edible arrangements v. 1-800-flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

62
 3787983v2 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF CONNECTICUT EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS INTERNATIONAL, LLC and EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS, LLC, Plaintiffs, v. 1-!!-FLO"ERS.COM, INC. and #UNE $. DELANE% and DA$ID DELANE% d&'&a FRUIT BOU(UETS STATEN ISLAND, D)f)ndants. * * * * * * * * * * * CI$IL ACTION NO. NO$EMBER +!, +!1 COMPLAINT Plaintiffs Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Int)nati0nal, LLC and Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, LLC, t02 t)i 302ns)l, f0 t)i 30/4laint aainst t) d)f)ndants all)) as f0ll05s* INTRODUCTION 1. Tis is an a3ti0n f0 s2'stantial da/a)s and in62n3tiv) )li)f aisin 02t 0f t)  2nla5f2l a3ts '7 a di)3t 30/4)tit 0 0f t) Plaintiffs, 1- !!-Fl05)s.30/, In3. 891F:;, and,  240n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, at l)as t 0n) 0f its 4ati3i4ants i n its disti'2ti0n n)t50< 0f ind)4)nd)nt fl0ists and&0 fan3is))s 0 li3)ns))s 8))aft) )f))d t0 as 9Disti'2t0: 0 30ll)3tiv)l7 as 9Disti'2t0s:; t0 30/4)t) 2nfail7 5it Plaintiffs and t0 2s24 Plaintiffs= 00d5ill and )42tati0n in t) /a<)t4la3) '7 2sin and ind23in 0t)s t0 2s) Plaintiffs= f)d)all7 )ist))d and in30nt)sta'l) tad)/a<s, and Plaintiffs= 5)ll-<n05n and 5)ll-)ad)d 40d23t d)sin in 40/0tin, /a<)tin and s)llin 1F=s 30/4)tin lin) 0f 40d23ts. Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 1 of 62

Upload: mark-h-jaffe

Post on 02-Jun-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 1/62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 2/62

 

- + -3787983v2

+.  Plaintiffs 05n and 04)at) a 4)n0/)nall7 s233)ssf2l '2sin)ss s4)3iali>in in

t) /a<)tin and sal) 0f f)s 32t f2it d)sin)d t0 )v0<) fl0al aan)/)nts 8s0/)ti/)s

)f))d t0 as 9F2it Aan)/)nts:; and f2it 30at)d 5it 3030lat) and 0t) t044ins

80t)5is) <n05n and )f))d t0 as 9Di44)d F2it: 40d23ts;. T)s) 40d23ts a) <n05n

)n)all7 as EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS. Plaintiffs= '2sin)ss as 05n f0/ a stat24 in

t) lat) 1??!s t0 t) /0st 5)ll )30ni>)d and /0st s233)ssf2l fan3is0 0f f2it )tail s)vi3)s

in t) Unit)d Stat)s.

@.  Plaintiffs av) 3)at)d a 2ni2) s)llin i/a) and 'and id)ntit7 f0 t)i

fa/02s 00ds and s)vi3)s '2ilt 240n t)i tad)/a<s, s)vi3) /a<s, and tad) d)ss tat

id)ntif7 Plaintiffs as t) s023) 0f i 2alit7, ')a2tif2ll7 d)sin)d f)s f2it ift 40d23ts.

T)s) 'and id)ntifi)s in3l2d) fa/ili)s 0f /a<s 'as)d 240n t) t)/s Edi'l): and

B022)t, as 5)ll as 0t) /a<s and tad) d)ss 30/4is)d 0f Plaintiffs= i30ni3 si 4)tal

dais7 5it /)l0n 'all 3)nt). T)s) 'and id)ntifi)s, '0t sinl7 and 30ll)3tiv)l7, av)

')30/) ind)li'l7 ass03iat)d 5it Plaintiffs in t) 42'li3 /ind and /a<)t4la3) t02 t)

Plaintiffs= s2'stantial )ff0t and )4)ns)..

.  In +!11, 1F, a fl0al and ift )tail), )/'a<)d 0n a st)adil7 )s3alatin

3a/4ain t0 30/4)t) 2nfail7 5it Plaintiffs in t) F2it Aan)/)nt and Di44)d F2it

/a<)ts '7 3047in and infinin and ind23in 0t)s t0 3047 and infin) /2lti4l) as4)3ts 0f

Plaintiffs val2a'l) int)ll)3t2al 404)t7.

.  1F /a<)ts its 30/4)titiv) f2it 40d23ts '7 )4)at)dl7 dis4la7in and

)f))n3in Plaintiffs /0st n0ta'l) tad)/a<s and tad) d)ss in its 40/0ti0nal /at)ials,

5)'sit)s and 40d23ts. 1Fs /a<)tin /at)ials, litt))d 5it 302ntl)ss at2it02s )f))n3)s

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 2 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 3/62

 

- @ -3787983v2

t0 Plaintiffs /a<s and 40d23t d)sin, )fl)3t a st2di)d att)/4t t0 /isa4404iat) t) 00d5ill

and )42tati0n Plaintiffs av) s4)nt s0 /23 ti/), /0n)7 and )ff0t 32ltivatin.

.  N0t 30nt)nt t0 )4l0it Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= val2a'l) 00d5ill 0n its 05n, 1F

as als0 ind23)d and 3a2s)d its disti'2ti0n n)t50< 0f ind)4)nd)nt fl0ists and&0 fan3is))s

and&0 li3)ns))s and 0t)s t0 2s) and infin) Plaintiffs= val2a'l) int)ll)3t2al 404)t7 in

40/0tin and s)llin 1F=s 30/4)tin 40d23t lin).

.  M0)0v), '0t 1F and its Disti'2t0 )/')d Plaintiffs /a<s in t) idd)n

30d) f0 t)i 5)'sit)s and 1F 2s)s Plaintiffs= /a<s in <)750d adv)tisin t0 3ann)l

Plaintiffs= 32st0/)s t0 t) d)f)ndants= 5)'sit)s.

.  T) n)t )ff)3t 0f tis 2nla5f2l 30nd23t is t0 3)at) a li<)li00d 0f 30nf2si0n and

d)3)4ti0n a'02t 5)t) 1F and its n)t50< 0f Disti'2t0s )it) a) a 4at 0f Plaintiffs

'2sin)ss 0 a) 0t)5is) affiliat)d 5it 0 a2t0i>)d '7 Plaintiffs. Ind))d, as a )s2lt 0f

1F=s 2nla5f2l 30nd23t, d032/)nt)d instan3)s 0f a3t2al 30nf2si0n av) al)ad7 0332)d.

?.  T)) is n0 l)iti/at) )as0n f0 1F 0 t0s) s)llin and 40/0tin its 40d23ts

t0 2tili>) t) Plaintiffs= tad)/a<s and 40d23t d)sin in 40/0tin 1F=s 30/4)tin 40d23t

lin) and tat 2s) as 3a2s)d and 30ntin2)s t0 3a2s) s2'stantial a/ and da/a) t0 Plaintiffs

and t)i val2a'l) int)ll)3t2al 404)t7 its.

1!.  A330dinl7, Plaintiffs 'in tis a3ti0n f0 tad)/a< infin)/)nt 42s2ant t0

1 U.S.C. H 111, fals) d)sinati0n 0f 0iin and fals) adv)tisin 42s2ant t0 1 U.S.C. H

11+8a;, tad)/a< dil2ti0n 42s2ant t0 1 U.S.C. H 11+83;, 30nti'2t07 tad)/a<

infin)/)nt, 30//0n la5 2nfai 30/4)titi0n and 2nfai and d)3)4tiv) tad) 4a3ti3)s

42s2ant t0 C0nn. G)n. Stat. HH +-11!a )t s)., t0 alt t) 2nla5f2l 30nd23t 0f 1F and its

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 3 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 4/62

 

- -3787983v2

Disti'2t0, 4)s)v) Plaintiffs= ad-50n )42tati0n and 00d5ill, 40t)3t t)i val2a'l)

int)ll)3t2al 404)t7 f0/ t) i)4aa'l) a/ and t) li<)li00d 0f 30nf2si0n 3a2s)d '7 t)

D)f)ndants= a3ts and )30v) Plaintiffs= )lat)d da/a)s.

THE PARTIES

11.  Plaintiff Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Int)nati0nal, LLC 8Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

Int)nati0nal; is a D)la5a) li/it)d lia'ilit7 30/4an7 5it a 4in3i4al 4la3) 0f '2sin)ss at ?

Ban)s R0ad, "allinf0d, C0nn)3ti32t !?+.

1+.  Plaintiff Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, LLC 8Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, LLC; is a

C0nn)3ti32t li/it)d lia'ilit7 30/4an7 5it a 4in3i4al 4la3) 0f '2sin)ss at ? Ban)s R0ad,

"allinf0d, C0nn)3ti32t !?+. Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Int)nati0nal and Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts, LLC a) ))inaft) 30ll)3tiv)l7 )f))d t0 as 9Plaintiffs: 0 Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts.

1@.  D)f)ndant 1-!!-Fl05)s.30/, In3. 891F; is a D)la5a) 3040ati0n 5it a

4in3i4al 4la3) 0f '2sin)ss at 1 Old C02nt7 R0ad, S2it) !!, Cal) Pla3), N)5 %0< 111.

1.  D)f)ndants #2n) $. D)lan)7 and David D)lan)7, d&'&a F2it B022)ts Stat)n

Island 89F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island: 0 9Disti'2t0:; a) individ2als )sidin in Stat)n

Island, N)5 %0< 5it a 4in3i4al 4la3) 0f '2sin)ss at @ Pa) Av)n2), Stat)n Island, N)5

%0< 1!@!?. 1F and F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island a) ))inaft) 30ll)3tiv)l7 )f))d t0 as

9D)f)ndants.:

 JURISDICTION AND VENUE

1.  C02nts On), T50 and T)) 0f tis a3ti0n ais) 2nd) t) tad)/a< la5s 0f t)

Unit)d Stat)s, 1 U.S.C. HH 11181;8a;, 11+8a;81; and 11+83;.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 4 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 5/62

 

- -3787983v2

1.  C02nts F02 and Fiv) 0f tis a3ti0n ais) 2nd) t) 30//0n la5, a) 60in)d

5it s2'stantial and )lat)d 3lai/s aisin 02t 0f t) tad)/a< la5s 0f t) Unit)d Stat)s and

a) s0 )lat)d t0 t) 3lai/s 5itin t) 0iinal 62isdi3ti0n 0f tis C02t tat t)7 f0/ 4at 0f

t) sa/) 3as) 0 30nt0v)s7 2nd) Ati3l) III 0f t) Unit)d Stat)s C0nstit2ti0n.

1.  C02nt Si 0f tis a3ti0n ais)s 2nd) stat) la5, C0nn. G)n. Stat. H+-11!a )t

s)., is 60in)d 5it s2'stantial and )lat)d 3lai/s aisin 2nd) t) tad)/a< la5s 0f t)

Unit)d Stat)s and is s0 )lat)d t0 t) 3lai/s 5itin t) 0iinal 62isdi3ti0n 0f tis C02t tat it

f0/s 4at 0f t) sa/) 3as) 0 30nt0v)s7 2nd) Ati3l) III 0f t) Unit)d Stat)s C0nstit2ti0n.

1.  S2'6)3t /att) 62isdi3ti0n is 30nf))d 240n tis C02t 42s2ant t0 1 U.S.C.

H 11+1, + U.S.C. HH 1@@1, 1@@, 1@ and t) d03tin) 0f s244l)/)ntal 62isdi3ti0n.

1?.  Tis C02t as 4)s0nal 62isdi3ti0n 0v) 1F '7 vit2) 0f its <n05in and

int)nti0nal infin)/)nt 0f Plaintiffs= tad)/a< its and its s2'stantial and 30ntin2in

30nta3ts 5it t) Stat) 0f C0nn)3ti32t as )vid)n3)d '7, a/0n 0t) tins, t) f0ll05in*

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 5 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 6/62

 

- -3787983v2

+!.  Tis C02t as 4)s0nal 62isdi3ti0n 0v) F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island '7 vit2)

0f its <n05in and int)nti0nal infin)/)nt 0f t) tad)/a< its 0f t) Plaintiffs, '0t 0f

5i3 a) d0/i3il)d in C0nn)3ti32t.

+1.  $)n2) is 404) in tis Disti3t 42s2ant t0 + U.S.C. H1@?18'; and 83;, ')3a2s)

D)f)ndants a) s2'6)3t t0 4)s0nal 62isdi3ti0n in tis Disti3t, 1F as tansa3t)d s2'stantial

and 30ntin2in '2sin)ss in tis Disti3t, ')3a2s) a s2'stantial 4at 0f t) )v)nts 0 0/issi0ns

ivin is) t0 t) 3lai/s 0332)d in tis Disti3t, in3l2din t) int)nti0nal infin)/)nt '7

D)f)ndants 0f Plaintiffs= val2a'l) tad)/a< its, and ')3a2s) a s2'stantial 4at 0f 404)t7

tat is t) s2'6)3t 0f tis a3ti0n is sit2at)d in tis Disti3t.

