PertanikaJ. Trop. Agric. Sci. 27(2): 91 - 99 (2004) ISSN: 1511-3701© Universiti Putra Malaysia Press

Effects of Sole and Amended Agricultural by Products on Soil Fertility andthe Growth and Chemical Composition of Budded Rubber

E.I MOYIN-JESUAgronomy Department, Federal College of Agriculture

Akure Ondo State, Nigeria

Keywords: Sole and amended cocoa husk, soil fertility, budded rubber, Akure, rainforest zone

ABSTRAK

Satu eksperimen telah dijalankan untuk menentukan kesan sekam koko yang diperbaiki dan yang tidakmenggunakan abu tandan kelapa sawit dengan najis ayam itik, ayam belanda, arnab dan sekam yangdigunakan pada tangkai akar getah (tunas getah yang dicantumkan pada akar) di kawasan zon hutan hujanAkure, Nigeria. Ada tiga belas rawatan pembaikan organik dijalankan pada 6t/ha dengan baja 300 kg/hasebagai rujukan pembaikan dan kawalan (tanpa baja, tanpa najis binatang). Rawatan disusun dalam aturanblok lengkap rawak (RBC) dan direplikakan sebanyak tiga kali, Rawatan pembaikan tanah organik jugadianalisis secara kimia dan parameter tunas getah direkodkan bagi ketinggian, jumlah dedaun, jumlah limfa,kawasan daun, nilai N, PL, K Ca, pH Mg tanah dan bahan organik (O.M) pada tanah dan daun. Keputusanmenunjukkan ada peningkatan yang signifikan (P< 0.05) pada kawasan dan jumlah daun, jumlah limfa,tanah dan nilai N, P, K, Ca, Mg dan pH tanah dan bahan organik (O.M) tunas getah di bawah rawatanpembaikan berbanding rawatan kawalan. Rawatan menggunakan tandan kelapa sawit dan najis ayam itikmenghasilkan limfa daun yang tertinggi. Penggunaan baja NPK, sekam (betari sisa kilang) dan rawatankawalan, mengurangkan jumlah limfa daun sebanyak 50%, 42% dan 92%. Pembaikan abu kelapa sawit +najis arnab juga menaikkan min ketinggian tunas pokok getah dengan 56% dan 46% berbanding najis ayamitik dan baja NPK, Abu tandan kelapa sawit dan hampas sekam koko meningkatkan K dan Mg pada tanahdan daun berbanding sekam sementara itu najis ayam belanda meningkatkan N, P, K, Ca, Mg pH tanah danO.M pada tunas, tanah dan daun getah berbanding najis ayam itik dan arnab.

ABSTRACT

An experiment was out to determine the effectiveness of sole and amended cocoa husk, oil palm bunch ash withpoultry, turkey, rabbit manure and spent grain on budded rubber root stock (grafted bud rubber on a root stock)in the field at Akure in the rainforest zone of Nigeria. There were thirteen organic amendment treatments appliedat 6t/ha with 300 kg/ha fertilizer as a reference treatment and a control (no fertilizer; no manure). The treatmentswere arranged in a randomized complete block (RBC) design and replicated three times. The soil organicamendment treatments were also chemically analysed while the parameters recorded for the budded rubber wereplant height, leaf number, number of nodes, leaf area, soil and leafN, PL, K Ca, Mg SoilpH and Organic matter(O.M). The results showed that there were significant increases (P<0.05) in plant height, leaf area, leaf number,nodes number, soil and leafN,P,K,Ca, Mg SoilpH and organic matter (O.M) of budded rubber under differentorganic amendment treatments compared to the control treatment Oil palm bunch ash + poultry manuretreatments had the greatest number of leaf nodes. Use of NPK fertilizer, spentgrain (sorghum based brewery waste)and control treatments reduced mean leaf node number by 50%, 42% and 92% respectively. The amendmentoil palm ash + rabbit manure also increase the mean plant height of budded rubber by 56% and 46% comparedto the poultry manure and NPK fertilizer respectively. Oil palm bunch ash and cocoa husk residues increased thesoil and leaf K and Mg compared to the spent grain while the turkey manure increased growth of budded rubber,soil and leafN, P, K, Ca, Mg Soil pH and O.M. more than poultry and rabbit.

