RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
1
Global trends in business service movements: the role of East Central Europe with special
emphasis on related methodological problems
Magdolna SassInstitute of Economics of the Hungarian
Academy of Sciences and ICEG EC
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
2
Outline of the presentation
1. BPO, East Central Europe/Hungary: new hosts
2. Methodological problems
3. Location advantages
4. Impact on the local economy
5. Relocation
6. ConclusionResearch on BPO in ECE is based on company interviews
Work in progress
Presentation based on the project „"Foreign Direct Investment in Central and Eastern Europe: What Kind of Competitiveness for the Visegrad Four?" and OTKA no. 68435 (Hungarian research fund).
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
3
East Central Europe and Hungary as a new location for BPO
• Movements of jobs/related FDI mainly between developed countries and India (started out from English-speaking countries, continental Europe only followed)
• in East Central Europe, especially the Czech Republic, Hungary and Poland are the main hosts to BPO projects, though their share is much lower than expected on the basis of media reports, Romania and Bulgaria catching up after 2007 (EU-membership)
• Estimation on the basis of the number of projects: 1400-1500 in Europe, 150-180 in the three countries in CEE (India, other Western European locations dominate), distributed approx. equally (biggest project go to India or are in W.Europe)
• Combined market share of CEE’s globally: less than 1 per cent (McKinsey (2006)) – still very limited
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
4
Hungary as a host to BPOService centres receiving financial incentives in Hungary
CompanyHome country Location in Hungary Number of jobs (actual or planned)
ExxonMobil USA Budapest 1200
IBM ISSC USA Budapest 1300
Diageo United Kingdom Budapest 600
Getronics Netherlands Budapest 510
Jabil USA Szombathely 719
SAP Germany Budapest 600
Tata India Budapest 450
Convergys USA Budapest 282
EDS USA Budapest, Szeged 1150
InBev Belgium Budapest 380
Budapest Bank USA Békéscsaba 530
Morgan Stanley United Kingdom Budapest 450
Citigroup USA Budapest 302
Vodafone United Kingdom Budapest 746
British Telecom United Kingdom Budapest, Debrecen 700
T-Systems Germany Budapest, Debrecen 1750
Source: ITDH
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
5
Hungary as a host to BPO
• Approx. 50 centres• Approx. 20-22 thousand people, 99 % white collar, between 80 and
90 % with university diploma and multiple language knowledge• Going to the countryside now (university towns close to the border
are the new locations)• Dynamic growth in output, exports (high share in EU27 comparison,
turnover centred on the EU, share of other services /other business services grew in services exports, specialisation indices show a relative specialisation on other business services – though methodological problems)
• Various activities (often more activities in one project)
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
6
Research questions and method
• Methodological problems of measurement• Location advantages determining the choice of the new location
(inside CEE)• Impact on the host economy• Relocations in business servicesMethods• Methodological problems: literature review and own calculations
(illustrations)• Location advantages and impact: questionnaire based company
interviews (5 in Hungary: 2 captive, 3 non-captive) and as a basis for comparison: 3-3 interviews in the Czech Republic, Poland and Slovakia;
• Case by case analysis for relocations for the period between July 2003 and September 2005, based on the database of Hunya, Sass (2005)
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
7
Methodological problems 11. Services – definition: missing, unclear (Knight, 1999; Bryson, 2001), Nachum
(1999): larger differences in between service industries than between services and manufacturing + lack of definition of business services (various definitions used)
2. FDI data – problems + usually small/diverse amounts invested (case studies: FDI in the range of 1 million to 1 billion USD in Hungary)
3. Number of projects can be misleading as well– differing sizes; number of jobs/employment can be the best proxy, but 1. data relatively old + usually less jobs are created in relocated and/or newly opened plants in CEECs (Hunya, Sass, 2005)
4. Captive and non-captive; manufacturing and services (captiveÍ) may be mixed up in one project
5. Categories: data are presented at a too high level of aggregation (e.g. in NACE); classification problems (Thakor, Kumar, 2000)
6. Data on services foreign trade would be good for showing the extent of BPO/relocation: many problems (transfer pricing, etc.) – see later
7. Inside BOP: services export lines are used for profit repatriation as well (evidence from Hungary)