GROWTH OF EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS’ BRAND AND BUSINESS

++.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Int)nati0nal is t) l)adin fan3is0 in t) f2it iftin

ind2st7, ')st <n05n f0 its atisti3all7 d)sin)d f)s F2it Aan)/)nts )v03ativ) 0f fl0al

d)sins and Di44)d F2it 40d23ts. T)s) il7 )ad)d 40d23ts a) availa'l) t02 an

)t)nsiv) n)t50< 0f fan3is)s t0202t t) Unit)d Stat)s and a'0ad, and t02 its

5)'sit)s, 3all 3)nt), 0n t) Int)n)t and a andf2l 0f 30/4an7-05n)d st0)s.

+@.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, LLC is t) 05n) and li3)ns0 0f, a/0n 0t) tins, t)

vai02s tad)/a<s, tad) d)ss, d0/ain na/)s, 3047its and 0t) int)ll)3t2al 404)t7 2s)d

and ass03iat)d 5it t) fa/02s EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS '2sin)ss and 'and, as s)t f0t

in )at) d)tail ')l05. Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, LLC li3)ns)s t)s) ass)ts t0 Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts Int)nati0nal f0 2s) and s2'li3)nsin t02 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

Int)nati0nal=s fan3is) s7st)/, 5)'sit)s and tid 4at7 Int)n)t )tail)s.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 6 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 7/62

 

- -3787983v2

+.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts is a )/a<a'l) A/)i3an s233)ss st07, '0n 02t 0f t)

)nt)4)n)2ial s4iit 0f its f02nd) and 05n), Tai Faid. M. Faid 423as)d is fist

fl05) s04 in East av)n, C0nn)3ti32t at t) a) 0f 1, and 5itin s)v)al 7)as ad 05n

is '2sin)ss t0 f02 l03ati0ns.

+.  Da5in 240n is )4)i)n3) and s233)ss as a fl0ist, M. Faid d)v)l04)d a

 2ni2) /a<)tin 40a/ 0f f)s 32t f2it 'as<)ts ')ain d)sins ins4i)d '7 fl0al

aan)/)nts. is visi0n t)n, and 30ntin2in t0da7, 5as t0 3)at) and 0ff) is 32st0/)s t)

i)st 2alit7 32t f2it in a f0/at )/inis3)nt 0f fl0al d)sins.

+.  In 1???, M. Faid 04)n)d t) fist EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS st0), t02

5i3 ) int0d23)d is 2ni2) 32t f2it aan)/)nts s32l4t)d t0 l00< li<) fl05)s and fl0al

d)sins.

+.  P0/4t)d '7 in2ii)s f0/ t0s) int))st)d in is n0v)l '2sin)ss and 3)ativ)

'andin, M. Faid ')an fan3isin is '2sin)ss in +!!1, 5it t) 04)nin 0f t) fist-)v)

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS fan3is) in "alta/, Massa32s)tts.

+.  F0/ t)n 0n, t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS 'and and '2sin)ss )4)i)n3)d

a4id 05t and )4ansi0n. B7 +!!, 62st t)) 7)as aft) t) la2n3 0f t) fist fan3is),

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 5as )30ni>)d as a/0n t) t04 !! fan3is)s in t) Unit)d Stat)s '7

Ent)4)n)2 Maa>in).

+?.  B7 +!!, t) !!t fan3is) 04)n)d in Ci3a0, and '7 +!11, tat n2/')

)a3)d 1!!!. T0da7, t)) a) 0v) 1+1 EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS st0)s in at l)ast 1+

302nti)s a02nd t) 50ld, 5it /0) tan 11!! l03at)d t0202t t) Unit)d Stat)s.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 7 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 8/62

 

- -3787983v2

@!.  B)70nd tis 05in fan3is) s7st)/, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts als0 /a<)ts its

00ds and s)vi3)s t02 a n2/') 0f additi0nal tad) 3ann)ls, in3l2din its 4042la

555.)di'l)aan)/)nts.30/ and 555.)di'l).30/ 5)'sit)s 8t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

")'sit)s;, t) 30/4an7s t0ll-f)) 3all 3)nt) 81--DOFRUIT;, a andf2l 0f 30/4an7-

05n)d st0)s, EDIBLE TO GO /all 02tl)t l03ati0ns, Jdi44)df2it.30/K,

J0s4italifts04.30/K, and A/a>0n /a<)t4la3).

@1.  In additi0n t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts sinat2) f)s F2it Aan)/)nts, t)

40d23t lin) as )4and)d t0 in3l2d) Di44)d F2it, f2it salads, f2it s2nda)s, ')v)a)s, and

vai02s 9a' and 0: 40d23ts. T) /a2is 40d23t lin) )/ains, 0f 302s), t) n05-

fa/02s f2it 40d23ts s32l4t)d in a fasi0n )/inis3)nt 0f fl0al d)sins.

@+.  As 30ni3l)d '7 t) '2sin)ss /)dia, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as 3li/')d t0 t)

 244) )3)l0n 0f fan3is0s in t) Unit)d Stat)s. F0 )a/4l), Edi'l) Aan)/)nts an<)d

nint 0n t) F0')s +!11 list 0f t04 fan3is)s t0 stat 5as na/)d 0n) 0f t) T04 1!!

Int)n)t R)tail)s '7 Int)n)t R)tail) /aa>in) 5as !t 0n Ent)4)n)2 Maa>in)s +!1@

Ent)4)n)2 Fan3is) !! and 5as an<)d @d 0n In3. /aa>in)s list 0f t04 f00d

')v)a) 30/4ani)s. M0st )3)ntl7, t) Fan3is) Ti/)s as an<)d Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

N0. 1+ in its list 0f t) 9T04 +!! Fan3is)s.:

@@.  T0da7, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts )n607s s7st)/ 5id) 0ss sal)s 0f its 'and)d

40d23ts and s)vi3)s in )3)ss 0f alf a 'illi0n d0llas ann2all7. Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

anti3i4at)s tat tis n2/') 5ill 30ntin2) t0 in3)as).

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 8 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 9/62

 

- ? -3787983v2

@.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= s4)3ta32la s233)ss is a di)3t )s2lt 0f its 30//it/)nt t0

40vidin a 30nsist)nt i 2alit7, ')a2tif2ll7 d)sin)d 40d23t tat is instantl7 )30ni>a'l)

'7 30ns2/)s as a f)s F2it Aan)/)nt /ad) '7 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts.

@.  As a )s2lt, 32st0/)s av) 30/) t0 ass03iat) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and its

val2a'l) tad) and s)vi3) /a<s as s7n0n7/02s 5it i 2alit7 and f)sn)ss. In fa3t,

30//0n 42'li3 )s40ns) t0 9Edi'l) Aan)/)nts: is 9I l0v) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts:

@.  An7 30ns2/) /is4)3)4ti0n 0 30nf2si0n as t0 t) s023) 0f an Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts 40d23t 5it D)f)ndants= 40d23ts 5ill i)4aa'l7 da/a) Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts= val2a'l) 'and and 00d5ill.

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS’

VALUABLE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY

@.  T) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts '2sin)ss is 4)di3at)d 0n t) i 2alit7 0f its 00ds

and s)vi3)s and t) 5)ll-<n05n tad)/a<s and tad) d)ss tat d)sinat) t0s) 00ds and

s)vi3)s.

@.  B7 /a<)tin and 40/0tin t)s) vai02s 'and id)ntifi)s a)ssiv)l7 in

30nn)3ti0n 5it its 2)l7 4042la 40d23ts and s)vi3)s, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as 3)at)d a

sta'l) 0f )t)/)l7 5)ll-<n05n /a<s and i30ni3 tad) d)ss tat t) 42'li3 2s)s t0 id)ntif7

and distin2is Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= 00ds in t) /a<)t4la3).

The Famous a! I"o#es#a$%e EDIBLE Ma&'s

@?.  At t) 30) 0f t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 'and is a fa/il7 0f tad)/a<s and

s)vi3) /a<s 30/4isin 0 30ntainin t) t)/s EDIBLE 0 EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS,

)it) al0n) 0 5it 0t) 50ds and&0 d)sins 830ll)3tiv)l7, t) EDIBLE Ma<s;. Edi'l)

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 9 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 10/62

 

- 1! -3787983v2

Aan)/)nts as '))n 2sin t) EDIBLE Ma<s sin3) at l)ast as )al7 as O3t0') @1, 1??

and t) EDIBLE Ma<s and vaiati0ns t))0f av) '))n )ist))d 5it t) Unit)d Stat)s

Pat)nt and Tad)/a< Offi3), in3l2din, 5it02t li/itati0n, t0s) list)d 0n Ei'it A ))t0.

!.  Pi/a7 a/0n t)s) EDIBLE Ma<s is t) fa/02s tad) na/), tad)/a< and

s)vi3) /a< EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS 8t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma<;.

1.  T) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma<, R). N0. +,?@,1, is in30nt)sta'l)

42s2ant t0 t) 40visi0ns 0f t) F)d)al Tad)/a< A3t 0f 1?, as a/)nd)d, 1 U.S.C.

H 1!1, )t s). 8t) 9Lana/ A3t:;, as is t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and L00,

R). N0. @,11,, a44)ain ')l05*

+.  T) EDIBLE Ma<s, in3l2din EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS and t) EDIBLE

ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and L00, a) '0adl7 )30ni>)d '7 t) )n)al 30ns2/in 42'li3

as id)ntif7in Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and its 40d23ts and s)vi3)s. Ind))d, t) EDIBLE

ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and L00, 5i3 4la7s 240n t) 3)ativ) a44li3ati0n 0f fl0al d)sins

t0 f2it 40d23ts, sat2at)s t) 32st0/) and tad) )4)i)n3).

@.  F0 )a/4l), t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< is 2s)d as t) na/) 0f

)v)7 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts st0) and fan3is). Ea3 s23 st0) f)at2)s sina) and vai02s

in-st0) and 40int-0f-423as) dis4la7s 0f t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and t)

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and L00, in3l2din 0n 300l)s, 302nt)s and 0t) d)30.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 10 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 11/62

 

- 11 -3787983v2

Fan3is))s at t) st0)s 5)a 3l0tin tat dis4la7s t) EDIBLE Ma<s t0 )inf03) 30ns2/)

4)3)4ti0n tat all t) 00ds and s)vi3)s t02 t) st0)s )/anat) f0/ Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts.

.  Additi0nall7, t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 40d23ts s0ld and d)liv))d t0 /an7

/illi0ns 0f 30ns2/)s ann2all7 all ')a t) EDIBLE Ma<s 0n 4a3<ain, '0)s and 0t)

ass03iat)d 30ntain)s and sal)s d032/)nts, s23 as inv0i3)s and d)liv)7 n0ti3)s.

.  Li<)5is), t) fa/ilia )fi)at)d d)liv)7 v)i3l)s tat d)liv) t)s) 40d23ts

t0 30ns2/)s 402dl7 dis4la7 t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and t) EDIBLE

ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and L00 40/in)ntl7 al0n t)i sid)s.

.  T) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS

Ma< and L00 a44)a 40/in)ntl7 at t) t04 0f )v)7 4a) 0f t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

")'sit)s, t02 5i3 302ntl)ss 30ns2/)s s04 f0 and 423as) 40d23ts 'and)d 5it t)

EDIBLE Ma<s.

.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts /a<)tin /at)ials, '032)s, 3atal0s, 30240ns and

s)ll s))ts all li<)5is) f)at2) t) EDIBLE Ma<s as a d)sinati0n 0f s023). Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts adv)tis)s a30ss all i/40tant /)dia t)l)visi0n, adi0, 4int, int)n)t,

diital, )-30//)3), and t02 s03ial /)dia, f0 )a/4l) and invaia'l7 )/4asi>)s t)

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< in t0s) adv)tis)/)nts.

.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts fan3is))s als0 2s) 40/0ti0nal /)3andis), s23 as

 6a3<)ts, sits, t-sits, ats and st0) sina) tat f2t) dis4la7 and 40/0t) t) EDIBLE

ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and L00.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 11 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 12/62

 

- 1+ -3787983v2

?.  T) )ff)3t 0f tis 30/4))nsiv) 40/0ti0n 0f EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS

Ma< and EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and L00 is tat 30ns2/)s 50 int)a3t 5it

t) 'and in an7 5a7 as 423as)s, s044)s 0 )v)n vi)5)s 0f adv)tisin 0 )fi)at)d

d)liv)7 v)i3l)s a) 30nstantl7 )/ind)d tat t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and L00 d)sinat) t) s023) 0f t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

f2it 40d23ts tat 3i32lat) )2lal7 t02 Unit)d Stat)s 30//)3).

