3/10/2017
1
Connecting the Dots to Strengthen Families in Wisconsin
Jim McKay, TEAM for West Virginia Children Cailin O’Connor, Center for the Study of Social Policy
Fulfilling the Promise, March 7, 2017
Our Agenda for Today• Morning:
– The four big ideas behind the Strengthening Families Approach
– Strengthening Families – Wisconsin
– The five protective factors
• Afternoon:– Applying Strengthening Families: Digging Deeper, by field
– Making the link
– Strengthening Families at the community level
– Café discussion and reflections
What makes your family strong?
Big Idea #1: A Protective Factors Approach
Risk Factors
Protective and Promotive
Factors
• Protective Factors: conditions or attributes of individuals, families, communities, or the larger society that mitigate or eliminate risk
• Promotive Factors: conditions or attributes of individuals, families, communities, or the larger society that actively enhance well-being
What we know: Families gain what they need to be successful when
key protective factors are robust in their lives and communities
3/10/2017
2
Big Idea #2: An Approach, Not a Model
• Research-based and evidence-informed• Applied in any setting that serves young children and their
families• Implemented through small but significant changes• Not parallel to, but integrated into existing practice• Cross-sector implementation core to the approach
Big Idea #3: A Changed Relationship with Parents
• Supporting parents’ ability to parent effectively• Involving parents as partners in achieving good outcomes
for children• Engaging parents effectively through programs• Engaging parents directly in mutually supportive
relationships that build protective factors• Partnering with parents to help design systems and
policies that work for children and families
Big Idea #4: Alignment with Developmental Science
• Paying attention to what the research tells us:– Critical periods of development – early childhood and
adolescence
– Importance of nurturing relationships in early childhood
– Effects of trauma on development, behavior and outcomes
• Providing tools and guidance to align practice with what we know about child development
A Protective/Promotive Factors Frame Across
Development
3/10/2017
3
Strengthening Families in Wisconsin Panel Discussion
• Connie Dunlap, Supporting Families Together Association
• Leslie McAllister, Department of Children and Families (Home Visiting Coordinator)
• Rebecca Murray, Child Abuse and Neglect Prevention Board
• Cailin O’Connor, Center for the Study of Social Policy
• Jane Penner-Hoppe, Department of Children and Families (Division of Safety and Permanence)
Five Protective Factors PARENTAL RESILIENCE
KNOWLEDGE of PARENTING and CHILD
DEVELOPMENT
SOCIAL CONNECTIONS
CONCRETE SUPPORT in TIMES of NEED
SOCIAL and EMOTIONAL COMPETENCE of
CHILDREN
Parental resilience
What it looks likeResilience to general life stress
• Hope, optimism, self confidence• Problem solving skills
• Self care and willingness to ask for help
• Ability to manage negative emotions
Managing stress and functioning well when faced with challenges, adversity and trauma
Resilience to parenting stress
• Not allowing stress to interfere with nurturing
• Positive attitude about parenting and child
Everyday actions• Demonstrate in multiple ways that parents are
valued
• Honor each family’s race, language, culture, history and approach to parenting
• Encourage parents to manage stress effectively• Support parents as decision-makers and help build
decision-making and leadership skills• Help parents understand how to buffer their child
during stressful times
Parental resilience
3/10/2017
4
Questions parents can use:• What are your dreams for yourself and your family?• What helps you cope with everyday life?• What kinds of frustrations do you deal with during
the day?• How are you able to meet your children’s needs
when you are dealing with stress?• What are your goals for your family or children in the
next week or month
Parental resilience Building blocks of resilience
Actively supporting resilience: A provider’s role
Build on parent strengths
Support skill building
Reinforce action
What it looks like• Nurturing parenting behavior• Appropriate developmental expectations• Ability to create a developmentally supportive environment
for child• Positive discipline techniques; ability to effectively manage
child behavior• Recognizing and responding to your child’s specific needs
Understanding child development and parenting strategies that support physical, cognitive, language, social and emotional development
Knowledge of parenting & child development Knowledge of parenting & child development
Everyday actions• Model developmentally appropriate interactions
with children
• Provide information and resources on parenting and child development
• Encourage parents to observe, ask questions, explore parenting issues and try out new strategies
• Address parenting issues from a strength-based perspective
3/10/2017
5
Knowledge of parenting & child development
Questions parents can use:• Talk about what your child does best and what you like about your
child.
• Tell me what you like about being a parent of an infant, preschooler, etc.
• What are some of the things that you find hard about being a parent?• What works best for your child when he/she is sad, angry or frustrated?• How have you seen other parents handle the same kinds of behaviors?• Tell me about the things that worry you about your child.• How do you encourage your child to explore his/her surroundings, try
new things and do things on his/her own?
