draft fy 2015 third quarter land use control inspection ... · fy 2015 third quarter land use...

32
Draft FY 2015 Third Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center Former Ravenna Army Ammunition Plant Portage and Trumbull Counties, Ohio Contract No. W912QR-13-C-0031 Prepared for: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Louisville District Prepared by: July 20, 2015

Upload: hoangminh

Post on 01-Sep-2018

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Draft

FY 2015 Third Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Former Ravenna Army Ammunition Plant Portage and Trumbull Counties, Ohio

Contract No. W912QR-13-C-0031

Prepared for:

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

Louisville District

Prepared by:

July 20, 2015

Draft FY 2015 Third Quarter Land Use Control Inspection

RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center Former Ravenna Army Ammunition Plant

Portage and Trumbull Counties, Ohio

Contract No. W912QR-13-C-0031

Prepared for:

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers

Louisville District

Prepared by:

July 20, 2015

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

LIST OF ACRONYMS AND ABBREVIATIONS

AOC Area of Concern

bgs Below Ground Surface

Camp Ravenna Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

EQM Environmental Quality Management, Inc.

FWGWMPP Facility-Wide Ground Water Monitoring Program Plan

FWSAP Facility-Wide Sampling and Analysis Plan

IRP Installation Restoration Program

LUC Land Use Control

MEC Munitions and Explosives of Concern

MK Mark

MRS Munitions Response Site

MSG Master Sergeant

Ohio EPA Ohio Environmental Protection Agency

OHARNG Ohio Army National Guard

PS Professional Surveyor

PMP Property Management Plan

RVAAP Ravenna Army Ammunition Plant

SOP Standard Operating Procedure

UXO Unexploded Ordnance

WBG Winklepeck Burning Grounds

1 2 Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center (Camp Ravenna) / 3 Former Ravenna Army Ammunition Plant (RVAAP) 4 Quarterly Land Use Control (LUC) Inspection Form 5 RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds 6 7 In accordance with the Camp Ravenna/former RVAAP Property Management Plan (PMP) dated August 8 2012 and Appendix A-1, an inspection of RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds (WBG) was conducted 9 by Don Trocchio on May 27 and 28, and June 1, 2, 3, 4, 8, 9, 10, 11 and 15, 2015.

10 11 The quarterly inspections required by the PMP include the following: 12

13 • Review of LUC training and documentation as applicable to WBG. 14 • Evaluation of the Camp Ravenna perimeter fence to ensure that it is maintained in a manner that is 15 protective and effective control and deters trespassers. 16 • Evaluation of activities at WBG to ensure that all activities executed within WBG are in compliance 17 with Ohio Army National Guard (OHARNG) range safety regulations/standard operation procedure 18 (SOP), established digging restrictions, and established exposure limits. All digging, intrusive 19 activities, or excavation on the WBG Area of Concern (AOC) outside of the Unexploded Ordnance 20 (UXO)/ Munitions and Explosives of Concern (MEC)-cleared areas within the Mark (MK) 19 21 Grenade Machinegun Range is prohibited with the following exceptions: 22 23 o Routine maintenance of roads, ditches, culverts and activities listed in A-1.4 of the PMP 24 (maintenance of targetry and associated lifting mechanisms, range maintenance activities 25 including removal of practice rounds, vegetation management, compatible natural resource 26 management activities, nuisance wildlife control, drainage maintenance, wetland 27 delineation, grassland management, scientific research and sampling activities); 28 o Ground surface repairs by authorized range personnel in support of authorized range 29 activities; and 30 o Digging along target array areas by authorized range personnel to a depth of 1 foot below 31 ground surface (bgs). 32 33 This shall also include evaluation of required range signage. The range is required to be marked 34 with signage in conformance with the requirements of the current Department of Army regulations. 35 • Evaluation of groundwater activities to ensure that any groundwater activities are being conducted 36 in a manner consistent with established LUCs. Groundwater use or extraction of groundwater 37 located at or underlying the WBG AOC or any portion thereof is prohibited, except for the following: 38 39 1. The installation, development, purging, and sampling of new or existing monitoring wells 40 in accordance with the most recent Facility-Wide Sampling and Analysis Plan (FWSAP) as 41 part of the AOC-specific Installation Restoration Program (IRP) or Facility-Wide Ground 42 Water Monitoring Program Plan (FWGWMPP). 43 2. The abandonment and replacement of monitoring wells damaged by activities conducted on 44 Camp Ravenna and wells no longer utilized as part of IRP or FWGWMPP activities, in 45 accordance with Ohio Environmental Protection Agency (Ohio EPA) guidance, the most 46 recent FWSAP, and applicable Ohio Administrative Code requirements. 47 48 LUC deficiencies or inconsistent land uses that are identified must be reported and identified on the quarterly 49 inspection form/report. These deficiencies must also be reported immediately to the Army, along with 50 suggestions on how to remedy the deficiencies. 51 52 53

