Download - SPP 2013 DC Case Status
) )
SPA 2013 DC STATUS OF CASESAs of May 06, 2013
MUN. / CITY / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE
----------------- -̂------------------------
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
1. Cordova,Cebu
II
13-001(DC)
Mayor Adelino B. Sitoy
vs.
Rex Ong Salud a.k.a. W akee Salud
Resolution (SD) - x^x the instant Petition is GRANTED. Accordingly,\the COC of respondent Rex Ong Salud is hereby CANCELLED
w1 MR (to the Resolution d lted Dec. 26, 2012) filed by respondent-movant on January 10, 2013
Resolution No. 9614 - xxx In view of the foregoing, there being no order or resolution emanating from the higher courts restraining the implementation of the aforementioned final and executory decision, the Commission RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to CANCEL the Certificate of Candidacy filed by and REMOVE from the Certified List of Candidates the name of Rex Ong Salud a.k.a. Wakee Salud as Mayor of Cordova, Cebu in the May 13, 2013 NLE for failure to comply with the qualifications of an elective local official/ Let the Law Dept, implement this Resolution
December 26, 2012
January 15, 2013
2. Councilor District 6,
Quezon City
I
13-002(DC)
In Re: Petition to disqualify Ma. Theresa E. Gana as candidate for councilor of District 6, Quezon City
Nino A. Holgado
vs.
Ma. Theresa E. Gana
--------------------1------------------------------------
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISM ISS this case for being M OOT and ACADEMIC
January 10, 2013
)
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE\
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
3. Lone District of Camiguin
II
13-003(DC-F)
Pedro P. Romualdo
vs.
Homobono A. Adaza
For: To Deny Due Course or To Cancel COC
I Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby 'DISMISSED
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
\
\
January 21, 2013
February 07, 2013
4. Bacolod City, Negros Occidental
1
13-004(DC)
In Re: Petition to declare candidate Julius S. Sayson as nuisance candidate
in the coming May 13, 2013 Midterm Election
Jude Thaddeus A. Sayson
vs.
Julius S. Sayson
Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby GRAFTED. JULIUS S. SAYSON is hereby declared as NUISANCE CAN D ID A TE and his Certificate of Candidacy for the position of Mayor of Bacolod City, is hereby ordered CANCELLED
January 29, 2013
5. Dingras, llocos Norte
1
13-005(DC)
i
Erdio E. Valenzuela
vs.
Marynette R. Gamboa
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to GRANT the Petition. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy for the position of Mayor of Dingras, llocos Norte filed by the respondent Marynette R. Gamboa is hereby DENIED DUE C O U RSE AND CANCELLED for misrepresenting her eligibility to the position for which the Certificate of Candidacy was filed, pursuant to Section 78, in relation to Section 74, both of the O EC and Section 40 (e) of the Local Government Code
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY this Motion for Reconsideration for LACK OF MERIT. Consequently, March 6, 2013 Resolution of the Commission First Division is hereby affirmed
March 06, 2013
April 19, 2013
1
Page 2 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
V
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
6. Science City of Munoz,
Nueva Ecija
II
13-006(DC)
Ester Abrina Lazaro
vs.
Jerry Urmatan Lazaro*\\
Order {SD) - xxx the Commission (SD) hereby orders as follows: 1. To NOTE the “Manifestation/Motion To Withdraw Petition" filed on Oct. 24, 2012 with attached Sworn Affidavit of Withdrawal of COC dated Oct. 15, 2012; 2. To CO NSIDER this instant petition withdrawn as prayed for by the petitioner Ester Abrina Lazaro assisted by Atty. Francisco B. Sibayan, counsel for petitioner; and 3. To CANCEL the CONFERENCE scheduled on Nov. 9, 2012
November 06, 2012
7. Dipolog City, Zamboanga
del Norte
II
13-007(DC)
Julius B. GajoViera
vs.
Cecilia G. Jalosjos-Carreon
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Course to Respondent Cecilia G. Jalosjos-Carreon's Certificate of Candidacy
January 24, 2013
8. First District of Quezon
City
I
13-008(DC)
Rita Katherine D. Crisologo
vs.
Albert Crisologo
Resolution (FD) - xxx the petition is hereby GRANTED. Respondent Albert Crisologo is hereby declared as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE, and his Certificate of Candidacy for Congressman of District I, Quezon City, for the 13 May 2013 NLE is CANCELLED
January 31, 2013
9. Libon, Albay
1
13-009(DC)
John Vasquez Dycoco
vs.
Domingo B. Samson
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS this case for LACK OF MERIT
January 10, 2013
10.
*
Lone District of Bacoor,
Cavite
1
13-010(DC)
Jessie B. Castillo
vs.
Leonardo C. Castillo
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to G RANT the instant petition. LEO NARDO C. CASTILLO is hereby DECLARED as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE and accordingly, his C O C is hereby CANCELLED
Order (FD) - xxx hereby DENIES said motion for the
December 11, 2012
i
Page 3 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
)
M U N ./C IT Y /PROVINCE
SPA201x3
\
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
\
\
1
following reasons: 1. Failure to pay the corresponding fee for filing a motion for reconsideration; and 2. Lacking the number of copies required by the rules / The motion for reconsideration will still be denied for being pro-forma
January 22, 2013
11. Tubao, La Union
I
13-011(DC)
^ Wilfredo S. Garcia
vs.
Wilfredo G. Garcia
Resolution (FD) - xxx resolves to G R A NT the instant Petition. Respondent Wilfredo G. Garcia is declared as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE, accordingly, his Certificate of Candidacy is hereby DENIED and CANCELLED
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby DENIED for lack of merit
January 29, 2013
May 03, 2013
12. Cortes,Bohol
I
13-012(DC)
Atty. Claudita M. Gifard
vs.
Roberto L. Tabanera
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition dated 29 October 2012
March 21, 2013
13. Pagalungan,Maguindanao
il
13-013(DC)
Giamaludin Nor
vs.
Mohammad S. Andoy
Resolution (SD) - xxx resolves to uphold the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent MOHAMMAD S. ANDOY for the mayoralty position in the Municipality of Pagalungan, Province of Maguindanao
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby DENIED
January 16, 2013
April 24, 2013
14. TurtleIslands,
Tawi-Tawi
II
13-014(DC)
Mibaral M. Tang
vs.
Mardan M. Julkanain
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISM ISSED for lack of merit
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
January 16, 2013
February 21, 2013
r
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
\15. I Turtle
Islands, Tawi-Tawi
\
\ 1
\ft\
13-015(DC)
Mibaral M. Tang
vs.
Rodolfo M. Velasquez
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to G R A NT the Petition dated 08 October 2012. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent RODOLFO M. VELASQUEZ is hereby EXCLUDED for failure to comply with Section 73 of the OEC
January 22, 2013
\\
\
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT respondent Rodolfo M. Velasquez’ Motion for Reconsideration (Of the Resolution dated 22 January 2013), SET ASIDE the Commission (First Division) Resolution dated 22 January 2013 and G IVE DUE CO URSE to respondent’s Certificate of Candidacy. The Law Dept, is hereby DIRECTED to endorse the records of this case to the Integrated Bar of the Philippines, Committee on Bar Discipline, for their appropriate action against Atty. Carlo B. Gomez
April 05, 2013 \\
16. TurtleIslands,
Tawi-Tawi
II
13-016(DC)
Mibaral M. Tang
vs.
Sarajul M. Jihim
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISM ISSED for lack of merit
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
January 21, 2013
March 13, 2013
17. TurtleIslands,
Tawi-Tawi
1
13-017(DC)
Mibaral M. Tang
vs.
Taha S. Sadalani
Submitted for resolution
18. Quezon City
II
13-018(DC)
Herbert M. Bautista
vs.
Romeo “Romy” S. Acebedo
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates’ Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the. May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 3. Acebedo, Romeo Sanchez - Mayor -
January 11, 2013
Page 5 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
)
MUN. / C ITY / PROVINCE
SPA2013 TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
DATED/PROMULGATED
\
REMARKS
Quezon City xxx \19. Province of
Agusan del Norte
II
13-019(DC)
In Re: Petition for declaration of George M. Lumongsod as a nuisance
candidate for Governor in the Province of Agusan del Norte in the May 13,
2013 Elections
Ma. Angelica Rosedell Amante-Matba
vs.
George M. Lumongsod
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates’ Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 23. Lumongsod, Jorge Maceda - Governor - Agusan del Norte xxx
January 11, 2013
\\a
\
20. Province of Surigao del
Sur
II
13-020(DC)
In the matter of Petition to declare Iberet Murillo Correos as nuisance
candidate
Manuel O. Alameda, Sr.
vs.
Iberet Murillo Correos
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED
January 02, 2013
21. Province of Surigao del
Sur
II
13-021(DC)
In the matter of the Petition to declare Edwin G. Deligero as nuisance
candidate for the Office of Governor of Surigao del Sur
Johnny T. Pimentel
vs.
Edwin Deligero
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS this Petition for LACK OF MERIT
i
April 01, 2013
Page 6 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
)
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED
REMARKS
22. Leyte, Leyte
II
13-022(DC)
Andres Nautilus P. Salvacion
vs.
Arnold James M. Ysidoro
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition v is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit \
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
%\
March 12, 2013
March 27, 2013
23. Marcos, llocos Norte
II
13-023(DC)
Salvador S. Pillos
vs.
Arsenio A. Agustin
Omnibus Resolution (SD) - xxx the petitions are
hereby DENIED for lack of merit \
Resolution (EB) - xxx the MR of Petitioner Stewart D. De La Cruz in SPA No. 13-024 (DC) is denied fdy lack of merit. On the other hand, the Motion for Reconsideration of Petitioner Salvador S. Pillos in SPA No. 13-023 (DC) is granted; consequently, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Arsenio A. Agustin is hereby CANCELLED and DENIED DUE COURSE
January 28, 2013
April 23, 2013
24. Marcos, llocos Norte
II
13-024(DC)
Stewart T. De La Cruz
vs.
Napoleon A. Duldulao
Omnibus Resolution (SD) - xxx the petitions are hereby DENIED for lack of merit
Resolution (EB) - xxx the MR of Petitioner Stewart D. De La Cruz in SPA No. 13-024 (DC) is denied for lack of merit. On the other hand, the Motion for Reconsideration of Petitioner Salvador S. Pillos in SPA No. 13-023 (DC) is granted; consequently, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Arsenio A. Agustin is hereby CANCELLED and DENIED DUE COURSE
January 28, 2013
April 23, 2013
rPage 7 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
)
M U N ./C IT Y /PROVINCE
SPA2013 TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
25. South District,
Cebu City
1
13-025(DC)
Ronald O. Diola & Tisha Aisha Y. Gonzalez
vs.
Augustus “Jun” G. Pe, Jr.
Petition for Disqualificaation and/or To Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC
Resolution (FD) - \x x x RESOLVES, to GRANT the Petition dated 10 O&tober 2012. ACCORDINGLY, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Augustus ‘Jun’ G. Pe, Jr., is hereby DENIED and CANCELLED
Order (FD) - xxx MRs elevated to en banc \
Omnibus Motion filed W pets-movants on April 29, 2013 ^
\
February 01, 2013
March 12 & 17, 2013
26. Bacacay,Albay
II
13-026(DC)
In Re: Petition for denial of due course to Certificate of Nomination and
Acceptance
Luis B. Hefti
vs.
Orlando Binamira
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Due Course to Respondent Binamira’s Certificate of Nomination and Acceptance and UPHOLD his status as an official nominee of the Nacionalista Party in the 13 May 2013 Elections
January 21, 2013
27. Tayum,Abra
II
13-027(DC)
Placido Eduarte, Jr.
vs.
