economic transformation and poverty reduction

138

Upload: others

Post on 11-Sep-2021

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction
Page 2: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

书书书

!"#$#%&" '()$*+#(%),&#$)$-

.#/0(,1 20-3",&#$4

5#6&,7)880$0-&$97&$):70;8&$< &,

7)880$&$=+(&")

>#;3%0 ?$04

@)&$A&$-&$<*)$-.#;&"1 B%8;&"),&#$*

97&$)CD=9E,3-1 F(#38

Page 3: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!!78,09&5"960$%%+9,0&0.,02$00,"(0+6+0&9,&0":,(6&9(+6,"(+#2"(:&9&(2&0"9/+(,0&. ;3 68&<8,(+=>?<@6$.3

A9"$5 .$9,(/ "##$=%%&

78&0&2"(:&9&(2&0:"06&9&. +( &B28+(/&":&B5&9,&(2&0+(. 59"%"6&. #&+9(,(/ "( ,%5"96+(66"5,209&#+6&. 6"

59"%"6,(/ /9"C68 +(. 9&.$2,(/ 5"D&963E(+%&#3)>&D&#"5%&(61+96(&908,50F?/9,2$#6$9&EG$9+#>&D&#"5%&(6+(.

-"". @&2$9,63F4(:9+069$26$9&F+(. 68&H(+;#,(/ H(D,9"(%&(6:"9H(6&959,0&>&D&#"5%&(6&78&%+,( #&00"(0.9+C(

:9"%68&0&.,02$00,"(0C&9&0$;0&I$&(6#3 59&0&(6&. +(. .,02$00&. +6+5"#,23 03%5"0,$%,( J&,K,(/&

>$9,(/ 68&0&&D&(60E68&.,+#"/$&+%"(/ 5+96,2,5+(60:9"%<8,(+E?:9,2+( 2"$(69,&0+(. ,(06,6$6,"(0+(. 68&."("9

2"%%$(,63 :"2$0&. "( 6C" 68&%&0)

,&<8,(+L0&B5&9,&(2&":&2"("%,2/9"C68 +(. 5"D&963 9&.$26,"(E,(2#$.,(/ 68&2"(69,;$6,"( ":,(6&9(+6,"(+#

+00,06+(2&E+(. ,609&#&D+(2&:"9"68&9.&D&#"5,(/ 2"$(69,&0E5+96,2$#+9#3 ,( ?:9,2+&

,,&<8,(+L0&2"("%,22" "5&9+6,"( C,68 ?:9,2++(. 68&#&00"(068+6<8,(++(. >?<*&%;&902+( 08+9&C,68 &+28

"68&96" ,(29&+0&68&2"##&26,D&,%5+26"::"9&,/( +,. "( 9&.$2,(/ 5"D&963 ,( ?:9,2+&

78&<8,(+>?<@6$.3 A9"$5 ,02"=28+,9&. ;3 68&4(6&9(+6,"(+#1"D&963 G&.$26,"( <&(69&,( <8,(+M41G<<N+(.

68&'H<>L0>&D&#"5%&(6?00,06+(2&<"%%,66&&M>?<N&-$968&9,(:"9%+6,"( "( 68&@6$.3 A9"$5 +(. ,60+26,D,6,&0,0

+D+,#+;#&"( 68&4(6&9(&6+6)!!!&"#$%%&&$' &$!!!&&(%)&&$'*)+%*%),'

!

OH2"("%,279+(0:"9%+6,"( +(. 1"D&963 G&.$26,"()P"C,68+55&(&. ,( <8,(+E8&#5,(/ ,68+55&( ,( ?:9,2+O

Page 4: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

A#(06#(-

!"#$#%&" '()$*+#(%),&#$)$-.#/0(,1 20-3",&#$4

5#6&,5)880$0-&$97&$):50;8&$< &,5)880$&$=+(&")

A#(06#(-"#C*&<$0-G1 H70$< I0$J)&)$-K(&)$=,6##-

'D&968&#+06'# 3&+90E<8,(+8+0$(.&9/"(&+59":"$(. &2"("%,269+(0:"9%+6,"( +(. #,:6&. 8$(.9&.0

":%,##,"(0":5&"5#&:9"%5"D&963&78,059"2&008+09&08+5&. 68&/#";+#&2"("%3 +(. 28+(/&. 68&

&2"("%,22"(6&B6:"9(+6,"(0+(. 5&"5#&+##+9"$(. 68&C"9#.&

78,09&5"96;3 68&<8,(+=>?<@6$.3 A9"$5 /+68&906"/&68&968&:9$,60":+( &B69+"9.,(+93 .,02$00,"(

"D&968&#+066C" 3&+90+%"(/ &B5&960+(. "::,2,+#0:9"%<8,(+E?:9,2++(. 'H<>Q>?<2"$(69,&0"(

68&C+30,( C8,28 ?:9,2+E+(. ,60.&D&#"5%&(65+96(&90E%,/86.9+C "( <8,(+R0.&D&#"5%&(6

&B5&9,&(2&&

78&<8,(+=>?<@6$.3 A9"$5 C+0:"9%&. ,( "##$ +0+K",(6D&(6$9&;&6C&&( 68&4(6&9(+6,"(+#1"D&963

G&.$26,"( <&(69&,( <8,(+M41G<<N+(. 68&'H<>R0>&D&#"5%&(6?00,06+(2&<"%%,66&&M>?<N&

78&&06+;#,08%&(6":68&41G<<,( "##( 0&9D&0+0+( ,%5"96+(65#+6:"9%6" +00&%;#&+(. 08+9&68&

06"93 ":<8,(+R0+.%,9+;#&5"D&963 9&.$26,"( 9&2"9.&78&>?<S&6C"9T "( 1"D&963 G&.$26,"(EC,68

,60:"2$0"( 68&.&D&#"5%&(6":59".$26,D&2+5+2,63 +(. 68&69+(0:"9%+6,"( ":68&#,D&0+(. C&#:+9&":

68&5""9E59"D,.&. 68&,(,6,+#,(6&9:+2&C,68 68&41G<<&-9"% 68,068&<8,(+=>?<@6$.3 A9"$5

&%&9/&.&

78&@6$.3 A9"$5 #+$(28&. +59"/9+%%&"::"$9%+K"9&D&(60)"( .&D&#"5%&(65+96(&908,50F

+/9,2$#6$9&F,(:9+069$26$9&F+(. &(6&959,0&.&D&#"5%&(6&?##C&9&E+,%&. +608+9,(/ &B5&9,&(2&0+(.

.&&5&(,(/ $(.&906+(.,(/&78&.,02$00,"(0.$9,(/ 68&0&&D&(60E+%"(/ <8,(&0&E?:9,2+(E>?<+(.

"68&9,(6&9(+6,"(+#5+96,2,5+(60E C&9& .3(+%,2E :$6$9&="9,&(6&.E ":6&( 9&D&+#,(/ +(. +#C+30

5+00,"(+6&&>&05,6&/9&+6+28,&D&%&(60E<8,(+06,##:+2&0%+(3 28+##&(/&0&U&8+D&2"(:,.&(2&68+6

?:9,2+(0C,###&+9( :9"%<8,(&0&&B5&9,&(2&0E;$6;+0&. "( 68&,9"C( 9&+#,63&78&9&C+0(" +66&%56,(

68,00&9,&06" .&9,D&+(&C2"(0&(0$0&

7C" T&3 5",(60.,. &%&9/&:9"%68&0&.,02$00,"(068+6C&C"$#. #,T&6" 8,/8#,/86)

!

!78&:,906,08"C%$28 <8,(+R0&2"("%,269+(0:"9%+6,"( 8+02"(69,;$6&. 6" ,605"D&963

9&.$26,"(&78&59"2&00":9&:"9%+(. "5&(,(/=$5 C+0;+0&. "( &B5&9,%&(6+6,"(E%"(,6"9,(/

+(. 68&02+#,(/ $5 ":0$22&00:$#%".&#0&46,068,02"(6,($+#59"2&00":#&+9(,(/ +(.

,(("D+6,"(E,(2#$.,(/ 68&&B5#,2,6&::"966" .9+C:9"%+.D+(2&. ,(6&9(+6,"(+#59+26,2&E68+6

8+0.9,D&( <8,(+R069+(0:"9%+6,"(&78,0,(D"#D&. 5"0,6,"(,(/ 68&9"#&0":/"D&9(%&(6+(.

%+9T&6E+(. +;0"9;,(/ #&00"(0;3 59"%"6,(/ #&+9(,(/ ,(06,6$6,"(0+(. ,(2&(6,D,0,(/ 8$%+(

6+#&(6&<8,(+2"(6,($+##3 ,.&(6,:,&0+(. 2"(:9"(60C&+T(&00&0+(. &%&9/,(/ (&C28+##&(/&0E

0$28 +068&%+K"99&;+#+(2,(/ ":,60&2"("%3E$(0$06+,(+;#&.&D&#"5%&(6+(. 68&28+##&(/&0

":/#";+#,0+6,"(E&(D,9"(%&(6+#,00$&0+(. 2#,%+6&28+(/&&78,0,09&:#&26&. ,( ,60%"68 :,D&=

3&+95#+( C8,28 %+T&068&0&T&3 5$;#,25"#,23 9&:&9&(2&5",(60&

!

!78&0&2"(. ,068+668&9&,0+2"%%"( ,(6&9&06+%"(/ ?:9,2+(0E<8,(&0&+(. 'H<>Q>?<

"

OH2"("%,279+(0:"9%+6,"( +(. 1"D&963 G&.$26,"()P"C,68+55&(&. ,( <8,(+E8&#5,(/ ,68+55&( ,( ?:9,2+O

Page 5: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

2"$(69,&0,( 68&&%&9/&(2&":C&##=:$(26,"(,(/ &2"("%,&0+(. 06+6&0,( ?:9,2+68+6&(2"$9+/&

68&5+96,2,5+6,"( ":5&"5#&,( 68&.&D&#"5%&(659"2&00&G+5,. 5"D&963 9&.$26,"( +(. 9,0,(/

%,..#&2#+00&0C,##:$9(,08 68&&00&(6,+#8$%+( 2+5,6+#:"9:+06E#&+9(,(/=;+0&. .&D&#"5%&(6

,( 68&"%

06

2&(6$93&78,0,068&;+0,259"K&26":?:9,2+( (+6,"(0+(. 5&"5#&68&%0&#D&0E

689"$/8 68&?:9,2+( V(,"( +(. 689"$/8 68&C8"#&9+(/&":?:9,2+( ,(06,6$6,"(0+(.

59"2&00&0&78,0+(. 68&&D"#$6,"( ":+22"$(6+;#&/"D&9(%&(60+9&06&+.,#3 2"(069$26,(/ 68&

5"#,23 ;+0,0:"9&2"("%,269+(0:"9%+6,"( +29"0068&2"(6,(&(6&

78,09&5"96,0,( 6C" D"#$%&0&78&:,9062+56$9&068&&00&(6,+#5",(60&%&9/,(/ :9"%.,02$00,"(0+668&

:"$9&D&(60+(. 59&0&(6068&%+,( :,(.,(/0&78&03(68&0,09&5"960,( 68&0&2"(. D"#$%&5#+2&68&,00$&0

,( 68&2"(6&B6":68&"(=/",(/ 9&0&+928 "( <8,(++(. 68&.&D&#"5%&(659"2&00%"9&/&(&9+##3&

78&<8,(+=>?<@6$.3 A9"$5 C,##("C%"D&"( :9"% 68&0&;,/ 68&%&06" &(/+/&EC,68 ?:9,2+(

,(06,6$6,"(0E,( K",(6#&+9(,(/ 59"2&00&0"( .&D&#"5%&(62"="5&9+6,"( ,( 05&2,:,22"(6&B60&78&

";K&26,D&,06" 29&+6&"55"96$(,6,&06" #&+9( 6"/&68&9+(. :9"%&+28 "68&9E6" ,%59"D&68&2"##&26,D&

,%5+26":.&D&#"5%&(6&::"960+(. 6" &(#+9/&68&02"5&:"9.&D&#"5%&(62"="5&9+6,"(&

U&;&#,&D&68+668,0T,(. ":59+/%+6,2,(6&9+26,"( 2+( 2"(69,;$6&%$28 6" 68&;$,#.,(/ ":68&%$6$+#

$(.&906+(.,(/ +(. 2"(:,.&(2&+%"(/ ?:9,2+(E<8,(&0&+(. 'H<>Q>?<+26"90(&2&00+93 6" 0$55"96+

.3(+%,2+(. 0$06+,(+;#&.&D&#"5%&(65+68 :"9?:9,2+,( 68&2"(6&B6":+9+5,.#3 9&2"(:,/$9,(/ /#";+#

&2"("%3&

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

W8&(/ U&(T+,!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!J9,+( ?6C"".

>&5$63 >,9&26"9 <8+,9

78&@6+6&<"$(2,#X&+.,(/ A9"$5 '::,2&": 'H<>>&D&#"5%&(6?00,06+(2&<"%%,66&&

1"D&963 ?##&D,+6,"( +(. >&D&#"5%&(6E<8,(+

#

OH2"("%,279+(0:"9%+6,"( +(. 1"D&963 G&.$26,"()P"C,68+55&(&. ,( <8,(+E8&#5,(/ ,68+55&( ,( ?:9,2+O

Page 6: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

="J$#6;0-<0%0$,*

?0&9,&0"::,D&&D&(602"(06,6$6&. 68&<8,(+=>?<@6$.3 A9"$5L0C"9T 59"/9+%%&:9"%"##$ 6" &+9#3

"#%% +(. /&(&9+6&. 68,09&5"96Y78&0&&D&(60,(D"#D&. 68&&(/+/&%&(6+(. 0$55"96":%+(3 5&"5#&

:9"%<8,(+E'H<>2"$(69,&0+(. ?:9,2+Y

78&59"/9+%%&0+(. 68&05&+T&90+(. 5+96,2,5+(60E"D&9(## 5&"5#&,( +##E+9&#,06&. ,( 68&?((&B&06"

68,09&5"96Y78&,9+26,D&2"(69,;$6,"(0%+.&68,0&B5&9,&(2&+2"(6,($+##&+9(,(/ 59"2&00C,68 C,.&

5&905&26,D&0E.9+C,(/ "( 68&T("C#&./&E9&0&+928 C"9T +(. 5&905&26,D&0":+##68"0&,(D"#D&.Y

J&8,(. 68&02&(&0E68&%&%;&90":68&<8,(+=>?<@6$.3 A9"$5 2"(69,;$6&. 68&6,%&+(. ,.&+068+6

C&9&29$2,+#6" 2"(2&56$+#,0,(/ +(. ,%5#&%&(6,(/ 68,059"/9+%%&Y78&,9/"D&9(%&(60+(. "9/+(,0+6,"(0

2"(69,;$6&. 6" ;$./&6+93 2"060+(. 6" 59"D,.,(/ #"/,06,2+#0$55"96"( +;9"+.#3 08+9&. +(. :#&B,;#&;+0,0Y

!"#$"%&'()*$+,-./ 012-3

-&.-/+"$,)P$+(/ <8&(/C&,+(. G,28+9. <+9&3

0"$(%1&$)X,Z,+"3$(

-&.2(+)($,)[&+(=G+58+&#<8+5"((,&9&EG";&96P++0+(. X,?(08+(

3(45($,)[&((,:&9?.+%0E-9+(\",0J"(6&%50ES,2T <"06&##"E1&6&9<9+,/=*2]$+,.&E?.9,+(

>+D,0EJ9$(" A&"9/&0EP&U&(5,(/EG3"6+9" P+3+08,E18,# +95ES+"8,9" ,6+("E*+"

Z,+"K,(/E@,%"( @8+95&E*,28+&#@6,9(C&,00E7+.+08,@$_$T,E7"9,7D&,6+(. [&"(/ $(=A,#

-&.&$)"6+1&$)U+(/ +(

7&"618(%$(1+$"+19

:;<--9U$ W8"(/EZ$ P$,EP&Z,+"K$(EU+(/ Z,+"#,(EX,X,(3,EW8+(/ P$,."(/EW8+(/

Z,+"3,(/ +(. [,( G+(

=>-09["( X"%"3EJ,##S,2"#E +9&( ["9/&(0&(E*,28+&#X+,9.E?(/&#+@6$+96+(. <,(.3 G"00

78&<8,(+=>?<@6$.3 A9"$5 ,0/9+6&:$#6" +##68&5+96,2,5+(60:"968&,96,%&E68&,99&+.,(&006" 69+D&#

#"(/ .,06+(2&0+(. 68&,95+00,"(+6&&(/+/&%&(6,( C8+6;&2+%&+( &(#,/86&(,(/ 59"2&00":5&&9

#&+9(,(/ "( 68&T&3 :9"(6,&90":.&D&#"5%&(6+(. /#";+#,0+6,"( ,( <8,(++(. ,( ?:9,2+Y@5&2,+#68+(T0

+9&.$&6" +($%;&9":5&"5#&,( 5+96,2$#+9Y

78&,(05,9+6,"( :"968&@6$.3 A9"$5 2+%&:9"%78&@6+6&<"$(2,#X&+.,(/ A9"$5 '::,2&":1"D&963

?##&D,+6,"( +(. >&D&#"5%&(6MXA'1NE5+96,2$#+9#3 ,60>&5$63 >,9&26"9EU+(/ A$"#,+(/E+(. :9"%68&

4(6&9(+6,"(+#1"D&963 G&.$26,"( <&(69&,( <8,(+M41G<<NE5+96,2$#+9#3 ,60>,9&26"9=A&(&9+#EU$ W8"(/E

+(. >&5$63 >,9&26"9EP$+(/ <8&(/C&,Y78&59"2&00C+005+9T&. ;3 +C"9T08"5E"9/+(,0&. +668&'H<>

,( -&;9$+93 "##) ;3 @"#D&,/ J$8#E6" 08+9&#&00"(0:9"%<8,(+L05"D&963 9&.$26,"( &B5&9,&(2&Y

78&<8+,9":68&'H<>>&D&#"5%&(6?00,06+(2&<"%%,66&&M>?<NEH28T+9. >&$6028&9E:+2,#,6+6&.

:"$(.,(/ ":68&@6$.3 A9"$5 +6.,02$00,"(0C,68 68&XA'1+(. 68&*,(,0693 ":<"%%&92&

M*'-<'*N.$9,(/ +D,0,66" J&,K,(/ ,( [$#3 "##)Y78&U"9#. J+(T <"$(693 >,9&26"9,( J&,K,(/ +6

68&6,%&E>+D,. >"##+9E&B59&00&. ,%%&.,+6&0$55"96:"968&2"(2&56Y

$

OH2"("%,279+(0:"9%+6,"( +(. 1"D&963 G&.$26,"()P"C,68+55&(&. ,( <8,(+E8&#5,(/ ,68+55&( ,( ?:9,2+O

Page 7: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

4( 68&,%5#&%&(6+6,"( 58+0&EW8&(/ U&(T+,EC8" 0$22&&.&. U+(/ A$"#,+(/ +668&XA'1E

5+96,2,5+6&. +26,D&#3 ,( 68&&D&(60E+0C&##+0XA'1L0>,9&26"90=A&(&9+#:"94(6&9(+6,"(+#<"=

"5&9+6,"(E,(,6,+##3 W8+(/ X&,+(. 68&( 0$;0&I$&(6#3 X,<8$(/$+(/Y

19":&00"9X,Z,+"3$(E>&+( ":68&<&(69&:"94(6&/9+6&. ?/9,2$#6$9+#>&D&#"5%&(6":68&<"##&/&":

P$%+(,6,&0+(. >&D&#"5%&(6@6$.,&0E<8,(+?/9,2$#6$9+#V(,D&90,63E8+0;&&( +( ,(069$%&(6+#

,(6&##&26$+#+(. "9/+(,0+6,"(+##&+.&9+6+##06+/&0E+(. ,( 5+96,2$#+9,( 8,09"#&+0>,9&26"9":68&@6$.3

A9"$5Y78&@6$.3 A9"$5L0<"="9.,(+6"9EU+(/ +(EC+068&%+,( +$68"9":68&03(68&0,09&5"960Y

-"968&&D&(6,( J+%+T" "( ?/9,2$#6$9&EG$9+#>&D&#"5%&(6+(. -"". @&2$9,63E2"=05"(0"9&. ;3 68&

A"D&9(%&(6":*+#,E05&2,+#68+(T0+9&.$&6" 68&19,%&*,(,06&9E*".,;" @,.,;&:"9"5&(,(/ 68&

&D&(6+(. 6" 68&*,(,06&9":?/9,2$#6$9&E?#+00+(&?/ ?/+68+(&E+(. 68&*,(,06&9":X,D&06"2T +(.

-,08&9,&0E*+.&#&,(&>,+##" J+E:"968&,92"(69,;$6,"(0Y78&-9&(28 >&D&#"5%&(6?/&(23 6""T "( 68&

#"2+#2"="9.,(+6,"( 6+0T0C,68 %+K"92"(69,;$6,"(0:9"%P&9DaJ"$/+$#6+(. [&+(=-9+(\",0<+D+(+Y

78&<8,(&0&?%;+00+."96" *+#,EW8+(/ A$"I,(/E/+D&0$;06+(6,+#0$55"96Y

-"968&&D&(6,( ?..,0?;+;+"( 68&H(+;#,(/ H(D,9"(%&(6:"9H(6&959,0&>&D&#"5%&(6E05&2,+#68+(T0

+9&.$&6" 68&<"%%,00,"( ":68&?:9,2+( V(,"( :"98"06,(/ 68&"5&(,(/ %"9(,(/ +(. ("6+;#3 6" ,60

<8+,9%+(E[&+( 1,(/E+(. 6" ,60<"%%,00,"(&9:"9H2"("%,2?::+,90E*+BC&##*TC&_+#+%;+E:"9

68&,9+26,D&5+96,2,5+6,"(Y78+(T0+9&+#0" .$&6" 68&V(,6&. S+6,"(0H2"("%,2<"%%,00,"( :"9?:9,2+

MVSH<?N:"968&,90$55"96E05&2,:,2+##3 6" ["0$a>,"(aE>,9&26"9:"9-"". @&2$9,63 +(. @$06+,(+;#&

>&D&#"5%&(6E+(. H%%+($&#S(+."_,&E>,9&26"9:"9H2"("%,2>&D&#"5%&(6Y-"968&A"D&9(%&(6":

H68,"5,+E7+.&00&P+,#&E@6+6&*,(,06&9:"94(.$0693E/+D&+T&3("6&05&&28YV@?4>6""T 68&#&+. ,(

#"2+#"9/+(,0+6,"( ":68&&D&(6EC,68 ["8( H./+96+T,(/ "( 68&T&3 2"="9.,(+6,(/ 9"#&Y78&S"9C&/,+(

H%;+003 +#0" +00,06&. C,68 #"2+#,(5$60E%+(+/&. ;3 G"#:G&&Y78&V@?%;+00+."96" 68&?:9,2+(

V(,"(E*,28+&#J+66#&E59"D,.&. "5&(,(/ 9&%+9T0Y

-"968&&D&(608&#. ,( J&,K,(/E 68&41G<< 59"D,.&. :+2,#,6,&0E +.%,(,069+6,D&0$55"96+(.

+22"%%".+6,"( +(. %&+#0:"9,(D,6&. 5+96,2,5+(60Y78&:,906&D&(6E"( >&D&#"5%&(61+96(&908,50E

;&(&:,6&. :9"%05&2,:,20$55"96:9"%A&9%+(3 59"D,.&. ;3 G";&96P++0+(. *,28+&#@6,9(C&,00Y78&

&D&(6C+0"5&(&. ;3 -9&. '%+8EV/+(.+L0*,(,06&9":@6+6&:"9-,(+(2&Y-"968&&D&(6"(

4(:9+069$26$9&E68&H$9"5&+( V(,"( 59"D,.&. 5+96,2$#+90$55"96E$(.&968&#&+.&908,5 ":1&6&9<9+,/=

*2I$+,.&+(. C,68 +00,06+(2&:9"%S,28"#+0<"06&##"E@,%"( @8+95&+(. [$&9/&( G,66&9Y

-"9&+28 &D&(6E68&U"9#. J+(T 2"%%,00,"(&. 68&?:9,2+( <&(69&:"9H2"("%,279+(0:"9%+6,"( ,(

A8+(+6" 2"(.$262"(0$#6+6,"(0ED,+68&A#";+#>&D&#"5%&(6X&+9(,(/ S&6C"9TE+%"(/ ?:9,2+(

&B5&960+(. "::,2,+#0Y78&0&C&9&%".&9+6&.E0$%%+9,0&. +(. :&. ,(6" .,02$00,"(0;3 H. J9"C(Y

78+(T0+9&+#0" .$&6" 68&<8,(&0&"::,2,+#0C8" +66&(.&. 68&&D&(60+(. :"##"C&. 68&+26,D,6,&0":68&

@6$.3 A9"$5E,( 5+96,2$#+9E:9"% 68&*,(,0693 ":<"%%&92&EA+" $+(3$+(E>&5$63 >,9&26"9=

A&(&9+#":68&>&5+96%&(6":?,. 6" -"9&,/( <"$(69,&0EX$ -&(/E +(/ J,(/K,+( +(. <+,-+(/F+(.

:9"% 68&<8,(&0&?2+.&%3 ":4(6&9(+6,"(+#79+.&+(. H2"("%,2<"="5&9+6,"( M<?47H<NE,60

19&0,.&(6EP$" [,+(/$"E+(. 19":&00"9Z$&P"(/E>,9&26"9":,60>&5+96%&(6":>&D&#"5%&(6

?00,06+(2&Y-9"%68&?:9,2+( >&5+96%&(6":68&*,(,0693 ":-"9&,/( ?::+,90E],$ J"8$+E?%;+00+."9

:"9-'<?<?::+,90E+(. <"$(0&##"9U+(/ Z,(%,( +#0" 5+96,2,5+6&.Y

4( 0$22&&.,(/ H2T8+9. >&$6028&9+0>?<<8+,9EJ9,+( ?6C"". +26,D&#3 0$55"96&. 68&@6$.3 A9"$5

+(. 5+96,2,5+6&. ,( 68&1"#,23 @3%5"0,$%,( J&,K,(/ ,( [$(&"#%%E6" 6+T&06"2T ":68&9&0$#60":68&

C"9T 59"/9+%%&:9"%"##$=%% +(. 6" 8&#5 #+$(28 +(&C58+0&":C"9TY

%

OH2"("%,279+(0:"9%+6,"( +(. 1"D&963 G&.$26,"()P"C,68+55&(&. ,( <8,(+E8&#5,(/ ,68+55&( ,( ?:9,2+O

Page 8: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

="(#$1%*

?<J-!!!!?:9,2+( <+5+2,63 J$,#.,(/ -"$(.+6,"(

?<H7 ?:9,2+( <&(69&:"9H2"("%,279+(0:"9%+6,"(

?HG< ?:9,2+( H2"("%,2G&0&+928 <"(0"96,$%

?->J ?:9,2+( >&D&#"5%&(6J+(T

?4<> ?:9,2+( 4(:9+069$26$9&<"$(693 >,+/("06,2

?1G* ?:9,2+( 1&&9G&D,&C*&28+(,0%

?G4? ?00&00,(/ G&/,"(+#4(6&/9+6,"( ,( ?:9,2+

?V ?:9,2+( V(,"(

<??>1 <"%59&8&(0,D&?:9,2+( ?/9,2$#6$9&>&D&#"5%&(61#+(

<?JG4 <"##+;"9+6,D&?:9,2+( J$./&6G&:"9%4(,6,+6,D&

<?47H< <8,(&0&?2+.&%3 ":4(6&9(+6,"(+#79+.&+(. H2"("%,2<""5&9+6,"(

<>@A <8,(+=>?<@6$.3 A9"$5

>?< >&D&#"5%&(6?00,06+(2&<"%%,66&&M'H<>N

H<'U?@ H2"("%,2<"%%$(,63 ':U&06?:9,2+( @6+6&0

-?' -"". +(. ?/9,2$#6$9&'9/+(,0+6,"( MV(,6&. S+6,"(0N

-?G? -"9$%:"9?/9,2$#6$9+#G&0&+928 ,( ?:9,2+

->4 -"9&,/( >,9&264(D&06%&(6

-'<?< -"9$%"( <8,(+=?:9,2+<"="5&9+6,"(

A71 A9"C68 +(. 79+(0:"9%+6,"( 1#+(

A>1 A9"00>"%&06,219".$26

4<? 4(:9+069$26$9&<"(0"96,$%:"9?:9,2+

4-1G4 4(6&9(+6,"(+#-"". 1"#,23 G&0&+928 4(06,6$6&

4*- 4(6&9(+6,"(+#*"(&6&93 -$(.

41G<< 4(6&9(+6,"(+#1"D&963 G&.$26,"( <&(69&,( <8,(+

*>A *,##&((,$%>&D&#"5%&(6A"+#

*'-<'* *,(,0693 ":<"%%&92&":68&1&"5#&*0G&5$;#,2":<8,(+

SH1?> S&C1+96(&908,5 :"9?:9,2+*0>&D&#"5%&(6

SA' S"(=/"D&9(%&(6+#'9/+(,0+6,"(

'>? '::,2,+#>&D&#"5%&(6?00,06+(2&

'H<> '9/+(,0+6,"( :"9H2"("%,2<"="5&9+6,"( +(. >&D&#"5%&(6

14>? 1+96(&908,5 :"94(:9+069$26$9&>&D&#"5%&(6,( ?:9,2+

14V0 19"K&264%5#&%&(6+6,"( V(,60

1'!SH7 >?<S&6C"9T "( 1"D&963 G&.$26,"(

111 1$;#,2=59,D+6&1+96(&908,5

@HW @5&2,+#H2("%,2W"(&

@*H @%+##+(. *&.,$%=0,_&. H(6&959,0&

@1? @69+6&/,21+96(&908,5 :"9?:9,2+

7?W?G? 7+(_+(,+=W+%;,+G+,#C+3

7!H 7"C(08,5 +(. !,##+/&H(6&959,0&

VS>1 V(,6&. S+6,"(0>&D&#"5%&(619"/9+%%&

VSH<? V(,6&. S+6,"(0H2"("%,2<"%%,00,"( :"9?:9,2+

V(,JG?4S V(,D&90,6,&0EJ$0,(&00+(. G&0&+928 ,( ?/9,2$#6$9+#4(("D+6,"(

V@> V(,6&. @6+6&0>"##+9

U7' U"9#. 79+.&'9/+(,0+6,"(

&

OH2"("%,279+(0:"9%+6,"( +(. 1"D&963 G&.$26,"()P"C,68+55&(&. ,( <8,(+E8&#5,(/ ,68+55&( ,( ?:9,2+O

Page 9: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

')G;0 #+9#$,0$,*

4567856) ,,,

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

*$9:58;7)07<7:!+ D

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

*$65:=<+ D,,

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$>*?!76@

7$5:5<A$!6*:+456<*!A5:*:)?5B76!=67)C$!A5:>58

!A!>*??7:7)A:$>A:*D>7;?A:0A!>*??7:A:*46A$*(<*A:

!;7++5:+ %

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$>*?!76E

)7B7;5?<7:!?*6!:76+>A?+4560658!>*:)?5B76!=

!67)C$!A5: %$

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$>*?!76F

*06A$C;!C6*;!6*:+456<*!A5:D0658!>*:)?5B76!=

!67)C$!A5: ''

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$>*?!76G

A:46*+!6C$!C67H!>745C:)*!A5:4560658!>*:)?5B76!=

!67)C$!A5: +,

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

$>*?!76I

7:!76?6A+7)7B7;5?<7:!*:)7$5:5<A$!6*:+456<*!A5:H

!$67*!A:0!>77:*J;A:07:BA65:<7:! -%

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

*::7K7A

)7B7;5?<7:!?*6!:76+>A?+4560658!>*:)?5B76!=

!67)C$!A5:DJ7ALA:0D$>A:*DEM NEO 5$!5J76EPPO ,$

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!4?&?AHS>? ,$

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!4J&1?G74<41?S7@X4@7 )-

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

*::7K7AA

*06A$C;!C6*;!6*:+456<*!A5:D0658!>*:)?5B76!=

Q67)C$!A5:DJ*<*95D<*;ADER NEM *?6A;EP@P $%

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!44?&?AHS>? $%

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!44J&1?G74<41?S7@X4@7 $$

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

*::7K7AAA

A:46*+!6C$!C67H!>745C:)*!A5:4560658!>*:)?5B76!=

Q67)C$!A5:J7ALA:0D$>A:*D@O NEP +7?!7<J76EP@P %#'

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!444?&?AHS>? %#'

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!444J&1?G74<41?S7@X4@7 %%%

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

*::7K7AB

7:!76?6A+7)7B7;5?<7:!*:)7$5:5<A$!6*:+456<*!A5:H

Q$67*!A:0!>77:*J;A:07:BA65:<7:!D*))A+*J*J*D

Q7!>A5?A*D@S N@R 47J6C*6=EP@@ %%(

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!4!?&?AHS>? %%(

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

!4!J&1?G74<41?S7@X4@7 %"'

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

'

OH2"("%,279+(0:"9%+6,"( +(. 1"D&963 G&.$26,"()P"C,68+55&(&. ,( <8,(+E8&#5,(/ ,68+55&( ,( ?:9,2+O

Page 10: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

书书书

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!"#$%&'(

!"#$#%&" '()$*+#(%),&#$

)$-.#/0(,1 20-3",&#$

4#5&,6)770$0-&$86&$)9

60:7&$; &,6)770$&$<+(&")

=)&$>0**#$*

!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 11: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

?/0(/&05

!"##$%#&'#()#*+(,-#**.(*/&.0 1"'(+2*#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(+(,%.4#&35 &#,6)3'.(

"+4#7##(+33&+)3'(8 06)"'(3#&#*3/&.0 7.3"9/&')+().6(3&'#*+(,3"#'(3#&(+3'.(+-

,#4#-.%0#(3).006('35:!. &#*%.(,3. 3"'*'(3#&#*3/.&3"##$)"+(8#./%#&*%#)3'4#*+(,

#$%#&'#()#;3"#1"'(+<=91>36,5 ?&.6%@+*A.'(3-5 *#36%75 3"#B(3#&(+3'.(+-C.4#&35

D#,6)3'.(1#(3#&'(1"'(+ EBCD11F+(,GH1=2*=#4#-.%0#(39**'*3+()#1.00'33##

E=91F:

I

!"#>36,5 ?&.6% '**6%%.&3#, 75 -#+,'(8 1"'(#*#,#4#-.%0#(3&#*#+&)"

'(*3'363'.(*;*#4#&+-=910#07#&*+(,.7*#&4#&*+(,9/&')+(#$%#&3*+(,'(*3'363'.(*:

9@:"$/@ +0&:,&0";,(6&:(+6,"(+#2"(;&:&(2&0,(<"#<,(/ "<&:!"" 5+:6,2,5+(60;:"%A@,(+BC;:,2+

+(. 6@&."(":2"%%$(,63B6@&A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5 @+0B0,(2&#""$B;"2$0&. 6@,0&H2@+(/&

+(. #&+:(,(/ "( ;"$:,%5":6+(66"5,20:&#+6&. 6" 5:"%"6,(/ /:"?6@ +(. :&.$2,(/ 5"<&:63),I

.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50J ,,I +/:,2$#6$:&B ;"". 0&2$:,63 +(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6J ,,,I

,(;:+06:$26$:&J+(. ,<I6@&&(+K#,(/ &(<,:"(%&(6;":&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6LF5&2,;,2+##3B6@&0&

&<&(60;"2$0&. "( 6?" 6@&%&0)

!

%A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2& ";&2"("%,2 /:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B ,(2#$.,(/ 6@&

2"(6:,K$6,"( ";,(6&:(+6,"(+#+00,06+(2&B +(. ,60:&#&<+(2&;":"6@&:.&<&#"5,(/

2"$(6:,&0B5+:6,2$#+:#3 ,( C;:,2+L

!

%A@,(+M0&2"("%,22"D"5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2++(. 6@&#&00"(06@+6A@,(++(. ECA

*&%K&:02+( 0@+:&?,6@ &+2@ "6@&:6" ,(2:&+0&6@&2"##&26,<&,%5+260";;":&,/( +,. "(

:&.$2,(/ 5"<&:63 ,( C;:,2+L

9@,0("6&0$%%+:,0&06@&%+,( #&00"(0#&+:(66@:"$/@ 6@,0.,+#"/$&"( &+2@ ";6@&0&6@&%&0L9@&

&00&(6,+#;,(.,(/0+:&)

!

%A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2&0@"?0B+/+,(B6@+6:+5,. &2"("%,2+(. 0"2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6,( 5"":

2"$(6:,&02+( @+55&(B,( +2"(6&H6";/#"K+#,0+6,"(B@"#(*3&.(8 ,#4#-.%0#(3<

.&'#(3#,-#+,#&*"'%#0#&8#*;/.)6*#,.(,#4#-.%0#(3%#&/.&0+()#&+3"#&3"+(.(

#(3&#()"#,%.-')'#*+(,'(3#&#*3*:B(*6)"+ ).(3#$3;3"#+&3')6-+3'.(./+ (+3'.(+-

%&.A#)3/.&#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(@'3"'(+ 8#(#&+3'.(;0.3'4+3#*+(,+)3'4+3#*

%#.%-#+)&.**3"#).6(3&5 '(+ (#@(+3'.(+-).(*#(*6*:

!

%9*'(3"#)+*#./1"'(+2*#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(;'(3#&(+3'.(+-+**'*3+()#)+(

*6%%.&3+(,*%##,6%9/&')+2*3&+(*/.&0+3'.(+(,%.4#&35 &#,6)3'.(%&.)#**;

@"#().()#'4#,+(,,#*'8(#,'(3"'*3&+(*/.&0+3'.(/&+0#@.&J:

&

%-":;$:6@&:,(;":%+6,"( "( 6@&A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5 +(. ,60+26,<,6,&0B0&&)!!!"#$%&&"'%( ":!!!"')&*"'%(+

*,&+&*-(

"

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 12: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!"#$#%&" '()$*+#(%),&#$)$-.#/0(,1 20-3",&#$

82"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"( ,06@&5:"2&00,( ?@,2@ +5"":B:$:+#DK+0&. 2"$(6:3 K&2"%&0+%,..#&D,(2"%&

2"$(6:3 ?,6@ +:,0,(/ 0@+:&";,(.$06:3 +(. 0&:<,2&0,( /:"00."%&06,25:".$26NGE1I+(.

&%5#"3%&(6'1:".$26,<,63 +(. ,(2"%&5&:2+5,6++(. O"K 2:&+6,"( /:"? ;+06'4( 6@,05:"2&00B

+/:,2$#6$:+#5:".$26,<,63 :,0&0B?@,#&#+K"$:%"<&0;:"% ;+:%06" 6"?(0+(. 2,6,&0B+(. 6@&:&,0+

.&%"/:+5@,26:+(0,6,"( +0K,:6@ :+6&0;+##'9@&&2"("%3 K&2"%&0,(<"#<&. ,( /#"K+#0$55#3 2@+,(0,(

?+306@+6/&(&:+6&2"(6,($"$0#&+:(,(/ K3 .",(/ +(. $5D/:+.,(/ ";&(6&:5:,0&D#&<&#2+5+2,6,&0

N,'&'.3(+%,22+5+2,63 .&<&#"5%&(6I'C0$55":6,<&B.&<&#"5%&(6+#06+6&5:"<,.&0<,0,"(B5#+((,(/B

K$./&6,(/B2"D":.,(+6,"( +(. 6@&%&+(0;":5+:6,2,5+6":3 (+6,"(+#&(/+/&%&(6' 4(;:+06:$26$:&

,(<&06%&(6+(. ,(06,6$6,"(+#.&<&#"5%&(6+:&.3(+%,2&#&%&(60";&2"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"('

K"+3'**. *3&'J'(8 '(3"#-+*3*'$35 5#+&*'*3"+33"#3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**)+()"+(8#%..&

,#4#-.%'(8 ).6(3&'#*'(3. %&.*%#&.6*).6(3&'#*'(.(-5 + /#@,#)+,#*;@'3"+ ,&+0+3')/+--'(

%.4#&35 &+3#*L1"'(+ *3+(,*.63+*+ (.3+7-#+(,&#)#(3#$+0%-#L

!"#$%&'()*+,"%$-.*/0),1 )0-23,#*$.)*30''*/0),"0 4%',,"#),1 10%)'

98&')6-36&+-&#/.&0+(,,#4#-.%0#(3'('3'+3#,1"'(+2*8&.@3"%+3"+(,%&.4',#,3"#/.6(,+3'.(

/.&+ @',#&6&7+('*+3'.(M#$%.&3<.&'#(3#, 8&.@3" %&.)#**LC <,##+/&DK+0&. &H5&:,%&(6?,6@

2@+(/,(/ #+(. 6&($:&+::+(/&%&(60;":;+%,#,&05:"<,.&. +2:,6,2+#(&?,(2&(6,<&;":5:".$26,"(B+(.

?@&( P$,2Q#3 :&5#,2+6&. +2:"00A@,(+B/&(&:+6&. +%+O":,(2:&+0&,( ;"". 0$55#,&0+(. ,(2"%&0'

N+)J#, 6% 75 %67-') '(4#*30#(3'( &6&+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#; #(3#&%&'*# +(, 3#)"(.-.8')+-

'0%&.4#0#(3*;3"#&6&+-*6&%-6*#*8#(#&+3#,75 *0+--/+&0*7#)+0#3"#7+*'*/.&+ @".-#*5*3#0

./(+3'.(+-#).(.0'),#4#-.%0#(36@:"$/@ 6@&6:+(0;&:";2+5,6+#+(. #+K"$:6" 6"?(0+(. 2,6,&0;:"%

+( ,(2:&+0,(/#3 .,<&:0,;,&. +(. 5:".$26,<&+/:,2$#6$:+#0&26":'

9(#+&-5 #$%#&'0#(3@'3"+ *%#)'+-#).(.0')O.(#E>HPF'(>"#(O#(.%#(#,3"#@+5 /.&+ *6%%-5

)"+'(<7+*#,0.,#-./'(,6*3&'+--#+&('(8;?@,2@ ?+0+#0" :&5#,2+6&. ,( "6@&:F8R0+(. <+:,"$0"6@&:

,(.$06:,+#2#$06&:0+(. (&6?":Q0'1:"/:&00,<&#,K&:+#,0+6,"( ";6@&."%&06,2%+:Q&6?,6@ &H6&(0,<&

5:,<+6,0+6,"(B2:&+6&. +@,/@#3 2"%5&6,6,<&&(6&:5:,0&DK+0&. &2"("%3 ?,6@ &H6&(0,<&:&/,"(+#+(.

(+6,"(+#6:+(05":6#,(Q+/&0' !"#1"'(#*#+63".&'3'#*+)3'4#-5 *.68"3'(3#&(+3'.(+-+', +(,

'(4#*30#(3+0+0$55#&%&(66" (+6,"(+#:&0"$:2&0B("6+0+%+O":"(D/",(/ ;,(+(2,(/ 06:&+%'!"#5

*+@+(,0+(+8#,/.&#'8(+',+(,'(4#*30#(3+*+ 0#+(*3. +)Q6'&#J(.@<".@+(,0+(+8#0#(3

*J'--*3. *%##,6%3"#0.,#&('*+3'.(./1"'(#*#+8&')6-36&#;'(,6*3&5 +(,'(/&+*3&6)36&#LA@,(+

A.'(#,3"#K!G 6@:"$/@ +5:"2&006@+6/&(&:+6&. ?,.&.,02$00,"( +(. #&+:(,(/ ,( A@,(++K"$6

&(/+/&%&(6,( 6@&/#"K+#&2"("%3'N'-+3#&+-+(,06-3'-+3#&+-,.(.&*"+4#%&.4',#,).(*',#&+7-#

#$%#&3'*#;J(.@-#,8# +(, 3&+'('(8; K:,(/,(/ ,( ?":#.D2#+00+(+#36,2+#%&6@".0;":5$K#,2

%+(+/&%&(6+(. &2"("%,2.&<&#"5%&(6B,(2#$.,(/ 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('

!"#*3+3#+(, %&.4'()'+-+(, )'35 +63".&'3'#*"+4#7##( +)3'4#*6%%.&3#&*./#(3#&%&'*#

,#4#-.%0#(33"&.68"3"#%&.4'*'.(./'(/&+*3&6)36&#;./3#(.(+ ).*3<&#).4#&5 7+*'*;+(,3"#

#$%+(*'.(./3"#*)'#()#+(,3#)"(.-.85 7+*#L9@&,(06,6$6,"(+#,(;:+06:$26$:&0;":@,/@&:&.$2+6,"(B

,(2#$.,(/ %+(+/&%&(66:+,(,(/B?&:&.&<&#"5&. +602+#&'!"##(3#&%&'*#*#)3.&"+*/-.6&'*"#,'(

3"'*).(3#$3;@'3"/+*3-#+&('(8 %&.)#**#*;:"%&(/+/&%&(6,( ,(6&:(+6,"(+#0$55#3 2@+,(0+(. O",(6

<&(6$:&0?,6@ ;":&,/( ,(<&06":0+0?&##+0%+O":5:"/:+%%&0;":A@,(&0&/:+.$+6&02@"#+:0@,50+K:"+.

#

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 13: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

+(. 02@&%&06" +66:+26K+2Q A@,(&0&&H5+6:,+6&0+(. &(/+/&&%,(&(6,(6&:(+6,"(+#&H5&:60'1-.*#+(,

/.&@+&,<-..J'(8 '(3#&+)3'.(7#3@##(*3+3#+63".&'3'#*+(,#(3#&%&'*#*"+*7##(+('(3#8&+-%+&3./

3"#8&.@3"0.,#-L

!"#%&'4+3#*#)3.&"+*7##(*67*3+(3'+--5 ,#4#-.%#,+(,"+*7#).0#(.@3"#,.0'(+(3*.6&)#./

#0%-.50#(3E.4#&RSTF+(,'().0#E.4#&UST ./?=CFLC#6@"$/@ 6@&:&+:&06,##+0,/(,;,2+(6

($%K&:";#+:/&06+6&&(6&:5:,0&0+(. 6@&;,(+(2,+#0&26":,0."%,(+6&. K3 06+6&K+(Q0+(. "6@&:

,(06,6$6,"(0B6@&3 +:&%+:Q&6":,&(6&. ";6&( ?,6@ &H6&(0,<&&H6&:(+#K$0,(&00#,(Q+/&0B,(2#$.,(/ ,(

C;:,2+'N9@&4(.$06:,+#+(. A"%%&:2,+#S+(Q ";A@,(+D6@&4ASAD"?(0#"T ";6@&F6+(.+:. S+(Q

,( F"$6@ C;:,2+I'

!"#'00#(*#3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**.4#&3"#-+*3VS 5#+&*"+*(.37##(+)).0%-'*"#,@'3".63

*#&'.6*#).(.0');*.)'+-+(,#(4'&.(0#(3+-).*3*)06:$26$:+#&2"("%,2,%K+#+(2&0B+:$:+#D$:K+(

.,<,.&B#+(. :,/@60,00$&0B,(6&:(+#%,/:+6,"( 06:&00&0B(+6$:+#:&0"$:2&.&/:+.+6,"( +00"2,+6&. ?,6@

,(6&(0,<&;+:%,(/ +(. 0"2,+#.,05+:,6,&0+2:"00A@,(+B?,6@ +@,/@ .&/:&&";,(2"%&,(&P$+#,63B

,(2#$.,(/ 6@&5&:0,06&(2&";&H6:&%&5"<&:63 ?@,2@ 06,##+;;&260"<&:&(" %,##,"( 5&"5#&'C0.&02:,K&.

K&#"?B6@&0&2@+##&(/&0+:&("?6@&;"2$0";+66&(6,"( ";6@&A@,(&0&+$6@":,6,&0'

51$%6#3 3%.%3#,1 -0/04*.60$,

A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2&0@"?0+/+,(B6@+6:+5,. &2"("%,2+(. 0"2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6,( 5"":2"$(6:,&02+(

@+55&(B,( +2"(6&H6";/#"K+#,0+6,"(B@"#(*3&.(8 ,#4#-.%0#(3

!

.&'#(3#,-#+,#&*"'%#0#&8#*;

/.)6*#,.(,#4#-.%0#(3%#&/.&0+()#&+3"#&3"+(.(#(3&#()"#,%.-')'#*+(,'(3#&#*3*'4( 0$2@ +

2"(6&H63"#+&3')6-+3'.(./+ (+3'.(+-%&.A#)3/.&#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(@'3"'(+ 8#(#&+3'.(;

0.3'4+3#*+(,+)3'4+3#*%#.%-#+)&.**3"#(+3'.('(+ (#@(+3'.(+-).(*#(*6*L

4(6&:+26,(/ ?,6@ 6@&:,2@ 0"$:2&0";,.&+0+(. /#"K+#Q("?#&./&+<+,#+K#&6@:"$/@ ;#"?0";6:+.&B

,(<&06%&(6B+,. +(. 5&"5#&B0$2@ +5:"O&26:&#&+0&0@$%+( &(&:/3 +(. 5:".$26,<,63B/&(&:+6,(/

.3(+%,2+(. .,<&:0,;,&. 2+5+2,6,&0B+(. 2:&+6,(/ +%".&:(B&(6&:5:,0&&2"("%3 6@+6,(6&/:+6&06@&

(+6,"( +(. #,(Q0,(6" :&/,"(+#+(. /#"K+#&2"("%,2.3(+%,20'

!&+(*/.&0+3'.(#$%#&'#()#*+&#(.36('/.&0'9@&3 +:&@,/@#3 2"(6&H6$+#+(. .,<&:0&'N633"#5 +--

).(*'*3./+ ,5(+0')-#+&('(8 %&.)#**B06+:6,(/ ;:"%6@&,(,6,+#2"(.,6,"(0";&+2@ 2"$(6:3 +(. 6@&(

5:"/:&00,<&#3 +(. 5:+/%+6,2+##3 K$,#.,(/ "( &H,06,(/ 06:&(/6@0'9@&"(D/",(/ 5:"2&00";#&+:(,(/ +(.

.3(+%,22+5+2,63 .&<&#"5%&(60""( K&/,(06" 2@+(/&6@&&2"("%,2+(. #,;&5"00,K,#,6,&0;":%,##,"(0";

2,6,U&(0B?,6@ %$#6,5#3,(/ 2&(6:&0";,(,6,+6,<&+(. &(6&:5:,0&'9@&/:"?,(/ :+(/&";&%&:/,(/

&2"("%,&06".+3B,(2#$.,(/ A@,(+B4(.,++(. S:+U,#B&+2@ 5:"<,.&.,;;&:&(6<+:,+6,"(0";6@,0K+0,2

$(.&:#3,(/ 5:"2&00'

!"#1"'(+<=91>36,5 ?&.6%/.6(,3"+3#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(+(,'3*,&+0+3')'0%+)3'(

&#,6)'(8 %.4#&35 7#)+0#+ &#)6&&'(8 3"#0#'(#+)"./'3*#4#(3*L=5(+0'))+%+)'35 ,#4#-.%0#(3

@+*+(#$%-')'33.%')'(3"##4#(3.(H(3#&%&'*#=#4#-.%0#(3L!"#'0%-')+3'.(*./3"'*+%%&.+)"

+&#&#/-#)3#,'(3"#-#**.(*,#3+'-#,7#-.@L

$

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 14: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

73*$*6#3 ,)%$'8*)6%,#*$#'.*''#940 #$:8)#3% +#,"#$% (0$0)%,#*$

9).(*#(*6*'*76'-,'(8;'(7.3"%&'4+3#+(,.//')'+-+%%&+'*+-*;+(,'(GH1= +*@#--+*

#0#&8'(8 0+&J#3).6(3&'#*;3"+39/&')+ @'--7#3"#(#$37'8 #0#&8'(8 &#8'.('46,0?&##D5#+2&. 6"

K&(&;,6;:"%6@&(&?0"$:2&0";.&%+(.B,(<&06%&(6+(. 6&2@("#"/3 ,( 6@&%$#6,5"#+:/#"K+#&2"("%3J

5"<&:63 ,0.&2#,(,(/ "( 6@&?@"#&J6@&>4!VC4EF2@+##&(/&,0("? K&,(/ Q&56,( 2@&2Q ,( %"06

2"$(6:,&0J6@&6:+O&26":3 ";5:"/:&006"?+:.06@&*,##&((,$%E&<&#"5%&(6G"+#0N*EG0I@+0K&&(

06:,Q,(/ "( 0"%&;:"(60B+(. 6@&:&,006,##6@&5"00,K,#,63 ";:&+2@,(/ 6@&6+:/&60K3 #"&! ,( %+(3

2"$(6:,&0'

?.4#&(+()#3&#(,*"+4#7##(%.*'3'4#;3".68"(.36('4#&*+--5LN&#+J'(8 .63./&#)6&&'(8

*'36+3'.(*.//&+8'-'35 &#0+'(*+ /&.(3'#&/.&3".*#).6(3&'#*@"#&#3"#3&+(*'3'.(/&.0 +

%+3&'0.('+-*3+3#3. + )+%+7-#*3+3#'**3'--@.&J'(%&.8&#**'C(+6,"(+#&2"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"(

5:"O&26%+3 ,( ;+265:"<,.&6@&?+3 ;":?+:. ,( 0$2@ 2+0&0+0+:+##3,(/ 5",(6;":+(&?(+6,"(+#

2"(0&(0$0'

G4#&+--;3"'*-+*3,#)+,#"+*7##(3"#7#*3/.&9/&')+ *'()#'(,#%#(,#()#;+(,9/&')+ '*#(A.5'(8

.(#./3"#"'8"#*3#).(.0')8&.@3"&+3#*'(3"#@.&-,B5:"O&26&. 6" :&+2@ !T ,( #"&&B$5 ;:"%

)'(T ,( #"&" +;6&:+P$,2Q :&K"$(. ;:"%6@&/#"K+#:&2&00,"( ";#""$'=&2&(6.&K6:&#,&;,(,6,+6,<&0

@+<&%+:Q&.#3 :&.$2&. .&K6K$:.&(0+(. ,%5:"<&. 2:&.,6?":6@,(&00'

8%5#"3%&(6/:"?6@ :&%+,(02"(06:+,(&. K3 +06,##(+::"? &H5":6+(. 5:".$26,"( K+0&'S$6?,6@

5"5$#+6,"( ,( 0$KDF+@+:+( C;:,2+5:"O&26&. 6" :,0&6" $*+ %,##,"( ,( #"&!B$5 ;:"% !&( %,##,"( ,(

&$$"B6@&:&,0+5:"%,0,(/ %+:Q&6?,6@ .3(+%,2@$%+( 2+5,6+#'C(&?%,..#&2#+00,0:,0,(/'9@&

5"6&(6,+#;":;+06/:"?6@ +(. 06:$26$:+#6:+(0;":%+6,"( ,06@$0&(":%"$0+(. '(+ @.&-,@"#&#',#+*

+(,.&8+('*+3'.(+&#3"#J#5 ,&'4#&*./8&.@3";9/&')+ ).6-,*##4#&5 /+*3%&.8&#**3.@+&,*

0',,-#<'().0#*3+36*+(,-+&8#<*)+-#%.4#&35 &#,6)3'.('(3"#).0'(8 ,#)+,#*'

!"#3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**'(9/&')+ ).6-,#4#(7#/+*3#&3"+(#-*#@"#&#B/,<&( 6@&5"00,K,#,6,&0

;":/#"K+#&2"("%,206:$26$:+#2@+(/&+(. 6&2@("#"/,2+##&+5;:"//,(/'C;;":.+K#&6+K#&6.&<,2&0;":

?&K 2"((&26,"( 2"$5#&. ?,6@ 6@&$(.&:0&+;,K:&D"56,22+K#&0("? ,( 5#+2&B0%+##D02+#&0"#+:

6&2@("#"/,&0B+(. (+("6&2@("#"/,&0;":B,(6&:+#,+B5#+(6K:&&.,(/J0$2@ 6&2@("#"/,2+#+.<+(2&0+:&";

@$/&:&#&<+(2&6" 6@&5+:6,2$#+:/&"/:+5@3 ";6@&C;:,2+( 2"(6,(&(6+(. 2+( 6:+(0;":% .&<&#"5%&(6

5:"05&260"( %+(3 ;:"(60B&2"("%,2B0"2,+#+(. 5"#,6,2+#'C("6@&:(&?#&

06

2&(6$:3 5@&("%&("( ,06@&

02"5&;":,(6&:+26,"( ?,6@ 6@&:+(/&";(&?#3 &%&:/,(/ 2"$(6:,&0B,(2#$.,(/ A@,(+B4(.,+BS:+U,#+(.

"6@&:0B6@+6+:&2:&+6,(/ 6@&(&?B%$#6,5"#+:?":#. &2"("%3 ";6".+3B;$:6@&:&(:,2@,(/ 6@&;#"?";

,.&+0+(. Q("?#&./&;:"%?@,2@ C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&02+( .:+?'

!"'(J'(8 '(3#&0*./+ 3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%+&+,'80'3*#-/)"+(8#*3"#@+5 '(@"')"+ ).6(3&5 *##*

'3*#-/;+(,'*%#&)#'4#,'

9@&A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5B?,6@ 06:"(/ ,(<"#<&%&(6";C;:,2+( ";;,2,+#0+(. &H5&:60B@+0K&&(

+00&00,(/ @"?&2"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"( ,( C;:,2+2+( @+55&(B+/+,(066@&K+2Q/:"$(. ";6@&A@,(&0&

&H5&:,&(2&B+(. @"?2"##&26,<&+,. &;;":602+( @&#5 ,( 6@&?,.&:6:+(0;":%+6,"( 5:"2&00'

%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 15: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!"#$%#&'()#*+, $)#-(./)%#$+/-*)/0'(('(*/((+12'3 4'5'2/*%'-$#(# 2'#)-+-6 *)/0'((L

./)&'00'1 2),34%)-'23/)3%,1-2'%0,3#'1 $%'&)--,%)*))$56&'11)&3)* 3' 3/)241*,0)13,5-'4%&)-'2

)&'1'0#&(%'!3/

!

#*),-7#11'8,3#'1 ,1* '%(,1#-,3#'1!./#-#-!/,3#-%)$5#&,95)!#3/ *)8)5'$0)13:

'%#)13)* 5),*)%-/#$!;1* 3/)-)-'4%&)-'2(%'!3/ ,%)9)&'0#1( 0'%)$'!)%2453/,1 )8)%,-<1'!5)*()

,&&4045,3)-,1* *#--)0#1,3)-2,-3)%3/,1 )8)%9)2'%)#1 /#-3'%67,-=/#1,>-%)&'%* -/'!-!

;*61,0#&5),%1#1( $%'&)--3,<)-/'5* #1 , &'413%68#, #13)%,&3#'1-!#3/ 1)! #*),-7$%'*4&3-,1*

'%(,1#-,3#'1,50'*)5-3/,3,%)#1&%),-#1(56,941*,13#1 3/)0453#$'5,%7&'11)&3)*7(5'9,5)&'1'06'23/)

"#

-3

&)134%6!?4-#1)--0'*)5-3/,3,%)2'41* 3' !'%<5'&,55679)&'0)!#*)56%)$5#&,3)* ,1* 3/)1

$%'(%)--#8)56#0$%'8)*7#1 ,1 )1*'()1'4-$%'&)--'2&'13#14,54$(%,*#1(7,&%'--3/))&'1'06:

,(%#&4534%)7#1*4-3%67#12%,-3%4&34%),1* -)%8#&)-!

./)-3,3)-/,$)-3/)'8)%,55)&'1'0#&$'5#&62%,0)!'%<,1* 3/)/40,1 ,1* #1-3#343#'1,5#1&)13#8)-,1*

&,$,&#3#)-3' ,9-'%9 ,1* -$%),* #*),-,1* '%(,1#-,3#'1,5$%'&)--)-!./,3()1)%,3)-,1 )@$,1*#1(7

)13%)$%)1)4%#,5)13)%$%#-)-)&3'%7#1 3/)2'%0,5)&'1'067,95)3' $,%3#&#$,3)#1 &'0$)3#3#8)5'&,57%)(#'1,5

,1* (5'9,58,54)&/,#1-!./)-3,3)$5,6-,1 ,&3#8)%'5)#1 -4$$56#1( A/,%*A,1* A-'23A#12%,-3%4&34%),3

),&/ -3,()7()1)%,3#1( 5,%())@3)%1,5#3#)-!/#&/ ,%))--)13#,53' 3/)(%'!3/ $%'&)--!B#-#1( )0$5'60)13

,1* #1&'0)--3#045,3)3/)5'&,5)&'1'06,1* &%),3)1)!C'9-!D'8)%36%,3)-9)(#1 3' 2,55*%,0,3#&,556!

E13)1-#8)2))*9,&<0)&/,1#-0-9)3!))1 3/)-3,3),1* 3/))13)%$%#-)-)&3'%#*)13#26!/,3#-!'%<#1( ,1*

!/,31))*-&'%%)&3#8),&3#'1!D)%2'%0,1&)7%,3/)%3/,1 )-3,95#-/)* #13)%)-3-79)&'0)-3/)%)2)%)1&)$'#13

2'%$'5#&60,<#1(!./)-3,3)#18)-3-,33)13#'1 ,1* %)-'4%&)-#1 )13%)$%)1)4%-/#$ ,1* #11'8,3#'17!/#&/ ,%)

41*)%-4$$5#)* #1 , $''%)&'1'06!F&'1'0#&,1* -'&#,5&/,1()9)&'0)-3%,1-2'%0,3#'1,5%,3/)%3/,1

#1&%)0)13,5!

;2%#&,1 #1-3#343#'1-,%)$,6#1( 04&/ ,33)13#'1 1'!3' /'!3' 2'-3)%3/)*)8)5'$0)13,5-3,3)#1 ;2%#&,!./#-

!,-3/)&)13%,53/)0)'23/);114,5G'#13;H+HIF=;J))3#1( '2;2%#&,1 J#1#-3)%-'2K#1,1&)7!/#&/

$%'*4&)* , -)3'2%)&'00)1*,3#'1-2'%2'-3)%#1( 3/)*)8)5'$0)13,5-3,3)#1 ;2%#&,!./)5,3)-3C'#13;114,5

B)$'%3'23/);2%#&,1 H1#'1 ,1* 3/)HIF&'1'0#&='00#--#'1 2'%;2%#&, $%'8#*)-, &'0$%)/)1-#8)

$%'-$)&34-2'%/'!*)8)5'$0)13,5-3,3)-&'45* 5),* 3/))&'1'0#&3%,1-2'%0,3#'1 $%'&)--#1 ;2%#&,!./)

;2%#&,1 =)13%)2'%F&'1'0#&.%,1-2'%0,3#'179,-)* #1 ;&&%,7#-&'1*4&3#1( &,-)-34*#)-'2;2%#&,1

&'413%#)-4-#1( 3/)3%,1-2'%0,3#'1 5)1-,1* !#55$495#-/ ,1 ,114,5;2%#&,1 .%,1-2'%0,3#'1 B)$'%32%'0

"$#"!

7'.')'-0'(

8"-/9:;<%+=4(.$06:,+#F6:+6&/,&0+(. 8(6&:5:,0&E&<&#"5%&(6)!,&?0;:"%8+06C0,+'1:&0&(6+6,"( 6" 6@&A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

&<&(6"( 8(6&:5:,0&E&<&#"5%&(6BC..,0CK+K+B-&K:$+:3 #"&&

>"'-69?-,)'@=406@&A@,(&0&*".&#=&5#,2+K#&W1:&0&(6+6,"( 6" 6@&A"(;&:&(2&"( *+2:" +(. G:"?6@ 1"#,2,&0,( 6@&X+Q&";6@&

A:,0,0B4*-BX+0@,(/6"( EAB*+:2@ ( ,-B#"&&

A/-'(9B"#)2'(#-, 7/%')9C#<2=9@&Y&?Z+#.":-+260)4.&+0B4(06,6$6,"(0B1"5$#+6,"( +(. >$%+( A+5,6+#'Y+6,"(+#S$:&+$ ";

82"("%,2=&0&+:2@BX":Q,(/ 1+5&:&!"$)B[$(&#""$

D+-9A<($+-E+.<=Y&?F6:$26$:+#82"("%,20)+;:+%&?":Q ;"::&6@,(Q,(/ .&<&#"5%&(6'X":#. S+(QJ1"#,23 =&0&+:2@ X":Q,(/

1+5&:BX1F!&$(B-&K:$+:3 #"&"

A<%#9B#2'($/<(=9@&Y&?>+:<&06)C/:,2$#6$:+#4(("<+6,"( ,( C;:,2+''H;":. \(,<&:0,63 1:&00B#"&&

D+9F+#/G<-=9" E&<&#"5 C/:,2$#6$:&D]&. G:"?6@ +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( ,( 9+(U+(,+'4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,(

A@,(+N41=AAI+(. X":#. S+(QB[$#3 #"&"

HIJB?#-, ?H=82"("%,2=&5":6"( C;:,2+#"&&)G"<&:(,(/ E&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2+

!

6@&:"#&";6@&06+6&,( &2"("%,2

6:+(0;":%+6,"('*+:2@ #"&&

&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 16: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

@01 !:0%0$,*#+86&$)A*!B70(&0$"0

9@&;"##"?,(/ +:&6@&;$(.+%&(6+#&#&%&(60,( A@,(+M00$22&00,( %+00,<&#3 :&.$2,(/ 5"<&:63 +(.

2:&+6,(/ +%,..#&D,(2"%&2"$(6:3 +(. ?,##2"(6,($&6" $(.&:#,&A@,(+M0"(D/",(/ &;;":606" +..:&006@&

%+(3 :&%+,(,(/ 2@+##&(/&06@+6A@,(+@+0,.&(6,;,&. ;":,60.&<&#"5%&(6B+.O$06%&(6+(. 0"2,+#?&##D

K&,(/^

;"0 )0'.*$'#940 -0/04*.60$,<*)#0$,0-',%,0

W+J'(8 #).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(3"#)#(3&+-86','(8 .7A#)3'4#./8.4#&(0#(3;+*1"'(+ ,','(

3"#-+3#IRUS*;@'3"'3*&#/.&0+(,.%#('(8 6%%.-')'#*X

!

%1:"<,.&0+K+0,0;":?,.&2"(0&(0$0+(. 5+:6,2,5+6,"( +2:"000"2,&63 ,( +(+6,"(+#5:"O&26'

!

%E:,<&05:+/%+6,2B&<,.&(2&DK+0&. 5"#,23 %+Q,(/ +(. 2#"0&"(D/",(/ :&<,&?";5&:;":%+(2&'

!

%*+Q&05&:;":%+(2&,( 6&:%0";/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( 6@&6&06;":5"#,2,&0+(.

:&0"$:2&+##"2+6,"('

!

%F6:&(/6@&(0#&+:(,(/ +(. ,(("<+6,"('

!

%8H&:2,0&0.,02,5#,(&"( 6@&&;;,2,&(23 +(. &;;&26,<&(&00";K"6@ /"<&:(%&(6+(. &(6&:5:,0&0'

!

%1$60+@,/@ 5:,":,63 "( 5"#,23%+Q,(/ 2+5+2,63 +(. ,(<&06%&(6,( :&0&+:2@ +(. &H6&(0,"(

2+5+2,6,&0,( $(,<&:0,6,&0+(. ,(06,6$6&0+(. #,(Q,(/ 6@&%6" %,(,06:,&0+(. 6@&.&2,0,"( +(.

,%5#&%&(6+6,"( 5:"2&00&0'

!

%8(2"$:+/&06@&&%&:/&(2&";+?&##D&.$2+6&. 5:";&00,"(+#%,..#&2#+00+(. +66:+2606+#&(6&.

5&"5#&6" :&6$:( @"%&6" ?":Q ;":6@&,:2"$(6:,&0'

=048<)04#%$30 %$-*+$0)'"#.

>#-/<&#-'+()#"+*7##(+ /6(,+0#(3+-%&'()'%-#./1"'(#*#*3&+3#85L9@,05:,(2,5#&,0,%K&..&.

.&&5#3 ,( A@,(+M006:"(/ "?(&:0@,5 ";,60"?( .&<&#"5%&(65+6@ ?@,#&+K0":K,(/ Q("?#&./&;:"%+

?,.&:+(/&";&H6&:(+#+26":0B,(2#$.,(/ ,(<&06":0+(. &H5&:60B+(. &(/+/,(/ ?,6@ K,#+6&:+#+(.

%$#6,#+6&:+#5"#,23 5:"2&00&0)

!

%A@,(+@+0K&&( .&<&#"5,(/ ,60%&.,$%+(. #"(/D6&:%.&<&#"5%&(606:+6&/,&0,( :&#+6,"( 6"

"(D/",(/ 2@+(/&0,( 6@&(+6,"(+#+(. /#"K+#2"(6&H6+(. $0&0,60-,<&D_&+:1#+( ,(06:$%&(66"

,%5#&%&(66@"0&06:+6&/,&0?,6@ +.O$06&. 5"#,23 ,(6&:<&(6,"(0'

!

%8H6&:(+#0$55":6B0$2@ +0;":&,/( ,(<&06%&(6+(. +,.B,0,(2":5":+6&. ?,6@,( 6@"0&06:+6&/,&0

+(. 5"#,2,&0B?@,2@ %+Q&06@,0&H6&:(+#0$55":6%":&&;;&26,<&'

!

%1"#,23 .&<&#"5%&(6+(. 6&2@(,2+#2+5+2,6,&0@+<&+#?+30K&&( 2&(6:+#5"#,23 2"(2&:(0B

5:"<,.,(/ +K+0,0;":%"(,6":,(/ +(. +22"$(6+K,#,63 0306&%0+6K"6@ 6@&2&(6:+#+(. #"2+#

/"<&:(%&(6#&<&#0'

'

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 17: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

>0)8*)6%$30<9%'0-.294#3 6%$%(060$,%$--030$,)%4#'%,#*$

=#4#-.%0#(3<.&'#(3#,-#+,#&*"'%&#Q6'&#,+ "'8"Q6+-'35 %67-')0+(+8#0#(3).&%*/.&%.-')5

/.&0+3'.(+(,'0%-#0#(3+3'.(+3)#(3&+-+(,-.)+--#4#-*X

!

%F&#&26,"( 5:"2&.$:&0;":2,<,#0&:<,2&+(. 5"#,6,2+#";;,2&?&:&:&;":%&. 6" :&P$,:&

&.$2+6,"(+#+66+,(%&(6B@+(.0D"( &H5&:,&(2&+(. 5:"<&( ,(.,<,.$+#5&:;":%+(2&'

!

%9@&2&(6:+#5#+((,(/ 0306&%?+0:&5#+2&. K3 +%+:Q&6":,&(6&. 5#+((,(/ 0306&%'

!

%F,/(,;,2+(6.&2&(6:+#,0+6,"( /&(&:+6&. K"66"%D$5 ,(,6,+6,<&06@+6?&:&?,.&#3 :&5#,2+6&.'

!

%E&<&#"5%&(62"%5&6,6,"( K&6?&&( 2,6,&0+(. 6"?(0;"06&:&. ,(2:&+0&. /:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('

!

%9+H+6,"( 0306&%:&;":%:&,(;":2&. #"2+#:&<&($&0+(. K$./&60'

>*4#31 )0'0%)3"3%.%3#,#0'%$-#$$*/%,#*$'1',06'

!"#3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**'*'(3#(*'4#'(.(<8.'(8 %.-')5 3#*3'(8 +(,+,+%3+3'.(7+*#,.(

#4',#()#LA@,(+@+02:&+6&. +( &H6&(0,<&0&6";,(06,6$6,"(+#2+5+2,6,&0,( 6@&@+:. +(. 0";602,&(2&06"

&(+K#&6@&+(+#30,0";5&:;":%+(2&B5:"K#&%0+(. 0"#$6,"(0'9@&&H5&:,%&(6D&<+#$+6&D02+#&$5 0$22&00

5:,(2,5#&,0?,.&#3 +55#,&. +(. :+5,.#3 ,%5#&%&(6&.'9@,0@+0.&%+(.&. 6@&&H5+(0,"( ";@,/@&:

&.$2+6,"( +(. 6@&.&<&#"5%&(6";:&0&+:2@ ,(06,6$6,"(0#,(Q&. 6" 5"#,23 .&2,0,"( %+Q,(/ +(.

,%5#&%&(6+6,"('X":#. &H5&:6,0& @+0K&&( 0"$/@6+(. +66:+26&. 6@:"$/@ ,(2&(6,<&02@&%&0B

,(6&:(+6,"(+#5+:6(&:0@,50+(. ";6&( <,++,. 5:"/:+%%&0'

?00-9%3@ 603"%$#'6'8*)#-0$,#81#$( %$-%--)0''#$( 3"%440$(0'

1"'(+2*'0%&#**'4#3&+(*/.&0+3'.("+*+-*. 8#(#&+3#,*3&#**#*+(,'07+-+()#*7.3"'(3#&(+--5 +(,

#$3#&(+--5;+*(.3#,+7.4#L!"#*#0+A.&)"+--#(8#*+&#',#(3'/'#,+(,+,,&#**#,'(3"#(#@/'4#<

5#+&%-+(@"')"'()-6,#*%.-')5 +)3'.(*+'0#,+3X

!

%-"2$0,(/ %":&"( 6@&P$+#,63 ";/:"?6@ +(. ,%5:"<,(/ 6@&;$(26,"(,(/ ";+22"$(6+K,#,63 0306&%0'

!

%9+2Q#,(/ ,(2"%&+(. :&/,"(+#.,05+:,6,&0B,(2#$.,(/ :$:+#V$:K+( ,(2"%&+(. &P$,63 ,00$&0'

!

%=+,0,(/ ."%&06,22"(0$%56,"( +(. :&.$2,(/ :&#,+(2&"( &H6&:(+#.&%+(.'

!

%=&5+,:,(/ &(<,:"(%&(6+#.+%+/&B,(2#$.,(/ ;+:%#+(. .&/:+.+6,"(B+(. %+(+/,(/ $:K+(,0+6,"('

!

%8#,%,(+6,(/ &H6:&%&5"<&:63 6@:"$/@ 6+:/&6&. %&+0$:&0;":6@&06,###+:/&($%K&:0";<&:3

5"":5&"5#&'

D#*%.(*'7-#,#4#-.%0#(3<.&'#(3#,8.4#&(0#(3&#0+'(*#**#(3'+-'(+ 0.&#,'4#&*#+(,).0%-#$

#).(.05 +(,*.)'#35X

!