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

\\BUFFALONAS\ContractFiles\Technical\VISTA_Reports\LUC_Reports\FY2015_LUC_Reports\3rd_Quarter_FY2015\Draft\Draft_Q3_FY2015_WBG_LUC.docx Page 2

54 Review of LUCs – Management/Effectiveness/Corrective Action 1. AOC Map Is the AOC map current with respect to AOC boundaries, land activities, and prescribed LUCs?

The AOC map was reviewed on May 28, 2015 by Don Trocchio, Professional Surveyor (PS), and it is current with respect to AOC boundaries, land activities and prescribed LUCs.

2. Camp Ravenna Perimeter Fence Is the Camp Ravenna perimeter fence and associated gates being maintained in order to be an effective and protective control and deter trespassers?

The perimeter fence is currently being maintained by OHARNG staff to ensure it is an effective and protective land use control. In FY 2014, over 4500’ of the perimeter fence at the west end of the facility was replaced and/or had barbed wire repairs completed. Also in FY 2014, a large section of fence (posts and fabric) on the northern perimeter from the Trumbull/Portage County line west to just west of former Post 34 was replaced. As observed during the FY 2015 3rd quarter inspection, the fence has been repaired at 8 locations since the previous quarterly inspection in February/March 2015. These locations are NW10A, NW12, NE31, NE34, NE35, SW6B, SW18 and SW22A. Attachment 1, Figure 1 Index Map and Summary Table, and associated Detail Sheets present the damaged fence areas and photographs of repaired areas.

3. Activities and Land Use a.) This AOC is restricted from residential land use. Has residential use occurred? Have other land

use changes occurred?

Based on an interview with OHARNG Range Control Staff (Master Sergeant [MSG] Rex Hufenbach) on June 11, 2015 at the OHARNG Headquarters Building, no residential land use has occurred. Additionally, there has been no change in land use at the AOC since the previous inspection.

b.) What activities have occurred at WBG since the last inspection?

The WBG/MK19 Range has been utilized for training purposes (i.e., MK19 Range firing/activities) since the last inspection. Additionally, mowing has occurred since the previous inspection. All activities are in accordance with designated LUCs/restrictions.

c.) Are activities (digging, range maintenance etc.) at WBG being conducted in compliance with OHARNG range safety regulations/SOP and established digging restrictions?

Based on an interview with MSG Rex Hufenbach on June 11, 2015, all activities within WBG are being conducted in compliance with OHARNG Range Safety Regulations/SOP and established digging restrictions. All activities are in accordance with those set forth in the PMP.

d.) Is the required range signage in place and functional? The range is required to be marked with signage in conformance with the requirements of the current Department of Army regulations. If not, describe what corrective actions will be undertaken?

MSG Rex Hufenbach stated all signage is placed at 200-meter intervals and found to be upright and intact and in conformance with Army regulations. Annual repairs for signage along the surface danger zone perimeter were conducted in May 2015.

e.) Groundwater: Groundwater use or extraction of groundwater located at or underlying the WBG AOC or any portion thereof is prohibited, except for the following:

1. The installation, development, purging, and sampling of new or existing monitoring wells in accordance with the most recent FWSAP as part of the AOC-specific IRP or FWGWMPP.

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

\\BUFFALONAS\ContractFiles\Technical\VISTA_Reports\LUC_Reports\FY2015_LUC_Reports\3rd_Quarter_FY2015\Draft\Draft_Q3_FY2015_WBG_LUC.docx Page 3

2. The abandonment and replacement of monitoring wells damaged by Installation activities, and wells no longer utilized as part of IRP or FWGWMPP activities, in accordance with Ohio EPA guidance, the most recent FWSAP and applicable Ohio Administrative Code requirements.

f.) Have any groundwater activities been conducted and, if yes, are they within the established control

parameters?