Jose Marie Brillantes y Mailed
i
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is GRANTED. The Certificate of Candidacy of JOSE MARIE M. BRILLANTES for Mayor of the Municipality of Tayum, Province of Abra is hereby DENIED DUE CO URSE and CANCELLED
Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant motion for reconsideration is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the January 28, 2013 Resolution of the Commission (SD) is hereby REVERSED and SET ASIDE
Manifesttion filed by petitioner through counsel on April 22, 2013 (no majority votes re Resolution April 12, 2013)
January 28, 2013
April 12, 2013
r Page 8 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) '■ )
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATEDREMARKS
28. Province of Zamboanga
del Sur
II
13-028(DC)
Antonio H. Cerilles \
vs.
Dominador G. Jalosjos, Jr.
Resolution No. 9612 - xxx/ In view of the foregoing, the Commission RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to CANCEL the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Dominador G. Jalosjos, Jr. as Governor of Zamboanga del Sur in the May 13, 2013 NLE/ Let the Law Dept,
implement this Resolution
January 15, 2013
29. 2na Dist. of Zamboanga
del Sur
II
13-029(DC)
Antonio H. Cerilles
vs.
Marjorie N. Jalosjos
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
OrCJer (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
February 01, 2013
March 13, 2013
30. 2na District of Cebu City
II
13-030(DC)
In Re: Petition to declare Bert L. Abella as nuisance candidate for the position of Member, Sangguniang Panlungsod
of the 2nd District of Cebu City in the upcoming May 13, 2013 Elections and
To Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC
Nendell Hanz L. Abella
vs.
Bert L. Abella
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates' Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 2. Abella, Bert Leo - Member, S. Panlungsod (2nd Dist.) - Cebu City xxx
January 11, 2013
31. Lakewood, Zamboanga
del Sur
II
13-031(DC)
-i----------------
Canuto Cavan Enerio, Jr. and Roger Bonghanoy Polinar
vs.
Jean Paul Villaflor Jalosjos
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
February 01, 2013
r Page 9 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
MUN. / CITY PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
32. Tanjay City, Negros Oriental
II
13-032(DC)
In Re: Petition to Declare Edwin S. Teves a nuisance candidate and to
deny due course to or cancel his COC for Mayor, Tanjay City, Negros Oriental,
pursuant to Section 69 of the OEC
Lawrence S. Teves \Edwin S. ^eves
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby GRANTED, Edwin S. Teves’s Certificate of Candidacy is hereby CANCELLEDwith Separate Concurring Opinion of Comm. Padaca
March 21, 2013
33. 1s' District of Palawan
II
13-033(DC)
Roberto V. Rodriguez
vs.
Randy M. Rodriguez
Omnibus Resolution (SD) - xxx the consolidated cases are resolved as follows: In SPA No. 13-033 (DC), the petition to declare Randy M. Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is hereby DISMISSED. However, Randy M. Rodriguez is ordered not to use and place 'Toto" as the nickname to appear in the official ballot/ In SPA No. 13- 105 (DC)(F) the petition to declare Roberto “Toto” Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is also DISMISSED
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Omnibus Resolution dated January 28, 2013 is REVERSED and SET ASIDE. Accordingly, respondent Randy M. Rodriguez is declared a NUISANCE CANDIDATE. Consequently, his CERTIFICATE OF CANDIDACY is hereby CANCELLED
January 28, 2013
w / SPA 13-105
May 02, 2013
34.
i
SantiagoCity,
IsabelaProvince
II
13-034(DC)
Re: Petition for declaration of candidate as a nuisance candidate
Armando S. Tan
vs.
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is GRANTED. Respondent MARK ALVIN A. TAN is hereby DECLARED as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE and accordingly, his COC is hereby CANCELLED
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and
January 04, 2013
January 11, i
) )
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATEDREMARKS
\\\
Mark Alvin A. Tan to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates’ Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 35. Tan, Mark Alvin Arquero - Mayor, - Santiago City, Isabela xxx
2013 \
35. Province of Abra
1
13-03 A (DC) ^
Eustaquio P. Bersamin
vs.
\ Joel B. Bersamina
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates’ Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 10. Bersamina, Joel Bicera - Governor, - Province of Abra xxx
January 11, 2013
36. Bulakan,Buiacan
1
13-036(DC)
Patrick Neil F. Meneses
vs.
Emmanuel N. Meneses
Resolution (FD) - xxx the petitionis hereby GRANTED. Respondent Emmanuel N. Meneses is hereby declared as NUISANCE CANDIDATE, and his Certificate of Candidacy for Mayor of Bulakan, Buiacan, for the 13 May 2013 National and Local Elections is CANCELLED
January 21, 2013
37. Ramon,Isabela
1
13-037(DC)
Derrick M. Vizcarra
vs.
Wilfredo L. Tabag
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS this case for LACK OF MERIT
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration filed by petitioner Derrick M. Vizcarra is DENIED. Accordingly, the Resolution of the Commission (FD) promulgated on 23 Janaury 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED
January 23, 2013
April 23, 2013
38. Tineg, Abra
1
13-038(Dc)
In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course or to Cancel COC for
Mayor of Cita Acosta Crisologo in the Municipality of Tineg, Abra
Corinthia Dannang Crisologo
Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED
April 10, 2013
1
r Page 11 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
\M U N ./C IT Y /
PROVINCESPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATEDREMARKS
\\\
vs.
Cita Acosta Crisologo\
39. ̂Tineg, Abra
\\ 1
\\
13-039(DC)
Corinthia Dannang Crisologo
vs.
Cita Acosta Crisologo
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to GRANT the Petition. Accordingly, respondent Cita A. Crisologo is hereby DECLARED a nuisance candidate pursuant to Section 69 of the OEC
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Motion for Reconsideration and to AFFIRM the First Division’s ruling declaring Respondent Cita Acosta Crisologo a nuisance candidate
January 22, 2013
March 22, 2013
\
\\
\a\
40. Tineg, Abra
II
13-040(DC)
In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course or To Cancel COC for
Mayor of Clemencio P. Ramirez in the Municipality of Tineg, Abra
Edwin B.Crisologo, Sr.
vs.
Clemencio P. Ramirez
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. Accordingly, the Decision of this Commission dated 16 January 2013 stands
January 16, 2013
March 22, 2013
41. Tineg, Abra
I
13-041(DC)
In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course or To Cancel C O C for Mayor of Cromwell S. Luna in the Municipality of
Tineg, Abra
Edwin B. Crisologo, Sr.,
vs.
Cromwell S. Luna
Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. The assailed Resolution of the Commission’s First Division dated 29 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRM ED IN TOTO
i
January 29, 2013
April 05, 2013
Page 12 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )\\
MUN. / CITY / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED
\
REMARKS
42. Second District,
Agusan del Sur
II
13-042(DC)
Rodolfo Galido Plaza
vs.
Mauricio Cuevas Plaza, Jr.
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates’ Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 29. Plaza, Mauricio Jr. C. - Member, House of Representatives (2nd Dist.) - Agusan del Sur xxx
January 11, 2013
\
\\
43. Province of Agusan del
Sur
1
13-043(DC)
Victor Galido Plaza
vs.
Mariano Curato Plaza
Submitted for resolution \«\
44. ZamboangaCity
II
13-044(DC)
Marinao Isabelle G. Climaco-Salazar
vs.
Romeo Garcia Jalosjos
Resolution No. 9613 - xxx RESOLVES, to CANCEL and DENY due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zamboanga City in the May 13, 2013 NLE
January 15, 2013
45. SantiagoCity
1
13-045(DC)
In Re: Petition to Deny Due Course and To Cancel COC of Samuel
“Docsam” Navarro
E. Orestes S. Ferrer
vs.
Samuel “Docsam" Navarro
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to G R A NT the Petition dated 10 October 2012. ACCORDINGLY, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Samuel Navarro is hereby DENIED and CANCELLED
January 15, 2013
rPage 13 o f 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
)\
) ‘
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
46. Cortes, Surigao del
Sur
1
13-046(DC)
William M. Angos
vs.
Senonina P. Cuanan
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, td D ISMISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT '
Resolution (EB) - xxx Petitioner William A. Angos’ Motion for Reconsideration dated 11 March 2013 is hereby DENIED for lack of merit and the\ Resolution dated 30 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED. Consequently, Respondent Senonina P. C iianan may be validly substituted in accordance with the provisions of Section 77 of the OEC \
»\
January 30, 2013
April 23, 2013
47. Province of Kalinga
1
13-047(DC)
Allen Jesse C. Mangaoang
vs.
G. Farnaw A. Claver
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition for LACK OF MERIT
Order (FD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
January 10, 2013
January 22, 2013
48. San Fernando City, La Union
II
13-048(DC)
Gerald C. Tabac
vs.
Reynaldo T. Jucutan
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Reynaldo T. Jucutan is hereby CANCELLED
Order (SD) - Acting on the Motion for Issuance of Certificate of Finality filed by pet through counsel on April 18, 2013, praying that a Certificate of Finality be issued on the Resolution promulgated on Jan. 23, 2013 for the instant case, the Commission (SD) hereby DIRECTS Atty. Jado Rafael A. Bognedon, counsel for the respondent, to file his comment on said motion
January 21, 2013
April 23, 2013
rPage 14 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
)V )
MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
49. Taytay,Rizal
I
13-049(DC)
Janet De Leon Mercado
vs.
Jessica “Janet” C. De Leon
Resolution (FD) V- xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT the petition praying to declare JESSICA “JANET” C. DE LEON as nuisance candidate
Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant MR is denied for lack of merit ^
December 19, 2012
March 14, 2013
50. Lone District of the City of
San Jose del Monte,
Buiacan
II
13-050(DC)
In the matter of the Petition to Deny Due Course To or Cancel COC of Imelda A. Papin as Congressional
Candidate in the Lone District of the City of San Jose Del Monte, Province of
Buiacan
Arangkada San Joseno Political Party represented by its Secretary General,
Mr. Zosimo B. Lorenzo
vs.
Imelda A. Papin
Resolution (SD) - xx^the Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Imelda A. Papin is hereby G RANTED. Accordingly, her Certificate of Candidacy^is CANCELLED
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby GRANTED. The Resolution of the Commission (SD) dated 31 January 2013 is hereby REVERSED and SET ASIDE
January 31, 2013
April 18, 2013
51. Silang,Cavite
I
13-051(DC)
In Re: In the matter of the Petition to Declare Pablito V. Angcaya as nuisance
candidate
Armando A. De Castro
vs.
Pablito V. Angcaya
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT the Petition and DECLARE respondent PABLITO V. ANGCAYA as a nuisance candidate. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent is hereby CANCELLED
January 22, 2013
i
Page 15 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) 1 )
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
52. SanPascual,Batangas
II
13-052(DC)
Antonio Jordan Tabares, Jr. \
\vs.
Antonio Dimayuga
\
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to GRANT the instant Petition. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Antonio Dimayuga is hereby CANCELLED
Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant motion is hereby GRANTED. The January 28, 2013 Resolution of the Commission (SD) is hereby REVERSED and SET ASIDE
January 28, 2013
May 02, 2013
53. Lone District of
Marinduque
1
13-053(DC)
Joseph Soccoro B. Tan
vs.
Atty. Regina Ongsiako Reyes
'Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of respondent REGINA ONGSIAKO REYES is hereby CANCELLED
Order (FD) - xxx MR filed by respondent through counsel elevated to en banc
March 27, 2013
April 16, 2013
54. SanPascual,Batangas
II
13-054(DC)
Antonio Jordan Tabares, Jr.
vs.
Ma. Brenda Kenrick, alias Ma. Brenda Dimayuga
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED
January 21, 2013
55. Bayugan City, Agusan
del Sur
1
13-055(DC)
Ferdinand Marcus Martir Banosia
vs.
