TOWARD A NEW MODEL OF SCHOLARLY COMMUNICATION
DID
CA
SC
AD
ES
YING DING VINCENT LARIVIÈRE STAŠA MILOJEVIC MIKE THELWALL
CASSIDY SUGIMOTO & BLAISE CRONIN
f ONGPHAN CHOEMPRAYONG Presentation design:
’
AG
EN
DA
• Then and Now
• Scholarly Communication Models
• DID Cascades Project
• Challenges and Opportunities
THEN AND NOW FORMS & FORA
1970 2010
Working draft
Occasional paper
Preprint
Conference paper
Journal article
Monograph
Book review
Review article
Encyclopedia
1 2 3 4
Q W E R
A S D
Z X C
Who are PUBLISHERS?
Author (blogger, self-archiver, etc.)
Library/Institution (Repository)
Journal of record Monograph publisher
University press
1970 2010
1 2 3 4
Q W E R
A S D
Z X C
nano scripts, micro scripts, macro scripts, mega scripts, molecular scripts, mutable scripts, mobile scripts
Manuscripts
(Davenport, 1995) QUANTUM PUBLISHING
What are PUBLICATIONS?
1970 2010
practices
Snail mail
AUTHORIAL
Typewriter
Print journal
W @
1970 2010
COMMUNICATIVE
interaction
Audiences
Conferences
Manual circulation
Author
1970 2010
Tweeting,
Blogging,
Tagging,
Commenting
OF WORK Impact
Delicious
Comments
CiteULike
CrossRef 0 100 200 300 400 500
Days since article publication
Alt-metrics activity timelines
(priem, 2012)
1970 2010
1970 2010
Personal indexing
Recommender systems
Full-text searching
Tagging
Bookmarking
Crowdsourcing
Online reference services
RESEARCH FINDING
SCHOLARSHIP CITING
Percentage of papers needed to obtain 20%, 50%, and 80% of the citations received using a 2-year citation window, by field, 1900–2005.
(Larivière, Gingras, & Archambault, 2009)
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
V S 10
NEW ERA Velocity Virality Vibrancy Variety Versioning Volume Venality Vanity Validity Veri!ability
TIME FOR A NEW MODEL ?
GARVEY & GRIFFITH 1972
Year
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Initiates work
Annual APA Convention
Meeting of state, Regional or special society
Reports to sizable restricted audiences
Reports of Preli. findings
Completed work
Submits manuscript
Journal publication
Technical reports
Preprints
Preprints
APA Convention
Program
APA Convention Proceedings
Listing of Manuscripts accepted
Psychological abstracts
Manuscript rejected
Manuscript published
Psychological abstracts
Annual Review
Cited in other articles
Psychological bulletin
Specialized Text
treatises
Report to Informal audiences
UNISIST 1971
PRODUCERS
ABSTRACTING & INDEXING SERVICES
PUBLISHERS, EDITORS
LIBRARIES
INFORMATION CENTERS
CLEARING HOUSES
DATA CENTERS
USERS
PRIMARY SOURCES
SECONDARY SOURCES
TERTIARY SERVICES
Selection Production Distribution
Analysis & storage Dissemination
Evolution Compression Consolidation
Quali!ed surveys
(tabular) (formal)
(unpublished) (published)
(informal)
Talks, lectures, conferences, etc.
Letters to editors, preprints, etc. Books, Journals esis, reports
Abstracts & Index
Journals
Catalogs, Guides Reference Services,
etc. Reviews,
Syntheses, etc.
Special Bibliographies,
Translations, etc.
Revised unisist (Sondergaard, Andersen, & HjØrland, 1971)
PRODUCERS
ABSTRACTING & INDEXING SERVICES
E-LIBRARIES
SCIENTIFIC & RESEARCH
ORGANIZATIONS SERVERS
USERS
PRIMARY SOURCES
SECONDARY SOURCES
TERTIARY SERVICES
Selection Production Distribution
Analysis & storage Dissemination
Evolution Compression Consolidation
Dictionaries, thesaurus
formal informal
E-mail, List servers, UseNet news newsgroups,
Electronic meeting/webcam conferencing E-journals
Online journals
esis, reports
Abstracts & Index
Journals OPACS
Reviews, Syntheses, etc.
Special Bibliographies,
Translation
PREPRINT DATABASES
PUBLISHERS EDITORS
PEER-REVIEW
SEARCH ENGINES/META SEARCH TOOLS AND VIRTUAL LIBRARIES/DIRECTORIES/CLEARNING HOUSES
INTERNET BASED SOURCES
NEW MODEL
Draft
Report
Book
Tweet
Cura
ted
DB
Creator
Consumer
Prosumer
DID CASCADES project
& CHALLENGES
opportunities [ ] of the new world