8. Recording problems present in both manufacturing and services9. Relocation: only on a case by case basis, but even this can be misleading
(relocated and new activities ,mixed in one project)
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
8
Methodological problems 2• Specific problem: large differences between reported and mirror
statistics, which indicates that data are unreliable• Reasons:
– different thresholds and different correction methods in EU-member countries,
– simplified reporting, – coverage different, – exchange rates used , – double or triple reporting due to „intermediary” trade (important in the
EU), – no reporting, – VAT-fraud,– Time lag in reporting
• Relatively big in goods trade, and is expected to be even larger for services trade due to even more problematic tracing (no actual cross border transport of goods is involved)
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
9
Methodological problems 3
• Correction: problematic (both sides (reported and mirror statistics) are „moving targets”)
• Extent: in 2006: export overreported by almost 10 %, import underreported by almost 4 %
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
10
Problems with services trade data% difference between reported and mirror services trade statistics, 2006
-60,0
-40,0
-20,0
0,0
20,0
40,0
60,0
80,0
Belgiu
m
Bulga
ria
Czech
Rep
ublic
Denm
ark
Ger
man
y (in
cludin
g ex-
GDR from
199
1)
Eston
ia
Irelan
d
Gre
eceSpa
in
Franc
eIta
ly
Cypru
s
Latv
ia
Lith
uani
a
Luxe
mbo
urg
(Gra
nd-Duc
hé)
Hunga
ryM
alta
Nethe
rland
s
Austri
a
Polan
d
Portu
gal
Roman
ia
Slove
nia
Slova
kia
Finlan
d
Sweden
Unite
d Kin
gdom
%
export
import
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
11
Problems with „other services” trade statistics (related to BPO)
% differences between reported and mirror statistics, foreign trade in other services, 2006
-150,0
-100,0
-50,0
0,0
50,0
100,0
%
export
import
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
12
Trade statistics: goods and services
difference between reporter and mirror statistics, goods and services export and import, 2006, without Cyprus
-60,0
-40,0
-20,0
0,0
20,0
40,0
60,0
80,0
%
services export
services import
goods export
goods import
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
13
Location advantages 1
• determine which countries are chosen as hosts to new or relocated service centres (based on Dunning (1983) OLI-paradigm)
• similar to those of efficiency seeking investments (costs and availability of appropriately trained or trainable skilled work in the required quantity) + specific: infrastructure (mainly telecom)
• Additional: availability of certain services (financial etc.), good regulatory and business environment, protection of IP, office space, geographical proximity/same/similar time zone in some cases (nearshoring), different time zone in others, language knowledge (specific: other than English European languages, „small” European languages (including Turkish in Hungary))
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
14
Location advantages 2 – inside the region
Specific advantage: knowledge of „smaller” languages, good geographical position
Inside CEE:Poland stands out with its size (bigger
projects), location (NE, Baltics)Czech Republic: central location, best
flight connections, specialisation on IT
Hungary: minor languages (minorities in neighbouring countries), good location (CEE, towards SEE)
Choosing among the three countries is based on:
• Earlier presence of the company;• Previous good (or bad) experience
with the country;• Choice is influenced by the relative
dynamism, success of local affiliates;• Special language requirements;• Active lobbying of the local affiliate;• Quality of life, culture, English
schooling etc. in the target city, especially in cases when expatriates are involved
• Very limited role of incentives (mainly for bigger projects)
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
15
Impact on the host economy 1
• Companies with foreign participation have the potential to impact upon positively on the business environment, on local companies in the host country, though this impact is not automatic
• Analysed in the literature almost exclusively in manufacturing, though it is relevant for services sector FDI as well
• While the share of the three analysed countries in BPO is not high, from the host economy point of view, these are big projects and have a potentially big impact on the local economy
• Various fields of impact on the local economy is analysed on the basis of company interviews:
1. Job creation2. Linkages and other local contacts3. Impact on the business environment and infrastructure4. Spillovers through trained employees5. Market acces, FT, BOP
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
16
Impact on the host economy 2Job creation- Significant impact: in Hungary approx.