Analiz Efren Sevandal For: Annulment/Render Void and consider as not filed COC Due to Late Filing
Resolution (FD) - xxx resolves to DENY the petition for LACK OF MERIT
Resolution <EB) - xxx petitioner’s Motion for Reconsideration is hereby DENIED for utter lack of merit
January 21, 2013
April 24, 2013
I
) )
MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
56. 4m District of Quezon Province
1
13-056(DC)
w/SPA13-057
Wigbferto R. Tanada, Jr.
vs.
Alvin J^hn S. Tanada
\\9
\
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISM ISS the two Petitions, SPA No. 13-056 (DC) and SPA 13-057 (DC) for LACK OF MERIT
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration dated 18 February 2013 is PARTIALLY GRANTED. The Motion for Reconsideration for SPA No. 13-057 (DC) is DENIED for LACK OF MERIT. However, the Motion for Reconsideration for SPA No. 13-066 (DC) is GRANTED. Accordingly, Respondent Alvin John S. Tanada’s Certificate of Candidacy for the position of Member of the House of Representatives for the 4th district of the Province of Quezon is hereby CANCELLED
January 29, 2013
w /SPA 13-057
April 25, 2013
57. 4m District of Quezon Province
13-057(DC)
Wigberto R. Tanada, Jr.
vs.
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISM ISS the two Petitions, SPA No. 13-056 (DC) and SPA 13-057 (DC) for LACK OF MERIT
January 29, 2013
w /SPA 13-056
1w/SPA13-056
Alvin John S. Tanada Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration dated 18 February 2013 is PARTIALLY GRANTED. The Motion for Reconsideration for SPA No. 13-057 (DC) is DENIED for LACK OF MERIT. However, the Motion for Reconsideration for SPA No. 13-056 (DC) is GRANTED. Accordingly, Respondent Alvin John S. Tanada’s Certificate of Candidacy for the position of Member of the House of Representatives for the 4th district of the Province of Quezon is hereby CANCELLED
April 25, 2013
rPage 17 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
\I ) )
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA\2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
\
\
58. District 1, Province of
Albay
I
\3-058\DC)
IVictor S. Ziga
Edgardo T. Vosotros, Atty. Arsenio N. Base, Jr.
Atty. Julian C. Cargullo
vs.
Edcel Burce Lagman, Jr.
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Instant Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel Certificate of Candidacy dated 08 October 2012 for LACK OF MERIT
Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is denied for lack of merit
January 30, 2013
April 25, 2013
\
\i59. Indang,
Cavite
II
13-059(DC)\
\
Perfecto V. Fidel
vs.
Lineth Espineli Abutin
Urgent Petition to Disallow Improper, Misleading and Confusing Registration of Last Name of Candidate and to Correct Comelec Official List of Candidates’ Names to Appear on the Official Ballot
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is GRANTED. Respondent LINETH ESPINELI-ABUTIN's use of the last name FIDEL to appear on the official ballot is hereby DISALLOWED. The Election Officer of Indang, Cavite is hereby DIRECTED to correct the Official List of Candidates who filed their Certificate of candidacy for the May 13, 2013 National and Local Elections to reflect the correct last name of respondent as ESPINELI-ABUTIN
January 11, 2013
60. 4tn District of the Province ofCamarines
Sur
I
13-060(DC)
Gilmar S. Pacamarra, in his capacity as registered voter of Precinct 7A,
Barangay San Antonio, San Jose, Camarines Sur
vs.
Ariel “Aga” A. Muhlach
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel the Certificate of Candidacy of the respondent Ariel “Aga” A. Muhlach for LACK OF MERIT
Manifestation with Motion (To Withdraw Petitioner’s Motion for Reconsideration) filed by counsel for petitioner Gilmar S. Pacamarra on April 29, 2013
January 15, 2013
Page 18 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
\
MUN. / c / r / / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
\
* 1 .\
\1\
Sasmuan,Pampanga
II
13-061(DC)
Nardo M. Velasco
vs.
Pedro L. Velasco
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is DENIED for lack of merit
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is hereby DENIED. The Resolution of the Commission (SD) dated January 28, 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED
January 28, 2013
April 24, 2013
\\
\\
62. \ First District i of Quezon \ Province9\
1
13-062(DC)
Romeo Laguador Villenas and Raffy Rosal Fernandez
vs.
Wilfrido Mark Me. Cormick Enverga
Pauline Ann Carpio Villasenor, Petitioner-intervenor
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition
Order (FD) - xxx MRs elevated to en banc
January 15, 2013
January 29, 2013
\\
\ 9\
63. Tangalan,Aklan
1
13-063(DC)
In Re: Petition to deny due course to or cancel Certificate of Candidacy of Noel
Teston y Delos Santos as Mayor of Tangalan, Aklan for the 2013 National,
Local and ARMM Elections
Gene Torre Fuentes
vs.
Noel Teston y Delos Santos
Submitted for resolution
64. 1st District of Bulacan
I
13-064(DC-F)
Ma. Victoria R. Sy-Alvarado
vs.
Sahiron Dulah Salim
Submitted for resolution
1
Page 19 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED
V
REMARKS
65. Province o f
Bulacan
1
13-065(DC-F)
Wilhelmino M. Sy-Alvarado
vs.
Ernesto D. Balite
Resolution (FD) - xxx the petition is hereby GRANTED. Respondent Ernesto D. Balite is hereby declared as NUISANCE CANDIDATE, and his Certificate of Candidacy for Governor of Bulacan for the 13 May 2013 National and Local Elections is CANCELLED
Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. Accordingly, the Decision of this Commission (First Division) dated 29 January 2013 stands
January 29, \2013
\
\M arcli22,
201^a
66. Province of Bulacan
II
13-066(DC-F)
Daniel R. Fernando
vs.
Josephine Cagiwa Lopez
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit
January 'l6, 2013
67. Province of Bulacan
II
13-067(DC-F)
Daniel R. Fernando
vs.
Jayson Olarte Ocampo
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent JAYSON OLARTE OCAMPO as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE is hereby DENIED for utter lack of merit
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration dated 25 February 2013 for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 01 February 2013 is hereby AFFIRM ED
February 01, 2013
April 23, 2013
68. Viga,Catanduanes
II
13-068(DC)
Gilbert C. Olfindo
vs.
Abelardo M. Abundo, Sr.
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED
January 02, 2013
r Page 20 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
)
MUN. / C I T Y / PRO VINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
69. Mayantoc,Tarlac
II
13-069(DC-F)
lluminado E. Pobre, Jr.
vs.
Marciano Dela Cruz Pulido
Resolution (SD) - xxx the p^ition is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of MARCIANO DELA CRUZ PULIDO is hereby CANCELLED
*t
January 16, 2013
70. Fifth District of Manila
I
13-070(DC)
Richard C. Ibay
vs.
Jose Antonio L. Ibay
Resolution (FD) - xxx resolves to GRANT the instant Petition. Respondent JOSE A N TO N lb L. IBAY’s Certificate of Candidacy is hereby dlENIED and CANCELLED \
9
January 31, 2013
71. Ternate,Cavite
I
13-071(DC)
Jayson D. Cabana
vs.
Francisco L. Cabana, Jr.
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the Petition dated 11 October 2012 for being M OOT and ACADEMIC. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Francisco L. Cabana, Jr. is hereby CANCELLED. Let a copy of this Resolution be FORW ARDED to the Law Dept, of the Commission with regard to the finalization of the Official List of Candidates for the 13 May 2013 National, Local and ARMM Elections
January 15, 2013
72. CaloocanCity
I
13-072(DC)
Dionisio F. Guillarte
vs.
Fred Naim Bello
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates’ Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 45. Bello, Fred Naim - Mayor - Caloocan City xxx
January 11, 2013
73. CaloocanCity
II
13-073(DC)
In Re: Petition to declare as a nuisance candidate, Luis San Pedro Razo,
candidate for the Position of Mayor of Caloocan City in the 2013 National and
Local Elections, denying dife course
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates’ Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013
January 11, 2013
Page 21 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
\J
\I )
m un . / c / r r /PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
and/or cancelling his COC
Laura Bucao Vital
vs.
Luis San Pedro Razo
Elections: xxk 53. Razo, Luis San Pedro - Mayor - Caloocan City kxx
*
\74. Cabagan,
Isabela
1
13-074(DC-F)
Rodolfo B. Albano, Jr.
vs.
Francisco B. Flores, Comelec Cabagan, Isabela, Represented by EO Josephine
Z. Mallannao
Resolution (FD) -W x x the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED for LAC^K OF MERIT
Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED for utter lack of merit. The assailed Resolution is AFFIRMED en toto
January 22, 2013
April 24, 2013
75. Pililla, Rizal
1
13-075(DC)
In the matter of the disqualification of Tomas N. Aguirre, as candidate for Municipal Councilor of Pililla, Rizal
Eduardo Z. Vidanes,Brgy. Quisao, Pililla, Riza
vs.
Tomas N. Aguirre
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to D ISM ISS the instant Petition for utter lack of merit
April 25, 2013
76. Sipalay City Negros
Occidental
II
13-076(DC)
Rodolfo Divinagracia
vs.
Oscar Chua Montilla, Jr., Ma. Gina Montilla Lizares
i . . . . . ...
Resolution (SD) - xxx in view of the foregoing, the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ENY the instant Motion for Reconsideration and to AFFIRM the Second Division’s ruling
January 28, 2013
April 23, 2013
r Page 22 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
\
)
/Wl/W. / C /7T/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
77. 2na District of the
Province of Cagayan
II
13-077(DC-F)
In Re: Petition for declarations Sherwin Calimag y Cabasag a .lia . “Win” as nuisance candidate for the position of Congressman for the 2nd
District of Cagayan\
Baby Aline Vargas-Alfonso ^
vs. ^
Sherwin Calimag y Cabasag
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates' Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 12. Calimag, Sherwin C. - Member, House of Representatives, (2nd Dist.) - Province of Cagayan xxx
January 11, 2013
78. Calbiga,Samar
1
13-078(DC-F)
Santiago B. Abelido
vs.
Nicasio “Cas” Labalan Abaigar
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT the instant Petition to Deny Due Course/ Cancel COC. Accordingly, the COC filed by Nicasio Labalan Abaigar for the position of mayor in Calbiga, Samar is hereby CANCELLED for containing false material representation pertinent to residence
Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED, for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution of the First Division is hereby AFFIRMED
January 28, 2013
May 03, 2013
79. Toledo City, Cebu
II
13-079(DC-F)
Lina Dela Pena Jalover, Georgie A. Huiso, and Velvet Barquin Zamora
vs.
John Henry R. Osmefia
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the Petition for LACK OF M ERIT
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
April 03, 2013
April 25, 2013
fPage 23 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
;
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE
\
STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
80. Toledo City, Cebu
II
13-080(DC-F)
Noe BVNeo and Cecilia Apurado ' Edoloverio
vs.
Antonio P. Yapha, JR.
V
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Due Course filed by Petitioners Neo and Apurado and DECLARES that Respondent Yapha is qualified to run for Vice Mayor of Toledo City, Province of Cebu in the 13 May 2013 Elections
w/ MR filed by petitioners
January 24, 2013
81. Candijay,Bohol
I
13-081(DC-F)
Sergi^G . Amora, Jr.
\ vs.
Christopher B. Tutor
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition
January 29, 2013
82. Balabagan, Lanao del
Sur
II
13-082(DC-F)
Edna Ogka Benito
vs.
Amer R. Sampiano
Submitted for resolution
83. Sevilla,Bohol
1
13-083(DC-F)
In Re: Petition to Cancel COC of Juliet Dano y Bucag for the position of
Municipal Mayor in the Municipality of Sevilla, Bohol on the ground of material
misrepresentation
Marie Karen Joy Digal y Bungagong
vs.
Juliet Dano y Bucag
Submitted for resolution
r Page 24 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
\
84. Pavia, Iloilo
1
\ 13-084 ' (DC-F)
\\
\«\
In Re: Petition to declare Michael Jimena Gorriceta a.k.a. Michael J.
