dr neil j. bristow · 2016. 3. 29. · 05-dec-2011 1 dr neil j. bristow presentation at oecd...

29
05-Dec-2011 1 Dr Neil J. Bristow Presentation at OECD Steelmaking Raw Materials Workshop Paris, France 5 th December 2011 H & W Worldwide Consulting [email protected] +61240286268 1. Brief Steel Outlook 2. Iron Ore Markets and Drivers 3. Metallurgical Coal and Coke 4. Scrap, Metallics and Direct Reduction 5. Manganese and FerroAlloys 6. Summary and Policy issues H & W Worldwide Consulting

Upload: others

Post on 13-Feb-2021

27 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 05-Dec-2011

    1

    Dr Neil J. Bristow

    Presentation at OECD Steelmaking Raw Materials Workshop

    Paris, France 5th December 2011

    H & W Worldwide

    Consulting [email protected] +61240286268

    1. Brief Steel Outlook

    2. Iron Ore Markets and Drivers

    3. Metallurgical Coal and Coke

    4. Scrap, Metallics and Direct Reduction

    5. Manganese and FerroAlloys

    6. Summary and Policy issues H & W Worldwide Consulting

    mailto:[email protected]

  • 05-Dec-2011

    2

    • A year in two parts strong steel output/demand in H1 then weakness in H2 as economy slows

    • Major dislocations to raw materials supply due to weather events in Australia and Brazil, strikes Canada

    • Markets tight in early 2011, now softer, what happens if 2012 is stronger than predicted?

    • Continued moves to change raw materials pricing – push to indices across iron ore and coal

    • Emergence of new basins for coal and new iron ore impact more pronounced in 2012-3

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    0

    500

    1000

    1500

    2000

    2500

    Mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Crude Steep production by Region

    China India Asia ex China, India Europe NAFTA South America CIS Middle East

    1,000

    1,100

    1,200

    1,300

    1,400

    1,500

    1,600

    1,700

    1,800

    1,900

    2010 2011 2012 2013 2014

    Millio

    n t

    on

    nes

    Steel and pig iron production growth

    Crude Steel

    Pig Iron

    H & W Worldwide Consulting Source: WSA, H&W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    3

    0

    200

    400

    600

    800

    1000

    1200

    1400

    1600

    1800

    Mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Pig Iron production by Region

    China India

    Asia ex China, India Europe

    NAFTA South America

    CIS Middle East

    60

    62

    64

    66

    68

    70

    72

    74

    Pe

    rce

    nta

    ge

    Global BOF Production Share

    Rise of

    China

    Forecast

    China’s growth will raise BF/BOF share by ~0.8% in 2012-3, as the majority of the global pig iron increase derives from Chinese growth in BF productivity and expansions relying mainly on imported raw materials.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting Source: WSA, H&W Worldwide Consulting

    Vast low cost high grade iron ore reserves

    No met coal

    No scrap/some merchant pig iron

    Favour BF/BOF

    Vast high grade iron ore reserves

    Very limited met coal

    No scrap/some sponge iron

    Favour BF/BOF

    Limited iron ore reserves

    Some met coal

    No scrap/minor DRI

    Favour BF/BOF + EAF

    Vast iron ore reserves

    Extensive met coal

    Scrap/some DRI

    Favour BF/BOF + EAF

    Low grade iron ore reserves

    Large met coal reserves

    No Scrap

    Favour BF/BOF

    SE Asia

    China

    Russia

    India

    In addition to China steel growth to 2014 will be driven by other countries, with a majority favouring the BF route relying on imported seaborne coking coal and domestic iron ore.

    Brazil

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    4

    Oxygen enrichment

    Pulverised Coal Injection

    Deadman

    Recent Blast Furnace Changes:

    – Reline enlargements

    – Pulverised coal injection

    – Oxygen enrichment of the blast

    – Larger working volumes

    – Low gangue feed

    – Bosh / Hearth cooling

    – Computer control / heat & mass

    balance models

    – Instrumentation advances

    The BF has been the King and has seen of many challengers. It will remain the main producer of iron for

    steelmaking into the future, no change in near term.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Iron Ore 0-25%

