dual head-up guidance system (hgs) on embraer 190/195
DESCRIPTION
Dual Head-Up Guidance System (HGS) on Embraer 190/195. Courtesy of. Historic Background. Landing Point Designator (Lunar Module). High Level Control of vehicle´s trajectory High Level & Effective Descision Making Input Pilot supported by Computer and Avionics Ideal allocation of tasks: - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 1
Dual Head-Up Guidance System (HGS) on Embraer 190/195
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 2
Courtesy of
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 3
Historic Background
Landing Point Designator (Lunar Module)
High Level Control of vehicle´s trajectory
High Level & Effective Descision Making Input
Pilot supported by Computer and Avionics
Ideal allocation of tasks:
Pilot: Assessing Monitoring Deciding Back-Up for Automation
Machine: Precise Thrust Control Data Computations Warnings and Alerts
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 4
Historic Background
Landing Point Designator (Lunar Module)
Formed the core of man-machine system
Enabled Pilot to remain the active controller
Highest Level of
Man – Machine Integration
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 5
Decision for Dual HGS on the Embraer 190/195 family
Head-Up Display
Formes the core of man-machine system
Enables Pilot to remain the active controller
Higher Level of
Man – Machine Integration
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 6
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Risk Assessment
Will a flight be safer
when using HGS ?
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 7
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Risk Assessment
Autoland HGS
CAT III CAT III
Where did we start with HGS ?What are the risks?
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 8
T/O Taxi
Traffic, WXApproach, Landing, Taxi
Cat IIIa Autoland only usedin approach and for landing
HGS can be used in all phases of flight
Data
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Only approx. 2% of all landings with Autoland
During > 97% of all approaches no Safety Benefits with Autoland
Autoland Systems limited for straight and standard ILS/MLS Approaches
Autoland not capable for PBN/RNP Approaches, (design & certification)
HUD Safety Benefits during 100% of all flights from Takeoff until Landing
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 9
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Design
Σ F = m x a
E = ½ m v²
Precise Energy - Management Indication
Speed Error Tape Flight Path Symbol
Acceleration Caret
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 10
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Design
Instantaneous Indication auf Brake / Autobrake Performance
Immediate Decision Tool
Reduced Risk of Runway Overrun /Excursion
RWY2500LO
MED
HI
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 11
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Data
Improved Touch Down Performance
Improved Landing Footprint
No HGS With HGSCRJ
MUC RWY 08R
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 12
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
AnalysisHead-Up Flight Operations Full Time Providing Greater Situational and Operational Awareness
Superior Precision Control and Energy Management in all Regimes of Flight
Low Visibility Takeoff on Type II and Type III localizers
Category II/III Approaches
Rollout Guidance for AIII mode
Reduced ILS Interference
RNP / GLS / PBN / LPV Approaches
Runway Remaining
Deceleration Rate Index
Tailstrike Advisory
Smoother TCAS Corrective Guidance
No Transition Head-Down to Head –Up at DA(H
Reduce Minima by replacing or supplementing approach and runway lighting
Improved Single Engine Operation in T/O
Weather Avoidance
Superior Steep Turns / Stall Recovery
Flight Path Reference – Visual Approaches
Better Energy Management During Rejected Takeoffs (RTO)
EVS / Synthetic Vision
Intuitive Upset Recovery
A/L Capability
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 13
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Analysis Results
Autoland
HGS
CAT III
CAT III
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 14
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
RisksDo Pilots become HGS criples?
Will they maintain PFD or Head down skills ?
Flying against the sun?
Flying at night ?
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 15
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Analysis
HGS Symbology compatible with PFD
Flight Path Vector Flight Path Angle
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 16
4 HGS Proficiency Levels
Level 1 : Initial IntroductionTunnelling, Fixation, Adaptation (can be reduced using FTD)
Level 2 : Secondary AwarenessPrioritizing the information acquisition (FFS Phase)
Level 3 : A World beyond the combinerIntegration HGS into conformal world and combining other cockpit information
Level 4 : The HUD as another flight Deck Tool / HGS as the Primary Flight Display ReferenceFinal Stage of proficiency, symbology becomes second naturePilot becomes more aware of air mass effect and performance (Aircraft)
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 17
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Analysis Results
RISK = Threat
Defence Measures
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 18
The system is: human(s) + machine
Optimize the system, not the machine
Mindell´s Law*) :
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Analysis Results
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 19
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Analysis ResultsConclusions of Report September 2009
HGS would have likely or highly likely prevented the following percentage of a accidents
– 38% of all the accidents/incidents• 69% of Takeoff and Landing Accidents• 57% of Loss-of-Control Accidents• 33% of Miscellaneous Accidents• 19% of Propulsion Accidents• 3% of Undercarriage related accidents
The most influential individual HGS safety properties were:– Flight Path Vector– Flight Path Acceleration– Speed Error Tape
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 20
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Analysis ResultsWhy are dual HUDs standard on the B 787 Dreamliner ?