%X,6@ 6@&2@+##&(/&0";K&2"%,(/ +@,/@D,(2"%&2"$(6:3 +(. +( +26,<&5+:6";6@&/#"K+#

/"<&:(+(2&0306&%BA@,(+M05"#,23 :&<,&?+(. +.O$06%&(65:"2&00&0B,(;":%&. K3 ;&&.K+2Q

%&2@+(,0%0+(. /#"K+#2@+(/&B+:&%":&,%5":6+(66@+( &<&:BK"6@ ."%&06,2+##3 +(.

,(6&:(+6,"(+##3'

(

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 18: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

C0/0:#7%0$,D,(),0;&0*)$-C0/0:#7%0$,8#E#70(),&#$

&$<+(&")

73*$*6#3 .0)8*)6%$30 %$-,"0 ',%,0 #$:8)#3%

D#*%.(*'7-#,#4#-.%0#(3<.&'#(3#,*3+3#*@'3"+ (+3'.(+-%&.A#)3/.&#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(+&#

3"#J#5 3. 9/&')+2*%&.8&#**+(,3"#&#,6)3'.(./%.4#&35L

!"'*@+*3"#0+'(0#**+8#3"+39/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3*).(4#5#,3"&.68".633"#1"'(+<=91>36,5

?&.6%2*/.6&#4#(3*L

K#--</6()3'.('(8 *3+3#*'(9/&')+ +&#+-*. + ).00.('(3#&#*3./9/&')+ +(,'3*#).(.0')%+&3(#&*

+*0.&##$3#(*'4##).(.0')-'(J+8#*@'3"9/&')+ +&#)&#+3#,Y+(,3"#5 +&#+ ).00.('(3#&#*3./

3"#'(3#&(+3'.(+-).006('35 +*+ @".-#+*'3@.&J*.(8-.7+-%67-')8..,*+8#(,+*;'()-6,'(8

%#+)#+(,*#)6&'35;"#+-3";0'8&+3'.(+(,)-'0+3#)"+(8#L

?.)+0# K)/@(L#($@"'-C/2+0G>G-,)/%'(#)'?5/+,',

?.)+0#-)'('#)0"/-$"'6)/@$")'0/), #-, *)/(*'0$(*)'('-$', #$$"'B"+-#M4?B>$<,GK)/<*N('5'-$(

("/@', $"#$+-$"'*')+/, OPQR STRRR9./<))'0<))+-6 *)/12'%("#, 0/($/5')TU *')#--<%+-2/($*')

0#*+$# +-0/%'6)/@$"9#00/<-$+-6 ./)#2%/($#22/.?.)+0#N(("/)$.#229)'2#$+5'$/ (<00'((.<2,'5'2/*+-6

)'6+/-(=#L&'413)%:$%'*4&3#8))&'1'0#&#1&)13#8)-3%4&34%)-M##LN9''0,1* 94-3O$495#&2#1,1&)-M###L

)5#3),1* )3/1#&,556:9,-)* #1&'0),1* !),53/ &,$34%)7-'0)3#0)-#18'58#1( 5,%():-&,5)&'%%4$3#'1 96,

2)!M,1* #8L-3,3)2,#54%)'%9%),<*'!1!P/)%)3/)-)$%'95)0-/,* 9))1 ,8'#*)* '%'8)%&'0)7;2%#&,1

&'413%6(%'!3/ %,3)-!)%),0'1( 3/)/#(/)-3#1 3/)!'%5*!./)%)-),%&/ -/'!)* 3/,3&'1-3#343#'1-

$%'8#*#1( 2'%, &'1-3%,#1)* )@)&43#8)7$,%3#&45,%56!#3/ 3)%05#0#3-7!'45* 5,%()56!'%<#1 %)-'58#1( 3/)-)

$%'95)0-!

7'.')'-0'

L/(<9?<6<($+-=.,<#1( 3/);2%#&,1 Q%'!3/ D%'&)--K'%!,%*R;8'#*#1( D'5#&6S61*%'0)-MD%)-)13,3#'1 3' 3/)=/#1,:T;=S34*6

Q%'4$ F8)13'1 3/)F1,95#1( F18#%'10)132'%F13)%$%#-)T)8)5'$0)137;**#-;9,9,7K)9%4,%6"$##!

L/(<9?<6<($+-=H1*)%-3,1*#1( 3/);2%#&,1 Q%'!3/ B)&'%*R3/)E0$'%3,1&)'2D'5#&6S61*%'0)-,1* Q'8)%1,1&)!HIH:PETFB

T#-&4--#'1 D,$)%"$$%+"

!"#7+*')+07'3'.(./3"#9/&')+(Z('.(;@',#-5 *6%%.&3#,75 3"#'(3#&(+3'.(+-).006('35;

'()-6,'(8 1"'(+ +(, GH1=M=91 0#07#&*;'*3. #(*6&#3"+39/&')+( ).6(3&'#*7#).0#

&#*%.(*'7-#,#4#-.%0#(3<.&'#(3#,*3+3#*;#(A.5'(8 %#+)#+(,*3+7'-'35L

73*$*6#3 (*/0)$%$30 %$-)0(#*$%4#$,0()%,#*$A

;"0 0/*4/#$( 8)%60+*)@ 8*):8)#3%$-0/04*.60$,

!"#*3&+3#8')'0%.&3+()#./#).(.0')8.4#&(+()#+(,&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.(@+*+ 0+A.&0#**+8#

/&.09/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3*'(3"#1"'(+<=91>36,5 ?&.6%2*#4#(3*L

9/&')+2*-#+,#&*"+4#7##()&#+3'(8 3"#%.-')'#*+(,*3&6)36&#*/.&%#+)#+(,*3+7'-'35 +(,

#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(+)&.**3"#).(3'(#(3L4( 6@&#+06.&2+.&BC;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0@+<&%+.&<&:3

)

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 19: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

0,/(,;,2+(65:"/:&00,( ,%5:"<,(/ &2"("%,25"#,23B+6K"6@ %+2:"&2"("%,2#&<&#0+(. +60&26":+#+(.

%,2:"&2"("%,2#&<&#0'1:"/:&00@+0+#0" K&&( %+.&,( :&.$2,(/ 2,<,#+(. :&/,"(+#2"(;#,260BK$66@&:&

+:&:&%+,(,(/ 2@+##&(/&0";&#,6&+(. &6@(,22+56$:&";:&0"$:2&0B2"::$56,"( +(. 06+6&K:&+Q."?('

-":0"%&.&2+.&0;"##"?,(/ ,(.&5&(.&(2&B%"06C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0:&#,&. "( #"(/D6&:%&H6&:(+#0$55":6

;":5"#,23 +(+#30,0+(. +.<,2&B?@&6@&:;:"%,(6&:(+6,"(+#":/+(,0+6,"(0":5:";&00,"(+#2"(0$#6+(60'

C(. 3"#*0+--%.%6-+3'.(*'O#./0+(5 9/&')+().6(3&'#*0#+(*3"+33"#).*3./)&#+3'(8 3"#'&.@(

%.-')5 +(+-5*'*+(,&#*#+&)")+%+)'3'#*'*"'8"L

C&.8&#**'4#-5;".@#4#&;9/&')+('(*3'363'.(*"+4#)&#+3#,*"+&#,)+%+)'3'#*/.&%.-')5 +(+-5*'*

+(,&#4'#@;+)&.**+ &+(8#.//'#-,*;,(2#$.,(/ 5"#,6,2+#.&<&#"5%&(6B:&/,"(+#,(6&/:+6,"(B

,(;:+06:$26$:&B /&(.&: ,00$&0B +/:,2$#6$:&B 02,&(2& +(. 6&2@("#"/3B +(. ,(;":%+6,"( +(.

2"%%$(,2+6,"(06&2@("#"/,&0'

9@&:&/,"(+#&2"("%,22"%%$(,6,&0+:&?":Q,(/ 6" &(#+:/&+(. ,(6&/:+6&6@&&2"("%,205+2&0,(

C;:,2+'4( 2"(O$(26,"( ?,6@ 6@&C;:,2+( \(,"( +(. "6@&:,(06,6$6,"(0+(. 5:"2&00&0B6@&3 +:&

.&<&#"5,(/ 5#+(0+(. 5:"/:+%%&06" O",( $5 6@&<+062"(6,(&(6B0" 6@+6,60@$%+( +(. (+6$:+#?&+#6@

2+( K&;$##3 K$60$06+,(+K#3 6$:(&. ,(6" ?,.&05:&+. 5:"05&:,63 ;":C;:,2+(0'

:8)#3%&'.%,"+%1'%"0%-A=*60 @01 *)#0$,%,#*$'

!"#%&.*%#)3*/.&#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.("+4#(#4#&7##(7#33#&'(9/&')+L9@&@,/@&:/:"?6@

5&:;":%+(2&,( 6@&#+06.&2+.&,( C;:,2+:&;#&260+( $(.&:#3,(/ 6:&(. 6"?+:.0,%5:"<&. &2"("%,2

/"<&:(+(2&,( C;:,2++(. 6@&:&0"#$6,"( ";%+(3B,;("6+##B2"(;#,260'9@&C;:,2+( \(,"( +(. ,60

06:$26$:&0+(. +/:&&. 5"#,23 ;:+%&?":Q0"( 5"#,6,2+#+(. &2"("%,2/"<&:(+(2&B0$55":6&. K3 6@&\Y

82"("%,2A"%%,00,"( ;":C;:,2+N\Y8ACI+(. 6@&C;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q NC;ESIB@+<&%+.&

+#+:/&2"(6:,K$6,"( 6" 6@,0'

!"#(#@%&.*%#)3*+-*. &#/-#)33"#'0%+)3*.((+36&+-&#*.6&)#,#0+(,./#0#&8'(8 #).(.0'#*L

9@&0&5:"05&2602"$#. 05&&. $5 6@&:&0"#$6,"( ";:&%+,(,(/ 5:"K#&%0";;:+/,#,63 +(. 2"(;#,26+06@&

,(2&(6,<&06" K&5+:6";6@&C;:,2+( /:"?6@ 06":3 +(. :&/,"(+#,(;:+06:$26$:&5:"/:+%%&0K&2"%&%$2@

06:"(/&:'

B(3"#-'8"3./3"#,'*)6**'.(*+33"#1"'(+<=91>36,5 ?&.6%2*#4#(3*;*.0#J#5 .&'#(3+3'.(*/.&

9/&')+(*3+3#*+(,.&8+('*+3'.(*+(,3"#'&,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*3. *"+&#'()-6,#X

!

[*+Q&+ 8&##(#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(?,6@,( +/&(&:+6,"( 6" ;#"$:,0@,(/ %,..#&D,(2"%&

%".&:( &2"("%,&0?,6@ #"?5"<&:63 :+6&0B6@&Q&3 ;:+%&?":Q ;":6@,(Q,(/ +K"$6C;:,2+M0

;$6$:&'

!

%F$55":63"##0#&8#()#./&#*%.(*'7-#,#4#-.%0#(3<.&'#(3#,*3+3#*+(. +..:&00:,0Q0";

06+6&2+56$:&B2"(;#,26+(. K:&+Q."?(BK3 &(0$:,(/B6@:"$/@ 6:+(05+:&(23 +(. (+6,"(+#+(.

,(6&:(+6,"(+#+22"$(6+K,#,63 0306&%0B6@+6,(2"%&+(. (+6$:+#?&+#6@ ,0@+:(&00&. ;":(+6,"(+#

5:"O&260";&2"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"('

!

%8H5#",66@&"55":6$(,6,&0+6@+(. ("?;":+8&')6-36&+-0.,#&('*+3'.(;K"6@ 0%+##+(. #+:/&

02+#&B6" /&(&:+6&+?,.&05:&+. /:"?6@ .3(+%,2?,6@ 0$55#3 2@+,(0+(. &2"("%,2#,(Q+/&0

6@+6,(6&/:+6&06@&(+6,"(+#+(. :&/,"(+#&2"("%,&0+(. O",(0$5 ?,6@ /#"K+#%+:Q&60'F%+##

;+:%&:0B%&( +(. ?"%&(B6+Q&"( 6@&2@+:+26&:";&(6:&5:&(&$:0,( 6@,0%".&:( 0&26":B

*!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 20: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

/&(&:+6,(/ ,(2"%&0+(. @&#5,(/ 6" 2"::&26@,/@ %+#($6:,6,"( :+6&0'

!

%F$55":66@&,#4#-.%0#(3./9/&')+( &#8'.(+-J(.@-#,8#%-+3/.&0*+(. 2&(6:&0";

&H2&##&(2&+0+%&+(0";05&&.,(/ $5 6@&+2P$,0,6,"( ";6&2@("#"/3 ,( +/:,2$#6$:&+(. ,( "6@&:

+:&+0'

!

%9@,(Q +(. ?":Q ,( 6&:%0";,(2:&+0,(/ 6@&%"%&(6$% "( &#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.(+(. 6@&

2:&+6,"( ";:&/,"(+#+(. 2"(6,(&(6+#&2"("%,2.3(+%,20+(. ,(;:+06:$26$:&'

!

%C."563"#,5(+0'))+%+)'35 ,#4#-.%0#(3+%%&.+)"6" &(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6B06+:6,(/

?,6@ 2$::&(606:&(/6@0V+.<+(6+/&0B?,6@ "(D/",(/ +.+56+6,"( +(. ,(6&:+26,"( K&6?&&( 6@&

06+6&+(. &(6&:5:,0&06" 5:"%"6&;+06#&+:(,(/ +(. 2+5+2,63 K$,#.,(/ ,( K"6@ 6@&5$K#,2+(.

5:,<+6&0&26":0'

!

%!+J#3&+,#;'(4#*30#(3+(,+',+*.%%.&36('3'#*3. *%##,6%-#+&('(8 %&.)#**#*;+2P$,:&

6&2@("#"/,&0+(. %+(+/&%&(6%".&#0+(. 0Q,##06@+62+( K&+.+56&. 6" 6@&C;:,2+( 2"(6&H6'

!

%F$55":66@&#0#&8#()#./+ )&#+3'4#0',,-#)-+**6@:"$/@ $5?+:. %"K,#,63 +(. +66:+26,(/

&H5+6:,+6&6+#&(66" :&6$:( @"%&,( 6@&2"(6&H6";6@&(+6,"(+#&2"("%,25:"O&26;":&2"("%,2

6:+(0;":%+6,"(B6" 5:"<,.&6@&&(6:&5:&(&$:,+#0Q,##0+(. 6@&?&##D&.$2+6&. @$%+( :&0"$:2&0

(&&.&. 6" %+(+/&+%":&2"%5#&HB%":&":/+(,0&. &2"("%3 6@+6&(/+/&0,( :&/,"(+#+(.

/#"K+#%+:Q&60'

51$%6#3'*8-0/04*.60$,3*<*.0)%,#*$#$:8)#3%

!"#&+%',-5 #4.-4'(8 06-3','0#(*'.(+-&.-#./1"'(+ '(9/&')+(,#4#-.%0#(3@+*@',#-5

@#-).0#,+3+--./3"#1"'(+<=91 >36,5 ?&.6%2*#4#(3*+*%&.4','(8 (#@ *).%#+(,(#@

,'4#&*'35 '(9/&')+2*#$3#&(+-#).(.0')&#-+3'.(*L

A@,(++(. '8AEVECA2"$(6:,&0+##@+<&#"(/ 6:+.,6,"(0";5:"<,.,(/ +,. +(. ?,.&:&2"("%,22"D

"5&:+6,"( 6" C;:,2+'9@&,:&(6&:5:,0&0BK"6@ 06+6&+(. 5:,<+6&B5#+3 #+:/&:"#&0,( C;:,2+( .&<&#"5%&(6'

X@,#&'8AEVECA2"$(6:,&0@+<&+22"$(6&. ;":6@&%+O":0@+:&";6:+.&B,(<&06%&(6+(. +,. ;#"?0

?,6@ C;:,2+B3"#)6&&#(3,5(+0')*./1"'(#*#3&+,#+(,'(4#*30#(3+(,+',+&#0+J'(8 '3+ J#5

,&'4#&'(9/&')+(,#4#-.%0#(3L

!"#1"'(#*#8.4#&(0#(32*\?.'(8 .63] %.-')5 #().6&+8#*1"'(#*##(3#&%&'*#*3. '(4#*3+7&.+,;

%+&3-5 3. "#-%,'4#&*'/5 1"'(+2*-+&8#&#*#&4#*.//.&#'8(#$)"+(8#L*+(3 A@,(&0&+,. 5:"O&260+:&

K&,(/ 06:$26$:&. "( +( &(6&:5:,0&K+0,06" /&(&:+6&0$06+,(+K,#,63'C(. A@,(+B+#"(/ ?,6@ '8AE+(.

"6@&:2"$(6:,&0B,0,(<&06,(/ 6" &H5+(. ",#+(. %,(&:+#:&0"$:2&0$55#,&0'

!"#&#'*0+A.&*).%#/.&1"'(+ 3. '()&#+*#/6&3"#&3"#*)+-#./'3*3&+,#;'(4#*30#(3+(,+',3.

9/&')+L9@,0?,##.&5&(. "( 6@&&;;&26,<&(&00+(. 6@&0$06+,(+K,#,63 ";6@&/:"?6@ 6:+O&26":,&0";,60

C;:,2+( 5+:6(&:0'46?,##+#0" ,(<"#<&?":Q,(/ ?,6@ 6@&#+:/&:+/&(.+0;"::&/,"(+#,(6&/:+6,"( +(. "(

6@&0$22&00;$#;$(26,"(,(/ ";6@&+:2@,6&26$:&;":5&+2&+(. 06+K,#,63 ,( C;:,2+'

1"'(+2*'(*3'363'.(*/.&%-+(('(8 +(,,#-'4#&'(8 +',+(,.3"#&.//')'+-/'(+()'+-&#*.6&)#*"+4#

#4.-4#,*'8('/')+(3-5 *'()#3"#0',<IRRS*;?,6@ 6@&2:&+6,"( ";05&2,+#;,(+(2,+#,(06,6$6,"(0+(. 6@&

.&<&#"5%&(6";2"D":.,(+6,"( 0306&%0+%"(/ *,(,06:,&0'9@&;,(+(2,+#,(06,6$6,"(0+:&2+5+K#&";

5$66,(/ 6"/&6@&:#+:/&5+2Q+/&0";;,(+(2,+#0$55":6;":,(;:+06:$26$:&'

!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 21: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!"#1"'(+<=91>36,5 ?&.6%@+*'0%&#**#,+33"#&#+,'(#**./3"#1"'(#*#+63".&'3'#*3. 7#

'(4.-4#,'(3&+(*/.&0+3'4#'(4#*30#(3+(,'(/&+*3&6)36&#%+)J+8#*L9@&:&+.,(&00";A@,(+6" K&

,(<"#<&. ,( ,(6&:D:&/,"(+#,(;:+06:$26$:&?+0+#0" ?&#2"%&. +(. &(2"$:+/&.BK$,#.,(/ "( A@,(+M0

&(/+/&%&(6,( 6@&2"D"5&:+6,"( "( C;:,2+( ,(;:+06:$26$:&'>"?A@,(&0&;,(+(2,(/ 6&:%0%,/@6+;;&26

6@&2"%5&6,6,<&5"0,6,"( ";C;:,2+( ,(<&06":0+(. 2"(06:$26,"( 2"%5+(,&0?+0+P$&06,"( :+,0&. ;":

2"(0,.&:+6,"('C(. 5:"<,.,(/ %":&"55":6$(,6,&0;":#"2+#2"%5+(,&0K3 :&#+H,(/ ,606,&. +,. 5:+26,2&0

?"$#. K&+0,/(,;,2+(62"(6:,K$6,"( K3 A@,(+6" @&#5,(/ C;:,2+( &(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6'

9@&:&+:&P$&06,"(0"( *6*3+'(+7'-'35 +(,3&+(*%+&#()5;?@,2@ +:&,%5":6+(6;":6@&;$##"?(&:0@,5

+(. +22"$(6+K,#,63 ";6@&.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&02"(2&:(&.'4( ":.&:;":C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&06" K&;$##3 ,(

6@&.:,<&:M00&+6,( 6@&,::&#+6,"(0?,6@ .&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0B,6?,##K&,%5":6+(6;":6@&%6" @+<&

%":&2"%5#&6&,(;":%+6,"( +K"$6#&<&#0+(. 2"(.,6,"(0";+00,06+(2&+(. "( 6@&&;;&26,<&6&:%0";

<+:,"$02"%%&:2,+#.&+#06@+65+:6(&:0+:&K:,(/,(/ 6" 6@&6+K#&'

=91).6(3&'#*+&#&#76'-,'(8 3"#'&,#4#-.%0#(3*6%%.&3/.&9/&')+ '(3"#/'#-,*./+8&')6-36&#

+(,'(/&+*3&6)36&#;+/3#&3@. ,#)+,#*./,#)-'(#'(3"#*#+&#+*L9@&3 +:&+#0" ;"2$0,(/ ,( 6@&

2"(6&H6";6@&D,%#-T)&5,%,3#'1 '1 ;#* F22)&3#8)1)--+(. 6@&;&&%, ;()1*, 2'%;&3#'17,( 5+:6(&:0@,5

?,6@ C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0+(. "6@&:.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0B"( 0$55":6,(/ 06:"(/ .&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:3

"?(&:0@,5B2"$(6:3 5$K#,2%+(+/&%&(60306&%0B:&0$#60D;"2$00&. +55:"+2@&0+(. #"2+#+22"$(6+K,#,63'

1:"<,.,(/ %":&5:&.,26+K,#,63 ,( +,. ;#"?0+(. ?":Q,(/ ,( #"(/&:6,%&;:+%&0:&%+,( 2@+##&(/&0,( 6@,0

2"(6&H6'

9/&')+2*#$3#&(+-#).(.0')-'(J+8#*+&#+-*. 7#'(8 #(&')"#,75 3"#+)3'4'35 ./.3"#&#0#&8'(8

0+&J#3#).(.0'#*LC (&? 0&6";2"%5+:+6,<&+.<+(6+/&0+(. 2"%5#&%&(6+:,6,&0,0&%&:/,(/ ,(

C;:,2+M0;":&,/( &2"("%,2:&#+6,"(0@,50+(. ,6,0,%5":6+(66@+6C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0+:&+K#&6" 0@+5&

6@&0&,(6&:+26,"(0,( 6&:%0";6@&,:"?( .&<&#"5%&(6;:+%&?":Q0+(. .&6&:%,(&6@&,:"?( .&<&#"5%&(6

5+6@0'

9**'*3'(8 9/&')+().6(3&'#*3. "+4#'(,#%#(,#(3,#4#-.%0#(3)+%+)'3'#*'*+ 7+*');*"+&#,

.7A#)3'4#./1"'(+ +(,GH1=M=91).6(3&'#*LA$::&(6.&<&#"5%&(60,( A@,(&0&+(. ECA2"D

"5&:+6,"( 5"#,2,&0?@,2@ 5:"%,0&6" ,%5:"<&6@&2"@&:&(2&+(. P$+#,63 ";6@&0$55":6;":C;:,2+(

.&<&#"5%&(6,(2#$.&)

!

%9@&5$K#,2+6,"( K3 A@,(+";6?" /"<&:(%&(6X@,6&1+5&:0'

!

%9@&+/:&&%&(66@+66@&C;:,2+( \(,"( ?,##("?K&+;$##%&%K&:";6@&-'ACA'

!

%C5$K#,206+6&%&(6K3 6@&ECA?&#2"%,(/ 6@&,(2:&+0,(/ :"#&";&%&:/,(/ 2"$(6:,&0+0

5:"<,.&:0";.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&'

!

%9@&5:&5+:+6,"(0;":6@&S$0+( >,/@D]&<&#-":$%"( C,. 8;;&26,<&(&00'

;)%$'.%)0$31 %$-3*).*)%,0 '*3#%4)0'.*$'#9#4#,#0'

8(6&:5:,0&0BC;:,2+( +(. ;":&,/(B?,##@+<&+Q&3 :"#&,( 0@+5,(/ 6@&;$6$:&.&<&#"5%&(65+6@ ;":

C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0'C/+,(066@,0K+2Q/:"$(.B).&%.&+3#*.)'+-&#*%.(*'7'-'3'#*+(,8&##(8&.@3"

)"+--#(8#*+(,.%%.&36('3'#*+&#'0%.&3+(3+&#+*/.&).<.%#&+3'.(+0.(8 +--,#4#-.%0#(3

%+&3(#&*L9@&A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5 #,(Q&. ,(6" :&#+6,"(0@,50K&6?&&( A@,(&0&+(. C;:,2+(

&%5#"3&:0B&(6&:5:,0&0+(. &H5&:60,( 6@&+:&+";#+K"$:06+(.+:.0+(. 0$55#3 2@+,( %+(+/&%&(6'

"!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 22: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

C( C;:,2+( 5#+6;":%;":.,02$00,(/ 2":5":+6&0"2,+#:&05"(0,K,#,63 ,00$&02"$#. 5#+3 +:"#&,( 6@,0

2"(6&H6'

1"'(+;GH1=+(,.3"#&).6(3&'#*@".*##(3#&%&'*#*+&#+)3'4#'(9/&')+ "+4#+ 0+A.&'(3#&#*3'(

).(3&'763'(8 +)3'4#-5 3. 3"#,#4#-.%0#(3./9/&')+(#).(.0')8.4#&(+()#+&&+(8#0#(3*'(3"#*#

+&#+*L

#!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 23: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

>0**#$*+#(C0/0:#7%0$,8#E#70(),&#$

B"%,!"#$% 3%$40%)$

1"'(+ "+*,#4.3#,06)""'8"<-#4#-+33#(3'.(3. 9/&')+(,#4#-.%0#(3.4#&3"#,#)+,#*;@'3"

&#86-+&4'*'3*75 3.%-#+,#&*+(,;'(3"#-+*3,#)+,#;"+*)&#+3#,3"# G191+(,+**.)'+3#,

%&.)#**#*/.&+&3')6-+3'(8 +(,'0%-#0#(3'(8 '3*+**'*3+()#3. 9/&')+LC(&?A@,(+DC;:,2+=&0&+:2@

A&(6:&@+0K&&( 0&6$5'A@,(+5+:6,2,5+6&0,( \Y5&+2&Q&&5,(/ %,00,"(0,( C;:,2+'46@+0+#0" 2:&+6&.

;,(+(2,+#,(06,6$6,"(0+(. ,(06:$%&(60;":";;,2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6;,(+(2,(/'9@&05&2,+#+.<+(6+/&0";

A@,(&0&+,. ,( 05&&. +(. 2"06B&05&2,+##3 ,( ,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. 2"(06:$26,"(B+(. ,60:&05"(0,<&(&006"

#"2+#:&P$&060+:&+55:&2,+6&. ,( C;:,2+'4( 6@&#+06;&?%"(6@0BA@,(+@+05$K#,0@&. 6?" 0,/(,;,2+(6

X@,6&1+5&:0)

!

%G(3&+,#+(,#).(.0')).<.%#&+3'.(@'3"9/&')+ ?@,2@ &H5:&00&. A@,(+M0.&0,:&6" ?":Q

?,6@ "6@&:06" O",(6#3 5:"%"6&5&+2&B.&<&#"5%&(6+(. 5:"/:&00,( C;:,2+'

!

%G(/.&#'8(+',;?@,2@ 5:"<,.&. +( "<&:<,&?";A@,(+M0+,. &;;":60+(. 5"#,2,&0"<&:6@&

5+06.&2+.&0+(. +(("$(2&. +(&?,(6&:%,(,06&:,+#2"D":.,(+6,"( 0306&% ;":%+(+/,(/ ,60

;":&,/( +,. +(. 5#+(06" ,(2:&+0&+,. P$+#,63 +(. 6" ?":Q +(. #&+:( ?,6@ ,(6&:(+6,"(+#

.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0,( 6@,0:&05&26'

!"#1"'(+<=91 >36,5 ?&.6%/.6(,3"+31"'(+ ).6-,).(3&'763#/6&3"#&3. 9/&')+(

,#4#-.%0#(375X

!

[N&'(8'(8 0.&#./'3*3&+(*/.&0+3'.(+-3"'(J'(8 '(3. '3*%.-')5 ,'+-.86#@'3"9/&')+L

!

[_#-%'(8 3. *".@".@3"#-#+&('(8 0.,#-./,#4#-.%0#(3)+(@.&J3. 76'-,3"#)+%+)'35

/.&,'4#&*'/'#,%+&3')'%+3'.('(3"#8-.7+-#).(.05;'()-6,'(8 3"&.68"-#+&('(8 /&.0

/.&#'8(+',+(,'(4#*30#(3L

!

[>6%%.&3'(8 9/&')+(Z('.(*3&6)36&#*+(,%.-')5 /&+0#@.&J*+(,@.&J'(8 0.&#+33"#

&#8'.(+-+(,*67&#8'.(+--#4#-*;'()-6,'(8 3. ,#4#-.%'(3#&&#8'.(+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#+(,

J(.@-#,8#%-+3/.&0*L

!

[_#-%'(8 9/&')+().6(3&'#*3. -#+&(/&.03"#@+5*1"'(+ *6))#**/6--5 0+(+8#,+',+(,

/.&#'8('(4#*30#(3;%+&3')6-+&-5 3"&.68"'(3#8&+3'.(./+',%&.A#)30+(+8#0#(3'(3.

&#86-+&0'('*3&5 *3&6)36&#*L

!

[N#'(8 0.&#3&+(*%+&#(3'('3*+',%&.8&+00'(8 +(,3"#3#&0*./'3*/'(+()'(8;+(,

+**'*3'(8 9/&')+().6(3&'#*'(3"#+**#**0#(3.//'(+()'+-*6*3+'(+7'-'35 '**6#*L

!

[_#-%'(8 3. '0%-#0#(39/&')+(+(,'(3#&(+3'.(+-).,#*.().&&6%3'.(;&#*.6&)#&#4#(6#*

+(,).&%.&+3#*.)'+-&#*%.(*'7'-'35L

!

[>3&#(83"#('(8 J(.@-#,8#+7.639/&')+().(,'3'.(*+0.(8 +',*3+//@.&J'(8 .(+(,'(

9/&')+L

!

[K.&J'(8 .('3*+',Q6+-'35 +8#(,+ +(,'(3&.,6)'(8 + *5*3#0+3')+%%&.+)"3. '3*+',

0+(+8#0#(3*5*3#0*;'()-6,'(8 %-+(('(8;0.('3.&'(8 +(,#4+-6+3'.(*5*3#0*L

$!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 24: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

B"%,C7!5D5:!60690)'3%$40%)$

GH1=M=910#07#&*%&.4',#+ @',#&+(8#./*6%%.&33. 9/&')+().6(3&'#*;'()-6,'(8 %&.A#)3;

*#)3.&+(,76,8#3*6%%.&3L9@&3 @+<&K&&( ?":Q,(/ ?,6@ C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0,( +<+:,&63 ";;":$%06"

,%5:"<&+,. &;;&26,<&(&00B+(. 6@&ECA@"0606@&1+:,0E&2#+:+6,"( ;"##"?D$5 5:"2&00B?@,2@ ("?@+0

+.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:3 2"D2@+,:B+(. +9+0Q 9&+% "( F"$6@DF"$6@ A"D"5&:+6,"('9@&:&,0("?+(

&H5#,2,6&;;":6B;"2$0&. "( .&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0 "?( 2"(2&:(0B6" 2"::&266@&&H2&002"060+(.

5&:<&:0&,(2&(6,<&0";+( &H6&(0,<&+,. 0306&% ?,6@ %$#6,5#&.&#,<&:3 2@+((&#0+(. 2"(.,6,"(0+(.

2"%5#&H 5:"2&00&0']+:/&.&2#,(&0,( +,. 6" +/:,2$#6$:&+(. ,(;:+06:$26$:&,( 6@&&$$"0B+0+,. #&<&#0

;&##+(. 0"2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6+(. /"<&:(+(2&+00,06+(2&:"0&B+:&("?K&,(/ :&<&:0&. +06@&/:"?6@B

+/:,2$#6$:&+(. +,.D;":D6:+.&+/&(.+0:&2&,<&(&?+66&(6,"('C,. 6" C;:,2+@+0/:"?( 0,/(,;,2+(6#3 "<&:

:&2&(63&+:0B6@"$/@ :&%+,(,(/ 0"%&.,06+(2&;:"%6@&+(("$(2&. 6+:/&6";."$K#,(/ +,. K3 #"&!'C

($%K&:";"6@&:,%5":6+(6'8AE?":Q +:&+0+:&+#0" /&(&:+6,(/ 2"D"5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2+B("6+K#3 "(

6+H+6,"( +.%,(,06:+6,"( +(. ,(6&:(+6,"(+#6+H ,(6&/:,63B,(<&06%&(6+(. 5$K#,2&H5&(.,6$:&%+(+/&%&(6'

C(. 6@&'8AE @&#500$55":66@&C;:,2+( 1+:6(&:0@,5 -":$% ?@,2@ %+,(6+,(0+.,+#"/$&5:"2&00

+00"2,+6&. ?,6@ 6@&G-'9@&ECA@+0:&2&(6#3 ,00$&. +06+6&%&(6?&#2"%,(/ 6@&05&2,+#2"(6:,K$6,"(

";.&<&#"5%&(6&H5&:,&(2&+(. 2"D"5&:+6,"( 2+5+2,6,&0;:"%&%&:/,(/ 2"$(6:,&0+(. +(&?"5&((&006"

6@&,:5+:6,2,5+6,"( ,( ECA+26,<,6,&0'

!"#1"'(+<=91>36,5 ?&.6%/.6(,3"+3GH1=M=910#07#&*).6-,).(3&'763#/6&3"#&3.

9/&')+(,#4#-.%0#(375X

!

[ &+0'(8 3"#'&).<.%#&+3'.('(3#&0*./3"##).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**;8.'(8

7#5.(,+',#//#)3'4#(#**3. + @',#&,#4#-.%0#(3#//#)3'4#(#**).()#%3+%%-'#,3. 9/&')+L

!

[=.'(8 0.&#3. "#-%76'-,*)'#()#+(,3#)"(.-.85 )+%+)'3'#*;"'8"#&#,6)+3'.(*5*3#0*

+(,J(.@-#,8#%-+3/.&0*;@'3"3"#%.3#(3'+-/.&)&#+3'(8 &#8'.(+-+(,).(3'(#(3+-

(#3@.&J*J#%3'(4'#@;,&+@'(8 .(3"#'&#$%#&'#()#'(3"#*#/'#-,*@'3"1"'(+ +(,.3"#&

#0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*L

!

[>6%%.&3'(8 9/&')+(Z('.(*3&6)36&#*+(,%.-')5 /&+0#@.&J*L

!

[_#-%'(8 3. '0%-#0#(39/&')+(+(,'(3#&(+3'.(+-).,#*.().&&6%3'.(;&#*.6&)#&#4#(6#*

+(,).&%.&+3#*.)'+-&#*%.(*'7'-'35L

!

[W+'(3+'('(8 3"#&#)#(30.0#(360 ./*6%%.&3/.&+8&')6-36&#+(, '(/&+*3&6)36&#

,#4#-.%0#(3;@.&J'(8 '( &#-#4+(3/.&60*@'3" #0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*@'3" *%#)'+-

J(.@-#,8#+(,#$%#&3'*#L

!

[H$+0'('(8 ".@+',&#%.&3'(8 )+(7#33#&)+%36&#3"#3#)"(')+-).<.%#&+3'.(+)3'4'3'#*./

#0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*'(3#&0*3"#'&'0%+)3;+(,(.3A6*33"#'&0.(#3+&5 ).*3L

!

[D#4'#@'(8 ".@).0%+&+3'4#+,4+(3+8#;).*3*3&6)36&#*+(,).0%-#0#(3+&'3'#*0+5 7#

*"'/3'(8 +0.(8 +**'*3+()#%&.4',#&*+*#0#&8'(8 %+&3(#&*76'-,6%3"#'&+',+)3'4'3'#*L

!

[H$%-.&'(8 ".@3&+,#;'(4#*30#(3+(,+',-'(J+8#*+(,/'(+()'(8 %+)J+8#*)+(0.7'-'*#

+,,'3'.(+-+)3.&*+(,)+%'3+-/.&#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**#*'(9/&')+L

%!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 25: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

B"%,:8)#3%$3*2$,)#0'3%$40%)$

9/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3*'(3"#1"'(+<=91 >36,5 ?&.6%2*#4#(3*@#&#,#3#&0'(#,3"+33"#'&

).6(3&'#**".6-,,#/'(#3"#'&.@(/636&#*L9@&3 06:&00&. 6@+65"#,6,2+#+(. &2"("%,2;:+/%&(6+6,"(

%+.&:&/,"(+#,(6&/:+6,"( &00&(6,+#'C(. 6@&3 #""Q&. 6" C;:,2+( #&+.&:06" 6+Q&$5 6@&6+0Q ";2:&+6,(/

+:&05"(0,K#&.&<&#"5%&(6D":,&(6&. 06+6&+K#&6" K:,(/ 6"/&6@&:&6@(,2+##3 2"%5#&H 0"2,&6,&0+(. &(0$:&

5&+2&+(. 5:"/:&00,( 6@&,:(&,/@K"$:@"".0'4( ;+26BC;:,2+( ,(06,6$6,"(0+(. 5"#,23 +(+#30,0+(.

:&<,&?5:"2&00&0@+<&K&&( /&66,(/ 06:"(/&:"<&:6@&#+06.&2+.&'1"#,23 ;:+%&?":Q0+(. &2"("%,2

%+(+/&%&(6+:&2#&+:#3 ,%5:"<,(/'=&/,"(+#&2"("%,22"%%$(,6,&0+:&2"%5#&H +(. "<&:#+55,(/ +(.

:&/,"(+#&2"("%,2#,(Q+/&0+:&/:"?,(/ "(#3 0#"?#3BK$66@&:&+:&(&? ,%5$#0&0'C/:,2$#6$:+#

.&<&#"5%&(6@+0K&2"%&+@,/@ 5:,":,63 ?,6@ +( +26,<&B2"(6,(&(6+#+/&(.+'A"%%$(,2+6,"(

6&2@("#"/,&0+(. K$0,(&00%".&#0@+<&K&&( ;"$(. 6@+6?":Q ?,6@ /:&+60$22&00,( C;:,2+'S$6

2"%5&6,6,<&&#,6&0+(. &6@(,2,6,&0+:&06,##+%+O":5:"K#&% ,( +($%K&:";2"$(6:,&0'9@&C;:,2+(

\(,"( @+06@&.,;;,2$#66+0Q ";;+2,#,6+6,(/ 0"#$6,"(06" 0$2@ 5:"K#&%0'46@+06" K&:&2+##&.B@"?&<&:B

6@+6%+(3 &%&:/,(/ &2"("%,&0";6".+3 K&/+( 6@&,:0$22&0006":,&0;:"%0,6$+6,"(0";2"(;#,26+(.

6$:%",#B?@,2@ 6:+(0;":%+6,"(+##&+.&:0@,5 ?+0+K#&6" :&0"#<&'9@&:&+:&2#&+:&H+%5#&0";6@,0,(

C;:,2+?@,2@ 2+( 0&:<&+0+( ,(05,:+6,"( ;":0$06+,(+K#&5"#,6,2+#0&66#&%&(60,( 6@&:&%+,(,(/ 6:"$K#&.

5+:60";6@&2"(6,(&(6'

!"#1"'(+<=91 >36,5 ?&.6% /.6(, 3"+39/&')+( ).6(3&'#*).6-, ).(3&'763#/6&3"#&3.

,#4#-.%0#(3+3".0#75X

!

[ .*3#&'(8 3"##0#&8#()#./+ &#*%.(*'7-#;,#4#-.%0#(3<.&'#(3#,*3+3#@'3"+ %.-'3')+-

).(*#(*6*3"+3&#+)"#*+)&.**).0%#3'3'4##-'3#*+(,#3"(')'3'#*L

!

[!+J'(8 3"##).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%+&+,'80;@.&J'(8 3"&.68",5(+0'))+%+)'35

%&.)#**#*+*3"#/&+0#@.&J/.&,#4#-.%0#(3*3&+3#8'#*;(+3'.(+--5 +(,&#8'.(+--5L

N&'(8'(8 ,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*3. 3"'(J'(3"#*#3#&0*+-*.;+(,%&#*#(3'(8 *3&+3#8'#*

+(,.%#&+3'.(+-%&.8&+00#*+(,%&.A#)3*'(3"'*).(3#$3L

!

[C6*"'(8 +"#+,@'3"3"#&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.(+8#(,+ +(,/'(,'(8 )&#+3'4#*.-63'.(*3. 3"#

,#4#-.%0#(3./'(3#&<&#8'.(+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#L

!

[D#'(/.&)'(8 3"#%&'.&'35 /.&+8&')6-36&+-0.,#&('*+3'.(+(,'3*&.-#'()&#+3'(8 +

7&.+,-5 7+*#,8&.@3",5(+0');(+3'.(+--5 +(,&#8'.(+--5L

!

[ #4#&+8'(8 3"#).006(')+3'.(*&#4.-63'.('(9/&')+ 3. #$%-.'3'3*%.3#(3'+-/.&-#+%/&.88'(8

'(J(.@-#,8#+)Q6'*'3'.(+(,#(3#&%&'*#)&#+3'.(+(,8-.7+-#).(.0')-'(J+8#*L

!

[=#4#-.%'(8 /6&3"#&3"#%.-')5 +(+-5*'*+(,&#4'#@)+%+)'3'#*+(,%&.)#**#*(.@'(%-+)#

'(9/&')+ /.&%&+80+3')%.-')5 0+J'(8 +(,%#&/.&0+()#&#4'#@LH(*6&'(8 3"+33"#)'4'-

*#&4')#'*%#&/.&0+()#.&'#(3#,L

!

[1&#+3'(8 )-.*#'(3#&+)3'.(*7#3@##(3"#*3+3#+(,0+&J#3#(3#&%&'*#*'(+ /.&@+&,<-..J'(8

%#&/.&0+()#<7+*#,0.,#+(,%&.0.3'(8 -#+&('(8 +(,3#)"(.-.85 +)Q6'*'3'.()+%+)'3'#*L

!

[!+J'(8 '(*%'&+3'.( /&.0 *6))#**/6-#0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*; '()-6,'(8 *#)6&'(8 3"#

0+$'0607#(#/'3/&.0 '(3#&(+3'.(+-+**'*3+()#75 *3&#(83"#('(8 .@(#&*"'%;)+%+)'35

,#4#-.%0#(3+(,0636+--#+&('(8L

&!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 26: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

')F&$; ,60 G#(F #+,60 86&$)EC<8D,3-1 H(#37I#(5)(-

9)"'#4'(8 3"#Z('3#,a+3'.(*W'--#(('60=#4#-.%0#(3?.+-*'*+ ).00.(.7A#)3'4#/.&1"'(+

+(,=910#07#&*L9@&:&,0+#0" +/:&&%&(66@+66@&,(6&:(+6,"(+#2"%%$(,63 0@"$#. 06:&(/6@&( 2"D

"5&:+6,"( +(. O",(6#3 :,0&6" 6@&2@+##&(/&0;+2,(/ .&<&#"5%&(6B,(2#$.,(/ 6@&(&?2@+##&(/&0";

2#,%+6&2@+(/&B;"". 0&2$:,63B&(&:/3 0&2$:,63 +(. &5,.&%,2.,0&+0&0?@,2@ @+<&+//:+<+6&. &H,06,(/

,%K+#+(2&0,( 6@&/#"K+#&2"("%3 +(. ?,.&(&. 6@&/+5 K&6?&&( :,2@ +(. 5"":5&"5#&'

.&'3*%+&3;3"#1"'(+<=91>36,5 ?&.6%@'--3+J#/6&3"#&'3*'((.4+3'4#&.-#.//.&8'(8 +

0636+--#+&('(8 &#-+3'.(*"'%7#3@##(1"'(+ +(,=91W#07#&*3. %&.0.3#8&.@3"+(,&#,6)#

%.4#&35 '(,#4#-.%'(8 ).6(3&'#*LE$:,(/ #"&&D&#B6@&F6$.3 G:"$5M0%+,( %".+#,63 ?,##2@+(/&

;:"%#+:/&D;":%+66@&%+6,22"(;&:&(2&06" +#,%,6&. ($%K&:";+26,"(D":,&(6&. ="$(.6+K#&0'9@&0&

2"$#. 6+Q&6@&;":%";5#+6;":%0;":0@+:,(/ &H,06,(/ Q("?#&./&+(. &H5&:,&(2&J;"2+#5",(60;":O",(6

06$.,&0+(. ;,&#. ?":Q +66@&2"$(6:3 "::&/,"(+##&<&#J":O",(6+00&00%&(60V&<+#$+6,"( ?":Q0@"50'

9@&="$(.6+K#&0?,##2"(6,($&6" K&"5&( 5:"2&00&0K:,(/,(/ 6"/&6@&:(+6,"(+#+(. ,(6&:(+6,"(+#

";;,2,+#0B&H5&:60B5:,<+6&0&26":+(. 2,<,#0"2,&63 5+:6,2,5+(60"( +;#&H,K#&K+0,06" /&(&:+6&%$6$+#

#&+:(,(/ "( 6"5,20";2"%%"( ,(6&:&06'9@,02+( @&#5 ,(;":% 5"#,23 %+Q,(/ ,( +%$#6,5"#+:?":#.

?@&:&5:"05&:,63B0$06+,(+K,#,63 +(. 5&+2&+:&K"6@ 5"00,K#&+(. (&2&00+:3 ;":%+(3 %":&5&"5#&6@+(

&<&:K&;":&+(. &00&(6,+#;":@+:%"(,"$0?":#. .&<&#"5%&(6'

!"#@.&J./3"#1"'(+<=91>36,5 ?&.6%)+(+-*. /+)'-'3+3#%.-')5 ,'+-.86#7#3@##(1"'(+ +(,

3"#=91.('(3#&(+3'.(+-,#4#-.%0#(3).<.%#&+3'.(L

'!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 27: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction
Page 28: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&')

C0/0:#7%0$,.)(,$0(*6&7*

+#(H(#5,6)$-.#/0(,1 20-3",&#$

J0&K&$;986&$)9LMELN?",#O0(LPPN

)!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 29: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

=)&$=0**);0*

E0''*$'8)*6!"#$%

!

71"'(+2*#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(@+**%+&J#,75 '3*(+3'.(+-%&.A#)3;+,.%3#,'(3"#

-+3#IRUS*;3. 7#).0#+ 0',,-#<'().0#).6(3&5 @'3"'(+ 8#(#&+3'.(;@'3"+ ,#)'*'4#

&#,6)3'.('(%.4#&35L9@&A@,(&0&#&+.&:0@,5 ?+006:"(/#3 2"%%,66&. 6" ?":Q,(/ ;":6@&

K&(&;,6";6@&?@"#&(+6,"(''?(&:0@,5 ";6@,0(+6,"(+#5:"O&26?+005:&+. ?,.&#3 +(. .&&5#3

?,6@,( A@,(+'aS"66"%D$5b,(,6,+6,<&0+6<,##+/&+(. 5:"<,(2,+##&<&#0?&:&&(2"$:+/&. K3 +(

+26,<&06+6&'-":,605+:6B6@&06+6&,(<&06&. ,( 5$K#,2/"".0B6@:"$/@ &H5&:,%&(6+#

+55:"+2@&0;"##"?&. K3 :+5,. 02+#,(/ $5 ";0$22&00;$#02@&%&0'=&;":%02:&+6&. +%".&:(B

0%+##;+:%&:DK+0&. +/:,2$#6$:&+(. +2"%5&6,6,<&&(6&:5:,0&&2"("%3'

!

%1"'(+ +)3'4#-5 *.68"3,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*"'%*3. +))#-#&+3#'3*3&+(*/.&0+3'.(

%&.)#**L-":&,/( +,. 2"(6:,K$6&. 0,/(,;,2+(6#3'C,. 0$55":6&. ,(;:+06:$26$:&.&<&#"5%&(6+(.

,(.$06:,+#+(. +/:,2$#6$:+#%".&:(,0+6,"(B+0?&##+00"2,+#.&<&#"5%&(60$2@ +0,( &.$2+6,"(

+(. @&+#6@'F$K0&P$&(6#3B6@&:&?+0+6:+(0;&:";,.&+0+(. Q("?#&./&+(. ,(06,6$6,"(+#

2+5+2,63 +2:"00+?,.&:+(/&";0&26":0+(. 5$K#,2%+(+/&%&(6'

!

%9-#+&('(8 )6-36&#"#-%#,3. +))#-#&+3#3"#)+3)"<6%%&.)#**+(,&#,6)#%.4#&35L9@,0

2$#6$:&,(<"#<&. .&<&#"5,(/ 6@&2+5+2,63 6" /&(&:+6&+(. 2:,6,2+##3 :&<,&? 5"#,2,&0'9@&

@,/@&:&.$2+6,"( 0&26":@+0K&&( /:&+6#3 &H5+(.&. +(. +?,.&:+(/&";:&0&+:2@ ,(06,6$6&0

2:&+6&.'9@&2,<,#0&:<,2&,02"%5&6,6,<&#3 :&2:$,6&. +(. #&+.&:0@,5 0&#&26,"( 5:"2&00&0+:&

K$,#6+:"$(. &H5&:,&(2&B0$22&00+(. :"6+6,"('

!

%!"#1"'(#*#+63".&'3'#*%&.8&#**'4#-5 ,#4#-.%#,+(#//#)3'4#*5*3#0/.&0+(+8'(8 /.&#'8(

+',L9@,0K&2+%&+( ,(6&/:+#5+:6";6@&(+6,"(+#&2"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"( 5:"2&00+(.

%&2@+(,0%0;":+##"2+6,(/ :&0"$:2&0BK"6@ +2:"00%,(,06:,&0+0?&##+06" 5:"<,(2&0+(. "6@&:

#"2+#+.%,(,06:+6,"(0'9@&:&?+0(" ."(":2"(0$#6+6,<&/:"$5 0306&%'1:"O&26%+(+/&%&(6

?+05:"<,.&. 6@:"$/@ ,%5#&%&(6+6,"( $(,60?,6@,( 6@&&06+K#,0@&. 5$K#,2+.%,(,06:+6,"(

06:$26$:&0+(. 5+3 02+#&0'A@,(&0&5:"O&26%+(+/&:0?&:&05&2,+##3 6:+,(&. +(. &(2"$:+/&. 6" K&

+26,<&2"D":.,(+6":0'9@&,:&H5&:,&(2&?+0<+#$&. ,( 6@&,:0$K0&P$&(62+:&&:0'

!

%1"'(+ "+*'3*.@(;bS 5#+&<-.(8 3&+,'3'.(./%&.4','(8 +',3. /.&#'8().6(3&'#*L'<&:

6,%&B6@&;"2$0";6@&0&5:"/:+%%&0@+00@,;6&. ;:"%+K+0,0,( 5"#,6,2+#;:,&(.0@,5 6" +

;"$(.+6,"( ,( %$6$+#&2"("%,2K&(&;,6'A@,(&0&.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&,0("? 5:"<,.&.

6@:"$/@ %,(,06:,&0B06+6&&(6&:5:,0&0+(. ;,(+(2,+#,(06,6$6,"(0+(. 5:"<,(2,+#K".,&0B?,6@,(

+( ,(6&:%,(,06&:,+#2"D":.,(+6,"( 0306&% ?,6@ +K:"+.&:.&<&#"5%&(6+(. &2"("%,22"D

"5&:+6,"( 5&:05&26,<&'4( 6@,02"(6&H6BA@,(&0&&(6&:5:,0&0+:&+#0" &(2"$:+/&. 6" ,(<&06,(

.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0'

=2..*),#$( :8)#3%&',)%$'8*)6%,#*$

!

%!"#&# +&# *'8('/')+(3 -#**.(* 3"+3 9/&')+ )+( ,&+@ /&.0 1"'(+2* #).(.0')

3&+(*/.&0+3'.(#$%#&'#()#L9@&0&#&00"(0:&%+,( <+#,.B.&05,6&6@&.,;;&:&(2&0,( 5"#,6,2+#B

@$%+( +(. 5@30,2+#/&"/:+5@3 +(. @,06":3'

*"

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 30: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!

% .&0+(5 9/&')+(*;3"#&#'*+ &#+-'*+3'.(3"+33"#'&(.@ 0.&#,'4#&*##).(.0')

%+&3(#&*"'%*%&.4',#(#@.%%.&36('3'#*/.&,#3#&0'('(8 3"#'&#).(.0')/636&#LC;:,2+(

2"$(6:,&0("?@+<&+?,.&::+(/&";.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:06@+( &<&( +.&2+.&+/"B?,6@ 6@&

&%&:/,(/ 2"$(6:,&0B,(2#$.,(/ A@,(+B5#+3,(/ ,(2:&+0,(/#3 ,%5":6+(6+(. .3(+%,2:"#&0,( +,.B

6:+.&+(. ,(<&06%&(6:&#+6,"(0@,50B+#"(/0,.&6@&:&#+6,"(0@,50?,6@ 5+:6(&:0,( '8AE2"$(6:,&0'

!

%!"#3'0#'*&'%#/.&+(#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.('(9/&')+L'<&:+/&(&:+6,"(BC;:,2+6""

2+( 2:&+6&%,..#&D,(2"%&2"$(6:,&0+(. :&.$2&5"<&:63 "( +%+00,<&02+#&B+0A@,(+@+0'

C;:,2+M0,%5:"<&. /:"?6@ 5&:;":%+(2&"<&:6@&#+06.&2+.&BK+0&. "( ,%5:"<&. &2"("%,2

/"<&:(+(2&B.&K6:&.$26,"( 5:"2&00&0+(. /:"?,(/ @$%+( 2+5,6+#B%+Q&6@,0;&+0,K#&'

=&2&(6+.<+(2&0,( #"?D2"06,(;":%+6,"( +(. 2"%%$(,2+6,"(06&2@("#"/,&02+( 05&&. $5 6@&

6:+(0;":%+6,"( 5:"2&00&0'

!

%9/&')+2*,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*(##,3. *6%%.&39/&')+(*3&6)36&#*+33"#).(3'(#(3+-+(,

&#8'.(+--#4#-*/.&#).(.0');%.-'3')+-+(,*#)6&'35 ).<.%#&+3'.(LX,6@ "<&:!" 0"<&:&,/(

06+6&0B";6&( <&:3 0%+##B6@&:&+:&%+(3 5"#,6,2+#2"%5#&H,6,&06@+62:&+6&.,;;,2$#62@+##&(/&0

";#&+.&:0@,5 +(. 2"(;#,26:&0"#$6,"('4( 6@,02"(6&H6B+##";C;:,2+M0.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0

0@"$#. ,(<&06,( &2"("%,2+(. 5&+2&K$,#.,(/ ,(,6,+6,<&0+2:"00K":.&:0B6" @&#5 2:&+6&

C;:,2+( .&<&#"5%&(6.3(+%,206@+6&(2"%5+00+/:,2$#6$:+#+(. .&%"/:+5@,25"6&(6,+#+(.

2+56$:&6@&K&(&;,60";(+6$:+#:&0"$:2&&H6:+26,"('

!

%9/&')+2*)+%+)'35 3. *"+%#'3*#$3#&(+-#).(.0')&#-+3'.(*@'--,#3#&0'(#3"#'0%+)3./

#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(.(&#,6)'(8 %.4#&35L9@&:&+:&("?%$#6,5#&;:+%&?":Q0;":

.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50?,6@ C;:,2+'9@&0&,(2#$.&6@&-'ACAN-":$%"( A@,(+DC;:,2+

A"D"5&:+6,"(I+(. "6@&:&%&:/,(/ 2"$(6:3VC;:,2+;":$%0+0?&##+05+:6(&:0@,50?,6@

<+:,"$0'8AE %&%K&:0' C;:,2+(02+( &(0$:& 6@+66@&0& <+:,"$0 5+:6(&:0@,50+:&

2"%5#&%&(6+:3 +(. .:+?"( 6@&5:"2&00&0;":C;:,2+( 5"#,6,2+#B&2"("%,2+(. 0&2$:,63 2"D

"5&:+6,"( +0?&##+0C;:,2+( 5#+6;":%0;":,(6&##&26$+##&+.&:0@,5'

!

%G@(#&*"'%;)+%+)'35 ,#4#-.%0#(3+(,0636+--#+&('(8 @#&#J#5 #-#0#(3*./1"'(+2*

+%%&.+)" 3. 8#33'(8 3"#0+$'060 7#(#/'3/&.0 '(3#&(+3'.(+-+**'*3+()#L 9@&0&

;$(.+%&(6+#":,&(6+6,"(0?,##+#0" 0&:<&C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0?&##+06@&3 ?":Q ?,6@ 6@&,:

%$#6,5#&.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0'

!"

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 31: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

C0/0:#7%0$,!B70(&0$"0*&$86&$) )$-<+(&") &$,60 >)*,

'6(00 C0")-0*

C/0)/#0+

!"#*3&'J'(8-5 ,'//#&#(3,#4#-.%0#(3#$%#&'#()#*+(,)"+--#(8#*'(1"'(+ +(,'(9/&')+ .4#&3"#

-+*33"'&35 5#+&*%&.4',#+ &')"7+)J,&.%/.&',#(3'/5'(8 8#(#&+--#**.(*/.&,#4#-.%0#(3

%+&3(#&*"'%*L

C+&3')'%+(3*'(3"#1"'(+<=91>36,5 ?&.6%#4#(3.(,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*"'%*&#).8('*#,3"+3

3"#4#&5 ,'//#&#(3%.-'3')+-+(,#).(.0')8#.8&+%"'#*+*@#--+*3"#"'*3.&'#*./1"'(+ +(,9/&')+

0#+(3"+3*6)"8#(#&+--#**.(*(##,3. 7#)+&#/6--5 /.&06-+3#,;7#+&'(8 '(0'(,3"#/6(,+0#(3+-

,'//#&#()#*X

!

%1"'(+;+*+ -+&8#6('3+&5 *3+3#?,6@ 0&<&:+#6@"$0+(. 3&+:0";&H5&:,&(2&B@+0+.,;;&:&(6

0&6";2+5+2,6,&06@+( 3"#9/&')+().(3'(#(3./0.&#3"+(cS "'8"-5 4+&'#,*3+3#*B%"06

@+<,(/ /+,(&. ,(.&5&(.&(2&"(#3 0"%&*" 3&+:0+/"'

!

%d6*3VS 5#+&*+8.;1"'(+ @+*%..&#&3"+(0.*39/&')+().6(3&'#*+(,@+*A6*3

7#8'(('(8 3. ).0%&#"#(*'4#-5 &#/.&0'3*#).(.0')0.,#-+(,%.-'3')+-%&'()'%-#*LA@,(+

?+006,###+:/&#3 $(2"((&26&. ?,6@ 6@&?":#. &2"("%3'

!

%933"+3*+0#0.0#(3;'(IReS;9/&')+().6(3&'#*"+,*%#(33@. ,#)+,#**##J'(8

%+3"@+5*/.&@+&,;#).(.0')+--5 +(,%.-'3')+--5;/&.0+ )#(36&5 ./).-.('+-&6-#+(,./

)#(36&'#*./&#*.6&)##$%-.'3+3'.(B,(2#$.,(/ 6@&&H5#",6+6,"( ";@$%+( :&0"$:2&0<,+6@&

0#+<&6:+.&K&;":&6@+6'>$%+( +(. ,(06,6$6,"(+#2+5,6+#?+002+:2&+66@+66,%&''( 6@&"6@&:

@+(.B,(6&/:+6,"( ";%,(&:+#+(. +/:,2$#6$:+#&H5":6,(.$06:,&0,(6" 6@&?":#. &2"("%3 ?+0

@,/@BK+0&. "( 2"#"(,+#5+66&:(0'F"$6@ C;:,2+?+006,##+( +5+:6@&,. 06+6&'

!"#3&+(*/.&0+3'.(./1"'(+ .4#&3"#*#3"&##,#)+,#*'*+(+*3.6(,'(8 #%.)"'(@.&-,#).(.0')

"'*3.&5L46,0("?6@&0&2"(. #+:/&06&2"("%3 ,( 6@&?":#.B?,6@ %,..#&D,(2"%&06+6$0+(. +%+00,<&

:&.$26,"( ,( 5"<&:63B?,6@ .3(+%,2&H5":6,(.$06:,&00&:<,(/ 6@&?@"#&?":#. ?,6@ ,(&H5&(0,<&

%+($;+26$:&. /"".0B(.@./3#(+33"#-#+,'(8 #,8#./3"#%&.,6)3)5)-#L

!.,+5 1"'(+ /+)#*#).(.0'))"+--#(8#*;7&.68"3.(75 '3**6))#**X

!

%460:"#&,( /#"K+#&2"("%,2/"<&:(+(2&+(. 6@&%+(+/&%&(6";,60#+:/&,(6&:(+6,"(+#

:&0&:<&0'

!

%9@&(&&. 6" :&06:$26$:&6@&A@,(&0&&2"("%3 6" %"<&K&3"(. ,60&H5":6D":,&(6&. /:"?6@

%".&#'

!

%F&:,"$0(&?,(&P$+#,6,&0+(. 5&:0,06,(/ +:&+0";5"<&:63'

!

%\:K+(,0+6,"( +(. &(<,:"(%&(6,00$&0'

!

%9@&/#"K+#2@+##&(/&0";2#,%+6&2@+(/&+(. ,(6&:(+6,"(+#0&2$:,63'

""

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 32: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

=6&'(8 3"'*3'0#./+*3.('*"'(8 %&.8&#**'(1"'(+;%&.-.(8#,+(,).0%-#$ %.-'3')+-*3&688-#*+(,

#).(.0')*".)J*7-.)J#,,#4#-.%0#(3%&.)#**#*'(9/&')+LD#-+3'4#'().0#-#4#-*;+(,*.0#3'0#*

+7*.-63#'().0#-#4#-*;/#--/.&(#+&-5 3@. ,#)+,#*X

!

%9@&#&+.&:0@,5 ;":(+6,"( K$,#.,(/ +(. 6@&K:"+. 5+:6,2,5+6,"( +(. 2+5+2,6,&0(&&.&. 6"

6:+(0;":%6@&,:&2"("%,&0&%&:/&. ,( "(#3 +<&:3 ;&?C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0'

!

%*+(3 #&+.&:0+(. "6@&:Q&3 +26":0?&:&$(+22"$(6+K#&;":&,6@&:5$K#,2;$(.0":&2"("%,2

5&:;":%+(2&'

!

%A,<,#+(. :&/,"(+#+:%&. 2"(;#,260@+66&:&. #,<&0+(. #,<&#,@"".0+(. $(.&:%,(&. ,(<&06%&(6

2"(;,.&(2&'

!

%4(6&:(+6,"(+#&2"("%,2232#&0/&(&:+6&. ,(6&:#,(Q&. 2"%%".,63 5:,2&+(. .&K62:,0&0+(.

;$:6@&:.&5&(.&(23 "( 6@&,(6&:(+6,"(+#;,(+(2,+#+:2@,6&26$:&'

!

%A"::$56&#,6&0.,<&:6&. @$/&0$%0+?+3 ;:"% ,(<&06%&(6,( C;:,2+( .&<&#"5%&(6K3

&H5#",6,(/ #+H ,(6&:(+6,"(+#6+H +(. K+(Q,(/ :&/,%&0+(. &H6&:(+#5"#,6,2+#+(. 2"%%&:2,+#

,(6&:&060'

!"#-+*3,#)+,#"+**##(0.&#%&.0'*'(8 *'8(*L9/&')+ '*(.@7#8'(('(8 3. 7#%#&)#'4#,+*+(

#0#&8'(8 &#8'.(L

N633"##**#(3'+-,#0.8&+%"')+(,+8&')6-36&+-&#4.-63'.(*"+4#*3'--3. 7#'('3'+3#,'(0.*3

9/&')+().6(3&'#*;#4#(+*3"#%&.)#**./,#4#-.%'(8 9/&')+(0+&J#3*+(,*6%%-5 )+%+)'3'#*8#3*

6(,#&@+5L

B(+ 8-.7+-#).(.05 @"#&#(#@%-+5#&*+(,(#@3#)"(.-.8'#*%&.4',#(#@%+3"@+5*/.&)+3)"'(8

6%;3"##0#&8#()#./3"#(#)#**+&5 %.-'3')+-).(,'3'.(*+(,-#+,#&*"'%'(9/&')+ '*3"#J#5 /+)3.&L

>0)'.03,#/0'8)*6!"#$%A;)%$'8*)6%,#*$%$->*/0),1 F0-23,#*$#$

% 50/04*.60$,%4=,%,0

1"'(#*#%+&3')'%+(3*',#(3'/'#,+ *#3./J#5 #-#0#(3*./3"#&#/.&0 %&.)#**3"+3-#,3. 1"'(+2*

*6))#**X

!

%]&+.&:0@,5 ?@,2@ /&(&:+6&. +(. 0$06+,(&. +( ,(05,:,(/ a(+6,"(+#5:"O&26b)+2@,&<,(/ %,..#&D

,(2"%&2"$(6:3 06+6$06@:"$/@ &2"("%,2:&;":%?,6@,( +/&(&:+6,"('

!

%C5:+/%+6,2B0$06+,(&. +55:"+2@ 6" 6@&6:+(0,6,"( 6" +( &(6&:5:,0&DK+0&. %+:Q&6&2"("%3'

!

%9@&&+:#3 0$22&00,( 0@+:5#3 :+,0,(/ +/:,2$#6$:+#5:".$26,"( +(. 5:".$26,<,63B?@,2@ .:"<&+

%+00,<&+(. :+5,. :&.$26,"( ,( 5"<&:63 ?,6@,( +;&?3&+:0'

!

%9@&06+6&+(. 6@&%+:Q&6?&:&K"6@ &00&(6,+#'F6:"(/ ,(<&06%&(6,( 6@&5$K#,2/"".0

N5"#,2,&0B,(06,6$6,"(0+(. ,(;:+06:$26$:&I(&&.&. +6K"6@ 2&(6:+#+(. #"2+#/"<&:(%&(6#&<&#0

;":6@&&%&:/&(2&";+0$22&00;$#&(6&:5:,0&&2"("%3'

1.(3#$36+--5;+/:+00:""60D":,/,(+6&. :&;":%";#+(. 6&($:&0306&%005+:Q&. +( +/:,2$#6$:+#:&<"#$6,"(

+(. +>"(/ Z"(/D#,(Q&. F5&2,+#82"("%,2R"(&5:"<,.&. +:&5#,2+K#&%".&#;":&H5":6D":,&(6&.

%+($;+26$:,(/'4( 2"%K,(+6,"(B6@&0&(&?K$0,(&00%".&#0/&(&:+6&. ;"". 0&2$:,63B0$:5#$02+5,6+#

#"

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 33: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

+(. +%+00,<&;#"?";5&"5#&";;;+:%0,(6" %":&5:".$26,<&&%5#"3%&(6+(. "$6";5"<&:63B?@,#&

06:,26#+?02"(6:"##&. 5"5$#+6,"( /:"?6@'

!"#*#).(3#$36+-/#+36&#*+&#(.3%&#*#(3#-*#@"#&#L9(,1"'(+2**6))#**"+*'3*#-/)"+(8#,3"#

).(3#$3/.&.3"#&,#4#-.%'(8 ).6(3&'#*;)&#+3'(8 (#@.%%.&36('3'#*+(,)"+--#(8#*+(,+ @.&-,

@"#&#3"#).*3./B1!*"+*%-600#3#,;'(%+&3,6#3. -.@0+(6/+)36&'(8 ).*3*'(1"'(+L

N633"#&#+&#0.&#8#(#&+--#**.(*/&.01"'(+2*#$%#&'#()#+*@#--X

!

%1"#,23 %+Q,(/ +(. 2+5+2,63 K$,#.,(/ ?&:&K+0&. "( -#+&('(8 +(,%#&/.&0+()#+*3"#J#5

)&'3#&'.(+(. &<"#<&. +06@&&2"("%3 +(. 0"2,&63 &<"#<&. 6@:"$/@ 6,%&B";6&( ,( $(;":&0&&(

?+30'

!

%9@&A@,(&0&06+6&?+0+K#&6" 6+Q&6@,0+55:"+2@ 6@:"$/@ +4.','(8 *3+3#)+%36&#75 #-'3#*

+(,*%#)'+-'(3#&#*3*+(. ;"2$0,(/ "( ,(2#$0,<&/:"?6@ +06@&"(D/",(/ (+6,"(+#5:"O&26'

!

%9)+%+)'35 /.&%.-')5 +(+-5*'*+(,%#&/.&0+()#&#4'#@@+*#*3+7-'*"#,<,+6@&2:&+6,"( ";

&2"("%,2+(. 0"2,+#5"#,23 :&0&+:2@ ,(06,6$6&0B5,#"65:"/:+%%&0;"##"?&. K3 :+5,. 02+#,(/

$5B+(. %&:,6"2:+6,2#&+.&:0@,5 0&#&26,"( 5:"2&00&0'!"#8.4#&(+()#*5*3#0#4.-4#,;:"%+

2"%%+(. &2"("%3 6" +(&6?":Q&. &2"("%3 ?,6@ +@,/@ .&/:&&";.&2&(6:+#,0+6,"( 2"$5#&.

?,6@ <+:,"$0;&&.K+2Q +(. +22"$(6+K,#,63 0306&%00$K06,6$6,(/ ;":"5&( 5"#,6,2+#2"%5&6,6,"('

!

%!"#%.-')5 ,'&#)3'.(**#3+33"#3.%#().6&+8#,@',#*%&#+,-.)+-+(,%&'4+3#'('3'+3'4#'

9"/&6@&:?,6@ 6@&#&+:(,(/DK3D.",(/ 2$#6$:&B6@,0@+0%+.&;":+:+5,. 6:+(0;":%+6,"(

5:"2&00'

1"'(#*#%+&3')'%+(3*',#(3'/'#,+ (607#&./@#+J(#**#*'(3"#3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**@"')""+4#

(.@7#).0#%.-')5 %&'.&'3'#*X

!

%X,6@ +06+:6,(/ 5",(6,( 6@&&$("0+0+( &/+#,6+:,+( 5""::$:+#06+6&BA@,(+M06:+(0;":%+6,"(

@+00&&( 6@&&%&:/&(2&";0+A.&'(#Q6+-'3'#*+(,+ *'8('/')+(3&6&+-<6&7+(,'4',#L

!

%C#&*'*3'(8 &6&+-@#-/+&#'**6#*+(,&#8'.(+-'(#Q6+-'3'#*+:&6@&0$KO&26";(&?:$:+#

@&+#6@ +(. &.$2+6,"( 5:"/:+%%&0B6+:/&6&. :&/,"(+#,(<&06%&(65#+(0+(. +6&(D3&+:06:+6&/3

6" &#,%,(+6&5"<&:63'

!

%H(4'&.(0#(3+-).*3*+(,#$3#&(+-'3'#*@#&#/.&3.. -.(8 -#/3.63./3"#%.-')5 #Q6+3'.(

@'3"0+(5 (#8+3'4#).(*#Q6#()#*;@"')"+&#).*3-5 3. &#%+'&L8(<,:"(%&(6+#2"060+(.

&H6&:(+#,6,&0+:&("? K&,(/ ;+26":&. ,(6" 5"#,2,&0B 5#+((,(/ +(. ,(2&(6,<&0' *+O":

5:"/:+%%&06" 2"(;:"(66@&/:&&(@"$0&/+05:"K#&%+:&,( 6:+,('\:K+( 6:+;;,22"(/&06,"( ,0

+#0" 6@&0$KO&26";(&?5"#,23 &;;":60'

!

%H$)#**'4##$%.&3<.&'#(3+3'.(+(,"'8"*+4'(8*&+3#*"+4#8#(#&+3#,*3&6)36&+-,.0#*3')

+(,#$3#&(+-'07+-+()#*LA@,(+,0("?&(/+/&. ,( 6@&0,/(,;,2+(6+.O$06%&(60,( 5"#,2,&0

+(. 6@&06:$26$:&";.&%+(. +(. "$65$6+(. ,0+#&+.,(/ 5#+3&:,( 6@&/#"K+#&2"("%,2

/"<&:(+(2&5:"2&00&0:&P$,:&. 6" +2@,&<&+.3(+%,2&P$,#,K:,$%,( 6@&A@,(&0&&2"("%3 +(.

6@&/#"K+#&2"("%3'

$"

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 34: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

>0)'.03,#/0'8)*6:8)#3%A>)*9406'%$-.)*()0''#$% 8)%(60$,0-3*$,#$0$,

9/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3*',#(3'/'#,3"#@#+J(#**#*./0+(5 9/&')+(*3+3#*+*3"#J#5 %&.7-#0*X

!

%Z(&#*.-4#,'**6#*./%.-'3')+--#8'3'0+)5 +(,@',#*%&#+,*3+3#)+%36&#+:&5:&<&(6,(/ 6@&

&%&:/&(2&";.&<&#"5%&(6+#06+6&0,( %+(3 2"$(6:,&0,( C;:,2+'

!

%!"#/&+80#(3#,(+36&#./9/&')+(%.-'3')+-8#.8&+%"5;.&6&:%,(&. K3 2"#"(,+#5+66&:(0B

,0+;$(.+%&(6+#;+26":,( :&6+:.,(/ 6@&&%&:/&(2&";2"@&:&(606+6&0+(. 5",(606" 6@&

,%5":6+(2&";2"(6,(&(6+#+(. :&/,"(+#/"<&:(+(2&06+(.+:.0+(. 5:"2&00&0'

!

%98&')6-36&+-%&.,6)3'4'35 '*-+88'(8 +(,/#&3'-'35 &+3#*&#0+'( "'8"L1"<&:63 +(.

%+#($6:,6,"( +:&%+O":.&<&#"5%&(6;:"(6,&:0'

!

%!"#/&+80#(3+3'.(./'(3#&(+3'.(+-+**'*3+()##//.&3*;@'3"06-3'%-#'(*3'363'.(*;"'8"

3&+(*+)3'.( ).*3* +(, -.@ %&#,')3+7'-'35; "+* %-+)#, + -+&8# 76&,#( .( 3"#

+,0'('*3&+3'.(./0+(5 9/&')+(*3+3#*+(,)&#+3#,%&.7-#0*./3&+(*%+&#()5 +(,

+)).6(3+7'-'35L

!

%N.3"7'-+3#&+-+(,06-3'-+3#&+-,.(.&*"+4#%&.8&+00#,+',-+&8#-5 .(+ (+3'.(+-

7+*'*L>6%%.&3/.&&#8'.(+-%&.8&+00#*"+*7##(3"##$)#%3'.(&+3"#&3"+(3"#&6-#L

!