Facility-wide Ground Water Monitoring Well sampling is conducted by Environmental Quality Management, Inc. (EQM) on a semi-annual basis in this area. During an interview on June 15, 2015 with Mr. Scott Spesshardt of EQM, he stated that all Ground Water Monitoring activity is conducted in accordance with the FWGWMPP and the parameters for groundwater monitoring as set forth in the PMP, Appendix A-1. A facility-wide groundwater sampling event took place in March 2015. The next FWGWMPP sampling event is currently scheduled for July 2015.

4. Inspections and Reporting a.) Inspections are required on a quarterly basis. Are quarterly inspections being completed?

Quarterly Inspections have been completed for FY 2013 and FY 2014. This is the third Quarterly Inspection to be conducted for FY 2015. All Quarterly Inspections for FY 2013, FY 2014 and FY 2015 were conducted in accordance with the approved PMP dated August 2012.

b.) An annual report is required. Has the annual report been completed and submitted?

The Final FY 2014 Annual Report was submitted on January 12, 2015 and approved on March 17, 2015.

5. Training (as applicable to WBG) a.) Was LUC training (specific to WBG) being conducted as applicable? Describe the training

(content/who attended/who provided/documentation of training).

LUC training is provided annually to all Camp Ravenna staff and tenant units at Camp Ravenna. The LUC training is typically provided by Katie Tait and/or Tim Morgan, Camp Ravenna-Environmental. The training provides an overview of the history of the facility, the ongoing cleanup work, the location of the cleanup sites, any land use controls/restrictions on AOCs/Munitions Response Sites (MRS), and specific restrictions for WBG. Using units also receive an in-brief prior to firing on the range. Using units and tenant units at Camp Ravenna are not allowed down range. Environmental contractors who access WBG are also provided with an in-brief which informs them of the LUCs/restrictions at the AOC. They must read and sign the in-brief form. Training materials and rosters are on file in the Camp Ravenna Environmental Office. LUC training specific to WBG was held on March 3rd and 5th, 2015 for Camp Ravenna units/staff. US Army Corps of Engineer personnel received the LUC briefing on June 2, 2015 prior to accessing the southern portions of the Winklepeck Burning Grounds AOC to conduct their MEC probability assessment for the adjacent Open Demolition Area # 2 MRS. Training will be conducted for additional Camp Ravenna staff and contractors that missed the March training dates as needed.

b.) If training was not provided, explain why and what corrective actions were initiated? N/A

55 56 57

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

\\BUFFALONAS\ContractFiles\Technical\VISTA_Reports\LUC_Reports\FY2015_LUC_Reports\3rd_Quarter_FY2015\Draft\Draft_Q3_FY2015_WBG_LUC.docx Page 4

58 6. Description of any observed/noted LUC violation(s): The Camp Ravenna perimeter fence has 5 missing sections/openings/holes in the fence fabric and areas that are in disrepair as documented in this report. These areas have been assigned the following call-out numbers: NW1B, NW13, NE32, NE36 and NE37. See Attachment 1 – Figure 1 Index Map to Facility Perimeter Fence Inspection and attached Detail Sheets.

7. Date of Notification of LUC violation (if applicable): The Army was notified via e-mail on June 3, 4 and 8, 2015 of four new fence defects discovered during the 3rd Quarter FY 2015 facility perimeter fence evaluation. These locations are NW13, NW1B, NW36 and NW37 (See Attachment 1, Figure 1 Index Map and Summary Table, and associated detail sheets).

8. Description of any corrective actions taken to remedy observed LUC violation(s) or recommended corrective actions: As observed during the third quarter LUC inspection, the following perimeter fence defects were repaired: NE31, NE34, NE35, SW6B, SW18, SW22A, NW10A and NW12.

Attachment 1 – Figure 1 Index Map to Facility Perimeter Fence Inspections shows previous fence deficiencies that have been repaired and/or reported since the last inspection.

These efforts of the OHARNG staff to repair the identified deficiencies in the fence have improved the condition of the fence since the last inspection.

9. Additional Notes/Comments:

As requested by the Ohio EPA, WBG photographs taken during the LUC Inspection are included with this report (Attachment 2, Supplemental Detail Sheet No. 1).