Providing “just in time” parenting education
Express Empathy
Ask Good Questions
Provide Informatio
n and Perspective
Develop Strategies
Coach, Model and Mentor
Lift up Successes
Social connections
What it looks like• Multiple friendships and supportive relationships
with others
• Feeling respected and appreciated• Accepting help from others, and giving help to
others• Skills for establishing and maintaining connections
Positive relationships that provide emotional, informational, instrumental and spiritual support
Social connections
Everyday actions• Help families value, build, sustain and use
social connections
• Create an inclusive environment
• Facilitate mutual support
• Promote engagement in the community and participation in community activities
Social connectionsQuestions parents can use:
• Who can you call for advice or just to talk?
• How often do you see them?
• Do you have family members or friends nearby who can help you out once in a while?
• Do you belong to a church, temple, mosque, women’s group or men’s group?
• Do you have a child in a local pre-school, school or Head Start program
3/10/2017
6
Building an Eco-map
YouFriend
Friend
Sister
Spouse
Child
Co‐worker
Parent at your child’s school
Co‐worker
Concrete support in times of need
What it looks like• Seeking and receiving support when needed• Knowing what services are available and how to
access them• Adequate financial security; basic needs being met• Persistence
• Advocating effectively for self and child to receive necessary help
Access to concrete support and services that address a family’s needs and help minimize stress caused by challenges
Concrete support in times of need
Everyday actions• Respond immediately when families are in crisis• Provide information and connections to services in
the community• Help families to develop skills and tools they need
to identify their needs and connect to supports
Concrete support in times of need
Questions parents can use:• Identify from the parents’ perspective their most immediate need, such
as staying in their house, keeping a job or paying the heating bill.
• Look at steps the parents have taken to deal with the problem and assess how it is or is not working.
• Talk about current connections such as community or other local resources, faith-based communities, pre-school or school relationships and pediatricians to name a few.
• Explore the parents’ ability to find ways to access services such as transportation, encouragement, phone calls and other personal help
FOODJOB TRAINING
EDUCATION
HEALTH CARE
CLOTHING
SHELTERDOMESTIC VIOLENCE SERVICES
SUBSTANCE ABUSE
SERVICESMENTAL HEALTH
CARESPECIALIZED
SERVICES FOR CHILDREN
A bridge to services
3/10/2017
7
The Luck of the Draw: Setting up the game
• Take three index cards each• Label each of your cards, front and back:
• Shuffle and make a pile of each category for your table
BLANK SIDE LINED SIDETime of need A challenging situation for a family
Service A type of formal service available in your community
Support An informal support a family might have
The Luck of the Draw: How to play• You will take three turns as a group at your table
• First turn, select one card from each pile – Discuss: Will the service and/or the informal support help the family deal
with this challenge?
• Second turn, select one card from each pile – Discuss: Are the challenges mounting? What help is available from the
services and supports you’ve drawn so far?
• Third turn, select another “time of need” card and turn over all remaining services and supports cards– Discuss: How could you help this family navigate the available services
and supports to get the help they need?
Social & emotional competence of children
What it looks likeFor the parent:
• Warm and consistent responses that foster a strong and secure attachment with the child
• Encouraging and reinforcing social skills; setting limits
Family and child interactions that help children develop the ability to communicate clearly, recognize and regulate their emotions and establish and maintain relationships
For the child:• Age appropriate self-regulation
• Ability to form and maintain relationships with others
• Positive interactions with others• Effective communication
Social & emotional competence of children
Everyday actions• Help parents foster their child’s social emotional
development
• Model nurturing care to children
• Include children’s social and emotional development activities in programming
• Help children develop a positive cultural identity and interact in a diverse society
• Respond proactively when social or emotional development needs extra support
Social & emotional competence of children
Questions parents can use:• When you spend time with your child what do you like to do
together?
• What does your child do when he/she is sad, angry or tired?
• What are your child’s greatest gifts and talents?
• How do you encourage these talents?
• What do you do when your child does something great?
• What routines do you keep in caring for your young child?
3/10/2017
8
Children’s Social Emotional Skills to Build
EmpathizeDevelop Strategies
Control Response to Feelings
Recognize and
Communicate Emotions
How to remember the Protective Factors
Digging Deeper: Applying Strengthening Families in Your Work
•Home Visiting (3 groups - Wilderness 25, Wilderness 4, and Wilderness 1)
•Home Visiting Supervisors (stay in main ballroom)
•Early Care and Education (Tundra EF)
•Early Head Start (Glacier AB)
•Family Support / Parent Education / Community Response (Glacier CD)
•Child Welfare (Tundra CD)
•Birth to Three / Infant Mental Health (Tundra AB)
•Applying Protective Factors in our Own Lives (Sandstone 89)
Digging Deeper Handouts and Tools
Handouts and tools for today’s sessions are available on the Conference website and via the Conference App.
https://eventmobi.com/ftp2017/
Making the Link
• How does Strengthening Families connect to other frameworks, other initiatives, other ongoing work?– Individual fields: “Making the Link” factsheets and crosswalks
– Relevance and integration within Core Competencies across various fields, parent engagement portion of Young Star, etc.