%_60+(+(,/'(+()'+-)+%'3+-'*7#'(8 #$%.&3#,+(,3"'*@'--).(3'(6#6(3'-3"#9/&')+(

8&.@3"*3.&5 7#).0#*+ -#+,'(8 8-.7+-'(4#*30#(33"#0#;,&+@'(8 '(%..-*./3+-#(3+(,

/'(+()#/&.0+&.6(,3"#@.&-,;'()-6,'(8 /&.03"#9/&')+(,'+*%.&+L

9-3".68"3"#*#%&.7-#0*+&#*3'--'(%-+5X

!

%>6))#***3.&'#*"+4##0#&8#,+(. @$%+( +(. ,(06,6$6,"(+#2+5+2,6,&0+(. C;:,2+( ,.&(6,6,&0

+:&?&##,( +.<+(2&";6@&06+:6,(/ 5",(6+6,(.&5&(.&(2&'F"$6@ C;:,2+@+06+Q&( ,605#+2&+0

+#&+. 5#+3&:"( 6@&2"(6,(&(6B5"#,6,2+##3 +(. &2"("%,2+##3'

!

%D#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.('*#**#(3'+-+(,'*+,4+()'(8LA"(6,(&(6+#+(. :&/,"(+#5"#,6,2+#B

0&2$:,63 +(. &2"("%,2+:2@,6&26$:&0+:&/:+.$+##3 /+,(,(/ 06:&(/6@'

!

%!"#(#@+)3.&*+(,%+33#&(*'(3"#8-.7+-#).(.05 +&#%&#*#(3'(8 (#@.%%.&36('3'#*/.&

9/&')+(8&.@3"+(,#).(.0')%+&3(#&*"'%*L

!

%B(3#&(+3'.(+-+(,9/&')+('(4#*3.&*+&#&#*%.(,'(8 3. 3"#(#@ 8&.@3"%&.*%#)3*'(

9/&')+L

%"

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 35: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

'60 2#:0 #+C0/0:#7%0$,.)(,$0(*6&7*&$86&$0*0 )$-<+(&")$

C0/0:#7%0$,

!"#$%AG'#$( -0/04*.60$,%''#',%$30 %'%$%33040)%,*)*840%)$#$( %$-

,)%$'8*)6%,#*$

1"'(+ "+*7##("'8"-5 *6))#**/6-'(6*'(8 /.&#'8(,#4#-.%0#(3+**'*3+()#3. *%##,6%'3*.@(

3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**L'K6+,(,(/ ;":&,/( +,. +0+0"$:2&";#&+:(,(/ ?+0+( &H5#,2,6"KO&26,<&B

+:6,2$#+6&. K3 6@&#&+.&:0@,5'

>&(2&B1"'(+ *.68"33. *%#)'/5 +(,.73+'(%+&3')6-+&).(3&'763'.(*/&.0 '(,'4',6+-,.(.&*B

#,(Q&. 6" ,60,(6&:(+#5#+((,(/ +(. 2"D":.,(+6,"( 5"#,2,&0'

B(.3"#&@.&,*;1"'(+ 3..J3"#-#+,'(.73+'('(8 +(,0+(+8'(8 '3*+',La. ,.(.&8&.6%.&

).(*6-3+3'.(%&.)#**#0#&8#,LB(3#&(+-1"'(#*#).<.&,'(+3'.(+(,0+(+8#0#(3%&.)#**#*@#&#

,#4#-.%#,'(*3#+,L

933"#7#8'(('(8;?@&( A@,(+M05"<&:63 #&<&#0?&:&06,##+2$6&+(. ;,(+(2,+#+(. %+(+/&%&(6

:&0"$:2&0?&:&02+:2&BA@,(+:&2&,<&. *'8('/')+(3*6%%.&3/.&'(/&+*3&6)36&#76'-,'(8 +(,'(,6*3&'+-

0.,#&('*+3'.(L

d+%+(%-+5#,+ %+&3')6-+&-5 '0%.&3+(3&.-#'(3"'*'('3'+-%#&'.,B,(2#$.,(/ K3 2"%K,(,(/ 6:+.&B

,(<&06%&(6+(. .&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&B+( +55:"+2@ +55#,&. K3 A@,(+6".+3 ,( ,60"?( +,. 6" 2"$(6:,&0

,( C;:,2++(. &#0&?@&:&'

+3#&B+0A@,(+M0"?( ;,(+(2,+#:&0"$:2&006:&(/6@&(&.B+(. ;":&,/( ,(<&06%&(6/:&?B3"#/.)6*./

1"'(+2*+',0+(+8#0#(336&(#,0.&#)#(3&+--5 3. 3"#+)Q6'*'3'.(./J(.@<".@;'(3"#+&#+*./

3#)"(.-.85;+8&')6-36&#;"'8"#&#,6)+3'.(;6&7+('*+3'.(;3&+(*%.&3+(,%67-')+,0'('*3&+3'.(L

!"#'(3#&(+-).<.&,'(+3'.(%&.)#**@+*#-+7.&+3#;".&'O.(3+--5 +)&.**0'('*3&'#*+(,4#&3')+--5

@'3"%&.4'()#*;)'3'#*+(,3.@(*L=.(.&*@#&#(.3'(4.-4#,'(3"'*).0%&#"#(*'4#%&.)#**L9@&,:

2"##&26,<&;,(+(2,+#2"(6:,K$6,"( ?+0("6+0,/(,;,2+(65:"5":6,"( ";A@,(+M0.&<&#"5%&(6K$./&6B&<&(

6@"$/@ A@,(+K&2+%&6@&6"5 :&2,5,&(62"$(6:3 ;":6@&%&%K&:0";6@&'8AEM0E&<&#"5%&(6

C00,06+(2&A"%%,66&&NECAI+0+?@"#&B+0?&##+0;":+($%K&:";ECA%&%K&:0,(.,<,.$+##3'

1"'(+ 6*#,C&.A#)3B0%-#0#(3+3'.(Z('3*ECBZ*F*6))#**/6--5 75 #(*6&'(8 3"+33"#5 @#&#/6--5

'(3#8&+3#,'(3. #$'*3'(8 %67-')0+(+8#0#(3*3&6)36&#*+(. 6@+65:"O&26";;,2&:0+K0":K&. 6@&Q("?D

@"?+(. %+(+/&%&(60Q,##0+(. 6""Q 6@&% ;":?+:. ,( 6@&,:0$K0&P$&(62+:&&:0BK&2"%,(/ +(&?

&#&%&(6,( A@,(+M05$K#,2+.%,(,06:+6,"('

!"6*;'(*5*3#0')3#&0*;1"'(+ 8+'(#,06)"'(3#&0*./',#+*+(,0+(+8#0#(33..-*+(,*J'--*L

9@&.,:&262"(6:,K$6,"( ";."(":06" 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( ?+0("60" %$2@ 6@:"$/@ ;,(+(2,+#0$55":6;":

5:"/:+%%&0BK$66@:"$/@ ,(("<+6,<&%&6@".00$2@ +02"%5:&@&(0,<&5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( +55:"+2@&0+(.

5+:6,2,5+6":3 5"<&:63 +00&00%&(60B,(2#$.,(/ /&(.&:+(. %,(":,63 .,%&(0,"(0'F,%,#+:#3 ,( "6@&:

+:&+0D0$2@ +0&(<,:"(%&(6+#5:"6&26,"( +(. ,(6&:(+6,"(+#2"%5&6,6,<&K,..,(/ D,.&+0+(. %&6@".0+(.

+2+.&%,2+(. 5:";&00,"(+#&H2@+(/&0@+<&@+. ?,.&,%5+26'

1"'(+ *3'--*##J*).<.%#&+3'.(@'3"%+&3(#&*/&.0GH1=+(,.3"#&).6(3&'#*3"+3)+("#-%'33.

&"

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 36: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

,#+-@'3"'3*)6&&#(3,#4#-.%0#(3)"+--#(8#*L9@&@,/@#3 2"D":.,(+6&. 0306&%?,6@,( 6@&A@,(&0&

/"<&:(%&(6@+0/,<&( ?+3 6" +%":&.&2&(6:+#,0&. +55:"+2@ ?@&:&6@&:&,0+?,.&:+(/&";

5+:6(&:0@,50+6+###&<&#0+(. +2:"00A@,(+N6@&a%+(3D6"D%+(3b%".&#I'A@,(+M0"?( .&<&#"5%&(6

&;;":60+:&2"(2&(6:+6&. ,( 6@&X&06&:( 5:"<,(2&0+(. ,( 6+2Q#,(/ 05&2,;,2+:&+0";5"<&:63 +(.

%+#($6:,6,"(B$0,(/ 5,#"65:"/:+%%&0+(. :+5,. 02+#,(/ $5 ";0$22&00;$#&H5&:,%&(60'

:8)#3%$!*2$,)#0'AH00,#$( ,"0 3"%440$(0 *8*+$0)'"#.*8-0/04*.60$,

',)%,0(#0'%$-.*4#3#0'

9&#%#+3#,0#**+8#/&.09/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3*@+*3"+33"#)+%+)'35 ./+ ).6(3&5 3. ,#3#&0'(#'3*

.@(/636&#@+*3"#)&'3#&'.(75 @"')",#4#-.%0#(3*6))#***".6-,7#A6,8#,L'( 6@+602":&B6@&3

&H5:&00&. %+O":2"(2&:(06@+6,( %+(3 C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0B+;6&:6@:&&.&2+.&0";0,/(,;,2+(6+,.

.&5&(.&(2&B6@,02+5+2,63 06,##:&%+,(05:"K#&%+6,2'

9',&#-+3'.(*"'%*@'3"GH1=M=91,.(.&*@#&#*##(3. "+4#6(,#&0'(#,-.)+--#+,#&*"'%+(,

)+%+)'3'#*L*$#6,#+6&:+#D#&. 2"(0$#6+6,<&/:"$5 +(. 5"#,23V#"+( +55:"<+#5:"2&00&0@+. 2"%5:"%,0&.

"?(&:0@,5 ";5"#,2,&0+(. +22"$(6+K,#,63J5:&.,26+K,#,63 ";:&0"$:2&;#"?0@+. K&&( #"?J1:"O&26

4%5#&%&(6+6,"( \(,60@+. K&&( %"<&. "$60,.&";:&/$#+:5$K#,2+.%,(,06:+6,"( 06:$26$:&0+(. 5+3

02+#&0+(. @+. $(.&:%,(&. #"2+#2+5+2,63 :+6@&:6@+( K$,#.,(/ ,6'

!"'*,'*)6**'.()+0#7+)J3. 3"#*5*3#0')@#+J(#**./0+(5 9/&')+(*3+3#*+(,3"6*".@3. /.*3#&

3"##0#&8#()# ./,#4#-.%0#(3+-*3+3#*@'3" -#+,#&*"'% ).00'33#, 3. *3+3# +(, 0+&J#3

%#&/.&0+()#+(,+)).6(3+7'-'35L

K"#&#+(#//#)3'4#*3+3#"+*7##(+7*#(3B+,. 2"D":.,(+6,"( #&. K3 ."(":0@+. &%&:/&. 6" 0"#<&+

2"##&26,<&+26,"( 5:"K#&%,( 6@&5:"<,0,"( ";+,.L!"#C+&'*=#)-+&+3'.(.(9',H//#)3'4#(#**+(,

3"#9))&+ 98#(,+ /.&9)3'.(&#%&#*#(3+(+8&##0#(3.(".@3. &#*.-4#3"'*).--#)3'4#+)3'.(

%&.7-#0'(+ @+5 3"+3"#-%*76'-,-.)+--#+,#&*"'%+(,'(*3'363'.(+-+(,0+(+8#0#(3)+%+)'3'#*;

+(,3"#&#75 /.*3#&*3"#3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**@"')"'(3'0#0+J#*+',"'*3.&5L

9/&')+ '*%&.4','(8 #$+0%-#*./".@3"'*+%%&.+)")+(@.&J'F"%&2"$(6:,&0@+<&K&&( +K#&6"

/&(&:+6&K:"+. +/:&&%&(6"( .&<&#"5%&(6/"+#0+(. 06:+6&/,&0+(. +:&5:".$2,(/ .&<&#"5%&(6:&0$#60'

C;:,2+( 5"#,23 ;":++(. ,(06,6$6,"(0+:&("?5:"<,.,(/ 06:+6&/,2.,:&26,"(0B"5&:+6,"(+#;:+%&?":Q0+(.

/"". 5:+26,2&0+(. +<,K:+(6C;:,2+( 5"#,23 .&K+6&$0,(/ C;:,2+( 5"#,23 :&0&+:2@ 2+5+2,6,&0'9/&')+(

8&.@3"&+3#*"+4#0.4#,3. + "'8"#&-#4#-.4#&3"#-+*3,#)+,#L

'"

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 37: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

C0/0:#7%0$,<**&*,)$"0 ,#<+(&")Q'5#'()-&,&#$*&$I:3B

50/04*.60$,:''#',%$30 8)*6!"#$%

C+&3')'%+(3*&#).8('*#,3"+31"'(+ '*(.3+ \(#@] %&.4',#&./+',L4(.&&. ,( #"&"BA@,(+@&#. +

(+6,"(+#2&#&K:+6,"( 6" %+:Q 6@&*"

6@

+((,<&:0+:3 ";aA@,(+C,.b'

4( ,60;,:065@+0&B6@:"$/@ $(6,#6@&#+6&&$("0BA@,(&0&+,. ?+0#,(Q&. 6" 6@&5"#,6,2+#+/&(.+0";

0$55":6,(/ #,K&:+6,"( %"<&%&(60+(. +2@,&<,(/ :&2"/(,6,"( ,( 6@&\(,6&. Y+6,"(0'9@&8,/@61:,(2,5#&0

";A@,(&0&+,. 0&6"$6,( &$!* 5:"<,.&:$#&0;":A@,(+M0"?( K&@+<,"$:+0+."(":B+(. :&%+,( +

:&;&:&(2&5",(6'9@&9+(U+(,+DR+%K,+=+,#?+3 N9CRC=CI,06@&%"06;+%"$05:"O&26";6@,05&:,".B

$(.&:6+Q&( ?@&( A@,(+?+006,##5"":+(. ,( 6@&%,.06";6@&2$#6$:+#:&<"#$6,"('

&.0 3"#-+3#IRUS*;1"'(#*#+',%.-')5 "+*7##(#**#(3'+--5 %&+80+3');7+*#,.(0636+-

#).(.0')7#(#/'3L4( 6@&&$-"0BA@,(+:&@+K,#,6+6&. 0"%&";,60&+:#,&:5:"O&260,( 5"06D,(.&5&(.&(2&

C;:,2++(. 5#+2&. 6@&%"( +O",(6<&(6$:&;""6,(/ ?,6@ +( "(D/",(/ A@,(&0&%+(+/&%&(65:&0&(2&'46

@+00,(2&K$,#6;$:6@&:"( 6@&&(6&:5:,0&DK+0&. %".&#";,%5#&%&(6,(/ +(. 0$06+,(,(/ ,605+:6,2,5+6,"( ,(

+,. &;;":60'

B(3"#0',<IRRS*;1"'(+ #*3+7-'*"#,3"#H$B0 N+(J;3"#98&')6-36&+-=#4#-.%0#(3N+(J./

1"'(+ +(,3"#1"'(+ =#4#-.%0#(3N+(JE+(,;6(,#&3"+3;3"#1"'(+ =#4#-.%0#(3 6(,F+0

2@+((&#0;":";;,2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6;,(+(2&/",(/ K&3"(. 6:+.,6,"(+##"+(0B/:+(60B<"#$(6&&:0B6:+,(,(/B

6&2@(,2+#+00,06+(2&+(. .&K6:&#,&;B+##$(.&:+2"D":.,(+6,"( 0306&% ":/+(,0&. K3 6@&*,(,06:3 ";

A"%%&:2&+(. $#6,%+6&#3 K3 6@&F6+6&A"$(2,#'

X@,#&6@&A@,(&0&/"<&:(%&(65$K#,0@&00$2@ .+6++06@&($%K&:";5:"O&260,6@+0,%5#&%&(6&. N&$*"

6" %":&6@+( &#" .&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0K3 6@&&(. ";#""$IB,6."&0("65$K#,0@ ;,/$:&0"( 6@&<+#$&";

6@&0&5:"O&260'Y&<&:6@&#&00BA@,(+M0-,02+#_&+:K""Q ,(2#$.&0.+6+"( ,'*76&*#0#(3*./8&+(3*;

(.(<'(3#&#*3-.+(*+(,*67*','#*/.&).()#**'.(+--.+(*/&.0 4+&'.6*0'('*3&'#*@"')""+4#

3.3+--#,+&.6(,Z>=f 7'--'.('(&#)#(35#+&*'!"#(.(<).()#**'.(+-/'(+()'(8 /&.03"#\%.-')5

7+(J*] 0#(3'.(#,+7.4#"+*8&.@(4#&5 *67*3+(3'+--5L_#+,-'(#/'86&#*+&#./3#(0'*-#+,'(8

86',#*3. +0.6(3*+)36+--5 ).00'33#,+(,,'*76&*#,".@#4#&L

a#4#&3"#-#**;'3'*)-#+&3"+31"'(#*#*3+3#7+(J*+(,*3+3##(3#&%&'*#*"+4#7#).0#0+A.&(#@

%-+5#&*.(3"#9/&')+(*)#(#+7-#3. /6(,4#&5 -+&8#%&.A#)3*L

C05+:6";,60a/",(/ "$6b5"#,23B1"'(+ "+*#().6&+8#,0+(5 1"'(#*#%&'4+3#).0%+('#*3.

#*3+7-'*".%#&+3'.(*'(9/&')+ E+(,.3"#&%+&3*./3"#@.&-,FL9@&,::&2&(6&H5&:,&(2&,(

.&<&#"5,(/ A@,(&0&+(. /#"K+#%+:Q&60%&+(06@&3 +:&2"%5&6,6,<&+(. P$,2Q'

1"'(+2*3&+,'3'.(+-+(,(#@+**'*3+()#'*)-#+&-5 @#-).0#,'(9/&')+B+0+2"$(6&:5",(66" 6@+6

5:"<,.&. K3 ECA."(":0'A@,(+M005&&. +(. +%K,6,"( ,( ,(;:+06:$26$:&5:"O&260+(. 5$K#,2K$,#.,(/0

5:"<,.&/"". <+#$&;":%"(&3 +(. K:,(/ +.,;;&:&(6Q,(. ";5+:6(&:0@,5B%":&,(6&/:+6&. ?,6@ 6:+.&+(.

,(<&06%&(6'

B(fSSS;1"'(+ '(*3'8+3#,3"# .&60 .(1"'(+<9/&')+ 1.<.%#&+3'.(EG191FB+5#+6;":%;":

5:"%"6,(/ K"6@ 5"#,6,2+#.,+#"/$&+(. &2"("%,22"D"5&:+6,"( +(. 6:+.&B?,6@ +<,&?6" 0&&Q,(/ %$6$+#

:&,(;":2&%&(6+(. 2"%%"( .&<&#"5%&(6' -'ACA @+0.&<&#"5&. ,(6" +%$#6,D#&<&#.,+#"/$&

("

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 38: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

%&2@+(,0%K&6?&&( %,(,06&:0+(. 0&(,":";;,2,+#0+(. +2"(0$#6+6,"( 5#+6;":%;":,60%&%K&:0M#&+.&:0B

;":&,/( %,(,06&:0+(. C;:,2+( +%K+00+.":06" A@,(+'A"(6+260K&6?&&( 6@&,:5+:#,+%&(60B5"#,6,2+#

5+:6,&0+(. #"2+#+$6@":,6,&0@+<&+#0" .&&5&(&.'C-'ACA%&&6,(/ ,0@&#. &<&:3 6@:&&3&+:0+6

%,(,06&:,+##&<&#N+(. +6@&+.0";06+6&#&<&#,( #""*I'1#+((,(/ ;":6@&;$6$:&.&<&#"5%&(6";A@,(+D

C;:,2+:&#+6,"(0,0,(2:&+0,(/#3 6+Q,(/ 5#+2&?,6@,( 6@,0;":$%'

9&#+*@"#&#1"'(+2*,#4#-.%0#(3).<.%#&+3'.( %&+)3')#).6-, 7#*3&#(83"#(#, @#&#+-*.

',#(3'/'#,75 %+&3')'%+(3*L9@&0&,(2#$.&.)

!

%9@&$5D/:+.,(/ ";A@,(+M0+,. %+(+/&%&(60306&% 6" .&+#?,6@ 6@&(&? #&<&#";

,(<"#<&%&(6B+(. %":&6:+,(,(/ ;":A@,(+M0;":&,/( +,. 5&:0"((&#'

!

%9@&5:"<,0,"( ";%$2@ /:&+6&:6:+(05+:&(23 "( A@,(+M0+,. +26,<,6,&0+(. 6@&,:;,(+(2,+#6&:%0'

!

%9@&&06+K#,0@%&(6";+%"(,6":,(/ +(. &<+#$+6,"( 0306&%;":A@,(+M0+,.'

!

%*":&/&(&:+##3BK:,(/,(/ %":&";A@,(+M0"?( &H5&:,&(2&+0+0$22&00;$#:&2,5,&(6";+,. 6"

6@&?+3 ,( ?@,2@ ,6.&0,/(0+(. ,%5#&%&(60,60.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&5:"/:+%%&0,( C;:,2+

?"$#. :+,0&6@&P$+#,63 ";A@,(+M0+,. +(. 6:+(0;&:,%5":6+(62+5+2,6,&06" C;:,2+"(

%+(+/,(/ ;":&,/( +00,06+(2&'

50/04*.60$,:''#',%$30 8)*65:!H0690)'

C+&3')'%+(3*,'*)6**#,3"#J#5 /#+36&#*./3"#-+&8#*"+&#./=910#07#&*g).<.%#&+3'.(#//.&3

,#4.3#,3. 9/&')+().6(3&'#*X

!

%9@&2"(6&(6+(. 5"#,2,&0@+<&<+:,&. +2:"006@&:+(/&";ECA%&%K&:0B,(2#$.,(/ 6@&

8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"( +0?&##+0,60%&%K&:06+6&0'*$#6,#+6&:+##3B6@&X":#. S+(QB6@&

4*-+(. 6@&\YE1B"K0&:<&:06" 6@&ECAB@+<&5#+3&. ,%5":6+(6:"#&0'

!

%=&2&(6#3B'EC;:"% ECA%&%K&:06" C;:,2+@+0K&&( :,0,(/ +6"<&:&"T 5&:3&+:B

+#6@"$/@ ;+##,(/ 0@":6";6@&5:"%,0&";+."$K#,(/ ";+,.'C6\FE)) K,##,"( 5&:3&+:B,6,0

+0,/(,;,2+(6;#"?B+#6@"$/@ 6@&+26$+#2+0@ 6:+(0;&:06" C;:,2+( /"<&:(%&(60+:&";6&(

0,/(,;,2+(6#3 #"?&:B+0"6@&:.,06:,K$6,"( %&6@".0+:&$0&. ,(6&(0,<&#3B5+:6,2$#+:#3 6&2@(,2+#

+00,06+(2&+(. YG'0'

!

%-+06D.,0K$:0,(/ K$./&60$55":6@+05#+3&. +( ,%5":6+(6:"#&0,(2&6@&%,.D&$-"0'!+:,"$02"D

":.,(+6,(/ ;":+@+<&K&&( $0&. ;":+..:&00,(/ 6@&,00$&0";2"##&26,<&+26,"( ,(<"#<&. ,(

5:"<,.,(/ 6@&0$55":6+(. 0@+5,(/ ,60$0&0$2@ +06@&F5&2,+#1:"/:+%%&;":C;:,2++(. ,60

0$22&00":6@&F6:+6&/,21+:6(&:0@,5 ;":C;:,2+NF1CIB+#"(/ ?,6@ 6@&:&#&<+(64*-+(.

X":#. S+(Q ;+2,#,6,&0+(. ("? 6@&G#"K+#1+:6(&:0@,5 "( 1$K#,2-,(+(2,+#*+(+/&%&(6

;$(26,"(,(/ +05+:6";6@&1+:,0E&2#+:+6,"( ;"##"?D$5 +:2@,6&26$:&'

!

%F&26":+#+##"2+6,"(0";ECA%&%K&:0+,. @+<&0@"?( 0,/(,;,2+(60@,;60"<&:6,%&B?,6@ +,.

;":+/:,2$#6$:&+(. ,(;:+06:$26$:&@+<,(/ ;+##&( .:+%+6,2+##3 .$:,(/ 6@&&$$"0?@,#&+,. ;":

@$%+( 2+5,6+#N@&+#6@B&.$2+6,"(B/&(.&:I+(. /"<&:(+(2&&H5+(.&. 06&+.,#3 ,( 6@,05&:,".'

9@&:&+:&0,/(06@+6ECA+(. %$#6,#+6&:+#+,. ;":+/:,2$#6$:&+(. ,(;:+06:$26$:&,0:,0,(/ +/+,(

+(. 6@&+,.D;":D6:+.&6@&%&,0.:+?,(/ +66&(6,"( 6" 6@&/:"?6@ +(. 6:+.&.,<&:0,;,2+6,"(

+/&(.+0'

)"

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 39: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

9/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3*4.')#,).()#&(3"+3=91 ,.(.&%&+)3')#*@#&#*3'--).0%&.0'*'(8 3"#

)+%+)'35 ./9/&')+( ).6(3&'#*3. '0%-#0#(33"#.@(#&*"'%;+-'8(0#(3+(, "+&0.('*+3'.(

%&'()'%-#*./3"#C+&'*=#)-+&+3'.(+(,"#()#3"##$#&)'*#./(+3'.(+-*.4#&#'8(35LC(. 6@&

&H6&(0,<&$0&";YG'.&#,<&:3 2@+((&#0?+0";6&( +66@&&H5&(0&";#"2+#0306&%,22+5+2,6,&0'

!"#'()&#+*'(8 (607#&./(#@+)3.&*'(3"#/.&0 ./*#)3.&+-+(,3"#0+3')8-.7+-/6(,*+(,

%"'-+(3"&.%')+)3'4'3'#*0#+(*3"+3+ \0+(5<3.<0+(5] +',*5*3#0 '*#0#&8'(8;7&'(8'(8 (#@

*.6&)#*./'('3'+3'4#763+-*. (#@).<.&,'(+3'.('**6#*L

=91%+&3')'%+(3*(.3#,3"+33"#GH1=M=91<".*3#,K.&J'(8 C+&35 .(9',H//#)3'4#(#**'*(.@

%&.4','(8 + 8-.7+-/.&60 ?@&:&.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0BK,#+6&:+#."(":0"#. +(. (&?B%$#6,#+6&:+#

,(06,6$6,"(0B05&2,+#;$(.0BYG'0+(. 1+:#,+%&(6+:,+(0+:&?":Q,(/ 6"/&6@&:,( 6@&;:+%&?":Q ";6@&

1+:,0E&2#+:+6,"( 6" ,%5:"<&+,. 5:+26,2&0+(. .&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50'9@&X":Q,(/ 1+:63 "( C,.

8;;&26,<&(&00,(2#$.&0+05&2,+#;":$%;":6@&F"$6@DF"$6@ .,%&(0,"(0";+,. &;;&26,<&(&00'46,(6&:+260

?,6@ 6@&E&<&#"5%&(6A"D"5&:+6,"( -":$% ";6@&\(,6&. Y+6,"(0'9/&')+().6(3&'#*+&#%-+5'(8

+)3'4#-#+,#&*"'%&.-#*'(3"#*#(#@/.&60*/.&@.&J'(8 .(8-.7+-,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*"'%*L

*#

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 40: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

8#$":3*&#$*

50/04*.60$,%$-;)%$'8*)6%,#*$#$:8)#3% #$% !"%$(#$( I4*9%473*$*61

1"'(+2*&#0+&J+7-##).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**.4#&3"#-+*33"&##,#)+,#*"+*)"+(8#,

0+(5 ,'0#(*'.(*./3"#8-.7+-#).(.05;'()-6,'(8 3"#,#4#-.%0#(3.%%.&36('3'#*+(,)"+--#(8#*

/.&9/&')+L1"'(+ '*(.@%-+5'(8 + J#5 06-3','0#(*'.(+-&.-#'(9/&')+(,#4#-.%0#(3;+-.(8 @'3"

.3"#&-+&8##0#&8'(8 #).(.0'#*+(,3"#,#4#-.%#,#).(.0'#*;+*+(#).(.0')+(,,#4#-.%0#(3

%+&3(#&L

C+&3')'%+(3*&#8+&,#,3"'**'36+3'.(+*+("'*3.&')+(,@#-).0#(#@.%%.&36('35 @"')"9/&')+(

).6(3&'#*06*3+%%&.+)"*3&+3#8')+--5;*. +*3. ,#3#&0'(#3"#'&.@(,#4#-.%0#(3%+33#&(*+(,

%&'.&'3'#*L .&9/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3*;3"'*@+*3"#0.*3/6(,+0#(3+-0#+('(8 ./,#4#-.%0#(3L

!"#%+&3')6-+&'(*%'&+3'.(3"+31"'(+ '*7&'(8'(8 3. 3"#9/&')+(,#4#-.%0#(3%#&*%#)3'4#'*3"+3+

).0%&#"#(*'4##).(.0')+(,*.)'+-3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**+(,(.3+7-5 %.4#&35 &#,6)3'.()+(7#

+)).0%-'*"#,'(+ 8#(#&+3'.('

!

%!"#J#5 ).(,'3'.(/.&3"'*'*+ *3&.(8 ,#4#-.%0#(3+-*3+3#;+ *3+3#3"+3X

!

[1&#+3#*+( '()-6*'4#;6('/5'(8 (+3'.(+-4'*'.(; +&.6(, '().0#8&.@3";%.4#&35

&#,6)3'.(+(,*6*3+'(+7-#,#4#-.%0#(3L

!

[>6%%.&3*+ 4'7&+(30+&J#3#).(.05 @'3"3"#0+A.&%67-')'(4#*30#(3*'(\"+&,] +(,

\*./3] '(/&+*3&6)36&#(##,#,3. 0+J#'3@.&J;@'3"'(+ *6*3+'(+7-#/'*)+-#(4'&.(0#(3L

!

[ .*3#&*3"##0#&8#()#./,5(+0')).0%#3'3'4#/'&0*@'3"3"#-#+&('(8 )6-36&#+(,

)+%+)'35 /.&).(3'(6.6*6%<*J'--'(8 +(,'((.4+3'.(;+)&.**+--*#)3.&*;/&.0 *0+--

/+&0'(8 3. 0+(6/+)36&'(8 3. *#&4')#+(,)6-36&+-'(,6*3&'#*L

!

[9,A6*3*%.-')'#*+(,'()#(3'4#*%&+80+3')+--5 .4#&3'0#'(+ %&.8&#**'4#0+((#&6*'(8

#4',#()#+(,#$%#&'0#(3+3'.(;&#*%.(,'(8 3. (#@ )"+--#(8#*+(,&#).8('*'(8 +(,

).&&#)3'(8 ,'*3.&3'.(*+(,+&#+*./*.)'+-+(,#(4'&.(0#(3+-,'*3&#**;3"&.68"/##,7+)J

+(,+)).6(3+7'-'35 0#)"+('*0*L

!

[1&#+3#*).(*'*3#(3+(,#//')'#(3+,0'('*3&+3'4#*5*3#0*+(,#//#)3'4#3#)"(')+-#$%#&3

*5*3#0*L

!

[9)3'4#-5 *6%%&#**#*).&&6%3'.(+(,%&#,+3.&5 7#"+4'.&3"+33"&#+3#(3"#*6*3+'(+7'-'35

./3"#,#4#-.%0#(3+-*3+3#L

50/04*.60$,>%),$0)'"#.'#$% ;)%$'8*)6#$( :8)#3%

C+&3')'%+(3*&#).8('*#,3"+39/&')+().6(3&'#*(.@"+4#0+(5 (#@,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*;%67-')

+(,%&'4+3#;+0.(8 3"##0#&8'(8 #).(.0'#*;/&.0 @"')"3"#5 )+(8+'(06)"'(3#&0*./

-#+&('(8 +(, #).(.0')+(, *.)'+-'(3#&+)3'.(;8.'(8 7#5.(, 3"#3&+,'3'.(+-,#4#-.%0#(3

+**'*3+()#).()#%3L

!#

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 41: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

G@(#&*"'%;)+%+)'35 ,#4#-.%0#(3+(,0636+--#+&('(8 +&#*"+&#,).()#%3*@"')"%&.4',#+ 7+*'*

/.&).0%-#0#(3+&5 #//.&3*75 3"'*@',#('(8 &+(8#./,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*L

.&9/&')+;3"##//.&33. )&#+3#)."#&#(3(+3'.(+-;&#8'.(+-+(,).(3'(#(3+-*3&+3#8'#*+(,

8.4#&(+()#+&)"'3#)36&#*7#).0#*+( #4#( 0.&#'0%.&3+(3%&'.&'35 /.&#(*6&'(8 9/&')+(

.@(#&*"'%+(,@',#*%&#+,7#(#/'3*3. 9/&')+(%#.%-#/&.0 ,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*"'%*;.-,+(,

(#@L

N.3"1"'(+ +(,=910#07#&*E+(,.3"#&,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*F)+(,. 0.&#3. @.&J@'3"'(

3"##0#&8'(8 9/&')+(/&+0#@.&J*/.&&#8'.(+-).<.%#&+3'.(+(,3. &#*.-4#3"#%&.7-#0*./@#+J

*3+3#*@"')"%#&%#36+3#%.4#&35 +(,)&#+3#(#8+3'4#*%'--.4#&*/.&9/&')+((#'8"7.6&"..,*L

>.0#9/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3**3&#**#,3"#'0%.&3+()#./#(*6&'(8 3"+33"#*%#)'+-/#+36&#*./1"'(+2*

,#4#-.%0#(3+**'*3+()#@#&#(.3,'-63#,75 '(3#&(+3'.(+-).<.&,'(+3'.(+(,+33#0%3*3. ,#/'(#

).00.(%&+)3')#*L

!"#'()&#+*'(8-5 %-6&+-'*3')(+36&#./'(3#&(+3'.(+-,#4#-.%0#(3).<.%#&+3'.(@+*&#).8('*#,75

+--%+&3')'%+(3*+*+ /+)3+(,+ 4+-6+7-#(#@%"#(.0#(.(L

!"'*(#@%"#(.0#(.()&#+3#*7.3")"+--#(8#*+(,.%%.&36('3'#*/.&@.&J'(8 3.8#3"#&3. #(*6&#

3"+33"#).(3&'763'.(./,#4#-.%0#(3).<.%#&+3'.(3. 3"#9/&')+(3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**#*'*

.%3'0'*#,L!"#).0%+&+3'4#+,4+(3+8#*+(,).0%-#0#(3+&'3'#*./3"#&+(8#./,#4#-.%0#(3

%+&3(#&*)+(+(,*".6-,).(*3'363#+ 0.&#.&-#**)."#&#(3.4#&+--#//.&3L!"'*@'--&#Q6'&#.(<

8.'(8 ,'+-.86#;&+3"#&3"+(,#3+'-#,).<.&,'(+3'.(;+33"#'(3#&(+3'.(+--#4#-L

N63.%%.&36('3'#*/.&@.&J'(8 3.8#3"#&.(%+&3')6-+&%&.7-#0*+(,"#-%'(8 3. '0%&.4#3"#

Q6+-'35 +(,'0%+)3./+',*".6-,7#*#'O#,+*3"#5 +&'*#L

K.&J'(8 '(@+5*3"+3*3&#(83"#(9/&')+()+%+)'3'#*/.&#//#)3'4#+(,+)).6(3+7-#-#+,#&*"'%+(,

0+(+8#0#(3@'--7#0.&#'0%.&3+(33"+(#4#&L

"#

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 42: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!"#$%&'*

<;(&"3:,3():'()$*+#(%),&#$9H(#5,6

)$-.#/0(,1 20-3",&#$

J)%)F#9=):&9LRELM<7(&:LPSP

##

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 43: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

=)&$=0**);0*

E0''*$'8)*6!"#$%

!

7F%+##@"#.&:+/:,2$#6$:&.:"<&A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#:&<"#$6,"(B?@,2@ 5:"<,.&. 6@&K+0,0;":

A@,(+M0.:+%+6,2&2"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( ,( 6@&#+06cd 3&+:0

!

7S"6@ 6@&06+6&+(. 6@&%+:Q&605$::&. "( A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#:&<"#$6,"(^1$K#,25"#,2,&0

,(2:&+0&. ,(2&(6,<&0;":;+%,#3 ;+:%,(/BK&/,((,(/ ?,6@ +5:+/%+6,2:&;":%";#+(. 6&($:&

+::+(/&%&(60 =$:+#,(.$06:,&0+(. ";;D;+:%O"K0?&:&/&(&:+6&. 6@:"$/@ 05&2,+#02@&%&0;":

:$:+#&(6&:5:,0&0+(. &%5#"3%&(62:&+6,"(^

!

71:"/:&00,<&?,.&(,(/ ";:&/,"(+#+(. (+6,"(+#%+:Q&60#&. 6" %":&.,<&:0,63 +(. /:&+6&:

05&2,+#,0+6,"( ?,6@,( 6@&+/:,2$#6$:+#0&26":4(2&(6,<&0;":;+:%&:06" %&&6%+:Q&6.&%+(.0

?&:&0$55":6&. K3 5$K#,2,(<&06%&(6;":,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. 0%+##D;+:%&:":,&(6&. +/:,2$#6$:+#

:&0&+:2@ +(. &.$2+6,"(B+##+05+:6";+K:"+.B2"D":.,(+6&. +/&(.+6" +2@,&<&%&.,$%+(.

#"(/D6&:%"KO&26,<&0

!

7-+:%5:".$26,<,63 :"0&:+5,.#3 +0+:&0$#69@,02:&+6&. &2"("%,20$:5#$0&06@+6;$&##&. K"6@

:$:+#+(. $:K+( ,(.$06:,&0X,6@ ;&:6,#,63 :+6&0@&#. ,( 2@&2QB5&:2+5,6+;"". 5:".$26,"( +(.

2"(0$%56,"( +#0" :"0&P$,2Q#3^

!

7Z("?#&./&0$55":6&. A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#06:+6&/,&0+(. 5:"/:&00,<& .,<&:0,;,2+6,"(^

E&2,0,"(D%+Q,(/ ?+0&<,.&(2&DK+0&.^A@,(+0"$/@6+(. +K0":K&. +/:,2$#6$:+#Q("?D@"?

;:"%"6@&:2"$(6:,&0B,(2#$.,(/ ECA*&%K&:0?,6@ 05&2,+#&H5&:6,0&

!

7=$:+#5"<&:63 06,##&H,060,( 5+:60";A@,(+6".+3 9@,0,0+2"(2&:( ;":6@&/"<&:(%&(6?@,2@

,0+..:&00,(/ ,66@:"$/@ %&+0$:&06" :+,0&:$:+#?&#;+:&B,(2:&+0&0&:<,2&0+(. ,%5:"<&

,(;:+06:$26$:&

=2..*),#$( :8)#3%&'%()#324,2)%4,)%$'8*)6%,#*$

!

%9@&:&+:&Q&3 #&00"(0;":C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0;:"% A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2&B.&05,6&%+O":

.,;;&:&(2&0,( 2"(6&H6BK"6@ @,06":,2+#+(. /&"/:+5@,2+#'

!

%C;:,2++#0" @+00"%&,%5":6+(60$22&0006":,&0,( +/:,2$#6$:&'S$6+K:"+.#3 K+0&.

+/:,2$#6$:+#:&<"#$6,"( @+006,##6" 2"%&B5"5$#+6,"( /:"?6@ :&%+,(0<&:3 @,/@ +(.

%+#($6:,6,"( ,0?,.&05:&+.'

!

%8H5#".,(/ C;:,2+( ;"". .&%+(. +(. ,%5":605:&0&(6+( "55":6$(,63 ;":C;:,2+'S3

:&05"(.,(/ 6" 6@,0.&%+(.BC;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&2+( K&2"%&+%+O":(&? 0"$:2&";

."%&06,2+##3D+(2@":&. /:"?6@ +(. &%5#"3%&(6B?,6@ &H6&(0,<&&2"("%,2#,(Q+/&0+(.

5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( ,%5+260'

!

%C/:,2$#6$:+#,00$&0,( C;:,2+6:+(02&(. (+6,"(+#K"$(.+:,&0'C/:,2$#6$:&,0("?+5:,":,63 ;":

6@&C\VY81CEB?@,2@ @+0.&<&#"5&. +( "<&:+:2@,(/ 06:+6&/,2;:+%&?":Q +(. +(&?

+:2@,6&26$:&;":;":%$#+6,(/ +(. ,%5#&%&(6,(/ +/:,2$#6$:+#5"#,2,&0+(. :&0&+:2@ +/&(.+0+6

$#

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 44: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

6@&2"(6,(&(6+#B:&/,"(+#+(. (+6,"(+##&<&#0'

!

%ECA*&%K&:0+(. A@,(+@+<&+#"(/ @,06":3 ";0$55":6;":C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&B?,6@ %,H&.

:&0$#60B+(. 6@&:&,0%$2@ 02"5&;":%$6$+##&+:(,(/ +(. 2"D"5&:+6,"(B+6(+6,"(+#B:&/,"(+#

+(. 2"(6,(&(6+##&<&#0'

!

%G:&+6&:,(;":%+6,"( 0@+:,(/ +(. &H2@+(/&,0(&&.&. 6" 0$55":6K&66&:%$6$+#$(.&:06+(.,(/

+(. 2"##+K":+6,"( K&6?&&( C;:,2+(0+(. 6@&,:,(6&:(+6,"(+#5+:6(&:0+0?&##+0&<,.&(2&DK+0&.

.&2,0,"( %+Q,(/'

!

%ECA+,. ;":C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&;&##0@+:5#3 ,( 6@&#+066?&(63 3&+:0BK$6(&?,(,6,+6,<&0+:&

("?"5&:+6,"(+#+(. 6@&6:&(. ,0:&<&:0,(/'C/:,2$#6$:&,0+Q&3 5+:6";A@,(+M0-'ACA

$(.&:6+Q,(/0''6@&:,(6&:(+6,"(+#5+:6(&:0+:&("?K:,(/,(/ ,%5":6+(6&H5&:,&(2&B,(2#$.,(/

?,6@ #+:/&D02+#&2"%%&:2,+#+/:,2$#6$:&K+0&. "( #+(. 02,&(2&+(. %+(+/&%&(6Q("?D@"?'

!

%9@&(&? C;:,2+( 5"#,2,&0B+:2@,6&26$:&+(. #&+.&:0@,5 5:"<,.&+;$#2:$% ?@,2@ ECA

%&%K&:0BA@,(++(. "6@&:,(6&:(+6,"(+#5+:6(&:02+( $0&+0+2"%%"( :&;&:&(2&5",(6,(

0@+5,(/ 6@&,:+/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( N2;6@&ACCE1+(. -C=C;:+%&?":Q0B

+(. 6@&5"#,23 .&<&#"5%&(6+(. :&<,&??":Q ";6@&C;:,2+( \(,"(B\Y8AC+(. C-ESI'

%#

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 45: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

@01 !:0%0$,*#+,60 86&$) <;(&"3:,3():'()$*+#(%),&#$D,#(1

1"'(+ "+*+ *3&.(8 )6-36&#.//..,%&.,6)3'.(*3&#3)"'(8 7+)J3".6*+(,*./5#+&*;7633"#7+*')

).(,'3'.(*/.&+8&')6-36&#'(1"'(+ +&#(.3/+4.6&+7-#'C:+K#&#+(. ,0("6+K$(.+(6+(. ?+6&:,0

02+:2&'A@,(+M02"%5+:+6,<&+.<+(6+/&."&0("6#,&,( +/:,2$#6$:&+(. +/:,2$#6$:+#&H5":60+:&("6+

0,/(,;,2+(65+:6";,60&2"("%3'A@,(+@+0:&2&,<&. <&:3 #,66#&;":&,/( .,:&26,(<&06%&(6;":+/:,2$#6$:&'

a#4#&3"#-#**;+(+8&')6-36&+-3&+(*/.&0+3'.("+*3+J#(%-+)#'(1"'(+;,&'4#(75 %.-')5 &#/.&0*

+(,'()#(3'4#*,%5+26,(/ +66@&#"2+##&<&#+(. 2&(6&:&. "( ,%5:"<,(/ #+(. +(. #+K"$:5:".$26,<,63'

A@,(+,0("?+%,..#&D,(2"%&2"$(6:3 ;&&.,(/ ,60&'+ K,##,"( 5&"5#&N+K"$6#"T ";6@&?":#.M0

5"5$#+6,"(I?,6@ "(#3 &"T ";6@&?":#.M0+:+K#&#+(. +(. *'!T ";6@&?":#.M0?+6&::&0"$:2&0'

C.-')5 &#/.&0*7#8+(@'3"+ 0.,#*3;%&+80+3')&#/.&0./-+(,3#(6&#;@"')"*"+&%-5 '()&#+*#,

3"#'()#(3'4#*/.&/+0'-5 #//.&3;&#*6-3'(8 '('3'+--5 '(+ 0+A.&'()&#+*#'(8&+'(%&.,6)3'.(LX,6@

6@&,(6:".$26,"( ";6@&>"$0&@"#. A"(6:+26=&05"(0,K,#,63 F306&%B;+%,#,&0?&:&+##"2+6&. ,(;":%+#

#&+0&0;":0%+##5#"60";2"%%$(+##3 @&#. #+(.'9@,0:&;":%"<&:2+%&+05&2,;,2.30;$(26,"( 2:&+6&. ,(

6@&&:+";6@&1&"5#&M0A"%%$(&0B+(. #+,. 6@&K+0,0;":6@&.&<&#"5%&(6";+%+:Q&6&2"("%3'-:"%

6@&%,.D&$$"0B+/:,2$#6$:+#%+:Q&60?&:&#,K&:+#,0&.J06+6&2"(6:"#";/:+,( %+:Q&60+(. :&/,"(+#

K+::,&:0?&:&5:"/:&00,<&#3 &#,%,(+6&.J+(. #+K"$:D,(6&(0,<&%+($;+26$:,(/ K&/+( 6" +K0":K 0$:5#$0

#+K"$:;:"%6@&;+:%0'

!"#>3+3#;0+&J#3*+(,*0+--/+&0#&*"+4#7##(3"#3"&###**#(3'+-/.&)#**"+%'(8 1"'(#*#

+8&')6-36&#*'()#3"#&#/.&0*7#8+('(IRUeL9@:"$/@ K"6@ a6"5D."?(b+(. aK"66"%D$5b+55:"+2@&0

+(. +:&+.,(&006" &H5&:,%&(6+(. +.+56B+K&(,/(B6:,5+:6,6&,(6&:+26,"( @+0&%&:/&.B?@&:&6@&

;+:%&::&05"(.06" %+:Q&6(&&.0?@,#&6@&F6+6&B6@:"$/@ &H5+(.,(/ +/:,2$#6$:+#&H5&(.,6$:&0B

5:"<,.&0+06:"(/#3 0$55":6,<&:+(/&+(. P$+(6,63 ";5$K#,2/"".0.,:&26&. +66@&:$:+#&2"("%3'9@,0

5$K#,2;$(.,(/ ;":+/:,2$#6$:&B?@,2@ K3 #+??+0:&P$,:&. 6" &H2&&. 6@&&H5+(0,"( ";6@&"<&:+##5$K#,2

&H5&(.,6$:&0B$(.&:5,((&. ;+06/:"?6@ ,()

!

%4::,/+6,"( +(. "6@&:@3.:"#"/,2+#%+(+/&%&(60306&%0B:$:+#:"+.0+(. ;&:6,#,0&:5:".$26,"('

!

%F2,&(2&+(. 6&2@("#"/3 ;":;+:%&:0B<,+6@&&06+K#,0@%&(6";"<&:&"" %+O"::&0&+:2@

,(06,6$6&02#"0&#3 :&#+6&. 6" ;+:%D#&<&#5:+26,2&+(. +/:,2$#6$:+#&H6&(0,"( 2&(6:&06"

.,00&%,(+6&Q("?#&./&'

!

%1:"%"6,"( ";";;D;+:% &%5#"3%&(66@:"$/@ .&<&#"5%&(6";<,##+/&+(. 6"?(D#&<&#

&(6&:5:,0&0B<,+0$2@ ,(,6,+6,<&0+06@&9"?(0@,5 +(. !,##+/&8(6&:5:,0&002@&%&+(. 6@&

F9C=5:"/:+%%&'

!

%9@&06:$26$:+#.,<&:0,;,2+6,"( ";;+:%,(/ ;:"% 06+5#&/:+,(06" ;":&06:3B#,<&06"2Q +(.

<&/&6+K#&5:".$26,"( +0A@,(+M0,(.$06:,+#+(. 0&:<,2&&2"("%3 /:&?+(. .&%+(. 5+66&:(0

2@+(/&.'

!

%4(<&06%&(6,( @$%+( 2+5,6+#6@:"$/@ :$:+#&.$2+6,"( +(. ;+:%&:&H6&(0,"( 0&:<,2&0'

!

%F"2,+#5:"6&26,"( <,+06+K,#,0+6,"( ";;+:%&:M0,(2"%&0B?,6@ 6@&>"$0&@"#. A"(6:+26

=&05"(0,K,#,63 F306&%B+0,6&<"#<&.B+#0" 5:"<,.,(/ +:$:+#@"%&K+0&;":$:K+( %,/:+(60'

!

%E&<&#"5%&(6";:$:+#D$:K+( &2"("%,2 #,(Q+/&0+00"2,+6&. ?,6@ .3(+%,2 /:"?6@ ";

&#

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 46: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

%+($;+26$:,(/ +(. ,(<&06%&(6,( 6:+(05":6,(;:+06:$26$:&'

!"'*%.-')5 %+)J+8#@+*8'4#(3"#"'8"#*3%.-'3')+-%&'.&'35 +(,*3&.(8 %67-')-#+,#&*"'%;/&.0

3"#)#(3&+-3"&.68"3. -.)+--#4#-*L9@&+(($+#06+6&%&(6"( :$:+#5"#,23 @+0K&&( :&/+:.&. +06@&

aY$%K&:'(&b5"#,23 ."2$%&(6'C(. 6@&5"#,23 5+2Q+/&?+05:"/:&00,<&#3 +.+56&. ,( +( ,(2:&%&(6+#

;+0@,"('

W6)"./3"#+)3'.(3..J3"#/.&0./%&.4'()'+-;-.)+-;#(3#&%&'*#+(,'(,'4',6+-'('3'+3'4#*L=$:+#

A:&.,6A"D"5&:+6,<&0@&#5&. ?,6@ ;+:%&:;,(+(2&BK$6"<&:?@&#%,(/#3 6@&;,(+(2&2+%&;:"% 6@&

0+<,(/0";;+:%&:06@&%0&#<&05+:6,2$#+:#3 <,+6@&#"?2"06";;+%,#3 #+K"$:B?@,2@ ,( ;+26?+0+(

,%5":6+(6;":%";,(<&06%&(6;":6@&?@"#&A@,(&0&&2"("%3 +66@+65",(6'

!"#&#*6-3*"+4#7##(*3+&3-'(8'-:"%&$(- 6" #""-BA@,(+M0+(($+#+<&:+/&&2"("%,2/:"?6@ :+6&

@+0K&&( +K"$6$T'*&+(?@,#&B5"5$#+6,"( 5"#,2,&0#,%,6&. 5"5$#+6,"( /:"?6@ 6" O$06&'"(T 5'+'

C/:,2$#6$:+#GE1/:&?K3 +K"$6)'*T 5'+'+(. ;+:%&:0 ,(2"%&0K3 (T 5'+'9".+3BO$06#""

%,##,"( 0%+##;+:%&:0B?,6@ +( +<&:+/&@"#.,(/ ";"'*! @&26+:&0B;&&. +5"5$#+6,"( ";&'+ K,##,"('

C.4#&35 &#,6)3'.("+*7##(0+**'4#'9@&,(2,.&(2&";5"<&:63 ,( A@,(+;&##;:"%+&T ,( &$(- 6"

$'!T ,( &$$" +(. 6@&( 6" #'!T ,( #""-'-"". 0&2$:,63 @+0K&&( :+.,2+##3 ,(2:&+0&. K3 6@&:,0&+(.

.,<&:0,;,2+6,"( ";;"". 5:".$26,"(B/:&+6#3 "$606:,55,(/ 5"5$#+6,"( /:"?6@B?@,2@ ?+0Q&56,( 2@&2Q'

9@&2"(6:,K$6,"( ";+/:,2$#6$:&6" 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( @+0K&&( 6@:&&6,%&0@,/@&:6@+( 6@+6";"6@&:

0&26":0'9@$0B+/:,2$#6$:&@+0K&&( 6@&;$(.+%&(6+#;+26":;":A@,(+M05"<&:63 :&.$26,"( +(. ;"".

0&2$:,63'

!"#1"'(#*##$%#&'#()#*".@*3"+3*0+--/+&0#&<7+*#,+8&')6-36&#)+(7#3&+(*/.&0#,'(3. +

,5(+0')/.&)#,;5"#,23 #&+.&:0@,5 6+Q&0+2"%5:&@&(0,<&B06:+6&/,2+55:"+2@B0&66,(/ 06:"(/

,(2&(6,<&0B+(. /,<&05$K#,2,(<&06%&(6,( +/:,2$#6$:&B+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6%":&/&(&:+##3B6@&

@,/@&065:,":,63)

!

%=+,0,(/ #+(. +(. #+K"$:5:".$26,<,63 6@:"$/@ ,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(6B;+:%&:DK+0&.

6&2@("#"/3 .&<&#"5%&(6+(. ,(6&(0,;,&. $0&";;&:6,#,0&:0,0";$(,<&:0+#:&#&<+(2&'

!

%9@&0%+##;+:%&:DK+0&. 06:+6&/3 :&P$,:&0K"6@ 05&2,+#,0+6,"( +(. .,<&:0,;,2+6,"( 6" /&(&:+6&

&2"("%,&0";02+#&,( 5:".$26+(. /&"/:+5@,2+#+:&+0B+(. 6@&.&<&#"5%&(6";+/:"D,(.$06:3

&(6&:5:,0&0+(. 0$55#3 2@+,(0'

9/6&3"#&-#**.(/&.01"'(+2*#$%#&'#()#'*3"#'0%.&3+()#./8#(#&+3'(8 .//</+&0#0%-.50#(3

?@,2@ 0&:<&06" ,(2:&+0&#+K"$:5:".$26,<,63 ,( +/:,2$#6$:&B:+,0&+(. .,<&:0,;3 :$:+#,(2"%&0+(.

/&(&:+6&0$:5#$0,(2"%&?@,2@ 6@&( K&2"%&0+%+O":.:,<&:";2+5,6+#;":%+6,"( ;":6@&?@"#&

&2"("%3''$65$6+(. &%5#"3%&(6,( 6"?( +(. <,##+/&&(6&:5:,0&0/:&?&H5"(&(6,+##3B+( $(;":&0&&(

:&0$#6";6@&5"#,23 :&;":%0B+(. K3 6@&%,.D&$$"0+22"$(6&. ;":+0,/(,;,2+(60@+:&";GE1B,(.$06:,+#

"$65$6+(. &H5":60'

!.,+5;1"'(+ *3'--).(/&.(3*'0%.&3+(3&6&+-,#4#-.%0#(3)"+--#(8#*+(. A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#+(.

#+(. 5"#,2,&0+:&,( +2"(6,($,(/ 06+6&";5:+/%+6,2&<"#$6,"()

!

%=$:+#,(2"%&0+(. 0"2,+#?&#;+:&:&%+,(0+Q&3 5"#,23 6+:/&6B+K0":K,(/ 0,/(,;,2+(65$K#,2

&H5&(.,6$:&0'

!

%F"%&:&/,"(0:&%+,( 5"<&:63 06:,2Q&( .$&6" .,;;,2$#6/&"/:+5@3 +(. @$%+( 2+5,6+#

'#

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 47: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

2"(06:+,(60'

!

%8(<,:"(%&(6+#+(. P$+#,63 ,00$&0+:&"6@&:%+O":2"(2&:(0,( 6@&"(D/",(/ &;;":66" ;&&. +

5"5$#+6,"( ";&'+ K,##,"( ?,6@ :,0,(/ ,(2"%&0'C(. A@,(&0&+/:,2$#6$:&,02+:K"( ,(6&(0,<&'

!

%]+(. #&+0&:,/@60+(. #+(. %+:Q&6,00$&0,( +0"2,&63 ("?#,<,(/ %+,(#3 ,( +#+:/&($%K&:";

K,/ $:K+( +:&+0+:&K&,(/ +..:&00&. 6@:"$/@ ;$:6@&::&;":%0B?,6@ "5&(D&(.&. #+(. #&+0&

:,/@60+(. 5#"6D#&<&#2&:6,;,2+6,"( +(. :&/,06:+6,"( +06@&#+6&0606+/&'C#+(. %+:Q&6B?,6@

/:&+6&:5:"6&26,"( ";#+(. :,/@60B,0K&/,((,(/ 6" &%&:/&'

1"'(+2*#$%#&'#()#+-*. 5'#-,**.0#/6&3"#&-#**.(*.//6(,+0#(3+-&#-#4+()#X

!

%]&+:(,(/ ;:"%&H6&:(+#0"$:2&0B,(2#$.,(/ 6@:"$/@ 0,/(,;,2+(6."(":+00,06+(2&B@+005&&.&.

$5 6@&&%&:/&(2&";+%".&:( +/:,2$#6$:+#0306&%?,6@ A@,(&0&2@+:+26&:,06,20'

!

%8<,.&(2&DK+0&. 5"#,23D%+Q,(/ 2+5+2,63B?,6@ &H5&:,%&(6+6,"(B,(;":%+6,"( /+6@&:,(/ +(.

%"(,6":,(/B@+0K&&( ;$(.+%&(6+#'1:+/%+6,0%+(. /:+.$+#,0%@+<&K&&( Q&3 ;&+6$:&0";

6@&+55:"+2@BK$6"<&:+" 3&+:06@&+22$%$#+6&. 2@+(/&0,( 5"#,2,&0B,(06,6$6,"(0+(.

5&:;":%+(2&@+<&K&&( .:+%+6,2'

!

%1+:6,2,5+6":3 .&<&#"5%&(6B?,6@ /:+00D:""60+26,"( +66@&<,##+/&#&<&#+(. ?+6&:D$0&:0

+00"2,+6,"(0N?@&:&A@,(+@+0#&+:(&. ;:"%C;:,2+( &H+%5#&0IB5#+30+2&(6:+#:"#&'

(#

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 48: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

<+(&")A*<;(&"3:,3(0 )$-23():C0/0:#7%0$,Q

T$60(&,)$"0 )$-?77#(,3$&,&0*

A"%5+:&. 6" A@,(+B,(2&(6,<&0+(. 6@&,(<&06%&(62#,%+6&;":C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&@+<&K&&( &H6:&%&#3

5"":+(. C;:,2+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#@,06":3 @+0K&&( 2"%5#,2+6&.'C%+00,<&&H5":6";#+K"$:<,+6@&0#+<&

6:+.&.$:,(/ 6@&&*

6@

6" &$

6@

2&(6$:,&05:"<,.&. +06:"(/ ,%5&6$06"?+:.0#+(.D&H6&(0,<&D:+6@&:6@+(

#+K"$:D,(6&(0,<&D+/:,2$#6$:&'9@&( 2"#"(,0+6,"( K:"$/@6+;"2$0"( 2+0@ 2:"5 5:".$26,"( ;":&H5":6B

?,6@ ,(;:+06:$26$:&B#+(. "?(&:0@,5 +(. %+(+/&%&(60306&%0B:&0&+:2@ +(. 6&2@("#"/3 /&+:&.

+22":.,(/#3'

B(9/&')+;/..,%&.,6)3'.(/.&3"#-.)+-%.%6-+3'.('*+ 7+)J@+&,*#)3.&+(,*J'--*,#4#-.%0#(3

+(,3#)"(.-.85 /.&3"#0+**./*0+--/+&0#&*"+*7##((#8-#)3#,L-"". 5:".$26,"( 5&:2+5,6+@+0

;+##&( +0"$65$606+/(+6&. +(. 6@&.&%"/:+5@,26:+(0,6,"( ?+0N+(. :&%+,(0I.&#+3&.'E&05,6&,60

+/:,2$#6$:+#5"6&(6,+#BC;:,2+@+0K&2"%&+0,/(,;,2+(6,%5":6&:";;"". ;":,60/:"?,(/ 5"5$#+6,"( D

("?%":&6@+( & K,##,"( 5&"5#&D5+:6,2$#+:#3 ,( $:K+( 2&(6:&0'9@&:&@+0K&&( +;+,#$:&6" &H5#",66@&

5"6&(6,+#;":.3(+%,2$:K+(D:$:+#,(6&:+26,"('!+#$&2@+,(0B+(. %".&:( +(. ,(("<+6,<&0%+##;+:%,(/

0306&%0B+:&06,##&%K:3"(,2'4::,/+6,"( +(. ;&:6,#,0&:0+:&$(.&:.&<&#"5&.'9@&%+(+/&%&(6";

%,(&:+#?&+#6@ @+0/&(&:+##3 ("6@&#5&. ,(<&06%&(6+(. 2"%5&6,6,<&(&00,( C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&'

9(#@/.)6*.(+8&')6-36&#'(3"#fI

*3

1#(36&5X1"+--#(8#*+(,.%%.&36('3'#*'C0C;:,2+( 5"#,23

%+Q&:0#""Q 6" /&(&:+6&+(. 0$06+,( @,/@&:/:"?6@ :+6&06" 2+62@ $5 ?,6@ /:"?6@ :+6&0,( &%&:/,(/

%+:Q&60+(. %&&66@&*,##&((,$%E&<&#"5%&(6G"+#0N*EG0IB,(2#$.,(/ 6@&*EG6+:/&66" :&.$2&

@$(/&:B6@&:,2@ 5"6&(6,+#";C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&,0("?2"%,(/ ,(6" ;"2$0'9@&:&+:&+($%K&:";

0$22&0006":,&0,( C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&B,( 6&:%0";,%5:"<&. 0&&. 6&2@("#"/,&0N:,2&B2+00+<+B

0":/@$%B2"2"+BK+(+(+0I+(. 6@&2:&+6,"( ";/#"K+#<+#$&2@+,(0N;#"?&:0B;:&0@ <&/&6+K#&0I'*"06

,%5":6+(6#3B+(&?#&<&#";5"#,23 +66&(6,"( +(. 5"#,6,2+##&+.&:0@,5 ,0&%&:/,(/'

Z&7+('*+3'.(;%.%6-+3'.(8&.@3"+(,+ &'*'(8 0',,-#)-+**+&#)&#+3'(8 + "68#8&.@3"0+&J#3/.&

/..,'(9/&')+ '3*#-/L!"'*%&.4',#*3"#7+*'*/.&+ (#@0.,#&(;*0+--".-,#&<7+*#,+8&')6-36&#L

X@,#&C;:,2+M0,(6&:(+6,"(+#%+:Q&60;":+/:,2$#6$:+#2"%%".,6,&0N,(2#$.,(/ 2"2"+B6&++(. 2";;&&I

+:&#,Q&#3 6" K&06:"(/&:6@+( ,( :&2&(6.&2+.&0B6@&C;:,2+( ;"". %+:Q&6?,##2:&+6&+(&?.3(+%,2B

/:"?,(/ ;:"%\FE!" K,##,"( ,( #"&" 6" \FE&!" K,##,"( K3 #"+"'A$::&(6#3B;"". ,%5":60+:&\FE

+" K,##,"(B$5 ;:"%\FE&+ K,##,"( ,( 6@&&$$"0'F$55#3,(/ 6@,0%+:Q&6?"$#. /&(&:+6&6@&:&<&($&0

(&&.&. 6" .:+?,( 6@&(&2&00+:3 ;,(+(2,(/ +(. ,(<&06%&(6+(. .&&5&( +(. .,<&:0,;3 C;:,2+M0&2"("%,2

06:$26$:&'9" 6+Q&$5 6@,0"55":6$(,63B0&<&:+#%+O":@$:.#&0%$06K&"<&:2"%&)

!

%9@&%+00,<&$(.&:2+5,6+#,0+6,"( ";C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&+(. %,00,(/ :$:+#+(. ,(6&::&/,"(+#

,(;:+06:$26$:&'

!

%9@&;:+/%&(6+6,"( ";+/:,2$#6$:+#%+:Q&60,( +2"(6,(&(6";!+ 2"$(6:,&0B0"%&?,6@ P$,6&

0%+##5"5$#+6,"(0N$ C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0@+<&5"5$#+6,"(0";#&006@+( # %,##,"(I'

!

%9@&$(.&:.&<&#"5%&(6";Q&3 %+:Q&60;":+/:,2$#6$:+#,(5$60'

!

%9@&#"?0Q,##K+0&";0%+##;+:%&:0B6@&%+O":,63 ";?@"%+:&?"%&('

!

%9@&.&%"/:+5@,20+00"2,+6&. ?,6@ 2"(6,($,(/ @,/@ ;&:6,#,63 :+6&0DC;:,2+?,##+22"$(6;":&

K,##,"( ";6@&\(,6&. Y+6,"(M0&06,%+6&. ,(2:&+0&";#') K,##,"( ,( 6@&?":#. 5"5$#+6,"(

)#

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 49: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

K&6?&&( #"&" +(. #"!"'

!

%9@&#,%,6&. $56+Q&";6@&;+:%,(/ +(. .,06:,K$6,"( 0306&%0(&&.&. 6" K&2"%5&6,6,<&?,6@

,%5":60B?@,2@ 2$::&(6#3 0$55#3 6@&/:"?,(/ $:K+( %+:Q&60,( C;:,2+'

!

%]"(/D6&:%.&5&(.&(2&"( ;"". +,. ,( 0"%&:&/,"(0'

K'3"3"#/&+80#(3+3'.(./9/&')+;+8&')6-36&+-%.-')5 0+J'(8 )-#+&-5 "+*"'8").*3*;K"6@ ,( 6&:%0

";&H5&:6,0&+(. ,( 6&:%0";5"#,6,2+#2"(0&(0$0K$,#.,(/ ,( 0" %+(3 06+6&0B/:&+6#3 &H+2&:K+6&. K3

2"(;#,26";<+:,"$0Q,(.0";6&( +6":(&+:6@&0$:;+2&B?,6@,( +(. +%"(/ 2"$(6:,&0'C(. 6@&%$2@ #"?&:

5"5$#+6,"( .&(0,6,&0,( %$2@ ";C;:,2+%&+( 6@+6,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. 0&:<,2&0@+<&@,/@ 2"060'

!. +,,&#**3"#*# )"+--#(8#*; 3"# #0#&8#()# ./).(3'(#(3+-+(, &#8'.(+-%.-')5<0+J'(8

0+)"'(#&5;+-.(8*',#(+3'.(+-%.-')'#*;'*+ 0+A.&36&('(8 %.'(3LF&<&:+#:&2&(6,(,6,+6,<&0%&:,6

@,/@#,/@6,(/)

!

%!"#1.0%&#"#(*'4#9/&')+(98&')6-36&#=#4#-.%0#(3C-+(E199=CF;;":%$#+6&. ,(

#""+B,0("? 6@& K+0,2 :&;&:&(2& 5",(6;":6@& C;:,2+( \(,"(VY81CE %&%K&:

/"<&:(%&(60BK+2Q&. $5 K3 6@&2"%%,6%&(6";C;:,2+( \(,"( %&%K&:0+66@&#""+ *+5$6"

F$%%,66" K$,#. $5 6@&,:+/:,2$#6$:+#K$./&606" &"T ";6"6+#5$K#,2&H5&(.,6$:&0'

!

%!"# .&60/.&98&')6-36&+-D#*#+&)"'(9/&')+ E9D9FBK+0&. ,( G@+(+B,05:"<,.,(/ +

;"2+#5",(6;":6@&.&<&#"5%&(6";6@&Q("?#&./&2"%5"(&(6";6@&ACCE1<,+,(6&/:+6&.

(+6,"(+#B0$KD:&/,"(+#+(. 2"(6,(&(6+#+/:,2$#6$:+#:&0&+:2@ 0306&%0'

!

%9/&')+(_#+,*./>3+3#+&#(.@ 3+J'(8 + 0+A.&'(3#&#*3'(+8&')6-36&#+(,/..,

*#)6&'35;+(,3"#'((.4+3'.(+(,7&.+,#&%.-')5 '**6#*+**.)'+3#,@'3"3"'*+8#(,+L4(

E&2&%K&:#"&"B6@&8+06C;:,2+( A"%%$(,63 >&+.0";F6+6&@&#. +K:+,(06:"%,(/ %&&6,(/

?,6@ 6@,0;"2$0'F$2@ "<&:+:2@,(/ 5"#,6,2+##&+.&:0@,5 ,0&00&(6,+#;":6@&%$#6,D0&26":+#B

%$#6,D.,%&(0,"(+#+/&(.+:&P$,:&. ;":+/:,2$#6$:+#6:+(0;":%+6,"('

!

%9@:&&%+O":,(,6,+6,<&0+:&K&,(/ .&<&#"5&. O",(6#3 K3 6@&C;:,2+( \(,"(B6@&\(,6&. Y+6,"(0

82"("%,2A"%%,00,"( ;":C;:,2+N\Y8ACI+(. 6@&C;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q NC;ESI

,(<"#<,(/)

h[A"(6,(&(6D?,.&2"D"5&:+6,"( 6" .&<&#"5 +( ,(6&/:+6&. C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:+#&2"("%3 ?,6@

0306&%0+55:"+2@&02"<&:,(/ %+:Q&60B 06:+6&/,22"%%".,6,&0B ,(;:+06:$26$:&+(.

:&0&+:2@ +(. ?,6@ 2"D":.,(+6,"( +%"(/ 6@&=&/,"(+#82"("%,2A"%%$(,6,&0'

h[]+(. ,00$&0,( K"6@ $:K+( +(. :$:+#+:&+0'C;:+%&?":Q +(. /$,.&#,(&0?&:&+."56&. K3

6@&C;:,2+( \(,"( ,( #""$B6" K&,(6&/:+6&. ,(6" (+6,"(+#2"%5+260'

h[C( C;:,2+( 1#+((,(/ +(. 1"#,23 A&(6:&;":A#,%+6&A@+(/&+(. +2#,%+6&2@+(/&

,(;":%+6,"( 5:"/:+%%&'

9@&199=C5:"<,.&0+;:+%&?":Q ;":(+6,"(+#2"%5+260+(. 0$KD:&/,"(+#V:&/,"(+#5:"/:+%%&0K+0&.

+:"$(. ;"$:5,##+:0)

!

%]+(. +(. ?+6&::&0"$:2&0.&<&#"5%&(6V%+(+/&%&(6'

!

%=$:+#,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. 6:+.&2+5+2,6,&0;":%+:Q&6+22&00'

!

%-"". 0$55#3 2@+,(0+(. :&05"(0&06" &%&:/&(23 ;"". 2:,0&0'

*$

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 50: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!

%C/:,2$#6$:+#:&0&+:2@B6&2@("#"/3 .,00&%,(+6,"( +(. +."56,"('

F"%&#* ACCE1(+6,"(+#D#&<&#2"%5+260@+<&K&&( 0,/(&. NK3 &(. [$(&#"&"I+(. +5"062"%5+26

5"#,23 :&<,&?0306&%,0,( 5#+2&$(.&:6@&$%K:&##+";6@&C;:,2+( \(,"(B6" 05&&. 6@&%"<&;:"%

:"+.%+506" .&6+,#&. ,(<&06%&(65#+(0'

9@& 9D9@+05$6,( 5#+2&+($%K&:";2"(6,(&(6+#5:"/:+%%&0;":.&<&#"5,(/ 6@&Q("?#&./&K+0&";

C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&)

!

%-":,(("<+6,"( 0306&%0+55:"+2@&0+(. 6@&.,00&%,(+6,"( ";+/:,2$#6$:+#6&2@("#"/,&0'

!

%-":06:&(/6@&(,(/ +/:,2$#6$:+#,(;":%+6,"( +(. #&+:(,(/ 0306&%0'

!

%-":5:"%"6,(/ $(,<&:0,63 &.$2+6,"( #,(Q&. 6" ,(("<+6,"( ,( +/:,2$#6$:&+(. +/:,DK$0,(&00

N\(,S=C4Y,(,6,+6,<&I'

!

%-":K$,#.,(/ C;:,2+( 2+5+2,63 6" K$,#. 2+5+2,63'

-C=C,00,/(,;,2+(6K&2+$0&,6K:,(/0B;":6@&;,:066,%&BC;:,2+( #&+.&:0@,5 6" 6@&+/:,2$#6$:+#:&0&+:2@

+/&(.+?@,2@B$(6,#:&2&(6#3B@+0K&&( .&;,(&. +(. ":/+(,0&. K3 &H6&:(+#,(06,6$6,"(0?,6@"$6+(

"<&:+##2"(6,(&(6+#;:+%&?":Q'

!$

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 51: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

8#E#70(),&#$5&,6<+(&") #$<;(&"3:,3(0 )$-23():C0/0:#7%0$,

A@,(++(. %+(3 %&%K&:0";6@&'8AE E&<&#"5%&(6C00,06+(2&A"%%,66&&NECAI@+<&5:"<,.&.

