dr. ben d. sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/iap2018-human-fact… ·...

17
humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’s Lecture 2: Human-machine Teaming Designing for The Human

Upload: others

Post on 25-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’s

Lecture 2: Human-machine Teaming

Designing for The Human

Page 2: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Do You Trust Automation and Autonomy?

• Do you trust your crockpot?

Page 3: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Do You Trust Automation and Autonomy?

• Do you trust your cruise control?

Page 4: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Do You Trust Automation and Autonomy?

• How about an automated dentist?

Page 5: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Human Trust of Machine Partners

• How important is trust?

• What aspects of machine systems (with

humans included!) help and hurt trust?

Page 6: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Human and Machine Strengths and Limitations

(Fitts,1954)

• What are you good at?

• Where do you need help?

Page 7: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Human and Machine Strengths and Limitations

(Fitts,1954)

Page 8: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Human and Machine Strengths and Limitations

› Replication

› Speed & Power

› Simultaneous Operation

› Short Term Memory

› Computation

› Long Term Memory

› Perception

› Judgement

› Induction

› Improvisation

M

H

(deWinter, 2015)

(Fitts,1954)

Page 9: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Consider a Case of Perception: Prevalence Effects

Airport Scanner

(Mitroff & Biggs, 2014)

(deWinter, 2015)

Page 10: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Consider a Case of Perception: Prevalence Effects

(Mitroff & Biggs, 2014)

(deWinter, 2015)

Page 11: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

• How about your spam filter?

Do You Trust Automation and Autonomy?

Page 12: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Trust in Human-machine Teaming

Page 13: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Trust in Human-machine Teaming

Better spam protection lowers frequency

M

Page 14: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Trust in Human-machine Teaming

As the machine become better, the human gets worse

M

Page 15: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Do You Trust Automation and Autonomy?

As the machine become better, the human gets worse

• In absolute terms the human is still protected

• What are the implications for trust?

• Can we design spam protection that is a better teammate?

M

Page 16: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Can we design better

human-machine teams?

Page 17: Dr. Ben D. Sawyer’sbendsawyer.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/01/IAP2018-Human-Fact… · humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer >bsawyer@mit.edu > More at bendsawyer.com

humanfactors.mit.edu > © 2018 Dr. Ben D. Sawyer > [email protected] > More at bendsawyer.com

Questions