    Sinter 50-85%

    Pellets 0-100%

    Coke 650-290kg

    Pulverised coal injection 0-220kg

    Natural Gas 0-60kg

    Fuel Oil 0-100kg

    Lump Ore Coke

    • Raw Materials costs ~60-75% of liquid steel costs

    • Transportation costs ~ 6-15% of liquid steel costs

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    5

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Key roles of

    coke in the BF

    1. Energy

    2. Source of Carbon

    3. Strength

    4. Permeability

    Molten slag

    Gas flow (coke)

    Liquid flow

    Sintered Ore Coke +

    Carbon monoxide

    +

    Iron oxide

    Carbon dioxide

    +

    Iron

    Coke

    +

    Oxygen

    Carbon

    dioxide

    Molten iron

    Carbon

    monoxide

    Carbon dioxide

    +

    Coke

    Key takeaway no

    change in coke

    quality

    Key roles of

    Ferrous materials

    in the BF

    1. Low RDI

    2. Strength

    3. Even softening

    /melting

    4. High reducibility

    Molten slag

    Gas flow (coke)

    Liquid flow

    Sintered Ore, lump, pellets Coke +

    Fe2O3 + CO

    Coke

    +

    Oxygen

    Carbon

    dioxide

    Molten iron

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Carbon

    monoxide

    Carbon dioxide

    +

    Coke

    Fe2O3 + C

    CO2 +

    Fe (l)

    Key takeaway no

    change in ferrous

    quality

  • 05-Dec-2011

    6

    Tumble /Shatter Index

    Decrepitation

    Reduction Degradation Index

    Reducibility

    Softening/melting behaviour

    ferrous

    burden

    quality

    No change in near term for ferrous burden materials as BF remains core production unit. Increased

    productivity, lower fuel and slag rates remain key targets for ironmakers.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Diagram: Techint

    Heavy melt Scrap

    50 100% Shredded Scrap

    0 – 50%

    HBI

    0 – 40% DR ore

    0 – 80%

    Some EAF’s have coal/oxy injection

    for additional heating

    EAF drivers will also remain unchanged, with adjustments to feedstocks as EAF steelmakers seek to

    move up the value chain into higher quality flat products, SB’s etc - rising need for DRI, premium scrap

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    7

    Melting rate Resistance to hot oxidising

    gases

    Carbon content

    Size

    DRI poor poor average excellent

    HBI poor average average excellent

    Heavy melting scrap

    average average poor poor

    Shredded scrap high density

    average/

    excellent poor poor excellent

    Pig Iron excellent excellent excellent excellent

    Liquid Iron excellent N/A excellent liquid

    Increasing EAF use is not all bad for the BF, as merchant pig iron makes an excellent part feed for modern

    EAF’s as does liquid hot metal, BF linked to EAF’s in the future?

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Cost of iron ore and coking coal as percent of global HRC steel price

    0%

    10%

    20%

    30%

    40%

    50%

    60%

    70%

    80%

    1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010

    % o

    f ste

    el

    pri

    ce

    Iron ore Coking coal

    Major raw materials have risen very sharply in price and are now close to record % shares of the cost of steel based on HRC. This is driving steelmakers to seek to use cheaper and more difficult to use

    steelmaking raw materials.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting Source: Macquarie Research estimates, September 2011

  • 05-Dec-2011

    8

    • Raw Materials Impurities • Increase fuel rates and lower productivity

    • Can cause breakdown of coke, refractory attack

    • Lead to recycling in BF and environmental problems

    • Make BF slag unusable

    • Freight • Increase costs and carbon footprint

    • Losses and degradation during transport

    • Stockpiles, dusts, environmental issues

    • Supply and Quality • Increasing demand seeing moves to new materials from new locations