0$55":6;":C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0 +/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(60,(2&6@&&$*"0'9@,00$55":6@+0/"(&

6@:"$/@ <+:,"$05@+0&0'

E**@#$( 9%3@A:6#J0-)03*)-

!"#$%

A@,(+K&/+( 6" 5:"<,.&6&2@(,2+#+00,06+(2&,( 6@&5"06D,(.&5&(.&(2&5&:,".B2"(2#$.,(/ K,#+6&:+#

+/:&&%&(60?,6@ +($%K&:";C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0'4( 6@&5&:,". &$!$ 6" &$-!B%+(3 (&?5:"O&260?&:&

,%5#&%&(6&.B%+,(#3 0$55":66" 0%+##@"#.&:0BK$6,(2#$.,(/ 0"%&#+:/&;+:%0+(. +/:,DK$0,(&00&0'C0

"6@&:5:"<,.&:0";6&2@(,2+#+00,06+(2&;"$(.BP$+#,63 +(. 0$06+,(+K,#,63 ?&:&";6&( 5:"K#&%+6,2;":

A@,(&0&5:"<,.&:0";+00,06+(2&6" +/:,2$#6$:&,( C;:,2+'-+,#$:&05:"%56&. +0&+:2@ ;":K&66&:

+55:"+2@&0'9@$0B;:"%6@&%,.D&$-"0B6@&:&?+0+%"<&6" :&<,0,6B2"(0"#,.+6&+(. :&("<+6&6@&

5":6;"#," ";5:"O&260+(. 6" &(/+/&"( 6@&K+0,0";6@&%$6$+#K&(&;,65:,(2,5#&'A@,(&0&06+6&

2"%5+(,&0K&/+( 6" 5#+3 +:"#&<,+O",(6<&(6$:&0+(. 2"(06:$26,"( +(. %+(+/&%&(62"(6:+260'-:"%

6@&%,.D&$$"0BA@,(+6""Q 6@&&(6&:5:,0&DK+0&. +55:"+2@ ;$:6@&:B2"(0,.&:,(/ 6@+6O",(6<&(6$:&0B?,6@

"(D/",(/ A@,(&0&,(<"#<&%&(6+66@&%+(+/&%&(6+(. 6&2@(,2+##&<&#0B?+06@&K&06?+3 6" &(0$:&

0$06+,(+K,#,63'9@,0+55:"+2@ ?+0+5+:6";A@,(+M05"#,23 ";&(2"$:+/,(/ ,60&(6&:5:,0&06" a/"

/#"K+#bBK$6,6+#0" 2"(06,6$6&. +?+3 ";2+::3,(/ ;":?+:. 6@&&;;":60K&/$( ,( 6@&&+:#3 &$*"0B6@$0

5:"<,.,(/ 2"(6,($,63 ";&(/+/&%&(6'C#"(/0,.&6@&";;,2,+#5:"/:+%%&B0"%&A@,(&0&&%,/:+(606"

C;:,2+B+26,(/ ,(.&5&(.&(6#3B@+<&%"<&. ,(6" ;+:%,(/ +(. .,06:,K$6,"(B0$55#3,(/ $:K+( 2&(6:&0B+0

6@&3 @+<&."(&@,06":,2+##3 ,( %+(3 "6@&:5+:60";6@&?":#.'

A@,(+M0"KO&26,<&0,( +/:,2$#6$:+#2"D"5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2+@+<&+#?+30K&&(B+(. 2"(6,($&6" K&B

.,:&26&. +6K""06,(/ C;:,2+( 2+5+2,63 6" 0$55#3 ."%&06,2%+:Q&60B:+6@&:6@+( ?":#. %+:Q&60B":;":

@&#5,(/ 6" 0$55#3 A@,(+?,6@ ;"".'C0O$06.&02:,K&.BA@,(+,0("?K:,(/,(/ +2"%%&:2,+#+55:"+2@

6" ,602"D"5&:+6,"(B,( ?@,2@ A@,(&0&+/:"D,(.$06:3 &(6&:5:,0&0?,##5#+3 +( ,%5":6+(6:"#&BK:,(/,(/

"(D/",(/ %+(+/&%&(6+(. 6&2@(,2+#Q("?D@"?+(. @,/@ 6&2@ 0&&.0+(. "6@&:0$55#,&0'9@&/:"?,(/

($%K&:";A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#6&2@("#"/3 .&%"(06:+6,"( 2&(6:&0;":&H+%5#&+:&.&0,/(&. 6" "5&:+6&

"( +2"%%&:2,+#K+0,0?,6@,( +;&?3&+:0''6@&:&%&:/,(/ 5+:6(&:0B0$2@ +0S:+U,#BC:/&(6,(++(.

4(.,+B+:&?":Q,(/ +#"(/ 0,%,#+:#,(&0'ECA*&%K&:0@+<&#+:/&+/:"D,(.$06:,&0?@,2@ +:&+#:&+.3

<&:3 +26,<&,( 6@&%".&:(,0+6,"( ";C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&B,(2#$.,(/ 0%+##@"#.&:;+:%,(/'9@&

+/:,2$#6$:+#2"D"5&:+6,"( 5:"/:+%%&0";+##6@&0&5:"<,.&:0";+00,06+(2&2+( @&#5 6" @+:(&006@&0&

2"%%&:2,+#2+5+2,6,&06" 0$55":66@&&%&:/,(/ C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:+#06:+6&/,&0'

9@&P$+(6,63 ";A@,(+M00$55":6;":C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&,0("6Q("?(B0,(2&A@,(+."&0("6+66@,06,%&

5$K#,0@ 0306&%+6,206+6,06,20"( ,602"D"5&:+6,"( +(. 6@,02"D"5&:+6,"( 6+Q&0+<+:,&63 ";;":%0+(.

2"(2&00,"(+#,63'A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#+00,06+(2&5:"O&260+(. 5:"/:+%%&0@+<&("6K&&( 0$KO&266" +(3

0306&%+6,2&<+#$+6,"( 5:"2&00&0B+#6@"$/@ 6@&A@,(&0&*,(,06:3 ";C/:,2$#6$:&$(,6?@,2@ ,%5#&%&(60

%+(3 ";6@&0&,0$0&. 6" &<+#$+6,"(06@:"$/@ 6@&?":Q ,6."&0;":%$#6,#+6&:+#+/&(2,&0'

"$

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 52: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

5:!H0690)'

ECA*&%K&:05$62"(0,.&:+K#&&;;":6,(6" +/:,2$#6$:&,( C;:,2+,( 6@&&$*"0+(. &$("0B+##"2+6,(/

0$K06+(6,+#P$+(6,6,&0";+,.'C;,:06?+<&";&;;":6?&(6,(6" 2:"5 +(. #,<&06"2Q 5:"O&260?,6@ +<,&?6"

?,.&05:&+. :&5#,2+6,"('C0&2"(. ?+<&?+0K+0&. "( 6@&2"(2&56";,(6&/:+6&. :$:+##,<&#,@"".0'

X@,#&K"6@ +55:"+2@&0?&:&+(. :&%+,( <+#,.B6@&3 .,. ("6+..:&006@&%+2:" 5:"K#&%0";5"#,23 +(.

:&/,"(+#,(6&/:+6,"(B+(. 6@$02"$#. ("6%+Q&+( ,%5+26,( 6@&;+2&";#+:/&5"#,23 .,06":6,"(0B0$2@ +0

"<&:<+#$&. &H2@+(/&:+6&0+(. "6@&:;":%0";$:K+( K,+0B?@,2@ $(.&:%,(&. 6@&5:";,6+K,#,63 ";

+/:,2$#6$:&B+(. ?@,#&6@&;"2$0";C;:,2+( .&<&#"5%&(65"#,2,&0+(. &H5&(.,6$:&0?+0&#0&?@&:&'

F6:$26$:+#+.O$06%&(65"#,2,&0,(6:".$2&. ,( 6@&%,.D&$-"0?&:&.,:&26&. +62"::&26,(/ 5:"K#&%0?,6@

6@&K+0,2,(2&(6,<&06:$26$:&0B?@,2@ 6@&3 .,. ,( 0"%&,%5":6+(6%&+0$:&BK$6?,6@"$6+..:&00,(/ K+0,2

,(06,6$6,"(+#B;"". 0&2$:,63 +(. 0"2,+#5:"6&26,"( ,00$&0'C0+:&0$#6B5:".$26,<,63 @+006+/(+6&. +(.

%+#($6:,6,"( +(. @$(/&:@+<&05:&+.'C66@,05",(6B6@&:&,006,##+5:"K#&% ";,(2&(6,<&0+(.

,(06,6$6,"(0;":,(("<+6,<&0%+##;+:%,(/'

'<&:6@,05&:,".B6@&:&?+0+0@+:5 ;+##,( ECA*&%K&:0M+00,06+(2&6" +/:,2$#6$:&B+0+,. +/&(2,&0

#"062"(;,.&(2&,( 6@&,:2+5+2,63 6" ?":Q &;;&26,<&#3 ,( 6@,00&26":'C,. 6" +/:,2$#6$:&;&##;:"%&)T ";

ECA";;,2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&N'ECI,( &$-" 6" )T ,( #""-'*&+(?@,#&B?@,#&6@&:&?+0

5:"/:&00"( %+:Q&6+22&00+(. &H5":60$K0,.,&0B6:+.&:$#&0@+<&:&%+,(&. $(2"(.$2,<&6" %+O":#"(/D

6&:%,(<&06%&(6,( +/:"D,(.$06:,&0.,:&26&. +6&H5":6%+:Q&60'

E**@#$( 8*)+%)-A=2..*),#$( :8)#3%&'$0+',)%,0(#0'%$-

%)3"#,03,2)0 8*),"0 ,)%$'8*)6%,#*$*8%()#324,2)0

Y&?@":,U"(0;":+/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6+(. 2"D"5&:+6,"( @+<&&%&:/&. ,( 6@&#&062&(6$:3)

!

%!"#W=?*"+4#*3'06-+3#,+ &#(#@#,/.)6*.(%.4#&35 &#,6)3'.(B?@,2@ ,( C;:,2+

%&+(0+%+O":&;;":66" 2"%K+65"<&:63 ,( :$:+#+:&+0?@&:&6@&%+O":,63 ";5"":5&"5#&

#,<&'C(. C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0+:&("?K&/,((,(/ 6" 0&&+/:,2$#6$:&B@$%+( .&<&#"5%&(6+(.

&(<,:"(%&(6+#%+(+/&%&(6V2#,%+6&2@+(/&:&05"(0&+0+Q&3 5+:6";6@&,:06:+6&/3 ;":

:+,0,(/ /:"?6@ :+6&06" 6+Q&D";;#&<&#0'C66@&0+%&6,%&B/#"K+#;"". 0&2$:,63 @+0K&2"%&

+( ,00$&,( 6@&?+Q&";6@&#""- /#"K+#;"". 2:,0,0'9@&?":#. 0$55#3V.&%+(. K+#+(2&,0

2@+(/,(/'-"". 5:,2&0#""Q 6" K&"( +:,0,(/ 6:&(. ,( 6@&2"%,(/ .&2+.&0B/&(&:+6,(/B,(6&:

+#,+B(&?,(6&:&06,( #+(. +2P$,0,6,"(0K3 ,(<&06":0;":#+:/&D02+#&;+:%,(/'C,.D;":D9:+.&

5:"/:+%%&0B?,6@ 06:"(/ +/:,2$#6$:+#2"(6&(6B @+<& K&&( 5:"%"6&. ,( 6@& E"@+

E&<&#"5%&(6="$(. 6&H60+(. 5:"2&00&0B?,6@ %+(3 2"$(6:,&0B,(2#$.,(/ A@,(+B+26,<&,(

6@&G#"K+#C,. ;":9:+.&:&<,&?5:"2&00@"06&. K3 6@&X":#. 9:+.&':/+(,0+6,"( +(. 6@&

'8AE'

!

%1"'(+ "+*'(+686&+3#,3"#3&'#(('+- .&60 .(1"'(+<9/&')+ 1.<.%#&+3'.(EG191F

?@,2@ @+0+0,/(,;,2+(6+/:,2$#6$:&2"%5"(&(6'9@&&%5@+0,0$(.&:6@&-'ACA,0"(

6:+,(,(/ ";;+:%&:0+(. 6&2@("#"/3 6:+(0;&:+(. .,00&%,(+6,"(B("6+K#3 ;":@3K:,. :,2&0&&.0'

9@,05:"/:+%%&,0,%5#&%&(6&. <,+6@&&06+K#,0@%&(6";$5 6" +" +/:,2$#6$:+#6&2@("#"/3

.&%"(06:+6,"( 2&(6:&0,( C;:,2+B6:+,(,(/ ;":# """ +/:,2$#6$:+#6&2@(,2,+(0,( A@,(+B6@&

.,05+62@ ";!" +/:,2$#6$:+#6&2@("#"/3 6&+%0+(. 0$55":6;":6@&-"". +(. C/:,2$#6$:&

':/+(,0+6,"(M0N-C'M0I05&2,+#0"$6@D0"$6@ 2"D"5&:+6,"( 5:"/:+%%&;":;"". 0&2$:,63'9@&

#$

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 53: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

+/:,2$#6$:+#6&2@("#"/3 2&(6:&0+:&6" K&2"(06:$26&. +(. 06+:6&. $5 K3 A@,(&0&+/:"D,(.$06:3

&(6&:5:,0&0B?,6@ 0$55":6;:"%6@&A@,(&0&;":&,/( +,. K$./&6;":6@&;,:063&+:0BK$66@&+,%

,06" %+Q&6@&%+0$06+,(+K#&5+:6";@3K:,. :,2&DK+0&. ;+:%,(/ 0306&%0,( C;:,2+B?@,2@

?"$#. K&@&#5&. K3 6@&2&(6:&0K&,(/ 2"((&26&. $5 6" K:"+.&:+(. :&#+6&. ,(,6,+6,<&0'

A@,(+M006:+6&/3 ,06" 2"(6:,K$6&6" +(. 5+:6,2,5+6&,( 6@&/:"?6@ ";C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&;":

C;:,2+( ;"". 0$55#3B:+6@&:6@+( 6" 5:"%"6&#+:/&D02+#&;+:%,(/ ;":A@,(+M0"?( ;"".

(&&.0'A@,(+@+02"(0,.&:+K#3 #+:/&:,(<&06%&(60,( +/:,2$#6$:&,( "6@&::&/,"(0";6@&

?":#.B,(2#$.,(/ ]+6,( C%&:,2+'

!

% ..,*#)6&'35 '(9/&')+ "+*7#).0#+ 0+A.&'(3#&(+3'.(+-'**6#@'3"+ (#@9/&')+( ..,

>#)6&'35 B('3'+3'4#(.@.%#&+3'.(+-L8%&:/,(/ ;:"%6@&.,+#"/$&5:"2&00?,6@ C;:,2+6@+6

K&/+( ?,6@ 6@&Z+(+(+0Q,0G- F$%%,6,( #""#B+( C;:,2+( -"". F&2$:,63 4(,6,+6,<&?+0

#+$(2@&. +66@&#CP$,#+G- F$%%,6,( #""$B?,6@ 6@&2"%%,6%&(6";\FE## K,##,"( "<&:

6@&;"##"?,(/ 6@:&&3&+:0'9@,00$55":6,0K&,(/ 6:+2Q&. +(. %+55&. K3 +0&(,":";;,2,+#0

/:"$5B?,6@ +<,&?6" &(0$:,(/ 6@+66@&"<&:+##&;;":6,0"56,%,0&. +(. 6@&%"%&(6$%

0$06+,(&.'9@&2$::&(6\(,6&. F6+6&0C.%,(,06:+6,"( ,0%+Q,(/ ;"". 0&2$:,63 +Q&3 5:,":,63

;":,60.&<&#"5%&(6+(. ;":&,/( 5"#,2,&0BK$,#6+:"$(. 2"$(6:3D"?(&. (+6,"(+#06:+6&/,&0;":

;"". 5:".$26,"( +(. ($6:,6,"('[+5+( ,0$(.&:6+Q,(/ +%+O"::&":,&(6+6,"( ";,60+,. ;:"%

C0,+6" C;:,2+B?,6@ +/:,2$#6$:&B+(. 5+:6,2$#+:#3 :,2&6&2@("#"/3B+0+%+O":&#&%&(6'

!

%H0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*+&#+ 8&.@'(8 *.6&)#./'(4#*30#(3;+**'*3+()#+(,3#)"(.-.85

3&+(*/#&'-C=C@+0+:&/$#+:.,+#"/$&+(. O",(6:&0&+:2@ ?,6@ S:+U,#M0%+O":5+:+06+6+#

+/:"D,(.$06:,+#;,:%B8%K:+5+'S:+U,#,+( Q("?D@"?2"$#. K&6@&Q&3 6" &H5#",6,(/ :&/,"(0

0$2@ +06@&G$,(&+0+<+((+@0B?@,2@ +:&6@:&&6,%&0+0K,/ +06@&S:+U,#,+( 2&::+." :&/,"(B

?,6@ #"?5"5$#+6,"( .&(0,6,&0+(. :&+0"(+K#&:+,(;+##N0$2@ +:&0"$:2&,(.,2+6&06@+6#+:/&D

02+#&2"%%&:2,+#;+:%,(/ ;":&H5":62"$#. +#0" @+<&+5#+2&,( C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:+#

.&<&#"5%&(6I'4(.,+( +/:,2$#6$:+#&H5&:,&(2&+(. 02,&(2&,0+("6@&:0"$:2&";:&#&<+(6

Q("?#&./&'F"$6@ Z":&+,0K$,#.,(/ ,605+:6(&:0@,5 ?,6@ C;:,2++(.B("?6@&#+6&06%&%K&:

";6@&ECAB,0:+5,.#3 &H5+(.,(/ ,60+,. 5:"/:+%%&']+(. 5$:2@+0&0K3 &%&:/,(/ 2"$(6:,&0

+:&K&,(/ :&/,06&:&. +(. ,(2:&+0,(/#3 02:$6,(,0&.B+#6@"$/@ 6@&,:6:$&02+#&,0";6&( "<&:D

&06,%+6&.'

!

%C&'4+3#/.6(,+3'.(*+(,+)+,#0')+(,&#*#+&)"'(*3'363'.(*@+<&&(2"$:+/&. +(. ,(<&06&.

,( 6@&5:"5"0,6,"( 6@+6+( +/:,2$#6$:+#:&<"#$6,"( ,05"00,K#&,( C;:,2+BK+0&. "( 0%+##

;+:%,(/'

$$

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 54: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

8#$":3*&#$*

E0''*$'8)*6!"#$% #$%$:8)#3%$3*$,0J,

A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2&0$55":60%$2@ ";6@&6@,(Q,(/ "( 6@&:"#&";0%+##;+:%&:0,( C;:,2+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#

:&<"#$6,"()

!

%W.,#&(;*0+--".-,#&<7+*#,/+&0'(8 +(,,'*3&'763'.(M'(/&+*3&6)36&#%+33#&(*@'--7#

&#Q6'&#,B.,;;&:&(6;:"% 6@"0&";6@&&H5":6D.:,<&( ,(.$06:,+#2"%%".,63 0$55#3 0306&%0

?@,2@ +:&6@&@&:,6+/&";6@&2"#"(,+#&:+N?@,2@ +#0"B@"?&<&:B(&&. %".&:(,0+6,"( ,( 6@&

2"(6&H6";:,0,(/ /#"K+#.&%+(. ;":;"". +(. "6@&:+/:,2$#6$:+#5:".$260B+(. ;+##,(/ %+:Q&6

0@+:&0";C;:,2+( 5:".$2&:0I'

!

%!"#%&.,6)3'4'35 +(,%&./'3+7'-'35 ./*0+--</+&0#&**".6-,7#J#5 %.-')5 3+&8#3*B?,6@

5:+/%+6,2B&<,.&(2&DK+0&. +55:"+2@&06" :&2"(06:$26,(/ 0%+##D;+:%&:5:".$26,"( 0306&%0

"<&:6@&(&H66?" .&2+.&0'9@,0.&%+(.0)

h[_'8"+(,*6*3+'(#,-#4#-*./'(4#*30#(3'(J#5 %67-')8..,*/.&3"#&6&+-*#)3.&B

0$2@ +0:"+.0+(. ,::,/+6,"( ,(;:+06:$26$:&B+(. 0$55":6;":,(5$6D:&#+6&. ,(.$06:,&0B0$2@

+0;&:6,#,0&:0+(. 0&&.0B?,6@ (&?&2"("%,2#,(Q+/&0+(. &(6&:5:,0&"55":6$(,6,&06@+6

2:&+6&+(&?%+:Q&6&2"("%3 ,( :$:+#+:&+0'

h[>#)6&'(8 &'8"3*+(,'(3#&#*3*./*0+--".-,#&*,( #+(. 5"#,2,&0B,(2#$.,(/ 6@&:,/@60

+(. ,(6&:&060";?"%&( ;+:%&:0'

h[B()#(3'4#* /.& .//</+&0 #(3#&%&'*# #0%-.50#(3 )&#+3'.( 6@:"$/@ &(6&:5:,0&

.&<&#"5%&(6N:,0,(/ ";;D;+:%&%5#"3%&(6+(. #"(/&:02@""#,(/ ?,##@&#5 6" ,(2:&+0&6@&

?+/&0+(. :&+#,(2"%&0";;+:%#+K"$:B5+:6,2$#+:#3 ?"%&(I'

h[9/&')+(<,&'4#(*5*3#0*/.&*6%%.&3'(8 (#@;'((.4+3'4#/+&0'(8 3#)"(.-.8'#*+(,

#//#)3'4#-#+&('(8 *5*3#0*/.&*0+--/+&0#&*L9@&:&+:&0,/(,;,2+(6,(("<+6,"(0

+<+,#+K#&,( C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&B+#%"06+##2"(2&:(,(/ 0&&. <+:,&6,&0B;":?@,2@ 6+Q&D$5

2+( K&/:&+6#3 +22&#&:+6&.'S$6,(("<+6,"( (&&.06" 05:&+. 6" 0",#%+,(6&(+(2&+(.

,%5:"<&%&(6B+(. ;+:%,(/ 0306&%0B,(2#$.,(/ ,(6&(0,<&%$#6,D2:"55,(/ %&6@".0'

h[!"#*J'--'(8<6%./*0+--/+&0#&*B6@&&%&:/&(2&";+/:,2$#6$:&+0+%".&:( 5:";&00,"(

+(. 6@&,%5:"<&%&(6";:$:+##,<,(/ &(<,:"(%&(60B,(2#$.,(/ 6@:"$/@ &.$2+6,"( +(.

@&+#6@ 0&:<,2&0'

h[a#@).006(')+3'.(+(,#(#&85 3#)"(.-.8'#*$(+<+,#+K#&,( 6@&&+:#,&:06+/&0";

A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#6:+(0;":%+6,"( ?,##"5&( $5 "55":6$(,6,&0;":#&+5;:"//,(/ ,(

C;:,2+( ;+:%,(/ +(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6'

K01 5#)03,#*$'8*):8)#3% %$-#,'50/04*.60$,>%),$0)'

!"##0#&8#()#./+8&')6-36&#+*+ 3.%%&'.&'35 /.&9/&')+(,#4#-.%0#(3+(,+ (#@9/&')+(

+&)"'3#)36&#/.&3"#8.4#&(+()#./+8&')6-36&+-,#4#-.%0#(3'*+("'*3.&')0.0#(3L465:"%,0&06"

K:,(/ :&+#C;:,2+( "?(&:0@,5B;"$(.&. "( &<,.&(2&DK+0&. 5"#,23 %+Q,(/ +(. 2"(6,($,(/ +.+56+6,"( ";

5"#,2,&0+(. 0$55":6B6" C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&'9@,0Q&3 #&00"( ;:"% A@,(+,06@$0+#:&+.3 K&,(/

+K0":K&.'46(&&.06" K&0$55":6&. +(. K$,#6$5"( K3 +##";C;:,2+M0.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0'

%$

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 55: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

..,%&.,6)3'.(/.&9/&')+(0+&J#3*'*3"#J#5 ,5(+0')/.&9/&')+(+8&')6-36&#'(3"#/636&#L

*&&6,(/ ;+06D/:"?,(/ C;:,2+( .&%+(. ;":+.,<&:0,;3,(/ :+(/&";;"".0,0+%+O":(&?.&<&#"5%&(6

.3(+%,2'S$66@&/&+80#(3+3'.(./9/&')+ '*+ 0+A.&7+&&'#&3. &#+-'*'(8 3"'*%.3#(3'+-)

!

%9@$0&#8'.(+-+(,).(3'(#(3+-'(3#8&+3'.( ";+/:,2$#6$:&6@:"$/@ 6:+.&B,(<&06%&(6B

,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. +/:,2$#6$:+#6&2@("#"/,&0,0+Q&3 ;:"(6,&:;":C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0+(. 6@&,:

.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0'

!

%9@,0@+0,%5":6+(6%.-'3')+-+(,*#)6&'35 *5*3#0 ,'0#(*'.(*B0,(2&6@&2"(;,.&(2&";

,(<&06":0B2"(0$%&:0+(. %,/:+6":3 #+K"$:,0.&&5#3 ,(<"#<&.'

9*@#--+*@.&J'(8 7'-+3#&+--5;'3'*'0%.&3+(33"+3=91 W#07#&*;1"'(+ +(,.3"#&

#0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*+-*. #(8+8#+33"#&#8'.(+-+(,).(3'(#(3+--#4#-*B?":Q,(/ ?,6@ 6@&C;:,2+(

\(,"(VY81CE+(. :&/,"(+#06:$26$:&0'9@&199=C+(. 9D9 5:"<,.&+;:+%&?":Q ?,6@ +

2"(6,(&(6+#+(. ,(6&::&/,"(+#.,%&(0,"( 6@+6%$06K&;$:6@&:.&<&#"5&.)

!

%1"'(+ +(,.3"#&-+&8##0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*)+(0+J#+ *%#)'+-).(3&'763'.(+6+##6@&0&

#&<&#0?,6@ 6@&,:.,<&:0&:&2&(6&H5&:,&(2&0";+/:,2$#6$:+#6:+(0;":%+6,"('

!

%C0.&#).()#&3#,#//.&375 +--./9/&')+2*,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*6" /" K&3"(. (+6,"(+##3

K+0&. +00,06+(2&5:"/:+%%&06" ?":Q ?,6@,( 6@&C;:,2+( ;:+%&?":Q06@+6@+<&:&2&(6#3

&%&:/&. ?"$#. +.. 5"?&:;$##3 6" 6@&2@+(/&5:"2&00,( C;:,2+( +/:,2$#6$:&'

W+A.&+,A6*30#(3*+&#3"6*(#)#**+&5 '(+%%&.+)"#*K3 C;:,2++(. ,60.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0B

,(2#$.,(/ ECA*&%K&:0BA@,(++(. "6@&:&%&:/,(/ 2"$(6:,&0,( ":.&:6")

!

%>3&#(83"#(3"#)+%+)'35 /.&#4',#()#<7+*#,%.-')5 +(,'3*'0%-#0#(3+3'.(+3).6(3&5;

&#8'.(+-+(,).(3'(#(3+--#4#-;#07&+)'(8 +-*. 3"#)"+--#(8#*+(,.%%.&36('3'#*./

)-'0+3#)"+(8#+(,+,,&#**'(8 0+)&.;*3&6)36&+-+(,0')&.<-#4#-'**6#*L!"'*'0%-'#*

8&#+3#&'(/.&0+3'.(*"+&'(8 +(,0.&#*5*3#0+3')#4+-6+3'.(./).<.%#&+3'.(+)3'4'3'#*L

!

[C&.4',#*6%%.&33. ).6(3&5 +(,&#8'.(+-*5*3#0*+(,'(*3'363'.(*/.&+8&')6-36&#+(,

&6&+-,#4#-.%0#(3+(,*#3%&.A#)3*+(,%&.8&+00#*'(3"#/&+0#@.&J./).6(3&5<

.@(#,&.+,0+%*+(,+)3'.(%-+(*L

!

[N&'(8 &#8'.(+-+(,).(3'(#(3+-%#&*%#)3'4#*'(3. /.)6*;+(,'(3#8&+3#3"#*#%#&*%#)3'4#*

'(3. %-+(('(8;'(4#*30#(3+(,#$3#&(+-+**'*3+()#%&.8&+00#*L

!

[H$3#(,3'0#/&+0#*/.&'(4#*30#(3+(,)"+(8#%&.)#**#*+)&.**IS 3. fS 5#+&*L

&$

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 56: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!"#$%&'+

T$+()*,(3",3(0Q

'60 +#3$-),&#$+#(H(#5,6)$-

.#/0(,1 20-3",&#$

J0&K&$;986&$)9SNELPD07,0%O0(LPSP

'$

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 57: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

=)&$=0**);0*

E0''*$'8)*6!"#$% #$%$:8)#3%$!*$,0J,

!

7N.3"&6&+-+(,6&7+('(/&+*3&6)36&#+&#J#5 #-#0#(3*'(,#4#-.%'(8 8&.@3"%+3"*3"+3

%6--%..&@.0#( +(,0#( .63./%.4#&35 75 '()&#+*'(8 3"#'&%&.,6)3'4'35 +(,

8#(#&+3'(8 %.*'3'4#&6&+-<6&7+(#).(.0')'(3#&+)3'.(+(,0'8&+3'.(LW+**'4#%.4#&35

&#,6)3'.("+%%#(*3"'*@+5 +(,&#Q6'&#*+ "68#'()&#+*#'('(/&+*3&6)36&#%&.4'*'.(

@'3"'(+ f 3. V ,#)+,#3'0#/&+0#L

!

[N+*')&6&+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#)+(7#8#(#&+3#,75 ).006('35 #//.&3*6*'(8 -.)+--+7.6&+3

-.@).*3;@"')"'*+('0%.&3+(3/.&0./)+%'3+-'(4#*30#(3LN63-+&8#&.(<8.'(8 #//.&3*

&#Q6'&#.(<8.'(8 %-+(('(8 +(,/6(,'(8 %&.)#**#*3"+3%&.4',#(+3'.(+-'0%#36*+(,

'()#(3'4#*/.&-.)+-+63".&'3'#*3. 76'-,'0%-#0#(3+3'.()+%+)'3'#*+(,3. %#&/.&0L

!

[?&.@3",&'4#*'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#0+(,+(,8#(#&+3#*%67-')&#4#(6#*3"+3)+(/'(+()#

%67-')'(4#*30#(3'('(/&+*3&6)36&#

!

0.4'(8 3. 3"'*4'&36.6*)'&)-#'*J#5L?&.@3"<

,&'4#('(/&+*3&6)36&#,#0+(,+-*. )&#+3#*3"##(4'&.(0#(3/.&).*3<&#).4#&5 *5*3#0*

3"+3%&.4',#3"#7+*'*/.&+ "'8",#8&##./*#-//'(+()'(8L

!

[H$%.&3<-#,8&.@3" &#Q6'&#*"'8"<%#&/.&0+()#'(/&+*3&6)36&#*#&4')#*.( 3'0#-'(#*

-'(J#,3. *3&+3#8')%-+(('(8 ./#$%.&3+)3'4'3'#*+(,+,+%3#,3. 3"#(##,*+(,&"53"0*./

+ ,'4#&*'/5'(8 &+(8#./#$%.&3*LW+(+8#0#(3+(,0+'(3#(+()#*5*3#0*3"+3)+(+**6&#

*6)""'8"%#&/.&0+()#+&#3"6*#**#(3'+-L

!

[B(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3'(1"'(+ "+*+-*. #(+7-#,3"#'(3#8&+3'.(./3"#1"'(#*#

#).(.05 +)&.**+ @',#*%+(./'(,6*3&'#*+(,-.)+3'.(*;'3*#-/+ 0+A.&4#)3.&./

#).(.0')8&.@3"L

!

[!"#'(/&+*3&6)36&#%-+(('(8;).(*3&6)3'.(+(,0+(+8#0#(3%&.)#**#*&#Q6'&#+ "'8"

,#8&##./%&./#**'.(+-%.-')5 +(+-5*'*).07'(#,@'3"#//#)3'4#%.-'3')+-%&.)#**#*/.&

,#)'*'.(0+J'(8 +(,'0%-#0#(3+3'.(

!

,#)'*'.(<0+J'(8 +(,'0%-#0#(3+3'.("+4#

&#Q6'&#,#$3#(*'4#,#-'7#&+3'4#+(,).<.&,'(+3'.(%&.)#**#*'(1"'(+;3"#&#"+*7##((.

*".&3)63L

!

[!"6*76'-,'(8 3"#%&./#**'.(*;'(*3'363'.(*;%&.)#**#*+(,+(+-53')+-+(,0+(+8#0#(3

3..-*/.&'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3"+*7##(+ ).0%-#$ %&.)#**L1"'(+2*+)"'#4#0#(3

.(3"#*#/&.(3*#07.,'#*06)"-#+&('(8 /&.03"#%+&3')'%+3'.(./GH1=).6(3&'#*+(,

06-3'-+3#&+-'(*3'363'.(*'(1"'(+2*'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3L

!

[1"'(+ *3'--/+)#*0+A.&)"+--#(8#*'(3"#/'(+()'(8 +(,0+(+8#0#(3./'(/&+*3&6)36&#;

#(*6&'(8 3"#'&'(3#8&'35;).&&#)3'(8 '(#Q6'3'#*+(,,'*%+&'3'#**6)"+*-+(,&'8"3*+(,

3&+(*/#&*;@"')""+4#7##(+ 0+A.&*.6&)#.//'(+()'(8 /.&6&7+('(/&+*3&6)36&#;+(,

'(4#*3'(8 '( '(/&+*3&6)36&#3"+3@'--"#-% #-'0'(+3#+&#+*./%#&*'*3'(8 %.4#&35L

B(/&+*3&6)36&#/.&+ 8&##(#).(.05 @'3"+('()&#+*'(8 6&7+(%.%6-+3'.('(-+&8#)'3'#*

'*+ /6&3"#&)"+--#(8#./&#-#4+()#3. 9/&')+L

($

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 58: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

K01 5#)03,#*$'8*):8)3%$%$-#,'50/04*.60$,>%),$0)'

!

[9/&')+ "+*+ 0+A.&,#/')'3'('(/&+*3&6)36&#%&.4'*'.(@"')"06*37#.4#&).0#+*+(

#**#(3'+-%+&3./3"#%&.)#**./8#(#&+3'(8 8&.@3"3"+3)&#+3#*A.7*+(,%6--*3"#0+**#*

./%..&@.0#(+(,0#(.63./%.4#&35L

!

[!"#+))#-#&+3'.(./8&.@3"'(9/&')+ *'()#3"#0',<IRRS*'*%&.4','(8 + 7+*'*/.&

,#0+(,<-#,'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3L9\7'8 %6*"] .(9/&')+('(/&+*3&6)36&#@.6-,

*'8(+-3"+39/&')+ "+*(.@7#).0#+ 8&.@3"<.&'#(3#,).(3'(#(3@'3"+ ,.0#*3')0+&J#3

3"+3'*8&.@'(8 /+*3+(,@'3"(#@%&.,6)3'.(%.3#(3'+-L

!

[!"#&#'*+ (#@+&)"'3#)36&#/.&+ *5*3#0+3')+%%&.+)"3. '(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3'(

9/&')+;3"#C+&3(#&*"'%/.&B(/&+*3&6)36&#=#4#-.%0#(3'(9/&')+ ECB=9F;@"')"@'--

,&+@.(3"#+(,3"#B19EB(/&+*3&6)36&#1.(*.&3'60 /.&9/&')+F+(,3"#,#3+'-#,

).6(3&5<7+*#,%')36&#./6(0#3,#0+(,*%&#%+&#,75 3"#9/&')+(B(/&+*3&6)36&#

1.6(3&5 ='+8(.*3')E9B1=FL

!

[?'4#(3"#J#5 '0%.&3+()#./&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.(3. 9/&')+(8&.@3"%&.)#**#*;7.3"'(

3#&0*./#$%.&3,#4#-.%0#(3+(,,'4#&*'/')+3'.(+(,'(3#&0*./\A.'('(8 6%] 9/&')+;

)&.**<7.&,#&'(/&+*3&6)36&#'*+ )&'3')+-/&.(3'#&/.&9/&')+L!&+(*%.&3).&&',.&*;

&#8'.(+-%.@#&%..-*+(,7&.+,7+(,).006(')+3'.(*+&#*".@'(8 3"#@+5

!

).0%-#$

'**6#*.//'(+()'(8;.&8+('*+3'.(+(,0+(+8#0#(3+&#'(4.-4#,+(,7#"'(,3"+3+&#3"#

0.&#7+*'))"+--#(8#*./%.-'3')+-).<.%#&+3'.(+(,%#+)#+(,*3+7'-'35 '(3"#*".&3+(,

-.(8 3#&0*LD#8'.(+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#*)"#0#*).6-,7#+('(3#8&+-%+&3./3"#*.-63'.(*

3. &#0+'('(8 +&#+*./)'4'-).(/-')3'(9/&')+L

!

[9/&')+2*,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*)+(%-+5 J#5 &.-#*"#&#;)&.@,'(8 '(%&'4+3#*#)3.&

'(4#*3.&*3..LK'3"'3*-+&8#*6&%-6*./'(4#*3'7-#/6(,*+(,+ 3+&8#3/.&).(4#&3'(8 +

*"+&#./3"#*#/6(,*'(3. &#+-+**#3*;1"'(+ ).6-,%-+5 + -#+,'(8 &.-#'(8#(#&+3'(8 0.&#

".-'*3')+%%&.+)"#*3. '(/&+*3&6)36&#+(,0+(6/+)36&'(8 ,#4#-.%0#(3+)&.**+ @',#&

&+(8#./).6(3&'#*;6*'(8 '3*#$%#&'0#(3+-3#)"('Q6#*3. 3#*3.63*6)" ".-'*3')

+%%&.+)"#*'(+ *#-#)3'.(./).6(3&5 ).(3#$3*L>#4#&+-7'-+3#&+-+(,06-3'-+3#&+-,.(.&*

+&#+-*. 6*#/6--5 (.@-#4#&+8'(8 6%3"#'&'(/&+*3&6)36&#*6%%.&3L

!

[ .)+-&6&+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#&#0+'(*+ J#5 ,#4#-.%0#(34#)3.&'(9/&')+;%+&3')6-+&-5

&.+,*3"+3+--.@*67*'*3#()#/+&0#&*3. %+&3')'%+3#'(0+&J#3*+(,A.'('(,5(+0')

%&.)#**#*./'()&#+*'(8 %&.,6)3'4'35;#).(.0')0.,#&('*+3'.(+(,6&7+('*+3'.(L

!

[9*'(1"'(+;3"#'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3%&.)#**@'--7.3"&#Q6'&#+(,"#-%3.

8#(#&+3#+ (#@ -#4#-./#$%#&3'*#+(,%.-')5 +(+-5*'*;+(,8&.@3"'(3"#&#-#4+(3

%&./#**'.(*;+-.(8 @'3"*67<(+3'.(+-;(+3'.(+-+(,&#8'.(+-%.-'3')+-+(,'(*3'363'.(+-

%&.)#**#*/.&/'(+()'(8;,#)'*'.(0+J'(8;0+(+8#0#(3+(,0+'(3#(+()#L=#4#-.%'(8

3"#*#)+%+)'3'#*@'--7#+ 0+A.&).(3&'763'.(3. 9/&')+2*#0#&8#()#+*+ %&.<+)3'4#

%+&3')'%+(3'(3"#8-.7+-#).(.05L

)$

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 59: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

T$+()*,(3",3(0 )*,60 I#3$-),&#$+#(H(#5,6)$-.#/0(,1

20-3",&#$Q'60 I()%05#(F +#(,60 C&*"3**&#$

4(;:+06:$26$:&@+0+Q&3 :"#&,( 5:"%"6,(/ /:"?6@ +(. :&.$2,(/ 5"<&:63)

!

[i'+ 3"#'0%+)3.(8&.@3"%.3#(3'+-6@:"$/@ 6@&5:"<,0,"( ";&00&(6,+#0&:<,2&00$2@ +0

&(&:/3B6:+(05":6B?+6&:+(. 2"%%$(,2+6,"(0'

!

%i'+ 3"#'0%+)3./'(/&+*3&6)36&#).(*3&6)3'.("( /:"?6@ +(. &%5#"3%&(6'

!

%i'+ 3"#'0%+)3.(%#.%-#2*-'4#*+(,.%%.&36('3'#*

!

3"#/6(,+0#(3+-,#4#-.%0#(3

'0%+)3<6@:"$/@ &(+K#,(/ 6@&6,%&";%&(B?"%&( +(. 2@,#.:&( 6" K&%":&5:".$26,<&B

:&.$2,(/ 6:+(0+26,"(02"060B5:"%"6,(/ 2"%%$(,2+6,"(0B+(. 2:&+6,(/ &2"("%,2+(. 0"2,+#

,(6&:+26,"(0'

98+'(*33"'*7+)J8&.6(,%+&3')'%+(3*+8&##,3"+33"#&#@#&#3"&###**#(3'+-8#(#&')'**6#*'(

/&+0'(8 +(,+**#**'(8 %.-')'#*+(,%#&/.&0+()#'(3"#/'#-,./'(/&+*3&6)36&#X

!

[H(*6&'(8 *6*3+'(+7'-'35

!

,(2#$.,(/ ;,(+(2,(/B%+,(6&(+(2&+(. &(<,:"(%&(6+#,%5+26'

!

%9)"'#4'(8 #//')'#()5

!

,(2#$.,(/ 5#+((,(/B :&0"$:2& +##"2+6,"( +(. 5$K#,2D5:,<+6&

5+:6(&:0@,50'

!

%B()&#+*'(8 '0%+)3

!

"( /:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B,(2#$.,(/ 5:"2$:&%&(6+55:"+2@&0B

#"2+#&2"("%3 #,(Q+/&0+(. 5+:6,2,5+6":3 .&2,0,"(D%+Q,(/ 5:"2&00&0;":,(<"#<,(/ 5"":

5&"5#&'

9@$06@&.,02$00,"(0+66@,0&<&(6?&:&":/+(,0&. ("6,( 6&:%0";0&26":0BK$6,( 6&:%0";%.-')'#*+(,

%#&/.&0+()#+)&.***#)3.&*L

B(3"'*/&+0#@.&J;+ )&'3')+-/+)3.&'*3"#)+%+)'35 ./3"#*3+3#3.X

!

%W+J#%.-')'#*+(,&#*.6&)#+--.)+3'.(,#)'*'.(*@"')"+&#7.3"&'8.&.6*+(,'()-6*'4#'(

3#&0*./'0%+)3L

!

[H(*6&##//#)3'4#'0%-#0#(3+3'.( +&&+(8#0#(3*; '()-6,'(8 '()#(3'4#*/.&#//')'#(3

0+(+8#0#(3+(,0+'(3#(+()#.(+(.(<8.'(8 7+*'*L

9@&6?" .+30";,'*)6**'.(3"6*&+(8#,@',#-5 +)&.**8.4#&(+()#;%.-')5 +(,)+%+)'35 '**6#*B+0

?&##+06@&;,(+(2,(/ +(. 5#+((,(/D5:"O&26232#&,00$&06@+6+:&2"%%"(#3 6@&;"2$0";,(;:+06:$26$:&

.,02$00,"(0'

9@&.,02$00,"(0+#0" :&2"/(,0&. 6@&<+06,'//#&#()#*7#3@##(1"'(+;?@&:&6@:&&.&2+.&0";%+O":

,(<&06%&(6&;;":6@+<&6:+(0;":%&. 6@&,(;:+06:$26$:&0,6$+6,"(B+(,9/&')+B?@&:&,(;:+06:$26$:&

,(<&06%&(6&;;":6@+0#+//&. K&@,(. "<&:6@,05&:,".B2:&+6,(/ 6@&(##,/.&+ 0+**'4#)+3)"<6%'(

'(/&+*3&6)36&#%&.4'*'.(L !"# ).(3#$3'( 9/&')+ '* ./).6&*# ,'//#&#(3; %.-'3')+--5 +(,

8#.8&+%"')+--5;+(,3#)"(.-.8')+-%&.8&#**'*&#,6)'(8 ).*3*+(,#$%+(,'(8 .%%.&36('3'#*.4#&

3'0#L

*%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 60: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

86&$)A*T$+()*,(3",3(0 D,#(1

>*4#3#0'%$-:3"#0/060$,'ALMNO<.)0'0$,

933"#7#8'(('(8 ./'3*&#/.&0%#&'.,'(IRUeB6@&:&@+. K&&( 6?" .&2+.&0";,(<&06%&(6,( @&+<3

,(.$06:,&0B,(2#$.,(/ 2"+#B",#+(. 5"?&:BK$61"'(+2*'(/&+*3&6)36&#@+*'(%..&*"+%#B,( K"6@

:$:+#+(. $:K+( +:&+0'4( 3"#/'&*3,#)+,#./3"#&#/.&0 #&+;5:,":,63 ?+0/,<&( 6" ,(;:+06:$26$:&

.&<&#"5%&(6;":3"#&6&+-&#/.&0%&.8&+00#+(,/.&3"#*%#)'+-#).(.0')O.(#*E>HP*FL*$2@

:$:+#,(;:+06:$26$:&?+0K$,#6?,6@ ;:&&#+K"$:+66@&#"2+##&<&#+(. ;"".D;":D?":Q 5:"/:+%%&0B$0,(/

#+K"$:D,(6&(0,<&2"(06:$26,"( %&6@".0'

C06@&/:"?6@ 5:"2&00/"6$(.&:?+3 ,( 6@&:$:+#&2"("%3 +(. 6@&F8R0B,(;:+06:$26$:&K&2+%&+

/:"?6@ K"66#&(&2Q'4( 6@&&$$"0B,(;:+06:$26$:&K&2+%&+%+O":2"%5"(&(6";6@&;,<&D3&+:5#+(0+(.

6@&#"(/D6&:%/"+#0;":#"&"B.:,<&( K3 /:"?6@ ,( 6@&:&+#&2"("%3'

B(*3'363'.(+-;0+(+8#&'+-+(,/'(+()'+-&#/.&0*@#&#%63'(%-+)#'(3"##+&-5 IRRS*X

!

[N6,8#3+&5 +--.)+3'.(*@#&#&#%-+)#,75 *3+3#-.+(*;7630.&#%+&3')6-+&-5 75 \*#-/<

/'(+()'(8];@'3").*3&#).4#&5 7#).0'(8 +('0%.&3+(3%&'()'%-#;+**.)'+3#,@'3"-.+(*

3. %&.A#)3<*%#)'/')+8#()'#*+(,%&.4'()'+-+(,-.)+-+63".&'3'#*;/&.0 *3+3#<.@(#,

%.-')5 7+(J*L

!

[9(#@8#(#&+3'.(./#(8'(##&*@+*3&+'(#,L9(,+ ).0%#3'3'4#).(*3&6)3'.('(,6*3&5

@+*/.*3#&#,;@'3"*3+3#<.@(#,+(,%&'4+3#).0%+('#*L

!

[=#-#8+3'.(3. %&.4'()#*8#(#&+3#,).0%#3'3'.(3. 76'-,3"#7#*3'(/&+*3&6)36&#L

!

[B(3"#&6&+-+&#+*;*%#)'/')8.+-*/.&%&.4','(8 '(/&+*3&6)36&#.(+ @".-#<4'--+8#7+*'*

@#&#'(3&.,6)#,+(,&6&+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#"+*).(3'(6#,3. 7#+ 3+&8#3+&#+ @'3"

#4.-4'(8 %.-')'#*+(,&#*.6&)#%&.4'*'.(*L

!

[B(fSSS;/6&3"#&0#+*6&#*/.&&6&+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#3+&8#3'(8 %..&#&+&#+*@#&#

'(3&.,6)#,+(,+ (#@%&'.&'35 /.&76'-,'(8 3&+(*%.&3-'(J*3. 3"#@#*3#&(%&.4'()#*@+*

#*3+7-'*"#,L

9*%+&3./3"'*.4#&+--%&.)#**;'(3#&<&#8'.(+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#@+*%-+((#,+(,76'-3;'(3#8&+3'(8

3"#1"'(#*##).(.05 /.&3"#/'&*33'0#LC( &H5:&00?+3 0306&%@+0K&&( 2"(06:$26&. +(. +#+:/&:+,#

(&6?":Q @+0K&&( 2:&+6&. ,(2#$.,(/B%"06:&2&(6#3B@,/@D05&&. :+,#'\:K+( 6:+(05":6@+0K&&(

%".&:(,0&.'9@&A@,(&0&2"(06:$26,"( ,(.$06:3 @+0.&<&#"5&. 2+5+2,6,&06" 6+Q&"( #+:/&5:"O&260+(.

,0("?@,/@#3 2"%5&6,6,<&,(6&:(+6,"(+##3'

!"#%-+(('(8 *5*3#0%&.4',#,+ ).<.&,'(+3'(8 +(,%&'.&'3'*'(8 0#)"+('*07#3@##(3"#*3+3#+(,

%&.4'()'+-+(,-.)+-+63".&'3'#*;+(,7#3@##(+ -+&8#&+(8#./0'('*3&'#*LE&2,0,"( %+Q,(/ ";6&(

6""Q 0,/(,;,2+(66,%&+0+(+#36,2+#+(. ":/+(,0+6,"(+#,00$&0?&:&.,02$00&. +6#&(/6@'F5&2,+#,0&.

+/&(2,&0?&:&2:&+6&. ;":,%5#&%&(6+6,"(B#,(Q&. 6" 0&26":+#%,(,06:,&0B?,6@ 5&:;":%+(2&:&5":6,(/'

!"#*#/+)3.&*"+4#).(3&'763#,3. 3"#*6%%-5;.4#&VS 5#+&*;./+ 0+A.&(#@ *3.)J ./

'(/&+*3&6)36&#).((#)3'(8 6%&6&+-+(,6&7+(+&#+*+(,3"#4+&'.6*&#8'.(*./1"'(+ ?@,2@ @+0

!%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 61: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&(+K#&. A@,(+6" :&.$2&5"<&:63 0@+:5#3B5:"<,.&;"". 0&2$:,63 ;":&'! K,##,"( 5&"5#&+(. /&(&:+6&

;+06B&H5":6D":,&(6&. /:"?6@'

1"'(+2*'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3"+*7##(.4#&@"#-0'(8-5 /'(+()#,/&.0 ,.0#*3')%67-')

*.6&)#*;@'3"6*#&/##*+(,*67<(+3'.(+-/'(+()'(8 0#)"+('*0*%-+5'(8 '0%.&3+(3&.-#*LC66@&

%+2:"&2"("%,2#&<&#B6@&@,/@ ."%&06,20+<,(/0:+6&B?@,2@ :"0&:+5,.#3 ?,6@ 6@&/:"?6@ 5:"2&00B@+0

$(.&:5,((&. ,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(6'A@,(+@+0("6.:+?( 6" +(3 /:&+6&H6&(6"( -E4":1110;":

,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(6'=+6@&:B6@&"?(&:0@,5 @+0K&&( Q&56?,6@,( A@,(+B#,(Q&. 6" 6@&."%&06,2

5#+((,(/ 0306&%+(. (+6,"(+#+(. 0$KD(+6,"(+##&<&#0";/"<&:(%&(6B+(. 6" 6@&."%&06,2;,(+(2,(/

0306&%+0,6.&<&#"5&.B?,6@ #"2+#/"<&:(%&(6;,(+(2,(/ <&@,2#&0+(. 6@&06+6&D"?(&. 5"#,23 K+(Q0'

N-E4+(. O",(6<&(6$:&0@+<&K&&( $0&. ,( %+($;+26$:,(/ "5&:+6,"(0;":@,/@D05&&. 6:+,(0B+,:2:+;6B

:"+. <&@,2#&0+(. 2"(06:$26,"( &P$,5%&(6I'

;"0 F*40 *8C7!5%$-H24,#4%,0)%4?#$%$30 %$-7J.0),#'0

a#4#&3"#-#**;GH1=).6(3&'#*"+4#%-+5#,'0%.&3+(3&.-#*LB(3"#IRRS*;1"'(+ 7#8+(3. ,&+@

.(3"##$%#&3'*#;+**'*3+()#+(,.//')'+-/'(+()#/&.0 GH1=).6(3&'#*L8+:#,&:,( 6@&:&;":%

5:"2&00B?@&( A@,(+M0"?( ;,(+(2,+#2+5+2,63 ?+006,###,%,6&.B[+5+( @+. +#:&+.3 5:"<,.&. :&0"$:2&D

K+0&. #"+(0+(. @&#5&. %".&:(,0&K+0,2,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. ,(.$06:3'S$65:"/:&00,<&#3B+06@&/:"?6@

5:"2&00/+,(&. %"%&(6$%B0&#;D;,(+(2,(/ ";5:"O&260+(. 5:"<,(2,+#V#"2+#D#&<&#,(<&06%&(6K&2+%&6@&

%+O":;,(+(2,(/ 06:&+%0;":,(;:+06:$26$:&B?,6@ 06+6&D"?(&. 5"#,23 K+(Q05#+3,(/ +( ,%5":6+(6:"#&B

K$6,(.&5&(.&(6";6@&2&(6:+#/"<&:(%&(6K$./&6+(. 5$K#,2.&K6%+(+/&%&(6'

GH1=M=91).6(3&5 8.4#&(0#(3*+(,).&%.&+3'.(*"+4#7##("#+4'-5 '(4.-4#,'(3"#)&#+3'.(./

0.,#&(3&+(*%.&3'(/&+*3&6)36&#'(1"'(+ '(3"'*).(3#$3

!

,(2#$.,(/ +,:5":60B%&6:"0BK:,./&0B

&H5:&00?+30+(. @,/@D05&&. :+,#B?,6@ 2"(2&00,"(+##"+(0+(. &H5":62:&.,6#"+(0#,(Q&. 6" 2"06D

:&2"<&:3 +::+(/&%&(60'N633"##**#(3'+-).(3&'763'.("+*7##(+**'*3+()#@'3"0+(+8#0#(3

*5*3#0*+(,3&+'('(8 +(,3#)"(.-.85L

!"#K.&-,N+(J+(,.3"#&,.(.&*'(3&.,6)#,1"'(#*#.//')'+-*+(,#$%#&3*3. 3"#(.3'.(./3"#

%&.A#)3)5)-#+(,'3*4+&'.6*+(+-53')+-+(,.&8+('*+3'.(+-3..-*;'()-6,'(8 /#+*'7'-'35 *36,'#*;

).*3<7#(#/'3+(+-5*'*;).0%#3'3'4#7',,'(8 +(, #4+-6+3'.(L 9@&0&6&2@(,P$&0+:&("? ?&##

&06+K#,0@&. ,( 6@&A@,(&0&,(;:+06:$26$:&5#+((,(/ +(. %+(+/&%&(60306&%'

93+(.3"#&-#4#-;*%#)'/')#$%#&3'*#"+*"+,+ 0+A.&'0%+)3;;":&H+%5#&[+5+(&0&6"?( 5#+((,(/

Q("?D@"? "( %+(+/,(/ +%&/+#"5"#,0?+0+( ,%5":6+(6,(;#$&(2&"( 6@&5#+((,(/ ";%".&:(

F@+(/@+,'C(. 6@&X":#. S+(Q ;+2,#,6+6&. +22&006" ?":#.D2#+00&H5&:6,0&"( 2:&+6,(/ +(. %+(+/,(/

6@&A@,(&0&&H5:&00?+3 0306&%'9@&X":#. S+(Q +#0" ;,(+(2&. 6@&,(6:".$26,"( ";6@&$:K+( :"+.

%+,(6&(+(2&0306&%''8AE2"$(6:,&0+(. 2":5":+6,"(0@&#5&. ;,(+(2&+(. K$,#. 6@&%&6:" 0306&%0,(

S&,O,(/ +(. F@+(/@+,'9@&:&+:&%+(3 "6@&:0,%,#+:06":,&0'

;"0 P6.%3,*$>*/0),1 F0-23,#*$%$-C2,',%$-#$( P''20'

B(/&+*3&6)36&#'(4#*30#(3"+*"+,+ -+&8#'0%+)3.4#&3"#-+*33"'&35 5#+&*3"&.68"3"#+))#**./

%..&@.0#(+(,0#(3. A.7*+(,7+*')*#&4')#*L=$:+#+:&+0K&2+%&2&(6:&0";&(6&:5:,0&+66@&

6"?( +(. <,##+/&#&<&#B@&#5&. K3 05&2,+#,(2&(6,<&02@&%&0:&#+6&. 6" 6@&05&2,;,20";6@&A@,(&0&

2"(6&H6,( 6@&&+:#3 3&+:0";6@&:&;":%'C(. 6@&K:"+.&:6:+(0;":%+6,"( 5:"2&006" +( &H5":6D":,&(6&.

"%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 62: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

%+($;+26$:,(/ K+0&;":6@&/#"K+#&2"("%3B?,6@ +##6@&,(;:+06:$26$:&2:&+6,"( ,(<"#<&. ,( 6@+6B5$##&.

%,##,"(0";5&"5#&"$6";:$:+#+:&+06" $:K+( +:&+0+(. $(.&:5,((&. 6@&&%&:/&(2&";+#+:/&%,..#&

2#+00B+#K&,6?,6@ +:+5,. :,0&,( ,(&P$+#,63'

G//6(,+0#(3+-'0%.&3+()#;3"#&#'*(.@+ *3&.(8-5 #*3+7-'*"#,)+%+)'35 /.&'(/&+*3&6)36&#%.-')5

+(+-5*'*;%-+(('(8 +(,,#)'*'.(0+J'(8;).<.&,'(+3'.(+(,'0%-#0#(3+3'.(+(,*6%%.&3'(8

&#*#+&)")+%+)'3'#*+(,'(3#--#)36+-)+%'3+-L

1"'(#*#%+&3')'%+(3*(.3#,;".@#4#&;3"+306)" &#0+'(*3. 7#,.(#BK"6@ ,( 6&:%0";

,(;:+06:$26$:&0$55#3 +(. ,( 6&:%0";5"#,2,&0+(. ,(06,6$6,"(+#%&2@+(,0%0)

!

%*+(+/&%&(6+(. %+,(6&(+(2&,00$&0@+<&("6+#?+30K&&( ;$##3 :&0"#<&.'

!

%9@&5:"/:&00,<&.&#&/+6,"( ";:"+. 2"(06:$26,"( 6" 5:"<,(2,+#+$6@":,6,&0%+3 :&.$2&+66&(6,"(

6" ,(6&:D:&/,"(+#:"+. 2"(06:$26,"(B?@&:&05,##"<&:00$2@ +06@&:&.$26,"( ";,(<&(6":3 #&<&#0

+:&5"6&(6,+##3 @,/@'

!

%=+5,.#3 :,0,(/ 2+:"?(&:0@,5 ,02:&+6,(/ $:K+( /:,.#"2Q0'

!

%1$K#,2.&K6,00$&0+:&K&2"%,(/ +2"(2&:( +65:"<,(2,+#B%$(,2,5+#+(. #"2+##&<&#0'

!

%!&06&. ,(6&:&060("?&H,06+0+;+26":,( 5"#,23 %+Q,(/'

!

%9@&%+(+/&%&(6";#+(. +2P$,0,6,"( +(. 0+#&0B?@,2@ @+<&K&&( ,(6&(0,<&#3 $0&. 6" ;,(+(2&

$:K+( ,(;:+06:$26$:&B@+02"(6:,K$6&. 6" :,0,(/ ,(&P$+#,63'

!

%4(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(6,0+%+O":2"%5"(&(6";5#+((,(/ 6@&(&H65@+0&";5"<&:63

:&.$26,"( ,( .,0+.<+(6+/&. :&/,"(0,( A@,(+'

#%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 63: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

<+(&")A*T$+()*,(3",3(0 86)::0$;0*)$-?77#(,3$&,&0*

C;:,2+( 2"(6:,K$6":0+(. 5+:6,2,5+(605:"<,.&. &<,.&(2&";3"#4#&5 -.@'(/&+*3&6)36&#%&.4'*'.(

+)&.**+--./3"#0+A.&'(/&+*3&6)36&#*#&4')#+&#+*

!

#-#)3&')'35M#(#&85;&.+,*;@+3#&+(,

).006(')+3'.(*L!"'**'36+3'.('*).(*3&+'('(8 %&.8&#**'(&#,6)'(8 %.4#&35 +(,&#3+&,'(8 3"#

#$%+(*'.(./A.7<)&#+3'(8 /'&0*LC66@&0+%&6,%&B6@&@,/@&::+6&";&2"("%,2/:"?6@ 0,(2&6@&

%,.D&$$"0@+0K&&( 0,/(,;,2+(6#3 +00,06&. K3 :,0,(/ :+6&0";,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(6?@,#&B+66@&0+%&

6,%&B2:&+6,(/ (&?#&<&#0";.&%+(. ;":,(;:+06:$26$:&0&:<,2&0'1.(3'(6#,%&.8&#**.(%#+)#+(,

*#)6&'35;8.4#&(+()#+(,&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.('*+(#**#(3'+-).0%.(#(3./76'-,'(8 .(3"#*#(#@

%&.*%#)3*/.&'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3'(9/&')+ +(,3+J'(8 /6&3"#&3"#)&.**<7.&,#&%&.A#)3*

(##,#,3. \A.'(6%] 9/&')+ +(,)&#+3#(#@,5(+0')*./'(3#&<&#8'.(+-3&+,#+(,'(4#*30#(3L

;"0 Q0+:8)#3%$:)3"#,03,2)0 8*)P$8)%',)23,2)0 P$/0',60$,

j(.@-#,8#./9/&')+2*'(/&+*3&6)36&#(##,*+(,'**6#*"+*7##(*'8('/')+(3-5 '0%&.4#,75 3"#

9/&')+(B(/&+*3&6)36&#1.6(3&5 ='+8(.*3')E9B1=F%&.A#)3B?,6@ +( ,(,6,+#06$.3 ";#) 0$KDF+@+:+(

2"$(6:,&02"%5#&6&. ,( #"&"B6" K&$5.+6&. "( +( "(D/",(/ K+0,0+(. ?,6@ 2"$(6:3 2"<&:+/&6" K&

&H5+(.&.'

!"#9B1=*36,5 "+**".@(3"+3*6*3+'('(8 +(,*3&#(83"#('(8 3"#8&.@3",5(+0')'(9/&')+ @'--

&#Q6'&#+ \7'8 %6*"] '('(/&+*3&6)36&#'(4#*30#(3.(+ *)+-##$)##,'(8 %&#4'.6*#*3'0+3#*L1"?&:

0$55#,&0+22"$(6;":6@&K,//&060@+:&";&H5&(.,6$:&2+62@D$5'C(.BK&2+$0&";6@&&2"("%,2

/&"/:+5@3 ";C;:,2+B+0,/(,;,2+(65+:6";6@,0?,##(&&. 6" K&0$KD:&/,"(+#+(. 2"(6,(&(6+#B?@,2@ ,0+

05&2,+#2@+##&(/&K&2+$0&";6@&5"#,6,2+#/&"/:+5@3 ";C;:,2+B?,6@ %":&6@+( !" 06+6&0'

9(#@+&)"'3#)36&#/.&,#4#-.%'(8 9/&')+2*'(/&+*3&6)36&#"+*7##(#*3+7-'*"#,75 3"#9/&')+(

Z('.(;?@,2@ @+06@&%+(.+6&;":2"D":.,(+6,(/ +(. @+:%"(,0,(/ C;:,2+M0&2"("%,2B0"2,+#+(.

,(;:+06:$26$:&5"#,2,&0B?,6@ 0&26":5"#,2,&0+(. %+06&:5#+(0K+0&. "( 6@&?":Q ";6@&=&/,"(+#

82"("%,2A"%%,00,"(0'9@&(&?2"D":.,(+6,"( %&2@+(,0%

!

6@&C&.8&+00#/.&B(/&+*3&6)36&#

C&.4'*'.('(9/&')+ ECB=9F

!

?,##.&<&#"5 +( ,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(65:"/:+%%&N0@":6B%&.,$%

+(. #"(/D6&:%I+(. +( ,%5#&%&(6+6,"( +(. +26,"( 5#+('

!"#CB=9@'--+-*. %&.4',#+('(3#&/+)#@'3",#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*'(3#&#*3#,'(*6%%.&3'(8

&#8'.(+-+(,).(3'(#(3+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#L9@&14EC,(,6,+6,<&,0K&,(/ O",(6#3 #&. K3 6@&C;:,2+(

\(,"( A"%%,00,"(B6@&Y81CEF&2:&6+:,+6+(. 6@&C;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q'46?,##K&+K#&6"

.:+?"( 6@&?":Q ";6@&4(;:+06:$26$:&A"(0":6,$%;":C;:,2+N4ACI+(. 6@&C;:,2+( 4(;:+06:$26$:&

A"$(6:3 E,+/("06,25:"O&26'

?#$%$3#$(R!%.%3#,1 %$-=2',%#$%9#4#,1 P''20'

9Q6#*3'.(+&'*'(8 '(,'*)6**'.(*@+*@"#3"#&8&.@3"'(9/&')+ "+*&#+)"#,+ &+3#@"')"'*

)&#+3'(8 &#+-,#0+(,/.&'(/&+*3&6)36&#;+(,&#+-'()&#+*#*'(8.4#&(0#(3&#4#(6#*3. "#-%

*6%%.&33"#%&.4'*'.(./'()&#+*#,,.0#*3')/'(+()'(8L9@&0&.3(+%,20@+. .:,<&( ,(;:+06:$26$:&

,(<&06%&(6,( A@,(+,( 6@&&$$"0'9@&C4AE06$.3 0&&%06" @+<&+(0?&:&. 6@,0P$&06,"( ,( 6@&

+;;,:%+6,<&B6@"$/@ 6@&:&?&:&2"(2&:(0+K"$66@&;&+0,K,#,63 ";+K,/ 5$0@ +55:"+2@ ,( &2"("%,&0

$%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 64: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

?@&:&/:"?6@ :&%+,(00#"?B+(. 0"%&0Q&56,2,0%+K"$6#+:/&B;,(+(2,+#D/+5 +(+#30,0+02"%5+:&. ?,6@

@"#,06,2B%$#6,D3&+:,%5#&%&(6+6,"( 5#+(0?,6@ :&+.3D6"D/" 5:"O&260K+2Q&. K3 ;&+0,K,#,63 06$.,&0+(.

;,(+(2,(/ +::+(/&%&(60'*+(3 +(("$(2&%&(60";#+:/&D02+#&5:"O&260,(<"#<,(/ ,(;:+06:$26$:&5:"<,0,"(

+05+:6";#+:/&:,(<&06%&(65+2Q+/&0?,6@ :&0"$:2&DK+0&. :&5+3%&(66&:%0@+<&K&&( 6@,(#3 K+0&.B,(

6&:%0";:&0&+:2@ +(. ;,(+(2,+#6&:%0B+(. #+2Q,(/ ,( 6:+(05+:&(23B?,6@ ?&+Q ;"##"?D$5'

9(.3"#&/6(,+0#(3+-).()#&(@+*3"#"68#)+%+)'35 ).(*3&+'(3*'(9/&')+(*3+3#)+%+)'35 '(

%-+(('(8 +(,0+(+8#0#(3./'(/&+*3&6)36&#;+3+---#4#-*D%+2:"&2"("%,25"#,23 +(+#30,0+(.

5#+((,(/BK$./&6,(/ +(. %&.,$%D6&:% &H5&(.,6$:&5#+((,(/B+$.,6,(/ +(. +22"$(6+K,#,63 0306&%0B

5$K#,2+.%,(,06:+6,"( +62&(6:+#+(. 5:"<,(2,+##&<&#0+(. 2+5+2,63 ;":2"D":.,(+6,"( +%"(/ #,(&

%,(,06:,&0+(. +66@&0$KD:&/,"(+#+(. 2"(6,(&(6+##&<&#0'!"#*#)"+--#(8#*@'--&#Q6'&#3"#

,#4#-.%0#(3./*3&.(8 +(,#//#)3'4#*3+3#'(*3'363'.(+-*3&6)36&#*L9@,0?+0"(&";6@&:&+0"(0?@3

C;:,2+(0?&:&#""Q,(/ &+06

!

6" 0&&@"?6@&0&2@+##&(/&0@+. K&&( +..:&00&. ,( :&2&(66,%&0,( A@,(+

+(. "6@&:0$22&00;$#C0,+( &2"("%,&0'

!"#,'*)6**'.(3"#(0.4#,3. 3"#Q6#*3'.(.//'(+()'+-*6*3+'(+7'-'35'A@,(+@+. %+(+/&. 6"

%+,(6+,( %+2:"&2"("%,206+K,#,63 ?@,#&:+,0,(/ ,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. "6@&:5$K#,205&(.,(/ +00+<,(/0:+6&0

+(. 6+H :&<&($&0:"0&+(. 6@&,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(60?&:&:+,0,(/ 6@&5:".$26,<,63 ";6@&&2"("%3'

4( C;:,2+B,6?"$#. K&,%5":6+(66" %+,(6+,( %+2:" 06+K,#,63 +(. &(0$:&6@+6,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(60

?&:&&;;,2,&(6+(. &(@+(2&. 5:".$26,<,63'-+06/:"?6@ ";&H6&:(+##3 ;,(+(2&. ,(;:+06:$26$:&?"$#.

:&P$,:&$(.&:#3,(/ 06:$26$:+#&2"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"( 6" K&5:"2&&.,(/ +#0" +6+;+065+2&B,;K$./&6

K+#+(2&0+(. &H6&:(+#.&K6+22$%$#+6,"( ?&:&6" K&0$06+,(+K#&'9@,0?"$#. 2"(06,6$6&+<,:6$"$0

2,:2#&'X,6@"$60$2@ +2"(;#$&(2&";;+26":0BK$./&6+(. .&K62"(06:+,(60?"$#. :&P$,:&#"?&:05&&.

#,%,606" K&"K0&:<&.'

!"#$%&'F*40 #$,"0 7J.%$'#*$*8:8)#3%&'P$8)%',)23,2)0

!"#9/&')+(8&.@3"+(,'(/&+*3&6)36&#.63-..J+%%#+&#,3. *.0#1"'(#*#.//')'+-*+(,#$%#&3*3.

%&#*#(3+ "68#.%%.&36('35 3. 0+3)"6%1"'(+2*4#&5 -+&8#/'(+()'+-&#*.6&)#*E#$)#**/.&#'8(

&#*#&4#*(##,'(8 3. 7#,'4#&*'/'#,'(3. &#+-+**#3*@'3"-.(8<3#&0'().0#*3&#+0*F@'3"9/&')+2*

%&#**'(8 (##,*/.&-+&8#<*)+-#'(4#*30#(3'( '(/&+*3&6)36&#/.&&#*.6&)#,#4#-.%0#(3+(,

#).(.0'),'4#&*'/')+3'.(L!"'*).6-,8#(#&+3#+ 0+A.&@'(<@'(8&.@3",&'4#&/.&7.3"9/&')+(

).6(3&'#*+(,1"'(+ '(3"#).0'(8 ,#)+,#*L

>6)"+ ,5(+0')%&.)#**./)+%'3+-#$%.&3'(8 75 1"'(+ 3. 9/&')+ @+**##(75 7.3"9/&')+(+(,

1"'(#*##$%#&3*3. &#Q6'&#*.0#/6(,+0#(3+-)"+(8#*./+%%&.+)".(7.3"*',#*X

!

[1"'(#*#/'(+()'(8 /.&9/&')+(,#4#-.%0#(3'*)6&&#(3-5 "#+4'-5 /.)6*#,.(A6*3k

).6(3&'#*

!

9(8.-+;H3"'.%'+;a'8#&'+ +(,>6,+(<+(,.4#&+--"+*7##(-+&8#-5

%'#)#0#+-LC#+:/&D02+#&2+5,6+#6:+(0;&:+2:"00+?,.&:0&#&26,"( ";2"$(6:,&0?"$#. :&P$,:&

06:+6&/,25+2Q+/&0";,(;:+06:$26$:&;,(+(2&+(. +00"2,+6&. ,(<&06%&(60,( 6@&"6@&:0&26":0";

6@&&2"("%3B,(2#$.,(/ +#0" ;,(+(2,(/ ,(6&:D:&/,"(+#5:"O&260+(. .&<&#"5%&(6'

!

%!"'*@.6-,'(4.-4#7&'(8'(8 '(.3"#&'(4#*3'(8 ).6(3&'#*+(,%+&3(#&*L

!

[1"'(#*#%&'4+3#'(4#*30#(3'(9/&')+ @.6-,+-*. %-+5 + 7'8 &.-#L8<&( ,;6@&0@+:&";6"6+#

A@,(&0&5:,<+6&,(<&06%&(6/",(/ 6" C;:,2+:&%+,(0:&#+6,<&#3 0%+##B,6,0+#:&+.3 :,0,(/ ;+06B

+26,<&#3 &(2"$:+/&. K3 6@&a/",(/ "$6b5"#,23 ";6@&A@,(&0&/"<&:(%&(6'

%%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 65: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!

%B3+-*. '0%-'#*8.'(8 7#5.(,+ 3&+,'3'.(+-/.)6*.(%67-')76'-,'(8*'(1"'(+2*+',

%&.8&+00#*B6" &(2"%5+00+?,.&::+(/&";,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. 0&26":+#,(<&06%&(60'

1"'(+ "+*'(,')+3#,;3"&.68"3"# G191%&.)#**+(,'3*&#)#(3K"'3#C+%#&*.(3&+,#+(,

/.&#'8(+',;3"+3'3'*&#+,5 3. *"'/3'(3"#*#,'&#)3'.(*L1+:6,2,5+(600+?%+O":,%5#,2+6,"(0;":6@&

(+6$:&+(. 6:+(05+:&(23 ";A@,(+M0;,(+(2,(/ 6:+(0+26,"(0B("6+K#3 ;":6@"0&,(<"#<,(/ 2"%%".,63D

K+0&. ,(<&06%&(60+(. :&5+3%&(66&:%0'A@,(&0&2"(2&00,"(+#;,(+(2,(/ ,0,(2:&+0,(/B("6+K#3 ,( 6@&

-'ACA2"(6&H6'*$2@ ";6@&#&(.,(/ +#:&+.3 /"&0K&3"(. 6@&:&+#% ";2"(2&00,"(+#;,(+(2,(/B

+#6@"$/@ 06,##6@:"$/@ 6@&Q&3 A@,(&0&5"#,23 K+(Q0?@,2@ +:&06+6&D"?(&.'

!"#1"'(#*#%.-')5 7+(J*/.&,#4#-.%0#(3-#(,'(8;3"#HlBW N+(J+(,3"#1"'(+ =#4#-.%0#(3

N+(J;@#&#*##(3. 7#+7-#3. ,#%-.5 8..,)+%+)'3'#*/.&%&.A#)3+(+-5*'*;*#-#)3'.(+(,

0+(+8#0#(3;'()-6,'(8 &'*J+(+-5*'*B0" 6@&5"6&(6,+#+(. 6@&(&&. ;":0@+:,(/ 6@&0&0Q,##0?,6@

C;:,2+( 5+:6(&:2"$(6:,&02"$#. %+Q&+#+:/&2"(6:,K$6,"( 6" :&0"#<,(/ 6@&C;:,2+( 06+6&2+5+2,63

5:"K#&%'X,6@ /:&+6&:6:+(05+:&(23B6@,0?"$#. +#0" 06:&(/6@&( #"2+#"?(&:0@,5 +(. +22"$(6+K,#,63

5:"2&00&0B+Q&3 6" #"(/&:D6&:%0$06+,(+K,#,63 ";+(3 %+O":06+Q&@"#.,(/ ,( C;:,2+( .&<&#"5%&(6'C(.