Gorriceta as nuisance candidate for the position of Municipal Mayor of the
Municipality of Pavia, Iloilo and to Deny Due Course to or Cancel his Certificate of Candidacy as a nuisance candidate
Michael Barrido Gorriceta
vs.
Miichael J. Gorriceta
Order (FD) - xxx the instant Petition for Denial/ Cancellation of COC of Michael Jimena Gorriceta is hereby DISMISSED for being M O O T and ACADEMIC
April 25, 2013 \
\\
\9\
85. 5tn District of Cebu
II
13-085(DC-F)
In the matter of the petition to deny due course or cancel the COC of Gilbert
Wagas as Congressional Candidate in the 5th District of Cebu
Joel Quino
vs.
Gilbert W agas
Submitted for resolution
86. Ginatilan,Cebu
II
13-086(DC-F)
Dean Michael P. Singco
vs.
Patrocinio ‘'Pat" R. Singco
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit
Resolution (EB) - xxx the instant motion is DENIED en toto
January 16, 2013
April 24, 2013
Page 25 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
\87
\
\
Estancia,Iloilo
II
13-087(DC-F)
Rene S. Cordero
vs.
Mario B. Golingan
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration dated 06 February 2013 for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 16 Januar 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED
January 16, 2013
April 05, 2013
\
V
\•
First District of Antipolo
City
II
13-088(DC-F)
In the matter of Petition to declare Danilo “Uding” Zaratan Aquino a
nuisance candidate and his COC be denied due course and be cancelled
Prudencio Marco Aquino
vs.
Danilo Zaratan Aquino
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby GRANTED. Respondent Danilo Zartan Aquino is hereby declared a NUISANCE CANDIDATE, and consequently, his CERTIFICATE OF CANDIDACY for the position of Member, Sangguniang Panlungsod, 1st Dist., Antipolo City, Rizal is hereby ordered CANCELLED
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution of the Commission (Second Division) dated 21 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED
January 21, 2013
April 05, 2013
\\
89. Guinsiiiban,Camiguin
I
13-089(DC-F)
Joanne Marie C. Rubin
vs.
Saturnino S. Lumba
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the Petition dated 06 October 2012 for LACK OF MERIT
January 15, 2013
90. MambajaoCamiguin
I
13-090(DC-F)
Ma. Victoria J. Jansol
vs.
Roberto L. Odarve
Resolution (FD) - xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent ROBERTO L. ODARVE as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE is hereby DENIED for utter lack of merit
April 16, 2013
91. Carles, Iloilo 13-091(DC-F)
Petition for Disqualification of Rodolfo Dumayas as candidate for Sangguniang
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petitions for Disqualificationof respondents* Rodolfo S. Dumayas
January 21, 2013
Page 26 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED
\
REMARKS
IIBayan Member of the Municipality of
Carles, Iloilo as provided under Rule 25 of the Comelec Rules of Procedure as
amended by Resolution No. 9523
Alvin V. Barnes vs.
Rodolfo Dumayas
and Arnel T. Francisco to run in the 13 May 2013 elections as Sangguniang Bayan Members of the Municipality of Carles, Iloilo are DISMISSED and their Certificates of Candidacies are UPHELD
\
\
\\
\92. Milagros,
Masbate
II
13-092(DC-F)
Florence P. De Jesus
vs.
Luz Cleta R. Bakunawa
Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel the COC of Luz Cleta R.
Bakunawa
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Due Course to Respondent LUZ CLETA REYES BAKUNAWA’S Certificate of Candidacy
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
March 07, 2013
March 27, 2013
93. Carles, Iloilo
1
13-093(DC-F)
Petition for Disqualification of Arnel Francisco as candidate for
Sangguniang Bayan Member of the Municipality of Carles, Iloilo as provided under Rule 25 of the Comelec Rules of Procedure as amended by Resolution
No. 9523
Alvin V. Barnes
vs.
Arnel Francisco
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petitions for Disqualification of respondents Rodolfo S. Dumayas and Arnel T. Francisco to run in the 13 May 2013 elections as Sangguniang Bayan Members of the Municipality of Carles, Iloilo are D ISM ISSED and their Certificates of Candidacies are UPHELD
January 21, 2013
)
MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
94. EasternSamar
II
13-094(DC-F)
Hon. Conrado B. Nicart, Jr.
vs.
Alfredo C. Hobayan
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition i ̂ DENIED for lack of merit '
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. Accordingly, the Resolution of the Honorable Commission’s Second Division promulgated on 28 January 2013 stands ^
January 28, 2013
April 23, 2013
95. Mambajao,Camiguin
II
13-095(DC-F)
Ma. Victoria J. Jansol
vs.
Pacundo Ebarle
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit \
*
January16,2013
96. MambajaoCamiguin
1
13-096(DC-F)
Ma. Victoria J. Jansol
vs.
Isabelo P. Paraiso
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT
January 11, 2013
97. MambajaoCamiguin
1
13-097(DC-F)
Ma. Victoria J. Jansol
vs.
Gil G. Fabe
Resolution (FD) - xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent GIL G. FABE as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE is hereby DENIED for utter lack of merit
May 03, 2013
98. MambajaoCamiguin
1
13-098(DC-F)
Ma. Victoria J. Jansol
vs.
Renato L. Tamayo, Sr.
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Petition dated 09 October 2012 for LACK OF MERIT
January 15, 2013
Page 28 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
MUN. / C I T Y / P RO VINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
99. Mambajao,Camiguin
11
13-099(DC-F)
Ma. Victoria J. Jansol
vs.
Jim S. Dagondon
Resolution \(S D ) - xxx the Petition is hereby DISMISSED\for lack of merit
i
January 16, 2013
100. Mambajao,Camiguin
II
13-100(DC-F)
Ma. Victoria J. Jansol
vs.
Danilo M. Pabillan
Resolution (SD4 - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED for sack of merit
\•\
January 16, 2013
101. MambajaoCamiguin
1
13-101(DC)
Ma. Victoria J. Jansol
vs.
Diosdado B. Aranas
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
March 21, 2013
102. Mambajao,Camiguin
II
13-102(DC-F)
Ma. Victoria J. Jansol
vs.
Pepe E. Pabillore
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
January 16, 2013
103. MambajaoCamiguin
1
13-103(DC-F)
Ma. Luisa D. Romualdo
vs.
Angustia H. Jadman
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition filed against respondent Angustia H. Jadman for LACK OF MERIT
January 11, 2013
rPage 29 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE
\
STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
104. MambajaoCamiguin
I
13-104(DC-F)
Roldan A. Chan V
vs.
Antonio D. Gultiano\
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Petition for LACK OF MERIT
March 21, 2013
105. First District of Palawan
II
13-105(DC-F)
Randy “Toto” Rodriguez \
vs. ^
Roberto “Toto” Rodriguez
Omnibus Resolution (SD) - xxx the consolidated cases are resolved as follows: In SPA No. 13-033 (DC), the petition to declare Randy M. Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is hereby DISMISSED. However, Randy M. Rodriguez is ordered not to use and place “Toto” as the nickname to appear in the official ballot/ In SPA No. 13- 105 (DC)(F) the petition to declare Roberto “Toto” Rodriguez as a nuisance candidate is also DISM ISSED
January 28, 2013
w /S P A 13- 033
106. South Ubian, Tawi-
Tawi Province
I
13-106(DC-F)
Mustapha J. Omar
vs.
Gamal S. Hayudini
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES as it hereby RESOLVED, to DISMISS the petition filed against respondent Gamal S. Hayudini for LACK OF M ERIT
January 31, 2013
107. Tandubas,Tawi-Tawi
I
13-107(DC-F)
In Re: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancel COC
Albert H. Kahong
vs.
Mindalyn Idlana Abubakar
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the petition praying to disqualify respondent Mindalyn Idlana Abubakar
January 15, 2013
Page 30 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
108. MabalacatCity,
PampangaProvince
II
13-108(DC-F)
\ Noelito B. Castro
vs.
Noli M. Castro*
Petition to Beclare Respondent, Noli M. castro\a nuisance candidate
\
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition to Declare Respondent NOLI “JUN” M. CASTRO as a NUISANCE CANDIDATE is hereby DENIED for utter Jack of merit
January 11, 2013
109. Cortes, Surigao del
Sur
II
13-109(DC-F)
Senbnina P. Cuanan
' vs.
Alfonso G. Cuanan
Petition for Cancellation of COC
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is GRANTED. Respondent Alfonso G. Cuanan is hereby declared a NUISANCE CANDIDATE, and consequently, his CERTIFICATE OF CANDIDACY for the position of Mayor of the Municipality of Cortes, Surigao Del Sur is hereby ordered CANCELLED
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
January 16, 2013
February 14, 2013
110. Oras,EasternSamar
II
13-110(DC-F)
Noel Ramonito M. Montallana
vs.
Aldin M. Montallana
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition of NOEL RAMONITO M. MONTALLANA is hereby DENIED
January 16, 2013
111. La Paz, Abra
I
13-111(DC-F)
Joseph Sto. Nino B. Bernos
vs.
Florencia B. Bernos
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Motion for Reconsideration and to AFFIRM the First Division’s ruling
January 28, 2013
March 22, 2013
\I ) )
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
\
112. 1SI District,\ Quezon ̂Province
II
13-112(DC-F)
\
\
Teresita O. Dator Represented by Atty. Jorge B. Vargas
as her Attorney-in-fact
vs.
Isidro D. Dator
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
January 16, 2013 \
\
\113. Quezon
Province
I
13-113(\)C-F)
Petition for the declaration of candidate Rolando Merano for position of
Governor of Quezon Province as a nuisance candidate
David C. Suarez
vs.
Rolando Merano
Order (FD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED for failure to file within the reglementary period
November 20, 2012
\
\
114. Gainza,Camarines
Sur
I
13-114(DC-F)
In the matter of the petition to disqualify Romeo A. Gontang and/or to deny due
course to or cancel his COC for the position of Mayor of Gainza, Camarines
Sur, pursuant to title 2, chapter 1, Section 40 (A) of RA 7160 in relation
with Rule 25 of En Banc Comelec Resolution No. 9523
Serafin A. Encinas
vs.
Romeo A. Gontang
Resolution (FD) - xxx the Verified Petition is hereby DISMISSED
January 22, 2013
Page 32 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
1
) ) \
MUN. / CITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
\115. Zamboanga
City
II
13-115(DC)
Roel B. Natividad, Arturo N. Onrubia & Ahmad Narzad K. Sampang
vs.
Romeo G. Jalosjos
Resolution No. 9613 - xxx RESOLVES, to CANCEL and DENY due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zamboanga City in the May 13, 2013 NILE
January 15, 2013 V
\... A_ . ...- - ...........
•j16.
\»\
Jaen, Nueva Ecija
II
13-116(DC)
SP01 Wilson P. Hipolito
vs.
Rolando I. Manalo
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED
January 21, 2013
\
\1
117. First District of Samar
I
13-117(DC-F)
w/ SPA 13-168
(DC)
Elmer M. Candido
vs.
Arnold Vasquez Tan
Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant consolidated Petitions are hereby DENIED
Order (FD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
January 29, 2013
February 14, 2013
118. Hernani,EasternSamar
II
13-118(DC-F)
Wilmar “Mema" Siguan Candido
vs.
Wilmar “Memo” Daga Candido
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition to declare Wilmar “Memo” Daga Candido as a nuisance candidate is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, respondent's Certificate of Candidacy is CANCELLED
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution of the Commission (SD) dated 28 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED
January 28, 2013
April 08, 2013
rPage 33 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
119. Province of Camiguin
I
13-119(DC-F)
James A. Ederango
vs.