59 Original Inspection Completed by:

Signature:

Printed Name: Don Trocchio

Title: Professional Surveyor Organization: Vista Sciences Corporation

Date: June 23, 2015 60

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center Former Ravenna Army Ammunition Plant

FY 2015 Third Quarter Land Use Control Inspection

RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds

ATTACHMENT 1

Figure 1 Index Map

FY 2015 Callout/Repair Summary Table

Detailed Quadrant Maps

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

Figure 1 Index Map

S W 1S E2

PORTAGE CO.TRUMBULL CO.

S W 12

S E4

S W 14 S E5S W 15

S W 16

S W 17,19

S W 20

S W 21

S W 6B, S W 22A

NE30

S ee S upplementa lDeta il S heet No.1

NW 11

NE31

NE15A

NE33

S ee Deta il a t Left

NE35NE34

NE32

S W 18

NW 13

NW 10A

NE36

NE37

Gree

nleaf

Road

Gree

nleaf

Road

Perimeter Road

Perimeter Road

Charlestown RoadCharlestown Road

Road

5DRo

ad 5D

Road

4BRo

ad 4B

South Service Road

South Service Road

Road 5CRoad 5C

Road 2CRoad 2C

Road

2DRo

ad 2D

Newton Falls RoadNewton Falls Road

George RoadGeorge Road

Road

7BRo

ad 7B

Smalley Road (C.H. 228)Smalley Road (C.H. 228)

Road

1ERo

ad 1E

State

Rou

te 80

Free

dom

Road

State

Rou

te 80

Free

dom

Road

Wink

lepec

k Roa

dWi

nklep

eck R

oad

Road

1BRo

ad 1B

South C Road

South C Road

Perimeter Road

Perimeter RoadPerimeter RoadPerimeter Road

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road

Newton Falls RoadNewton Falls Road

Road

7BRo

ad 7B

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luther K ing Jr. Pla ceLouisville, K Y 40202

Projection Da tum is NAD83, Ohio S ta tePla ne R ecta ngula r Grid, North Z one

Produced in June 2015 for:

NW

SW SE

NE

FIGURE 1 INDEX MAP

W BG R VAAP-05

LegendLUC Inspection of Perimeter Fence

Perimeter Fence Eva lua ted (29.8 miles)

Opening in fence (2'≥) a nd/or fa bric missing/da ma ged (4 loca tions)R epa ired in FY 2015 (25 Loca tions T ota l)Ga tes (26 loca tions for reference only, no deta il sheets)All ga tes a ppea r to be ma inta ined a nd a re in working order Ba r S ca le in Feet

0 5,000 10,000 15,0002,500 Feet

=W inklepeck Burning Grounds

Perimeter Fence Eva lua ted

W INK LEPECK BU R NING GR OU NDS (W BG) R VAAP-05 LAND U S E CONT R OL (LU C) INS PECT ION 3rd Qtr. FY 2015

Porta ge & T rumbull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

Ohio

*

S W 1

S W 24

S W 24

Deta il

Deta il S heetR epa ir in ProgressCa llout

Deta il S heetCa llout

Deta il S heetR epa ir Ca llout

R epa ir in progress (1 loca tion)

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

NW 1B

NW 12 & NW 1B Deta il

NW 12NW 12

NW 1B

FIGURE 1 INDEX MAP TO FACILITY PERIMETER FENCE INSPECTIONSEE ATTACHED SUMMARY TABLE AND DETAIL SHEETS FOR EACH

DESIGNATED CALLOUT LOCATION

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

FY 2015 Callout/Repair Summary Table

Northing EastingNW1B 6/3/2015 repeat poacher hole (3) 571637 2356382NW13 6/2/2015 poacher hole 570866 2353636

NE32 3/30/2015 12in tree has fallen on to the fence 563254 2384389NE36 6/4/2015 poacher hole 572329 2379236NE37 6/4/2015 poacher hole 572335 2380333

NE30 7/21/2014 poacher hole 571083 2382464

SE04 11/25/2013 washout logged as type 2 on 2-27-14 0271 photo 558980 2377933SE05 04/22/2014 washout below undamaged fence 550299 2358851

SW14 4/14/2014 poacher hole in fence 549386 2334237SW15 7/15/2014 tree blow down 549438 2339580SW16 7/15/2014 tree blow down/damaged fence 554267 2328362SW17 7/15/2014 tree blow down/fence top damaged 556228 2328345SW19 7/15/2014 tree blow down/top fence damaged 556581 2328342SW20 7/15/2014 hole in bottom of fence below sign 559398 2330974SW21 7/15/2014 hole at bottom of fence 559659 2331945SW22 7/16/2014 poacher hole 560762 2335683