?,6@ /:&+6&:$0&";#"2+#5+:6(&:0,( 5:"O&26,%5#&%&(6+6,"(B#"2+#&2"("%,2#,(Q+/&0+(. 0Q,##

+2P$,0,6,"( 2"$#. K&5"?&:;$#%$#6,5#,&:0";A@,(&0&.&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( ,( C;:,2+'

F092#4-#$( C7!5%$-H24,#4%,0)%4P$8)%',)23,2)0 =2..*),8*)

:8)#3%$50/04*.60$,

GH1=).6(3&'#*+&#(.@@.&J'(8 3. &#76'-,3"#'&*6%%.&3/.&'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3'(

9/&')+ +/3#&3@. ,#)+,#*./,#)-'(#L9@,0,(2#$.&0B("6+K#3B0$55":6;":6@&&H5+(0,"( ";

,(;:+06:$26$:&#&(.,(/ K3 6@&C;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(QB6@&X":#. S+(Q +(. 6@&8$:"5&+( \(,"('

G&:%+(3B-:+(2&B[+5+(B6@&\(,6&. F6+6&0+(. A+(+.+@+<&05&2,;,2K,#+6&:+#5:"/:+%%&0'

!"#H6&.%#+(Z('.(,0K$,#.,(/ +(&? &;;":6"( ,(;:+06:$26$:&$(.&:6@&8\ 1+:6(&:0@,5 "(

4(;:+06:$26$:&B?,6@ 0$K06+(6,+#+##"2+6,"(0;:"%6@&8$:"5&+( E&<&#"5%&(6-$(. #&<&:+/,(/ ;,(+(2&

;:"%6@&8$:"5&+( 4(<&06%&(6S+(Q

!

8\=&"" %,##,"( ";";;,2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&N'ECI

2+( #&<&:+/&8\=&'! K,##,"( ";5:"O&26;,(+(2&6@:"$/@ 6@&;,(+(2,+#&(/,(&&:,(/ ";6@&4(;:+06:$26$:&

9:$06-$(.'9@&1+:6(&:0@,5 &(2"%5+00&02"(6,(&(6+#B:&/,"(+#+(. (+6,"(+##&<&#0B?,6@ +%"<&;:"%

+5:"O&26DK+0&. +55:"+2@ 6" +0&26":+#D#&<&#+55:"+2@ +(. +;"2$0"( 6:+(0K"$(.+:3 2"((&26,"(00$2@ +0

6:+(05":62"::,.":0'9@&K+0,2B06:+6&/,2#,(&0+:&&H5:&00&. ,( 6&:%0";2"((&26,<,63 +(. +22&00

"KO&26,<&0;":?+6&:B&(&:/3B4A90+(. 6:+(05":6'9@&5:,(2,5#&0";6@&1+:,0E&2#+:+6,"( "( C,.

8;;&26,<&(&00+:&+55#,&.B?,6@ "?(&:0@,5 ";6@&5:"/:+%%&0+(. 6@&.,+#"/$&5:"2&00K3 6@&

/"<&:(%&(6+(. ?,6@ #&+. ."(":0,( <+:,"$00&26":06" :&.$2&6:+(0+26,"( 2"060'9@&:&,0+.3(+%,2

5:"2&00?@&:&6@&/"<&:(%&(6+(. 6@&."(":0+:&O",(6#3 ,(<"#<&. ,( 06:+6&/3 +(. ,%5#&%&(6+6,"(B

,(2#$.,(/ 0$06+,(+K#&+::+(/&%&(60;":.&#,<&:3'F$06+,(+K,#,63B6:+(05+:&(23 +(. +22"$(6+K,#,63B/"".

/"<&:(+(2&,( 6&:%0";5$K#,20&26":%+(+/&%&(6+(. ,(06,6$6,"( K$,#.,(/ +(. 2"D":.,(+6,"( +:&K+0,2

"KO&26,<&0'

!"#Z('3#,>3+3#*@+0+( C;:,2+4(;:+06:$26$:&1:"/:+%%&6" 5:"<,.&2+5+2,63 K$,#.,(/ +(. 0$55":6

0&:<,2&0"( :&(&?+K#&+(. 2"(<&(6,"(+#&(&:/3 5:"O&260'd+%+(@+0+05&2,+#;"2$0"( 6:+(05":6

2"::,.":02"((&26&. ?,6@ &(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6+(. &2"("%,2.,<&:0,;,2+6,"('9@&K.&-,N+(J+(.

6@&9/&')+(=#4#-.%0#(3N+(J@+<&:&5:,":,6,0&. 6@&,:,(;:+06:$26$:&5":6;"#,"0'

&%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 66: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

;"0 P$3)0%'#$( F*40 *8C,"0)50/04*.60$,>%),$0)'

B3@+*(.3#,3"+3.3"#&,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*@'3"*'8('/')+(3&.-#*'()-6,#B(,'+ +(,3"#?6-/

>3+3#*;@'3"N&+O'-;j.&#+ +(,!6&J#5 +-*. "+4'(8 #$%#&'#()#+(,)+%+)'3'#*@'3"06)"3.

).(3&'763#LF"$6@ C;:,2+B?,6@ ,60&H5&:,&(2&+(. &H5&:6,0&+(. &(6&:5:,0&0,( ,(;:+06:$26$:&B@+0+

:"#&6@+6+#0" &(2"%5+00&05$K#,2&H5&(.,6$:&+(. 6+H+6,"( ,00$&0B,(2#$.,(/ /&(.&:D0&(0,6,<&

K$./&6,(/'9@$0BC;:,2+@+0+%$#6,5#3,(/ :+(/&";5+:6(&:0?@" 2+( 5#+3 +:"#&,( 6@&:+5,. &H5+(0,"(

";,(;:+06:$26$:&.&<&#"5%&(6+2:"006@&2"(6,(&(6'

:S#( >2'"*$:8)#3%$P$8)%',)23,2)0AH%@#$( #,B*)@

97'8 %6*".('(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3'(9/&')+ *".6-,"+4#+ *3&.(8-5 %.*'3'4#'0%+)3.(

#(3#&%&'*#,#4#-.%0#(3+(,0+(+8#0#(3+(,-+7.6&/.&)#*J'--/.&0+3'.('(9/&')+LB3@'--

3"#&#/.&#7#'0%.&3+(3/.&+--%&.4',#&*./,#4#-.%0#(3+**'*3+()#3. 9/&')+ 3. *##J3. %&.0.3#

3"#*#'0%+)3*B6@:"$/@ 5:"2$:&%&(6.&2,0,"(0BO",(6<&(6$:&0+(. 5+:6(&:0@,50+(. 06+;;,(/ +(.

6:+,(,(/ 5"#,2,&0+0?&##+00$55":6;":<"2+6,"(+#+(. 6&:6,+:3 &.$2+6,"( 5:"/:+%%&0B";6&( ,(<"#<,(/

0$KD:&/,"(+#06:$26$:&0B.&0,/(&. 6" 5:".$2&+%+O":&H5+(0,"( ";2"%5&6&(6&(/,(&&:0B%+(+/&:0+(.

0Q,##&. ?":Q&:0'

!"#+,4#(3./3"#CB=9/&+0#@.&J*".6-,+**'*3+--,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*3. "+4#+ 7#33#&

.4#&4'#@./9/&')+('(/&+*3&6)36&#%&.8&+00#*+(,.7A#)3'4#*+(,3. #().6&+8#3"#,#4#-.%0#(3

./9/&')+(#(3#&%&'*#LC;:,2+( 5+:6,2,5+(60?&:&2"(2&:(&. 6@+6A@,(&0&,(;:+06:$26$:&.&<&#"5%&(6

5:"/:+%%&0"5&:+6,(/ ?,6@ A@,(&0&2"(6:+26":0+(. 6@&0$55":6";6@&5"#,23 K+(Q00@"$#. 0&&Q ?+30

";2:"?.,(/ ,( C;:,2+( &(6&:5:,0&0B6+Q,(/ 2+:&6" +<",. :,0Q0";2:"?.,(/ "$6C;:,2+( &(6&:5:,0&

.&<&#"5%&(6'

!"#*)+-'(8 6%./9/&')+(#(3#&%&'*#,#4#-.%0#(3+-*. %63*+ 0+A.&%&#0'60 .(3"#Q6+-'35 ./

%.-'3')+-%&.)#**#*+(,,#)'*'.(0+J'(8;*'()#3"##//#)3'4#/6()3'.('(8 +(,#).(.0')%&.,6)3'4'35

./'(/&+*3&6)36&#@'--7#)&'3')+-3. 3"#*6*3+'(+7'-'35 +(,8&.@3"+(,%.4#&35 &#,6)3'.('0%+)3./

3"#8&.@'(8 *3.)J./'(/&+*3&6)36&#'(4#*30#(3LC;:,2+( 5+:6,2,5+(60("6&. ,( 6@,0:&/+:. 6@+6

5"#,6,2+#.&2,0,"( %+Q,(/ ,( C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0+(. ,( .&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0(&&.&. 6" K&&%K&..&. ,(

+(+#36,2+#?":Q +(. ;&+0,K,#,63 06$.,&0+(. ?,.&2"(0$#6+6,"( 5:"2&00&06@+6?"$#. /,<&#&/,6,%+23 6"

5:"O&260&#&26,"( +(. ,(;:+06:$26$:&5:"/:+%%&0'9@&/"". /"<&:(+(2&";,(;:+06:$26$:&.&<&#"5%&(6,0

+#0" &00&(6,+#6" 6@&;,(+(2,+#0$06+,(+K,#,63 ";+K,/ 5$0@ "( ,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(6'

'%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 67: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

8#$":3*&#$*

E0''*$'8)*6!"#$% #$%$:8)#3%$!*$,0J,

!

%N.3"&6&+-+(,6&7+('(/&+*3&6)36&#+&#J#5 #-#0#(3*'(,#4#-.%'(8 8&.@3"%+3"*3"+3

%6--%..&@.0#( +(,0#( .63./%.4#&35 75 '()&#+*'(8 3"#'&%&.,6)3'4'35 +(,

8#(#&+3'(8 %.*'3'4#&6&+-<6&7+(#).(.0')'(3#&+)3'.(+(,0'8&+3'.(LW+**'4#%.4#&35

&#,6)3'.("+%%#(*4'+ 3"'*%&.)#**+(,&#Q6'&#*+ "68#'()&#+*#'('(/&+*3&6)36&#

%&.4'*'.(@'3"'(+ f 3. V ,#)+,#3'0#/&+0#L

!

[N+*')&6&+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#)+(7#8#(#&+3#,75 ).006('35 #//.&3*6*'(8 -.)+--+7.6&+3

-.@).*3;@"')"'*+('0%.&3+(3/.&0./)+%'3+-'(4#*30#(3LN63-+&8#&.(<8.'(8 #//.&3*

&#Q6'&#.(<8.'(8 %-+(('(8 +(,/6(,'(8 %&.)#**#*3"+3%&.4',#(+3'.(+-'0%#36*+(,

'()#(3'4#*/.&-.)+-+63".&'3'#*3. 76'-,'0%-#0#(3+3'.()+%+)'3'#*+(,3. %#&/.&0L

!

[?&.@3",&'4#*'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#0+(,+(,8#(#&+3#*%67-')&#4#(6#*3"+3)+(/'(+()#

%67-')'(4#*30#(3'('(/&+*3&6)36&#

!

0.4'(8 3. 3"'*4'&36.6*)'&)-#'*J#5L?&.@3"<

,&'4#('(/&+*3&6)36&#,#0+(,+-*. )&#+3#*3"##(4'&.(0#(3/.&).*3<&#).4#&5 *5*3#0*

3"+3%&.4',#3"#7+*'*/.&+ "'8",#8&##./*#-//'(+()'(8L

!

[H$%.&3<-#,8&.@3" &#Q6'&#*"'8"<%#&/.&0+()#'(/&+*3&6)36&#*#&4')#*.( 3'0#-'(#*

-'(J#,3. *3&+3#8')%-+(('(8 ./#$%.&3+)3'4'3'#*+(,+,+%3#,3. 3"#(##,*+(,&"53"0*./

+ ,'4#&*'/5'(8 &+(8#./#$%.&3*LW+(+8#0#(3+(,0+'(3#(+()#*5*3#0*3"+3)+(+**6&#

*6)""'8"%#&/.&0+()#+&#3"6*#**#(3'+-L

!

[B(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3'(1"'(+ "+*+-*. #(+7-#,3"#'(3#8&+3'.(./3"#1"'(#*#

#).(.05 +)&.**+ @',#*%+(./'(,6*3&'#*+(,-.)+3'.(*;'3*#-/+ 0+A.&4#)3.&./

#).(.0')8&.@3"L

!

[!"#'(/&+*3&6)36&#%-+(('(8;).(*3&6)3'.(+(,0+(+8#0#(3%&.)#**#*&#Q6'&#+ "'8"

,#8&##./%&./#**'.(+-%.-')5 +(+-5*'*).07'(#,@'3"#//#)3'4#%.-'3')+-%&.)#**#*/.&

,#)'*'.(0+J'(8 +(,'0%-#0#(3+3'.(

!

,#)'*'.(<0+J'(8 +(,'0%-#0#(3+3'.("+4#

&#Q6'&#,#$3#(*'4#,#-'7#&+3'4#+(,).<.&,'(+3'.(%&.)#**#*'(1"'(+;3"#&#"+*7##((.

*".&3)63L

!

[!"6*76'-,'(8 3"#%&./#**'.(*;'(*3'363'.(*;%&.)#**#*+(,+(+-53')+-+(,0+(+8#0#(3

3..-*/.&'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3"+*7##(+ ).0%-#$ %&.)#**L1"'(+2*+)"'#4#0#(3

.(3"#*#/&.(3*#07.,'#*06)"-#+&('(8 /&.03"#%+&3')'%+3'.(./GH1=).6(3&'#*+(,

06-3'-+3#&+-'(*3'363'.(*'(1"'(+2*'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3L

!

[1"'(+ *3'--/+)#*0+A.&)"+--#(8#*'(3"#/'(+()'(8 +(,0+(+8#0#(3./'(/&+*3&6)36&#;

#(*6&'(8 3"#'&'(3#8&'35;).&&#)3'(8 '(#Q6'3'#*+(,,'*%+&'3'#**6)"+*-+(,&'8"3*+(,

3&+(*/#&*;@"')""+4#7##(+ 0+A.&*.6&)#.//'(+()'(8 /.&6&7+('(/&+*3&6)36&#;+(,

'(4#*3'(8 '( '(/&+*3&6)36&#3"+3@'--"#-% #-'0'(+3#+&#+*./%#&*'*3'(8 %.4#&35L

B(/&+*3&6)36&#/.&+ 8&##(#).(.05 @'3"+('()&#+*'(8 6&7+(%.%6-+3'.('(-+&8#)'3'#*

'*+ /6&3"#&)"+--#(8#./&#-#4+()#3. 9/&')+ +*6&7+(,#4#-.%0#(38+3"#&*%+)#L

(%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 68: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

K01 5#)03,#*$'8*):8)#3% %$-#,'50/04*.60$,>%),$0)'

!

[9/&')+ "+*+ 0+A.&,#/')'3'('(/&+*3&6)36&#%&.4'*'.(@"')"06*37#.4#&).0#+*+(

#**#(3'+-%+&3./3"#%&.)#**./8#(#&+3'(8 8&.@3"3"+3)&#+3#*A.7*+(,%6--*3"#0+**#*

./%..&@.0#(+(,0#(.63./%.4#&35L

!

[!"#+))#-#&+3'.(./8&.@3"'(9/&')+ *'()#3"#0',<IRRS*'*%&.4','(8 + 7+*'*/.&

,#0+(,<-#,'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3L!"#&#)#(3).0%&#"#(*'4#*36,5 75 3"#

9/&')+(B(/&+*3&6)36&#1.6(3&5 ='+8(.*3')E9B1=F%&.A#)3;@"')"@'--7##$3#(,#,.(

+ ).(3'(6'(8 7+*'*;%&.4',#*3"#/'&*3,#3+'-#,).6(3&5<7+*#,%')36&#./3"#6(0#3

,#0+(,*L

!

[!"#&#'*+-*. + (#@ +&)"'3#)36&#/.& + *5*3#0+3') +%%&.+)" 3. '(/&+*3&6)36&#

,#4#-.%0#(3'(9/&')+;3"#C+&3(#&*"'%/.&B(/&+*3&6)36&#=#4#-.%0#(3'(9/&')+

ECB=9F@"')"@'--,&+@.(3"#9B1=+(,3"#B19EB(/&+*3&6)36&#1.(*.&3'60 /.&

9/&')+FL

!

[?'4#(3"#J#5 '0%.&3+()#./&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.(3. 9/&')+(8&.@3"%&.)#**#*;7.3"'(

3#&0*./#$%.&3,#4#-.%0#(3+(,,'4#&*'/')+3'.(+(,'(3#&0*./\A.'('(8 6%] 9/&')+;

)&.**<7.&,#&'(/&+*3&6)36&#'*+ )&'3')+-/&.(3'#&/.&9/&')+L!&+(*%.&3).&&',.&*;

&#8'.(+-%.@#&%..-*+(,7&.+,7+(,).006(')+3'.(*+&#*".@'(8 3"#@+5

!

).0%-#$

'**6#*.//'(+()'(8;.&8+('*+3'.(+(,0+(+8#0#(3+&#'(4.-4#,+(,7#"'(,3"+3+&#3"#

0.&#7+*'))"+--#(8#*./%.-'3')+-).<.%#&+3'.(+(,%#+)#+(,*3+7'-'35 '(3"#*".&3+(,

-.(8 3#&0*LD#8'.(+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#*)"#0#*).6-,7#+('(3#8&+-%+&3./3"#*.-63'.(*

3. &#0+'('(8 +&#+*./)'4'-).(/-')3'(9/&')+L

!

[9\7'8 %6*"] .(9/&')+('(/&+*3&6)36&#@.6-,*'8(+-3"+39/&')+ "+*(.@7#).0#+

8&.@3"<.&'#(3#,).(3'(#(3@'3"+ ,.0#*3')0+&J#33"+3'*8&.@'(8 /+*3+(,@'3"(#@

%&.,6)3'.(%.3#(3'+-L9/&')+2*,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*)+(%-+5 J#5 &.-#*"#&#;)&.@,'(8

'(%&'4+3#*#)3.&'(4#*3.&*3..L

!

[K'3"'3*-+&8#*6&%-6*./'(4#*3'7-#/6(,*+(,+ 3+&8#3/.&).(4#&3'(8 + *"+&#./3"#*#

/6(,*'(3. &#+-+**#3*;1"'(+ ).6-,%-+5 + -#+,'(8 &.-#'(8#(#&+3'(8 0.&#".-'*3')

+%%&.+)"#*3. '(/&+*3&6)36&#+(,0+(6/+)36&'(8 ,#4#-.%0#(3+)&.**+ @',#&&+(8#./

).6(3&'#*;6*'(8 '3*#$%#&'0#(3+-3#)"('Q6#*3. 3#*3.63*6)"".-'*3')+%%&.+)"#*'(+

*#-#)3'.(./).6(3&5 ).(3#$3*L

!

[!"#H6&.%#+(Z('.('*(.@-#4#&+8'(8 6%'3*'(/&+*3&6)36&#*6%%.&3;'(3#8&+3'(8 3"#

%&'()'%-#*./.@(#&*"'%+(,)+%+)'35 ,#4#-.%0#(3L!"#Z('3#,>3+3#*+(,d+%+(+&#

+-*. "#-%'(8 @'3"*3&+3#8')+**'*3+()#L9(,+ &+(8#./#0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*+&#(.@+-*.

+)3'4#%+&3(#&*'('(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3L>.63"9/&')+ "+*+ %+&3')6-+&&.-#LB3

@'--7#'0%.&3+(33"+3+--3"#*##//.&3*7#)."#&#(3;@'3"/6()3'.(+-).<.%#&+3'.(+(,

).0%#3'3'.(;+(,#(*6&'(8 3"+39/&')+(#(3#&%&'*#*+&#/.*3#&#,'(3"#%&.)#**L9--3"#*#

%.**'7'-'3'#*'0%-5 + /6&3"#&,#8&##./).()#&3+3'.(+0.(8 9/&')+ +(,'3*,#4#-.%0#(3

%+&3(#&*L

!

[ .)+-&6&+-'(/&+*3&6)36&#&#0+'(*+ J#5 ,#4#-.%0#(34#)3.&'(9/&')+;%+&3')6-+&-5

&.+,*3"+3+--.@*67*'*3#()#/+&0#&*3. %+&3')'%+3#'(0+&J#3*+(,A.'('(,5(+0')

)%

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 69: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

%&.)#**#*./'()&#+*'(8 %&.,6)3'4'35;#).(.0')0.,#&('*+3'.(+(,6&7+('*+3'.(L

!

[9*'(1"'(+;3"#'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3%&.)#**@'--7.3"&#Q6'&#+(,"#-%3.

8#(#&+3#+ (#@ -#4#-./#$%#&3'*#+(,%.-')5 +(+-5*'*;+(,8&.@3"'(3"#&#-#4+(3

%&./#**'.(*;+-.(8 @'3"*67<(+3'.(+-;(+3'.(+-+(,&#8'.(+-%.-'3')+-+(,'(*3'363'.(+-

%&.)#**#*/.&/'(+()'(8;,#)'*'.(0+J'(8;0+(+8#0#(3+(,0+'(3#(+()#L=#4#-.%'(8

3"#*#)+%+)'3'#*@'--7#+ 0+A.&).(3&'763'.(3. 9/&')+2*#0#&8#()#+*+ %&.<+)3'4#

%+&3')'%+(3'(3"#8-.7+-#).(.05L

*&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 70: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!"#$%&',

!$,0(7(&*0 C0/0:#7%0$,

)$-!"#$#%&" '()$*+#(%),&#$Q

8(0),&$; ,60 !$)O:&$; !$/&(#$%0$,

<--&*<O)O)9!6&#7&)9SUESRI0O(3)(1 LPSS

!&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 71: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

=)&$=0**);0*

E0''*$'8)*6!"#$%

!

71"'(+2*-#+,#&*"'%*#3.63+ 7.-,+(,0.3'4+3'(8 4'*'.(6" K&2"%&+%,..#&D,(2"%&

2"$(6:3 ?,6@,( +/&(&:+6,"('9@+6<,0,"( .:"<&+5:+/%+6,2+(. 5:"/:&00,<&5"#,23 +55:"+2@

K+0&. "( &H5&:,%&(6B#&+:(,(/B:&5#,2+6,"( +(. "(D/",(/ +.+56+6,"('

!

%9@,0+55:"+2@ %-+)#,-#+&('(8 +(,'((.4+3'.(+33"#"#+&3./3"#8&.@3"%&.)#**B+##,&.

?,6@ 5&:;":%+(2&DK+0&. 5"#,23 +(. &<+#$+6,"( 0306&%0B2:&+6,"( ";2"%5&6,6,<&%+:Q&60+(.

+22"$(6+K,#,63 ;":5:"/:&00'

!

%9@&*#Q6#()#./#$%#&'0#(3;+**#**0#(3+(,*)+-'(8 6%K&2+%&?,.&#3 5:+26,0&.B?,6@

,(6&:+26,"( K&6?&&( :&0&+:2@&:0B5"#,23 %+Q&:0+(. #"2+#+26":0'

!

%j#5 %.-')5 *"'/3*#0#&8'(8 /&.0 -.)+-#$%#&'0#(3*?&:&6@&:&;":% ";#+(. 6&($:&

+::+(/&%&(60B?@,2@ .:"<&$5 +/:,2$#6$:+#5:".$26,<,63B05&2,+#&2"("%,2U"(&0B?@,2@

2:&+6&. +K+0,0;":&(/+/&%&(6,( /#"K+#<+#$&2@+,(0B+(. 5:,<+6,0+6,"(B?@,2@ @&#5&. 6"

.&2&(6:+#,0&6@&&2"("%3'

!

%9"/&6@&:B3"#*#&#/.&0*)&#+3#,*3&.(8 '()#(3'4#*/.&#(3#&%&'*#)&#+3'.(B?@,2@ ?&:&

0$55":6&. K3 5$K#,25:"/:+%%&0+6#"2+#B5:"<,(2,+#+(. (+6,"(+##&<&#0;":&(6&:5:,0&

0$55":6B,(2#$.,(/ K"6@ a@+:.b,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. a0";6b,(;:+06:$26$:&N&05&2,+##3

,(06,6$6,"(0;":+55#,&. :&0&+:2@ +(. .&<&#"5%&(6I+(. 5"#,23 :&0&+:2@ #,(Q&. 6" .&2,0,"(

%+Q,(/'

!

%!"#-#+&('(8 )6-36&#4+-6#, +(, &#3+'( 3+-#(3#, %#.%-#L C(.B "(D/",(/ 05&2,+#

5:"/:+%%&0@+<&+66:+26&. K+2Q 6+#&(6&. A@,(&0&;:"% 6@&.,+05":++(. K:"$/@6#&+.,(/

?":#. &H5&:606" A@,(+'

!

%!&+,#;'(4#*30#(3+(,+',@#&#&#8+&,#,+*+ &')"*.6&)#./',#+*+(,(#3@.&J'(8 ;:"%

?@,2@ A@,(&0&&(6&:5:,0&0+(. &H5&:602"$#. #&+:(B:&5#,2+6&+(. ;$:6@&:.&<&#"5'

!

%!"#-#+&('(8 )6-36&#%#&0#+3#, @',#-5B0$55":6&. K3 0&26":+(. #"2+6,"(D05&2,;,2

2"(0$#6+6,"( 5:"2&00&0,( ?@,2@ #"2+#+$6@":,6,&0+26&. +00&:<,2&5:"<,.&:06" &(6&:5:,0&

.&<&#"5%&(6?,6@ ;+06D6:+2Q :&05"(0&06" (&?2@+##&(/&0+(. "55":6$(,6,&0'

!

%!"#%&'4+3#*#)3.&#0%-.50#(3)&#+3'.(3"+3&#*6-3#,/&.03"'*#(3#&%&'*#<&')"*3&+3#85

8#(#&+3#,6%@+&,0.7'-'35 /.&0'--'.(*./%#.%-#B5$##,(/ 6@&%;:"%5"<&:63 +(. /,<,(/

:,0&6" +(&?5:";&00,"(+#%,..#&2#+00+K#&6" ;,##+##6@&:"#&0(&&.&. ,( +%":&2"%5#&H

+(. 6&2@("#"/3D,(6&(0,<&&2"("%3'

!

%!"'*@".-#%&.)#**"+*3+J#(VS 5#+&*B06+:6,(/ ?,6@ 0%+##K&/,((,(/0+(. 0%+##

&(6&:5:,0&0'9@&:&?+0(" .&6+,#&. K#$&5:,(6BK$6:+6@&:+5:"2&00";.3(+%,22+5+2,63

.&<&#"5%&(6BK+0&. "( #&+:(,(/ +03"$ /" +(. 0"#<,(/ 6@&(&H65:"K#&%+0,6+:,0&0B.:,<&(

K3 6@&"<&:+##(+6,"(DK$,#.,(/ /"+#0'

!

%1"'(+2*3&+(*/.&0+3'.(*".6-,(.37#',#+-'*#,;".@#4#&L9@&&#6@ ;,<&D3&+:5#+(

"&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 72: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

,.&(6,;,&0+(. +..:&00&00"%&%+O":2@+##&(/&0'F&:,"$00"2,+#06:&00&0+(. #+:/&,%K+#+(2&0

K&6?&&( :,2@ +(. 5"":+(. .,;;&:&(6:&/,"(0@+<&+:,0&('8H6:&%&5"<&:63 06,##&(<&#"5&0

+:"$(. 6?" @$(.:&. %,##,"( A@,(&0&5&"5#&'8(<,:"(%&(6+#.+%+/&;:"%6@&,(,6,+#3&+:0";

(&/#&265&:0,060'

!

%!"#*#)"+--#(8#*+--'0%-5 *3&6)36&+-&#*%.(*#+(,'(*3'363'.(+-)"+(8#LG:&&( /:"?6@

@+0K&2"%&+6"5 5:,":,63 6" :&.$2&6@&&(&:/3 ,(6&(0,63 ";A@,(&0&/:"?6@ +(. 2:&+6&/:&&(

#,<,(/ &(<,:"(%&(60'C(&?6&(D3&+:5#+( ;":6+:/&6&. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('C(. 5"#,2,&0+:&

K&,(/ :&D/&+:&. 6" 5:"%"6&@,/@&:."%&06,22"(0$%56,"( +(. #&00:&#,+(2&"( &H5":6/:"?6@B

?,6@ 0,/(,;,2+(6:&06:$26$:,(/ ,%5#,2+6,"(0'

?*',0)#$( ,"0 7$,0).)#'0 73*$*61 #$:8)#3%

9/&')+ )+(0+J#/+&<&#+)"'(8 #).(.0')+(,*.)'+-%&.8&#**'(3"#(#$3VS 5#+&*LC;:,2+M02$::&(6

0,6$+6,"( 0@"$#. ("6K&+00&00&. +/+,(06A@,(++0,6,0("?BK$6?,6@ A@,(++0,6?+0,( 6@&&$-"0'

C;:,2+M06:+(0;":%+6,"( ?,##K&.,;;&:&(6;:"%6@&A@,(&0&&H5&:,&(2&K&2+$0&6@&2"(6&H6$+#;+26":0D

@,06":,2+#B5"#,6,2+#B/&"/:+5@,2B&2"#"/,2+#+(. 6&2@("#"/,2+#

!

+:&<&:3 .,;;&:&(6'S$6BC;:,2+?,##

@+<&,%5":6+(6#+6&2"%&:+.<+(6+/&0B,(2#$.,(/ 6@&%$#6,D5"#+:/#"K+#&2"("%3 ?,6@ (&?0"$:2&0";

.&%+(. +(. K$0,(&00%".&#0+(. (&?6&2@("#"/,&0?@,2@ ?,##@&#5 C;:,2+6" #&+5;:"/ ;":?+:. ,( 0"%&

2:$2,+#+:&+0'

B(-..J'(8 +"#+,+39/&')+2*3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.*%#)3*;3"#'**6#./#(3#&%&'*#,#4#-.%0#(3'*

)#(3&+-+(,8.#*@#--7#5.(,3"#/+0'-'+&-'*3*./3"'(8*3. ,. 3. '0%&.4#3"#%.-')5 +(,76*'(#**

#(4'&.(0#(3Lj#5 ,'0#(*'.(*+&#X

!

[a+3'.(<76'-,'(8 -#+,#&*"'% @'3" + )-#+&4'*'.( +(, ).00'30#(33. 7#).0'(8 +(

'()-6*'4#;@#--</6()3'.('(8 0',,-#<'().0#).6(3&5 @'3"'(3"#(#$38#(#&+3'.(;0##3'(8

+(,8.'(8 7#5.(,3"#W=?*L

!

[H//#)3'4#*3+3#*+(,&#*%.(*'7-#).&%.&+3#8.4#&(+()#'(9/&')+ 7#).0#+ *3&+3#8')

'(3#&#*3/.&1"'(+ +(,.3"#&#0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*;+*3"#5 76'-,6%3"#'&%+&3')'%+3'.('(

9/&')+2*,#4#-.%0#(3L!&+(*%+&#()5;/'(+()'+-*6*3+'(+7'-'35 +(,/'*)+-'(3#8&'35 +&#

'0%.&3+(3'(3"'*).(3#$3+(,&#Q6'&#).<.%#&+3'4#'(3#&(+3'.(+-+(,,.0#*3')#//.&3*L

!

[!&+(*/.&0+3'.(@'--7.3",#0+(,+(,%&.,6)#+ "68#'()&#+*#'(.&8+('*+3'.(+-

)+%+)'35 '( 7.3" 3"#%67-') +(, %&'4+3#*#)3.&*'( 9/&')+L C#&/.&0+()#<7+*#,

.&8+('*+3'.('*3"#*.6&)#./4+-6#<+,,#,+3+---#4#-*LH(3&#%&#(#6&*#**#(3'+--5 7&'(8

',#+*3.8#3"#&@'3".&8+('*+3'.(LC+&3')'%+3'.('(-.)+-;&#8'.(+-+(,8-.7+-*6%%-5

)"+'(*@'--*%##,6%3"#.&8+('*+3'.(+--#+&('(8 %&.)#**+(,3"##$%+(*'.(./3"#/.&0+-

#).(.05L

!

[!&+(*/.&0+3'.('*+ %#.%-#<7+*#,%&.)#**L .*3#&'(8 6%@+&,0.7'-'35;3"#&.-#./3"#

,'+*%.&+ +(,3"##0#&8#()#./+ 8&.@'(8 %&./#**'.(+-0',,-#)-+**'(+ %&.)#**./

,5(+0'))+%+)'35 ,#4#-.%0#(3'*+ *3&+3#8')%+&3./3"#3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**L9

/+4.6&+7-#'(3#--#)36+-)-'0+3#'*+*'0%.&3+(3+*+ 8..,'(4#*30#(3)-'0+3#+(,8..,

'(/&+*3&6)36&#L

!

[d.'('(8 6%3"#9/&')+().(3'(#(33"&.68"&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.(+(,'(/&+*3&6)36&#+(,

#&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 73: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

%&.0.3'(8 -'(J+8#*7#3@##(3"#+8&')6-36&#;'(,6*3&5 +(,*#&4')#**#)3.&*+(,&6&+-<

6&7+(+&#+*'*+ ,5(+0')8&.@3"/&.(3'#&/.&9/&')+L

!

[H//#)3'4# .(<8.'(8 '(3#&+)3'.(M+,+%3+3'.( 7#3@##( %.-')5 0+J#&*; &#*#+&)"#&*;

#).(.0')+)3.&*+(,%67-')/##,7+)J'*3"#7+*'*/.&3"#/+*3-#+&('(8<7+*#,8&.@3"3"+3

'*%.**'7-#@'3"3"#+7*.&%3'.(./',#+*/&.0 0+(5 *.6&)#*;,.0#*3');&#8'.(+-+(,

8-.7+-L

!

[9/&')+().6(3&'#*g#//.&3*3. *"+%#3"#'&.@((+3'.(+-+(,&#8'.(+-,#4#-.%0#(3

%+3"@+5*+&#7#'(8 *6%%.&3#,75 3"#'&,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*'(3"#8&.@'(8 (607#&./

9/&')+(J(.@-#,8#%-+3/.&0*;%+&3(#&*"'%/.&60*+(,%##&&#4'#@%&.)#**#*+)&.**+

@',#*%#)3&60./'**6#*L

!

[9/&')+(.@(#&*"'%'**3&#(83"#('(8L!"#%.-')5 /&+0#@.&J*+(,'(*3'363'.(*#0#&8'(8

/.&8&.@3";8.4#&(+()#+(,&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.('(9/&')+ %&.4',#+ )#(3&+-%.'(3./

&#/#&#()#/.&/636&#).<.%#&+3'.(L

$&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 74: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

D0,,&$; ,60 8#$,0B,+#(C1$)%&" !$,0(7(&*0 C0/0:#7%0$,

&$86&$) )$-<+(&")

E,02$00,"( +66@,0%&&6,(/ ,( C..,0CK+K+";6@&A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5 #,(Q&. K+2Q 6" Q&3 6@&%&0

&%&:/,(/ ;:"% 6@&F6$.3 G:"$5M0;,:06&<&(6,( S&,O,(/ ,( F&56&%K&:#""$B?@,2@ $(.&:#,(&. 6@&

,%5":6+(2&";+06:"(/ .&<&#"5%&(6+#06+6&?,6@ +( ,(2#$0,<&(+6,"(+#5:"O&26;":&2"("%,2

6:+(0;":%+6,"(']&+.&:0@,5 ,0Q&3 6" 5:"<,.,(/ 6@&<,0,"( +(. #,(Q,(/ ,66" 5$K#,25"#,2,&0+(.

5&:;":%+(2&'

A@,(&0&5+:6,2,5+(600&6"$66@&(+::+6,<&";@"?B,( &$(-BA@,(&0&#&+.&:0@+. 0&6"$6+<,0,"( ;":6@&

6:+(0;":%+6,"( ";6@&(+6,"( ;:"%5"<&:63 6" %,..#&D,(2"%&06+6$0?,6@,( +/&(&:+6,"()

!

%9@,0<,0,"( ?+0("60&6"$6+0+.&6+,#&. K#$&5:,(6BK$60&:<&. 6" /$,.&5"#,23 %+Q,(/ +0+(

&H5&:,%&(6+#B5:+/%+6,25:"2&002#"0&#3 #,(Q&. ?,6@ &H6&(0,<&5&:;":%+(2&%"(,6":,(/ +(.

;&&.K+2Q 0306&%0'

9@&2:&+6,"( ";+( &(6&:5:,0&D.:,<&( %+:Q&6&2"("%3 &%&:/&. ;:"% 6@,05:"2&00'9@&K&/,((,(/0

?&:&)

!

%CK"66"%D$5 :&;":%";#+(. 6&($:&+::+(/&%&(60B?@,2@ 2:&+6&. 06:"(/ 5:".$26,"( ,(2&(6,<&0

+(. #+,. 6@&K+0,0;":";;D;+:%&(6&:5:,0&+(. &%5#"3%&(6,( 6@&:$:+#0&26":'

!

%9@&0&66,(/ $5 ";+( &H5&:,%&(6+#05&2,+#&2"("%,2U"(&NF8RIB?@,2@ K&2+%&6@&K+0,0;":

6@&.&<&#"5%&(6";+/#"K+##3 2"%5&6,6,<&%+($;+26$:,(/ 0&26":B.:+?,(/ "( 6@&#+:/&#+K"$:

5""#:&#&+0&. K3 6@&0$22&00";6@&:$:+#:&;":%0'

1"#,2,&0+(. 5:,":,6,&0?&:&.&6&:%,(&. ,( :&#+6,"( 6" &%&:/,(/ &H5&:,&(2&+(. "55":6$(,6,&0+06@&

5:"2&00&<"#<&.)

!

%F,/(,;,2+(62+5+2,6,&0;":5"#,23 +(+#30,0+(. &%5,:,2+#06$.,&0?&:&2:&+6&. ,( %,(,06:,&0B,(

6@&$(,<&:0,6,&0+(. ,( 02,&(6,;,2,(06,6$6&0+0+K+0,0;":,(;":%,(/ 5"#,23 .&<&#"5%&(6+(.

:&<,&?+(. +22"$(6+K,#,63'

!

%A,<,#0&:<,2&+55",(6%&(60K&2+%&2"%5&6,6,<&+(. 5&:;":%+(2&K+0&.'

!

%1"#,6,2+##&+.&:0@,5 ?+00$KO&266" :"6+6,"( +(. 0&#&26,"(B ?,6@ 06:"(/ 5&:;":%+(2&

"KO&26,<&0B,(2&(6,<&0+(. &<+#$+6,"('

9@&5#+((&. &2"("%3 +(. 6@&&H6&(0,<&06+6&&(6&:5:,0&0306&%?&:&6:+(0;":%&. ,(6" +2"%5&6,6,<&

&2"("%3 ?,6@ &H6&(0,<&5:,<+6,U+6,"( +(. .&2&(6:+#,U+6,"( 6" 5:"<,(2,+#+(. 6"?( +(. <,##+/&#&<&#0)

!

%C66@&0+%&6,%&B6@&06+6&,(<&06&. @&+<,#3 ,( 0$55":6,<&a@+:.b+(. a0";6b,(;:+06:$26$:&'

!

%*$2@ 5"#,23 &;;":6+(. ,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(6@+0K&&( (&&.&. 6" #,(Q $5 6@&<+:,"$0

:&/,"(0";A@,(+'

!"#1"'(#*#0'&+)-#"+**##("6(,&#,*./0'--'.(*./%#.%-#-'/3#,/&.0%.4#&35;3"#)&#+3'.(./

+ -+&8#6&7+(0',,-#)-+**+(,+ ,.67-#*6&%-6*./,.0#*3')*+4'(8*+(,/.&#'8(#$)"+(8#L

C66@&0+%&6,%&B6@&:&@+<&K&&( 2"(0,.&:+K#&0"2,+#06:&00&0+(. +22$%$#+6,(/ 0"2,+#+(. &2"("%,2

%&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 75: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

,%K+#+(2&0'46,0,%5":6+(6("66" ,.&+#,0&A@,(+M06:+(0;":%+6,"( 06":3J6@&:&?&:&%,06+Q&0+(.

0&6K+2Q0+(. %+(3 :&;":%0+:&06,##(&&.&.'C(. %":&6@+( !"T ";A@,(+M05"5$#+6,"( ,006,##:$:+#)

!

%!"#(#@1"'(#*#/'4#<5#+&%-+(#""Q06" +..:&006@&0&2@+##&(/&0)6" ,(2:&+0&6@&P$+#,63

+(. 0$06+,(+K,#,63 ";/:"?6@ %":&6@+( 6@&:+6&";/:"?6@J:+,0&."%&06,22"(0$%56,"( :+6&0

+(. :&.$2&6@&&H5":6D":,&(6+6,"( ";,(.$06:3J2"::&26?,.&(,(/ 0"2,+#+(. :&/,"(+#

,%K+#+(2&0J&#,%,(+6&:&%+,(,(/ 5"<&:63J+(. 0@+:&+26,<&#3 ,( 6@&/"<&:(+(2&";6@&

,(6&:(+6,"(+#0306&%D+##6@,0,%5#3,(/ +22&#&:+6&. ,(06,6$6,"(+#:&;":%'

9/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3*+33"#9,,'*97+7+ 0##3'(8 +8+'(',#(3'/'#,3"#(##,/.&-#+,#&*"'%'(

9/&')+(*3+3#*3. )&#+3#'()-6*'4#;0.3'4+3'(8;(+3'.(+-4'*'.(*+(,%.-'3')+-).(*#(*6*;+(,3.

8#(#&+3#3"#%.-')5 %&.)#**#*+(,%67-')8..,*3. *%##,6%3"#3&+(*/.&0+3'.(./3"#'&).6(3&'#*

3. 0',,-#<'().0#*3+36*L

9@&/:"?6@ :&2":. ,( C;:,2+@+05,2Q&. $5 %+:Q&.#3 ,( :&2&(63&+:0B06,%$#+6&. K3 6@&+..,6,"(+#

.&%+(. ;":(+6$:+#:&0"$:2&0;:"% &%&:/,(/ &2"("%,&0B("6+K#3 A@,(++(. 4(.,+B+(. K3 5"#,23

,%5:"<&%&(60,( %+(3 C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0B,(2#$.,(/ :&/,"(+#,(6&/:+6,"( ;:+%&?":Q0'

9@&2"(6,($+6,"( +(. +22&#&:+6,"( ";6@,0$56$:( ,( /:"?6@ 5&:;":%+(2&?,##5:"%"6&B+(. .&%+(.B6@&

.&<&#"5%&(6";6@&&(6&:5:,0&0&26":'9@&:&+:&0,/(0";06:&(/6@&(,(/ /#"K+#,(<&06":5&:2&56,"(0";+(

$(;"#.,(/ C;:,2+( /:"?6@ 06":3'

C(+#30,0";6@&/:"?6@ :&2":.0";C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0,(.,2+6&06@+66@&:&#+6,<&$(.&:5&:;":%+(2&";6@&

5+06;&?.&2+.&02+( K&+66:,K$6&. 6" +($%K&:";5"#,23 03(.:"%&0

!

5&:<&:0&&2"("%,2,(2&(6,<&

06:$26$:&0J5:&.+6":3 #&+.&:0@,5B?,6@ :&(6D0&&Q,(/ +(. 2"::$56,"( +%"(/ &#,6&0+(. &6@(,2/:"$50J

K""%+(. K$065$K#,2&H5&(.,6$:&232#&0J+(. 06+6&;+,#$:&+(. K:&+Q."?('

!

%9"/&6@&:6@&0&03(.:"%&0:&.$2&. C;:,2+( /:"?6@ :+6&0"( +<&:+/&K3 #T 5&:2+5,6+"<&:

6@&&$*"D#""" 5&:,".B+22"$(6,(/ ;":%":&6@+( 6@&/:"?6@ /+5 ?,6@ "6@&:5+:60";6@&?":#.

&H2&56;":8+06C0,+'

!

%9@&5:"05&260;":6@&C;:,2+( /:"?6@ 06":3 6" K&2"%&+( &06+K#,0@&. 5@&("%&("(B+66:+26,(/

#+:/&+%"$(60";."%&06,2+(. ;":&,/( ,(<&06%&(6+(. &(6&:5:,0&2:&+6,"(B.&5&(. $5"(

+<",.,(/ 6@&0&:&2$::,(/ 03(.:"%&0,( 6@&;$6$:&'

9@$0B+a03(.:"%&D;:&&bC;:,2+?"$#. "5&( 6@&?+3 ;":+( C;:,2+( &2"("%,2%,:+2#&'9@&&<,.&(2&

0$//&0606@+66@&%"06&;;&26,<&?+3 ";+00$:,(/ 03(.:"%&D;:&&5"#,2,&0+:&2"(06,6$6,"(06@+65#+2&

2"(06:+,(60"( 6@&&H&2$6,<&B,(2#$.,(/ ("6+K#3 6@:"$/@ 6&:%#,%,6+6,"(0'

F6+6&K:&+Q."?( +(. 5:&.+6":3 #&+.&:0@,5 +:&5+:6,2$#+:#3 2"06#3B";6&( ,(<"#<,(/ 2"(;#,26?,6@ :&/,"(+#

:&5&:2$00,"(0'X,6@ "<&:!" 0"<&:&,/( 06+6&0B";6&( ?,6@ 2"%5#&H &6@(,2,63 5:"K#&%0B6@&&%&:/&(2&

";#&+.&:0@,5 ,( C;:,2+?,6@ &;;&26,<&(+6,"(DK$,#.,(/ 0Q,##0+(. .&<&#"5%&(6+#<,0,"( ,0;:&P$&(6#3

5:"K#&%+6,2'

=&/,"(+#,(6&/:+6,"( +(. 2"(6,(&(6+#5"#,23 .&;,(,6,"(B5&&::&<,&?5:"2&00&0B+(. 5&+2&+(. 0&2$:,63

+:2@,6&26$:&+:&";05&2,+#,%5":6+(2&,( 6@,02"(6&H6'9@&C;:,2+( \(,"( @+06@&0&%+(.+6&0+(. ,0

5:"/:&00,<&#3 5:"<,.,(/ 6@&aC;:,2+( 5$K#,2/"".0b6@+62+( +00$:&+.3(+%,2B03(.:"%&D;:&&/:"?6@

5+6@ ;":C;:,2+'

&&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 76: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

I#*,0(&$; ,60 !$,0(7(&*0 !"#$#%1Q86&$) )$-<+(&")

4( A@,(+B6@&2:&+6,"( ";6@&&(6&:5:,0&&2"("%3 ?&(6@+(. ,( @+(. ?,6@ 6@&2@+(/&;:"%+0"2,+#,06

&2"("%3 6" +%+:Q&6&2"("%3B+/:,2$#6$:+#:&;":% +(. 6@&.&2,0,"( 6" O",( $5 ?,6@ 6@&/#"K+#

&2"("%3)

!

%1"#,2,&06+:/&6&. 6"?( +(. <,##+/&&(6&:5:,0&2:&+6,"( N9!80IB05&2,+#&2"("%,2U"(&0+(.

?,.&05:&+. 5:,<+6,0+6,"( ";F6+6&D"?(&. &(6&:5:,0&0'C/:,2$#6$:+#%".&:(,0+6,"( ?+05$:0$&.

,( 6+(.&%?,6@ ,(.$06:,+#%".&:(,0+6,"(B,( +( &(6&:5:,0&D,(6&(0,<&.3(+%,25:"2&00'

!

%1"#,23 ;:+%&?":Q0?&:&,%5:"<&. 5:"/:&00,<&#3 +(. &<&(6$+##3 5$6,(6" #&/+#;":%?,6@ +

2"%5#&6&0&6";#+?02"<&:,(/ 9!80BF*8M0+(. -E4'9@&F6+6&%"<&. ;:"% K&,(/ +

:&/$#+6":6" K&,(/ +0&:<,2&5:"<,.&:+(. ;+2,#,6+6":;":&(6&:5:,0&2:&+6,"( +(. /:"?6@'

4(6&(0,<&2"(0$#6+6,"( 5:"2&00&0?&:&&06+K#,0@&. ,( 6"?(0B<,##+/&0+(. F8R06" .&+#?,6@

5:"K#&%0+(. "55":6$(,6,&0"( +;+06D6:+2Q K+0,0'

!

%4(;:+06:$26$:&?+0/,<&( @,/@ ,%5":6+(2&

!

6:+(05":6B?+6&:+(. &(&:/3'

!

%*+(+/&%&(606:&(/6@&(,(/ ;":F*80?+0+5:,":,63 +(. 06:+6&/,&0;":@,/@D6&2@ .&<&#"5%&(6

5$6,( 5#+2&'

!

%9".+3B"(#3 +T ";&(6&:5:,0&0+:&,( 6@&F6+6&0&26":'9@&3 +:&#+:/&&(6&:5:,0&0B

+22"$(6,(/ ;":+"T ";GE1BK$6$"T ";&%5#"3%&(6,0,( 6@&5:,<+6&0&26":'CK""%,(/

5:,<+6&0&26":@+0K&&( 6@&Q&3 .:,<,(/ ;":2&,( 6@&A@,(&0&&2"("%3'

B(9/&')+;3"#&#"+*7##(#$3#(*'4#%&'4+3'*+3'.(;7633"##0#&8#()#./+ 4'7&+(3;'((.4+3'4#

%&'4+3#*#)3.&"+*(.37##(*%.(3+(#.6*'(0+(5 9/&')+(*3+3#*LN639/&')+(%.-')5 0+J#&*;

'(*%'&#,75 +(,-#+&('(8 /&.01"'(+ +(,.3"#&#0#&8'(8 0+&J#3*;+&#(.@0+J'(8 #(3#&%&'*#

,#4#-.%0#(3+(, #0%-.50#(3+ ).&# %&'.&'35L 9(, (#@ 9/&')+( 76*'(#**0.,#-*+(,

#(3&#%&#(#6&*"'%+&#(.@#0#&8'(8 +(,3"#).&%.&+3#7+(J'(8 0+&J#3'*#$%+(,'(8X

!

[!"#&.-#./3"#>3+3#+*+ /+)'-'3+3.&./#(3#&%&'*#)&#+3'.("+*7##(&#).8('*#,'(3"#

)&#+3'.(;'(fSSc;./3"#9/&')+(Z('.(C&'4+3#>#)3.& .&60;3. ,#-'7#&+3#.(%.-')'#*

+(,*3&+3#8'#*L

!

[!"#9/&')+(Z('.("+*+ %&'4+3#*#)3.&,#4#-.%0#(3*3&+3#85 +(,+)3'.(%-+(;76'-3

+&.6(,*3&#(83"#(#,%.-')5 /&+0#@.&J*+(,'(*3'363'.(*;+(,&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.('*+

)#(3&+-3"&6*3L

!

[H("+()#,%+&3(#&*"'%7#3@##(1"'(+ +(,9/&')+ @'--7#./0636+-7#(#/'3L!"#

G191'*+ J#5 4#"')-#/.&3"'*+(,3&+,#+(,'(4#*30#(3-'(J*+&##$%+(,'(8 /+*3L

1"'(+2*.%#('(8 ./'3*0+&J#3*3. 9/&')+(#$%.&3*'*+-*. ./*3&+3#8')'0%.&3+()#

+-.(8*',#GH1=0+&J#3.%#('(8 %&.8&+00#*L

!"#1"'(+<=91 >36,5 ?&.6% %&.)#**%&.4',#*+(.3"#& #$)#--#(3%-+3/.&0 /.& *"+&'(8

#$%#&'#()#*X9/&')+(%+&3')'%+3'.(*".6-,7#'(*3'363'.(+-'*#,L9/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3*+&#(.3'(8 +

(#@+%%&#)'+3'.(+0.(8 GH1=).6(3&'#*./3"#&.-#./3"#>3+3#'(#).(.0'),#4#-.%0#(3+(,

#(3#&%&'*#)&#+3'.(Y+('0%.&3+(3+(,@#-).0#*"'/3'(&#)#(3,#4#-.%0#(33"'(J'(8L

'&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 77: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

C1$)%&" 8)7)"&,1 C0/0:#7%0$,QD,),0*9

!$,0(7(&*0*)$-=)(F0,*

X@+6C;:,2+2+( #&+:( ;:"% A@,(++(. "6@&:&%&:/,(/ &2"("%,&0,0("66@&05&2,;,2&H5&:,&(2&0B

?@,2@ +:&("6:&5#,2+K#&

!

&<&:3 2"$(6:3 ,0.,;;&:&(6+(. ?,##;":/&,60"?( /:"?6@ 5+6@J6@&:&?+0("

06+(.+:. C0,+( %".&#LX@+6,0:&5#,2+K#&,06@&K+0,206:+6&/3 ";5:"%"6,(/ #&+:(,(/DK3D.",(/ 6@:"$/@

2"%5&6,6,<&%+:Q&60B&(/+/,(/ ,( 0$55#3 2@+,(0B5:"<,.,(/ %&2@+(,0%0;"::+5,. ,(6&:+26,"( +(.

;&&.K+2Q K&6?&&( 6@&F6+6&+(. 6@&&(6&:5:,0&0&26":+(. 2:&+6,(/ 6@&@$%+( +(. ,(06,6$6,"(+#2+5,6+#

(&&.&. ;":%+(+/,(/ &(6&:5:,0&0?@,2@ 2+( 5:"/:&00,<&#3 %"<&$5 6@&<+#$&2@+,()

!

[ 9 ,5(+0'))+%+)'35 ,#4#-.%0#(3+%%&.+)"06+:60?,6@ 6@&,.&(6,;,2+6,"( ";&H,06,(/

06:&(/6@0+(. 5"00,K,#,6,&0+(. K$,#.0"( 6@+66@:"$/@ @+(.0D"( ;"2$0&. &;;":60+(. 6:,+#+(.

&::":'C#&+:(,(/ %,(.0&6,0";6@&&00&(2&'4(.$06:,+#,0+6,"( ,0("6+."2$%&(6B":&<&( +

5#+(BK$6+5:"2&00?,6@ +( "(D/",(/ 5"#,23 .,+#"/$&+(. 0&#;D"?(&. :&05"(0&06" 2@+(/,(/

2"%5+:+6,<&+.<+(6+/&0B?@,2@ (&&.06" K&<&:3 0&#;D.,02,5#,(&.'

1"'(+ ,',4#&5 @#--@'3"3"'*+%%&.+)"

!

,6@+. K&&( /"+#D":,&(6&.B&H5&:,%&(6+#+(. ?,6@

,(6&/:+6&. 5"#,2,&0+(. 5$K#,2,(<&06%&(60'46;"$(. &(6:3 5",(60+(. 6@&( %"<&. ;:"%6@&:&B?,6@

06:+6&/,2%+(+/&%&(6";;":&,/( ,(<&06%&(6+(. +,. ,(2":5":+6&. ,(6" ,60&<"#<,(/ /:"?6@ 5+6@'9@&

%"<&6" +%+:Q&6&2"("%3 +(. %&%K&:0@,5 ";6@&X9' @+. 5:"<,.&. &(6&:5:,0&0?,6@ %+(3

"55":6$(,6,&0'C ($%K&:";&(6&:5:,0&06@+6@+. K&/$( +00%+##B#"?D6&2@ 2"%5+(,&0?&:&("?B

6@:"$/@ @,/@#3 ,(("<+6,<&%+(+/&%&(6+(. 0$55":6,<&%+2:" +(. %,2:" 5"#,2,&0B+%"(/ 6@&-":6$(&

!""'9@&2"%5#&H %+(+/&%&(62+5+2,6,&0+(. 06:$26$:&0(&&.&. 6" :$( 6@&0&2"%5+(,&0@+. K&&(

2:&+6&. +#"(/ 6@&?+3'

H3"'.%'+;+0.(8 3"#9/&')+().6(3&'#*(.@ %6&*6'(8 +('(,6*3&'+-,#4#-.%0#(3*3&+3#85;'*

@.&J'(8 @'3" 3"# ,5(+0') )+%+)'35 ,#4#-.%0#(3 +%%&.+)"; 6(,#& '3* ?&.@3" +(,

!&+(*/.&0+3'.(C-+(E?!CFL?&.@3"'*&6(('(8 +3IIT %L+L+(,#$%.&38&.@3""+*7##(fcT

/.&3"#-+*3c 5#+&*L!"#+'0'*3. 7#).0#+ 0',,-#<'().0#'(,6*3&'+-'*#,).6(3&5 '(3"#(#$3IS

3. Ic 5#+&*'4(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(6+(. 5$K#,20";6?+:&B0$2@ +0?":Q 0Q,##,(/ +(. @,/@&:&.$2+6,"(

0306&%0B+:&K&,(/ 0@+:5#3 &H5+(.&. 6" 5:"<,.&+(&? /&(&:+6,"( ";0Q,##&. ?":Q&:0B2"%5&6&(6

%+(+/&:0+(. &(6:&5:&(&$:0'C/:,2$#6$:+#&(6&:5:,0&,0K&,(/ 06,%$#+6&. K3 +(+6,"(?,.&2"%%".,6,&0

&H2@+(/&?@,2@ .&#,<&:05:,2&%+Q,(/ +(. :+5,. 2+0@ 0&66#&%&(606" ;+:%&:0'4(.$06:3D0$55":60306&%0

+:&K&,(/ 2:&+6&. ,( 6@&;":%";,(06,6$6&0+(. 6:+,(,(/ 02@&%&06" +00,06&H,06,(/ +(. (&?&(6&:5:,0&06"

02+#&$5 6@&,:2+5+2,6,&0;":%+:Q&6'E&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0+:&@&#5,(/ ?,6@ <+:,"$0.,%&(0,"(0";6@,0

+/&(.+B?,6@ [+5+( 5:"<,.,(/ +.<,2&"( .3(+%,22+5+2,63 .&<&#"5%&(6%&6@"."#"/,&0+(. 2"(2:&6&

2+0&0'

.--.@'(8 3"'*+%%&.+)";3"#J#5 '(8&#,'#(3'*-#+,#&*"'%@"')"%&.0.3#*+ -#+&('(8 #(4'&.(0#(3

@'3"%'-.3'(8 +(,#$%#&'0#(3'(8;',#(3'/5'(8 +(,76'-,'(8 .((#@.%%.&36('3'#*+*3"##).(.05

,#4#-.%*LB3'0%-'#*+( #//#)3'4#*3+3#L8;;&26,<&06+6&0+(. &;;&26,<&%+:Q&60+:&6@&:&;":&

,(6&:.&5&(.&(6+(. ,(6&:+26,<&?,6@ ;+06;&&.K+2Q 5:"2&00&0+(. +.O$06%&(6'9@,0,%5#,&0.,02,5#,(&+(.

;$6$:&D":,&(6+6,"(B:+6@&:6@+( 6@&5:"6&26,"( ";+2P$,:&. ,(6&:&060":&2"("%,2:&(60'46+#0" ,%5#,&0

K:,(/,(/ 6@&0"2,+#5"#,23 +/&(.+K+2Q ,(6" 6@&&2"("%,2+/&(.++0@$%+( .&<&#"5%&(6+(. @$%+(

0&2$:,63 +:&Q&3 ,(5$60,(6" 6@&.&<&#"5%&(65:"2&00'F"2,+#5:"6&26,"( ,0("6?&#;+:&BK$6,(<&06%&(6

,( 6@,0/:"?6@ ;:+%&?":Q'

(&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 78: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

9(.3"#&J#5 '(8&#,'#(3'*3'0#LK"'-#9/&')+ @'--7#(#/'3/&.03"#-#+%</&.88'(8 .%%.&36('3'#*./

&#)#(33#)"(')+-%&.8&#**;'3'*'0%.&3+(33. &#).8('*#3"+31"'(+ '*@"#&#'3'*(.@ +/3#&

*3+&3'(8;VS 5#+&*+8.;+3+ %.'(3@"#&#0+(5 9/&')+().6(3&'#*+&#3.,+5LF"B,6,0(&2&00+:3

+K"<&+##6" 06+:6B+(. 6@&( 6" +.+56+(. ,%5:"<&5:"/:&00,<&#3'C;:,2+( 5+:6,2,5+(60@+. ,.&(6,;,&. ;"$:

Q&3 .:,<&:0)+#&+:(,(/ +(. &H5&:,%&(6+6,"( 2$#6$:&J0?,;6+(. 6,%&#3 ,(5$60;:"%2&(6:+#+(. #"2+#

/"<&:(%&(60,( C;:,2+J2"%5:&@&(0,<&,(2&(6,<&02@&%&0;":&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6J+(. &.$2+6,"(

+(. 0Q,##,(/ 5"#,2,&0.&0,/(&. 6" /&(&:+6&+5:".$26,<&?":Q;":2&'

)&

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 79: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

86&$) )$-<+(&") )$-,60 V05H:#O):!"#$#%1

X,6@ A@,(+M0a/",(/ /#"K+#b5"#,23 05$::,(/ .3(+%,2/:"?6@ ,( A@,(&0&,(<&06%&(6?":#.?,.&+(.

C;:,2+M0a#""Q,(/ &+06b5"#,23 #""Q,(/ &+06B6@&:&,0+( @,06":,2"55":6$(,63 ;":C;:,2+6" 5#+3 +(&?

:"#&,( /#"K+#<+#$&2@+,(0'S$66@&Q&3 ;+26":?,##K&C;:,2+M00$22&00,( 0@+5,(/ 5"#,23 :&05"(0&06@+6

2+( 2+56$:&6@,0"55":6$(,63'

'8AE,(<&06":006,##+22"$(6;":6@&%+O":5+:6";C;:,2+M0;":&,/( ,(<&06%&(606"2Q0+(. (&?,(;#"?0'

N633"#*3&.(8 3&+A#)3.&5 ./1"'(#*#'(4#*30#(3'(9/&')+ *688#*3*3"+3'3).6-,7#).0#3"#

-+&8#*3*.6&)#@'3"'(3"#(#$3,#)+,#B&<&( 6@"$/@ C;:,2+,0"(#3 6@&6@,:. .&06,(+6,"( ;":A@,(&0&

,(<&06%&(6+(. +22"$(60;":O$06!T ";A@,(+M06"6+#+(($+#"$6;#"?0";;":&,/( ,(<&06%&(6'

A@,(&0&,(<&06":0+:&+26,<&,( !" C;:,2+( 06+6&0+(. 6@&,(<&06%&(6,0,( +##Q,(.0";0&26":0,( +##Q,(.0

";5#+2&0B+#K&,6?,6@ +2"(2&(6:+6,"( ,( 0"%&! ":* C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0'!"#0+'('(4#*3.&*+&#(.3

1"'(#*#>3+3#<.@(#,#(3#&%&'*#*7631"'(#*#%&'4+3#).0%+('#*;0+'(-5 /&.0 + /#@%&.4'()#*

+(,@.&J'(8 @'3"3"#1"'(#*#,'+*%.&+L!"#5 +&#)"+&+)3#&'*#,75 + *3&.(8 #(3&#%&#(#6&'+-

*%'&'3B2"%K,(,(/ :,0Q 6+Q,(/ ?,6@ +5"?&:;$#?":Q &6@,2+(. ;"2$0&. "( 0&,U,(/ "55":6$(,6,&0+(.

+.O$06,(/ P$,2Q#3 6" #"2+#2"(.,6,"(0'9@&3 0&&C;:,2++0+2"(6,(&(6";"55":6$(,63B:+6@&:6@+(

5:"K#&%+6,2/:"$(.)

!

%9@&,:%"6,<+6,"(0,(2#$.&#"2+#%+:Q&6"55":6$(,6,&0B,(6&(0&2"%5&6,6,"( ,( A@,(+B0@,;6,(/

5:".$26,"( 6" C;:,2++(. +22&006" :+?%+6&:,+#0'A@,(&0&,(<&06":02"%5&6&?,6@ &+2@

"6@&:B("6?,6@ ;":&,/( ;,:%0B+(. :+:&#3 ?":Q ?,6@ C;:,2+( 2"%5+(,&0'

1$0@ ;+26":0,( A@,(+,(2#$.&6@&%&.8&#**'4#3&#(,3.@+&,**3&6)36&'(8 +',%&.A#)3*+*#(3#&%&'*#*B

?,6@ "(D/",(/ +26,<&,(<"#<&%&(6";A@,(&0&%+(+/&:0N;:"% a";;,2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&6"

";;,2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6,(<&06%&(6bIB+(. 6@&5:"<,0,"(B$(.&:-'ACAB";+\FE! K,##,"( 5""#";

+00,06+(2&;":5:,<+6&A@,(&0&,(<&06%&(6,( C;:,2+'

&.0 +( 9/&')+( %#&*%#)3'4#;3"#,#4#-.%0#(3'0%+)3@'--,#%#(, .( 3"#*#'(4#*30#(3*

8#(#&+3'(8 *%'--.4#&*./0+(+8#0#(3*J'--*+(,3#)"(')+-J(.@<".@ '(3. 3"#-.)+-#(3#&%&'*#

*#)3.&L

A@,(+M0"?( 5"#,23 6"?+:.0;":&,/( .,:&26,(<&06%&(6?+00@+5&. K3 6@&"KO&26,<&";%+H,%,0,(/ +(.

+K0":K,(/ 6@&0&#&+:(,(/ "55":6$(,6,&0B6" 05&&. $5 6@&%".&:(,0+6,"( ";,(.$06:,&0+(. K$0,(&00%".&#0

+(. 6" /+,( &(6:3 5",(60,(6" /#"K+#<+#$&2@+,(0'C#&+:(,(/ +55:"+2@ 6" ;":&,/( ,(<&06%&(6,( C;:,2+B

,( +/:,2$#6$:&B,(.$06:3 +(. 0&:<,2&0B?"$#. ,(<"#<&6@&&(2"$:+/&%&(6";&2"("%,2#,(Q+/&06@:"$/@

0$KD2"(6:+26,(/BO",(6<&(6$:&0+(. 5$K#,2D5:,<+6&5+:6(&:0@,50'9@&:&/,"(+#&2"("%,2,(6&/:+6,"(

5:"2&00,( C;:,2+,006:+6&/,2+##3 ,%5":6+(6@&:&B5:"<,.,(/ #+:/&:&2"("%,205+2&0;":0$2@ #,(Q+/&0

+(. ;":6@&O",(,(/ $5 ";+/:,2$#6$:&B,(.$06:3 +(. 0&:<,2&0'

A@,(+,05:"<,.,(/ +\FE& K,##,"( ;$(. ";+00,06+(2&;":C;:,2+( F*80B?@,2@ 2"$#. @&#5 6" K$,#.

0$2@ #,(Q+/&0''6@&:.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&5:"<,.&:0+:&+#0" @&#5,(/ ?,6@ 6@,0#,(Q+/&+/&(.+B

,(2#$.,(/ 6@:"$/@ 6@&$(63,(/ ";+,. +(. 6@&5:"%"6,"( ";#"2+#5:"2$:&%&(6"55":6$(,6,&0+0B;":

&H+%5#&B,( #"2+#+(. :&/,"(+#5:"2$:&%&(6";;"". +,.'

946-(#&+7-#/&.(3/.&9/&')+ '*3"#*.)'+-+(,#(4'&.(0#(3+-,'0#(*'.(*.//.&#'8('(4#*30#(3L9

35%')+-4'#@'*3"+31"'(+ '**%&#+,'(8 -+7.6&+(,#(4'&.(0#(3+-%&.7-#0*+&.6(,9/&')+ +(,

*'

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 80: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

.3"#&,#4#-.%'(8 ).6(3&'#*@"#&#'3'(4#*3*L!"#&#'*+ %&#**'(8 (##,3. #(8+8#1"'(#*#

).0%+('#*'(3"#-+(,*)+%#./*.)'+-,#4#-.%0#(3+(,8&##(8&.@3"'(9/&')+L

*+(3 A@,(&0&2"%5+(,&0." ("6@+<&6@&%+(+/&%&(60Q,##0+(. @":,U"(0(&&.&. ;":0$2@

&(/+/&%&(6'S$66" 0$06+,( 6@&,:,(<&06%&(6"<&:6@&#"(/ :$(B2":5":+6&0"2,+#:&05"(0,K,#,63 ?,##

(&&. 6" K&&%K&..&. ,( 6@&,:2":5":+6&06:+6&/,&0'>&#5,(/ 6@&%6" K&5+:6";6@&2":5":+6&0"2,+#

:&05"(0,K,#,63 +/&(.+?,##(&&. ,(6&:/"<&:(%&(6+#2"D"5&:+6,"( +(. +%$#6,.,%&(0,"(+#+55:"+2@)

!

%C( C;:,2+( 5#+6;":%"( 2":5":+6&0"2,+#:&05"(0,K,#,63 ,0(&&.&. 6" K:,(/ 6@,0+K"$6'

!

%9@&'8AE2+( +00,06?,6@ ,60&H5&:,&(2&?,6@ ,(<&06%&(65"#,2,&0+(. *Y8/$,.&#,(&0B+(.

,(06:$%&(600$2@ +06@&:,0Q +?+:&(&006""#;":?&+Q /"<&:(+(2&U"(&0+(. ,60.$&.,#,/&(2&

/$,.+(2&'

!

%X":Q "( 2#,%+6&2@+(/&+(. /:&&( /:"?6@ 06:+6&/,&0;":C;:,2+,( 6@&\Y8AC+(. \Y81

2+( @&#5 +(. 6@&'8AEM0/:&&( /:"?6@ 06:+6&/3 ,0+("6@&::&;&:&(2&5",(6;":.,+#"/$&+(.

&(/+/&%&(6NA@,(+,05+:6,2,5+6,(/ ,( 6@,0?":QI'

!'

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 81: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

C0/0:#7&$; J)*&" 8)7)"&,&0*Q.0#7:0 )$-T$*,&,3,&#$*

9@&2:&+6,"( ";+#&+:(,(/ 2$#6$:&:&P$,:&0+2#,%+6&,( ?@,2@ ,(6&##&26$+#0;&&#<+#$&. +(. $0&;$#J

,(06,6$6,"(0?@,2@ /&(&:+6&Q("?#&./&+(. .,00&%,(+6&,(;":%+6,"(J+(. 06:"(/ 2"%%&:2,+#.:,<&:0'

9&2@("#"/3 +(. ,.&+0+:&("60" %$2@ a6:+(0;&::&.b+0a+2P$,:&.bK3 ,(6&:+26,"( ?,6@ &H6&:(+#+26":0

?,6@ (&?Q("?#&./&+(. K$0,(&00%".&#06@+6+:&6+Q&( $5 K3 #"2+#+26":0+(. .&<&#"5&. ,( 6@&#"2+#

2"(6&H6B+(. ,( 6@&2"(6&H6";5+:6,2,5+6,"( ,( /#"K+#0$55#3 2@+,(0+(. 5+:6(&:0@,50'

A@,(+@+0.&0,/(&. 05&2,+#5:"/:+%%&06" +66:+266+#&(6&. A@,(&0&6" :&6$:( @"%&B5:"<,.,(/ 6@&%

?,6@ /"". #,<,(/ +(. ?":Q,(/ 2"(.,6,"(0+(. :"#&0+(. ,(06,6$6,"(+#&(<,:"(%&(60,( ?@,2@ 6@&3 2+(

%+Q&%+H,%$%,%5+26'9@&0&5:"/:+%%&0+#0" &H6&(. 6" K:,(/,(/ "6@&:6+#&(6&. 5&"5#&6" @&#5 ?,6@

A@,(+M0"(D/",(/ 6:+(0;":%+6,"()

!

%9@&3 2+( ,(<"#<&5+:6(&:0@,5 5:"/:+%%&0K&6?&&( #"2+#+(. &H6&:(+#,(06,6$6,"(0B0$2@ +0

$(,<&:0,6,&0+(. :&0&+:2@ ,(06,6$6&0'9@&3 +:&Q&3&. ,(6" ?&##D.&;,(&. (+6,"(+#"KO&26,<&0+(.

%,00,"(0,( 6@& 02,&(2&B 6&2@("#"/3 +(. &(6&:5:,0& .&<&#"5%&(6;,&#.0+(. 5$K#,2

%+(+/&%&(6'9@&%"065"?&:;$#,(2&(6,<&,06@&&H,06&(2&";+(+6,"(+#6:+(0;":%+6,"(

5:"O&266" ?@,2@ 6@&3 2+( %+Q&+( &;;&26,<&2"(6:,K$6,"('

9/&')+(%+&3')'%+(3**+@3@. J#5 )"+--#(8#*'(3"#'&#(4'&.(0#(3X

!

[ '&*3;3"#,#0.8&+%"'),5(+0')*0+,#%&'0+&5 *)"..-'(8 + %&'.&'35;763#0%-.5+7'-'35

&#Q6'&#**#).(,+&5 +(,3#&3'+&5 #,6)+3'.(;@"#&#3"#&#@#&#*3'--0+A.&,#/')'3*+(,

0'*0+3)"#*L

!

[>#).(,;0.*39/&')+(-#+,#&*"+,5#33. )&#+3#3"#(+3'.(+-%&.A#)3+(,'(3#--#)36+-

)-'0+3#3"[email protected],,&+@3+-#(3#,+(,#(3&#%&#(#6&'+-9/&')+(*7+)J3. 3"#'&).6(3&'#*L

C.-'3')+-+(,76*'(#**#-'3#*4#&5 ./3#(/.&0#,)-.*#,)'&)-#*@'3"#(3&#()"#,'(3#&#*3*

3"+3@#&#4#&5 "+&,3. %#(#3&+3#.&@.&J+&.6(,LB(3#--#)36+-*@#&#(.3@#-).0#,+(,

6*#,#//#)3'4#-5L!"#&#'*(.@+ -+&8#9/&')+(,'+*%.&+;@'3"3"#%.3#(3'+-3. 0+J#+

-+&8#'0%+)3L>.0#).6(3&'#*;'()-6,'(8 H3"'.%'+;+&#%633'(8 '(%-+)#*)"#0#*3.