Luisito P. Ucab
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the^ Petition dated 06 October 2012 for LACK of MERIT
February 01, i 2013
\120. Lagayan,
Abra
I
13-120(DC)
Antonio Maduli Bilong
vs.
Bernadine Sibayan-Joson
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition dated 19 October 2012
Rebruary 01, V 2013
\t
121. 7m District of Cavite
II
13-121(DC)
Laureano S. Mendoza, in his capacity as registered voter of Precinct 0 1 14A, Saiz De Junio Village, Sungay East,
Tagaytay City, Cavite
vs.
Gilbert Cesar C. Remulla
Resolution (SD) - xxx thepetition is hereby DISM ISSED for lack of merit
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
February 20, 2013
March 05, 2013
122. Lagayan,Abra
I
13-122(DC-F)
Bernadine Sibayan Joson
vs.
Cornelio David Malangen
For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS this case for LACK OF MERIT
January 15, 2013
123. Lagayan,Abra
II
13-123(DC-F)
Bernadine Sibayan Joson
vs.
Joel Baduli Bilong, Sr.
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to DENY the instant Petition for UTTER LACK OF MERIT
t
January 28, 2013
Page 34 o f 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
) ' )
MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate \
124. Lagayan,Abra
I
13-124(DC-F)
Bernadine Sibayan Joson
vs.
Ronnie Blaza Paingan
For: Declaration o f a candidate as nuisance candidate
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition filed against respondent Ronnie Blaza Paingan for LACK OF MERIT ^
\\
\a\
January 29, 2013
125. Lagayan,Abra
I
13-125(DC-F)
Bernadine Sibayan Joson
vs.
Antonio Maduli Bilong
For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition dated 19 October 2012
January 22, 2013
126. Lagayan,Abra
II
13-126(DC-F)
Bernadine Sibayan Joson
vs.
Alberto Ci-o Pasiguen
For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate
Resolution (SD) - RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Due Course to Respondent Ci-o Pasiguen’s Certificate of Candidacy
January 16, 2013
Page 35 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
127. Lagayan,Abra
J
13-127(DC-F)
Bernadine Sibayan Joson
vs.
Rubio Jimenez Sindon
For: Declaration of a candidate as nuisance candidate
Resolutidp (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
\
V\
April 10, 2013
128. Banguigui,Sulu
Province
I
13-128(DC)
Whajid Indanan Sahidulla
vs.
Addullajid S. Alih
Verified Petition to deny due course or cancel the COC under Sec. 78 in
relation to Sec. 74 of BP 881
Resolution (Ffy) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT the petition to den/,due course or cancel the certificate of candidacy of ADDULLAJID S. ALIH
Order (FD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
January 29, 2013
February 14, 2013
-
129. Sallapadan,ABra
I
13-129(DC)
Nenita M. Cardenas
vs.
Wilbert Enostacion For: Petition to deny due course to or
cancellation of COC
Submitted for resolution
130. Sallapadan,Abra
I
13-130(DC)
Nenita M. Cardenas
vs.
Wilbert Enostacion
t For: Petition for Disqualificaiton
Submitted for resolution
MUN. / C I T Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
131. CalbayogCity
I
13-131(DC-F)
Renato A. De Los ReVes
vs.
Angelie Tee Tan
\Petition to deny due course andfor to
Cancel COC \
Submitted for resolution
132. Province of Isabela
II
13-132(DC)
Re: In the matter of petition to <hny due course to or Cancellation of C$)C of candidate for Governor of the ProvTfice
of Isabela,
Pablo C. Guray, et al.
vs.
Lilia Mijares Uy
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: 1. To declare the following as NUISANCE candidates and to cause the immediate cancellation /deletion of their names from the Candidates’ Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections: xxx 37. Uy, Lilia Mijares - Governor - Province of Isabela xxx
January 11, 2013
133. 1st District, Province of
Isabela
II
13-133(DC-F)
Rodolfo T. Albano III
vs.
Stephen G. Soliven
Petition to declare a candidate as nuisance candidate
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to DENY the instant petition for UTTER LACK O F M ERIT
Resolution (EB) - xxx petitioner RODOLFO T. ALBANO Ill’s Motion for Reconsideration is hereby DENIED
January 17, 2013
April 24, 2013
134. 1st District, Province of
Isabela
*ll
13-134(DC-F)
Rodolfo T. Albano III
vs.
Ray Anthony Claravall Bafiez
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED for being moot and academic
April 23, 2013
i
Page 37 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
Petition to declare a candidate as ' nuisance candidate
135. 4m District of Nueva Ecija
II
13-135(DC)
Raul L. Villareal
\ vs
\O rlando A. Nagano
\For\ Cancellation of COC
\
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit
January 16, 2013
136. Dingras, llocos Norte
I
13-136(DC)
Esteban Foz Romero
vs.
Joefrey P. Saguid
For: Petition to deny due course to or Cancellation of COC
Resolution (FD) - xxx the Petition to Deny due course and/or to Cancel the COC of Respondent JOEFREY P. SAGUID is hereby DISMISSED
April 29, 2013
137. Dingras, llocos Norte
I
13-137(DC)
Roderick R. Trinidad
vs.
Nathaniel Ruben D. Taylan II
For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of COC
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISM ISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT
January 11, 2013
138. Dingras, llocos Norte
I
13-138(DC)
Joel B. Toribio
vs.
Elsie P. Garces
Resolution (FD) - xx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition for LACK OF MERIT
January 23, 2013
i
Page 38 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
\\\
For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of COC \
139. Dingras, I llocos Norte
II
13-139^ ( D C ,
\
Roderick R. Trinidad
vs.
Rowena Celerina P. Verzosa
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit
January 16, 2013
\I
\\
\
140. Dingras, llocos Norte
I
13-140(DC)
Joel Baraoidan Toribio
vs.
Rosalinda Ruiz Castro
For: Petition to Deny Due Course and/or to Cancel C O C
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC for LACK OF MERIT
February 01, 2013
141. Dingras, Hocos Norte
II
13-141(DC)
Alemar D. Rosqueta
vs.
Enriqueto J. Canete, Jr.
For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of COC
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of-merit
January 21, 2013
142. Dingras, llocos Norte
I
13-142(DC)
Bobby Perfecto R. Simeon
vs.
Osias A. Ballesteros
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT
i
January 11, 2013
Page 39 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
\
For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of COC
\\
t
143.
I\
Dingras, llocos Norte
I
13-143(DC)
Esteban F. Romero
vs.
Jose Mari Genaro B. Albano
For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellation of COC
Submitted for resolution " ' \
\
\\
144. DonVictoriano,
MisamisOccidental
II
13-144(DC)
Carlito M. Bongcac
vs.
Elsie M. Llanes
Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC of Respondent
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion for Reconsideration is DENIED. The assailed Resolution of the Second Division is hereby AFFIRMED
January 21, 2013
April 24, 2013
145. DonVictoriano,
MisamisOccidental
II
13-145(DC)
Ricardo L. Solatorio
vs.
Danny V. Pata
Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC of Respondent
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
February 01, 2013
146. DonVictoriano,
Misamis
13-146(DC)
Emilio C. Medel
vs.
Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is herebyDISMISSED for LACK OF M ERIT
i
February 01, 2013
r Page 4 0 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
)
) ‘ )
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
\150. Tuburan,
Cebu
II
13-150(DC)
Antonio M. Primacion and Lourdes D. Esmero
Vs.
Daphne A. Lagon
For: Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc of Daphne Arias Lagon as
Vice-Mayor of Tuburan, Cebu
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is DENIED for lack of merit \
Order (EB) - The Commission (Ej|3) hereby GRANTS the Comment and/or Opposition tq Petitioner’s Motion for Reconsideration filed by respondent through counsel on March 19, 2013 xxxi The Motion for Reconsideration filed on March 4,' 2013 is hereby DISM ISSED for failure of petitioners to pay motion fees in the amount of One Thousand Pesos (Php1,000.00)
January 28, 2013
April 02, 2013
151. Catanduanes
I
13-151(DC)
Larry S. Que
Vs.
Joseph C. Cua
Petition to Deny Due Course and to Cancel COC
Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant Petition is DENIED for lack of merit
Order (FD) - xxx MR filed by pet through counsel on April 19, 2013, xxx elevated to the Commission en banc for proper disposition
April 10, 2013
April 23, 2013
152. Bangar, La Union
II
13-152(DC)
Joy Pinzon Merin
Vs.
Saturnino Dingle
Petition to Cancel COC and to Disqualify Respodent due to ineligibility
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
January 24, 2013
February 07, 2013
i
Page 42 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
>\
MUN. / C ITY / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
153. 2™ District, Marcos,
llocos Norte
I
13-153(DC)
Salvador S. Pillos
Vs.
Ignacio A. Agustin
For: Petition to Deny Due Course to or Cancellationof CO C
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the instant Petition for UTTER LACK OF MERIT
\
\
March 06, 2013
154. Province of Camarines
Sur
I
13-154(DC)
Luis R. Villafuerte
Vs.
Miguel R. Villafuerte
Verified Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc of respondent Miguel Reyes Villafuerte as candidate for
Governor of the Province of Camarines Sur
Resolution iFD ) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition for LACK OF MERIT
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration dated 08 February 2013 for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution of the Commission (FD) promulgated on 15 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED
January 15, 2013
April 01, 2013
155. 2nc District of Antipolo
City
1
13-155(DC)
In Re: Petition to disqualify candidate to elective position
'Avelino P. De Quiroz
Vs.
Nixon R. Aranas
Submitted for resolution
i
Page 43 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
156. Aringay, La Union
II
13-156(DC)
Frank Ong Sibuma andVDino Ong Sibuma ^
Vs.
Napoleon Chan Ong
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
January 21, 2013
February 05, 2013
157. 4m District of the Province
ofCamarines
Sur
II
13-157(DC)
Crispin M. Imperial and Francisco Perico Dizon, in their capacity as
registered voters of Brgy. San\Juan, San Jose, Camarines Sur\
Vs.
Ariel Aquino Muhlach
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration dated 12 March 2013 for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 05 March 2013 is hereby AFFIRM ED
March 05, 2013
May 02, 2013
158. Datu Hoffer Ampatuan,
Maguindanao
I
13-158(DC)
Bongbong M. Ampatuan
Vs.
Mhurphy P. Ampatuan
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Petition for LACK OF M ERIT
Order (FD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
January 30, 2013
April 05, 2013
159. Datu Joffer Ampatuan,
Maguindana 0
II
13-159(DC)
Bongbong M. Ampatuan
Vs.
Yamashita B. Mangacop
Petition to disqualify for lack of qualificationsor possessing some
grounds for disqualification
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DISMISSED
May 06, 2013
Page 44 o f 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013 TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
160. 2na District of Bataan Province
II
13-160(DC)
\ Oscar R. Delos Reyes
'
Juan Miguel R. Bondoc, a.k.a. Onemig Bondoc
\
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Petition for Denial / Cancellation of Certificate of Candidacy
March 19, 2013
161. Estancia,Iloilo
I
13-161(DC)
V Mario B. Golingan
^ N/s.*' Rene S. Cordero
Resolution (FD) - xxx this Commission RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the instant Petition for utter lack of merit
April 29, 2013
162. Jipapad,EasternSamar
II
13-162(DC)
In Re: Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc of Leoncio P. Mato,
candidate for Mayor of Jipapad, Eastern Samar
Ruben P. Go
Vs.
Leoncio P. Mato
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is dismissed for lack of merit
January 21, 2013
163. Malinao,Albay
I
13-163(DC)
Ofelia Zanosa Bigata and Evelyn Borja Cellona
Vs.
