&9 < Z&,$12&&5 =m$4<&&609 g&14&1C %% > f M>

\0.&2-( O9 MJJ>9 QQR:/":($ 0*"0 *1 %/-.$0_ ($)/$."*&10 &1 ,/&2-/*05 -14 0:2-/"$(1 0"(-"$,*$0 &)/&.-/*3-"*&1;; /,'+.+3%' L#,!$%52: GA >I? f >BA

Y-("#*1, g9 >??>9 QQF#$ 1$' :14$(,(&:14;; ?0=<0 @#5,$. ,) .2# 0-#$+3%4 GL=>C >@ f MIY-("#*1, g9 o&#/ <9 MJJ>9 QQ<&/*7*-;0 1$' '-7$ &) %(&"$0";; ?0=<0 @#5,$. ,) .2# 0-#$+3%4 JK=HC

@ f >>Y*11$,-1 h9 MJJM9 QQg$-0*1, "#$ (-*1;; 12# ?#QR,$H#$ H@=BC9 @ O%(*/9 %% AI f HIY/&($0 a9 >??B9 QQvT$,:14- ($)&(5- -,(-(*-j;; sT$.&14 -,(-(*-1 ($)&(5jt /$,=%-5, HH B f >IY/811 O9 X-(04$1 F o9 >??H9 QQ]:(-/ .#-1,$9 ($,:/-"*&1 -14 0:0"-*1-2*/*"8;; ()*+$,)-#). %)&

/'%))+)! 0 GH >>@J f >>?Ma-(.UV - O9 a-(.UV - Y9 n:*"&V 1 g9 MJJI <% SL"#$$% &#' 0!"%T08$+' &# UVVVJ <% =$+4+4 &# '% /,'76 .+3%

#) ;,'+*+% sF#$ Q'-"$( '-(;O%(*/ MJJJ_ %&/*"*.-/ .(*0*0 *1 <&/*7*-t =GK\<9 g- G-3Ca/-005-1 P9 >???9 QQT"-"$ %&'$( 2$8&14 "#$ Q"$((*"&(*-/ "(-%;_ "#$ *1"$(1-"*&1-/*3-"*&1 &) "#$ 0"-"$;;

/,'+.+3%' L#,!$%52: 2@ ee? f e?eZ-/$ R ]9 MJJM9 QQW&$0 5:/"*.:/":(-/*05 5$1-.$j a&7$(1-1.$9 .:/":(-/ (*,#"0 -14 "#$ %&/*"*.0 &)

*4$1"*"8 *1 a:-"$5-/-;; P,"$)%' ,C <%.+) 0-#$+3%) E."&+#4 JK A@H f HMAZ-(%$( R g9 MJJ>()*+$,)-#). %)& E,3+#.:J W"-%) /#$45#3.+*#4 ,) ()*+$,)-#).%' >44"#4 =G($1"*.$E

Z-//9 S%%$( T-44/$ ]*7$(9 DPCZ-(7$8 W9 >?BA9 QQG&%:/-"*&19 ($0&:(.$0 -14 "#$ *4$&/&,8 &) 0.*$1.$;; (3,),-+3 L#,!$%52: LA=IC

MHe f MBBZ-:,#"&1 a9 >??@9 QQG(*7-"$ %(&)*"0k%:2/*. 4(&:,#"_ "#$ .($-"*&1 &) - .(*0*0 *1 '-"$( 5-1-,$5$1"

)&( h$0" b&(60#*($;; 1$%)4%3.+,) ,C .2# >)4.+.".# ,C ;$+.+42 L#,!$%52#$4O ?#Q E#$+#4 GJ A>? f AIIZ-:,#"&1 a9 MJJM9 QQX-(6$" 5-6*1,_ *1"$(1-"*&1-/*3-"*&1 -14 ,/&2-/ '-"$( 5-(6$"0;; ()*+$,)-#).

%)& /'%))+)! 0 JK B?> f @JBZ$-/8 o9 MJJ><'%-%4ON#%*+)!4O %)& A$!%)+3 =2,3,'%.#J B"'.+3"'."$%' L$%44$,,.4 G#*#',5-#).