INTRODUCTION for its latex production. The family also contains

Rubber, (Hevea brasiliensis) is a member of the P l a n t s s u c h a s c a s t o r o i l P l a n t imdnus comunis),family Euphorbiaceae and is mainly cultivated cassava (manihot esculentum) and many other

E.I MOYIN-JESU

species of tropical importance.The genus Heavea contains a number of

species but Hevea brasiliensis is the only specieswith very high isoprene content in its latex. Thelatex produced by the tree in processed intocommercial forms of rubber and has contributedenormously to the economies of Nigeria, Asianand other tropical countries in term or raw-materials for tire industries, foreign exchangeearnings and provision of employmentopportunities.

In spite of the utilization and importance ofthe crop, the rubber production in Nigeria isfacing serious problems at present because thetree area aging and there is a scarcity of newrubber seedlings or budded rubber to replaceover 532,364 hectares of aging and lowproduction rubber trees in the field. Thisreplacement is becoming difficult because ofacontinuous decline in soil fertility.

Efforts to improve soil fertility using differenttypes of inorganic fertilizers such as Urea,sulphate of ammonia and NPK tog row rubberseedlings or budded types, are limited by thecost of these materials, scarcity at the farmers'level and continued deterioration of soilproperties (Folorunso et al. 1995).

Umoti (1990) reported that cocoa, rubberand oil palm removed large amounts of plantnutrients in the nursery and field. Highproductivity of these crops could be achievedand sustained by massive application of inorganicfertilizers. However, inorganic fertilizers arebecoming very expensive (N1500.00 or US$15.00per bag) which poses a constraint to low incomefarmers who produce the major percentiles ofrubber, oil palm and cocoa in Nigeria.

Therefore, the complimentary use of organicfertilizers materials derived from oil palm, cocoa,rice, maize, cassava crops and animal wastessuch as poultry and turkey manures could helpto reduce the high cost of fertilizers. Due totheir natural abundance, organic amendmentssuch as oil bunch ash, wood ash spent grain(sorghum based brewery waste) and theiramended forms with turkey and poultry manuresas fertilizers have been used for growing maize,cassava and okra crops in Nigeria (Oladokun1986; Folorunso 1999).

Based on an extensive literature review, it isconcluded that there is scarcity of researchinformation pertaining to the of oil palm bunchash, wood ash, spent grain nad their amendedforms with turkey and poultry manures for

growing rubber either in the nursery or field.Therefore, there is a strong justification toinvestigate the use of these wastes to grow buddedrubber in the field.

The objectives of the research were as follows:i. To determine the effect of different organic

amendments on the performance of buddedrubber in the field

ii. To determine the effect of organicamendments on the soil and leaf chemicalcomposition of rubber in the field.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The experiment took place at Akure (Lat 7 ° ^ ,5° 10E1) in the rainforest zone of Nigeria. Theannual rainfall is 1300mm and the meantermperature is 70°F while the soil is a sandylaom, skeletal, kaolinitic isohyperthermic oxicpaleustalf (alfisol) or Ferric Luvisol (F.A.O).

Source and Preparation of the OrganicAmendments Used

Oil palm bunch ash and wood were obtainedfrom the oil palm and cassava processing unitsof Federal College of Agriculture, Akurerespectively. Cocoa husk was collected form thecollege cocoa farms while the spent grains(sorghum based brewery waste) were collectedfrom a nearby local brewery.

The turkey, poultry and rabbit manures werecollected form the college livestock farms. Theorganic residues were processed to allowdecomposition and reduction of C/N ratio. Thedried cocoa husk were ground a hammer millwhile the spent grain was chopped into pieces,and allowed to decompose. The turkey, poultryand rabbit manures were stored individually toallow for mineralisation and placed under shade.

Generally, all the organic wastes readilyavailable, sustainable and inexpensive for growingcomemrical quantities of budded rubber in thefield.

Field Experiment

The budded rubber root stocks were boughtform Rubber Research Institute of Nigeria(RRIN) Benin, Edo- State. The field site wascleared and the planting lines for the buddedwere marked with pegs.