!.  T) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< is fa/02s, as it is 5id)l7 )30ni>)d '7

t) )n)al 30ns2/in 42'li3 0f t) Unit)d Stat)s as a d)sinati0n 0f s023) 0f t) 00ds and

s)vi3)s 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, and it ')3a/) fa/02s 5)ll ')f0) 1Fs 2nla5f2l a3tiviti)s

30/4lain)d 0f ))in.

1.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts als0 2s)s and 40/0t)s /an7 diff))nt vaiati0ns 0f t)

EDIBLE Ma<s t0 )nan3) t) ass03iati0n ')t5))n t) EDIBLE Ma<s, t) 00ds and

s)vi3)s t)7 id)ntif7, and Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as t) s023) 0f t0s) 00ds and s)vi3)s.

+.  F0 )a/4l), Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as 2s)d EDIBLE, EDIBLE POPS, and

LITTLE EPRESSIONS B% EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS f0 vai02s f2it 40d23ts

EDIBLE TO GO f0 )tail s)vi3)s GET FRES "IT EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS f0

)tail, '2sin)ss /ana)/)nt, 30ns2ltin, and fan3is) s)vi3)s EDIBLE BRANDS f0

'2sin)ss /ana)/)nt and 30ns2ltin s)vi3)s EDIBLE CARES f0 3aita'l) s)vi3)s and

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS ARRANGEMENT FOAM f0 f0a/ s2440ts f0 f)s 32t f2it

aan)/)nts.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 12 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 13/62

 

- 1@ -3787983v2

@.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts als0 2s)s and 4lans t0 2s) 0t) vaiati0ns 0f t) EDIBLE

Ma<s in 30nn)3ti0n 5it vai02s additi0nal 40d23t 40/0ti0ns, ta lin)s, sl0ans and )3)ntl7

la2n3)d a 32st0/) )5ads 40a/ 3all)d EDIBLE RE"ARDS.

.  T) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS and 0t) EDIBLE Ma<s a) in))ntl7

distin3tiv). T)7 i/ainativ)l7 30/'in) t) n0/all7 dis4aat) n0ti0ns 0f fl05)

aan)/)nts, 5i3 a) dis4la7)d f0 t)i vis2al a44)al and n0t )at)n, and 32t f2it, t74i3all7

s)v)d as f00d.

.  B7 vit2) 0f tis )t)nsiv) 2sa) in 30nn)3ti0n 5it s0 /an7 il7 )ad)d

40d23ts and s)vi3)s, t) EDIBLE Ma<s av) ')30/) 5id)l7 <n05n t0 t) )n)al

30ns2/in 42'li3 0f t) Unit)d Stat)s, av) a32i)d sinifi3ant s)30nda7 /)anin, and

)4)s)nt 00d5ill 0f )n0/02s val2) t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts.

.  B)70nd t) EDIBLE Ma<s, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts als0 40/0t)s and 2s)s a

s)i)s 0f additi0nal /a<s t0 d)sinat) its 4042la f2it 40d23ts and )lat)d 00ds and

s)vi3)s.

The D(s#("#()e a! We%%*+o, BOU-UET Fam(%. o/ Ma&'s

.  Sin3) at l)ast as )al7 as 1???, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as 2s)d /a<s 30/4isin

0 30ntainin t) t)/ BOU(UET, t74i3all7 4)3)d)d '7 0n) 0 /0) 50ds, t0 d)sinat)

vaiati0ns 0f its f)s 32t f2it d)sins 8t) BOU(UET Ma<s;.

.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts fist ')an 2sin t) d)sinati0ns BERR% BOU(UET and

BERR% COCOLATE BOU(UET in 1???, f0ll05)d '7 BERR% TREE BOU(UET in +!!1,

f0 vai02s f)s-32t f2it 40d23ts.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 13 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 14/62

 

- 1 -3787983v2

?.  Sin3) tat ti/), Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as )4and)d tis fa/il7 0f /a<s t0

)/'a3) n2/)02s additi0nal vaiati0ns, in3l2din 5it02t li/itati0n, A BIRTDA%

BOU(UET, AMBITION BOU(UET, AUTUMN S"IQQLE BOU(UET, BATT%

BOU(UET, BERR% CANADIAN BOU(UET, BLAC CAT BOU(UET, BOOTASTIC

BOU(UET, BREAST CANCER A"ARENESS BOU(UET, COCOLATE BANANA

BOU(UET, CEER ME UP BOU(UET, DIPPED FRUIT BOU(UET, ETRA EFFORT

BOU(UET, FIRST MOMENTS BOU(UET, FRUITFUL ACIE$EMENT BOU(UET,

FRUIT TRUFFLES BOU(UET, OLIDA% BOU(UET, ONE% BEAR BOU(UET, #OB

"ELL DONE BOU(UET, #O%OUS BOU(UET, #UST BECAUSE BOU(UET, MERR%

GINGERBREAD MEN BOU(UET, MORNING MOTI$ATOR BOU(UET, OCANADA

BOU(UET, PATRIOTIC APPRECIATION BOU(UET, PEANUT BUTTER BOU(UET,

PEANUT BUTTER COCOLATE BOU(UET, PEARADISE BOU(UET, PRECIOUS

ARRI$AL BOU(UET, REINDEER SLEIG RIDE BOU(UET, ROC A B%E BOU(UET,

S"EET ANNI$ERSAR% BOU(UET, S"EET LIBERT% BOU(UET, S"EETEART

BOU(UET, S"EETEART S"IQQLE BOU(UET, TE ACCOMPLISMENT

BOU(UET, TE RECOGNITION BOU(UET, TRIPLE PLA% BOU(UET,

$ALENTINES S"EETIE BOU(UET, "ATERMELON I"I SUMMER BOU(UET,

"ELCOME ABOARD BOU(UET and %OURE TE BEST BOU(UET 830ll)3tiv)l7 5it

BERR% BOU(UET, BERR% COCOLATE BOU(UET and BERR% TREE BOU(UET, t)

BOU(UET Ma<s;.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 14 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 15/62

 

- 1 -3787983v2

!.  T) BOU(UET Ma<s a) in))ntl7 distin3tiv), i/ainativ)l7 30/'inin

n0ti0ns 0f its f)s 32t f2it aan)/)nts 5it t) t)/ 9'022)t,: 5i3 4)vi02sl7 5as

ass03iat)d )3l2siv)l7 5it fl05)s.

1.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts adv)tis)s and 40/0t)s its BOU(UET fa/il7 0f /a<s in

s23 a 5a7 tat t) 30ns2/in 42'li3 as 30/) t0 ass03iat) t) t)/ BOU(UET 5)n 2s)d in

30nn)3ti0n 5it 32t f2it aan)/)nts 5it Edi'l) Aan)/)nts.

+.  F0 )a/4l), Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as 0ff))d and 40/0t)d and int)nds t0

30ntin2) t0 0ff) and 40/0t) its 9B022)t 0f t) M0nt: 3l2' 5)) 30ns2/)s 300s) f0/

)it) Di44)d F2it '0)s 8t) Di44)d Dais7 Cl2'; 0 )2la F2it Aan)/)nts 8t) Dais7

Cl2'; f0 a @ /0nt /)/')si4 0 a 1+ /0nt /)/')si4.

@.  B)3a2s) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 2s)s and 40/0t)s t) BOU(UET Ma<s

)t)nsiv)l7 t02 its vai02s tad) 3ann)ls, and ')3a2s) t) 40d23ts t)7 d)sinat) a) s0

4042la and 5id)l7 423as)d and 40/0t)d a/0n 30ns2/)s, t) BOU(UET Ma<s av)

')30/) 5id)l7 <n05n t0 t) )n)al 30ns2/in 42'li3 0f t) Unit)d Stat)s, av) a32i)d

sinifi3ant s)30nda7 /)anin, and )4)s)nt 00d5ill 0f )n0/02s val2) t0 Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts.

.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, LLC 05ns n2/)02s Unit)d Stat)s f)d)al tad)/a<

)istati0ns f0 t) BOU(UET Ma<s, in3l2din 5it02t li/itati0n t0s) list)d 0n Ei'it B

))t0. R)istati0n N0s. @,+?,1 and @,+?,1 -- f0 t) BERR% BOU(UET and BERR%

TREE BOU(UET /a<s -- a) in30nt)sta'l).

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 15 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 16/62

 

- 1 -3787983v2

The D(s#("#()e a! Va%ua$%e DO FRUIT Ma&'s

.  Sin3) as )al7 as +!!, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as als0 2s)d /a<s 30/4isin 0

30ntainin t) t)/s DO FRUIT in 30nn)3ti0n 5it s)v)al 0f its 00ds and s)vi3)s 8t) DO

FRUIT Ma<s;. Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 2s)s and 40/0t)s diff))nt vaiati0ns 0f its DO

FRUIT Ma<s, in3l2din I DO FRUIT and "E DO FRUIT.

.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 2s)s t) DO FRUIT Ma<s '0t in 30nn)3ti0n 5it its f2it

40d23ts and as a d)sinati0n f0 its 0nlin) and )tail s)vi3)s )latin t0 f2it. A/0n 0t)

tins, t) DO FRUIT Ma< a44)as in Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 1--DOFRUIT 0d) n2/')

and is dis4la7)d 0n t) sid)s 0f fan3is)) )fi)at)d d)liv)7 v)i3l)s and 0n t) Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts ")'sit)s. Ea3 0f t) )/ail add)ss)s 0f t) 0v) 11!! N0t A/)i3an

fan3is))s in3040at) t) DO FRUIT Ma<s.

.  T) DO FRUIT Ma<s a) in))ntl7 distin3tiv). M0)0v), ')3a2s) Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts 2s)s and 40/0t)s t) DO FRUIT Ma<s, and ')3a2s) t) 40d23ts and s)vi3)s

t)7 d)sinat) a) 4042la a/0n 30ns2/)s, t) DO FRUIT Ma<s av) ')30/) 5)ll-<n05n,

av) a32i)d sinifi3ant s)30nda7 /)anin, and )4)s)nt 00d5ill 0f )at val2) t0 Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts.

.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, LLC 05ns t)) Unit)d Stat)s f)d)al tad)/a<

)istati0ns f0 t) DO FRUIT Ma<s, in3l2din 5it02t li/itati0n t0s) list)d 0n Ei'it C

))t0. R)istati0n N0. @,1?,? -- f0 t) /a< DO FRUIT -- is in30nt)sta'l).

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 16 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 17/62

 

- 1 -3787983v2

E!($%e A&&a0eme#s’ I"o(" S(1 Pe#a% Da(s. Des(0

?.  T) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts si 4)tal dais7 5it /)l0n 'all d)sin 8Si P)tal Dais7

D)sin; is an int)al 4at 0f t) 'and id)ntit7 tat as /ad) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts s0

s233)ssf2l.

!.  Tat d)sin, an )a/4l) 0f 5i3 a44)as ')l05, as ')30/) s7n0n7/02s 5it

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and its f)s F2it Aan)/)nts.

1.  T) Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin as '))n in3l2d)d in n2/)02s diff))nt F2it

Aan)/)nts 0ff))d '7 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts t02 its fan3is) s7st)/ and 5)'sit). T)ns

0f /illi0ns 0f 32t f2it aan)/)nts f)at2in t) Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin av) '))n disti'2t)d

 2nd) t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< '7 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, )it) di)3tl7 0

t02 its Fan3is) s7st)/ sin3) its int0d23ti0n in 1???.

+.  T) Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin is als0 a f)at2)d 40d23t in Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

EDIBLE POP 40d23t lin) 89Dais7 P04:;, int0d23)d in #an2a7 +!1. Sin3) t) int0d23ti0n

0f t) Dais7 P04, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as s0ld 0v) 1!,!!! Dais7 P04s t02 its 9in-st0):

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 17 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 18/62

 

- 1 -3787983v2

0nl7 /)3andisin. An )a/4l) 0f 05 t) Dais7 P04 is 40/0t)d is s05n ')l05*

@.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts vai02s adv)tis)/)nts and 40/0ti0nal /at)ials,

in3l2din '032)s and 5ind05 3lins, 5)'sit) 'ann)s, t)l)visi0n 30//)3ials, )/ail 'lasts,

40/0ti0n 0n s03ial /)dia 4latf0/s, and )fi)at)d d)liv)7 v)i3l) sina), 40/in)ntl7

f)at2) t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin, ')3a2s) it is s23 a st0n id)ntifi)

f0 t) 'and.

.  Li<)5is), t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts ")'sit) as 30nsist)ntl7 and 40/in)ntl7

dis4la7)d t) Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin sin3) at l)ast as )al7 as )al7 as +!!1 and as dis4la7)d

and 30ntin2)s t0 dis4la7 302ntl)ss i/a)s 0f 40d23ts ')ain t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Si

P)tal Dais7 D)sin.

.  Ind))d, t) 4i/a7 l00 2s)d f0 t) EDIBLE Ma<s f)at2)s an a'sta3t)d

da5in and d)sin /0d)l)d 0n t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin*

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 18 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 19/62

 

- 1? -3787983v2

Tis l00 )f))n3) t0 t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin )inf03)s t)

ass03iati0n ')t5))n t) 40d23t aan)/)nts and t) EDIBLE Ma<s and 'and )n)all7.