Salvador K. Moll
Petition To deny due course to or cancel COC)
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT the instant petition. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Salvador K. Moll is hereby DENIED DUE CO URSE TO AND/OR CANCELLED
Order (EB) - xxx hereby GRANTS the “Manifestation with Most Most Urgent Motion (To Deny Respondents’ Motion for Reconsideration for Lack of Jurisdiction) filed by pets through counsel on March 26, 2013, xxx/ The Motion for Reconsideration filed on March 4, 2013 is hereby DISMISSED for failure of petitioners to pay
February 01, 2013
w/ Separate Opinion of
Comm. Lim
April 02, 2013
i
Page 45 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE
\
SPA2013 TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
\
\ motion fees in the amount of One Thousand Pesos (Php1, 000.00)
\\
164. ZamboangaCity
■\\
13-164(DC)
Jose L. Lobregat & Adelante Zamboanga Party
Vs.
Romeo G. Jalosjos
Resolution No. 9613 - xxx RESOLVES, to CANCEL and DENY due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zamboanga City in the May 13, 2013 NLE
January 15, 2013
\\\\
165. 5tn District op, Quezon City 1
1
13-165(DC)
Manuel V. Macabuhay, Jr.
vs.
Arnold Francisco aka “Ogie Susano”
For: Petition for denial or Cancellation of COC
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition dated 29 October 2012
January 22, 2013
\9\
166. 3™Legislative District of
Camarines Sur
II
13-166(DC)
Nelson B. Julia
Vs.
Angel G. Naval
Verified Petition to deny due course to or cancel the coc
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Angel G. Naval for the position of Member of the Sangguniang Panlalawigan of the Third District of Camarines Sur is hereby CANCELLED
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
March 05, 2013
March 27, 2013
167. 3ro District of the Province
of Albay
II
13-167(DC)
Elmer Felix M. Pornel
Vs.
Fernando Vallejo Gonzalez
Joint Resolution (SD) - xxx the two (2) Petitions are hereby DISMISSED
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for reconsidedration dated 18 February 2013 for LACK OF MERIT. The Resolution promulgated on 31 January 2013 is hereby AFFIRMED *
January 31, 2013
April 05, 2013
w/SPA 13-178
r Page 46 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
\\ ) ) I
I\\
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED
\
REMARKS
168. 1slLegislative District of
Samar
13-168(DC)
w/SPA 13- 117
(DC)(F)
Tito M. Aniban
Vs.
Arnold Vasquez Tan
Resolution (FD) - xxx the instant consolidated Petitions are hereby DENIED
Pis. see SPA 13-117
January 29, 2013 \
\169. Tineg, Abra
II
13-169(DC)
Cromwell S. Luna
Vs.
Corinthia D. Crisologo
Petition to deny due course/Cancel coc
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
Order (SD) - xxx MR filed by pet through counsel on April 01, 2013 xxx elevated to en banc
March 12, 2013
April 17, 2013 \<5
\
170. 1st District of the Province of Palawan
I
13-170(DC)
Jesus L. Ustares, Sr., in his capacity as registered voter of Precinct 003A,Brgy. Bancal Municipality of Cuyo, Province
of Palawan
Vs.
Alvin Soteco Sandova
Submitted for resolution
171. SanAgustin,Romblon
I
13-171(DC)
Mar Dominic Abrencillo Correa
Vs.
Linda Jean Moreno Abero
Petition to deny due course to or cancel the coc
Submitted for resolution
Page 47 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED
REMARKS
172. San Jose, Camarines
Sur
II
13-172(DC)
Antonio Bermejo Chavez in his capacity as a registered voted of Brgy. Pugay,
San Jose, Camarines “Sur
Vs.
Eduardo Patriarca Pilapil
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to DENY the instant Petition for UTTER LACK OF MERIT \
\
\
February 01, 2013
173. Tarlac City
I
13-173(DC)
In Re: Petition for disqualification of Jerome H. La Pena as candidate for
City Mayor, Tarlac City
Esteban B. Aguas, Jr.
Vs.
Jerome H. Lapena
Submitted for resolution \
*\
174. Lupon,Davao
Oriental
II
13-174(DC-F)
In the matter of the petition for the disqualification of candidate Eva
Afahalces Larrobis Quinones- Mandalupe
Lanie R. Gamurot
Vs.
Eva Afahalces Larrobis Quinones- Mandalupe
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant Petition
February 01, 2013
175. SanRicardo,Southern
Leyte
13-175(DC-F)
In the matter of the petition to invalidate and strike out respondent’s Certificate of Candidacy for VMayor of San Ricardo,
Southern Leyte in the May 13, 2013 Elections due to ineligibility
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to GRANT thePetition dated 19 October 2012. Respondent JOVIC S.MEJIA is hereby excluded from the Certified List ofCandidatesi
March 21, 2013
Page 48 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) ■ >
\
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
I Generoso M. Herrera
Vs.
Jovic S. Mejia
With Motion to Declare Firfel and Executory Comelec Resolution Promulgated Inarch 21, 2013 filed by counsel for pet thru LBC reed on April 19, 2013
\\176. Second
Legislative District of Sarangani Province
I
13-176(DC-F)
In a matter of the petition to disqualify Provincial Board candidate Eugene L. Alzate of Sarangani Province, Region
XII
Mary Ann Gamino Gadian
Vs.
Eugene L. Alzate
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT \
Resolution (EB) - xxx the Motion V r Reconsideration is DENIED. The Resolution of the FiVst Division is hereby AFFIRMED
February 01, 2013
April 08, 2013
177. Inabanga,Bohol
I
13-177(DC)
Francisco L. Alesna, Jr.
Vs.
Atty. Epifanio B. Muneses
Petition to deny due course to or cancel coc
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the instant Petition for utter lack of merit
April 25, 2013
178. 3ra District of Albay
II
13-178(DC)
Renato M. Cervantes
Vs.
Fernando V. Gonzalez
Petition to deny due course and to cancfel coc
Joint Resolution (SD) - xxx the two (2) Petitions are hereby DISMISSED
January 31, 2013
w /S P A 13- 167
Page 49 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petiffon to Deny Due Course to Respondent Jose R. Ramirez, Jr.’s Certificate of Candidacy
DATED/PROMULGATED
179. Ligao City 13-179(DC)
Benjamin O. Matias
Vs.
Jose R. Ramirez, Jr.
Petition to deny due course and to cancel coc
January 16, 2013
iA-180. Zamboanga
City13-180(DC)
Jose L. Lobregat
Vs.
Romeo G. Jalosjos
Petition to deny due course to and/or to cancel COC
Resolution No. 9613 - xxx RESOLVES, to CANCEL and D E N \ due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zamboanga City in the May 13, 2013 NLE
January 15, 2013
181. District 1, PasayCity
I
13-181(DC)
Florencio C. Mateo
Vs.
Richard M. Advincula and Lexter N. Ibay
Submitted for resolution
182. Taal,Batangas
13-182(DC-F)
In the matter of the Petition to Cancel COC of Lino Vicente Montenegro y
Masangkay as candidate for Mayor of Taal, Batangas
Michael Rey Villano y Aseron
Vs.
Lino Vicente Montenegro y Masangkay
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant petition
January 15, 2013
REMARKS
Page 50 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
>
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
183. Marawi City
I
13-183(DC)
Arip M. Basfyian
Vs.
Shahanie Yasmin C. Salic\
\
Resolution (FD) - In view of the Affidavit dated 11 December 2012, executed by respondent attesting to the fact that she had already withdrawn her certificate of candidacy for vice-mayor of Marawi City, the instant petition is hereby DISM ISSED for being moot and academic. Besides, petitioner informed the Commission that he will no longer pursue his case against respondent
April 02, 2013
184. ZamboangaCity
II
13-184(DC)
Elbert C. Atilano \
Vs. '
Romeo G. Jalosjos
Petition to Deny Due Course to and/or to Cancel COC
Resolution No. 9613 - xxx RESOLVES, to CANCEL and DENY due course the Certificate of Candidacy filed by Romeo G. Jalosjos as Mayor of Zamboanga City in the May 13, 2013 NLE
January 15, 2013
185. Agno,Pangasinan
II
13-185(DC)
In the matter of the petition to deny due course to or cancel the coc of Gualberto
Ramirez Sison as a candidate for the position of Mayor of Agno, Pangasinan
Jose Pajeta, Jr.’
Vs.
Gualberto Ramirez Sison
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby GRANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Gualberto Ramirez Sison for the position of Mayor of the Municipality of Agno, Pangasinan is hereby CANCELLED
Order (SD) - xxx M R elevated to en banc
February 01, 2013
February 19, 2013
186. 3ra District of Quezon Province
1
13-186(DC)
Rodolfo Reyes Rosales
Vs.
Ma. Lourdes C. De Luna-Pasatiempo
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the instant Petition for LACK OF MERIT
January 29, 2013
i
Page 51 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
) >
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
1\ For: Disqualification and/or Cancellation of COC under Sec 43(b) of the Local Govt. Code pursuant to Sec. 1
of the 1987 Constitution
187. Ligao City
II
13-187(DC)
^ Bertito Latigay
\ Vs.
\ Manuel Laoang Garcia
Petition to deny due course and to cancel COC
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition to Deny Course to Respondent Manuel Laoang Garcia’s Certificate of Candidacy
January 21, 2013
188. Ligao City
II
13-188(DC)
Bertito Latigay
Vs.
Patricia Gonzales-Alsua
Petition to deny due course and to cancel COC
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED
February 01, 2013
189. Dingras, llocos Norte
1
13-189(DC)
Petition to disqualify Marynette Romero Gamboa as mayoralty candidate for the Municipality of Dingras, llocos Norte in
the May 13, 2013 Synchronized National Elections under Rule 25 of the
Comelec Rules of Procedure as amended by Comelec Resolution No.
9523 & Sec. 40, Local Gov’t Code
Nathaniel Ruben P. Taylan
Resolution (FD) - xxx RRESOLVES to DISMISS the Verified Petition for Disqualification filed by Nathaniel Ruben P. Taylan for being MOOT and ACADEMIC
March 21, 2013
it Page 52 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
MUN. / C I T Y / PRO VINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
\
. \ " Vs.
Marynette Romero Gamboa
\
\
190. Bulakan,Bulackn
i, \ a\
13-190(DC)
Rosendo C. Meneses III
Vs.
Emmanuel N. Meneses
Petition to deny due course to/Cancel the COC of Emmanuel N. Meneses
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is hereby DISMISSED for lack of merit
January 24, 2013
\
\\
\\
191. 5m District of Manila
II
13-191(DC)
Faith C. Maganto
Vs.
Mario Flores Cayabyab
Petition (To Deny Due Course to or to Cancel COC)
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the Petition to deny due course/ or cancel for lack of merit
April 17, 2013
192. Lucena City
I
13-192(DC-F)
Re: Petition to deny due course and/or cancellation of COC of Marijoe
Francisco Asensi
Juanito Y. Diaz
Vs.
Marijoe Francisco Asensi
Resolution No. 9610 - xxx RESOLVES, as follows: II. To declare the following as INELIGIBLE candidates for the positions aspired for due to their failure to meet the age requirement / not a registered voter, as reflected and admitted in their COC under oath during the preliminary hearings: xxx d. Asensi, Marjorie Francisco - Member, S. Panlungsod - Lucena City, Quezon xxx Further, to DENY due course to their COCs and to cause the immediate cancellation/deletion of their names from the Candidates’ Profile System and the Certified List of Candidates for the May 13, 2013 Elections; xxx
i
January 11, 2013
Page 53 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
MUN. / C ITY / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED
\
REMARKS
193. Cadiz City
II
13-193(DC-F)
Engr. Leonilo B. Hulleza
Vs.
Hon. Patrick G. Escalante
For: Petition to deny due course to or cancel a COC
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Petition for Denial/ Cancellation of Certificate of Candidacy
April 01, 2013^
\
\I
\194. Cortes,
Surigao del Sur
I
13-194(DC)
Senonina P. Cuanan
Vs.