There were thirteen organic amendmenttreatmnets viz:spent grain, rabbit manure, turkeymanure, spent grain + turkey manure, oil palmbunch ash + rabbit manure, cocoa husk + turkey

92 PERTANIKA J. TROP. AGRIC. SCL VOL. 27 NO. 2, 2004

EFFECTIVENESS OF ORGANIC AMENDMENTS ON BUDDED RUBBER IN AKURE, NIGERIA

manure with a field recommended chemicalfertilizer NPK 1 5 - 1 5 - 1 5 treatment applied at300kg/ha and a control (no fertilizer no manure).

The organic amendments were applied at6t/ha for the ordinary forms of spent grain,rabbit manure, turkey and oil palm bunch ashwhile their amended froms were applied at aratio of 50:50% by weight (3tha- 1 each).

Planting holes were dug 30cm deep andfilled with top soil halfway. Then each organicamendment was added and allowed to decay forten days before planting one budded rubberroot stock per hole at a spacing of 6m x 3m. The4th week after planting, sprouting of the scionsoccurred.

Weeding began 2 weeks after planting andevery 3 weeks until experiment was terminated.10ml a.i. of Karate/ 10L of water was sprayed onthem (sprouted scions of rubber) to controltermite attacks.

Five weeks after planting measurements orcounts of plant height, nodes number, leaf area,stem girth and leaf number were made andthese measurements or counts were representativeleaves of the plant and this was used to calculatetotal leaf area (cm2) per plant. (4.8 and 32weeks after planting), also these measurementswere done insitu.

Representative leaf samples were taken at20 weeks after planting for each treatment, placedin labelled envelopes and oven dried at 70°C for48 hours. Two grams of dried leaf samples wereweighed into crucible and dry-ashed in a mufflefurnace at 45°C for 6 hours.

The resulting ash was solubilized intosolution and analyzed for phosphorus (P) usingvanado-molybdate colouration and read onspectronic 20 at 442Um while the % K, Ca andNa were determined using a flame photometer.Magnesium content was determined with anatomic absorption spectrophotometer (Jackson1958). The % N was determine using the micro-Kjeldahi method (Jackson 1964).

Soil Analysis Before Planting

30 core soil samples were collected from 0-15cmdepth on the site, mixed thoroughly and the bulksamples were taken to the laboratory air-driedsieved with 2mm sieve and ready for routineanalysis.

The soil pH (1:1 soil/water and 1:2 soil/0.01 M Cacl2) was determined using a glass/calomel system (Crockford and Nowell 1956).

Organic carbon determination was done usingwet dichromate method (Walkley and Black1934). The organic C ws multiplied by 1.723 toget organic matter (O.M).

The exchangeable cations were extractedusing 1M NH40 (ammonium acetate) solutionand the amount of K, Ca and Na contents weredetermined on flame photometer usingappropriate element filters while Mg content inthe extract was read on atomic absorptionspectrophotometer (Jackson 1958). Theexchangeable acidity (H+ and Al3+) was measuredfrom 0.01 M KCI extracts by titrating with 0.1 MHCI (Mclean 1965).

Total nitrogen was determined by micro-kjedahl method (Jackson 1964) and the soilavailable phosophorus was extracted using BrayPi extractant (Murphy and Riley 1962) and theconcentration measured on a spectronic 20 at882Um.

Soil Analysis After Planting

Soil samples were taken from each treatmentplot using soil auger, air-dried, sieved with 2mmsieve for routine analysis of total N, available P,exchangeable K, Ca, Mg and Na contents, soilpH and O.M as described earlier under soilanalysis before planting.

Statistical Analysis

The data collected from the treatment effects ofthe organic amendments on the growthparameters such as plant height, leaf area, stemgirth, leaf number, nodes number, leaf and soilN,P,K,Mg, Soil pH and O.M were analysed usingan ANOVA F-test and their means were separatedand compared along the treatment effects usingDuncan Multiple Range Test (DMRT) at 5% level.

RESULT

Soil Analysis Before Planting of Budded Rubber

The physical and chemical properties of thesoils used for growing rubber are presented inTable 1. Using the established soil critical levelsin Southwest Nigeria for rubber production, thesoils are low in organic matter when comparedwith the critical level of 3% O.M (Agbooda andCorey 1973). The total nitrogen was less than0.14% considered as optimum for cocoa andrubber production (Obatolu 1989).

