8/8/2019 Dr. Harifin Tumpa - Judicial Activism, Judge Alignment to the Environment

1/10

8/8/2019 Dr. Harifin Tumpa - Judicial Activism, Judge Alignment to the Environment

2/10

Cmdjksoubi

Mtmdhvh``m{doubysx,auikethbyneHbiobethmboysedokbhtem

tymseiedhtht mthbdollob`o{doubysx"

Mnhknes

dousy

iedhthob

lmx

sefessei

cx

oynes

auiket

hb

iedhihbkthlh`msdmtetmbihbf`uebdeyne`ekm`ieve`owlebyof

ynedoubysx

8/8/2019 Dr. Harifin Tumpa - Judicial Activism, Judge Alignment to the Environment

3/10

E~mlw`e of iedhthobt {nhdn mse boy wsevhout`x

jbo{b hb Hbiobethmb `ekm` txtyel, `myesmiowyei cx @m{

Auikeiedhthobhbdhvh`dmteiedhthobynmysedokbhqetyneshknyt

ofyneEbvhsoblebyOskmbhqmyhob.BKO(,[M@NHhbhytdmwmdhyx

mtwmsyhetyoyneihtwuyeyoyneebvhsobleby.`ekm`tymbihbk(

auiketiedhthob

{no

sedokbhqe

yne

shkny

of

dhyhqebt

yo

fh`e

tuhy

hbynebmleofwuc`hdhbyesetyhbynedollob`m{txtyelht

jbo{bmtyneDhyhqeb@m{Tuhy"

8/8/2019 Dr. Harifin Tumpa - Judicial Activism, Judge Alignment to the Environment

4/10

Ynedousmkeofyneauiketyoioyne#hbbovmyhob#cxmww`xhbk

ynewshbdhw`et

of

ebvhsoblebym`

`m{

toleyhlet

boy

hb`hbe

{hyn

ynehbyesetyofedobolhdieve`owleby{nhdnboydobthieshbk

tutymhbmc`eieve`owlebywshbdhw`et"

Yneauike+t

iedhthob

ynmy

#wso

ebvhsobleby mww`x

yne

wshbdhw`eofysuetutymhbmc`eieve`owlebyyoynehbthknyfu`fms

mnemiyobe~ykebesmyhob"

8/8/2019 Dr. Harifin Tumpa - Judicial Activism, Judge Alignment to the Environment

5/10

Lmbim`m{mbkh Dmte

Dhvh`dmtet,htyned`mttmdyhob`m{tuhyhbLmbim`m{mbkhnh``

{nesetymye

dolwmbx

`hmc`e

of

yne

`mbit`hie

{nhdn

dmute

imlmkeyoynevh``mkebemscx"

Cxdobthieshbkynewshbdhw`eof#wsedmuyhobmsxwshbdhw`e yne

IewmsylebyofFosetysx.Wesnuymbh(`hmc`ecxboymww`xhbk

wsuiebdehb

yne

lmbmkeleby

of

fosetyt

mbi

`emi

yo

bmyusm`

ihtmtyest,`ottoftodheyxmbiedotxtyelimlmke"

Ynhtsu`hbkhtobee~mlw`e{neseyneauikew`mxtmbhlwosymby

so`e

hb

yne

iefebte

mbi

m`hkblebyt

yo

yne

ebvhsobleby"

Ynht

ynefhstyebvhsoblebym`dmteynmyhbdoswosmyehbyesbmyhobm`

ebvhsoblebym`wshbdhw`e"

8/8/2019 Dr. Harifin Tumpa - Judicial Activism, Judge Alignment to the Environment

6/10

IedhthobofyneMilhbhtysmyhveDousydmte{nhdntymyetynmy

ynesed`mlmyhobofynebosyndomtyofAmjmsymhthbvm`hi.h``ekm`(

fosEHMmbiweslhyyhbkuteofhbmwwsowshmyembidobysmsxyo

ynewshbdhw`et

of

kooi

kovesbmbde

hb

ebvhsoblebym`

lmbmkeleby"

8/8/2019 Dr. Harifin Tumpa - Judicial Activism, Judge Alignment to the Environment

7/10

UbiesDshlhbm`Dmtet,{em`tonmvemiedhthobt{nhdnmww`x

ynewshbdhw`e

of

#hbyes

&

hbysm

kebesmyhob#

dolchbei

{hyn

yne

wshbdhw`eof#ieyyesebyeffedy h"e"vesihdyhbynedshlhbm`

offebteofh``ekm`tm`eof{h`i`hfe,{nhdnhtdobthieseicxyne

auiketynmyynewsetebykebesmyhobmbikebesmyhobtfuyuse

nmveyne

shkny

yo

ebaox

yne

wsetebde

of

{h`i

mbhlm`t

ynmy

io

boycedolee~yhbdy,mbiynesefosemkmhbtyyneiefebimby{no

dollhyyeiynedshleofh``ekm`tm`eof{h`i`hfetebyebdeiyo

nemvx,yoyneiefebimbyosynedollubhyxfee`tfemsmbi

ieyessebyyo

thlh`ms

mdyt"

8/8/2019 Dr. Harifin Tumpa - Judicial Activism, Judge Alignment to the Environment

8/10

So`e of Auiket

Fsolynefe{e~mlw`etoftudniedhthob,hydmbcedobd`uiei

ynmyyne

auiket

nmve

mb

hlwosymby

so`e

fos

auihdhm`

mdyhvhtl

.os

sednyvhbihbk(hbfmvosofyneebvhsoblebymbifosyne

wsetesvmyhobofedotxtyelfubdyhobt,ynesefose,bedettmsxhb

ynefuyuseauiketoshebyeiebvhsoblebymbiymjemiedhthob

mbhbbovmyhve

wsoksetthve

vhthob

yo

sem`hqe

ynmy

ebvhsobleby

8/8/2019 Dr. Harifin Tumpa - Judicial Activism, Judge Alignment to the Environment

9/10

Dobd`uthob

YneTuwseleDousymtynenhknetydousyhbHbiobethmdobfhslhybedettmsxyohbdsemteynedmwmdhyxofauiketmyvmshout`eve`t

hb

osies

yo

nmve

mtysobk

ebvhsoblebym`

vhthob

mbi

hbyekshyx"

YneTuwseleDousyyoojtyewtyohbdsemteynedmwmdhyxof

auiket

yo

{hyn

etymc`htnhbk

yne

ebvhsoblebym`

autyhde

desyhfhdmyhob.desyhfheiAuiket(hbdoowesmyhob{hynyneLhbhtysxfosyneEbvhsoblebymbituwwosyeicxyneHbiobethmbDebyesobEbvhsoblebym`@m{.HDE@(mbiynem`ulbmemttodhmyhobofebvhsoblebym``m{ysmhbhbkfosauiket.HMWN@H("

DesyhfheiAuiketmsee~wedyeiyonmvemkooi}um`hyxmbihbyekshyxhbnmbi`hbkebvhsoblebym`dmtet"

8/8/2019 Dr. Harifin Tumpa - Judicial Activism, Judge Alignment to the Environment

10/10

Ynmbjxou