The Four Key Issues Shaping Latin
America’s Solar Market
Adam S. James | Analyst, Solar Markets
March, 2015
• Latin America PV Playbook
– Quarterly + Annual Report
• Latin America Pre-Conference: Solar Summit 2015
– April 14th
• Latin America Solar Newsletter
– Weekly
• Solar Summit: Mexico
– January 2016 in Mexico City
• Free White Paper on the Caribbean
– Coauthored with MC Group, released April 1
Also see…
Latin America in the Global
Context
Global Demand (2013-2020)
• Global demand for PV slowed in 2014, as APAC didn’t fully offset the decline in European
markets. However, we expect a rebound in 2015 with 33% growth.
• Emerging markets, including Latin America, will be 15% of all demand growth over the next 5
years
0 0 1 1 1 2 2 6 7 16 29 30 40 41 54 65 69 89 109134
230
294
363
452
562
696
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
2001
2002
2003
2004
2005
2006
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015E
2016E
2017E
2018E
2019E
2020E
Gig
aw
att
s (
DC
) o
f In
sta
lled
PV
Ca
pa
city
Global PV Demand (GWdc)Annual and Cumulative
Annual Market Cumulative Market
Latin America (2013-2020)
• The Latin America market is heavily influenced in the 2014-2016 timeframe by the Chilean market,
as you can see by the regional drop in 2017 due to the Chilean market declining from 2016
• What the topline numbers don’t show is that more countries are becoming viable and contributing
to the regional total out to 2018 – which is positive for the market overall
133 625
2,109 1,873
2,711 3,473
184 809
2,919
4,792
7,502
10,975
161%
370%
237%
-11%
45%28%
-50%
0%
50%
100%
150%
200%
250%
300%
350%
400%
-
2,000
4,000
6,000
8,000
10,000
12,000
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
An
nu
al G
row
th R
ate
Me
ga
wa
tts (
DC
) o
f In
sta
lled
PV
Ca
pa
city
Latin America Installed PV Demand (MWdc)Annual and Cumulative
Annual Cumulative Annual Growth Rate
• Chile dominant market in 2014 and 2015, declining to 2nd place in 2016-2017, and 3rd in 2018
• Mexico shows steady growth out to 2018, top market for 2016-2018
• Brazil more significant growth in later years, breaking into the top 3 in 2016 and the top 2 in 2018
• Central America also very prominent: Top 5 rankings include El Salvador and Guatemala in near
term, Honduras and Panama in later years
Latin America (2013-2020)
-
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
4,000
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Megaw
att
s (
DC
) of In
sta
lled P
V
Capacity
Latin America PV Demand by Market (MWdc)
Chile Mexico Brazil Rest of South America Central America Caribbean
• The topics reflect key issues shaping the largest markets in Latin
America: Mexico, Chile, Brazil and Central America
• However, the notion that these will be the largest markets are
premised on our Base Case forecasts – which rely on a set of
assumptions
• These markets could under/over perform – so from a risk
perspective it is important to understand why these markets are so
prominent
Choice of Topics?
Mexican Energy Reform
Mexico Forecast & Highlights
1 3 13 72 67 295
565
940
1,305
1 4 16 88 155
450
1,015
1,955
3,260
-
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
3,500
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Me
ga
wa
tts (
DC
) o
f In
sta
lled
PV
C
ap
acity
Mexico PV Demand (MWdc)Cumulative and Annual
Annual Cumulative
• While the Mexican market has grown at an incredible pace, the real opportunity lies ahead: 94%
of installed PV capacity by 2018 comes after 2014
• The primary opportunity is in utility-scale development, which amounts to 77% of expected
capacity between 2014 and 2018. Only 4 plants have been installed to date, 2 with fixed-price
PPAs (2012) and 2 with floating-price contracts (2013, 2014).