+) .2# 0)&#4 %)& 0-%9,) ,C ;,'+*+% =S1*7$(0*"8 &) D&"($ W-5$ G($009 T&:"# <$149 KDCZ$-/8 o9 G-:/0&1 G9 MJJJ9 QQG&/*"*.-/ $.&1&5*$0 &) *4$1"*"8 *1 <&/*7*- >?HM f >??@;; 12# P,"$)%' ,C

<%.+) 0-#$+3%) 0).2$,5,',!: L=MC M f M?Z$(0#2$(, \9 MJJI9 QQg-"*1 O5$(*.- -" - .(&00(&-40;; ?0=<0 @#5,$. ,) .2# 0-#$+3%4 JH=IC MJ f MIZ&&,$14-5 G9[-(,-0 a9 >???-9 QQR&1"*1:*4-4$0 8 4*0.&1"*1:*4-4$0 $1 /- ,$0"*&V 1 4$ -,:-

4$0%:$V 0 4$ /- *5%/$5$1"-.*&V 1 4$/ 1:$7& 5-(.& /$,-/;; sR&1"*1:*"*$0 -14 4*0.&1"*1:*"*$0 *1"#$ 5-1-,$5$1" &) '-"$( -)"$( "#$ *5%/$5$1"-"*&1 &) "#$ 1$' /$,-/ )(-5$'&(6t9 *1 0!"%4: B")+3+5+,4 sh-"$( -14 5:1*.*%-/*"*$0t \4! G Z&&,$14-5 =G\K]O[qG/:(-/ \4*"&($09R&.#-2-52-C %% >H> f >e>

M@M F G$(($-:/"

Page 21: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

Z&&,$14-5 G9[-(,-0 a9 >???29 QQg- .&5%/$i- ($/-.*&V 1 $1"($ 5:1*.*%-/*3-.*&V 19 ,&2$(1-2*/*4-48 /- ,$0"*&V 1 4$ -,:-;; sF#$ .&5%/$+ ($/-"*&10#*% 2$"'$$1 5:1*.*%-/*3-"*&19 ,&7$(1-1.$9 -14'-"$( 5-1-,$5$1"t9 *1 0!"%4 : B")+3+5+,4 sh-"$( -14 5:1*.*%-/*"*$0t \4! G Z&&,$14-5=G\K]O[qG/:(-/ \4*"&($09 R&.#-2-52-C %% M> f IH

P$00&% <9 >??J E.%.# 12#,$:J /"..+)! .2# =%5+.%'+4. E.%.# +) +.4 /'%3# =G&/*"8 G($009 R-52(*4,$Co-*5&'*"3 W9 F#*$/$ a9 G-.#$.& G9 >???9 QQF#$ $))$."0 &) 0"(:.":(-/ -4i:0"5$1" &1 4$)&($0"-"*&1

-14 )&($0" 4$,(-4-"*&1 *1 /&'/-14 <&/*7*-;; N,$'& G#*#',5-#). GH HJH f HMJo/$*1 Z T9 >??M ;,'+*+%J 12# (*,'".+,) ,C % B"'.+D#.2)+3 E,3+#.: M14 $4*"*&1 =L+)&(4 S1*7$(0*"8

G($009 D$' b&(6Co&#/ < Z9 >???9 QQ\.&1&5*. -14 %&/*"*.-/ ($0"(:.":(*1, *1 <&/*7*-_ "&&/0 )&( - 1$&/*2$(-/ -,$14-j;;

G#W 4*00$("-"*&19 R&(1$// S1*7$(0*"89 K"#-.-9 Dbo&#/ <9 MJJM9 QQT"-2*/*3*1, 1$&/*2$(-/*05 *1 <&/*7*-_ %&%:/-( %-("*.*%-"*&1 -14 %(*7-"*3-"*&1;;

/,'+.+3%' L#,!$%52: G2 AA? f ABMX-.g$&4 a9 a&&4'*1 X9 >???9 QQT%-.$9 0.-/$ -14 0"-"$ 0"(-"$,8_ ($"#*16*1, :(2-1 -14 ($,*&1-/

,&7$(1-1.$;; /$,!$#44 +) W"-%) L#,!$%52: GJ HJI f HMBX-(7*1 T9 g-:(*$ D9 >???9 QQO1 $5$(,*1, /&,*. &) :(2-1 '-"$( 5-1-,$5$1"9 R&.#-2-52-9 <&/*7*-;;

