ecogeographical approaches to characterize cwr adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › eucarpia...

27
Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap�ve traits useful for crop adapta�on José M. Iriondo 1 , Mauricio Parra 2 , M. Luisa Rubio 1 , Elena Torres 3 , Rosa García 4 1 Depto. Biología y Geología, Universidad Rey Juan Carlos, Móstoles, Madrid, Spain, 2 FAO. Division on the Intern. Treaty on Plant Gene�c Resources for Food and Agriculture. Rome, Italy 3 Depto. Biología Vegetal, Universidad Politécnica, Madrid, Spain 4 Centro de Recursos Fitogene�cos (CRF), INIA, Alcalá de Henares, Madrid, Spain. Prebreeding – fishing in the gene pool, EUCARPIA Gene�c Resources sec�on mee�ng. June 1013 2013, Alnarp, Sweden

Upload: others

Post on 29-May-2020

5 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Ecogeographical  approaches  to  characterize  CWR  adap�ve  traits  useful  

for  crop  adapta�on    

José  M.  Iriondo1,  Mauricio  Parra2,  M.  Luisa  Rubio1,  Elena  Torres3,  Rosa  García4  1  Depto.  Biología  y  Geología,  Universidad  Rey  Juan  Carlos,  Móstoles,  Madrid,  Spain,    

2  FAO.  Division  on  the  Intern.  Treaty  on  Plant  Gene�c  Resources  for  Food  and  Agriculture.  Rome,  Italy  3    Depto.  Biología  Vegetal,  Universidad  Politécnica,  Madrid,  Spain  

4  Centro  de  Recursos  Fitogene�cos  (CRF),  INIA,  Alcalá  de  Henares,  Madrid,  Spain.    

Pre-­‐breeding  –  fishing  in  the  gene  pool,  EUCARPIA  Gene�c  Resources  sec�on  mee�ng.  June  10-­‐13  2013,  Alnarp,  Sweden      

Page 2: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

European Commission, 2007, ECCP

Crop  adapta�on  and  climate  change  

Page 3: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Environmental  change  

Addi�ve  gene�c  varia�on  

Adap�ve  evolu�on  

  Wild  plants:  – Migra�on  –  Adap�ve  evolu�on  

Moving  phenotypic  op�ma  and  adap�ve  evolu�on  

Page 4: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Moving  phenotypic  op�ma  and  adap�ve  evolu�on  

Gomulkiewicz  &  Holt  (1995)  

  Wild  plants:  –  Adap�ve  evolu�on  

Page 5: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Moving  phenotypic  op�ma  and  adap�ve  evolu�on  

Gomulkiewicz  &  Holt  (1995)  

  Crops:  –  Ar�ficial  selec�on  –  Addi�ve  gene�c  varia�on:  (CWR)  

Page 6: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Need  to  op�mize  search  for  CWR  germplasm  accessions  and  

popula�ons  

   The  most  representa�ve  collec�on  with  the  least  accessions     Popula�on/accessions  most  likely  to  have  the  gene�c  addi�ve  variance  for  the  desired  traits  

Page 7: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Ecogeographical  approach  

G   E   GxE   Trait  

Parra-­‐Quijano,  M.,    Iriondo,  J.M.  y  Torres,  M.E.    A  review  of  applica�ons  of  ecogeography  and  geographic  informa�on  systems  in  plant  gene�c  resources.  Spanish  Journal  of  Agricultural  Research  (2012)  10:419-­‐429.    