.  T) Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin as ')30/) s0 3l0s)l7 ass03iat)d 5it Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts and its sinat2) lin) 0f 40d23ts s0ld 2nd) t) EDIBLE, BOU(UET and DO

FRUIT Ma<s, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as )ist))d t) /a< 9 PETAL APPROAC: in

30nn)3ti0n 5it '2sin)ss and fan3is) /ana)/)nt s)vi3)s.

.  B)3a2s) t) Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin as ')30/) s0 3l0s)l7 ass03iat)d 5it

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and its 40d23ts, tat d)sin is Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= 40t)3ta'l) tad)

d)ss and Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as a44li)d t0 )ist) its tad) d)ss 5it t) Unit)d Stat)s

Pat)nt and Tad)/a< Offi3), S)ial N0. @1?.

.  T) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin is distin3tiv) and n0n-

f2n3ti0nal. M0)0v), t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin is v)st)d 5it

)n0/02s s)30nda7 /)anin and 00d5ill. It s)v)s t0 id)ntif7 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and its

00ds and s)vi3)s and distin2is t)/ in t) /a<)t4la3).

79.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 05ns in30nt)sta'l) Unit)d Stat)s F)d)al R)istati0n N0.

@,@@,@@ 30v)in 0n) it)ati0n 0f t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts F2it Aan)/)nt f)at2in t)

Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin, d)4i3t)d '7 t) f0ll05in da5in:

"il) tis )istati0n 30v)s 0nl7 0n) it)ati0n 0f t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 40d23ts, t) Si

P)tal Dais7 D)sin f)at2) is a <)7 )l)/)nt.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 19 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 20/62

 

- +! -3787983v2

!.  Additi0nal Ea/4l)s 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 40d23ts d)4i3tin t) 5)ll-

<n05n Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin f0ll05*

1.  T) EDIBLE, BOU(UET and DO FRUIT Ma<s a) ))inaft) 30ll)3tiv)l7

)f))d t0 as t) EA Ma<s. Individ2all7 and 30ll)3tiv)l7, t) EA Ma<s and t) Si P)tal

Dais7 D)sin av) ')30/) 3iti3al 'and id)ntifi)s f0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and sinif7 t0 t)

30ns2/in 42'li3 t) s023) 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts il7 )st))/)d and i 2alit7

40d23ts and s)vi3)s.

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS HAS

E2TENSIVELY ADVERTISED AND PROMOTED THE EA MAR+S

+.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as )4)nd)d )ta0dina7 a/02nts 0f ti/), )ff0t and

/0n)7 in d)sinin, 3)atin, d)v)l04in and 40/0tin t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 'and. "it

)s4)3t t0 its int)ll)3t2al 404)t7, s4)3ifi3all7, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as inv)st)d 302ntl)ss

02s and /an7 /illi0ns 0f d0llas in d)v)l04in, 32ltivatin and 40/0tin t) EA Ma<s,

5i3 a) a/0n t) /0st i/40tant and val2a'l) '2sin)ss ass)ts 0f t) 30/4an7.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 20 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 21/62

 

- +1 -3787983v2

@.  In t) 4ast fiv) 7)as al0n) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as s4)nt in )3)ss 0f

1@,!!!,!!!.!! in adv)tisin t) EA Ma<s.

.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as 30ntin202sl7 and 30nsist)ntl7 40/0t)d t) EA

Ma<s, in3l2din t) EDIBLE Ma<s, t) BOU(UET Ma<s, t) DO FRUIT Ma<s and t)

Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin 0n its 5)'sit) sin3) at l)ast as )al7 as +!!1.

.  In additi0n, and ')70nd t) /an7 30//)3ial 2s)s n0t)d a'0v), Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts a)ssiv)l7 adv)tis)s and 40/0t)s t) EA Ma<s t02 4int, t)l)visi0n,

adi0, 0n-lin), diital /)dia, and 40/0ti0n t02 s03ial /)dia 4latf0/s. T)s)

adv)tis)/)nts and 40/0ti0ns )2lal7 f)at2) t) EDIBLE Ma<s, t) BOU(UET Ma<s

and 0n) 0 /0) 0f t) 0t) EA Ma<s.

.  T02 t) 7)as, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as )/'a<)d 0n /an7 nati0nal /)dia

3a/4ains t02 4int, 0nlin) /)dia, s03ial /)dia and t)l)visi0n adv)tisin.

.  #2st d2in Ma7 0f +!1 al0n), Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= t)l)visi0n 30//)3ials

ai)d 2nd)ds 0f ti/)s 0n t) /0st 4042la T$ 3ann)ls, in3l2din AE, Bav0, CMT,

C00<in Cann)l, DI%, E, ESPN, F00d N)t50<, all/a<, all/a< M0vi) Cann)l,

GT$, MC, Lif)ti/), Lif)ti/) M0vi) N)t50<, NBC, O"N, O7)n, TBS, TNT, T$

Land, USA and "GN.

.  T)s) 30//)3ials an d2in /an7 4042la s05s, in3l2din C)l)'it7 "if)

S5a4, D23< D7nast7, T) Ell)n D)G)n))s S05, G)7s Anat0/7, ))4in U4 "it

T) adasians, P)a3)s Da2t), T) R)al 02s)5iv)s 0f Oan) C02nt7, T)

T0da7 S05, T2) T0i, T) $0i3), and "at3 "at a44)ns Liv).

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 21 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 22/62

 

- ++ -3787983v2

?.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts T$ 30//)3ials als0 ai)d d2in a n2/') 0f t) +!1

NBA Pla70ff and C0nf))n3) Finals a/)s, and Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as '))n ann02n3)d as

t) s40ns0 0f 3)tain a/)s.

?!.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts als0 adv)tis)s its 00ds and s)vi3)s 0n 4042la adi0

stati0ns in3l2din ESPN, CBS, i)atRadi0 and Cl)a Cann)l stati0ns li<) Q1!! 8it M2si3;,

(1!.@ 8Classi3 R03<;, 1!. 8Lit)FM;. Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= adi0 adv)tis)/)nts av)

ai)d 0n t)s) stati0ns d2in t) S4in 0f +!1, as 5)ll as /an7 ti/)s ')f0).

?1.  D2in +!1@ al0n), t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts ")'sit), 5i3 f)at2)s )v)7

as4)3t 0f t) EA Ma<s, ad @,@1,+! visits t0 t) sit) 5it 0v) @,?@,+?? tansa3ti0ns

av)ain d2in tis 4)i0d ?+,! dail7 visits 5it a440i/at)l7 1!,!! 0d)s dail7 d2in

tis sa/) 4)i0d.

?+.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts als0 adv)tis)s and 40/0t)s its 40d23ts and s)vi3)s in

30nn)3ti0n 5it t) EA Ma<s via s03ial /)dia, in3l2din 0n T5itt), Fa3)B00<, %02T2')

and Pint))st.

?@.  F0 )a/4l), Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as a 4a) 0n Pint))st tat is f0ll05)d '7

0v) @,!! Pint))st 2s)s 8555.4int))st.30/&d0f2it&; Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= Fa3)'00< 4a)

as 5)ll 0v) !,!!! 9li<)s: 8555.fa3)'00<.30/&)di'l)aan)/)nts; Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts= %02T2') 3ann)l as 2nd)ds 0f s2's3i')s and its vid)0s av) ad 0v)

@!,!!! 9vi)5s: 8555.702t2').30/&)di'l)aan)/)nts; and Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= T5itt)

4a) is f0ll05)d '7 al/0st @!,!!! T5itt) 2s)s 8tt4s*&&t5itt).30/&)di'l);. Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts 40/0t)s its EA Ma<s in 30nn)3ti0n 5it its 40d23ts 0n )a3 0f t)s) s03ial

/)dia sit)s.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 22 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 23/62

 

- +@ -3787983v2

?.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts als0 an)s )t)nsiv) 42'li3it7 and 40sitiv) )vi)5s in

4int and 0t) /)dia. Maa>in)s and n)5s4a4)s anin f0/ Ent)4)n)2, F0')s, and

In3. t0 T) N)5 %0< Ti/)s and T) "all St))t #02nal av) f)at2)d st0i)s 0n Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts, its 40d23ts and s)vi3)s, and its fa/02s 'ands. As n0t)d a'0v), /an7 0f

t)s) /aa>in)s av) an<)d Edi'l) Aan)/)nts in t) 244) ti)s 0f fan3is) and f00d

ind2st7 '2sin)ss)s.

?.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as als0 '))n f)at2)d 0n nati0nall7 s7ndi3at)d s05s s23

as T) O4a "inf)7 S05, T) D03t0s=, T) T0da7 S05, Ra3)l Ra7, T) F00d

N)t50<, T) T0n7 Dan>a S05, MSNBC=s %02 B2sin)ss and CNBC=s 40a/s T) Bi

Id)a, On t) M0n)7 and T) Call, a/0n 0t)s, and as ad 40d23t 4la3)/)nt in 9it:

s)i)s s23 as Gl)).

?.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as als0 0v) t) 7)as 4atn))d 5it n2/)02s 0t)

fa/02s 'ands t0 40/0t) its 40d23ts and its EA Ma<s, s23 as Disn)7, al)7 Davids0n,

NASCAR and $ia30/, Int)nati0nal. F0 )a/4l), Edi'l) Aan)/)nts /a<)ts and s)lls its

9S40n)'0' Bi<ini B0tt0/ B022)t: 30/'inin its 5)ll-<n05n BOU(UET /a< 5it t)

fa/02s 3aa3t) 05n)d '7 $ia30/ Int)nati0nal, In3. "it Disn)7, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as

4atn))d t0 /a<)t and s)ll, f0 )a/4l), its 9Mi3<)7 M02s) Cl2'02s) B022)t: and its

9Disn)7 Pin3)ss En3ant)d B022)t.:

?.  As a )s2lt 0f t) l0n and 30ntin202s 2s), 40/0ti0n and adv)tis)/)nt 0f t)

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts '2sin)ss and t) EA Ma<s, as 5)ll as t) )t)nsiv) 30v)a) in t)

/)dia, t) EA Ma<s av) d)v)l04)d 5id)s4)ad 30ns2/) )30niti0n. T) EA Ma<s av)

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 23 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 24/62

 

- + -3787983v2

')30/) i30ns 0f /0d)n 30//)3) and f2n3ti0n as 2ni2) s023) id)ntifi)s f0 Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts.

34F’S UNLAWFUL CONDUCT

?.  D)f)ndant 1F is a fl0al and ift )tail), ')st <n05n as a d)liv)7 s)vi3) f0

fl05)s and )lat)d ifts.

??.  U40n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, 1F di)3tl7 and t02 a disti'2ti0n n)t50< 0f

ind)4)nd)nt fl0ists and fan3is))s&li3)ns))s 40/0t)s and disti'2t)s its 40d23ts.

1!!.  U40n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, in lat) +!11 1F d)3id)d t0 )nt) int0 t) /a<)t

f0 32t f2it aan)/)nts and, at tat ti/), fist la2n3)d its 555.f2it'022)ts.30/ 5)'sit)

8t) 9Infinin ")'sit):;, 0ff)in s0/) initial f2it 40d23ts tat 1F ass03iat)d 5it fl0al

aan)/)nts and f2it 30at)d 5it 3030lat) and 0t) t044ins.

1!1.  1F as 30ntin2)d and )4and)d its 32t f2it aan)/)nt 40d23t lin) 2nd) t)

9F2it B022)ts: 'and, s)llin and 40/0tin s23 40d23ts di)3tl7 0n t) Infinin

")'sit) and t02 its disti'2ti0n n)t50< 0f ind)4)nd)nt fl0ists and fan3is))s&li3)ns))s.

1!+.  In d0in s0, 1F )/'a<)d 0n a 3a/4ain t0 int)nti0nall7 i/itat) and infin)

t) EA Ma<s and 30nf2s) 30ns2/)s int0 ')li)vin tat 1F and its 00ds and n)t50< 0f

Disti'2t0s a) s0/)05 ass03iat)d 5it 0 a440v)d '7 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, 5i3

3a/4ain as )s3alat)d and 30ntin2)s t0 st)adil7 )s3alat).

1!@.  In 4ati32la, 5)n it )nt))d t) 32t f2it aan)/)nt /a<)t in lat) +!11, 1F

30s) a d0/ain and 'and na/) - 9F2it B022)ts: - tat in3040at)d Edi'l) Aan)/)nts=

5)ll-<n05n and distin3tiv) BOU(UET Ma<s.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 24 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 25/62

 

- + -3787983v2

1!.  Sin3) tat ti/), Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and 1F av) '))n inv0lv)d in /2lti4l)

adv)s) 403))dins in t) Tad)/a< Tial and A44)al B0ad 0f t) Unit)d Stat)s Pat)nt and

Tad)/a< Offi3), 4i/ail7 0v) t) BOU(UET Ma<s 8t) 9TTAB P03))dins:;.

