-
8/14/2019 Youth Transitions Policies in Latin America: New Perspectives and Their
1/2
Youth transitions policies in Latin America: new perspectives and their links with research
evidence
Claudia Jacinto
Summary
The presentation will discuss some research evidence on youth transition in Latin America
comparing them with some key features of youth transition policies and analyzing in what
extend the policies are based on research evidence. The paper is based in two pieces of
regional research on the subject developed by RedEtis, a regional network supported by IIEP-
UNESCO. The countries included are Argentina, Brazil, Colombia, Chile and Uruguay but
also a database of 202 policies and programs from the year 2000 was created and analyzed.
Evidence shows that youth transition is strongly conditioned by weaknesses and
segmentation both in educational system and in labour markets. Trajectories are de-
standarized, showing high rotation and mobility in the beginning of youth careers. All groups
show precarious trajectories but:
Some lead to formal, decent jobs and stability, or chosen self-employment with
good incomes: around 25 years old labour indicators begin to improve
Other trajectories do not show improvement, but persistence in precarious, not
chosen employment, with low incomes
Others show exclusion, long periods of unemployment, or extremely precarious
and/or informal jobs (even illegal jobs). Many types of disadvanges: structural,
household and personal conditions. Broken subjectivities.
Among the factors related to misleading transitions it can be mentioned: low educational
levels, lack of training, social and ethnic discrimination, spatial segregation, constellation of
disadvantages, in terms of Walther and Pohl.
One mayor finding in qualitative research is that, apart from structural factors and generalformulation of policies, the institutional, pedagogical and tutoring approaches are key to
reinforcing disadvantaged youth subjectivities and to understand why some misleading
trajectories can be changed into leading trajectories.
Youth employment policies in recent years, especially those related to undereducated youth,continue to give strong importance to vocational training, based on training centres and
NGOs and first job programmes has increased. Some new focuses that in part take into
account previous research
Promoting alternative pathways to finish primary and secondary schools
Orientation toward activation of young people
Promoting integrated training systems
But, there are still no permanent and articulated policies addressed to youth transition. Manyprogrammes have been based on a simplistic view of youth inclusion in the labour market, by
supplying too specific and/or low quality training in a one shot approach, disregarding the
importance of diplomas, and of an enlarged skills development approach. Internships and
work experiences are frequently oriented to integrated youth while the poorer are oriented toself-employment. Mostly the links of the vocational courses with regular vocational training
in a lifelong learning perspective are lacking. Counselling is frequently just to learn job
seeking skills, not in a holistic tutoring approach. And concerning the most disadvantaged,
-
8/14/2019 Youth Transitions Policies in Latin America: New Perspectives and Their
2/2
generally programmes do not take their constraints into account, such as lack of information,
social capital, resources, broken subjectivities, etc.
In conclusion, recent changes in youth transition policies do not show a new paradigm in
conceiving the youth transition process as a long and complex period and many segmented
pathways shown by research.