Atty. William M. Angos
Petition for Disqualification / Cancellation of COC
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the Petition for LACK OF MERIT
Resolution (EB) - xxx this instant MR is hereby DENIED for utter lack of merit
January 30, 2013
April 24, 2013
\a\
195. Cabugao, llocos Sur
II
13-195(DC)
Edgardo Cobangbang, Jr.
vs.
Amelia Amparo Sunio Abarquez
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby G RANTED. Accordingly, the Certificate of Candidacy of Respondent Amelia Amparo Sunio-Abarquez for the position of Mayor of the Municipality of Cabugao, llocos Sur is hereby CANCELLED
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
February 01, 2013
February 14, 2013
196. Uyugan,Batanes
I
13-196(DC-F)
In Re: Petition to deny due course to or cancellation of C O C
Jonathan Enrique V. Nanud, JR.
Vs.
Rogelio Batin Caballero
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to GRANT the instant Petition. The Certificate of Candidacy of respondent Caballero is hereby CANCELLED
i
May 03, 2013
Page 54 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
197. Munai, Lanao del
Norte
II
13-197(DC)
Re: Petition to disqualify Abdulazis A.M. Batingolo as candidate for
Municipal Mayor
Jamal Dansal Batalo and Fatima Itawa Macalinto
Vs.
Abdulazis M. Batingolo
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is Viereby
DISMISSED \
Order (SD) - xxx MR filed by pets through counsel on April 01, 2013 xxx elevated to en banc
\
\
\«
March 07, 2013
April 17, 2013
198. Tago, Surigao del
Sur
II
13-198(DC)
In the matter of the Petition to disqualify HERMINIGILDO PAREJA PIMENTEL,
JR. as candidate for Mayor of the Municipality of Tago, Surigao del Sur in
13 May 2013 Elections
Rogelio M. Pimentel
vs.
Herminigildo Pareja Pimentel, Jr.
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition for' disqualification against respondent HERMINIGILDO PAREJA PIMENTEL, JR. is hereby DISMISSED
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
March 27, 2013
April 25, 2013
199. Lone District of the
Province of Nueva
Vizcaya
1
13-199(DC)
Francisco Aggasid y Acedo
vs.
Rodrigo Perez y Pajarillo
Petition with Motion Ad Cautelam For Disqualification under Section 68 -
OEC
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the instant Petition for LACK O F MERIT
April 02, 2013
Page 55 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
i
) > )
MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
200. Labason, Zamboanga
del Norte
II
13-200(DC)
In the matter of the Petition to Disqualify Atty. Ramon P. Velasco as a candidate for Vice Mayor, Municipality of Labason,
Zamboanga del Norte in the May 13, 2013 Elections
Dr. Roberto R. Galon and Glenn E. Sanchez
Submitted for resolution \
\
\201. Uson,
Masbate
II
13-201(DC)
Jobelle C. Regular and Salvadora O. Sanchez
Vs.
Arlisa C. Recio-Denigris
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DENIED. Consequently, the petition for\disqualification against ARLISA C. RECIO-DENIGRIS \4 ordered DISMISSED
Order (SD) - xxx MR elevated to en banc
February 27, 2013
March 14, 2013
202. Buguey,Cagayan
1
13-202(DC)(F)
Licerio M. Antiporda III
Vs.
Wendelin C.Sibbaluca-Taruc
For: Disqualification
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the Petition to disqualify Wendelin C. Sibbaluca-Taruc pursuant to the second paragraph of Section 1, Rule 25 of the Commission’s Rules of Procedure as amended, and for utter lack of merit
March 21, 2013
203. Cortes, Surigao del
Sur
II
13-203(DC)
William M. Angos
Vs.
Leticia “Sonya” B. Cuanan and the Municipal Election Officer of Cortes,
Surigao del Sur
Submitted for resolution
i
Page 56 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) J
M U N ./C IT Y / PRO VINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
204. 1s'Congressional
District of Bataan
I
13-204(DC)
Edmund Lee Castafieda
Vs.
Felicito Payumo
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the Petition for UTTER LACK OF M ERIT
\
March 21, 2013
205. Dumalinao, Zamboanga
del Sur
II
13-205(DC)(F)
Petition to Deny Due Course To or Cancel Certificate of Candidacy
Brgy. Captain Wilfredo Duhaylungsod of Upper Dumalinao, et al.
Vs.
Pruelo D. Jalosjos
Resolution (SD) - xxx there being no order or resolution emanating from the higher courts restraining the implementation of the aforementioned final and executdry decision, the Second Division RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES to CANCEL the Certificate of Candidaiy filed by PRUELO D. JALOSJOS for the office of Mayor of Dumalinao, Zamboanga del Sur in the May 13, 2013 NLE for failure to comply with the required qualifications for an elective local official
April 22, 2013
206. Cortes, Surigao del
Sur
II
13-206(DC)
Alfonso G. Cuanan
Vs.
Leticia “Sonya” B. Cuanan
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Petition for Disqualification
April 03, 2013
207. Tanauan,Leyte
I
13-207(DC)(F)
Claudio M. Sabido, Sr.
Vs.
Pelagio R. Tecson, Jr.
Petition to Cancel Certificate of Candidacy
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition dated 28 December 2012
Order (FD) - xxx MR filed by pet through counsel elevated to en banc
March 06, 2013
April 16, 2013
tPage 57 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE
\
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
208. MacArthur,EasternSamar
II
13-208(DC)(F)
In Re: Petition to D&ny Due Course or To Cancel the Certificate of Candidacy
of Francisco C. Catayong, candidate for Mayor of MacArthur, Eastern Samar
Elvira A. Navidad\
vs \Francisco C. Catayong
Resolution (SD) - xxx the Petition is hereby DISM ISSED for lack of merit
March 27, 2013
209. Mambajao,Camiguin
I
13-209(DC)(F)
Pedro P. Romualdo
Vs.
Juan Margarito E. Neri
For: Disqualification under Rule 25 of the Comelec Rules of Procedure as amended by Resolution No. 9523
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition dated 11 January 2013 for LACK OF MERIT
Order (FD) - xxx MR filed by petitioner through counsel elevated to en banc
April 02, 2013
April 16, 2013
210. Bogo City, Cebu
II
13-210(DC)
Antonio F. Condor
Vs.
Rhett E. Minguez
For: Disqualification
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to D ISMISS the instant Petition for Disqualification
April 17, 2013
211. City of Manila
II
13-211(DC)
Atty. Alicia Risos-Vidal
Vs.
Joseph Ejercito Estrada
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISM ISSED for utter lack of merit
Resolution (EB) - xxx RESOLVES, to DENY the Motion for Reconsideration for LACK OF MERIT.
April 01, 2013
April 23, 2013
Page 58 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
VI ) )
MUN. / CITY/ PROVINCE
SPA 2013 ,
\
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
\ Consequently, the April 1, 2013 Resolution of the Commission SD is hereby affirmed
212. Presentacion,
CamarinesSur
II
13-212(DC)
Rodolfo R. Armea, Jr.
\ Vs
\ Jimmy Villete Delena
\\ Verified Petition to Disqualify
Respondent for Lack of Qualification
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant petition is hereby DISMISSED
Order (SD) - Without giving due course to his motion to intervene, the Commission (SD) hereby DENIES the “Motion for Reconsideration with Motion to Intervene Ad Cautelam (Of this Hon. SD’s Resolution dated 22 March 2013)” filed by Manuel P. Realda through counsel on April 1, 2013, praying for the ff. xxx for LACK OF LOCUS STANDI/ It must be emphasized that the Commission issued an Order on March 19, 2013 merely noting Mr. Realda’s motion to intervene because it was filed after the case is deemed submitted for resolution. This is also the reason why his name was not mentioned in the caption neither was his request to intervene included in the discussion of the assailed Resolution by this Commission
March 21, 2013
April 23, 2013
213. Tanauan,Leyte
II
13-213(DC)(F)
Atty. Agapito P. Pagayanan, Jr.
Vs.
Pelagio R. Tecson, Jr.
Petition for Disqualification
Resolution (SD) - xxx the petition is hereby DENIED. Consequently, the petition for disqualification against Pelagio Rudas Tecson, Jr. is ordered DISM ISSED
Order (SD) - xxx MR filed by pet through mail and reed on April 25, 2013 xxx elevated to en banc
April 01, 2013
April 30, 2013
214. Salcedo,EasternSamar
II
13-214(DC)
Atty. Melchor Llego Mergal
Vs.
Benjamin Gagante, Jr.
Submitted for resolution
i )y
Page 59 o f 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
\I ) ) \
\
MUN. /C I T Y / PRO VINCE
\
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
\
215. \ San ipascual, Batangas
\"V
13-215(DC)
Librado G. Dimaunahan
Vs.
Brenda Dimayuga, a.k.a. Ligaya Santos, a.k.a. Ma. Brenda Kenrick
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Petition for Disqualfiication
April 01, 2013 \\
\216. Caintsk, Rizal
\
■ \\
13-216(DC)
Engr. Crispino P. Pablo, Sr.
Vs.
Arturo L. Sicat
Resolution (SD) - xxx RESOLVES to DISMISS the instant Petition for Disqualification for lack of merit
Order (SD) - xxx MR filed by pet through counsel on April 26, 2013, xxx elevated to en banc
April 18, 2013
April 30, 2013
\
\*>
217. Bilar, Bohol
1
13-217(DC)(F)
In Re: Petition to disqualify a candidate pursuant to Sec. 68 of the O EC and Petition to Disqualify for possessing some grounds for disqualifications
Henry Ancog Uy
Vs.
Estrella Ancog-Anub
Submitted for resolution
218. San Pedro, Laguna
1
13-218(DC)
Norvic D. Solidum, Andres T . Reyes III, and Emmanuel A. Duran
Vs.
Calixto R. Cataquiz
Submitted for resolution
Page 60 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
MUN. / C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED
\REMARKS
219. Bustos,Buiacan
II
13-219(DC)
Ricardo N. Santos
Vs.
Carlito Reyes
Submitted for resolution
220. San Isidro, Surigao del
Norte
13-220(DC)
In the matter of the Petition to Disqualify Lalaine E. Dominos
Rudy M. Camingue
Vs.
Lalaine Espadero Dominos Petition for Disqualification
Submitted for resolution
221 . Davao City Valenzuela
city, Buiacan,
Pampanga, Camarines
Sur
13-221(DC)
Petition to Disqualify as Candidates the Named Respondents, and those
Similarly Situated, for being prohibited candidate under the Constitution as
they are “Clear and Obvious” Cases of Political Dynasties
Francisco Ashley L. Acedillo, et. al.
Vs.
Rodrigo Duterte, et al. and all similarly situated candidates
Resolution (SD) - xxx the instant Petition is hereby DISMISSED
w/ Motion for Reconsideration filed by counsel for petitioners on May 02, 2013
April 17, 2013
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVES, to DISMISS the instant Petition for utter lack of merit
222 . Cabugao, llocos Sur
I
13-222(DC)
Catherine Lacaste
Vs.
Josefina Vallejo
May 03, 2013
Page 61 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
MUN. /C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
223. Sapa-Sapa,Tawi-Tawi
11
13-223(DC)
Alshid L. Mohammad-ali
Vs.
Putli Aisa S. Matolo
Petition for Disqualification (of Respondent Putli Aisa S. Matolo from running as Municipal Mayor of Sapa- Sapa, Tawi-Tawi in the May 13, 2013
Automated NLE)
Submitted for resolution ^
\
\
\\
\9
224. 2na Congr‘1.District,
Province of Bataan
1
13-224(DC)
Oscar R. Delos Reyes
Vs.
Enrique T. Garcia, Jr.
For: Disqualification
Submitted for resolution
225. First District,
Surigao del
Sur
1
13-225(DC)
Mary Elizabeth Ty-Delgado
Vs.