+33&+)33"#'&,'+*%.&+*3. %+&3')'%+3#'(3"#(+3'.(+-,#4#-.%0#(3%&.A#)3L

j(.@-#,8#(#3@.&J*+&##4.-4'(8 '(9/&')+ +(,3"#&#"+4#7##(*.0#&#0+&J+7-#&#*6-3*;+*'(

3"#)+*#./3"#9/&')+(H).(.0')D#*#+&)"1.(*.&3'60 E9HD1F;@"')""+*"#-%#,3. -'/33"#

@".-#-#4#-./#).(.0')%.-')5 +(+-5*'*+(,,'*)6**'.('(9/&')+ +(,%&.4',#+ (#@8#(#&+3'.(./

%.-')5 +,4'*#&*+(,6('4#&*'35 3#+)"#&*'(3"##).(.0')*/'#-,L!"'*0.,#-'*7#'(8 &#%-')+3#,'(

.3"#&,'*)'%-'(#*LGH1=<=910#07#&*"+4#,.(#06)"3. *6%%.&33"'*(#3@.&J+(,3"#&#'*

*).%#/.&1"'(+ 3. "#-%@'3"3"'*J'(,./+%%&.+)"+-*.;+*'3'*(.@7#8'(('(8 3. ,. '(3"#

).(3#$3./3"# G191L!"#9HD1'*)6&&#(3-5 ).(,6)3'(8 + *#&'#*./).6(3&5 *36,'#*.(1"'(+<

9/&')+ 3&+,#+(,'(4#*30#(3&#-+3'.(*X

!

[!"#.(6*'*".@#4#&.(9/&')+(*3. 8#(#&+3#3"#3#)"(.-.8')+-8.4#&(+()#%.-')'#*+(,

'(*3'363'.(*(##,#,3. +7*.&73#)"(.-.8'#*L!"#&#"+*7##(&#+-*6))#**"#&#'(3"#/'#-,

./B1!*LN63;0.&#8#(#&+--5;&#*#+&)"+(,,#4#-.%0#(3'*(.3+ ,.0#*3')%&'.&'35 +(,

'*-+&8#-5 /6(,#, 75 ,#4#-.%0#(3+**'*3+()#%&.4',#&*L 9(, 9/&')+( J(.@-#,8#

%-+3/.&0*3.. ./3#(/.)6*.(3#)"(.-.85 %#&*#;&+3"#&3"+(.(3"#%.-')5 '**6#*;+(,

3"#5 3.. &+&#-5 +,,&#**%.-')5 0+J#&*L!"#5 (##,3. 7#0.&#06-3','*)'%-'(+&5 +(,

"'

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 82: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

0.&#.%#(3. 3+J'(8 .('((.4+3'.(+(,0#(3.&'(8 &.-#*L!"#&#'*%&.8&#**'(3"'*

,'&#)3'.(&#)#(3-5 '(3"#+&#+*./+8&')6-36&#E199=CF;%67-')/'(+()'+-0+(+8#0#(3

&#/.&0E19NDBF;&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.(E9DB9%&.)#**F;8.4#&(+()#&#/.&0 E9CDW

+(,3"#9/&')+(?.4#&(+()#D#%.&3%&.)#**F+(,)+%+)'35 76'-,'(8 E91N FL

!

[!"#'**6#*'(4.-4#, '( 3"#).00#&)'+-'*+3'.( ./3#)"(.-.85;*6)" +*'(3#--#)36+-

%&.%#&35;@#&#(.3@',#-5 &#).8('*#,.&6(,#&*3..,75 9/&')+(8.4#&(0#(3*;@'3"+

/#@(.3+7-##$)#%3'.(*LK+5*/.&@+&,*".6-,'()-6,#6('4#&*'35<'(,6*3&5<8.4#&(0#(3

%+&3(#&*"'%*Y*3&+3#8')6*#./8.4#&(0#(3).(3&+)3*Y+--'+()#*7#3@##(,.0#*3')+(,

/.&#'8(/'&0*Y+(,'(3#&(+3'.(+-&#*#+&)"+(,,#4#-.%0#(3/&+0#@.&J*LZ('4#&*'3'#*

).6-,7#8'4#(0.&#&#*%.(*'7'-'3'#*+(,#().6&+8#,3. 6(,#&3+J#%##&&#4'#@*;A.'(3

#4+-6+3'.(+(,A.'(33#+)"'(8L!"#5 *".6-,7#(6&36&'(8 3"#)6-36&#./)&#+3'4'35 +(,

'((.4+3'.('(%&.,6)30+&J#3*+(,3"#*%'&'3./,'*).4#&5

!

Q6+-'3'#*3"+3(.@#$'*3'(

1"'(+ +(,.3"#&#0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*+(,3+J#3'0#3. 76'-,+(,&#8'*3#&L

#'

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 83: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

H(00$H(#5,6Q!$/&(#$%0$,):.#:&"&0*)$-20;3:),&#$*

A@,(+;+2&00&:,"$0&(<,:"(%&(6+#2@+##&(/&0BK"6@ ,( ,602,6,&0+(. 6@&2"$(6:30,.&B+(. ,006,##@+<,(/

6" .&+#?,6@ #&/+23 5:"K#&%0;:"% (&/#&26";&(<,:"(%&(6+#05,##"<&:0,( 6@&&+:#3 3&+:0";,60

&2"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"('>"?&<&:B/:&&( /:"?6@ ,0("?+6"5 5:,":,63 +(. &%,00,"(0,(6&(0,63 ,0

;+##,(/ +0(&?6&2@("#"/,&0B&2"("%,2,(2&(6,<&0+(. 5$K#,25:"2&00&02"%&,(6" 5#+3 +(. 2,6,&0K&/,(

6" 2"%5&6&"( /:&&( 5&:;":%+(2&'C#+:/&,(.$06:3B?,6@ &(6&:5:,0&2:&+6,"( +(. &H5":60B,0("?

K&,(/ K$,#6+:"$(. 6@&6&2@("#"/,&0+(. &P$,5%&(6(&&. ;":/:&&( &2"("%,2/:"?6@)

!

%C;6&:(&/#&26,( 6@&&$-"0BA@,(+5$6,( 5#+2&,(06,6$6,"(+#+(. 5"#,23 ;:+%&?":Q0;":

&(<,:"(%&(6+#%+(+/&%&(6,( 6@&&$$"0'4( 6@,02&(6$:3B5$K#,25+:6,2,5+6,"( +(. 5$K#,2

5:&00$:&@+<&K&2"%&5+:6";6@&+55:"+2@B?,6@ +K,/ 2@+(/&,( %,(.0&6+(. +22&56+(2&";

6@&a5"##$6&:5+30b5:,(2,5#&'*&6@".0@+<&%"<&. ;:"% .,:&26/"<&:(%&(62"(6:"#0+(.

."?(06:&+%+K+6&%&(66" $506:&+%5:&<&(6,"( +(. &2"("%,2,(2&(6,<&0'9@&:&,0B@"?&<&:B

+:&#+6,<&#+2Q ";:&0&+:2@ 2+5+2,63 6" K+2Q $5 5"#,23 %+Q,(/ +(. 6@,0:&P$,:&0(&?@$%+(

+(. ,(06,6$6,"(+#:&0"$:2&0'

9/&')+;@'3"'3*-+&8#%.%6-+3'.(,#%#(,#(3.((+36&+-&#*.6&)#*/.&3"#'&-'4#-'"..,*;3"#*)+-#

./3"##$3&+)3'4#'(,6*3&'#*'(9/&')+ +(,3"##(3&#()"#,)5)-#./%.4#&35 +(,).(/-')3*3'--

6(3+0#,'(*.0#+&#+*;'*%+&3')6-+&-5 /&+8'-#'(+ ).(3#$3./&'*'(8 8-.7+-,#0+(,/.&&+@

0+3#&'+-*L933"#*+0#3'0#;3"#&#+&#(#@.%%.&36('3'#*@"')")+(7#+ )#(3&+-%+&3./9/&')+2*

3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**;76'-,'(8 .(3"#%6&*6'3./8&##(8&.@3"+*+ 8-.7+-.7A#)3'4#L9/&')+ )+(

7#(#/'3/&.03"#(#@3#)"(.-.8'#*+(,3"#,#0+(,/.&(#@#(4'&.(0#(3+-*#&4')#*;@"')")+(

8#(#&+3##(3#&%&'*#,#4#-.%0#(3X

!

[!"#&#+&#(#@%.-')5 /&+0#@.&J*).0'(8 '(3. %-+)#'(9/&')+ /.&/.&06-+3'(8 )-'0+3#

)"+(8#*3&+3#8'#*+(,&#*%.(*#*+(,/.&).6(3&5<-#4#-8&##(8&.@3"*3&+3#8'#*L!"#*#

)+(7#3"#76'-,'(8 7-.)J*/.&+ \8&##(#).(.0')3&+(*/.&0+3'.(] @"')"'*7.3"#//')'#(3

+(,,5(+0')+(,@'3"0+(5 .%%.&36('3'#*/.&#(3#&%&'*#,#4#-.%0#(3L933"#*+0#

3'0#;'3'*)&6)'+-3"+38&##( 8&.@3" 7#).0#*#07#,,#, '( ).&%.&+3# *.)'+-

&#*%.(*'7'-'3'#*+(,3"+33"#&#+&##//#)3'4#(+3'.(+-;&#8'.(+-+(,).(3'(#(3+-)+%+)'3'#*

/.&0+(+8'(8 3"#'**6#*+(,+)3'4'35 '(#$3&+)3'4#'(,6*3&'#*+(,%.--63'(8 '(,6*3&'#*;

'()-6,'(8 +8&')6-36&#LC&.4',#&*./,#4#-.%0#(3+**'*3+()#;'()-6,'(8 1"'(+ +(,.3"#&

#0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*+(,GH1=<=91)+("#-%@'3"3"'*+8#(,+L

$'

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 84: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

8#$":3*&#$*

C;:,2+2+( %+Q&;+:D:&+2@,(/ &2"("%,2+(. 0"2,+#5:"/:&00,( 6@&(&H6VS 3&+:0LC;:,2+M02$::&(6

0,6$+6,"( 0@"$#. ("6K&+00&00&. +/+,(06A@,(++0,6,0("?BK$6?,6@ A@,(++0,6?+0,( 6@&&$-"0'

C;:,2+M06:+(0;":%+6,"( ?,##K&.,;;&:&(6;:"%6@&A@,(&0&&H5&:,&(2&K&2+$0&6@&2"(6&H6$+#;+26":0D

@,06":,2+#B5"#,6,2+#B/&"/:+5@,2B&2"#"/,2+#+(. 6&2@("#"/,2+#

!

+:&<&:3 .,;;&:&(6'S$6BC;:,2+?,##

@+<&,%5":6+(6#+6&2"%&:+.<+(6+/&0B,(2#$.,(/ 6@&%$#6,D5"#+:/#"K+#&2"("%3 ?,6@ (&?0"$:2&0";

.&%+(. +(. K$0,(&00%".&#0+(. (&?6&2@("#"/,&0?@,2@ ?,##@&#5 C;:,2+6" #&+5;:"/ ;":?+:. ,( 0"%&

2:$2,+#+:&+0'

B(-..J'(8 +"#+,+39/&')+2*3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.*%#)3*;3"#'**6#./#(3#&%&'*#,#4#-.%0#(3'*

)#(3&+-+(,8.#*@#--7#5.(,3"#/+0'-'+&-'*3*./3"'(8*3. ,. 3. '0%&.4#3"#%.-')5 +(,76*'(#**

#(4'&.(0#(3Lj#5 ,'0#(*'.(*+&#X

!

[a+3'.(<76'-,'(8 -#+,#&*"'% @'3" + )-#+&4'*'.( +(, ).00'30#(33. 7#).0'(8 +(

'()-6*'4#;@#--</6()3'.('(8 0',,-#<'().0#).6(3&5 @'3"'(3"#(#$38#(#&+3'.(;0##3'(8

+(,8.'(8 7#5.(,3"#W=?*L

!

[H//#)3'4#*3+3#*+(,&#*%.(*'7-#).&%.&+3#8.4#&(+()#'(9/&')+ 7#).0#+ *3&+3#8')

'(3#&#*3/.&1"'(+ +(,.3"#&#0#&8'(8 ).6(3&'#*;+*3"#5 76'-,6%3"#'&%+&3')'%+3'.('(

9/&')+2*,#4#-.%0#(3L!&+(*%+&#()5;/'(+()'+-*6*3+'(+7'-'35 +(,/'*)+-'(3#8&'35 +&#

'0%.&3+(3'(3"'*).(3#$3+(,&#Q6'&#).<.%#&+3'4#'(3#&(+3'.(+-+(,,.0#*3')#//.&3*L

!

[!&+(*/.&0+3'.(@'--7.3",#0+(,+(,%&.,6)#+ "68#'()&#+*#'(.&8+('*+3'.(+-

)+%+)'35 '( 7.3" 3"#%67-') +(, %&'4+3#*#)3.&*'( 9/&')+L C#&/.&0(+)#<7+*#,

.&8+('*+3'.('*3"#*.6&)#./4+-6#<+,,#,+3+---#4#-*LH(3&#%&#(#6&*#**#(3'+--5 7&'(8

',#+*3.8#3"#&@'3".&8+('*+3'.(LC+&3')'%+3'.('(-.)+-;&#8'.(+-+(,8-.7+-*6%%-5

)"+'(*@'--*%##,6%3"#.&8+('*+3'.(+--#+&('(8 %&.)#**+(,3"##$%+(*'.(./3"#/.&0+-

#).(.05L

!

[!&+(*/.&0+3'.('*+ %#.%-#<7+*#,%&.)#**L .*3#&'(8 6%@+&,0.7'-'35;3"#&.-#./3"#

,'+*%.&+ +(,3"##0#&8#()#./+ 8&.@'(8 %&./#**'.(+-0',,-#)-+**'(+ %&.)#**./

,5(+0'))+%+)'35 ,#4#-.%0#(3'*+ *3&+3#8')%+&3./3"#3&+(*/.&0+3'.(%&.)#**L9

/+4.6&+7-#'(3#--#)36+-)-'0+3#'*+*'0%.&3+(3+*+ 8..,'(4#*30#(3)-'0+3#+(,8..,

'(/&+*3&6)36&#L

!

[d.'('(8 6%3"#9/&')+().(3'(#(33"&.68"&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.(+(,'(/&+*3&6)36&#+(,

%&.0.3'(8 -'(J+8#*7#3@##(3"#+8&')6-36&#;'(,6*3&5 +(,*#&4')#**#)3.&*+(,&6&+-<

6&7+(+&#+*'*+ ,5(+0')8&.@3"/&.(3'#&/.&9/&')+L

!

[H//#)3'4# .(<8.'(8 '(3#&+)3'.(M+,+%3+3'.( 7#3@##( %.-')5 0+J#&*; &#*#+&)"#&*;

#).(.0')+)3.&*+(,%67-')/##,7+)J'*3"#7+*'*/.&3"#/+*3-#+&('(8<7+*#,8&.@3"3"+3

'*%.**'7-#@'3"3"#+7*.&%3'.(./',#+*/&.0 0+(5 *.6&)#*;,.0#*3');&#8'.(+-+(,

8-.7+-L

!

[9/&')+().6(3&'#*g#//.&3*3. *"+%#3"#'&.@((+3'.(+-+(,&#8'.(+-,#4#-.%0#(3

%+3"@+5*+&#7#'(8 *6%%.&3#,75 3"#'&,#4#-.%0#(3%+&3(#&*'(3"#8&.@'(8 (607#&./

9/&')+(J(.@-#,8#%-+3/.&0*;%+&3(#&*"'%/.&60*+(,%##&&#4'#@%&.)#**#*+)&.**+

%'

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 85: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

@',#*%#)3&60./'**6#*L

!

[9/&')+(.@(#&*"'%'**3&#(83"#('(8L!"#%.-')5 /&+0#@.&J*+(,'(*3'363'.(*#0#&8'(8

/.&8&.@3";8.4#&(+()#+(,&#8'.(+-'(3#8&+3'.('(9/&')+ %&.4',#+ )#(3&+-%.'(3./

&#/#&#()#/.&/636&#).<.%#&+3'.(L

&'

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 86: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

<VV!W!D

<;0$-)*)$-7)(,&"&7)$,*:&*,*#+,60

86&$)EC<8D,3-1 H(#370/0$,*

''

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 87: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction
Page 88: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

<VV!W! T

C0/0:#7%0$,.)(,$0(*6&7*+#(H(#5,6)$-.#/0(,1 20-3",&#$

J0&K&$;986&$)9feEfR ?",#O0(fSSR

T)L<H!VC<

J)"F;(#3$-)$-#OK0",&/0*

9" ;+2,#,6+6&6@&0@+:,(/ ";&H5&:,&(2&0+(. 5:"%"6&#&+:(,(/ "( /:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B6@&

A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5 @+0K&&( &06+K#,0@&. K3 6@&4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,( A@,(+

N41=AAI+(. 6@&':/+(,0+6,"( ;":82"("%,2A"D"5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6M0E&<&#"5%&(6

C00,06+(2&A"%%,66&&N'8AEDECAIB+(. 0$55":6&. K3 %+(3 K,#+6&:+#+(. %$#6,#+6&:+#.&<&#"5%&(6

+/&(2,&0'9@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,0;"2$0,(/ ,60?":Q "( 6?" 6@&%&0)

!

%A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2&";/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B,(2#$.,(/ 6@&2"(6:,K$6,"( ";

,(6&:(+6,"(+#+00,06+(2&B+(. ,60:&#&<+(2&;":"6@&:.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0B5+:6,2$#+:#3 ,(

C;:,2+'

!

%A@,(+M0&2"("%,22"D"5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2++(. ,60,%5+26"( 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('

9@&"KO&26,<&";6@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,06" 5:"<,.&+( ,(6&:(+6,"(+#5#+6;":%;":&H2@+(/,(/ <,&?0+%"(/

+:+(/&";06+Q&@"#.&:0+(. .,06,##,(/ #&00"(0#&+:(6B6@$0&(@+(2,(/ 2+5+2,63 6" %&&60"%&";6@&(&?

2@+##&(/&0";/#"K+#.&<&#"5%&(6'9@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,06+Q,(/ +( &<&(60D.:,<&( +55:"+2@ ,( ":.&:6"

,(<"#<&+#+:/&:($%K&:";06+Q&@"#.&:0,( ,60+26,<,6,&0'

9@:"$/@ +0&:,&0";&<,.&(2&DK+0&. 5"#,23 .,+#"/$&&<&(60B6@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,0#""Q,(/ +6;"$:,00$&0

6@+6:&;#&266@&(&&.0,( %+(3 C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&06".+3)+I.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50BKI+/:,2$#6$:&B

;"". 0&2$:,63 +(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6B2I,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. .I6@&&(+K#,(/ &(<,:"(%&(6;":&(6&:5:,0&

.&<&#"5%&(6'

9@&F6$.3 G:"$5M0;,:06&<&(6"( aE&<&#"5%&(61+:6(&:0@,50;":G:"?6@ +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(b+,%0

6" ;"06&:+:,2@ .,02$00,"( +(. K:,(/ "$66:+(0;&:+K#&#&00"(06@+6?,##@&#5 ,(2:&+0&6@&,%5+26+(.

&;;&26,<&(&00";.&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"(L9@,0&<&(6?,##+#0" 0&66@&06+/&;":6@&F6$.3 G:"$5M0

0$K0&P$&(6&<&(60,( #"&" "( N+I+/:,2$#6$:&+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6BNKI,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. N2I6@&

&(+K#,(/ &(<,:"(%&(6;":&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6L*":&05&2,;,2+##3B6@&&<&(6?,##)

!

%4(2:&+0&$(.&:06+(.,(/ "( A@,(+M006:+6&/,&0B+55:"+2@&0+(. &H5&:,&(2&06"?+:.0#"(/D6&:%

&2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( "<&:6@&#+06+" 3&+:0J

!

%C(+#30&6@&+55:"+2@&0+(. &H5&:,&(2&0";A@,(+"( %+(+/,(/ ,(6&:(+6,"(+#.&<&#"5%&(62"D

"5&:+6,"(J

!

%8H+%,(&6@&:&#&<+(2&+(. ,%5#,2+6,"(0";A@,(+M0/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( &H5&:,&(2&

;":,602"D"5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0J

!

%-+2,#,6+6&+.&&5&:$(.&:06+(.,(/ ";.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50K3 .,;;&:&(606+Q&@"#.&:0,(

C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0+(. &H5#":&?+306" ,%5:"<&,60,%5+26"( :&.$2,(/ 5"<&:63'

)'

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 89: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

.(#;()%%0

G%#('(8 1#&#0.(5

1"+'&XK6P".(8;='&#)3.&<?#(#&+-;B(3#&(+3'.(+-C.4#&35 D#,6)3'.(1#(3&#'(1"'(+

"$)"" ,"$)&"

% K#-).0#D#0+&J*

&'R@&(/ X&(Q+,BE&5$63 E,:&26":B9@&F6+6&A"$(2,#]&+.,(/ G:"$5 ';;,2&";1"<&:63

C##&<,+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6BA@,(+

#'=,2@+:. A+:&3BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5B'8AE

!

%C,%0";6@&ECADA@,(+F6$.3 G:"$5

!

%'KO&26,<&0";6@,0;,:06&<&(6

"$)&" ,"$))" 1"'(#*#+(,9/&')+(C#&*%#)3'4#*X9(G4#&4'#@

&'A@,(+M0&2"("%,2.&<&#"5%&(6&H5&:,&(2&0+(. #&00"(0;":"6@&:5+:60";6@&?":#.

>%#+J#&)X&,[,+(/$"B-":%&:!,2&*,(,06&:";A"%%&:2&B1'='A@,(+

#'9@&(&&. ;":+( &;;&26,<&5+:6(&:0@,5 %".&#,( C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)-:&. [+2@+(D'%+2@ *+(.,:B*,(,06&:";F6+6&;":-,(+(2&B1#+((,(/ +(.

82"("%,2E&<&#"5%&(6B\/+(.+

-&../01O

50/04*.60$,>%),$0)'"#.'%$-!"#$%&'()*+,"

%$-.*/0),1 )0-23,#*$

4( 6@&6@:&&.&2+.&0;"##"?,(/ 6@&,(,6,+6,"( ";5:"D%+:Q&6:&;":%0,( &$(-BA@,(+@+005+:Q&. +(.

%+,(6+,(&. +:+5,. &2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. +2@,&<&. 6@&%"06:+5,. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( ,( @$%+( @,06":3'

\0,(/ 6@&(&?,(6&:(+6,"(+#5"<&:63 #,(&";*_*&'#!V.+3 N,( #""! 111IB,6,0&06,%+6&. 6@+6,( 6@&

#) 3&+:0+;6&:&$-& "<&:!(" %,##,"( 5&"5#&,( A@,(+?&:&#,;6&. "$6";5"<&:63 +(. 6@&5:"5":6,"( ";

6@&5"5$#+6,"( #,<,(/ ,( 5"<&:63 ;&##;:"% -)T 6" &*T NA@&( +(. =+<+##,"( #""-I'E$:,(/ 6@,0

5&:,".B&H6&:(+#&2"("%,2+(. .&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( 5#+3&. 0$K06+(6,+#:"#&0,( 5:"%"6,(/

&2"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 0"2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6+0?&##+0,( &(@+(2,(/ 2+5+2,63 6" +."56,(6&:(+6,"(+#

K&065:+26,2&0B6@$0&H5&.,6,(/ A@,(+M0,(6&/:+6,"( ,(6" 6@&/#"K+#&2"("%3'

A@,(+M0+2@,&<&%&(60+(. &H5&:,&(2&0";%+(+/,(/ .&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( @+<&(+6$:+##3 .:+?(

+66&(6,"( K3 6@&,(6&:(+6,"(+#2"%%$(,63'4( <,&? ";6@&.&<&#"5%&(62@+##&(/&06@+6:&%+,( ,(

C;:,2+B,6?,##K&$0&;$#6" 2"(0,.&:6@&,(06,6$6,"(0+(. 5"#,2,&0K&@,(. 6@&0&5"0,6,<&.&<&#"5%&(6

"$62"%&0,( A@,(+'

E+3 & ";6@&?":Q0@"5 0@+##;+2,#,6+6&+.,02$00,"( +K"$6@"?,(6&:(+6,"(+#.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50

@+<&?":Q&. ,( A@,(++(. @"?A@,(+@+0%+(+/&. 6" $6,#,0&.&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( 6" 5:"%"6&

/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('9@&0&00,"( 0@+##)

!

%A#+:,;3 A@,(+M006:+6&/3 +(. 5"#,2,&0,( +2@,&<,(/ :+5,. /:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('

!

%1:"<,.&+( "<&:<,&?";:"#&0";,(6&:(+6,"(+#.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50,( A@,(+M0/:"?6@ +(.

5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('

*(

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 90: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!

%8H+%,(&6@&:&#&<+(2&+(. ,%5#,2+6,"(0";A@,(+M0/:"?6@B 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( +(.

,(6&:(+6,"(+#.&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( &H5&:,&(2&;":C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0'

&")"" ,&")"!

1"+'&X>$+(/ A@&(/?&,BE&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(

A&(6:&,( A@,(+

W.,#&+3.&)],2@,+F+(&:D_,$BAF&(.BF?,6U&:#+(.

B(3&.,6)3'.(.(>#**'.(I .(1"'(+XG7A#)3'4#+(,1.(3#(3

4(6:".$26":3 06+6&%&(6K3)="K&:6>++0B>&+. ";8+06C0,+E,<,0,"(B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":

82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6BS*RBG&:%+(3

&")"! ,&&)""

j#5(.3#C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'Z&3 &H5&:,&(2&0";.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50K&6?&&( A@,(++(. ."(":0

>%#+J#&)Z+(/ S,(/O,+(BE,<,0,"( A@,&;B4(6&:(+6,"(+#E&5+:6%&(6B*,(,06:3 ";

A"%%&:2&B1'='A@,(+

#'E"(":M02"(6:,K$6,"( 6" A@,(+M0.&<&#"5%&(6)F6:+6&/,&0B1"#,2,&0+(. 1:+26,2&0

>%#+J#&)S&66,(+G:+(0"?B-:&,&\(,<&:0,6e6S&:#,(

+'A@,(+M006:+6&/,&0B+55:"+2@&0+(. 2+5+2,63 .&<&#"5%&(6,( .&<&#"5%&(62""5&:+6,"(

>%#+J#&)R@"$ >"(/BE,:&26":B4(06,6$6&";8$:"5&+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";

F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

&&)"" ,&&)+"

1.00#(3*

&'G&";;:&3 *?+$B82"("%,2F&2:&6+:3B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&V9:&+0$:3BZ&(3+

#'=+,(&:G"&:.&#&:B-":%&:E&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#+(. A"%%,00,"(&:;":C0,++(.

F"$6@ 8+06&:( 8$:"5&BS*RBG&:%+(3

+'A+" -&(/BF2@""#";1$K#,21"#,23 +(. *+(+/&%&(6B90,(/@$+\(,<&:0,63

&&)+" ,&+)"" G%#(='*)6**'.(@'3"3"#%+(#-

.)()::0:G#(F*6#7*XJ(0)F#3,*0**&#$

C0/0:#7%0$,8##70(),&#$)$-86&$)Q!B70(&0$"0*)$->0**#$*

&))"" ,&))&"

B(3&.,6)3'.()'KO&26,<&0";6@&5+:+##&#0&00,"(0

>%#+J#&)C.:,+( E+<,0B>&+. ";Y":6@ +(. 8+06C0,+E&5+:6%&(6BE-4EB\Z

&))&" ,&*)""

K.&J*".%IXW6-3'-+3#&+-*+(,1"'(+2*=#4#-.%0#(3

W.,#&+3.&)9@"%+0S"(02@+KBE,:&26":a82"("%,20";A#,%+6&A@+(/&b+(. aF,("D

G&:%+( 1"<&:63 *"(,6":,(/ +(. 8<+#$+6,"( 1:"O&26bBG4RA@,(+

D+%%.&3#6&)_+( X+(/BA"D":.,(+6":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

&))&" ,&)))"

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'>%#+J#&)Y,2@"#+0>"5&B-":%&:X":#. S+(Q A"$(6:3 E,:&26":;":A@,(+

#'>%#+J#&)F&:/&CK"$BC%K+00+.":";8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"( 6" A@,(+

+'>%#+J#&)f$&>"(/BE&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#

9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"(B*'-A'*

&)))" ,&*)"" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&))&" ,&*)""

K.&J*".%fXN'-+3#&+-*+(,1"'(+2*=#4#-.%0#(3

W.,#&+3.&)[g:/&( F6&,/&:BE&5$63 A"$(6:3 E,:&26":+(. E,:&26":a82"("%,2+(.

F6:$26$:+#=&;":%1:"/:+%%&bBG4RA@,(+

D+%%.&3#6&)*,2@+&#]+,:.BF&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306B'8AE

!(

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 91: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&))&" ,&!)""

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'>%#+J#&)X+(/ X&,#,BE&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#BA@,(+4(6&:(+6,"(+#A&(6:&;":

82"("%,2+(. 9&2@(,2+#8H2@+(/&0B*,(,06:3 ";A"%%&:2&B1'='A@,(+

#'>%#+J#&)Y+"@,:" Z,6+("BE,:&26":G&(&:+#B8+06+(. A&(6:+#C0,++(. 6@&A+$2+0$0B

[4AC

+'>%#+J#&)="K&:6>++0B>&+. ";8+06C0,+E,<,0,"(BS*RBG&:%+(3

)'>%#+J#&)C.:,+( E+<,0B>&+. ";Y":6@ +(. 8+06C0,+BE-4EB\Z

!'>%#+J#&)G:+(6*"::,0"(BC26,(/ A"$(0&##":BE&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(B

C$06:+#,+( 8%K+003 ,( S&,O,(/

&!)"" ,&*)"" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&))&" ,&*)""

K.&J*".%VX!"#C&'4+3#>#)3.&;a.(<?.4#&(0#(3G&8+('*+3'.(*+(, 1"'(+2*

=#4#-.%0#(3

W.,#&+3.&)=,2@+:. F2@,&:&BF&(,":82"("%,06B';;,2&";6@&A@,&;82"("%,06BC;:,2+(

E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q

D+%%.&3#6&)[&((,;&:C.+%0BA"$(0&##":;":4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"(B\FC4EA@,(+

&))&" ,&)))"

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'>%#+J#&)["@( -,6U/&:+#.B=&5:&0&(6+6,<&;":A@,(+B-":. -"$(.+6,"(

#'>%#+J#&)R@+" E+H,(/BE&5$63 F&2:&6+:3 G&(&:+#BA@,(+C00"2,+6,"( ;":YG'

A""5&:+6,"(

+'>%#+J#&)["&:/ X$66Q&B1:&0,.&(6B8$:"5&+( A@+%K&:";A"%%&:2&,( A@,(+

&)))" ,&*)"" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&*)#" ,&-)""

C-#(+&5 >#**'.(

1"+'&)C.:,+( Y/+0,B4(6&:(+6,"(+#82"("%,06B';;,2&";E&<&#"5%&(61+:6(&:0BS,#+6&:+#

+(. *$#6,#+6&:+#E,<,0,"(B\FC4E

&*)#" ,&*)!"

D#%.&3/&.0#+)"%+&+--#-@.&J*".%

K.&J*".%IXW6-3'-+3#&+-*+(,1"'(+2*=#4#-.%0#(3

D+%%.&3#6&)_+( X+(/BA"D":.,(+6":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

K.&J*".%fXN'-+3#&+-*+(,1"'(+2*=#4#-.%0#(3

D+%%.&3#6&)*,2@+&#]+,:.BF&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306B'8AE

K.&J*".%VX!"#C&'4+3#>#)3.&;a.(<?.4#&(0#(3G&8+('*+3'.(*+(, 1"'(+2*

=#4#-.%0#(3

D+%%.&3#6&)[&((,;&:C.+%0BA"$(0&##":;":4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"(B\FC4EA@,(+

&*)!" ,&())" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&())" ,&-)""

K.&J*".%>600+&5 EC-#(+&5F

F$%%+:3 06+6&%&(6)=,2@+:. A+:&3BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5B'8AE

-&../01T

50/04*.60$,>%),$0)'"#.'%$-:8)#3%&'I)*+,"

%$->*/0),1 F0-23,#*$

A@,(++(. C;:,2+D+2"(6,(&(6";!+ (+6,"( 06+6&0D@+<&@+. <&:3 .,;;&:&(65"<&:63 :&.$26,"(

"(

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 92: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&H5&:,&(2&0,( :&2&(6.&2+.&0'4( 2"(6:+066" 6@&K:"+.DK+0&. /:"?6@ ,( A@,(+B.&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2+

@+0K&&( @,/@#3 $(&<&('9@&:&@+0K&&( +%+:Q&. ,%5:"<&%&(6,( /"<&:(+(2&+(. &2"("%,2

;$(.+%&(6+#0,( %+(3 C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0+(. 5:"/:&00@+0K&&( %+.&6"?+:.0+2@,&<,(/ 6@&*,##&((,$%

E&<&#"5%&(6G"+#0B+#6@"$/@ 6@&:&2&(6;"".B;$&#+(. ;,(+(2,+#2:,0&0@+<&0&65:"/:&00K+2Q'

F,(2&6@&K&/,((,(/ ";6@&(&?%,##&((,$%BA@,(+@+0&(@+(2&. ,60&H2@+(/&+(. 2"D"5&:+6,"( ?,6@

%+(3 C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0+0:&;#&26&. K3 6@&0@+:5#3 :,0,(/ 6:+.&+(. ,(<&06%&(6;#"?0B+0?&##+0

2$#6$:+#+(. &.$2+6,"(+#&H2@+(/&0+(. .&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( +26,<,6,&0'A@,(+M0&(/+/&%&(62"$#.

5"6&(6,+##3 2"(6:,K$6&0,/(,;,2+(6#3 6" :&.$2,(/ C;:,2+M0&2"("%,2%+:/,(+#,0+6,"( +(. 2:&+6&(&?

"55":6$(,6,&0;":5:"%"6,(/ /:"?6@ +(. :&.$2,(/ 5"<&:63'9" +2@,&<&6@,05"6&(6,+#B,6?"$#. K&$0&;$#

6" 0@+:&&H5&:,&(2&0"( 6@&.,;;&:&(6635&0";.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50K&,(/ 5$:0$&. K3 <+:,"$0

06+Q&@"#.&:0)C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0B&06+K#,0@&. ."(":0+(. &%&:/,(/ &2"("%,&0'C##5+:6,&0,(<"#<&. ,(

0$55":6,(/ C;:,2+M0.&<&#"5%&(62+( #&+:( ;:"% &+2@ "6@&:0 &H5&:,&(2&+(. K&(&;,6;:"% 6@&

;":%+6,"( ";+2#"0&:2"D"5&:+6,<&06:$26$:&?,6@ 6@&2"%%"( +,%";?":Q,(/ 6" +2@,&<&*EG0'

E+3 # ";6@&5:"/:+%0@+##;+2,#,6+6&+.,02$00,"( +K"$6@"?,(6&:(+6,"(+#.&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( @+0

?":Q&.V,0?":Q,(/ ,( C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0'9@&0&00,"( ?,##)

!

%C(+#30&6@&5:"/:&00+(. 2@+##&(/&0";C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0,( 5:"%"6,(/ /:"?6@ +(. :&.$2,(/

5"<&:63'

!

%=&<,&?6@&&<"#$6,"(B+55:"+2@&0+(. #&00"(0";&2"("%,2+(. .&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( ,(

C;:,2+;:"%6@&5&:05&26,<&0";.,;;&:&(606+Q&@"#.&:0)C;:,2+B'8AEDECA%&%K&:0+(. A@,(+'

!

%>,/@#,/@66@&,%5+260";,(6&:(+6,"(+#.&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( "( C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0

/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('

!

%8H5#":&?@+6A@,(++(. ECA %&%K&:02+( #&+:( ;:"% &+2@ "6@&:+K"$6%+(+/,(/

.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50+(. 6@&+55:"+2@&06" &(@+(2&6@&&;;&26,<&(&00";,(6&:(+6,"(+#

.&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"('

"$)"" ,"$)&"

1"+'&)=,2@+:. A+:&3BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5B'8AE

W.,#&+3.&XE&K":+@ S:+$6,/+%B1:";&00":BC%&:,2+( \(,<&:0,63

B(3&.,6)3'.(XD#/-#)3'.(.(=+5 I +(,G7A#)3'4#*/.&=+5 f

4(6:".$26":3 06+6&%&(6K3)1@,#,5 Z+:5B=&/,"(+#A"":.,(+6":B8+06C0,+h1+2,;,2B

X":#. S+(Q 4(06,6$6&A@,(+';;,2&

$)&" ,&")#!

j#5(.3#C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'4%5#&%&(6+6,"( ";A@,(+M02"%%,6%&(60+66@&-'ACA

>%#+J#&)i,$ S"@$+BC%K+00+.":"( -'ACAC;;+,:0B*,(,06:3 ";-":&,/( C;;+,:0B

1'='A@,(+

#'E&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,5 K&6?&&( A@,(++(. C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)>&X&(5,(/BE,:&26":";C;:,2+( F6$.,&0F&26,"( ";6@&4(06,6$6&";X&06

C0,+( +(. C;:,2+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

+'9@&&<"#$6,"( ";5+:6(&:0@,5 %".&#0";ECA%&%K&:0

>%#+J#&)1,&::&[+2P$&6BA@,&;82"("%,06B-:&(2@ E&<&#"5%&(6C/&(23 +(. A@+,:B

ECAY&6?":Q "( 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(

)'1+:6(&:0@,5 %".&#0,( C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)-,:"U&*+(O,B-"$(.&:+(. E,:&26":B-+@+%$

!'E,;;&:&(6C;:,2+( 5&:05&26,<&0

!

-&&.K+2Q ;:"%6@&G#"K+#E&<&#"5%&(6Y&6?":Q 0&00,"(

>%#+J#&)8.?+:. Z'S:"?(BC;:,2+A&(6:&;":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

#(

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 93: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&"))! ,&&)"!

1.00#(3*

&'C.+%+G+3&BA@+,:%+(BC;:,2+A@,(+A"(0$#6,(/ G:"$5BF&(&/+#

#'4U$%,'@("BY+6,"(+#G:+.$+6&4(06,6$6&;":1"#,23 F6$.,&0B[+5+(

&&)"" ,&#)"" G%#(='*)6**'.(

.)()::0:G#(F*6#7*XJ(0)F#3,*0**&#$

C0/0:#7%0$,8##70(),&#$)$-<+(&")Q!B70(&0$"0*)$->0**#$*

&+)+" ,&+))"

B(3&.,6)3'.(K3 ],C(0@+(B4(06,6$6&";C;:"DC0,+( F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

G7A#)3'4#*./3"#%+&+--#-*#**'.(*

&+))" ,&!)+"

K.&J*".%IXC+&3(#&*"'% &+0#@.&J*

W.,#&+3.&)>&X&(5,(/BE,:&26":";C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B4(06,6$6&";X&06C0,+( +(.

C;:,2+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

D+%%.&3#6&)8.?+:. S:"?(BE,:&26":B1"#,23 C.<,0":3 F&:<,2&BC;:,2+( A&(6:&;":

82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

&+))" ,&))+"

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'>%#+J#&)C55,+@ -:+(2,0BY+6,"(+#A"":.,(+6":BY81CEB*,(,06:3 ";-":&,/(

C;;+,:0BG@+(+

#'C;:,2+D8\1+:6(&:0@,5

>%#+J#&)1&6&:A:+,/D*2i$+,.&B>&+. ";a=&#+6,"(0?,6@ ,(6&:(+6,"(+#":/+(,U+6,"(0

+(. ("(D8\F6+6&0bB8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

+'C;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(QM05+:6(&:0@,5 %".&#

>%#+J#&)=,2@+:. F2@,&:&B F&(,":82"("%,06B ';;,2& ";6@&A@,&;82"("%,06

N8A'YIBC;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q

)'1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( F6:+6&/3 N1=FI1:"2&00

>%#+J#&)-:&. [+2@+(D'%+2@ *+(.,:B*,(,06&:";F6+6&;":-,(+(2&B1#+((,(/ +(.

82"("%,2E&<&#"5%&(6B\/+(.+

!'>%#+J#&)*"Q/+.,9&(+BE,:&26":,( 2@+:/&";K,#+6&:+#2""5&:+6,"(B6@&9:&+0$:3B

F"$6@ C;:,2+

*'>%#+J#&)R@+(/ _+(0@&(/BE,:&26":B4(06,6$6&;":4(6&:(+6,"(+#82"("%,2=&0&+:2@B

YE=A

&))+" ,&!)+" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&+X)" ,&!X+"

K.&J*".%fX '(+()'(8 %+&3(#&*"'%*

W.,#&+3.&)S,##Y,2"#B>&+. ";1"<&:63 +(. G:"?6@ E,<,0,"(B'8AE

D+%%.&3#6&)Y,#092@&3+(BF&(,":C.<,0":BC;:,2+A&(6:&;":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

&+))" ,&))+"

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'>%#+J#&)]$ i,(/2@&(/B!,2&A@+,:%+(BA@,(+DC;:,2+E&<&#"5%&(6-$(.

#'>%#+J#&)-&(/ A@$(5,(/BE&5$63 G&(&:+#*+(+/&:BE&5+:6%&(6";82"("%,2

=&0&+:2@B6@&8H5":6D4%5":6S+(Q ";A@,(+

+'>%#+J#&)1+%&#+X@,6&BE,:&26":\FC4E,( ],K&:,+

)'>%#+J#&)["@+( A+$?&(K&:/@B>&+. ";E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"( F&26,"(B8$:"5&+(

A"%%,00,"( E&#&/+6,"( 6" A@,(+

!'>%#+J#&)[$.,2+'%+:,B1:,(2,5+#82"("%,06B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&+(. 82"("%,2

C;;+,:0B9+(U+(,+

$(

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 94: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&)))" ,&!)+" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&+))" ,&!)+"

K.&J*".%VXB0%-#0#(3'(8 C+&3(#&*"'%*

W.,#&+3.&)83"K 9&0;+3&BE,:&26":G&(&:+#B';;,2&";6@&1:,%&*,(,06&:B86@,"5,+

D+%%.&3#6&) *+" f,+"O,(/B E&<&#"5%&(6 A""5&:+6,"(B A@,(&0& C2+.&%3 ";

4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"(B*'-A'*

&+))" ,&))&"

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'>%#+J#&)f$ X&,U@"(/B4(06,6$6&";C0,++(. C;:,2+BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";*".&:(

4(6&:(+6,"(+#=&#+6,"(0

#'>%#+J#&)E,:Q S&6Q&BG4R1:"/:+%E,:&26":BaA"%%$(,63 E&<&#"5%&(61:"/:+%bB

*+#,

+'>%#+J#&)X$ [$(@$,BE,:&26":B1+:6(&:0@,50B9@&X":#. S+(Q

&)))" ,&!)+" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&!)!" ,&()&"

K.&J*".%>600+&5 N1#&(+:3I

1"+'&)>$+(/ A@&(/?&,BE&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(

A&(6:&,( A@,(+

&!)!" ,&*)#"

D#%.&3/&.0#+)"%+&+--#-@.&J*".%

K.&J*".%IXC+&3(#&*"'% &+0#@.&J*

D+%%.&3#6&)8.?+:. Z'S:"?(BC;:,2+A&(6:&;":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

K.&J*".%fX '(+()'(8 C+&3(#&*"'%*

D+%%.&3#6&)Y,#092@&3+(BF&(,":C.<,0":BC;:,2+A&(6:&;":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

K.&J*".%VXB0%-#0#(3'(8 C+&3(#&*"'%*

D+%%.&3#6&) *+" f,+"O,(/B E&<&#"5%&(6 A""5&:+6,"(B A@,(&0& C2+.&%3 ";

4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"(B*'-A'*

&*)#" ,&()&" G%#(='*)6**'.(

IUXIS

!

IeXSS

1-.*'(8 1#&#0.(5

1"+'&)>&f,+"O$(BE&5$63 E,:&26":B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,( A@,(+

&()#! ,&())"

>600+&5 ./3"#H4#(3

>%#+J#&)],f,+"3$(BE&+( ";6@&A"##&/&";>$%+(,6,&0+(. E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0B

A@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63 +(. E,:&26":";6@&A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

&())" ,&-)""

1-.*'(8 D#0+&J*

&'X$ R@"(/BE,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,( A@,(+

#'-:&. [+2@+(D'%+2@ *+(.,:B*,(,06&:";F6+6&;":-,(+(2&B1#+((,(/ +(. 82"("%,2

E&<&#"5%&(6B\/+(.+

%(

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 95: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

TO'.<2'T8T.<V'D >TD'

F&:/&CS'\%%%%%%%%%%C%K+00+.":B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"( E&#&/+6,"( 6" A@,(+

[&((,;&:CEC*F E&<&#"5%&(6A"$(0&##":\FC4EDA@,(+

9@"%+0C]S8=9 E,:&26":C;:,2+B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6B

G&:%+(3

*"@+%&. >+00+( C]4 F&2"(. F&2:&6+:3BF$.+( 8%K+003

[",2&C:+K+C]4G' A@,&;C.%,(,06:+6":BF"$6@&:( F$.+( =&2"(06:$26,"( hE&<&#"5%&(6-$(.B

F"$6@&:( F$.+(

CYA@$(3,(/ =&0&+:2@ -&##"?B4(06,6$6&";X&06C0,+( hC;:,2+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";

F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

SC4A@&(/3$ E,<,0,"( A@,&;BA@,(+4(6&:(+6,"(+#A&(6:&;":82"("%,2+(. 9&2@(,2+#8H2@+(/&B

*'-A'*

E,:Q S89Z8 E,:&26":B1:"/:+%%&.MC55$,+$H A"##&26,<,6j09&::,6":,+#&0N1CA9IBG4R*+#,B

G&:%+(3

9@"%+0S'YFA>CS E,:&26":B82"("%,20";A#,%+6&A@+(/&VF,("DG&:%+( 1"<&:63 *"(,6":,(/ h

8<+#$+6,"( 1:"O&26BG4RA@,(+BG&:%+(3

-:+(k",0S'Y98*1F E&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#BE&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(B*,(,06:3 ";-":&,/( C;;+,:0B

A"%%&:2&+(. E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(BS&#/,$%

E&K":+@ S=C\94GC* 1:";&00":B4(6&:(+6,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6BC%&:,2+( \(,<&:0,63B\FC

8.?+:. S='XY E,:&26":B1"#,23 C.<,0":3 F&:<,2&BC;:,2+( A&(6:&;":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

AC4-+(/ E&5+:6%&(6";C,. 6" -":&,/( A"$(6:,&0B*'-A'*

AC4[,((,$ A@,(+DC;:,2+E&<&#"5%&(6-$(.

AC'-&(/ =&0&+:2@ -&##"?BF2@""#";1$K#,21"#,23 +(. *+(+/&%&(6B90,(/@$+\(,<&:0,63

=,2@+:. AC=8_ A"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

["@+( AC\X8YS8=G> >&+. ";E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"( E&#&/+6,"( 6" A@,(+

[&+(D=+5@+&#A>C1'YY48=8 82"("%,06BC0,+E&5+:6%&(6B-:&(2@ E&<&#"5%&(6C/&(23

S&663 C(( A>\YG C%K+00+.":B8%K+003 ";A+(+.+

Y+(23 A''Z8 A"$(6:3 1:"/:+%%&A"":.,(+6":BA@,(++(. *"(/"#,+E&5+:6%&(6BX":#. S+(Q

G,":/," A'=9CFFC A"":.,(+6":B>&+#6@ 1:"O&260B46+#,+( A""5&:+6,"( ,( A@,(+

1&6&:A=C4G*Ai\C4E8 >&+. ";\(,6BEGE&<&#"5%&(6B=&#+6,"(0?,6@ ,(6&:(+6,"(+#":/+(,0+6,"(0+(. ("(

8\%&%K&:06+6&0B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

1&((3 EC!48F A"(0$#6+(6

C.:,+( EC!4F >&+.BY":6@ +(. 8+06C0,+BE-4E

-8YGA@$(5,(/ E&5$63 G&(&:+#*+(+/&:BE&5+:6%&(6";82"("%,2=&0&+:2@B6@&8H5":6D4%5":6S+(Q

";A@,(+

["@( -49RG8=C]E -":. -"$(.+6,"( ,( A@,(+

C55,+@ -=CYA4F 8H&2$6,<&F&2:&6+:3BY+6,"(+#C1=*G"<&:(,(/ A"$(2,#BG@+(+

GC'_$+(3$+( E&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#BE&5+:6%&(6";C,. 6" -":&,/( A"$(6:,&0B*'-A'*

C.+%+GC_8 A@+,:%+(B-"$(.&:BC;:,2+A@,(+A"(0$#6,(/ G:"$5BF&(&/+#

=+,(&:G'8=E8=]8= -":%&:E&5$63 E,:&26":+(. G&(&:+#A"%%,00,"(&:;":C0,++(. F"$6@ 8+06&:(

&(

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 96: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

8$:"5&B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6BG&:%+(3

S&66,(+G=CYF'XD!CY9=88AZ 1:";&00":BA@,(&0&F6$.,&0B-:&&\(,<&:0,63 S&:#,(

G\[,(/ =&0&+:2@ -&##"?BG#"K+#,0+6,"( 9&+%B4(06,6$6&";E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0

F6&<&( G\*S'> E&5$63 E,:&26":BY+6,"(+#1#+((,(/B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&+(. Y+6,"(+#1#+((,(/B

R+%K,+

="K&:6>CCF >&+. ";8+06C0,+E,<,0,"(B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6BG&:%+(3

*+( >C4 F&(,":4(6&:(+6,"(+#C.<,0":BA@,(+C00"2,+6,"( ;":YG'A""5&:+6,"(

>8X&(5,(/ E,:&26":";6@&E,<,0,"( ";C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B4(06,6$6&";X&06C0,+( +(. C;:,2+(

F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0BA@,(+

>8f,+"O$( E&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,( A@,(+

9:+23 >'Y 1:"O&260E,:&26":BA&(6:&;":A@,(&0&F6$.,&0BF6&##&(K"02@ \(,<&:0,63BF"$6@ C;:,2+

Y,2@"#+0>'18 E,:&26":BA&(6:&;":4(6&:(+6,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6BF6+(;":. \(,<&:0,63

4:&(&>'=F C.<,0":BA@,(+1:"/:+%%&BA&(6:&;":A""5&:+6,"( ?,6@ ("(D%&%K&:0B'8AE

*,2@+#>'=!C9 F#"<+Q,+( 8%K+003

>\CYGA@&(/?&, E&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+

-:&. *+(.,:[CA>CY'*CA> *,(,06&:";F6+6&B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&B1#+((,(/ +(. E&<&#"5%&(6B\/+(.+

1,&::&[CAi\89 8H&2$6,<&E,:&26":NF6:+6&/3I+(. A@,&;82"("%,06B-:&(2@ E&<&#"5%&(6C/&(23

[4Y=+( 1:"/:+%%&C00,06+(6B=&0&+:2@ E,<,0,"(B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,(

A@,(+

ZCYGS,(/O,+( E,<,0,"( A@,&;BE&5+:6%&(6";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2C;;+,:0B*'-A'*

1@,##,5 ZC=1 =&/,"(+#A"":.,(+6":B8+06C0,+h1+2,;,2BX":#. S+(Q 4(06,6$6&';;,2&,( A@,(+

["0&5@,(&["0&5@ Z44*S4]C 82"("%,06B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&+(. 82"("%,2C;;+,:0B9+(U+(,+B

Y+"@,:" Z49CY' E,:&26":DG&(&:+#B8+06+(. A&(6:+#C0,++(. 6@&A+$2+0$0E&5+:6%&(6B[4AC

=+0%$0CK,#./++:. Z=4F98YF8Y -,:06F&2:&6+:3B1"#,23 C;;+,:0B="3+#E+(,0@ 8%K+003BS&,O,(/

*,2@+&#]C4=E F&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306B1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( hG:"?6@ E,<,0,"(B'8AE

A@:,06"5@ ]CYG -,:06F&2:&6+:3B8%K+003 ";F?,6U&:#+(.

[+2P$&0]8A]8=AE\FCS]'Y G&(&:+#E,:&26":B-:&(2@ A@+%K&:";A"%%&:2&,( A@,(+

Z&:06,( ]849Y8= 8HD2"":.,(+6":\Y

]4C(0@+( 1:";&00":BE,:&26":B4(06,6$6&";C;:"DC0,+( F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

]4F@+"O$( E,<,0,"( A@,&;BA""5&:+6,"( E,<,0,"(B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+

]4f,+"3$( E&+(BA"##&/&";>$%+(,6,&0+(. E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

]4S" E,<,0,"( A@,&;BC0,+DC;:,2+E&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&BE&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@

A&(6:&";F6+6&A"$(2,#BA@,(+

]4CYG_$(;&(/ A@,(+A&(6:&;":4(6&:(+6,"(+#82"("%,28H2@+(/&0

]4\>+,K" 1:"O&26';;,2&:BA@,(+C;:,2+( S$0,(&00A"$(2,#h\YE1

]4\f,+(/ 1:"/:+%%&';;,2&:BE&5+:6%&(6";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2C;;+,:0B

*'-A'*

]4\>+(0"(/ E&5$63 E,:&26":B4(6&:(+6,"(+#E&5+:6%&(6BA@,(+8(6&:5:,0&A"(;&.&:+6,"(

]\Y+,O$( F&(,":82"("%,06B-":&,/( 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( A&(6:&B*,(,06:3 ";C/:,2$#6$:&B

A@,(+

]\i,(/2@&(/ E&5$63 1:&0,.&(6BA@,(+DC;:,2+E&<&#"5%&(6-$(.

]\R@,@$+ A@,(+DC;:,2+E&<&#"5%&(6-$(.

'(

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 97: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

]\],P$( A@,&;B8H2@+(/&E,<,0,"(B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,( A@,(+

]$2=4FA> A"$(0&##":BS&#/,+( 8%K+003

C(/&#+*C 1:"O&26';;,2&:B2@,(+C;:,2+( S$0,(&00A"$(2,#h\YE1

-,:"U&*CY[4 E,:&26":B-+@+%$ DY&6?":Q0;":F"2,+#[$06,2&BG@+(+

*C'f,+"O,(/ E&5+:6%&(6";E&<&#"5%&(6C00,06+(2&BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(.

82"( A""5 NAC498AIB*,(,06:3 ";A"%%&:2&BA@,(+

[&+(DA#+$.&*CFXCYC C00,06+(61:";&00":BG:+.$+6&F2@""#";82"("%,20BZ3"6" \(,<&:0,63

A'>"%&:*2E'YC]E ';;,2&:BF$5&:<,0":3 1:,<+6&F&26":B\FC4E

C#&H+(.&:*2]CA>]CY 8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"( E&#&/+6,"( 6" A@,(+

*84[+3"(/ *+(+/&:B'H;+%>"(/ Z"(/

X+#6&:*8_8= E&<&#"5%&(6A"$(0&##":B8%K+003 ";F?,6U&:#+(.

G:+(6*'==4F'Y C26,(/ A"$(0&##":BE&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(BC$06:+#,+( 8%K+003BS&,O,(/

G&";;:&3 *XC\ 82"("%,2F&2:&6+:3B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&BZ&(3+

C.:,+( YGCF4 4(6&:(+6,"(+#82"("%,06B';;,2&";E&<&#"5%&(61+:6(&:0BS,#+6&:+#+(. *$#6,#+6&:+#

E,<,0,"(B\FC4E

S,##Y4A'] >&+. ";1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( +(. G:"?6@ E,<,0,"(B'8AE

'U#&%Y\E=C]4 82"("%,2A"$(0&##":B9$:Q,0@ 8%K+003

4U$%,'>Y' 1:";&00":BY+6,"(+#G:+.$+6&4(06,6$6&;":1"#,23 F6$.,&0B[+5+(

[$.,2+'*C=4 1:,(2,5+#82"("%,06B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&+(. 82"("%,2C;;+,:0B9+(U+(,+

A&#,(&18_='YS4F9C F"2,+#F&26":F5&2,+#,06BC0,+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q =&0,.&(6*,00,"( ,( A@,(+

i4Y9,+( =&0&+:2@ -&##"?B4(06,6$6&";C0,+( hC;:,2+( F6$.,&0BA@,(+4(06,6$6&";

A"(6&%5":+:3 4(6&:(+6,"(+#=&#+6,"(0

i4\S"@$+ C%K+00+.":B-'ACAC;;+,:0B*,(,06:3 ";-":&,/( C;;+,:0BA@,(+

*+:3 -:+(k",0&=8YC=E 1:";&00":B\(,<&:0,63 ";A#&:%"(6B-:+(2&

-+;:jFC*CZ8 E,:&26":DG&(&:+#B41=V4-=C

],2@,+FCY8=D_4\ 1:&0,.&(6BC2+.&%3 ;":i$+#,63 ,( 9:+,(,(/ h8.$2+6,"(BA&(6&:;":F"2,+#D82"("%,2

E&<&#"5%&(6NAF8EIBF?,6U&:#+(.

*,2@+&#FA>C8-8= G&:%+( C%K+00+.":6" A@,(+

=,2@+:. FA>48=8 F&(,":82"("%,06BC;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q

_+#+/@$#,F8]8 F&(,":C.<,0":B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&BA"(/" NE=AI

F,%"( F>C=18 -,:06F&2:&6+:3B1"#,6,2+#E&#&/+6,"( ";6@&8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"( E&#&/+6,"( 6" A@,(+

]"(/ F>4 F&(,":4(6&:(+6,"(+#C.<,0":BA@,(+C00"2,+6,"( ;":YG'A""5&:+6,"(

F@+.:,2Q F4A>'Y8 E&5$63 E,:&26":BY+6,"(+#1#+((,(/B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&+(. Y+6,"(+#1#+((,(/B

R+%K,+

C#K,$0F49\*S8Z' A"$(0&##":BY+%,K,+( 8%K+003

C:&6,FZC-4ECZ4 -,:06F&2:&6+:3B82"("%,2+(. A"%%&:2,+#C;;+,:0BG:&&Q 8%K+003 ,( S&,O,(/

A+:#+8#&(+FY_E8= 82"("%,2F&26,"(B\F8%K+003 ,( S&,O,(/

_,(@"(/ F'YG F$KD:&/,"(+#1:"/:+%%&*+(+/&:B4(6&:(+6,"(+#-$(. ;":C/:,2$#6$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6

[g:/&( F984G8= E&5$63 A"$(6:3 E,:&26":G4RA@,(++(. E,:&26":B82"("%,2+(. F6:$26$:+#=&;":%

1:"/:+%%&BG&:%+(3

*,2@+&#F94=YX84FF C.<,0":B8+06C0,+F&26,"(B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6BG&:%+(3

X&,P,(/ F\Y F&(,":1"#,23 ';;,2&:BE&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(BC$06:+#,+( 8%K+003BS&,O,(/

((

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 98: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

F\Y]&, 1:"/:+%%&';;,2&:BA@,(+4(6&:(+6,"(+#A&(6:&;":82"("%,2+(. 9&2@(,2+#8H2@+(/&B

*'-A'*

9+.+0@,F\R\Z4 C00,06+(6E,:&26":BE&<&#"5%&(61+:6(&:0@,5 E,<,0,"(B'5&:+6,"(0F6:+6&/3

E&5+:6%&(6B[4AC

Y,#09A>8_CY F&(,":C.<,0":BC;:,2+A&(6:&;":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

*"Q/+.,98YC E,<,0,"( >&+.BA""5&:+6,"( ?,6@ A@,(+BY+6,"(+#9:&+0$:3BF"$6@ C;:,2+

83"K 98F-C_8 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B1$K#,2-,(+(2&4(06,6$6,"(0F$5&:<,0":3 C/&(23B';;,2&";6@&1:,%&

*,(,06&:B86@,"5,+

40+" 98R\ZC F&2"(. F&2:&6+:3B8%K+003 ";[+5+( ,( A@,(+

9":,Y&66&#@":069!849 E,:&26":BF&2:&6+:,+6;":1:,<+6&F&26":E&<&#"5%&(6BA"(;&.&:+6,"( ";Y":?&/,+(

8(6&:5:,0&

*+:,+( \=S4YC \Y4E'=&/,"(+#';;,2&BA@,(+

9,%" !'414' F&(,":C.<,0":;":G#"K+#F"2,+#1"#,23BE&5+:6%&(6;":E&<&#"5%&(61"#,23B

*,(,06:3 ";-":&,/( C;;+,:0B-,(#+(.

XCYGE+O$( E&5$63 A@,&;B=&0&+:2@ E,<,0,"(B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,( A@,(+

XCYG-&(/U$" E&5$63 E,<,0,"( A@,&;B4(6&:(+6,"(+#E&5+:6%&(6BA@,(+8(6&:5:,0&A"(;&.&:+6,"(

XCYGX&,#, E&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#BA@,(+4(6&:(+6,"(+#A&(6:&;":82"("%,2+(. 9&2@(,2+#

8H2@+(/&B*'-A'*

XCYGf,+"#,( E,<,0,"( A@,&;B=&0&+:2@ E,<,0,"(B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+

XCYG_+( A"D":.,(+6":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

XCYG_& E&5+:6%&(6";82"("%,2=&0&+:2@B6@&8H5":6D4%5":6S+(Q ";A@,(+

XCYG_, 1$K#,2C;;+,:0';;,2&:B\YX-1A@,(+

C(6@&+X8SS E,:&26":B\YX-1A@,(+

X84[,+(/$" F&2:&6+:3 G&(&:+#BA@,(+A&(6:&;":82"("%,28H2@+(/&0

1+%&#+X>498 *,00,"( E,:&26":B\FC4EB],K&:,+

*,2@+&#X48Y8Z8 -,(+(2,+#A"$(0&##":BE&5+:6%&(6";82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6B

8%K+003 ";6@&-&.&:+#=&5$K#,2";G&:%+(3

X\S,(/K,(/ C00"2,+6&1:";&00":BC:+K,2E&5+:6%&(6B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

X\-+( 4(6&:(+6,"(+#E&5+:6%&(6B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&BA@,(+

X\[$(@$, E,:&26":BG#"K+#1+:6(&:0@,5 +(. 9:$06-$(. '5&:+6,"(0BX":#. S+(Q

X\1&(/ A@,(+-"$(.+6,"( ;":1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(

X\X,U@"(/ E&5$63 E,:&26":B4(06,6$6&";C0,+( hC;:,2+( F6$.,&0BA@,(+4(06,6$6&";A"(6&%5":+:3

4(6&:(+6,"(+#=&#+6,"(0

X\R@"(/ E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,( A@,(+

["&:/ X\99Z8 1:&0,.&(6B8$:"5&+( A@+%K&:";A"%%&:2&,( A@,(+

f4'YG>"$ 8H5&:6B4(06,6$6&";8$:"5&+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

f\-+( A@,(+-"$(.+6,"( ;":1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(

f\F@+(0@+( 1:"/:+%%&C00,06+(6BA@,(+C00"2,+6,"( ;":YG'A""5&:+6,"(

f\X&,U@"(/ 4(06,6$6&";C0,++(. C;:,2+BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";*".&:( 4(6&:(+6,"(+#=&#+6,"(0

f\8>"(/ E,:&26":BE&56'";E&<&#"5%&(6C00,06+(2&BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&

+(. 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( NAC498AIB*,(,06:3 ";A"%%&:2&BA@,(+

_CYG],@$+ 1:";&00":B4(06,6$6&";X&06C0,+( hC;:,2+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#

F2,&(2&0

)(

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 99: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

R>CYG>$,."(/ E&5$63 E,<,0,"( A@,&;B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,( A@,(+

R>CYG_+( E"(":=&#+6,"(0';;,2&:B\YX-1A@,(+

R>CYG_+(0@&(/ E,:&26":B4(06,6$6&;":4(6&:(+6,"(+#82"("%,2=&0&+:2@BY+6,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6+(.

=&;":%A"%%,00,"(BA@,(+

R>CYG>+,K,(/ E&5$63 E,:&26":BX":#. 82"("%3 F6$.,&0BF@+(/@+,4(06,6$6&;":4(6&:(+6,"(+#F6$.,&0

R>CYG_"(/5&(/ =&0&+:2@ -&##"?B4(06,6$6&";X&06C0,+( hC;:,2+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";

F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

R>C'E+H,(/ E&5$63 F&2:&6+:3 G&(&:+#BA@,(+C00"2,+6,"( ;":YG'A""5&:+6,"(

R>8YGG$+(/$+( 8H5&:6B4(06,6$6&";8$:"5&+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

R>8YGX&(Q+, E&5$63 E,:&26":BF6+6&A"$(2,#]&+.,(/ G:"$5 ';;,2&";1"<&:63 C##&<,+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6N]G'1IBA@,(+

R>'\_"(/ E,<,0,"( A@,&;B-":&,/( 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( A&(6:&B*,(,06:3 ";C/:,2$#6$:&BA@,(+

R>'\f,+"O,(/ E,:&26":BC0,+DC;:,2+E&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&BE&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@ A&(6:&

";F6+6&A"$(2,#BA@,(+

R>'\>"(/ E,:&26":B4(06,6$6&";8$:"5&+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

*)

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 100: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

<VV!W! TT

<;(&"3:,3():'()$*+#(%),&#$9H(#5,6)$-.#/0(,1 20-3",&#$

J)%)F#9=):&9fUEfe <7(&:fSIS

TT)L<H!VC<

J)"F;(#3$-)$-#OK0",&/0*

9" ;+2,#,6+6&6@&0@+:,(/ ";&H5&:,&(2&0+(. 5:"%"6&#&+:(,(/ "( /:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B6@&

A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5 @+0K&&( &06+K#,0@&. K3 6@&4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,( A@,(+

N41=AAI+(. 6@&':/+(,0+6,"( ;":82"("%,2A"D"5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6M0E&<&#"5%&(6

C00,06+(2&A"%%,66&&N'8AEDECAIB+(. 0$55":6&. K3 %+(3 K,#+6&:+#+(. %$#6,#+6&:+#.&<&#"5%&(6

+/&(2,&0'9@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,0;"2$0,(/ ,60?":Q "( 6?" 6@&%&0)

!

%A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2&";/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B,(2#$.,(/ 6@&2"(6:,K$6,"( ";

,(6&:(+6,"(+#+00,06+(2&B+(. ,60:&#&<+(2&;":"6@&:.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0B5+:6,2$#+:#3 ,(

C;:,2+'

!

%A@,(+M0&2"("%,22"D"5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2++(. ,60,%5+26"( 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('

9@&"KO&26,<&";6@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,06" 5:"<,.&+( ,(6&:(+6,"(+#5#+6;":%;":&H2@+(/,(/ <,&?0+%"(/

+:+(/&";06+Q&@"#.&:0+(. .,06,##,(/ #&00"(0#&+:(6B6@$0&(@+(2,(/ 2+5+2,63 6" %&&60"%&";6@&(&?

2@+##&(/&0";/#"K+#.&<&#"5%&(6'9@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,06+Q,(/ +( &<&(60D.:,<&( +55:"+2@ ,( ":.&:6"

,(<"#<&+#+:/&:($%K&:";06+Q&@"#.&:0,( ,60+26,<,6,&0'

9@:"$/@ +0&:,&0";&<,.&(2&DK+0&. 5"#,23 .,+#"/$&&<&(60B6@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,0#""Q,(/ +6;"$:,00$&0

6@+6:&;#&266@&(&&.0,( %+(3 C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&06".+3)+I.&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50BKI+/:,2$#6$:&B

;"". 0&2$:,63 +(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6B2I,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. .I6@&&(+K#,(/ &(<,:"(%&(6;":&(6&:5:,0&

.&<&#"5%&(6'

9@&F6$.3 G:"$5M0;,:06&<&(6"( aE&<&#"5%&(61+:6(&:0@,50;":G:"?6@ +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(b6""Q

5#+2&,( S&,O,(/ ,( '26"K&:#""$'9@,00&2"(. &<&(6?,##;"2$0"( 6@&:"#&";+/:,2$#6$:&B;"". 0&2$:,63

+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6,( 5:"%"6,(/ /:"?6@ +(. :&.$2,(/ 5"<&:63'*":&05&2,;,2+##3B6@&&<&(6?,##)

!

%S:,(/ ;":6@ 6@&2"$:0&B06:+6&/,&0B+2@,&<&%&(60+(. 2@+##&(/&0";A@,(++(. C;:,2+(

2"$(6:,&0,( +/:,2$#6$:+#B;"". 0&2$:,63 +(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6+(. &H5#":&6@&:&#&<+(2&+(.

,%5#,2+6,"(0?,6@ &+2@ "6@&:J

!

%>,/@#,/@66@&0,/(,;,2+(6:"#&";+/:,2$#6$:&B;"". 0&2$:,63 +(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6,(

&2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( ";A@,(++(. C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0J

!

%C(+#30&6@&,%5+260";,(6&:(+6,"(+#6:+.&B;":&,/( ,(<&06%&(6+(. .&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&"(

+/:,2$#6$:+#/:"?6@ +(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6,( A@,(++(. C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0J

!

%8H+%,(&6@&,(2:&+0,(/ :"#&";A@,(+M0&(/+/&%&(6,( C;:,2+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6B,60

5"6&(6,+#,%5+26"( C;:,2+M05"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B+(. 6@&#&00"(0,(6&:(+6,"(+#."(":0@+<&

/+,(&. ,( 6@,0;,&#.'

!)

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 101: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

.(#;()%%0

G%#('(8 1#&#0.(5

1"+'&)C#+00+(&C/ C/+6@+(&B*,(,06&:";C/:,2$#6$:&B*+#,

"-)+" ,"$)""

K#-).0'(8D#0+&J*

P"#(8 K#(J+'BE&5$63 E,:&26":B9@&F6+6&A"$(2,#]&+.,(/ G:"$5 ';;,2&";1"<&:63

C##&<,+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6BA@,(+

P"+(8 ?6.Q'(8BA@,(&0&C%K+00+.":6" *+#,

D')"+&,1+&#5BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

G%#('(8 >%##)"

W.,'7. >','7#1:,%&*,(,06&:";6@&=&5$K#,2";*+#,

"$)"" ,$))"

1"'(#*#+(,9/&')+( C#&*%#)3'4#*.(98&')6-36&+-+(, D6&+-=#4#-.%0#(3X9(

G4#&4'#@

&'A@,(+M0C/:,2$#6$:&B-"". F&2$:,63 +(. =$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6)Z&3 1"#,2,&0+(.

F6:+6&/,&06"?+:.0G:"?6@ +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()

>%#+J#&)E$+( _,(/K,B1:&0,.&(6";A@,(+-"$(.+6,"( ;":1"<&:63 C##&<,+6,"(

#'-"06&:,(/ C/:,2$#6$:+#+(. =$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2+)A@+##&(/&0B'55":6$(,6,&0B

+(. 4%5#,2+6,"(0;":E"(":0MC00,06+(2&

>%#+J#&)["0$jE,"(jB E,:&26":B -"". F&2$:,63 +(. F$06+,(+K#& E&<&#"5%&(6

E,<,0,"(B\Y82"("%,2A"%%,00,"( ";C;:,2+N\Y8ACI

-&../01O

:()#324,2)0R8**-'032)#,1 %$-)2)%4-0/04*.60$,A

;"0#)3*$,)#92,#*$,*!"#$%&'()*+,"%$-.*/0),1 )0-23,#*$

A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6"<&:6@&#+06+" 3&+:0@+0;$&##&. ,60&2"("%,2.&<&#"5%&(6

+(. 2"(6:,K$6&. 6" 6@&%"06:+5,. :&.$26,"( ,( ,(2"%&5"<&:63 ,( @$%+( @,06":3L\0,(/ 6@&(&?

,(6&:(+6,"(+#5"<&:63 #,(&";l &L#!V.+3 N,( #""! 111IB,6,0&06,%+6&. 6@+6,( 6@&#) 3&+:0+;6&:&$-&

"<&:!&( %,##,"( 5&"5#&,( A@,(+?&:&#,;6&. "$6";5"<&:63 +(. 6@&5:"5":6,"( ";6@&5"5$#+6,"( #,<,(/

,( ,(2"%&5"<&:63 ;&##;:"% -)T 6" &*T NA@&( +(. =+<+##,"( #""-ILS3 ,(2:&+0,(/ +/:,2$#6$:+#

5:".$26,<,63BA@,(+@+0+#0" ,(2:&+0&. ,60;"". 0&2$:,63 +(. ("?$0&0#&006@+( &"T ";6@&?":#.M0

+:+K#&#+(. 6" ;&&. %":&6@+( #"T ";6@&?":#.M05"5$#+6,"( N>$+(/ [,Q$(B#""-IL4( A@,(+B6@&

5"00&00,"( ";;"". 2:"505&:2+5,6+,(2:&+0&. ;:"% #-!Z/ ,( &$(- 6" +:"$(. )""Z/ ,( #""- N],

f,+"3$( &6+#B#""$IL

*+(3 ;+26":0@+<&2"(6:,K$6&. 6" 6@&0$22&00;$#+/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6,( A@,(+L9@&Q&3

&#&%&(60?&:&#+(. :&;":%N;:"%+2"##&26,<&0306&%6" +( ,(.,<,.$+#@"$0&@"#.DK+0&. :&05"(0,K,#,63

2"(6:+260306&%IB+/:"D%+:Q&6:&;":%B6&2@("#"/,2+#,(("<+6,"(B&;;&26,<&+/:,2$#6$:+#5"#,2,&0+(.

,(2:&+0&. ,(<&06%&(6LC/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6+#0" 5#+3&. :&%+:Q+K#&:"#&0"( A@,(+M0:+5,.

,(.$06:,+#,0+6,"( +(. $:K+(,0+6,"(LS"6@ 0$:5#$0#+K"$:+(. 2+5,6+#;:"%6@&+/:,2$#6$:+#0&26":0""(

K&2+%&6@&%+O":0"$:2&0";,(.$06:,+#6:+(0;":%+6,"( ,( 6@&;":%";:$:+#&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6+(.B

0$K0&P$&(6#3B#+:/&02+#&$:K+(,0+6,"( +(. ,(.$06:,+#,0+6,"(B?@,2@ @+0+K0":K&. %":&)"" %,##,"(

5&"5#&;:"%:$:+#+:&+0.$:,(/ A@,(+M0@,/@&065"5$#+6,"( /:"?6@ &:+L46(&&.06" ("6&6@+60$2@ :+5,.