1!.  Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, LLC 0iinall7 fil)d 0440siti0ns aainst si a44li3ati0ns

fil)d '7 1F t0 )ist) /a<s 30/4isin 0 30ntainin FRUIT BOU(UETS. 1F )s40nd)d

'7 filin a n2/') 0f TTAB P03))dins. C2)ntl7 t)) a) @@ 4)ndin 0440siti0n and

3an3)llati0n a3ti0ns fil)d '7 1F aainst vai02s Edi'l) Aan)/)nts BOU(UET Ma<s.

1!.  M0) )3)ntl7, 1F as fil)d a 403))din t0 3an3)l Edi'l) Aan)/)nts,

LLC=s )istati0n f0 EDIBLE.

1!.  In additi0n, 240n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, ')innin d2in t) Fall 0f +!1@ and

in3)asin )2lal7 sin3) tat ti/), 1F as '))n st)adil7 ta3<in Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

'andin and tad)/a< 2s)s and in3040atin /0) and /0) 0f t) EA Ma<s and 0t)

int)ll)3t2al 404)t7 int0 its 05n infinin adv)tisin, 40d23ts, and /a<)tin.

1!.  In an int)vi)5 42'lis)d in t) O3t0') +!1@ L)ad)s Maa>in), 1Fs CEO

d)s3i')d t) 30/4an7s n)5 F2it B022)ts lin) and ann02n3)d, "it 02 F2it B022)ts

'and, 5) a) ta)tin Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, 5i3 as a '2ilt a !!-/illi0n-d0lla 3at)07

5it02t a n2/') t50 30/4)tit0. ") ai/ t0 3an) tat ... ") ')li)v) tat 5) 3an ta<) a

sinifi3ant sa) 0f t) '2sin)ss tat is al)ad7 t)) .: In 0t) int)vi)5s, t) sa/) CEO

stat)d is int)nti0n t0 4)n)tat) t) 32t f2it /a<)t in an a)ssiv) 5a7 in +!1.

1!?.  1F as 30s)n t0 ta)t Edi'l) Aan)/)nts n0t '7 d)v)l04in its 05n 'and

id)ntit7, '2t at) '7 30/4)tin 2nfail7 and infinin t) EA Ma<s. As a )s2lt, 1F is

3a2sin an aavat)d li<)li00d 0f 30nf2si0n and in fa3t a3t2al 30nf2si0n a/0n 30ns2/)s.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 25 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 26/62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 27/62

 

- + -3787983v2

Tis is a 'latant att)/4t '7 1F t0 div) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= 32st0/)s t0 its Infinin

")'sit).

11@.  M0)0v), 0n3) a 30ns2/) l00<in f0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as '))n l2)d t0

1F=s Infinin ")'sit), tat 30ns2/) 3ann0t ') an7tin 0t) tan 30nf2s)d '7 1Fs

infinin 30nd23t. Tat infin)/)nt is 0'vi02s 5it a )vi)5 0f t) Infinin ")'sit),

5i3 /a<)s )4)at)d )f))n3) t0 t) EA Ma<s '0t in its idd)n 30d) and a/4antl7

t0202t t) )4)ss 30nt)nt 0f t) Sit).

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 27 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 28/62

 

- + -3787983v2

11.  F0 )a/4l), 5)n 30ns2/)s fist visit t) Infinin ")'sit)=s 0/)4a),

)it) '7 t74in in t) int)n)t add)ss 0 s)a3in via G00l), t)7 a) ))t)d 5it a 4a)

titl) 0f 9Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nts: 40siti0n)d 0n a ta' i//)diat)l7 a'0v) t) d0/ain na/)*

8)/4asis add)d;. 9Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nts: is, 0f 302s), a 'latant )f))n3) t0 t)

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and, 5it 0nl7 t) d)s3i4tiv) 50d 9f2it: ins)t)d

')t5))n t) Ma<=s t50 50ds is 30nf2sinl7 si/ila t0 EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS.

11.  M0)0v), 1F 62ta40s)s tat infinin titl) 5it vai02s )f))n3)s t0

9'022)ts,: t2s inv0<in Edi'l) Aan)/)nts BOU(UET Ma<s and )4l0itin t)

li<)li00d tat 30ns2/)s 5ill 4)3)iv) t) 4ati)s t0 ') t) sa/) 0 s0/)05 30nn)3t)d 0

affiliat)d.

11.  U40n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, 1F d)li')at)l7 40a//)d t) 30d) f0 t) 0/)

4a) 0f t) Infinin ")'sit) t0 dis4la7 Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nts as t) titl) 0f t) 4a) in

t) '05s) ta', as ill2stat)d '7 t) f0ll05in 30d) ass03iat)d 5it t) 0/)4a)*

<title>Edible Fruit Arrangements I Chocolate Strawberries I FruitBouquets(SM)</title>  

8)/4asis add)d;.

11.  T) /)tadata f0 t) Infinin ")'sit) 30ntains t50 si/ila, at2it02s 2s)s 0f

t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma<, as d)4i3t)d in t) f0ll05in 30d) ass03iat)d 5it t)

0/)4a)*

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 28 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 29/62

 

- +? -3787983v2

<meta name="descrition" content="Send a delicious treat with FruitBouquet(SM)! ach edible arrangement #eatures a $ariet% o# #resh #lower shaed#ruit& chocolate co$ered strawberries 'am more!"/>

<a hre#="/howtocreatea#ruitbou*uet+cm,s=#ruitbou*uets,homea*e,

#reshtal-articlehowtocreate#ruit" name="FB,C.001">2ow to Create anEdible Fruit Arrangement ></a><br>

8)/4asis add)d;. N0ta'l7, t) fist )f))n3) a'0v) d0)s n0t a3t2all7 a44)a 0n t)

0/)4a) its)lf.

11.  Ind))d, )v)n t) 40st-d0/ain 4at 0f t) URL 0f n2/)02s 4a)s 0f t)

Infinin ")'sit) ')ta7 t) d)li')at) )/')ddin 0f t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma<

in 0ani>ati0nal 30d), as d)4i3t)d in t) f0ll05in*

8)/4asis add)d;.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 29 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 30/62

 

- @! -3787983v2

11?.  U40n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, 1F ins)t)d t)s) )f))n3)s t0 t) EDIBLE

ARRANGEMENTS Ma< as a titl) and in t) 30d) f0 t) Infinin ")'sit) t0 /ani42lat)

s)a3 )nin) s)a3 )s2lts and di)3t 5)' 32st0/)s s)a3in f0 t) )al Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts t0 t) Infinin ")'sit) and 1Fs 05n 40d23ts and s)vi3)s.

34F Is Us(0 The EA Ma&'s O The I/&(0(0 We$s(#e

1+!.  M0) tans4a)ntl7, t) Infinin ")'sit) is if) 5it n2/)02s )4)ss 2s)s 0f

t) EA Ma<s.

1+1.  1F is 2sin t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< 0 d)sinati0ns tat a)

30nf2sinl7 si/ila t0 tat Ma< in 40d23t d)s3i4ti0ns, adv)tisin 3047, and 0t) 2s)s in

30nn)3ti0n 5it and f0 4240s)s 0f 40/0tin sal) 0f 1Fs 40d23ts.

1++.  F0 )a/4l), t) Infinin ")'sit)s 0/)4a) and s)v)al 0t) 4a)s

t0202t t) sit) f)at2) t) f0ll05in invitati0n t0 C)at) an Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nt*

8)/4asis add)d;. N0ta'l7, 3li3<in 0n tis lin< l)ads t0 a 4a) tat /a<)s n0 )f))n3) t0 an

Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nt, 8as s05n ')l05; s0 t) 2s) 0f tis 30nf2sinl7 si/ila d)sinati0n

0n t) 0/) 4a) f2n3ti0ns t0 /isl)ad 30ns2/)s int0 ')li)vin tat t)7 a) a33)ssin )n2in)

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 30 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 31/62

 

- @1 -3787983v2

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 30nt)nt and t0 2nfail7 /ani42lat) 0ani3 s)a3 )nin) )s2lts.

1+@.  T)) is n0 )as0n f0 1F t0 d)s3i') its f2it 40d23ts -- 5i3 a) s)lf-

)vid)ntl7 40d23ts f0 30ns2/4ti0n -- as 9)di'l): 0t) tan t0 ass03iat) 1F 5it Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts and its fa/02s tad)/a<s. T)s) int)nti0nal )f))n3)s n0t 0nl7 ')ta7 1F=s

 2nla5f2l s3)/) t0 /isa4404iat) t) 00d5ill in))nt in t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS

Ma< '2t als0 s)v) t0 /isl)ad 30ns2/)s a'02t t) s023) 0f 1F=s 40d23ts. T)7

f2t)/0) ass2) tat int)n)t s)a3 )nin)s li<) G00l) 5ill di)3t 5)' s044)s s))<in

9Edi'l) Aan)/)nts: t0 1F=s Infinin ")'sit).

1+.  N2/)02s 0t) 4a)s 0f t) Infinin ")'sit) /a<) )4)at)d i/404) 2s)s

0f t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< '0t t0 )n)at) visits f0/ 502ld-') Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts Int)n)t s044)s and 30nf2s) 30ns2/)s int0 ')li)vin tat t)7 a) vi)5in an

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 31 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 32/62

 

- @+ -3787983v2

a2t0i>)d Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 40d23t. R)4)s)ntativ) )a/4l)s 0f t)s) infinin 2s)s

in3l2d)*

8)/4asis add)d;.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 32 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 33/62

 

- @@ -3787983v2

1+.  1F as als0 /i/i3<)d Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= fa/il7 0f BOU(UET Ma<s,

300sin d)li')at)l7 t0 id)ntif7 4ati32la f2it aan)/)nts 5it t) t)/ B022)t t0

/ai/i>) t) fals) i/4)ssi0n tat 1F is in s0/) 5a7 30nn)3t)d t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, as

ill2stat)d '7 t) f0ll05in*

8)/4asis add)d;.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 33 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 34/62

 

- @ -3787983v2

1+.  T)s) 2s)s /i/i3 t) f0/at and 30nt)t 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= BOU(UET

Ma<s '7 403))din t) t)/ B022)t 5it 0t) t)/s and 2sin t)s) d)sinati0ns as

40d23t tad)/a<s f0 4ati32la 32t f2it 'as<)ts.

1+.  Pati32lal7 iv)n all t) 0t) 2s)s 0f t) EA Ma<s, s044)s 0n t) Infinin

")'sit) 5ill nat2all7 ass2/) tat 1Fs 9B022)t: 40d23ts, s23 as its Ma<) T)i Da7

B022)t and %02 B)st S/il) B022)t, a) 4at 0f t) sa/) lin) 0f 40d23ts Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts d)sinat)s 2nd) its BOU(UET fa/il7, s23 as CEER ME UP BOU(UET,

ETRA EFFORT BOU(UET, #OB "ELL DONE BOU(UET, "ELCOME ABOARD

BOU(UET and %OURE TE BEST BOU(UET.

1+.  M0) s2'tl7 '2t n0 l)ss insidi02sl7, 0t) 4a)s 0f t) Infinin Sit) f)at2)

vaiati0ns 0f t) EDIBLE Ma<s t0 )nan3) t) fals) i/4)ssi0n tat 1Fs 40d23ts d)iv)

f0/ 0 a) 4at 0f t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts lin) 0f f2it it)/s, as ill2stat)d '7 t) f0ll05in*

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 34 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 35/62

 

- @ -3787983v2

8)/4asis add)d;. 9Edi'l) '022)ts,: as dis4la7)d a'0v), is a 30nflati0n 0f t50 0f t) /0st

i/40tant 0f t) EA Ma<s.

1+?.  F2t), 1F 2s)s t) t)/ 9Edi'l) B022)ts: 0n 4a)s 0f t) sit) tat d0 n0t

s)ll t)i 9'022)t: 40d23ts.

1@!.  Tis 9'ait and s5it3: ta3ti3 is 4ati32lal7 da/ain t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

5)n 30/'in)d 5it 1F=s 2s) 0f t) EDIBLE Ma<s in its <)750d adv)tisin and in its

/)tadata t0 div) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= 32st0/)s t0 t) Infinin ")'sit).

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 35 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 36/62

 

- @ -3787983v2

1@1.  In 4ati32la, 0n3) a 30ns2/) visits t) Infinin ")'sit), div)n t)) '7

1F=s 2nla5f2l 2s) 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= fa/02s Ma<s in its /)tadata and as <)750ds

5it )v)7 /a60 s)a3 )nin), 1F=s Infinin ")'sit) )2i)s tat t) 30ns2/) in42t a

>i4 30d) ')f0) dis4la7in 40d23ts availa'l) in t) 30ns2/)=s a)a. U40n inf0/ati0n and

')li)f, 1F=s 32t f2it aan)/)nts a) n0t availa'l) in /an7 a)as 0f t) 302nt7 and, 5)n a

30ns2/) f0/ 0n) 0f t0s) a)as in42ts is 0 ) >i4 30d), t) a'0v) )s2lts a) dis4la7)d --

/isl)adin t) 30ns2/) 50 5as s)a3in f0 t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts ")'sit) t0 ')li)v)

tat t)) a) n0 32t f2it aan)/)nts availa'l) in is 0 ) )0a4i3 a)a.