– Protective factors as a theme that runs across many child- and family-focused initiatives in the state
3/10/2017
9
Many resources available at www.strengtheningfamilies.net How do we know if we’re
making a difference?• Family level
–Protective Factors Survey
–Parents’ Assessment of Protective Factors
• Staff level–Staff survey
• Program level–Program self-assessments
–Standards of Quality self-assessment
About the Self-Assessments • Key implementation tool for programs adopting a
Strengthening Families Approach
• Helps programs identify “small but significant changes” that enhance their ability to build protective factors
• Created based on a national study of exemplary practice
• Designed to be used flexibly and to lead you to a concrete action plan
• Helps programs identify strengths & areas to focus
• Not an evaluation tool but a tool for continuous improvement
Four versions for different types of programs
3/10/2017
10
Strengthening Families Evaluation Portal
• Registration
• Self-Assessments
• Action Planning
• Parent & Staff Surveys
• Reports
http://www.strengtheningfamiliesevaluation.com
Taking a Community Approach to Strengthening Families
Engaging the public in prevention and strengthening families
• Affirm• Empower• Educate
• Affirm• Empower• Educate
Individual Actions
• Sense of connectedness
• Relationships
• Sense of connectedness
• Relationships
Community Engagement
• Engage in issues
• Mobilize
• Engage in issues
• Mobilize
Policy Advocacy
Talking with Parents about
Protective Factors
A case example: Magnolia Place
What would it take to have the 35,000 children living in the neighborhoods within the 5-square mile/500 blocks of the Magnolia Catchment Area break all records of success in their education and their health, and the quality of nurturing care and the economic stability they receive from their families and community?”
• Use SF protective factors as a philosophy to align practice among a network of 75 providers
• Baseline survey of 800 individuals on PFs• Café conversations with community members about what PFs mean to them• Dashboard—to examine monthly success in engaging families around PFs• Using EDI to measure impact on school readiness
Service Programs
3/10/2017
11
Shared Outcomes
and Measures
Magnolia Community Dashboard15 August 2011
% of 3rd Grade Children Who are Proficient in Reading
% Parents of Children 0-5 with Protective Factors % Parents of Children 0-5 Achieving Family Goals
% Parents Reporting Reading to Their Child Daily Parent Experiences with Care (in the Community Overall and % Parents Reporting Ties to NeighborsOverall and in Actively Improving Provider Settings)
% Parents Reporting Positive Relationship with Child % Parents Reporting Use of Bank Account % Parents Reporting Family-Centered/Empathetic Care
% Parents Discussing Resources for Families % Parents Asked About Developmental Concerns % Parents Asked About Family Stressors
% Parents Discussing Resources for Social Support % of Children Reached % Parents Asked About Depression
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
2010 2011 2012
At
Lea
st 1 N
eig
hbo
r Yo
u C
ou
ld D
iscu
ss
Per
so
na
l P
rob
lem
W
ith
Can
Get
Med
ical C
are
W
hen
Need
ed
Fle
xib
le W
hen
L
ife D
oesn
't G
o
As P
lan
ned
Social Connections (% with both)
Concrete Support in
Times of Need (% with all 6)
Resilience (% with all 5)
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
Through child care
% receiving care from this system
% reached by Magnolia Network partner
Safe
Pla
ces fo
r C
hild
to
Pla
y
No
t D
ep
ressed
Fo
od H
as
Not
Ru
n O
ut
Care
giv
ers
See
Ch
ild
Reg
ula
rly
Social Conditions
Parent Health
Economic Stability Parenting
0%
25%
50%
75%
100%
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
2010 2011 2012
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
2010 2011 2012
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
2010 2011 2012
0%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
2010 2011 2012
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
2010 2011 2012
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
2010 2011 2012
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
2010 2011 2012
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
2010 2011 2012
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
2010 2011 2012
Has IEPArea No. Comm Phys Lang Soc Emo 1+ 2+ (%)Northwest 137 12 10 17 17 7 30 18 7Southwest 15 27 0 0 13 13 40 13 --
Proportion of Kindergarten Children:
Developmentally vulnerable (%)
0 20 40 60 80 100
All children
"Children with parent <HS educa on
No. Total number of children assessedComm Communication and general knowledgePhys Physical health and wellbeing
Lang Language and cognitive skills 1+ Vulnerable on one or more domainsSoc Social competence 2+ Vulnerable on two or more domainsEmo Emotional maturity Has IEP Has special education plan
In actively improving doctor offices
In actively improving child care programs
In community overall
In actively improving family support programs
Goal
EDSI . EARLY
DEVELOPMENTAL
SCREENING
AND INTERVENTION
INITIATIVE A case example: Baptist Convention of New Jersey
In October of 2014, the General Baptist Convention of New Jersey voted to become Strengthening Families churches. The pastor of each of these churches will sign a covenant to promote the protective factors of families in their congregations. Reverend Darrell Armstrong, an early adopter of Strengthening Families, developed the covenant as a tool to engage clergy of any faith tradition in helping families to build protective factors as part of their ministry.