    • Testing and evaluation of “new” raw materials

    • Price of raw materials leading steelmakers to experiment with new

    materials H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Using carbon lean

    sources

    Smelting reduction

    Modern blast furnace 2010

    Advanced technologies

    Partial reduction with

    biomass or H2

    Sequestration

    Replace fossil carbon Improve efficiency

    Development

    CO

    2 e

    mis

    sio

    n p

    er

    ton

    ne

    of

    ste

    el 100%

    80%

    40%

    60%

    20%

    0%

    0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7

    „Learning curve‟

    1

    2

    4

    3

    Ta

    rge

    t

    Modern blast furnace 2020

    1a

    5

    Renewable carbon and capture

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    9

    1. Brief Steel Outlook

    2. Iron Ore Markets and Drivers

    3. Metallurgical Coal and Coke

    4. Scrap, Metallics and Direct Reduction

    5. Manganese and FerroAlloys

    6. Summary and Policy issues H & W Worldwide Consulting

    • Natural iron ores (or direct shipping ores (DSO) or run-of-mine ores) – ores as extracted from mines and not subjected to any processes of beneficiation other than sizing. • Lump ore – ore consisting of coarse particles, typically with a minimum size

    between 6 and 50mm.

    • Sintering Fine ore – ore consisting entirely of small particles. Upper size limit usually between 6.3 – 10mm.

    • Sized ore – ore prepared to meet specific size limits e.g. 6.3 x 30mm.

    • Processed ore – ore physically or chemically (rare) treated to make them more suitable for use. • Concentrates – processed ores in which the iron content has been increased,

    size typically 1mm to 0.125mm

    • Pellet Feeds – processed fine ores which have been ground and beneficiated, size typically

  • 05-Dec-2011

    10

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    The iron ore flow to Blast Furnace

    Concentrate

    Sinter plant

    Pellet plant

    Sinter

    Pellet

    Lump

    BF

    Fines

    Pellet Feed

    0 – 25%max

    0 – 90%max

    50 – 85%max

    The iron ore flow to the DR Shaft

    Concentrate

    Pellet plant Pellet

    Lump

    DR

    Pellet

    Feed

    ~5%

    ~95% Grinding

    Major ferrous raw materials flows are customer and region specific, increased variation is likely in the near future as new materials enter the market.

    Primary Melt Formation

    Granules Segregated Bed

    Humidified

    Granules

    Sinter

    Coarsening by

    granulation

    Charging on

    machine

    Humidification by

    water condensation

    Drying and calcination

    Solid-solid

    reactions Solid-melt

    reactions

    Cooling and solidification

    Ore Mix

    Drying

    Calcination

    Shrinkage/

    cracking

    Total melt generated

    1. 2.

    3.

    4. 5. 6.

    7.

    These sub-processes

    influence overall

    sintering performance. The response of certain

    ores can be quite different,

    e.g. goethite, magnetite

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    11

    70 92 113148

    208 275326

    384 444628

    626678

    0

    200

    400

    600

    800

    1000

    1200

    2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011e

    (millio

    n to

    nn

    es)

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    70

    (Ch

    ina

    % s

    ha

    re o

    f to

    tal tr

    ad

    e)

    World ex China China % share (RHS)

    China iron ore imports and share of global trade

    H & W Worldwide Consulting Source: CISA, China Customs, H&W Worldwide consulting

    The rise of China saw seaborne iron ore grow very rapidly . Ex China seaborne iron ore has not reached pre GFC levels and is unlikely to do so in 2012-3.

    Chinese iron ore imports are predominantly fines, estimated at ~90% of total figure with pellets ~5%

    of the total; the majority being hematite. Magnetite is excepted to increase in the future.

    China iron ore imports by source

    Fines Lump Pellet Hematite Magnetite

    Australia Yes predominant Yes very limited Yes majority very limited

    currently will rise

    Brazil Yes predominant very limited Yes Yes majority Very limited

    India Yes predominant limited very limited Yes majority no

    South Africa Yes predominant Yes no yes no

    Ukraine Yes majority no Yes minority yes very limited

    Canada Small no Yes majority yes very limited

    Russia yes no yes yes very limited

    Iran yes no no yes no

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    12

    China

    Other Developing

    Developed

    0

    100

    200

    300

    400

    500

    600

    700

    800

    2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020

    Mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Incremental Seaborne Iron Ore Growth

    23

    Seaborne Iron Ore

    Chinese imports will continue to grow as domestic supplies increase in cost and decline in grade , and as

    significant additional supply comes on stream from major producers leading to reduction in domestic supply.