Page 8: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Ecogeographical  approach  

   Adap�ve  gene�c  diversity  is  modulated  by  natural  selec�on       Limi�ng  environmental  condi�ons    shape  adap�ve  traits  

   Gene�c  flux     Muta�on     Dri�  

   Epistasis     Dominance  

Genotype  x  Environment  Environment  

Natural    Selec�on  

Addi�ve  gene�c  variance  

Genotype  

Trait  

Page 9: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Ecogeographical  approach  

   Gene�c  flux     Muta�on     Dri�  

   Epistasis     Dominance  

Genotype  x  Environment  Environment  

Natural    Selec�on  

Addi�ve  gene�c  variance  

Genotype  

Trait      Adap�ve  gene�c  diversity  is  modulated  by  natural  selec�on       Limi�ng  environmental  condi�ons    shape  adap�ve  traits  

Page 10: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Temperature,  rainfall,  bioclima�c  indices,  etc.  

Slope,  orienta�on,  eleva�on,  la�tude/longitude,  etc.  

Soil  type,  pH,  salinity,  organic  C,  soil  texture  etc.  

Environmental  factors  that  characterize  the  adap�ve  landscape  

…  over  100  variables  available  from  different  sources  (WorldClim,  FAO,  NOAA,  etc.)  

Ecogeographical  approach  

Page 11: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Ecogeographical  Land  Characteriza�on  Maps  

Genera�on  of  ecogeographical  categories  in  a  territory  

Page 12: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Ecogeographical  Land  Characteriza�on  Maps  

     To  combine  clima�c,  edaphic  and  geographic  data    to  enable  the  predic�on  of  pa�erns  of  adap�ve  gene�c  varia�on  according  to  geographic  origin  (Peeters  et  al.,  1990)  

Parra-­‐Quijano,  M.,  Iriondo,  J.M.,  Torres,  E.  Ecogeographical  land  characteriza�on  maps  as  a  tool  for  assessing  plant  adapta�on  and  their  implica�ons  in  agrobiodiversity  studies.  Gene�c  Resources  and  Crop  Evolu�on  (2012)  59:  205-­‐217  

Page 13: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

  To  obtain  a  complete  ecogeographical  characteriza�on  of  each  germplasm  accession  

  Over  100  ecogeographical  variables  associated  to  each  accession  with  quality  georeferencing  data.  

Ecogeographical  Characteriza�on  of  Germplasm  Collec�ons  

Page 14: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Ecogeographical  Core  Collec�ons     Ecogeographic  core  collec�ons  provide  good  representa�on  of  the  gene�c  diversity  of  the  original  collec�on.     Valida�on  of  ecogeographic  core  collec�ons  using  phenotypic  data  

Ecogeographical  Core  Collec�on  

P  

E  

Phenotypic  Core  Collec�on  REPRESENTATIVENESS  

Page 15: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

ü Phaseolus vulgaris seed collection

ü 15 morphological variables

ü Ecogeographical Core Colections compared to Phenotypic Core Collections and phenotypically assessed

Ecogeographical  Core  Collec�ons  

Page 16: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Phaseolus  vulgaris  Core  Collec�ons  

Ecogeographical  Core  Collec�ons  

Page 17: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

UPGMA-D Coverage WM-P Coverage CEM-P Coverage

Phaseolus  vulgaris  Core  Collec�ons  

Ecogeographical  Core  Collec�ons  

This  was  assesed  with  landraces.  Be�er  results  expected  with  CWRs.  

Page 18: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Iden�fica�on  of  geographic  gaps  

Op�mized  collec�on  of  CWR  germplasm  

   No  characteriza�on  of  CWR  gene�c  diversity.     Efficient  representa�on  of  adap�ve  gene�c  diversity  in  CWRs     Most  representa�ve  collec�on  with  the  fewest  accessions     Ecogeographical  representa�vity  to  adequately  represent  gene�c  diversity  useful  to  breeders  

Page 19: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Identification of ecogeographic gaps

Low  –  null  representa�on  

Op�mized  collec�on  of  CWR  germplasm  

Page 20: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Predic�ve  distribu�on  map  for  Lupinus  species  

Ecogeographic  gaps  in  high  species  richness  areas  

Op�mized  collec�on  of  CWR  germplasm  

Parra-­‐Quijano,  M.,  Iriondo,  J.M.,  Torres,  E.  Improving  representa�veness  of  genebank  collec�ons  through  species  distribu�on  models,  gap  analysis  and  ecogeographical  maps.  Biodiversity  and  Conserva�on  (2012)  21:79–96.    