• The second largest opportunity is in the commercial market, amounting to 11% of installed
capacity between 2014 and 2018
Old Market Structure
<500 kW distributed generation
• Fewer permitting requirements
• Basically unchanged
>500 kW self-supply
• Wheeling rates/energy bank
• Legal workaround to direct sale
• Almost 1 GW of old permits
<30 MW small producer
• >2 GW of old permits
• Basically merchant
• Supported by high diesel prices/transmission constraints in Baja
• Constitutional reform of the energy market (oil, gas, electricity)
• Acronym time: Used to be vertically integrated monopoly (CFE),
transitioning to a competitive wholesale market that includes CFE as
a player, but is managed by CENACE (grid operations unit, formerly
CFE), regulated by CRE, with policy set by SENER
• Nuts and Bolts: Composed of five markets (not incl. transmission)
– Day ahead/real time (Dec 31, 2015)
– Capacity market (Nov, 2015)
– Clean energy certificates market (2018)
– Medium-term energy auction (Oct, 2016)
– Clean energy certificates/capacity auction (Oct 2015 contracts in
2018)
Energy Reform
• Assessing what we know:
– Solar will compete in the open market signing PPAs with unregulated
clients (>3 MW 1 MW, CFE)
– Clean energy certificates/capacity auction/merchant market not likely to
be significant
– No preferential wheeling rates (makes old permits slightly more
attractive)
• Assessing what we don’t know:
– Clean energy certificates load requirement (8.6% of load in 2018
proposed). Not likely to be a good source of revenue, but will create
some demand. Solar competing against co-gen and wind.
– Retail/Wholesale tariffs: Perception vs. reality
– Contractual models for generators
Energy Reform
• 2015
– Distributed generation market growing
– Potential for self-supply projects
– One small producer project, maybe two
• 2016
– Several bilateral PPAs signed. Complications with tariffs, but rationale
more centered on solar as a hedge against volatility & advantage of
siting.
– Potential small auction for solar (Q4 of 2015, built in 2016)
– Continued distributed generation market, with some national players
beginning to emerge
• 2017-2018
– Continuation of above trends: solar value proposition improves with time
Expectations for the Future
Central American Risk and
Reward
Central America Forecast & Highlights
• Honduras biggest market in 2015, with El Salvador and Panama both significant contributors
• Tender driven market, plus very high tariffs in commercial and some residential markets
• This is the time horizon for utility-projects: likely drop-off after 2018, after which it’s mostly
distributed generation (commercial)
21 23
524
439
575602
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Me
ga
wa
tts (
DC
) o
f In
sta
lled
PV
C
ap
acity
Central America PV Demand (MWdc)
Costa Rica Belize Nicaragua Guatemala Panama El Salvador Honduras
• Four >1 MW plants built to date
– Costa Rica, 1.2 MW Miravalles
– Panama, 2.4 MW Sarigua
– Guatemala, 5 MW + 50 MW
• Additional tender offerings in Guatemala, El Salvador, Panama and direct
procurement in Honduras
• Tax incentives are key
• Migration of off-grid distributed generation business into the on-grid
segment motivated by interconnection rules
• Enormous amount of developer interest: 1.6 GW pipeline from ~50
companies
PV Industry Highlights To-Date
16
Base Case is the most likely forecast given current and expected
trends
Base Case Drivers
17
Technological/Environmental
• Solar costs
• High insolation
Resource Diversification
• Hydrological risk: Rainfall levels influence hydropower and biomass
• Fuel prices: Less hydropower and biomass creates heavier dependence on fuel oil
• Solar is a hedge against hydrological risk, as is wind and other RE
Market Forces
• Need for new supply: Growing demand/Capacity retirements
• Increasing electrification
• Shifting from public to private investment, increasing access to capital
The Base Case does include some constraints on market growth
Base Case Constraints
18
Fundamentals
• Less developed grid
• Limited total demand/Smaller grid
• Renewable integration
Risks
• Country risk: Corruption, repatriation, currency exchange, violence
• Counterparty risk: Tied with political risk, credit ratings for major utilities
• Others: Legal recourse in some places severely limited. Land titling can also be an issue. Experienced labor.
• What’s the end result? Upwards pressure on the cost of capital – especially non-local equity and commercial debt. Very limited options for financing DG also. Some exceptions: development banks, local equity, private debt (local and regional).
There are upside and downside scenarios for each country
Other Plausible Scenarios?