M$8%) E."&+#4 JI IA> f IHBXD]EX]Fog9 >??I /'%) &# 1,&,4 =a&7$(15$1" &) <&/*7*-9 g- G-3CX&#-1 a9 >??e9 QQO4i:0"5$1" -14 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 *1 a#-1-_ - .-0$ &) 4*5*1*0#$4 0&7$($*,1"8;;

/,'+.+3%' L#,!$%52: 2L=>C BH f ?AX:1u &3 \/01$( W9 MJJJ /,'76 .+3%4 /"8'+3%4 : 0!$+3"'."$% =%-5#4+)%J ()3"#).$,4 : G#4#)3"#).$,4

sG:2/*. %&/*.*$0 -14 %$-0-1" -,(*.:/":($_ $1.&:1"$(0 -14 4*0$1.&:1"$(0t =G/:(-/ \4*"&($09g- G-3C

D*.60&1 O9[-(,-0 R9 MJJM9 QQF#$ /*5*"-"*&10 &) '-"$( ($,:/-"*&1_ "#$ )-*/:($ &) "#$ R&.#-2-52-.&1.$00*&1 *1 <&/*7*-;; ;"''#.+) ,C <%.+) 0-#$+3%) @#4#%$32 G2=>C ?? f >MJ

L($//-1- ]9 >???9 QQ]$E%$10-14& %(&%&0*.*&1$0 8 .&1.$%"&0 0&2($ $/ 4$($.#& .&10:$":4*1-(*&;;s]$"#*16*1, %(&%&0-/0 -14 .&1.$%"0 &) .:0"&5-(8 /-'t 0$.76 3"', /$+-#$, J=BC A> f HA

L($//-1- ]9 MJJJ9 QQX:1*.*%-/*3-"*&1 -14 *14*,$1&:0 %$&%/$0 *1 <&/*7*-_ *5%-."0 -14 %$(0%$."*7$0;;9*1 12# =2%''#)!# ,C G+*#$4+.:J >)&+!#),"4 /#,5'# %)& @#C,$- ,C .2# E.%.# +) <%.+) 0-#$+3%\40 hO00*$09 a 7-1 4$( Z--(9 O Z&$6$5- =F#$/- F#$0*09 O50"$(4-5C %% >@> f >?A

L($//-1- ]9 MJJ>9 QQG(&%:$0"- 4$ 5&4*)*.-.*&V 1 4$ g$8 KD]O;; sG(&%&0-/ )&( "#$ 5&4*)*.-"*&1 &)"#$ KD]O /-'t 0$.76 3"', /$+-#$, L=?C IB f eB

G$(($-:/" F9 MJJI9 QQR#-1,*1, %/-.$0_ "(-101-"*&1-/ 1$"'&(609 $"#1*. %&/*"*.09 -14 .&55:1*"84$7$/&%5$1" *1 "#$ \.:-4&(*-1 O5-3&1;; /,'+.+3%' L#,!$%52: GG=>C e> f @@

G&/-18* o9 >?AA 12# L$#%. 1$%)4C,$-%.+,) =Y-((-( -14 ]*1$#-("9 D$' b&(6C]&14*1$//* W O9 X.R://&:,# P T9 P&#10&1 ] h9 >?@?9 QQO1-/80*1, 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1 %&/*.*$0 *1

4$7$/&%*1, .&:1"(*$0_ - %&/*"*.-/E$.&1&58 )(-5$'&(6;;G#*#',5-#). %)& =2%)!# GA HB f @BT-.#0 P9 >?@B9 QQF#$ <&/*7*-1 #8%$(*1)/-"*&1 -14 0"-2*/*3-"*&1;;0-#$+3%) (3,),-+3 @#*+#Q HH=MC

MB? f M@IT-.#0 P9 g-((-*1 Y9>??IB%3$,#3,),-+34 +) % L',8%' (3,),-: =G($1"*.$EZ-//9 \1,/$'&&4R/*))09 DPCT-1-2(*- Z9 >???9 QQR&10&/*4-"*1, 0"-"$09 ($0"(:.":(*1, $.&1&5*$09 -14 .&1)(&1"*1, '&(6$(0 -14