The available P was below the lOmg/kg Pwhich is to be the optimum for crop production(Agboola and Corey 1973). The exchangeable

PERTANIKAJ. TROP. AGRIC. SCI. VOL. 27 NO. 2, 2004 93

E.I MOYIN-JRSU

K, Ca, Mg and Na contents were below, 0.20,0.25 and 0.18 mg/kg that are considered asadequate for cocoa, oil palm and rubber crops(Agboola 1974).

The low values of soil N, P, K, Ca, Mg andNa and O.M were indications of the low inherentsoil fertility. Budded rubber root stocks plantedon such would respond favourably to theapplication of the organic amendments. Thesoils were sandy loam in texture, skeletal,kaolinitic, isohyperthemic oxic paleustalf (Alfisolor Ferric Luvisol (FAO) or Akure series (localclassification).

Chemical Composition of the Organic FertilizerMaterials Used

Table 2 presents the chemical properties of theorganic materials used for growing budded rubberroot stocks in the field. The poultry manure hadthe highest N, K and Mg levels when comparedto turkey and rabbit manures while turkeymanure had the highest P, Ca and Na levels.

The oil palm bunch ash had the highest%N, K, Ca Mg and Na levels when compared tococoa husk and spent grain. Spent grain is fairlylow in N, K, Ca, Mg and Na levels except in %P.The prior processing of the organic amendmenttreatments before application reduced their C/

N ratio.

Leaf Number of Budded Root StocksThe leaf number of budded rubber root stocksbetween 4 and 32 weeks after planting (WAP)under the different organic fertilizer treatmentsis presented in Table 3. There were significantincreases (p<0.05) in leaf number of buddedrubber under the different organic treatmentscompared to the control treatment.

The amended oil palm bunch ash+spentgrain treatments increased the leaf number ofbudded rubber by 26% and 64% compared tothe sole oil palm bunch ash and spent grainrespectively. The amended spent grain + turkeymanure and cocoa husk+spent grain treatmentsincreased leaf number of budded rubber by71% and 81% respectively when compared tothe control treatment.

The NPK fertilizer treatment increased theleaf population of budded rubber by 48%compared to spent grain treatment. However,the amended cocoa husk+spent grain increasedthe leaf number of budded rubber by 20%compared to NPK fertilizer. Of all sole residuetreatments, poultry manure resulted in thegreatest increase in leaf number then spentgrain and turkey manure.Leaf Area of Budded Rubber

TABLE 1Chemical analysis of the soil before the experiment

PH Exhangeable Cations

H20 Cacl2 Organic matter N K Ca Mg Na

_mg/kg _mmol/kg soil

5.80 5.30 0.45 0.08 7.62 0.09 0.11 0.17 0.16

TABLE 2Chemical analysis of the organic fertilizers used for the experiment

Organic Material

Spent grainRabbit manureTurkey manurePoultry manureOil palm bunch ashCocoa pod ash

N%

0.78a2.67c4.08d5.92e1.54b1.44b

AvailableP%

0.64c0.86e0.93f0.75d0.42b0.21a

K

0.12a0.29b0.42c0.48c2.40e1.26d

ExchangeableCa

%

0.118a0.30b0.60c0.54c1.25e0.91d

CationsMg

0.20a0.180.17a0.35b0.78d0.48c

Na

0.14b0.16c0.13b0.09a0.21d0.17c

94 PERTANIKA J. TROP. AGRIC. SCI. VOL. 27 NO. 2, 2004

EFFECTIVENESS OF ORGANIC AMENDMENTS ON BUDDED RUBBER IN AKURE, NIGERIA

TABLE 3The leaf number of budded rubber at 4.8 and 32 WAP under different organic amendments

Treatments

Control (No fertilizer)NPK 15-15-15Poultry manureRabbit manureTurkey manureOil palm bunch ashSpent grainSpent grain + Cocoa huskSpent grain + Oil palm bunch ashCocoa husk + turkey manureOil palm bunch ash + poultry manureOil palm bunch ash + rabbit manureSpent grain + poultry manureSpent grain + rabbit manureSpent grain + turkey manure

4

166435378556664

Weels

8

2101265114

121411101011128

After Planting

32

4151810101792023171616172012

Mean

2.33k10.3f

12.00d6.66h6.00ill.OOf5.30j13.0b15.0a

ll.OOef10.30f10.66f11.33c12.66c8.00g

Treatment means followed by the same letters are not significantly different from each other using Duncan MultipleRange Test at 5% level.