• Over 300 churches in NJ will sign the covenant• Protective factors have been aligned to key passages from scripture• Training available for clergy and lay faith leaders on how to implement a
protective factors approach in their work with parishioners
Faith Communities
A case example: Leelanau, Michigan
When the Leelanau Children’s Center, one of the early Strengthening Families exemplary programs decided they wanted to bring Strengthening Families to their community they started making some unusual partnerships. For example they knew traditional parenting education classes often face attrition and difficulty attracting the very families that need the support the most. So they teamed up with the local laundromat and pizza parlor to host a family night with conversation about common parenting issues. The pizza and laundry are free and the events are packed.
• Building protective factors in places where families already go• Partnership with service providers and community institutions
Community
Institutions
Businesses A case example: United Way’s“Strengthening Families @ Work”
United Way of Greater Atlanta developed “Strengthening Families @ Work” as a pilot project with support from United Way Worldwide. In this model, Human Resources staff are trained on the Strengthening Families Protective Factors Framework and provided tools to help them take a protective factors approach to their employees, including:
–Surveying employees about issues they are facing that challenge their work-life balance
–Providing “lunch and learn” seminars for employees on specific topics related to those challenges, e.g., parenting specific age groups, finding resources in the community, caring for aging parents
–Developing family-friendly policies in response to employees’ stated challenges
Community
Institutions
Employers
Broad-based policy advocacy campaign to end child poverty in West Virginia. Over 180 organizational partners including parents, social justice organizations, businesses, labor organizations, faith-based organizations, etc. Organized in communities across the state at a grassroots level.
Achieved 14 policy victories in 2 years including Medicaid expansion providing 160,000 with health insurance, Minimum Wage increase, access to childcare, pregnant workers fairness, Feed to Achieve, restored funding for children and families programs, criminal justice reform.
Policy Advocacy
A case example: Our Children, Our Future in WV
Elderly poverty in the U.S. decreased dramatically.
Between 1960 and 1995, the poverty rate of those aged 65 and above fell from 35% to 10% and remains steady despite economic recessions.
•Social Security
•Medicare
•Homestead exemptions
Policy Advocacy
A case example: Poverty Rates for Seniors
3/10/2017
12
Reflections / Next Steps
What are Cafés?
• Based on World Café Model• Method of guided conversations
about topics that matter• Promotes the Strengthening
Families Protective Factor Framework
• Builds collective wisdom• Fosters parent leadership and
parent-practitioner partnership• Promotes growth and action
Instructions
•Gather in groups of 4
•3 rounds of questions, 8‐10 minutes each
•Write, doodle, draw thoughts, ideas and questions.
•After each round, a host stays, others move to new tables, carrying new ideas and questions to the next conversation.
•The role of the host is to welcome newcomers, share highlights of the prior conversation and invite people to share.
•After the last round, we harvest the learning together.
The Job of the Host
•Welcome & invite people to their seats
•Pose the first question (posted)
•Encourage everyone to “lean in” and share
•At the end of the first round, the host stays while everyone else travels
•Introduce 2nd question
•At the end of the 2nd round, the host stays while everyone else travels again
•Introduce the 3rd question
•Harvest the learning
3/10/2017
13
Round 1 (10 mins)
What actions can you take to bolster implementation of
Strengthening Families in your program, in your community and/or in Wisconsin?
Round 2 (10 mins)
In thinking about your work to implement Strengthening Families (or doing the types of activities we have discussed today), what are some times when it really went well?
What were the factors or conditions that helped it succeed especially well at that time?
Round 3 (8 mins)
Please identify two to three people with whom you will share this information and discuss why
they are important to getting the word out.
Harvesting the Learning
Of the ideas and themes that emerged throughout the day, what stands out as most important? Most energizing?
What are you planning to do differently as a result of what has been shared and discussed today?
https://twitter.com/CtrSocialPolicy
https://www.facebook.com/pages/Center‐for‐the‐Study‐of‐Social‐Policy
www.cssp.orgwww.strengtheningfamilies.net