Page 21: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Prioritized locations for collecting Lupinus species in Spain

Op�mized  collec�on  of  CWR  germplasm  

CRF  Collec�ons  

Page 22: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Focused  Iden�fica�on  Germplasm  Strategies  

   Mackay  (1986,  1990,  1995)     Select  accessions/popula�ons  most  likely  to  have  desired  gene�c  varia�on  for  a  target  trait     Applied  to  tradi�onal  varie�es.  Even  more  appropriate  for  CWR.     Using  ecogeographical  data  for  predic�on  of  phenotypic  traits  before  evalua�on  trials.     FIGS  subsets  ≠ core  collec�ons  

Temperature

Salinity score

Elevation

Rainfall

Agro-climatic zone

Disease distribution

F I G SOCUSED DENTIFICATION OF ERMPLASM TRATEGY

Data layers sieve accessions

based on latitude & longitude

Illustration by Mackay (1995)

GIS  layers  /  

Ecogeographical  variables  

Germplasm  

Filtering  

Page 23: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Selected Brassica CWR populations with De Martonne aridity index values < 10

ELC map for Brassica L. Annual Precipitation map (Bioclim12)

Brassica CWR populations

Beta L., Brassica L. and Lupinus L.

Traits: Tolerance to drought and salinity

Focused  Iden�fica�on  Germplasm  Strategies  

Subset of first 100 Brassica CWR populations with the lowest De Martonne aridity index values

Page 24: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

  Wild populations of L. angustifolius L. from the Iberian Peninsula:

  Semiarid

  Subhumid

  Humid

Common garden

Reciprocal sowing in native localities

De M

aerto

nne a

ridity

categ

ories

Year 2013

Year 2014

Culture cycle for:

Evaluation under different water availability conditions

Seed production  

Reducing maternal effects  

Focused  Iden�fica�on  Germplasm  Strategies  

Page 25: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

If  we  are  able  to  map  the  different  adap�ve  scenarios  for  the  target  species,  we  can:  

§   Carry  out  efficient  germplasm  collec�ons  

§   Create  ecogeographical          core  collec�ons  (ex  situ    or  in  situ)  

§   Complement  genotypic/phenotypic        characteriza�on  

§   Determine  op�mal  places  to          mul�ply/regenerate  germplasm  

Conclusion  

§   Iden�fy  popula�ons/accessions  most  likely  to          have  the  desired  traits  

Page 26: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

  CAPFITOGEN:  Workshops  for  strengthening  the  capacita�on  of  na�onal  programs  of  plant  gene�c  resources  in  La�n  America  –  Interna�onal  Treaty  PGRFA  (h�p://www.plan�reaty.org/es/capfitogen)  –  ELC  Mapas:  Ecogeographical  Land  Characteriza�on  Maps  –  GEOQUAL:  Assessment  of  quality  of  georreferencing  informa�on    –  Representa:  Analysis  of  ecogeographical  representa�veness    –  ECOGEO:  Ecogeographic  characteriza�on  of  germplasm  –  ColNucleo:  Genera�on  of  Ecogeographic  Core  Collec�ons  –  DIVmapas  :  Maps  of  high  ecogeographical,  phenotypic,  gene�c  diversity  areas  –  FIGS_R:    Selec�on  of  germplasm  through  the  applica�on  of  abio�c  filters  

  Available  for  analysis  of  whole  European    territory  and  34  European  countries  –  On  demand:  [email protected],  [email protected]  –  Shortly  as  tools  in  the  “cloud”  available  through  internet  

On-­‐coming  ecogeographic  tools  

Page 27: Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap ve traits … › ngdoc › nordgen › Eucarpia › oral... · 2013-06-18 · Ecogeographical approaches to characterize CWR adap

Thank  you!