TABLE 4The leaf area (Cm2/tree) of budded rubber at 4, 8 and 32 and WAP under different organic amendments

Treatments

ControlNPK 15-15-15Poultry manureRabbit manureTurkey manureOil palm bunch ashSpent grainSpent grain + cocoa huskSpent grain + oil palm bunch ashCocoa husk + turkey manureOil palm bunch ash + poultryOil palm bunch ash + rabbit manureSpent grain + poultry manureSpent grain + rabbit manrueSpent grain + turkey manure

4

481188168857861971381289110485105114

Week After

8

75236160134170156123194263255181207170209227

Planting

32

100590398335424390308484698638453519426523568

Mean (Cm2)

74.30m314.90c213.00i179.00k226.30h208.00J163.90b258.40e366.50a340.60b24L50g276.50c227.00h279.00e

3030.00d

Treatment means followed by the same letters are not significantly different from each other using Duncan MultipleRange Test at 5% level

The leaf of budded rubber root stocks between4 and 32 weeks after planting (WAP) increasesignificantly (p<0.05) under the different organicfertilizers as presented in Table 4. The amendedoil palm bunch ash+spent treatment increasedthe mean leaf area of budded rubber in the fieldby 24% compared to the spent grain+rabbit

manure. It also increased the leaf area of buddedrubber by 43% compared to the sole form of oilpalm bunch ash treatment.

The amended oil palm bunch ash+spentgrain increased the leaf area of budded rubberby 14% compared to NPK fertilizer while thesame parameter increased by 80% when

PERTANIKAJ. TROP. AGRIC. SCI. VOL. 27 NO. 2, 2004 95

E.I MOYIN-JESU

compared to the control treatment. Among thesole residues used, poultry manure increasedthe leaf most, when compared toe the spentgrain and rabbit manure respectively.

Nodes Number of Budded RubberTable 5 shows the number of nodes of buddedrubber increased significantly (p<0.05) between4 and 32 weeks after planting (WAP) under thedifferent organic fertilizer treatments. Theamended oil palm bunch ash + poultry manureincreased the mean nodes number of buddedrubber by 50%, 42% and 92% compared to theNPK fertilizer, spent grain and control treatmentsrespectively.

Oil palm bunch + rabbit manure increasedthe nodes number of budded rubber 29% and53% compared to the oil palm bunch + poultrymanure and oil palm bunch ash (sole form)respectively. Poultry manure treatment alsoincreased the nodes number 27%, 45% and55% compared to turkey manure, rabbit manureand spent grain treatments respectively.

Plant Height of Budded RubberTreatments had significant (<0.05) effect onplant height 32 weeks after planting (Table 6).The amended oil palm bunch ash + rabbitmanure increased the plant height of budded

rubber by 56% and 46% compared to the poultrymanure and NPK fertilizer respectively. The sametreatment increased the plant height of buddedrubber by 85% compared to the controltreatment.

The poultry manure treatment increasedthe plant height of budded rubber by 53%compared to the spent grain treatment.

DISCUSSIONSoil used for planting of budded rubber trees inthe field were generally low in pH, O.M. N,P,K,Ca and Mg which could be responsible for thepoor growth of budded rubber as shown in thecontrol treatment. The observation was supportedby Agboola (1982) who had reported that poorgrowth of rubber trees was noticeable inundertilized soils, hence, it is expected that theapplication of spent grain, oil palm bunch ash,turkey, poultry and rabbit manures and cocoapod husk alone or in combination iwht manuresto the soil would increase growth of buddedrubber.

The increase in plant height, leaf area, nodesnumber, leaf number of budded rubber grownwith the sole and amended organic fertilizerscould be due to their rich chemical compositionand this finding agreed with Umoti (1990) andFolorunso (1999) who reported that oil palm

TABLE 5The increase in node number of budded rubber between 4 and 32 weeks after planting under

different organic treatments

Treatments

ControlNPK 15-15-15Poultry manureRabbit manureTurkey manureOil palm bunch ashSpent grainSpent grain + cocoa huskSpent grain + oil palm bunch ashCocoa husk + turkey manureOil palm bunch ash + poultryOil palm bunch ash + rabbit manureSpent grain + poultry manureSpent grain + rabbit manrueSpent grain + turkey manure

4

011111012222111

Week After

8

024222134445222

Planting

32

1363544668610545

Mean (Cm2)

0.33h2.00g3.66d2.00g2.66e2.33f1.66g3.33d4.00c4.66b4.00c5.66a2.66e2.33f2.67e

Treatment means followed by the same letters are not significantly different from each other using Duncan MultipleRange Test at 5% level.

