The Learning-centered Institution:
Pedagogy and Assessment for Student Success
Amy Driscoll WASC EDUCATIONAL SEMINAR
February 2008
2
Key Ideas Hallmarks of a Learning-centered
Education Defining Student Success A Learning-centered Assessment Process Designing Learning-centered Courses,
Programs, and Pedagogy Cycle of Assessment for Improving
Learning
5
Learning-centered Curriculum Synthesizes content Builds on previous learning Integrates education and experience Communicates values for and
connection to student lives Attends to learning needs= RELEVANCE, LONG-TERM MEMORY,
MOTIVATION, RESPONSIVE
6
Learning-centered Pedagogy Students have clear expectations Students are actively involved Students apply knowledge to important issues
and problems Student find relevance and value Students experience support and feedback for
learning Students are able to practice and take risks
=CONFIDENCE, ENGAGEMENT, PERSONAL LEARNING, SECURE ENVIRONMENT
7
Learning-centered Assessment Assessment is ongoing not episodic. Students understand and value the
criteria, standards, and methods by which they are assessed.
The purpose of assessment is to improve student learning.
Faculty consider student perspectives. The assessment activity makes sense to
students. =OWNERSHIP, SECURITY, CLARITY
8
Processes for Developing Learner-centered Education Reflect on purpose of assessment and define Align pedagogy/assessment with mission and
values of institution, department, faculty Articulate goals, outcomes, evidence,
criteria, and standards Design curriculum and pedagogy to achieve
learning outcomes Conduct collaborative review of student
evidence Use review to improve learning
9
Developing Learning-centered Assessment
Describe educational culture - fit? Engage in inquiry process-focus on
student success Study list of possible purpose(s) Consider how assessment can
support your intentions for student success
Define assessment with the inclusion of student success
10
Possible Purposes for Assessment:which purposes support student success?
Provide feedback to students Classify or grade achievement Enable students to correct errors and improve learning Motivate students focusing on their sense of
achievement Consolidate and summarize student learning Estimate students’ potential to progress to other courses Help students apply learning to practical contexts Give us feedback on how effective we are at promoting
learning Provide data for internal and external accountability
11
Possibilities:Purpose/Definition “The purpose of assessment is to
improve learning” (Angelo, 2000)
“Assessment is a dynamic pedagogy that extends, expands, enhances, and strengthens learning” (Driscoll, 2001)
12
Thinking about Assessment Does assessment flow from the institution’s
mission and reflect the educational values? from the department’s mission?
Does assessment address questions that people really care about?
Does assessment help faculty fulfill their responsibilities to students, to the public?
Does assessment promote student success?
Starting with Mission…
Missions contribute meaning to our definition of student success with the uniqueness of the institution.
14
Aligning Mission with Educational Goals for Assessment
Our central mission is to develop life-long learning skills, impart society’s cultural heritage, and educate and prepare for both the professions and advanced study.
15
Aligning Values With Educational Goals ESU has a commitment to
academic and personal integrity.
GOALS: Academic Integrity Personal Integrity
16
School/Departmental Missions
“respond effectively to issues of diversity, ambiguity, and conflict as natural parts of American politics”
(Division of Political Science) “work toward influencing health
behaviors through modification of lifestyles and changes to the environment” (School of Community Health)
17
Assessment Protocols for Learning-centered Assessment
GOAL OUTCOMES
Evidence
Criteria
Standards:a) Exemplary Achievementb) Satisfactory Achievementc) Unsatisfactory Achievement
19
Examples of Goals
Critical Thinking
Citizenship in a Democracy (Grad. School of Education)
Team work and Collaboration (School of Community Health
Ethics
20
Impact of Goals on Student Learning & Success Focuses student learning efforts for
increased success
Translates mission and values to help make sense of learning
Provides rationale for and makes meaning of curriculum and pedagogy to motivate for success
21
Student Learning Outcomes
Refer to Results in Terms of Specific Student Learning, Development, and Performance (Braskamp and Braskamp, 1997)
Answer the Question – “What Do We Expect of Our Students?” (CSU Report 1989)
Describe Actual Skills, Understandings, Behaviors, Attitudes, Values Expected of Students
22
Examples of Outcomes
Math: Use arithmetical, algebraic, geometric and statistical methods to solve problems.
Ethics: Identify and analyze real world ethical problems or dilemmas and identify those affected by the dilemma.
Culture and Equity: Analyze and describe the concepts of power relations, equity, and social justice and find examples of each concept in the U.S. society and other societies.
Team work: Listens to, acknowledges, and builds on the ideas of others.
23
Impact of Outcomes on Student Learning & Success Directs student learning efforts for
greater success
Motivates student learning efforts for greater success
Promotes deep learning due to understanding of expectations which leads to greater success
24
Evidence
Student Work that Demonstrates Achievement of Outcomes (Assignments, Projects, Presentations, Papers, Responses to Questions, Etc.)