    2010

    2020

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    133 134 136 145 153 136 138 157 170195

    254307

    358 376 388412 432

    41 44 55 5255 70 92

    111148

    208

    275

    326

    384444

    628 626678

    54%

    34%

    24%

    60%

    0

    100

    200

    300

    400

    500

    600

    700

    800

    900

    1000

    1100

    1200

    1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011e

    0%

    10%

    20%

    30%

    40%

    50%

    60%

    70%

    80%

    Domestic Iron Ore (62.0% Fe Equiv) Imported Iron Ore Domestic Ore Share Imported Ore Share

    Source: CISA, China Customs, H&W Worldwide consulting

    Million

    Ton

    nes

    Accurate information on domestic ore is difficult to get due to under reporting, double counting but

    domestic production is still rising to meet the need for iron units.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    13

    Beneficiation Balling High temperature reactions

    90% passing 45µm

    Magnetite - magnetic properties - in concentrate form - exothermic heating in pelletising

    Hematite - generally more costly - in concentrate form

    Hematite – goethite

    (Australian)

    X – less desirable because goethite lowers yield and hinders performance.

    X – not ideal because generally sold as coarse sinter fines

  • 05-Dec-2011

    14

    Source: Macquarie Research, company announcements, H&W Worldwide Consulting

    0

    100

    200

    300

    400

    500

    600

    700

    800

    2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

    mtp

    a

    Other

    Assmang

    Consolidated Thompson

    Mt Gibson

    Atlas

    CSN

    Anglo American

    FMG

    BHP Billiton

    Rio Tinto

    Vale

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Seaborne market likely to see significant growth to 2015, with ~65% projected to come from the “Big 3”.

    Capacity growth has been far slower than announced – typically ~50% in delays and reduced output.

    800

    900

    1000

    1100

    1200

    1300

    1400

    1500

    1600

    1700

    1800

    2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020

    Mil

    lio

    n to

    nn

    es

    Seaborne Iron Ore Supply Balance

    Seaborne Demand (Imports)

    Seaborne Supply (Exports)

    Seaborne market remains undersupplied until major new expansions in Australia and Brazil come on

    stream post 2013-4. Longer term planned expansions are ahead of demand growth.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting Source: Macquarie Research, H&W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    15

    Iron ore Supply Quality

    • Chemistry • Overall drift to lower grade in

    many countries • Lower Fe,

    • Higher SiO2 and Al2O3, • Higher P and LOI

    • Physical Properties • Trends to finer size

    • Reduced lump yield

    • Lower metallurgical properties of lump

    • Increasing ultra-fines – concentrates and pellet feed

    • Ore Types • Trends to increased magnetite

    • New Australian and West African magnetite

    Iron ore Future Demand

    • Chemistry • Overall demand for higher

    quality ores and sinters • Lower gangue and RDI,

    • Higher reducibility,

    • Physical Properties • Trends to coarser size

    • To granulate more finer ores

    • Lump mix – stronger and higher grade less decrepitation

    • Increased pellets

    • Ore Types • Trends to optimise use

    • Magnetite to pellets

    • Hematite to sinter

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    • Chemistry

    • Increased BF slag volumes and rising P levels

    • Move from lump to sinter/pellets

    • Sinter yields challenged, increased RDI lower RI

    • Higher silica loads – problems with slag granulation

    • Physical Properties

    • Increased pressure on sinter plant productivity

    • Moves to manage increased ultrafine ores

    • HPS sinter, secondary or selective agglomeration, micro pellets

    • Rising magnetite – move to pellets as poor sintering

    • Deterioration in sintering size – more concentrates poor

    granulation

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    16

    • Market dominated by China today and into the future

    • Current tight market to remain, strong markets to

    ~2014

    • Major new capacity coming on stream will balance

    market – timing important

    • Major changes in the future ore supply

    • Many deposits to see grade decline

    • More magnetite and finer ores

    • India exports – decline?