20-22 thousand people working in BPO (incl. captive)
- Medium to high skilled jobs (very little unskilled) for young university graduates, usually with (multiple) language knowledge
- Activities carried out: table (overtrained…), though VA/output among the highest in services
- Shortage of properly trained employees in all 3 countries – wages growing very fast (high attrition rate)
- Spreading out to the countryside (from the beginning in Poland, now in the Czech Republic and Hungary)
Linkages and other local contacts- (Very) limited backward linkages
(cleaning, security, cafeteria, etc., little substantial outsourcing)
- Forward linkages come as local companies become more „mature”, as competition is more intense (in Hungary seems to be more important compared to the other two countries)
- Contribution of linkages to raising the level of competitiveness/productivity of local companies: very limited
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
17
Table 16 Activities carried out in the companies interviewed in Hungary
Back officeCustomer contact Common
corporate functions
Knowledge services and decision analysis
Research and development
Transaction processing
Document management
Data entryData
processing
Call centres HRAccountingAdministrativeFinancial
servicesIT call centres
and other IT services
Quality management
Program and project management
Financial program management
Integration engineering
Supply chain management
Analytical accounting services
Business performance analysis
Cost analysis
Software development
Source: own compilation based on company interviews
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
18
Impact on the host economy 3
Impact on the business environment, infrastructure
- Competition for appropriately trained employees is intense: companies are more active locally, than „ordinary” FIEs (participation in local business associations, links with universities)
- Intense use of local infrastructure: in some cases results in better services
Spillovers through trained employees
- This seems to be one of the most important local impacts
- Trained employees in certain cases set up their own enterprises or go to work to domestic companies
- Not only skills, but business culture, business ethics are transferred through (former) workers
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
19
Impact on the host economy 4Market acces, BOP, FDI, FT, other• Methodological and data
problems• Export-intensive projects
(lower export/sales rate is above 60 %)
• Relatively high share in FDI stock (10 %) in Hungary
• Increase in services trade, especially in other services and other business services
• Balance of trade: turned positive (graph)
• Specialisation indices and RCA show change in business services towards relative specialisation and RCA
Graph 1 Balance of trade in computer services and Other business services, 1995-2006, million euros
-700
-600
-500
-400
-300
-200
-100
0
100
200
300
1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006
mill
ion
euro
s
Computer services Other business services
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
20
Relocation• Relocation: a process, in which either there is a transfer of production
capacities from another country, or there is a capacity extension in one affiliate parallel with a capacity reduction in another, or there is a capacity extension in one affiliate, while other affiliates‘ capacities do not change.
• Even more methodological problems• Case by case analysis is needed• In Hunya, Sass (2005): company cases of relocations in the period between
July 2003- September 2005• 9 of 61 cases affected business services (declared relocations)• Affected locations (from which the activity was transferred): mainly Western
Europe (Germany, the Netherlands, Austria, UK, Ireland, non-specified Western Europe) and the US
• Owners of companies: mainly US and UK• Activities: various, more than one per project, but not all activities of a firm
are relocations (company interviews)• Location in Hungary: mainly Budapest
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
21
Declared relocations in business services, July 2002-September 2005
CompanyActivity Foreign location
affectedMunkahely-teremtés vagy -veszteség
GE Capital (USA) Regional call centre Other Western European locations
+400-500
Renault Nissan(French-Japanese)
Regional logistics centre Austria +60-80
Electronic Data Systems (USA)
Regional centre Western Europe and the US
+350-400
Avis (UK) Financial administrative centre, regional call centre, financial-informatics services
Germany, (Belgium) +400
Diageo (UK) Extension of capacities of service centre, new activities (accounting)
UK +60
Electronic Data Systems (USA)
Capacity extension for new activities, call centre
Western Europe, USA
+400
Avis Europe Plc. (UK) Extension of financial services centre Western Europe +135
Maxtor Group (USA) African, European and Middle-Eastern service centre relocation (leaving call centre and financial planning there)
Ireland + Approx. 20
Marsh (USA) European accounting and administrative activities (except for UK, Ireland and the Netherlands)
UK +12
RSA Research Network Seminar, Outsourcing and Offshoring Business Services
22
Conclusion
CEEs/Visegrad countries increasingly involved in BPOMany methodological problems hinders the analysis (esp. the extent of
relocation)From a competitiveness point of view BPO projects in CEE- Contribute to the formation of a better domestic business environment, in
some cases availability of high quality services for domestic companies (forward linkages)
- Local contacts- backward linkages (suppliers): minimal, though, esp. forward linkages increasing over time
- Job creation for medium to high skilled, (though overtrained, partly due to the language knowledge requirement) spillovers through employees (skills, culture, ethics, own SMEs)
- Significant impact on the BOP, though due to methodological problems, it is difficult to quantify separately for these projects (FDI, FT-balance, profit repatriation etc.)
(Inside EU movements) Importance from the point of view of raising the competitiveness of overall EU-27