Designed for appropriate level of learning expectations (outcomes)
Opportunity for Different Ways of Demonstrating Learning
25
Examples of Evidence
Teamwork Role play or case study
Project or problem solving assignment
Math Mathematical and statistical projects and papers
Ethics A written accountA multi-media presentation or display boardAn audio tape
26
Impact of Evidence on Student Learning & Success Limit or expand the ways they demonstrate
learning - success for all students?
Enrich and enhance learning and success
Provide opportunity to integrate experience with learning for enhanced success
27
Criteria
Qualities Desired in Student Work (Evidence)
Represent Powerful Professional Judgment of Faculty
Guide Student Learning Efforts
Promote Lifelong Learning
Support Faculty in Making Objective Evaluations
28
Examples of Criteria
Math Accuracy Complexity Clarity and Coherence
Ethics Complexity (broad, multifaceted, interconnected) Conscious Awareness
Culture and Equity Range of Cultures Reflectivity and Integration
Teamwork Respect Flexibility
29
Impact of Criteria on Student Learning & Success Promotes confidence in their
learning efforts = success Promotes qualities of life-long
learning = life success Promotes habits of self assessment
= success Promotes student’s sense of
fairness of evaluation = increased effort = success
30
Standards/Rubrics
Describe Different Levels of Criteria
Describe Specific Indications of Criteria
Promote Understanding of Criteria
Support Faculty in Making Objective Evaluations
31
Examples of Standards/Rubrics
Math (Accuracy) Satisfactory: Contains few errors and those errors do not significantly
undermine the quality of the work.Considers and uses data, models, tools or processes that
reasonably and effectively address issues or problems. Unsatisfactory: One or more errors that significantly undermine the quality
of the work. Uses data, models, tools or processes in inappropriate or ineffective ways.
Ethics (Complexity) Standard for Excellent: Consistently views sophisticated and significant
dilemmas and issues with a broad focus and from multiple perspectives. Standard for Satisfactory: Usually views sophisticated and significant
dilemmas and issues with a broad focus, but may sometimes use a more narrow focus and may use fewer perspectives.
Standard for Unsatisfactory: Mainly views issues and dilemmas in simple terms and usually does so with a limited focus and minimal perspectives.
32
Impact of Standards on Student Learning & Success Guides level of student investment
= focused success Provides insight into the
assessment process – understanding leads to success
Promotes confidence in how their work will be evaluated – security in learning
33
Assessing Student Learning: Course, Program and Institutional Levels
1. Preparation: Determine purpose(s) and definition of assessment; Examine mission and values
4. Make outcomes, evidence, criteria, and standards “public and visible” (syllabi, programs, brochures)
5. Collect evidence ofstudent achievement
7. Revise outcomes and criteria, Improve pedagogy and curriculum for learner success
2. Design assessment: Articulate goals, Develop clear outcomes, evidence, criteria, and standards
6. Review and analyze student evidence
3. Alignment of curriculum and pedagogy with learning outcomes
34
Step 3: Aligning Curriculum and Pedagogy with Learning Outcomes Outcomes and Criteria as Planning
Focus Faculty Alignment Grids Learner Grids
35
Student Learning Outcome Example: Implications?
Students describe and assume personal responsibility in collaborative endeavors, and respect and support the contributions of others.
Students analyze ethical issues from a variety of cultural perspectives.
36
Standard:Multiple Perspectives EXCELLENT
The student examines his or her own thinking and experiences and those of others with consistent analysis of both for different perspectives on issues; he/she empathically considers those affected by the decisions and and weighs diverse possibilities from others’ perspectives before moving to action.
37
Step 4: Making Learning Outcomes ---Leads to Success
Public and Visible
Relevant and Meaningful
Motivating and Supportive of Learning
38
Step 5: Collect Evidence of Student Achievement
Collect representative samples from each course
Organize collaborative faculty teams for review
Use outcomes, criteria, and directions for assignments or assessments
39
Step 5: Review and Analyze Evidence Read holistically to determine
whether outcomes are achieved (reliability).
Several readings to identify examples of criteria (validity).
Final reading for insights about pedagogy, class structure and environment, and learning supports.
40
Changes in Teaching, Assessment and Reflection on Pedagogy to Promote Student Success
Scaffolding
Iterative assessment
Assessment used as a teaching tool
41
Processes for Developing Learning-centered Education and Student Success
Develop purpose and definition Review/analyze mission and values Articulate goals, outcomes, evidence,
criteria, and standards Designing curriculum and pedagogy Make assessment public and visible Systematically collect student evidence Conduct collaborative review of student
evidence Use review to improve learning
42
SUMMARY
Outcomes-based assessment will intentionally focus your teaching, curriculum, and assessment on student learning in ways that are authentic, helpful to you and your students, provide accountability for you and others, and actually increase student success.