NW11 11/26/2014 old abandoned rr utility pole leaning over top of fence 564883 2343968

NE15A 12/15/2014 poacher hole (repeat) 563240 2383872NE33 12/15/2014 8in tree has fallen on to the fence 563257 2384533

SE02 12/16/2014 washout 551498 2361141

SW12 11/18/2013 storm washout about 2 sections inlet needs cleared 552357 2330086SW24 11/20/2014 poacher hole 549402 2336086

NE31 3/18/2015 utility pole fallen on top of fence 572684 2363973NE34 3/19/2015 poacher hole 573073 2366913NE35 3/19/2015 repeat poacher hole of undocumented repair 572916 2365711

SW6B 3/17/2015 poacher hole in fence (repeat) 560708 2335572SW18 7/15/2014 hole under fence at culvert outlet 556241 2328345SW22A 3/17/2015 repeat poacher hole 560762 2335683

NW10A 3/18/2015 repeat cut poacher hole in new fence 571046 2354186NW12 3/19/2015 poacher hole 571617 2356355

REPAIRED 1ST QTR REPAIRED 2ND QTR REPAIRED 3RD QTR

FY 2015 3rd QUARTER CALLOUT/REPAIR SUMMARY TABLE

US Survey Ft

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center 3rd Qtr FY2015 LUC Inspection

Callout Date Comments

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

NE (Northeast) Quadrant

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road

Wads

worth

Roa

dWa

dswo

rth R

oad

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luther King Jr. Pla ceLouisville, KY 40202

0 600 1,200 1,800300 Feet

Ba r Sca le in Feet

Projection Da tum is NAD83, O hio Sta tePla ne Recta ng ula r Grid , North Z one

O hio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE31

PHOTO NE31 discovered 12/03/2014

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE31

LAND USE CO NTRO L (LUC) INSPECTIO N 3rd QUARTER FY 2015PERIMETER FENCE INSPECTIO N

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta g e & Trum b ull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

NE31

REPAIRCALLO UT

LegendO pening in fence (2'≥) a nd /or fa b ric m issing /d a m a g edRepa ired Perim eter Fence Eva lua ted

Prod uced in June 2015 for:

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

REPAIR PHOTO NE31 dated 06/03/2015

NE1

McKibben RoadMcKibben Road

Perim

eter R

oad

Perim

eter R

oad Smallsreed Road

Smallsreed Road

McKibben RoadMcKibben Road

McKibben RoadMcKibben Road

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luther King Jr. Pla ceLouisville, KY 40202

0 600 1,200 1,800300 Feet

Ba r Sca le in Feet

Projection Da tum is NAD83, O hio Sta tePla ne Recta ng ula r Grid , North Z one

Prod uced in June 2015 for:O hio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE32

PHOTO NE32 discovered 12/15/2014

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE32

LAND USE CO NTRO L (LUC) INSPECTIO N 3rd QUARTER FY 2015PERIMETER FENCE INSPECTIO N

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta g e & Trum b ull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National GuardButts Kistler Rd .

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

NE32

NE33

NE15A

REPAIRCALLO UT

LegendO pening in fence (2'≥) a nd /or fa b ric m issing /d a m a g edRepa ired Perim eter Fence Eva lua ted

REPAIR INPRO GRESS

PHOTO NE32 dated 06/08/2015 showing partial repair

NE10

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road

Paris

Wind

ham

Road

Paris

Wind

ham

Road

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luther King Jr. Pla ceLouisville, KY 40202

0 500 1,000 1,500250 Feet

Ba r Sca le in Feet

Projection Da tum is NAD83, O hio Sta tePla ne Recta ng ula r Grid , North Z one

Prod uced in June 2015 for:O hio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE34

PHOTO NE34 discovered 03/19/2015

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE34

NE31

LAND USE CO NTRO L (LUC) INSPECTIO N 3rd QUARTER FY 2015PERIMETER FENCE INSPECTIO N

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta g e & Trum b ull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

REPAIRCALLO UT

LegendO pening in fence (2'≥) a nd /or fa b ric m issingRepa ired Perim eter Fence Eva lua ted

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

NE35

NE34

REPAIR PHOTO NE34 dated 06/03/2015

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road

Paris

Wind

ham

Road

Paris

Wind

ham

Road

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luther King Jr. Pla ceLouisville, KY 40202