1@+.  F2t) )a3)'atin tis 9'ait and s5it3: ta3ti3, t) 30ns2/) is 2n<n05inl7

)di)3t)d t0 1F=s 0t) 5)'sit)s s23 as 1!!Fl05)s.30/ 0 1!!'as<)ts.30/ 5)) )&s)

is n05 s05n 1F=s 0t) ift 40d23ts s23 as 300<i)s, 3a<)s and fl05)s inst)ad 0f t)

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 40d23ts )&s) 5as 0iinall7 s))<in t0 423as).

1@@.  1F als0 /a<)s infinin and il7 30nf2sin 2s) 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

DO FRUIT Ma<s 0n t) Infinin ")'sit) '7 adv)tisin 40/0 30d)s f0 423as) 0f its

it)/s as f0ll05s*

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 36 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 37/62

 

- @ -3787983v2

1@.  T0 3)/)nt t) i/4)ssi0n tat 1F is )it) 4at 0f 0 ass03iat)d 5it Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts, 1F s3242l02sl7 304i)s t) i30ni3 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin

as 5)ll as Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 0v)all aan)/)nt d)sins.

1@.  N2/)02s 0f 1Fs f2it aan)/)nts 2s) a si 4)tal dais7 30nf2sinl7 si/ila

t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= i30ni3 Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin. F0 )a/4l)*

1@.  M0)0v), 1F as )4)at)dl7 and 'a>)nl7 304i)d /an7 0f t) 0v)all d)sins

0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= 32t f2it 'as<)ts. F0 )a/4l)*

34F’s P&o!u"#  E!($%e A&&a0eme#s’ P&o!u"# 

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 37 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 38/62

 

- @ -3787983v2

34F’s P&o!u"#  E!($%e A&&a0eme#s’ P&o!u"# 

1@.  T0 )v)n f2t) 30nf2s) 32st0/)s, 1F is )v)n 2sin a si 4)tal dais7 d)sin 0n

)v)7 4a) 0f t) Infinin ")'sit) in t) ta' l03at)d in t) 244) l)ft 30n) 0f t) 5)'4a)

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 38 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 39/62

 

- @? -3787983v2

5it t) 50ds 9Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nts: as d)4i3t)d ')l05.

1@.  ")n 1F /a<)ts 00ds 2sin t) Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin and 3047in t)

0v)all d)sin 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= 32t f2it aan)/)nts and d0)s s0 in 30n62n3ti0n 5it

)4)at)d, 30ns4i3202s )f))n3)s t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nts,

Edi'l) B022)ts:, B022)t, and DO FRUIT, 30ns2/)s a) ind23)d f0/ all di)3ti0ns

t0 ')li)v) tat t)7 a) 423asin 00ds s023)d f0/, a2t0i>)d '7 0 0t)5is) 30nn)3t)d t0

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts.

34F Is Us(0 #he EA Ma&'s o I#s O, We$s(#e a! o Th(&! Pa&#. We$s(#es

1@?.  1F d0)s n0t li/it its infin)/)nt t0 t) Infinin ")'sit). It is als0 2sin

t) 30nf2sinl7 si/ila d)sinati0n 0n its 05n 5)'sit), 555.1!!fl05)s.30/*

3e4re the best choice when shoin* #or *i#ts and #lowers 5ust because& or #orsecial occasions li-e Mother4s 6a% or 7alentine4s 6a%8 Choose the er#ect *i#t#rom the best selection o# roses& mi9ed bouquets& edible fruit arrangements&*ourmet bas-ets& and other *i#ts8 3ith a wide $ariet% o# colors& si:es andseasonal themes& we ha$e #lowers and *i#ts #or e$er%one8 3ith sameda% *i#tdeli$er%& we4re also %our source #or lastminute *i#ts& too!

8)/4asis add)d;

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 39 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 40/62

 

- ! -3787983v2

1!.  1F 2s)s tat sa/) 30nf2sinl7 si/ila d)sinati0n 0n tid-4at7 5)'sit)s, s23

as 555.a44l).30/*

11.  U40n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, 1F als0 2s)s t) 9DO FRUIT: Ma< in its

adv)tisin 0n tid 4at7 5)'sit)s, s23 as 555.30240ns.30/. F0 )a/4l)*

1+.  M0)0v), 1F as, t02 its a)nts at 555.30240ns.30/, 2s)d and

dis4la7)d t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma<

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 40 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 41/62

 

- 1 -3787983v2

and L00 in 30nn)3ti0n 5it its 9DO FRUIT: 30240n 3a/4ain. F0 )a/4l)*

U40n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, 1F and its a)nt, C0240ns.30/, In3., av) int)nti0nall7

att)/4t)d t0 30nf2s) 30ns2/)s and av) s233))d)d in d0in s0.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 41 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 42/62

 

- + -3787983v2

34F INDUCED ITS DISTRIBUTORS AND OTHERS TO INFRINGE

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS’ VALUABLE INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY RIGHTS

1@.  1F=s s3)/) and 302s) 0f 30nd23t t0 2s24 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= val2a'l)

00d5ill )t)nds t0 its 9F2it B022)t: n)t50< 0f Disti'2t0s and adv)tisin a)nts.

1.  1F as, 240n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, ind23)d and 3a2s)d its Disti'2t0s and

0t)s t0 infin) 0n t) EA Ma<s, in3l2din t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma<, t)

BOU(UET Ma<s, t) Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin and t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma<

and L00.

1.  As an initial /att), 1F=s n)t50< 0f Disti'2t0s s)llin 1F=s 9F2it

B022)t: lin) 0f 40d23ts a), 240n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, s)llin and 40/0tin 1F=s

9B022)t: 40d23ts 5i3, as dis32ss)d a'0v), infin) 0n Edi'l) Aan)/)nts BOU(UET

Ma<s.

1.  M0)0v), t) 1F Disti'2t0s a), 240n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, s)llin,

disti'2tin and 40/0tin 1F 40d23ts tat f)at2) a si 4)tal dais7 d)sin tat is 30nf2sinl7

si/ila t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts i30ni3 Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin.

1.  Ev)n /0) t02'lin, /an7 0f t) 1F n)t50< 0f Disti'2t0s a) 2sin

d)sinati0ns tat a) si/ila 0 id)nti3al t0 t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma<.

1.  F0 )a/4l), as all))d ')l05, d)f)ndant F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island is 2sin

t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and t) 30nf2sinl7 si/ila 9Edi'l) F2it

Aan)/)nt: d)sinati0n in t) /)tadata f0 its 5)'sit), 555.f2it'022)tstat)nisland.30/,

in an )ff0t t0 30nf2s) and d)3)iv) 32st0/)s. F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island is als0 2sin t)

30nf2sinl7 si/ila 9Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nt: d)sinati0n 0n its 5)'sit), 5)) it is s)llin

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 42 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 43/62

 

- @ -3787983v2

9B022)t: 40d23ts tat in3040at) a si 4)tal dais7 tat is 30nf2sinl7 si/ila t0 Plaintiffs=

Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin.

1?.  Si/ilal7, t) 1F disti'2t0 9Fl05)s '7 Addalia,: 0n t) 5)'sit)

f2it'022)tst0/siv).30/, is 2sin t) 30nf2sinl7 si/ila d)sinati0n 9Edi'l) F)s F2it

Aan)/)nt: t0 /a<)t and 40/0t) 1F=s 9F2it B022)ts: 'and.

1!.  Tis Disti'2t0 as si/4l7 add)d t) 4as) 9f)s f2it: in t) /iddl) 0f t)

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma<. Tis 30nf2sinl7 si/ila d)sinati0n, 5i3 is ')in 2s)d

and dis4la7)d in 30nn)3ti0n 5it 1F=s 9B022)t: 40d23ts f)at2in a si 4)tal dais7, is

si/ilal7 3al32lat)d t0 30nf2s) and d)3)iv) 30ns2/)s.

11.  1F Disti'2t0 "at)/ill Fl05)s F2it B022)ts, 5i3 t02ts its)lf as 9t)

1 Fl0ist 0f C0i3) f0 !!-Fl05)s Od)s in B05ad C02nt7: 0n its 5)'sit),

555.5at)/illfl05)s.30/, is 2sin t) 30nf2sinl7 si/ila d)sinati0n 9Edi'l) F2it

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 43 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 44/62

 

- -3787983v2

B022)ts: in its l00*

as 5)ll as t) 30nf2sinl7 si/ila d)sinati0ns 9Edi'l) F2it B022)t Aan)/)nts: and

9Edi'l) F2it B022)t Tainin Class)s: t0 40/0t) t) 1F lin) 0f 40d23ts.

1+.  M0)0v), tis 1F Disti'2t0 as )/')dd)d 0n its sit) a %02T2') vid)0

t02tin its '2sin)ss, at t) 30n3l2si0n 0f 5i3 t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and

L00 a) 40/in)ntl7 dis4la7)d. 

1@.  Tat dis4la7 0f t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and L00 lin<s t0 an

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts %02T2') vid)0. F0ll05in tat lin< d0)s n0t ta<) t) vi)5) t0 Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts= %02T2') 3ann)l, 05)v). Rat), tat lin< 0n t) 1F Disti'2t0=s

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 44 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 45/62

 

- -3787983v2

5)'sit) dis4la7s Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= vid)0 fa/)d 0n t) 1F Disti'2t0=s 5)'sit),

in3l2din t) f0ll05in i/a)s, a/0n 0t)s*

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 45 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 46/62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 47/62

 

- -3787983v2

FRUIT BOU-UETS STATEN ISLAND’S UNLAWFUL CONDUCT

1.  U40n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island, 5i3 t02ts its)lf as

94at 0f t) 1-!!Fl05)s.30/ fa/il7,: is a 4at 0f 1F=s n)t50< 0f Disti'2t0s.

1?.  Si/ila t0 1F, F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island is 2sin t) 30nf2sinl7 si/ila

9Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nt: d)sinati0n 0n its 5)'sit), 555.f2it'022)tstat)nisland.30/*

1!.  It is als0 2sin t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and t) 30nf2sinl7

si/ila 9Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nts: d)sinati0n in its /)tadata*

<meta name="descrition" content="Same da% deli$er% Fruit Bouquet& FreshFruit ;rran*ements& Edible Fruit Arrangements in Staten Island 8 ;rtisticall%desi*ned #ruit arran*ements #or birthda%s& anni$ersar%& new bab%& s%math% oran% occasion8 etals on a a*e will deli$er Fruit Bouquets ri*ht to %our door8"/>

<meta name="-e%words" content="Edible Arrangements& Fruit ;rran*ements&Floral Bouquets& Chea i#ts& Chea Funerals& S%math% Flowers& S%math%Fruit Bas-ets& S%math% Edible Fruit & Church 6ecorators& Church 6ecorations&0roical Flowers& Chocolates ;nd Stu##ed ;nimals& Funeral Fruit Bouquets&S%math% i#t& S%math% Flowers& S%math% Bas-ets& Chea Flower 6eli$er%&S%math% Flowers& Flower ;rran*ements& S%math% Flower 6eli$er%& Funeral

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 47 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 48/62

 

- -3787983v2

 ;rran*ements& ?ose ;rran*ements& Funeral Fruit Bouquets& et 3ell i#ts& et3ell i#t Bas-ets& Coo-ie Bas-ets& et 3ell i#t Bas-et& Best i#t Bas-ets&

 ;nni$ersar% i#ts" />

8)/4asis add)d;.

11.  T) 2s) 0f 9Edi'l) Aan)/)nts: and 9Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nts: in

30nn)3ti0n 5it t) 30nf2sin si/ila 9B022)t: and 9F2it B022)t: d)sinati0ns and t)

40/in)ntl7 dis4la7)d si 4)tal dais7 0n F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island=s 5)'sit) a) 3al32lat)d

t0 30nf2s) 32st0/)s int0 ')li)vin tat t)) is an ass03iati0n ')t5))n F2it B022)ts Stat)n

Island and Edi'l) Aan)/)nts.

DEFENDANTS’ UNLAWFUL CONDUCT

HAS CAUSED AND CONTINUES TO CAUSE CONFUSION IN THE

MAR+ET AND HAS HARMED AND DAMAGED EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS

1+.  1F is 2sin and ind23in 0t)s t0 2s) 30nf2sinl7 si/ila d)sinati0ns and

d)sins in 30nn)3ti0n 5it t) 40/0ti0n and sal) 0f its 40d23ts in 0d) t0 3)at) an

ass03iati0n ')t5))n 1F and Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= fa/02s EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS

Ma<s and val2a'l) and distin3tiv) EDIBLE Ma<s, BOU(UET Ma<s and DO FRUIT

Ma<s, and Si P)tal Dais7 D)sin in t) /inds 0f t) 30ns2/in 42'li3.