    • Chinese domestic production peaks and then declines

    • Will lead to significant changes in BF burdening H & W Worldwide Consulting

    1. Brief Steel Outlook

    2. Iron Ore Markets and Drivers

    3. Metallurgical Coal and Coke

    4. Scrap, Metallics and Direct Reduction

    5. Manganese and FerroAlloys

    6. Summary and Policy issues H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    17

    • Simple definition Coking coal and injection coal (PCI)

    • Coking coals (coals that enter the coke oven)

    • Hard Coking Coal (HCC)

    • Semi-hard coking coal

    • Semi- soft coking coal

    • “Fillers”

    • PCI Coals

    • Ultra low volatile coals

    • Low and mid volatile coals

    • High volatile coals and thermal coal

    Declining quality, range of

    properties and measures

    Declining coke replacement

    ratio, fixed carbon, energy

    Seaborne market definitions are some what regionally specific, especially when it comes to further dividing

    up coals into rank and volatile components.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    • Increased strength – larger BF‟s

    • Higher CSR - higher productivity

    • Larger mean size – increased permeability

    • Lower ash – reduced fuel rates

    • Move to HCC complimented by low ash CC’s

    • Strong growth – emergence of India

    • CRR rowing importance – coke price/cost rising

    • Rapid burn no residual char – clean Deadman

    • Low ash, high energy , low P, alkalis

    Active Coke Zone/

    Dripping Zone Blast

    Raceway

    Cohesi

    ve

    Zone

    Coke

    PCI

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    18

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    300

    Mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Seaborne metallurgical demand 2000-2010

    HCC SSCC PCI

    Seaborne coking coal imports

    150

    160

    170

    180

    190

    200

    210

    220

    230

    240

    250

    20

    00

    20

    01

    20

    02

    20

    03

    20

    04

    20

    05

    20

    06

    20

    07

    20

    08

    20

    09

    20

    10

    Mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Total

    Total Ex-China

    H & W Worldwide Consulting Source: McCloskey, Macquarie Research, H&W Worldwide Consulting

    Seaborne metallurgical coal market remains dominated by the HCC portion. PCI demand was curtailed due

    to the GFC but is predicted to grow strongly in the future. The GFC saw China become a major coking coal

    buyer, particularly of HCC coals.

    HCC remains the largest portion of the increase, as expected with new ovens in India and growing HCC imports

    into China. Larger BF’s & higher PCI also favour HCC demand.

    HCC

    SSCC

    PCI

    0

    100

    200

    300

    400

    500

    600

    2010

    2011

    2012

    2013

    2014

    2015

    2016

    2017

    2018

    2019

    2020

    2021

    2022

    2023

    2024

    2025

    mil

    lio

    n to

    nn

    es

    HCC

    SSCC

    PCI

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    300

    2010

    2011

    2012

    2013

    2014

    2015

    2016

    2017

    2018

    2019

    2020

    2021

    2022

    2023

    2024

    2025

    mil

    lio

    n to

    nn

    es

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Coal demand by type Coal demand growth by type

    Source : H&W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    19

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

    mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Seaborne Met Coal Supply

    Australia USA Canada Russia Others

    Australia 64%

    USA 9%

    Canada 11%

    Russia 3% Others

    13%

    2010

    No major changes in market structure major producers have retained position. USA retained ability to be

    “swing” producer, Australian market share steady growth ~54% to 64%.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting Source : GTIS, McCloskey, H&W Worldwide Consulting

    Australia 56%

    USA 23%

    Canada 11%

    Russia 3%

    Indonesia 2%

    Other 5%

    Source: GTIS, H&W Worldwide Consulting H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Australia is the dominant supplier of met coal to the market. The major 3 producers account for around

    89% of the total supply, with US at record exports due to demand and Australian floods

    Note: Severe floods in Australia has

    reduced exports severe in Q1 and Q2

  • 05-Dec-2011

    20

    Source: Macquarie Research, H&W Worldwide Consulting

    Major seaborne supply basin

    Major prospective supply basin

    Major domestic supply basin

    Tavan Tolgoi, Mongolia High political risk, no infrastructure in place, captive to Chinese market

    Shanxi, China Dangerous, high-cost mining conditions, costs escalating on regulatory burden and RMB appreciation

    Central Kalimantan High political risk, transport logistics uncertain

    Bowen Basin Increasing costs, lower quality, no low-hanging fruit

    Tete/Moatize Good mining conditions, challenging infrastructure

    Appalachia Increasing costs, regulations, declining reserves Western Canada

    High project development and operating costs, particularly in northern British Colombia, rail and port constraints near term.