0 500 1,000 1,500250 Feet

Ba r Sca le in Feet

Projection Da tum is NAD83, O hio Sta tePla ne Recta ng ula r Grid , North Z one

Prod uced in June 2015 for:O hio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE35

PHOTO NE35 discovered 03/19/2015

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE35

NE31

LAND USE CO NTRO L (LUC) INSPECTIO N 3rd QUARTER FY 2015PERIMETER FENCE INSPECTIO N

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta g e & Trum b ull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

REPAIRCALLO UT

LegendO pening in fence (2'≥) a nd /or fa b ric m issingRepa ired Perim eter Fence Eva lua ted

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

NE35

NE34

REPAIR PHOTO NE35 dated 06/03/2015

Perim

eter R

oad

Perim

eter R

oad

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luthe r King Jr. Pla c eLouis ville , KY 40202

0 500 1,000 1,500250 Fe e t

Ba r Sc a le in Fe e t

Proje c tion Da tum is N AD83, Ohio Sta tePla ne Re c ta ngula r Grid, N orth Z one

Ohio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE36

PHOTO NE36 discovered 06/04/2015

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE36

LAN D U SE CON TROL (LU C) IN SPECTION 3rd QU ARTER FY 2015PERIMETER FEN CE IN SPECTION

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta ge & Trum bull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

Erie Burning Grounds

Group 7

Porta ge Co. Trum bull Co.

Porta ge Co. Trum bull Co.

U .S.A. Gove rnm e nt owne d prope rty this s ide a ls o

N E30

REPAIRCALLOU T

LegendOpe ning in fe nc e (2'≥) a nd/or fa bric m is s ingRe pa ire d Pe rim e te r Fe nc e Eva lua te d

Produc e d in June 2015 for:

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

N E36 N E37

Perim

eter R

oad

Perim

eter R

oad

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luthe r King Jr. Pla c eLouis ville , KY 40202

0 500 1,000 1,500250 Fe e t

Ba r Sc a le in Fe e t

Proje c tion Da tum is N AD83, Ohio Sta tePla ne Re c ta ngula r Grid, N orth Z one

Ohio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE37

PHOTO NE37 discovered 06/04/2015

DETAIL SHEET FOR NE37

LAN D U SE CON TROL (LU C) IN SPECTION 3rd QU ARTER FY 2015PERIMETER FEN CE IN SPECTION

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta ge & Trum bull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

Erie Burning Grounds

Group 7

Porta ge Co. Trum bull Co.

Porta ge Co. Trum bull Co.

U .S.A. Gove rnm e nt owne d prope rty this s ide a ls o

N E30

REPAIRCALLOU T

LegendOpe ning in fe nc e (2'≥) a nd/or fa bric m is s ingRe pa ire d Pe rim e te r Fe nc e Eva lua te d

Produc e d in June 2015 for:

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

N E36 N E37

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

NW (Northwest) Quadrant

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road

Wadsworth RoadWadsworth Road

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luthe r King Jr. Pla c eLouisville , KY 40202

0 500 1,000 1,500250 Fe e t

Ba r Sc a le in Fe e t

Proje c tion Da tum is NAD83, O hio Sta tePla ne Re c ta ngula r Grid, North Z one

Produc e d in June 2015 for:O hio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR NW1BDETAIL SHEET FOR NW1B

LAND USE CO NTRO L (LUC) INSPECTIO N 3rd QUARTER FY 2015PERIMETER FENCE INSPECTIO N

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta ge & Trum bull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

REPAIRCALLO UT

LegendO pe ning in fe nc e (2'≥) a nd/or fa bric m issingRe pa ire d Pe rim e te r Fe nc e Eva lua te d

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

Se e De ta il Inse t Above

NW 1B

NW 12De ta il NW 12 & NW 1B

PHOTO NW1B dated 06/03/2015

Note : NW 1B wa s re porte d re pa ire d shortly a fte r thethe 2nd qtr inspe c tion (wa s NW 1A). The re pa ir wa sa ppa re ntly de stroye d soon the re a fte r a s shown be lowin photo.

