Teaching Points
I. Background informationII. Text analysis III. Introduction to the textIV. Rhetorical devicesV. Questions for discussion
I. Background Information
Charles Darwin & his The Origin of Species
The trialThe Person involved in the trial
1. Charles Darwin & The Origin of Species(1809-1882) British, world famous natura
list and bilogistOriginator of the theory of man’s evoluti
on by natural selectionWork: origin of species, descent of man
The process of natural selection “As many more individuals
of each species are born than can possibly survive, and as, consequently, there is a frequently recurring struggle for existence, it follows that any being, if it vary however slightly in any manner profitable to itself, under the complex and sometimes varying conditions of life, will have abetter chance of surviving, and thus be naturally selected. From the strong principle of inheritance, any selected variety will tend to propagate its new and modified form.”
The Trial John Thomas Scopes
came to Tennessee fresh out of college. In the spring of 1925, he had just completed his first year as science teacher and part-time football coach at the high school in the little town of Dayton. Scopes planned to return home to Kentucky for the summer. But in his words, "a beautiful blonde" distracted him and he stayed for another week hoping for a date. The decision changed his life forever.
The people involvedi. John Scope:the las
t surviving principal of the
famous Tennessee “Monkey Trial” of 1925. The man
whose name became synonymous with the teaching of evolution in American schools.
ii. Clarence Darrow(1857-1938): American lawyer.
He acted professionally in many cases against monopolies or on the side of labor;he pleaded for the Negro defendants in the Scottsboro trial (1932).
He was also the president of the American League to abolish Capital Punishment
iii. William Jennings Bryan (1860-
1925);American leader, editor, and popular lecturer; three times a nominee for the
presidency of the US.,Secretary of State (1901-
1913). Just before his death (1925) Bryan
figured as one of the prosecuting attorneys and a state’s witness against the teaching of
Darwinian evolution in the famed Scopes trial held at Dayton, Tennessee.
II. Text analysisPart I. A lead-in (para 1)A packed court on a sweltering July day in 1925,
all the three main characters are present: John Scopes,
Darrow and Bryan.Part II. A flashback(paras2-9)The reason why I was brought to court: 1)Teach
ing Darwin’s evolution in American schools.2) Fundamentalism was strong in Tennessee
Part III. The process of the Trial (paras10-43)The debate between the two sides--- wentthrou
gh several stages:
III. Introduction to the text
What is the main idea of the text?Analyzing the title: The trial that
rocked the world?Where, what , who
ForFor your your referencereferenceThe conflict between…
The trial:
State VS John Scope
fundamentalists VS the modernists
The fundamentalists:
They adhered to a literal interpretation of the
Old Testament.The modernists:
They accepted the theory advanced by Charles Darwin – that all animal life, including monkeys and men, had evolved from a common ancestor.
Defendant :John Scopes:an unknown school-teacher
(science masterand football coach) at the
secondary school inDayton before the trial. He taught
biology using Hunter’s Civic Biology.
The counsel for John Scopes’ defence:
Clarence Darrow: the famous criminal lawyer, well prepared andquite sure of himself (L.13); shrewd, 68-year-old (L.58); an agnosticDudley Field Malone:handsome and magnetic; a Catholic (L.61)Arthur Garfield Hays:quiet, scholarly and steeped in the law; a Jew
The counsel for the prosecution:William Jennings Bryan:the silver-tongued orator, three timesDemocratic nominee for President of the
U.S., leader of the fundamentalist movement; ageing, paunchy (L.55)
Tom Stewart:Bryan’s son, a lawyer, Tennessee’s
brilliant young attorney-general
Tennessee vs. John ScopesThe “Monkey Trial” --1925Clarence Darrow and William Jenni
ngs Bryan during the trial
Introduction to the Passage
The purpose of a piece of objective description:
---to record and reproduce a true picture with opinions and emotions of the author excluded
Introduction to the Passage
Ways of developing a piece of objective description:
---to begin with a brief general picture, divide the object into parts and organize the detailed description in order of space
V. Questions for Discussion
1. How much do you know about the author from this article?
2. What do you think of the struggles between fundamentalists and modernists?
3. Why was so much attention paid to this trial in an out-of-the-way small town in the U.S.?
4. Try to elaborate the views of Darrow and Malone and that of Bryan’s.
5. What have you learned about the Bible?