Download - walkway collapse analysis
Finite Element Analysis on Structure in Hyatt CollapseMeng Lu1, Jiaying Gao1
Department of Mechanical Engineering
* Values are arbitrary and only intend to cause beam failure so maximum loading of each design can be verified
Background• In July 1981, two suspended walkways at the
Kansas City Hyatt Regency hotel collapsed• During investigation of National Bureau of
Standards, the key connection on the supporting beam of the walk way is changed, shown in Fig. 1 below
• Inner rod on modified beam carries weight from second floor
Finite Element Model• Geometries of the 3D beam model for both
designs shown in Fig. 2• Only rod-beam connection simulation to
observe damage on beam due to loading• Loading condition based on actual beam
usage• Maximum force causing damage will be used
to evaluate effect of new design in terms of load carrying capacity
• Precise beam deformation are simulated and will be used to compared with physical evidence
Goal of the Project• Through Finite Element Method, applying
loading on both designs to cause failure.• Investigate both designs’ loading carrying
capacity and determine whether the modified design is as safe as original one (which was validated by designer)
Modified Original
Fig. 1 Modified and Original Design of Connection
Fig. 2 Modified (a) and original (b) beam models
(a)
(b)Fixed
130 kN 130 kN
140 kN
FEA Results:
Applying Load
Applying Displacement
• By applying load, accurate contact between rod and beam simulated
• Better loading history of outside rod shown below
Modified Design
Original Design
Fig. 3 Deformed Beams: Modified (Upper) and Original (Lower)
*Welded region marked in red
Fig. 4 Side view of two design before and after deformation
Accurate force compared to NBS test result
Conclusion1. Modified beam can only stand 21 kips, around 3.5
kips less then original design2. The modified beam is carrying weight from current
floor and 2nd floor. Thus the welded region is more likely to fail.
3. In original design, beam only carries weight from current level, thus less stress on the welded region
Beam has two sides welded together Results Discussion:
8” 4”