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road

George RoadGeorge Road

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luthe r King Jr. Pla c eLouis ville , KY 40202

0 600 1,200 1,800300 Fe e t

Ba r Sc a le in Fe e t

Proje c tion Da tum is NAD83, O hio Sta tePla ne Re c ta ngula r Grid, North Z one

Produc e d in June 2015 for:O hio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR NW10A

PHOTO NW10A discovered 03/18/2015

DETAIL SHEET FOR NW10A

NW 10A

LAND USE CO NTRO L (LUC) INSPECTIO N 3rd QUARTER FY 2015PERIMETER FENCE INSPECTIO N

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta ge & Trum bull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

REPAIRCALLO UT

LegendO pe ning in fe nc e (2'≥) a nd/or fa bric m is s ingRe pa ire d Pe rim e te r Fe nc e Eva lua te d

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

NW 13

REPAIR PHOTO NW10A dated 06/02/2015

NW 12NW 1B

NW 1

NW 3

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road

Wadsworth RoadWadsworth Road

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luthe r King Jr. Pla c eLouis ville , KY 40202

0 500 1,000 1,500250 Fe e t

Ba r Sc a le in Fe e t

Proje c tion Da tum is NAD83, O hio Sta tePla ne Re c ta ngula r Grid, North Z one

Produc e d in June 2015 for:O hio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR NW12

PHOTO NW12 discovered 03/19/2015

DETAIL SHEET FOR NW12

LAND USE CO NTRO L (LUC) INSPECTIO N 3rd QUARTER FY 2015PERIMETER FENCE INSPECTIO N

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta ge & Trum bull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

REPAIRCALLO UT

LegendO pe ning in fe nc e (2'≥) a nd/or fa bric m is s ingRe pa ire d Pe rim e te r Fe nc e Eva lua te d

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

Se e De ta il Ins e t Above

NW 1BNW 12De ta il NW 12 & NW 1B

REPAIR PHOTO NW12 dated 06/03/2015

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road

George RoadGeorge Road

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Ma rtin Luthe r King Jr. Pla c eLouis ville , KY 40202

0 600 1,200 1,800300 Fe e t

Ba r Sc a le in Fe e t

Proje c tion Da tum is NAD83, O hio Sta tePla ne Re c ta ngula r Grid, North Z one

Produc e d in June 2015 for:O hio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR NW13

PHOTO NW13 discovered 06/02/2015

DETAIL SHEET FOR NW13

NW 10A

LAND USE CO NTRO L (LUC) INSPECTIO N 3rd QUARTER FY 2015PERIMETER FENCE INSPECTIO N

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta ge & Trum bull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

REPAIRCALLO UT

LegendO pe ning in fe nc e (2'≥) a nd/or fa bric m is s ingRe pa ire d Pe rim e te r Fe nc e Eva lua te d

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

NW 13

NW 12

NW 1B

NW 1

NW 3

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

SE (Southeast) Quadrant

(No Detail Sheets for FY 2015 3rd Quarter LUC Inspection Report)

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

SW (Southwest) Quadrant

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road Bundling Road

Bundling Road

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Martin L uther King Jr. Plac eL o uisville, KY 40202

0 400 800 1,200200 Feet

Bar S c ale in Feet

Pro jec tio n Datum is N AD83, Ohio S tatePlane Rec tangular Grid, N o rth Z o ne

Ohio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR SW6B

PHOTO SW6B discovered 03/17/2015

DETAIL SHEET FOR SW6B

L AN D U S E CON T ROL (L U C) IN S PECT ION 3rd QU ART ER FY2015PERIMET ER FEN CE IN S PECT ION

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Po rtage & T rum b ull Co untyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

S W 6B

S W 22A

N o te: T he Callo ut "6B" indic ates this lo c atio n isthe 3rd rep eat; 22A is the 2nd rep eat.

REPAIRCAL L OU T

LegendOp ening in fenc e (2'≥) and/o r fab ric m issingRep aired Perim eter Fenc e Evaluated

Pro duc ed in June 2015 fo r:

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

REPAIR PHOTO SW6B dated 06/01/2015

S W 9

Road

2ARo

ad 2A

Road

3ARo

ad 3A

Road

1ARo

ad 1A

Perim

eter R

oad

Perim

eter R

oad

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. M a rtin Luther King Jr. Pla c eLouisville, KY 40202

0 400 800 1,200200 Feet

Ba r Sc a le in Feet

Projec tion Da tum is NAD83, Ohio Sta tePla ne Rec ta ngula r Grid , North Zone

Ohio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR SW18

PHOTO SW18 discovered 07/15/2014

DETAIL SHEET FOR SW18

LAND U SE CONT ROL (LU C) INSPECT ION 3rd QU ART ER FY 2015PERIM ET ER FENCE INSPECT ION

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Porta ge & T rum bull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

SW 19

SW 18

SW 17SW 17

Inset Deta il

SW 17 & SW 18

Prod uc ed in June 2015 for:

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

SW 18

REPAIR PHOTO SW18 dated 06/01/2015

REPAIRCALLOU T

LegendOp ening in fenc e (2'≥) a nd /or fa bric m issingRep a ired Perim eter Fenc e Eva lua ted

BEER

Y RD.