%$-0-1"0_ "#$ -1"*1&5*$0 &) <&/*7*-1 1$&/*2$(-/*05;;=,-5%$%.+*# E."&+#4 +) E,3+#.: %)& W+4.,$:K2 HIH f HeM

T-1-2(*- Z9 MJJJ9 QQ]$0*0"-1.$ -14 "#$ -("0 &) 4&5*1-"*&1_ 5*1$(0 -14 "#$ <&/*7*-1 0"-"$;; <%.+)0-#$+3%) /#$45#3.+*#4 GH=>C He f @>

T-V 1.#$3 4$ g&3-4- a9 >?@H9 QQg- 1:$7- %&/UV "*.- $.&1&V 5*.-;; sF#$ 1$' %&/*"*.-/ $.&1&58t X,$,(3,),6 -+3, L e

T.#:/"3 P9 MJJI9 QQ<&/*7*-_ "#$ '-"$( '-( '*4$10;; ?0=<0 @#5,$. ,) .2# 0-#$+3%4 JI=AC IA f IBT/-"$( W9 >?@?9 QQF$((*"&(*-/ %&'$( -14 "#$ %$(*%#$(-/ 0"-"$_ "#$ *00:$ &) 4$.$1"(-/*3-"*&1;;

G#*#',5-#). %)& =2%)!# GA HJ> f HI>T5*"# D9 >??M9 QQa$&,(-%#89 4*))$($1.$9 -14 "#$ %&/*"*.0 &) 0.-/$;;9 *1 /,4.-,&#$)+4- %)& .2# E,3+%'

E3+#)3#4 \40 P W&#$("89 \ a(-#-59 X X-/$6 =T" X-("*1;0 G($009 D$' b&(6C %% HB f B?T5*"# D9 >??e9 QQT%-.$0 &) 7:/1$(-2*/*"8_ "#$ 0%-.$0 &) )/&'0 -14 "#$ %&/*"*.0 &) 0.-/$;; =$+.+Y"# ,C

0).2$,5,',!: 2I=>C eI f BBTDGGEWDYR9 >??B G+%!),6 4.+3, &# '% E+."%3+,6 ) &# A$!%)+9%3+,)#4 1#$$+.,$+%'#4 &# ;%4#O =,-+.#6 4

&# Z+!+'%)3+%O 04,3+%3+,)#4 =,-")+.%$+%4 : <+4.%&, &# A$!%)+9%3+,)#4 X")3+,)%'#4 sW*-,1&0"*.&) "#$ .&14*"*&1 &) "$((*"&(*-/ 2-0$ &(,-1*3-"*&109 &7$(0*,#" .&55*""$$09 .&55:1-/ -00&.*-"*&10-14 /*0"$4 ):1."*&1-/ &(,-1*3-"*&10t =TDGG9 g- G-3C

T"-"$ ($0"(:.":(*1, -14 "#$ 0.-/$ %&/*"*.0 &) (:(-/ '-"$( ,&7$(1-1.$ *1 <&/*7*- M@I

Page 22: Perreault, T., 2005. State restructuring and the scale politics of rural

T'81,$4&:' \9 >??B-9 QQD$*"#$( ,/&2-/ 1&( /&.-/_ Q,/&.-/*3-"*&1; -14 "#$ %&/*"*.0 &) 0.-/$;;9 *1 E5%3#4,C L',8%'+9%.+,)J @#%44#$.+)! .2# /,Q#$ ,C .2# <,3%' \4! o ] R&+ =a:*/)&(4 G($009 D$' b&(6C%% >IB f >ee

T'81,$4&:' \9 >??B29 QQG&'$(9 1-":($9 -14 "#$ .*"8_ F#$ .&1N:$0" &) '-"$( -14 "#$ %&/*"*.-/ $.&/&,8&) :(2-1*3-"*&1 *1 a:-8-N:*/9 \.:-4&(9 >@@J f >??J;; ()*+$,)-#). %)& /'%))+)! 0 G? I>> f IIM

T'81,$4&:' \9 MJJJ9QQO:"#&(*"-(*-1 ,&7$(1-1.$9 %&'$(9 -14 "#$ %&/*"*.0 &) ($0.-/*1,;;()*+$,)-#).%)& /'%))+)! GJ E,3+#.: %)& E5%3# 2@ eI f Be