96 PERTANIKAJ. TROP. AGRIC. SCI. VOL. 27 NO. 2, 2004

EFFECTIVENESS OF ORGANIC AMENDMENTS ON BUDDED RUBBER IN AKURE, NIGERIA

TABLE 6The increase in plant height (cm) of budded rubber between 4 and 32 WAP under different organic residues

Treatments 8WAP

32 Mean

ControlNPK 15-15-15Poultry manureRabbit manureTurkey manureOil palm bunch ashSpent grainSpent grain + cocoa huskSpent grain + oil palm bunch ashCocoa husk + turkey manureOil palm bunch ash + poultryOil palm bunch ash + rabbit manureSpent grain + poultry manureSpent grain + rabbit manureSpent grain + turkey manure

4.3010.008.009.007.006.005.6010.0011.606.1012.0015.5010.0010.0010.00

6.0020.0016.7017.0016.0014.0013.0018.9023.0011.0028.0040.0023.8019.3019.00

9.0037.0030.0032.0029.0024.6022.0033.0043.0019.0041.2069.0039.0035.0035.00

6.42i22.37d18.23f

19.34ef17.58f14.81g13.54g20.64e25.88c12.04h27.06b41.5a

24.28c21.46de21.33d

TABLE 7The leaf chemical composition of budded rubber at 20 weeks after planting under different organic residues

Treatments

Control (no fertilizer)NPK 15-15-15Poultry manureRabbit manureTurkey manureOil palm bunch ashSpent grainSpent grain + cocoa huskSpent grain + oil palm bunch ashCocoa husk + turkey manureOil palm bunch ash + poultryOil palm bunch ash + rabbit manureSpent grain + poultry manureSpent grain + rabbit manureSpent grain + turkey manure

N

0.90k2.90b2.78c2.22g1.72h1.35i1.25j2.35f2.46e2.40c2.85b3.20a2.70c2.60d2.60d

P

0.1410.61b0.35J0.35j0.27k0.29k0.27k0.40hi0.42h0.35j0.53c0.69a0.45f0.45f0.43fg

K%

0.20m0.65b0.33j0.32J0.25L0.28k0.24L0.44ef0.45e0.36i0.50c0.95a0.42g0.48d

0.40gh

Ca

0.20k0.20k0.41f

0.30hi0.28J

0.30hi0.36g0.38g0.53e0.32h0.58b0.84a0.49d0.44e0.48d

Mg

0.15kl0.1010.2 lj0.25i0.33h

0.42de0.18k0.32h0.48d0.37fg0.53c0.86a0.64b0.34h0.39f

Na

0.1 Oh0.1 Oh0.15gO.llh0.14g0.39d0.1 Oh0.20f0.23f0.41d0.22f0.93a0.54b0.50c0.26

Treatment means within each group followed by the same letters are not significantly different from each other usingDuncan Multiple Range Test at 5% level.

bunch ash, cocoa husk and spent grain appliedin sole form or amended poultry manure andpig manure at 6t/ha increased significantly theplant height, leaf area and leaf number of oilpalm, rubber and coffee trees.

The nutrient contents in leaves of buddedrubber in the control plots were below the criticalof 0.25%P, 1.19%K, 0.8% Ca and 0.7% Mg asreported by Jones and Eck (1973), thus theleaves of the budded rubber exhibited deficiencysymptoms of N (yellow colouration), P (purple

colouration) and K (burnt leaf margin).The application of turkey poultry and rabbit

manure, oil palm bunch ash, spent grain andcocoa husk (either solely or amended forms)increased the leaf N,P,K, Ca and Mg contents ofbudded rubber compared to controls which maybe related to their chemical composition (Table2). This observation agreed with the views ofAdu-Daaph et al (1994) who reported that cocoahusk and oil palm bunch ash were good sourcesof P,K,Ca, Mg and Na when soil applied.