1@.  Ind))d, F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island is 2sin n0t 0nl7 30nf2sinl7 si/ila

d)sinati0ns s23 as 9Edi'l) F2it Aan)/)nts: and vaiati0ns 0f t) BOU(UET Ma<s, '2t

it is als0 2sin t) in30nt)sta'l) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma<.

1.  T)s) int)nti0nal )f))n3)s ass2) tat int)n)t s)a3 )nin)s li<) G00l) 5ill

di)3t 5)' s044)s s))<in 9Edi'l) Aan)/)nts: t0 1F=s infinin 40d23t lin). F2t),

t)s) int)nti0nal )f))n3)s n0t 0nl7 ')ta7 D)f)ndants= 2nla5f2l s3)/) t0 /isa4404iat) t)

00d5ill in))nt in t) EA Ma<s '2t als0 s)v) t0 /isl)ad 30ns2/)s a'02t t) s023) 0f

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 48 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 49/62

 

- ? -3787983v2

1Fs 40d23ts and t) ass03iati0n ')t5))n Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and 1F and its n)t50< 0f

Disti'2t0s, in3l2din F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island.

1.  T) Infinin ")'sit) and t) F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island 5)'sit) )a3 2s)s

t) EA Ma<s and F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island 0)s s0 fa as t0 2s) t) EDIBLE

ARRANGEMENTS Ma<, its)lf, in /)tadata.

1.  T)s) infinin 2s)s 0f t) EA Ma<s a) a 3l)a )ff0t t0 div)t Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts= 32st0/)s t0 t) infinin 5)'sit)s, 3)atin t) fals) i/4)ssi0n tat 1F

)it) is 0 is 30nn)3t)d t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and 3a2sin 30ns2/)s t0 ass03iat) Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts fa/02s and distin3tiv) Ma<s 5it 1F=s 9F2it B022)ts: '2sin)ss and

n)t50< 0f Disti'2t0s.

1.  T2s, 5it dis)ad f0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts BOU(UET Ma<s, t)

Infinin ")'sit) and t) 5)'sit)s 0f 1F=s n)t50< 0f Disti'2t0s, in3l2din F2it B022)ts

Stat)n Island, 2s) F2it B022)ts as t) na/) f0 t)i 0nlin) '2sin)ss)s, t) na/) f0 1F=s

40d23ts, and in t) 1F l00. As dis4la7)d a'0v), t) Infinin ")'sit) als0 30/'in)s

)f))n3)s t0 '022)ts 5it )di'l) t0 /ai/i>) t) fals) i/4)ssi0n tat t) 4ati)s a)

30nn)3t)d in s0/) 5a7.

1.  Giv)n Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 2s) and adv)tis)/)nt 0f its DO FRUIT Ma<s

sin3) +!!, and Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 2s) 0f t) DO FRUIT Ma< as 4at 0f its t0ll-f))

t)l)40n) f0 0d)s, 30ns2/)s )n302nt)in 1Fs DO FRUIT 40/0 30d)s 5ill nat2all7

ass2/) tat t) 30d)s a44l7 t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 40d23ts 0 a) 0t)5is) a2t0i>)d '7

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, 4ati32lal7 5)n it is 2s)d in 30/'inati0n 5it Edi'l) Aan)/)nts=

EDIBLE Ma<s and EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< and L00.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 49 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 50/62

 

- ! -3787983v2

1?.  Ind))d, 1F=s infin)/)nts a) al)ad7 3a2sin a3t2al 30nf2si0n a/0n t)

423asin 42'li3. F0 )a/4l), 32st0/)s av) 4)s)nt)d 1F=s 30240ns f0 )d)/4ti0n 0n

t) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts ")'sit), and av) ti)d t0 0d) 40d23t vi)5)d 0n t) 1F 5)'sit)

at l03al Edi'l) Aan)/)nts )tail l03ati0ns, and av) 30nta3t)d Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

30n3)nin 0d)s 4la3)d 0n t) Infinin ")'sit), ')li)vin tat t0s) 0d)s 5)) 4la3)d

5it Edi'l) Aan)/)nts.

1!.  T) da/a) t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts f0/ t) 2s) 0f its in30nt)sta'l) DO

FRUIT Ma< al0n), 0v) t) t50-da7 4)i0d tat Edi'l) Aan)/)nts is a5a) 0f, )3))ds

!!,!!!.

11.  T) li<)li00d 0f 30nf2si0n - and t) a3t2al 30nf2si0n tat as al)ad7 0332)d -

is )a3)'at)d '7 t) fa3t tat 1F and F2it B022)ts Stat)n Island /a<)t t) 1F 40d23ts t0

t) sa/) 3lass 0f 30ns2/)s t0 50/ Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= 40d23ts and s)vi3)s a) /a<)t)d

and s0ld.

1+.  U40n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, D)f)ndants= a3ts d)s3i')d a'0v) 5)) <n05inl7,

int)nti0nall7 and 5illf2ll7 and 30//itt)d 5it <n05l)d) 0f and dis)ad f0 Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts its.

1@.  D)f)ndants= 3al32lat)d i/itati0n and infin)/)nt 0f t) EA Ma<s is li<)l7 t0

3a2s), and is in fa3t 3a2sin 30nf2si0n, /ista<) and d)3)4ti0n a/0n t) 30ns2/in 42'li3 as

t0 t) s023) and 0iin 0f D)f)ndants= 00ds and s)vi3)s, and is li<)l7 t0 d)3)iv) and as

d)3)iv)d t) 42'li3 int0 ')li)vin tat D)f)ndants= 00ds and s)vi3)s 0iinat) f0/, a)

ass03iat)d 5it 0 a) a2t0i>)d '7 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, 0 tat Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

s40ns0s, 05ns, )nd0s)s, a440v)s 0 0t)5is) is 30//)3iall7 inv0lv)d 5it 0 )lat)d t0

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 50 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 51/62

 

- 1 -3787983v2

D)f)ndants= '2sin)ss and&0 tat D)f)ndants= 00ds and s)vi3)s a) f0/ t) sa/) s023) as

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, all t0 t) da/a) and d)ti/)nt 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= )42tati0n,

00d5ill and sal)s.

1.  U40n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, '7 vit2) 0f its 2nla5f2l 30nd23t, D)f)ndants av)

al)ad7 /ad) 0 5ill 30ntin2) t0 /a<) s2'stantial 40fits and ains t0 5i3 t)7 a) n0t in

la5 0 )2it7 )ntitl)d.

1.  D)f)ndants= 30nd23t 30nstit2t)s a 3lassi3 f0/ 0f 2nfai 30/4)titi0n* D)f)ndants

a) 2nla5f2ll7 a4404iatin t) val2a'l) )42tati0n and 00d5ill 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and

its 40d23ts f0 its 05n 30//)3ial ain, all in 30ntav)nti0n 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts=

in30nt)sta'l) tad)/a< its.

1.  As a )s2lt 0f D)f)ndants= a3ti0ns, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts and its fan3is))s

av) '))n da/a)d in an a/02nt t0 ') finall7 d)t)/in)d at tial, '2t 240n inf0/ati0n and

')li)f, is at t) ti/) 0f filin tis 30/4laint at l)ast ?,11,!!!.

1.  M0)0v), t) 2nla5f2l a3tiviti)s 0f D)f)ndants av) )s2lt)d and 5ill 30ntin2)

t0 )s2lt in i)4aa'l) a/ and in627 t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts. A/0n 0t) a/s, t)s)

a3ts d)4iv) Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 0f its a's0l2t) it t0 d)t)/in) t) /ann) in 5i3 its

i/a) is 4)s)nt)d t0 t) )n)al 42'li3 d)3)iv)s t) 42'li3 as t0 t) 0iin and s40ns0si4 0f

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 00ds and s)vi3)s 50nf2ll7 tad) 240n Edi'l) Aan)/)nts

)42tati0n and )3l2siv) its in its int)ll)3t2al 404)t7 and, t0 l)ss)n 30ns2/)s

4)3)4ti0n 0f t) 2alit7 0f Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 'and, 00ds and s)vi3)s.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 51 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 52/62

 

- + -3787983v2

COUNT ONE5 6T&a!ema&' I/&(0eme# Pu&sua# #o 37 U8S8C8 9 333: A0a(s# A%%

De/e!a#s; 

1.  Paaa4s 1-1, a'0v), a) )4)at)d and )-all))d as if f2ll7 s)t f0t ))in.

1?.  D)f)ndants= a3tiviti)s as d)s3i')d a'0v) 30nstit2t) tad)/a< infin)/)nt in

vi0lati0n 0f s)3ti0n @+ 0f t) Lana/ A3t, 1 U.S.C. H11181;8A;.

1!.  B7 vit2) 0f t) f0)0in, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as '))n da/a)d and 5ill

30ntin2) t0 ') da/a)d a's)nt )li)f f0/ tis C02t.

COUNT TWO5 6Fa%se Des(0a#(o o/ O&(0( Pu&sua# #o 37 U8S8C8 9 33<76a; A0a(s#

A%% De/e!a#s; 

11.  Paaa4s 1-1!, a'0v), a) )4)at)d and )-all))d as if f2ll7 s)t f0t ))in.

1+.  D)f)ndants= a3tiviti)s as d)s3i')d a'0v) 30nstit2t) tad)/a< infin)/)nt,

fals) d)sinati0n 0f 0iin, and 2nfai 30/4)titi0n in vi0lati0n 0f s)3ti0n @8a; 0f t) Lana/

A3t, 1 U.S.C. H11+8a;81;8A;.

1@.  B7 vit2) 0f t) f0)0in, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as '))n da/a)d and 5ill

30ntin2) t0 ') da/a)d a's)nt )li)f f0/ tis C02t.

COUNT THREE5 6T&a!ema&' D(%u#(o A0a(s# A%% De/e!a#s;

1.  Paaa4s 1-1@, a'0v), a) )4)at)d and )-all))d as if f2ll7 s)t f0t ))in.

1.  T) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< is fa/02s and distin3tiv) a/0n t)

)n)al 30ns2/in 42'li3 and as )n607)d s23 fa/) and distin3tiv)n)ss sin3) l0n ')f0) 1F

')an t0 2s) t) t)/ and vaiati0ns t))0f.

1.  D)f)ndants= a3tiviti)s as d)s3i')d a'0v) a) li<)l7 t0 dil2t), i/4ai and 'l2 t)

distin3tiv)n)ss 0f t) EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS Ma< in vi0lati0n 0f 1 U.S.C. H 11+83;.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 52 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 53/62

 

- @ -3787983v2

1.  B7 vit2) 0f t) f0)0in, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as '))n da/a)d and 5ill

30ntin2) t0 ') da/a)d a's)nt )li)f f0/ tis C02t.

COUNT FOUR5 6Co#&($u#o&. T&a!ema&' I/&(0eme# A0a(s# 34F;

1.  Paaa4s 1-1, a'0v), a) )4)at)d and )-all))d as if f2ll7 s)t f0t ))in.

1?.  T) 2s) '7 1F=s n)t50< 0f Disti'2t0s and 30240ns.30/ 0f t) EA Ma<s in

30nn)3ti0n 5it t) /a<)tin and sal) 0f 1F=s 9F2it B022)t: 40d23ts 30nstit2t)s

tad)/a< infin)/)nt, fals) d)sinati0n 0f 0iin, and 2nfai 30/4)titi0n in vi0lati0n 0f

s)3ti0n @8a; 0f t) Lana/ A3t, 1 U.S.C. HH 1118a; 11+8a;81;8A;.

1?!.  U40n inf0/ati0n and ')li)f, 1F int)nti0nall7 ind23)d its n)t50< 0f

Disti'2t0s and 30240ns.30/ t0 infin) t) EA Ma<s 0 30ntin2)d t0 s244l7 t0s)

disti'2t0s and 30240ns.30/, 5i3 t)7 <n)5 0 ad )as0n t0 <n05 5)) and a) )nain

in tad)/a< infin)/)nt.

1?1.  1F is, t))f0), 30nti'2t0il7 lia'l) f0 t) a/ and da/a) 3a2s)d t0

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts.

1?+.  B7 vit2) 0f t) f0)0in, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as '))n da/a)d and 5ill

30ntin2) t0 ') da/a)d a's)nt )li)f f0/ tis C02t.

COUNT FIVE5 6Commo La, U/a(& Com=e#(#(o A0a(s# A%% De/e!a#s;

1?@.  Paaa4s 1-1?+, a'0v), a) )4)at)d and )-all))d as if f2ll7 s)t f0t ))in.

1?.  Plaintiffs av) inv)st)d a s2'stantial a/02nt 0f ti/), )ff0t and /0n)7 in

d)v)l04in t)i 00d5ill in t) /a<)t4la3) and tat 00d5ill is in)ti3a'l7 lin<)d t0 t) EA

Ma<s.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 53 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 54/62

 

- -3787983v2

1?.  D)f)ndants av) a4404iat)d Plaintiffs= 00d5ill in vi0lati0n 0f Plaintiffs=

val2a'l) int)ll)3t2al 404)t7 its.