12# (3,),-+4. MJJM9 QQF(&:2/$4 '-"$(0;;9 >A W$.$52$(9 %% IM f IIF*.6$// O9 G$.6 P O9 >??H9 QQT&.*-/ ($,:/-"*&1 %C.#$ Y&(4*05_ ($,:/-"*&1 "#$&(89 1$&E/*2$(-/*05

-14 "#$ ,/&2-/ f /&.-/ 1$+:0;; (3,),-: %)& E,3+#.: GK IHB f I@eS(*&0"$ X9 MJJI9 QQ]$&(*$1"-( /- ($)&(5- -,(-(*-;; s]$4*($." "#$ -,(-(*-1 ($)&(5t <# B,)&#

G+5',-%.+Y"# =<&/*7*-1 $4*"*&1C 2=>>C =O:,:0"C A f H[-1 R&"" W g9 MJJJ 12# X$+#)&': <+Y"+&%.+,) ,C .2# /%4.J12# /,'+.+34 ,C G+*#$4+.: +) <%.+) 0-#$+3%;;

=S1*7$(0*"8 &) G*""02:(,# G($009 G*""02:(,#9 GOC[-1W-55$ G9 MJJM9QQW*0%&1*2*/*4-49 :0& 8 .-/*4-4 4$ /&0 ($.:(0&0 #UV 4(*.&0 $1 <&/*7*-;; =-7-*/-2*/*"89

:0$9 -14 N:-/*"8 &) '-"$( ($0&:(.$0 *1 <&/*7*-C9 :1%:2/*0#$4 ($%&(" )&( "#$ R&5*0*&V 1 %-(- /-a$0"*&V 1 K1"$,(-/ 4$/ O,:- $1 <&/*7*-9 @664$**AAA'+B;+9:0/?/+':5B*

[*4-/ P9 MJJI9 QQO// 4(*$4 :%;; 12# L"%$&+%)N##H': MB X-(.# f M O%(*/9 %-,$ MAb-0#-( W P9 >???9 QQW$5&.(-.89 *14*,$1&:0 5&7$5$1"09 -14 "#$ %&0"/*2$(-/ .#-//$1,$ *1 g-"*1

O5$(*.-;; N,$'& /,'+.+34 LG Be f >JAm$2-//&0 Z:("-4& Z9 n:*(&,- R($0%& \9 MJJI /,'76 .+3% : (3,),-76 % &# ',4 @#3"$4,4 ?%."$%'#4

@#),*%8'#4 #) ;,'+*+% sG&/*"*.0 -14 $.&1&5*.0 &) ($1$'-2/$ 1-":(-/ ($0&:(.$0 *1 <&/*7*-t=G/:(-/9 g- G-3C

m*55$($( o9 >??e9 QQW*0.&:(0$0 &1 0&*/ /&00 *1 <&/*7*-_ 0:0"-*1-2*/*"8 -14 "#$ 0$-(.# )&(0&.*&$17*(&15$1"-/ Q5*44/$ ,(&:14; ;;9 *1 <+8#$%.+,) (3,',!+#4 \40 ] G$$"9 X h-""0=]&:"/$4,$9 D$' b&(6C %% >>J f >MA

m*55$($( o9 MJJJ-9 QQ]$0.-/*1, *((*,-"*&1 *1 g-"*1 O5$(*.-_ "#$ .:/":(-/ *5-,$0 -14 %&/*"*.-/$.&/&,8 &) '-"$( ($0&:(.$0;; (3"-#)# H=MC >HJ f >BH

m*55$($( o9 MJJJ29 QQR&55$1"-(8_ 0&.*-/ 0.*$1.$ *1"$//$.":-/09 0:0"-*1-2/$ 4$7$/&%5$1" -14 "#$%&/*"*.-/ $.&1&5*$0 &) <&/*7*-;; P,"$)%' ,C <%.+) 0-#$+3%) 0).2$,5,',!: L=MC >B? f >@?

w MJJH - G*&1 %:2/*.-"*&1 %(*1"$4 *1 a($-" <(*"-*1

M@A F G$(($-:/"


Top Related