")

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 102: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

.&<&#"5%&(6,( +/:,2$#6$:&,( A@,(+@+0+#0" @+. 0&:,"$0";0"2,+#+(. &(<,:"(%&(62"(0&P$&(2&06@+6

A@,(+("?;+2&0L

*"06C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0@+<&:&+#,0&. 6@&,%5":6+(2&";+/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6;":

5:"%"6,(/ /:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(L*"065&"5#&,( C;:,2++:&06,##;+:%&:0K$6C;:,2+,0$(+K#&6"

;&&. ,60&#;B?@,2@ ,0:&#+6&. ("6"(#3 6" ,(+.&P$+6&,(<&06%&(6+(. 0$55#3 ,00$&0,( +/:,2$#6$:&K$6+#0"

K:"+.&:.&<&#"5%&(6,00$&0B(+6,"(+#+(. :&/,"(+#L9@&($%K&:";2@:"(,2+##3 $(.&:("$:,0@&. 5&"5#&

@+0:,0&( ;:"%&(+ %,##,"( ,( &$$"D$# 6" 0"%&#"" %,##,"( ,( &$$(D$$L';6@&0&B&$) %,##,"( N+)T ";

6@&5"5$#+6,"(I+:&,( 0$KDF+@+:+( C;:,2+NY81CEB#""#ILG,<&( 6@,02"(6&H6BA@,(+M0+2@,&<&%&(60

+(. &H5&:,&(2&0";+/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6@+<&,(2:&+0,(/#3 .:+?( +66&(6,"( ;:"%C;:,2+(

2"$(6:,&0L46,02"(0&P$&(6#3 (+6$:+#6" +0Q @"?A@,(+@+0+2@,&<&. 6@&:&0$#60,6@+0B?@+66@&

2"(6:,K$6,"( ";,(6&:(+6,"(+#+00,06+(2&?+0+(. 6@&&H6&(66" ?@,2@ A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2&02+( K&0@+:&.

?,6@ C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0L

E+3 & ";6@&?":Q0@"5 0@+##;+2,#,6+6&+.,02$00,"( +K"$6@"?+/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6@+<&6+Q&(

5#+2&,( A@,(+B@"?6@,0.&<&#"5%&(6@+0%+.&+2"(6:,K$6,"( 6" A@,(+M0/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B

5+3,(/ 5+:6,2$#+:+66&(6,"( 6" 6@&&H5&:,&(2&0+(. #&00"(0;":C;:,2+2"$(6:,&0L9@&0&00,"( 0@+##)

!

%A#+:,;3 A@,(+M006:+6&/3 +(. 5"#,2,&0,( +2@,&<,(/ +/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6;":6@&

2"$(6:3M0/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(L

!

%1:"<,.&+( "<&:<,&?";6@&2+$0&0";6@,00$22&00;$#+/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%(&6"<&:

#+06+" 3&+:0B.:+?05&2,+#+66&(6,"( 6" 6@&%+O":&#&%&(606@+6@+<&2"(6:,K$6&. 6" 6@,0

+2@&,<&%&(6+(. ,.&(6,;3 6@&2"(6:,K$6,"( ";,(6&:(+6,"(+#+00,06+(2&B+(. +#0" 6" .:+?6@&

#&00"(0;:"%6@&0&5:"2&00&0L

!

%8H+%,(&6@&:&#&<+(2&+(. ,%5#,2+6,"(0";6@,05:"/:&006" "6@&:.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0

5+:6,2$#+:#3 ,( C;:,2+L1+:6,2$#+:#3 $0&;$#?"$#. K&+(+#30,0"( A@,(+M0+55:"+2@ ,(

+2@,&<,(/ ;"". 0&2$:,63)6@&a@"?b+(. a?@+6bL

B(3&.,6)3'.(XG7A#)3'4#*+(,1.(3#(3

&")#" ,&")#!

1"+'&X>$+(/ A@&(/?&,BE&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(

A&(6:&,( A@,(+

W.,#&+3.&)],2@,+F+(&:D_,$BAF&(.BF?,6U&:#+(.

B(3&.,6)3.&5 *3+3#0#(3)="K&:6>++0B>&+. ";8+06C0,+E,<,0,"(B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":

82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6BG&:%+(3

&")#! ,&&)&"

j#5(.3#C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'C/:,2$#6$:+#+(. =$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6+(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( ,( A@,(+)Z&3 8H5&:,&(2&0

+(. ]&00"(0;":C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)],f,+"3$(BE,:&26":";A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5 +(. E&+( ";A"##&/&";

>$%+(,6,&0+(. E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

#LC/:,2$#6$:&E&<&#"5%&(6,( 6@&8A'XCFB+(. 6@&=&#&<+(2&";A@,(+M0C55:"+2@ ;":

6@,0F$KD:&/,"(

>%#+J#&) F+#,;"$ 9=C'=8B A"$(0&#": 6" 6@& 8A'XCF A"%%,00,"(&: ;":

C/:,2$#6$:&B8(<,:"(%&(6+(. X+6&:=&0"$:2&0B8A'XCFA"%%,00,"(

+L9@&=&#&<+(2&+(. 4%5#,2+6,"(0";A@,(+M0C/:,2$#6$:+#G:"?6@ +(. =$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6

;":C;:,2+)

>%#+J#&)-+( F@&(//&(BE,:&26":G&(&:+#B4-1=4

#)

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 103: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&&)&" ,&&)+"

1.00#(3*+(,='*)6**'.(*

&'_"$@"$ =+3%"(. F,K+,##3BC.<,0":"( ,00$&0";4(<&06%&(6+(. 4(6&/:+6,"(B

1:&0,.&(6M0';;,2&BA"6&. 4<",:&

#'E,:Q S&6Q&BE,:&26":";1:"/:+%N1CA9IBG9R*+#,

&&)+" ,&#)!" G%#(,'*)6**'.(

.)()::0:G#(F*6#7*

&))"" ,&))&"

G7A#)3'4#*./3"#%+&+--#-@.&J*".%*

>%#+J#&)[&((,;&:C.+%0BE&<&#"5%&(6A"$(0&##":B\FC4EBA@,(+

&))&" ,&*)""

K.&J*".%IXC.-')'#*+(,3"#'&'0%-#0#(3+3'.(

W.,#&+3.&X>&X&(5,(/BE,:&26":";C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B4(06,6$6&";X&06C0,+( +(.

C;:,2+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

D+%%.&3#6&X*,2@+&#]+,:.BF&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306B'8AE

&))&" ,&))!!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'A@,(+M0C/:,2$#6$:+#1"#,2,&0)1:"2&00+(. 4%5#&%&(6+6,"(

>%#+J#&)9+(/ *,(B E&5$63 F&2:&6+:3 G&(&:+#B A@,(+E&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@

-"$(.+6,"( NAE=-I

#'Z&3 F6:+6&/,&0+(. 1"#,2,&0;":A@,(+M0C/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6)]+(.

:&;":%B6"?(0@,5 &(6&:5:,0&0B%,/:+6,"( #+K"$:+(. %+:Q&6.&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)R@"(/ -$(,(/BY+(O,(/ C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

+'A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2&"( X+6&:=&0"$:2&*+(+/&%&(6+(. =$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)F@&( E+O$(BA@,(+4(06,6$6&";X+6&:=&0"$:2&0+(. >3.:"5"?&:=&0&+:2@B

*,(,06:3 ";X+6&:=&0"$:2&0

&)))" ,&*)"" G%#(,'*)6**'.(

&))&" ,&*)""

K.&J*".%fX>3&+3#8'#*+(,%#&/.&0+()#

1"+'&X8+:(m( 'MA#j,:,/@B!,2&A@+,:";1'!Y89+(. 4:,0@ C,.B4:&#+(.

D+%%.&3#6&X*+" f,+"O,(/BAC498AB*'-A'*BA@,(+

&))&" ,&))!!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'9@&="#&+(. 1&:;":%+(2&";=$:+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( 1"#,2,&0,( A@,(+

>%#+J#&)>$+(/ A@&(/?&,BE&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(

A&(6&:,( A@,(+

#'>"? +/:,2$#6$:&B;"". 0&2$:,63 +(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6@+<&2"(6:,K$6&. 6" 5"<&:63

:&.$26,"(

>%#+J#&)X+(/ F+(/$,B=&(%,( \(,<&:0,63 ";A@,(+

+'9@&=&#&<+(2&";A@,(+M0#+:/&02+#&5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( K+0&. "( +/:,2$#6$:&/:"?6@ +(.

:$:+#.&<&#"5%&(66"C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)S:$(" ]"02@BF&(,":82"("%,06BC-9C=B6@&X":#. S+(Q

&))!!D&*)"" G%#(,'*)6**'.(

$)

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 104: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&))&" ,&*)""

K.&J*".%VX!"#&.-#.//'(+()#+(,'(4#*30#(3;3#)"(.-.85 +(,'(3#&(+3'.(+-

)..%#&+3'.(

W.,#&+3.&X*"Q@6+:-+##B*,(,06:3 ";=$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6B*+$:,6+(,+

D+%%.&3#6&X_+( X+(/BA"D":.,(+6":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

&))&" ,&)))"

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'>"? A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:&+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6+:&;,(+(2&. +(. ?@+6:"#&";

,(<&06%&(65#+3&. ,( A@,(+M0C/:,2$#6$:+#+(. =$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)_+(/ i,$#,(BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

#'9&2@("#"/3 ,(("<+6,"( ,( A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)R@+(/ ]$K,+"BEG ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"( ";A@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";

C/:,2$#6$:+#F2,&(2&0

&)))" ,&*)"" G%#(,'*)6**'.(

&*)#" ,&-)""

C-#(+&5 *#**'.(

1"+'&X1&6&:A:+,/D*2i$+,.&B>&+. ";\(,6BEGE&<&#"5%&(6B8\

&*)#" ,&*)!"

D#%.&3/&.0#+)"%+&+--#-@.&J*".%

K.&J*".%IXC.-')'#*+(,3"#'&'0%-#0#(3+3'.(

D+%%.&3#6&)*,2@+&#]+,:.B'8AE

K.&J*".%fX>3&+3#8'#*+(,%#&/.&0+()#

D+%%.&3#6&)*+" f,+"O,(/BAC498AB*'-A'*BA@,(+

K.&J*".%VX3"#&.-#.//'(+()#+(,'(4#*30#(3;3#)"(.-.85 +(,'(3#&(+3'.(+-

)..%#&+3'.(

D+%%.&3#6&)_+( X+(/BA"D":.,(+6":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

&*)!" ,&())" G%#(,'*)6**'.(

>600+&5 .//'&*3,+52*,'*)6**'.(*

&())" ,&-)""

'l'+.56(BE&+( ";6@&A"##&/&";>$%+(,6,&0+(. E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0BA@,(+

C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63 +(. E,:&26":";6@&A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

D')"+&,1+&#5BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

-&../01T

=2..*),#$( %()#324,2)0R8**-'032)#,1 %$-)2)%4-0/04*.60$,

#$:8)#3% %$-#$3)0%'#$( ,"0#)#6.%3,*$

'2',%#$%940 ()*+,"%$-.*/0),1 )0-23,#*$

A@,(+@+0+:&#+6,<&#3 #"(/ @,06":3 ";0$55":6,(/ +/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2+B@+<,(/ 5:"<,.&.

,60;,:06;"". +00,06+(2&6" G$,(&+,( &$!$LF,(2&#"""B+/:,2$#6$:&@+0&%&:/&. +0"(&";6@&6"5

5:,":,6,&0";A@,(+M0.&<&#"5%&(62"D"5&:+6,"( ,( C;:,2+LC/:,2$#6$:&+(. ;"". 0&2$:,63 /+,(&. 6@&

;"2$0&0";6@&06:+6&/,2+/&(.+";A@,(+M0";;&:06" C;:,2+.$:,(/ -'ACA%&&6,(/ 2"(2#$.&. ,( Y"<L

#""$LA@,(+M00$55":6;":+/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2+@+0.,<&:0,;,&. ,(6" 6&2@(,2+#+00,06+(2&D

<,+%$#6,#+6&:+#%&2@+(,0%00$2@ +0?,6@ -C'M0F"$6@D6"DF"$6@ 5:"/:+%%&+(. 6@:"$/@ K,#+6&:+#

+/:&&%&(60?,6@ .,;;&:&(6C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0

!

+(. ,(06,6$6,"(+#2+5+2,63 .&<&#"5%&(6,(2#$.,(/ A@,(+D

C;:,2+C/:,2$#6$:+#9&2@("#"/3 A&(6:&0+(. 6&2@(,2+#6:+,(,(/ ;":C;:,2+( 6&2@(,2,+(0,( A@,(+L

%)

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 105: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

A@,(+M0;,&#.0";&(/+/&%&(6@+<&&H5+(.&. ,(6" #+(. .&<&#"5%&(6B2:"5 5:".$26,"(B#,<&06"2Q ;+:%

%+2@,(&:3 +(. ;"". 5:"2&00,(/L4( +..,6,"(BA@,(+M0&2"("%,22"D"5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2++#0" 0$55":60

+/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(66@:"$/@ 6@&5:"<,0,"( ";2"(2&00,"(+##"+(0+(. 5:,<+6&,(<&06%&(6L

'8AEDECA%&%K&:0+(. "6@&:.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&+/&(2,&0+#0" @+<&+#"(/ @,06":3 ";

0$55":6,(/ C;:,2+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6LC;:,2+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#%+:Q&6+(. ,60:&0&+:2@

+(. .&<&#"5%&(62+5+2,63 @+<&K&&( ,(;#$&(2&. K3 6@&."(":2"%%$(,63L46,02"(0&P$&(6#3 (+6$:+#6"

+0Q ?@+6#&00"(0A@,(+2+( .:+?;:"%6@,0,(6&:(+6,"(+#&H5&:,&(2&B&05&2,+##3 6" +22&#&:+6&C;:,2+M0

/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(L-":,605+:6BA@,(+M0"?( &H5&:,&(2&+(. &(/+/&%&(6,( C;:,2+

5:"<,.&0+( +#6&:(+6,<&.&<&#"5%&(6%".&#;":2"(0,.&:+6,"(L

E+3 # ";6@&5:"/:+% 0@+##;+2,#,6+6&+.,02$00,"( +K"$6@"? K"6@ A@,(+M0+(. "6@&:.&<&#"5%&(6

+00,06+(2&+/&(2,&0 &(/+/&%&(6,( C;:,2+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(62+( K&062"(6:,K$6&6" C;:,2+M0

/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(L9@&0&00,"( ?,##)

!

%=&<,&?6@&5"#,2,&0+(. 06:+6&/,&0A@,(+@+0.&<&#"5&. 6" 0$55":6C;:,2+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#

.&<&#"5%&(6+(. 6@&,::&5#,2+K,#,63 +2:"00C;:,2+L

!

%=&<,&?6@&.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&5"#,23 ;:"% "6@&:.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&+/&(2,&0"(

C;:,2+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6L

!

%>,/@#,/@66@&,%5+260";6@"0&,(6&:<&(6,"(0"( C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(L

!

%8H5#":&6@&%".+#,6,&0";06:&(/6@&(,(/ 6:,#+6&:+#2""5&:+6,"( K&6?&&( A@,(+B.&<&#"5%&(6

+00,06+(2&+(. C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0L

D#/-#)3'.(*.(=+5 I +(,G7A#)3'4#*/.&=+5 f

$)"" ,$)&"

1"+'&)=,2@+:. A+:&3BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

W.,#&+3.&XE&K":+@ S:+$6,/+%B1:";&00":BC%&:,2+( \(,<&:0,63

B(3&.,6)3.&5 *3+3#0#(3)1@,#,5 Z+:5B=&/,"(+#A"":.,(+6":B8+06C0,+h1+2,;,2BX":#.

S+(Q 4(06,6$6&

$)&" ,&")""

j#5(.3#%&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"( K&6?&&( E&<&#"5%&(6C/&(2,&0+(. C;:,2+,( 6@&-,&#. ";

C/:,2$#6$:+#+(. =$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6)Z&3 ]&00"(0

>%#+J#&)>&#%$6C02@&B*+(+/,(/ E,:&26":";4(06,6$6&;":C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B]&,5U,/

\(,<&:0,63

#'A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6+(. &2"("%,22""5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2+)Z&3 5"#,2,&0

+(. #&00"(0

>%#+J#&)f$&>"(/BAC498AB*'-A'*BA@,(+

+'E"(":M01&:05&26,<&"( C;:,2+M0C/:,2$#6$:&+(. =$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6B

>%#+J#&)[&+(D_<&0G:"02#+$.&BE,:&26":";'5&:+6,"(0BC;E

&")+" ,&&)""

1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(*

&'E,;;&:&(6C;:,2+( 5&:05&26,<&0

!

-&&.K+2Q ;:"% 6@&G#"K+#E&<&#"5%&(6]&+:(,(/

Y&6?":Q 0&00,"(B="0&K$. S$:$Q$B1"#,23 C.<,0":BC;:,2+A&(6&:;":82"("%,2

9:+(0;":%+6,"( NCA89I

#'["0$jE,"(jBE,:&26":B-"". F&2$:,63 +(. F$06+,(+K#&E&<&#"5%&(6E,<,0,"(B\Y

82"("%,2A"%%,00,"( ";C;:,2+N\Y8ACI

+'C(.:&S+6,"("BE,:&26":;":X&06C;:,2+';;,2&+(. F&(",:1:"/:+% ';;,2&:BF",#

>&+#6@ 1:"/:+%BCG=C

&&)"" ,&#)"" G%#(,'*)6**'.(

&)

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 106: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

.)()::0:G#(F*6#7*

G7A#)3'4#*./3"#%+&+--#-*#**'.(*

&+)+" ,&+))" B(3&.,6)3'.(X '9(*"+(;E,:&26":B4(06,6$6&";C;:"DC0,+( F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

&+))" ,&!)+"

K.&J*".%IX!"#).(3&'763'.(./,#4#-.%0#(3).<.%#&+3'.(

W.,#&+3.&X>&X&(5,(/BE,:&26":";C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B4(06,6$6&";X&06C0,+( +(.

C;:,2+( F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

D+%%.&3#6&X=,2@+:. F2@,&:&BF&(,":82"("%,06BC;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q

&+))! ,&))#!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'*".+#,6,&0+(. 5&:;":%+(2&0";A@,(+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#&(/+/&%&(6+(. .&<&#"5%&(6

2""5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)],[,+#,B*,(,06:3 ";C/:,2$#6$:&BA@,(+

#'A@,(+M0C,. +(. C/:,2$#6$:+#8(/+/&%&(6,( C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)E&K":+@ S:+$6,/+%B1:";&00":BC%&:,2+( \(,<&:0,63

+'4(2:&+0,(/ 6@&,%5+26";+/:,2$#6$:&"( /:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(

>%#+J#&)1&6&:S,&#&:BF&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306B'8AE

&))#! ,&!)+" G%#(,'*)6**'.(

&+))" ,&!)+"

K.&J*".%fX!"#%&'4+3#*#)3.&2*).(3&'763'.(

W.,#&+3.&)S,##Y,2"#B>&+. ";1"<&:63 +(. G:"?6@ E,<,0,"(B'8AE

D+%%.&3#6&)C.+%+A"$#,K+#3BA"(0&,##&:9&2@(,P$&B*,(,06:3 ";C/:,2$#6$:&B*+#,

&+))" ,&)))"

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'A@,(+M0+,.B6:+.&+(. ,(<&06%&(6,( C;:,2+

>%#+J#&*)[&+(D=+5@+&#A@+5"((,&:&+(. R@&(/ i,BC;E

#'-":&,/( ,(<&06%&(6,( C;:,2+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#)9@&2+0&";0$/+:2+(&,(*+#,

>%#+J#&)N;:"%]+F"2,j6j0$2:,n:&.$ Z+#+

!

F$Q+#+I-&(/ F@&3"(/B=&5:&0&(6+6,<&

,( *+#,BA@,(+],/@64(.$06:,+#A":5":+6,"( ;":-":&,/( 82"("%,2+(. 9&2@(,2+#

A""5&:+6,"(

+'9@&0$55":6K3 (&? ,(6&:(+6,"(+#.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2& +/&(2,&06" C;:,2+M0

+/:,2$#6$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)F6&<&( E+<,0B9@&G+6&0-"$(.+6,"(

)'9@&:"#&";6@&5:,<+6&0&26":,(<&06%&(6,( +/:,2$#6$:+#+(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)1@,##,5 4.:"B \5#+(. =,2& *,##&:0L A"L]6.B \/+(.+J +(. ;":%&:

C%K+00+.":6" A@,(+

&)))" ,&!)+" G%#(,'*)6**'.(

&+))" ,&!)+"

K.&J*".%VXj#5 '**6#*-..J'(8 +"#+,XB((.4+3'.(;)-'0+3#)"+(8#+(,%.%6-+3'.(

8&.@3"

W.,#&+3.&)Y+"@,:" Z,6+("BE,:&26":G&(&:+#B[4AC

D+%%.&3#6&)[+%&0Z&&#&3B4(6&:(+6,"(+#4(06,6$6&;":8(<,:"(%&(6+(. E&<&#"5%&(6

N,,&.I,( 86@,"5,+

')

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 107: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&+))" ,&)))"

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'8%&:/,(/ ,00$&0;"::$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)[&+(D[+2P$&0G+K+0B

#'X@3 A@,(++(. 8+06C0,+(&&. +/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2+W1"00,K#&111;":

6@+65$:5"0&

>%#+J#&)Z+60$%,>,:+("BE,:&26":G&(&:+#BC:&+F6$.,&0A&(6&:B4(06,6$6&";

E&<&#"5,(/ 82"("%,&0B[+5+( 8H6&:(+#9:+.&':/+(,U+6,"(

+'C;:,2+M0+/:,2$#6$:+#.&<&#"5%&(65"6&(6,+#;:"%6@&A@,(&0&5&:05&26,<&

>%#+J#&)i,G$K"BA"##&/&";>$%+(,6,&0+(. E&<&#"5%&(6BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#

\(,<&:0,63

)'9@&8%&:/,(/ 8<&:/:&&( C/:,2$#6$:&+(. 2#,%+6&2@+(/&,00$&0

>%#+J#&)C(6",(&Z+#,(/+(,:&BG#"K+#=&0&+:2@ 1:"O&26]&+.&:B4(6&:(+6,"(+#A&(6&:

;":=&0&+:2@ ,( C/:";":&06:3 N4A=C-D*+#,I

&)))" ,&!)+" G%#(,'*)6**'.(

K.&J*".%>600+&5

&!)!" ,&()&!

1"+'&)C."#;Z#"Q&D]&02@BE,:&26":BF6:+6&/3 A&(6:&;":Y&?1+:6(&:0@,50;":G#"K+#

E&<&#"5%&(6BG9R

&!)!" ,&*)#"

D#%.&3/&.0#+)"%+&+--#-@.&J*".%

K.&J*".%IX!"#).(3&'763'.(./,#4#-.%0#(3).<.%#&+3'.(

D+%%.&3#6&)=,2@+:. F2@,&:&BF&(,":82"("%,06BC;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q

K.&J*".%fX!"#%&'4+3#*#)3.&2*).(3&'763'.(

D+%%.&3#6&)C.+%+A"$#,K+#3BA"(0&,##&:9&2@(,P$&B*,(,06:3 ";C/:,2$#6$:&B*+#,

K.&J*".%VX ..J'(8 +"#+,XB((.4+3'.(;)-'0+3#)"+(8#+(,%.%6-+3'.(8&.@3"

D+%%.&3#6&)[+%&0Z&&#&3B,,&.

&*)#" ,&()&! G%#(,'*)6**'.(

1-.*'(8 1#&#0.(5

&()&! ,&-)"" 1"+'&)*,2@&#=&<&3:+(. .&*&(6@"(B-:&(2@ C%K+00+.":6" *+#,

>600+&5 ./3"##4#(3

&()#" ,&())"

'l'+.56(BE&+(BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63 +(. E,:&26":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

D')"+&,1+&#5BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

1-.*'(8D#0+&J*

&())" ,&-)""

E,+##" *+.&#&,(&S+B*+#,+( *,(,06&:";],<&06"2Q +(. -,0@&:3

>$+(/ A@&(/?&,BE&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B41=AA

()

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 108: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

TTOY.<2'T8T.<V'D >TD'

-+3&CEC*C =&0&+:2@&:B41C=BF&(&/+#

[&((,;&:CEC*F E&<&#"5%&(6A"$(0&##":\FC4EDA@,(+

*+6@,&$ CE['!4 1:&0,.&(6";#M4(6&:5:";&00,"( A"6"( .$ Kj(,(

C#+00+(&CGCGC9>CY8 *+#,+( *,(,06&:";C/:,2$#6$:&

>&#%$6CFA>8 *+(+/,(/ E,:&26":B4(06,6$6&";C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B]&,5U,/ \(,<&:0,63

E,+##" *+.&#&,(&SC *,(,06&:";],<&06"2Q +(. -,0@&:3B*+#,

E&#5@,(&SCS4YD184]]C=E *,(,06:3 ";-":&,/( C;;+,:0B-:+(2&

A@&,2Q SC9>4]_ 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0":B-C'S+%+Q"

C(.:&SC94'Y' E,:&26":;":X&06C;:,2+';;,2&+(. F&(,":1:"/:+%';;,2&:BF",#>&+#6@ 1:"/:+%

C##,+(2&;":+G:&&( =&<"#$6,"( ,( C;:,2+NCG=CI

E,:Q S89Z8 1CA91:"/:+%%&E,:&26":BG9RBG&:%+(3

1&6&:S48]8= F&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306B1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( +(. G:"?6@ E,<,0,"(B'8AE

-:+(2",0S'Y98*1F E&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#BE,:&26":+6&;":E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(B*,(,06:3 ";

-":&,/( C;;+,:0BS&#/,$%

>&:<&S'\GC\]9 E,:&26":BC-EDS+%+Q"B*+#,

E&K":+@ S=C\94GC* 1:";&00":B4(6&:(+6,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6BC%&:,2+( \(,<&:0,63B\FC

Y+6@+#,&S='CE>\=F9 1"#,23 ';;,2&:B*,(,06:3 ";-":&,/( C;;+,:0B-:+(2&

="0&K$. S\=\Z\ 1"#,23 C.<,0&:BC;:,2+( A&(6&:;":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( NCA89I

AC'>"(/%,( E,<,0,"( A@,&;BE&5+:6%&(6";4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"( +(. F"2,+#*"K,#,U+6,"(BF6+6&

A"$(2,#]&+.,(/ G:"$5 ';;,2&";1"<&:63 C##&<,+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6BA@,(+

F6&;+(" AC1'9'=94 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0":B4FA'FD46+#,+( A""5&:+6,"(

=,2@+:. AC=8_ A"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

[&+(D-:+(2",0AC!CYC E&5$63 E,:&26":BC-ES+%+Q"B*+#,

[&+(D=+5@+&#A>C1'YY48=8 82"("%,06BC0,+E&5+:6%&(6BC-EB1+:,0

F&Q"$ .,6G+"$00"$ A4FF8 A@,&;";F6+;;B1:,%&*,(,06&:M0';;,2&B*+#,

C%+."$ S"$K+2+:A4FF8 E,:&26":BY+6,"(+#C(,%+#1:".$26,"(B],<&06"2Q +(. -,0@,(/ *,(,06:3B*+#,

F+#,;A']_ A"$(0&##":B[4ACF&(&/+#

1,&::&DC(.:jA'=E8_ G#"K+#-"". F&2$:,63 1:"/:+%%&BF?,00C/&(23 ;":E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(

F&3."$ A'\]4SC]_ 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0":B],<&06"2Q +(. -,0@,(/ *,(,06:3B*+#,

>j:3 A'\]4SC]_ E,:&26":";Y+6,"(+#-,0@,(/B],<&06"2Q +(. -,0@,(/ *,(,06:3B*+#,

C.+%+A'\]4SC]_ 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0":BC/:,2$#6$:&*,(,06:3B*+#,

1&6&:A=C4GD*Ai\C4E8 >&+. ";\(,6BEGE&<&#"5%&(6B=&#+6,"(0?,6@ ,(6&:(+6,"(+#":/+(,0+6,"(0+(. ("(

8\%&%K&:06+6&0B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

F6&<&( EC!4F A"(0$#6+(6BG+6&0-"$(.+6,"( +(. *2Z,(0&3B\FC

=jO+(&Z'Y8E8*S8]8 8H&2$6,<&F&2:&6+:3BAY=CB*+#,

G+"$00"$ .,68%,#&E8*S8]8 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0":B8(<,:"(%&(6*,(,06:3B*+#,

]+$:&(6E8Y4C\ 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0":B8A'XCF

1+:+*"$00+E4C]]' 1:&0,.&(6";6@&-&.&:+6,"( ";-"$6+EO+##"(BG$,(&+

E4C==C 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0":BA+(+.,+( A""5&:+6,"(

CK.&#Q+.&:E4C==C E,:&26":Y+6,"(+#!&6&:,(+:3 F&:<,2&B],<&06"2Q +(. -,0@,(/ *,(,06:3B*+#,

["0$&E4'Y8 E,:&26":B-"". F&2$:,63 +(. F$06+,(+K#&E&<&#"5%&(6B\Y8AC

*S+2@,:E4'1 A@+,:%+( +(. A@,&;8H&2$6,<&';;,2&:BF'E8-498fBF&(&/+#

))

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 109: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

_,(/K,E\CY 1:&0,.&(6";A@,(+-"$(.+6,"( ;":1"<&:63 C##&<,+6,"(BA@,(+

["@( 8EGC= C/:,2$#6$:&E&<&#"5%&(6';;,2&:B\FC4EB86@,"5,+

S&2Q3 [L8=Z\] F&(,":E"(":C;;+,:0C.<,0":B\FC4EBX+0@,(/6"(

*"Q@6+:-C]] A"$(0&##":B*,(,06:3 ";=$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6B*+$:,6+(,+

-CYF@&(//&( E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#-"". 1"#,23 =&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&N4-1=4I

-8YGF@&3"(/ G&(&:+#*+(+/&:BA@,(+],/@64(.$06:,+#A":5":+6,"( ;":-":&,/( 82"("%,2+(.

9&2@(,2+#A""5&:+6,"(B*+#,';;,2&

F,%"( -=88*CY9]8 82"("%,068+06C;:,2+BF6+(.+:. S+(QBZ&(3+

[&+( [+2P$&0GCSCF F&(,"::&0&+:2@&:BC/:,2$#6$:+#=&0&+:2@ ;":E&<&#"5%&(6NA4=CEI

Sj+6:,2&GCZ\SC A8'=?+(.+-#":+B=?+(.+

[&+( _<&0G='FA]C\E8 E,:&26":";9&2@(,2+#'5&:+6,"(BC-EB1+:,0

*"$%"$(,G\4]]C\*8 A@,&;=&5:&0&(6+6,<&,( C;:,2+BA>4YC>\CE'YGA'=1L]9EBS&(,(

="K&:6>CCF >&+. ";8+06C0,+E,<,0,"(B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6BG&:%+(3

>8X&(5,(/ E,:&26":";6@&E,<,0,"( ";C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B4(06,6$6&";X&06C0,+( +(. C;:,2+(

F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0BA@,(+

Z+60$%,>4=CY' E,:&26":G&(&:+#BC:&+F6$.,&0A&(6&:B4(06,6$6&";E&<&#"5,(/ 82"("%,&0B[+5+(

8H6&:(+#9:+.&':/+(,U+6,"(

C#+,( >'\_'\f 1"#,23 ';;,2&:B8$:"5&+( \(,"(

>\CYGA@&(/?&, E&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+

1@,#,5 4E=' \5#+(. =,2&*,##&:0A"L]6.B\/+(.+B;":%&:C%K+00+.":6" A@,(+

S,:/,6['\FF8Y 1"#,23 ';;,2&:BG&:%+( 8%K+003B*+#,

[$#,+ZC4F8= >&+. ";6@&E,<,0,"(BX&06C;:,2+BS*RBG&:%+(3

C(6",(&ZC]4YGCY4=8 G#"K+#=&0&+:2@ 1:"O&26]&+.&:B4(6&:(+6,"(+#A&(6&:;":=&0&+:2@ ,( C/:";":&06:3

N4A=C-D*+#,I

1@,##,5 ZC=1 =&/,"(+#A"":.,(+6":B8+06C0,+h1+2,;,2BX":#. S+(Q 4(06,6$6&';;,2&,( A@,(+

[+%&0Z88]8_ =&0&+:2@ C00"2,+6&B4(6&:(+6,"(+#4(06,6$6&;":8(<,:"(%&(6+(. E&<&#"5%&(6,(

86@,"5,+

*+(.+F+.," Z849C 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0":B1:,%+6$:&B*+#,

Y+"@,:" Z49CY' E,:&26":DG&(&:+#B8+06+(. A&(6:+#C0,++(. 6@&A+$2+0$0E&5+:6%&(6B[4AC

S+/&(,Z49'GC E,:&26":BFY=$:+#_"$6@B=EAA"(/"

C."#;Z]'Z8D]8FA> E,:&26":BF6:+6&/3 A&(6:&;":Y&?1+:6(&:0@,50;":G#"K+#E&<&#"5%&(6BG9RB

G&:%+(3

*"@+%&. Z'YC=8 1"#,23 ';;,2&:BS&#/,+( 9&2@(,2+#A&(6:&

F+%K+Z'\*C=8 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0":B=$:+#82"("%,24(06,6$6&D48=B*+#,

>,:"3$Q,Z\S'9C 8H&2$6,<&C.<,0":6" 6@&E,:&26":G&(&:+#BE&<&#"5%&(6E&5+:6%&(6B[4AC

*,2@+&#]C4=E F&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306B1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( hG:"?6@ E,<,0,"(B'8AE

]4C(0@+( 1:";&00":BE,:&26":B4(06,6$6&";C;:"DC0,+( F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

]4[,+#, E&5$63 E,<,0,"( A@,&;B-":&,/( 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( A&(6&:B*,(,06:3 ";

C/:,2$#6$:&BA@,(+

]4],(3, 1:"/+%%&';;,2&:B=&0&+:2@ E,<,0,"(B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,(

A@,(+

]4F@+"O$( E,<,0,"( A@,&;BA""5&:+6,"( E,<,0,"(B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+

]4f,+"3$( E&+(BA"##&/&";>$%+(,6,&0+(. E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

S:$(" ]'FA> F&(,":82"("%,06BC-9C=BX":#. S+(Q

]+%,(&]'\* A"(0$#6+(6BC-EBF&(&/+#

**!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 110: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

*C'f,+"O,(/ =&0&+:2@&:BE&56L";-":&,/( C,.BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(.

82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( NAC498AIB*,(,06:3 ";A"%%&:2&BA@,(+

1@,#,55&*C=ACE8Y9 F&(,":C.<,0&:BF"2,+#1:"6&26,"( F&26":B4(6&:(+6,"(+#]+K"$:':/+(,0+6,"(

G&":/&*C=8A>8=C S$0,(&00E&<&#"5%&(6*+(+/&:BC;:,2+C/ 9&2@("#"/3 -"$(.+6,"( NCC9-I

[+2" *8S4\F 1"#,23 ';;,2&:BY&6@&:#+(.08%K+003

G:+2&],<,( *'F>C C00,06+(6E,:&26":B1#+((,(/ A"%%,00,"(B9+(U+(,+

9"%*\G4FC F&(,":1:"/:+%%&';;,2&:B*,(,06:3 ";C/:,2$#6$:&B\/+(.+

1+$#" Y8G=

"

C' A"%%&:2,+#A"$(0&##":B*"U+%K,P$&

],K",:&YG8YEC>C_' 9&2@(,2+#+.<,0":B*,(,06:3 ";C/:,2$#6$:&+(. ],<&06"2QBS$:$(.,

X,##,+%Y4A'] >&+. ";1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( +(. G:"?6@ E,<,0,"(B'8AE

Y'\= =&5:&0&(6+6,<&B-C'S+%+Q"B*+#,

8+:(m( 'MA]

!

4=4G> 4:,0@ C,.BE&5+:6%&(6";-":&,/( C;;+,:0B4:&#+(.

*+:,+%*+@+%+618==8C\ A"$(0&##":BC-EB1+:,0

i4G$K" 1:";&00":BA"##&/&";>$%+(,6,&0+(. E&<&#"5%&(6BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

*,2@&#=8!8_=CYEE8*8Y9>'Y -:&(2@ C%K+00+.":6" *+#,

]$2=4FA> A"$(0&##":BS&#/,$%8%K+003

-+;:jFC*CZ8 E,:&26":DG&(&:+#B41=V4-=C

],2@,+FCY8=D_4\ 1:&0,.&(6BC2+.&%3 ;":i$+#,63 ,( 9:+,(,(/ h8.$2+6,"(BA&(6&:;":F"2,+#D82"("%,2

E&<&#"5%&(6NAF8EIBF?,6U&:#+(.

Z+#;+FCY'G' 1"#,23 ';;,2&:B\YE1*+#,

[&+(DS+56,06&FC9A>4!4 C/:"D,(.$06:,+#BCG=4FC9A>BS&(,(

=,2@+:. FA>48=8 F&(,":82"("%,06BC;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q

A@+:#&0FA>4]9R 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0":BE&#&/+6,"( 6" 6@&8$:"5&+( \(,"(

F>8YE+O$( 1:";&00":BA@,(+4(06,6$6&";X+6&:=&0"$:2&0+(. >3.:"5"?&:=&0&+:2@BA@,(+

_"$@"$ =+3%"(. F4SC4]]_ C.<,0":"( 4(<&06%&(6+(. 4(6&/:+6,"(B1:&0,.&(2&";6@&=&5$K#,2BA"6&.M4<",:&

Z+00,%F4E4S8 1:"/:+%%&';;,2&:B-"". F&2$:,63 A"%%,00,"( ;":-"". F&2$:,63B*+#,

*".,K" F4E4S8 1:,%&*,(,06&:B=&5$K#,2";*+#,

S:j@,%+Y"$%K+:3 F4E4S8 1"#,23 ';;,2&:B*,(,06:3 ";8%5#"3%&(6+(. 1:";&00,"(+#9:+,(,(/B*+#,

*,2@+&#F94=YX84FF C.<,0":B8+06C0,+F&26,"(B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6BG&:%+(3

9+.+0@,F\R\Z4 C00,06+(6E,:&26":BE&<&#"5%&(61+:6(&:0@,5 E,<,0,"(B'5&:+6,"(0F6:+6&/3

E&5+:6%&(6B[4AC

9CYG*,( E&5$63 F&2:&6+:3 G&(&:+#BA@,(+E&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@ -"$(.+6,"(

'$0%+(&98=C A@,&;";F6+;;B*,(,06:3 ;":6@&1:"%"6,"( X"%&(BA@,#.:&( +(. -+%,#3B*+#,

C.:,&( 9>8C9=8 C%K+00+.":BS&#/,$%8%K+003 ,( *+#,

F+#,;"$ 9=C'=8 A"$(0&#":6" 6@&8A'XCFA"%%,00,"(&:;":C/:,2$#6$:&B8(<,:"(%&(6+(. X+6&:

=&0"$:2&0B8A'XCFA"%%,00,"(

XCYGF+(/$, 1:";&00":BF2@""#";C/:,2$#6$:+#82"("%,20+(. =$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6B=&(%,(

\(,<&:0,63 ";A@,(+

XCYGf,+"#,( E,<,0,"( A@,&;B=&0&+:2@ E,<,0,"(B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+

XCYG_+( A"D".,(+6":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

XCYG_,@$+( 1:";&00":BA"##&/&";>$%+(,6,&0+(. E&<&#"5%&(6BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

[+2"K XCF]CYE8= 1:,(2,5+#A"$(0&##":BY&6@&:#+(.08%K+003

1+%&#+X>498 *,00,"( E,:&26":B\FC4EV],K&:,+

X\F@$#,( C00"2,+6&=&0&+:2@ -&##"?BE&5+:6%&(6";=&/,"(+#82"("%3BY+6,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6

+(. =&;":%A"%%,00,"( NYE=AIBA@,(+

!*!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 111: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

f\8>"(/ E,:&26":BE&56";-":&,/( C,.BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2

A""5&:+6,"( NAC498AIB*,(,06:3 ";A"%%&:2&BA@,(+

_CYGi,$#,( 1:";&00":BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

8:(&06_8YGC]4Y'XC E,<,0,"( >&+.B*,(,06:3 ";C/:,2$#6$:&B=EA"(/"

R>CYGG$"P,(/ A@,(&0&C%K+00+.":6" *+#,

R>CYG]$K,+" E,:&26":G&(&:+#";4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"(BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";C/:,2$#6$:+#

F2,&(2&0

R>8YGX&(Q+, E&5$63 E,:&26":BF6+6&A"$(2,#]&+.,(/ G:"$5 ';;,2&";1"<&:63 C##&<,+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6N]G'1IBA@,(+

R>8YGi, A"(0$#6+(6BC-EB1+:,0

R>'YG-$(,(/ 1:";&00":BY+((,(/ C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63BA@,(+

"*!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 112: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

<VV!W! TTT

T$+()*,(3",3(0Q

'60 I#3$-),&#$+#(H(#5,6)$-.#/0(,1 20-3",&#$

J0&K&$;986&$)9IR hfS D07,0%O0(fSIS

T)L<H!VC<

J)"F;(#3$-)$-#OK0",&/0*

9" ;+2,#,6+6&6@&0@+:,(/ ";&H5&:,&(2&0+(. 5:"%"6&#&+:(,(/ "( &2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63

:&.$26,"(B6@&A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5 ?+0&06+K#,0@&. K3 6@&4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&

,( A@,(+N41=AAI+(. 6@&':/+(,0+6,"( ;":82"("%,2A"D"5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6M0E&<&#"5%&(6

C00,06+(2&A"%%,66&&N'8AEDECAI,( [+($+:3 #""$'

9@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,0;"2$0,(/ ,60?":Q "( 6?" 6@&%&0)

!

%A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2&";&2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B,(2#$.,(/ 6@&2"(6:,K$6,"( ";

,(6&:(+6,"(+#+00,06+(2&B+(. ,60:&#&<+(2&;":"6@&:.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0B5+:6,2$#+:#3 ,(

C;:,2+'

!

%A@,(+M0&2"("%,22"D"5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2++(. 6@&#&00"(06@+6A@,(++(. %":&&06+K#,0@&.

."(":02+( 0@+:&?,6@ &+2@ "6@&:6" ,(2:&+0&6@&2"##&26,<&,%5+26";;":&,/( +,. "( :&.$2,(/

5"<&:63 ,( C;:,2+'

9@&0&6@&%&0+:&K&,(/ +..:&00&. .$:,(/ +0&:,&0";&<,.&(2&DK+0&. 5"#,23 .,+#"/$&&<&(60B?@,2@

&(+K#&0+#+:/&:($%K&:";06+Q&@"#.&:06" K&,(<"#<&. ,( 6@&F6$.3 G:"$5M0+26,<,6,&0'=&;#&26,(/ 6@&

(&&.0,( %+(3 C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&06".+3B.$:,(/ #""$D&" 6@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,02"(0,.&:,(/ ;"$:6"5,20

?@,2@ ,(;#$&(2&K"6@ 6@&5+2&";&2"("%,2/:"?6@ +0?&##+06@&&H6&(66" ?@,2@ &2"("%,2/:"?6@

2"(6:,K$6&06" :&.$2,(/ 5"<&:63)

!

%E&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50'

!

%C/:,2$#6$:&B;"". 0&2$:,63 +(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6'

!

%4(;:+06:$26$:&'

!

%9@&&(+K#,(/ &(<,:"(%&(6;":&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6'

9@&F6$.3 G:"$5M0;,:06&<&(6"( aE&<&#"5%&(61+:6(&:0@,50;":G:"?6@ +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(b6""Q

5#+2&,( S&,O,(/BA@,(+,( '26"K&:#""$'9@&0&2"(. &<&(6"( aC/:,2$#6$:&B-"". F&2$:,63 +(. =$:+#

E&<&#"5%&(6;":G:"?6@ +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(b6""Q 5#+2&,( S+%+Q"B*+#,,( C5:,##"&"'

9@,06@,:. &<&(6?,##;"2$0"( 6@&:"#&";,(;:+06:$26$:&,( 5:"%"6,(/ &2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. :&.$2,(/

5"<&:63 K3 +..:&00,(/ 6@:&&Q&3 .,%&(0,"(0";,(;:+06:$26$:&.&<&#"5%&(6),I&(0$:,(/ 0$06+,(+K,#,63

!

,(2#$.,(/ ;,(+(2,(/B%+,(6&(+(2&+(. &(<,:"(%&(6+#,%5+26B,,I+2@,&<,(/ &;;,2,&(23

!

,(2#$.,(/

5#+((,(/B:&0"$:2&+##"2+6,"( +(. 5$K#,2D5:,<+6&5+:6(&:0@,50B+(. ,,,I,(2:&+0,(/ ,%5+26"( &2"("%,2

/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(

!

,(2#$.,(/ 5:"2$:&%&(6+55:"+2@&0B#,(Q+/&0,(6" 6@&#"2+#&2"("%3

+(. ,(<"#<,(/ 5"":5&"5#&,( .&2,0,"(D%+Q,(/ 5:"2&00&0'

#*!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 113: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

*":&05&2,;,2+##3B6@&&<&(6"( 4(;:+06:$26$:&?,##)

!

%=&<,&?6@&.&<&#"5%&(65+6@B06:+6&/,&0B+2@,&<&%&(60+(. 2@+##&(/&0";A@,(++(. C;:,2+(

2"$(6:,&0,( 6@&6@:&&.,%&(0,"(0";,(;:+06:$26$:&

!

&(0$:,(/ 0$06+,(+K,#,63B+2@,&<,(/

&;;,2,&(23 +(. ,(2:&+0,(/ ,%5+26'

!

%C(+#30&6@&%&+(06@:"$/@ ?@,2@ ,(<&06%&(60,( ,(;:+06:$26$:&@+<&K:"$/@6+K"$6&2"("%,2

/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( ,( A@,(+B+(. 2"(0,.&:6@&:&#&<+(2&";6@,0&H5&:,&(2&;":

2"$(6:,&0,( C;:,2+'

!

%8H+%,(&6@&,(2:&+0,(/ :"#&";A@,(+M0&(/+/&%&(6,( C;:,2+M0,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. ,605"6&(6,+#

,%5+26+(. 2"%5+:&6@,0?,6@ 6@&#&00"(0#&+:(6K3 ,(6&:(+6,"(+#."(":0'

!

%8H5#":&6@&"55":6$(,6,&0B%&+(0+(. K&(&;,60;:"% K&66&:2"D"5&:+6,"( "( 0$55":66"

,(;:+06:$26$:&K&6?&&( A@,(+BECA."(":0+(. C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0'

!

%9@&%+,( ;,(.,(/0+(. &%&:/,(/ #&00"(0;:"%6@&F6$.3 G:"$5M00&:,&0";&<&(60,( #""$D&"

?,##K&5:&0&(6&. +(. .,02$00&. +6+5"#,23 03%5"0,$%,( S&,O,(/ 5#+((&. ;":%,. #"&&'

$*!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 114: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

.(#;()%%0

1"+'&X_6+(8 1"#(8@#';=#%635 ='&#)3.&<?#(#&+-;B(3#&(+3'.(+-C.4#&35 D#,6)3'.(1#(3&#'(1"'(+

W+*3#&./1#&#0.('#*XC#3#&1&+'8<W)m6+',#;_#+,./Z('3;H6&.%#+(1.00'**'.(

$)"! ,$)#"

K#-).0'(8 &#0+&J*

R@&(/ X&(Q+,BE&5$63 E,:&26":BF6+6&A"$(2,#]&+.,(/ G:"$5 ';;,2&";1"<&:63

C##&<,+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6BA@,(+

$)#" ,$)+"

=#4#-.%0#(3).<.%#&+3'.('('(/&+*3&6)36&#+(,'0%-')+3'.(*/.&8&.@3"+(,%.4#&35

&#,6)3'.('(9/&')+

-+(6$ A@&:$B=&0&+:2@ E,:&26":B9@&Y":.,2C;:,2+( 4(06,6$6&

$)+" ,$))"

W+'( -#**.(* /&.0 3"# 1"'(+<=91 >36,5 ?&.6%2* #4#(3* .( =#4#-.%0#(3

C+&3(#&*"'%*+(,.(98&')6-36&#; ..,>#)6&'35 +(,D6&+-=#4#-.%0#(3

=,2@+:. A+:&3BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

-&../01O

;"0 !*$,)#92,#*$*8P$8)%',)23,2)0 ,*!"#$%&'

73*$*6#3 I)*+,"%$->*/0),1 F0-23,#*$

4(<&06%&(6,( ,(;:+06:$26$:&B$0,(/ K"6@ ."%&06,2+(. ,(6&:(+6,"(+#:&0"$:2&0B@+0K&&( 2:$2,+##3

,%5":6+(6;":A@,(+M0:&2&(6.&<&#"5%&(6'9@,:63 3&+:0+/"B6@:"$/@"$66@&2"$(6:3B$(:&#,+K#&B

,(&;;,2,&(6+(. 5"":#3 %+,(6+,(&. ,(;:+06:$26$:&

!

&05&2,+##3 ;":6:+(05":6B&(&:/3B?+6&:+(.

0+(,6+6,"( +(. ,::,/+6,"(

!

?+0+%+O":K"66#&(&2Q'F,(2&6@&(B6@&:&@+0K&&( 0$K06+(6,+#0$55":6;":

,(;:+06:$26$:&.&<&#"5%&(6,( :$:+#+:&+0B;":&H+%5#&;":,::,/+6,"( 0306&%0+(. 6:+(05":6'9@,0@+0

%+.&,65"00,K#&6" ,%5:"<&+/:,2$#6$:+#5:".$26,"(B.&05,6&&H6:&%&#3 02+:2&+:+K#&#+(. 5&:2+5,6+'46

@+0+#0" %+.&+0$K06+(6,+#2"(6:,K$6,"( 6" :&+5,(/ 6@&2"%5+:+6,<&+.<+(6+/&0;:"%#,(Q,(/ ."%&06,2

:&/,"(0+0?&##+0;+2,#,6+6&. A@,(+M0&(6:3 ,(6" /#"K+#%+:Q&60'9@&5&:6,(&(2&";6@&&H5:&00,"( a,;

3"$ ?+(66" K&:,2@B;,:06K$,#. +:"+.b@+0K&&( .&%"(06:+6&. ($%&:"$06,%&0+2:"00+##5+:60";

A@,(+'

E$:,(/ E+3 & ";6@,0&<&(6B.,02$00,"(0?,##&H+%,(&@"?,(;:+06:$26$:&@+0K&&( K$,#6$5 ,( A@,(++(.

@"?6@,0@+0%+.&+2"(6:,K$6,"( 6" A@,(+M0&2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B;"2$00,(/ "(

6@:&&Q&3 .,%&(0,"(0";,(;:+06:$26$:&.&<&#"5%&(6),I&(0$:,(/ 0$06+,(+K,#,63B,,I+2@,&<,(/

&;;,2,&(23B+(. ,,,I,(2:&+0,(/ ,%5+26"( /:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('1+:6,2$#+:+66&(6,"( ?,##K&

5+,. 6" ,.&(6,;3,(/ :&#&<+(6&H5&:,&(2&0+(. #&00"(0;":C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0B?@&:&,(;:+06:$26$:&(&&.0

:&%+,( /:&+6'9@&0&00,"( ?,##)

!

%A#+:,;3 A@,(+M006:+6&/,&0+(. 5"#,2,&0B+6K"6@ (+6,"(+#+(. 5:"<,(2,+##&<&#0B,( +2@,&<,(/

,(;:+06:$26$:&.&<&#"5%&(6;":6@&2"$(6:3M0&2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('

!

%1:"<,.&+( "<&:<,&?";6@&&2"("%,2+(. 0"2,+#2"(.,6,"(06@+6$(.&:5,((&. ,(;:+06:$26$:&

.&<&#"5%&(6"<&:6@&#+06+" 3&+:0,( A@,(+B.:+?,(/ 05&2,+#+66&(6,"( 6" @,/@#,/@6,(/ 6@&

%+O":&#&%&(606@+6@+<&2"(6:,K$6&. 6" 6@,0+2@,&<&%&(6B,.&(6,;3,(/ 6@&2"(6:,K$6,"( ";

,(6&:(+6,"(+#+00,06+(2&+(. .:+?,(/ "$6#&00"(0;:"%6@&0&5:"2&00&0'

%*!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 115: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

!

%8H+%,(&6@&:&#&<+(2&+(. ,%5#,2+6,"(0";6@,05:"/:&006" "6@&:.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0B

5+:6,2$#+:#3 ,( C;:,2+'9@,0?,##,(2#$.&+( +(+#30,0";A@,(+M0+55:"+2@ ,( 6@&,(;:+06:$26$:&

+:&++(. 6@&:"#&5#+3&. K3 5,#"65:"O&260N?@&6@&:":("6,(<"#<,(/ "$60,.&."(":0I,(

A@,(+M0"<&:+##:&;":%5:"2&00'

C-#(+&5 %&#*#(3+3'.(*

&")"" ,&")"!

B(3&.,6)3'.(3. >#**'.(I

],f,+"3$(BE&+(BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63 +(. E,:&26":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

&")"! ,&")#!

!"#&.-#./,.(.&*'(1"'(+ '(3"#/'#-,./'(/&+*3&6)36&#

X+(/ >+,%,(B8\2"(0$#6+(6+(. C00"2,+6&1:";&00":BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63 6"

5:&0&(66@&8\ 06$.3 "( aA@,(+M0,(;:+06:$26$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6+(. A@,(+M0,%5+26"(

C;:,2+M0,(;:+06:$26$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6b

&")#! ,&"))!

9&#1"'(+2*#$%#&'#()#*'(3"#/'#-,./'(/&+*3&6)36&#6*#/6-3. 9/&')+n

["0&5@ '(O+#+B4(06,6$6&;":E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0B\(,<&:0,63 ";Y+,:"K,

&"))! ,&#)&! 1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(*

.)()::0:G#(F*6#7*

B(3&.,6)3'.(XD.7#&3_++*;_#+,./H+*39*'+ ='4'*'.(;NWP;N.((

K.&J*".%IX_.@1"'(+ "+*#(*6&#,*6*3+'(+7'-'35 '('(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3

E'()-6,'(8 /'(+()'(8;0+'(3#(+()#+(,#(4'&.(0#(3+-'0%+)3F

1"+'&XF,%"( F@+:5&B-,:06F&2:&6+:3B8\E&#&/+6,"( ,( S&,O,(/

D+%%.&3#6&X[&((,;&:C.+%0BE&<&#"5%&(6A"$(0&##":B\FC4E

&+))! ,&))&!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'F$ *,(/B=&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&;":-,02+#F2,&(2&B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&

!

C67-') '(+()#

+(,B(/&+*3&6)36&# '(+()#

#'],( [,+K,(BF&(,":=&0&+:2@ -&##"?BE&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@ A&(6&:BF6+6&A"$(2,#D

B(3#&(+3'.(+-,.(.&*2).(3&'763'.(3. 1"'(+2*'(/&+*3&6)36&#;+(,#$%#&'#()#-#+&(#,

+'Y+"@,:" Z,6+("BE,:&26":G&(&:+#B[4ACD1"'(+2*>6*3+'(+7-#Z&7+(+(,D#8'.(+-

B(/&+*3&6)36&#=#4#-.%0#(3<D.-#*./B(3#&(+3'.(+-=.(.&*

&))&! ,&!))! 1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(

K.&J*".%fX_.@1"'(+ "+*+)"'#4#,#//')'#()5 '(3"#,#-'4#&5 ./'(/&+*3&6)36&#

E'()-6,'(8 %-+(('(8;&#*.6&)#+--.)+3'.(+(,%67-')<%&'4+3#%+&3(#&*"'%*F

1"+'&XX+(/ f,+"#,(BE,<,0,"( E,:&26":B=&0&+:2@B41=AA

D+%%.&3#6&X*,2@+&#F6,:(?&,00BS*R

&+))! ,&))&!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'9+(/ *,(BAE=-D!"#).(3&'763'.(./>3+3#<.@(#,#(3#&%&'*#*

#'],R@,/+(/

!

>"(/ Z"(/ \(,<&:0,63

!

H//')'#()5 ./3&+(*%.&3'(/&+*3&6)36&#

'(4#*30#(3'(1"'(+

+'],$ R@,B]&+. 4(;:+06:$26$:&F5&2,+#,06BX":#. S+(QBB(/&+*3&6)36&#=#4#-.%0#(3

+(,8&.@3"+(,3"#K.&-,N+(J

&))&! ,&!))! 1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(

&*!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 116: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

K.&J*".%VX_.@1"'(+ "+*'()&#+*#,3"#'0%+)3.(#).(.0')8&.@3"+(,%.4#&35

&#,6)3'.(./'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3E'()-6,'(8 %&.)6&#0#(3+%%&.+)"#*;-'(J+8#*

'(3. 3"#-.)+-#).(.05 +(,'(4.-4'(8 %..&%#.%-#'(,#)'*'.(<0+J'(8 %&.)#**#*F

1"+'&X[&+(D=+5@+&#A@+5"((,&:&BC;E

D+%%.&3#6&XC.:,+( E+<,0B>&+. ";A@,(++(. C0,+BE-4E

&+))! ,&))&!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&' E+<,. F"K&#B C0,+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q D9=N2* +%%&.+)"#*/.& %&.<%..&

'(/&+*3&6)36&#%&.A#)3*

#'R@+(/ ],(H,$B4(06,6$6&";G&"/:+5@,2F2,&(2&0+(. Y+6$:+#=&0"$:2&0=&0&+:2@B

A@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F2,&(2&0DB(/&+*3&6)36&#+(,%.4#&35

&))&! ,&!))! 1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(

C-#(+&5 *#**'.(+(,.%#(,'*)6**'.(

&*)"" ,&*)+"

D#%.&3*/&.03"#%+&+--#-@.&J*".%*X

H(*6&'(8 *6*3+'(+7'-'35X[&((,;&:C.+%0B\FC4E

9)"'#4'(8 #//')'#()5X*,2@+&#F6,:(?&,00BS*R

B()&#+*'(8 '0%+)3XC.:,+( E+<,0BE-4E

&*)+" ,&())" 1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(

>600+&5 .//'&*3,+52*,'*)6**'.(*

&())" ,&()!" =,2@+:. A+:&3BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

&()!" ,&-)"" ],f,+"3$(BE&+(BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63 +(. E,:&26":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

-&../01T

=2..*),#$( #$8)%',)23,2)0 #$:8)#3% %$-P$3)0%'#$(

#,'P6.%3,*$73*$*6#3 I)*+,"%$->*/0),1 F0-23,#*$

F$KDF+@+:+( C;:,2+0$;;&:0;:"% +@$/&,(;:+06:$26$:&K+2Q#"/B+6K"6@ 6@&(+6,"(+#+(. :&/,"(+#

#&<&#0'S3 .&5:&00,(/ ;,:%5:".$26,<,63 +(. :&6+:.,(/ 5&:2+5,6+/:"?6@ :+6&0B2"(0$%&:0,( C;:,2+5+3

&H2&56,"(+##3 @,/@ 5:,2&0;":,(;:+06:$26$:&0&:<,2&0JK&6?&&( 6?,2&+(. 6&( 6,%&0%":&6@+( ,(

.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0,( "6@&::&/,"(0'C(($+#,(;:+06:$26$:&(&&.0,( C;:,2+@+<&K&&( 2"06&. +6\FE

$+ K,##,"( N";?@,2@ "(&6@,:. ;":%+,(6&(+(2&I'C(($+#05&(.,(/ N."%&06,2+(. ;":&,/(B5$K#,2+(.

5:,<+6&I,0("?+K"$6\FE)! K,##,"( +(. &;;,2,&(23 /+,(0?":6@ \FE&( K,##,"( +:&+<+,#+K#&'9@,0

#&+<&0+( +(($+#;$(.,(/ /+5 ";\FE+& K,##,"( N":!T ";GE1IB%+,(#3 ,( 6@&5"?&:0&26":'

A@,(+,0@&#5,(/ 6" ;,##6@,0/+5'X@,#&6@&:&+:&(" ";;,2,+#.+6++<+,#+K#&"( A@,(+M0&2"("%,22"D

"5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2+BA@,(+M06"6+#0$55":6;":C;:,2+( ,(;:+06:$26$:&DK"6@ 2"(2&00,"(+#+(. ("(D

2"(2&00,"(+#D@+0K&&( &06,%+6&. 6" @+<&"02,##+6&. +6+:"$(. \FE!"" %,##,"( +3&+:,( 6@&&+:#3

#"""0B:,0,(/ 6" \FE! K,##,"( ,( #""( +(. ,( #""- N+22":.,(/ 6" 6@&4(;:+06:$26$:&A"(0":6,$%;":

C;:,2+I'A@,(&0&,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(60@+<&K&&( :&2":.&. ,( +! 2"$(6:,&0+2:"000$KDF+@+:+(

C;:,2+']"+(0;:"% 6@&A@,(+8H4% S+(Q +22"$(6;":6@&<+06%+O":,63 ";A@,(+M0,(;:+06:$26$:&

'*!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 117: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

;,(+(2&;":C;:,2+'

9@&9+(U+(,+DR+%K,+=+,#?+3B2"%5#&6&. ,( &$(*B,0"(&";6@&&+:#,&06+(. #+:/&065:"O&2606@+6

A@,(+@+02"%5#&6&. ,( C;:,2+'=&2"/(,0,(/ 6@+6o$(.&:.&<&#"5&. ,(;:+06:$26$:&,0+( "K06+2#&6"

C;:,2+M0.&<&#"5%&(6+(. ,(6&/:+6,"(oNF@+:%8#DF@&,Q@ C26,"( 1#+( #"&" ,#"&#IB%":&:&2&(6#3

A@,(+M00$55":6;":,(;:+06:$26$:&@+0/"(&%+,(#3 ,(6" 5"?&:N&05&2,+##3 @3.:"5"?&:IB6:+(05":6

N&05&2,+##3 :+,#?+30I+(. 6&#&2"%%$(,2+6,"(0N%+,(#3 &P$,5%&(60$55#3I'X+6&:5:"O&260+66:+266@&

#&+060$55":6'A@,(+,06@$0;"##"?,(/ ,60"?( &H5&:,&(2&K3 ;"2$0,(/ "( +:&+06@+62"(6:,K$6&6"

&H5+(.,(/ 6@&5:".$26,<&5"6&(6,+#";6@&&2"("%3'C66@&0+%&6,%&B2:"00DK":.&:,(;:+06:$26$:&%+3

@+<&+@,/@&:5:,":,63 ;":C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&06@+( ;":A@,(+'

'8AEDECA%&%K&:0+(. "6@&:.&<&#"5%&(6+/&(2,&0+#0" @+<&+#"(/ @,06":3 ";0$55":6,(/ C;:,2+M0

,(;:+06:$26$:&'4( #""( +(. ,( #""-BK,#+6&:+#+(. %$#6,#+6&:+#."(":0.,0K$:0&. +6"6+#";+55:"H,%+6&#3

\FE ) K,##,"( ";";;,2,+#.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&N'ECI6" 0$55":6&2"("%,2,(;:+06:$26$:&

.&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2+N+22":.,(/ 6" '8AE;,/$:&0I'C;:,2+M0,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. ,60:&0&+:2@ +(.

.&<&#"5%&(62+5+2,63 @+<&+#0" K&&( ,(;#$&(2&. K3 6@&."(":2"%%$(,63'G,<&( 6@+6A@,(+,0("?6@&

#+:/&06&H6&:(+#0"$:2&";,(;:+06:$26$:&,(<&06%&(6,( C;:,2+B,6,0(+6$:+#6" +0Q ?@+6#&00"(0A@,(+

2+( .:+?;:"% 6@,0,(6&:(+6,"(+#&H5&:,&(2&B&05&2,+##3 6" +22&#&:+6&&2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63

:&.$26,"( ,( C;:,2+B+(. @"?2"D"5&:+6,"( 2+( K&06:&(/6@&(&.'

*+(3 .,;;,2$#6,00$&00$::"$(. ;":&,/( ,(<"#<&%&(6,( ,(;:+06:$26$:&,( C;:,2+B?@&6@&:;:"%A@,(+":

'8AE2"$(6:,&0'9@&0&,00$&0,(2#$.&),I&(0$:,(/ 0$06+,(+K,#,63B,,I+2@,&<,(/ &;;,2,&(23B+(. ,,,I

,(2:&+0,(/ ,%5+26"( &2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"('9:+(05+:&(23 ,0+("6@&:.,;;,2$#6,00$&

K$6@+0K&&( :&2&,<,(/ ,(2:&+0,(/ +66&(6,"( :&2&(6#3 N0$2@ +0,( 6@&GD#" 9":"(6" F$%%,6

E&2#+:+6,"(ILE+3 # ";6@,0&<&(6?,##;+2,#,6+6&+.,02$00,"( +K"$6@"?A@,(++(. "6@&:.&<&#"5%&(6

+/&(2,&02+( +..:&006@&0&,00$&06" 0$55":6C;:,2+M0.&<&#"5%&(6'9@&0&00,"( ?,##)

!

%=&<,&?6@&5"#,2,&0+(. 06:+6&/,&0A@,(+@+0.&<&#"5&. 6" 0$55":6C;:,2+M0.&<&#"5%&(6,(

6@&;,&#. ";,(;:+06:$26$:&'

!

%=&<,&?6@&,%5+26";.&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&5"#,2,&0";"6@&:.&<&#"5%&(6+/&(2,&0"(

C;:,2+M0.&<&#"5%&(6,( 6@&;,&#. ";,(;:+06:$26$:&'

!

%>,/@#,/@66@&,%5+260";6@"0&,(6&:<&(6,"(0"( &2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( ,(

C;:,2+'

!

%8H5#":&6@&%".+#,6,&0+(. &H5&26&. K&(&;,60";06:&(/6@&(,(/ 6:,#+6&:+#2"D"5&:+6,"( K&6?&&(

A@,(+BECA%&%K&:0+(. C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0,( 6@&;,&#. ";,(;:+06:$26$:&'

W+*3#&./1#&#0.('#*X_#K#(%'(8;='&#)3.&;9/&')+(>36,'#*;1"'(#*#9)+,#05 ./>.)'+->)'#()#*

C-#(+&5 %&#*#(3+3'.(*

$)"" ,$)#"

j#5(.3#%&#*#(3+3'.(

!

9,,&#**'(8 9/&')+2*'(/&+*3&6)36&#(##,*Xj#5 )"+--#(8#*;

J#5 ).(3&'763'.(*

A+##,H6&Z+%K+(.+B1:,(2,5+#4(;:+06:$26$:&F5&2,+#,06BF&2:&6+:,+6";6@&4(;:+06:$26$:&

A"(0":6,$%;":C;:,2+BC;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q

$)#" ,$))"

j#5(.3#%&#*#(3+3'.(X1"'(+2**6%%.&3/.&'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3'(9/&')+X

H(*6&'(8 *6*3+'(+7'-'35;+)"'#4'(8 #//')'#()5 +(,'()&#+*'(8 '0%+)3

X+(/ [,+(3&BA@,&;82"("%,06BA@,(+8f4*S+(Q

(*!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 118: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

$))" ,$)!"

1"'(#*#/'(+()#./.4#&*#+*'(/&+*3&6)36&#XC.-')'#*;+%%&.+)"#*+(,'(*3&60#(3*

E&K":+@ S:+$6,/+%B1:";&00":BC%&:,2+( \(,<&:0,63

$)!" ,&")""

!"##4.-63'.(./=91W#07#&*g*6%%.&3/.&'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3XC.-')'#*;

+%%&.+)"#*+(,'(*3&60#(3*

[$&:/&( Z&66(&:B4(;:+06:$26$:&1"#,23 C.<,0":BEGE&<&#"5%&(6B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

&")""

!

&&)"" 1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(*

&&)&!

!

&#)"" =#7&'#/'(8*+(,).00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(*).(3'(6#,

&&)&! ,&&)#!

##,7+)J/&.03"#?-.7+-=#4#-.%0#(3 #+&('(8 a#3@.&J1.(*6-3+3'.(

8.?+:. S:"?(BE,:&26":BC;:,2+( A&(6&:;":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(BG@+(+

&&)#! ,&&)+!

##,7+)J/&.0/'#-,4'*'3*3. =LDL1.(8. +(,P+07'+

>+(0>"#%1&6&:0&(B+(. F+((&*+:0B8\2"(0$#6+(60

&&)+!

!

&#)"" 1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(*

.)()::0:G#(F*6#7*

B(3&.,6)3'.(X '9(*"+(;='&#)3.&;B(*3'363#./9/&.<9*'+(>36,'#*;C#J'(8 Z('4#&*'35

K.&J*".% IX H(*6&'(8 *6*3+'(+7'-'35 E'()-6,'(8 /'(+()'(8; 0+'(3#(+()# +(,

#(4'&.(0#(3+-'0%+)3F

1"+'&XY+"@,:" Z,6+("BE,:&26":G&(&:+#B[4AC

D+%%.&3#6&XY,2Q A"06&##"B8\

&+)&! ,&+))!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'>&#%$6C02@&BE,:&26":B4(06,6$6&;":C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B]&,5U,/ \(,<&:0,63 DN6'-,'(8

6%\*./3] '(/&+*3&6)36&#

#'A@&( A@$+(B\(,<&:0,63 ";*&#K"$:(&B8\2"(0$#6+(6

!

>6*3+'(+7'-'35 ./#$3#&(+--5<

*6%%.&3#,'(/&+*3&6)36&#'(9/&')+

+'X+(/ ]$"BAC498AB*'-A'* DB(/&+*3&6)36&#+*+('(3#8&+3#%+&3./1"'(+<

9/&')+ =#4#-.%0#(31..%#&+3'.(+(,3"#(#@-5 #*3+7-'*"#,1"'(+<9/&')+ D#*#+&)"

1#(3#&

&+))! ,&!)&! 1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(

K.&J*".%fX9)"'#4'(8 #//')'#()5 E'()-6,'(8 %-+(('(8;&#*.6&)#+--.)+3'.(*+(,

%67-')<%&'4+3#%+&3(#&*"'%*F

1"+'&X9+.+0@,F$U$Q,B[4AC

D+%%.&3#6&X9":,9<&,6BA"(;&.&:+6,"( ";Y":?&/,+( 8(6&:5:,0&

)*!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 119: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&+)&! ,&+))!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'f$&>"(/BE,:&26":BAC498AB*'-A'*

!"#/#+36&#*./1"'(+2*'(/&+*3&6)36&#'(4#*30#(3*'(9/&')+

#'*+:63( E+<,&0BE,:&26":BA@,(+DC;:,2+Y&6?":QBG":."( 4(06,6$6&";S$0,(&00

F2,&(2&B\(,<&:0,63 ";1:&6":,+BF"$6@ C;:,2+D1"'(#*#/.&#'8('(4#*30#(3'(9/&')+(

'(/&+*3&6)36&#

+''Q&3 ]' '(3&O&Q?&B*+(+/,(/ E,:&26":BA&(6&:;":F$06+,(+K#&G"<&:(+(2&;

?.4#&(+()#'**6#*+(,'(/&+*3&6)36&#,#4#-.%0#(3'(9/&')+

&+))! ,&!)&! 1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(

K.&J*".% VX B()&#+*'(8 '0%+)3.( #).(.0') 8&.@3" +(, %.4#&35 &#,6)3'.(

E'()-6,'(8 %&.)6&#0#(3+%%&.+)"#*;-'(J+8#*'(3. 3"#-.)+-#).(.05 +(,'(4.-4'(8

%..&%#.%-#'(,#)'*'.(0+J'(8 %&.)#**#*F

1"+'&X*+" f,+"O,(/BAC498A

D+%%.&3#6&XS,##Y,2"#B'8AE

&+)&! ,&+))!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'>,6"0@,F@"O,B[4ACB-":%&:!,2&A@+,:";1'!Y89

?6'-,'(8 C&'()'%-#*/.&6*'(8 B(/&+*3&6)36&#3. &#,6)#%.4#&35

#'F+((&*+:0BA&(6&:;":A@,(+F6$.,&0<1"'(+2*#(8+8#0#(3+(,'3*'0%+)3.(

9/&')+2*8&.@3"+(,%.4#&35 &#,6)3'.(

+'[&+( A#+$.&*+0?+(+B=&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&";[4AC

&+))! ,&!)&! 1.00#(3*+(,,'*)6**'.(

C-#(+&5 >#**'.(+(,.%#(,'*)6**'.(

&!)+" ,&*)""

D#%.&3*/&.03"#%+&+--#-@.&J*".%*X

H(*6&'(8 *6*3+'(+7'-'35XY,2Q A"06&##"B8\

9)"'#4'(8 #//')'#()5X9":,9<&,6BA"(;&.&:+6,"( ";Y":?&/,+( 8(6&:5:,0&

B()&#+*'(8 '0%+)3XS,##Y,2"#B'8AE

>600+&5 ./3"##4#(3

&()"" ,&()&" =,2@+:. A+:&3BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

&()&" ,&()#" ],f,+"3$(BE&+(BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63 +(. E,:&26":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

1-.*'(8 1#&#0.(5

1"+'&XC#3#&1&+'8<W)m6+',#;_#+,./Z('3;H6&.%#+(1.00'**'.(;N&6**#-*

&()+" ,&-)""

1-.*'(8 &#0+&J*

R@+(/ ]&,BE,:&26":DG&(&:+#";4(6&:(+6,"(+#C;;+,:0B]G'1

["( ]"%"3BE,:&26":;":E&<&#"5%&(6A"D"5&:+6,"(B'8AE

*!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 120: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

TTTOY.<2'T8T.<V'D >TD'

[$@+(+CC]9' C2+.&%,29:+,(&&B8%K+003 ";-,(#+(.

[&((,;&:CEC*F E&<&#"5%&(6A"$(0&##":\FC4EDA@,(+

CQ"(/K"?+SLC*CECF\Y E"26":BS&(0"( 4.+@"0+\(,<&:0,63BS&(,( A,63BY,/&:,+BY,/&:,+

>&#%$6CFA>8 *+(+/,(/ E,:&26":B4(06,6$6&";C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B]&,5U,/ \(,<&:0,63

SC4A@&(/3$ E,<,0,"( A@,&;BA@,(+4(6&:(+6,"(+#A&(6:&;":82"("%,2+(. 9&2@(,2+#8H2@+(/&B

*'-A'*

X"#;@+:. S8>=8YF A"$(0&##":B>&+. E&5+:6%&(6";82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6B8%K+003

";6@&-&.&:+#=&5$K#,2";G&:%+(3

E&K":+@ S=C\94GC* 1:";&00":B4(6&:(+6,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6BC%&:,2+( \(,<&:0,63B\FC

8.?+:. S='XY E,:&26":B1"#,23 C.<,0":3 F&:<,2&0BC;:,2+( A&(6&:;":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(B

G@+(+

="0&K$. S\=\Z\ 1"#,23 C.<,0&:BC;:,2+( A&(6&:;":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( NG@+(+I

=,2@+:. AC=8_ A"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

A+AC==4YG9'Y *,(,06&:B8%K+003 ";6@&=&5$K#,2";G$,(&+DS,00+$

[&+(D=+5@+&#A>C1'YY48=8 82"("%,06BC0,+E&5+:6%&(6BC-EB1+:,0

A>8YA@$+( C00,06+(61:";&00":B9@&\(,<&:0,63 ";*&#K"$:(&

A>8YF@$@"(/ E,06,(/$,0@&. 1:";&00":BA4CAEB\(,<&:0,63 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#S$0,(&00h82"("%,20

-+(6$ A>8=\ =&0&+:2@ E,:&26":B9@&Y":.,2C;:,2+4(06,6$6&B86@,"5,+

Y,2@"#+0A'F98]]' -,:06A"$(0&##":B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

1&6&:A=C4GD*Ai\C4E8 >&+. ";\(,6BEGE&<&#"5%&(6B=&#+6,"(0?,6@ ,(6&:(+6,"(+#":/+(,0+6,"(0+(. ("(

8\%&%K&:06+6&0B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

C.:,+( EC!4F >&+.BY":6@ +(. 8+06C0,+BE-4E

*+:63( [LEC!48F E,:&26":BA@,(+DC;:,2+Y&6?":QBG":."( 4(06,6$6&";S$0,(&00F2,&(2&B\(,<&:0,63 ";

1:&6":,+

_<&0E8[CAi\48=E8='F

!