• Principal argument: “Standard equipment dual HUDs will save at least one aircraft over the life of the program”
• 90% of customers wanted dual HUDs but Boeing assumed only 10 to 20% would select the option
– Limited “hard” payback on autoland equipped aircraft
– Most airlines have difficulty quantifying safety benefit
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 21
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Analysis ResultsIncreased Situation Awareness for both pilots
Conformal Flight Path Vector with HUD compatible to HDD
Real Time Aircraft Energy Monitoring and improved assessment of deviations
Increased Landing Accuracy (Landing Footprint)
Reduced Risk of Hard Landings / Tailstrike
Visual Indication of Brake Performance and Remaining Runway
Improved Decision Making Tool during Takeoff, Approach and Landing
Intuitive Guidance during abnormal situations, e.g. Unusual Attitude, Engine failure
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 22
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Risk Assessment
Will a flight be safer
when using HGS ?
Yes !
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 23
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Analysis ResultsBoth Pilots need the same level of information
Both pilots need to have the same tools for HGS benefits
Both pilots are active controllers !
Dual Independant HGS Installation
Decision:
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 24
Operational Aspects
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Reduced Minimas with HUD (EU OPS: Lower than CAT I/II minimas)
PBN / RNP Capability - Operational Benefits with EGNOS starting end of 2009
PBN / RNP Takeoff and Go-around
GBAS / LPV approaches evolving
October 2009: FAA CAT I : 1400 ft / DH 150 ft
CAT IIIb Capability (FAA)
All Approaches using the same operational procedures
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 25
Flight Safety and Operational Benefits
Operational Benefits
Will a flight be more
economical with HGS ?
Yes !
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 26
Operating Philosophy
HGS Operation
HGS will be used during all phases of flight
All Approaches will use the same SOPs.
Flight Path - Energy Flying Pitch - Power
Use of an appropriate Level of Automation is a Standard Procedure
Manual Flying while using Autothrottle
Practicing Manual Flying Skills is encouraged ( Pilots to keep proficient with basic flying skills)
First Officers qualified to conduct CAT III Approaches (2011)
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 27
Achievements
HGS Operation
CAT III Operational Approval after 6 weeks of Operation
GPS Approaches - RNP ready
Steep Approach Approval into London City Airport (5,5°) E190 only
All Non Precision Approaches flown as CDA - like an ILS
Flight Path Controlled Landing Technique
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 28
Training Outline & Requirements
Training
Competency-Based Training and Assessment DOC 9868
New setup of Training to include FTD and FFS
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 29
Training Outline & Requirements
Training
JetBlue First Dual HGS Operator on E 190 in 2006
Advanced Training and Qualification Program on A320 and E190
HGS Training from Day 1
CBT Home Study Phase
Use of FTD and FFS
Solution Based Training
Task Allocation
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 30
Training Outline & Requirements
Training
Basic CAT III Training in FTD
System Knowledge using FTD
Integrating HGS Training
Procedure Training
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 31
Training Outline & Requirements
Training
Criterias as per JAR FCL
Elimination of Memory Items and use of QRC
Extended Training for unreliable airspeed and altitude
Flying with STBY Instruments only
Double Engine Failure
CAT III Operation with Single Engine Operation
Emergency Descend with pilot´s incapacitation
Special Training Event without the use of a QRH
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 32
Growth Capability
Future Developements
Enhanced Vision System Synthetic Vision System
Technical Feasibility vs. Economy
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 33
Growth Capability
Future Developements
Takeoff Safety Enhancement:
Thrust = F = m x a
Insufficient Thrust:
Precise Tool for Abort Decision
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 34
Growth Capability
Future Developements
Takeoff and Landing Safety Enhancement:
Remaining Runway Alert
Precise Tool for Landing Abort Decision
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 35
Research
Future Developments
M.I.T Center for Automation, Robotics & Society
MIT International Center for Air Transportation
Evaluation & Verification of Training Programs with
Studies and Future Concepts
Dual HGS on E190/195WATS 28.April 2010Seite 36
The Journey has started
Thank You !