However, increased leaf and soil chemical

PERTANIKAJ. TROP. AGRIC. SCI. VOL. 27 NO. 2, 2004 97

E.I MOYIN-JESU

TABLE 8The soil chemical composition of the field planted to budded rubber at 52 weeks after

planting under different treatments

Treatments

Control (no fertilizer)NPK 15-15-15Poultry manureRabbit manureTurkey manureOil palm bunch ashSpent grainSpent grain + cocoa huskSpent grain + oil palm bunch ashCocoa husk + turkey manureOil palm bunch ash + poultryOil palm bunch ash + rabbit manureSpent grain + poultry manureSpent grain + rabbit manureSpent grain + turkey manure

PH(h2O)

5.40e5.10f6.50c

6,45cd6.60bc6.90b6.206,48c7.10a6.53c

7.00ab7.20a6.70b

6.40cd6.80b

O.M%

0.23g0.28g2.30e2.26e2.35e2.30e1.76f2.58d3.31b2.85c3.34b3.80a2.93c2.67d2.75cd

N% •

0.03f0.32bc0.28cd0.24d0.26d0.23d0.16e0.29c0.29c0.30c

0.35ab0.39a

0.31bc0.28cd0.34b

PMg/kg soil

4.5j34.2b24.5g26.5f22.7h21.7hi20.5i25.5f33.2c31.9d35.2b37.2a27.3ef28.6e26.3f

K

0.03i3.42bc2.49g2.25h

2.78de3.18c2.47g2.48ef2.65e2.91d3.62b4.53a2.52f2.86d2.81de

Ca

0.05i0.03i2.09g1.97g

2.07f1.89g1.04h2.74d2.63de2.17f3.89b4.29a3.62b3.40c2.60e

MgMmol/kg

0.04h0.02h1.32f1.28f1.32f1.25f0,81g1.64e1.62e2.46b2.05c3.5a

1.86d1.65c1.68e

Na

0.06g0.025g0.80d0.69e

0.74de0.64ef0.62f0.88c

0.85cd1.10b1.09b1.25a

L20ab0.92bc0.93bc

Treatment means within each group followed by the same letters are not significantly different from each using DuncanMultiple Range Test at 5% level.

composition and growth parameters of buddedrubber by the oil palm bunch ash and cocoahuks blended with turkey, rabbit and poultrymanures compared with their sole forms couldbe explained in term of their better nutrientlevels form organically-amended fertilizers thantheir unamended forms.

The effect of turkey and poultry manure onthe growth, leaf and soil chemical compositionof budded rubber compared to the spent grainand cocoa husk is consistent with the highervalues of soil N, P,K,K, Ca, Mg and O.M of theformer than that of the latter. The observationagreed with Folorunso (1999) who reported thatthe spent grain had lower C, N, Ca, Mg, P, K andZn content and C/N ratio 1:14 which wouldmake it more resistant to degradation and theirnutrients might be made slowly available to plantscompared to turkey, poultry and rabbit manures.

The fact that oil palm bunch ash and cococahusk pod increased the soil pH is consistent withthe previous finding that the ash containedmainly K, Ca and Mg (Ojeniyi 1995). The NPKfertilizer also reduced the soil pH and this couldbe a result of acidication associated withcontinuous use of 300 kg NPK 15-15-15 fertilizerapplied per hectare which was a standard practiceused for budded rubber in the field. The abovestatement is consistent with the fact thatapplication of high amount of NPK fertilizer

would increase the NH4+ cation sorption on the

soil surface leading to increased soil acidity(Barber 1962). The phenomenon is alsoresponsible for the reduction in soil O.M. becausethe soil acidity reduced the activities of microbialorganisms, especially aerobic bacteria(inotrosomonas and nitrobacter) which are Nfixers cause poor organic matter build up.

CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATIONOil palm bunch ash, cocoa pod husk, turkey,poultry manures, spent grain and rabbit manuresare effective sources of nutrients because theiradditions to the soil have enhanced the leaf andsoil N, P,K, Ca, Mg, soil pH and O.M. plantheight, leaf area, leaf number and nodes numberof budded rubber in the field.