    Elga Challenging infrastructure, much delayed project

    Kuzbass Large reserves, but very long route to coast and export markets

    Very little new supply likely before late 2012, infrastructure close to capacity and recovery from

    2011 flood event has been slower than predicted.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    2012 will see new coals from Mozambique, Mongolia and Indonesia enter the market, these are different to

    traditional coking coals.

    Source : GTIS, Australian Customs, H&W Worldwide Consulting H & W Worldwide Consulting

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    140

    160

    180

    2008 2009 2010 2011a

    millio

    n t

    on

    nes

    Major Met Coal Producers

    Australia Canada USA

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    12

    14

    millio

    n t

    on

    nes

    Australian exports

    SSCC HCC

    US producers have increased exports in 2011 to make up for Australian losses due to the weather and are

    expected to remain in the market as Australia and Canada grow.

  • 05-Dec-2011

    21

    Source : GTIS, H&W Worldwide Consulting

    Chinese met coal imports have declined in 2011 but continue to grow, from Mongolia . Australian

    exports declined due to weather and pricing effects – Chinese swing price buyers

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    -10

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    Total Australia Mongolia Russia USA Canada Indonesia

    mil

    lio

    n to

    nn

    es

    China import changes

    2008

    2009

    2010

    2011 YTD

    Changes

    0

    50

    100

    150

    200

    250

    300

    350

    400

    450

    500

    Mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Seaborne Metallurgical coal exports

    Vietnam

    Venezuela

    USA

    South Africa

    Russia

    Poland

    Other

    New Zealand

    Mozambique

    Mongolia

    Indonesia

    Colombia

    China

    Canada

    Australia

    Seaborne market likely to see increase in 2012, subject to weather effects, with demand weak will China re-

    enter the market?

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    22

    • Trends for rising ash levels in new mines and some

    new basins (Mozambique)

    • General drift down in fluidity in number of regions

    • New coals have different properties and characteristics

    than current seaborne coals

    • Vitrinite levels higher in new basins – new blends

    • Reduced volumes of ULV PCI coals and rising P levels

    • Widening quality range across HCC/SHCC/SCC

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    • Trends for rising ash will see rising BF slag volumes

    • Cokemakers will seek new blends with new coals

    • Will high vitrinite levels see greater “carrying capacity”

    • Will trends to ULV coals for PCI change to higher VM

    coals?

    • Search for high carbon, low ash fillers – increased use

    of pet coke?

    • Now to NG as an injectant or co-injectant for ash and

    environmental benefits?

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    23

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    12

    14

    16

    18

    mil

    lio

    n to

    nn

    es

    Chinese coke exports

    China has supplied coke short regions such as Europe and US prior to the GFC. But with high duties and

    moves to reduce energy intensive exports it is highly unlikely that will return to high levels of exports.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting Source: GTIS

    Source : GTIS, H&W Worldwide Consulting

    Coke exports illustrate the extremely weak position in 2009, recovery in 2010 has been mixed and might

    slowing, but what happens when ROW fully recovers if China limits exports?

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    12

    14

    mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Chinese coke exports

    2008

    2009

    2010

    2011

    0

    0.2

    0.4

    0.6

    0.8

    1

    1.2

    1.4

    1.6

    1.8

    mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Chines coke monthly exports

  • 05-Dec-2011

    24

    • Mature steel industries tend to be coke short

    • Europe, US etc

    • India has a large merchant coke sector but remains coke short

    • China has large (40%) tariffs on coke exports to reduce energy

    intensive exports

    • Other exporters are Poland, Russia and Ukraine, Australia could

    join as it shuts one BF

    • Who will replace China when markets return to pre GFC levels of

    production if China doe not return to high levels of exports?

    • Will new cokemaking technologies (HRCO) see more ovens built

    or will another country replace China, e.g. India?

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    1. Brief Steel Outlook

    2. Iron Ore Markets and Drivers

    3. Metallurgical Coal and Coke

    4. Scrap, Metallics and Direct Reduction

    5. Manganese and FerroAlloys

    6. Summary and Policy issues H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    25

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    Mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Scrap exports

    China India Asia ex China, India Europe NAFTA South America CIS Middle East Africa Oceania

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    140

    Mil

    lio

    n t

    on

    ne

    s

    Scrap imports

    China India Asia ex China, India

    Europe NAFTA South America

    CIS Middle East Africa

    Oceania

    US sees a growth export of scrap, mainly to selected Europe and Asia. CIS has declined as more is

    now used domestically.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting Source: WSA

    400

    450

    500

    550

    600

    650

    700

    750

    Millio

    n t

    on

    nes

    Global Scrap forecast consumption

    Rising steel production will see scrap demand increase in both BOF and EAF vessels. DRI will also

    play an important part in steelmaking with coal based DRI/HBI likely to join gas based processes.