Phiip Arreza Pichay
For: Disqualification
Submitted for resolution
226. KidapawanCity
1
13-226
(DC)
Panfilo Ignalan Caingat
Vs.
Ernido Y. Gantuangco
i
Submitted for resolution
r Page 62 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
MUN. / C ITY / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
227. First District of Surigao del Norte
II
13-227(DC)
Gertrudes C. Saberon
Vs.
Rep. Francisco T. Matugas
For: Disqualification
Submitted for resolutidn
\
\\
228. Sulu
1
13-228(DC)
Muammar S. Tulawie
Vs.
Abdusakur M. Tan
Submitted for resolution \
\ a*
229. Mapun, Province of Tawi-Tawi
II
13-229(DC)
In Re: Petition for Disqualification of Jaiman Hasim Kanding as candidate for
Vice-Mayor in the Municipality of Mapun, Province of Tawi-Tawi
Abdulharik Abdulhalim Kiram
Vs.
Jaiman Hasim Kanding, a.k.a. Elwin Bin Liol
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm (resetting)
230. 4th District of Nueva Ecija
1
13-230(DC)
Pedro A. Fajardo and Desita C. Garcia
Vs.
Magnolia Rosa C. Antonino Nadres i
Resolution (FD) - xxx RESOLVED, as it hereby RESOLVES, to DENY the Petition for Disqualification dated 27 Feb. 2013 for LACK OF MERIT
April 30, 2013
Page 63 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
)
MUN. / C ITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
231. San Andres, Romblon
I
13-231(DC)
In Re: The Disqualification of Dr. Fernald Rovillos as candidate for Mayor
of the Town of San Andres, Romblon
Atty. Geminiano G. Galicia, Jr.
^Submitted for resolution
\232. Babatngon,
Leyte
II
13-232(DC)(F)
In the matter of the petition to deny due course or to cancel certificate of
candidacy of Marcelina S. Engle for Vice-Mayor of Babatngon, Leyte
Vice-Mayor Winston B. Menzon
Vs.
Marcelina S. Engle
Submitted for resolution
\
\9\
234. Datu Saudi Ampatuan,
Maguindanao
II
13-233(DC)
Kadil Kango Maslamama
Vs.
Datuwata Utto Adzis
Submitted for resolution
234. Datu Saudi Ampatuan, Maguindanao
I
13-234(DC)
Norodin Makung Ali
Vs.
Saudi Sean Biruar Ampatuan III
Submitted for resolution
235. Culasi,Antique
II
13-235(DC)
i
Joel A. Lomugdang
Vs.
Bibiano A. Herco
Submitted for resolution
i /
Page 64 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
\
) )
Ml/N. / C /7Y/ P R O V I N C E
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
236. Manabo,Abra
II
13-236(DC)
In Re: Petition forlDisqualification from Continuing as Qandidate for Acts
Declared by Law Grounds for Disqualification and Lack of Residency
Requirement of a Candidate \V
Arturo S. (Sayao
Vs. \
Rhandolf G. L iW d o t
Submitted for resolution
237. Madalag,Aklan
1
13-237(DC)
Orlando B. Inosanto, Sr.
Vs.
Alfonso A. Gubatina
For Disqualification under Sec. 68, BP Big. 881
Submitted for resolution
238. Kitaotao,Bukidnon
II
13-238(DC)
Lynard Allan S. Bigcas
Vs.
Lorenzo A. Gawilan, Jr.
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm (resetting)
239. Province of Bukidnon
1
13-239(DC)
Lynard Allan S. Bigcas
Vs.
Jose Maria R. Zubiri
Submitted for resolution
Page 65 of T7 (SPA 2013 DC)
> )
MUN. / C ITY / PROVINCE
SPA 201^
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
240. Pagayawan, Lanao de!
Sur
I
13-24® (DC) '
In the matter of Petition for Disqualification of Nassief Benito
Sharrief as Mayoralty Candidate in Pagayawan, Lanao del Sur in
connection with the May 13, 2013 i National and Local Elections
\ Hanifa U. Aloyodan-Diamael \\ Vs.9
Nassief Benito Sharief
Submitted for resolution
241. Pagayawan, Lanao del
Sur
1
13-241(DC)
In the matter of Petition for Disqualification of Oweida P. Dalidig as
mayoraly candidate in Pagayawan, Lanao del Sur in connection with the
May 13, 2013 National and Local Elections
Hanifa U. Aloyodan-Diamael
Vs.
Oweida P. Dalidig
Submitted for resolution
242. Sta.Catalina,OrientalNegros
II
13-242(DC)
In the matter of the Petition for Disqualification of Ligaya Gamo
Pacanza as candidate for the position of Vice-Mayor of Sta. Catalinga, Oriental
Negros
Ruben P. Melodia
Vs.
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm (resetting)Reset to May 09, 2013
1
y
r Page 66 of 77 (SPA 2013 DC)
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE O F THE CASE STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
\Ligaya Gamo Pacanza
243. 13-243(DC)
In the matter of the Petition to Cancel Certificate of Candidacy of Maria Belen “Maribel” Andaya Eusebio as candidate
for Mayor of Pasig City
Anthony Panton Sanchez, Noel Maaba Medina, John Gavierez Peralta, Fern
Posis Rivera
Vs.
Maria Belen “Maribel” Andaya-Eusebio
Petition for Disqualification
Submitted for resolution
244.
245.
246.
1 District, City of Tandag,
Surigao del Sur
I
13-244(DC)
Angelito G. Paurna
Vs.
Mary Elizabeth Delgado
Submitted for resolution
Balanga,Bataan
13-245(DC)(F)
Elmer Malixi Castrence, Norman Del Mundo Guila
Vs.
Ludovico Peter Paul Banzon Pascual Jr.
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm (resetting)
Tubod, Lanao del
Norte
13-246(DC)
Carolyn E. Paclipan and Nelson L. Suan
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm (resetting)
Page 6 7 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
VI
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
251. Mamburao,Occidental
Mindoro
13-251(DC)
Arturo F. Dela Cruz, Dennis R. Giliberte, Jeric Isidor S. Sarmiento
Vs.
Alan Taroma Aquino
Petition for Disqualification
Submitted for resolution
252. Pantar, Lanao del
Norte
13-252(DC)
Malik T. Alingan
Vs.
Mohamad Limbona
For: Disqualification
Submitted for resolution
253. Alangalang,Leyte
13-253(D C)(F)
Loreto T. Yu
Vs.
Andres G. Yu
Opposition to the Substitution and/or Cancellation of Certificate of Candidacy of Andres G. Yu
Summons w/ NOC set on May 07, 2013; 2pm (resetting)
254. Province of Antique, Anini-y, Antique,
Valderrama,
13-254(DC)
Cornelio P. Aldon and Raymundo T. Roquero
Vs.
Order (SD-COC) xxx Conference scheduled today is hereby cancelled/ counsels are hereby given a period of 3 days from today within which to file their manifestations
April 29, 2013
Page 69 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
)\I
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS
\
DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
Antique
II
Gov. Exequiel B. Javier, Vice-Gov. Rosie A. Dimamay, SP Member J
Tobias M. Javier, SP Member Edgar D. Denosta, SP Member Dino Roel T.
Operiano, SP Member Rolando Plameras, SP Member Teopisto C. Estaris, Jr., SP Member Victor R.
Condez, SB Member Maryvic H. Near, and Vice-Mayor Christopher B. Maguad
\\
\
\\
255. Lone District
of Nueva
Vizcaya
II
13-255(DC)
Jose C. Aleta III and Antonio L. Abellon, Jr.
Vs.
Luisa Lloren Cuaresma
Summons w/ NOC set^ on May 06, 2013; 2pm (resetting)
256. CaloocanCity
1
13-256(DC)
Jonathan A. Garcia
Vs.
Ricojudge Janvier “RJ” Echiverri
Submitted for resolution
257. City of Balanga, Bataan
II
13-257(DC)
Jimmy S. Bustamante
Vs.
Jose Enrique Garcia, III
Submitted for resolution
258. Alegria,Cebu
II
13-258(DC)
Edwin Sato, Miguel Lendio, Randy Rebalde, Fidel Libradilla, Nestor
Endona, and Joel Aias-as
* Vs.
Submitted for resolution
Page 70 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) 1 )
M U N . / C I T Y /
P R O V I N C E
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUSDATED/
PROMULGATED REMARKS
Raul Guisadio \
\
Petition for Disqualification
259. Lone Legislative District of Mountain Province
II
13-259(DC)
Joseph Denver S. Puyongan
Vs.
Maximo B. Dalog, Sr.
Verified Petition for Disqualification (Under Rule 25 of the Comelec Rules of
Procedure as Amended by Comelec Resolution No. 9523)
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm \resetting)
\*
260. Madridejos,Cebu
II
13-260(DC)
Arvin Gido Rosales
Vs.
Salvador S. Dela Fuente
Petition for Disqualification (Of Respondent Salvador S. Dela Fuente from Running as Municipal Mayor of
Madridejos, Cebu in the May 13, 2013 Automated National and Local
Elections)
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm
261. CaloocanCity
II
13-261(DC)
i
Medina Victoria Laurino
Vs.
Luis Chito Abel
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm
1 y
Page 71 o f 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
II .) )
M U N ./C IT Y / PROVINCE
SPA2013
TITLE OF THE CASE
\
STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
262. Balangkaya n, Eastern
Samar
II
13-262(DC)
Atty. AlUan C. Contado
Vs.
Nita B. Aide \
\
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm
263. Taraka, Lanao del Sur
1
13-263(DC)
Nashiba G. Su^agayan
\Vs.^
Faisal E. Usman
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm
264. Kalayaan,Palawan
1
13-264(DC)
Eugenio B. Bito-onon, Jr.
Vs.
Noel F. Osorio
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm Reset to May 09, 2013
265. 2na Dist. Of Pangasinan
And
Lingayen,Pangasinan
1
13-265(DC)
In Re: Petition for Disqualification of Candidacies of Leopoldo N. Bataoil for Member of House Representatives 2nd
District of Pangasinan and Ramon N. Bataoil for Municipal Councilor of Pangasinan
Richard Beil P. Ortega
Vs.
Leopoldo N. Bataoil and Ramon N. Bataoil
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm
Reset to May 08, 2013
266. First District of llocos Sur
II
13-266(DC)
Bertrand A. Baterina
Vs.
Ronald V. Singson
Summons w/ NOC set on May 06, 2013; 2pm Reset to May 09, 2013
Page 72 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
) )
MUN. / CITY/ PROVINCE
SPA2013
\
TITLE OF THE CASE STATUS DATED/PROMULGATED REMARKS
\
267. 1Sl District of Caloocan
City
1
13-267T O
\
\
Mary Ann Joy M. Jimenez
Vs.
Enrico “Recom” Echiverri
Petition for Disqualification
Summons w/ NOC set on May 09, 2013; 2pm Xs
268. Tuburan,Cebu
II
13-268 \ (DC)
In Re: Petition to disqualify the candidates of One Cebu Party for
Elective Positions in the Municipality of ' Tuburan, Cebu pursuant to the
provisions of Comelec Resolution No.
Maricel N. Cajeras
Vs.
Rose Marie Gerona-Suezo, Daphne Arias Lagon
Summons w/ NOC set on May 09, 2013; 2pm
269. Angeles City
1
13-269(DC)
Adelaido I. Bacani, Jr.
Vs.
Edgardo D. Pamintuan
Summons w/ NOC set on May 09, 2013; 2pm
270. BalangaCity,
Bataaan
II
13-270(DC)
Jose Enrique S. Garcia III
Vs.
Jimmy S. Bustamante
Summons w/ NOC set on May 09, 2013; 2pm
Page 73 of 7 7 (SPA 2013 DC)
\\
) )Vt
) )\
)