Spent grain was the least effective inpromoting budded rubber growth while theamended residues with turkey, poultry and rabbitmanures performed well. Oil palm bunch ash +rabbit manure, oil palm bunch ash + poultrymanure and cocoa husl + turkey applied at 6t/ha improved nutrient availability and wouldensure sustainable cultivation of budded rubberon soils of low fertility in the humid tropics.Thus, they can be used in place of scarce andexpensive inorganic fertilizers.

REFERENCES

PERTANIKA J. TROP. AGRIC. SCI. VOL. 27 NO. 2, 2004

EFFECTIVENESS OF ORGANIC AMENDMENTS ON BUDDED RUBBER IN AKURE, NIGERIA

ADU DAAPH H.K., J. COBBINA and E.O ASARE. 1994.

Effect of cocoa pod ash on the the growthof maize . / of Agric Cambridge 132: 31-33.

AGBOOLA, A.A. 1974. Organic Material as

Fertilization. Ppl47-152. F.A.O Bull 27, RomeItaly.

AGBOOLA, A.A. and R.B COREY. 1973. Soils testing

N,P,K, for maize in the soils derived frommetamorphic and igneous rocks of WesternState of Nigeria. Journal of West African ScienceAssociation 17(2): 93-100.

AGBOOLA, A.A. 1982. Organic manuring and greenmanuring in tropical agricultural system. InProceeding of 12h International Congress of SoilScience, New Delhi India, p. 198-212, 8-16February.

BARBER, S.A. 1962. Exchange equilbra, selectivityand effective diffusion coefficient of K insoils. Soil Science Soc of Amer. J. p. 39.

CROCKFORD, L. and R. NOWELL. 1956. Laboratory

Manual of Physical Chemistry. Experiments 31and 32. p. 58-59. New York: John Wiley andSons.

FOLORUNOS, O.O, A.A. AGBOOLA and G.O. ADEOYE.

1995. Use of fractional recovery model tocalculate potassium needs of some soil seriesin South Western Nigeria. Journal of TechnicalEducation, NBTE. 1&2: 57-67.

FOLORUNSO, O.O. 1999. Use of plant residues for

improving soil fertility and yield of okra(Abelmoschus esculentum L). Ph.D. Thesis,Federal University of Technology, Akure.

JACKSON, M.L. 1958. Soil Chemical Analysis, p. 57-67. Englewood Cliffs N.J.: Prentice Hall.

JACKSON, M.L. 1964. Soil Chemical Analysis, pp. 86-92. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice HallInc.

JONES, BJ. and H.V. ECK. 1973. Plant analysis as

as aid in fertilizing corn and grain sorghum.In Soil Testing and Plant Analyses Rev. ed SoilSci. Soc. Amer, ed. Walsh andJ.D. Beaton, p.349-364. Madison, Winconsin, USA.

MCLEAN, E.O. 1965. Aluminium. In Methods of

Soil Analyses Part 2, ed. M.C.A. Black, MCABlack, p. 927-932.

MURPHY, J. and J.P. RILEY. 1962. A modified single

solution method for determination ofphosphate in natural waters. Analytical Glumi- Ada. 27: 31-36.

OBATOLU, C O . 1989. Complementary user of

organic manures and inorganic fertiizersfor cocoa and rubber production. In 1st

National Conference on Organic FertilizerUtilization, p. 15-19, held I Kaduna, Nigeria.

OJENIYI, S.O. 1995. That our soil may not die.

10th inaugural lecture, p. 3-5, March 23,federal University of Technology, Akure.

OLADOKUN, M.A.O. 1986. Use of cocoa pod huskas fertilizer for maize production. NigeriaJournal of Agronomy 1(3): 103-109.

TITILAYO, E.O. 1982. The evaluation of various

types of organic wastes as sources of nutrientfor growth and yield maize. Ph.D Thesis,University of Ibadan, Ibadan Nigeria p. 70-80.

UMOTI V. 1990. Complimentary use of organic

and inorganic fertilizers for tree and forestcrop production in Nigeria. 3rd AnnualOrganic Fertilizer Conference, p. 163-175, heldin Durbar Hotel, Kaduna.

WALKEY, A. and LA BLACK. 1934. An examination

of degtajaroff method for determining soilorganic acid filtration method. Soil Sci. 37:29-38.

(Received: 19 March 2002)(Accepted: 14 September 2004)

PERTANIKAJ. TROP. AGRIC. SCI. VOL. 27 NO. 2, 2004 99