8 >&+. ";F&2:&6+:,+6B8\DC;:,2+4(;:+06:$26$:&9:$06-$(.B8$:"5&+( 4(<&06%&(6S+(Q

E8YG>$,@$, =&0&+:2@ C00,06+(6BA4CAEB\(,<&:0,63 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#S$0,(&00h82"("%,20

E"%,(,P$&E8F=\8]]8 C00,06+(6E,:&26":BF6:+6&/3B1"#,23 +(. =&<,&?E&5+:6%&(6B4*-

F,;,Q,#&E'YGC -,:06F&2:&6+:3B8%K+003 ";6@&=&5$K#,2";R,%K+K?&

G\'1&, E&5$63DE&+(BA"##&/&";82"("%,20+(. *+(+/&%&(6BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

G\'f,+"S&, E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(06,6$6&";A"%5:&@&(0,<&9:+(05":6+6,"(BYE=A

="K&:6>CCF >&+. ";8+06C0,+E,<,0,"(B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6BG&:%+(3

>CYi,(/ C00"2,+6&1:";&00":BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

>CY_+( C00"2,+6&=&0&+:2@&:BE&5+:6%&(6";C0,+DC;:,2+=&0&+:2@BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";

4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"(B*'-A'*

>8X&(5,(/ E,:&26":";6@&E,<,0"( ";C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B4(06,6$6&";X&06C0,+( +(. C;:,2+(

F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0BA@,(+

>8f,+"O$( E&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+

G"&:,#. >8GG8]\YE F&(,":A#,%+6&A@+(/&C.<,0":B\(,6&. Y+6,"(0E&<&#"5%&(61:"/:+%

>\CYGA@&(/?&, E&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+

_$(DG,#[8'YG =&0,.&(6=&5:&0&(6+6,<&BZ":&+4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"( C/&(23NZ'4ACI

[4f, 1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63 >&+#6@ F2,&(2&A&(6&:

!!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 121: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

E+<,. ]LSLZC*C=C 8#&26:,2+#8(/,(&&:B82"("%,2A"%%$(,63 ";X&06C;:,2+( F6+6&0A"%%,00,"(BF,&::+

]&"(&

A+##,H6&ZC*SCYEC 1:,(2,5+#4(;:+06:$26$:&F5&2,+#,06B4(;:+06:$26$:&A"(0":6,$%;":C;:,2+B=?+(.+

ZCYGS,(/O,+( E,<,0,"( A@,&;BE&5+:6%&(6";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2C;;+,:0B*'-A'*

1@,##,5 ZC=1 =&/,"(+#A"":.,(+6":B8+06C0,+h1+2,;,2BX":#. S+(Q 4(06,6$6&';;,2&,( A@,(+

[$&:/&( Z899Y8= >&+. ";82"("%,2.&<&#"5%&(6B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

X,##,+%Z4YGF*4]] F&(,":C.<,0":6" C-=!1B9@&X":#. S+(Q

Y+"@,:" Z49CY' E,:&26":DG&(&:+#B8+06+(. A&(6:+#C0,++(. 6@&A+$2+0$0E&5+:6%&(6B[4AC

>+2@,%*LZ'\*C=8 A@+,:5&:0"(BF$K F+@+:+( C;:,2+( 9:+(05":61"#,23B*+#,

=+0%$0CK,#./++:. Z=4F98YF8Y -,:06F&2:&6+:3B="3+#E+(,0@ 8%K+003 S&,O,(/

*,2@+&#]C4=E F&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306B1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( hG"?6@ E,<,0,"(B'8AE

A@:,06"5@ ]CYG -,:06F&2:&6+:3B8%K+003 ";F?,6U&:#+(.

F+%D@3$(/ ]88 S&,O,(/ =&5:&0&(6+6,<&';;,2&B8H5":6D4%5":6S+(Q ";Z'=8C

]4C(0@+( 1:";&00":BE,:&26":B4(06,6$6&";C;:"DC0,+( F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

]4],(3, 1:"/+%%&';;,2&:B=&0&+:2@ E,<,0,"(B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,(

A@,(+

]4="(/ =&0&+:2@ -&##"?BA@,(+4(06,6$6&0";A"(6&%5":+:3 4(6&:(+6,"(+#=&#+6,"(0

]4X&(6+" C00,06+(6=&0&+:2@&:BA@,(+4(06,6$6&0";A"(6&%5":+:3 4(6&:(+6,"(+#=&#+6,"(0

]4f,+"3$( E&+(BA"##&/&";>$%+(,6,&0+(. E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

]4R@,/+(/ C00,06+(61:";&00":B\(,<&:0,63 ";>"(/ Z"(/

]4Y[,+K,( F&(,":=&0&+:2@ -&##"?BE&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@ A&(6&:BF6+6&A"$(2,#

]4\>+(0"(/ E&5$63 E,:&26":BA@,(+8(6&:5:,0&A"(;&.&:+6,"(

]4\_"$;+ !,2&1:&0,.&(6BA@,(+4(06,6$6&";4(6&:(+6,"(+#F6$.,&0

]4\f,+(/ F&(,":1:"/:+%';;,2&:BE&5+:6%&(6";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2C;;+,:0B

*'-A'*

]4\R@, ]&+. 4(;:+06:$26$:&F5&2,+#,06BX":#. S+(Q

["( ]'*'_ E,:&26":BE&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"( E,:&26":+6&B'8AE

]\-&(/ E,<,0,"( A@,&;BE&5+:6%&(6";C,. 6" -":&,/( A"$(6:,&0B*'-A'*

]\f,( E&5$63 E,:&26":B4(06,6$6&;":G#"K+#>&+#6@B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

]\'F+((& 8\2"(0$#6+(6

]\'_$ -,:06F&2:&6+:3BE&5+:6%&(6";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2C;;+,:0B*'-A'*

*CF@,Q$( 8.,6":D,(DA@,&;BC;:,2+*+/+U,(&

F+((&*C=F 1:"O&26*+(+/&:VA"(0$#6+(6B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

*C'f,+"O,(/ =&0&+:2@&:BE&56L";-":&,/( C,.BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(.

82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( NAC498AIB*,(,06:3 ";A"%%&:2&BA@,(+

*+6,#.+F?,##+*CF\ZC -,:06F&2:&6+:3B8%K+003 ";6@&\(,6&. =&5$K#,2";9+(U+(,+

[&+(DA#+$.&EL*CFXCYC 1:";&00":BZ3"6" \(,<&:0,63 h[4AC=&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&BA"(/"

*\G&(/3$+( C00,06+(6=&0&+:2@&:BA@,(+4(06,6$6&";4(6&:(+6,"(+#F6$.,&0

*,2@&#&*'=CYC C:2@,6&26B8%K+003 ";46+#3D.&<&#"5%&(62""5&:+6,"( ";;,2&

[$06,( AL*\SCYGC E,:&26":B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&+(. Y+6,"(+#1#+((,(/BR+%K,+

G,#K&:6*X8=8=\**C894 F&(,":9:+(05":682"("%,06BA'*8FCF&2:&6+:,+6BZ&(3+

1+$#" [":/&1&:&,:+YCFA4*8Y9' *,(,06&:A"$(0&##":B8%K+003 ";1":6$/+#,( S&,O,(/

X,##,+%Y4A'] >&+. ";1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( +(. G:"?6@ E,<,0,"(B'8AE

="/&:Y'=E F&(,":C.<,0":BC;:,2+( E&5+:6%&(6B4*-

X,#;:&. CK"Q,'*C=4 1:,(2,5+#82"("%,06B*,(,06:3 ";F6+6&;":1#+((,(/BY+6,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6+(. !,0,"(

#"+"BZ&(3+

"!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 122: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

["0&5@ 'L'Y[C]C =&0&+:2@ -&##"?B4(06,6$6&;":E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0B\(,<&:0,63 ";Y+,:"K,BZ&(3+

'Q&3 ]L'Y_8[8ZX8 *+(+/,(/ E,:&26":BA&(6&:;":F$06+,(+K#&G"<&:(+(2&B86@,"5,+

E"%,(,P$&18==8C\ C.<,0":BE&<&#"5%&(6C/&(23 ";-:+(2&

>+(0>"#%1898=F8Y 1:"O&26*+(+/&:VA"(0$#6+(6B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

9"%=C--8=9_ !,0,6,(/ =&0&+:2@ -&##"?BF2@""#";4(6&:(+6,"(+#F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

G+(&0@ =CFCGC* F&(,":1:,<+6&F&26":F5&2,+#,06B9@&X":#. S+(Q

F6&<&( ["@( FCS8_ 1"#,23 C.<,0&:B\(,6&. Y+6,"(0E&<&#"5%&(61:"/:+%

F>CYGf,+"%,(/ E&5$63 E,:&26":BA@,(+8(6&:5:,0&A"(;&.&:+6,"(

F,%"( F>C=18 -,:06F&2:&6+:3B1"#,6,2+#E&#&/+6,"( ";6@&8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"( 6" A@,(+

>,6"0@,F>'[4 A@,&;=&5:&0&(6+6,<&B-:+(2&';;,2&B[+5+( 4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"( C/&(23

E"(/+F4-4Z4]8 8%K+003 ";6@&=&5$K#,2";R,%K+K?&

A+:#+FY_E8= F&2"(. F&2:&6+:3B82"("%,2F&26,"(B\F8%K+003 S&,O,(/

E+<,. F2"66F'S8] 1:,(2,5+#=&0$#60*+(+/&%&(6F5&2,+#,06BC0,+( E&<&#"5%&(6S+(Q

*,2@+&#F94=YX84FF C.<,0":B8+06C0,+F&26,"(B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6BG&:%+(3

F\*,(/ !,2&5:&0,.&(6B=&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&;":-,02+#F2,&(2&B*,(,06:3 ";-,(+(2&

9+.+0@,F\R\Z4 C00,06+(6E,:&26":BE&<&#"5%&(61+:6(&:0@,5 E,<,0,"(B'5&:+6,"(0F6:+6&/3

E&5+:6%&(6B[+5+( 4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"( C/&(23

C.+%FXC4 82"("%,2+(. 1:".$26,<&F&26":NCCF=!I;":4:,(/+B=&/,"(+#A"%%,00,"(&:0';;,2&

C/:,2C.<,0&:+(. C00,06+(6C.%,(,06:+6,<&F&2:&6+:3

9CYG*,( E&5$63 F&2:&6+:3 G&(&:+#BA@,(+E&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@ -"$(.+6,"(

["(+09CZ'E['\ 8H5&:6B8AACFB82"("%,2A"%%$(,63 ";A&(6:+#C;:,2+( F6+6&0A"%%,00,"(WB

A+%&:""(

9":,Y&66&#@":069!849 E,:&26":BF&2:&6+:,+6;":1:,<+6&F&26":E&<&#"5%&(6BA"(;&.&:+6,"( ";Y":?&/,+(

8(6&:5:,0&

XCYGA@&(3+( C00"2,+6&=&0&+:2@&:BE&5+:6%&(6";E&<&#"5%&(6C00,06+(2&BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";

4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"(B*'-A'*

XCYG>+,%,( C00"2,+6&1:";&00":BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

XCYG[,+(3& A@,&;82"("%,06B9@&8H5":6D,%5":6S+(Q ";A@,(+

XCYG[,(H,+ E&5$63 E,:&26":BA&(6&:;":A@,(&0&C/:,2$#6$:+#1"#,23BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";

F2,&(2&0

XCYG]$" E&5$63 E,:&26":BA@,(+DC;:,2+=&0&+:2@ A&(6&:BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#

9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"(B*'-A'*

XCYGF$H,+ E"26":BA&(6&:;":>$%+( +(. 82"("%,2E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

XCYGf,+"#,( E,<,0,"( A@,&;B=&0&+:2@ E,<,0,"(B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+

XCYGf,O$( 9@,:. F&2:&6+:3B*,(,06:3 ";-":&,/( C;;+,:0

XCYG_+( A"D":.,(+6":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

X'=$,., C%K+00+.":B*,(,06:3 ";-":&,/( C;;+,:0

X\[,( C00"2,+6&1:";&00":BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

f4Y_, C00"2,+6&1:";&00":BF2@""#";C/:,2$#6$:+#82"("%,20+(. =$:+#E&<&#"5%&(6B

=&(%,( \(,<&:0,63 ";A@,(+

f\8>"(/ E,:&26":BE&56";-":&,/( C,.BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2

A""5&:+6,"( NAC498AIB*,(,06:3 ";A"%%&:2&BA@,(+

_CYGi,$#,( 1:";&00":BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

R8YGC,5,(/ C00,06+(6=&0&+:2@&:BA@,(+4(06,6$6&";4(6&:(+6,"(+#F6$.,&0

R>CYG>+,0&( 1:";&00":BA4CAEB\(,<&:0,63 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#S$0,(&00h82"("%,20

#!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 123: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

R>CYG]&, E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#C;;+,:0BF6+6&A"$(2,#]&+.,(/ G:"$5 ';;,2&";1"<&:63

C##&<,+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6";A@,(+

R>CYG],(H,$ 1:";&00":BA&(6&:;":A@,(&0&C/:,6$#6$:+#1"#,23BACF

R>CYG_+(K,(/ ]&26$:&:B90,(/@$+\(,<&:0,63BF2@""#";1$K#,25"#,23 +(. *+(+/&%&(6

R>8YGX&(Q+, E&5$63 E,:&26":BF6+6&A"$(2,#]&+.,(/ G:"$5 ';;,2&";1"<&:63 C##&<,+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6N]G'1IBA@,(+

R>'\X&,@"(/ =&0&+:2@ C00,06+(6BA4CAEB\(,<&:0,63 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#S$0,(&00h82"("%,20

*+:,+((&R4FF 8%K+003 ";-:+(2&BS&,O,(/

$!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 124: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

<VV!W! TZ

!$,0(7(&*0 C0/0:#7%0$,)$-!"#$#%&" '()$*+#(%),&#$Q

8(0),&$; ,60 !$)O:&$; !$/&(#$%0$,

<--&*<O)O)9!,6&#7&)9IbEIU I0O(3)(1 fSII

T)L<H!VC<

J)"F;(#3$-)$-#OK0",&/0*

9" ;+2,#,6+6&6@&0@+:,(/ ";&H5&:,&(2&0+(. 5:"%"6&#&+:(,(/ "( /:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B6@&

A@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5 ?+0&06+K#,0@&. K3 6@&4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6:&,( A@,(+

N41=AAI+(. 6@&':/+(,0+6,"( ;":82"("%,2A"D"5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6M0E&<&#"5%&(6C00,06+(2&

A"%%,66&&N'8AEDECAIB,( [+($+:3 #""$'9@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ,0;"2$0,(/ ,60?":Q "( 6?" 6@&%&0)

!

%A@,(+M0&H5&:,&(2&";&2"("%,2/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"(B,(2#$.,(/ 6@&2"(6:,K$6,"( ";

,(6&:(+6,"(+#+00,06+(2&B+(. ,60:&#&<+(2&;":"6@&:.&<&#"5,(/ 2"$(6:,&0B5+:6,2$#+:#3 ,( C;:,2+'

!

%A@,(+M0&2"("%,22"D"5&:+6,"( ?,6@ C;:,2++(. 6@&#&00"(06@+6A@,(++(. ECA*&%K&:02+( 0@+:&

?,6@ &+2@ "6@&:6" ,(2:&+0&6@&2"##&26,<&,%5+26";;":&,/( +,. ( :&.$2,(/ 5"<&:63 ,( C;:,2+'

9@&0&6@&%&0+:&K&,(/ +..:&00&. .$:,(/ +0&:,&0";&<,.&(2&DK+0&. 5"#,23 .,+#"/$&&<&(60B?@,2@

&(+K#&0+#+:/&:($%K&:";06+Q&@"#.&:06" K&,(<"#<&. ,( 6@&F6$.3 G:"$5M0+26,<,6,&0'=&;#&26,(/ 6@&

(&&.0,( %+(3 C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&06".+3B6@&F6$.3 G:"$5 ":/+(,0&. 6@:&&&<&(60.$:,(/ #""$D#"&" "(

6"5,20?@,2@ ,(;#$&(2&K"6@ 6@&5+2&";&2"("%,2/:"?6@ +0?&##+06@&&H6&(66" ?@,2@ &2"("%,2

/:"?6@ 2"(6:,K$6&06" :&.$2,(/ 5"<&:63)

!

%E&<&#"5%&(65+:6(&:0@,50'

!

%C/:,2$#6$:&B;"". 0&2$:,63 +(. :$:+#.&<&#"5%&(6'

!

%4(;:+06:$26$:&'

9@&F6$.3 G:"$5M0;,:06&<&(6"( aE&<&#"5%&(61+:6(&:0@,50;":G:"?6@ +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(b6""Q

5#+2&,( S&,O,(/BA@,(+,( '26"K&:#""$'9@&0&2"(. &<&(6"( oC/:,2$#6$:&B-"". F&2$:,63 +(. =$:+#

E&<&#"5%&(6;":G:"?6@ +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(o6""Q 5#+2&,( S+%+Q"B*+#,,( C5:,##"&"'9@&

6@,:. &<&(6"( a4(;:+06:$26$:&b6""Q 5#+2&,( S&,O,(/BA@,(+,( F&56&%K&:#"&"'

9@,0;"$:6@ &<&(6?,##;"2$0"( 6@&&(+K#,(/ &(<,:"(%&(6;":&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6'*":&

05&2,;,2+##3B6@&&<&(6?,##)

!

%>,/@#,/@66@&0,/(,;,2+(6:"#&6@+6&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6B6:+.&+(. ,(<&06%&(65#+3 ,( 6@&

2:&+6,"( ";#"2+#B:&/,"(+#+(. /#"K+#<+#$&2@+,(0+(. 6@&.3(+%,2,%5+26"( &2"("%,2

/:"?6@B&%5#"3%&(6+(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( ,( A@,(++(. C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0'

!

%*+5 "$66@&2"$:0&B06:+6&/,&0B+2@,&<&%&(60+(. 2@+##&(/&0";A@,(++(. C;:,2+( 2"$(6:,&0

,( 2:&+6,(/ &(+K#,(/ &(<,:"(%&(60;":&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6+(. &H5#":&6@&:&#&<+(2&+(.

,%5#,2+6,"(0";6@&#&00"(0;:"%&+2@'

9@&%+,( ;,(.,(/0+(. &%&:/,(/ #&00"(0;:"%6@&F6$.3 G:"$5M00&:,&0";&<&(60?,##K&5:&0&(6&. +(.

.,02$00&. +6+5"#,23 03%5"0,$%,( S&,O,(/ 5#+((&. ;":C5:,##"&&'

%!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 125: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

.(#;()%%0

G%#('(8 1#&#0.(5

1"+'&)["( ]"%"3BE,:&26":;":E&<&#"5%&(6A"D"5&:+6,"(B'8AE

"-)+" ,"$)""

K#-).0'(8 D#0+&J*

[&+( 1,(/BA@+,:%+(BA"%%,00,"( ";6@&C;:,2+( \(,"(

],A@$(/$+(/BE,:&26":DG&(&:+#BE&5+:6%&(6";4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"( +(. F"2,+#

*"K,#,U+6,"(B9@&F6+6&A"$(2,#]&+.,(/ G:"$5 ';;,2&";1"<&:63 C##&<,+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6N]G'1I

*,2@+&#S+66#&B\(,6&. F6+6&0C%K+00+.":6" 6@&C;:,2+( \(,"(

"$)"" ,"$))"

j#5(.3#>%##)"#*X1"'(#*#+(, 9/&')+( C#&*%#)3'4#*.( 3"#H(4'&.(0#(3/.&

H(3#&%&'*#=#4#-.%0#(3X9(.4#&4'#@

&'8(+K#,(/ 8(<,:"(%&(6;":8(6&:5:,0&0E&<&#"5%&(6,( A@,(+)Z&3 06:+6&/,&0+(.

5"#,2&0"<&:#+06+" 3&+:0)f$ >$,BE,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"(

A&(6:&,( A@,(+N41=AAI

#'A:&+6,(/ +( 8(+K#,(/ 8(<,:"(%&(6;":8(6&:5:,0&E&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2+)Z&3

2@+##&(/&0,( C;:,2+( :&/,"()9+.&00&>+,#&BF6+6&*,(,06&:";4(.$06:3B86@,"5,+

i$&06,"(0+(. C(0?&:0

-&../01O

!)0%,#$( +0%4,",")*2(",)%$'8*)6#$( .**))2)%403*$*6#0'A

.294#3 .*4#3#0'%$-.)#/%,0 #$#,#%,#/0 #$!"#$% %$-:8)#3%

A@,(+M006&+.,#3 @,/@ &2"("%,2/:"?6@ @+0K&&( #+:/&#3 .$&6" :+5,. &H5+(0,"( ";6@&&(6&:5:,0&

&2"("%3B?@,2@ %+.&A@,(+6@&?":#.M05:".$26,"( 5#+(6'=+5,. &(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6B06,%$#+6&.

K3 02@&%&00$2@ +06@&9"?(0@,5 +(. !,##+/&8(6&:5:,0&0N9!8I+(. 6@&F5&2,+#82"("%,2R"(&0

NF8R0I@+0+66:+26&. "<&:#"" %,##,"( 5&+0+(60"$6";;+:%,(/'9@,0#+K"$:6:+(0;":%+6,"( %+.&+

/:&+62"(6:,K$6,"( 6" A@,(+M05"<&:63 :&.$26,"( :&2":.'-+<"$:+K#&2"(.,6,"(02:&+6&. K3 +( &(+K#,(/

&(<,:"(%&(6K"6@ ,( 6&:%0";a@+:.?+:&bN&'/',(;:+06:$26$:&I+(. a0";6?+:&bN&'/'5"#,2,&0+(.

,(06,6$6,"(0I?&:&6@&K+0,0;":+##Q,(.0";:$:+#+(. $:K+( &(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6'46,06@&:&;":&

(+6$:+#6" +0Q @"? 6@,0?+0."(&'X@+6Q,(.0";+26,"(0+(. %&+0$:&02:&+6&. 6@,0&(+K#,(/

&(<,:"(%&(6;":&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6"<&:#+06+" 3&+:0W

C2:"006@&C;:,2+( 2"(6,(&(6B%+(3 2"$(6:,&0@+<&&(6&:&. +5"0,6,<&/:"?6@ 06+/&"<&:#+06&" 3&+:0'

9@&+22&#&:+6,"( ";&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6B&05&2,+##3 5:,<+6&&(6&:5:,0&@+0K&&( +Q&3 06:+6&/3 6"

5:"%"6&/:"?6@ +(. 5"<&:63 :&.$26,"( ,( C;:,2+'C;6&:6?" #"06.&2+.&0B%+O":,%5:"<&%&(60@+<&

K&&( %+.&,( &2"("%,2/"<&:(+(2&+(. 2"(;#,26:&0"#$6,"( ,( +:+(/&";2"$(6:,&0B+(. 5:"/:&00,0+#0"

K&,(/ %+.&"( @$%+( .&<&#"5%&(6B+(. 6@&*,##&((,$% E&<&#"5%&(6G"+#0:&%+,( +66+,(+K#&,;

@$%+( 2+5,6+#,(<&06%&(60+(. 5"#,2,&0:&2&,<&0$06+,(&. &;;":6'A"(6,($,(/ &;;":60+:&(&&.&. 6" Q&&5

$5 6@,05:"/:&00+(. +..:&00:&%+,(,(/ 5:"K#&%+:&+0+0+K+0,0;":C;:,2+M02+62@D$5 5:"2&00'

A@,(+,0("?+@,/@#3 <,0,K#&&2"("%,2+26":,( C;:,2+'9:+.&K&6?&&( 6@&6?" :&/,"(0,0:&+2@,(/

\FE&"" K,##,"(J+22$%$#+6&. ,(<&06%&(6K3 A@,(&0&;,:%0,0?&##"<&:\FE&# K,##,"( +(. A@,(+@+0

&!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 126: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

";;&:&. +66:+26,<&B+(. 0"%&6,%&0P$,6&#+:/&B6,&. 5+2Q+/&0";#"+(06" ;,(+(2&6:+.&B,(<&06%&(6+(.

.&<&#"5%&(6'*+O":(&?6+:/&60?&:&+(("$(2&. +66@&:&2&(6)6@ -'ACA'A@,(+,0&(/+/&. ,( %+(3

0&26":0+(. ,60,(;#$&(2&"( .&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2+,0,(2:&+0,(/'C;:,2+2#&+:#3 ?&#2"%&0A@,(++0+

(&?+(. ,%5":6+(65+:6(&:B&05&2,+##3 ?@&( ,62"%&06" ,(;:+06:$26$:&+(. ,(<&06%&(60@&#5,(/ 6" K$,#.

#"(/&:D6&:%/:"?6@'4(<&06%&(60,( 6:+.&2+5+2,63 +(. A@,(+M0"5&(,(/ ";,60%+:Q&66" /"".0+(.

0&:<,2&0;:"%C;:,2++:&+#0" <&:3 ,%5":6+(6'

9@&:&;":&B,6,0";5+:6,2$#+:,(6&:&066" $(.&:06+(. ?@+66@&2:&+6,"( ";+( &(+K#,(/ &(<,:"(%&(6

,(<"#<&0,( A@,(++(. ,( C;:,2+B@"?&(+K#,(/ 5"#,2,&0+22&#&:+6&5:,<+6&&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6+(.

.,:&26;":&,/( ,(<&06%&(6+(. @"?2+5+2,6,&0+:&2:&+6&. 6@"$/@ 6@,0.3(+%,25:"2&00'

A:&+6,(/ +( &(+K#,(/ &(<,:"(%&(6@+0K&&( 6@&2":&&#&%&(6";A@,(+M0,(2:&%&(6+#.&<&#"5%&(6

#&+:(,(/ &H5&:,&(2&0'9@&&(+K#,(/ 06:+6&/3 +(. 5"#,2,&0,(2#$.&6@"0&6" .&<&#"5 F5&2,+#82"("%,2

R"(&0NF8R0IB+(. 0$55":6;":F*80K3 %,2:" ;,(+(2&+(. #,(Q,(/ 6@&%?,6@ %+:Q&60'4( 5+:6,2$#+:B

F5&2,+#82"("%,2R"(&05#+3&. +Q&3 :"#&+0+6&06,(/ /:"$(. ;":&2"("%,2:&;":%0B;":+66:+26,(/

;":&,/( .,:&26,(<&06%&(6B;":2+6+#30,(/ ,(.$06:,+#2#$06&:0B+(. ;":#&+:(,(/ (&?6&2@("#"/,&0+(.

,(2$K+6,(/ (&?%+(+/&%&(65:+26,2&0'4( ;+26BF8R0?&:&$0&. 6" :&.$2&:&0,06+(2&+(. "55"0,6,"( 6"

2:,6,2+#:&;":%0+(. K$,#. K:"+. 0$55":6;"::&;":%06@:"$/@ .&%"(06:+6,"( +(. 2"(6:"##&.

&H5&:,%&(6+6,"('9:+.&D#&. /:"?6@ ;$&##&. 6@&.&<&#"5%&(6";%+(3 2"+06+#+:&+0B2:&+6&. %":&O"K

"55":6$(,6,&0'C:&2&(6X":#. S+(Q 06$.3 &06,%+6&. 6@+6+0";#""(BF8R006,##+22"$(6&. ;":+K"$6

##T ";(+6,"(+#GE1B+K"$6)*T ";-E4B+K"$6*"T ";&H5":60B+(. /&(&:+6&. ,( &H2&00";+"

%,##,"( O"K0'

46,0+#0" ";5+:6,2$#+:,(6&:&066" $(.&:06+(. +K:"+.&::+(/&";,00$&0+(. &H5&:,&(2&:&#+6&. 6" 6@&

A@,(&0&&(+K#,(/ &(<,:"(%&(6;":&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6)2:&+6,(/ O"K06@:"$/@ :$:+#+(. %,2:"

&(6&:5:,0&0J#+K"$:+(. ?+/&5"#,2,&0J6:+,(,(/ +(. 2+5+2,63 K$,#.,(/ 6@:"$/@ O",(6<&(6$:&0+(. +,.

5:"/:+%%&0J#"2+#+$6"("%3 +(. .&2,0,"( %+Q,(/J2"%5&6,6,"( K&6?&&( :&/,"(0+(. 2,6,&0J

K$:&+$2:+23 +(. :&/$#+6,"(J+22&006" ;,(+(2,(/J2:&+6,"( ";+55:"5:,+6&6&2@("#"/3 +(. ,(;:+06:$26$:&'

9@&.,02$00,"(00@"$#. ("6"(#3 @,/@#,/@6&H5&:,&(2&0BK$6+#0" 6@&#&00"(0#&+:(6;:"% 6@&:+5,.

6:+(0;":%+6,"( 5:"2&00,( A@,(+'

9@&&<&(6?,##2"<&:+##";6@&+K"<&$(.&:6?" Q&3 6@&%&0"( 0$22&&.,(/ .+30)

!

%X@+6:"#&.,. &(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(65#+3 ,( A@,(+M0&2"("%,26:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. ?@+6

+:&6@&/&(&:+##&00"(0WX@+606:+6&/,&0+(. 5"#,2,&0@+<&%+.&A@,(+0$22&00;$#,(

$6,#,0,(/ .,:&26;":&,/( ,(<&06%&(6+(. &(2"$:+/,(/ 6:+(0;&:0";6&2@("#"/3 +(. 6&2@(,2+#

0Q,##0"<&:6@&#+06+" 3&+:0B0" 6@+6,62"$#. &(6&:,(6" 6@&<+#$&2@+,(0";6@&/#"K+#

&2"("%3W

!

%X@+6+:&6@&06:+6&/,&0&%&:/,(/ ,( C;:,2+;":&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6W

S+0&. "( 6@&.,02$00,"(0$(.&:6@&0&6?" 6@&%&0B?@+66@&( +:&6@&Q&3 ,00$&0+(. #&00"(0

:&/+:.,(/),I:$:+#&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6B,,IF5&2,+#82"("%,2R"(&0+(. ,,,I;":&,/( .,:&26

,(<&06%&(6'

'!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 127: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

C)1 ?$0Q'60 D,(),0;&" 2#:0 #+!$,0(7(&*0 C0/0:#7%0$,

&$,60 '()$*+#(%),&#$.(#"0**

&")+" ,&")+! B(3&.,6)3'.(X-+(6$ A@&:$B=&0&+:2@ E,:&26":BY":.,2C;:,2+4(06,6$6&N*".&:+6":I

&")+! ,&&)+!

j#5(.3#C&#*#(3+3'.(*X

F6:$26$:+#9:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 82"("%,2E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)*+f,+"@&B!,2&1:&0,.&(6";E&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@ C2+.&%3 ";Y+6,"(+#

E&<&#"5%&(6+(. =&;":%A"%%,00,"( ";1'='A@,(+

9+Q,(/ 6@&C;:,2+( G:"?6@ 1:"2&00-":?+:.)C<",.,(/ 5"#,23 03(.:"%&0

>%#+J#&)C$/$06,( -"0$BE&5$63 E,:&26":B\YDX4E8=

='*)6**+(3*

4(.$06:,+#F6:+6&/,&0+(. 8(6&:5:,0&E&<&#"5%&(6)!,&?0;:"%8+06C0,+

>%#+J#&)4U$%,'@("

!

Y+6,"(+#G:+.$+6&4(06,6$6&;":1"#,23 F6$.,&0B[+5+(J+(.

C.<,0":6" 6@&G"<&:(%&(6";86@,"5,+

C;:,2+( S$0,(&00*".&#0+(. 8(6&:5:,0&E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)1@,#,5 '.&:+B*+(+/,(/ E,:&26":;":\/+(.+BF6+(.+:. S+(Q

&&)+! ,&#)+" G%#(='*)6**'.(

.)()::0:G#(F*6#7*

&))"" ,&))&"

B(3&.,6)3'.(E'(%-#(+&5F

[&((,;&:C.+%0BE&<&#"5%&(6A"$(0&##":B\FC4EBS&,O,(/

&))&" ,&*)""

K.&J*".%IXC.-')'#*3. H().6&+8#H(3&#%&#(#6&*"'%;>6%%.&3D6&+-H(3#&%&'*#*;

W')&.<>WH*+(,1&#+3#d.7G%%.&36('3'#*

W.,#&+3.&X["0$&E,"(&B\Y8AC

D+%%.&3#6&)*:'*,2@+&#]+,:.BF&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306B'8AE

&))&! ,&)))!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'8H5&:,&(2&0";E&<&#"5,(/ =$:+#8(6&:5:,0&0,( A@,(+)9@&:"#&";/"<&:(%&(6

>%#+J#&)X+(/ >+,%,(BA"##&/&";>$%+(,6,&0+(. E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0BA@,(+

C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

#'A@,(+M01"#,2,&0";F$55":6,(/ '$6?+:.04(<&06%&(6

>%#+J#&)f$&>"(/BE,:&26":BE&<&#"5%&(6C00,06+(2&BAC498AB*'-A'*

&)))! ,&*)"" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&))&! ,&*)""

K.&J*".%fXH(+7-'(8 H(4'&.(0#(3/.&>%#)'+-H).(.0')P.(#*E>HP*F+(,

1-6*3#&*'(1"'(+ +(,9/&')+

W.,#&+3.&)E"$/#+0R@,@$+R&(/BF&(,":82"("%,06BX":#. S+(Q

D+%%.&3#6&)E&K":+@ S:+$6,/+%BC%&:,2+( \(,<&:0,63

&))&" ,&))!!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'A@,(+DC;:,2+E&<&#"5%&(6-$(.M0F6:+6&/3 +(. C55:"+2@ ,( F$55":6,(/ 82"("%,2A"D

"5&:+6,"( R"(&0

>%#+J#&)],$ >+(H,"(/B1:"O&26*+(+/&:B8+06C;:,2+E&5+:6%&(6BA@,(+DC;:,2+

E&<&#"5%&(6-$(.

#'8H5&:,&(2&0";F5&2,+#82"("%,2R"(&0+(. A#$06&:E&<&#"5%&(6,( A@,(+)9@&2+0&

";F@&(U@&(

>%#+J#&)_$+( _,%,(BE&5$63 E,:&26":BF8RA&(6:&BF@&(U@&( \(,<&:0,63

+'F5&2,+#82"("%,2R"(&0,( C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)F&&?:+OY$(.#+##BE,:&26":";*+($;+26$:,(/ A#$06&:B*+$:,6,$0S"+:. ";

4(<&06%&(6NS'4IB*+$:,6,$0

(!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 128: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&)))! ,&*)"" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&))&! ,&*)""

K.&J*".%VX!&+(*/.&0+3'4# =B+(,C.&3/.-'. B(4#*30#(3'(1"'(+ +(,'(9/&')+

W.,#&+3.&)>&X&(5,(/BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

D+%%.&3#6&)*,2@+&#F6,:(?&,00BS*RVG4R

&))&! ,&)))!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'A@,(+M0-E4+(. ,60=&#&<+(2&6" C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)]< S"BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&+(. 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"(

NAC498AIB*,(,06:3 ";A"%%&:2&B1'='A@,(+

#'A@,(+M04(<&06%&(6,( C;:,2+)Z&3 2@+##&(/&0

>%#+J#&)X$ -+(/BA@,(+DC;:,2+A&(6:&BAC498AB*'-A'*

+'8%&:/,(/ 1+66&:(0";F,("DC;:,2+( 9:+.&+(. 1"6&(6,+#0;":8(6&:5:,0&E&<&#"5%&(6,(

C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)[&+(DA#+$.&*+0?+(+B[4AC=&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&

&)))! ,&*)"" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&*)#" ,&()+"

K.&J*".%>600+&5 EC-#(+&5F

1"+'&)-+(6$ A@&:$B=&0&+:2@ E,:&26":BY":.,2C;:,2+4(06,6$6&

&*)#" ,&*)!"

D#%.&3/&.0#+)"%+&+--#-@.&J*".%

K.&J*".%IXC.-')'#*3. H().6&+8#H(3&#%&#(#6&*"'%;>6%%.&3D6&+-H(3#&%&'*#*;

W')&.<>WH*+(,1&#+3#d.7G%%.&36('3'#*

D+%%.&3#6&)*,2@+&#]+,:.B'8AE

K.&J*".%fXH(+7-'(8 H(4'&.(0#(3/.&>%#)'+-H).(.0')P.(#*E>HP*F+(,

1-6*3#&*'(1"'(+ +(,9/&')+

D+%%.&3#6&)E&K":+@ S:+$6,/+%BC%&:,2+( \(,<&:0,63

K.&J*".%VX!&+(*/.&0+3'4# =B+(,C.&3/.-'. B(4#*30#(3'(1"'(+ +(,'(9/&')+

D+%%.&3#6&)*,2@+&#F6,:(?&,00BS*RVG4R

&*)!" ,&()+" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&()+" ,&$)""

N6*'(#**D.6(,3+7-#

P/6*')-6'4%&'0$,16!,133' *' 94-#1)--#1 ;2%#&,U P/,3,%)3/)9#(()-3&'1-3%,#13-

6'4 2,&)U E26'4 &'45* &/,1()'1)$'5#&6#1 6'4%'$)%,3#1( )18#%'10)137!/,3!'45* 6'4

&/,1()U

W.,#&+3.&)=,2@+:. A+:&3BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

&'*+:6,( Z+0&Q&(.&

!

A@+,:%+(B-&.&:+6,"( ";\/+(.+8%5#"3&:0

#'],$ >+,#,(B=&5:&0&(6+6,<&,( 86@,"5,+BF,("@3.:"

+'E+,R@,Q+(/

!

A@+,:%+( ";S"+:. ";E,:&26":0BR&( E+,G:"$5

)'_+:+

!

9" K&2"(;,:%&.

!'8:%3+0C%&#/+BA8'BC22&00A+5,6+#VC22&00=&+#806+6&BR&%&( S+(Q

*'*&+U+C0@&(+;,B8(+6S+(Q

-&../01T

="%.#$( 9%'#3 3%.%3#,1 8*)0$,0).)#'0 -0/04*.60$,AT26%$

)0'*2)30'R#$',#,2,#*$'%$-)0(24%,#*$'#$!"#$% %$-:8)#3%

8(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6@+0K&&( +%+O":+<&($&;":A@,(+6" 5:"%"6&6@&2+5+2,6,&0";,60@$%+(

:&0"$:2&0+(. ,(06,6$6,"(0B<,+#&+:(,(/DK3D.",(/ 5:"2&00&0+(. 5:+/%+6,2+.+56+6,"('=$:+#&(6&:5:,0&

)!!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 129: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

.&<&#"5%&(6BF8R0+(. 2#$06&:0+(.B;,(+##3B"5&(,(/ $5 6" -E4@+<&+##2"(6:,K$6&. 6" 6@&2:&+6,"( ";

2+5+2,6,&06@+6.,. ("6&H,06+66@&"$60&6";6@&:&;":%+(. /:"?6@ 5:"2&00+66@&&(. ";6@&&$("0'9@&

2+5+2,63 K$,#.,(/ @+0,(2#$.&. @$%+( .&<&#"5%&(6B,(06,6$6,"(+#2+5+2,63 .&<&#"5%&(6+(. +0?&##B

6&2@("#"/3 ,(("<+6,"('=$:+#&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(65:"/:+%%&0B0$2@ +06@&aF5+:Q 1:"/:+%bB

/:&+6#3 &(2"$:+/&. :$:+#&(6&:5:,0&0?@,2@ .&<&#"5&. ,(6" +2"%5&6&(60&26":'9@&,(06,6$6,"(+#

2+5+2,63 ;":%+(+/,(/ F8R0+(. 2#$06&:0+22$%$#+6&. "<&:6,%&

9@&:&,0("?+/:&+6"55":6$(,63 ;":A@,(+6" 0@+:&,60&H5&:,&(2&0+(. #&00"(0,( 6@,02+5+2,63 2:&+6,"(

?,6@ C;:,2+'46,0+#0" ,%5":6+(66" 0@+:&@"?A@,(+M0&(/+/&%&(6,( C;:,2+2+( +22&#&:+6&#"2+#<+#$&

2:&+6,"(B6:+(0;&:";6&2@("#"/3B2+5+2,63 K$,#.,(/ +(. 0$06+,(+K#&.&<&#"5%&(6,( C;:,2++0,60

,(<&06%&(6:"#&,( C;:,2+,(2:&+0&0'

=+5 !@. ./3"#%&.8&+0*"+--/+)'-'3+3#,'*)6**'.(.(X

!

%X@+6+:&6@&Q&3 &H5&:,&(2&0+(. #&00"(0;:"% A@,(+;":.&<&#"5,(/ +06:"(/ @$%+( +(.

,(06,6$6,"(+#2+5+2,63 6" 5:"%"6&&(6&:5:,0&.&<&#"5%&(6WX@+62+( C;:,2+#&+:( ;:"%6@&5:"2&00W

!

%>"?2+( 6@&&H5+(.,(/ ($%K&:0";3"$(/ 5&"5#&&(6&:,(/ 6@&#+K"$:;":2&,( C;:,2+K&

+55:"5:,+6&#3 0Q,##&. 6" %+62@ 6@&(&&.0";+( &H5+(.,(/ &(6&:5:,0&K+0&.D&2"("%3 ,( K"6@

:$:+#+(. $:K+( +:&+0W

!

%X@+66&2@("#"/,2+#2+62@D$5 5:"2&00&0+(. Q("?#&./&5#+6;":%0+:&&%&:/,(/ ,( C;:,2++(.

@"?2+( .&<&#"5%&(6+00,06+(2&5:"<,.&:0@&#5W

!

%>"?6" &(@+(2&6@&$(.&:06+(.,(/ ";K"6@ ."%&06,2+(. ;":&,/( &(6&:5:,0&0,( C;:,2+"( 6@&

,%5":6+(2&";2":5":+6&0"2,+#:&05"(0,K,#,63B0$55":6,(/ #+K"$:+(. &(<,:"(%&(6+#06+(.+:.0

+(. +(6,D2"::$56,"( &;;":60'>"?2+( 6@&,%+/&";A@,(&0&;,:%0K&,%5:"<&. ,( 6@&0&+:&+0W

!

%>"?2+( C;:,2+%+Q&6@&%"06";(&?/:&&( /:"?6@ "55":6$(,6,&0W>"?2+( .&<&#"5%&(6

+00,06+(2&@&#5W

C)1 LQC0/0:#7&$; J)*&" 8)7)"&,&0*Q.0#7:09T$*,&,3,&#$*)$-20;3:),&#$*

"$)"" ,"$)&"

D#/-#)3'.(*.(=+5 I +(,G7A#)3'4#*/.&=+5 f

W.,#&+3.&)-+(6$ A@&:$B=&0&+:2@ E,:&26":BY":.,2C;:,2+4(06,6$6&

"$)&" ,&")&"

j#5(.3#C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'8;;&26,<&*&+0$:&06" S$,#. A+5+2,63 ;":8(6&:5:,0&E&<&#"5%&(6)9@&A@,(&0&

&H5&:,&(2&

>%#+J#&)A@&( f,+"@"(/BE,:&26":B8(6&:5:,0&=&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&BE&<&#"5%&(6

=&0&+:2@ A&(6:&";6@&F6+6&A"$(2,#

#'*+O":A"(06:+,(60+(. '55":6$(,6,&0,( C;:,2+6" E&<&#"5 +F6:"(/ A+5+2,63 ;":

8(6&:5:,0&E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)EO+%&#A@:,KB';;,2&";82"("%,2C;;+,:0BC;:,2+( \(,"( A"%%,00,"(

+'A@,(&0&8(6&:5:,0&0,( C;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6)S$0,(&00%".&#0+(. .&<&#"5%&(6,%5+26

>%#+J#&)[,(/ G$B=&0&+:2@ -&##"?B4(06,6$6&;":E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0

)''8AE8(6&:5:,0&0,( C;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)C(.:&+G"#.06&,(BF&(,":82"("%,06B'8AE

*"!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 130: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&")+" ,&")!"

='*)6**'.(*X1.00#(3+3.&*)

!

%F$(,#F,(@+B*+(+/,(/ E,:&26":BY+6@+( 8*8

!

%-&&.K+2Q ;:"% 6@&G#"K+#E&<&#"5%&(6]&+:(,(/ Y&6?":Q A"(0$#6+6,"()8.?+:.

S:"?(BE,:&26":BCA89

&")!" ,&#)"" G%#(='*)6**'.(

.)()::0:G#(F*6#7*

&+)+" ,&+))"

B(3&.,6)3'.(E'(%-#(+&5F

],C(0@+(B4(06,6$6&";C;:"DC0,+( F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

&+))" ,&!)+"

K.&J*".%IX_60+(D#*.6&)#*=#4#-.%0#(3/.&H(3#&%&'*#*=#4#-.%0#(3+(,

!#)"(.-.85 !&+(*/#&

W.,#&+3.&)8%%+($&#Y(+."U,&B\Y8AC

D+%%.&3#6&)*+" f,+"O,(/BAC498AB*'-A'*

&+))! ,&))&!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'A@,(+M0aC66:+26,(/ 4(6&##&26$+#=&0"$:2&0;:"%CK:"+.b1:"/:+%%&

>%#+J#&)_$ f,(BC00,06+(6=&0&+:2@ -&##"?BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";1&:0"((&#F2,&(2&

#'A@+##&(/&0";C;:,2+>$%+( =&0"$:2&0E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)X,##,+%]3+Q$:?+BC;:,2+( 82"("%,2=&0&+:2@ A"(0":6,$%

+'9:+(0;&:+(. Z("?#&./&1#+6;":%0,( C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)C,.+'5"Q$D*&(0+@BE,:&26":";4A9BF2,&(2&+(. 9&2@("#"/3 E,<,0,"(B

\Y82"("%,2A"%%,00,"( ;":C;:,2+

&))&! ,&!)+" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&+))! ,&!)+"

K.&J*".%fX>6*3+'(+7-#1.&%.&+3#C&+)3')#*

W.,#&+3.&)9":,9<&,6BA"(;&.&:+6,"( ";Y":?&/,+( 8(6&:5:,0&

D+%%.&3#6&)'Q&3 '(3&O&Q?&BA&(6:&;":F$06+,(+K#&G"<&:(+(2&

&+))! ,&))#!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&']+K"$:-":2&9:+(0,6,"(0+(. 400$&0,( C;:,2+( E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&*)4]'

!

6" K&2"(;,:%&.

#'4%5:"<,(/ X":Q,(/ A"(.,6,"(0,( F$55#3 A@+,(0)]&00"(0+(. &H5&:,&(2&

>%#+J#&)R@"$ X&,."(/BA@,(+A"$(6:3 E,:&26":BS$0,(&00;":F"2,+#=&05"(0,K,#,63

+'F$06+,(+K#&A":5":+6&1:+26,2&0";A@,(&0&A"%5+(,&0,( C;:,2+)1"#,23 +(. &H5&:,&(2&

>%#+J#&)_$ X$BE&5$63 E,:&26":G&(&:+#BA@,(+8(6&:5:,0&0A"(;&.&:+6,"(

)'F"2,+#E,+#"/$&,( \/+(.+

>%#+J#&)*+:6,( Z+0&Q&(.&BA@+,:%+(B-&.&:+6,"( ";\/+(.+8%5#"3&:0

&))#! ,&!)+" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&+))! ,&!)+"

K.&J*".%VXH(4'&.(0#(3+-C.-')'#*+(,D#86-+3'.(*

W.,#&+3.&)="/&:A":(;":6@BECAE&#&/+6&;":Y&?R&+#+(. +(. ECA!,2&DA@+,:

D+%%.&3#6&)1&6&:A:+,/D*2i$+,.&B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

!"!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 131: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

&+))! ,&))&!

C&#*#(3+3'.(*

&'8(<,:"(%&(6+#A"(0&P$&(2&0+(. =&/$#+6,"(0,( A@,(+M08(6&:5:,0&E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)],$ *,(/P$+(BE,:&26":BA&(6:&;":>$%+( +(. 82"("%,2E&<&#"5%&(6

F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

#'8(<,:"(%&(6+#400$&0+(. -E4,( C;:,2+

>%#+J#&)F&:/&S"$(.+B>&+. ";6@&\Y81

+'G:&&( G:"?6@)A@+##&(/&0+(. '55":6$(,6,&0;":C;:,2+( 8(6&:5:,0&E&<&#"5%&(6

>%#+J#&)\Y8AC

!

6" K&2"(;,:%&.

&))&! ,&!)+" G%#(='*)6**'.(

&!)!" ,&()&!

K.&J*".%>600+&5 EC-#(+&5F

W.,#&+3.&)-+(6$ A@&:$B=&0&+:2@ E,:&26":BY":.,2C;:,2+4(06,6$6&

&!)!" ,&*)#"

D#%.&3/&.0#+)"%+&+--#-@.&J*".%

K.&J*".%IX_60+(D#*.6&)#*=#4#-.%0#(3/.&H(3#&%&'*#*=#4#-.%0#(3+(,

!#)"(.-.85 !&+(*/#&

D+%%.&3#6&)*+" f,+"O,(/BAC498A

K.&J*".%fX>6*3+'(+7-#1.&%.&+3#C&+)3')#*

D+%%.&3#6&)'Q&3 '(3&O&Q?&BA&(6:&;":F$06+,(+K#&G"<&:(+(2&

K.&J*".%VXH(4'&.(0#(3+-C.-')'#*+(,D#86-+3'.(*

D+%%.&3#6&)1&6&:A:+,/D*2i$+,.&B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

&*)#" ,&()"" G%#(='*)6**'.(

1-.*'(8 1#&#0.(5

W.,#&+3.&)-+(6$ A@&:$B=&0&+:2@ E,:&26":BY":.,2C;:,2+4(06,6$6&

&()#" ,&-)+"

>600+&5 ./3"#H4#(3

=,2@+:. A+:&3BA"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

],f,+"3$(BE,:&26":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

1-.*'(8 D#0+&J*

f$ >$,BE,:&26":G&(&:+#B41=AA

*+H?&##*Q?&U+#+%K+BC;:,2+( \(,"( A"%%,00,"(

C6" Y&?+,G&K:&+KBA@,&;82"("%,2C.<,0":6" 6@&1:,%&*,(,06&:";86@,"5,+

["( ]"%"3BE,:&26":;":E&<&#"5%&(6A"D"5&:+6,"(B'8AE

""!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 132: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

TTTOY.<2'T8T.<V'D >TD'

*FCCSEC]]C> >&+. ";82"(%,21"#,2,&0+(. E,<,0,"(BC;:,2+( \(,"( A"%%,00,"(

]&KK+U]+:K,CSE8]-89C> C#/&:,+( 8%K+003

+(+3&CS8=C 1:"2$:&%&(6';;,2&:B\FC4E

[&((,;&:CEC*F A"$(0&##":-":4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"(B\(,6&. F6+6&08%K+003BS&,O,(/

8:%3+09LC*8]GC -"$(.&:hA8'';C22&00A+5,6+#F&:<,2&0FLAL4(<&06%&(6A"%5+(3

8(:,P$&YLCYG\8F'*' A"$(0&##":B8P$+6&:,+#G$,(&+8%K+003

*&+U+CF>8YC-4 \Y8ACV8(+6S+(Q N\(.&:-":%+6,"(I1:"%"6&:

E+?,6CFF8-C 49';;,2&:B\FC4E

>+(0SCYZ8YS8=G C%K+00+.":BY&6@&:#+(.08%K+003B86@,"5,+

'?&( SC=E8= !,0,6,(/ -&##"?BA&(6&:-":G#"K+#E&<&#"5%&(6

["+" SC==CECF F&2"(. F&2:&6+:3BC(/"#+8%K+003B86@,"5,+

*,2@+&#SC99]8 \(,6&. F6+6&0C%K+00+.":6" C\

Y,2"#+S8]]'Y' -,:06A"$(0&##":B8\E,:&26":

*,2@&#&S'C=4' F&(,":82"("%,2C.<,0":B46+#,+( E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(B46+#,+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

-:+(2",0S'Y98*1F E&5$63 E,:&26":BG&(&:+#E,:&26":+6&-":E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(B*,(,06:3 ';

-":&,/( C;;+,:0BS&#/,$%

F&:/&S'\YEC >&+. ],+,0"( ';;,2&B\Y81

*"@+%&. S'\YGC*=8 E&5$63 >&+.B9$(,0,+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

E&K":+@ S=C\94GC* 1:";&00":BC%&:,2+( \(,<&:0,63

*++:6&( S='\X8= C%K+00+.":D+6D]+:/&;":4(("<+6,"(BA"@&:&(2&hZ("?#&./&*+(+/&%&(6B*,(,06:3

';-":&,/( C;;+,:0

8.?+:. S='XY E,:&26":BC;:,2+( A&(6&:-":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

="0&K$. S\=\Z\ 1"#,23 C.<,0":BC;:,2+( A&(6&:-":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

=,2@+:. AC=8_ A"DA@+,:BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

[&+(D=+5@+&#A>C1'YY48=8 82"("%,06BC0,+E&5+:6%&(6BE&<&#"5%&(6C/&(23 ';-:+(2&

A@$+( A>8Y ]&26$:&:B*&#K"$:(&\(,<&:0,63

f,+"@"(/ A>8Y E,:&26":B8(6&:5:,0&4(06,6$6&BE&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@ A&(6:&";6@&F6+6&A"$(2,#

-+(6$ A>8=\ =&0&+:2@ E,:&26":B9@&Y":.,2C;:,2+4(06,6$6&B\550+#+BF?&.&(

="/&:A'=Y-'=9> Y&?R&+#+(. E&<&#"5%&(6A"$(0&##":B*,(,06:3 ';-":&,/( C;;+,:0C(. 9:+.&JY&?

R&+#+(. 8%K+003B1+:,0

1&6&:A=C4GD*Ai\C4E8 >&+. ';\(,6BEGE&<&#"5%&(6B=&#+6,"(0?,6@ 4(6&:(+6,"(+#':/+(,0+6,"(0+(.

("(D8\*&%K&:F6+6&0B8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

R@,Q+(/ EC4 A8'BR&(.+,G:"$5

F+:+@D[+(&ECYA>48 F&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306BC;:,2+( A&(6&:-":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

F&%$(&0@ E8*89='F 1:,<+6&F&26":C.<,0":B\FC4E

["0$jE4'Y

!

E,:&26":B-"". F&2$:,63 C(. F$06+,(+K#&E&<&#"5%&(6E,<,0,"( N-FFEEI

'$%+:E4'1 C$2VF5"B8%5#"3&%&(6BC\A

'$0%+(&E,"5 E4'1 F&2"(. A"$(0&##":JF&(&/+#8%K+003B86@,"5,+

["@( 8EGC= C/:,2$#6$:&';;,2&:B\FC4E

>+((+@D=&K&22+8%%+8E4YG8= >&+. ';=&0&+:2@ hF&(,":*+(+/&:B-:"(6,&:C.<,0":3

!,26":,+8GS89C_' 1"#,23 ';;,2&:BC;:,2+( \(,"( A"%%,00,"(

CK.$#:+@,%8]CS8E ],K3+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

#"!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 133: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

S&2Q3 [L8=Z\] F&(,":E"(":C;;+,:0C.<,0":B\FC4E

-&06$0-C[CYC 9:+.&1"#,23 8H5&:6BC\A

*",K+CL-'-CYC -,:06F&2:&6+:3B],K&:,+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

C$/$06,( Z?+0,-'F\ E&5$63 E,:&26":B\Y\(,<&:0,63 DX":#. 4(06,6$6&;":BE&<&#"5%&(682"("%,20

=&0&+:2@B-,(#+(.

A&#0" -=CYAC -,:06F&2:&6+:3BS:+U,#,+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

8%5@:&( -\-C X+6&:F&26":A"(0$#6+(6B[+5+(&0&8%K+003B86@,"5,+

G&.,"( GC*'=C A"(0$#6+(6B\Y8AC

E&%,:&?G89CA>8X 86@,"5,+( 82"("%,2=&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&

EO+%&#G>=4S 1:,<+6&F&26":E,<,0,"( A@,&;BC;:,2+( \(,"( A"%%,00,"(

1@,#,5 G4CYY8AAA>4Y4 =&0&+:2@ C00,06+(6B\(,<&:0,63 ";F6C(.:&?0BF2"6#+(.

C(.:&+G']EF984Y F&(,":82"("%,06B'8AE

E,.,&:G=8S8=9 =&/,"(+#*+(+/&:-":86@,"5,+BF$.+(BF"%+#,+C(. 8:,6:&+BC/&(2&-:+(k+,0&E&

Ej<&#"55&%&(6

F<&( G=4** E,:&26":BA&(6&:';A@,(&0&F6$.,&0C6F6&##&(K"02@BF"$6@ C;:,2+

[,(/ G\ =&0&+:2@&:B1:";&00":BG#"K+#,0+6,"( 9&+%B4(06,6$6&';E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0

f,+"O,&G\ A@,(&0&C%K+00+.":6" 86@,"5,+B*,(,06:3 ';-":&,/( C;;+,:0BA@,(+

_+@3+G\]F8!8Y [$(,":1:"/:+%A"":.,(+6":B9$:Q,0@ 4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6

C/&(23 N94ZCI

>&,(U>CS8=9>8\8= >&+. ";';;,2&BC$06:,+( 8%K+003 E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(

9+.&00&>C4]8 F6+6&*,(,06&:B*,(,06:3 ';4(.$06:3B86@,"5,+

X+(/ >C4*4Y A"##&/&";>$%+(,6,&0hE&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

=3"6+:" >C_CF>4 C00,06+(6E,:&26":BE&<&#"5%&(61+:6(&:0@,5 E,<,0,"(B'5&:+6,"(0F6:+6&/3

E&5+:6%&(6B[+5+( 4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"( C/&(23

X&(5,(/ >8 E,:&26":';9@&E,<,0"( ';C;:,2+( F6$.,&0B4(06,6$6&';X&06C0,+( C(. C;:,2+(

F6$.,&0BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ';F"2,+#F2,&(2&0

>&(.:,Q >84[E8Y C.<,0":6" *,(,06&:";-,(+(2&

["@+( >8]]CYE -,:06F&2:&6+:3BY":?+3 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

Y,2"#+0>8=4Y 8+06C;:,2+A"::&05"(.+(6

>+<+:. >'ZFY8F A"$(0&##":BY":?&/,+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

F&+( >'_ F&(,":E&<&#"5%&(6F5&2,+#,06B4:,0@ C,.BE&5+:6%&(6";-":&,/( C;;+,:0B4:&#+(.

*"@+%&. 4E=4FF 8AC";;,2&:B8:,6:&+( %,00,"(

G#":,+4RCZF F5&2,+#C006LEFCBC\A

-+0,Q+[4--C= *,2:"&(6&:5:,0&C.,0":B\FC4E

1&:(,##&E+@#&:ZC=E8] C%K+00+.":BE+(,0@ 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

*+:6,( ZCF8Z8YE8 A@+,:%+(B-&.&:+6,"( ';\/+(.+8%5#"3&:0B-\8

[+%&0Z88]_ =&0&+:2@ C00"2,+6&B4(6&:(+6,"(+#4(06,6$6&;":8(<,:"(%&(6hE&<&#"5%&(6

Y3,Q" Z>'RC E,5#"%+6,2C66+2@&BF"$6@ C;:,2+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

>+,#&Z4S=89 1"#,6,2+#';;,2&:B\(,6&. F6+6&08%K+003B86@,"5,+

_"$(/D>?+( Z4* A"$(0&##":BZ":&+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

Y+"@,:" Z49CY' E,:&26":DG&(&:+#B8+06C(. A&(6:+#C0,+C(. 9@&A+$2+0$0E&5+:6%&(6B[+5+(

4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"( C/&(23

=&(&YM/$&66,+Z'\CFF4 E,:&26":B';;,2&';82"("%,2C;;+,:0BC\

F&:@+6Z\A\ZZ\=9 F&(,":1:"/:+%A"":.,(+6":J9$:Q,0@ 4(6&:(+6,"(+#A""5&:+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6

C/&(23 N94ZCI

'..D4(/&Z!C]>84* C%K+00+.":BY":?&/,+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

$"!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 134: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

]+$:&( ]CE8YF'Y 1"#,6,2+#';;,2&:B\(,6&. F6+6&08%K+003B86@,"5,+

*,2@+&#]C4=E F&(,":1"#,23 C(+#306B1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( hG:"?6@ E,<,0,"(BE&<&#"5%&(6A"

'5&:+6,"( E,:&26":+6&B'8AE

]"$,0&]C]4S8=9

!

E&5$63 E,:&26":>PB86@,"5,+1:"/:+%BA+(+.,+( 4(6&:(+6,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6C/&(23

S,:6@&8#,0+K&6@ ]C=F8Y A"$(0&##":BE+(,0@ 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

]4C(0@+( 1:";&00":B4(06,6$6&";C;:"DC0,+( F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

]4A@$(/$+(/ E,:&26":G&(&:+#BE&5+:6%&(6";4(6&:(+6,"(+#A"D"5&:+6,"( +(. F"2,+#*"K,#,0+6,"(B

F6+6&A"$(2,#]&+.,(/ G:"$5 ';;,2&";1"<&:63 C##&<,+6,"( +(. E&<&#"5%&(6N]G'1I

]4],(3, 1:"/:+%%&';;,2&:B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:4( A@,(+N41=AAI

]4f,+"3$( E&+(BA"##&/&';>$%+(,6,&0C(. E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0BA@,(+C/:,2$#6$:+#\(,<&:0,63

]4\>+,#,( =&5:&0&(6+6,<&4( 86@,"5,+BF,("@3.:" A":5":+6,"( ]6.L

]4\[$( R&(.+,G:"$5

]4\*,(P$+( E,:&26":BA&(6:&;":>$%+( +(. 82"("%,2E&<&#"5%&(6F6$.,&0B1&Q,(/ \(,<&:0,63

]4\>+(H,"(/ 1:"O&26*+(+/&:BA@,(+DC;:,2+E&<&#"5%&(6-$(.

["( ]'*'_ E,:&26":BE&<&#"5%&(6A"D'5&:+6,"( E,:&26":+6&B'8AE

*":,( ]\A F&2"(. F&2:&6+:3B*+$:,6,$08%K+003B86@,"5,+

]!S" =&0&+:2@&:BAC498AB*'-A'*

X,##,+%]_CZ\=XC 8H&2$6,<&E,:&26":BC;:,2+( 82"("%,2=&0&+:2@ A"(0":6,$%NC8=AI

*CA@&(/#,+(/ R&(.+,G:"$5

*Cf,+"@& E&5$63 E,:&26":BE&<&#"5%&(6=&0&+:2@ C2+.&%3 ';Y+6,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6+(.

=&;":%A"%%,00,"( NE=AIBA@,(+

C(/&#,P$&*CGCYGC F&2"(. A"$(0&##":BG+K"( 8%K+003

8#&(&*CZ'YY8Y F&(,":C.<,0&:BC;:,2+( A&(6&:-":82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"(

*C'f,+"O,(/ C00"2,+6&=&0&+:2@&:BE&5+:6%&(6";E&<&#"5%&(6C00,06+(2&BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";

4(6&:(+6,"(+#9:+.&C(. 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"(B*'-A'*

]$2+*C=CYG'Y4 8$:"5&+( A"%%,00,"(

[+%&0*C=48 F&2"(. F&2:&6+:3B*+$:,6,$08%K+003B86@,"5,+

S&(O+%,( *CF4]C ],K:+:,+(BCA8=

[&+(DA#+$.&*CFXCYC =&0&+:2@&:B[4AC=&0&+:2@ 4(06,6$6&

F,&(U&(,*C989C R,%K+K?&8%K+003B86@,"5,+

>":6&(0&*S8C 4(6&:5:&6&:BC\

*,Q&*2AC=9>_ F&(,":C.<,0&:B\ZE-4EB86@,"5,+

],(6"( *A>\Y\ E,5#"%+6,2C66+2@&BF"$6@ C;:,2+( 8%K+003

_,(/ *84 R&(.+,G:"$5

S&6@#&@&%*8YG4F9\ 82"("%,06BY,#&S+0,( E,02"$:0&BAV'86@,"5,+Y+6,"(+#E,02"$:0&-":$%

-,00&@+D90,"( *8YG4F9\ E,:&26":B*&Q&##&\(,<&:0,63

*+H?&##*ZX8RC]C*SC A"%%,00,"(&:BC;:,2+( \(,"( A"%%,00,"(

E&<+( *''E]8_ 1"#,6,2+#A"$(0&##":BF"$6@ C;:,2+( 8%K+003

85@:+,%*'=8*'>']' *,(,06&:A"$(0&##&:B]&0&6@" 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

F,"#,K&*'\FFC -,:06F&2:&6+:3B8P$+6&:,+#G$,(&+8%K+003B86@,"5,+

*?+%+Q+*\]CGC 82"("%,2A"$(0&##":BR+%K+,+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

G,:%+*\]C9\ E,:&26":B86@,"5,+( 8%5#"3&:0C00"2,+6,"(

S&(&.&@+*\F4]]' 82"("%,2C66+2@&B8$:"5&+( \(,"(

R&%&.&(&@ Y8GC9\ *+(+/,(/ 1+:6(&:B8:(06h_"$(/ 86@,"5,+

C.:,+( YGCF4 4(6&:(+6,"(+#82"("%,06B\FC4E

F&&?:+OY\YE]C]] E,:&26":BS"+:. ";4(<&06%&(6B*+$:,6,$0

%"!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 135: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

C((&Y_CZC9' 9@,:. F&2:&6+:3B\/+(.+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

1@,#,5 'E8=C *+(+/,(/ E,:&26":;":\/+(.+BF6+(.+:. S+(Q

4U$%,'>Y' 1:";&00":BC.<,0":6" 6@&G"<&:(%&(6";86@,"5,+BY+6,"(+#G:+.$+6&4(06,6$6&-":

1"#,23 F6$.,&0B[+5+(

X,##,+%'ZC4Z'8 -,:06F&2:&6:3B8%K+003 ";G@+(+B86@,"5,+

R&2+:&+0'ZSCGCS8= 'A*B8:,6:&+( %,00,"(

A"(06+(2,+']4* 9@:,. F&2:&6+:3BC(/"#+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

'Q&3 ]L'Y_8[8ZX8 *+(+/,(/ E,:&26":BA&(6&:;":F$06+,(+K#&G"<&:(+(2&

C##&00+(.:" '!4 !1B-"$(.+6,"( ;":4(6&:(+6,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6

G$,##+$%&'XCFFC A"$(0&##":B8%K+003 ";A"(/"DS:+UU+<,##&B86@,"5,+

[&+( 14YG A@+,:%+(BC;:,2+( \(,"( A"%%,00,"(

]+U+::&1'948= 1:,<+6&F&26":C.<,0":B\FC4E

i4Y[,&%,(/ F&(,":C.<,0":BA@,(+8(6&:5:,0&A"(;&.&:+6,"(

i\i,+(/ 4(6&:5:&6&:BS&,O,(/ -":&,/( F6$.,&0\(,<&:0,63

="#;=88 E&5$63 A@,&;";*,00,"(BY":?&/,+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

F+#"%"( FC*8Y 9&2@(,2+#C.<,0&:"( 9:+.&+(. =&/,"(+#4(6&/:+6,"(B*,(,06:3 ';-,(+(2&B*+$:,6,$0

=+#;FA>=pE8= -,:06A"$(0&##":B=&/,"(+#E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(BG&:%+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

F>4R@+( ]&26$:&:BA@,(+-":&,/( C;;+,:0\(,<&:0,63

F>4Y>&3D_"$(/ Z'4ACBZ":&+

Z"(,(K+F4E4S

!

MF *&%K&:";1+:#,+%&(6BG"<&:(%&(6";*+#,

*,/$&#F4]!8=F9=8 A"$(0&##":B8%K+003 ";1":6$/+#B86@,"5,+

F$Q,(.&:F4YG> A"$(6:3 E,:&26":B4(6&:(+6,"(+#*"(&6+:3 -$(.

F$(,#F4Y>C *+(+/,(/ E,:&26":BY+6@+( 8*8]6.

G,":/," F1C=CA4 E,:&26":B46+#,+( E&<&#"5%&(6A""5&:+6,"(

9"%F9CC] *,00,"( E,:&26":B\FC4E

="(+#. F98_8= E,:&26":BZ9RBG&:%+(3

*,2@+&#F94=YX84FF C.<,0":B8+06C0,+F&26,"(B-&.&:+#*,(,06:3 ;":82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"( +(.

E&<&#"5%&(6BG&:%+(3

40#+%FXC]8> 1:"/:+%%&A"":.,(+6":';;,2&:BC\A

CU+(+?9CEE8FF8 E,:&26":B*'-C

G,:$%9CEE8FF8 8H5&:6B86@,"5,+( 4(<&06%&(6C/&(2&

9":,Y&66&#@":069!849 E,:&26":BF&2:&6+:,+6;":1:,<+6&F&26":E&<&#"5%&(6BA"(;&.&:+6,"( ";Y":?&/,+(

8(6&:5:,0&

1,&::&!8=Y>8F 82"("%,2hA"%%&:2,+#A"$(0&##":-":86@,"5,+C(. EO,K"$6,B-:&(2@ 8%K+003B

86@,"5,+

A@:,06"5@&:XCGY8= >&+. ";F&26,"(B8\E&#&/+6,"(

1+$#XC]98=F E-4E86@,"5,+BS:,6,0@ 8%K+003 C..,0CK+K+

XCYGf,+"#,( E,<,0,"( A@,&;B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:4( A@,(+N41=AAI

XCYGf,(%,( A"$(0&##":BC;:,2+( E&5+:6%&(6BA@,(&0&*,(,06:3 ';-":&,/( C;;+,:0

XCYG_+( A"":.,(+6":BA@,(+DECAF6$.3 G:"$5

C,Q" XC9CYCS8 A"":.,(+6":;":82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"(B[+5+(&0&8%K+003B86@,"5,+

X'Y*,Q3&"(/ 1:"/:+%%&';;,2&:B\Y81

X\-+(/ C00,6+(6=&0&+:2@&:BAC498AB*'-A'*

X\[$( R&(.+,G:"$5

f\>$, E,:&26":G&(&:+#B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+N41=AAI

f\[,( 1:"/:+%%&';;,2&:B4(6&:(+6,"(+#1"<&:63 =&.$26,"( A&(6&:,( A@,(+N41=AAI

&"!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 136: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

!"#$%&'(&)*+,( -,(.,(/0+(. 1"#,23 4%5#,2+6,"(0

f\R&#+, =&0&+:2@ C.<,0":BA@,(+DC;:,2+E&<&#"5%&(6-$(.

f\8>"(/ E,:&26":BE&5+:6%&(6";E&<&#"5%&(6C00,06+(2&BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";4(6&:(+6,"(+#

9:+.&C(. 82"("%,2A""5&:+6,"(B*'-A'*

_\X$ E&5$63 E,:&26":DG&(&:+#BA@,(+8(6&:5:,0&A"(;&.&:+6,"(

_\f,( C00,06+(6=&0&+:2@ -&##"?BA@,(&0&C2+.&%3 ";1&:0"((&#F2,&(2&

_\CY_,%,(/ 1:";&00":BE&5$63 E,:&26":BA@,(+A&(6&:;":F5&2,+#82"("%,2R"(&=&0&+:2@B

F@&(U@&( \(,<&:0,63BA@,(+

S,:$Q R8Y8S8 C00,06+(6*+(+/&:BZ'4AC

E"$/#+0R@,@$+R8YG F&(,":82"("%,06BX":#. S+(QBC-F-1

R>'\X&,."(/ A@,(+A"$(6:3 E,:&26":BS$0,(&00;":F"2,+#=&05"(0,K,#,63 NSF=I

=&$K&( R\9\ -,:0F&2:&6+:3BR+%K,+( 8%K+003B86@,"5,+

'"!

782"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63 =&.$26,"()>"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+B@&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+7

Page 137: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction

%

图书在版编目 !A41" 数据

%经济转型与减贫# 中国的经验和对非洲发展的启示 .82"("%,29:+(0;":%+6,"( +(. 1"<&:63

=&.$26,"(# >"?,6@+55&(&. ,( A@,(+$ @&#5,(/ ,6@+55&( ,( C;:,2+'&$ 政策报告# 英文V中国,发展援

助委员会研究小组著L%北京# 中国财政经济出版社$ #"&&'&&

%4FSY$(- ,( ,!"$! ,+#*- ,+

%

"

'

#

经&%

$

'

#

中& %

%

'

#

扶贫,经济政策,中国,英文%

&

'

#

-&#)'(

%中国版本图书馆A41数据核字 !#"&&" 第 #+)-+& 号

%责任编辑# 吴%敏%%%%%%%%%%%%%责任校对# 李琳一

%封面设计# 九州设计%%%%%%%%%%%%版式设计# 录文通

%封面照片来源# 徐%进

出版

ZD # /001#

#

222'3451/'36

7,89:;# 3451/ <3451/'36

!版权所有%翻印必究"

社址# 北京市海淀区阜成路甲 #- 号%邮政编码# &""&)#

营销中心电话# --&$")"*%北京财经书店电话# *)"++)+*%-)")&++*

北京中兴印刷有限公司印刷%各地新华书店经销

(-( =&"$# 毫米%&* 开%-'! 印张%#+" """ 字

#"&& 年 && 月第 & 版%#"&& 年 && 月北京第 & 次印刷

定价# +"'"" 元

>?@A$(- ,( ,!"$! ,+#*- ,+BC'#(*!

!图书出现印装问题$ 本社负责调换"

本社质量投诉电话# "&" ,--&$"())

Page 138: Economic Transformation and Poverty Reduction