UK CCS C Bi-annual
AIM:Connectivity between UK academics working on or with CCSInteraction with “Industry” and “Stakeholders” on CCS
THIS MEETING (Today):PlenaryGroups : ImpactReport back
TeaSmall groupsReport back
Bar
Food and interactionUK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
1
THIS MEETING (Tomorrow):Plenary and resultsIndustry statementsSmall groups: Impact future
TeaSynthesis report back 2 daysEPSRC & DECC statements
“Free” Lunch
UKCCSC
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
2
UK CCS Community Network Meeting
University College London
2 April 2012
Research
and
Pathways to Impact
Development
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
3
What is an “Impact”
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
4
You (University), or You (Industry , business, Stakeholder)
• Get paid• Have to produce something• To a timescale• To standards of quality• Is used /useable / useful• Enhanced society / culture / Quality of life
How are outputs
used , measured, understood ?
How are outputs
used , measured, understood ?
Aim
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
5
• Updated UK research Map
• Investigation of the perception of Impact
• Helping you understand your impacts
Case studies in the evaluation of impactsCase studies in the evaluation of impacts
What Research Councils “think”
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
6http://www.rcuk.ac.uk/kei/impacts/Pages/home.aspxhttp://www.rcuk.ac.uk/kei/impacts/Pages/home.aspx
How to work with this ?
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
7
• Divide up the problem
1)Think about what we do NOW ….
Tea Break
2) Work on some of YOUR specific examples
Talk to the people around you ….
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
8
• On your left, right, front, rear
• One A3 handout between 2 (cheap !)
• Pick 5 areas UK does WELL
• Pick 5 areas the UK has MISSED (and should fix)
• TOP 5 of all areas – doing / should do/ could do
Group feed back on ONE sheet W M T Group feed back on ONE sheet W M T
Example
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
9
W
W
W
W
W
Results
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
10
Each box on the RCUK map of Impacts was given a keyword.
The number of “votes” for each keyword was recorded, and that table of data from all the
groups in the whole meeting was displayed as a Word Cloud. That shows the centrality
and size of the keyword visually, depending on the number of votes cast
Key to Keywords used, relating to RCUK
diagram
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
11
Output 1: votes for “Does well”
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
12
Output 2: votes for “Essential”
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
13
Output 3: votes for “Top 5”
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
14
sustainability
Academics
Disciplines
Innovation
Training
Knowledge
Teaching
Wealth
Health
Research
Organisations
Organisational-Effectiveness
Investment
Sustainability
Commercialisation
Quality-of-life
Society
Policy-making
Engagement
Analysis
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
16
There was , not surprisingly, a strong vote for academic outputs having a strong impact
As one would expect, each group listed “commercialisation” as an essential impact which
the UK should deliver. Creating “wealth” and public “engagement” were also felt to be
important impacts which the UK should be delivering.
And, perhaps most intriguing, was the vote that “Policy” and “Commercialisation” were not
being achieved very well.
It is, of course, arguable if this academic-dominated focus group is representative or
qualified enough to have a full suite of perspectives on those two impacts.
But the concern is clear …….
After teabreak
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
17
What to do ? …. Form groups
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
18
• It’s a bit much to expect engineers to think about storage
(Although I’m sure that the converse is simple)
SO ………
• Move into thematic groups, focused around expertise and problems on / with / in CCS
Themes
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
19
1) Capture (all flavours)
2) Transport (on shore, offshore, shipping)
3) Environment (land and sea and factories)
4) Storage
5) Systems
6) Social + policy + economics + legal
What to do 2 : after Tea
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
20
• Pick 2 projects (maybe 3) to work on as EXAMPLES – something that one/more are working on NOW
• Work out YOUR impacts across the WHOLE table, some fields may be blank
* Methods to define and recognise* How did you identify the impact
• Work out HOW you can deliver the Impact
• Does the project have impact in other CCS areas
• Timescale of (various) impacts
Sector Results (maybe)
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
21
Industry
PublicPolicy and Media
Researchers
W
e
y
b
u
r
W
e
y
b
u
r
G
r
e
e
n
R
i
v
e
r
G
r
e
e
n
R
i
v
e
r
S
y
s
t
e
m
S
y
s
t
e
m
r
o
g
e
n
T
u
r
b
i
n
e
r
o
g
e
n
T
u
r
b
i
n
e
N
Z
E
C
N
Z
E
C
Q
I
C
S
Q
I
C
S
N
e
a
r
C
O
2
N
e
a
r
C
O
2
M
A
T
T
R
A
N
M
A
T
T
R
A
N
C
O
2
s
m
e
ll
C
O
2
s
m
e
ll
P
A
C
T
P
A
C
T
c
t
i
v
a
t
C
a
r
b
o
n
c
t
i
v
a
t
C
a
r
b
o
n
Timescale Results (maybe)
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
22
W
e
y
b
u
r
n
W
e
y
b
u
r
n
Now
1 - 5
5 - 10
10 - 25
G
r
e
e
Ri
v
e
r
G
r
e
e
Ri
v
e
r
H
y
d
r
o
g
e
n
H
y
d
r
o
g
e
n
A
c
t
i
v
a
t
C
a
r
b
o
n
A
c
t
i
v
a
t
C
a
r
b
o
n
P
A
C
T
P
A
C
T
N
Z
E
C
N
Z
E
C
S
y
s
t
e
m
s
S
y
s
t
e
m
s
Q
I
C
S
Q
I
C
S
N
e
a
r
C
O
2
N
e
a
r
C
O
2
M
A
T
T
R
A
N
M
A
T
T
R
A
N
C
O
2
s
m
e
ll
C
O
2
s
m
e
ll
Learning: Things to DO in future when
displaying Impacts and plotting sectors
UK CCS Consortium 2&3 April2012
23
1) Display time as linear with probability function of impact along it
2) Display impact as triangle or polygon, centered on the mode, or better as a spider
diagram centred on mode.
Probable that most impacts are much longer term than the inventors believe or know at
this time.
Need now to look at FUTURE where do you want to be, and back-cast to present, to invest
in technologies which will help get from now to future