Perimeter RoadPerimeter Road Bundling Road

Bundling Road

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Martin L uther King Jr. Plac eL o uisville, KY 40202

0 400 800 1,200200 Feet

Bar S c ale in Feet

Pro jec tio n Datum is N AD83, Ohio S tatePlane Rec tangular Grid, N o rth Z o ne

Ohio

*

DETAIL SHEET FOR SW22A

PHOTO SW22A discovered 03/17/2015

DETAIL SHEET FOR SW22A

L AN D U S E CON T ROL (L U C) IN S PECT ION 3rd QU ART ER FY2015PERIMET ER FEN CE IN S PECT ION

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Po rtage & T rum b ull Co untyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

S W 06B

S W 22A

REPAIRCAL L OU T

LegendOp ening in fenc e (2'≥) and/o r fab ric m issingRep aired Perim eter Fenc e Evaluated

Pro duc ed in June 2015 fo r:

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

N o te: T he Callo ut "6B" indic ates this lo c atio n isthe 3rd rep eat; 22A is the 2nd rep eat.

REPAIR PHOTO SW22A dated 06/01/2015

S W 9

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center Former Ravenna Army Ammunition Plant

Quarterly Land Use Control Inspection

RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds

ATTACHMENT 2

Supplemental Detail Sheet No. 1

Draft FY2015 3rd Quarter Land Use Control Inspection RVAAP-05 Winklepeck Burning Grounds Camp Ravenna, Ohio

Supplemental Detail Sheet No. 1

Palle

t Roa

d A W

est

Palle

t Roa

d A W

est

Palle

t Roa

d B W

est

Palle

t Roa

d B W

est

Palle

t Roa

d E W

est

Palle

t Roa

d E W

est

Palle

t Roa

d B E

ast

Palle

t Roa

d B E

ast

Palle

t Roa

d C E

ast

Palle

t Roa

d C E

ast

Palle

t Roa

d D E

ast

Palle

t Roa

d D E

ast

Palle

t Roa

d C W

est

Palle

t Roa

d C W

est

Palle

t Roa

d E Ea

stPa

llet R

oad E

East

Palle

t Roa

d D W

est

Palle

t Roa

d D W

est

George RoadGeorge Road

Greenleaf Road

Greenleaf Road

George RoadGeorge Road

Sand

Creek

Louisville District

US Army Corps ofEngineers

600 Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. PlaceLouisville, KY 40202

0 690 1,380 2,070345 Feet

Bar Scale in Feet

Projection Datum is NAD83, Ohio StatePlane Rectangular Grid, North Zone

Ohio

*

SUPPLEMENTAL DETAIL SHEET NO.1SUPPLEMENTAL DETAIL SHEET NO.1

Camp Ravenna Joint Military Training Center

Portage & Trumbull CountyLOCATOR MAP

Ohio Army National Guard

Photo No.1looking west

LAND USE CONTROL (LUC) INSPECTION PERIMETER FENCE INSPECTION

3rd QUARTER FY2015Photo No.2looking east

Photo No.3looking west

Photo No.4looking east

=Winklepeck Burning Grounds

Perimeter Fence Evaluated

Mar

k 19

Ran

ge

Win

klep

eck

Bur

ning

Gro

unds

(WB

G)

WINKLEPECK BURNING GROUNDS (RVAAP-05)PHOTO IMAGES WITHIN THE

Produced in June 2015 for:

Camp Ravenna JMTC1438 State Route 534 SWNewton Falls, OH 44444

Don Trocchio, [email protected] 17T NF01946150 (NAD83)

PHOTO No.1 06/10/2015

PHOTO N0.2 06/10/2015 PHOTO N0.4 06/10/2015

PHOTO N0.3 06/10/2015