19
Primary Upside Risks• Rate restructuring
• Tenders
• Government programs/financing
• Additional incentives (FiT, net metering, or tax exemptions on income, land, import, or VAT)
• SEIPAC demand (impact complex: pricing vs. demand)
• Global dynamics (supply or demand)
• Access to capital
Primary Downside Risks
• Rate restructuring
• Political instability (in re: to state-backed tenders)
• SEIPAC (see above)
• Reputational risk for solar
• Revoked incentives
Assessment the Future
20
Overall, central America is very opportunistic and high risk/high reward
• Honduras/El Salvador/Guatemala as opposed to Panama/Costa Rica/Colombia
There is a ceiling on growth, even in more ambitious upside scenario
• Short term: mostly utility-scale driven by tenders
• Small grids/limited demand
• Long-term DG markets will be core drivers of growth
Likely to be many challenges w/r/t project development
• Pipeline forecasts will frequently be revised
• PPAs: Necessary but not sufficient
• Land access/titling
• Financing: Dev banks commercial lending. Likely to be local players
• Limited off-takers: some in bilateral market, some in regulated market. Symptomatic of larger demand limitations.
Financing for distributed generation will take time
• Credit system
• Watch Mexico
The Future of Chile
• The Chilean market is almost exclusively driven by utility-scale project development (99%)
• In 2015, we expect almost 1 GW to be installed, 50% the total for the Latin America region
• Starting in 2016, we expect most procurement to occur through the auctions with fixed-price
PPAs, although there will still be some bilateral activity
• The primary change is the introduction of new transmission lines between 2016 and 2018, that
eliminate the pricing congestion that has spurred merchant projects and incentivized large
consumers
Chile Forecast & Highlights
3 11
507
1,457
1,866
2,329
2,795
3 8
494
945
402 453 454
-
500
1,000
1,500
2,000
2,500
3,000
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Me
ga
wa
tts (
DC
) o
f In
sta
lled
PV
C
ap
acity
Chile PV Demand (MWdc)Cumulative and Annual
Cumulative Annual
2014 – 2018 CAGR - 41%
• Past growth driven by PPAs and merchant projects
• Assumed certain pricing conditions on the grid
• New transmission will likely have the effect of relieving pricing
congestion on certain points of the grid. While average net prices
may go up slightly, it will eliminate very high points.
• Future growth mostly PPA-driven, including auctions
– Large base of industrial demand, but keep in context of 12.3 GW total
needs out to 2030 (8.7 GW in SIC, 3.6 in SING)
– Auction structure positive for solar
• Potential for increased prices based on hydrological risk and fuel
price volatility
Drivers and Risks
Brazil’s Complexity & Potential
Brazil Forecast & Highlights
19 22 85
195
420
660
19 41 126
321
741
1,401
-
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018
Me
ga
wa
tts (
DC
) o
f In
sta
lled
PV
C
ap
acity
Brazil PV Demand (MWdc)Cumulative and Annual
Annual Cumulative
• The Brazilian market has a mix of growth across all segments, with primary variable being whether
projects with PPAs from either the reserve auction or the unregulated auction move ahead
– We view as very likely in 2016/17 but questionable in 2015 due to lack of off-takers in
unregulated market
• In 2015, we expect almost 85 MW to be installed, making it the fifth largest market
• We expect the residential and commercial markets to grow steadily in the Base Case
• Mainly tender-driven market
– Regulated and unregulated market
– Low PPAs ($80/MWh – $100/MWh)
– High taxes for imported equipment + financing requirements on local content (+
high domestic interest rates, labor taxes)
• Taxes on net electricity consumption hurt the distributed generation market
– State-by-state
• Other factors at play:
– Currency risk
– Political risk
– Drought
• Main upside drivers:
– Tax breaks on PV equipment (or, to a lesser extent, raw materials)
– Re-negotiated PPAs at higher rates
– Access to capital
Drivers and Risks
Thank you!
The data and analysis for this presentation has come from GTM
Research’s special regional report
For content questions, Adam James can be reached at
For sales/account questions, please contact Justin Freedman at
Thank You!