1?.  B7 vit2) 0f t) f0)0in, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts as '))n da/a)d and 5ill

30ntin2) t0 ') da/a)d a's)nt )li)f f0/ tis C02t.

COUNT SI25 6V(o%a#(o o/ CUTPA> Co8 Ge8 S#a#8 99 :<*33?a e# se@8 A0a(s#

34F;

1?.  Paaa4s 1-1?, a'0v), a) )4)at)d and )-all))d as if f2ll7 s)t f0t ))in.

1?.  Plaintiffs a) 4)s0ns 5itin t) /)anin 0f C0nn. G)n. Stat. HH +-11!a8@; and

+-11!8a; )ntitl)d t0 'in an a3ti0n 2nd) t) C0nn)3ti32t Unfai Tad) Pa3ti3)s A3t, C0nn.

G)n. Stat. H +-11!a, )t s). 89CUTPA:;.

1??.  At all )l)vant ti/)s, 1F 5as a 4)s0n a3tin in t) 30nd23t 0f tad) 0

30//)3) 5itin t) /)anin 0f C0nn. G)n. Stat. HH +-11!a )t s).

+!!.  T) f0)0in a3ti0ns 0f 1F 30nstit2t)s 2nfai and d)3)4tiv) a3ts and 4a3ti3)s

in t) 30nd23t 0f tad) 0 30//)3) tat a) 2n)ti3al, 2ns3242l02s and 0ff)nsiv) t0 42'li3

40li37, and a) a vi0lati0n 0f C0nn. G)n. Stat. H +-11!'8a;.

+!1.  As a )s2lt 0f t) f0)0in 2nfai and d)3)4tiv) a3ts and 4a3ti3)s, Plaintiffs

av) s2ff))d an as3)taina'l) l0ss 5itin t) /)anin 0f C0nn. G)n. Stat. HH +-11!8a; and

av) s2ff))d da/a)s in an a/02nt t0 ') d)t)/in)d at tial.

+!+.  T) f0)0in a3ti0ns 0f 1F s05 3al32lat)d, d)3)itf2l and 2nfai 30nd23t, and

)3<l)ss indiff))n3) t0 t) its 0f t) Plaintiffs. A330dinl7, 1F is lia'l) t0 Plaintiffs f0

42nitiv) da/a)s 42s2ant t0 C0nn. G)n. Stat. H +-11!8a;.

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 54 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 55/62

 

- -3787983v2

+!@.  Plaintiffs a) tans/ittin a 3047 0f tis C0/4laint t0 t) Att0n)7 G)n)al 0f

t) Stat) 0f C0nn)3ti32t and t0 t) C0//issi0n) 0f C0ns2/) P0t)3ti0n f0 t) Stat) 0f

C0nn)3ti32t, as )2i)d '7 C0nn. G)n. Stat. H +-11!83;.

PRAYER FOR RELIEF

WHEREFORE, Edi'l) Aan)/)nts )s4)3tf2ll7 d)/ands*

1.  A d)3laati0n tat D)f)ndants, '7 t)i 2na2t0i>)d 2s) 0f Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts= )ist))d tad)/a<s and&0 d)sinati0ns 30nf2sinl7 si/ila t))t0, as

infin)d 240n Edi'l) Aan)/)nts= tad)/a<s and as 2s)d fals) d)sinati0ns 0f 0iin and

as in62)d Plaintiffs= 00d5ill and '2sin)ss )42tati0n in vi0lati0n 0f la5, and tat

D)f)ndants av) d0n) s0 int)nti0nall7, d)li')at)l7 and 5illf2ll7, all t0 t) l0ss and d)ti/)nt

0f t) Plaintiffs

+.  A 4)/an)nt in62n3ti0n )stainin D)f)ndants and t)i 0ffi3)s, a)nts,

s)vants, )/4l07))s, )4)s)ntativ)s, 4a)nts, s2'sidiai)s, affiliat)s, divisi0ns, s233)ss0s

and assins and all t0s) 4)s0ns 0 )ntiti)s in a3tiv) 30n3)t 0 4ati3i4ati0n 5it an7 0f t)/

50 )3)iv) a3t2al n0ti3) 0f t) in62n3tiv) 0d), f0/ 30nti'2tin t0, 3a2sin 0 a')ttin

an7 0f t) f0ll05in a3ti0ns*

A. 2sin 0 infinin 240n an7 0f t) EA Ma<s

B. )nain in an7 a3ts 0 a3tiviti)s di)3tl7 0 indi)3tl7 3al32lat)d t0 tad)

 240n t) EA Ma<s 0 t) )42tati0n and 00d5ill 0f t) Plaintiffs 0 5i3 in an7

/ann) 30/4)t)s 2nfail7 5it Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 0 its affiliat)s 0 s2'sidiai)s and

C. /a<in an7 )4)s)ntati0n in3l2din an7 2s) 0f '032)s, l)tt))ad,

'2sin)ss 3ads, sins 0 an7 0t) 5itt)n inf0/ati0n 0 an7 Int)n)t 5)'sit) indi3atin

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 55 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 56/62

 

- -3787983v2

0 i/4l7in tat D)f)ndants a) in an7 5a7 30nn)3t)d 0 affiliat)d 5it 0 s40ns0)d '7

Edi'l) Aan)/)nts 0 an7 0f its affiliat)s 0 s2'sidiai)s.

@.  Tat D)f)ndants d)liv) t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts f0 d)st23ti0n all /at)ial

8in3l2din, 5it02t li/itati0n, all 40d23ts, 3atal0s, adv)tis)/)nts, 40/0ti0nal /at)ials,

'032)s, sins, dis4la7s, stati0na7 and '2sin)ss 3ads;, 5itin t)i 40ss)ssi0n, 32st0d7 0

30nt0l, )it) di)3tl7 0 indi)3tl7, tat infin) t) EA Ma<s 0 an7 0t) /a<s 0 tad)

d)ss 30nf2sinl7 si/ila t))t0, 42s2ant t0 1 U.S.C. H 111,

.  Tat D)f)ndants ') di)3t)d t0 fil) 5it t) C02t and s)v) 240n Edi'l)

Aan)/)nts, 5itin tit7 8@!; da7s aft) )nt7 0f final 62d/)nt, a )40t in 5itin and

 2nd) 0at s)ttin f0t in d)tail t) /ann) and f0/ '7 5i3 it as 30/4li)d 5it t)

40visi0ns s)t f0t in 4aaa4s + and @, a'0v), 42s2ant t0 1 U.S.C. H 1118a;

.  Tat D)f)ndants ') di)3t)d t0 a3302nt f0 and 4a7 t0 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts f0

all ains, 40fits and advanta)s )ali>)d '7 D)f)ndants and 1F=s n)t50< 0f Disti'2t0s

)s2ltin f0/ t) sal) 0f infinin 40d23ts 42s2ant t0 1 U.S.C. H 1118a;.

. Tat Edi'l) Aan)/)nts )30v) f0/ D)f)ndants t) )at) 0f t)) ti/)s

t) a/02nt 0f D)f)ndants= 40fits 0 an7 da/a)s s2stain)d '7 Edi'l) Aan)/)nts, t0)t)

5it int))st 0n s23 a/02nt and t) 30sts 0f tis a3ti0n 42s2ant t0 1 U.S.C. H 1118a;

. Tat D)f)ndants ') )2i)d t0 t)/inat) t) Int)n)t 5)'sit)

555.f2it'022)ts.30/ and 555.f2it'022)tstat)nisland.30/ and an7 Int)n)t 5)'sit) in

D)f)ndants= 30nt0l 2sin 0 in3040atin t) t)/ 9f2it '022)t: 2ntil all infinin /at)ial

as '))n )/0v)d f0/ s23 sit)s

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 56 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 57/62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 58/62

 EIBIT A

3787983v2

MAR+ REGISTRATION

NO8

DATE

REGISTERED

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS R). N0. +,@,@+ R)ist))d &&!!

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS R). N0. +,?@,1 R)ist))d @&++&!

R). N0. @,11, R)ist))d ?&1+&!

GET FRES "IT EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS R). N0. @,+,+@ R)ist))d &+&!

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS ARRANGEMENTFOAM

R). N0. @,,!1 R)ist))d 1+&?&!

EDIBLE NUMBERS R). N0. @,,! R)ist))d 1+&?&!

FRUTATION B% EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS R). N0. 1,+&+@&! R)ist))d 1+&+@&!

TE EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS CORPORATECOLLECTION

R). N0. @,?,@1 R)ist))d +&+&!?

LITTLE EPRESSIONS B% EDIBLEARRANGEMENTS

R). N0. @,?, R)ist))d &+&!?

EDIBLE BRANDS R). N0. @,,+ R)ist))d &1&!?

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS R). N0. @,,1! R)ist))d ?&&1!

R). N0. @,,11 R)ist))d ?&&1!

FANC% FRUIT B% EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS R). N0. @,,1+ R)ist))d ?&1&1!

FRUTATION B% EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS R). N0. @,,? R)ist))d 1+&1&1!

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 58 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 59/62

 

- ? -3787983v2

MAR+ REGISTRATION

NO8

DATE

REGISTERED

EDIBLE TO GO R). N0. ,!,! R)ist))d 1+&&11

"ELCOME TO TE "ORLD OF EDIBLEARRANGEMENTS

R). N0. ,+@,@ R)ist))d 1&&1@

R). N0. ,@!!,++ R)ist))d @&1+&1@

EDIBLE R). N0. ,@1?,?! R)ist))d &1&1@

EDIBLE ARRANGEMENTS R). N0. ,@+,1! R)ist))d &@!&1@

EDIBLE CARES R). N0. ,1,? R)ist))d 1&+1&1

EDIBLE NUMBERS R). N0. ,?+,?! R)ist))d &+&1

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 59 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 60/62

 EIBIT B

3787983v2

MAR+ REGISTRATION NO8 DATE REGISTERED

BERR% COCOLATE BOU(UET R). N0. @+?+@ R)ist))d?&+&!

COCOLATE BANANA BOU(UET R). N0. @@?@ R)ist))d @&&!

DIPPED FRUIT BOU(UET R). N0. @@?!+ R)ist))d @&11&!

BERR% BOU(UET R). N0. @+?1 R)ist))d &+!&!

BERR% TREE BOU(UET R). N0. @+?1 R)ist))d &+!&!

BREAST CANCER A"ARENESSBOU(UET

R). N0. @1 R)ist))d &&!

ETRA EFFORT BOU(UET R). N0. @??!1 R)ist))d ?&?&!

FRUITFUL ACIE$EMENTBOU(UET

R). N0. @!1! R)ist))d ?&1&!

MORNING MOTI$ATOR BOU(UET R). N0. @!1 R)ist))d ?&1&!

%OURE TE BEST BOU(UET R). N0. @!1 R)ist))d ?&1&!

TE ACCOMPLISMENTBOU(UET R). @!11 R)ist))d ?&1&!

TE RECOGNITION BOU(UET R). N0. @!1+ R)ist))d ?&1&!

S"EETEART BOU(UET R). N0. @!@? R)ist))d ?&+@&!

ROC A B%E BOU(UET R). N0. @+ R)ist))d 11&&!

S"EET LIBERT% BOU(UET R). N0. @+! R)ist))d 11&&!

#OB "ELL DONE BOU(UET R). N0. @+1 R)ist))d 11&&!

"ELCOME ABOARD BOU(UET R). N0. @+1 R)ist))d 11&&!

AMBITION BOU(UET R). N0. @@?@ R)ist))d 1+&?&!

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 60 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 61/62

 

- 1 -3787983v2

MAR+ REGISTRATION NO8 DATE REGISTERED

PATRIOTIC APPRECIATIONBOU(UET

R). N0. @1@@ R)ist))d &&!?

PEANUT BUTTER BOU(UET R). N0. @?1! R)ist))d 1!&&!?PEARADISE BOU(UET R). N0. @!! R)ist))d 11&@&!?

FRUIT TRUFFLES BOU(UET R). N0. @! R)ist))d +&1&1!

A BIRTDA% BOU(UET R). N0. @! R)ist))d &1&1!

PEANUT BUTTER COCOLATEBOU(UET

R). N0. @1? R)ist))d &&1!

S"EET ANNI$ERSAR% BOU(UET R). N0. @@1@ R)ist))d ?&+&1!

DIPPEDFRUIT.COM R). N0. @?++@ R)ist))d 11&+&1!

BLAC CAT BOU(UET R). N0. 1? R)ist))d &@&1+

MERR% GINGERBREAD MENBOU(UET

R). N0. @++? R)ist))d &+@&1@

Case 2:14-cv-01744 Document 1 Filed 11/20/14 Page 61 of 62

8/10/2019 Edible Arrangements v. 1-800-Flowers.com - keyword advertising, edible arrangement design.pdf

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/edible-arrangements-v-1-800-flowerscom-keyword-advertising-edible-arrangement 62/62