    Source: Midrex, H&W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    26

    Scrap 86%

    Pig Iron 9%

    DRI 5%

    Overall metallics trade • Scrap the dominant traded metallic

    • Most consumed where generated e.g. DRI,

    • Rising impurity levels and move to higher quality steel boosting virgin

    iron

    • Environmental concern remains re

    scrap – radioactive sources

    • Future increased use internally in

    CIS, possibly US

    • Scrap pool in China ~2020 for

    growing scrap based EAF

    • Rise in coal based DRI

    With growing demand for metallics will there is a shortage of scrap and increased investment in

    alternatives such as DRI and even pig iron, especially in scrap short countries?

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    1. Brief Steel Outlook

    2. Iron Ore Markets and Drivers

    3. Metallurgical Coal and Coke

    4. Scrap, Metallics and Direct Reduction

    5. Manganese and FerroAlloys

    6. Summary and Policy issues H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    27

    • ~90% of Mn is used in the steel industry mainly as ferroalloys

    • Mn has no substitute thus increased steel demand = more Mn demand

    • Mn use in steel had declined to ~2000 but has slightly increased due

    to the advent of China

    • Mn is also used in stainless steel with high levels in 200 series ~8%

    • Most M alloys are HCFeMn and SiMn mainly used in flat and long

    products respectively

    • Majority of Mn ore is in South Africa, with high grade deposits in

    Australia and Gabon

    • China has large low grade deposits and needs to import higher grade

    ore to make alloys for its strong steel production

    • Mn has some environmental concerns and has challenged the industry

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Mn ore grade

    Mn ore production

    Major reserves of Mn ore are in South Africa, although grades are declining. High grade ores have a

    more limited life in Australia and Gabon. Problems with infrastructure, power in South Africa and

    Government policies have raised questions as to the future of Mn ore growth.

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    28

    • ~90% of Mn is used in the steel industry mainly as ferroalloys

    • Mn has no substitute thus increased steel demand = more Mn demand

    • Mn use in steel had declined to ~2000 but has slightly increased due

    to the advent of China

    • Mn is also used in stainless steel with high levels in 200 series ~8%

    • Most M alloys are HCFeMn and SiMn mainly used in flat and long

    products respectively

    • Majority of Mn ore is in South Africa, with high grade deposits in

    Australia and Gabon, current problems in South Africa are a concern

    • China has large low grade deposits and needs to import higher grade

    ore to make alloys for its strong steel production

    • Mn has some environmental concerns and has challenged the industry

    H & W Worldwide Consulting

    1. Brief Steel Outlook

    2. Iron Ore Markets and Drivers

    3. Metallurgical Coal and Coke

    4. Scrap, Metallics and Direct Reduction

    5. Manganese and FerroAlloys

    6. Summary and Policy issues H & W Worldwide Consulting

  • 05-Dec-2011

    29

    • BF will remain the major production route – current RM parameters will remain highly important

    • Markets were tight in H1 in due to demand and weather events, now softer , possible recovery in 2012-3 back to tighter markets?

    • Drift down to lower grade in many existing mines in Iron ore, Coking coal and Manganese ore

    • New steelmaking raw materials will enter the market, finer higher grade ores and high ash and vitrinite coals

    • Government policies are changing:

    • Australia “leading” the way with MRRT and carbon taxes,

    • China seeking to curb energy intensive exports.

    • US making mine permitting more difficult

    • Governments wanting to share in resources boom, Mongolia coal, copper

    • Environmental pressures seeking curbs to mining and land allocation

    • Land allocations becoming more difficult across many countries, in Asia,

    Africa and Developed world H & W Worldwide Consulting

    Thank you for listening

    [email protected] +61240286268

    H & W Worldwide

    Consulting

    mailto:[email protected]